Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Rizvi 2021
Rizvi 2021
Health Care
To cite this article: Farwa Rizvi, Elizabeth Hoban & Joanne Williams (2021): Barriers and enablers
of contraceptive use among adolescent girls and women under 30 years of age in Cambodia:
a qualitative study, The European Journal of Contraception & Reproductive Health Care, DOI:
10.1080/13625187.2021.1884220
Article views: 38
RESEARCH ARTICLE
CONTACT Farwa Rizvi rizvifa@deakin.edu.au School of Health and Social Development, Faculty of Health, Deakin University, 221 Burwood Highway,
Burwood, 3125, VIC, Australia
ß 2021 The European Society of Contraception and Reproductive Health
2 F. RIZVI ET AL.
consent was obtained from the participants prior to com- women’s contraceptive use patterns [1,19]. Categories were
mencing the interviews and was digitally recorded [11]. assigned and codes were used as labels to allocate compo-
The participants received details of appropriate psycho- nents of meaning to the transcriptions [17,18]. Major and
logical and SRH counselling services before the start of the minor themes were then identified and placed under one
interviews. of the three levels of the model [17–19].
An interview guide was used because it allowed the Ethics approval was obtained from the Deakin University
researchers to cover the major topics in the interviews [15]; Human Research Ethics Committee (DUHREC 2018-218) in
the photo-elicitation method facilitates conversations about September 2018 and from the Cambodian National Ethics
topics that are challenging to discuss [9] and provides an Committee for Health Research (NECHR 313), Ministry of
opportunity to obtain information from participants with Health, in December 2018.
low levels of literacy [10]. The interview guide was devel-
oped and pilot-tested, and necessary changes were made
Results
[16]. It included questions related to the participants’
knowledge and perceptions of the barriers and enablers of Of the 30 participants, eight were single and not sexually
modern contraceptive use, discontinuation and switching. active; of the 22 who were sexually active, 12 were married
During the photo-elicitation activity, preselected images of and 10 were unmarried and in a sexual relationship.
different contraceptive methods were shown one by one Seventeen participants were rural to urban migrants, 16 of
to each participant, followed by the same basic prompts whom lived in Phnom Penh and one lived in Siem Reap
that were used for each image: ‘Do you know about this City. One participant had impaired vision, so we asked
type of contraception?’ Follow-up questions were: ‘Are you about her knowledge of the different modern contracep-
currently using any contraceptive method?’ and ‘Why do tive methods instead of showing her the pictures. Another
you prefer this type of contraceptive method (modern/trad- participant had a physical disability and she used crutches
itional)?’ We also followed the participant’s lead as she for mobility support. Table 1 shows participants’ sociode-
talked about the images and gently asked questions and mographic characteristics.
used probes, always following the interview guide. The
selected images were deemed to be culturally and ethically
appropriate and no brand names were included [5,9,10]. Individual level of social ecological model
Information about the withdrawal method, a traditional Misconceptions about modern contraception
contraceptive method, was explored using the Khmer word The participants had concerns about perceived health side
for this method. effects, including headaches, vomiting and weight gain,
The photo-elicitation interviews were one-off and lasted with the use of hormonal contraception such as oral
for 45–60 min. Thirty adolescent girls aged 16–19 years and contraceptive pills (OCPs), or heavy menstrual bleeding
women aged 20–27 years participated in the interviews. associated with the use of an intrauterine contraception
The participants were given a code to maintain their ano- device (IUCD).
nymity. Interviews were conducted until data saturation
My friend told me some people had headaches after they used
was achieved [11]. All participants were given an opportun- pills. I will choose the natural way. My boyfriend uses pull out
ity for member checking so that they could inspect the [withdrawal method] and it is ok.
final interview transcript before the researchers began for-
P12, 20 years, sexually active
mal qualitative data analyses [17]; however, only three
women requested their transcript be sent to them for My cousin told me if I use the pill wrongly I would have some
complications.
member checking.
Rigour was ensured by pilot testing the interview guide, P17, 23 years, married
integrating the photo-elicitation method into the interview If I use the coil [IUCD] it would also have some complications.
and using a maximum variation purposeful sampling strat- For example, if it does not work well with me, I would
egy to select adolescent girls and women who were single, experience pain and bleeding … and get thinner. These are
married or sexually active in a union [16,17]. A quality con- the problems.
trol check was conducted on six (20%) randomly selected P17, 23 years, married
interview transcripts by back translation of the six English
Some women believed that the IUCD was a ‘foreign
language transcripts into Khmer and checking the tran-
object’ that caused injuries inside women’s bodies or it
scription quality by listening to the audiotapes by an inde-
floated inside their abdomen. These fears were reinforced
pendent senior female Cambodian transcriptionist.
by the negative experiences of a friend or family member.
After the interviews were transcribed and translated into
English, the first author read the transcriptions several I don’t like the coil [IUCD] inside me. [I’m] not interested
times and classified the data into various categories and because I am afraid it is unsafe. It can get out in my body. It
will go out in my stomach and I will not be able to eat, [I will]
codes [17,18]. The researchers performed an inductive the- get thin and it will make holes in my stomach, so I don’t want
matic analysis of the data manually using the reduction to use it.
and transformation of data technique, which included tar-
P16, 22 years, married
geted selection and transformation of data in the interview
transcriptions [17,18]. Bronfenbrenner’s social ecological
model was adapted as the theoretical framework to cat- Fear of infertility. Participants feared the loss of fertility,
egorise the themes that emerged at the three levels (indi- which was explicitly associated with hormonal contracep-
vidual, microenvironment and macroenvironment) affecting tion including OCPs and injections.
Table 1. Participants’ sociodemographic characteristics.
Age Place of Migrant from Current contraceptive method used/desire for
Participant no. (years) residence province Education status Job description Relationship status future contraception
P1–P5 19 Phnom Penh No 1st year university Full-time student Single Subdermal implant in future, if in a steady
17 Year 11 relationship, or condoms
18 Year 12 (part-time
beautician)
16 Year 10
18 Year 11
P6 23 Phnom Penh No Bachelor’s degree Junior manager Sexually active since 14 years Withdrawal method (fear of using OCPs)
of age
P7 26 Phnom Penh Kratie Year 6 Garment factory Married (1 month) Not using any contraception
worker
P8 24 Phnom Penh Prey Veng Year 5 Shopkeeper Married (3 years) OCPs after an unintended pregnancy
1 child aged 2 years
P9 25 Phnom Penh Kandal Year 6 Garment factory Married (6 years) Withdrawal method
worker 1 child aged 5 years OCPs started after first baby (unintended
pregnancy)
P10 19 Phnom Penh Kampong Cham 1st year university Full-time student Sexual partner for 4-6 months Withdrawal method
Subdermal implant in future
P11 17 Phnom Penh Prey Vihear 1st year university Full-time student Single Subdermal implant in future
P12 20 Phnom Penh Kampong Cham 2nd year university Full-time student Sexually active for 3-4 months Withdrawal method
P13 25 Phnom Penh Kratie Year 12 Housewife Married (7 years) Withdrawal method
1 child aged 5 years Subdermal implant not available
P14 20 Phnom Penh Takeo 2nd year university Part-time shop Single –
worker
P15 27 Phnom Penh Kratie Year 12 Part-time shop Married (8 years) Withdrawal method
worker 2 children aged 6 and OCPs started after second baby (unintended
3.5 years pregnancy)
P16 22 Phnom Penh Preah Vihear Bachelor’s degree Administrative Married (1 month) Withdrawal method and calendar method
assistant
P17 23 Siem Reap No Year 8 Housewife Married (4 years) Withdrawal method
Province 1 child aged 1 year
P18 24 Siem Reap Preah Vihear Year 7 Housewife Married (5 years) OCPs started after second baby (unintended
Province 2 children aged 4 and pregnancy)
1.5 years
P19 26 Phnom Penh No Year 7 Part-time shop Married (7 years) Withdrawal method
worker 2 children aged 6 and 2 years OCPs started after second baby (unintended
pregnancy)
P20 25 Phnom Penh Kandal Bachelor’s degree Government Married (2 months) Withdrawal method
Visual impairment officer
(blindness)
P21 24 Phnom Penh Kandal Bachelor’s degree Disability Married (2 years) OCPs
Physical disability (uses services
crutches) officer
P22 23 Siem Reap No Bachelor’ degree Teacher Married (1 month) Withdrawal method
P23 22 Phnom Penh Takeo Year 5 Garment factory Widow Withdrawal method
worker Now engaged and sexually
active
P24 20 Phnom Penh Preah Vihear Year 10 Shop worker Sexually active Withdrawal method
P25 21 Phnom Penh No Year 12 Family business Single –
worker
THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CONTRACEPTION & REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE
(continued)
4 F. RIZVI ET AL.
Modern contraception includes SARC methods: OCPs for continued monthly use, progestin-only pills, emergency contraception pill (morning-after pill), hormonal injectables and condoms; LARC methods: IUCDs and subdermal implants;
Current contraceptive method used/desire for changes. They tell me women cannot have a baby afterwards. I
already decided not to use it.
P6, 23 years, sexually active
Withdrawal method
Withdrawal method their husbands were using the withdrawal method. These
women had already heard about OCPs from the health
care staff at their pre- and postnatal visits to the health
centres.
My husband told me about it [withdrawal method]. He wants
Traditional contraception includes behavioural methods (such as withdrawal or coitus interruptus, abstinence and the calendar rhythm method) and other folk methods (including herbs). this. My second baby was born early … [I] did not want it
then. After my second baby, I got information about OCPs and
now I am using pills.
Sexually active
Sexually active
Sexually active
manager
Programme
worker
Telecoms
seller
Currently completing
not 100% effective, but you have to really trust your partner.
master’s degree
Year 5
and non-reversible, permanent modern contraceptive methods: female and male sterilisation.
Prey Veng
No
Phnom Penh
Phnom Penh
Phnom Penh
Place of
25
18
19
19
or pharmacies.
Related to unmarried women, it is shameful to buy, because if
P27
P28
P29
P30
[judgement] from the pharmacy. They will think badly of her. autonomy to make choices about SRH and contraception;
But, if they [women] are married, it is normal to buy it. culturally restricted access to modern contraception, espe-
P1, 19 years, single cially among unmarried, sexually active women; absence of
SRH education in schools; and non-availability of subdermal
Influence of health care workers. Five women received implants at health centres.
information about modern contraception during their preg- There were three main reasons why some participants
nancy when they attended pre- and postnatal check-ups. did not want to use modern contraception: poor SRH liter-
This reassurance by health care personnel motivated them acy associated with the utility and efficacy of modern
to begin using OCPs for contraception. contraceptive methods; limited access to modern contra-
I used to be afraid of it [OCPs] too, but after asking for advice ceptive methods due to social and cultural barriers and
from [the] health centre, they said there are no bad effects to taboos; and the short-term nature of sexual relationships,
our health at all. I went to see the doctor after [having] my baby. especially among unmarried women.
P9, 25 years, married Five participants switched from the withdrawal method
to OCPs after having an unintended pregnancy which
served as a wake-up call. This switch might also point
Macroenvironment level of social ecological model
towards their husband’s belated support for modern
SRH knowledge contraceptive use in order to avoid another unintended
All participants reported not receiving any formal informa- pregnancy. Previous research indicated that Cambodian
tion or counselling about SRH and contraception while at women aged 15-29 years were significantly more likely to
school or university, by staff in health centres or from their use modern contraceptive methods after having an unin-
mother or another female family member. tended pregnancy [1].
Withdrawal is a traditional contraceptive method that
They don’t have enough education about that … In school
the teachers just don’t educate us about it because they are
has a high failure rate, resulting in unintended pregnancy,
shy. And women themselves feel ashamed of getting all this unsafe abortion or sexually transmitted infection [20–25].
information and education, so they don’t have it. Most women in our study knew that the withdrawal
P22, 23 years, married
method was not 100% effective in preventing pregnancy,
but they were not involved in the decision-making process
Sources of information about contraceptive methods. in choosing a contraceptive method; instead their husband
Study participants who had completed at least years 10–12 or partner made the decision. Two studies in Cambodia
of high school were quite familiar with accessing social reported a threefold increased likelihood of Cambodian
media and all had smart phones with internet connections. women using effective, modern contraception if their hus-
bands wanted a smaller family [26,27].
I searched for all this information from newspapers, magazines,
TV and social media, because they use this to increase
information [about contraception] to people.
Differences and similarities in relation to other studies
P2, 17 years, single
Almost half of the participants in our study were migrants
I don’t think they [young women] would go to a pharmacist, who had moved to Phnom Penh and Siem Reap Province
because they are really embarrassed. They would absolutely go
online [and] try to search for the information.
with their husband after marriage. These women had lim-
ited access to nearby SRH services and effective counselling
P5, 18 years, single by health care personnel about modern contraception.
Thus, young Cambodian women face a number of per-
Desire to use subdermal implants sonal, social and financial challenges accessing SRH services
Nine participants (four single, four sexually active in a owing to the rapid rural to urban migration and industrial-
union, one married) expressed a desire to use subdermal isation [3,7,27]. Cultural barriers also play a significant role
implants as a long-acting reversible contraceptive (LARC) in limiting a young woman’s access to modern contracep-
method in the future because of the implants’ longevity tive methods, especially if she is unmarried [6,7].
(3–5 years) and hormonal dose. Previous studies have pointed towards young
Cambodian women’s limited autonomy to insist on safe
I checked for it [subdermal implant], but they were not
[available] at the pharmacy. sex and condom use from their male partner or husband
[26,28]. Our findings are consistent with the existing litera-
P27, 25 years, sexually active
ture that there is a dearth of person-centred SRH and
There [are] a lot of pills. Anything you take there’s going to be contraceptive counselling for the many modern methods
a side effect. But I checked online for it [subdermal implant]. I of contraception (both short-acting [SARC] and LARC meth-
wanted to have it [so that] I [would] not need to ask [my]
ods) available to women in Cambodia. In Cambodia, ado-
boyfriend to use condoms, but it is not [available] anywhere.
lescent girls and women under 30 years of age are a
P30, 19 years, sexually active vulnerable group when they become sexually active.
Discussion
Relevance of the findings: implications for clinicians
Findings and interpretation and policy-makers/health care providers
The main themes that emerged from the data include: fear We recommend a multipronged national SRH literacy pro-
of the side effects of modern contraceptives; low personal gramme in Cambodia to educate men and women, with a
6 F. RIZVI ET AL.
countries using demographic and health surveys. BMC Reprod non-users of hormonal contraceptive methods in
Health. 2019;16:1–15. Pursat Province, Cambodia. Women Health. 2011;51(3):
[25] Dude A, Neustadt A, Martins S, et al. Use of withdrawal and 256–278.
unintended pregnancy among females 15–24 years of age. [28] Lai S-L, Tey N-P. Contraceptive use in Cambodia: does house-
Obstet Gynecol. 2013;122(3):595–600. hold decision-making power matter? Cult Health Sex. 2020;
[26] Ung M, Boateng GO, Armah FA, et al. Negotiation for safer sex 22(7):778–793.
among married women in Cambodia: the role of women’s [29] Chandra-Mouli V, Plasons M, Barua A, et al. Adolescent sexual
autonomy. J Biosoc Sci. 2014;46(1):90–106. and reproductive health and rights: a stock-taking and call-to-
[27] Samandari G, O’Connell KA. “If we can endure, we continue”: action on the 25th anniversary of the ICPD. Sex Reprod Health
understanding differences between users, discontinuers, and Matters. 2019;27(1):336–339.