Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Asma Yousaf
BS. English
Asma Yousaf
Student ID: 13174-D
BS English
Department of English
DEDICATION
TO MY BELOVED PARENTS
Acknowledgment
Allah the Almighty bestows His greatest grace upon me in completing this great
task of my life. I want to pay thanks to my supervisor, Miss Naina Shezeen for sharing
her vision, experience, insight, kind guidance positive comments and constructive
criticism.
My deepest thanks to my friends, whose benevolence and affection help and love
proved a great deal in undertaking this endeavor and without them nothing would be
possible. They always motivate me to complete the task in a specified span of time.
Various obstacles were removed by them and they were sending me positive vibes
Asma Yousaf
1
Approval Certificate
This is to certify that the dissertation submitted by Miss Asma Yousaf, is of sufficient standard to justify
its acceptance by Department of English, Qurtuba University of Science and Information Technology
Supervisor
External Supervisor
1.
Dr.
2.
Dr.
2
Abstract
The paper aims to investigate Tariq Rahman's short story "The Bingo" under the shadow of
Postcolonial theory. Postcolonial theory tells the readers about how colonized people started
resistance against the colonizers and how their efforts were fruitful. The paper points out
various aspects of postcolonial theory with the aim to help out the future researchers. The study
is carried out with a careful scrutiny of the meanings and answers of the questions posed in the
introduction part. Furthermore, the paper aims to decode the complexities of the postcolonial
theory with a detailed literature review chapter that would help the readers to understand the
meaning of the theory and the way it is applied on Tariq Rahman's short story "The Bingo".
3
Chapter 1
Introduction
It is critical academic study of culture political, and economic legacy of colonialism and
imperialism, focusing on impact of human control and exploit of un colonized people their ands.
post colonialism involves discussion of experience such as slavery, migration, suppression, and
resistance difference, race gender as well as response to discounts of imperial Europe such as
A growing concern among post. colonialism critics has also been with racial minorities in west,
embracing, native, and African Americans in US, British Asian, and Africans Caribbeans in u.k.
In post -colonialism .it is according to Frantz fanon who develop the idea of other in his writing
This study seeks to consider how literature describe the other. The other by definition lack’s
In this sense he can described as foreign the one who doesn't speak given language, he is
To understand the concept of self and other the formalist approach is used which is an important
idea that helps the understand how meaning are beings shaped created in text.
4
In 19 century, British prime minister William Gladstone stated that justice delayed is justice
denied.
His adage contain unconscious irony, given glad stones various leadership positions and
appointment within the government of largest colonizer and dealer of injustice to nonneutropenic
Post - colonial theory asks for justice. It seeks to speak to vast and horrific social and
It challenges the superiority of dominant western perspective and seeks to re-position and
The collapse of great European empires, their replacement by world economic hegemony of
united States ,the study erosion of nation state and of traditional geopolitical frontiers along with
mass global migration and creation of so called multicultural societies, the intensified
exploitation of ethnic groups within the west and peripheral societies elsewhere, the formidable
power of new transnational corporations all of this developed spaces since committed to re-dress
This study is carried out to find out the aspects of Postcolonialism in Tariq Rahman's story 'The
Bingo' using Postcolonial theory as the theoretical framework. The researcher focused
To find out Postcolonial aspects in the short story "The Bingo" by Tariq Rahman
1. What aspects of Postcolonialism are present in Tariq Rahman's short story "The Bingo"?
This study will be conducted to find out aspects of Postcolonialism in Tariq Rahman's
short story. It will be a crucial study as little to no work has been done on Pakistani writers'
literary texts. The researcher hopes that this study will fill a required gap in the field of research
Though Postcolonial study is a vast area to explore, it still leaves a gap and this study will
be delimited to only postcolonial perspective. There will be many areas to explore for the future
researchers.
6
Chapter 2
Literature Review
Rao (2013) writes that 'Postcolonialism and globalization: Towards a historicization of their
inter-relation'
Simon During Cultural Studies. This article distinguishes between critical and reconciliatory
postcolonialisms, arguing that the former seeks radical alternatives to modernity based on non-
Western traditions and lifeways, while the latter works to reconcile colonized peoples to
colonialism. It argues further that the category of globalization has, for the most part, superseded
that of 'postcolonialism' and that critical postcolonialism needs to be seen not simply as
globalization's enemy but (in part) as its effect. That is, globalization and critical postcolonialism
have a weakly dialectical relation, a case made by examining the recent Māori renaissance in
New Zealand. What are the implications of this way of thinking for history? By examining two
late eighteenth century texts, Ossian's poems and Sir William Chambers' 'A Dissertation on
Oriental Gardening', the article suggests that the histories of globalization and postcolonialism
Said’s Orientalism in 1978. The signal achievement of this work is its conceptualization of the
colonial encounter as entailing not only the physical violence of military conquest and economic
exploitation, but also an epistemic violence enacted by particular forms of knowledge tethered to
imperial power. Said named this cognitive dimension of Western imperialism ‘Orientalism’—a
7
term that he defines in three ways at the outset of the eponymously named book. In its most
obvious sense, Orientalism names a field of academic enquiry encompassing anyone who
teaches, writes about, or researches the ‘Orient’. Second, Orientalism is a ‘style of thought’
based upon an ontological and epistemological distinction made between ‘the Orient’ and ‘the
Occident’. In this sense, Orientalism names a Western tendency to dichotomize the world into a
series of us/them contrasts and to essentialize the resultant ‘other’, so that the backward, savage,
Manichean opposition of civilizational proportions. Third, from the late eighteenth century
onwards, ‘Orientalism can be discussed and analyzed as the corporate institution for dealing with
the Orient—dealing with it by making statements about it, authorizing views of it, describing it,
by teaching it, settling it, ruling over it: in short, Orientalism as a Western style for dominating,
restructuring, and having authority over the Orient’ (Said 1985: 2-‐3). As such, Orientalism
articulates a relationship of knowledge to power that is both instrumental (to rule them you have
to know them) and constitutive, producing the putative reality (the ‘Orient’) that it describes.
Enabled by the brute material superiority of European imperial power, the production of
Masood (2019) ponders that Postcolonialism is the critical academic study of the cultural,
political and economic legacy of colonialism and imperialism, focusing on the impact of human
control and exploitation of colonized people and their lands. More specifically, it is a critical
8
theory analysis of the history, culture, literature, and discourse of (usually European) imperial
power.
He further goes on to say that Postcolonialism encompasses a wide variety of approaches, and
theoreticians may not always agree on a common set of definitions. On a simple level, through
anthropological study, it may seek to build a better understanding of colonial life—based on the
assumption that the colonial rulers are unreliable narrators—from the point of view of the
colonized people. On a deeper level, postcolonialism examines the social and political power
relationships that sustain colonialism and neocolonialism, including the social, political and
cultural narratives surrounding the colonizer and the colonized. This approach may overlap with
studies of contemporary history, and may also draw examples from anthropology,
of postcolonial studies examine the effects of colonial rule on the practice of feminism,
Rukundwa and Aarde (2007) write that Postcolonial theory formulates its critique around the
social histories, cultural differences and political discrimination that are practiced and
postcolonial critique is concerned with the history of colonialism “only to the extent that history
has determined the configurations and power structures of the present.” Postcolonial critique also
as the source and inspiration of its politics. Postcolonial critique can be defined as a dialectical
discourse which broadly marks the historical facts of decolonization. It allows people emerging
from socio-political and economic domination to reclaim their sovereignty; it gives them a
9
negotiating space for equity. A number of theorists share this view, including Kenyatta
(1996:1-5); Dube (1996); Segovia (2000:11-34) and Punt (2001, 2003). However, anti-colonial
movements are not uniform. Many of them are contextually confined, although drawn together,
and their heterogeneous principles form a postcolonial theory. Moreover, disciplines do overlap
and contradictions are inescapable. This is particularly true when postcolonial theory draws more
of its material from other disciplines and activities in a given context (cf Segovia 1999:111-113;
“threatens privileges and power” (Young 2003:7) by rejecting and challenging the superiority of
some cultures over others. Its priority is to administer equality and justice to people. According
experiences of oppression and struggles for freedom after the “tricontinental”3 awakening in
Africa, Asia and Latin America: the continents associated with poverty and conflict. Postcolonial
criticism focuses on the oppression and coercive domination that operate in the contemporary
world (Young 2001:11). The philosophy underlying this theory is not one of declaring war on the
past, but declaring war against the present realities which, implicitly or explicitly, are the
neocolonialism and its agents (international and local) that are still enforced through political,
Barker, Hulme, and Iverson (1996) write that the issues of colonialism and imperialism have
recently come to the forefront of thinking in the humanities. Disciplines such as history,
literature and anthropology are taking stock of their extensive and usually unacknowledged
legacy of Empire. At the same time, contemporary cultural theory has had to respond to post-
10
colonial pressure, with its different registers and agendas. This volume ranges, geographically,
from Brazil to India and South Africa, from the Andes to the Caribbean and the USA. This range
the very idea of the" postcolonial" itself. Contributors include Annie Coombes, Simon During,
Peter Hulme, Neil Lazarus, David Lloyd, Anne McClintock, Zita Nunes, Benita Parry, Graham
Pechey, Mary Louise Pratt, Renato Rosaldo and Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak.
Carey and Festa (2009) say that over the last thirty years, postcolonial critiques of European
imperial practices have transformed our understanding of colonial ideology, resistance, and
cultural contact. The Enlightenment has played a complex but often unacknowledged role in this
discussion, alternately reviled and venerated as the harbinger of colonial dominion and avatar of
liberation, as target and shield, as shadow and light. This volume brings together two arenas-
eighteenth-century studies and postcolonial theory-in order to interrogate the role and reputation
interrogations of Western imperial aspirations. With essays by leading scholars in the field,
Postcolonial Enlightenment address issues central not only to literature and philosophy but also
to natural history, religion, law, and the emerging sciences of man. The contributors situate a
range of writers-from Hobbes and Herder, Behn and Burke, to Defoe and Diderot-in relation
both to eighteenth-century colonial practices and to key concepts within current postcolonial
theory concerning race, globalization, human rights, sovereignty, and national and personal
identity. By enlarging the temporal and geographic framework through which we read, the
essays in this volume open up alternate genealogies for categories, events and ideas central to the
Sawant (2012) holds the view that The Post - colonial Literature and theory investigate what
happens when two cultures clash and one of them with accompanying ideology empowers and
deems itself superior to other. The Writers of Empire Writes Back use the term “‘post-colonial’
to cover all the culture affected by the imperial process from the moment of colonization to the
present day” (2). Post-colonialism marks the end of colonialism by giving the indigenous people
the necessary authority and political and cultural freedom to take their place and gain
independence by overcoming political and cultural imperialism. Postcolonial discourse was the
outcome of the work of several writers such as Aime Cesaire, Frantz Fanon, Ngugi WA Thiago,
Edward Said, Bill Ashcroft and his collaborators, Gayatri Spivak. The concept of post-
colonialism (or often postcolonialism) deals with the effects of colonization on cultures and
societies. The term as originally used by historians after the second World War such as ‘post-
colonial state’, where ‘post-colonial’ had a clearly chronological meaning, designating the post-
independence period. However, from the late 1970s the term has been used by literary critics to
discuss the various cultural effects of colonization. Although the study of the controlling power
of representation in the colonized societies had begun in the late 1970s with the text such as
Said’s Orientalism, and led to the development of what came to be called ‘Colonialist Discourse
Theory’ in the work of critics such as Spivak and Bhabha, the actual term ‘post-colonial’ was not
employed in these early studies of the power of colonialist discourse to shape the form and
opinion and policies in the colony and metropolis. “Postcolonialism”, in the words of Charles E.
Bressler, “is an approach to literary analysis that concerns itself particularly with literature
written in English in formerly colonized countries” (265). It usually excludes literature that
represents either British or American viewpoints, and concentrates on Writings from colonized
cultures in Australia, New Zealand, Africa, South America, and other places and societies that
12
were once dominated by European cultural, political and philosophical tradition. Although there
is little consensus regarding the proper content, scope and relevance of postcolonial studies, as a
critical ideology it has acquired various interpretations. Like deconstruction and other various
where even its spelling provides several alternatives. The critics are not in agreement whether the
term should be used with or without hyphen: I. e. ‘Post-colonial’ and ‘postcolonial’ have
suggested by phrases like ‘after colonialism’, ‘after independence’, ‘after the end of empire’
whereas the term ‘postcolonialism’ referring to all the characteristics of a society or culture from
Batool et al. (2021) write that their paper dealt with various narratological tachniques employed
Fauzia Janjua try to explain identity from different perspective in her words. She describe that
we are living in multiple world and there we have different identities based upon our culture ,
She also try to put light on different point of view on India and Pakistan culture based identity.
She also try to explain the Geo - political , situations from king to the present Pakistan that we
brought from India .she also concluded that literary writers are of influence and adolsence over
there leadership in particular in defining concept of that literature has help the concept of identity
and literary writers can help the construction of social ,culture and personal identities .
13
Jaweria munir umt Lahore she can apply three stage model of post - structuralist ,deconstructive
process , as proposed by Barry 2002 on literary text short story Tariq rehman ( the bingo) .
1. verbal stage
At the verbal stage she says that contradictory words are selected which shows isolation and sub
2. Textual stage
3. Linguistic stage
The surface meaning of short story is called into question and found as contradictory to
hidden meaning.
They were not slaves it seemed , he took his paw in his big hand. At surface level the narrator
shows his disliking for bingos but at deeper level he creates a sort of affection and responsible
Chapter 3
Research Methodology
Postcolonial theory and approach is one of the analysis undertaken for the paper. In this
approach, similar and dissimilar ideas and concepts are seen in unparallel positions of the subject
and the masters i.e. marginal and centre‘s tension. For the purpose, theoretically, structural point
of view and structuralism, in which, things, ideas and concepts are in binary opposition where
one point is identified by the help of other angles. But this structural frame is further decoded
The research will be conducted in Qualitative manner. The theoretical framework that will be
used is Postcolonial theory. It will be used as a sieve and the short story The Bingo will be
examined through this framework. Culture hegemony :As Marxist logic ,social authority
examinations the capacities of financial course inside the base and superstructure ,from from
which gramsci created the capacities of social course inside the social structures made for and by
social mastery.within the hone of dominion ,social authority happens when the working and the
laborer classes accept and acknowledge that the winning social standards of society practically
portrays the common arrange of things in society .In the war for position ,the working class
comprehensibility politically teach the working classes to see that the winning social standards
are not normal and unavoidable social conditions and to recognize that the social develops of
( state ,church ,and social strata ),the traditions ( custom and convention),and convictions
Social authority capacities by surrounding the worldview of the administering lesson ,and the
social and financial structures that encapsulate it, as fair, genuine and outlined for the advantage
of all,indeed in spite of fact that these structures may as it were advantage the administering
lasson . This kind of control is particular from run the show by constrain ,as in military
fascism ,since it permits the administering lesson to work out specialist utilizing the ' quiet '
The bunch that controls these teach controls the rest f society .culture authority s most
unequivocally showed when those ruled by prevailing gather come to accept that the financial
and social conditions of their society are common and inescapable ,instead of made by
individuals with a vested intrigued in specific,social ,financial ,and political orders .Gramsci
created the concept of social authority in an exertion to clarify why the worker _ led revolution
that marx anticipated within the past century had not come to pass. Central to Marx's hypothesis
of capitalism was the conviction that the devastation of this financial framework was built into
the framework itself since capitalism is introduced on the abuse of working lesson by the
administering lesson. Marx contemplated that laborers seem as it were take so much financial
abuse sometime recently they would rise up and oust the administering lesson .Be that as it
Chapter 4
Text : we are reached the academic gates and were told that we are third .Tajassur seemed so
tired that cadet sergeant sent us to rest after rifle cleaning the fraud .he passed out 20 in course
and I bet it , it was all because of all his wonderful oral expression in English and wit he read
his lesson half an hour before the model discussion and co- gent arguments .he was liked but our
immature platoon_ mates and they thought he was a good sort. Post colonialism apply on the
text . We are under the control of Europeans and greatly impressed by their language English .so
Hegemony: Hegemony term social authority determine from the old Greek word
hegemonia ,which demonstrate the administration and the regime of the hegemon. In political
science ,authority is the geopolitical dominance worked out by realm by the risk of Mediation ,an
Gramsci investigation of authority hence includes an examination of the ways in which such
capitalist thoughts are spread and acknowledged as commonsensical and typical.A hegemonic
course is one that's able to achieve the assent of other social powers ,and the maintenance of this
assent is a progressing venture. To secure this assent requires a bunch to get it it's claim interface
in connection to the mode of generation ,as well as the inspiration, yearnings ,and
17
interface of other bunches. Beneath capitalism, Gramsci watched the persistent commitment of
the teach of gracious society to the forming of mass cognitions. By means of this concept of the
national popular, he too appeared how authority required the verbalization and conveyance of
One of the foremost broad application of Gramsci’s conception of authority has been to the
investigation of worldwide relations and universal political economy ,by means of the so - called
translational verifiable realism .Researcher inside this convention have been cautious to
recognize their extend from the way authority has been utilized inside standard realist universal
relations ,or IR worldwide relations .In state centered IR examination authority indicates the
presence inside the universal framework of overwhelming state or group of states. Within
hegemon (Britain within the 19 century and the joined together states after 1945) creates patterns
of steadiness inside the worldwide framework. The hegemon includes a self-interest within the
conservation of framework and is, hence arranged to endorse the systems security with its
military might
The transnational authentic realist school sees states as critical components of hegemonic orders
but partners authority with the financial, political and social structures that encourage specific
These world orders work through the proliferation of rules and standards, numerous of which are
given authenticity through universal organization and educate and of which the foremost vital
Worldwide educate or hence seen as either conduits for the legitimation of specific
thoughts and social strengths. In this way, for occurrence, the hegemonic arrange of the 19
century was guaranteed by teach such as gold standard and standards such as free exchange, a
well by British military control and worldwide reach of the British imperium.
Text: Pakistan was not created to be a slave colony Bengal was treated as colony by the cusp
officers. The army officers made fun of our men and beat them. Hegemony apply on the text.
after making colonies ruled the eastern people where they settled. After it they tortured their
Mimicry: progressively vital term in post - colonial hypothesis, since it has come to portray
the irresolute relationship between colonizer and colonized. when colonial talk empower the
colonized subject to' mimic ‘the colonizer, by embracing the colonizer's social propensities,
suspicions, teach and values, the result is never a basic propagation of those characteristics. The
result may be a blurred copy of the colonizer that can be very debilitating.
Typically, mimicry is never exceptionally distant from joke, since it can show up to spoof
anything it mirrors. mime mimicry finds a split within the certainty of colonial dominance an
instability in its control of the conduct of the colonized. Mimicry has frequently been an
unmistakable objective of royal policy. For occurrence, Ruler Macaulay's 1835 diminutive to
parliament disparaged oriental learning, and supported the generation of English craftsmanship
The term mimicry has been vital role in Homie Bhabha’s see of the indecision of colonial talk.
For him, the result of recommendations like Macaulay's is that mimicry is the method by which
19
the colonized subject is replicated as' almost the same but not quite ' .The replicating of the
colonizing culture ,conduct ,conduct and values by the colonized contains both joke and a certain
' menace ' , so that mimicry is at once likeness and menace .mimicry reveals the impediment
within the specialist of colonial talk ,nearly as in spite of the fact that colonial specialist
definitely encapsulates the seeds of the possess destruction. The line of plummet of the ' mimic
man' that rises in Macaulay's composing claims Bhabha, can be followed through the works of
Kipling, Forster, Orwell and Naipaul, and s the impact of ' an imperfect colonial mimesis in
which to be Anglicized is decidedly not to be English. The results of this for post - colonial
Mimicry is regularly seen as something despicable, and dark or brown individual locks in
mimicry is as a rule disparaged by other individual of his or her gather for doing so. There are
very a number of colloquial insuperable that allude to mimicry, such as coconut - to depict a
brown individual who carries on like he is white or "Oreo “, which is the same but as rule
connected to dark individual. Connected in turn around, term that's now and then utilized is
wigger. Though mimicry could be exceptionally vital concept in considering approximately the
relationship between colonizing and colonized people groups, and numerous individuals have
verifiably been criticized as imitates or mimicry men, it is curiously that nearly no one ever
There is another, much more clear way in which mimicry can really be subversive or engaging
when it includes the replicating of ' western' concepts of equity, flexibility flexibility, and the run
the show of law .one sees an illustration of this in foresters’ entry to India, with a generally
minor character named Mr. Amritrao, legal counselor from Calcutta, whom the British Anglo
20
Indians fear. They fear him not since he is out of line in fact, what is debilitating around him is
accurately the reality that he has learned sufficient of the standards of British law to realize that
those standards ought to, in all decency apply to Indians as much as to British. As a foreign
educated, Engle English talking Indian attorney in colonial India, he can be derided as mimic
man' or a babu, but it may be that mockery covers over a cautious fear that the British lawful
The illustration of Amritrao on forester’s novel might lead to broader political dialog numerous
anti- colonial patriot developments on Asia and Africa developed out of what may well be
thought of as mimicry of western political thoughts. The student of history Partha Chatterjee
patriotism adjusted to the Indian setting. The subsidiary thoughts of equity, popular, govern
government, and equality, as they were utilized by activists, tended to induce adjusted to nearby
culture. The individual who did this best was Mohandas k. Ghandi. Ghani took symbols of
Indian monkish life and straight forwardness alongside dynamic western concepts of
communism and utilized that unused combination of thoughts to mobilize the masses of standard
indians, most of whom had small coordinate contact with British. Through Gandhi, Indian
I'm spite of the fact mimicry is nearly Continuously utilized in postcolonial ponders with
reference to colonials and worker minorities copying white social and etymological standards.
Text: There was no hurry no protocol and no fiction. They had soft, cute childlike smiles. They
spoke a bit of Urdu and Amina knew a little English too. Mimicry apply on text: we try to copy
21
the Britishers, their culture and language also. This act is clearly seemed in above language that
Indian personality and colonialism sociohistorical perspective it has a rule been the privilege of
social researcher and history specialists to study the cascading impact of social alter in Asian
nations and cultures such as India and Japan, counting the energetic intuitive of
traditional ,westernizing and modernizing impacts .In spite of the fact that this wider perspective
on the elements of social alter fundamental our understanding might require a complementary
examination in depth of individual caught within the whirling vortexes of alter .it is the issue of
evolving psychoanalytic brain research of social alter pertinent to the Indian and Japanese
Government and colonialism are not as it were related to troops and attacking lands but they are
related to the social and social affect that colonizer made on the colonized community. This
effect can be seen indeed after the flight of attacking troops. This affect is not as it were money
related and military but it covers the social angles of the lives of colonized country. After the
takeoff of the colonizer, he take off his convictions way to life, social way, morals dialect and
political speculation that attack each person portion of the character of colonized country.
One of the most variable that are related to post-colonial affect is hybridity. I hybridity speaks to
colonial affect that comes about in separating and dividing the colonized character, culture and
philosophy. This affect makes an interesting blend between two societies to be specific, eastern
22
and western societies. hybridity speaks to western colonial culture that distorted the national
Homi Bhabha essential adjustment of term was his explanation " sign taken for wonders " in
which he depict hybridity as suppressive gadget through which colonized individual can
challenge the abuse of colonizer .it is worth specifying that hybridity incorporates a definition
that portrays the individual of colonized lands who have a double personality it can be
characterized as western eastern social clash that came out of long time of colonialism and
Text: And we sat in jeep and went away. Nothing mattered here Taj Assur and his mother were
no longer alive to accuse me. Bangladesh was free and Pakistan army was surrender.
Apply on text: British left Pakistan and Bangladesh in identity crisis by dividing them into
different states.
Text: I admire the courage of John Nicolson and Sir Hugh rose in 1857, he said yes, sir the
battle account is inspiring said major dost Muhammad the second in command.
Sir the viewing too are brave said major Azhar Khan one of company commander " yes, yes that
Apply on text. Muslims Hindus and British worked together in any field but Muslims were
considered inferior and British were superior because they proved themselves more civilized.
23
References
448.
https://postcolonial.net/2019/04/what-is-postcolonial-studies/
Rukundwa, L. S., & Van Aarde, A. G. (2007). The formation of postcolonial theory. HTS
Barker, F., Hulme, P., & Iverson, M. (Eds.). (1996). Colonial discourse/postcolonial theory.
Carey, D., & Festa, L. (Eds.). (2009). The postcolonial enlightenment: Eighteenth-century