yp
ANNEX A
OSAL
SAMPLE ACTION RESEARCH PROP!
“Mental Models: Ald In Improving Reading De atalades
of Grado 6 Struggling Reader
| CONTEXT AND RATIONALE
lives, Pe
Reading Is a life-long process and It Is a part of our daily People
read elther for entertainment and pleasure or for in of knoe
and Information, In the leaching ~ leaming process, rede fe i a ie
role to leamers, if leamers do not have the reading 5} Kills, ine Ee - ie ! by
them to comprehend Ideas and concepts. The Departmen a ae 105
given focus on the development of reading skills among ee omer,
through IIs varlous reading enhancement programs. Varlous Z ni oe and
workshops on reading have been undertaken fo equip teac! ie wit the
necessary skills In teaching reading fo the leamers, However, despite the
efforts to Improve the reading skills of the learners, recent results of the
reading Inventories show high percentage of non-readers and frustrated
readers among the leamers as revealed by the standardized fool known
as Philippine Informal Reading Inventory (Phil-IRI).
In SDO Masbate Province, the Identified learners under frustration leve
during the Phil - iRI tes! In June 2019 reached as high as 15, 879. The data
indicated alarming state of reading abilities of most of the leamers. This
scenario Is not only true to Masbate but similar challenge is confronting all
other parts of the country specially In public schools.
During the SY 2019-2020 in Masagana Elementary School, the Phil-l®!
fest result of Grade 6 class showed that only 6 out of 35 pupils or 17%
scored 14 and above In the Group Scteening Test (GST) in English; which
means that only 6 are independent readers while 7 out of 35 or 20% is
instructional level and 22 out of 35 pupils or 63% are at frustration level.
The result Is alarming considering that they are already in Grade 6 and
are not yet reading at their grade level. Nevertheless, If the problem Is no!
given due and Immediate action, the problem would affect pupils’ leaming
and level of achievement in other subject areas due to thelr very limited!
lack of reading comprehension skills. They are having difficulty in learning
38yr 7
the lessons of the different learning areas since comprehension skill is
needed in all subjects.
These circumstances can be narrowed down fo the lack of
comprehension among the leamers in the frustration level, Though learners
canread fluently, they are finding difficulties in grasping Ideas and concepts
about what they are reading. And these problems need Immediate action
for these greatly affect the transfer of learning. Reading and comprehension
are very significant fo one another.
Comprehension is the essence of reading and it is an active Process
of constructing meaning from a passage or a text (Durkin, 1993), Thus,
comprehension is very significant among leamers for the pursuit of
knowledge. There is a relationship between reading comprehension and
reading strategies. Reading strategies affects teading comprehension,
reading comprehension affects reading strategies (Muijselaar, et al, 2015),
Kelly (2019) emphasized also that the importance of teading
comprehension cannot be understated. According to Kelly (2019), effective
reading strategies that would help develop the reading comprehension
skills of the leamers include generating questions before reading and
answering It after the reading process, reading aloud and monitor,
Promoting cooperative talk, giving attention to text structure, taking notes or
annotate texts to create vocabulary list, using context clues, using graphic
organizers, practicing PQ4R Method (Preview, Question, Read, Reflect, Recite
and Review, summarizing and monitoring their understanding.
With the seven strategies that may contribute to a successful reading
comprehension, visualizing is considered as one. Visualizing which may
be in the form of images, pictures, drawings, videos or models. Thus, the
Use of mental models such as pictures can greatly contribute to the reading
comprehension of leamers. Mental models are visual representation
Consisting of both structure and process (a flow chart of sorts) that helps
4G student comprehend content knowledge. Leamers who are taught and
tained on developing mental models in mind are found to demonstrate
Much better understanding and comprehension.
Itis in this juncture that the proponent will conduct this action roe
Study entitled "Mental Models: Aid in Improving Reading Comprehen:
Of Grade 6 Struggling Readers”.
39RESEARCH QUESTION
This study aims to reduce the number of leamers In frustration Tead,
level from 22 to 0 In Grade 6 pupils of Masagana Elementary Scho
School Year 2019 - 2020 through teaching strategies using Mental Mode,
Specifically, it will seek answers to the following questions:
1. What teaching strategies can be applied In using the meni
Models to Improve the reading comprehension of the leamers j,
frustration reading level?
2. How do mental models improve comprehension?
3. How effective mental models are In reducing the number of Grade
6 learners under frustration reading level?
ll, PROPOSED INNOVATION, INTERVENTION AND STRATEGY
As an intervention to the emerging problem on the alarming number
‘of leamers in frustration level, this study will utilize Mental Models like
pictures and videos as aid on reading comprehension. The participants»
of the study will be subjected to a daily class session utilizing reading
Materials with picture-counterpart or video-counterparl for one hour during
schooldays to be facilitated by the teacher-researcher for 3 months. There
will be weekly reading assessments to be conducted using Phil-IRI tools in
order to measure the progress of the leamers. The weekly progress of the
readers in frustration level will be recorded using the Tracking of Weekly
Progress Template.
\V. ACTION RESEARCH METHODS
A Participants and/or Other Data Sources of Information
The twenty-two Grade 6 pupils of Masagana Elementary Scho
Whose reading abilities are at frustration level are the subjects of this
study. Their reading level is determined after the conduct of individud
Treading inventory pre-test using the standardized PhiI-IRI tools, Eact
pupil's word recognition level, teading speed and comprehension skis
are tested and measured. All of them were able to recognize the words
well having word reading scores of 90%-100% and able to read the
Passages alt varying speed. However, they failed in the comprehensio"
test which made their reading levels fall under frustration level garnering
comprehension scores of 58% and below.
>»3. Data Gathering Methods ' ’
This study will utilize a combination of quantitative {pre-experimental)
and qualitative research methods. To see the effect of the Intervention
which Is the use of mental models in teaching reading, the Phil-IR|
tool will be used before, during and after the duration, The results of
which will be tabulated and graphed to further Convey the effect. An
observation will also be conducted once a week in order to look into
the effect of the intervention in terms of learners’ behavior and class
participation. The researcher will request a co-teacher who could do
the observation using the tool that will be formulated by the researcher
which may include participation during class discussion, presentations
and other class engagements. The observer will be oriented on the
process ahead of time. Furthermore, a checklist of desired behavior will
be utilized fo objectively capture the improvement on the Performance
of the identified participants.
The researcher will also conduct an interview from randomly
selected participants of the study. Two Participants every week shall
be interviewed. This will be done in order to elicit opinions, feelings
and experiences from them. The data gathered will be utilized by the
researcher as a feedback mechanism that would help her in navigating
the flow of the study specially in the conduct of the teading session.
C Data Analysis Plan
The recorded raw scores using the Phil-IRI fools before, during
and after the intervention will be tabulated, graphed and analysed
quantitatively by the researcher. This will serve as the main measure of
the effectiveness of the use of mental models in reducing the number
of the identified struggling readers in the class,
However, the weekly interview to wo randomly selected participants
will be utilized in getting feedback as to the appropriateness of the
Strategy in addressing the problem. The responses also during interview
will be further used in the discussion of the final analysis of the study. The
data gathered though observation using the designed observation tool
Gnd observation checklist shall be also part of the progress monitoring
Of the intervention, The data will give the researcher a grasp of the effect
Intervention while the study is on process. This will also lead a
Some adjustments to the implementation of the intervention, whenever
Necessary,
4|
All the data gathered during observation, interview and Teadin,
assessment will be compared and Itangulated to surface the holistic
effect of the intervention to the teading abilities of the participants, they,
Classtoom behavior as well as the effect of the Intervention to the well.
being of the patiicipants as a reader,
D. ACTION RESEARCH WORK PLAN AND TIMELINES
The action research activities are outlined in the table below:
ST =
ACTIVITIES TARGET DATE | PERSONS INVOLVED,
PRE RESEARCH ACTIVITIES: Researcher
* Making of proposa! | June 2019 School Head
* Approval of proposal Schools Division
Research
Committee (SDRC)
RESEARCH ACTIVITES:
* Implementation of
the study July to Researcher
* Tabulation and Ocotober, Respondents
anaiysis of data 2019
* Interpretation of the
gathered data
* Preparation of the
research paper
POST RESEARCH ACTIVITIES:
* Printing of the
tesearch report November Researcher
* Submission of the 2019 Schools Division
fesearch report to the Research
Division Research Committee (SDRC)
Committee for review BERF committee
+ Submission of the
final copy
Table 1 Work Plan and TimelinesYr
ACTIVITES;
Making
Approval
RESEARCH
Impleme
analysis
tesearch
ACTIVITES.
par RISTARCH
the study
Tabulation and
Interpretation of the
gathered dala
Preparation of the
Month } Month
| 2
of proposal
of proposal
ACI
Ntatlon of
of data
Paper
Month | Month | Monit
$ 4 4
Month
6
ACTIVITIES:
POST RESEARCH
fesearch
Submis!
Printing of the
fesearch report to the
SDRC for review
Teport
lon of the
Submission of the
final copy
Table 2 Gani! Charl of Actio
n Research Activilles— COST ESTIMATES
ACTIVITIES RESOURCE NEEDED
Preparation and printing of Bond paper
tesearch proposal Internet connection
Printing of the reading Reproduction fee
Materials and other related
documents
Snacks/meals duting Interview | Food a
Printing and binding of Printing a -
completion results binding a ar
Travel Expenses (submission | Van and tricycle WW
of proposal and completion
report) —
Publication of research results | Journal Publication 4,000.00
fee
TOTAL 30,000.00
F. PLANS FOR DISSEMINATION AND UTILIZATION
The result of the study will be shared to fellow teachers during
School and District Leaming Action Cell sessions for possible adoption
of the strategy employed. To further disseminate the result of the study,
the researcher will Present the study in a research conference and
Publish it through reliable research joumal.
G. REFERENCES
Durkin, D. (1993), Teachin
ig them fo read (6th Ed). Boston: Allyn and
Bacon,
Kelly, M. (Updated January 16, 2019), 10
Strategies All Students Need. Wh
Comprehension Is Ne
Reading Comprehension
YY Addressing Reading
Cessary@htips://www.thoughtco.com
Muijselaar, M. M, L, & de Jong, P. F, (2015), Developmental Relations
Between Reading Comprehensi
Retrieved September 24, 2019 from
8438,2017.12787, 3.