&UtWLFDDR*DUDQWLVPR3HQDO

+LSHUEyOLFR0RQRFXODU
$QD3DXOD&RXWR
Advogada. Professora de Direito Processual Penal
na graduação e na pós-graduação da Universidade
Estácio de Sá. Especialista em Direito Processual Ci-
vil pela Universidade Veiga de Almeida. Especialista
em Direito Público e Direito Privado pela Escola da
Magistratura do Estado do Rio de Janeiro. Mestra
em Direito pela Universidade Estácio de Sá. Douto-
randa em Direito pela Universidade Estácio de Sá.

0DUFR&RXWR
Juiz de Direito do Tribunal de Justiça do Estado do
Rio de Janeiro. Ex-Promotor de Justiça no Ministé-
rio Público do Estado do Rio de Janeiro. Especialis-
ta em Direito Penal e Direito Processual Penal pela
Universidade Estácio de Sá. Mestre em Direito pela
Universidade Estácio de Sá. Doutorando em Direito
pela Universidade Estácio de Sá.

6XPiULR5HVXPR$EVWUDFW,QWURGXomR2*DUDQWLVPR
3HQDO,GHDOL]DGRSRU/XLJL)HUUDMROL2*DUDQWLVPR3HQDO,QWH
JUDO2*DUDQWLVPR3HQDO+LSHUEyOLFR0RQRFXODU&RQFOX
VmR5HIHUrQFLDV%LEOLRJUiILFDV
5(6802(VWHWUDEDOKRWHPFRPRREMHWRRJDUDQWLVPRSH
QDO3DXWDVHDLQYHVWLJDomRSHORVHJXLQWHSUREOHPDGHTXHIRUPD
RVRSHUDGRUHVGR'LUHLWRWrPHPEDVDGRDVVXDVWHVHVXWLOL]DQGRR
JDUDQWLVPRSHQDOLGHDOL]DGRSRU/XLJL)HUUDMROL"$ILPGHDQDOLVDU
HVVD TXHVWmR SURS}HVH FRPSDUDU R FKDPDGR JDUDQWLVPR SHQDO
LQWHJUDOHRFKDPDGRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOKLSHUEyOLFRPRQRFXODU$
MXVWLILFDWLYDSDUDHVWHWUDEDOKRGHFRUUHGRIDWRGHDDFDGHPLDQmR
SRGHUILFDUjPDUJHPGRTXHDFRQWHFHQDUHDOLGDGHIRUHQVH$SHV
TXLVDSRGHFRQWULEXLUSDUDRDYDQoRQDFRPSUHHQVmRVREUHRSDSHO

148 \R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \
GRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDO$PHWRGRORJLDGHSHVTXLVDXWLOL]DGDFRQVLVWH
QDDQiOLVHGRVGLVSRVLWLYRVOHJDLVHPYLJRUQR%UDVLOHGHWH[WRVGRX
WULQiULRVTXHDERUGDPRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDO2REMHWLYRGRWUDEDOKR
pGHPRQVWUDUDIRUPDFRPRRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOpLQGHYLGDPHQWH
LQYRFDGRQDSUiWLFDIRUHQVH2VUHVXOWDGRVGDSHVTXLVDLQGLFDPTXH
SDUWHGDGRXWULQDWHPFRQWULEXtGRSDUDHVVHGHVYLRGHRUGHPSUiWL
FD$FRQFOXVmRpQRVHQWLGRGHTXHSDUDHPEDVDUDVVXDVWHVHVQR
JDUDQWLVPRSHQDORVRSHUDGRUHVGR'LUHLWRGHYHPWHUPDLRUFRP
SURPLVVRFRPDVLGHLDVVXVWHQWDGDVSRU/XLJL)HUUDMROL
3$/$95$6&+$9(*DUDQWLVPRSHQDO,QWHJUDO+LSHU
EyOLFRPRQRFXODU
$%675$&77KLVZRUNKDVDVLWVREMHFWWKHSHQDOJXDUDQWHHV
WKHRU\7KHLQYHVWLJDWLRQLVEDVHGRQWKHIROORZLQJSUREOHPKRZ
KDYHOHJDOSUDFWLWLRQHUVEDVHGWKHLUWKHVLVRQWKHSHQDOJXDUDQWHHV
WKHRU\DVGHYLVHGE\/XLJL)HUUDMROL",QRUGHUWRDQDO\]HWKLVTXHV
WLRQDFRPSDULVRQEHWZHHQWKHVRFDOOHGLQWHJUDOSHQDOJXDUDQWHHV
WKHRU\ DQG WKH VRFDOOHG K\SHUEROLF PRQRFXODU SHQDO JXDUDQWHHV
WKHRU\LVSURSRVHG7KHMXVWLILFDWLRQIRUWKLVZRUNVWHPVIURPWKH
IDFWWKDWWKHDFDGHP\FDQQRWEHNHSWDSDUWIURPZKDWKDSSHQVLQ
IRUHQVLFUHDOLW\7KLVUHVHDUFKPD\FRQWULEXWHWRDGYDQFLQJWKHXQ
GHUVWDQGLQJRIWKHUROHRISHQDOJXDUDQWHHV7KHUHVHDUFKPHWKRGR
ORJ\XVHGFRQVLVWVRIWKHDQDO\VLVRIOHJDOSURYLVLRQVLQIRUFHLQ%UD
]LODQGWKHRUHWLFDOWH[WVWKDWDGGUHVVSHQDOJXDUDQWHHV7KHSXUSRVH
RIWKLVSDSHULVWRGHPRQVWUDWHKRZSHQDOJXDUDQWHHVDUHLPSURSHU
O\LQYRNHGLQIRUHQVLFSUDFWLFH7KHUHVXOWVRIWKLVUHVHDUFKLQGLFDWH
WKDWSDUWRIWKHGRFWULQHKDVFRQWULEXWHGWRWKLVSUDFWLFDOGHYLDWLRQ
7KHFRQFOXVLRQLVWKDWLQRUGHUWREDVHWKHLUWKHVLVRQWKHSHQDOJXD
UDQWHHVWKHRU\OHJDOSUDFWLWLRQHUVPXVWKDYHDJUHDWHUFRPPLWPHQW
WRWKHLGHDVVXSSRUWHGE\/XLJL)HUUDMROL
.(<:25'63HQDOJXDUDQWHHVWKHRU\,QWHJUDO+\SHUER
OLFPRQRFXODU

,1752'8d­2
$UHDOLGDGHIRUHQVHFULPLQDOWHPGHPRQVWUDGRGLDULDPHQ
WHR³HPSUHJR´GRFKDPDGRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOHPVLWXDo}HVEDV

\R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \ 149
WDQWHGLYHUVDVOHYDQGRVHDFUHUTXHWRGRVRVSHGLGRVIRUPXOD
GRVSHODVGHIHVDVSRGHPVHUHPEDVDGRVQDPHQFLRQDGDWHRULD
(PYHUGDGHDILUPDUTXHRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOWHPVLGR³HP
SUHJDGR´ QR GLD D GLD IRUHQVH FRQVLVWH HP YHUGDGHLUD IRUoD GH
H[SUHVVmR$ULJRURTXHVHSRGHDILUPDUVHPTXDOTXHUFKDQFH
GHHUURpTXHH[SUHVVLYDTXDQWLGDGHGHDGYRJDGRVHGHIHQVRUHV
S~EOLFRV WHP HPEDVDGR DV VXDV WHVHV QR JDUDQWLVPR SHQDO TXH
DFUHGLWDPH[LVWLURXQRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOTXHTXHUHPDFUHGLWDU
TXHH[LVWDVHPTXDOTXHUSUHRFXSDomRHPVHJXLURTXHYHUGDGHL
UDPHQWHIRLLGHDOL]DGRSRU/XLJL)HUUDMROL
1mRVmRUDURVRVFDVRVHPTXHSHGLGRVLQXVLWDGRVVmRIRU
PXODGRVFRPDDILUPDomRGHTXHGHYDPVHUGHIHULGRVHPUHVSHL
WRDRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOFRPRVHQXQFDVHSXGHVVHLQGHIHULUXP
SOHLWRGHIHQVLYRVHPGHVUHVSHLWRjPHQFLRQDGDWHRULD
&RPDFRODERUDomRGHSDUWHGDGRXWULQDTXHDWtWXORGHH[D
PLQDURJDUDQWLVPRSHQDODFDEDSRUVXVWHQWDUWHVHVTXHQHOHQmR
HQFRQWUDPIXQGDPHQWRPXLWRVDGYRJDGRVHGHIHQVRUHVS~EOLFRV
ILFDPHVWLPXODGRVDIRUPXODUVHXVSHGLGRVOHYDQGRHPFRQWDQmR
SURSULDPHQWHRHQVLQDPHQWRGH/XLJL)HUUDMROLPDVVLPDYLVmR
EDVWDQWHGLVWRUFLGDTXHDOJXQVDXWRUHVGHOHDSUHVHQWDP
e QHVVH FHQiULR TXH HVWH DUWLJR SUHWHQGH GHVHQYROYHU DV
VXDVLGHLDVEXVFDQGRGHPRQVWUDUTXHDFRQWULEXLomRGRJDUDQ
WLVPRSHQDOWDOFRPRLGHDOL]DGRpYHUGDGHLUDPHQWHLPSRUWDQWH
SDUDR'LUHLWRQmRVHQGRQHFHVViULRTXHVHH[WUDSROHPRVYHUGD
GHLURVOLPLWHVGDPHQFLRQDGDWHRULDSDUDHPSUHJiODHPVLWXD
o}HVLQFRPSDWtYHLVFRPDPHVPD

2*$5$17,6023(1$/,'($/,=$'2325/8,*,
)(55$-2/,
2GRXWULQDGRU/XLJL)HUUDMROLQRWDELOL]RXVHSHODWHRULDGR
JDUDQWLVPRSHQDOSRUHOHLGHDOL]DGDVHQGRFHUWRTXHDVXDPDLV
FRQKHFLGDREUDTXDOVHMD³'LUHLWRHUD]mRWHRULDGRJDUDQWLVPR
SHQDO´FXMDTXDOLGDGHWpFQLFDOKHJDUDQWHXPLQHJiYHOSUHVWtJLR

/XLJL)HUUDMROLQDVFHXHP)ORUHQoDQD,WiOLDHPGHDJRVWRGHWHQGRDWXDGRFRPRMXL]GHD
$SDUWLUGHIRLSURIHVVRUGH)LORVRILDGR'LUHLWRH7HRULD*HUDOGR'LUHLWRQD8QLYHUVLGDGHGH&DPHULQR
RQGHWDPEpPIRLGLUHWRUGD³)DFROWiGL*LXULVSUXGHQ]D´'HVGHOHFLRQDQD8QLYHUVLGDGHGH5RPD7UH

150 \R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \
DSURIXQGDDDQiOLVHVREUHTXHVW}HVSHQDLVHSURFHVVXDLVSHQDLV
FRPDVTXDLVRVRSHUDGRUHVGR'LUHLWRGLDULDPHQWHVHGHSDUDP
(YLGHQWHPHQWH D H[WHQVmR GHVWH DUWLJR QmR SHUPLWH XPD
DQiOLVHPDLVGHQVDGDWHRULDPHQFLRQDGDPDVpLPSRUWDQWHUHV
VDOWDUDOJXQVSULQFtSLRVQRVTXDLVDPHVPDVHHPEDVDDILPGH
TXH VH SRVVD RSRUWXQDPHQWH LQWHUSUHWDU TXHVW}HV FRWLGLDQDV
TXHPHUHFHPUHIOH[mRQHVWHPRPHQWR
1HVVH DVSHFWR FDEH UHJLVWUDU RV VHJXLQWHV SULQFtSLRV H[
SUHVVDPHQWH PHQFLRQDGRV SHOR DXWRU FRPR EDVH GH VXD WHRULD
 SULQFtSLR GD UHWULEXWLYLGDGH RX GD FRQVHTXHQFLDOLGDGH GD
SHQD HP UHODomR DR GHOLWR  SULQFtSLR GD OHJDOLGDGH QR VHQ
WLGR ODWR RX QR VHQWLGR HVWULWR  SULQFtSLR GD QHFHVVLGDGH RX
GDHFRQRPLDGR'LUHLWR3HQDOSULQFtSLRGDOHVLYLGDGHRXGD
RIHQVLYLGDGHGRHYHQWRSULQFtSLRGDPDWHULDOLGDGHRXGDH[
WHULRUL]DomR GD DomR  SULQFtSLR GD FXOSDELOLGDGH RX GD UHV
SRQVDELOLGDGH SHVVRDO  SULQFtSLR GD MXULVGLFLRQDULHGDGH QR
VHQWLGRODWRRXQRVHQWLGRHVWULWRSULQFtSLRDFXVDWyULRRXGD
VHSDUDomRHQWUHMXL]HDFXVDomRSULQFtSLRGR{QXVGDSURYD
RXGDYHULILFDomRHSULQFtSLRGRFRQWUDGLWyULRRXGDGHIHVD
RXGDIDOVHDELOLGDGH
([SRVWRVRVGH]SULQFtSLRVPHQFLRQDGRVpLPSRUWDQWHGHV
WDFDU DOJXQV SRQWRV TXH VHUmR ~WHLV QD FRPSUHHQVmR GD WHRULD
JDUDQWLVWD FRPR XP WRGR LPSHGLQGR TXH VHMDP IHLWDV DQiOLVHV
UDGLFDOPHQWHIDYRUiYHLVDRVLQGLFLDGRVRXDRVDFXVDGRVTXHHP
YHUGDGHQmRWrPUHVSDOGRQDVLGHLDVGH/XLJL)HUUDMROL
8PSULPHLURSRQWRDVHUGHVWDFDGRWUDWDGRUHFRQKHFLPHQ
WR IHLWR SHOR DXWRU GD QHFHVVLGDGH GR 'LUHLWR 3HQDO WDQWR TXH
GHVWDFDGRRSULQFtSLRGDUHWULEXWLYLGDGHRXGDFRQVHTXHQFLDOL
GDGHGDSHQDHPUHODomRDRGHOLWR3RUWDQWRQmRVHSRGHLQFOXL
ORHQWUHDTXHOHVTXHVXVWHQWDPRDEROLFLRQLVPRSHQDORXVHMD
QmRVHSRGHTXDOLILFiORFRPRDEROLFLRQLVWD

)(55$-2/,/XLJLDireito e razãoWHRULDGRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDO6mR3DXOR(GLWRUD5HYLVWDGRV7ULEXQDLV
S
2WHUPRDEROLFLRQLVWDpDTXLHPSUHJDGRID]HQGRUHIHUrQFLDjVGRXWULQDVTXHDFXVDPR'LUHLWR3HQDOGH
LOHJtWLPRVHMDSRUTXHPRUDOPHQWHQmRDGPLWHPQHQKXPWLSRGHREMHWLYRFRPRFDSD]GHMXVWLILFDUDVDIOL
o}HVTXHRPHVPRLPS}HVHMDSRUTXHFRQVLGHUDPYDQWDMRVDDDEROLomRGDIRUPDMXUtGLFRSHQDOGDVDQomR
SXQLWLYDHDVXDVXEVWLWXLomRSRUPHLRVSHGDJyJLFRVGHFRQWUROHVRFLDOGHWLSRLQIRUPDO

\R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \ 151
 e EHP YHUGDGH TXH R UDGLFDOLVPR GRV DEROLFLRQLVWDV QmR
FKHJDDFRQWDPLQDUGHIRUPDVLJQLILFDWLYDRVRSHUDGRUHVGR'L
UHLWRVVHQGRFHUWRTXHQHVWHSRQWRHVSHFtILFRVHUHFRQKHFHGH
XPDIRUPDJHUDODLPSUHVFLQGLELOLGDGHGR'LUHLWR3HQDOVREUH
WXGRSDUDSXQLUSUiWLFDVFULPLQRVDVPDLVJUDYHVJLUDQGRDGLV
FXVVmRSURSULDPHQWHVREUHRJUDXGDSHQDDVHUDSOLFDGDHVXD
IRUPDGHDSOLFDomRHQmRVREUHDVXDQHFHVVLGDGH
8PVHJXQGRSRQWRDVHUGHVWDFDGRUHIHUHVHjDGRomRGR
FKDPDGR SULQFtSLR GD QHFHVVLGDGH RX GD HFRQRPLD GR 'LUHLWR
3HQDORTXDOLPSRUWDRUHFRQKHFLPHQWRGDLPSUHVFLQGLELOLGDGH
GDUHVSRVWDSHQDOQRVFDVRVSDUDRVTXDLVQmRVHYHULILTXHDOJX
PDDOWHUQDWLYDUD]RiYHO
9HMDVH TXH Ki FRHUrQFLD QD DGRomR GRV GRLV SULQFtSLRV
PHQFLRQDGRVQDPHGLGDHPTXHVHUHFRQKHFHDLPSRUWkQFLDGR
'LUHLWR3HQDODIDVWDQGRVHRVDUJXPHQWRVDEROLFLRQLVWDVPDVp
UHVVDOWDGRRVHXstatus GHultima ratio
8PWHUFHLURSRQWRDVHUGHVWDFDGRUHODFLRQDVHDRSULQFtSLR
DFXVDWyULRRXGDVHSDUDomRHQWUHMXL]HDFXVDomRVHQGRLPSRU
WDQWHWDODVSHFWRHVSHFLDOPHQWHSDUDTXHVHUHVJXDUGHDLPSDU
FLDOLGDGHGRMXOJDGRU
2GHVDILRSDVVDQmRDSHQDVSHODVHSDUDomRIRUPDOQDDWX
DomRGHVVHVGRLVLPSRUWDQWHVRSHUDGRUHVGR'LUHLWRăMXL]HDFX
VDGRUăPDVVREUHWXGRSHODHTXLGLVWkQFLDTXHRMXOJDGRUGHYH
JXDUGDUGHDPEDVDVSDUWHVVHPDTXDOGLILFLOPHQWHVHUiSRVVt
YHOHVSHUDUXPMXOJDPHQWRYHUGDGHLUDPHQWHMXVWR
8PTXDUWRSRQWRDVHUGHVWDFDGRUHIHUHVHDRSULQFtSLRGR
{QXVGDSURYDRXGDYHULILFDomRVHJXQGRRTXDOVHFKHJDjFRQ
FOXVmROyJLFDQRVHQWLGRGHTXHFDEHjDFXVDomRFRPSURYDUDFXOSD
GRDFXVDGRGHVFDEHQGRDRDFXVDGRFRPSURYDUDVXDLQRFrQFLD
,VVRpIDFLOPHQWHFRQVWDWDGRTXDQGRVHUHFRUGDTXHRSULQ
FtSLRGDLQRFrQFLDSUHYLVWRHPVHGHFRQVWLWXFLRQDODSHQDVFRQ
IHUHDRDFXVDGRRstatus GHFXOSDGRDSyVRWUkQVLWRHPMXOJDGRGD
VHQWHQoDFRQGHQDWyULDRXGRDFyUGmRFRQGHQDWyULR

$UW/9,,GD&RQVWLWXLomR)HGHUDOQLQJXpPVHUiFRQVLGHUDGRFXOSDGRDWpRWUkQVLWRHPMXOJDGRGH
VHQWHQoDSHQDOFRQGHQDWyULD

152 \R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \
 'LDQWHGHWDLVSULQFtSLRVTXHQmRUHYHODPTXDOTXHUUDGLFD
OLVPRGH/XLJL)HUUDMROLpLPSRUWDQWHYHULILFDUDDQiOLVHTXHVHWHP
IHLWRSRUSDUWHGDTXHOHVTXHDGHUHPDRFKDPDGRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDO
LQWHJUDOVHQGRFHUWRTXHSRVWHULRUPHQWHVHUiIXQGDPHQWDOH[DPL
QDUVLWXDo}HVQDVTXDLVILFDFODUDDRSomRGHDOJXQVRSHUDGRUHVGR
'LUHLWRSHORFKDPDGRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOKLSHUEyOLFRPRQRFXODU

2*$5$17,6023(1$/,17(*5$/
/RJRGHLQtFLRFRQYpPGHILQLURFKDPDGRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDO
LQWHJUDOFRPRVHQGRDDSOLFDomRGDWHRULDGRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOLGH
DOL]DGDSRU/XLJL)HUUDMROLFRPDULJRURVDREVHUYkQFLDGRVGLUHLWRV
IXQGDPHQWDLVLQGLYLGXDLVHFROHWLYRVPDVWDPEpPFRPDREVHU
YkQFLDGRVGHYHUHVIXQGDPHQWDLVGR(VWDGRHGRVFLGDGmRV
9HMDVHTXHRVPHQFLRQDGRVGLUHLWRVHGHYHUHVIXQGDPHQ
WDLVWrPVHGHFRQVWLWXFLRQDOQDGDMXVWLILFDQGRTXHVHDSOLTXHP
RVGLUHLWRVFRPWRGDDIRUoDHTXHVHHVTXHoDPRVGHYHUHVFRPR
VHRVPHVPRVQmRWLYHVVHPDPHVPDSUHYLVmR
(PDUWLJRTXHH[DPLQDFXLGDGRVDPHQWHRJDUDQWLVPRSH
QDO 'RXJODV )LVFKHU GH IRUPD DFHUWDGD GHVWDFD D QHFHVVLGDGH
GHVHUHPREMHWRGHSUHRFXSDomRSHORVRSHUDGRUHVGR'LUHLWRDV
GXDVyWLFDVUHIHULGDVQRVVHJXLQWHVWHUPRV
(PVtQWHVHGRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOLQWHJUDOGHFRUUHDQH
FHVVLGDGH GH SURWHomR GH EHQV MXUtGLFRV LQGLYLGXDLV H
WDPEpPFROHWLYRVHGHSURWHomRDWLYDGRVLQWHUHVVHVGD
VRFLHGDGHHGRVLQYHVWLJDGRVHRXSURFHVVDGRV

6DOLHQWHVHTXHQDGDMXVWLILFDRHPEDVDPHQWRGHWHVHVIOD
JUDQWHPHQWHGHVFDELGDVDWtWXORGHREVHUYkQFLDGDWHRULDGRJD
UDQWLVPRSHQDOVHQGRFHUWRTXHPXLWRDRFRQWUiULRRTXHHQ
FRQWUDDPSDURQDPHQFLRQDGDWHRULDpMXVWDPHQWHDDGRomRGH
UD]RiYHLVSRQWRVGHYLVWDHQmRXPUDGLFDOLVPRLQMXVWLILFDGR
&XULRVDPHQWH PXLWRV DGYRJDGRV H GHIHQVRUHV S~EOLFRV
VXVWHQWDPFRPYHHPrQFLDDQHFHVVLGDGHGHVHUHPFRQIHULGDVDV
),6&+(5'RXJODV2TXHpJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOLQWHJUDO",Q&$/$%5,&+%UXQR),6&+(5'RXJODV
3(/(//$ (GXDUGR Garantismo penal integral TXHVW}HV SHQDLV H SURFHVVXDLV FULPLQDOLGDGH PRGHUQD H
DSOLFDomRGRPRGHORJDUDQWLVWDQR%UDVLO6DOYDGRU(GLWRUD-XVSRGLYPS

\R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \ 153
PHVPDVFRQGLo}HVGHDWXDomRSDUDDDFXVDomRHSDUDDGHIHVDQR
TXHHIHWLYDPHQWHWrPUD]mR
1mRID]TXDOTXHUVHQWLGRVHSUHVWLJLDUDDFXVDomRHPH[
FHVVRWUDWDQGRDVSUHWHQV}HVGHIHQVLYDVFRPPiYRQWDGHFRPR
VHQmRIRVVHGHYHUGRMXL]TXHSUHVLGHRSURFHVVRVHPDQWHUHTXL
GLVWDQWHGHDPEDVDVSDUWHV
9HMDVHTXHVRERSRQWRGHYLVWDIRUPDOHPUHJUDROHJLV
ODGRU FRQIHUH WUDWDPHQWR LJXDOLWiULR j DFXVDomR H j GHIHVD QmR
VHSRGHQGRDFXViORGHSULYLOHJLDUTXDOTXHUGDVSDUWHVQRWUDWD
PHQWROHJLVODWLYR
3URYDLVVRSRUH[HPSORpRIDWRGHRVSUD]RVUHFXUVDLVVH
UHPLGrQWLFRVSDUDDDFXVDomRHSDUDDGHIHVDQmRVHYHULILFDQGR
TXDOTXHU GHVFRPSDVVR QR WUDWDPHQWR LJXDOLWiULR TXH DV SDUWHV
PHUHFHPWHUQRSURFHVVR
$OLiVpVDELGRTXHRGHIHQVRUS~EOLFRWHPSUD]RHPGREUR
FRQIRUPH SUHYLVWR QR DUW Ĉ † Ĉ GD /HL  HP UHGDomR
GDGDSHOD/HLHQRVDUWLJRV,,H,GD/HL
&RPSOHPHQWDU
0DVKiPRWLYRVEDVWDQWHUD]RiYHLVSDUDTXHVHFRQILUDHVVH
WUDWDPHQWRGHVLJXDOQmRVHSRGHQGRGHVFRQKHFHUDVFRQGLo}HV
HP TXH DWXD R GHIHQVRU S~EOLFR H D GLILFXOGDGH TXH R PHVPR
HQIUHQWDQmRREVWDQWHRVHXSUHSDURWpFQLFRGLDQWHGDDYDVVDOD
GRUDTXDQWLGDGHGHSURFHVVRVTXHVmRVXEPHWLGRVjVXDDQiOLVH
3RUWDQWR R SRQWR TXH LQWHUHVVD QHVWH PRPHQWR VH UHIHUH
HP YHUGDGH DR GHVHMR DSUHVHQWDGR SRU PXLWRV DGYRJDGRV H
GHIHQVRUHV S~EOLFRV QR VHQWLGR GH TXH SUHYDOHoDP D TXDOTXHU
$UWĈ†ĈGD/HL1RV(VWDGRVRQGHD$VVLVWrQFLD-XGLFLiULDVHMDRUJDQL]DGDHSRUHOHVPDQWLGD
R'HIHQVRU3~EOLFRRXTXHPH[HUoDFDUJRHTXLYDOHQWHVHUiLQWLPDGRSHVVRDOPHQWHGHWRGRVRVDWRVGR
SURFHVVRHPDPEDVDVLQVWkQFLDVFRQWDQGRVHOKHVHPGREURWRGRVRVSUD]RV
$UWGD/HL&RPSOHPHQWDU6mRSUHUURJDWLYDVGRVPHPEURVGD'HIHQVRULD3~EOLFDGD8QLmR
,ăUHFHEHULQFOXVLYHTXDQGRQHFHVViULRPHGLDQWHHQWUHJDGRVDXWRVFRPYLVWDLQWLPDomRSHVVRDOHPTXDO
TXHUSURFHVVRHJUDXGHMXULVGLomRRXLQVWkQFLDDGPLQLVWUDWLYDFRQWDQGRVHOKHVHPGREURWRGRVRVSUD]RV
$UWGD/HL&RPSOHPHQWDU6mRSUHUURJDWLYDVGRVPHPEURVGD'HIHQVRULD3~EOLFDGR'LVWULWR
)HGHUDOHGRV7HUULWyULRV
,ăUHFHEHULQFOXVLYHTXDQGRQHFHVViULRPHGLDQWHHQWUHJDGRVDXWRVFRPYLVWDLQWLPDomRSHVVRDOHPTXDO
TXHUSURFHVVRHJUDXGHMXULVGLomRRXLQVWkQFLDDGPLQLVWUDWLYDFRQWDQGRVHOKHVHPGREURWRGRVRVSUD]RV
$UWGD/HL&RPSOHPHQWDU6mRSUHUURJDWLYDVGRVPHPEURVGD'HIHQVRULD3~EOLFDGR(VWDGR
GHQWUHRXWUDVTXHDOHLORFDOHVWDEHOHFHU
,ăUHFHEHULQFOXVLYHTXDQGRQHFHVViULRPHGLDQWHHQWUHJDGRVDXWRVFRPYLVWDLQWLPDomRSHVVRDOHPTXDO
TXHUSURFHVVRHJUDXGHMXULVGLomRRXLQVWkQFLDDGPLQLVWUDWLYDFRQWDQGRVHOKHVHPGREURWRGRVRVSUD]RV

154 \R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \
FXVWRRVLQWHUHVVHVGHVHXFOLHQWHRXDVVLVWLGRSUDWLFDPHQWHVXV
WHQWDQGR TXH DV UHJUDV SURFHVVXDLV DSHQDV GHYHP VHUYLU SDUD
IDYRUHFrORHQXQFDSDUDSUHMXGLFiOR
$LQGDFRPUHODomRjTXHVWmRGRVSUD]RVSURFHVVXDLVTXH
FRUUHWDPHQWH R OHJLVODGRU SUHYLX GH IRUPD LJXDOLWiULD SDUD D
DFXVDomRHDGHIHVDDSUiWLFDIRUHQVHWHPUHYHODGRXPDTXHVWmR
VLPSOHVHDRPHVPRWHPSRLQWHUHVVDQWH
&RPR p GH FRQKHFLPHQWR JHUDO R OHJLVODGRU SUHYLX PR
PHQWRVHVSHFtILFRVSDUDDDFXVDomRHDGHIHVDLQGLFDUHPDVWHVWH
PXQKDVTXHSUHWHQGHPRXYLUHPMXt]RRSRUWXQL]DQGRDSURGX
omRGHSURYDVRUDLVSDUDDPEDVDVSDUWHV
'HVVDPDQHLUDRDUWcaputGR&33DILUPDTXHRPar-
quetQRPRPHQWRGRRIHUHFLPHQWRGDGHQ~QFLDGHYHLQGLFDUDV
VXDVWHVWHPXQKDVHQTXDQWRRDUW$caputGR&33DILUPD
TXHDGHIHVDGHYHLQGLFDUDVVXDVWHVWHPXQKDVSRURSRUWXQLGDGH
GDDSUHVHQWDomRGDVXDUHVSRVWDSUHOLPLQDU
2OHJLVODGRUQmRSRGLDWHUVLGRPDLVFODURHPWDLVGLVSRVLWLYRV
PDVDLQGDDVVLPPXLWRVDGYRJDGRVHGHIHQVRUHVS~EOLFRVLQVLVWHP
HPQmRLQGLFDUDVVXDVWHVWHPXQKDV³SURWHVWDQGRSHODSURGXomR
GHSURYDRUDO´RXPHVPRLQGLFDQGRWHVWHPXQKDVVDELGDPHQWHILF
WtFLDVDOJXPDVFRPQRPHVGHDUWLVWDVHGHSHVVRDVIDPRVDVID]HQ
GRVHXPDYHUGDGHLUDEULQFDGHLUDQRSURFHVVRFULPLQDO
3RVWHULRUPHQWHGLDVDQWHVGDVDXGLrQFLDVGHLQVWUXomRHMXO
JDPHQWRRXPHVPRQRPRPHQWRGDVDOXGLGDVDXGLrQFLDVRVDGYR
JDGRVHRVGHIHQVRUHVS~EOLFRVTXDOLILFDPDVVXDVYHUGDGHLUDVWHV
WHPXQKDV LQFOXVLYH HP PXLWDV RSRUWXQLGDGHV WUD]HQGRDV SDUD
GHSRUHPMXt]RVHPTXDOTXHUFRPXQLFDomRSUpYLDQRSURFHVVR
5LJRURVDPHQWHGHYHPVHULQGHIHULGDVWDLVRLWLYDVSRUTXHIRL
VXSHUDGRRPRPHQWRSURFHVVXDODGHTXDGRSDUDDYLQGDDRVDXWRV
GDVTXDOLILFDo}HVGDVWHVWHPXQKDVRTXHFDXVDSHUSOH[LGDGHHDWp
PHVPRLQGLJQDomRSRUSDUWHGRVDGYRJDGRVHGHIHQVRUHVS~EOLFRV
$UWGR&33$GHQ~QFLDRXTXHL[DFRQWHUiDH[SRVLomRGRIDWRFULPLQRVRFRPWRGDVDVVXDVFLUFXQV
WkQFLDVDTXDOLILFDomRGRDFXVDGRRXHVFODUHFLPHQWRVSHORVTXDLVVHSRVVDLGHQWLILFiORDFODVVLILFDomRGR
FULPHHTXDQGRQHFHVViULRRUROGDVWHVWHPXQKDV
$UW$GR&331DUHVSRVWDRDFXVDGRSRGHUiDUJXLUSUHOLPLQDUHVHDOHJDUWXGRRTXHLQWHUHVVHj
VXDGHIHVDRIHUHFHUGRFXPHQWRVHMXVWLILFDo}HVHVSHFLILFDUDVSURYDVSUHWHQGLGDVHDUURODUWHVWHPXQKDV
TXDOLILFDQGRDVHUHTXHUHQGRVXDLQWLPDomRTXDQGRQHFHVViULR

\R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \ 155
 eFODURTXHRDUWcaputGR&33SHUPLWHDRLWLYDGD
FKDPDGDWHVWHPXQKDGHMXt]RPDVSDUDWDQWRpQHFHVViULRTXHR
MXOJDGRUUHFRQKHoDDQHFHVVLGDGHGHVXDRLWLYDQmRFRQVWLWXLQGR
GLUHLWRGDGHIHVDDRLWLYDGHWHVWHPXQKDTXHQmRIRLGHYLGDPHQWH
TXDOLILFDGDQRPRPHQWRGDDSUHVHQWDomRGDUHVSRVWDSUHOLPLQDU
(QWHQGHUTXHDDPSODGHIHVDJDUDQWLGDSHORWH[WRFRQVWL
WXFLRQDO DXWRUL]D R GHVUHVSHLWR DRV PRPHQWRV SURFHVVXDLV IL
[DGRVSHOROHJLVODGRUGHPDQHLUDLQHTXtYRFDHPYHUGDGHFRQV
WLWXLXPLQGHVFXOSiYHOGHVYLRGHSHUVSHFWLYDVHQGRFHUWRTXHD
ULJRUDDFXVDomRHWDPEpPDGHIHVDGHYHPHVWDUDWHQWDVDRTXH
GLVS}HROHJLVODGRU
8PRXWURSRQWRTXHVHPRVWUDLQWHUHVVDQWHpDSUHVHUYDomR
GRVGLUHLWRVTXHDYtWLPDSRVVXLDTXDOGHYHVHUUHVSHLWDGDHWUD
WDGD GLJQDPHQWH GXUDQWH WRGRV RV DWRV SURFHVVXDLV PRUPHQWH
QDTXHOHVHPTXHDVXDSUHVHQoDpQHFHVViULD
eVDELGRTXHRDUWcaputGR&33EXVFDJDUDQWLUXP
PtQLPRGHWUDQTXLOLGDGHSDUDDYtWLPDQRPRPHQWRGHVHXGH
SRLPHQWRHPMXt]RUD]mRSHODTXDOHPFDVRVH[FHSFLRQDLVRUpX
GHYHUiVHUUHWLUDGRGDVDODGHDXGLrQFLDVGXUDQWHDVXDRLWLYD
9HMDVHTXHROHJLVODGRUIRLFXLGDGRVRDSRQWRGHDILUPDU
TXHRUpXDSHQDVQmRDVVLVWLUiDRGHSRLPHQWRGDYtWLPDVHDVXD
SUHVHQoDFDXVDUKXPLOKDomRWHPRURXVpULRFRQVWUDQJLPHQWRR
TXHVLJQLILFDGL]HUTXHHPUHJUDRDFXVDGRSUHVHQFLDUiDRLWLYD
7DPEpPGHIRUPDFXLGDGRVDROHJLVODGRUSUHYLXHPWDLV
FDVRV D SDUWLFLSDomR GR DFXVDGR DWUDYpV GH YLGHRFRQIHUrQFLD
VHQGRFHUWRTXHHOHDSHQDVQmRDVVLVWLUiDRGHSRLPHQWRGDYtWL
PDTXDQGRWDPEpPHVVDDOWHUQDWLYDVHPRVWUDULQYLiYHO
$LQGD DVVLP DTXHOHV TXH UDGLFDOL]DP LQGHYLGDPHQWH D
XWLOL]DomR GR JDUDQWLVPR SHQDO VXVWHQWDP TXH D DPSOD GHIHVD
JDUDQWHDRUpXSHUPDQHFHUQDVDODGHDXGLrQFLDVGXUDQWHWRGDV
$UWGR&332MXL]TXDQGRMXOJDUQHFHVViULRSRGHUiRXYLURXWUDVWHVWHPXQKDVDOpPGDVLQGLFDGDV
SHODVSDUWHV
$UWĈ/9GD&RQVWLWXLomR)HGHUDO$RVOLWLJDQWHVHPSURFHVVRMXGLFLDORXDGPLQLVWUDWLYRHDRVDFX
VDGRVHPJHUDOVmRDVVHJXUDGRVRFRQWUDGLWyULRHDPSODGHIHVDFRPRVPHLRVHUHFXUVRVDHODLQHUHQWHV
$UW6HRMXL]YHULILFDUTXHDSUHVHQoDGRUpXSRGHUiFDXVDUKXPLOKDomRWHPRURXVpULRFRQVWUDQJL
PHQWRjWHVWHPXQKDRXDRRIHQGLGRGHPRGRTXHSUHMXGLTXHDYHUGDGHGRGHSRLPHQWRIDUiDLQTXLULomR
SRUYLGHRFRQIHUrQFLDHVRPHQWHQDLPSRVVLELOLGDGHGHVVDIRUPDGHWHUPLQDUiDUHWLUDGDGRUpXSURVVH
JXLQGRQDLQTXLULomRFRPDSUHVHQoDGRVHXGHIHQVRU

156 \R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \
DVRLWLYDVDVHUHPUHDOL]DGDVVHPTXDOTXHUH[FHomRHVTXHFHQGR
VHTXHDH[HPSORGRUpXWDPEpPDYtWLPDpWLWXODUGHGLUHLWRV
7DPEpPFRPUHODomRjYtWLPDRDUW†ĈGR&33SUH
YrRVHXGLUHLWRGHVHULQIRUPDGDTXDQWRDRLQJUHVVRHVDtGDGR
DFXVDGRGDSULVmRjGHVLJQDomRGHGDWDSDUDDXGLrQFLDHjVHQ
WHQoDHUHVSHFWLYRVDFyUGmRVTXHDPDQWHQKDPRXPRGLILTXHP
+iXPDHYLGHQWHSUHRFXSDomRGROHJLVODGRUFRPDYtWLPD
VHQGRFHUWRTXHVHEXVFDSUHVHUYiODGHQRYDVLQYHVWLGDVGRUpX
DRPHVPRWHPSRHPTXHVHSUHWHQGHPDQWrODLQIRUPDGDVREUH
R DQGDPHQWR GR SURFHVVR Mi TXH QDWXUDOPHQWH D UHSHUFXVVmR
SURFHVVXDOpGHVHXLQWHUHVVH
1HVVD PHGLGD p SUHFLVR FRPSUHHQGHU TXH R FKDPDGR JD
UDQWLVPRSHQDOLQWHJUDOLPS}HRUHFRQKHFLPHQWRGRVGLUHLWRVSUH
YLVWRVQDOHJLVODomRHPYLJRUTXHQmRVHUHIHUHPH[FOXVLYDPHQWH
DRLQGLFLDGRQRLQTXpULWRSROLFLDORXDRDFXVDGRQRSURFHVVRFUL
PLQDOXPDYH]TXHWDPEpPRXWURVDWRUHVăHPHVSHFLDODYtWLPD
ăWrPGLUHLWRVDVHUHPUHFRQKHFLGRVQRFRQWH[WRSURFHVVXDO
)HLWDV HVVDV REVHUYDo}HV p IXQGDPHQWDO H[DPLQDU R UDGL
FDOLVPR TXH H[LVWH QR SRQWR GH YLVWD GH DOJXQV RSHUDGRUHV GR
'LUHLWRQRPRPHQWRHPTXHDGRWDPDWHRULDGRJDUDQWLVPRSH
QDORTXHYHUGDGHLUDPHQWHOKHVFRQIHUHXPDYLVmRGLVWRUFLGD
GHXPDWHRULDWmRLPSRUWDQWHQRPXQGRMXUtGLFR

2*$5$17,6023(1$/+,3(5%Ï/,&20212&8/$5
2WtWXORGHVWHDUWLJRDJRUDWUDWDGRPDLVHVSHFLILFDPHQWH
GHFRUUHGHXPDH[SUHVVmREDVWDQWHSUHFLVDDGRWDGDSRU'RXJODV
)LVFKHUDTXDOPHOKRUILFDH[SOLFLWDGDQDVSDODYUDVGRPHQFLR
QDGRDXWRU
4XDOTXHUSUHWHQVmRjSUHYDOrQFLDLQGLVFULPLQDGDDSH
QDV GH GLUHLWRV IXQGDPHQWDLV LQGLYLGXDLV LPSOLFD ă DR
PHQRV SDUD QyV ă XPD WHRULD TXH GHQRPLQDPRV GH
JDUDQWLVPR SHQDO KLSHUEyOLFR PRQRFXODU HYLGHQFLDVH
GHVSURSRUFLRQDOPHQWH KLSHUEyOLFR H GH IRUPD LVROD
$UW†ĈGR&332RIHQGLGRVHUiFRPXQLFDGRGRVDWRVSURFHVVXDLVUHODWLYRVDRLQJUHVVRHjVDtGD
GRDFXVDGRGDSULVmRjGHVLJQDomRGHGDWDSDUDDXGLrQFLDHjVHQWHQoDHUHVSHFWLYRVDFyUGmRVTXHDPDQ
WHQKDPRXPRGLILTXHP

\R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \ 157
 GD PRQRFXODU D QHFHVVLGDGH GH SURWHomR DSHQDV GRV
GLUHLWRVIXQGDPHQWDLVLQGLYLGXDLVGRVFLGDGmRVRTXH
FRPRYLVWRQmRpHQXQFDIRLRSURSyVLWR~QLFRGRJD
UDQWLVPRSHQDOLQWHJUDO

2DXWRUQmRSRGLDWHUVLGRPDLVSUHFLVRXPDYH]TXHKiSRU
SDUWHGHPXLWRVRSHUDGRUHVGR'LUHLWRXPH[DJHURGLULJLGRPD[L
PL]DQGRVHRVGLUHLWRVHPIDYRUGRVLQGLFLDGRVQRVLQTXpULWRVSROL
FLDLVHGRVDFXVDGRVQRVSURFHVVRVFULPLQDLVFRPRVHRJDUDQWLVPR
SHQDOLGHDOL]DGRSRU/XLJL)HUUDMROLWLYHVVHDSHQDVHVVHSURSyVLWR
HVTXHFHQGRVHGRVGHPDLVHQYROYLGRVQRFRQWH[WRSURFHVVXDO
+i VHPSUH TXHVW}HV GH RUGHP SUiWLFD TXH EHP GHPRQV
WUDPWDOH[DJHURGLULJLGRVHQGRLQWHUHVVDQWHWUDQVFUHYHUDHPHQ
WDGHXPDFyUGmRRULXQGRGR7ULEXQDOGH-XVWLoDGR5LR*UDQGH
GR6XOLQVHULGRQROLYURLQWLWXODGR*DUDQWLVPR3HQDO$SOLFDGR
HVFULWRSRU$PLOWRQ%XHQRGH&DUYDOKR
5RXERPDMRUDGR$JUDYDQWHGRDUWLQFLVR,,DOtQHDV
cHh$IDVWDPHQWR3DODYUDGDYtWLPD(VSHFLDOYDORU
$SDODYUDGDYtWLPDHPGHOLWRVGDHVSpFLHRQGHWXGR
RFRUUH jV HVFRQGLGDV DVVXPH HVSHFLDO YDORU Pi[LPH
TXDQGRQmRSURYDGRLQWHUHVVHHVS~ULRQDFRQGHQDomR
$DJUDYDQWHGHFRPHWHUFULPH³FRQWUDYHOKR´QmRpYH
ULILFiYHOWmRVySRUFULWpULRFURQROyJLFRPDVSHODVFRQ
GLo}HVSHVVRDLVGRRIHQGLGR

$DJUDYDQWHGD³VXUSUHVD´QmRVHDSOLFDDRVGHOLWRVGHURX
ERSRUTXHtQVLWDjFRQGXWDGRSUySULRFULPHă³YLROrQFLD´
¬ XQDQLPLGDGH GHUDP SDUFLDO SURYLPHQWR DR DSHOR
SDUDUHGX]LUDSHQDLPSRVWD

2 SRQWR HVSHFtILFR TXH VH SUHWHQGH DERUGDU QHVVH MXOJDGR

GL]UHVSHLWRjH[FOXVmRGDFLUFXQVWkQFLDDJUDYDQWHGHFRUUHQWHGD
),6&+(5'RXJODV2TXHpJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOLQWHJUDO",Q&$/$%5,&+%UXQR),6&+(5'RXJODV
3(/(//$ (GXDUGR Garantismo penal integral TXHVW}HV SHQDLV H SURFHVVXDLV FULPLQDOLGDGH PRGHUQD H
DSOLFDomRGRPRGHORJDUDQWLVWDQR%UDVLO6DOYDGRU(GLWRUD-XVSRGLYPS
&$59$/+2$PLOWRQ%XHQRGH*DUDQWLVPRSHQDODSOLFDGR5LRGH-DQHLUR(GLWRUD/XPHQ-XULVS
7ULEXQDOGH-XVWLoDGR5LR*UDQGHGR6XO$SHODomRMXOJDGDHPGH]

158 \R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \
FRQGLomRGHYHOKRGDYtWLPDHVSHFLDOPHQWHSRUTXHQRFDVRFRQ
FUHWRDGHIHVDDRDSHODUVHTXHUVXVWHQWRXWDOWHVHDTXDOIRLUHFR
QKHFLGDGHRItFLRSHOR7ULEXQDOGH-XVWLoDGR5LR*UDQGHGR6XO
1R FDVR FRQFUHWR D YtWLPD WLQKD  DQRV GH LGDGH UD]mR
SHODTXDODVHQWHQoDGHSULPHLURJUDXQRPRPHQWRGDIL[DomRGD
SHQDUHFRQKHFHXDLQFLGrQFLDGDFLUFXQVWkQFLDDJUDYDQWHSUHYLV
WDQRDUW,,hGR&yGLJR3HQDO
¬ pSRFD GRV IDWRV R PHQFLRQDGR GLVSRVLWLYR LPSXQKD R
DFUpVFLPRGDSHQDTXDQGRDYtWLPDWLYHVVHRstatus GH³YHOKR´
VHQGR FHUWR TXH SRVWHULRUPHQWH SRU IRUoD GD /HL  D
VXD UHGDomR IRL DOWHUDGD SDUD GHWHUPLQDU R DFUpVFLPR GD SHQD
QRVFDVRVHPTXHDYtWLPDWHQKDPDLVGHVHVVHQWDDQRVGHLGDGH
(QWUHWDQWRRDFyUGmRDOXGLGRDILUPDTXHDYHOKLFHQmRpFUL
WpULRFURQROyJLFRSDUDFRQFOXLUTXHRIDWRGHDYtWLPDWHUDQRV
GHLGDGHQmROKHFRQIHUHQHFHVVDULDPHQWHRstatus GHYHOKRGH
IRUPDTXHSDUDDLQFLGrQFLDGDPHQFLRQDGDFLUFXQVWkQFLDDJUD
YDQWHVHULDQHFHVViULRFRPSURYDUDIUDJLOLGDGHGDYtWLPDGHFRU
UHQWHGRVHXWHPSRGHYLGDRTXHQmRRFRUUHXQRFDVRFRQFUHWR
(P RXWUDV SDODYUDV DGRWDQGR XP FULWpULR QmR SUHYLVWR
SHOROHJLVODGRURDFyUGmRWUDWRXGHDOLYLDUDUHVSRVWDSHQDOTXH
OKH IRL LPSRVWD QD VHQWHQoD VHQGR GLItFLO DFUHGLWDU TXH DOJXP
MXOJDGRILFDULDLPXQHGHFUtWLFDVHDGRWDVVHRPHVPRUDGLFDOLVPR
FRQWUiULRDRVLQWHUHVVHVGDGHIHVD
2XWUR LQWHUHVVDQWH H[HPSOR SUiWLFR GR UDGLFDOLVPR TXH
RULHQWDDDWXDomRGHDOJXQVRSHUDGRUHVGR'LUHLWRHPIDYRUGRV
DFXVDGRV SRGH VHU LJXDOPHQWH FROKLGR QD UHIHULGD REUD HVFULWD
SRU$PLOWRQ%XHQRGH&DUYDOKRVHQGRFHUWRTXHRMXOJDPHQWR
WDPEpPDGYpPGR7ULEXQDOGH-XVWLoDGR5LR*UDQGHGR6XO
$TXHVWmRUHODFLRQDVHjLQFLGrQFLDGDFLUFXQVWkQFLDDJUD
YDQWHSUHYLVWDQRDUW,,eGR&yGLJR3HQDOVHQGRDHPHQWD
GRUHVSHFWLYRDFyUGmRHVFODUHFHGRUDGRHQWHQGLPHQWRDGRWDGR
YDOHQGRDVXDWUDQVFULomR
$UWGR&yGLJR3HQDO6mRFLUFXQVWkQFLDVTXHVHPSUHDJUDYDPDSHQDTXDQGRQmRFRQVWLWXHPRX
TXDOLILFDPRFULPH
,,WHURDJHQWHFRPHWLGRRFULPH
KFRQWUDFULDQoDPDLRUGHVHVVHQWDDQRVHQIHUPRRXPXOKHUJUiYLGD
&$59$/+2$PLOWRQ%XHQRGH*DUDQWLVPRSHQDODSOLFDGR5LRGH-DQHLUR(GLWRUD/XPHQ-XULVS

\R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \ 159
 3HQDO5RXERPDMRUDGR&LUFXQVWkQFLDDJUDYDQWH&ULPH
FRPHWLGRFRQWUDLUPm&RQWUROHGHFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGH
$JUHVVmR DRV SULQFtSLRV GD LJXDOGDGH VHFXODUL]DomR H
UDFLRQDOLGDGH,QFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGHSDUFLDOVHPUHGX
omRGHWH[WRGRDUWLJRLQFLVR,,³H´GR&yGLJR3HQDO
2 SDWULP{QLR H DLQWHJULGDGHGDLUPmGRGHQXQFLDGR
HQTXDQWR EHQV MXUtGLFRV PHUHFHP D PHVPD SURWHomR
TXHpDOFDQoDGDDTXDOTXHUGRSRYRVRESHQDGHYLROD
omRDRSULQFtSLRFRQVWLWXFLRQDOGDLJXDOGDGH
6H D FRQGLomR SDUHQWDO QmR IDFLOLWRX D FRQVXPDomR GR
FULPHWDPSRXFRUHYHVWLXGHVFXPSULPHQWRGHGHYHUMX
UtGLFRDVVLVWHQFLDORXFDXVRXGDQRSVLFROyJLFRjYtWLPD
QmR Ki UD]mR DOJXPD SDUD R DFUpVFLPR GH SHQD SRLV D
YDORUDomRGHFLUFXQVWkQFLDTXHHPQDGDDOWHUDRMXt]RGH
UHSURYDomRDJULGHRSULQFtSLRGDUDFLRQDOLGDGH
$H[DVSHUDomRGDSHQDFDOFDGDWmRVRPHQWHQRGHVFXP
SULPHQWRGHXPGHYHUPRUDOGHILGHOLGDGHGHXPLUPmR
SDUDFRPRRXWURDJULGHRSULQFtSLRFRQVWLWXFLRQDOGD
VHFXODUL]DomR
&RPSHWHDRMXOJDGRUILVFDOL]DUDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGHGD
OHLVXSULPLQGRGHQWUHVHXVVHQWLGRVSRVVtYHLVDTXHOHV
LQFRPSDWtYHLV FRP RV SUHFHLWRV FRQVWLWXFLRQDLV XWLOL
]DQGRVH GD WpFQLFD GD LQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDGH SDUFLDO
VHPUHGXomRGHWH[WROLomRGR3URI/rQLR/XL]6WUHFN
¬XQDQLPLGDGHGHUDPSDUFLDOSURYLPHQWRDRDSHOR
2TXHVHYHULILFDWDPEpPQHVVHFDVRFRQFUHWRpDRSomRH[D
JHUDGDHPSUROGDGHIHVDFULDQGRVHXPPHFDQLVPRSDUDDIDVWDU
DRSomRFODUDPHQWHIHLWDSHOROHJLVODGRUVHPTXDOTXHUPiFXODj
&RQVWLWXLomR)HGHUDO
9HMDVH TXH R DUW  ,, e GR &3 SUHYr H[SUHVVDPHQWH
HGHPDQHLUDUD]RiYHODPDMRUDomRGDSHQDTXDQGRVHWUDWDGH
FULPHSUDWLFDGRFRQWUDLUPmRRTXHH[DWDPHQWHRFRUUHXQRFDVR
7ULEXQDOGH-XVWLoDGR5LR*UDQGHGR6XO$SHODomRMXOJDGDHPMXQ
$UWGR&yGLJR3HQDO6mRFLUFXQVWkQFLDVTXHVHPSUHDJUDYDPDSHQDTXDQGRQmRFRQVWLWXHPRX
TXDOLILFDPRFULPH
,,WHURDJHQWHFRPHWLGRRFULPH
HFRQWUDDVFHQGHQWHGHVFHQGHQWHLUPmRRXF{QMXJH

160 \R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \
DJRUD HP GHVWDTXH VHQGR FHUWR TXH DSHQDV XP HVIRUoR PXLWR
JUDQGHGRDSOLFDGRUGDOHLHXPDFHUWDFULDWLYLGDGHSRGHPVHU
FDSD]HVGHDIDVWDUDDSOLFDomRGDPHQFLRQDGDQRUPD
9HUGDGHLUDPHQWH DLQGD TXH D FKDPDGD LQFRQVWLWXFLRQD
OLGDGHSDUFLDOVHPUHGXomRGHWH[WRVHMDVXVWHQWDGDSRUDOJXQV
DXWRUHV RDFyUGmRHPH[DPHXWLOL]RXVHGHWDOWpFQLFDSDUD
GHIRUPDH[DJHUDGDDOLYLDUDVLWXDomRGRFRQGHQDGR
3DUDHQFHUUDUHVWHWySLFRpLPSRUWDQWHHQIDWL]DUXPH[HP
SOR DLQGD PDLV JULWDQWH GH RSomR GR DSOLFDGRU GR 'LUHLWR SHOR
FKDPDGRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOKLSHUEyOLFRPRQRFXODUFRQVWDQWHQD
Mi PHQFLRQDGD REUD GH$PLOWRQ %XHQR GH &DUYDOKR UDGLFDOL
]DQGRVHGHIRUPDPXLWRFODUDRSURSyVLWRGHVXDYL]DUDVLWXD
omRGRDFXVDGR
2FDVRWUDWDGHXPDWHQWDWLYDGHURXERSUDWLFDGDSRUGXDV
SHVVRDV WHQGR RFRUULGR R GHVPHPEUDPHQWR GRV DXWRV VHQGR
FHUWRTXHSRURSRUWXQLGDGHGRMXOJDPHQWRGHXPGRVHQYROYL
GRVDMXt]DGHSULPHLURJUDXFRQGHQRXRDFXVDGRSRUWHQWDWLYD
GHURXERVLPSOHVH[FOXLQGRDFDXVDGHDXPHQWRGHSHQDGHFRU
UHQWHGRFRQFXUVRGHDJHQWHV
,QFRQIRUPDGR R 0LQLVWpULR 3~EOLFR LQWHUS{V UHFXUVR GH DSH
ODomRWHQGRDVHJXQGDLQVWkQFLDFRQILUPDGRDVHQWHQoDPHUHFHQGR
GHVWDTXHDHPHQWDGRDFyUGmRFRQILUPDWyULRTXHWHYHRVHJXLQWHWHRU
5RXER &RQFXUVR &RUUXSomR GH PHQRUHV &RFXOSD
ELOLGDGH
6HDJUDYHDPHDoDHPHUJHXQLFDPHQWHHPUD]mRGDVX
SHULRULGDGH QXPpULFD GRV DJHQWHV QmR VH VXVWHQWD D
PDMRUDQWHGRFRQFXUVRVRESHQDGH³ELVLQLGHP´
,QHSWDpDLQLFLDOGRGHOLWRGHFRUUXSomRGHPHQRUHV/HL

675(&./rQLR/XL]Jurisdição constitucional e hermenêutica3RUWR$OHJUH/LYUDULDGR$GYRJDGR

S
 &/Ê9( &OqPHUVRQ 0HUOLQ A fiscalização abstrata da constitucionalidade do Direito brasileiro 6mR 3DXOR
(GLWRUD5HYLVWDGRV7ULEXQDLVS
&$59$/+2$PLOWRQ%XHQRGH*DUDQWLVPRSHQDODSOLFDGR5LRGH-DQHLUR(GLWRUD/XPHQ-XULVS
$UWGR&yGLJR3HQDO6XEWUDLUFRLVDPyYHODOKHLDSDUDVLRXSDUDRXWUHPPHGLDQWHJUDYHDPHDoD
RXYLROrQFLDDSHVVRDRXGHSRLVGHKDYrODSRUTXDOTXHUPHLRUHGX]LGRjLPSRVVLELOLGDGHGHUHVLVWrQFLD
†ž$SHQDDXPHQWDVHGHXPWHUoRDWpPHWDGH
,,VHKiRFRQFXUVRGHGXDVRXPDLVSHVVRDV

\R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \ 161
 TXHQmRGHVFUHYHRDQWHFHGHQWHPHQRUHVQmR
FRUURPSLGRV H R FRQVHTXHQWH HIHWLYD FRUUXSomR SHOD
SUiWLFDGRGHOLWRDPSDUDGRHPGDGRVVHJXURVFROHWD
GRVQDIDVHLQTXLVLWRULDO
2SULQFtSLRGDFRFXOSDELOLGDGHID]DVRFLHGDGHWDP
EpP UHVSRQGHU SHODV SRVVLELOLGDGHV VRQHJDGDV DR
FLGDGmRăUpX
5HFXUVRLPSURYLGRFRPORXYRUjMXt]DVHQWHQFLDQWH

2TXHVHSHUFHEHFRPJUDQGHQLWLGH]QRFDVRHPGHVWDTXH
pXPDFHUWDPLRSLDGRDSOLFDGRUGDOHLXPDYH]TXHHPQHQKXP
PRPHQWR R OHJLVODGRU SUHWHQGHX SHUPLWLU WDO LQWHUSUHWDomR D
TXDOVyWHPOXJDUVHYHUGDGHLUDPHQWHRSURSyVLWRIRUEHQHILFLDU
DTXDOTXHUFXVWRRDFXVDGRDOLYLDQGRDUHVSRVWDSHQDOTXHOKH
VHMDFRQIHULGD
6mRHVVHVMXOJDGRVTXHWURX[HPRVSDUDH[HPSOLILFDUDTXHV
WmRHPXLWRVRXWURVTXHHYLGHQFLDPDHTXLYRFDGDLQYRFDomRGD
WHRULDGRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOLGHDOL]DGDSRU/XLJL)HUUDMROLHWDQWDV
YH]HVDSOLFDGDVREXPSRQWRGHYLVWDTXHQHJDDVXDRULJHP

&21&/86­2
$WtWXORGHFRQFOXVmRpLPSRUWDQWHUHJLVWUDUTXHDWHRULDGR
JDUDQWLVPRSHQDOpDGRWDGDGHPDQHLUDWmRGLVWLQWDSHORVRSHUD
GRUHVGR'LUHLWRTXHDVXVWHQWDPTXHRDQDOLVWDPDLVGHVDWHQWR
FRUUHRULVFRGHFRQFOXLUTXHH[LVWHPDLVGHXPDWHRULD
,VVR SRUTXH RV SULQFtSLRV Mi H[WHUQDGRV QHVWH HVWXGR TXH
HPEDVDPYHUGDGHLUDPHQWHDWHRULDLGHDOL]DGDSRU/XLJL)HUUDMR
OLQmRSHUPLWHPDVXDDSOLFDomRUDGLFDOVHUYLQGRPXLWRDRFRQ
WUiULRSDUDHPEDVDUXPDUD]RiYHODSOLFDomRGDPHVPD
$SHQDVSDUDOHPEUDUGHWUrVGRVGH]SULQFtSLRVMiUHIHUL
GRVQHVWHHVWXGRpSUHFLVRUHJLVWUDUTXHQLQJXpPSRGHQHJDUD
LPSRUWkQFLDSRUH[HPSORGRSULQFtSLRDFXVDWyULRRXGDVHSD
UDomRHQWUHMXL]HDFXVDomRGRSULQFtSLRGR{QXVGDSURYDRX
GDYHULILFDomRRXGRSULQFtSLRGRFRQWUDGLWyULRRXGDGHIHVDRX
GDIDOVHDELOLGDGH
7ULEXQDOGH-XVWLoDGR5LR*UDQGHGR6XO$SHODomRMXOJDGDHPPDU

162 \R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \
 $H[HPSORGRVGHPDLVSULQFtSLRVHVVHVWUrVDFLPDGHVWD
FDGRVYLDELOL]DPXPSURFHVVRFULPLQDOTXHDWHQGHDRVLQWHUHV
VHVGDVSDUWHVHSHUPLWHPDSURODomRGRMXOJDPHQWRGDPDQHLUD
PDLVMXVWDSRVVtYHO
1DGDMXVWLILFDTXHVHUDGLFDOL]HDWHRULDSDUDDGRWiODFRPR
EDVHSDUDTXDOTXHUWLSRGHSHGLGRDVHUIRUPXODGRSHORVDGYR
JDGRVHGHIHQVRUHVS~EOLFRVFRPRVHWDPEpPDRVLQGLFLDGRVQR
LQTXpULWRSROLFLDORXDRVUpXVQRSURFHVVRFULPLQDOSURSULDPHQWH
GLWRQmRSXGHVVHPVHULPSRVWDVUHJUDVDVHUHPREHGHFLGDV
1mRVmRWRGRVRVSHGLGRVGHIHQVLYRVTXHGHYHPVHUDFROKL
GRVVHQGRDEVROXWDPHQWHLQGHYLGDDLGHLDQRVHQWLGRGHTXHRJD
UDQWLVPRSHQDOSRVVDVHUXWLOL]DGRFRPRIXQGDPHQWRSDUDTXDO
TXHUSHGLGRDVHUIHLWRHPSUROGRVLQGLFLDGRVRXGRVDFXVDGRV
e LPSRUWDQWH UHJLVWUDU TXH H[LVWHP RXWUDV SHVVRDV HQYRO
YLGDVQRSURFHVVRFULPLQDOFXMRVGLUHLWRVGHYHPVHULJXDOPHQWH
UHFRQKHFLGRV H UHVSHLWDGRV FRPR DV WHVWHPXQKDV H DV YtWLPDV
SRUH[HPSOR
(PVXDREUD³(VWDGRSyVGHPRFUiWLFRQHRREVFXUDQWLVPR
H JHVWmR GRV LQGHVHMiYHLV´ 5XEHQV &DVDUD ID] XPD HVSpFLH GH
GHVDEDIRFRPUHODomRDRTXDOQmRFRQFRUGDPRVPDVTXHPHUHFH
WUDQVFULomRGLDQWHGDVHULHGDGHFRPDTXDORPHQFLRQDGRDXWRU
HQIUHQWDRWHPD
3HUFHEHVHSRLVTXHVyVHUiSRVVtYHOUHFRQVWUXLUR(VWD
GR'HPRFUiWLFRGH'LUHLWRVHRVPHPEURVGDVDJrQFLDV
HVWDWDLV HP HVSHFLDO GR 3RGHU -XGLFLiULR IRUHP GRWD
GRVGDFRUDJHPQHFHVViULDSDUDID]HUFXPSULURSURMHWR
FRQVWLWXFLRQDO&RUDJHPTXHIDOWDVHPSUHTXHDVGHFL
V}HVMXGLFLDLVVHGLVWDQFLDPGDVQRUPDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDLV
SDUDDWHQGHUjVPDLRULDVGHRFDVLmRRXVHVXEPHWHUDRV
LQWHUHVVHV GRV JUDQGHV JUXSRV HFRQ{PLFRV H GDTXHOHV
TXHGHWrPRSRGHUSROtWLFR6HPFRUDJHPSDUDID]HUYD
OHUDV³UHJUDVGRMRJR´QmRKi(VWDGR'HPRFUiWLFRGH
'LUHLWRHVLPPHURVLPXODFURDTXLORTXHVHHVWiDFKD
PDUGH(VWDGRSyVGHPRFUiWLFR
&$6$5$5XEHQV(VWDGRSyVGHPRFUiWLFRQHRREVFXUDQWLVPRHJHVWmRGRVLQGHVHMiYHLV5LRGH-DQHL
UR(GLWRUD&LYLOL]DomR%UDVLOHLUDS

\R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \ 163
 7HPRVRPDLRUUHVSHLWRSHODWUDMHWyULDSURILVVLRQDOHDFDGr
PLFDGH5XEHQV&DVDUDPDVGLYHUJLPRVQRSRQWRHPTXHDILUPD
TXHDFRUDJHPpQHFHVViULDSDUDDREVHUYkQFLDGRTXHQRPLQD
FRPRSURMHWRFRQVWLWXFLRQDO
e FHUWR TXH VH SRGH DSRQWDU IDOKDV GR VLVWHPD GH MXVWLoD
EUDVLOHLURRTXHDOLiVSRGHVHUIHLWRWDPEpPFRPUHODomRDRTXH
RFRUUHHPPXLWRVRXWURVSDtVHVPDVpSUHFLVRFRPSUHHQGHUTXHR
UHFRQKHFLPHQWRGRFKDPDGRSURMHWRFRQVWLWXFLRQDOKiGHVHUIHLWR
SRUWRGRVRVRSHUDGRUHVGR'LUHLWRVHMDSDUDUHFRQKHFHUHUHVSHL
WDUGLUHLWRVGRVLQGLFLDGRVQRVLQTXpULWRVSROLFLDLVRXGRVDFXVDGRV
QRVSURFHVVRVFULPLQDLVSURSULDPHQWHGLWRVVHMDSDUDUHFRQKHFHU
HUHVSHLWDUGLUHLWRVGHRXWURVHQYROYLGRVQRFRQWH[WRSURFHVVXDO
2FRUUHTXHRUHFRQKHFLPHQWRHRUHVSHLWRGHGLUHLWRVGHRX
WURVHQYROYLGRVQRFRQWH[WRSURFHVVXDOSRGHHYHQWXDOPHQWHJHUDU
SUHMXt]R DRV LQGLFLDGRV QR LQTXpULWR SROLFLDO RX DRV DFXVDGRV QR
SURFHVVRFULPLQDOWXGRHPREVHUYkQFLDjVFKDPDGDVUHJUDVGRMRJR
2MRJRSURFHVVXDOYHUGDGHLUDPHQWHGHYHVHUMRJDGRFRPD
REVHUYkQFLDGDVUHJUDVTXHOKHVmRSHUWLQHQWHVVHMDSDUDIDYRUH
FHURVLQGLFLDGRVQRVLQTXpULWRVSROLFLDLVHRVUpXVQRVSURFHVVRV
FULPLQDLVVHMDSDUDSUHMXGLFiORVVHQGRDEVROXWDPHQWHLQGHYLGD
DDGRomRGRJDUDQWLVPRSHQDOKLSHUEyOLFRPRQRFXODU
$ILQDOQmRH[LVWHMRJRFXMDVUHJUDVVHPSUHIDYRUHoDPDSH
QDVXPGRVMRJDGRUHVY

5()(5Ç1&,$6%,%/,2*5È),&$6
&$59$/+2$PLOWRQ%XHQRGHGarantismo penal aplicado
5LRGH-DQHLUR(GLWRUD/XPHQ-XULV
&$6$5$5XEHQVEstado pós-democráticoQHRREVFXUDQWLV
PRHJHVWmRGRVLQGHVHMiYHLV5LRGH-DQHLUR(GLWRUD&LYLOL]DomR
%UDVLOHLUD
&/Ê9(&OqPHUVRQ0HUOLQA fiscalização abstrata da consti-
tucionalidade do Direito brasileiro6mR3DXOR(GLWRUD5HYLVWDGRV
7ULEXQDLV
)(55$-2/,/XLJLDireito e razãoWHRULDGRJDUDQWLVPRSH
QDO6mR3DXOR(GLWRUD5HYLVWDGRV7ULEXQDLV

164 \R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \
 ),6&+(5 'RXJODV 2 TXH p JDUDQWLVPR SHQDO LQWHJUDO"
,Q &$/$%5,&+ %UXQR 3(/(//$ (GXDUGR ),6&+(5 'RX
JODV&RRUGGarantismo penal integralTXHVW}HVSHQDLVHSURFHV
VXDLVFULPLQDOLGDGHPRGHUQDHDSOLFDomRGRPRGHORJDUDQWLVWD
QR%UDVLO6DOYDGRU(GLWRUD-XVSRGLYP
675(&./rQLR/XL]Jurisdição constitucional e hermenêutica
3RUWR$OHJUH/LYUDULDGR$GYRJDGR

\R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 22, n. 1, p. 148 - 165, Janeiro-Março. 2020 \ 165