You are on page 1of 8

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/225749595

Pyriculariopsis calatheae sp. nov., a novel anamorphic hyphomycete from the


Atlantic forest of Brazil causing leaf spots on Calathea longifolia

Article  in  Mycological Progress · August 2011


DOI: 10.1007/s11557-010-0704-3

CITATIONS READS

4 451

4 authors, including:

Dartanha J. Soares Fabiano Branco Rocha


Brazilian Agricultural Research Corporation (EMBRAPA) Universidade Federal de Sergipe
59 PUBLICATIONS   605 CITATIONS    15 PUBLICATIONS   357 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Robert Weingart Barreto


Universidade Federal de Viçosa (UFV)
286 PUBLICATIONS   7,019 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Detection of peanut smut (Thecaphora frezii) in Brazilian peanut growing areas with emphasis in the state of Sao Paulo. View project

Prospecting phytopathogenic fungi to the biological control of Ipomoea spp.(morninglories) View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Robert Weingart Barreto on 18 July 2014.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Mycol Progress (2011) 10:315–321
DOI 10.1007/s11557-010-0704-3

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Pyriculariopsis calatheae sp. nov., a novel anamorphic


hyphomycete from the Atlantic forest of Brazil causing leaf
spots on Calathea longifolia
Dartanhã J. Soares & Fabiano B. Rocha &
Lidiane L. Duarte & Robert W. Barreto

Received: 14 June 2010 / Revised: 3 August 2010 / Accepted: 24 August 2010 / Published online: 14 September 2010
# German Mycological Society and Springer 2010

Abstract The new species Pyriculariopsis calatheae is The Marantaceae (prayer-plant family), has a pantropical
described causing leaf spots on Calathea longifolia distribution, but is absent from Australia (Heywood et al.
(Marantaceae). It represents an addition to the mycobiota 2007), it occurs mainly in the Americas, where more than 30
of the tropical seasonal semi-deciduous montane forest, a genera and 350 species occur (Souza and Lorenzi 2008). In
component of the Brazilian Atlantic forest and a highly Brazil, there are 12 native genera and about 150 native
threatened ecosystem. species on record. The largest group of species belongs to
the genus Calathea. Sometimes, plants in this genus become
Keywords Anamorphic fungi . Dematiaceous the main component of the forest understory, especially in
hyphomycetes . Marantaceae . Mycodiversity wet areas, as in some valleys of the Atlantic rainforest.
Species in the genus Calathea are widely used as ornamental
and this is the most easily recognized genus, within the
Introduction Marantaceae (Souza and Lorenzi 2008).
Observation of fresh samples of C. longifolia leaves
In December 2003, during a 4-day fungal survey in a bearing those necrotic spots revealed the presence of a
stretch of tropical seasonal semi-deciduous montane forest, dematiaceous hyphomycete constantly associated with such
a component of the Brazilian Atlantic forest and a highly lesions. The fungus was readily recognized as belonging to
threatened ecosystem (see Soares and Barreto 2005, for the Dactylaria–Pyricularia complex; however, after more
more details) in the municipality of Viçosa (state of Minas careful examination, it was concluded that it better fitted
Gerais) Brazil, leaves of Calathea longifolia (Schauer) within Pyriculariopsis M.B. Ellis sensu Matsushima
Klotzsch ex Körn (Marantaceae) showing large necrotic (1975). This paper provides an account on the morphology
spots were collected (Fig. 1). and identity of this fungus.

Taxonomical novelty: Pyriculariopsis calatheae D.J. Soares, F.B. Materials and methods
Rocha & R.W. Barreto
D. J. Soares : F. B. Rocha : L. L. Duarte : R. W. Barreto (*) Samples with foliar spots were collected, examined under a
Departamento de Fitopatologia, Universidade Federal de Viçosa,
stereo-microscope and dried in a plant press. Slides with
Viçosa, Minas Gerais 36570-00, Brazil
e-mail: rbarreto@ufv.br free-hand sections of infected plant tissues and fungal
structures scraped from the surface were mounted in
D. J. Soares
e-mail: dartjs@yahoo.com.br lactophenol. Representative specimens of the fungus were
deposited in the herbarium at the Universidade Federal de
Present Address: Viçosa (Herbarium VIC).
D. J. Soares
Observations, measurements and line drawings were
Embrapa Algodão,
Rua Oswaldo Cruz 1143, prepared using an Olympus BX 50 light microscope fitted
Centenário, Campina Grande/PB, Brazil 58428-095 with a drawing tube. Measurements of taxonomically
316 Mycol Progress (2011) 10:315–321

relevant structures were made at ×1,000 magnification.


Samples were also examined under scanning electronic
microscope (SEM). Small leaf fragments bearing abundant
fungal structures were selected and dried for 7 days in a
dessicator containing silica-gel. The leaf fragments were
then covered with a gold-palladium coat in a sputter
coater (Balzers; FDU 010) and examined under a SEM
(Carl Zeiss; LEO VP 1430) with variable pressure.
The fungus isolation was performed by directly trans-
ferring conidia with a sterile fine-pointed needle from the
lesions onto Petri dishes containing Vegetable Broth Agar
(Pereira et al. 2003). Pure cultures were preserved in silica-
gel (as described in Dhingra and Sinclair 1995), and were
deposited at the culture collection of the Departamento de
Fitopatologia of the Universidade Federal de Viçosa
(accession number: OF 55) and in the reference culture
centre Coleção Brasileira de Microrganismos de Ambiente
e Industria of the UNICAMP (accession number: CBMAI
1060).
Cultures were described based on observations of
colonies produced as follows: 5-mm-diam culture discs,
obtained from the margin of actively growing 7-day-old
cultures, were transferred to the centre of each of a series of
plates contain 15 mL of V8 juice-agar (V8), malt extract
agar (MEA) (2%) and potato dextrose agar (PDA); plates
were sealed with cling film and maintained in a growth
chamber with a temperature of 26±2°C for 7 days with a
12-h light regime (light provided by two white and one
near-UV lamp located 35 cm above the plates).
Three healthy individuals of Calathea longifolia were
used to perform the pathogenicity test. Each individual was
sprayed with a 1.0 x 106 conidia/mL conidial suspension in
0.5% Tween 20. Half of the leaves of each individual plant
were surface-injured with the help of a sterile needle. The
control (non-inoculated) plants with and without injuries
were sprayed with a 0.5% Tween 20 suspension. After
inoculation, the plants were placed in a humid chamber for
48 h and then moved to a greenhouse. The plants were
examined for disease symptoms 10 and 20 days after
inoculation.
DNA was extracted as follows: culture discs taken
from the margin of actively growing colonies on PDA
were transferred to liquid medium (as described in
Alfenas 1998) and incubated during 7 days under 27°C
Fig. 1 Pyriculariopsis calatheae leaf spot symptoms on Calathea in the dark. Mycelium was dried in the dark at room
longifolia. a General view of the plants in the forest understory
showing leaf spot symptoms. b Close-up view of a severely damaged
temperature and powdered in liquid nitrogen using a
leaf. c Close-up view of a leaf spot (adaxial surface). d Close-up view mortar and pestle. DNA was extracted using the cetyl-
of a leaf spot (abaxial surface). e,f Result of pathogenicity test 10 (e) trimethylammonium bromide (CTAB)-based protocol
and 20 (f) days after inoculation showing similar leaf spots from those (Murray and Thompson 1980). The pellet was resus-
observed in the field
pended with 40 μm Tris-EDTA + RNAase at 37°C for 2 h.
Sequence of the ITS region were amplified by PCR using
the reverse primer ITS4 and the forward primer ITS5 (White
et al. 1990). The amplification reaction were performed in a
Mycol Progress (2011) 10:315–321 317

50-μl reaction volume [PCR conditions: 1 μl each primer, Colonies on PDA, MEA and V8 are very similar,
1 μl DNTPs, 1 μl DNA, 0.7 μl Taq (phoneutria), 3.75 μl initially white becoming greyish with age, lanose at the
buffer, 1.25 μl MgCl2, 40.3 μl H2O]. After electrophoresis in centre velvety at the edges, with uneven margin and with
0.8% agarose gel stained with ethidium bromide, DNA was concentric diurnal zonation (less conspicuous on V8), dry,
purified using the High Pure PCR Product Purification Kit but with inconspicuous formation of small droplets appear-
(Roche Mannheim, Germany). ing over the mycelium with age; reaching 14 mm diam. on
The purified product was sequenced using Big Dye PDA, 16 mm diam. on MEA and 20 mm diam. on V8 after
Terminator Cycle Sequencing Kits (v3.1; Applied Bio- 7 days; sporulating on all media (abundantly in older
systems, Foster City, CA, USA) with the same primers as cultures) under the growth conditions provided.
used for amplification on the MegaBACETM1000 DNA
Sequencing System. The sequence was edited by the Notes A literature search for fungi reported as associated to
Staden Package, ver. 1.6.0 (Staden 1996) to generate a Calathea spp. and other genera of the Marantaceae yielded
consensus sequence. no species of Pyriculariopsis. The new species was
compared with the eight accepted species in the genus
Pyriculasiopsis following the key provided by Iturriaga
Taxonomy et al. (2008), and had a morphology that was distinct from
all of those species. It is of significance that a Pyricularia
Pyriculariopsis calatheae D.J. Soares, F.B. Rocha & R.W. leaf-spot (viz. P. guarumaicola F.C. Albuquerque & M.L.
Barreto sp. nov. (Figs 1, 2 and 3) Duarte, recorded as Piricularia guarumeicolae) was
MycoBank: 512390 recorded from the Brazilian Amazon on Ischnosiphon
GenBank: GU294490 simplex Hub. (Albuquerque and Duarte 1971), and a second
Affinis Pyriculariopsis parasitica sed conidiophoribus record of a Pyricularia causing leaf-spots on Marantaceae
brevioribus (36–170 μm) et conidiibus minoribus (18–36× was made in Greece by Pappas and Paplomatas (1998). The
5–7 μm), 1–2 septatis differt. latter authors recorded Pyricularia oryzae Cavara on
Teleomorph: not seen Ctenanthe oppenheimiana (E.Morr.) K. Schum. and C.
Etymology: based on the host genus setosa Eichl., imported from Brazil, and showed, by
Holotype: Brazil, Minas Gerais, Viçosa, ‘Mata do Seu inoculation tests, that isolates from Ctenanthe had a wide
Nico’ on Calathea longifolia (Marantaceae), December of host range within the Marantaceae, including several
2003, D.J. Soares (VIC 30699; ex-type culture CBMAI Calathea species, but isolates from rice did not cause
1060). infections on marantaceous hosts. In both cases, the correct
Lesions on living leaves amphigenous, starting as small generic identity of the fungus is to be regarded as doubtful
yellow dots becoming circular to elliptic, pale-brown to since identifications were based mainly in the conidial
brown, sometimes with a darker centre and with concentric morphology and no reference was made to conidial
haloes, the external halo dark-brown, surrounded by a large secession, which is critical for the placement of fungi in
dark-yellow border fading into irregular paler and indistinct Pyricularia or Pyriculariopsis. Illustrations in both cases
margins, 0.5–11×0.5–7.5 cm, sometimes coalescing and seem to show a schizolytic rather than rhexolytic secession
leading to the necrosis of significant portions of leaves; on and the symptoms are highly similar to those described
petioles elliptic, similar in colour to the foliar lesions, but here. Nevertheless, both P. guarumaicola and P. oryzae
smaller and with a narrow yellow border; conidiophores (isolate from Ctenanthe) have conidial sizes which are
macronematous, isolate, straight, cylindrical, 36–170×4– clearly distinct from those of P. calatheae. While P.
5.5 μm, usually inflated at the base reaching 9.0 μm diam., guarumaicola has conidia 20–28×10–12 μm and P. oryzae
0–7 septate, chestnut to dark brown, darker and thicker- from Ctenanthe has conidia 18–32×7–12 μm; the conidia
walled at the base, paler toward the apex, smooth; in P. calatheae are narrower, 18-36×5–7 μm ,and have a
conidiogenous cells polyblastic terminal, becoming inter- clearly rostrate apex which is absent or not so pronounced
calary, cylindrical, proliferating sympodially, denticulate, in the other species.
22.5–70×3.5–5.5 μm, pale brown to subhyaline, smooth; A fragment of approximately 490 bp was amplified and
denticles conic-truncated, not separated by septa, 0.5– the sequence data were submitted to the National Center for
1.5 μm long, conidia acropleurogenous, cylindrical- Biotechnology Information, where it was assigned the
fusiform to obclavate, 18–36×5–7 μm, 1–2-septate, often accession number GU294490. This was compared by
with a rostrate apical cell, 3–12×2–4 μm, pale brown to BLASTn with other entries in Genbank, and the closest
subhyaline, basal cell paler and supra-basal cell darker, match was Pyricularia costina (GenBank Accession
smooth, hila protuberant, sometimes somewhat dark; GQ340561) with 91% of nucleotide homology (over
conidial secession schizolytic. 100% query coverage). Our isolate also shares 89% of
318 Mycol Progress (2011) 10:315–321

Fig. 2 Conidiophores and


conidia of Pyriculariopsis
calatheae. a A conidiophore
with attached conidia. b,c
Apices of conidiophores
showing the paler
conidiogenous cells and the
conic-truncate denticles (note in
c a younger conidium still
attached to a denticle). d A
close-up of the inflated base of
the conidiophore. e–g Conidia
(note: in e the versicolorous
conidium with a paler basal cell;
in f the schizolytic conidial
secession, arrowed; and in g
some darker hila, arrowed).
Scale bars 10 μm, except in (a)
20 μm

identity with Pyricularia zingiberis (GenBank Accession contradict this. No obvious entrance wounds were seen in
AB274434) and 88% with Dactylaria junci (GenBank association with the fungus in the field or on samples
Accession AY265320). There are no other entries in brought to the laboratory. Controls did not develop leaf
Genbank with sequences of ITS rDNA region for Pyricu- spots. The fungus was reisolated from the inoculated leaves
lariopsis isolates available for comparisons. fulfilling Koch’s postulates.
Ten days after inoculation, the first symptoms were
observed as small spots (∼5 mm diam.) (Fig. 1e) and
20 days after inoculation, typical lesions of P. calatheae
with sporulation were observed (Fig. 1f). Such lesions only Discussion
developed on leaves that has previously been injured; intact
leaves that were inoculated remained healthy. Although this Pyriculariopsis was erected to accommodate P. parasitica
could be interpreted as an indication that P. calatheae is a (Sacc. & Berl.) M.B. Ellis (Syn.: Pyricularia musae S.
secondary, opportunistic pathogen, observations in the field Hughes) (Ellis 1971). Ellis recognized it as differing from
Mycol Progress (2011) 10:315–321 319

Fig. 3 Scanning electron


micrographs and line-drawings
of conidia and conidiophores of
Pyriculariopsis calatheae. a,b
Detail of the inflated base of the
conidiophores showing its origin
directly through the host
epidermis. c Detail of the
conic-truncate denticles. d
Rostrate conidia and the
conidiophores with inflated and
darker bases and paler rostrate
apices. Scale bars 10 μm

Pyricularia by the absence of a septum separating its preferred to maintain the genus Pyriculariopsis based on its
denticles from the conidiophore. Therefore, Ellis (1971) short, stout conidiophores and rostrate conidia rather than
interpreted the conidial secession in Pyriculariopsis as on its conidial secession. Although the significance of
schizolytic whereas in Pyricularia this would be rhexolytic. conidial secession as a character in the Pyricularia–
Later, Matsushima (1975) also recognized the conidial Pyriculariopsis remains an unresolved issue, which was
secession in Pyriculariopsis as schizolytic rather than left aside in recent publications dealing with this genus such
rhexolytic as in Pyricularia. This assumption was followed as Park and Shing (2009) and Iturriaga et al. (2008). A
in the descriptions of species of Pyriculariopsis by several recent molecular study (Bussaban et al. 2005) reinforces the
authors (Davydkina and Melnik 1989; Matsushima 1989; separation between Pyricularia and Pyriculariopsis and
Castañeda Ruiz and Kendrick 1990; Reddy et al 2002). additionally placed Pyriculariopsis outside the Magnapor-
Conversely, de Hoog and van Oorschot (1985) noted that thaceae clade. These authors concluded that the genus
illustrations of the type species of Pyriculariopsis given in Pyriculariopsis should be maintained based mainly in its
Matsushima (1980) showed the conidial secession to be straight or curved, obclavate and rostrate conidia, a trait
rhexolytic instead of schizolytic. Even so these authors also useful to separate Pyriculariopsis from the still
320 Mycol Progress (2011) 10:315–321

polyphyletic genus Dactylaria. The present study on P. fact that Zingiberales is a sister order with Commelinales
calatheae and observations on other members of Pyricular- and Poales, the possibility of such a relationship among
iopsis suggests that an additional feature that appears useful these pathogenic species appears even more likely, since
for the delimitation of Pyriculariopsis, and that apparently almost all species belonging to Pyricularia have been found
has been overlooked by previous workers, is the presence and described on hosts belonging to these orders of
of versicolorous conidia which was consistently observed monocots and may have coevolved with their hosts.
or illustrated for most species accepted in this genus, as
pointed out by Whitton et al. (2001). Nevertheless, Acknowledgements The authors thank the Conselho Nacional de
Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq) and the Fundação
confirmation of this character-state is still required for
de Amparo à Pesquisa de Minas Gerais (FAPEMIG) for financial
Pyriculariopsis amomi (Z.D. Jiang & P.K. Chi) X.H. Lai & support; SEM work was undertaken at the Núcleo de Microscopia e
H.L. Gao (Lai & Gao 1991). Microanálises of the Universidade Federal de Viçosa with the
Presently eight species are accepted in Pyriculariopsis technical support of Claudia A. Vanetti.
(Iturriaga et al. 2008). These appear to belong to two
distinct ecological groups: one is composed of saprotrophs,
occurring on foliar and stem debris and the other includes References
plant pathogens parasitizing monocot hosts belonging to the
Zingiberales. The former includes the following species: P. Albuquerque FC, Duarte LR (1971) Duas novas espécies de
appendiculata Matsush., P. breviphora Matsush., P. indica Pyricularia coletadas na Amazônia. Pesquisa Agropecuária Bras
6:177–181
B.S. Reddy, Manohar., D.K. Agarwal & V. Rao, P. miogae Alfenas AC (1998) Eletroforese de izoenzimas e proteínas afins:
Matsush., P. formosa R.Fernández, R.F. Castañeda & Iturr. fundamentos e aplicações em plantas e microrganismos. Editora
and P. theobromae R.F. Castañeda & W.B. Kendr. The UFV, Viçosa, MG
latter includes: P. parasitica, P. amomi and the new species Bussaban B, Lumyong S, Lumyong P, Hyde KD, McKenzie EHC
(2003) Three new species of Pyricularia are isolated as
P. calatheae. An additional undetermined Pyriculariopsis zingiberaceous endophytes from Thailand. Mycologia 95:519–
was also recorded causing leaf spots on Heliconia in 524
Hawaii, but no description of that fungus was provided Bussaban B, Lumyong S, Seelanan T, Park DC, McKenzie EHC,
(Uchida and Kadooka 1994). Hyde KD (2005) Molecular and morphological characterization
of Pyricularia and allied genera. Mycologia 97:1002–1011
The fact that the BLAST search performed indicated that Castañeda Ruiz RF, Kendrick B (1990) Conidial fungi from Cuba: II.
isolates belonging to Pyricularia and Dactylaria shared the University of Waterloo Biology Series 32:1–61
highest homology with our isolate is explained by the Davydkina TA, Melnik VA (1989) Two new hyphomycetes from the
absence of sequences of ITS rDNA region for Pyricular- genera Cordana and Pyriculariopsis. Mikol Fitopatol 23:110–113
de Hoog GS, van Oorschot CAN (1985) Taxonomy of Dactylaria
iopsis in GenBank and the known close relationship of complex VI. Key to the genera and check-list of epithets. Stud
these two genera with Pyriculariopsis (Bussaban et al. Mycol 26:97–122
2005). Dhingra OD, Sinclair JB (1995) Basic plant pathology methods, 2nd
The genus Pyricularia was recently confirmed to be edn. Lewis, Boca Raton
Ellis MB (1971) Dematiaceous hyphomycetes. CMI, Kew, Surrey,
monophyletic (Hirata et al 2007) and it would be of interest, England
although outside the scope of the present work, that a Heywood VH, Brummitt RK, Culham A, Seberg O (2007) Flowering
molecular-phylogenetic study is performed for members of plant families of the world. Firefly, Ontario, Canada
Pyriculariopsis and related taxa, and to test the hypothesis Hirata K, Kusaba M, Chuma I, Osue J, Nakayashiki H, Mayama S,
Tosa Y (2007) Speciation in Pyricularia inferred from multilocus
that pathogenic species of Pyriculariopsis and Pyricularia phylogenetic analysis. Mycol Res 111:799–808
have a common ancestor, particularly those which are Iturriaga T, Fernández R, Castañeda Ruiz RF, Minter DW, Abarca GH
pathogens of members of the Zingiberales. This plant order (2008) A new anamorphic fungus from Venezuela: Pyricular-
includes all known hosts of Pyriculariopsis, a likely iopsis formosa. Mycotaxon 105:337–342
Lai XH, Gao HL (1991) A new combination of Pyriculariopsis. Acta
indication of evolutionary specialization within this host Mycol Sinica 10:79–80
order, similar to that conjectured for Pyricularia (Bussaban Matsushima T (1975) Icones microfungorum a Matsushima lectorum.
et al 2003; 2005) and for the pathogenic species of Cordana Published by the author, Kobe, Japan
(Soares et al 2005). Such a study may prove that species of Matsushima T (1980) Saprophytic microfungi from Taiwan. Part1.
Hyphomycetes. Matsushima Mycol Mem 1:1–82
Pyricularia/Pyriculariopsis on Zingiberales are closely Matsushima T (1989) Matsushima Mycol Mem 7:1–100
related and distinct from the group of saprotrophic species Murray MG, Thompson WF (1980) Rapid isolation of high molecular
in Pyriculariopsis and from those of Pyricularia described weight plant DNA. Nucleic Acids Res 8:4321–4325
in others monocots hosts. Isolates of Pyricularia guaru- Pappas AC, Paplomatas EJ (1998) Pyricularia leaf spot: a new disease
of ornamental plants of the family Marantaceae. Plant Dis
maicola, P. oryzae (isolate from Ctenanthe), as well as 82:465–469
several others previously described as causing disease on Park MJ, Shin HD (2009) A new species of Pyricularia on
members of Zingiberales should be included. In view of the Commelina communis. Mycotaxon 108:449–456
Mycol Progress (2011) 10:315–321 321

Pereira JM, Barreto EC, Maffia LA (2003) Corynespora cassiicola f. no Brasil, baseado em APGII, 2nd edn. Editora Plantarum, Nova
sp. lantanae: a potential biocontrol agent for Lantana camara Odessa, São Paulo, Brazil
from Brazil. Biol Control 26:21–31 Staden R (1996) The Staden Sequence Analysis Package. Mol
Reddy BS, Manoharachary C, Agarwal DK, Rao V (2002) Two new Biotechnol 5:233–241
hyphomycetes from India. Indian Phytopathol 55:213–215 Uchida JY, Kadooka CY (1994) A new disease of Heliconia caused
Soares DJ, Barreto RW (2005) Pseudocercospora siparunae a new by Pyriculariopsis. Phytopathology 84:1119 [Abstract].
cercosporoid fungi from the Brazilian Tropical Forest. Myco- White TJ, Bruns T, Lee S, Taylor J (1990) Amplification and direct
taxon 92:273–277 sequencing of fungal ribosomal RNA genes for phylogenetics.
Soares DJ, Nechet KL, Barreto RW (2005) Cordana versicolor sp. In: Innis MA, Gelfand DH, Sninsky JJ, White TJ (eds) PCR
nov. (dematiaceous hyphomycete) causing leaf-spot on Canna protocols: a guide to methods and applications. Academic, San
denudata (Cannaceae) in Brazil, with observations on Cordana Diego, pp 315–322
musae. Fungal Divers 18:147–155 Whitton SR, McKenzie EHC, Hyde KD (2001) Microfungi on the
Souza HM, Lorenzi H (2008) Botânica sistemática – Guia ilustrado Pandanaceae: Nakatopsis gen. nov., a new hyphomyecete genus
para identificação das famílias de fanerógamas nativas e exóticas from Malaysia. Fungal Divers 8:163–171

View publication stats

You might also like