IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA, CRIMINAL DIVISION “X” CASE NO: 50-2017-CF-008722-AXXX-MB STATE OF FLORIDA. vs, SHEILA KEEN-WARREN, Defendant J ADDENDUM TO MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION AND MOTION FOR ISSUANCE OF WRITTEN OPINION ON ORDER DENYING DEFENDANT'S SECOND AND THIRD MOTIONS TO COMPEL ‘THE STATE TO PRODUCE BRADY INFORMATION The Defendant, Sheila Keen-Warren, through undersigned counsel, hereby files this addendum to her Motion for Reconsideration and Motion for Issuance of Written Opinion on Order Denying Defendant’s Second and Third Motions to Compel the State to Produce Brady Information. [D.E, No. 863]. This Addendum addresses the following evidence, which mysteriously appeared five years after Ms. Keen-Warren’s arrest and nine days before her trial— the “clown sighting file” Clown s 1ghTiNg’S In further support of this Motion, the Defendant states as follows: I. In her Third Motion to Compel the State to Produce Brady Information, Ms. Keen-Warren moved this Court to order the State to produce this “clown sighting fille.” [D.E.No. 845]. According to the initial lead detective, Detective Bill Williams, this file contains clown sightings and citizen leads from the day of Marlene Warren’s murder, which he placed in a file called the “clown sighting file.” Jd. at | 2. For the past 40 months, dating back to June 26, 2019, the State maintained that it did not have the file, and the current lead detective, Detective Paige McCann, refused to look for this file. Id. at 2. 3. For this reason, Ms. Keen-Warren sought relief from this Court to protect her constitutional rights pursuant to Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963). She asked the Court to order the State to look for evidence that could secure her freedom—nothing more: As of the date of this Motion, the State has failed to produce the clown sighting file. The State has relied on a lead detective who is unwilling to do anything to locate this evidence. This is especially disconcerting because the file contains other leads to this homicide and would necessarily aid Ms. Keen-Warren’s defense. As such, Ms. Keen-Warren moves this Court to enter an Order requiring the State to search for and immediately turn over the clown sighting file Ud. 2-3, 4. On October 11, 2022, at the hearing on Defendant’s motions to compel, the State id-not-dispute-that-the-requested- information” constituted Brady material, —Without-“any evidentiary support, the State told this Court that it did not have the information and materials that the Defendant requested, The State maintained that it did its due diligence. The Defense, on the other hand, provided the Court with transcripts from Detective McCann's depositions where she conceded that she did nothing to locate this file. 5. Nevertheless, following the hearing, the Court issued a written order summarily denying Ms. Keen-Warren’s motion and did not order the State to look for this exculpatory evidence,6 On October 12, 2022, one day after the hearing, eight days before her trial, 40 months after the initial request, and 60 months after her arrest, the State informed the Defense that it found new evidence: the “clown sighting file.” Exhibit 1, Clown Sighting File. 7. The State admitted that the clown sighting file was located in, of all places, a box at the State Attorney's Office. 8. The State further admitted that this is the same box that contained the other crucial discovery the State produced last month, 4.5 years after Ms. Keen-Warren’s arrest. 9. Specifically, the State found the clown sighting file in the same box where it found the initial lead homicide investigator, Tim Valentine's, case file from 1991. This ease file contained a new witness who calls into question the reliability of the State's witnesses from the costume shop.! 10. ‘The State claimed that it did not see the “clown sighting file” when it initially looked through the box. The State said that the “clown sighting file” may have been mislabeled. To be clear, the folder is labeled “clown sightings.” 11. The 25-page “clown sighting file” contains roughly 40 credible leads, These leads have names, addresses, and phone numbers, Needless to say, this will take the Defense considerable time and resources to investigate. 12. Ideally, this Court would not have to order the State to do its job, but, as the Defense has pointed out time and again, this is not ideal. Ms. Keen-Warren deserves a fair trial. WHEREFORE, the Defendant respectfully files this Addendum and requests that this Honorable Court grant its Motion for Reconsideration. ' The Defense relayed this to the Court when explaining that the State’s repeated discovery violations have made it impossible to effectively prepare for trial, 3Respectfully submitted, (s/ Greg Rosenfeld és/Amy Morse GREG ROSENFELD, ESQ AMY MORSE, ESQ. Florida Bar No.: 92006 Florida Bar No.: 388475 Law OFFICES OF GREG ROSENFELD, P.A, Morse AND Morst, L.L.C. SISN, Flagler Drive, Suite P-300 2240 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard, Suite 300 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 West Palm Beach, FL 33409 (561) 409-5804 (561) 651-4145 Greg@RosenfeldLegal.com Amy@MorseLegal.com Attorney for Defendant Attorney for Defendant &/ Jesse Ison JESSE W. ISOM, ESQ. Florida Bar No.: 98588 Law OrrIces OF GREG ROSENFELD, P.A. SISN. Flagler Drive, Suite P-300 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 (561) 409-5804 Greg@RosenfeldLegal.com Attomey for Defendant CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE THEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing has been furnished by e-service to the Office of the State Attorney, Division “MCU,” at FELMCU@sal5.org: Reid Scott, Assistant State Attomey, at RScott@sal5.org: Kristen Grimes, Assistant State Attorney, at KGrimes@sal5.org; and Amy Morse, sq, Attorney for the Defendant, at Amy@morselegal.com, on this 13th day of October, 2022, 4/ Greg Rosenfeld Greg Rosenfeld, Esq, Law OFFICES OF GREG ROSENFELD, P.A.EXHIBIT 1OF-7OI7 ZF Wir berthGOT E T rr cer a Orerge Pants laewsy Lome Aro - overg Wis a Wns Ait te Send Tent Very Hemry 300 65 ~ | Sgueaey Uri Look) ile Waren Le Wea Prpgh cancph {0 %m ~ Appt Upon Tenet QM - 12[s[1 wIF Lele rots Early 30'S ie Woknmm wn oe wip by Inorg Eckard STREATOOE WMUNGER BTBSON “etentones reese cal LY - CametaSeevou CJ. wilicatragsin CJ] - fiowrneaYourcan [-] — Wenlstaseeyou L}S90 Wes, OW Fd arate Haye A/e Netbeloimido Uc the, Phe Mees shopoul) GrIyo, Des haute hour Reddy tableny > ptendin. AL peor pthok gees be dtl. thisinbac ) he yan) hers Gow panda iL ubats fo te Cnchen vical Elie nighecSlupey 0OF/Bpagn G-PP-FO. Satey) Cee Ca — ov bt oppo $2002. ut - Out Beleedor ae: ? Lott OY SEL (tg atl _hacwyr tee x at Ler, emg FSR |g ALL. Ot HAL. ae roe Sb - Heol 77028 ee K Ae weg wf Bat * lows ac . (baaked bike ee BIL ON FE fos wipe tie Le gc ha ae pap Mf?| | | Gell | sl Fo ZS iste Ree, ee Reem Avo w/mr SRUN He sew & Passe wiry cwwe Pwr Dalek e As wH ore CeRatews east mee gue Se rerser | eee Seae: et A | on Sar S/ze BeTwten | (Ze ew, | : (S00 Seas RAM Sagara Beets eee 14 Here Tee OFF Sree ar oe pte cere oN “enmicwoes be" oc SFE SHE SH A whe Le Banen, Gouyernate Foe : Greta BY Ersrec> aw eres, ——— oa dint & 10% Ave: (slesthond) oth Bed Cov- Barek o Olds 4:00 - 41S Am Saaz inevning Cefawsred S- 25-59 de Oreba BIEB/4 6 Fut ip Cwunw soir feeo wie GEOL ewe HR, (277% sr ¢ ME 16 ave morrt Minar Cre, = Prank Wind Dye ccm lotr ¢ FLA. Mongo Tork - Heavy St (Bebines i was) VAW= Black 6 Sylar only | pes. Orenyist Lig ~ Mowe, gles, sdaflid upr= Ste wat into Eclares - HHS Am = V3 OAm,Crssanore Peer, o——s Kaye, PB, Fl. fr Se Gay a Clow Bk Bend chen en pelle fete ttt ao Bo Ce a elo car — Senet - KH Ty. =e 7 je IST ewwnenet Life Long slice colons Sel — hte shmeeGlulfo Qase tur t aad igo Dek eeeainmmmms s 310/4 8 ae feos G AM OSEATF ow win on May 20 Ar PUBL seme Looms ee farson cane veo Rae ste wom & Betisak "SAD yeuR THR Ghee wer! Cees caiee. peer ee ot tere Ageet aC Went Feeuy Soe eo —— a omens *K/ * wr 35-do eee rlayy (7s 090 Dard AH wee sie , Ro ac a Harpe. ya Ge [cae ey OT pe OLee qerlt clemeas, Re Vet Scere re on OS wlaer D, Liss Thar | 1s £4 aa JSTors @ Fan sc0%?23 _ Seksa209- Hata aE ww A) ESS Liujlai 625) (a pee pedustiies SAT abot (1:00 © 1: 30am red bn folle I 7? front? GJoor of, 2 noste beset 19 Chaar wwtfre~ osled Mirection for wider DL¢bAS/ facihty jy Grea - Hd Yold biag & wos betynd LhLe 2149 pctson AL fot Lijit Alla. ter gt at oF Va” : Atte teva.Brig ht Ves . 4 i orarge Mianand fen) “sf B89 fe wl Fe ut Ful good > bg . mansk Gairrld ‘anand NWT) Lorie avr arcerd eyes wl Bible, we. Jeo oy far79E)OS-A9-FO. we sa ex 7 ee On (ee = fOwd/ \ (fee oe ew kh on C js prod: Ai. dea ty a Clit olaeg not Aerie BM aK COA = a lee ne geet) Lhar EW Ga.O5-AP-9O. Ge eae sh jor (ee S41 = | Mn bony Ge oe pe BS aA ta ana & Ca _ Ck Ce a Clin pate net Aeynt nL AAD ox CON ovr?) CO tO OSE na (qeseny Lihat Ww Car. ee16:00 gan feds re are Blvd. € ofr (ae) 7 hike Cae lm EXE four aie whe then 7 Sila Beuguct Reseding Hat BAcomsc@® Booeet et Teles ae ‘BEATA s (20/4 2315 ape [write Cpe OULU TABLE sliaive = 5s f2elne Gee eam Give ~ Greer LET SS) Ppce Porm Conde a2) || ae ew (2 sr fureTs ep Pam BteKe Lancs: (74s wwe wie saw SsuBseer Ger eer er OE, ea Pare Cag Ry so tot HiaTes (2D Rte tat * azal fn po EC sure / wares ei UR (BAD pone EIS Ar RELY, wate a. (z0eo — SEE aAOO Seedgol 5 g-27-40 -(y ore. Epe Tes Bes 0% cot TY (in SR om SITU Ar BOO reas Geese Oa eaten ate iat Anan e We, BAT ue Tena wae crow) Mar nO pe ge ee. Ue tee ET ree SET. “ O627 non = An? | Pree WALLY EC anseak stan? ee cer oF monte wou Cee Bush Aes & beer oe eee Gace Spe cecos ce Gere cee ee RU I actentee Ae 8 cego, WER Swe le GRETA Semmes ee THIS tT cepone D SASL ae, wehT™M SeunrD (Be 7 Bere ie SB ¢ Paracas 0110 Rae Va AN tae? SO EGER ar cau tS BD zee BA ee “ 0935 mamma SOS TIERED” QDoesee Ree | say somtene fartuap 1 Marnier Pece S4erR me Cane > Gem™meue un An a) Ae SH TE testo, Secs Mae fe450 Wb isyt TA. lod a5 Opell, (Mk —= Si CLD) On Te faclo- hrc. Yb leredle Poul. fsa. Qt 10:2 Am. Wal bers. Cao Wap Chuan 14 Colon - 2uskd Qntad. man drrooed Ab Boas ad. Red Nase 0 Wig Cred Qik MAdouys) [Mas dlicdrt fee A100. Audit QYyanecad Gilt Pitke (Au- Liab: ee Brower COeerty wha Clore" Leetlins One” —_————— oe ibe Shigt hesnd. Remember lbat Gar Lethad Like. 64 rake Chu. - hoe LO Unsttry ppg Olid t- Oddiat2Suen aam i — ee = saat ait _Lle#. “Ze Saf term lel, L100 df | 2 Flas si J night Ioan 2 ae a a Lin —— -— Rb NB _L_ Clown seit eee cote day, bac {EEO ia Lldlfewerl, me LSsps/'t 6 / San Odea brbarwAa I === BIE Bloe pHreaoxr fo bunoer fog Dawe Thee = ert elrew— Aa. fe A Sm Mac - 41055. are Proce. atv Ewhewye ve Beebib o— Mecetv< ecm. eins, AGUA L., aks Ly tek, [295 weet pur on Mates £0 tau bhowre on Var CLrew. 440d whe gelen, Leen abget hha fy ee wel face — ee ART, Vak ate pesct rr LY lacles CL We pee a ES eeo6sg sfav[70 Det piithioma week Si 3 1D) the. ——— 2 FEST ID sg GRE FR en ae a Pe - 2200 ew —eherern ued grren e 2 ae del pet ee clot. ma ade. as tare oe oS ge pele 4 a> eure en z - evoke eth elem rakes pa grey | ene sant om _t2 : spe posed ina sig ch pees bey sha _evosth torn Tc bebo a plin ft Dy eee Stix. 1800 eee vesSIGNED "Tors @ Form soe-030~ $30 Jo SE) ELIE ae a Ma a « coer cet’ a Lok far $7960 "Yh. cd ab-3-Ge | oe2e | BM 9,4 Batlouae L Wbnth a fo OE ie as 3 au er 8 mee OE re a B-/), fp facilhe anew 4 Bolelttee a. Po