Professional Documents
Culture Documents
High-Quality, High-Volume Spay & Neuter & Other Shelter Surgeries
High-Quality, High-Volume Spay & Neuter & Other Shelter Surgeries
com
High-Quality, High-Volume Spay and Neuter and Other Shelter Surgeries
www.ajlobby.com
www.ajlobby.com
High-Quality, High-Volume Spay and Neuter and
Other Shelter Surgeries
www.ajlobby.com
Sara White
2020
ISBN-13: 9781118517208
www.ajlobby.com
v
Contents
List of Contributors ix
Preface xiii
Acknowledgments xv
3 Instrumentation for Spay–Neuter 53
Amber Burton and Sara White
4 Asepsis 65
Brian A. DiGangi
www.ajlobby.com
vi Contents
19 Amputation 375
Joseph P. Weigel
www.ajlobby.com
Contents vii
www.ajlobby.com
viii Contents
Index 633
www.ajlobby.com
ix
List of Contributors
Mark W. Bohling, DVM, PhD, DACVS Brian A. DiGangi, DVM, MS, DABVP (Canine &
Staff Surgeon Feline Practice, Shelter Medicine Practice)
Animal Emergency and Specialty Center Senior Director, Shelter Medicine
Knoxville, TN, USA Shelter Outreach
Member, 2008 and 2016 ASV Veterinary Task ASPCA
Force to Advance Spay‐Neuter Gainesville, FL, USA
Karla Brestle, DVM Diana L. Eubanks, DVM, MS, DABVP (canine and
Senior Director – Strategic Medical feline), Fellow Academy of Veterinary Dentistry
Operations Clinical Professor
ASPCA Spay/Neuter Alliance Service Chief, Community Veterinary Services
Asheville, NC, USA Department of Clinical Sciences
Member, 2008 and 2016 ASV Mississippi State University College of
Veterinary Task Force to Advance Veterinary Medicine
Spay‐Neuter Mississippi State, MS, USA
Stephanie Janeczko, DVM, MS, DABVP Sheilah Robertson, BVMS (Hons), PhD, DACVAA,
(Canine & Feline Practice, Shelter Medicine DECVAA, DACAW, DECAWBM (WSEL),
Practice), CAWA CVA, MRCVS
Vice President, Shelter Medicine Services Senior Medical Director
Shelter & Veterinary Services Lap of Love Veterinary Hospice
ASPCA Member, 2016 ASV Veterinary Task Force to
New York, NY, USA Advance Spay‐Neuter
Preface
Why do we need a spay and neuter textbook? document was published in JAVMA in 2008 as
Spaying and neutering are often the first “The Association of Shelter Veterinarians’ vet-
(and in some cases, the only) surgeries that erinary medical care guidelines for spay‐neuter
students learn in veterinary school, and are programs” (Looney et al. 2008). The goals of
expected skills for every new graduate in gen- these guidelines were to promote acceptance of
eral small‐ or mixed‐animal practice. It can be spay–neuter practice by the veterinary pro-
tempting to dismiss them as “beginner surger- fession and the public, as well as to provide
ies,” the easily trivialized but sometimes terri- guidance for veterinarians and spay–neuter
fying rites of passage into the veterinary programs regarding standards of care and prac-
profession. Perhaps because spaying and neu- tices based on scientific evidence and expert
tering are skills learned so early and repeated opinion. The ASV Spay Neuter Task Force
so often in a general practitioner’s veterinary reconvened in 2014 to update and expand the
career, they are rarely the subject of continuing document, resulting in “The Association of
education seminars and articles, and general Shelter Veterinarians’ 2016 Veterinary Medical
practitioners may go their entire career with- Care Guidelines for Spay‐Neuter Programs”
out modifying or even questioning the tech- (Griffin et al. 2016).
niques for spaying and neutering that they High‐quality, high‐volume spay–neuter (or
learned as third‐year veterinary students. HQHVSN, the awkward but now widely used
At the same time, spaying and neutering acronym adopted by the first Spay Neuter Task
have been central to efforts to reduce the over- Force) is the field of veterinary medicine that
population and euthanasia of unwanted and began with the efforts of spay–neuter pioneers
unowned cats and dogs. The spay–neuter clin- in the 1970s through the 1990s, and became
ics and programs that have arisen over the past firmly established and advanced by the publi-
several decades recognized the need for mini- cation of the 2008 and 2016 spay–neuter guide-
mally invasive, efficient techniques that would lines. HQHVSN is defined as “efficient surgical
shorten surgical times and improve patient initiatives that meet or exceed veterinary medi-
recovery. This textbook pulls together many of cal standards of care in providing accessible,
the surgical, anesthetic, peri‐operative, and targeted sterilization of large numbers of cats
operational techniques discovered, developed, and dogs to reduce their overpopulation and
and popularized over the decades by these subsequent euthanasia” (Griffin et al. 2016).
innovative spay–neuter pioneers. Until now, practitioners new to HQHVSN or
As the field of spay–neuter developed, practi- isolated in their practice have had no single
tioners recognized the need for greater accept- place to turn to find out about HQHVSN tech-
ance and clarity. In 2006, a task force was niques and protocols and the evidence sup-
convened that developed the first guidelines for porting them, or about spay–neuter program
medical care in spay–neuter programs; this types, their implementation and staffing, and
xiv Preface
their effects on animal populations and indi- While many of the techniques covered in
vidual animal health. Many of the techniques Part One are well known to experienced
used in HQHVSN have been taught at confer- HQHVSN surgeons, some of the anomalies,
ences and mentorship programs and shared complications, and complicated presentations
and spread between practitioners, and many are unusual and may be once‐in‐a‐lifetime
have been subjects of peer‐reviewed research; cases for some. Experienced practitioners may
however, few appear in textbooks. Nevertheless, also learn of useful variations on or alterna-
the medical, surgical, and peri‐operative care tives to their accustomed techniques, or dis-
described in this book need not be limited to cover new ways of preventing or addressing
high‐volume or shelter settings – it is applica- frustrating complications.
ble wherever veterinary surgery is performed. Part One concludes with a section on other
This book is divided into two parts, and each common shelter surgeries and associated anes-
of those parts is divided into several sections. thetic procedures, and can serve as a reference
Part One, Clinical Techniques and Patient for shelter surgeons with a variety of levels of
Care, is concerned with evidence‐based clini- experience. This section includes amputations,
cal knowledge and skills, including peri‐opera- eye surgeries, vulvar or rectal prolapse treat-
tive, anesthetic, and surgical techniques. Part ment, and dental extractions.
Two, Fundamentals of HQHVSN, introduces Part Two of this book moves away from the
the high‐volume surgical setting and the spe- clinical care of individual patients and into
cial organizational, logistical, and epidemio- the structures and systems fundamental to
logic challenges that arise when striving to HQHVSN, with sections on population medi-
optimize a clinic’s operations and impact. cine, human resources and wellbeing, and
The book is intended for a range of audiences: HQHVSN program models. Optimizing the
from the veterinary student to the experienced potential of HQHVSN requires more than just
HQHVSN practitioner, and from the veterinary proficiency in the clinical care (anesthesia
technician to the aspiring spay–neuter clinic and surgery) of individual patients. Effective
founder. Part One begins with chapters on the HQHVSN programs must understand the
determination of patient sex and neuter status, effects of their interventions on animal popu-
reproductive anomalies and pathologies, the lations and individuals; they must combine
selection of surgical instruments and suture, their clinical skills with appropriate staffing
infectious disease control, asepsis, and stress and facilities to allow an efficient and stream-
reduction in the clinic. The sections on anesthe- lined workflow; they must institute systems
sia and surgery cover general principles as well that are financially, physically, and emotion-
as specific techniques and protocols, including ally sustainable. Chapter 23 serves as an intro-
chapters on avoiding and managing both anes- duction and roadmap to the second half of this
thetic and surgical complications, and a chapter book. The material here should be of interest
on anesthetic and surgical techniques in rabbits to anyone seeking to establish a new HQHVSN
and other small mammals. program or improve an existing one.
References
Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al. Looney, A.L., Bohling, M.W., Bushby, P.A. et al.
(2016). The Association of Shelter (2008). The Association of Shelter
Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical care Veterinarians’ veterinary medical care
guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. JAVMA guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. JAVMA
249: 165–188. 233: 74–86.
xv
Acknowledgments
First, I want to thank the original four editors took the time to explain and describe surgical
of the book: Brenda Griffin, Karla Brestle, techniques in words, back in the days of dial‐
Philip Bushby, and Mark Bohling. These four up internet, before YouTube. From the shel-
veterinarians have been instrumental in tervet electronic mailing list that I joined in
establishing and promoting the field of 2001 to today’s shelter veterinary and spay
HQHVSN; this book would not have existed neuter Facebook communities and hqhvsnvets
without them. I have had the privilege of online group, you have been and continue to
working with all four of these people in dif- be my mentors and my inspiration. Thank you
ferent capacities over the past decade and a also to my online colleagues who contributed
half: as teammates on the ASV Spay Neuter photos for this textbook – your eagerness,
Task Force and co‐authors on the 2008 and openness, and surgical and photographic skills
2016 Guidelines, as co‐teachers in pediatric have made this book better.
spay–neuter wet labs, and finally as contrib- And a huge thank‐you to all the authors who
uting authors to this textbook. Thank you for have contributed chapters to this textbook. It is
being my mentors and colleagues, and for your expertise that has driven the field of
believing I could do this. Thanks especially to HQHVSN forward and that makes this book all
Brenda, who during my editorship has that it is. This book is a first edition, but it is
been my cheerleader and sounding board, also a revision: by the time I signed on as editor
my informant and historian, and a bridge in early 2018, many of the submitted manu-
between the original vision for this book and scripts had become dated. I want to thank the
its evolution and re/vision. The encourage- authors for their patience and willingness to
ment, context, and friendship you have offered revise or even overhaul these chapters in order
throughout this process have supported and to make the materials as relevant, timely, and
inspired me. useful as possible.
I also want to thank all the HQHVSN and And finally, thanks to my wife Tina, who
shelter veterinarians I have met over the years kept the refrigerator full and the woodstove
in person and online. My early teachers in this stoked during my many long hours of writing
field were all virtual (but real!) colleagues who and editing.
1
Part One
Section One
(a) (b)
Figure 1.1 External genitalia of a female puppy (a) and adult dog (b). Note the tear-drop shape of the
vulva, which is located in the caudal inguinal area between the hind limbs.
(a) (b)
Figure 1.2 External genitalia of a male puppy (a) and adult dog (b). The penis is encased in a sheath
(called the prepuce) and the testicles lie within the scrotum. Note that the adult dog’s prepuce is well
covered with hair and the scrotum is much more pendulous than that of the male puppy.
depending on the individual dog. Although fact that cryptorchidism is one of the most
late descent of one or both testicles is possible f requently recognized congenital defects in
during this time frame, it may not be desirable small animal practice, it is not necessarily the
to postpone castration (Griffin et al. 2016). most common reason that one or both testicles
In dogs, the reported prevalence of cryptor are not readily palpable in the scrotum of
chidism ranges from 0.8 to 10%, with the high young puppies. In fact, a more common reason
est rates often occurring in certain breeds, might be temporary retraction into the ingui
including Chihuahuas, miniature schnauzers, nal area. Indeed, when the testicles are not
Pomeranians, toy and miniature poodles, readily palpable in the scrotum, it may not
Shetland sheepdogs, Yorkshire terriers, boxers, indicate that a puppy is truly cryptorchid;
and German shepherd dogs (Yates et al. 2003; rather, it may simply be a function of the fact
Birchard and Nappier 2008). Despite the that small, slippery testicles can easily escape
Sex Determination 7
detection during examination because they surgeon avoid unnecessary exploration for the
sometimes retract into the inguinal area when gonads. Whenever possible, the goal should be
digital pressure is applied. Furthermore, it is to verify that both testicles are present in the
possible for one or both testicles to slip back scrotum prior to surgery, so that the surgeon
through its respective external inguinal ring can plan accordingly if cryptorchidism truly
into the canal or abdomen. This can occur in exists. For information on surgical castration of
awake patients, and in the author’s experience it cryptorchid dogs, see Chapter 14.
occurs even more commonly when a pediatric
puppy is anesthetized and placed in dorsal
Sexing Cats
recumbency. If the testicles are absent from the
scrotum on palpation, lifting the patient into In contrast to dogs, determining the sex of cats
an upright position often allows the “missing” can be more challenging, particularly in the
testicle(s) to descend back into its proper ana case of small kittens. Unlike dogs, where the
tomic location in the scrotum. This can be done external genitalia of both sexes are readily visi
by holding the puppy gently around the chest to ble in the inguinal (groin) area, the external
support its body weight, taking care to support genitalia of male and female cats are located in
the head and neck if needed, while allowing the the perineal region beneath the tail. The small
hind limbs to gently hang down (Figure 1.3a–c). size of the species’ penis and vulva, combined
Alternatively, with the puppy in dorsal recum with the fact that these structures are generally
bency, gentle continuous digital pressure may well covered by hair, further complicates their
be applied to “smooth” down the soft tissue of identification. Upon inspection, the penis is not
the groin, beginning in the area of the inguinal visually obvious in tomcats at any age and, prior
rings and continuing caudally toward the scro to weaning age, the presence of the testicles in
tum; this action will usually push the missing the scrotum is usually not visually apparent
testicle(s) back into the scrotal sac (Figure 1.4a–c). either. Although present in the scrotum at or
These techniques can be used to locate testicles within a few days of birth, the testes are simply
that “disappear” from the scrotum and help the too small to be either visually apparent or easily
Figure 1.3 (a–c) Holding a puppy upright in this position with the hind limbs hanging down may allow
the testicles to descend back into their proper anatomic location within the scrotal sac (a). Initially, the left
testicle was retracted back into the inguinal area proximal to the scrotum (b), but it quickly reappeared in
the scrotum when the puppy was held in this position (c).
8 1 Determination of Patient Sex and Spay–Neuter Status
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 1.4 (a–c) With the puppy in dorsal recumbency, the soft tissue of the groin can be digitally
“smoothed” down from the area of the inguinal rings toward the scrotum in order to gently push the
testicles back into the scrotal sac.
palpable in the first few weeks of life. Although scrotal palpation may cause small testicles to
the feline penis never becomes visually obvious, temporarily slip into the inguinal region, where
the testes do quickly become larger as kittens they may elude detection. The techniques previ
grow and are increasingly readily visible ously described for returning such testicles to
beneath the anus by six to eight weeks of age. their proper anatomic location in the scrotum
Usually by the time of a kitten’s first veterinary can be used for kittens as well as puppies.
visit, the testicles are readily palpable in the Notably, the absence of testicles following neu
scrotum (Griffin 2006). If one or both testicles is tering can also make sexual determination of a
absent, a diagnosis of cryptorchidism is highly tomcat difficult for untrained observers.
likely: delayed or late testicular descent is pos Careful inspection of the perineal area is nec
sible but very uncommon in cats. The reported essary in order to determine the sex of a cat or
prevalence of cryptorchidism is relatively low in kitten. For adults, an individual’s overall body
cats (<2%), although much higher rates have type and/or appearance may sometimes sug
been reported in the Persian breed (Millis et al. gest the cat’s sex. For example, many male cats
1992). As is the case in pediatric puppies, care are larger in stature with heavier bones than
must be taken to ensure accurate examination, female cats, and most calico cats are females
because gentle digital pressure applied during (Figure 1.5). That said, such characteristics
Sex Determination 9
(a) (b)
Figure 1.6 (a) Anogenital anatomy of a female kitten. White arrow: anus. Black arrow: small slit-like
opening of vulva. Note the relatively small distance between the anal and genital openings. (b) Anogenital
anatomy of a male kitten. White arrow: anus. Black arrow: small dot-like opening of penis. Note the
relatively large distance between the anal and genital openings.
10 1 Determination of Patient Sex and Spay–Neuter Status
Figure 1.8 Anogenital anatomy of a sexually Figure 1.9 Anogenital anatomy of a neutered male
intact adult tomcat. The hair-covered testicles are adult cat. White arrow: anus. Black arrow: small
readily identifiable beneath the anus. The opening dot-like opening of penis. Note the relatively large
to the penis is not seen because it is obscured distance between the anal and genital openings.
from view by the testicles. The empty hair-covered scrotum lies in between.
Distinguishing between Sexually Intact and Previously Altered Dogs and Cats 11
(a) (b)
Figure 1.10 (a and b) The large size of this mature cat combined with the lack of facial jowls suggest a
neutered male cat; however, inspection of his anogenital region reveals a punctate opening immediately
ventral to the anus – somewhat resembling the anogenital anatomy of a female cat. Shaving the area
around the urethral stoma revealed scarring from previous suture lines and careful palpation revealed the
absence of either a penis or a vulva. This cat was therefore determined to be a neutered male cat that had
undergone previous perineal urethrostomy surgery. Source: Photo courtesy of Sara White.
On rare occasions, a patient may present may not present itself again in the future.
with a combination of both male and female Although no one wants an animal to undergo
sex organs. Chapter 2 includes information unnecessary anesthesia and surgery, this will
about male and female pseudohermaphrodit sometimes be necessary to ensure that an ani
ism and other atypical sexual genotypes and mal leaves the spay–neuter clinic without
phenotypes in dogs and cats. the possibility of reproducing in the future.
Provided there is no compelling medical
reason not to proceed with such surgery, the
Distinguishing between Sexually benefits will likely outweigh the risks for the
Intact and Previously Altered vast majority of patients when spay–neuter
Dogs and Cats status remains uncertain.
That said, there will be a number of cases
In preparation for spay–neuter surgery, it is not where the clinician can verify the spay–neuter
only important to determine the correct sex of status of the patient without surgery. First and
a dog or cat, but one should also make an foremost, each patient should be carefully
attempt to determine if the animal has been inspected for the presence of a standard identi
previously spayed or neutered. This can be sur fication mark indicating previous surgical
prisingly difficult in some cases, and it sterilization. The Association of Shelter
behooves the clinician to approach this task Veterinarians (ASV) recommends the use of
carefully and cautiously, especially in the con permanent, visibly distinct identifying marks
text of a spay–neuter program where the to indicate that an animal has been spayed or
opportunity to neuter any individual animal neutered: a green linear tattoo should be used
12 1 Determination of Patient Sex and Spay–Neuter Status
to identify all neutered pet animals and ear tip Table 1.1 Association of Shelter Veterinarians
ping should be used to identify all community (ASV) recommendations for standard placement
of green linear tattoos for identification
cats (Griffin et al. 2016; Figures 1.11 and 1.12). of neutered dogs and cats (Griffin et al. 2016).
Table 1.1 describes the recommended standard
locations for the placement of green linear tat Sex and
toos. Note that removal of the hair from the species Location of green linear tattoo
ventral abdomen will sometimes be necessary
to ensure discovery of green linear tattoos, Female On or immediately lateral to the
dogs and ventral midline incision; if a flank
cats approach is used to spay a female
patient, the tattoo should be
placed in the area where a ventral
midline spay incision would have
been placed
Male dogs At the caudal aspect of the
abdomen in the pre‐scrotal
incision or pre‐scrotal area
immediately lateral to the prepuce
Male cats In the area where a ventral
midline spay incision would
typically be placed
For those animals whose spay–neuter status Thus, the absence of scrotal testicles causes
remains undetermined, a thorough and sys infertility; however, it does not prevent the
tematic clinical evaluation should follow. To development of androgen‐dependent behav
avoid incorrect or invalid determinations, iors. For this reason, cryptorchid dogs and cats
the clinician’s assessment should be based may present with a history of urine marking or
on objective findings rather than subjective spraying, fighting, attraction to females,
impressions whenever possible. mounting, and in the case of tomcats, urine
odor (Millis et al. 1992). This is especially sig
nificant in the case of tomcats because urine
Male Dogs and Tomcats:
spraying is a leading reason for relinquishment
Reproductively Intact, Cryptorchid,
of pet cats by their owners (Salman et al. 2000).
or Neutered?
Cryptorchidism is an important differential
Most male patients that present without the diagnosis to consider, especially in adolescent
presence of scrotal testicles have been previ or young adult tomcats, since this is the
ously neutered. However, a few male patients expected time for puberty and the onset of
will lack scrotal testes because of either such behavioral effects of testosterone.
bilateral cryptorchidism or unilateral cryptor Although relatively uncommon, this cause of
chidism, where surgical removal of the spraying is associated with an excellent prog
scrotal testicle was previously performed. nosis, since removing the retained testicle(s)
Distinguishing these animals and ensuring most often results in resolution of spraying
that they are properly sterilized will likely have (Griffin 2006).
major positive impacts on their future health In dogs, cryptorchidism may be associated
and wellbeing. with clinical signs of feminization, including
gynecomastia (mammary enlargement) and
Definitions alopecia in affected dogs. This is because
As previously described, cryptorchidism is a abdominally retained testes are at increased
congenital defect in which one or both of the risk for development of Sertoli cell tumors,
testes do not descend into the scrotum at the especially in older dogs. Retained testicles are
appropriate time (see also Chapter 2 on also at increased risk of spermatic cord torsion,
common reproductive anomalies). Although which can result in signs of an acute abdomen
unilateral cryptorchidism is more common, (Ley et al. 2003).
bilateral cryptorchidism also occurs. In either
case, the testicles may be retained anywhere Diagnosis
along their normal path of descent from the In addition to obtaining any available clinical
abdomen: in the abdomen, inguinal ring, or history, diagnostic evaluation should include
subcutaneous tissue of the groin between the physical examination. In the case of tomcats,
inguinal ring and scrotum. Monorchidism, physical examination alone is a highly reliable
which is defined as the presence of only a means of diagnostic determination of neuter
single testicle, is exceedingly rare in both status. Unfortunately, the same is not true for
dogs and cats. For this reason, dogs and cats dogs and other means of diagnosis such as
presenting with only one testicle should be ultrasound and hormonal evaluation, when
considered cryptorchid until proven otherwise available, are often required.
(Ley et al. 2003).
History If history is available, it can be very
Clinical Signs helpful to the clinician tasked with deter
Retained testes do not produce spermatozoa, mining the a nimal’s true neuter status. Even
but do produce testosterone (Ley et al. 2003). with a history of previous castration, the
14 1 Determination of Patient Sex and Spay–Neuter Status
(a) (b)
Figure 1.13 (a) The presence of penile spines in a male cat as seen in this photo is diagnostic for the
presence of a testicle. (b) The absence of penile spines in an adult tomcat as seen in this photo verifies
previous neutering. Within a few weeks of castration, penile spines atrophy and the penile mucosa becomes
smooth and flat in appearance.
Distinguishing between Sexually Intact and Previously Altered Dogs and Cats 15
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 1.14 (a) This male cat, who was believed to be neutered, presented with a history of undesirable
male behaviors including spraying, fighting, and breeding behavior. In this photo he has been sedated for
examination. Note the presence of jowls. (b) Examination revealed the absence of scrotal testicles. Note
that the anus is at the bottom of the photo in this picture. (c) Examination also revealed the presence of
penile spines with full penile extrusion. This cat was a bilateral cryptorchid and both testicles were found
in the abdomen at the time of surgery. Following surgery, the cat recovered uneventfully and all of the
previously displayed undesirable behaviors ceased.
age) in order to prevent the development of has not been shown to be clinically significant,
undesired male behaviors. In many tomcats though it can be more difficult to exteriorize
neutered prior to puberty, the balanopreputial the penis for catheterization in the event the
fold remains intact and complete penile extru patient requires a urinary catheter (Herron
sion is not possible (Root et al. 1996b). Thus, if 1972; Stubbs and Bloomberg 1995; Stubbs et al.
the balanopreputial fold is intact in an adult 1996; Howe et al. 2000; Spain et al. 2004).
cat, this objective finding is consistent with In contrast, penile barbs are not part of the
previous neutering (Figure 1.15). In other anatomy of male dogs: the penile mucosa
words, the inability to fully extrude the penis appears flat and smooth in both intact and neu
of an anesthetized adult cat can be considered tered males of this species. Although dogs lack
equally reliable as the absence of penile spines penile spines, there are some physical character
for verification of neuter status. Of note is that istics of their external genitalia that are consist
failure of the balanopreputial fold to regress ently observable depending on the age at which
16 1 Determination of Patient Sex and Spay–Neuter Status
Figure 1.15 The balanopreputial fold of this Figure 1.17 Comparison of scrotal testicle (left)
neutered male cat remains intact, preventing and retained testicle (right) from a cryptorchid
complete extrusion of the penis. Presence of the tomcat. Retained testicles are generally smaller
balanopreputial fold in a post-pubertal male cat than scrotal testicles. The retained testicle pictured
indicates previous castration. here was removed from the inguinal ring and
palpation was not possible through the large
inguinal fat pad of this cat.
Figure 1.18 Comparison of facial features of a neutered male cat (left) and an intact tomcat (right). Note
the thick neck and the presence of large jowls in the intact tomcat.
inhibiting pituitary production of follicle‐ need for surgery. In contrast, negative test
stimulating hormone and LH. Following results suggest previous neutering (Axner and
castration, serum concentrations of these Strom‐Holst 2015; Themmen et al. 2016).
reproductive cascade hormones increase as a Reported sensitivities and specificities of AMH
result of the lack of negative feedback from the assays vary: in a study of 27 male cats, the
gonads. A commercially available point‐of‐ reported sensitivity and specificity were 100%
care LH test (Witness® LS, Zoetis, Parsippany, (Axner and Strom‐Holst 2015), whereas in a
NJ, USA), which was originally developed as a study of 98 male dogs, the sensitivity and spec
means of determining ovulation timing in ificity were 76 and 100%, respectively
dogs, has been used as a diagnostic aid to eluci (Themmen et al. 2016). In the latter study,
date neuter status (Figure 1.19). A “positive” AMH testing correctly identified all neutered
test is consistent with previous neutering, male dogs, but unfortunately failed to correctly
while a negative result supports the need for identify a significant number of intact male
surgery. In a study of 53 male cats, the reported dogs.
sensitivity and specificity were 85 and 95%,
respectively (Krecic et al. 2018). In a study of Assessment and Follow-Up
10 dogs, the reported sensitivity and specificity Spay–neuter programs should have policies
were 100% (Wheeler and Kutzler 2010). Point‐ and protocols in place to optimize identifica
of‐care tests have the obvious advantages of tion of previously neutered male dogs and cats
being very convenient and providing rapid, and to ensure proper sterilization of cryp
same‐day results. As more data from field stud torchid animals.
ies becomes available to evaluate the perfor Verification of previous castration is gener
mance of this patient‐side test in dogs, its use ally much easier in cats, since examination of
may become an increasingly attractive option the penis allows for an accurate assessment in
for determination of neuter status. the majority of cases. Only in very young kit
A final diagnostic option is measurement of tens and very recently neutered cats may find
serum concentrations of AMH through a refer ings be equivocal. When penile spines are
ence laboratory. AMH is continuously pro present, surgery is indicated. Conversely, if the
duced by the Sertoli cells of the testes in cat is verified to be neutered based on the
post‐pubescent male dogs and tomcats, and absence of penile spines or an intact balano
production continues throughout an animal’s prepucial fold in an adult cat, then marking
reproductive life. Thus, positive test results in a the cat in accordance with the ASV guidelines
post‐pubertal patient are consistent with the for identification of neutered cats is indicated.
No one will ever have to wonder again!
In dogs, verification of neuter status is fre
quently more challenging. The one exception
might be an adult dog with an infantile penis.
In this case, it is probably safe to assume the
patient has been previously castrated. In the
absence of such a finding, hormonal testing
will be necessary for diagnostic confirmation,
unless a testicle is readily palpable in the ingui
Figure 1.19 Witness LH test device. A nal area or a Sertoli cell tumor is diagnosed.
commercially available point-of-care LH test Point‐of‐care LH test kits are a convenient and
(Witness LS, Zoetis, Parsippany, NJ, USA) may be
promising option. When such hormonal test
used to distinguish reproductively intact and
spayed dogs and cats. This test is simple to use and ing is not an option due to lack of resources,
requires only four drops of serum. assessment of neuter status should be based on
Distinguishing between Sexually Intact and Previously Altered Dogs and Cats 19
Diagnosis
In addition to obtaining any available clinical Figure 1.20 Cat in heat. An estrual queen exhibits
history, diagnostic evaluation should also a typical display of lordosis and tail deflection.
20 1 Determination of Patient Sex and Spay–Neuter Status
to help verify the presence of behavioral signs Physical Examination A complete physical
of estrus (Griffin 2001, 2006). examination should be performed. The overall
In the bitch, estrus is accompanied by dra body condition should be noted. Metabolic rate
matic physical changes, including marked has been shown to significantly decrease and
enlargement of the vulva and bloody dis a tendency toward obesity has been well
charge, which are easy to recognize documented in spayed cats compared to
(Figure 1.21). In contrast, physical changes reproductively intact queens (Flynn et al. 1996;
accompanying estrus are very subtle in cats. Root et al. 1996a). If a cat is very overweight, a
The queen’s vulva becomes only slightly clinical suspicion that she has been previously
edematous and hyperemic, but remains so spayed is warranted. In contrast, changes in
small and well covered by hair that changes metabolic rate following ovariohysterectomy
are rarely noticed. Furthermore, vulvar dis have not been as well defined in bitches.
charge is scant, and because of the fastidious These findings are consistent with the
grooming habits of the queen, rarely noted common clinical experiences of many
(Griffin 2001). In cases where the presence of surgeons, who find themselves regularly
behavioral estrus is present or suspected at performing “big fat dog spays” but rarely
the time of examination, vaginal cytology to performing ovariohysterectomies in highly
look for the presence of cornified vaginal epi obese feline patients.
thelial cells can be performed for confirma To facilitate examination, the ventral abdo
tion. Owners should also be questioned men should be shaved from the umbilicus to the
carefully regarding potential exposure to pubis, and the skin of the midline carefully
exogenous hormones, such as hormone inspected for the presence of a scar. In some
replacement therapy, that could account for cases, sedation will be necessary for hair
clinical signs (Griffin 2006). removal and thorough examination. Using a
good light source to aid in inspection of the area
is often rewarding. Applying a small amount of
isopropyl alcohol to the skin may aid in visuali
zation of linear scars that may otherwise remain
undetected. In the author’s experience, palpa
tion is not a reliable indicator of the presence of
a spay scar. Some intact females have a promi
nent linea alba that may be mistaken for a scar,
and spayed cats and dogs frequently have scars
that are not readily palpable, yet may be visual
ized once the overlying hair is removed.
Although looking for a ventral abdominal scar
is recommended, discovery of a scar does not
verify that an animal has been previously spayed
with certainty and should never be used as the
sole criterion for assessment. The clinician must
interpret this finding cautiously and in context
with all other findings (e.g. history, body condi
tion score, mammary development, etc.) in
order to make the best possible assessment. In
some cases, scars may be the result of other
Figure 1.21 Dog in heat. Note the marked
swelling of the labia and the presence of bloody abdominal procedures such as C‐section
discharge. (Figure 1.22). In addition, previously spayed
Distinguishing between Sexually Intact and Previously Altered Dogs and Cats 21
Figure 1.23 The shaved abdomen of a spayed cat. Careful inspection of the mammary glands may be
helpful in distinguishing reproductively intact and spayed queens, since the mammary glands of spayed
cats are generally underdeveloped or atrophic. Note the presence of a “spay scar” (arrow). This cat’s body
condition with ample abdominal fat also suggests that she is spayed.
22 1 Determination of Patient Sex and Spay–Neuter Status
(a) (b)
Figure 1.24 Clinicians should never use small vulvar size as a singular means of assessing spay status. In
each photo, the vulva appears relatively small and underdeveloped, yet the reproductive status and history
of these two bitches are very different. (a) Vulva of a three-year-old intact Great Pyrenees bitch. She
whelped a litter six months prior to this photograph being taken. (b) Vulva of an eight-year-old spayed
female Great Pyrenees bitch. She was spayed one year prior to this photo being taken.
surge. A study of 216 female cats revealed a 91% tion. The convenience of a point‐of‐care test
specificity and a 92% sensitivity using the Witness and the diagnostic accuracy reported to date
LH test (Krecic et al. 2018). In this study, it was make the Witness LH test an especially desira
unknown whether cats were displaying signs of ble option for spay status determination. Both
estrus at the time of presentation for ovariohyster LH and AMH testing may also be helpful in
ectomy. A study of 236 cats revealed a sensitivity the diagnosis of ovarian remnant syndrome
of 69% and a specificity of 100% using the same in dogs and cats. For more information on
test (Morrow et al. 2018). In other words, the test diagnosis of ovarian remnant syndrome, see
correctly detected all intact queens, and impor Chapter 18.
tantly there were no false positive results that
would have incorrectly identified an intact cat as Assessment and Follow-Up
previously spayed. For cats without signs of heat, Spay–neuter programs should have policies
the point‐of‐care Witness LH test appears to be a and protocols in place to optimize identifica
highly useful means of distinguishing intact and tion of previously spayed female dogs and cats
spayed cats, while avoiding the need always to and to ensure that all patients are ultimately
perform surgery to confirm spay status. spayed. Ensuring that ovariohysterectomy is
Alternatively, tests for measuring AMH may complete will not only prevent unwanted
be used to distinguish spayed and sexually estrus behavior and pregnancies, it will also
intact animals, since serum concentrations of safeguard the health and welfare of the indi
AMH are only present in intact animals. AMH vidual. Verification of previous spaying with
is continuously produced by the ovaries in post‐ absolute certainty is sometimes difficult and
pubescent queens and bitches, and production resources to perform hormonal testing may not
continues throughout the animal’s reproduc be available. In some cases, the clinician will
tive life. AMH tests are positive in mature intact be able to make a confident assessment based
animals, while negative results are consistent on multiple findings consistent with a previ
with previous ovariohysterectomy (Place et al. ously spayed animal. For example, it is reason
2011; Axner and Strom‐Holst 2015; Themmen able to assume that an obese adult cat with a
et al. 2016; Alm and Holst 2018). When using ventral midline scar and underdeveloped
this test, is important to recognize that negative mammary glands has been previously spayed.
results may also be seen in intact females tested In the event of available testing, it is also very
before reproductive maturity or after reproduc reasonable to assume that dogs and cats with
tive senescence. In one study of 31 female cats, positive LH test results have been spayed, pro
AMH testing had 100% sensitivity and specific vided they are not tested while in heat.
ity (Axner and Strom‐Holst 2015). Exploratory surgery is the final and most
A recent study of 125 dogs utilized both definitive diagnostic option for assessing spay
AMH and LH testing for spay status determi status. Many surgeons will not “mark” a
nation (Alm and Holst 2018). Excluding female animal as spayed unless they have
bitches in heat, LH testing identified 100% of either personally removed the ovaries or per
intact bitches compared to 88% correctly iden formed a negative exploratory laparotomy
tified by AMH testing. In some instances, low themselves. This approach is indeed wise and
concentrations of AMH were obtained in recommended, given how good the girls can be
intact bitches, leading to incorrect classifica at fooling us sometimes.
References
Alm, H. and Holst, B.S. (2018). Identifying Mullerian hormone or luteinizing hormone.
ovarian tissue in the bitch using anti‐ Theriogenology 106: 15–20.
24 1 Determination of Patient Sex and Spay–Neuter Status
Aronson, L.R. and Cooper, M.L. (1967). Penile hormone test for help in distinguishing
spines of the domestic cat: their endocrine‐ between sexually intact and ovariectomized or
behavior relations. Anat. Rec. 157: 71–78. castrated domestic cats. J. Feline Med. Surg. 20
Axner, E. and Strom‐Holst, B. (2015). (10): 955–961.
Concentrations of anti‐Mullerian hormone in Ley, W.B., Holyoak, G.R., Digrassie, W.A. et al.
the domestic cat: relation with spay or neuter (2003). Testicular and epididymal disorders.
status and serum estradiol. Theriogenology 83: In: The Practical Veterinarian: Small Animal
817–821. Theriogenology (ed. M.R. Kustritz), 457–491.
Birchard, S.J. and Nappier, M. (2008). St. Louis, MO: Elsevier Science.
Cryptorchidism. Compend. Contin. Educ. Lofstedt, R.M. and VanLeeuwen, J.A. (2002).
Pract. Vet. 30: 325–337. Evaluation of a commercially available
Flynn, M.F., Hardie, E.M., and Armstrong, P.J. luteinizing hormone test for its ability to
(1996). Effect of ovariohysterectomy on distinguish between ovariectomized and
maintenance energy requirement in cats. sexually intact bitches. JAVMA 220:
JAVMA 209: 1572–1581. 1331–1335.
Griffin, B. (2001). Prolific cats: the estrous cycle. Memon, M.A., Ganjam, V.K., Pavletic, M.M.
Compend. Contin. Educ. Pract. Vet. 23: et al. (1992). Use of human chorionic
1049–1056. gonadotropin stimulation test to detect a
Griffin, B. (2006). Feline reproductive hormones: retained testis in a cat. JAVMA 201: 1602.
diagnostic usefulness and clinical syndromes. Miller, D.M. (1995). Ovarian remnant syndrome
In: Consultations in Feline Internal Medicine V in dogs and cats: 46 cases (1988–1992). J. Vet.
(ed. J.R. August), 217–226. St Louis, MO: Diagn. Investig. 7: 572–574.
Elsevier Saunders. Millis, D.L., Hauptman, J.G., and Johnson, C.A.
Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al. (1992). Cryptorchidism and monorchism in
(2016). The Association of Shelter cats: 25 cases (1980–1989). JAVMA 200:
Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical care 1128–1130.
guidelines for spay–neuter programs. JAVMA Morrow, L.D., Gruffydd‐Jones, T.J., Skillings, E.
249 (2): 165–188. et al. (2018). Field study assessing the
Gunzel‐Apel, A.R., Seefeldt, A., Eschricht, F.M. performance of a patient‐side blood test to
et al. (2009). Effects of gonadectomy on determine neuter status in female cats based
prolactin and LH secretion and the pituitary on detection of luteinising hormone. J. Feline
thyroid axis in male dogs. Theriogenology 71: Med. Surg. 21: 553–558.
746–753. Olson, P.N. (2003). Prepuberal gonadectomy
Herron, M.A. (1972). The effect of prepubertal (early age neutering) in dogs and cats. In:
castration on the penile urethra of the cat. The ractical Veterinarian: Small Animal
JAVMA 160: 208–211. Theriogenology (ed. M.R. Kustritz), 165–181.
Howe, L.M., Slater, M.R., Boothe, H.W. et al. St. Louis, MO: Elsevier Science.
(2000). Long‐term outcome of gonadectomy Olson, P.N., Mulnix, J.A., and Nett, T.M. (1992
performed at early age or traditional age in May). Concentrations of luteinizing hormone
cats. JAVMA 217: 1661–1665. and follicle‐stimulating hormone in the serum
Johnston, S.D., Root, M.V., and Olson, P.N.S. of sexually intact and neutered dogs. Am. J.
(1996). Ovarian and testicular function in the Vet. Res. 53 (5): 762–766.
domestic cat: clinical management of Place, N.J., Hansen, B.S., Cheraskin, J. et al.
spontaneous reproductive disease. Anim. (2011). Measurement of serum anti‐Mullerian
Reprod. Sci. 42: 261–274. hormone concentration in female dogs and
Krecic, M.R., DiGangi, B.A., and Griffin, B. cats before and after ovariohysterectomy.
(2018). Accuracy of a point‐of‐care luteinizing J. Vet. Diagn. Investig. 23 (3): 524–527.
References 25
Richardson, E.F. and Mullen, H. (1993). Stubbs, W.P. and Bloomberg, M.S. (1995).
Cryptorchidism in cats. Compend. Contin. Implications of early neutering in the dog and
Educ. Pract. Vet. 15: 1342–1345. cat. Semin. Vet. Med. Surg. 10: 8–12.
Root, M.V., Johnston, S.D., and Olson, P.N. Stubbs, W.P., Bloomberg, M.S., Scruggs, S.L.
(1996a). The effect of prepubertal and et al. (1996). Effects of prepubertal and
postpubertal gonadectomy on heat production postpubertal gonadectomy on physical and
measured by indirect calorimetry in male and behavioral development in cats. JAVMA 209:
female domestic cats. Am. J. Vet. Res. 57: 1864–1871.
371–374. Themmen, A.P.N., Kalra, B., Visser, J.A. et al.
Root, M.V., Johnston, S.D., and Olson, P.N. (2016). The use of anti‐Mullerian hormone as
(1996b). The effect of prepubertal and a diagnostic for gonadectomy status in dogs.
postpubertal gonadectomy on penile extrusion Theriogenology 86: 1467–1474.
and urethral diameter in the domestic cat. Vet. Wallace, M.S. (1991). The ovarian remnant
Radiol. Ultrasound 37: 363–366. syndrome in the bitch and queen. Vet. Clin.
Salman, M.D., Hutchison, J., Ruch‐Gallie, R. North Am. Small Anim. Pract. 21: 501–517.
et al. (2000). Behavioral reasons for Wheeler, R. and Kutzler, M. (2010). LH testing is
relinquishment of dogs and cats to 12 shelters. accurate for diagnosing the presence or
J. Appl. Anim. Welf. Sci. 2: 93–106. absence of testicular tissue and dogs
Spain, C.V., Scarlett, J.M., and Houpt, K.A. [abstract]. Clin. Theriogenol. 2: 382.
(2004). Long‐term risks and benefits of Yates, D., Hayes, G., Heffernan, M., and Beynon,
early‐age gonadectomy in cats. JAVMA 224: R. (2003). Incidence of cryptorchidism in dogs
380–387. and cats. Vet. Rec. 152 (16): 502–504.
27
Over the course of their practice, the high‐ First, chromosomal sex (XX or XY) is estab
quality high‐volume spay–neuter (HQHVSN) lished at fertilization. Next, gonadal differenti
surgeon can expect to see a number of unusual ation is determined by the sex chromosomes of
presentations of patient sex resulting from var the individual – the development of ovaries
ious disorders of sexual development (DSDs), confers the gonadal sex of females, while the
as well as a variety of reproductive tract pathol development of testes confers that of males.
ogies that may also be discovered at the time of Ultimately, phenotypic sexual development
spay–neuter surgery. This chapter reviews the (internal and external genitalia) occurs in
embryonic process of sexual determination response to gene expression which prompts
and differentiation and discusses the clinical the production of various chemical substances
findings associated with various DSDs. Notable and ultimately the male and female hormones.
reproductive pathologies (such as pyometra, Current knowledge and understanding of
ovarian cysts, mammary hyperplasia, and these processes suggest that an active interplay
ectopic fetuses) that may be seen at the time of of testis‐producing versus ovary‐producing
spay–neuter surgery are also briefly reviewed. products is responsible for normal develop
ment. This is in contrast to the traditional or
historical view that deemed ovarian develop
Embryology of Sexual ment a default that occurred in the absence of
Development a Y chromosome. This current knowledge of
normal development makes it easier to under
Normal embryologic development of the stand how anomalous development can occur.
canine and feline reproductive tracts is briefly In the developing embryo, mesodermal tissue
reviewed here for the purpose of informing the forms the urogenital ridge, which splits into the
reader’s understanding of normal versus anom nephrogenic cord (which goes on to form the
alous development (Figure 2.1). For more urinary tract) and the genital ridge. Primordial
detailed information, readers are referred to germ cells from the yolk sac migrate in the
comprehensive reviews of embryology of the developing embryo to the genital ridge in the
dog and cat, which are readily available else first trimester of pregnancy. These cells must be
where in the veterinary literature (McGeady present for formation of the gonads to occur,
et al. 2006; Fletcher and Weber 2012). and it is the formation of a specific type of gonad
During embryologic development, sexual (i.e. male or female) that directs all further
differentiation occurs in three sequential steps. development. The initial undifferentiated, or
28 2 Disorders of Sexual Development and Common Reproductive Pathologies
Indifferent gonad
Testis Ovary
Penis Clitoris
Genital tubercle
Figure 2.1 Normal embryologic development of the canine and feline reproductive tract.
DHT, dihydrotestosterone; Insl3, insulin-like peptide 3; MIS, müllerian-inhibiting substance.
indifferent, gonad is stimulated to form either form early seminiferous tubules. Genes and
an ovary or a testis by virtue of the chromosome their products associated with formation of the
complement of the developing embryo. In the testis include Sox‐9 and Sf‐1, which stimulate
presence of the indifferent gonad, both the wolf development of Sertoli cells and Leydig cells
fian ducts (also known as the mesonephric (also known as interstitial cells). The fetal
ducts) and the müllerian ducts (also known as testes secrete testosterone during gestation
the paramesonephric ducts) are present. These (Arrighi et al. 2010).
ducts go on to form the internal male and female Three secretory products from the fetal testes
reproductive tracts, respectively. guide development of the male tubular tract
A region of the Y chromosome, the Sry or and external genitalia. Sertoli cells secrete
sex‐determining region, contains genes that müllerian‐inhibiting substance (MIS; also
express products directing formation of cords known as anti‐müllerian factor or anti‐müllerian
of tissue enclosing the primordial germ cells to hormone), which inhibits continuing development
Disorders of Sexual Development 29
of the female ductal tract. Leydig cells secrete dihydrotestosterone. Secretion of MIS from the
testosterone and insulin‐like peptide 3 (Insl‐3). fetal testis causes regression of the müllerian
Testosterone and its metabolite, dihydrotestos ducts. Under the influence of dihydrotestoster
terone, promote development of the male one, the urethra and prostate form from the
ductal tract and external genitalia. Insl‐3 plays urogenital sinus, the penis from the genital
a role in mediation of the process of testicular tubercle, and the prepuce and scrotum from
descent (Nef and Parada 2000; Cassata et al. the genital swellings and surface ectoderm.
2008; Arrighi et al. 2010). In the absence of a Y chromosome, a con
Testicular descent occurs in three stages and flicting set of gene products guides gonad
requires the presence of hormonally active tes development. Wnt‐4 promotes development of
tes and gubernacula – embryonic structures the ovary by inhibiting formation of Leydig
that attach to the caudal pole of each gonad cells and stimulating mesothelial cells sur
(Baumans et al. 1982, 1983). Each embryonal rounding primordial germ cells to form sex
testis is held caudal to the respective kidney by cords that break apart into primordial follicles
the cranial suspensory ligament, while the (Nef and Parada 2000). Wnt‐4 is also present
caudal pole of the testis is attached to the exter and active in the fetal male prior to sex differ
nal inguinal ring by its gubernaculum. The entiation, but is repressed by Sox‐9 (Carlson
first stage of testicular descent, abdominal 2018). Wnt‐4 also upregulates expression of
translocation, is characterized by maintenance Dax‐1, which inhibits Sf‐1 by downregulating
of the testes at the internal inguinal rings as Sox‐9, and subsequently inhibits male develop
the body lengthens and the gubernacula ment (Nef and Parada 2000; Christensen 2012).
stretch and thin (Amann and Veeramachaneni The fetal ovaries secrete estrogen.
2007). This stage is mediated by Insl‐3 The female tubular tract forms from the
(Christensen 2012). The second stage, transin müllerian ducts. The müllerian ducts form the
guinal migration, is associated with increase in uterine tubes (oviducts), uterine horns, uterine
size of the gubernacula due to increased intra body, cervix, and cranial vagina. Under the
cellular fluid, with subsequent dilation of the influence of estrogen, the caudal vagina and
inguinal canals. This, coupled with increasing vestibule form from the urogenital sinus, the
intraabdominal pressure and contraction of clitoris from the genital tubercle, and the vulva
the internal inguinal rings and abdominal from the genital swellings and surface
oblique muscles, pushes the testes through the ectoderm.
inguinal canals. This stage is testosterone
dependent. In the final stage of testicular
descent, inguinoscrotal descent (which is also Disorders of Sexual Development
testosterone dependent), the gubernacula
decrease in size and migrate to the scrotum, DSDs are present at birth, but are often not
ultimately pulling the testes into the scrotal sac identified until affected individuals with abnor
(Nef and Parada 2000; Christensen 2012). A mal genitalia are presented for spay–neuter
final factor contributing to translocation of the surgery. DSDs include abnormalities of chro
testis into the scrotum is release of the chem mosomal sex, abnormalities of gonadal sex (the
oattractant calcitonin gene‐related peptide gonads do not correspond to the chromosomal
from the genitofemoral nerve, which inner sex), and abnormalities of phenotypic sex
vates the distal quarter of the scrotum (Kitchell (internal or external genitalia do not agree with
et al. 1988; Amann and Veeramachaneni 2007). the gonads and sex chromosome complement).
The male tubular tract (i.e. the epididymis In all cases, gonadectomy is recommended for
and vas deferens) forms from the wolffian affected individuals. In rare cases, affected indi
ducts under the influence of testosterone and viduals may have concurrent signs of urinary
30 2 Disorders of Sexual Development and Common Reproductive Pathologies
tract abnormalities, in which case additional testes and XY chromosomes, but external geni
medical evaluation is warranted, ideally prior tals appear feminine, resulting in some mix
to spay–neuter surgery. ture or blurring of sexual anatomy. The degree
of feminization varies – a penis may be present
or, more often, a vulva with an enlarged clito
Nomenclature
ris. The testes may be located in the abdomen,
Nomenclature in veterinary medicine to scrotum, or lateral to the vulva, and internally
describe the abnormalities is changing to bet vestigial oviducts and a uterus may be present.
ter incorporate findings of molecular diagnosis A true hermaphrodite (Figure 2.2) has at least
and to match that used in the human litera one ovary and at least one testis, or at least one
ture. Historically, the term “intersex” was used ovotestis, regardless of chromosomal (XX or
to describe any condition in which the animal XY) or phenotypic sex (Dreger et al. 2005).
has characteristics of both sexes and encom Finally, the term “sex reversal” is sometimes
passed both pseudohermaphrodites and true used to denote abnormalities of gonadal sex.
hermaphrodites (Howard and Bjorling 1989). In this case, the gonads present do not match
Currently, the term “intersex” is being replaced the individual’s karyotype (i.e. XX males, XX
with “disorder of sexual development” and true hermaphrodites, XY females, XY true
divided into three main categories: sex chro hermaphrodites).
mosome DSD, XX DSD, and XY DSD. Sex chro In most cases, the HQHVSN or shelter vet
mosome DSD is any abnormality of sex erinarian presented with a patient with ambig
chromosome number associated with a DSD. uous or mixed sex characteristics will have no
Examples include Klinefelter’s syndrome idea of the chromosomal sex, the true gonadal
(XXY) and Turner’s syndrome (XO), both of sex or the genetic origins of the particular DSD
which are associated with underdeveloped (Figure 2.3). Whether using new or old nomen
internal and external genitalia and abnormal clature, the correct categorization of the
cycling or infertility. XY DSD describes any
abnormality of gonads, or internal or external
genitalia, in an individual with one X and one
Y chromosome, while XX DSD describes any
such abnormality in an individual with two X
chromosomes (Meyers‐Wallen 2012a).
The terms hermaphrodite and pseudoher
maphrodite have been phased out and replaced
in human healthcare, but are still commonly
used in veterinary settings and veterinary pub
lications and may be most familiar to readers.
These DSDs represent discordance between
gonadal and phenotypic sex (i.e. errors in the
sex differentiation processes). In short, a
female pseudohermaphrodite has ovaries and
XX chromosomes, but the external genitals
appear masculine, resulting in some mixture
or blurring of sexual anatomy. The degree of
masculinization ranges from a normal vulva Figure 2.2 True hermaphrodite cat. This cat
appeared to be unilaterally cryptorchid, but upon
with mild clitoral enlargement to a somewhat
exploration for the abdominal testicle, a uterus and
normal penis and prepuce with an internal ovaries, as well as the abdominal testicle, were
prostate. A male pseudohermaphrodite has found. Source: Photo courtesy of Kristin Budinich.
Disorders of Sexual Development 31
abnormality in dogs and cats. Affected indi f ormation, or may be due to the presence of
viduals typically have hypoplastic testes and multiple cell lines, either as a chimera (two cell
are infertile. Other examples of abnormalities lines derived from two zygotes) or as a mosaic
of chromosomal sex include XO syndrome (two cell lines derived from one zygote). Male
(monosomy X, known as Turner’s syndrome in calico or tortoiseshell cats with XY/XY or XX/
humans) and XXX syndrome (trisomy X; XY karyotypes may be fertile, but many
O’Connor et al. 2011). Both are very rarely affected male cats have karyotypes with abnor
reported in the veterinary literature and are typ mal cell lines (for example XY/XXY) and are
ically associated with underdeveloped internal infertile (Malouf et al. 1967; Loughman et al.
and external genitalia and infertility. Finally, 1970; Loughman and Frye 1974; Hageltorn
chimeras or mosaics (XX/XY and XY/XY) and Gustavsson 1981; Long et al. 1981). Male
represent another possible abnormality in chro calico cats with XXY genotype (Klinefelter’s
mosomal development. These animals may syndrome) are infertile (Meyers‐Wallen
have a variety of different presentations, rang 2012b). Regardless of their fertility status,
ing from those with normal sexual development bilateral scrotal testes are often present in tom
to true hermaphrodites (Strain et al. 1998). cats with any of these sex chromosome abnor
malities. For those tomcats that are infertile,
Male Calico Cats the testes may appear relatively small.
One specific example of an abnormality of Sex chromosome DSD is not the only way
chromosomal sex is the calico or tortoiseshell that a calico cat can present as a male, although
male cat (Figure 2.5a and b), which is almost it appears to be by far the most common. There
always related to a sex chromosome DSD. In is a report of a single calico cat with male exter
cats, white coat color is carried on an auto nal genitalia who presented bilaterally cryp
some. Orange and non‐orange (black) are torchid, but who had an XX karyotype
alleles on the X chromosome (Chastain et al. accompanied by an adrenal enzyme deficiency
1988). For a male cat to exhibit both orange causing androgen excess (Meyers‐Wallen
and non‐orange, he must have two different X 2012b). Two other case reports describe an
chromosomes. This can be due to a simple SRY‐negative, testicular XX tortoiseshell cat
increase in the number of sex chromosomes with apparently normal scrotal testes (De
from nondisjunction errors during gamete Lorenzi et al. 2017) and an SRY‐positive XX
(a) (b)
Figure 2.5 (a and b) Male calico cat neutered at a HQHVSN clinic. Both testicles were in the scrotum, and
the cat had penile spines. Source: Photo courtesy of Pamela Krausz.
Disorders of Sexual Development 33
tortoiseshell cat with a juvenile penis without 2009). Affected dogs may be asymptomatic or
spines, two vas deferens, no scrotum, and no may present with clinical signs of hyperestro
detectable gonads (Szczerbal et al. 2015). genism due to neoplasia of retained testes,
When presented with a male calico cat for including gynecomastia, pendulous preputial
neutering, the spay–neuter veterinarian is sheath, symmetrical nonpruritic alopecia, and
unlikely to know the genetic and/or hormonal attraction of male dogs; pyometra; urinary
mechanism behind the cat’s unusual presenta tract disease; abdominal pain; or prostate dis
tion. Fortunately, these cats can be approached ease (Brown et al. 1976; Nickel et al. 1992; Wu
like any other cat castration. If a male calico et al. 2009; Christensen 2012). Dogs with this
has scrotal testes, he should be neutered rou condition with at least one scrotal testicle are
tinely without abdominal exploration for addi fertile (Meyers‐Wallen 2012b). Similar abnor
tional gonads. If the cat appears cryptorchid, malities are likely in cats, but have not been
then abdominal surgery is obviously required, confirmed (Meyers‐Wallen 2012b). Surgical
and the gonads and tubular system may be removal of gonads and all tubular reproductive
those of a male, female, or true hermaphro structures is indicated.
dite. While there is a small chance that a calico
male with two scrotal testes could also have Defects in Androgen-Dependent
internal vestigial female tubular structures, Masculinization
these may cause no future problems, and In this case, XY males develop bilateral testes
routine abdominal exploration of these cats is and no müllerian duct derivatives, but experi
not warranted unless clinical problems are ence incomplete masculinization of the inter
evident. nal and external genitalia. A variety of defects
in androgen‐dependent masculinization are
possible and can result in abnormal pheno
XY Disorders of Sexual
types ranging from mild to severe. Examples
Development
of defects include insufficient androgen
As previously stated, XY DSD describes any production, androgen resistance, and defi
abnormality of gonads, or internal or external ciencies in androgen receptors. Affected
genitalia, in an individual with one X and one individuals may have poorly developed or
Y chromosome. These include XY males with ambiguous external genitalia (as in a male
failure of the müllerian ducts to regress, as pseudohermaphrodite). In particular, one
well as individuals with defects in androgen‐ such defect results in “testicular feminization
dependent masculinization. The XY DSD clas syndrome,” where an animal has testes, usu
sification therefore encompasses both male ally is cryptorchid, and is a phenotypic female
pseudohermaphrodites and true hermaphro (Meyers‐Wallen et al. 1989; Peter et al. 1993).
dites (also known as ovotesticular DSD). The fault in development is due to defective
androgen receptor function and the condition
Persistent Müllerian Duct Syndrome may be hereditary in dogs and cats (Meyers‐
Persistent müllerian duct syndrome (PMDS) is Wallen et al. 1989; Peter et al. 1993). The
a hereditary condition of miniature Schnauzers testes are present in affected animals and
in the United States and of basset hounds in secrete normal amounts of testosterone and
Europe, and has been reported in other breeds MIS, therefore müllerian duct derivatives are
as well. Affected dogs possess male external absent. However, masculinization is absent or
genitalia, but develop both male and female incomplete as a result of the defect in the
internal tubular structures (i.e. they develop a androgen receptor gene. Other clinical
uterus). In addition, many affected dogs are presentations associated with defects in
cryptorchid (Nickel et al. 1992; Meyers‐Wallen androgen‐dependent masculinization include
34 2 Disorders of Sexual Development and Common Reproductive Pathologies
cryptorchid animals, hypospadias, and other most likely polygenic recessive (Amann and
abnormalities of the penis and/or prepuce. Veeramachaneni 2007). Heritability, defined as
the amount of variation in the population due
Cryptorchidism Cryptorchidism (Figure 2.6) is to genetic factors, is reported to vary by breed,
characterized by failure in the descent of one with a range from 0.23 in boxers to 0.75 in
(unilateral) or both (bilateral) testis from the German shepherd dogs (Neilen et al. 2001;
abdominal cavity to the scrotum (Burke 1986). Dolf et al. 2010). Although cryptorchidism can
Undescended or incompletely descended only be exhibited in male dogs (sex‐limited
testes may be located in the abdomen, in the trait), bitches can carry genes for abnormal tes
inguinal canal, or in the subcutaneous tissue ticular descent and carriers bred to carriers
between the inguinal canal and the scrotum. will produce affected pups (Gubbels et al.
Testes should be descended into the scrotum in 2009). Breeding of carriers also is associated
most dogs and cats by 5 days of age, and one‐ with increased litter size and increased num
fourth of those not descended by 10 days of age ber of males in the litter, suggesting that selec
will descend by 14 weeks of age (Dunn et al. tion for those desirable traits may contribute to
1968). In one study of 1494 cryptorchid dogs, the persistence of cryptorchidism in a breeding
testicular descent occurred in 24.5% by population (Turba and Willer 1988; Gubbels
six months of age, with descent of testes more et al. 2009).
common in dogs with unilateral cryptorchidism Cryptorchidism is more prevalent in pure
than in those with bilateral cryptorchidism bred animals than in crossbred animals, in
(Dunn et al. 1968). By six months of age on some specific breeds of dog and cat, and in
average, the inguinal canal is closed in dogs smaller variants of a given type of breed, for
and further testicular descent is not likely. example toy poodles compared to standard
Genetic, epigenetic, and environmental poodles (Hayes et al. 1985; Millis et al. 1992).
factors contribute to abnormal testicular The reported incidence is 1.2–12.9% in dogs
descent (Amann and Veeramachaneni 2007). and 0.007–1.7% in cats (Priester et al. 1970;
The mode of inheritance is not defined, but is Kawakami et al. 1984; Millis et al. 1992; Ruble
and Hird 1993). Cryptorchidism may be unilat
eral or bilateral, with unilateral cryptorchid
ism more common (Millis et al. 1992). There is
no difference in incidence between right uni
lateral and left unilateral cryptorchidism
(Kawakami et al. 1984; Millis et al. 1992;
Nelson and Couto 1994), although one report
(Mattos et al. 2000) indicates that the lack of
descent in dogs is found twice as often on the
right side as on the left.
Abnormalities associated with cryptorchid
ism in dogs include PMDS, umbilical hernias,
hypospadias, micropenis, and phimosis
(Brown et al. 1976; Pope and Swaim 1985;
Nickel et al. 1992; Switonski et al. 2012).
Concurrent abnormalities reported in cats
include cardiac murmurs, microphthalmia
and upper eyelid agenesis, patellar luxation,
Figure 2.6 Subcutaneous cryptorchid adult dog.
The cryptorchid testis is evident just lateral to the tarsal defect, and shortened tail (Richardson
prepuce. Source: Photo courtesy of Sara White. and Mullen 1993).
Disorders of Sexual Development 35
(a) (b)
Figure 2.7 Hypospadias in two tomcats. In both photos the cats have been anesthetized, prepped, and
positioned in dorsal recumbency for castration. In both cases, two scrotal testicles are present. In the
absence of clinical signs of urinary problems, castration can be surgically approached as for any other
tomcat. (a) This cat’s urethral opening is large (white arrow) and his prepuce has not formed completely, so
that his penis could be mistaken for an enlarged clitoris. Source: Photo courtesy of BobbieJean Baker. (b)
This cat is similar to the first, but the prepuce has been partially reflected to expose the tip of the penis.
Note that penile spines are evident. In this photo, the anus is covered by a gauze sponge. Source: Photo
courtesy of Rebecca Trejo.
Figure 2.8 Hypospadias in dogs. (a) An adult Boston Terrier with hypospadias. This dog is also cryptorchid.
Location and evaluation of the urethral orifice are needed in order to determine the appropriate surgical
management necessary for this patient in addition to castration. In cases of hypospadias, the orifice may be
located anywhere along the ventrum of the glans penis to the perineum. (b) The prepuce of the same
Boston Terrier as in (a). The dog had openings on each side of the partially formed prepuce that resembled
a vulva with smegma-like discharge. Source: Photos courtesy of Brooke Groskopf. (c) Hypospadias in a puppy.
Testicles are present caudally on each side of the urethra. Source: Photo courtesy of Alana Canupp.
(Howard and Bjorling 1989; Root et al. 1996). XX Disorders of Sexual Development
Persistence of a portion of this fold usually is
As previously stated, XX DSD describes any
seen as a band of tissue connecting the glans
abnormality of gonads, or internal or external
penis to the shaft of the penis or to the preputial
genitalia, in an individual with two X chromo
mucosa (see Chapter 1, Figure 1.14). Dogs may
somes. The XX DSD classification therefore
be asymptomatic or may have clinical
encompasses both female pseudohermaphro
manifestations including dysuria, discomfort
dites and true hermaphrodites. The degree of
or inability to breed by natural service or have
phenotypic masculinization has been corre
semen collected by manual ejaculation, licking
lated to the proportion of testicular tissue pre
of the penis/prepuce, phallocampsis (curvature
sent in a given individual (Meyers‐Wallen
of the erect penis), and urine scald dermatitis
2012a). Clinical presentations range from a
of the inguinal area and medial hindlimbs
normal vulva with mild clitoral enlargement to
(Belkin 1969; Hutchison 1973; Ryer 1979;
a somewhat normal penis and prepuce with an
Balke 1981; Pugh et al. 1987; Sahay et al. 1987;
internal prostate.
Olsen and Salwei 2001). Diagnosis is by
XX sex reversal has been well documented in
inspection and surgical repair involves simple
dogs, although it has not been reported in cats.
transection of the frenulum, which usually is
Affected dogs can either have both ovarian and
avascular.
testicular tissue (true hermaphrodites or
ovotesticular DSD) or only testicular tissue
Micropenis Micropenis, or infantile penis, is
(pseudohermaphrodites or testicular DSD;
an unusually small penis relative to the size of
Meyers‐Wallen 2012a). Individuals with XX sex
the dog. This condition may be associated with
reversal have an XX karyotype, testes or ovotes
cryptorchidism, phimosis, or intersex states
tes, and abnormal male genitalia, such as a
(Proescholdt and DeYoung 1977; Root Kustritz
small or caudally displaced penis, or ambigu
2001). Clinical manifestations include
ous female genitalia, such as a prepuce‐like
dripping of urine, hematuria, dysuria, and
vulva (Figure 2.9; Hare et al. 1974; Sommer and
balanoposthitis (Proescholdt and DeYoung
Meyers‐Wallen 1991). Clinical presentations
1977).
range from true hermaphrodites – partially
masculinized females with ovotestes – to XX
Phimosis Phimosis is inability to extrude the
males with malformed male external genitalia
penis. Congenital phimosis usually is
and cryptorchid aspermatogenic testes. This
associated with a stenotic preputial orifice
condition is inherited as an autosomal reces
such that the urine stream is very small and
sive trait in American cocker spaniels. Other
the prepuce may fill with urine (Papazoglou
breeds, including English cocker spaniels, bea
and Kazakos 2002). The penis may or may not
gles, Weimaraners, pugs, and German short‐
be normal and other abnormalities may be
haired pointers, have also been reported to have
present, such as cryptorchidism (Jacobs and
a hereditary predisposition (Stewart et al. 1972;
Baughman 1977; Pope and Swaim 1985). The
Hare et al. 1974; Christensen 2012).
condition may be congenital or acquired. The
Other less dramatic abnormalities of the
most common causes of acquired phimosis are
female reproductive tract can also result from
scarring from lacerations following trauma,
variations in development. These may involve
sucking of the puppy’s or kitten’s prepuce by
the ovaries, uterus, vagina, and/or vulva. In
littermates, and licking from the dam.
many cases, these abnormalities will be clini
Neoplasia in this area may also narrow the
cally insignificant, although some may require
preputial orifice (Papazoglou and Kazakos
special treatment. Additionally, a number of
2002). Surgical repair involves recreation of a
reproductive pathologies may be seen in
preputial orifice.
38 2 Disorders of Sexual Development and Common Reproductive Pathologies
(a) (c)
(b)
Figure 2.10 Ovarian cysts. (a) Ovarian cyst in a cat. Cyst measuring approximately 1 cm is to the right
above the hemostat tip, and actively cycling ovary with corpora hemorrhagica is to the left above the
hemostat. Source: Photo courtesy of Jaime Feroli Giunta. (b) Very large ovarian cyst from a cat. No normal
ovarian tissue is visible. Source: Photo courtesy of Faith Perrin. (c) Cat with large ovarian cyst and pyometra.
Source: Photo courtesy of Catherine Malgieri.
Disorders of Sexual Development 39
(a) (b)
Figure 2.12 Ovarian pedicle nodules in a cat can be (a) adhered to the ovarian vessels or (b) located in
the suspensory ligament. Despite their proximity to the ovary, these nodules are not accessory ovarian
tissue, but are adrenal cortical tissue or mesonephric remnants. Source: Photos courtesy of Kim Culbertson.
40 2 Disorders of Sexual Development and Common Reproductive Pathologies
(a) (b)
Figure 2.13 Uterus unicornis. (a) In this cat uterus, the uterine horn on the left is normal and the horn on
the right is hypoplastic. Ovaries are present on each side. Source: Photo courtesy of Faith Perrin. (b) Uterus
unicornis in a puppy. The uterine horn at the top of the photo is normally developed, while the one at the
bottom of the photo has not developed. Both ovaries are present. Source: Photo courtesy of Brenda Griffin.
Disorders of Sexual Development 41
(a) (b)
Figure 2.14 Segmental aplasia of the uterus. (a) This dog has segmental aplasia with dilation of the
uterine segments proximal to the aplastic segments. Source: Photo courtesy of Robyn Barton. (b) This cat
with segmental aplasia has normally developed uterine horns only at the tips near the ovaries. The tissue is
not dilated or fluid filled, only enlarged due to the cat’s active cycling. Source: Photo courtesy of Sara White.
is sero‐mucoid to mucoid. Bacterial infection is ( especially cats) show no signs of illness and
not a component of either of these conditions are diagnosed with pyometra incidentally at
(von Reitzenstein et al. 2000). Hydrometra and the time of spay surgery. Techniques and
mucometra are generally incidental findings, considerations for spaying a cat or dog with
as they may not cause any clinical signs other pyometra are described in Chapter 12.
than decreased fertility (Hagman 2014). In
cats, CEH is frequent in nulliparous queens Ectopic Fetuses The presence of one or more
over three years of age and in any queen over extrauterine fetuses is another pathology that
five years of age (Agudelo 2005), and it is may be an incidental finding at the time of
common to see some degree of hydrometra in routine spay surgery (Figure 2.16a–f). Ectopic
older cat spays. fetuses have been reported in both cats and
Pyometra (Figure 2.15b and c) is the accu dogs, though their occurrence is considered
mulation of purulent material in the uterus very rare (Nack 2000; Rosset et al. 2011; Eddey
due to bacterial infection. It is a luteal phase 2012; Chong 2017). Although a palpable
disease, meaning it occurs following estrus abdominal mass would be evident on physical
once estrogen concentrations have peaked and examination, affected cats and dogs often
declined and progesterone concentrations are display no overt clinical signs. For this reason,
elevated. The influence of these hormones is ectopic fetuses may remain undiscovered for
believed to be an integral part of the pathogen weeks, months, or even years. In some cases,
esis of this potentially life‐threatening disease. affected animals do present with nonspecific
The combination of opportunistic bacteria signs such as fever, lethargy, inappetence, and/
ascending from the vagina into the uterus or vomiting, although there is no clear
combined with an abnormal endometrium association between duration of the ectopic
due to CEH appears to further predispose fetus and the onset of such signs. Ectopic
animals to pyometra (von Reitzenstein et al. fetuses have been discovered in both sexually
2000). Pyometra is generally thought of as an intact and previously spayed patients.
emergency (von Reitzenstein et al. 2000; Ectopic pregnancies (i.e. pregnancies that
Hagman 2014), although many patients occur outside of the uterus) are well known in
42 2 Disorders of Sexual Development and Common Reproductive Pathologies
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 2.15 (a) Hydrometra in a cat. Source: Photo courtesy of Debbie Statland. (b and c) Pyometra in a
dog. Pyometras can become greatly enlarged. Source: Photos courtesy of Sherri Therrien.
Figure 2.16 Ectopic fetuses. (a) This recently acquired, otherwise healthy-appearing stray dog was
presented for spay surgery and removal of a large, firm, nonmovable mass from the ventral abdominal wall
noted by the owner. (b) On pre-surgical physical examination, a second large, firm mass was palpated in the
caudal abdomen. This mass, which is visible through the abdominal incision, was removed. (c) Once
removed, the membranous outer covering of the mass was resected, revealing a well-developed fetal puppy.
(d) Next, the uterus was exteriorized and a large omental adhesion (left) was discovered on the uterine
horn, presumably at the site of a previous rupture. This adhesion was attached to both the spleen and
abdominal wall, creating the mass effect that the owner had originally noted. Source: Photos courtesy of
Janice Ramirez and Coco’s Animal Welfare, and surgeon Karina Valenti. (e) Ectopic fetus discovered during
ovariohysterectomy of a feral cat. In this photo, both uterine horns are visible, with scarring from previous
uterine rupture visible near the bifurcation. The grayish-green mass attached to the omentum on the right
is an encapsulated fetus. Source: Photo courtesy of Alexandra Devine. (f) Ectopic fetuses have also been
reported in rabbits (Segura Gil et al. 2004). These three ectopic fetuses of varying sizes were discovered
incidentally during ovariohysterectomy of a clinically normal rabbit. Note the normal appearance of the
uterus. Source: Photo courtesy of Erin Doyle
Disorders of Sexual Development 43
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
44 2 Disorders of Sexual Development and Common Reproductive Pathologies
humans and are typically classified as either lacking, since the presence of ectopic fetuses
tubal or abdominal, depending on the site of may not be discovered for months or years.
implantation (Nack 2000; Rosset et al. 2011; Abdominal radiographs and/or ultrasound
Eddey 2012; Chong 2017). Tubal pregnancies findings are consistent with the presence of a
have not been reported in dogs and cats. tightly curled fetus in an extrauterine location,
Abdominal ectopic pregnancies are classified with or without the presence of free abdominal
as either primary or secondary. In the case of a fluid. Exploratory surgery is both diagnostic
primary abdominal ectopic pregnancy, a ferti and therapeutic. The number and location of
lized ovum is expelled into the abdomen prior extrauterine fetuses may vary. One or more
to implantation and develops a “placental rela fetuses may be present, and they may be
tionship” with a peritoneal or omental surface. located in the omentum surrounding the intes
In contrast, secondary abdominal ectopic preg tines, mesentery, broad ligament of the uterus,
nancy occurs when a fetus initially gestates in ovary, and/or body wall. In some cases, exten
the uterus and then later enters the abdomen sive dissection will be required for removal.
as a result of uterine wall rupture. The vast Nonetheless, the prognosis is considered excel
majority (if not all) of the cases of ectopic preg lent: in all reported cases affected patients
nancies in cats and dogs are secondary, and are recovered well from surgery (Nack 2000;
perhaps better termed ectopic fetuses, rather Rosset et al. 2011; Eddey 2012; Chong 2017).
than pregnancies, since these fetuses do not
remain viable in extrauterine locations. Vagina/Vulva
Ectopic fetuses in dogs and cats typically Clitoral Hypertrophy/Os Clitoris Clitoral hyper
result from uterine rupture during pregnancy. trophy, with or without presence of a
Uterine wall rupture can occur as a result of cartilaginous or bony internal structure, is
external trauma or during parturition, espe often the first physical evidence of true
cially when signs of dystocia are present. A his hermaphroditism or pseudohermaphroditism
tory of trauma, evidence of uterine trauma, noted by owners or veterinarians (Figure 2.17a
and gross findings of mummified fetuses in the and b). The structure is sensitive and its
abdomen without evidence of implantation or presence is frequently associated with vulvar
a placental relationship with abdominal organs licking, urinary incontinence, and/or recurrent
are all consistent with the diagnosis of ectopic vaginitis (Tangner et al. 1982; Mantri and
fetus. However, evidence of trauma may be Vishwasrao 1994). Removal of the gonads may
(a) (b)
Figure 2.17 (a) Clitoral hyperplasia in a puppy and (b) abdominal testicles and uterus were located during
surgery. Source: Photo courtesy of Maroqui Serrano.
Disorders of Sexual Development 45
or may not cause decrease in size of the clitoral c ontributing factors to a wide variety of clini
tissue. Before surgical removal of the clitoris is cal problems, ranging from urinary inconti
attempted, passage of a urinary catheter and/ nence, vaginal pooling of urine, recurrent
or radiographic contrast studies to define urinary tract infection, recurrent vaginitis, and
placement of the urethra within or around infertility to inability to breed or whelp natu
related structures are strongly recommended. rally (Burdick et al. 2014). When clinical signs
Clitoral hypertrophy may also occur in oth are present, correction of the malformation
erwise normally developed female dogs as a may be warranted to treat the underlying con
result of exogenous exposure to androgens. dition. Among the various vestibulovaginal
Perhaps the most common example of this is malformations, a persistent or imperforate
in racing greyhounds, because the drug mibo hymen is generally the easiest to treat, because
lerone is commonly used for estrus suppres these can usually be broken down digitally. For
sion. Withdrawal of the drug and removal of the remainder of these conditions, invasive
the gonads may result in partial reversal. If surgery has historically been performed for
associated clinical signs are present, surgery correction, including vaginectomy, vagino
may be indicated in these cases as well. plasty, and vaginal resection and anastomosis,
among others – all of which are associated
Vestibulovaginal Malformations Various vestib with potentially serious risks and complica
ulovaginal malformations have been reported tions (Kyles et al. 1996; Kieves et al. 2011).
in dogs, including an imperforate or persistent More recently, endoscopic‐guided laser abla
hymen, vestibulovaginal stenosis, vaginal seg tion has been described as a noninvasive diag
mental hypoplasia or aplasia, persistent para nostic and therapeutic option. This technique
mesonephric septal remnant, vaginal septa, provides an effective, safe, and minimally
and dual vaginas (Capel‐Edwards 1977; Holt invasive treatment option for dogs with various
and Sayle 1981; Wykes and Soderberg 1983; vaginal malformations, avoiding the need for
Root et al. 1995; Kyles et al. 1996; Nomura more invasive surgery (Burdick et al. 2014).
et al. 1997; Burdick et al. 2014). Septa and stric
tures most often form at the vestibulovaginal Mammary Hyperplasia
junction, because that is where the parameso Another reproductive pathology that the spay–
nephric ducts and urogenital sinus join during neuter surgeon may encounter is mammary
embryologic development. There may be cystic hyperplasia, a non‐neoplastic enlargement of
dilation with accumulation of estrous secre one or more mammary glands in cats
tions if there is no outflow to the caudal vagina (Figure 2.18). It most often occurs in sexually
(Nomura et al. 1997; Baines et al. 1999; intact young queens that are actively cycling
Tsumagari et al. 2001; Viehoff and Sjollema (Little 2011), although it may occur in intact
2003). Failure of closure of the dorsal commis queens of any age, as well as in female or male
sure of the vulva and complete vulvar agenesis cats receiving progestin treatment (Payan‐
have also been reported in dogs, as have rec Carreira 2013). The benign fibroglandular pro
tovaginal and rectovestibular fistulas (Burke liferation of the mammary glands occurs under
and Smith 1975; Capel‐Edwards 1977; Meij the influence of progesterone. As such, it
et al. 1990; Tivers and Baines 2010). There are occurs during the luteal phase of the estrous
no reported genetic or breed predispositions cycle and may also occur during pregnancy.
for any of these malformations, and their prev Although cats are considered induced ovula
alence is unknown (Burdick et al. 2014). tors, affected cats need not have been bred to
In some individuals vestibulovaginal malfor develop the condition, because ovulation can
mations are incidental findings, whereas in occur as a result of noncopulatory stimulation.
others they may be underlying causes or Anywhere from one to all mammary glands
46 2 Disorders of Sexual Development and Common Reproductive Pathologies
References
Adelsberger, M.E. and Smeak, D.D. (2009). Amann, R.P. and Veeramachaneni, D.N.R.
Repair of extensive perineal hypospadias in (2007). Cryptorchidism in common eutherian
a Boston terrier using tubularized incised mammals. Reproduction 133: 541–561.
plate urethroplasty. Can. Vet. J. 50: Arlt, S.P. and Haimerl, P. (2016). Cystic ovaries
937–942. and ovarian neoplasia in the female dog – a
Ader, P.L. and Hobson, H.P. (1978). systematic review. Reprod. Domest. Anim 51
Hypospadias: a review of the veterinary (Suppl 1): 3–11.
literature and a report of three cases in the Aronson, L.R. and Cooper, M.L. (1967). Penile spines
dog. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 14: 721–727. of the domestic cat: their endocrine‐behavior
Agudelo, C. (2005). Cystic endometrial relations. Anat. Rec. (Hoboken) 157: 71–78.
hyperplasia‐pyometra complex in cats. A Arrighi, S., Bosi, G., Groppetti, D. et al. (2010).
review. Vet. Quart. 27: 173–182. An insight into testis and gubernaculum
Altera, K. and Miller, L. (1986). Recognition of dynamics of Insl3‐RXFP2 signalling during
feline parovarian nodules as ectopic testicular descent in the dog. Reprod. Fertil.
adrenocortical tissue. JAVMA 189: 71–72. Dev. 22: 751–760.
References 47
Atkinson, M.C. (1998). Polyorchidism in a dog. Capel‐Edwards, K. (1977). Double vagina with
Vet. Rec. 143: 684–685. perineal agenesis in a bitch. Vet. Rec. 101: 57.
Baines, S.J., Speakman, A.J., Williams, J.M. et al. Carlson, B.M. (2018). Human Embryology and
(1999). Genitourinary dysplasia in a cat. J. Sm. Developmental Biology. St Louis, MO: Elsevier.
Anim. Pract. 40: 286–290. Cassata, R., Iannuzzi, A., Parma, P. et al. (2008).
Balke, J. (1981). Persistent penile frenulum in a Clinical, cytogenetic and molecular evaluation
cocker spaniel. Vet. Med. Sm. Anim. Clin. 76: in a dog with bilateral cryptorchidism and
988–990. hypospadias. Cytogenet. Genome Res. 120:
Batista Arteaga, M., Gonzalez Valle, F., Cabrera 140–143.
Martin, F. et al. (2000). Morphologic and Chang, J., Jung, J.‐H., Yoon, J. et al. (2008).
endocrinological characteristics of retained Segmental aplasia of the uterine horn with
canine testes. Canine Pract. 25: 12–15. ipsilateral renal agenesis in a cat. J. Vet. Med.
Baumans, V., Dikjstra, G., and Wensing, C.J.G. Sci. 70: 641–643.
(1982). The effect of orchiectomy on Chastain, C.B., Guilford, W.G., and Schmidt, D.
gubernacular outgrowth and regression in the (1988). The 38,XX/39,SSY genotype in cats.
dog. Int. J. Androl. 5: 387–400. Comp. Cont. Educ. Pract. 10: 18–22.
Baumans, V., Dijkstra, G., and Wensing, C.J.G. Chong, A. (2017). A case of feline ectopic
(1983). The role of a non‐androgenic testicular abdominal fetuses secondary to trauma. Can.
factor in the process of testicular descent in Vet. J. 58: 400.
the dog. Int. J. Androl. 6: 541–552. Christensen, B.W. (2012). Disorders of sexual
Belkin, P.B. (1969). Persistence of a penile development in dogs and cats. Vet. Clin. N.
frenulum in a dog. Mod. Vet. Pract. 50: 80. Am. Sm. Anim. Pract. 42: 515–526.
Brookshire, W.C., Shivley, J., Woodruff, K. et al. Cox, V.S., Wallace, L.J., and Jessen, C.R. (1978).
(2017). Uterus unicornis and pregnancy in An anatomic and genetic study of canine
two feline littermates. J. Feline Med. Surg. cryptorchidism. Teratology 18: 233–240.
Open Rep 3 (2): 1–5. https://doi. De Lorenzi, L., Banco, B., Previderè, C. et al.
org/10.1177/2055116917743614. (2017). Testicular XX (SRY ‐negative) disorder
Brown, T.T., Burek, J.D., and McEntee, K. (1976). of sex development in cat. Sex. Dev. 11: 210–216.
Male pseudohermaphroditism, cryptorchism, Dolf, G., Holle, D., Gaillard, C. et al. (2010).
and Sertoli cell neoplasia in three miniature Heritabilities for abdominal cryptorchidism
schnauzers. JAVMA 169: 821–825. and umbilical hernia in dog. World Congress
Burdick, S., Berent, A.C., Weisse, C., and on Genetics Applied to Livestock Production,
Langston, C. (2014). Endoscopic‐guided laser Leipzig. Germany. http://www.wcgalp.org/
ablation of vestibulovaginal septal remnants system/files/proceedings/2010/heritabilities‐
in dogs: 36 cases (2007–2011). JAVMA 244: abdominal‐cryptorchidism‐and‐umbilical‐
944–949. hernia‐dog.pdf (accessed 3 August 2019).
Burke, T.J. (1986). Causes of infertility. In: Small Dreger, A.D., Chase, C., Sousa, A. et al. (2005).
Animal Reproduction and Infertility (ed. T.J. Changing the nomenclature/taxonomy for
Burke), 233–235. Philadelphia, PA: Lea & intersex: a scientific and clinical rationale.
Febiger. J. Pediatr. Endocrinol. Metabol. 18: 729–734.
Burke, T.J. and Smith, C.W. (1975). Vulvo‐ Dunn, M., Foster, W., and Goddard, K. (1968).
vaginal cleft in a dog. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Cryptorchidism in dogs: a clinical survey.
Assoc. 11: 774–777. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 4: 180–182.
Burstyn, U. (2010). Management of mastitis and Dybdahl Thomsen, P., Byskov, A.G., and Basse,
abscessation of mammary glands secondary to A. (1987). Fertility in two cats with X‐
fibroadenomatous hyperplasia in a chromosome mosaicism and unilateral
primiparturient cat. JAVMA 236: 326–329. ovarian dysgenesis. J. Reprod. Fertil. 80: 43–47.
48 2 Disorders of Sexual Development and Common Reproductive Pathologies
Eddey, P.D. (2012). Ectopic pregnancy in an features of 410 dogs. Int. J. Cancer 18:
apparently healthy bitch. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. 482–487.
Assoc. 48: 194–197. Hayes, H.M. and Wilson, G.P. (1986). Hospital
Eissa, H., Farghali, H., and Osman, A. (2017). incidence of hypospadias in dogs in North
Persian queens: pathological and America. Vet. Rec. 118: 605–606.
ultrasonography evaluation of ovarian affections Hayes, H.M., Wilson, G.P., Pendergrass, T.W.
in Egypt. J. Anim. Health Behav. Sci. 1: 2. et al. (1985). Canine cryptorchidism and
Fletcher, T.F. and Weber, A.F. (2013). Veterinary subsequent testicular neoplasia: case‐control
developmental anatomy. http://vanat.cvm. study with epidemiologic update. Teratology
umn.edu/vanatpdf/embryolectnotes.pdf 32: 51–56.
(accessed 3 August 2019). Holt, P.E. and Sayle, B. (1981). Congenital
Galanty, M., Jurka, P., and Zielinska, P. (2008). vestibulovaginal stenosis in the bitch. J. Sm.
Surgical treatment of hypospadias: techniques Anim. Pract. 22: 67–75.
and results in six dogs. Pol. J. Vet. Sci. 11: Howard, P.E. and Bjorling, D.E. (1989). The
235–243. intersexual animal – associated problems.
Gelberg, H., McEntee, K., and Heath, E. (1984). Prob. Vet. Med. 1: 74–84.
Feline cystic rete ovarii. Vet. Pathol. 21: 304–307. Hutchison, J.A. (1973). Persistence of the penile
Goo, M.‐J., Williams, B.H., Hong, I.‐H. et al. frenulum in dogs. Can. Vet. J. 14: 71.
(2009). Multiple urogenital abnormalities in a Jacobs, D. and Baughman, G.L. (1977). Preputial
Persian cat. J. Feline Med. Surg. 11: 153–155. defect in a puppy. Mod. Vet. Pract. 58:
Gubbels, E.D.G., Scholten, J., Janns, L. et al. 522–523.
(2009). Relationship of cryptorchidism with Jurka, P., Galanty, M., Zielinski, P. et al. (2009).
sex ratios and litter sizes in 12 dog breeds. Hypospadias in six dogs. Vet. Rec. 164:
Anim. Reprod. Sci. 113: 187–195. 331–333.
Guimaraes, L.D., Bourguignon, E., Santos, L.C. Kawakami, E., Tsutsui, T., Yamada, Y. et al.
et al. (2013). Canine perineal hypospadias. (1984). Cryptorchidism in the dog: occurrence
Arq. Bras. Med. Vet. Zootec. 65 (6): 1647–1650. of cyrptorchidism and semen quality in the
Haase‐Berglund, M.L., Yang, C., and cryptorchid dog. Jap. J. Vet. Sci. 46: 303–308.
Premanandan, C.L. (2019). Histologic Kieves, N.R., Novo, R.E., and Martin, R.B.
evaluation of parovarian nodules in the cat. J. (2011). Vaginal resection and anastomosis for
Feline Med. Surg. https://doi.org/10.1177/1098 treatment of vestibulovaginal stenosis in 4
612X19867166. dogs with recurrent urinary tract infections.
Hageltorn, M. and Gustavsson, I. (1981). XXY‐ JAVMA 239: 972–980.
trisomy identified by banding techniques in a Kipnis, R.M. (1974). Membranous penile urethra
male tortoiseshell cat. J. Hered. 72: 132–134. and preputial abnormality in a dog. Vet. Med.
Hagman, R. (2014). Diagnostic and prognostic Sm. Anim. Clin. 69: 750–751.
markers for uterine diseases in dogs. Reprod. Kitchell, R.L., Kirk, E.J., Johnson, R.D. et al.
Domes. Anim. 49 (Suppl 2): 16–20. (1988). Comparative studies of the cutaneous
Hardy, R.M. and Root Kustritz, M.V. (2005). areas of the external genitalia of the dog, tom
Theriogenology question of the month: cat, ram and billy goat. Anat. Histol. Embryol.
hypospadias in a dog. JAVMA 227: 887–888. 17: 88–89.
Hare, W.C.D., McFeely, R.A., and Kelly, D.F. Kyles, A.E., Vaden, S., Hardie, E.M. et al. (1996).
(1974). Familial 78Xx male Vestibulovaginal stenosis in dogs: 18 cases
pseudohermaphroditism in three dogs. (1987–1995). JAVMA 209: 1889–1893.
J. Reprod. Fertil. 36: 207–210. Laznicka, A., Jaresova, H., Vitasek, R. et al.
Hayes, H.M. and Pendergrass, T.W. (1976). (1997). Segmental aplasia of the Mullerian
Canine testicular tumors: epidemiologic duct in bitches. Veterinár̆ství 47: 410–412.
References 49
Little, S. (2011). Feline reproduction: problems Memon, M.A., Ganjam, V.K., Pavletic, M.M.
and clinical challenges. J. Feline Med. Surg. 13: et al. (1992). Use of human chorionic
508–515. gonadotropin stimulation test to detect a
Long, S.E., Gruffydd‐Jones, T., and David, M. retained testis in a cat. JAVMA 201: 1602.
(1981). Male tortoiseshell cats: an examination Meyers‐Wallen, V.N. (1991). Clinical approach to
of testicular histology and chromosome infertile male dogs with sperm in the
complement. Res. Vet. Sci. 30: 274–280. ejaculate. Vet. Clin. N. Am. Sm. Anim. Pract.
Loughman, W.D. and Frye, F.L. (1974). XY/XYY 21: 609–633.
bone marrow karyotype in a male Siamese‐ Meyers‐Wallen, V.N. (2009). Review and update:
crossbred cat. Vet. Med. Sm. Anim. Clin. 69: genomic and molecular advances in sex
1007–1011. determination and differentiation in small
Loughman, W.D., Frye, F.L., and Condon, T.B. animals. Reprod. Dom. Anim. 44 (Suppl 2): 40–46.
(1970). XX/XXY bone marrow mosaicism in Meyers‐Wallen, V.N. (2012a). Inherited diseases
three male tricolor cats. Am. J. Vet. Res. 31: of the reproductive tract in dogs and cats.
307–314. Clin. Theriogenol. 4: 244–250.
Malouf, N., Benirschke, K., and Hoefnagel, D. Meyers‐Wallen, V.N. (2012b). Gonadal and sex
(1967). XX/XY chimerism in a tricolored male differentiation abnormalities of dogs and cats.
cat. Cytogenet. Genome Res. 6: 228–241. Sex. Dev. 6: 46–60.
Mantri, M.B. and Vishwasrao, S.V. (1994). Meyers‐Wallen, V.N., Wilson, J.D., Griffin, J.E.
Pseudo‐hermaphroditism in a German et al. (1989). Testicular feminization in a cat.
Shepherd dog – a case report. Ind. Vet. Surg. JAVMA 195: 631–634.
15: 98. Millis, D.L., Hauptman, J.G., and Johnson, C.A.
Marcella, K.L., Ramirez, M., and Hammerslag, (1992). Cryptorchidism and monorchism in
K.L. (1985). Segmental aplasia of the uterine cats: 25 cases (1980–1989). JAVMA 200:
horn in a cat. JAVMA 186: 179–181. 1128–1130.
Marino, G., Barna, A., Mannarino, C. et al. Nack, R.A. (2000). Theriogenology question of
(2010). Stromal cysts of the canine ovary: the month. JAVMA 217: 182–184.
prevalence, diagnosis and clinical Nef, S. and Parada, L.F. (2000). Hormones in
implications. Veterinaria (Cremona) 24: 9–15. male sexual development. Genes Dev. 14:
Mattos, M.R.F., Simoes‐Mattos, L., and 3075–3086.
Domingues, S.F.S. (2000). Cryptorchidism in Neilen, A.L.J., Janss, L.L.G., and Knol, B.W.
dog. Ciência Anim. 10 (1): 61–70. (2001). Heritability estimations for diseases,
McEntee, M. (1990). The Ovary. Reproductive coat color, body weight, and height in a birth
Pathology of Domestic Mammals. San Diego, cohort of boxers. Am. J. Vet. Res. 62: 1198–1206.
CA: Academic Press. Neilsen, S.W. and Lein, D.H. (1974).
McGeady, T.A., Quinn, P.J., FitzPatrick, E.S. International histological classification of
et al. (2006). Male and female reproductive tumors of domestic animals. VI. Tumors of
system. In: Veterinary Embryology (eds. T.A. the testis. Bull. World Health Org. 50: 71–78.
McGeady, P.J. Quinn, E.S. Fitzpatrick, et al.), Nelson, R.W. and Couto, C.G. (1994). Distúrbios
244–267. Ames, IA: Wiley Blackwell. do pênis, prepúcio e testículos. In:
McIntyre, R.L., Levy, J.K., Roberts, J.F. et al. Fundamentos de medicina interna de pequenos
(2010). Developmental uterine anomalies in animais, 2e (eds. R.W. Nelson and C.G.
cats and dogs undergoing elective Couto), 513–517. Rio de Janeiro: Koogan.
ovariohysterectomy. JAVMA 237: 542–546. Nickel, R.F., Ubbink, G., VanDerGaag, I. et al.
Meij, B.P., Voorhout, G., and VanOosterom, (1992). Persistent Mullerian duct syndrome in
R.A.A. (1990). Agenesis of the vulva in a the basset hound. Tidjschr. Diergeneesk. 117:
Maltese dog. J. Sm. Anim. Pract. 31: 457–460. 31S.
50 2 Disorders of Sexual Development and Common Reproductive Pathologies
Nomura, K., Koreeda, T., Kawata, M. et al. animals: general considerations. Am. J. Vet.
(1997). Vaginal atresia with transverse septum Res. 31: 1871–1879.
in a cat. J. Vet. Med. Sci. 59: 1045–1048. Proescholdt, T. and DeYoung, D. (1977). Infantile
O’Connor, C.L., Schweizer, C., Gradil, C. et al. penis in the canine. ISU Vet. 2: 59–60.
(2011). Trisomy‐X with estrous cycle Pugh, D.G., Caudle, A.B., and Wenzel, J. (1987).
anomalies in two female dogs. Theriogenology A persistent frenulum in a dog. Canine Pract.
76: 374–380. 14: 38–40.
Olsen, D. and Salwei, R. (2001). Surgical Reif, J.S. and Brodey, R.S. (1969). The
correction of a congenital preputial and penile relationship between cryptorchidism and
deformity in a dog. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. canine testicular neoplasia. JAVMA 155:
37: 187–192. 2005–2010.
Papazoglou, L.G. and Kazakos, G.M. (2002). Reis, R.H. (1966). Unilateral urogenital agenesis
Surgical conditions of the canine penis and with unilateral pregnancy and vascular
prepuce. Comp. Contin. Educ. Pract. Vet. 24 abnormalities in the cat (Felis domestica).
(3): 204–218. Wasmann J. Biol. 24: 209–222.
Pavletic, M. (2007). Reconstruction of the Richardson, E.F. and Mullen, H. (1993).
urethra by use of an inverse tubed bipedicle Cryptorchidism in cats. Compend. Cont. Educ.
flap in a dog with hypospadias. JAVMA 231: Pract. 15: 1342–1369.
71–73. Robinson, G.W. (1965). Uterus unicornis and
Payan‐Carreira, R. (2013). Feline mammary unilateral renal agenesis in a cat. JAVMA 147:
fibroepithelial hyperplasia: a clinical 516–518.
approach. In: Insights from Veterinary Root, M.V., Johnston, S.D., and Johnston, G.R.
Medicine (ed. R. Payan‐Carreira), Ch. 8. (1995). Vaginal septa in dogs: 15 cases
London: IntechOpen https://doi. (1983–1992). JAVMA 206: 56–58.
org/10.5772/55550. Root, M.V., Johnston, S.D., Johnston, G.R. et al.
Pendergrass, T.W. and Hayes, H.M. (1975). (1996). The effect of prepuberal and
Cryptorchism and related defects in dogs: postpuberal gonadectomy on penile extrusion
epidemiologic comparisons with man. and urethral diameter in the domestic cat. Vet.
Teratology 12: 51–56. Radiol. Ultrasound 37: 363–366.
Peter, A.T., Markwelder, D., and Asem, E.K. Root Kustritz, M.V. (2001). Disorders of the
(1993). Phenotypic feminization in a genetic canine penis. Vet. Clin. N. Am. Sm. Anim.
male dog caused by non‐functional androgen Pract. 31: 247–258.
receptors. Theriogenology 40: 1093–1105. Rosset, E., Galet, C., and Buff, S. (2011). A case
Pope, E.R. and Swaim, S.F. (1985). Surgical report of an ectopic fetus in a cat. J. Feline
reconstruction of a hypoplastic prepuce. J. Med. Surg. 13: 610–613.
Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 22: 73–77. Rousset, N., Abbondati, E., Posch, B. et al.
Poth, T., Breuer, W., Walter, B. et al. (2010). (2011). Unilateral hydronephrosis and
Disorders of sex development in the hydroureter secondary to ureteric atresia, and
dog – adoption of a new nomenclature and uterus unicornis in a young terrier. J. Sm.
reclassification of reported cases. Anim. Anim. Pract. 52: 441–444.
Reprod. Sci. 121: 197–207. Ruble, R.P. and Hird, D.W. (1993). Congenital
Prestes, N.C., Bicudo, S.D., Landin Alvarenga, abnormalities in immature dogs from a pet
F.C. et al. (1997). Aplasia of one uterine horn store: 253 cases (1987–1988). JAVMA 202:
associated with pyometra in a female dog. Vet. 633–636.
Noticias 3: 133–134. Ryer, K.A. (1979). Persistent penile frenulum in
Priester, W.A., Glass, A.G., and Waggoner, N.S. a cocker spaniel. Vet. Med. Sm. Anim. Clin. 74:
(1970). Congenital defects in domesticated 688.
References 51
Sahay, P.N., Dass, L.L., Mukherjee, R. et al. Szczerbal, I., Stachowiak, M., Dzimira, S. et al.
(1987). Phallocampsis due to persistent (2015). The first case of 38,XX (SRY‐positive)
frenulum in a dog. Ind. Vet. J. 64: 524–525. disorder of sex development in a cat. Mol.
Schulman, M.L. and Bolton, L.A. (1997). Uterine Cytogen. 8: 22.
horn aplasia with complications in two Tangner, C.H., Breider, M.A., and Amoss, M.S.
mixed‐breed bitches. JSAVA 68: 150–153. (1982). Lateral hermaphroditism in a dog.
Segura Gil, P., Peris Palau, B., Martı́nez JAVMA 181: 70–71.
Martı́nez, J. et al. (2004). Abdominal Tivers, M. and Baines, S. (2010). Surgical
pregnancies in farm rabbits. Theriogenology diseases of the female genital tract. 2. Vagina
62: 642–651. and external genitalia. In Pract. 32: 362–369.
Sommer, M.M. and Meyers‐Wallen, V.N. (1991). Tsumagari, S., Takagi, K., Takeishi, M. et al. (2001).
XX true hermaphroditism in a dog. JAVMA A case of a bitch with imperforate hymen and
198: 435–438. hydrocolpos. J. Vet. Med. Sci. 63: 475–477.
Stewart, R.W., Menges, R.W., Selby, L.A. et al. Turba, E. and Willer, S. (1988). The population
(1972). Canine intersexuality in a pug genetics of cryptorchidism in German boxers.
breeding kennel. Cornell Vet. 62: 464–472. Monatsh. Veterinärmed. 43: 316–319.
Strain, L., Dean, J.C., Hamilton, M.P., and Viehoff, F.W. and Sjollema, B.E. (2003).
Bonthron, D.T. (1998). A true hermaphrodite Hydrocolpos in dogs: surgical treatment in
chimera resulting from embryo amalgamation two cases. J. Sm. Anim. Pract. 44: 404–407.
after in vitro fertilization. N. Engl. J. Med. 338 von Reitzenstein, M., Archbald, L.F., and
(3): 166–169. Newell, S.M. (2000). Theriogenology question
Sumner, S.M., Grimes, J.A., Wallace, M.L., of the month. JAVMA 216: 1221–1223.
and Schmiedt, C.W. (2018). Os clitoris in Wu, X., Wan, S., Pujar, S. et al. (2009). A single
dogs: 17 cases (2009–2017). Can. Vet. J. 59: base pair mutation encoding a premature stop
606–610. codon in the MIS type II receptor is
Switonski, M., Payan‐Carreira, R., Bartz, M. et al. responsible for canine persistent Mullerian
(2012). Hypospadias in a male (78,XY;SRY‐ duct syndrome. J. Androl. 30: 46–56.
positive) dog and sex reversal female Wykes, P.M. and Soderberg, S.F. (1983).
(78,XX;SRY‐negative) dogs: clinical, Congenital abnormalities of the canine vagina
histological and genetic studies. Sex. Dev. 6: and vulva. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 19:
128–134. 995–1000.
53
Instrumentation for Spay–Neuter
Amber Burton and Sara White
The purpose of this chapter is to aid the sur- achieving small incisions in feline spay
geon in the selection of instruments, suture, procedures.
and needles when performing an ovariohyster- The scalpel handle used for spay–neuter pro-
ectomy (spay) or orchidectomy (neuter) proce- cedures is the number 3 scalpel handle, which
dure. Instruments and suture are the interface is sized to accommodate size 10 and 15 blades.
between surgeon and patient, and are integral However, many HQHVSN veterinarians prefer
to every aspect of our surgical performance, not to use a scalpel handle while cutting with a
including efficiency, precision, patient out- scalpel blade (White 2018). Although conven-
comes, and surgeon comfort. tional wisdom states that the use of blades on
scalpel handles is safer than using unattached
blades, other literature suggests that about 10%
Instrument Selection of scalpel injuries in human healthcare occur
during disassembly of the blade from the han-
The type and number of surgical instruments dle (Perry et al. 2003). At this time, research is
vary depending on type of surgery and age and not available to determine whether scalpel
condition of the patient. The surgical instru- injuries are more likely in HQHVSN with or
ments used in spay–neuter can be divided into without the use of a scalpel handle.
those used for cutting, manipulation of tissue, There are advantages and disadvantages to
manipulation of needle and suture, adequate the elimination of the scalpel handle for spay–
hemostasis, and drape securement. neuter. Advantages of not using a handle
include elimination of the time required to
assemble and disassemble the blade and han-
Cutting Instruments
dle, elimination of the risks of injury during
Instruments used for cutting include scalpel assembly and disassembly, and the perceived
blades, scalpel handles, and scissors ability to make smaller and quicker move-
(Figure 3.1). The two most commonly used ments with the blade alone than with the
scalpel blades in high‐quality high‐volume blade with handle. The reduction of the num-
spay–neuter (HQHVSN) are size 10 and size ber of instruments included in each surgery
15. Blade size selection is usually based on the pack can also be advantageous, by reducing
size of the patient (the smaller the patient, the both initial pack purchase price and staff time
smaller the blade) and on the surgeon’s prefer- for instrument cleaning and pack assembly.
ence. Size 15 blades are particularly useful for Disadvantages of using unattached scalpel
54 3 Instrumentation for Spay–Neuter
(a) (b)
Figure 3.2 (a) Instruments used for manipulation of tissue. Pictured from left to right: Adson-Brown
forceps, rat-toothed thumb forceps, and Snook spay hook. (b) Difference in tips of Adson-Brown (left) and
rat-toothed forceps (right). Notice the large interlocking teeth of the rat-toothed forceps.
Instrument Selection 55
surgeons prefer Adson or larger rat‐tooth for- deep cavities, it is less likely that suture will be
ceps, or include more than one type of thumb prematurely cut, as this occurs most often
forceps in their surgery packs (White 2018). when visibility is poor and when suturing in a
The other instrument commonly used for restricted space.
tissue manipulation in HQHVSN is the spay
hook, which is used to retrieve the uterine
Instruments for Hemostasis
horn during spay surgery. Two styles of spay
hook are available, Snook and Covault. Snook In order to obtain a clear visualization of sur-
hooks have a flat tip and Covault hooks have a gery, instruments are needed to provide ade-
ball or button tip (Nieves et al. 1993). Snook quate hemostasis. The types of hemostatic
hooks are more commonly used and more forceps used are Halstead mosquito, Kelly,
readily available, and vary considerably in both Crile, and Rochester–Carmalt (Figure 3.4).
the width and the curvature of the hook. These forceps can be either straight or curved.
Mosquito forceps have transverse serrations
Instruments for Needle and Suture that extend the full length of the jaws and are
Manipulation used for clamping small vessels to prevent or
control hemorrhage. Mosquito forceps are also
The Mayo–Hegar needle holder and the Olsen– used for performing instrument ties in the
Hegar needle holder are two instruments that pediatric canine and feline neuter, as well as
are commonly used to manipulate suture or to ovarian pedicle ties in the feline spay. Kelly
hold needles (Figure 3.3). These instruments and Crile hemostatic forceps are used for con-
differ in that the Olsen–Hegar needle holder trolling hemorrhage from small and medium‐
has suture scissors incorporated in the jaws, sized vessels. In addition, they can be used to
thus eliminating the step of cutting suture with crush tissue and blood vessels when placing
Mayo scissors (Nieves et al. 1993). The Olsen– ligatures. These forceps are similar in that they
Hegar needle holder is preferred by most have serrations along the tip of the instrument
HQHVSN surgeons (White 2018). that are transverse to the jaws. The transverse
While there is some risk with Olsen–Hegar serrations ensure that the vessel is less likely to
needle holders of inadvertently cutting suture slip when the tip of the hemostat is applied to
while attempting to grasp the suture or needle, the vessel. The Kelly hemostatic forceps differ
this consequence may be reduced with from the Crile forceps in that in the Kelly, the
attention and practice. In addition, since spay–
neuter surgeries do not require suturing in
transverse serrations only extend half the s ynthetic, and monofilament or multifilament.
length of the jaws (Nieves et al. 1993). The The first major characteristic to consider when
Rochester–Carmalt forceps have longitudinal ser- selecting a suture is whether the suture is
rations along the jaws, with transverse serrations absorbable or nonabsorbable. Absorbable
on the tip of the instrument. These forceps are suture loses its tensile strength within 60 days
designed to provide maximum hold of clamped of use and is eventually absorbed by the body
tissue, and are commonly used for clamping the by either phagocytosis or hydrolysis (Boothe
ovarian pedicle of large canine spays. 1993; Edlich and Long 2008). Absorbable
suture is typically utilized for internal ligations
and closure of tissues. It is commonly used for
Instruments for Drape Securement
closing tissues, including body wall (linea
Some HQHVSN surgeons use towel clamps to alba), subcutaneous tissues, and skin (bur-
secure surgical drapes to the patient’s skin. The ied interrupted or intradermal pattern).
most commonly used style is the Backhaus Nonabsorbable suture is suture that retains
towel forceps. Multiple towel forceps may be tensile strength for longer than 60 days and is
used to secure each drape to the patient. Towel typically not absorbed by natural mechanisms.
clamps are most commonly included in dog It is used when suture is desired to be perma-
spay packs, and are more likely to be incorpo- nently left within the tissues, or to be removed
rated in surgery packs that include paper at a later date. Except for the occasional use of
drapes compared to those with cloth drapes stainless steel, nonabsorbable suture material
(White 2018). This may be due to the differ- is not typically used in HQHVSN surgeries
ences in the draping qualities of cloth versus (White 2018).
paper, or may be related to the desire to avoid The second major characteristic to consider
damaging reusable cloth drapes and shorten- when selecting a suture is whether the suture
ing the life of the drape material. is natural, synthetic, or metallic. Natural
suture is derived from a plant or animal source,
and can elicit tissue reactions due to the pro-
Suture Selection tein composition of the suture. Tensile strength
duration is variable and may range from a cou-
The primary function of suture is to provide ple of days to months, and these materials may
support and apposition of tissue until healing have a tendency to fray during knot construc-
has occurred. The ideal suture should main- tion (Edlich and Long 2008). Examples of nat-
tain high tensile strength throughout healing, ural suture include surgical gut (catgut) and
should be easy to handle, and should provide silk. Synthetic sutures were introduced in
excellent knot security. Suture should also be order to reduce risk of tissue reaction, and to
easy to sterilize and not cause reaction of tis- have less variability in tensile strength and
sue. Other properties desired in suture include absorption (Boothe 1993). Synthetic suture is
that it be safe, nontoxic, noncarcinogenic, and the most common type of suture used in spay–
not facilitate bacterial growth. This section will neuter (White 2018).
describe how suture is classified, and will The third major characteristic to consider
describe the properties of common suture when selecting a suture is whether the suture
types used in spay–neuter. is monofilament or multifilament (braided).
Monofilament suture is one single, smooth
strand of suture. This type of suture passes eas-
Suture Materials and Use
ily through tissue, but can be difficult to han-
Suture material is generally classified accord- dle due to a tendency to take the shape that it
ing to three characteristics based on its compo- maintained in the original package, called
sition: absorbable or nonabsorbable, natural or “memory.” Multifilament suture is constructed
Suture Selection 57
with several strands of filament braided from packaging, thus decreasing handling
together. This type of suture allows good knot ability.
security and easy handling, but produces “tis- Polyglactin 910 (Coated Vicryl) is a synthetic
sue drag” when pulled through tissue. This multifilament suture that is supplied as a
drag can be traumatic to tissue, as well as cre- coated suture that is easy to handle, with mini-
ate a potential source for bacterial infection in mal tissue drag and minimal tissue reaction.
a contaminated environment. In order to avoid Coated Vicryl retains 75% of its tensile strength
this, manufacturers have developed polymer after 14 days and 25% after 28 days, and is com-
coatings for selected suture types (Edlich and pletely absorbed between 56 and 70 days (Dunn
Long 2008). These coatings function to reduce 2005).
tissue drag and potential for bacterial coloniza- Differences in the amount of tissue reaction
tion, but can significantly decrease knot between the various types of synthetic absorb-
security. able sutures have been studied, and some
Commonly used sutures in veterinary amount of inflammatory reaction is seen with
medicine for spay–neuter procedures include every absorbable suture type, whether mono-
synthetic monofilament absorbable sutures filament or braided (Freeman et al. 1987). Any
such as poliglecaprone 25 (Monocryl®) and of these suture types are acceptable, and most
polydioxanone (PDS® II), synthetic braided surgeons will choose their suture based on
absorbable sutures such as polyglactin 910 handling preferences and duration of tensile
(Coated Vicryl®; all from Ethicon, Inc., Cornelia, strength.
GA, USA), and stainless steel. Synthetic mono- The suture material that has the highest ten-
filament absorbable suture is by far the most sile strength is stainless steel. Stainless steel
commonly used suture type in HQHVSN has excellent knot security and produces no
(White 2018). inflammatory tissue reaction. It is very cost‐
Poliglecaprone 25 (Monocryl) is an absorba- effective, making it an appropriate choice for
ble monofilament suture that is synthetic in situations involving large volumes of daily sur-
origin. Its properties include moderate tensile geries, such as animal shelters or spay–neuter
strength, low tissue drag, low tissue reactivity, clinics (Mackey n.d.). Steel suture may be
and ease of handling. It has high initial tensile steam sterilized without loss of tensile strength,
strength with excellent knot security. This but should not be sterilized on a wooden spool,
suture has rapid loss of tensile strength, with as lignin from the wood may cling to the suture
nearly 75% lost by day 14 after implantation. (Dunn 2005). Stainless steel suture can be used
By day 21, almost all suture tensile strength is on ovarian and uterine pedicles, body wall clo-
lost. Undyed Monocryl loses tensile strength sure (linea alba), and subcutaneous tissue.
about 25% more rapidly than dyed Monocryl Stainless steel is not considered acceptable for
(Dunn 2005). external closure of skin. The major disadvan-
Polydioxanone (PDS II) is an absorbable tage of stainless steel is the difficulty with han-
monofilament suture that is also synthetic in dling and the learning curve required for
origin. Its properties include excellent tensile efficient use. Steel suture will also dull the
strength, low tissue drag, and low tissue reac- blades on suture scissors or Olsen–Hegar nee-
tivity. Polydioxanone maintains the longest dle holders more quickly than other types of
tensile strength of nearly all synthetic absorb- suture (Mackey n.d.). In practice, stainless
able sutures, retaining nearly 75% strength steel suture is not used in the majority of
after 14 days. By 28 days, nearly half of tensile HQHVSN practices, and those veterinarians
strength is maintained. Complete absorption who do use it often use monofilament absorb-
does not occur until close to 180 days after able suture during other portions of the same
suture implantation (Dunn 2005). A disadvan- surgeries in which they use stainless steel
tage of polydioxanone is that it retains memory (White 2018).
58 3 Instrumentation for Spay–Neuter
Nylon and polypropylene are synthetic non- puppies in the 10–20 lb (4.5–9 kg) range, either
absorbable sutures used for external closure of 3‐0 or 2‐0 suture is acceptable.
skin. External skin sutures are not recom- For adult dog spays, suture size preferences
mended for use in HQHVSN practice, and in a vary considerably. Most veterinarians choose
survey of 81 spay–neuter veterinarians, none 3‐0 suture for dogs under 10 lb (4.5 kg), 2‐0 for
used synthetic nonabsorbable sutures (White dogs weighing 10–40 lb (4.5–18 kg), 2‐0 or 0 for
2018). If external closure of skin is desired, it is dogs weighing 40–50 lb (18–22 kg), and 0 for
acceptable to use synthetic absorbable suture dogs over 50 lb (22 kg). Some surgeons select
in the skin (Sylvestre et al. 2002; Parell and size 1 suture, especially in dogs of 70 lb (30 kg)
Becker 2003; Rosenzweig et al. 2010) as an and over (White 2018).
alternative to nonabsorbable suture types.
Suture Sizes for Feline Spay
For kitten spays, 4‐0 or 3‐0 suture is commonly
Suture Size
used and is appropriate. For adult feline spays,
Once the composition type of the suture is most surgeons like to use 3‐0 suture (White
selected, another factor that must be consid- 2018). Some surgeons prefer to use a larger
ered is the size of the suture. Suture size can suture size such as 2‐0 on adult cats, especially
range from 11‐0 to 7, with 11‐0 being the small- for the ligation of the uterine body in cats who
est diameter (Dunn 2005). Tensile strength is are pregnant or in estrus.
directly related to the size of the suture, with
larger suture having greater tensile strength. Suture Sizes for Adult Canine
Suture size is selected based on how much ten- Castration
sile strength is required by the tissue type, For dog neuters, most veterinarians choose 3‐0
using the smallest diameter suture that will suture for dogs under 20 lb (9 kg) and 2‐0
adequately hold the mending tissue (Dunn suture for dogs who are 20–50 lb (9–22 kg). For
2005). The most common suture sizes used in dogs over 50 lb (22 kg), veterinarians may
spay–neuter surgery range from 4‐0 to 1 (White choose 2‐0 or 0 suture. In larger dogs, many
2018), with size 0 or 1 utilized in tissue that veterinarians use a large suture (such as 0) for
needs the greatest tensile strength (linea alba cord ligations, and smaller suture (such as 3‐0)
of a large dog spay). for the subcutaneous and/or subcuticular clo-
It is important to note that stainless steel is sures and for ligation of subcutaneous bleeders
sized differently from other suture types. It is (White 2018).
sized according to gauge, and ranges from 18 Suture material is not typically used for pedi-
gauge to 41 gauge. The two common sizes used atric canine castration or for feline castration.
in spay–neuter for stainless steel are 32 gauge
and 34 gauge (Mackey n.d.).
Suture Packaging
Suture Sizes for Canine Spay Suture material is generally supplied in either
The suture selected for a canine spay can be single‐use packets or multiuse cassettes. Each
utilized on all tissues, thus only requiring one type of packaging is commonly used in
suture size (or pack) per surgery. However, HQHVSN clinics (White 2018).
some surgeons select a smaller suture (such as Suture packets are sterile packages that con-
3‐0) for closure of subcutaneous and subcutic- tain a length of suture, usually between 18 and
ular tissues. 36 cm, attached or “swaged on” to a needle. To
For puppy spays under 10 lb (4.5 kg), most use a suture packet, the outer layer is peeled
veterinarians select 3‐0 suture, and for puppies open and the entire packet is handed sterilely
over 20 lb (9 kg), most select 2‐0 suture. For to the surgeon or dropped sterilely onto the
Needle Selection 59
opened surgery pack. Once the suture with its is already attached to the needle, making it
swaged‐on needle has been used on one unnecessary to thread an eyed needle. Also,
patient, it cannot safely be resterilized for use since suture packets are supplied sterilely for
on a different patient. each surgery, there is less chance that mishan-
Suture cassettes are multiuse suture material dling of the packaging before or between sur-
dispensers that contain either 25 or 50 m of geries could lead to contamination of the
suture material (Figure 3.5). Cassettes are usu- suture. However, suture packets are more
ally placed within a suture cassette rack, which expensive than cassette suture. In addition, the
holds the cassette upright and available for the length of suture provided in each packet may
surgeon’s use. The interior of the cassette be much more than needed for a given surgery,
remains sterile, and the suture material exits and since leftover suture from packets cannot
the cassette through a small opening. In order be reused on a different patient, this excess
to obtain suture, the veterinarian must grasp suture is wasted.
the exposed suture end with an instrument or A major advantage of suture cassettes is that
gloved fingers and pull upward to dispense the they cost less to use than suture packets. This is
desired amount of suture. The veterinarian both because the cost per centimeter of cas-
then cuts the suture near where it exits the cas- sette suture is lower, and because fewer cen-
sette, leaving 1–2 cm of suture exposed. To timeters of suture are typically dispensed for
place sutures using material from a cassette, an each surgery. An additional advantage of using
eyed needle must be used. suture cassettes is that they facilitate using dif-
Suture cassettes come with a cover or cap ferent sizes of sutures for different parts of the
that should be placed over the exposed suture surgery. It is possible to use a large size of
end when not in use. When the cassette is first suture for ligations and body wall closure, and
opened for the day or for the surgical session, a smaller suture for subcuticular and intrader-
the exposed portion of the suture that was in mal closure. The disadvantages of cassettes is
contact with the inside of the cap or cover is no the learning curve for the use of eyed needles
longer sterile. This suture should be “tipped”; and the care that must be taken to maintain
that is, the exposed tip of the suture should be sterility of the contents.
removed and discarded prior to obtaining
suture for surgery.
Each type of packaging has advantages and Needle Selection
disadvantages. The major advantage of suture
packets is that they are convenient. The suture Suture needles are required in surgery to facili-
tate the passage of suture through tissues. The
appropriate selection of needle type provides
easy penetration of tissue with as little trauma
as possible. An ideal needle should be strong,
stable when held with needle holders, and
maintain sharpness of point throughout the
procedure.
point. The characteristics and size of the nee- proportional to an increase in suture size. If a
dles can be located on the packaging of the small suture size is selected, such as 3‐0, an
selected needle or suture. appropriate needle length would also be small
The structure of the needle varies by whether (approximately 26 mm). If a larger suture (2‐0)
suture comes from the manufacturer already were selected, the appropriate needle length
attached at the hub of the needle. When nee- would be larger (approximately 36 mm).
dles are already attached to suture, they are The type of needle point is also important to
termed “swaged‐on” needles; otherwise, they consider during needle selection. The two pri-
are termed plain needles or eyed needles mary needle types characterized by the point
(Dunn 2005). If a plain needle is used, steri- are cutting and noncutting needles. A cutting
lized suture must be threaded through the eye needle is designed with three edges that allow
of the needle in order to suture. the needle to pass easily through dense and
The shape of a needle can either be straight thick tissue. The two major types of cutting
or curved. Straight needles are used when plac- needles are conventional and reverse‐cutting
ing sutures in superficial wounds near the skin needles. Both have edges that form a triangle,
and are not typically used for spay–neuter sur- but they differ by which surface of the needle
gery. Curved needles can be used for closing all contains the cutting edge. The conventional
tissue layers, and are appropriate for suturing cutting needle has a cutting edge along the
tissue in spay–neuter. The most commonly concave (inner) surface, while the reverse‐cut-
used curved needles in spay–neuter are half ting needle has a cutting edge on the convex
circle or a three‐eighths circle needles. (outer) surface. Reverse‐cutting needles are
Measurements of a needle’s size include considered superior to conventional cutting
chord length, diameter, and needle length needles due to the reduced risk of cutting out
(Figure 3.6; Dunn 2005; Smith and Macsai tissue and increased needle strength (Boothe
2007). The chord length is the straight‐line dis- 1993). A noncutting needle is known as a taper
tance measured from the needle point to the or taper‐point needle. This needle is rounded
swage or eye. The diameter of the needle is the in cross‐section and does not have any sharp
thickness or gauge of the needle. The needle edges. The taper needle passes through tissue
length is the distance measured along the nee- by stretching rather than cutting. The sharp-
dle itself from point to end (measured in mil- ness of a taper needle is measured by the taper
limeters). Needle length is the most commonly ratio. A high taper ratio is desired to produce
used measurement for needle selection. optimum sharpness, thus reducing tissue
Increase in needle length should be directly trauma. In spay–neuter a reverse‐cutting needle
Total length
Surgical Packs 61
Figure 3.7 An example of a surgery pack for an Figure 3.8 An example of a surgery pack for a
adult dog spay. This pack contains two Rochester- standard feline spay/pediatric canine spay. This
Carmalt hemostats, four Kelly hemostats, a Mayo pack contains two mosquito hemostats, two Kelly
scissor, an Olsen-Hegar needle holder, a thumb hemostats, a Mayo scissor, an Olsen-Hegar needle
forceps, and a Snook spay hook. holder, a thumb forcep, and a Snook spay hook.
62 3 Instrumentation for Spay–Neuter
References
Freeman, L.J., Pettit, G.D., Robinette, J.D. et al. Rosenzweig, L.B., Abdelmalek, M., Ho, J., and
(1987). Tissue reaction to suture material in the Hruza, G.J. (2010). Equal cosmetic outcomes
feline linea alba: a retrospective, prospective, with 5‐0 poliglecaprone‐25 versus 6‐0
and histologic study. Vet. Surg. 16: 440–445. polypropylene for superficial closures.
Mackey, W.M. (n.d.). Stainless‐steel sutures. Dermatol. Surg. 36: 1126–1129.
QuickSpay. http://quickspay.com/articles. Smith, J.H. and Macsai, M.S. (2007). Needles,
html (accessed 14 March 2019). sutures, and instruments. In: Ophthalmic
Nieves, M.A., Merkley, D.F., and Wagner, S.D. Microsurgical Suturing Techniques (ed. M.S.
(1993). Surgical instruments. In: Textbook of Macsai). Berlin: Springer.
Small Animal Surgery, 2e (ed. D. Slatter). Sylvestre, A., Wilson, J., and Hare, J. (2002). A
Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders. comparison of 2 different suture patterns for
Parell, G.J. and Becker, G.D. (2003). Comparison skin closure of canine ovariohysterectomy.
of absorbable with nonabsorbable sutures in Can. Vet. J. 43: 699–702.
closure of facial skin wounds. Arch. Facial White, S. (2018). Surgery packs and suture in
Plast. Surg. 5: 488–490. HQHVSN. ergovet. http://ergovet.com/
Perry, J., Parker, G., and Jagger, J. (2003). Scalpel surgery‐packs‐and‐suture‐in‐hqhvsn (accessed
blades: reducing injury risk. Adv. Exposure 18 August 2018).
Prev. 6: 37–48.
65
Asepsis
Brian A. DiGangi
… it is from the vitality of the atmospheric the surgical environment, thereby preventing
particles that all the mischief arises …. their entrance into the surgical wound and the
—Lord Joseph Lister associated morbidity. Maintaining asepsis is
considered the standard of care for surgical
sterilization and has a direct impact on patient
Is Asepsis Really a Requirement outcome (Association of Operating Room
for Spay–Neuter Surgery? Nurses 2006; Griffin et al. 2016; Hedlund
2007). In addition, the perceived lack of such
In 1846, Ignaz Phillip Semmelweiss set out to standards is frequently cited as an argument
tackle the 10% mortality rate attributed to sep against shelter animal practice and high‐
sis in the First Obstetrical Clinic of the Vienna quality high‐volume spay–neuter (HQHVSN)
General Hospital. Over the next year, he cor clinics (Becker 2011; Tumblin and Hoekstra
rectly surmised the theory of fomite transfer 2011; Woloshyn 2010). In order to correct these
of disease, instituted a handwashing protocol, misperceptions, advance the field of shelter
and dropped the mortality rate to 1.3% seem medicine, and continue to ensure surgical
ingly overnight (Longo 1995). Around the complication rates lower than those reported
same time in Great Britain, Joseph Lister by general practitioners and tertiary care insti
began his successful experimentation with tutions, HQHVSN surgeons must be especially
topical antiseptics and the preparation of sur strict in their adherence to evidence‐based
gical instruments in the management of aseptic practices.
contaminated wounds and other afflictions In the human medical field, surgical site
requiring surgical intervention (Lister 1867). infections (SSIs) occur in 3% of all surgical pro
With these two medical pioneers leading the cedures and make up 14–22% of all healthcare‐
way, our understanding of disease transmis associated infections (Barie and Eachempati
sion was strengthened, countless lives were 2005). As well as contributing a significant eco
saved, and the field of infection control along nomic burden to healthcare systems, such
with the concept of aseptic technique was infections result in an estimated 9000–20 000
born. deaths each year (Emori and Gaynes 1993;
The goals of aseptic technique are to prevent Klevens et al. 2007). While two‐thirds of
cross‐contamination during surgery and to human SSIs are limited to incisional infec
minimize the amount of microorganisms in tions, the majority of SSI‐related deaths were
66 4 Asepsis
Table 4.1 Reported rates of surgical site infections (SSIs) in dogs and cats.
Operating Separate working unit Single‐purpose unit within Designated area within
room isolated from general main facility multipurpose room; identified
facility traffic with physical and visual barriers
Equipment and supplies
Surgical Separately wrapped Large pack of instruments for Liquid chemical sterilization;
instruments instrument packs for multiple surgeries; individual individual instruments used on a
each procedure; steam, instruments used on a single single patient and reprocessed
gas, or plasma patient; steam, gas, or plasma
sterilization utilized sterilization utilized
Suture Individually packaged Reeled suture, sterilely Individually packaged or reeled
materials suture for each patient acquired for each patient suture; sterile, unused portions
shared between patients
Surgical personnel
Surgical Surgical attire worn
Dedicated surgical attire Surgical attire worn throughout
attire worn by all personnel; throughout the day; jacket/ the day
attire not worn outside lab coat worn outside of
operating room; attire operating room
changed/laundered daily
Caps and masks worn at Caps and masks worn while Caps and masks worn for all
all times within procedures are in progress procedures except for castration
operating room of cats and pediatric puppies
Single‐use, sterile, Single‐use, sterile surgical Sterile gowns not utilized
surgical gowns and gowns worn for all but aseptic technique is
gloves worn by surgeons abdominal procedures; maintained; single‐use sterile
for all operating room single‐use, sterile gloves gloves worn for all procedures
procedures worn for all procedures except cat castrations when
single‐use examination gloves
are worn
Surgeon Surgical scrub or rub Surgical scrub or rub Surgical scrub or rub performed
prep performed prior to each performed prior to a series prior to individual or a series of
procedure and prior to of procedures; sterility is procedures except for closed
entering operating room maintained between castration of cats and pediatric
procedures; new single‐use puppies
sterile gloves are donned
prior to each procedure
Patient preparation
Skin scrub Hair removal and Hair removal and operative Hair removal and operative site
operative site prepared site prepared after anesthetic prepared within operating room
after anesthetic induction in designated area
induction and prior to of operating room
entering operating room
Draping Complete sterile draping Complete sterile draping Complete sterile draping
performed for all performed for all abdominal performed for all abdominal
operating room procedures and castration procedures
procedures of adult dogs; clean barrier
draping performed for
castration of cats and
pediatric puppies
68 4 Asepsis
s urgical procedures, and patient recovery. personnel should be allowed into the operating
Additional areas that may enhance efficiency room and conversation should be kept to a min
and promote infection control include dressing imum (Letts and Doermer 1983). Overall traffic
rooms, supply rooms, an instrument pack flow through the surgical clinic should be
preparation room, and a designated area for thought of as unidirectional and, to promote
donning sterile gowns and gloves. Closed compliance, the facility should be laid out such
doors between clean operating environments that the desired flow pattern is the most direct
and contaminated areas of the facility will aid path for personnel and animals to follow
in infection control and the promotion of asep (Figure 4.1).
tic technique (Fossum 2007a). Although a designated, separate working
When designing a surgical facility, careful unit isolated from general facility traffic is the
attention should be paid to traffic flow patterns ideal arrangement for an operating room envi
to ensure maximum efficiency and minimize ronment (Fossum 2007a), many spay–neuter
opportunities for disease transmission. One programs operate under “field” conditions in
study of SSI risk in dogs and cats demonstrated which this environment must be re‐created in
a 1.3 times greater risk of SSI for each addi a different location on a frequent basis. In such
tional person in the operating room (Eugster conditions, priority should be given to each of
et al. 2004). To minimize this risk, only essential the following points in order to promote
Intake/Discharge
Housing &
physical
examination
Anesthesia &
Recovery surgery
preparation
Operating
room
Surgeon
Dressing room
preparation
Figure 4.1 Traffic flow through the surgical clinic should be unidirectional to minimize opportunities for
contamination of the operating room. Sterile areas are indicated by red lines.
Minimum Requirements for Aseptic Surgery 69
a sepsis and minimize the chances of cross‐ istics of the operating room thought to increase
contamination and the occurrence of SSIs the risk of SSI development include contami
(Fossum 2007a; Mangram et al. 1999): nated medications, inadequate sanitation
practices, and inadequate ventilation (Barie
1) Select an area of sufficient size for neces
and Eachempati 2005); steps to minimize the
sary personnel and equipment.
risks posed by these factors should be addressed
2) Create physical and/or visual barriers to
in standard operating protocols. Sanitation
control and minimize traffic flow
practices that should be completed between
(Figure 4.2).
handling different patients, on a daily basis,
3) Establish a clean, uncluttered environment
and on a weekly basis to maintain a sanitary
(e.g. remove wall posters, discard perisha
operating room environment are presented in
ble items, cover ceiling fans; place a clean
Table 4.3. Specific disinfectants and their
tarpaulin over surfaces that cannot be
proper usage will be discussed in Chapter 5.
removed or cleaned prior to use).
4) Select an area with constant humidity and
temperature and good air flow. Ancillary Equipment
5) Utilize equipment and surfaces that are
Countless pieces of equipment and supplies
amenable to cleaning and disinfection (e.g.
come into contact with spay–neuter patients
smooth, non‐porous) or cover surfaces with
throughout their clinic experience. Each of
clean, disposable drape material.
these items has the potential to harbor patho
The operating room itself represents a gens and transmit disease if not properly
c ommon point for the transfer of infectious sanitized between patients. In fact, biologic
disease agents that is often overlooked in clinic contamination and transmission of both
sanitation protocols. Environmental character bacteria and viruses have been demonstrated
Figure 4.2 During set-up of this field clinic, a curtain has been placed as a highly visible, physical barrier
separating the patient receiving area from the operating environment.
70 4 Asepsis
through needles, syringes, intravenous (IV) that contact intact skin (e.g. electrocardiogram
tubing lines, and laryngoscope blades and han leads, blood pressure cuffs) in between each
dles that have not been thoroughly disinfected use. Items such as endotracheal tubes, some
between uses (Fleming and Ogilvie 1951; breathing circuits, filters, needles, and syringes
Meier 2002; Morell et al. 1994; Roberts 1973; are considered single‐use items to be discarded
Shulan et al. 1985; Trepanier et al. 1990). When after use (Association of Operating Room
contaminated items enter the clean operating Nurses 2005). Many of these single‐use items
room environment, they jeopardize the sur are commonly reused in veterinary medicine;
geon’s ability to maintain surgical asepsis. in these cases following the recommendations
Common items that are overlooked in spay– for sterilization and disinfection based on level
neuter clinic sanitation protocols are presented of patient contact already described seems
in Box 4.1. prudent. Maintaining a large stock supply of
Recommended practices in the human these items for sanitizing once at the end of
healthcare industry call for complete steriliza each day, utilizing disposable covers or single‐
tion of items that come into contact with the use towels to protect equipment surfaces, or
vascular system or sterile body tissue (e.g. IV limiting shared use of items to groups of
catheters, IV tubing), disinfection of items that patients that are normally exposed to one
contact mucous membranes (e.g. laryngoscope another (e.g. animals residing in the same
blades, masks), and thorough cleaning of items household or shelter housing unit) may help
promote good sanitary practices without nega
tively impacting clinic efficiency.
Box 4.1 Commonly Overlooked Surgical
and Anesthetic Equipment to Sanitize
between Patients Surgical Instruments
Perhaps the pieces of equipment with the
●● Pulse oximeters
greatest opportunity to impact asepsis are the
●● Laryngoscopes
surgical instruments themselves. Aseptic
●● Eye lubricant containers
surgery cannot be achieved unless each surgi
●● Ventilation bags
cal instrument that contacts body tissues or
●● Anesthetic circuits
blood is sterile at the time of use (Fossum
●● Clippers
2007b; Griffin et al. 2016). There are three dis
●● Stethoscopes
tinct components to the proper preparation of
●● Thermometers
instruments for use in surgical procedures that
●● Patient positioning devices
warrant discussion: cleaning and decontami
●● Thermoregulatory devices
nation, packaging, and sterilization.
Minimum Requirements for Aseptic Surgery 71
Cleaning and Decontamination
Box 4.2 Manual Cleaning and
Removal of organic contamination (e.g.
Decontamination of Surgical Instruments
blood and mucous) through cleaning and
(Association of Operating Room Nurses
decontamination of reusable surgical instru
2002b; Association of Surgical
ments must be undertaken prior to attempts
Technologists 2009)
at sterilization. In fact, the ability to achieve
sterilization is dependent upon the number, ●● Wipe off visible organic material with a
type, and resistance of microorganisms that clean, moist sponge
are present as well as the presence or absence ●● Flush instrument lumens with water
of biofilms (Association of Operating Room ●● Immerse in a solution of warm water
Nurses 2006). Organic contamination of (80–110 °F) and detergent
items may inactivate or prevent penetration ●● Scrub instruments with purpose-
of chemical germicides as well as increase designed instrument cleaning brush (Do
the bio‐burden of the equipment such that not use scouring pads or abrasive cleaning
sterilization is not possible (Favero and Bond agents)
2001). If allowed to dry on surgical instru ●● Thoroughly rinse instruments with tap
ments, blood, body fluids, and saline can water to remove detergent residue and
result in corrosion, rusting, and pitting, organic material
which can also impede the sterilization pro ●● Rinse instruments with distilled/de-ionized
cess (Association of Operating Room Nurses water to prevent staining
2002b). Cleaning with a detergent and water ●● Place instruments in the unlocked or
is likely the most effective as well as cost‐effi open position on an absorbent, lint-free
cient means of removing organic material towel to dry
(Dvorak et al. 2008; Quinn and Markey 2001).
A pH‐neutral, low‐foaming, free‐rinsing
detergent should be safe for most surgical Packaging
equipment (Association of Operating Room After appropriate cleaning, decontamination,
Nurses 2002b). The use of enzymatic cleaners and drying, surgical instruments must be pack
can aid in the removal of proteins from surgi aged for processing. The choice of packaging
cal instruments and these are often commer system will depend upon the type of item being
cially available in combination products sterilized and the method of sterilization being
containing detergents. If not removed for utilized (Association of Operating Room
decontamination and re‐packaging immedi Nurses 2007a). For most stainless‐steel surgi
ately after use, surgical instruments can be cal instruments utilized in HQHVSN pro
immersed in a detergent–water solution grams, woven cotton muslin (minimum thread
(+/− enzymatic cleaner) until processing count 140), non‐woven SMS (spunlace‐melt
(Association of Operating Room Nurses blown‐spunbonded) materials, woven cotton/
2002b, Association of Surgical Technologists polyester‐blend fabrics, or paper‐plastic peel
2009). However, unless indicated by the man packages will be sufficient (Fossum 2007c).
ufacturer’s instructions, instruments should When reusable woven textiles are used, it is
not be immersed in cleaning solutions for important they be laundered between each
extended periods of time (i.e. longer than use, even if no visible contamination is pre
20 minutes) in order to preserve integrity and sent. In addition to its cleaning effects, laun
extend useful life (Fossum 2007c). Box 4.2 dering serves to rehydrate the material and
describes a recommended step‐by‐step pro prevent superheating during the sterilization
cess for manual cleaning and decontamina process, which can inhibit sterilization
tion of surgical instruments. (Association of Operating Room Nurses
72 4 Asepsis
Sources: Rutala and Weber (2008), Fossum (2007b), Association of Operating Room
Nurses (2006), Sebben (1984), Young (1993).
a
For every 1000 ft of altitude, an additional 0.5 psi above 15 psi (normal atmospheric pressure
at sea level) is needed.
b
Item should be unwrapped and placed in a perforated metal tray; observe 10‐minute
exposure times for porous items or those with lumens.
in the loss of sterilization (Association of use of both chemical and biological process
Operating Room Nurses 2006; Fossum 2007b). indicators. Chemical indicators, in the form of
The sterilizer’s mechanical settings should tape or paper strips, are available for steam,
not be relied upon as the sole means of moni gas, and plasma sterilization (Fossum 2007b).
toring the effectiveness of sterilization proce These devices are commonly placed both
dures. Additional best practices include the inside and outside of each surgical pack and
74 4 Asepsis
Reported effective
Antiseptic Concentration Pros Cons contact times
Sources: World Health Organization (2009), Dvorak et al. (2008), Fossum (2007e), Hsieh et al. (2006), Crabtree et al.
(2001), Heit and Riviere (2001), Paulson (1994), Larson et al. (1990).
Brushing protocols have not demonstrated products designed for hygienic purposes alone.
enhanced antimicrobial effects compared to Program supply coordinators should take care
brushless methods; in fact, in some cases a to match the intended use with the labeled indi
greater reduction in microbial counts and lower cations of the specific product purchased.
operating costs were associated with brushless Surgeons should note that the technique for
protocols (Barbadoro et al. 2014; Hobson et al. application of surgical hand rubs (see Figure 4.3)
1998; Howe et al. 2006; Larson et al. 2001; Loeb is different than that used for traditional scrub
et al. 1997; Mulberry et al. 2001; Park et al. 2006; solutions (Kramer et al. 2002; Widmer et al.
Tanner et al. 2008; Tavolacci et al. 2006; Widmer 2010). In addition, when such products are
et al. 2010). used, hands should be free from visible contam
It is important to note that not all brushless, ination and thoroughly dried. In most cases,
waterless, antiseptic rubs or gels have equiva this will require thorough handwashing with
lent efficacy and that the contact time required non‐medicated soap (WHO 2009).
for surgical antisepsis is generally greater than For the high‐volume surgeon, scrubbing
that for purely hygienic purposes. In addition to prior to each procedure may not be practical or
products intended for surgical antisepsis, possible. In these cases, it is acceptable to
manufacturers often have additional waterless perform a complete surgical scrub at the
76 4 Asepsis
Figure 4.3 World Health Organization surgical handrubbing technique. Reproduced with permission of
the World Health Organization: https://www.who.int/infection-prevention/countries/surgical/
NewSurgicalA3.pdf.
Minimum Requirements for Aseptic Surgery 77
removal is performed to the start of the surgical ypothermia, and reduce cosmesis, while too
h
procedure (Alexander et al. 1983; Seropian and small an area may result in contamination of
Reynolds 1971). To minimize skin trauma in the surgical field (Figure 4.4). Clipped hair
veterinary patients, hair clipping should be per should be removed from the environment with
formed with an electric clipper and a sharp a vacuum (Fossum 2007e). For patients with
number 40 clipper blade in the same direction fine hair or in locations without electricity, use
as the hair growth. In patients with dense hair of a one‐sided adhesive lint roller is also
coats, initially using a coarser blade (e.g. num effective.
ber 10) followed by a number 40 blade may be After thorough hair removal, antiseptic prep
most effective (Fossum 2007e). The size of the aration of the surgical site can begin. It is ideal
clipped area should be proportional to the size to perform a general cleansing scrub prior to
of the patient, the drape fenestration (for pre‐ transporting the patient into the operating
fenestrated drapes), and the anticipated inci room where the sterile skin preparation takes
sion, allowing for expansion of the surgical place (Fossum 2007e). The purpose of this pro
field if necessary. Excess clipping may increase tocol is to ensure that the surgical site does not
the risk of trauma and infection, promote become contaminated during transportation
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 4.4 Patients being prepared for ovariohysterectomy. (a) The clipped area is too small to maintain
aseptic technique. If extension of the incision is necessary, the surgical site will become contaminated.
(b) The clipped area is too wide for this patient and will promote hypothermia. In addition, the clipped area
extends over the borders of the rib cage – it is unlikely that any complications encountered during
ovariohysterectomy will require the surgeon to perform a thoracotomy. (c) This patient is clipped
appropriately for its size and the anticipated surgical procedure. The clipped area extends from the xiphoid
to the pubis and follows the borders of the rib cage laterally. *, xiphoid; ], pubis; ---, borders of rib cage.
Minimum Requirements for Aseptic Surgery 79
and positioning of the patient on the operating 2005; Hibbard et al. 2002). Multiple protocols
table. Application of an antiseptic‐soaked for the application of antiseptics have proven
gauze sponge to the anticipated incision site effective (e.g. alternating antiseptic scrub with
and use of a specific handling technique for alcohol or saline rinse, antiseptic scrub followed
small patients may help in protecting the pre by sprays or paints, antiseptic spray alone, wip
pared surgical site (Figure 4.5). Should there be ing skin dry after scrubbing, leaving skin to air
any question of contamination after position dry, etc.; Geelhoed et al. 1983; Kutarski and
ing the patient on the operating table, the ster Grundy 1993; Moen et al. 2002; Osuna et al.
ile scrub should be repeated. Alternatively, 1990; Shirahatti et al. 1993). Perhaps more
both hair removal and antiseptic preparation important than the antiseptic chosen or the
can be performed in one location, as long as application protocol are the provisions that the
precautions are taken not to contaminate the skin surface is clean prior to beginning the sur
surgical site or operating environment. gical scrub, that the appropriate contact time for
Antiseptic agents useful in preparing the the chosen antiseptic is observed, and that
surgical site are similar to those described for application of the agent does not result in recon
surgeon preparation (Table 4.5). Phenolic tamination of the surgical site (Association of
compounds (e.g. hexachlorophene, para‐chloro‐ Operating Room Nurses 2002a). Figure 4.6
meta‐xylenol or PCMX, triclosan) and quater describes the appropriate technique for manual
nary ammonium salts should not be used, as application of pre‐operative antiseptic solutions.
they are associated with significant toxicities in
animals and safe, effective alternatives are read
ily available (Dvorak et al. 2008; Fossum 2007e;
Heit and Riviere 2001; Merianos 2001). Many
commercially available patient preparation
solutions contain one or more additional 4
antiseptics that have been shown to enhance
antimicrobial efficacy or persistence (Hibbard 7
8
1
3
5
2
6
Once the scrub of the surgical site is com (Ford and Crowther 1922; Gawande 2009;
plete, it should be allowed to dry thoroughly McDonald’s 2013). For surgery in particular,
prior to draping (Fossum 2007e). Although wet the relationship between the performance of a
drape material has been shown to enhance high volume of procedures and low rates of
bacterial strike‐through, the effectiveness of surgical complications has long been scientifi
barrier drapes in protecting the patient against cally established (Birkmeyer et al. 2013;
SSI is the subject of debate in human surgical Donabedian 1984; Flood et al. 1984, 1984b;
care (Belkin 2002; Blom et al. 2002; Hadiati Luft 1980). Some critical components of reduc
et al. 2012; Mangram et al. 1999). Their role in ing SSIs and other surgical complications in
veterinary surgery, however, seems more both humans and animals include taking steps
obvious given the relatively high risk of hair to reduce both total anesthetic time and surgi
or fecal contamination of the surgical site cal procedure time, ensuring adequate host
(Looney et al. 2008). Patient draping is gener immune defense, maintaining normothermia,
ally accomplished in two layers: placement of ensuring euglycemia, providing supplemental
field drapes or towels to cover contaminated oxygen during and shortly after surgery, and
areas outside of the prepared surgical field, fol providing adequate analgesia (Brodbelt et al.
lowed by placement of a fenestrated drape to 2008; Brown et al. 1997; Brunn 1970; Burrow
isolate the anticipated incision site (Fossum et al. 2005; Cruse and Foord 1973; Eugster
2007e). While a number of human and veteri et al. 2004; Nicholson et al. 2002; Sessler 2006;
nary studies have demonstrated no reduction Velasco et al. 1996). By its very nature,
in SSI with the use of adhesive incise drapes in HQHVSN necessitates the integration of such
combination with barrier drapes, the true practices which also promote positive out
impact of the traditional two‐layer draping comes. Sections Two and Three will discuss
technique in preventing SSI is unknown specific anesthetic and surgical techniques to
(Owen et al. 2009; Webster and Alghamdi help the HQHVSN surgeon achieve these goals.
2007). It is common in HQHVSN programs to
utilize a single fenestrated drape to isolate the
incision site. As long as reasonable precautions
Frequently Asked Questions
are taken to keep drape material dry and to
remain conscious of the limits of the sterile
Can Masking Tape Be Used to Secure
field, there is no evidence that this technique
Paper-Plastic Instrument Pouches?
results in increased risk of SSI. If drapes are
not pre‐fenestrated, creating a fenestration Masking tape is commonly used as an inexpen
prior to applying the drape material to the sive alternative to sealing paper‐plastic instru
patient may help prevent contamination of ment pouches with sterilization indicator tape.
sterile surgical scissors by the patient’s skin. This is not a reliable method of ensuring an
airtight seal that will not be compromised
throughout the sterilization process. Masking
How Do you Maintain Asepsis tape adhesive will melt around 150 °F (much
while Increasing Efficiency lower than the temperatures achieved during
of HQHVSN Programs? steam sterilization), while the adhesive found
in indicator tape contains a polyacrylate that
In healthcare, as in many other industries, maintains its adhesive properties up to 300 °F.
ensuring a high‐quality outcome goes hand in Melted adhesive can result in disruption of the
hand with improvements in efficiency, stream seal and/or opening of the package during
lined operational practices, and the use of the sterilization process (Fisher Scientific,
individuals with highly specialized skill sets personal communication, February 8, 2013).
Frequently Asked Questions 81
References
Alexander, J.W., Fischer, J.E., Boyajian, M. et al. caring for surgical instruments and powered
(1983). The influence of hair‐removal methods equipment. AORN J. 75 (3): 627–638.
on wound infections. Arch. Surg. 118 (3): 347–352. Association of Operating Room Nurses (2004).
Amass, S.F., Vyverberg, B.D., Ragland, D. et al. Recommended practices for surgical hand:
(2000). Evaluating the efficacy of boot baths in antisepsis/hand scrubs. AORN J. 79 (2):
biosecurity protocols. J. Swine Health Prod. 8 416–431.
(4): 169–173. Association of Operating Room Nurses (2005).
Association of Operating Room Nurses (2002a). Recommended practices for cleaning,
Recommended practices for skin preparation handling, and processing anesthesia
of patients. AORN J. 75 (1): 184–187. equipment. AORN J. 81 (4): 856–870.
Association of Operating Room Nurses (2002b). Association of Operating Room Nurses (2006).
Recommended practices for cleaning and Recommended practices for sterilization in
www.ajlobby.com
References 83
the perioperative practice setting. AORN J. 83 Belák, S., Karlsson, O.E., Blomström, A.L. et al.
(3): 700–722. (2013). New viruses in veterinary medicine,
Association of Operating Room Nurses (2006b). detected by metagenomic approaches. Vet.
Recommended practices for maintaining a Microbiol. 165 (1–2): 95–101.
sterile field. AORN J. 83 (2): 402–416. Belkin, N.L. (2002). Barrier surgical gowns and
Association of Operating Room Nurses (2007a). drapes: just how necessary are they? Text.
Recommended practices for selection and use Rent. 1: 66–73.
of packaging systems for sterilization. AORN Benedict, K.M., Morley, P.S., and Van Metre,
J. 85 (4): 801–812. D.C. (2012). Characteristics of biosecurity and
Association of Operating Room Nurses (2007b). infection control programs at veterinary
Using peel packages inside containers or teaching hospitals. JAVMA 233 (5): 767–773.
wrapped instrument trays. AORN J. 86 (3): Birkmeyer, J.D., Finks, J.F., O’Reilly, A. et al.
461–462. (2013). Surgical skill and complication rates
Association of Surgical Technologists (2008). after bariatric surgery. N. Eng. J. Med. 369:
AST recommended standards of practice for 1434–1442.
surgical drapes. http://www.ast.org/pdf/ Bischofberger, A.S., Brauer, T., Gugelchuk, G.
Standards_of_Practice/RSOP_Surgical_ et al. (2010). Difference in incisional
Drapes.pdf (accessed 17 February 2013). complications following exploratory
Association of Surgical Technologists (2009). celiotomies using antibacterial‐coated suture
Recommended standards of practice for the material for subcutaneous closure: prospective
decontamination of surgical instruments. randomised study in 100 horses. Equine Vet. J.
http://www.ast.org/pdf/Standards_of_ 42 (4): 304–309.
Practice/RSOP_Decontamination_%20 Block, S.S. (2001). Peroxygen compounds. In:
Surgical%20Instruments_.pdf (accessed 8 Disinfection, Sterilization, and Preservation, 5e
February 2013). (ed. S.S. Block), 185–204. Philadelphia, PA:
Ayliffe, G.A., Collins, B.J., Lowbury, E.J. et al. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
(1967). Ward floors and other surfaces as Blom, A.W., Gozzard, C., Heal, J. et al. (2002).
reservoirs of hospital infection. J. Hyg. 65 (4): Bacterial strike‐through of re‐usable surgical
515–536. drapes: the effect of different wetting agents.
Baines, S. (1996). Surgical asepsis: principles and J. Hosp. Infect. 52 (1): 52–55.
protocols. In Pract 18: 23–33. Brodbelt, D.C., Pfeiffer, D.U., Young, L.E. et al.
Barbadoro, P., Martini, E., Savini, S. et al. (2014). (2008). Results of the confidential enquiry
In vivo comparative efficacy of three surgical into perioperative small animal fatalities
hand preparation agents in reducing bacterial regarding risk factors for anesthetic‐related
count. J. Hosp. Disinfect. 86: 64–67. death in dogs. JAVMA 233 (7): 1096–1104.
Barie, P.S. and Eachempati, S.R. (2005). Surgical Brown, D.C., Conzemius, M.G., Shofer, F. et al.
site infections. Surg. Clin. N. Am. 85 (6): (1997). Epidemiologic evaluation of
1115–1135. postoperative wound infections in dogs and
Beauchamp, R.O., St. Clair, M.B., Fennell, T.R. cats. JAVMA 210 (9): 1302–1306.
et al. (1992). A critical review of the toxicology Brunn, J. (1970). Post‐operative wound infection.
of glutaraldehyde. Crit. Rev. Toxicol. 22 (3–4): Predisposing factors and the effect of a
143–174. reduction in the dissemination of
Becker, M. (2011). Should veterinarians offer staphylococci. Acta Medica Scandinavica
spays below cost? http://www.vetstreet.com/ S514: 1–89.
dr‐marty‐becker/should‐veterinarians‐offer‐ Burrow, R., Batchelor, D., and Cripps, P. (2005).
spays‐below‐cost?WT.mc_id=mbfacebook%3 Complications observed during and after
Bcostofspaying (accessed 8 February 2013). ovariohysterectomy of 142 bitches at a
www.ajlobby.com
84 4 Asepsis
veterinary teaching hospital. Vet. Rec. 157: autoclave. Expanded Program on Immunization
829–833. in the Americas Newsletter 6 (6): 5–8.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Favero, M.S. and Bond, W.W. (2001). Chemical
(2010). HIV transmission. http://www.cdc. disinfection of medical and surgical materials.
gov/hiv/resources/qa/transmission.htm In: Disinfection, Sterilization, and Preservation,
(accessed 17 February 2013). 5e (ed. S.S. Block), 881–917. Philadelphia, PA:
Character, B.J., McLaughlin, R.M., Hedlund, C.S. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
et al. (2003). Postoperative integrity of Fleming, A. and Ogilvie, A.C. (1951). Syringe
veterinary surgical gloves. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. needles and mass inoculation technique. BMJ
Assoc. 39 (3): 311–320. 1 (4706): 543–546.
Crabtree, T.D., Pelletier, S.J., and Pruett, T.L. Flood, A.B., Scott, W.R., and Ewy, W. (1984).
(2001). Surgical antisepsis. In: Disinfection, Does practice make perfect? Part I: the
Sterilization, and Preservation, 5e (ed. S.S. relation between hospital volume and
Block), 919–934. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott outcomes for selected diagnostic categories.
Williams & Wilkins. Med. Care 22 (2): 98–114.
Cruse, P.J. and Foord, R. (1973). A five‐year Flood, A.B., Scott, W.R., and Ewy, W. (1984b).
prospective study of 23,649 surgical wounds. Does practice make perfect? Part II: the
Arch. Surg. 107 (2): 206–210. relation between volume and outcomes and
Donabedian, A. (1984). Volume, quality, and the other hospital characteristics. Med. Care 22
regionalization of health care services. Med. (2): 115–125.
Care 22 (2): 95–97. Foley, P.L., Henderson, A.L., Bissonette, E.A.
Dvorak, G., Petersen, C.A., Rovid Spickler, A. et al. (2001). Evaluation of fentanyl
et al. (2008). Disinfection 101. In: Maddie’s transdermal patches in rabbits: blood
Infection Control Manual for Animal Shelters concentrations and physiologic response.
(eds. C.A. Petersen, G. Dvorak and A. Rovid Comparative Med. 51 (3): 239–244.
Spickler), 42–65. Ames, IA: Center for Food Ford, H. and Crowther, S. (1922). My Life and
Security and Public Health, Iowa State Work. Garden City, NY: Garden City
University, College of Veterinary Medicine. Publishing.
Edmiston, C.E., Seabrook, G.R., Goheen, M.P. Ford, H.R., Jones, P., Gaines, V. et al. (2005).
et al. (2006). Bacterial adherence to surgical Intraoperative handling and wound healing:
sutures: can antibacterial‐coated sutures controlled clinical trial comparing coated
reduce the risk of microbial contamination? VICRYL plus antibacterial suture (coated
J. Am. Coll. Surg. 203 (4): 481–489. polyglactin 910 suture with triclosan) with
Emori, T.G. and Gaynes, R.P. (1993). An coated VICRYL suture (coated polyglactin 910
overview of nosocomial infections. Clin. suture). Surg. Infect. 6 (3): 313–321.
Microbiol. Rev. 6 (4): 428–442. Fossum, T.W. (2007a). Surgical facilities,
Etter, S.W., Ragetly, G.R., Bennett, R.A. et al. equipment, and personnel. In: Small Animal
(2013). Effect of using triclosan‐impregnated Surgery, 3e (ed. T.W. Fossum), 15–18. St.
suture for incisional closure on surgical site Louis, MO: Mosby Elsevier.
infection and inflammation following tibial Fossum, T.W. (2007b). Sterilization and
plateau leveling osteotomy in dogs. JAVMA disinfection. In: Small Animal Surgery, 3e (ed.
242 (3): 355–358. T.W. Fossum), 9–14. St. Louis, MO: Mosby
Eugster, S., Schawalder, P., Gaschen, F. et al. Elsevier.
(2004). A prospective study of postoperative Fossum, T.W. (2007c). Principles of surgical
surgical site infections in dogs and cats. Vet. asepsis. In: Small Animal Surgery, 3e (ed. T.W.
Surg. 33: 542–550. Fossum), 1–8. St. Louis, MO: Mosby Elsevier.
Expanded Program on Immunization in the Fossum, T.W. (2007d). Preparation of the
Americas (1984). Using a pressure cooker as an surgical team. In: Small Animal Surgery,
www.ajlobby.com
References 85
3e (ed. T.W. Fossum), 38–45. St. Louis, MO: Hobson, D.W., Woller, W., Anderson, L. et al.
Mosby Elsevier. (1998). Development and evaluation of a new
Fossum, T.W. (2007e). Preparation of the alcohol‐based surgical hand scrub formulation
operative site. In: Small Animal Surgery, with persistent antimicrobial characteristics
3e (ed. T.W. Fossum), 32–37. St. Louis, MO: and brushless application. Am. J. Infect. Cont.
Mosby Elsevier. 26 (5): 507–512.
Frobisher, M. (1939). Disinfection in the home. Howe, L.M., Halvorson, K.T., Simpson, R.B.
Am. J. Nurs. 39 (1): 833–839. et al. (2006). Waterless, scrubless, alcohol‐
Gawande, A. (2009). The Checklist Manifesto. based surgical scrub agent compared to
New York: Metropolitan Books. traditional surgical scrub using chlorhexidine.
Geelhoed, G.W., Sharpe, K., and Simon, G.L. Am. J. Infect. Cont. 34 (5): 112–113.
(1983). A comparative study of surgical skin Hsieh, H., Chiu, H., and Lee, F. (2006). Surgical
preparation methods. Surg. Gynecol. Obstet. hand scrubs in relation to microbial counts:
157 (3): 265–268. systematic literature review. J. Adv. Nurs. 55
Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al. (1): 68–78.
(2016). The Association of Shelter Humphreys, H., Marshall, R.J., Ricketts, V.E.
Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical care et al. (1991). Theatre over‐shoes do not reduce
guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. JAVMA operating theatre floor bacterial counts.
249 (2): 165–188. J. Hosp. Infect. 17 (2): 117–123.
Hadiati, D.R., Hakimi, M., and Nurdiati, D.S. Isaza, N. and DiGangi, B.A. (2012). Cultivating
(2012). Skin preparation for preventing compassion: University of Florida Merial
infection following caesarean section. shelter animal medicine clerkship. 2012
Cochrane Database Syst. Rev., Sep 12 (9): Maddie’s Shelter Medicine Conference,
CD007462. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858. University of Florida, Gainesville.
CD007462.pub2. Jatzwauk, L., Schone, H., and Pietsch, H. (2001).
Heal, J.S., Blom, A.W., Titcomb, D. et al. (2003). How to improve instrument disinfection by
Bacterial contamination of surgical gloves by ultrasound. J. Hosp. Infect. 48: S80–S83.
water droplets spilt after scrubbing. J. Hosp. Johnson, J.A. (2002). Nosocomial infections. Vet.
Infect. 53 (2): 136–139. Clin. N. Am. Small 32: 1101–1126.
Hedlund, C.S. (2007). Surgery of the Justinger, C., Moussavian, M.R., Schlueter, C.
reproductive and genital systems. In: Small et al. (2009). Antibacterial [corrected] coating
Animal Surgery, 3e (ed. T.W. Fossum), of abdominal closure sutures and wound
702–774. St. Louis, MO: Mosby Elsevier. infection. Surgery 145 (3): 330–334.
Heit, M.C. and Riviere, J.E. (2001). Kikuchi‐Numagami, K., Saishu, T., Fukaya, M.
Chemotherapy of microbial diseases. In: et al. (1999). Irritancy of scrubbing up for
Veterinary Pharmacology and Therapeutics, surgery with or without a brush. Acta Derm.
8e (eds. J.E. Riviere and M.G. Papich), Venereol. 79 (3): 230–232.
783–795. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley‐Blackwell. Klevens, R., Edwards, J., Richards, C.L. et al.
Hibbard, J.S. (2005). Analyses comparing the (2007). Estimating health care‐associated
antimicrobial activity and safety of current infections and deaths in U.S. hospitals, 2002.
antiseptic agents: a review. J. Infus. Nurs. 28 Public Health Rep. 122 (2): 160–166.
(3): 194–207. Kramer, A., Rudolph, P., Kampf, G. et al. (2002).
Hibbard, J.S., Mulberry, G.K., and Brady, A.R. Limited efficacy of alcohol‐based hand gels.
(2002). A clinical study comparing the skin Lancet 359 (9316): 1489–1490.
antisepsis and safety of ChloraPrep, 70% Kreisler, R.E., Shaver, S.L., and Holmes, J.H.
isopropyl alcohol, and 2% aqueous (2018). Outcomes of elective gonadectomy
chlorhexidine. J. Infus. Nurs. 25 (4): procedures performed on dogs and cats by
244–249. veterinary students and shelter veterinarians
www.ajlobby.com
86 4 Asepsis
in a shelter environment. JAVMA 253: Mayhew, P.D., Freeman, L., Kwan, T. et al.
1294–1299. (2012). Comparison of surgical site infection
Kutarski, P.W. and Grundy, H.C. (1993). To dry rates in clean and clean‐contaminated wound
or not to dry? An assessment of the possible in dogs and cats after minimally invasive
degradation in efficiency of preoperative skin versus open surgery: 179 cases (2007–2008).
preparation caused by wiping skin dry. Ann. JAVMA 240 (2): 193–198.
R. Coll. Surg. Engl. 75 (3): 181–185. McAuley, T. (2009). Specifications for
Larson, E.L., Aiello, A.E., Heilman, J.M. et al. temperature and humidity in sterile storage
(2001). Comparison of different regimens for environments – Where’s the evidence?
surgical hand preparation. AORN J. 73 (2): Healthcare Infect. 14: 131–137.
412–420. McDonald’s (2013). The Ray Kroc story. http://
Larson, E.L., Butz, A.M., Gullette, D.L. et al. www.mcdonalds.com/us/en/our_story/
(1990). Alcohol for surgical scrubbing? Infect. our_history/the_ray_kroc_story.html
Contr. Hosp. Epidemiol. 11 (3): 139–143. (accessed 16 February 2013).
Lee, C.H., Montville, T.J., and Sinskey, A.J. Meier, B. (2002). Reuse of needle at hospital
(1979). Comparison of the efficacy of steam infects 50 with hepatitis C. New York Times
sterilization indicators. Appl. Environ. (10 October), p. 22. http://www.nytimes.
Microbiol. 37 (6): 1113–1137. com/2002/10/10/us/reuse‐of‐needle‐at‐
Letts, R.M. and Doermer, E. (1983). hospital‐infects‐50‐with‐hepatitis‐c.html
Conversation in the operating theatre as a (accessed 8 February 2013).
cause of airborne bacterial contamination. Merianos, J.J. (2001). Surface‐active agents. In:
J. Bone Joint Surg. Am. 65 (3): 357–362. Disinfection, Sterilization, and Preservation,
Lister, J. (1867). On the antiseptic principle in 5e (ed. S.S. Block), 283–320. Philadelphia, PA:
the practice of surgery. BMJ 8: 246–248. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
Loeb, M.B., Wilcox, L., Smaill, F. et al. (1997). Miller, J.J., Powell, G.M., Olavesen, A.H. et al.
A randomized trial of surgical scrubbing with (1973). The metabolism and toxicity of
a brush compared to antiseptic soap alone. phenols in cats. 540th Meeting of the
Am. J. Infect. Cont. 25 (1): 11–15. Biochemical Society University of Oxford 10
Longo, L.D. (1995). Classic pages in obstetrics and 11, pp. 1163–165.
and gynecology. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 172 Ming, X., Nichols, M., and Rothenburger, S.
(1): 236–237. (2007). In vivo antibacterial efficacy of
Looney, A., Bohling, M., Bushby, P. et al. (2008). MONOCRYL plus antibacterial suture
The Association of Shelter Veterinarians (Poliglecaprone 25 with triclosan). Surg. Infect.
veterinary medical care guidelines for spay‐ 8 (2): 209–214.
neuter programs. JAVMA 233 (1): 74–86. Misteli, H., Weber, W.P., Reck, S. et al. (2009).
Luft, H.S. (1980). The relation between surgical Surgical glove perforation and the risk of
volume and mortality: an exploration of surgical site infection. Arch. Surg. 144 (6):
causal factors and alternative models. Med. 553–558.
Care 18 (9): 940–959. Moen, M.D., Noone, M.B., and Kirson, I. (2002).
Mangram, A.J., Horan, T.C., Pearson, M.L. et al. Povidone‐iodine spray technique versus
(1999). Guideline for prevention of surgical traditional scrub‐paint technique for
site infection, 1999. Infect. Cont. Hosp. preoperative abdominal wall preparation. Am.
Epidemiol. 20 (4): 250–280. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 187 (6): 1436–1437.
Marco, F., Vallez, R., Gonzalez, P. et al. (2007). Morell, R.C., Ririe, D., James, R.L. et al. (1994).
Study of the efficacy of coated Vicryl plus A survey of laryngoscope contamination at a
antibacterial suture in an animal model of university and a community hospital.
orthopedic surgery. Surg. Infect. 8 (3): 359–365. Anesthesiology 80 (94): 960.
www.ajlobby.com
References 87
Morinaga, T., Hasegawa, G., Koyama, S. et al. rates: a randomized equivalence study. JAMA
(2010). Acute inflammation and 288 (6): 722–727.
immunoresponses induced by ortho‐ Park, E.S., Jang, S.Y., and Kim, J.M. (2006).
phthalaldehyde in mice. Arch. Toxicol. 84 (5): Comparison of a waterless, scrubless CHG/
397–404. ethanol surgical scrub to povidone‐iodine
Mulberry, G., Snyder, A.T., Heilman, J. et al. surgical scrubs. Am. J. Infect. Cont. 34 (5):
(2001). Evaluation of a waterless, scrubless 30–31.
chlorhexidine gluconate/ethanol surgical Paulson, D. (1994). Comparative evaluation of
scrub for antimicrobial efficacy. Am. J. Infect. five surgical hand scrub preparations. AORN J.
Cont. 29 (6): 277–382. 60 (2): 249–256.
Mulcahy, D.M. (2003). Surgical implantation of Quinn, P.J. and Markey, B.K. (2001). Disinfection
transmitters into fish. Inst. Lab. Anim. Res. J. and disease prevention in veterinary
44 (4): 295–306. medicine. In: Disinfection, Sterilization, and
Muqbil, I., Burke, F.J., Miller, C.H. et al. (2005). Preservation, 5e (ed. S.S. Block), 1069–1103.
Antimicrobial activity of ultrasonic cleaners. J. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams &
Hosp. Infect. 60 (3): 249–255. Wilkins.
Nakamura, T., Kashimura, N., Noji, T. et al. Renberg, W.C. (2012). Sterilization. In:
(2013). Triclosan‐coated sutures reduce the Veterinary Surgery Small Animal (eds. K.M.
incidence of wound infections and the costs Tobias and S.A. Johnston), 147–151. St. Louis,
after colorectal surgery: a randomized MO: Elsevier Saunders.
controlled trial. Surgery 153 (4): 576–583. Reuss‐Lamky, H. (2012). Beating the bugs:
Nicholson, M., Beal, M., Shofer, F. et al. (2002). sterilization is instrumental. AAHA Denver
Epidemiologic evaluation of postoperative 2012 Yearly Conference Proceedings.
wound infection in clean‐contaminated Roberts, R.B. (1973). Cleaning the laryngoscope
wounds: a retrospective study of 239 dogs and blade. Can. J. Anaesth. 20 (2): 241–244.
cats. Vet. Surg. 31: 577–581. Rutala, W.A., Weber, D.J., and Healthcare
Nishioka, S. and Gyorkos, T.W. (2001). Tattoos as Infection Control Practices Advisory
risk factors for transfusion‐transmitted Committee (2008). Guideline for disinfection
diseases. Int. J. Infect. Dis. 5 (1): 27–34. and sterilization in healthcare facilities.
Noorani, A., Rabey, N., Walsh, S.R. et al. (2010). http://www.cdc.gov/hicpac/pdf/guidelines/
Systematic review and meta‐analysis of disinfection_nov_2008.pdf (accessed 8
preoperative antisepsis with chlorhexidine February 2013).
versus povidone‐iodine in clean‐contaminated Sebben, J.E. (1984). Sterilization and care of
surgery. Brit. J. Surg. 97 (11): 1614–1620. surgical instruments and supplies. J. Am.
Osuna, D.J., DeYoung, D.J., and Walker, R.L. Acad. Dermatol. 11 (3): 381–392.
(1990). Comparison of three skin preparation Seropian, R. and Reynolds, B.M. (1971). Wound
techniques. Part 2: clinical trial in 100 dogs. infections after preoperative depilatory versus
Vet. Surg. 19 (1): 20–23. razor preparation. Am. J. Surg. 121 (3): 251–254.
Owen, L.J., Gines, J.A., Knowles, T.G. et al. Sessler, D.L. (2006). Non‐pharmacologic
(2009). Efficacy of adhesive incise drapes in prevention of surgical wound infection.
preventing bacterial contamination of clean Anesthesiol. Clin. 24 (2): 279–297.
canine surgical wounds. Vet. Surg. 38 (6): Shirahatti, R.G., Hoshi, R.M., Vishwanath, Y.K.
732–737. et al. (1993). Effect of pre‐operative skin
Parienti, J.J., Thibon, P., Heller, R. et al. (2002). preparation on post‐operative wound
Hand‐rubbing with an aqueous alcoholic infection. J. Postgrad. Med. 39 (3): 134–136.
solution vs traditional surgical hand‐ Shulan, D.J., Weiler, J.M., Koontz, F. et al. (1985).
scrubbing and 30‐day surgical site infection Contamination of intradermal skin test
www.ajlobby.com
88 4 Asepsis
syringes. J. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 76 (2): Velasco, E., Thuler, L.C., Martins, C.A. et al.
226–227. (1996). Risk factors for infectious complications
Stockton, K.A., Morley, P.S., Hyatt, D.R. et al. after abdominal surgery for malignant disease.
(2006). Evaluation of the effects of footwear Am. J. Infect. Cont. 24 (1): 1–6.
hygiene protocols on nonspecific bacterial Wang, Z.X., Jiang, C.P., Cao, Y. et al. (2013).
contamination of floor surfaces in an equine Systematic review and meta‐analysis of
hospital. JAVMA 228 (7): 1068–1073. triclosan‐coated sutures for the prevention of
Storch, M.L., Rothenburger, S.J., and Jacinto, G. surgical site infection. Brit. J. Surg. 100 (4):
(2004). Experimental efficacy study of coated 465–473.
VICRYL plus antibacterial suture in guinea Webster, J. and Alghamdi, A.A. (2007). Use of
pigs challenged with Staphylococcus aureus. plastic adhesive drapes during surgery for
Surg. Infect. 5 (3): 281–288. preventing surgical site infection. Cochrane
Sun, D.X., Zhang, F.G., Geng, Y.Q. et al. (1996). Database Syst. Rev., Oct 17 (4): CD006353.
Hepatitis C transmission by cosmetic tattooing Weightman, N.C. and Banfield, K.R. (1994).
in women. Lancet 347 (9000): 541. Protective over‐shoes are unnecessary in a day
Tanner, J., Swarbrook, S., Stuart, J. et al. (2008). surgery unit. J. Hosp. Infect. 28 (1): 1–3.
Surgical hand antisepsis to reduce surgical site Weiland, L., Croubels, S., Baert, K. et al. (2006).
infection. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 1: 1, Pharmacokinetics of a lidocaine patch 5% in
CD004288–49. https://doi. dogs. J. Vet. Med. 53 (1): 34–39.
org/10.1002/14651858. Widmer, A.F., Rotter, M., Voss, A. et al. (2010).
Tavolacci, M.P., Pitrou, I., Merle, V. et al. (2006). Surgical hand preparation: state‐of‐the‐art.
Surgical hand rubbing compared with surgical J. Hosp. Infect. 74: 112–122.
hand scrubbing: comparison of efficacy and Woloshyn, C. (2010). Cheap spays, neuters won’t
costs. J. Hosp. Infect. 63 (1): 55–59. fix the animal overpopulation. Veterinary
Trepanier, C.A., Lessard, M.R., Brochu, J.G. et al. Economics (15 November). http://
(1990). Risk of cross‐infection related to the veterinarybusiness.dvm360.com/vetec/
multiple use of disposable syringes. Can. J. Veterinary+business/Cheap‐spays‐neuters‐
Anaesth. 37 (2): 156–159. wont‐fix‐the‐animal‐overpopula/
Tumblin, D. and Hoekstra, H. (2011). How to ArticleStandard/Article/detail/693827
compete with spay‐neuter clinics. dvm360, (accessed 8 February 2013).
Jan. 1. http://veterinarybusiness.dvm360.com/ World Health Organization (2009). WHO
how‐compete‐with‐spay‐neuter‐clinics Guidelines on Hand Hygiene in Healthcare.
(accessed 21 August 2019). Geneva: World Health Organization.
Vasseur, P.B., Levy, J.K., Dowd, E. et al. (1988). Young, J.H. (1993). Sterilization with steam
Surgical wound infection rates in dogs and under pressure. In: Sterilization Technology
cats. Data from a teaching hospital. Vet. Surg. (eds. R.F. Morrissey and G. Briggs Phillips),
17 (2): 60–64. 120–151. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold.
www.ajlobby.com
89
The importance of adequate infection control hosts and locations. Infectious disease trans-
in veterinary hospitals cannot be overstated, mission can occur via direct contact, fomites,
and it may be even more important in spay– aerosols, and oral and vector‐borne routes
neuter facilities where there are a high number (Stull et al. 2018). Sanitation protocols, hygiene
of animals belonging to different owners, shel- while handling animals, and traffic flow
ters, or rescue groups admitted to the facility through the facility are all important factors in
daily. Animals may come from different geo- preventing disease transmission, as is the isola-
graphic regions; may have received little or no tion of all sick animals from apparently healthy
veterinary care, including vaccinations, prior ones and separation of animals by source, age,
to presenting to the clinic; and may be juvenile and vaccination status (Peterson et al. 2008;
or with an altered immune status that may Newbury et al. 2010; Miller and Zawistowski
make them more susceptible to disease. Some 2013).
of the animals will have owners, while others This chapter will provide an overview of best
will come from animal shelters or rescue practices regarding sanitation, hygiene in
groups. Some of the animals may be clinically animal handling, vaccination, and prevention
ill, while others may be sub‐clinically infected of infectious disease outbreaks in a spay–
with an infectious disease and also be conta- neuter clinic setting. In addition, the routine
gious to other animals in the facility. It is espe- use of antibiotics for animals undergoing elec-
cially important in this setting that strict tive spay–neuter procedures will be discussed.
sanitation guidelines are in place, and, if pos-
sible, requirements for vaccination prior to
elective surgery. Many diseases can be pre- Hygiene
vented by vaccination, and young puppies and
kittens are particularly vulnerable in these set- Animal housing protocols, animal handling,
tings due to their immature immune systems and employee hygiene are of particular
and probable maternal antibody interference concern in the prevention of infectious disease
to vaccination. in high‐quality high‐volume spay–neuter
There are many ways to decrease the risk of (HQHVSN) clinic settings. With the potential
exposure to diseases in animal hospitals and to have many unrelated animals from differing
shelters. Infectious disease control and preven- geographic areas in a relatively small space,
tion depend on interrupting the transmission there is an increased risk of disease spread if
of pathogens from the infected animal to new strict animal handling protocols are not in
www.ajlobby.com
90 5 Infectious Disease Control in Spay–Neuter Facilities
place. In addition, areas with animal contact kittens will be housed together or with their
including housing, surgical prep, surgery, and mother, or at least in pairs if kennel space does
recovery areas must be adequately sanitized at not allow the entire litter to be housed in one
the end of each day or when the animals leave, cage or run. The stress of being separated from
to ensure that animals arriving the next day for littermates can lead to fear imprinting and a
surgery are not at risk. higher susceptibility to disease caused by expo-
sure to infectious organisms.
As described in the section on sanitation
Animal Housing
later in this chapter, in clinics whose housing
Housing in the HQHVSN clinic will vary with areas are not “all in/all out,” the order of sani-
clinic size and delivery model, and may consist tation should proceed from most vulnerable to
of individual cages or runs, or portable crates least vulnerable patients in order to reduce the
or pet carriers (Griffin et al. 2016). In addition, likelihood of infectious disease spread.
the animal housing area of the clinic may be
limited to a single room or vehicle (as in a
Animal Handling and Clinic Flow
mobile clinic), or may include multiple hous-
ing spaces that allow for physical separation Animal handling is an important component
between groups or categories of animals. in infection control, especially in settings
Regardless of this variability, clinics should where there is a high daily turnover of patients.
develop strategies to limit cross‐contamination
among patients from multiple sources and in Potentially Infectious Patients
differing states of health. In facilities that have Patients should be watched for signs of infec-
space for physical divisions among housing tious disease from arrival until discharge. If
areas, clinics should consider housing and potential signs of infectious disease are noted,
handling animals in cohorts by source, age, the affected animal(s) and any littermates or
health, and vaccination status; in facilities animals from the same household or source
with limited space or physical barriers, cohort should be segregated from other patients for
housing may be accomplished by grouping the duration of their clinic stay. If the sick or
cohort animals near each other and by han- exposed animals are determined to be appro-
dling in order from most to least vulnerable. priate surgical candidates, they should be
An alternative for reducing exposure and scheduled for surgery after surgeries on all
cross‐contamination between cohorts might apparently healthy animals have been com-
be to schedule patients from different sources pleted (Griffin et al. 2016).
on different days (Griffin et al. 2016).
Pediatric patients pose a significant Infectious Disease Control through
challenge to spay–neuter facilities. Due to their the Clinic Day
immature immune systems, presence of All staff should be aware of the potential for
maternal antibodies, and probable lack of the spread of infectious microorganisms as the
vaccination, they are particularly susceptible animal moves through the clinic throughout
to infection. To prevent the spread of infectious the surgery day. Animal contact surfaces
diseases to vulnerable animals, puppies, should be cleaned and disinfected between
kittens, and any unvaccinated animals should patients, including areas and equipment used
be housed separately from other dogs and cats during examinations, surgical preparation,
(Newbury et al. 2010). Adult animals, espe- surgery, and recovery (Stull et al. 2018). Direct
cially those that have no known vaccine contact between unrelated animals should be
history, should never be housed with unrelated avoided during the animals’ stay at the clinic;
pediatric patients. Ideally, litters of puppies or this may be most challenging on the recovery
www.ajlobby.com
Hygiene 91
www.ajlobby.com
92 5 Infectious Disease Control in Spay–Neuter Facilities
Sanitation
Physical Cleaning
Sanitation is an important tool for prevention A proper sanitation protocol begins with the
of the spread of infectious diseases in veteri- basics. Physical cleaning is an important yet
nary hospitals. The goal of sanitation is to often overlooked step in the sanitation process.
lower the numbers of infectious organisms to a Physical cleaning includes the removal of all
non‐infective dose in the environment by using organic material (feces, urine, vomitus, blood,
physical cleaning and chemical or physical dis- and dirt) prior to application of an appropriate
infection to destroy susceptible pathogens detergent. Fecal material should be removed
(Peterson et al. 2008). Sanitation is especially manually and not hosed down the kennel drain,
important in clinics with a high turnover of a practice that can contaminate neighboring
patients daily, and proper sanitation is impera- areas by aerosolizing pathogens. In addition,
tive when animals with unknown vaccination kennel drains are often overlooked in the sanita-
histories or disease exposures are housed in tion process, so that residual infective feces
close proximity to one another. could pose an infection risk for future patients.
Following physical removal of feces, all sur-
faces of the cage or kennel should be cleaned
Order of Sanitation
with a detergent to remove residual organic
In clinics that operate on an “all in/all out” material from the enclosure. Any commercial
basis, the order in which cages and kennels are dishwashing detergent will suffice, and there is
cleaned may not be important. However, in no need to purchase specialty detergents from
veterinary clinics and animal shelters that chemical companies for this purpose. Remember
house animals before and after their scheduled that each cage has six surfaces, including the
surgery, the order of cleaning becomes more doors, and all should be thoroughly cleaned prior
important. In general, the most vulnerable ani- to application of the disinfectant. Cage and ken-
mals should be cared for first; this includes nel doors are often overlooked in the cleaning
pediatric patients regardless of vaccination process, and it may be especially difficult to
status. These patients’ immune systems may remove dried organic material from the cage or
not be fully developed, and because of possible kennel bars prior to applying disinfectants. Many
maternal antibody interference with vaccina- cage doors can be removed and placed in trays to
tion, they may be more susceptible to infec- soak before scrubbing. Cleaning may also require
tion. Pathogenic organisms from other animals “elbow grease” to scrub stubborn stains and
may infect these animals via fomite transmis- dried‐on material from surfaces. Periodically,
sion by staff if other areas are cleaned first. The and depending on traffic through the facility, sur-
next to be sanitized is the housing area of any faces should be cleaned with special degreaser
unvaccinated adult animals, or adult animals detergents to remove accumulated biofilm.
with an unknown vaccine history. While many Following physical cleaning, any residual
adult dogs in households have immunity to detergent should be rinsed or wiped away with
parvovirus infection by one year of age, over a clean, damp cloth before applying the disin-
60% of adult dogs entering a southern animal fectant product. This is especially important
shelter had insufficient immunity to canine because many disinfectants are deactivated by
distemper virus (CDV) and canine parvovirus detergents. In addition, excess water used for
(CPV) (Lechner et al. 2010). These animals rinsing should be squeegeed or wiped away
Sanitation 93
prior to applying the disinfectant to prevent wet surfaces further dilute the product, so
further dilution of the disinfectant product. removing excess water prior to disinfectant
application is also important.
Adequate contact time should be allowed to
Disinfection
ensure the efficacy of the disinfectant product.
Disinfection refers to the application of a Most products require a minimum of 10 min-
chemical or the use of a physical force (heat or utes of contact time prior to rinsing, but as
steam) to kill pathogens in the environment. with mixing, the manufacturer’s guidelines
Disinfectants are applied to inanimate objects should always be followed. Some newer disin-
in order to kill microorganisms, whereas anti- fectants require only two to three minutes of
septics are applied directly to the animal for contact time with surfaces prior to rinsing
the same purpose (Peterson et al. 2008). While (Omidbakash and Satter 2006).
chemical disinfectants are essential to the Another important consideration when mix-
development of sanitation protocols, there are ing disinfectants from a stock solution of
safety concerns for both the animals and the concentrated product is adequate labeling of
personnel using the products. the mixed product. The container should be
There are many classes of disinfectants with labeled with the name of the product, the date
different efficacies for certain pathogens. It is it was mixed, the name of the person preparing
important to know which type of disinfectant the mixture, as well as an expiration date.
destroys what type of microorganism, as that Disinfectants may have very different ranges of
will inform infection control protocols. It is efficacy after the product is mixed. For exam-
also important that the manufacturer’s guide- ple, when sodium hypochlorite is diluted with
lines for dilution be followed, as too dilute or water at appropriate concentrations to destroy
too concentrated disinfectants may not result microorganisms, it is only efficacious for
in the desired effect. Too much dilution will 24 hours (Miller and Zawistowski 2013).
result in loss of efficacy, whereas a concen- Broad‐spectrum disinfectants destroy a wide
trated product may result in injury to the ani- range of infectious organisms, but may not
mals (Figure 5.2). Disinfectants applied to very cover a particular pathogen the clinic is con-
cerned about. Therefore, some knowledge
about some of the more common disinfectants
used in veterinary practice is imperative for
developing effective disease control strategies
(Figure 5.3).
Oxidizing Agents
Quaternary
Disinfectant Halogens: Halogens: Peroxygen Ammonium
Category Alcohols Alkalis Aldehydes Chlorine Iodine Compounds Phenols Compounds
ethanol, calcium hydroxide, formaldehyde, sodium hypochlorite povidone-iodine hydrogen peroxide/ ortho-phenylphenol, benzalkonium chloride,
Common isopropanol sodium carbonate, glutaraldehyde, (bleach), calcium accelerated HP, orthobenzylpara- alkyldimethyl
Active calcium oxide ortho-phthalaldehyde, hypochlorite, chlorine peracetic acid, chlorophenol ammonium chloride
Ingredients dioxide potassium
peroxymonosulfate
One-Stroke Environ , Roccal-D ,
Sample Trade Rescue , Oxy-Sept
Synergize Clorox , Wysiwash Pheno-Tek II , DiQuat , D-256
Names* 333 , Virkon-S
Tek-Trol , Lysol
• Fast acting • Slow acting • Slow acting • Fast acting • Stable in storage • Fast acting • Can leave residual • Stable in storage
• Rapid • Affected by pH • Affected by pH • Affected by pH • Affected by pH • May damage some film on surfaces • Best at neutral or
evaporation • Best at high temps and temperature • Frequent application • Requires metals (e.g., lead, • Can damage alkaline pH
• Leaves no • Corrosive to metals • Irritation of skin/ • Inactivated by UV frequent copper, brass, zinc) rubber, plastic; • Effective at high temps
residue • Severe skin burns; mucous membrane radiation application • Powdered form non-corrosive • High concentrations
Characteristics • Can swell or mucous membrane • Only use in well • Corrodes metals, • Corrosive may cause mucous • Stable in storage corrosive to metals
harden rubber irritation ventilated areas rubber, fabrics, • Stains clothes membrane irritation • Irritation to skin • Irritation to skin, eyes,
and plastics • Environmental • Pungent odor • Mucous membrane and treated • Low toxicity at lower and eyes and respiratory tract
hazard • Noncorrosive irritation surfaces concentrations
• Environmentally
friendly
Bactericidal + + + + + + + +
Virucidal ±a + ± + + + + + Enveloped
Fungicidal + + + + + ± + +
Tuberculocidal + ± + + + ± + –
Sporicidal – + + + ± + – +
Factors Inactivated by Effective in presence Effective in presence Inactivated by
Rapidly
Inactivated by organic matter, Rapidly inactivated of organic matter, of organic matter, organic matter,
Affecting Variable inactivated by
organic matter hard water, by organic matter hard water, soaps, hard wat er, soaps, and hard water, soaps and
Effectiveness organic matter
soaps and detergents and detergents detergents anionic detergents
+ = effective; ± = variable or limited activity; – = not effective a - slow acting against nonenveloped viruses (e.g., norovirus)
*DISCLAIMER: The use of trade names serves only as examples and does not in any way signify endorsement of a particular product.
R : Fraise AP, Lambert PA et al. (eds).Russell, Hugo & Ayliffe’s Principles and Practice of Disinfection, Preservation and Sterilization, 5th ed. 2013. Ames, IA: Wiley-Blackwell;
McDonnell GE. Antisepsis, Disinfection, and Sterilization: Types, Action, and Resistance. 2007. ASM Press, Washington DC. Rutala WA, Weber DJ, Healthcare Infection Control Practices
Advisory Committee (HICPAC). 2008. Guideline for disinfection and sterilization in healthcare facilities. Available at: http://www.cdc.gov/hicpac/Disinfection_Sterilization/toc.html;
Quinn PJ, Markey FC et al. (eds). Veterinary Microbiology and Microbial Disease. 2nd ed. 2011. West Sussex, UK: Wiley-Blackwell, pp 851-889.
effective against non‐enveloped viruses, and in many cases their arrival at the HQHVSN
are not sporicidal, mycobacteriocidal, or fungi- clinic is the first time their pet has visited a vet-
cidal (Dvorak 2008). erinarian (White et al. 2018). Other owners
may not have continued their pets’ veterinary
visits to complete the recommended vaccina-
Vaccination tion schedule. In addition, many pet owners
may be concerned with what they consider the
It is highly recommended that animals enter- overvaccination of their pet and refuse vacci-
ing HQHVSN clinics be vaccinated with modi- nation. Nevertheless, HQHVSN facilities
fied live (MLV) vaccines at least one week prior should follow the recommended standard of
to admission whenever possible (Miller and care for vaccination, inform owners of the
Hurley 2009; Newbury et al. 2010). While peri‐ importance of vaccination prior to admission
operative vaccination is safe and acceptable for surgery, and discuss the risks to animals
when necessary and can effectively confer that have not received adequate vaccination
immunity (Griffin et al. 2016), it is in most prior to admission.
cases ineffective at protecting animals during
their clinic stay. The use of MLV vaccines is
Core Vaccinations
recommended over the use of killed vaccine
because killed products require booster vacci- Vaccination guidelines for companion animals
nation after three weeks to provide adequate have been established by the American Animal
protection, whereas MLV and recombinant Hospital Association (AAHA; Ford et al. 2017)
vaccines begin to provide protection within and the American Association of Feline
hours to days (Abdelmagid et al. 2004; Larson Practitioners (AAFP; Scherk et al. 2013). Dogs
and Schultz 2006; Miller and Hurley 2009). In and cats should be vaccinated with core vac-
addition, when used in pediatric patients, MLV cines beginning at six to eight weeks of age, or
vaccine products are better able to overcome as early as four weeks for puppies and kittens
maternal antibody interference than killed housed in animal shelters or high‐density envi-
vaccines. Pediatric patients are particularly ronments. Vaccination should continue every
vulnerable to contracting infectious diseases three to four weeks (or every two weeks in an
due to a number of factors, including maternal animal shelter) until the animal is at least six-
antibody interference with vaccination, inabil- teen weeks of age. Animals over six months of
ity to mount an effective immune response due age with an unknown vaccination history
to an immature immune system, and increased should be vaccinated prior to admission when-
stress due to separation from littermates or ever possible. Subsequent vaccinations for
being in unfamiliar surroundings (Buonavoglia adult animals should be repeated once in three
et al. 1992; Jas et al. 2009; DeCramer et al. to four weeks, or two weeks from initial vacci-
2011). This increase risk to pediatric animals is nation if in a shelter environment (Richards
present even in private veterinary hospitals, et al. 2006; Welborn et al. 2011).
even though a lower volume of animals is pre- Core vaccines for dogs include a combina-
sented for surgery in these settings. tion MLV or recombinant vaccine for CDV,
Despite the recommendation for vaccination canine parainfluenza virus (CPiV), CPV, and
prior to admission, it is unrealistic to assume canine adenovirus‐2 (CAV‐2). Bordetella bron-
that all animals will have received timely chiseptica vaccine is not a core vaccine for
vaccination with core vaccines prior to presen- dogs living in the community, but it is consid-
tation to the spay–neuter facility. Many clients ered a core vaccine for shelter dogs (Ford
may not have the financial resources to provide et al. 2017). Core vaccines for cats include
routine veterinary care for their animals, and feline herpesvirus‐1 (FHV), FCV, and FPV
References 99
(Scherk et al. 2013). It is important to remem- for rabies vaccination. The required age for
ber that vaccination for some diseases rabies vaccination is determined by the county
provides incomplete or inadequate protection or municipality where the animal resides.
against infection in most animals, although Most commercially available rabies vaccines
clinical signs may be less pronounced. For are labeled for use in dogs and cats 12 weeks of
example, vaccination with FHV‐1 provided age and older, are killed virus vaccines, and
protection in 75% of vaccinated cats. require the addition of an adjuvant to stimu-
Conversely, vaccination for FPV can provide late the immune system to elicit an immune
excellent immunity ( 99%) even after only response. The exception to this is the feline
one vaccine (Schultz 2006). rabies Purevax® vaccine, which uses a canary
It is recommended that veterinarians follow pox vector and is labeled for use in kittens as
the AAFP vaccination site guidelines for cats young as 8 weeks of age; however, most munic-
and kittens, with FVRCP vaccine administered ipalities throughout the United States will not
below the elbow in the right forelimb, rabies recognize a vaccine given before 12 weeks of
vaccine below the knee in the right hindlimb, age, regardless of the label.
and any vaccine containing killed feline leuke-
mia virus (FeLV) below the knee in the left
hindlimb (Richards et al. 2006). Use of Antibiotics in Elective
For more information on infectious diseases Surgical Procedures
and vaccination of animals in the shelter
setting, the reader is referred to the books The use of prophylactic antibiotics to prevent
Infectious Disease Management in Animal infection during routine spay–neuter proce-
Shelters (Miller and Hurley 2009) and Shelter dures is not recommended. In general, the risk
Medicine for Veterinarians and Staff, 2nd edn of infection at the surgical site is directly
(Miller and Zawistowski 2013). related to the length of the surgical procedure
and whether there are breaks in asepsis (Brown
et al. 1997). Antibiotics should be reserved for
Rabies Vaccine
those patients in whom a known break in asep-
Rabies vaccination, though not generally con- sis has occurred, the surgical procedure is
sidered a core vaccine, should be required of prolonged, the animal has significant skin
all dogs and cats old enough to receive it prior disease or other infection that may result in
to or at the time of elective surgery. Because contamination during surgery, or the animal
rabies infection in humans is an almost uni- has a traumatic infected wound or other condi-
formly fatal zoonotic disease, most municipali- tion such as pyometra that could benefit from
ties require rabies vaccination in companion a prescribed course of antibiotics. Unless
animals. If an animal has not been vaccinated indicated for other current active infection,
against rabies prior to admission for surgery, prolonged use of antibiotics after surgery
many clinics will vaccinate at the time of spay– should be avoided in animals with clean
neuter surgery to fulfill the legal requirements wounds (Griffin et al. 2016).
References
Abdelmagid, O., Larson, L., Payne, L. et al. hepatitis, and distemper virus challenges. Vet.
(2004). Evaluation of the efficacy and duration Ther. 5 (3): 173–186.
of immunity of a canine combination vaccine Brown, D.C., Conzemius, M.G., Shofer, F. et al.
against virulent parvovirus, infectious canine (1997). Epidemiologic evaluation of
100 5 Infectious Disease Control in Spay–Neuter Facilities
postoperative wound infection in dogs and exposure under shelter‐like conditions. Vet.
cats. JAVMA 10 (9): 1302–1306. Ther. 7 (2): 113–118.
Buonavoglia, C., Tollis, M., Buonavoglia, D. et al. Lechner, E.S., Crawford, P.C., and Levy, J.K.
(1992). Response of pups with maternal (2010). Prevalence of protective antibody titers
derived antibody to modified‐live canine for canine distemper virus and canine
parvovirus vaccine. Comp. Immunol., parvovirus in dogs entering a Florida animal
Microbiol. Infect. Dis. 15 (4): 281–283. shelter. JAVMA 236 (12): 1317–1321.
DeCramer, K.G.M., Stylanides, E., and van McDonnell, G.E. (2007). Antisepsis, Disinfection,
Vuuren, M. (2011). Efficacy of vaccination at 4 and Sterilization: Types, Action, and
and 6 weeks in the control of canine Resistance. Washington, DC: ASM Press.
parvovirus. Vet. Microbiol. 149 (1–2): 126–132. Miller, L. and Hurley, K. (2009). Infectious
Dvorak, G.D. (2008). Disinfection 101. Ames, IA: Disease Management in Animal Shelters.
Center for Food Security and Public Health. Ames, IA: Wiley‐Blackwell.
Eterpi, M., McDonnell, G., and Thomas, V. Miller, L. and Zawistowski, S. (2013). Shelter
(2009). Disinfection efficacy against Medicine for Veterinarians and Staff, 2e. Ames,
parvoviruses compared with reference viruses. IA: Wiley‐Blackwell.
J. Hosp. Infect. 73: 64–70. Moriello, K.A. (2015). Kennel disinfectants for
Ford, R.B., Larson, L.J., McClure, K.D. et al. Microsporum canis and Trichophyton sp. Vet.
(2017). 2017 AAHA canine vaccination Med. Int. 2015: 853937.
guidelines. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 53: Newbury, S., Blinn, M.K., Bushby, P.A. et al.
243–251. (2010). Guidelines for Standards of Care in
Fraise, A.P., Maillard, J.‐Y., Sattar, S. et al. (eds.) Animal Shelters. Apex, NC: Association of
(2013). Russell, Hugo & Ayliffe’s Principles and Shelter Veterinarians.
Practice of Disinfection, Preservation and Omidbakash, N. and Satter, S.A. (2006). Broad‐
Sterilization, 5e. Ames, IA: Wiley‐Blackwell. spectrum microbial activity, toxicologic
Gehrke, C., Steinmann, J., and Goroncy‐Bermes, assessment, and materials compatibility of a
P. (2004). Inactivation of feline calicivirus, a new generation of accelerated hydrogen
surrogate of norovirus (formerly Norwalk‐like peroxide‐based environmental surface
viruses), by different types of alcohol in vitro disinfectant. Am. J. Infect. Cont. 34 (5):
and in vivo. J. Hosp. Infect. 56 (1): 49–55. 251–257.
Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al. Peterson, C.A., Dvorak, G., and Spickler, A.R.
(2016). The Association of Shelter (2008). Maddie’s® Infection Control Manual for
Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical care Animal Shelters. Ames, IA: Center for Food
guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. JAVMA Safety and Public Health, Iowa State
249: 165–188. University.
Jas, D., Aeberle, C., Lacombe, V. et al. (2009). Quinn, P.J., Markey, B.K., Leonard, F.C. et al.
Onset of immunity in kittens after vaccination (eds.) (2011). Veterinary Microbiology and
with a non‐adjuvanted vaccine against feline Microbial Disease,
panleukopenia, feline calicivirus, and feline 2e. Chichester: Wiley‐Blackwell.
herpesvirus. Vet. J. 182 (1): 86–93. Richards, J.R., Elston, T.H., Ford, R.B. et al.
Larson, E.L. (1995). APIC guidelines for (2006). The 2006 American Association of
handwashing and hand antisepsis in health Feline Practitioners Feline Vaccine Advisory
care settings. Am. J. Infect. Cont. 23 (4): Panel report. JAVMA 229 (9): 1405–1441.
251–269. Rutala, W. and Weber, D. (2008). Guideline for
Larson, L.J. and Schultz, R.D. (2006). Effect of Disinfection and Sterilization in Healthcare
vaccination with recombinant canine Facilities, 2008. Atlanta, GA: Centers for
distemper virus vaccine immediately before Disease Control and Prevention.
References 101
Rutala, W.A., Weber, D.J., and Healthcare Weese, J.S. (2004). Barrier precautions, isolation
Infection Control Practices Advisory protocols, and personal hygiene in veterinary
Committee (HICPAC) (2008). Guideline for hospitals. Vet. Clin. N. Am. Equine Pract. 20
disinfection and sterilization in healthcare (3): 543–559.
facilities. http://www.cdc.gov/hicpac/ Welborn, L.V., DeVries, J.G., Ford, R. et al.
Disinfection_Sterilization/toc.html (accessed (2011). American Animal Hospital
16 August 2019). Association canine vaccination guidelines.
Scherk, M.A., Ford, R.B., Gaskell, R.M. et al. http://www.aahanet.org/PublicDocuments/
(2013). 2013 AAFP feline vaccination advisory CanineVaccineGuidelines.pdf (accessed 7
panel report. J. Feline Med. Surg. 15: 785–808. March 2013).
Schultz, R.D. (2006). Duration of immunity for White, S.C., Scarlett, J.M., and Levy, J.K. (2018).
canine and feline vaccines: a review. Vet. Characteristics of clients and animals served
Microbiol. 117 (1): 75–79. by high‐volume, stationary, nonprofit spay‐
Stull, J.W., Bjorvik, E., Bub, J. et al. (2018). 2018 neuter clinics. JAVMA 253: 737–745.
AAHA infection control, prevention, and
biosecurity guidelines. JAAHA 54: 297–326.
103
fear‐induced tachycardia increases the risk of signals, the most obvious of which involve
serious cardiac arrhythmias during anesthetic changes in their body postures and vocaliza
induction (Trim 1999). Furthermore, ongoing tions. When animals experience stress and fear,
stress can impede patient recovery by inhibit they generally become tense – their bodies
ing normal maintenance behaviors such as eat stiffen, and tension can also be seen in their
ing, eliminating, and restful sleeping. It can faces (Figure 6.1). They are often wide‐eyed,
also impact immunity. In cats, the role of acute and their ears tend to shift back or sideways.
stress in the development of respiratory infec Some individuals remain silent, while others
tion, particularly feline viral rhinotracheitis may hiss, growl, bark, whine, or even scream.
(feline herpesvirus), has been well docu In addition to active communication, ani
mented (Sparkes et al. 2016). mals also communicate passively. Passive com
Proactively managing patient stress and fear munication includes both “lack of behavior”
improves patient wellbeing by positively (such as refusing to eat a tasty treat, freezing in
impacting both physical health and behavior. place, or avoiding contact) and physiologic
In terms of behavior, animals that remain calm changes that one might discover through very
are generally much easier to handle, while ani careful observation or physical examination.
mals that are stressed or fearful frequently For example, one might notice rapid breathing
resist handling. If a more forceful approach is and dilated pupils in a fearful animal. Excessive
used to handle a fearful or resistant subject, the shedding is also common when animals are
individual’s fear will increase and displays of nervous or otherwise stressed. A careful
aggressive behavior will be more likely, increas observer can deduce what an individual ani
ing the odds of injury to the animal and staff. mal is experiencing emotionally by accurately
For some animals, fear imprinting may interpreting body language and vocalizations,
occur – in this case, a single traumatic event as well as by understanding these more passive
such as forceful handling can result in the forms of communication.
patient learning a lasting negative association,
which could make handling and care much
more difficult in the future. In contrast, if
patient stress and fear are minimized, animals
are calmer and more tractable, facilitating the
delivery of efficient, quality care.
It is important to recognize that there are individual animal will respond a little differ
many ways in which dogs and cats communi ently, staff can learn to prevent and minimize
cate that they are experiencing stress and negative emotional responses during the spay–
fear – behavioral responses vary greatly among neuter process by carefully considering how
individuals. The “four Fs” are often used to animals are likely to perceive the environment
describe common types of behaviors associ and making adjustments to avoid or mitigate
ated with fear and stress: these are fight, flight, potential stressors and fear‐inducing stimuli.
fret/fidget, and freeze behaviors. Some animals When staff are observant and in tune with
display “fight” behaviors, including struggling, how the environment, as well as their own
growling, snarling, hissing, biting, or lunging. actions, can impact patient stress, they can
Such aggressive behavior is the animal’s take simple, practical steps to mitigate it. The
attempt to drive away a perceived threat. Other response of an individual animal will depend
animals display “flight behaviors.” In this case, not only on their unique genetic makeup, level
they may cower, look away, and move away as of socialization, personality, and prior experi
they attempt to escape, hide, or otherwise ence, but also on the severity and number of
avoid or evade contact. They often tuck their given stressors and their duration of exposure
tails and try to retreat or roll over to resist han to them. Obviously, the more severe the stress
dling. Still other animals display “fret or fidget” and the longer it lasts, the more difficult it is
behaviors – they might move restlessly, pacing, for an animal to cope and the more likely they
shifting, or nervously jumping about. A careful will be to suffer harmful effects from it. When
observer might notice that they nervously lick stress is perceived as unescapable, uncontrol
their lips, lift a paw, yawn, or scratch them lable, or unpredictable, it is especially severe.
selves. Finally, some animals display “freeze” When individual animals experience stress
behaviors. These animals should not be mis and fear, their emotional reactions can affect
taken as relaxed; instead they are tense and fro the responses of others in the clinic. Stress and
zen in a helpless sort of state. Many stressed fear are literally “contagious” among groups of
and fearful animals display a mixture of fight, animals: the process of “emotional contagion”
flight, fret/fidget, and freeze behaviors. The is a simple and widespread form of emotional
presence of these behaviors tells us that the transfer that occurs among animals whereby
animal is stressed and fearful, and not that animals shift their own emotional state, upon
they are mean, nasty, or unsocialized. When perceiving the emotions of other animals, in
one sees these behaviors, one should respond the same direction (Spinka 2012). This process
with compassion, adjusting interactions with can multiply both negative and positive emo
the animal to reduce their perception of a tions in animal groups. This has important
threat. In addition, an attempt should be made implications in the clinic setting and should be
to ascertain additional triggers that may be carefully considered when determining the
contributing to the patient’s stress and fear, so timing of caring for those patients that are con
that steps can be taken to reduce or eliminate sidered to potentially be the most reactive.
them as soon as possible. Regardless of the precise nature of a particu
lar spay–neuter program or the physical facili
ties in which it operates, there are many simple
Reducing Patient Stress things that staff can do to mitigate environmen
and Fear tal stressors and promote a positive emotional
environment for animals and people alike. A
Reducing patients’ fear and stress begins with healthy emotional environment provides posi
understanding the potential impact of the tive, compassionate caregiving by well‐trained
clinic environment. While it is true that each staff members and actively reduces potential
106 6 Strategies to Reduce Stress and Enhance Patient Comfort during the Spay–Neuter Process
stressors and fear‐inducing stimuli such as loud The ability of animals to detect even very
noises, other intense or overwhelming stimuli, small amounts of scent in the environment
haphazard interactions, and frequent inter makes it particularly important to remove
ruptions. Animals can cope with new and potentially stressful scents to the extent possi
unknown stimuli provided that fear responses ble. In contrast, pleasant, soothing odors such
are not overwhelming or sensitizing. It is espe as lavender may be useful additions to the
cially helpful for staff to critically consider the environment, because they may be calming for
environment from the animals’ perspective. animals and people alike.
Sense of Sight
Animals’ Senses, Perceptions,
Compared to human beings, dogs and cats
and Environmental Management
possess a considerably wider visual field, while
Dogs and cats have astonishing and unique sen their visual acuity, depth perception, and color
sory capabilities, and the ways in which they vision remain less well developed. They are
perceive the environment around them are highly sensitive to movement, and can see and
greatly influenced by these senses. Possessing function in very dim light. Because of their
some knowledge and understanding of how greater peripheral vision, dogs and cats
animals’ senses contribute to their unique often see things beyond the field of view of
perceptions can go a long way toward helping their human caregivers. Rapid movements
staff to create an environment that is less intimi frequently startle them, particularly when
dating and more relaxing for patients. Thinking they are in a novel environment, and may
in terms of what the animals are experiencing – invoke abrupt, impulsive, and/or exaggerated
what they are hearing, smelling, seeing, and responses. Furthermore, sudden or rapid move
feeling – is a key to environmental management ment toward an animal is likely to induce fear
for stress reduction. because it is generally interpreted as a threat.
Similarly, animals are likely to view certain pos
Sense of Hearing tures, such as leaning over them or reaching
Dogs and cats possess very acute hearing, and toward them, as threatening. With all of this in
can detect many sounds that go unnoticed by mind, caregivers can avoid triggering stress and
caregivers. They are highly sensitive to sounds fear responses simply by moving slowly, calmly,
and loud noises, especially in an unfamiliar and deliberately, and by avoiding threatening
environment. Vocal signals from other animals postures while working with patients. Blocking
such as howling, crying, yowling, or hissing visual stimuli in the environment is often a very
can invoke apprehension and fear for those in effective means of reducing patient stress and
audible range. In particular, the sounds of fear. For example, doors can be shut to block
barking dogs are especially stressful and fear outside activity; towels can be used to cover an
invoking for cats. For all of these reasons, min animal’s head, blocking their vision during a
imizing loud and sudden noises, including procedure; a towel can be draped over a carrier;
barking, is a crucial component of environ or a visual barrier can be hung on the front of a
mental management to reduce patient stress cage or run.
and promote comfort.
Sense of Touch
Sense of Smell Dogs and cats can be very sensitive to
Dogs and cats also possess incredibly keen senses touch – and remembering this is a key to
of smell. As such, avoiding strong and noxious reducing stress during handling. The way in
odors (such as the smell of isopropyl alcohol) has which they are touched greatly influences
the potential to reduce stress and fear. their response to it. Using slow, steady contact
Reducing Patient Stress and Fear 107
Control noise
in the Spay–Neuter Clinic
●●
quiet environment will be the key to providing for another, thus a “one size fits all” approach
a low‐stress handling experience. As such, ani is best avoided. Instead, several tools should be
mal care protocols should be flexible enough to available and selected based on the appraisal of
allow staff to meet the needs of individual the individual animal and situation. Towel
patients whenever possible. Avoiding escapes wraps are often useful aids for handling cats
and the need to recapture is also crucial, and small dogs. Well‐fitted basket muzzles are
because these will greatly increase stress, as useful for preventing dog bites and are gener
well as the risk of animal and staff injury. ally better tolerated and safer for patients that
Simply ensuring that doors and windows are traditional cone or tie muzzles. Likewise,
closed prior to opening animal enclosures is an Elizabethan collars can be useful and humane
imperative part of low‐stress handling. tools for protecting the handler from bites from
Most animals respond best to gentle restraint both dogs and cats. In some cases, chemical
and react negatively when “over‐restrained.” restraint should be administered with the use
In many instances, skillful, patient, and/or of humane restraint equipment such as nets or
creative management and handling will avoid squeeze devices. The use of control poles
the need for additional physical restraint, should be avoided and they should never be
improving animal and staff safety while reduc used to restrain cats. In all cases, calm han
ing stress. When physical restraint is necessary dling is essential. Box 6.2 contains a list of
to avoid human injury or injury to an animal, it resources for low‐stress handling.
should be of the least intensity and duration
necessary. Proper equipment in good working Provide Information to Caregivers
order and adequate staff should be readily in Advance
available in the event that either is needed to Providing key information to caregivers in
ensure safe and successful handling. The way advance can reduce patient stress during trans
in which equipment is used is crucial to ensure port and admission. In particular, caregivers
that it mitigates and limits stress versus will benefit from instruction regarding selec
increasing the risk of physical or emotional tion of transport carriers, acclimating pets to
harm. Techniques or equipment suitable for carriers and securing them in place, and ensuring
one animal or situation may be inappropriate comfortable temperatures during transport, as
well as knowing what to expect when they fear invoking to them. As such, from the time
arrive at the clinic. In many instances, infor they arrive at the clinic and continuing through
mation can be made readily available through out their stay, care should be taken not to place
the program’s website or via volunteers. For cats within spatial, visual, or auditory range of
cats, using plastic carriers from which the top dogs whenever possible. For this reason, some
half can be easily removed is recommended to programs rotate surgery days for dogs and cats,
facilitate getting a reluctant cat out in a low‐ admitting only one species on a given day to
stress manner. Most plastic carriers also have avoid exposing cats to the sights, sounds, and
the advantage of affording cats some privacy, smells of canine patients. If canine and feline
since they typically have solid, partially slatted patients are admitted on the same day, they
sides. Caregivers should be instructed to should be kept as separate as possible in wait
loosely cover wire carriers with a towel or ing, housing, surgery, and recovery areas. The
sheet to shield cats from visual stimuli. order and timing of the day’s surgery schedule
Whenever possible, staff should ask in advance can facilitate such separation.
if patients have a history of being highly reac Providing elevated surfaces, such as counter
tive during veterinary visits or are feral, so that tops or shelving, on which to rest carriers con
staff can plan ahead accordingly. taining cats is a simple but powerful means of
reducing patient stress, because cats instinc
Maintain a Calm Reception Area tively feel more secure when they can perch at
Reception areas can be busy, crowded, and a high vantage point, “out of a predator’s
stressful during the time of patient admission reach.” In addition, the use of visual barriers
and discharge. Scheduling should strive to can also provide separation and privacy for
alleviate bottlenecks and minimize wait times. animals. Towels or sheets can be provided in
Staff should always take care to maintain a the waiting room for covering carriers contain
calm demeanor during admission and release ing cats immediately upon entry, shielding
processes by working in a quiet, steady manner them visually from stress‐invoking stimuli.
and talking in calm and soothing tones. Simply
taking care to minimize noise and rapid move Control Noise
ments will go a long way to making animals Minimizing loud and sudden noises, includ
feel comfortable during these processes. ing barking, is a crucial component of envi
Weather permitting, leaving animals in cars ronmental management to reduce patient
until such time that someone is available to stress and promote comfort at all time points
transport them directly to housing areas will during the spay–neuter process. Housing
minimize congestion and stress in reception design and soundproofing systems can help.
areas. Likewise, leaving them in housing areas Noise can be also be blunted by using back
until discharge procedures are complete will ground sounds such as soothing music, water
minimize the time spent in reception areas fountains, or white noise machines. In par
during release. ticular, a radio playing soft music at a low vol
ume will provide a welcome distraction and
Separate Species may prevent animals from being startled by
Dogs and cats should always be kept separate to loud noises. Importantly, most caregivers
the greatest extent possible (Griffin et al. 2016). enjoy listening to the radio, and happy car
Naturally possessing heightened fight‐or‐flight egivers positively contribute to a low‐stress,
responses, feline patients are particularly prone relaxed environment. Staff and volunteers
to experiencing acute stress and fear in novel should refrain from loud talking and always
environments, and the presence and sounds of take care to minimize noise during the course
unfamiliar dogs are extremely distressing and of their duties.
110 6 Strategies to Reduce Stress and Enhance Patient Comfort during the Spay–Neuter Process
Ensure Warmth
Patient comfort relies on ensuring appropriate
ambient temperatures and adequate patient
warmth throughout the clinic, before, during, and
after surgery. Hypothermia may lead to anesthetic
complications and prolonged recoveries, and
being chilled contributes substantially to patient
stress and discomfort. For all of these reasons,
ambient temperature and humidity should be
well controlled in the clinic, avoiding drafts.
Bedding materials, such as papers, towels, or
blankets, should be used to help keep animals Figure 6.6 A reluctant small dog who was
warm and dry. By providing each individual uncomfortable walking on a leash is carried
animal with a cozy towel or blanket, staff can through a ward in the arms of a caregiver. Note the
use of a soft blanket to visually shield her from the
improve body warmth and patient comfort as environment.
well as improving general biosecurity by reducing
cross‐contamination among patients (Figure 6.5).
The Association of Shelter Veterinarians’ standing or walking on traditional flooring. If a
Veterinary Medical Care Guidelines for Spay– dog refuses to walk, placing a non‐slip mat in
Neuter Programs include numerous recommen front of him may help him to get started. This
dations for preserving body temperature and will be enough for many dogs to gain confi
actively warming patients (Griffin et al. 2016). dence walking in the building. Dogs should
never be dragged by the scruff or on a leash. If
Ensure Secure Footing they are too uncomfortable to walk, they
Many dogs are uncomfortable walking on tile should be lifted and carried (Griffin et al. 2016;
floors and older animals may have difficulty Figure 6.6). Ensuring secure footing for both
Reducing Patient Stress and Fear 113
dogs and cats will ease stress and fear, while combinations provide patients with multi
facilitating animal movement, handling, and modal analgesia and balanced anesthesia
examination. Other examples include placing when administered in appropriate doses”
a non‐slip mat on a scale, or a towel or sheet of (Griffin et al. 2016). Stress and pain during
newspaper on a slick exam surface. injections are also mitigated by using low‐
stress handling techniques and small‐gauge
Use Tasty Treats needles, and by changing needles prior to
Tasty treats are powerful tools for putting pets at injection to ensure they are as sharp and
ease in new situations. They can aid in distrac smooth as possible.
tion, redirection, and counterconditioning of
both dogs and cats, though dogs are more likely Facilitate Elimination
to partake of treats than many cats. Even in a For dogs that are house trained, regular oppor
surgical clinic, treats can be safely used to facili tunities to go outside to eliminate are very
tate administration of both oral and injectable important, because eliminating inside can be
medications. Depending on the program’s sur extremely stressful for them. If cats are to be
gery schedule, the use of solid treats may or may held for more than 12 hours, a litter box
not be feasible given the need for withholding should be provided once the patient is
food for a few hours prior to surgery. However, a ambulatory. According to the Association of
tiny amount of soft cheese spread, such as Shelter Veterinarians’ Veterinary Medical
canned cheese or cream cheese products, can be Care Guidelines for Spay‐Neuter Programs,
used to facilitate administration of oral medica “Prolonged confinement without opportuni
tions, such as trazodone or gabapentin, when ties for urination and defecation away from
given a couple of hours or more prior to anes the enclosure can increase patient stress and
thesia. Freezing clear broth in a small paper cup discomfort. This problem may be exacerbated
and allowing an animal to lick it briefly is a safe by perioperative administration of fluids and
option prior to anesthesia and can be used to certain anesthetic agents such as α2‐adreno
facilitate low‐stress handling during examina ceptor agonists, which can increase urine
tion and anesthetic injection. Following post‐ output. In addition, confinement inhibits
operative recovery, many patients will benefit elimination behavior in some patients. For all
both physically and emotionally from a small, of these reasons, expression of the patient’s
palatable meal. Canned foods or soft cheese bladder, including both male and female
spreads can also simplify administration of oral patients, during anesthesia may improve com
analgesics in the post‐operative period. fort in the immediate post‐operative period.
For overnight stays, an absorbent substrate,
Minimize Stress during Injections such as paper, litter, or bedding, should be
“Total intramuscular anesthesia” is an efficient provided for cats. Dogs should be walked, pro
and safe technique utilized by many spay– vided that doing so does not pose a safety risk
neuter programs. The Association of Shelter to staff; housed in an enclosure such as a run
Veterinarians’ Veterinary Medical Care that allows for elimination away from the rest
Guidelines for Spay‐Neuter Programs state: ing area; or provided with an absorbent sub
“Administering a single injection that includes strate in their enclosures. Traps housing
sedative, analgesic, and anesthetic induction community cats should be covered to decrease
agents may reduce patient pain and stress, patient stress and should be elevated to allow
compared with administering multiple injec urine and feces to fall through the wire bot
tions … Recommended combinations for single toms away from the patient or lined with
injections include α2‐adrenoreceptor agonists, absorbent material that can be safely changed
opioids, and dissociative drugs because such if soiled” (Griffin et al. 2016; Figure 6.7).
114 6 Strategies to Reduce Stress and Enhance Patient Comfort during the Spay–Neuter Process
(a) (b)
Figure 6.10 (a) By raising and lowering the guillotine doors, a cat is safely and humanely transferred from
a cat den to a squeeze cage for restraint. Note the use of a cage cover. (b) The design of the squeeze cage
allows the cat to be gently pushed over to one side to facilitate injection through the bars of the cage.
Following injection, the cat can be covered to reduce stress.
(a) (b)
Figure 6.11 (a) Commercially available “hand shield” for use with a cat den (Tomahawk Live Trap,
Hazelhurst, WI). (b) An injection can be administered through one of the circular holes in the durable
transparent plastic shield while the handler uses it to gently confine the cat in the back of the den. Note
that the cat den is positioned on its end and that the handler is wearing protective gloves for added safety.
Reducing Patient Stress and Fear 117
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 6.12 Freeman cage net (Animal Care and Equipment Services [ACES], Boulder, CO) is used to
humanely handle a cat in an enclosure. The design of the net allows the user to close the opening to the
net using a special sliding mechanism on the handle of the pole. (a) The net is placed over the cat. (b) As
the handler moves closer, the cat moves farther into the net and the net is closed. (c) The handler calmly
and gently rolls the net onto the pole to confine the cat securely, preventing thrashing. A towel can then be
used to cover the cat while an anesthetic injection is administered.
(a) (b)
Figure 6.13 (a) A commercially available box trap (Tomahawk Live Trap, Tomahawk, WI). When a cat steps
on the spring-loaded foot plate to reach the food bait, the trap door will close and lock. (b) A cat enters a
box trap. Covering the trap serves to make it more inviting. In addition, it will help to reduce stress and fear
by providing cover and security, helping to calm the cat once captured.
120 6 Strategies to Reduce Stress and Enhance Patient Comfort during the Spay–Neuter Process
cat escape. Indeed, if provided an opportunity, spay–neuter programs provide services exclu
most cats will successfully escape, and serious sively to community cats or do so only on
injury can occur if individuals have to recap particular days; others integrate their care into
ture them. In addition, escaped cats can be the clinic’s daily routine while caring for a vari
destructive as they attempt to hide and resist ety of both canine and feline patients. In the
recapture. latter case, arranging for cats to be admitted
Caregivers should be required to present cats during a “quiet” time, or through a separate
for surgery in individual covered traps. Some entrance, is highly recommended. Clinic per
sonnel should have sheets or towels readily
available to cover cats at the time of entry in
case they arrive uncovered. Staff should imme
diately transfer cats in their covered traps to
dedicated holding wards, which are quiet,
dimly lit, and free of non‐essential foot traffic
(Figure 6.15). Exit doors should always remain
securely closed to reduce stress as well as to
prevent escapes in the event that a cat is some
how released from a trap.
Keeping cats confined in traps not only
reduces stress and the risk of escapes, it facili
Figure 6.14 Commercially available drop trap, tates administration of anesthetics. With the cat
which is fully collapsible for ease of transport
(Tomahawk Live Trap, Hazelhurst, WI). A drop trap confined in a trap, this can be done without
can be used to humanely capture cats that will not extensive handling, minimizing stress and
enter a box trap. Strong-smelling food is placed on enhancing safety for both cats and personnel.
the ground beneath the trap, and the caregiver
This is accomplished by quietly but quickly
waits covertly nearby until the cat takes the bait.
From the remote location, the caregiver pulls a standing the trap on end and using a commer
string to remove the prop stick, causing the trap to cially available “trap divider” to more tightly
drop, capturing the cat. A guillotine-style transfer confine the cat. This allows an intramuscular
door is used to safely transfer the cat from the
injection to be administered to the cat between
drop trap into a regular box trap or transfer cage
for transport. the trap’s wire bars (Figure 6.16). In this way,
(a) (b)
Figure 6.15 Proper holding procedures for feral cats. (a) A dedicated ward is provided for holding
community cats that arrive in traps. (b) To reduce stress, traps remain covered and the ward is kept quiet
and dimly lit. For safety and security, cats remain in their covered traps before and after surgery.
Reducing Patient Stress and Fear 121
(a) (b)
Figure 6.16 (a) A commercially available “trap divider” (Animal Care and Equipment Services [ACES],
Boulder, CO) is used to humanely restrain a cat in a box trap to facilitate intramuscular injection of an
anesthetic agent. (b) The trap is gently and swiftly turned on one end, and the device is inserted, confining
the cat for the injection.
of trapping and with subsequent feedings. For c reate low‐stress, positive emotional environ
community cats, a starting oral dosage of ments in the workplace, which will result in
50 mg/cat can be used and repeated as needed calmer patients that pose fewer risks to them
up to every six hours. selves and their caregivers. Calmer patients facili
tate high‐quality, efficient, and humane care.
Simply stated, reducing patient stress and fear
Conclusion translates into better medicine. By using a holistic
approach to reducing patient stress and fear, staff
With training, experience, and a willingness to will ultimately create a more pleasant work envi
work together, spay–neuter program staff can ronment for everyone, animals and humans alike.
References
Carlstead, K., Brown, J.L., and Strawn, W. (1993). McMillan, F.D. (2002). Development of a mental
Behavioral and physiological correlates of wellness program for animals. JAVMA 220:
stress in laboratory cats. Appl. Anim. Behav. 965.
Sci. 38: 143. Pankratz, K.E., Ferris, K.K., Griffith, E.H. et al.
Gilbert‐Gregory, S.E., Stull, J.W., Rice, M.R., and (2018). Use of single‐dose oral gabapentin to
Herron, M.E. (2016). Effects of trazodone on attenuate fear responses in cage‐trap confined
behavioral signs of stress in hospitalized dogs. community cats: a double‐blind, placebo‐
JAVMA 249 (11): 1281–1291. controlled field trial. J. Feline Med. Surg. 20
Griffin, B. (2011). Care and control of (6): 535–543.
community cats. In: The Cat: Clinical Pereira, J.S., Fragoso, S., Beck, A. et al. (2016).
Medicine and Management (ed. S.E. Little), Improving the feline veterinary consultation:
1290–1309. St. Louis, MO: Elsevier. the usefulness of Feliway spray in reducing
Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al. cats’ stress. J. Feline Med. Surg. 18 (12):
(2016). The Association of Shelter 959–964.
Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical care Siracusa, C., Manteca, X., Cuenca, R. et al.
guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. JAVMA (2010). Effect of a synthetic appeasing
249 (2): 165–188. pheromone on behavioral, neuroendocrine,
Griffin, B., DiGangi, B., and Bohling, M.A. immune, and acute‐phase perioperative stress
(2010). Review of neutering cats. In: responses in dogs. JAVMA 237 (6): 673–681.
Consultations in Feline Internal Medicine VI Sparkes, A., Bond, R., Buffington, T. et al. (2016).
(ed. J.R. August), 776–790. St. Louis, MO: Impact of stress and distress on physiology
Elsevier/Saunders. and clinical disease in cats. In: International
Gruen, M.E. and Sherman, B.L. (2008). Use of Society of Feline Medicine Guide to Feline Stress
trazodone as an adjunctive agent in the and Health: Managing Negative Emotions to
treatment of canine anxiety disorders: 56 Improve Feline Health and Wellbeing, 39–52.
cases (1995–2007). JAVMA 233 (12): Tisbury: International Cat Care www.icatcare.
1902–1907. org.
Gruen, M.E., Roe, S.C., Griffith, E. et al. (2014). Spinka, M. (2012). Social dimension of emotions
Use of trazodone to facilitate postsurgical and its implication for animal welfare. Appl.
confinement in dogs. JAVMA 245 (3): Anim. Behav. Sci. 138: 170–181.
296–301. Stevens, B.J., Frantz, E.M., Orlando, J.M. et al.
McCobb, E.C., Patronek, G.J., Marder, A. et al. (2016). Efficacy of a single dose of trazodone
(2005). Assessment of stress levels among cats hydrochloride given to cats prior to veterinary
in four shelters. JAVMA 226: 548. visits to reduce signs of transport‐ and
References 123
examination‐related anxiety. JAVMA 249 (2): van Haaften, K.A., Eichstadt, L.R., Stelow, E.A.
202–207. et al. (2017). Effects of a single pre‐
Trim, C.M. (1999). Anesthetic emergencies and appointment dose of gabapentin on signs of
complications. In: Manual of Small Animal stress in cats during transportation and
Anesthesia (ed. R.R. Paddleford), 147–195. veterinary examination. JAVMA 251 (10):
Philadelphia, PA: W.B. Saunders. 1175–1181.
125
Section Two
pre‐existing medical causes did not solely and 2016 at a single high‐volume clinic were
cause death.” This study generated risk factors analyzed (Levy et al. 2017). In this study peri‐
for different species and paved the way for operative mortality was defined as a death that
improving anesthetic management in small occurred in the 24‐hour period beginning with
animals (Brodbelt et al. 2007, 2008a, b; Brodbelt the first administration of sedation or anes
2009). thesia drugs. The results are summarized in
Animals were assigned a health status; ani Table 7.2.
mals with an ASA status of 1 or 2 were consid In the Levy et al. study, the mortality rate
ered “healthy” and those with an ASA status of was almost 10‐fold lower than in animals clas
3–5 “sick.” Assignment of ASA status is shown sified as “healthy” in the CEPSAF study, but as
in Table 7.1. The overall risk of death was 0.17% in the CEPSAF study, mortality in cats was
in dogs and 0.24% in cats. In healthy dogs and higher than in dogs. The overall low mortality
cats the risks were 0.05 and 0.11%, respectively. rate in the spay and castration study may be
In sick dogs and cats the risks were 1.33 and explained by the patient population being
1.40%, respectively. healthy, surgery being elective, short proce
Peri‐operative mortality statistics are now dure times, and surgeons who are specialized
available for dogs and cats undergoing spay or in these surgical procedures. In both dogs and
castration in a high‐volume setting. Medical cats, mortality in males was less than in
records and mortality logs for 42 349 dogs and females, which may reflect the longer anesthe
71 557 cats that were neutered between 2010 sia times and more invasive surgery of the
latter. Community cats represented 76% (26/34)
of the feline deaths and for all feline deaths
Table 7.1 The American Society of (34), a likely reason or contributing factor was
Anesthesiologists (ASA) physical status classification
system with examples.
found in 13: upper respiratory tract disease
(n = 5), suspected diaphragmatic hernia
ASA
(n = 2), and pregnancy (n = 6).
physical Criteria
status Example
When Do Most Deaths Occur? (Brodbelt et al. 2008b). Due to their greater sur
face area to bodyweight ratio, smaller patients
The CEPSAF results reveal that most deaths
lose more body heat; the complications of
occur post‐operatively: in dogs, 47% of deaths
hypothermia are discussed later in the chapter.
occurred during this time and in cats the figure
Mask induction of anesthesia was found to
is 61%. Based on this study the most critical time
significantly increase mortality (a 5.9‐fold
appears to be the first three hours after the end
increase in risk compared to induction with an
of anesthesia. Despite the lower overall mortal
injectable agent followed by maintenance with
ity rate in the Levy et al. (2017) study, the timing
an inhalant agent; Brodbelt et al. 2008b). For
of death was similar to that reported by Brodbelt
this reason, either the use of pre‐medication
and colleagues: 21 of the 34 cat deaths (61%)
followed by induction of anesthesia with
occurred post‐operatively, with 20 occurring
injectable drugs, or an “all‐in‐one” injectable
prior to discharge and 1 after discharge, and all
induction technique is recommended. Inhalant
4 of the canine deaths occurred post‐operatively,
agents are potent cardiovascular and respira
with 2 (50%) before discharge and 2 after dis
tory depressant drugs and techniques to
charge. Of note was that 10 cats scheduled for
decrease their use are encouraged; this
surgery died pre‐operatively; this was during
includes pre‐medication with analgesics, seda
preparation, when patients may not have been
tives, and tranquilizers, and the use of local
as closely monitored as during surgery in the
analgesics.
operating room (Levy et al. 2017). This under
In the CEPSAF study increasing age was a
scores the recommendation that staff must be
risk factor in dogs, with dogs over 12 years of
vigilant at all times; close observation and mon
age having an odds ratio of 7 if dogs 6 months
itoring increase the likelihood of recognizing
to 8 years of age were used as a reference
problems and initiating rapid intervention.
point (Brodbelt et al. 2008b). However, breed
and weight were not accounted for, therefore it
What Are the Causes of Death? is difficult to interpret these results given the
In the CEPSAF study, an independent panel differences in life expectancy related to size. In
reviewed details of each anesthetic death and the study by Levy and others, patient age was
tried to ascertain a cause. Cardiovascular or res only available in the final year of the study
piratory causes accounted for 74 and 72% of (approximately 12% of dogs), but there was no
deaths in dogs and cats, respectively. Likely con difference in mortality between juveniles
tributing factors in cats in the spay and castration (<6 months of age) and adults in this sub‐set of
study were upper respiratory tract disease, sus dogs, suggesting that anesthesia at a young age
pected ruptured diaphragm, and pregnancy. As is not a risk factor.
in human anesthetic‐related deaths, human error
plays a role. For example, in the CEPSAF study, Cats
two dogs died after the adjustable pressure‐limit Overall the risk associated with anesthesia in cats
ing (APL or “pop‐off”) valve of the anesthetic is significantly higher than for dogs (Brodbelt
machine was left closed (Brodbelt et al. 2008a). et al. 2008a; Levy et al. 2017). Of particular inter
Safety equipment for preventing this accident est is the data showing that the risk in “healthy
will be discussed later in this chapter. cats” is greater than in “healthy dogs,” but mor
tality is similar in both species when they are
classified as “sick” (Brodbelt et al. 2007). This
Risk Factors
may be a result of some cats being more difficult
Dogs than dogs to examine leading to incorrect health
Dogs with lower bodyweights (<5 kg) may be at classification, or may be due to the presence of
increased risk of anesthetic‐related death difficult to detect or “silent” diseases.
130 7 Principles of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Safety, and Monitoring
One such reason for the higher risk in overdosing (Brodbelt et al. 2007). However,
“healthy” cats may be the presence of sub‐ mortality in juvenile cats (<6 months of age) is
clinical cardiac disease. In “overtly” or “appar no different to that of adult cats (Nutt et al.
ently” healthy cats, the incidence of 2016).
hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM) may be A surprising finding was that the use of
as high as 15% (Cote et al. 2004; Paige et al. intravenous (IV) fluids increased the risks of
2009), thus cats may be misclassified. However, death in both healthy and sick cats (Brodbelt
since cats with cardiac disease can appear clin et al. 2007). One reason may be inaccurate and
ically healthy and do not all have murmurs, it inappropriate fluid volume delivery. The blood
is difficult to detect or even suspect these volume in cats is smaller in cats than in
patients without echocardiography or N‐termi dogs – approximately 40–60 ml/kg compared
nal pro‐brain natriuretic peptide (NT‐proBNP) to 80–90 ml/kg in dogs – yet historically intra
testing (Oyama 2016), neither of which is eas operative fluid rates of 10 ml/kg/hour have
ily accessible in a HVHQSN or shelter setting. been recommended for both species (Raskin
The number of deaths from all respiratory 2009; Davis et al. 2013). If an apparently
causes were similar in dogs and cats (20 and healthy cat has underlying cardiac disease, it is
16%, respectively), but respiratory obstruction likely they cannot tolerate fluid loads. The
was reported more frequently in cats (Brodbelt 2013 American Animal Hospital Association
et al. 2008a). There are increased odds of death (AAHA) and American Association of Feline
associated with endotracheal intubation in Practitioners (AAFP) fluid therapy guidelines
cats that initially seem counterintuitive (Clarke suggest lower fluid rates than in the past (Davis
and Hall 1990; Brodbelt et al. 2007). However, et al. 2013).
the cat’s larynx is small and laryngospasm can
make intubation challenging, and it has been
suggested that trauma and resultant swelling Pre-anesthetic Evaluation
may contribute to post‐anesthetic obstruction.
Airway management is discussed later in this Ideally, pre‐anesthetic assessment includes
chapter. obtaining a history from the owner, a full phys
Body weights at either end of the spectrum ical examination and in some cases biochemi
(<2 kg or >6 kg) increased the risk of death in cal and hematologic analyses of blood, or other
cats (Brodbelt et al. 2007). Small cats may be screening tests such as a urinalysis. In some
susceptible to hypothermia and its associated cases a history and/or physical examination is
complications and may pose more challenges not obtainable (e.g. stray and feral animals).
related to intubation and monitoring. Heavy The animal’s temperament should be assessed
cats may be at increased risk of respiratory and recorded, as this will influence the choice
compromise (e.g. reduced diaphragmatic of anesthetic protocol; for example, unsocial
excursions due to abdominal and thoracic fat, ized animals will require an “all‐in‐one” tech
especially when placed in dorsal recumbency) nique whereby a single injection of a mix of
and excess tissue mass around the neck may drugs will render them unconscious, whereas
result in post‐operative obstruction. a calm and friendly adult dog may receive
Cats older than 12 years are twice as likely to acepromazine and an opioid followed by
die compared to cats aged 6 months to 5 years. induction of anesthesia with an IV agent.
This increased risk was independent of their An accurate bodyweight is desirable, espe
ASA status, and may be a result of decreased cially in very small animals, to ensure accurate
respiratory and cardiovascular reserve, or dosing of drugs, but in some cases the body
because older patients have decreased weight will only be estimated. When dealing
anesthetic requirements, leading to relative with community cats that will be trapped, one
Pre-anesthetic Evaluation 131
can weigh each trap in advance and write the a nimals may have a result that is outside this
weight of the trap clearly with a permanent range, which can delay the procedure or lead to
marker on the top of the trap; at intake, the further, sometimes unnecessary testing. A
trap with the cat can be weighed and the study of 1500 dogs stated that when no poten
weight of the cat calculated. tial issues were noted in the history or physical
examination, any abnormalities in the pre‐
operative blood work were usually of little clin
Assigning Health Status
ical significance and did not lead to any major
Assigning a patient’s health status is important changes in the anesthetic protocol (Alef et al.
for assessing peri‐operative risks, for determin 2008). The same study revealed that based on
ing which pre‐operative tests to perform, and pre‐anesthetic screening blood work, approxi
for choosing anesthetic drugs. Using a stand mately 8% of dogs were assigned a higher ASA
ardized assessment system also assists in status, surgery was delayed in 0.8%, additional
retrospective and prospective studies of peri‐ pre‐anesthetic treatment was undertaken in
operative morbidity and mortality. The recom 1.5%, and in 0.2% the anesthetic protocol was
mended system is based on the ASA physical changed. Hematologic and biochemical analy
status classification which has six categories; ses of 101 dogs aged over 7 years resulted in 30
in veterinary medicine we use statuses 1 new diagnoses (e.g. neoplasia, hyperadreno
through 5 because status 6 (anesthesia to corticism) and cancelation of surgery in 13 of
remove organs for donor purposes) is not these patients (Joubert 2007). When analyzing
applicable; see http://www.asahq.org/ risk factors for anesthetic death in sick dogs
standards‐and‐guidelines/asa‐physical‐status‐ (ASA 3–5), having a pre‐operative blood test
classification‐system and Table 7.1. was associated with reduced odds of death,
particularly in ASA category 4–5 dogs (Brodbelt
2006). In a UK veterinary practice where pre‐
Pre-anesthetic Blood Work
anesthesia blood tests in dogs and cats are
There is little disagreement that prior blood optional (owner decision), it was clear that cli
chemistry and hematologic analyses are valu ents opted in when their pet was older, with
able in some patient groups, but it is debated the mean age of dogs and cats undergoing
whether this can be justified for every patient, screening being 9.6 and 11.6 years, respectively
especially healthy animals undergoing elective (Davies and Kawaguchi 2014). This study
procedures. In many situations pre‐operative found that at least one blood test fell outside
blood work cannot be obtained, for example the reference range established for the clinic in
from non‐socialized cats. In other cases there 95 and 97% of dogs and cats, but was not neces
are economic constraints to performing screen sarily clinically significant. Clinicians voiced
ing tests or limited access to equipment for concern over blood results in approximately
analyses. Several studies in human anesthesi 8% of dogs and changed the anesthetic proto
ology question the need for pre‐anesthetic col in 4% of cases. In cats, concern was
laboratory testing in healthy patients and most expressed about the results in 15% of patients
conclude that pre‐operative testing is overused. and in 9% decisions about the anesthetic proto
When no abnormalities surface during history col were changed. In 1% of all cases, a problem
taking and clinical examination, there appears that was not suspected from the pet’s history or
to be little value in conducting pre‐anesthetic physical examination was uncovered and the
blood tests (Chung et al. 2009; Benarroch‐ authors concluded that pre‐anesthetic screen
Gampel et al. 2012). Reference ranges estab ing can be valuable for the management of
lished by laboratories usually incorporate 80% dogs and cats undergoing anesthesia (Davies
of the population, therefore 20% of healthy and Kawaguchi 2014).
132 7 Principles of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Safety, and Monitoring
Based on evidence from human anesthesia patient. This can be achieved with a combina
and from a smaller number of veterinary stud tion of carefully selected drugs, pheromones,
ies, there appears to be negligible benefit to and implementation of low‐stress and fear‐free
biochemical or hematologic screening in handling. See Chapter 6 for more information
apparently healthy animals (ASA 1–2). In ani about stress reduction in the spay–neuter clinic.
mals assigned a higher ASA status and in geri
atric patients it is more clear‐cut, with the Pheromones
published veterinary studies providing justifi Synthetic analogues of feline facial pheromone
cation that pre‐anesthetic screening is of value (FFP; Feliway®, Ceva Animal Health Care,
in terms of anesthetic management and out Libourne, France) are widely used to reduce
come. However, there is still no substitute for a stress and stress‐related problems in cats (Mills
thorough clinical examination by trained per et al. 2011). Handling and the process of anes
sonnel, and if pre‐anesthetic blood screening thesia may be stressful for cats due to the novel
and other tests are conducted they should be interventions they encounter, a strange envi
regarded as adjuncts, not alternatives to the ronment, and exposure to unknown animals
patient’s physical assessment. and personnel. Kronen and colleagues looked
at the benefits of FFP (sprayed on cage paper
before placing the cat in the cage) in the pre‐
Components of Anesthesia
anesthetic period and reported that it had addi
tional calming effects in cats that received
Pre-medication
acepromazine and helped calm cats that had
The goals of pre‐medication include sedation not received acepromazine (Kronen et al.
of the patient to facilitate handling and reduce 2006). FFP has also been reported to increase
stress, provision of preventive analgesia, and food consumption and grooming behavior in
reduction of the dose of anesthetic agents. cats (Griffith et al. 2000). Pheromone therapy,
Attainment of these goals is associated with a including dog‐appeasing pheromone (Adaptil®,
decrease in the risk of anesthetic‐related death Ceva Animal Health) may have a role to play in
(Brodbelt 2009), and may be accomplished a shelter or HVHQSN environment.
with sedatives, tranquilizers, and opioids,
administered either alone or in combination. Gabapentin and Trazodone
In most cases pre‐medicant drugs are given Gabapentin (50 or 100 mg per cat) adminis
intramuscularly (IM), but some are suitable for tered in a suspension (Ora‐Plus suspending
administration by the subcutaneous (SC; e.g. vehicle and Ora‐Sweet flavored syrup vehicle,
acepromazine) or oral transmucosal route (e.g. Perrigo®, Dublin, Ireland, in a 50 : 50 ratio) to
dexmedetomidine in cats; Slingsby et al. 2009). community cats after trapping decreased their
If IV access is easy to achieve or an IV catheter fear responses when compared to placebo
is in place, most pre‐medicant drugs can be treatment (Pankratz et al. 2018). After weigh
given by this route at reduced doses. ing the cats, the dose used ranged from 9.2 to
47.6 mg/kg. Peak effect occurred two hours
after administration, but there were no differ
Stress Reduction
ences in sedation scores between gabapentin‐
Stress, fear, and anxiety should be minimized as and placebo‐treated cats.
much as possible in the peri‐operative period, as Trazodone is a serotonin (5‐HT) antagonist/
this may alleviate negative physiologic changes, reuptake inhibitor and is classified as an “atypi
including tachycardia, hypertension, ileus, and cal” antidepressant. Favorable results have
increased circulating catecholamines, and been published on its use for decreasing behav
enhance the overall emotional experience of the ioral signs of stress in hospitalized dogs and for
Components of Anesthesia 133
Pre-oxygenation
Recovery
Pre‐oxygenation is recommended in compro
mised patients, brachycephalic breeds, obese As highlighted by the results of the CEPSAF
patients, and pregnant animals, as these situa study and the data from a high‐volume spay
tions involve animals with limited respiratory and castration clinic, the recovery period is
reserves or an anticipated difficult intubation. when most anesthetic mortalities occur
If a healthy dog breathing room air prior to (Brodbelt 2009; Levy et al. 2017). It is highly
induction becomes apneic, the dog will desatu recommended that patients recovering from
rate – peripheral capillary oxygen saturation anesthesia are closely observed for at least
(SpO2) 90%, partial pressure of oxygen (PaO2) three hours. If sufficient staff are available, a
60 mmHg – within 69.6 ± 10.6 seconds, and dedicated recovery area should be set up where
in some cases within 30 seconds. For the same staff are always present. If this is not possible,
animal breathing oxygen via a face mask for a recovery area can be set up in an area of the
3 minutes prior to induction, this time is clinic where people are always present who
extended to 297.8 ± 42 seconds, a difference of may be performing several tasks, including
almost 4 minutes (McNally et al. 2009). observing recovering patients – this is not
134 7 Principles of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Safety, and Monitoring
interactive visual analogue scale (DIVAS). tool (Holton et al. 2001). The original tool has
With this system, animals are first observed been shortened to give it utility in a busy clini
undisturbed and from a distance. The reason cal setting (Reid et al. 2007; Murrell et al. 2008).
for this is that some animals do not display This tool is available for download from http://
overt pain behaviors in the presence of a car w w w. n e w m e t r i c a . c o m / a c u t e ‐ p a i n ‐
egiver, but may do so when they think they are measurement. The categories for assessment
unobserved; this is likely a protective mecha include vocalization, attention to the wound,
nism against potential “predators.” Following mobility on rising, response to palpation of the
the initial observation, the assessor approaches, wound or painful area, posture, and overall
handles the patient, and encourages it to move demeanor.
around; the surgical incision (or injured area)
and surrounding area is palpated, and a final Cats
overall assessment of pain is made. This Brondani and colleagues (Brondani et al. 2011,
approach overcomes some of the deficiencies 2013) created a multidimensional composite
of purely observational systems; for example, an scale by observing cats undergoing ovariohys
animal in pain may remain very still and quiet terectomy. Brondani and colleagues have
because they are in pain and would be over created a website with videos that demonstrate
looked and untreated without an interaction. the behaviors in their tool, as well as cases to
It is now accepted that quantitative measure test yourself and a download link (http://www.
ments of behavior are the most reliable methods animalpain.com.br/en‐us). This is an excellent
for assessing pain in animals, and that if the resource for staff training.
methodology used to develop and validate these Another tool is the Glasgow Composite
systems is rigorous, they can be objective, with Measures Pain Scale‐Feline (rCMPS‐Feline),
minimal observer bias (Holton et al. 2001). which includes facial expressions (Calvo et al.
Multidimensional systems are particularly 2014; Holden et al. 2014; Reid et al. 2017). This
important when self‐reporting is not possible. tool was developed using cats undergoing dif
They must incorporate components that have ferent types of surgery or with medically
been proven to be sensitive and specific indica related pain. English and Spanish versions are
tors of pain in the species being studied. available for download from http://www.
Knowledge of the normal behavior of a species newmetrica.com/acute‐pain‐measurement.
and the individual being evaluated is important, There are seven assessments (questions) in
as deviations from normal behavior may sug the Glasgow acute pain scale:
gest pain, anxiety, fear, or other stressors.
1) Vocalization
Normal behaviors should be maintained post‐
2) Posture
operatively if an animal is comfortable.
3) Attention to the wound
Grooming is a normal behavior, but licking
4) Interaction with people
excessively at a wound or incision can be an
5) Response to palpation of the wound or
indicator of pain, so the two should be differen
painful area
tiated. The occurrence of new behaviors such as
6) Facial expressions
a previously friendly animal becoming aggres
7) Overall demeanor
sive, or a playful and friendly animal becoming
reclusive, should raise our suspicion that pain The maximum score a cat can achieve is 20,
may not have been adequately addressed. and intervention is suggested with a score of 5.
A feline grimace scale is currently being
Dogs developed and shows promise for ease of use,
In dogs, the Glasgow Composite Measure Pain validity, reliability, and inter‐ and intraobserver
Scale (GCMPS) is a reliable and widely used agreement (Evangelista et al. 2018).
136 7 Principles of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Safety, and Monitoring
TIP OF
result in rebreathing. After measuring the
SHOULDER INCISORS ETT, it should be cut to the correct length
(Figure 7.2). Figure 7.3 shows placement of an
ETT that was excessively long in a puppy and
Figure 7.4 shows the tube after it was cut.
Tracheal injury related to intubation is well
documented in cats (Hardie et al. 1999;
Mitchell et al. 2000; Bhandal and Kuzma 2008;
Bauer et al. 2009), as is damage to the larynx
(Hofmeister et al. 2007). Approximately
70–75% of tracheal ruptures reported are in
cats that have undergone dental procedures.
Figure 7.2 The endotracheal tube should reach Presenting signs include subcutaneous emphy
form the incisors to the point of the shoulder. If it sema, coughing, gagging, and varying severity
is too long, cut at the appropriate site (black mark
on the tube). of dyspnea occurring any time from 4 hours to
12 days post‐anesthesia.
In a cadaveric model, Hardie and others
(Hardie et al. 1999) documented that overin
flation of the cuff is the cause of tears in cats
and that they occur directly over the cuff. One
theory is that cuffs are overinflated due to a
fear of aspiration, especially when perform
ing dental and other oral procedures. Larger
tears are more difficult to repair or medically
manage; therefore, the choice of ETT should
be made with care. Two different types of
cuffs are available on ETTs: one is a low‐
volume, high‐pressure cuff and the other
is a high‐volume, low‐pressure cuff. High‐
Figure 7.3 In this image, there is excessive dead volume, low‐pressure cuffs have a larger con
space because the endotracheal tube is excessively
tact area with the tracheal wall and, because
long.
tears occur directly over the cuff, they will be
longer than with low‐volume, high‐pressure
cuffs. The cuff should only be inflated if
necessary; this is contrary to the common
technique of routinely inflating every cuff
immediately after intubation. The seal can be
tested by occluding the APL valve (the “pop‐
off”) and squeezing the reservoir bag – air is
added in small increments to the cuff until
there is no leak at 15 cmH2O. As an added
safety measure, a small (1 ml or 3 ml) syringe
should be used to restrict the volume of air
that can be added to the cuff. The use of
water‐soluble gel on the cuff improves the air
Figure 7.4 Dead space has been decreased by way seal, even at low cuff inflation pressures
shortening the endotracheal tube. (Blunt et al. 2001). Oxygen masks and
Fluid Therapy 139
s upraglottic airway devices (SGADs) are alter v entilation must always be available for emer
natives to cuffed ETTs in cats; their use will gency use; this includes a range of ETT sizes, a
depend on the conformation of the cat (e.g. laryngoscope, Ambu bag, or anesthesia
brachycephalic), and the type and duration of machine, and a source of oxygen. See
the procedure. Chapter 11 for details on emergency proce
One SGAD (Cat v‐gel®, Docsinnovent Ltd., dures and cardiopulmonary resuscitation.
London, UK; Figure 7.5) has been designed to
conform to the shape of the feline larynx and
pharynx and has undergone clinical assess Fluid Therapy
ment (Crotaz 2013; van Oostrom et al. 2013;
Barletta et al. 2015; Prasse et al. 2016). This A cost– and time–benefit analysis of IV fluid
device rests over the laryngeal inlet and the tip administration sets and IV catheter use should
lodges in the esophageal opening. There was be made based on the procedure being per
less stridor and greater food consumption in formed. Healthy adult and pediatric patients
the immediate recovery period after use of an do not necessarily require fluids during short,
SGAD compared to an ETT (van Oostrom et al. elective surgical procedures that are associated
2013; Barletta et al. 2015). In spontaneously with minimal blood loss; one study reported
breathing cats there was no difference in the no differences in blood pressure in healthy
measured isoflurane concentration at the dogs undergoing elective surgical procedures
mouth when ETTs and SGADs were compared with or without IV fluids (Gaynor et al. 1996).
(van Oostrom et al. 2013). During mechanical However, clinics should have the ability to
ventilation up to an airway pressure of 16 administer fluids in specific cases on an as‐
cmH2O, there was less leakage with an SGAD needed basis, for example pregnant animals
than an ETT (Prasse et al. 2016). Inexperienced undergoing ovariohysterectomy or cesarean
veterinary students were able to secure an air section, dehydrated or compromised animals,
way more quickly and with fewer attempts and in cases where significant blood loss may
when they used an SGAD instead of an ETT be anticipated (e.g. limb amputation or enu
and less propofol was required with the former cleation surgery). When intraoperative IV flu
device (Barletta et al. 2015). ids are used, the appropriate dose should be
If intubation is not routinely performed, administered. The 2013 AAHA and AAFP
equipment for emergency intubation and fluid therapy guidelines suggest lower doses
than in the past, for example 5 ml/kg/hour in
healthy dogs, with a 25% reduction in rate
every hour (Davis et al. 2013).
As previously discussed, the use of IV fluids
was associated with an increased risk of mor
tality in healthy and sick cats (Brodbelt et al.
2007). Although confounding factors should
be considered (i.e. those cats receiving IV flu
ids may have been at greater anesthetic risk to
begin with), these findings warrant reassess
ment of fluid therapy protocols in anesthetized
cats. As previously discussed, the blood vol
ume of cats is approximately 60 ml/kg com
pared to 80–90 ml/kg in dogs (Raskin 2009).
Figure 7.5 A supraglottic airway device
specifically designed for cats. The side port is The 2013 AAHA and AAFP Fluid Therapy
attached to a side-stream capnograph. Guidelines for Dogs and Cats suggest 3 ml/kg/hr
140 7 Principles of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Safety, and Monitoring
Equipment
Safety Equipment
A complete review of anesthetic and monitor A patient safety incident is one that causes
ing equipment is outside the scope of this injury or is potentially harmful to the patient.
chapter and can be found elsewhere (Shelby Many of these events are caused by human
and McKune 2014; Robertson et al. 2018), but error and are preventable (Hofmeister et al.
specific and pertinent points related to anes 2014).
thetic principles will be addressed. All anesthesia machines should be fitted
with an in‐circuit manometer and a device to
prevent high airway pressures occurring,
Oxygen Supply
which can cause barotrauma (Robertson et al.
Traditionally, most veterinary clinics have 2018). A manometer is essential for safely
used oxygen cylinders or bulk tanks of liquid delivering manual breaths or if a mechanical
oxygen as their source of oxygen for anesthesia ventilator is used; the pressure should never
machines. A feasible alternative are oxygen exceed 20 cmH2O and a range of 12–16 cmH2O
concentrators, which are commercially availa is usually adequate for delivering a normal
ble as small portable units. An oxygen concen tidal volume (10–15 ml/kg) to a patient. The
trator uses room air (21% oxygen) to produce a manometer is also required when checking for
gas that contains 95% oxygen, which is compa leaks around an ETT (Figure 7.6).
rable to medical‐grade oxygen supplied in cyl One potentially lethal accident is leaving the
inders (Barrand 2011). Oxygen concentrators APL valve (“pop‐off”) closed, which results in
require a power source, but can be run off a a rapid rise in airway pressure and risk of baro
power inverter (Barrand 2011). The advantages trauma and cardiac arrest – this occurs very
include cost savings after the initial outlay, quickly (<30 seconds) in small patients on a
minimal maintenance, and an “on demand” non‐rebreathing system. In a university teach
source of oxygen. Investing in this equipment ing hospital, patient safety incidents were
will result in long‐term cost savings and may recorded over a 11.5‐month period; approxi
be ideal for mobile or MASH (mobile animal mately 26% of incidents were due to closed
sterilization hospital) clinics. APL valves. After this finding, a checklist was
Body Temperature 141
Figure 7.7 A pop-off safety relief valve; this opens Body Temperature
at a preset pressure to relieve patient circuit
pressure and prevent barotrauma. Maintaining normothermia is important for
cardiac function, metabolism, normal enzyme
implemented to include checking that the APL activity, nerve conduction, hemostasis, pre
valve was open before attaching a patient to venting post‐operative wound infections, and
the anesthesia machine. After this interven improving post‐operative comfort, and is an
tion, problems were logged again and the inci important goal of anesthetic management.
dence of closed APL valves dropped to 16% Hypothermia occurs commonly in dogs and
(Hofmeister et al. 2014). By adding a pop‐off cats that undergo anesthesia and the conse
safety relief valve or a pop‐off occlusion valve quences are greatly underestimated (Evans
to every anesthesia machine, the occurrence of et al. 1973; Waterman 1975; Pottie et al. 2007;
this accident should be minimal, but it requires Redondo et al. 2012a, b). In humans, peri‐anes
that the safety devices themselves are checked, thetic hypothermia is linked to increased mor
as they can malfunction. A pop‐off safety relief tality. In veterinary medicine, studies show
valve is shown in Figure 7.7; these automati that cats weighing less than 2 kg, dogs under
cally relieve patient circuit pressure by open 5 kg, senior patients, and those undergoing
ing at a preset pressure (e.g. 20 cmH2O). long procedures have a greater peri‐operative
142 7 Principles of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Safety, and Monitoring
mortality risk (Brodbelt et al. 2007, 2008b); processes that drive the mechanisms control
hypothermia is likely in these patient popula ling heat loss or gain in the correct direction.
tions. It is important to identify at‐risk patients Temperature sensors exist centrally (hypothal
and understand why animals become cold, the amus, spinal cord, brain stem, abdominal
adverse effects of low body temperatures, and organs, and skeletal muscles) and peripherally
current options for the prevention and treat (warm and cold receptors in the skin). The
ment of peri‐operative hypothermia. hypothalamus acts by integrating thermal
input and controlling effector organs, in many
ways acting as a thermostat. Heat gains can be
Thermoregulation
obligatory or facultative. Obligatory gains
The body is divided into two compartments: occur independently of thermoregulation and
the core, containing the most metabolically include heat from basal metabolism, eating,
active organs; and the periphery, which acts as and exercise. Facultative gains act to restore
a buffer between the external environment and thermal balance; the most important source is
the core. Thermoreceptors in the skin, the from shivering. In animals, over 75% of heat
hypothalamus, and other areas of the body losses occur from the body surface, with the
provide feedback to the posterior hypothala remainder coming from the respiratory tract.
mus, which regulates body temperature. In a When an animal is anesthetized, many
conscious animal, temperature is tightly factors interrupt normal thermoregulation.
controlled to within an inter‐threshold range Anesthesia abolishes behavioral responses – for
of ±0.2 °C (Clark‐Price 2015). This is accom example, the animal cannot no longer seek out
plished via behavioral responses, changes in a warm environment. Anesthesia also reduces
body metabolism and blood flow to the skin, the metabolic rate, alters hypothalamic func
and shivering or panting. tion, and reduces muscle tone and effector
Heat loss occurs by four main mechanisms: responses (shivering). In addition, operating
room environments and surgical procedures
Conductive heat loss is the transfer of heat
(exposure of body cavities) impose large ther
from a warmer object to a cooler one when
mal losses on patients. In anesthetized patients,
they are in direct contact with each other.
the inter‐threshold range increases to ±2.5 °C
An example is an animal lying directly on a
and mechanisms to stem heat loss do not come
cold stainless‐steel table.
into play until there is a significant drop in
Convective heat loss occurs when warm air
body temperature.
next to the body is displaced by cool air
Anesthesia‐induced hypothermia (AIH) can
(“wind chill”). An example is placing the
be divided into three phases. In phase 1 there is
animal near an air vent or in a draft.
redistribution of heat from the core to the
Radiative heat losses occur due to infrared
periphery. This phase begins as soon as animals
emission from an object to cooler surround
are pre‐medicated, due to direct effects on cen
ings. One example is housing an animal in a
tral (hypothalamic) thermoregulation by seda
cold room.
tives, tranquilizers, and opioids; in addition,
Evaporative heat losses occur when liquids
peripheral vasodilation associated with the use
change to vapors, taking heat with them.
of acepromazine increases heat loss from the
Examples include evaporation of moisture
body surface. After induction of anesthesia
from exposed serosal surfaces and the res
there is loss of autonomic control and anes
piratory tract, and evaporation of alcohol or
thetic agents such as propofol and inhalant
other liquids used to prepare surgical sites.
anesthetics cause vasodilation. Heat loss in
Homeothermy, the balance between heat phase 1 is primarily via conduction and convec
loss and heat gain, involves complex sensing tion, which account for up to 80% of total heat
Body Temperature 143
loss. Body temperature can drop quickly, with associated with longer anesthesia, major ver
the greatest rate of heat loss occurring in the sus minor procedures, and increasing ASA
first 20 minutes following induction; in one status (Redondo et al. 2012a). Other studies in
study, cats’ temperatures fell on average by cats showed a correlation between duration of
1.2 °C during the first hour of anesthesia anesthesia and severity of heat loss (Kelly et al.
(Redondo et al. 2012a). The second phase of 2012). In a review of 1525 canine anesthesia
AIH is a continued but slower loss of heat records, the prevalence of hypothermia at the
to the cooler surrounding environment. end of the procedure was mild 51.5%, moder
Additional losses occur by evaporation from ate 29.3%, and severe 2.8% (Redondo et al.
exposed serosal surfaces and via the respiratory 2012b). Factors that were related to a greater
tract; respiratory losses are increased when the drop in temperature included the time from
animal is breathing cold, dry oxygen and/or pre‐medication to induction of anesthesia,
inhalant agents. Heat production is also duration of anesthesia, physical status, type of
reduced due to a decrease in metabolic rate procedure, and body surface area.
caused by anesthesia. The third phase of AIH is
termed the plateau phase and typically occurs
Physiologic Effects of Hypothermia
after three hours of anesthesia. The plateau
occurs due to two mechanisms: first, although Hypothermia causes changes in metabolism,
reduced from normal, the animal’s heat pro coagulation, and cardiovascular function
duction begins to exceed heat losses; and sec (heart rate and rhythm), increases the likeli
ond, the lower end of the inter‐threshold range hood of wound infection, and contributes to
is reached, triggering autonomic responses to patient discomfort during recovery. Recovery
preserve heat such as vasoconstriction. is delayed in hypothermic patients due to
decreased metabolism and elimination of
injectable anesthetic agents (Pottie et al. 2007).
Which Patients Are at Risk?
Inhalant agents are more soluble in blood at
Every patient undergoing general anesthesia is lower than normal temperature, and this, com
at risk for developing hypothermia. In the bined with a decrease in anesthetic require
CEPSAF study, overall mortality rates in dogs ments in these patients, can lead to a relative
and cats were 0.17 and 0.24%, respectively, but anesthetic overdose and prolonged recovery
cats weighing less than 2 kg, dogs under 5 kg, times. Return of spontaneous respiration is
and older animals were at increased risk delayed by hypothermia. In dogs anesthetized
(Brodbelt et al. 2008b). Duration of anesthesia for neutering, the esophageal temperature at
increases the risk of mortality; Brodbelt and the end of the procedure had a significant
colleagues (Brodbelt et al. 2008b) showed an impact on recovery times (Pottie et al. 2007).
increased risk when duration of anesthesia Normothermic dogs (>38.0 °C) assumed ster
exceeded 1.5 hours and this may be related to nal recumbency in a mean of 7.7 ± 3.8 minutes
hypothermia. In a review of 275 feline anesthe (time from turning off the vaporizer to extuba
sia cases, Redondo and colleagues (Redondo tion), whereas those that were between 35.0
et al. 2012a) reported that at the end of the pro and 35.4 °C took 23.4 ± 22.1 minutes (Pottie
cedure mild hypothermia was present in 26.5% et al. 2007).
of cats, moderate hypothermia in 60.4%, and Blood loss increases in hypothermic patients,
severe hypothermia in 10.5%. No mortalities and this effect is well documented in humans.
occurred in normothermic cats (38.5–39.5 °C), Blood viscosity is increased and coagulopa
whereas the mortality index (%) was 6.89 in thies occur due to inhibition of platelet func
severely hypothermic cats (<34.0 °C). In this tion, platelet sequestration, and diminished
study the greatest drops in temperature were enzymatic activity in the clotting cascade. In
144 7 Principles of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Safety, and Monitoring
dogs, clot formation takes longer in hypother cats post‐operatively (Brodbelt et al. 2007).
mic blood, but the clots formed are equivalent Sites for temperature monitoring include the
in strength to clots formed in normothermic rectum, ear, and esophagus. Rectal or auricular
blood (Taggart et al. 2012). readings are affected by perfusion at the site of
The correlation between wound infection monitoring, local inflammation, and fecal
and hypothermia is well documented in material. Although auricular readings are
humans. Several factors contribute to this, quick to obtain, one study in cats reported poor
including impairment of the immune response, correlation between auricular and rectal tem
cutaneous vasoconstriction, and local tissue perature when readings were taken with a vet
hypoxia. Leukocyte phagocytosis, antibody erinary‐specific infrared thermometer (Kunkle
production, and cytokine production also et al. 2004). Another investigator observed
decrease as body temperature drops. In dogs good agreement when an auricular thermom
and cats, wound infection has been linked to eter designed for humans was used in cats
the duration of anesthesia, and again hypo (Sousa et al. 2013); however, in an earlier
thermia may play a contributing role (Beal paper, the authors reported discordance
et al. 2000; Eugster et al. 2004). between the two sites when similar equipment
Severe hypothermia causes bradycardia, was used in dogs (Sousa et al. 2011). Esophageal
decreased cardiac output, and hypotension. temperature probes can be used in anesthe
Catecholamine levels are increased in tized patients to provide an estimate of core
hypothermia, as is cardiac irritability. temperature and should be placed in the distal
Bradyarrhythmias such as atrioventricular third of the esophagus. In order to track trends,
block are common and ventricular fibrillation it is best to choose one site and one device and
and asystole can occur. The usual intervention use these consistently.
to treat bradycardia is to administer atropine or Because rectal and auricular measurements
glycopyrrolate, but in hypothermic patients are invasive, time consuming, and stressful to
the heart is less responsive to these drugs many animals and may result in cross‐contam
(Cookson and DiPalma 1955). ination, non‐contact infrared thermometry is
During recovery, shivering increases meta attractive in a shelter setting. However, in cats,
bolic oxygen consumption and can lead to different devices and recording sites failed to
hypoxemia and metabolic acidosis. Intraocular provide reliable results (Nutt et al. 2016).
and intracranial pressures are increased and
discomfort results from muscle rigidity and
Prevention and Treatment
movement around surgical incisions. Humans
describe feeling cold and shivering as extremely Because of the many negative effects of hypo
unpleasant in the immediate recovery period. thermia, steps should be taken to recognize,
In newborn babies, warmth is an effective non‐ prevent, and treat it. In humans, pre‐warming
pharmacologic analgesic technique during with forced air warming of skin for 10–20 minutes
painful procedures such as vaccination (Gray before general anesthesia is documented to
et al. 2012). significantly reduce the incidence of hypother
mia and post‐operative shivering (Horn et al.
2012). The goal of this technique is to increase
Temperature Monitoring
the peripheral temperature, thereby minimiz
Body temperature is not always closely moni ing redistribution hypothermia (phase 1),
tored or recorded in anesthetized patients; which occurs after pre‐medication and induc
therefore, hypothermia often goes undetected. tion of anesthesia. Although a similar study
In one study, temperature was recorded in only has not been published in small dogs or cats,
1–2% of cats during surgery and in 11–15% of placing dogs weighing 10 kg in an incubator
Body Temperature 145
before induction of anesthesia had no positive undergoing similar procedures and duration of
effect on peri‐operative hypothermia or post‐ anesthesia. The dogs placed on the heated mat
operative shivering (Rigotti et al. 2015; Aarnes had a higher nadir and end‐of‐procedure tem
et al. 2017). perature (Kibanda and Gurney 2012). A patient
Warming techniques can be divided into two simulation study using the HotDog system
types: passive and active. Passive warming showed that heating is not uniform across the
methods include the use of blankets, bubble entire blanket: 95% of the time test sites did not
wrap, reflective blankets, and placing socks reach the set temperature on the control unit,
over limbs to minimize heat loss to the and in 2.3% of readings exceeded it (McCarthy
environment. Warmer ambient temperatures et al. 2018). These authors warn that hyper
in the patient preparation areas, operating thermic injury may be possible with this tech
rooms, and recovery areas also decrease nology along with inefficient and uneven
patient–environment temperature gradients. warming. It is common for fluid (e.g. lavage
Active warming methods include circulating solutions, urine) to accumulate between the
warm water blankets, forced air warmers, or patient and blanket in clinical scenarios; when
heating mats made from conductive fabric. saline was used in the simulator model to
Circulating warm water blankets are often mimic this, blanket temperatures became sig
placed under animals during surgery. These nificantly lower, therefore the anesthetist
blankets have been employed in various ways: should ensure good patient–blanket contact
in one study warm water blankets were placed and remove accumulated fluid.
over, under, or around the feet of dogs, and the Warmed rice bags, heated fluid‐filled bags,
latter position was most effective at reducing and hot water bottles are popular, but must be
heat loss (Cabell et al. 1997). These blankets used with caution as they can cause thermal
are less popular in the recovery areas as they burns. In addition, these devices cool quickly
are often punctured by claws and nails. Forced to room temperature and will then draw heat
warm air devices (e.g. 3M™ Bair Hugger™ from the patient, defeating their purpose.
Therapy, 3M, St Paul, MN; WarmTouch™, Thermal burns can also occur with the use of
Covidien, Boulder, CO; Thermacare® Warming electric blankets, infrared lamps, and a forced
System, Stryker, Portage, MI) can minimize warm air device hose without attaching it to a
heat loss in anesthetized cats (Machon et al. diffusion blankets.
1999) and are widely used in veterinary medi Additional areas where small changes in
cine. These work best if they are used continu protocol can help mitigate heat losses include
ously from the time of pre‐medication until the use of warm preparation solutions for
animals are returned to their cages or kennels. cleansing the surgical site, and removing any
However, when resources are limited, a single excess solution from the animal.
unit can be used to rewarm multiple animals at The use of warm IV fluids has been advo
once during recovery (Figure 7.1). In dogs, a cated, but at the administration rates used and
forced warm air device was superior to a circu the duration of most elective procedures, this
lating warm water blanket in minimizing AIH intervention will not have a significant influ
(Clark‐Price et al. 2013). ence on body temperature. There was no
Heating blankets made from semi‐conduc difference in body temperatures in cats
tive polymeric fabric are available (HotDog®, undergoing ovariohysterectomy when a non‐
Augustine Temperature Management, Eden rebreathing circuit and a pediatric circle
Prairie, MN). These blankets come in different system were compared (Kelly et al. 2012).
sizes, are flexible, reusable, and durable. In Proprietary data shows that a heated breathing
dogs, this device was compared to a forced circuit specially designed to attach to all stand
warm air system in dogs of similar weight and ard anesthesia machines reduces heat loss
146 7 Principles of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Safety, and Monitoring
from the respiratory tract (DarvallVet, Gladesville, c irculatory function (by palpating and assess
NSW, Australia). These two pieces of equip ing pulse rate, rhythm, and quality, or using a
ment are unlikely to be a good investment for a blood pressure monitor), oxygenation (by
shelter or HVHQSN clinic. assessing mucus membrane color or using a
Peri‐operative hypothermia is a common pulse oximeter), ventilation (by observation of
complication of general anesthesia in small the patient’s respiratory rate and pattern or use
animal patients. By keeping procedure times to of a capnograph), and body temperature is
a minimum and using simple measures to pre vital to patient safety.
vent and treat hypothermia, patient comfort Dyson and colleagues showed the value of
will be improved and morbidity and mortality trained personnel in veterinary medicine: the
decreased. presence of a technician whose primary focus
was anesthetic management of the patient sig
nificantly reduced the odds of a complication
Monitoring occurring (Dyson et al. 1998); the value of
trained personnel is also emphasized in the
A monitor can be described as an instrument ASV 2016 Veterinary Medical Care Guidelines
or device used for observing, checking, or for Spay–Neuter Programs (Griffin et al. 2016).
keeping a continuous record. The verb “to The Academy of Veterinary Technicians in
monitor” means to observe and check the pro Anesthesia and Analgesia is the organization
gress or quality of something over a period of that oversees specialization in this discipline,
time. Monitors extend the human senses, but with a rigorous application and examination
do not replace them. As such, a monitor can process (www.avtaa‐vts.org). Many veterinary
only warn the user of an adverse event; it can conferences have lectures and laboratory
not intervene. Initiating a response remains a sessions dedicated to improving the skills of
vital function of the person in charge of a veterinary technicians that are charged with
patient’s anesthetic event. It is imperative that overseeing a patients’ anesthesia care. The
practitioners understand the data the monitors AAHA anesthesia guidelines for dogs and cats
display and what to do when an abnormality toolkit is an excellent resource and includes
arises. Much of the reduction in anesthetic anesthesia staff training questionnaires
patient mortality in humans is a result of better (http://www.aaha.org/professional/resources/
anesthetic drugs, equipment, and monitoring anesthesia.aspx).
devices, yet an intraoperative incident still The study spearheaded by Brodbelt (Brodbelt
occurs in 1 out of 10 of patients (Haller et al. et al. 2007) is the first time that the value of
2011) and these events are primarily due to monitoring has been shown to save lives in vet
human error, underscoring the importance of erinary medicine: monitoring the pulse and
the anesthesia team members in delivery of using a pulse oximeter significantly reduced
safe anesthesia to patients. mortality in cats, although the same advan
The American College of Veterinary tages could not be statistically demonstrated in
Anesthesia and Analgesia has developed small dogs. It is well worth investing time in learning
animal monitoring guidelines (http://www. how best to utilize a pulse oximeter; one study
acvaa.org/docs/Small_Animal_ indicated that the best site for probe placement
Monitoring_2009.doc). The ASV also includes in cats is the rear paw (Matthews et al. 2003).
suggestions for monitoring anesthetized This is an ideal site when performing oral
patients in its guidelines for spay and neuter procedures or if a cat is not intubated but
programs (Griffin et al. 2016). Monitoring of receiving oxygen via face mask. Fluorescent
the depth of anesthesia (by assessing jaw tone, and operating room lights can interfere with
eye position, and reflexes), adequacy of the light‐emitting diode of the probe and
Conclusions 147
s ensor; therefore, it is recommended to place a ensure things are done in a consistent manner
barrier (e.g. a gauze sponge) over the probe despite turnover of staff. For example, anesthe
after it is placed on the patient to prevent this. sia machines should be checked prior to each
When selecting a monitor, it is important to use; excellent downloadable check lists
choose one which has a good audible signal, for are available (http://www.abbottanimalhealth.
example a pulse oximeter or Doppler ultrasonic com/veterinary‐professionals/education/
flow detector, because personnel respond more anesthesia/tools.html) and these can be lami
rapidly to a change in sound than to a visual dis nated and attached to the machine.
play. In addition, in a busy setting where multi Perhaps one of the biggest mistakes we can
tasking is common, it is not possible to observe make in clinical medicine is not to learn from
a visual display at all times. Another inexpen our previous mistakes. Based on how the avia
sive monitoring device is an esophageal stetho tion industry has dealt with “critical incidents,”
scope, which allows heart rate and respiratory the medical profession is also seeing the bene
rate to be auscultated; this can be checked fre fits of SOPs, checklists, clinical guidelines,
quently by personnel or attached to an audible improved specialty training, teamwork, and
amplification and visual (flashing red light) out communication (Haller et al. 2011; Arriaga
put device for continuous assessment (APM et al. 2013). When surgical‐crisis checklists
Audible Patient Monitor, A.M. Bickford, Inc., were available, only 6% of life‐saving steps
New York, www.ambickford.com). were missed during a crisis such as a cardiac
arrest, compared to 23% when checklists were
unavailable (Arriaga et al. 2013). Each clinic
Record Keeping should develop specific SOPs and checklists
that are relevant to its practice. Ready‐to‐use
Anesthesia records must be kept for legal pur checklists that span the time from pre‐induction
poses and to help advance our understanding to recovery are available from the AVA (https://
of risks associated with anesthesia, as was ava.eu.com).
done with the valuable CEPSAF study. The Incident reporting is also important for
legal requirements vary between countries and improving patient safety (Mahajan 2010).
within the United States from state to state. When an adverse event occurs in a clinic there
Veterinarians are responsible for knowing are lessons to be learned; the incident should
what the requirements for record keeping in be documented in detail and carefully ana
their locale are and adhering to or ideally lyzed during a debrief so that protocols can be
exceeding these. The AAHA has a comprehen adjusted to prevent the same incident in the
sive yet user‐friendly sedation and anesthesia future.
form for purchase. The Association of
Veterinary Anaesthetists (AVA) based in
Europe has various anesthesia and monitoring Conclusions
forms and checklists available for download at
no cost (https://ava.eu.com). Anesthesia and analgesia are key components
to the success of a shelter’s spay and neuter
program. Anesthesia must be time and cost
Use of Standard Operating efficient and associated with a low morbidity
Procedures and Checklists and mortality rate. When appropriate anes
thetic protocols are used that include multi
Standard operating procedures (SOPs) should modal analgesia, along with close monitoring
be embraced in clinical practice: they improve by trained personnel and attention to detail,
safety, compliance, and accountability and these goals can be achieved.
148 7 Principles of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Safety, and Monitoring
References
Aarnes, T.K., Bednarski, R.M., Lerche, P., and Brodbelt, D. (2009). Perioperative mortality in
Hubbell, J.A. (2017). Effect of pre‐warming on small animal anaesthesia. Vet. J. 182: 152–161.
perioperative hypothermia and anesthetic Brodbelt, D.C., Pfeiffer, D.U., Young, L.E., and
recovery in small breed dogs undergoing Wood, J.L. (2007). Risk factors for anaesthetic‐
ovariohysterectomy. Can. Vet. J. 58: 175–179. related death in cats: results from the
Alef, M., von Praun, F., and Oechtering, G. confidential enquiry into perioperative small
(2008). Is routine pre‐anaesthetic animal fatalities (CEPSAF). Br. J. Anaesth. 99:
haematological and biochemical screening 617–623.
justified in dogs? Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 35: Brodbelt, D.C., Blissitt, K.J., Hammond, R.A.
132–140. et al. (2008a). The risk of death: the
Arriaga, A.F., Bader, A.M., Wong, J.M. et al. confidential enquiry into perioperative small
(2013). Simulation‐based trial of surgical‐ animal fatalities. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 35:
crisis checklists. N. Engl. J. Med. 368: 365–373.
246–253. Brodbelt, D.C., Pfeiffer, D.U., Young, L.E., and
Barletta, M., Kleine, S.A., and Quandt, J.E. Wood, J.L. (2008b). Results of the
(2015). Assessment of v‐gel supraglottic confidential enquiry into perioperative small
airway device placement in cats performed by animal fatalities regarding risk factors for
inexperienced veterinary students. Vet. Rec. anesthetic‐related death in dogs. JAVMA 233:
177: 523. 1096–1104.
Barrand, K. (2011). Oxygen supply – a possible Brondani, J.T., Luna, S.P., and Padovani, C.R.
alternative. In Pract. 33: 42–45. (2011). Refinement and initial validation of a
Bauer, M.D., Clark‐Price, S.C., and McFadden, multidimensional composite scale for use in
M.S. (2009). Anesthesia case of the month. assessing acute postoperative pain in cats. Am.
JAVMA 234: 1539–1541. J. Vet. Res. 72: 174–183.
Beal, M.W., Brown, D.C., and Shofer, F.S. Brondani, J.T., Mama, K.R., Luna, S.P. et al.
(2000). The effects of perioperative (2013). Validation of the English version of
hypothermia and the duration of anesthesia the UNESP‐Botucatu multidimensional
on postoperative wound infection rate in composite pain scale for assessing
clean wounds: a retrospective study. Vet. postoperative pain in cats. BMC Vet. Res. 9:
Surg. 29: 123–127. 143.
Benarroch‐Gampel, J., Sheffield, K.M., Duncan, Cabell, L.W., Perkowski, S.Z., Gregor, T., and
C.B. et al. (2012). Preoperative laboratory Smith, G.K. (1997). The effects of active
testing in patients undergoing elective, peripheral skin warming on perioperative
low‐risk ambulatory surgery. Ann. Surg. 256: hypothermia in dogs. Vet. Surg. 26: 79–85.
518–528. Calvo, G., Holden, E., Reid, J. et al. (2014).
Bhandal, J. and Kuzma, A. (2008). Tracheal Development of a behaviour‐based
rupture in a cat: diagnosis by computed measurement tool with defined intervention
tomography. Can. Vet. J. 49: 595–597. level for assessing acute pain in cats. J. Small
Blunt, M.C., Young, P.J., Patil, A., and Haddock, Anim. Pract. 55: 622–629.
A. (2001). Gel lubrication of the tracheal tube Cambridge, A.J., Tobias, K.M., Newberry, R.C.,
cuff reduces pulmonary aspiration. and Sarkar, D.K. (2000). Subjective and
Anesthesiology 95: 377–381. objective measurements of postoperative pain
Brodbelt, D.C. (2006). The confidential enquiry in cats. JAVMA 217: 685–690.
into perioperative small animal fatalities. PhD Chung, F., Yuan, H., Yin, L. et al. (2009).
thesis. London University. Elimination of preoperative testing in
References 149
ambulatory surgery. Anesth. Analg. 108: Evans, A.T., Sawyer, D.C., and Krahwinkel, D.J.
467–475. (1973). Effect of a warm‐water blanket on
Clark‐Price, S. (2015). Inadvertent perianesthetic development of hypothermia during small
hypothermia in small animal patients. Vet. Clin. animal surgery. JAVMA 163: 147–148.
North Am. Small Anim. Pract. 45: 983–994. Gaynor, J.S., Wertz, E.M., Kesel, L.M. et al.
Clark‐Price, S.C., Dossin, O., Jones, K.R. et al. (1996). Effect of intravenous administration of
(2013). Comparison of three different methods fluids on packed cell volume, blood pressure,
to prevent heat loss in healthy dogs and total protein and blood glucose
undergoing 90 minutes of general anesthesia. concentrations in healthy halothane‐
Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 40: 280–284. anesthetized dogs. JAVMA 208: 2013–2015.
Clarke, K.M. and Hall, L. (1990). A survey of Gilbert‐Gregory, S.E., Stull, J.W., Rice, M.R., and
anaesthesia in small animal practice. AVA/ Herron, M.E. (2016). Effects of trazodone on
BSAVA report. J. Ass. Vet. Anaesth 17: 4–10. behavioral signs of stress in hospitalized dogs.
Cookson, B.A. and Dipalma, J.R. (1955). Severe JAVMA 249: 1281–1291.
bradycardia of profound hypothermia in the Gray, L., Lang, C.W., and Porges, S.W. (2012).
dog. Am. J. Phys. 182: 447–453. Warmth is analgesic in healthy newborns.
Cote, E., Manning, A.M., Emerson, D. et al. Pain 153: 960–966.
(2004). Assessment of the prevalence of heart Griffith, C.A., Steigerwald, E.S., and Buffington,
murmurs in overtly healthy cats. JAVMA 225: C.A. (2000). Effects of a synthetic facial
384–388. pheromone on behavior of cats. JAVMA 217:
Crotaz, I.R. (2013). An observational clinical 1154–1156.
study in cats and rabbits of an anatomically Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al.
designed supraglottic airway device for use in (2016). The Association of Shelter
companion animal veterinary anaesthesia. Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical care
Vet. Rec. 172: 606. guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. JAVMA
Davies, M. and Kawaguchi, S. (2014). Pregeneral 249: 165–188.
anaesthetic blood screening of dogs and cats Gruen, M.E., Roe, S.C., Griffith, E. et al. (2014).
attending a UK practice. Vet. Rec. 174: 506. Use of trazodone to facilitate postsurgical
Davis, H., Jensen, T., Johnson, A. et al. (2013). confinement in dogs. JAVMA 245: 296–301.
2013 AAHA/AAFP fluid therapy guidelines Haller, G., Laroche, T., and Clergue, F. (2011).
for dogs and cats. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. Morbidity in anaesthesia: today and tomorrow.
49: 149–159. Best Pract. Res. Clin. Anaesthesiol. 25: 123–132.
Dyson, D.H., Maxie, M.G., and Schnurr, D. Hardie, E.M., Spodnick, G.J., Gilson, S.D. et al.
(1998). Morbidity and mortality associated (1999). Tracheal rupture in cats: 16 cases
with anesthetic management in small animal (1983–1998). JAVMA 214: 508–512.
veterinary practice in Ontario. J. Am. Anim. Harrison, K.A., Robertson, S.A., Levy, J.K., and
Hosp. Assoc. 34: 325–335. Isaza, N.M. (2011). Evaluation of
Eugster, S., Schawalder, P., Gaschen, F., and medetomidine, ketamine and buprenorphine
Boerlin, P. (2004). A prospective study of for neutering feral cats. J. Feline Med. Surg. 13:
postoperative surgical site infections in dogs 896–902.
and cats. Vet. Surg. 33: 542–550. Hofmeister, E.H., Quandt, J., Braun, C., and
Evangelista, M.C., Watanabe, R., O’toole, E., Shepard, M. (2014). Development,
Pang, D.S.J., and Steagall, P.V. (2018). Facial implementation and impact of simple patient
expressions of pain in cats: development of safety interventions in a university teaching
the Feline Grimace Scale. Association of hospital. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 41: 243–248.
Veterinary Anaesthetists Spring Meeting, Hofmeister, E.H., Trim, C.M., Kley, S., and
Grenada, West Indies (12–13 March). Cornell, K. (2007). Traumatic endotracheal
150 7 Principles of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Safety, and Monitoring
intubation in the cat. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 34: Lascelles, B.D., Cripps, P.J., Jones, A., and
213–216. Waterman‐Pearson, A.E. (1998). Efficacy and
Holden, E., Calvo, G., Collins, M. et al. (2014). kinetics of carprofen, administered
Evaluation of facial expression in acute pain preoperatively or postoperatively, for the
in cats. J. Small Anim. Pract. 55: 615–621. prevention of pain in dogs undergoing
Holton, L., Reid, J., Scott, E.M. et al. (2001). ovariohysterectomy. Vet. Surg. 27: 568–582.
Development of a behaviour‐based scale to Levy, J.K., Bard, K.M., Tucker, S.J. et al. (2017).
measure acute pain in dogs. Vet. Rec. 148: Perioperative mortality in cats and dogs
525–531. undergoing spay or castration at a high‐
Holton, L.L., Scott, E.M., Nolan, A.M. et al. volume clinic. Vet. J. 224: 11–15.
(1998). Comparison of three methods used for Machon, R.G., Raffe, M.R., and Robinson, E.P.
assessment of pain in dogs. JAVMA 212: (1999). Warming with a forced air warming
61–66. blanket minimizes anesthetic‐induced
Horn, E.P., Bein, B., Bohm, R. et al. (2012). The hypothermia in cats. Vet. Surg. 28: 301–310.
effect of short time periods of pre‐operative Mahajan, R.P. (2010). Critical incident reporting
warming in the prevention of peri‐operative and learning. Br. J. Anaesth. 105: 69–75.
hypothermia. Anaesthesia 67: 612–617. Matthews, N.S., Hartke, S., and Allen, J.C. Jr.
Joubert, K.E. (2007). Pre‐anaesthetic screening (2003). An evaluation of pulse oximeters in
of geriatric dogs. J. S. Afr. Vet. Assoc. 78: 31–35. dogs, cats and horses. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 30:
Kelly, C.K., Hodgson, D.S., and McMurphy, R.M. 3–14.
(2012). Effect of anesthetic breathing circuit McCarthy, D., Matz, B., Wright, J., and Moore, L.
type on thermal loss in cats during inhalation (2018). Investigation of the HotDog patient
anesthesia for ovariohysterectomy. JAVMA warming system: detection of thermal
240: 1296–1299. gradients. J. Small Anim. Pract. 59: 298–304.
Kelly, D.J., Ahmad, M., and Brull, S.J. (2001). McNally, E.M., Robertson, S.A., and Pablo, L.S.
Preemptive analgesia II: recent advances and (2009). Comparison of time to desaturation
current trends. Can. J. Anaesth. 48: 1091–1101. between preoxygenated and
Kibanda, J.O. and Gurney, M. (2012). nonpreoxygenated dogs following sedation
Comparison of two methods for the with acepromazine maleate and morphine
management of intraoperative hypothermia in and induction of anesthesia with propofol.
dogs. Vet. Rec. 170: 392. Am. J. Vet. Res. 70: 1333–1338.
Kissin, I., Lee, S.S., and Bradley, E.L. Jr. (1998). Mills, D.S., Redgate, S.E., and Landsberg, G.M.
Effect of prolonged nerve block on (2011). A meta‐analysis of studies of
inflammatory hyperalgesia in rats: prevention treatments for feline urine spraying. PLoS One
of late hyperalgesia. Anesthesiology 88: 6: e18448.
224–232. Mitchell, S.L., McCarthy, R., Rudloff, E., and
Kronen, P.W., Ludders, J.W., Erb, H.N. et al. Pernell, R.T. (2000). Tracheal rupture
(2006). A synthetic fraction of feline facial associated with intubation in cats: 20 cases
pheromones calms but does not reduce (1996–1998). JAVMA 216: 1592–1595.
struggling in cats before venous Murrell, J.C., Psatha, E.P., Scott, E.M. et al. (2008).
catheterization. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 33: Application of a modified form of the Glasgow
258–265. pain scale in a veterinary teaching centre in the
Kunkle, G.A., Nicklin, C.F., and Sullivan‐ Netherlands. Vet. Rec. 162: 403–408.
Tamboe, D.L. (2004). Comparison of body Nutt, K.R., Levy, J.K., and Tucker, S.J. (2016).
temperature in cats using a veterinary infrared Comparison of non‐contact infrared
thermometer and a digital rectal thermometer. thermometry and rectal thermometry in cats.
J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 40: 42–46. J. Feline Med. Surg. 18: 798–803.
References 151
Oyama, M.A. (2016). Cardiac blood tests. In: cats: validation and intervention level. Vet.
August’s Consultations in Feline Internal Rec. 180: 449–453.
Medicine, vol. 7 (ed. S.E. Little), 363–368. Rigotti, C.F., Jolliffe, C.T., and Leece, E.A.
St Louis, MO: Elsevier. (2015). Effect of prewarming on the body
Paige, C.F., Abbott, J.A., Elvinger, F., and Pyle, temperature of small dogs undergoing
R.L. (2009). Prevalence of cardiomyopathy in inhalation anesthesia. JAVMA 247: 765–770.
apparently healthy cats. JAVMA 234: Robertson, S.A., Gogolski, S.M., Pascoe, P. et al.
1398–1403. (2018). AAFP feline anesthesia guidelines.
Pankratz, K.E., Ferris, K.K., Griffith, E.H., and J. Feline Med. Surg. 20: 602–634.
Sherman, B.L. (2018). Use of single‐dose oral Shelby, A.M. and McKune, C.M. (2014).
gabapentin to attenuate fear responses in Anesthesia monitoring and equipment. In:
cage‐trap confined community cats: a Small Animal Anesthesia Techniques (eds.
double‐blind, placebo‐controlled field trial. A.M. Shelby and C.M. McKune), 13–38.
J. Feline Med. Surg. 20: 535–543. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley‐Blackwell.
Pottie, R.G., Dart, C.M., Perkins, N.R., and Shih, A.C., Robertson, S., Isaza, N. et al. (2008).
Hodgson, D.R. (2007). Effect of hypothermia Comparison between analgesic effects of
on recovery from general anaesthesia in the buprenorphine, carprofen, and buprenorphine
dog. Aust. Vet. J. 85: 158–162. with carprofen for canine ovariohysterectomy.
Prasse, S.A., Schrack, J., Wenger, S., and Mosing, Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 35: 69–79.
M. (2016). Clinical evaluation of the v‐gel Slingsby, L.S., Taylor, P.M., and Monroe, T.
supraglottic airway device in comparison with (2009). Thermal antinociception after
a classical laryngeal mask and endotracheal dexmedetomidine administration in cats: a
intubation in cats during spontaneous and comparison between intramuscular and oral
controlled mechanical ventilation. Vet. transmucosal administration. J. Feline Med.
Anaesth. Analg. 43: 55–62. Surg. 11: 829–834.
Quimby, J.M., Smith, M.L., and Lunn, K.F. Smith, J.D., Allen, S.W., Quandt, J.E., and
(2011). Evaluation of the effects of hospital Tackett, R.L. (1996). Indicators of
visit stress on physiologic parameters in the postoperative pain in cats and correlation
cat. J. Feline Med. Surg. 13: 733–737. with clinical criteria. Am. J. Vet. Res. 57:
Raskin, R.E. (2009). Hematologic Disorders. In: 1674–1678.
Clinical Medicine of the Dog and Cat, 2e (ed. M. Sousa, M.G., Carareto, R., Pereira‐Junior, V.A.,
Schaer), 227–253. London: Manson Publishing. and Aquino, M.C. (2011). Comparison
Redondo, J.I., Suesta, P., Gil, L. et al. (2012a). between auricular and standard rectal
Retrospective study of the prevalence of thermometers for the measurement of body
postanaesthetic hypothermia in cats. Vet. Rec. temperature in dogs. Can. Vet. J. 52: 403–406.
170: 206. Sousa, M.G., Carareto, R., Pereira‐Junior, V.A.,
Redondo, J.I., Suesta, P., Serra, I. et al. (2012b). and Aquino, M.C. (2013). Agreement between
Retrospective study of the prevalence of auricular and rectal measurements of body
postanaesthetic hypothermia in dogs. Vet. Rec. temperature in healthy cats. J. Feline Med.
171: 374. Surg. 15: 275–279.
Reid, J., Nolan, A., Hughes, J. et al. (2007). Steagall, P.V., Taylor, P.M., Rodrigues, L.C. et al.
Development of the short‐form Glasgow (2009). Analgesia for cats after
Composite Measure Pain Scale (CMPS‐SF) ovariohysterectomy with either
and derivation of an analgesic intervention buprenorphine or carprofen alone or in
score. Anim. Welf. 16: 97–104(8). combination. Vet. Rec. 164: 359–363.
Reid, J., Scott, E.M., Calvo, G., and Nolan, A.M. Taggart, R., Austin, B., Hans, E., and Hogan, D.
(2017). Definitive Glasgow acute pain scale for (2012). In vitro evaluation of the effect of
152 7 Principles of Anesthesia, Analgesia, Safety, and Monitoring
relax, undisturbed, in a quiet place after they significant hypotension. However, acepromazine
have been given pre‐medicant agents, other- is contraindicated in hypovolemic or hypoten-
wise the effects may be sub‐optimal; observa- sive animals and is not recommended prior to a
tion during this time is warranted as surgical procedure where significant blood loss
unexpected effects may occur (e.g. profound is anticipated. Acepromazine should be used
sedation or vomiting with aspiration or airway cautiously in pediatric patients: because it may
obstruction). Recommended doses of pre‐med- have a longer duration of action, its vasodilatory
icant agents are shown in Table 8.1. properties promote heat loss and hypothermia
in an already vulnerable population; if used, low
Acepromazine, Acetylpromazine, “ACE” doses are recommended (0.01–0.02 mg/kg).
Acepromazine (also known as acetylpromazine Unlike alpha2‐adrenergic agents, acepromazine
or ACE) is a long‐acting and inexpensive seda- is not reversible. The maximum recommended
tive with many beneficial effects in dogs and dose is 0.05 mg/kg; higher doses offer no addi-
cats. It is anesthetic sparing and reduces the tional benefits and may cause more unwanted
requirements for inhalant anesthetics by a mean cardiovascular effects. The effects of metabolic
of 40% (Heard et al. 1986). It has antiemetic scaling should be considered when using this
properties and reduces the incidence of vomit- drug: if the calculated dose exceeds 2 mg in a
ing associated with opioid administration large dog, it is recommended to give a maximum
(Valverde et al. 2004; Koh et al. 2014). Although of 2 mg. Contrary to common belief, it is not con-
acepromazine causes vasodilation, at clinically traindicated in dogs with a history of seizures: in
recommended doses (Table 8.1) in healthy, a retrospective study, none of the 36 dogs with
hydrated patients this usually does not result in known seizure history showed adverse effects
Table 8.1 Drugs used for pre-medication or sedation in dogs and cats; unless indicated these doses are
for intramuscular (IM) use and doses are for when the drug is used as the sole agent. When combinations
of drugs are employed (e.g. dexmedetomidine and an opioid), lower doses may be used.
when it was used as a tranquilizer during their Pypendop and Ilkiw 2014). It may be difficult
hospital stay. In the same report, 10 dogs to differentiate sedation from analgesia after
that were actively seizing were given aceproma- administration of these drugs, but it should be
zine; in 6 seizures ceased for between 1.5 and remembered that the dose required for analge-
8 hours and in 2 dogs seizures did not recur sia is much higher than that required for seda-
(Tobias et al. 2006). tion (Slingsby and Taylor 2008).
Although dogs and cats may appear deeply
Alpha2-Adrenergic Agonists sedated, it is important to be aware that ani-
The three most commonly used alpha2‐adren- mals are arousable; this can happen if there is
ergic agonist drugs in small animal anesthesia a sudden loud noise or a painful procedure is
are xylazine, medetomidine, and dexmedeto- attempted, for example suturing a wound
midine. All three drugs provide sedation, anal- without using additional analgesia such as a
gesia, and muscle relaxation, but they differ in local anesthetic. Arousal can be extremely sud-
their selectivity for the alpha2‐receptor com- den, and animals may bite or scratch clinic
pared to the alpha1‐receptor; selectivity for personnel; such unexpected arousal is anecdo-
alpha2‐receptors is greatest for dexmedetomi- tally reported most frequently when alpha2‐
dine, followed by medetomidine, then xylazine adrenergic agents have been given. To avoid
(Murrell and Hellebrekers 2005). injury, never let your guard down around a dog
In historical mortality studies (Clarke and or cat that is sedated.
Hall 1990; Dyson et al. 1998), the alpha2‐adren- Medetomidine is a racemic mixture of two
ergic agonist xylazine was associated with an optical stereoisomers: dexmedetomidine (the
increased risk of death in dogs; however, in the active enantiomer) and levomedetomidine,
Confidential Enquiry into Perioperative Small with the latter thought to be pharmacologi-
Animal Fatality (CEPSAF) study, medetomi- cally inactive (Murrell and Hellebrekers 2005).
dine was not associated with an increased risk In some countries both are available, but in the
(Brodbelt et al. 2008) and it is assumed that this United States dexmedetomidine has replaced
would hold true for dexmedetomidine. One medetomidine and is labeled for use in dogs
explanation for the risk associated with xyla- and cats. Medetomidine can be compounded
zine is that it can sensitize the heart to ventricu- to reduce drug costs. Dexmedetomidine is
lar arrhythmias (Tranquilli et al. 1986), whereas available in two concentrations: 500 μg
the more specific alpha2‐adrenergic agonist (0.5 mg)/ml and 100 μg (0.1 mg)/ml; the latter
drug dexmedetomidine does not (Hayashi et al. is appropriate for accurate administration in
1991). The contribution of xylazine to peri‐ dogs under 10 kg and in cats. It can be given IV
anesthetic mortality in cats is less clear. One or IM in dogs, but only the IM route is recom-
study showed an increased risk when xylazine mended in cats. The recommended doses,
was used with ketamine (Clarke and Hall based on body surface area (BSA), route of
1990); in contrast, a different study found that administration, and purpose (pre‐anesthetic
xylazine combined with ketamine did not medication or sedation and analgesia) are
increase the risk of cardiac arrest in cats (Dyson available in an easy‐to‐read chart format which
et al. 1998). It is difficult to say what the risks of is available for download at the manufacturer’s
xylazine use are in cats because of different website (http://www.zoetisus.com/products/
study designs, drug combinations, and health cats/dexdomitor/index.aspx). It may be espe-
status of the cats in the reports. cially important to dose based on BSA to
Medetomidine and dexmedetomidine pro- account for metabolic scaling in very small
vide reliable dose‐related sedation, muscle puppies and kittens. Inadequate depth of anes-
relaxation, and analgesia (Slingsby and thesia in kittens under 1.5 kg given injectable
Waterman‐Pearson 2000b; Kuusela et al. 2001; combinations was thought to be a result of
156 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
them having a higher BSA to body mass ratio; and not the OTM gel marketed for canine noise
therefore some clinicians have created proto- aversion (Sileo® Orion Pharma Animal Health,
cols that take this into account, so smaller Zoetis, Parsippany, NJ).
patients receive a larger dose on a mg/kg basis All alpha2‐adrenergic agonist drugs have
(Joyce and Yates 2011). profound effects on the cardiovascular system.
Dexmedetomidine and medetomidine are These include bradycardia, bradyarrhythmias,
extremely reliable, useful, and effective agents decreased cardiac output, increased systemic
in a wide variety of settings and are especially vascular resistance, and increased blood pres-
useful in patients that are not well socialized or sure (Murrell and Hellebrekers 2005).
difficult to handle due to fear, stress, or behav- Dexmedetomidine and medetomidine signifi-
ioral issues. The differences between the two cantly reduce the requirements for injectable
drugs are difficult to summarize despite multi- and inhalant anesthetic drugs, in some cases
ple studies, because of the range of doses used by up to 80%. The decrease in anesthetic
and physiologic and clinical effects that are requirements, cardiac output, and bradycardia
dose dependent (Murrell and Hellebrekers have clinical significance: when administering
2005). An injectable anesthetic protocol using IV anesthetic induction drugs, the injection
a combination of ketamine, buprenorphine, site (e.g. cephalic vein) to brain circulation
midazolam, and either dexmedetomidine or time is prolonged, therefore injectable anes-
medetomidine was evaluated in kittens and thetic drugs should be given initially at low
adult cats undergoing castration (Bruniges doses and time allowed for the drug to have an
et al. 2016). All cats were given atipamezole at effect before deciding to give more. If mask
the same dose 40 minutes after induction and inductions are performed, loss of conscious-
the investigators stated that the choice of ness may occur very rapidly. It is easy to over-
alpha2‐adrenergic drug had little effect. dose animals with injectable or inhalant agents
The alpha2‐adrenergic drugs may be used if the effects of an alpha2‐adrenergic agonist
alone for sedation or combined with an opioid are not taken into consideration. Other conse-
to provide additional analgesia and sedation. quences resulting from the cardiovascular
They are common components of a total inject- changes include paler mucus membranes, dif-
able induction protocol, for example when ficulty in obtaining pulse oximeter readings,
combined with ketamine or tiletamine/zolaz- and finding it more challenging to place an
epam and an opioid. intravenous catheter.
In fractious, aggressive, or extremely fearful The use of dexmedetomidine and medetomi-
animals, oral transmucosal (OTM) administra- dine in the face of cardiac disease is controver-
tion can be extremely effective and is a safe tech- sial. In cats with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy,
nique for veterinary staff. In cats, buccal or in particular those with left ventricular outflow
OTM administration of dexmedetomidine at obstruction, no detrimental effects were seen
40 μg/kg provided similar sedation to the same after administration of medetomidine (20 μg/
dose given IM (Slingsby et al. 2009). A case kg IM). In dogs with poor ventricular function,
series in dogs (n = 4) using a mean dose of the increase in afterload caused by alpha2‐adr-
32.6 μg/kg provided satisfactory sedation and energic agonist drugs is not well tolerated.
safe handling of the dogs. It was possible to The alpha2‐adrenergic agonists are eme-
deliver the drug by spraying into a dog’s mouth togenic; however, specific drug and species dif-
from a distance of 0.6 m, using a 3 ml syringe ferences are reported. Vomiting increases
and 22‐gauge needle; onset time to suitable intraocular and intracranial pressure; con-
sedation was approximately 20 minutes (Cohen traindications would include patients with a
and Bennett 2015). Note that these studies use penetrating corneal foreign body or deep cor-
the injectable formulation of dexmedetomidine neal ulcer, and if there is any suspicion or
Anesthesia 157
history of head trauma. Aspiration is a possible of their pharmacologic properties. When xyla-
sequela because sedation occurs rapidly with zine was launched in the early 1970s its
this class of drug, therefore all patients should potency, anesthetic‐sparing effects, and side
be observed closely following administration. effects were underestimated; it was used in a
The alpha2 drugs are used to induce vomit- cavalier manner and in patients we would not
ing in cats after toxin ingestion, so this side use it on today based on our experience and
effect should be expected when they are used knowledge of drugs in this class (Sinclair
as sedatives. When used alone in cats, one 2003). The safety outcomes of these drugs have
study reported vomiting with xylazine and improved in parallel with our increased knowl-
dexmedetomidine in 51.1% and 58% of cats, edge and experience of them.
respectively, which was not statistically differ- Alpha2‐adrenergic agonist drugs are reversi-
ent (Willey et al. 2016). After xylazine was ble. Atipamezole (5 mg/ml) is a specific reversal
given at approximately 0.5 mg/kg IM, 60% of agent for dexmedetomidine and medetomi-
cats vomited (Thies et al. 2017). When dexme- dine. Reversal is not always required, and some
detomidine was used as a pre‐medicant prior anesthetists prefer to allow patients to remain
to general anesthesia in cats (McSweeney et al. sedated and wake up slowly. Atipamezole is
2012), 31% of cats vomited compared to 6% of used when a rapid recovery is beneficial; for
placebo‐treated cats. Administering ondanse- example, in pediatric patients when it is desir-
tron (0.22 mg/kg IM) with dexmedetomidine able for them to eat soon after a procedure.
(40 μg/kg) at the same time (mixed in the same Although used widely in both dogs and cats, it
syringe) reduced the incidence of vomiting is only labeled for IM use in dogs. After admin-
from 78% (placebo group) to 33%; pre‐treat- istration of atipamezole, it must be remem-
ment with ondansetron 30 minutes before dex- bered that any residual analgesia as well as
medetomidine was not effective, with 67% of sedation is reversed, therefore other analgesics
cats vomiting (Santos et al. 2011). The alpha2‐ should already be on board. In a report of
agonists are frequently used in combination applying “fast‐track surgery principles” in a
with an opioid and dissociative agent as a total clinical feline neutering setting, pain scores
intramuscular anesthetic (TIMA) technique in were not different between cats that did or did
cats, and when used as such vomiting is less not receive atipamezole; all cats were anesthe-
likely but is not eliminated. When medetomi- tized with a combination of dexmedetomidine,
dine, buprenorphine, and ketamine were com- ketamine, and hydromorphone and received
bined and used in community cats undergoing meloxicam immediately after surgery (Hasiuk
sterilization, 8% vomited (Harrison et al. 2011). et al. 2015). Atipamezole reliably shortened
Vomiting is also reported in dogs following recovery time in adult cats and kittens given
administration of alpha2‐adrenergic agonists. ketamine, buprenorphine, midazolam, and
Review articles state that 20–50% of dogs vomit either dexmedetomidine or medetomidine for
following xylazine and 8–20% after medetomi- castration, with kittens recovering faster than
dine (Sinclair 2003; Lemke 2004). adults (Bruniges et al. 2016).
In the author’s experience, all three alpha2‐ In dogs, the recommended dose of atipam-
adrenergic agonist drugs are extremely valua- ezole is a volume equal to the volume of
ble components of shelter medicine anesthesia dexmedetomidine (based on the 500 μg/ml
protocols. The reports of xylazine use and concentration) given. It is not labeled for use
increased mortality in dogs (Clarke and Hall in cats but when used, the volume of atipam-
1990; Dyson et al. 1998) should be carefully cri- ezole usually given is half (if the 500 μg/ml of
tiqued (Sinclair 2003). The safety of sedative dexmedetomidine is used) or one‐tenth (if
and anesthetic drugs depends on how they are the 100 μg/ml concentration is used) of the
used, combined with a robust understanding initial dexmedetomidine volume. Joyce and
158 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
Yates (2011) suggest a dose of atipamezole of are unpredictable; animals may become disin-
between 10 and 50% of the original volume of hibited, resulting in a patient that is agitated,
medetomidine in their “quad” protocol for excited, and difficult to restrain. The beneficial
cats (discussed later in this chapter). Some effects of benzodiazepines (sedation) are more
authors have reported that giving atipame- predictable in senior or debilitated animals;
zole subcutaneously (SC) results in calmer midazolam is more versatile as it can be given
albeit slower recoveries in cats compared to IV or IM, whereas diazepam can only be given
IM administration (Harrison et al. 2011). IV. Benzodiazepines are beneficial as co‐induc-
Atipamezole (25–50 μg/kg IM) can be used to tion agents; when given after a small dose of
reverse xylazine in dogs and cats. propofol or alfaxalone, the total dose of the lat-
Yohimbine (0.1 mg/kg IM, SC, or slow IV) ter drugs required to intubate dogs is signifi-
has historically been used to reverse the effects cantly reduced, quality of induction is
of xylazine, but is difficult to source commer- improved, and it can be cost saving (Sanchez
cially and has largely been replaced by atipam- et al. 2013; Liao et al. 2017). Benzodiazepines
ezole. Yohimbine can be compounded, but should be available in the event a patient has a
users are reminded that compounded drugs do seizure and should be readily available or given
not undergo efficacy testing. pre‐emptively to cases with a known history of
Reversal of alpha2‐drugs is not recom- seizures. Another advantage of benzodiaz-
mended until at least 20 minutes after the orig- epines is the additional muscle relaxation they
inal injection unless emergency reversal is provide, which is beneficial during abdominal
required (Joyce and Yates 2011). surgery in obese patients.
Benzodiazepines
Induction of Anesthesia
Benzodiazepines (midazolam and diazepam)
are not recommended as pre‐medicant agents For recommended doses of induction agents,
in healthy dogs and cats because their effects see Table 8.2.
Table 8.2 Drugs and doses for intravenous induction of anesthesia. After pre-medication (Table 8.1) lower
doses may be sufficient.
due to an increase in the injection site to brain used, this results in equal volumes of each
circulation time. A single dose of propofol is drug. Ketamine at anesthetic doses should be
expected to last 5–10 minutes and anesthesia can used with caution in animals with head trauma
be continued with additional “top‐ups” (1–2 mg/ and eye injuries or glaucoma, as ketamine can
kg when needed) or a continuous‐rate infusion increase intracranial and intraocular pressure.
(3–4 μg/kg/minute), or by an inhalant agent. Sub‐anesthetic doses used to supplement anes-
Recoveries are usually smooth, rapid, and com- thesia or analgesia (see later) are unlikely to
plete following propofol. cause problems.
Sedation lasted for approximately 120 minutes. infusions can also be used – these methods are
Neither dose resulted in pulse oximeter read- approved and “on label.”
ings (SpO2) falling below 95% when cats Adequate pre‐medication is recommended
breathed room air, there was no dose‐related in dogs and cats to ensure a smooth recovery
effect on heart rate, and although systolic arte- (Jimenez et al. 2012). Alfaxalone has been eval-
rial pressure (SAP) and respiratory rate were uated for induction of anesthesia in puppies
higher in the low‐dose group, values were and kittens under 12 weeks of age after pre‐
within clinically acceptable ranges (SAP medication with acepromazine (0.03 mg/kg),
100 mmHg). Retching and vomiting did not morphine (0.3 mg/kg), and atropine (0.04 mg/
occur at either dose, but hypersalivation was kg; O’Hagan et al. 2012a, b). The mean induc-
seen in cats given the higher dose; based on tion dose in kittens was 4.7 ± 0.5 mg/kg and
these results, 5 mg of tiletamine and 5 mg of 1.7 ± 0.3 mg/kg in puppies. In kittens, anesthe-
zolazepam per kg administered onto the sia was maintained with isoflurane or supple-
mucosal surface is recommended (Nejamkin mental doses of alfaxalone, and puppies were
et al. 2019). In the study described here, the maintained on isoflurane. In both studies the
drug was placed in the buccal pouch with a quality of induction and recovery was accepta-
syringe; this author has had success when tile- ble and cardiovascular and respiratory param-
tamine and zolazepam have been sprayed into eters were well maintained.
the mouths of cats, which was achieved using a Alfaxalone is an appropriate induction agent
Luer Lock syringe and needle or IV catheter for healthy or compromised patients and,
with the stylet removed. based on the vitality scores of newborn pup-
pies, is a good choice for cesarean section
Alfaxalone (Doebeli et al. 2013; Metcalfe et al. 2014).
Alfaxalone (Alfaxan®, Jurox, Rutherford, NSW, In some countries, but not the United
Australia; Alfaxan multidose, 10 mg/ml) is a States, IM administration of alfaxalone is
synthetic neurosteroid that is solubilized in 2‐ approved in cats. Recent data suggests a
hydroxypropyl‐beta‐cyclodextrin and used in a dose of 5 mg/kg (0.5 ml/kg) to produce deep
wide range of species, but labeled for use in sedation but not general anesthesia (Deutsch
dogs and cats, to produce general anesthesia et al. 2017; Rodrigo‐Mocholi et al. 2018).
and muscle relaxation. In the United States Butorphanol is often combined with alfax-
alfaxalone is a Schedule IV drug and appropri- alone to provide analgesia and additional
ate records must be kept. When it was first sedation (Ribas et al. 2015; Deutsch et al.
launched, a big disadvantage was the lack of 2017). A combination of alfaxalone (3 mg/kg),
preservative, which dictated discard of unused butorphanol (0.2 mg/kg), and dexmedetomi-
drug six hours after the bottle was broached. dine (10 μg/kg) was sufficient to perform cas-
The newer formulation (Alfaxan multidose) tration, and produced a better‐quality albeit
contains a mixture of preservatives and has a longer recovery compared to cats that were
28‐day shelf life after the first dose is with- given ketamine (5 mg/kg) as a substitute for
drawn. Alfaxalone has a high therapeutic alfaxalone (Khenissi et al. 2017). Reports on
index (significantly greater than propofol), but the quality of recovery after IM alfaxalone
should be given slowly and “to effect” for range from good to poor, with the most com-
induction of anesthesia; the manufacturer monly reported side effects being opisthoto-
recommends that the induction dose is given nos, exaggerated responses to touch and
over 60 seconds. Cats require a higher induc- noise, and twitching (Deutsch et al. 2017;
tion dose than dogs (see Table 8.2). Duration Rodrigo‐Mocholi et al. 2018). To decrease
of anesthesia can be extended by giving these side effects cats should be recovered in a
additional “top‐up” doses and constant‐rate quiet area with subdued lighting. Partial pressure
162 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
of oxygen (PaO2) values should be monitored intubation was faster with sevoflurane
and supplemental oxygen is often required (210 ± 57 seconds versus 236 ± 60 seconds
(Deutsch et al. 2017). respectively; Lerche et al. 2002). Chamber or
“tank” inductions may be necessary in some
Inhalant Anesthetic Agents cats, but IM injection of drug combinations
Mask inductions are discouraged as they are (see later in this chapter) is recommended. Use
stressful for patients, expose personnel to waste of feline facial pheromones sprayed on the
anesthetic gas, and in dogs increase the risk of inside of the chamber or on a towel which is
anesthetic death (Brodbelt et al. 2008). If they then placed in the chamber is recommended.
are performed, this should be an exception, not A similar stepwise process as described for
the rule, and prior sedation is preferable. Face mask inductions should be followed: after the
masks made of clear plastic and fitted with a cat is placed in the chamber and the lid
rubber gasket should be used so that the color of secured, oxygen should be given first, then the
the tongue or lips can be observed, and a seal vaporizer turned on and turned up every
achieved. To prevent breath holding and strug- 30 seconds. Before removing the lid, the cat’s
gling, a “stepwise” induction technique is righting reflex should be checked by turning
advised. The circuit should be filled with oxygen the box from side to side.
and the face mask placed over the animal’s
muzzle for 30–60 seconds, then the vaporizer
Maintenance of Anesthesia
turned on and the setting on the dial increased
every 30 seconds. There may be a short‐lived Following induction of anesthesia with an
excitement phase and if this happens increasing injectable agent, anesthesia may be continued,
the vaporizer setting more rapidly helps over- if needed, with repeated boluses of some
come this. For mask inductions sevoflurane induction agents (propofol or alfaxalone) or
may offer some advantages. When induction of with an inhalant anesthetic agent delivered via
anesthesia in a stepwise fashion was compared endotracheal tube, supraglottic airway device
using isoflurane or sevoflurane in non‐pre‐med- (cats), or face mask. Even if inhalant agents
icated dogs, the latter was smoother and faster are not used, SpO2 should be monitored and
(Johnson et al. 1998); in this study both agents equipment for oxygen supplementation be
resulted in a rapid and smooth recovery. In readily available.
another study there was no difference in induc- Isoflurane and sevoflurane are the most com-
tion time between sevoflurane and isoflurane, monly available agents and there is no data to
nor in pre‐medicated versus non‐pre‐medicated support that one is “safer” than the other;
dogs, although sedation did result in a better therefore, choice of agent may be based on cost,
quality of induction (Pottie et al. 2008). with isoflurane being considerably less expen-
Regardless of the inhalant agent used or if dogs sive when compared in an equipotent manner.
are sedated or not, induction time (defined as Both agents produce significant dose‐related
the time to reach a plane of anesthesia sufficient cardiovascular and respiratory depression.
for endotracheal intubation) can be over three Vasodilation causes hypotension and also
minutes (Pottie et al. 2008); in a high‐volume enhances heat loss from the periphery.
spay–neuter setting routine mask inductions Although sevoflurane is less soluble and should
are unacceptable (Association of Shelter result in more rapid changes of anesthetic
Veterinarians’ Veterinary Task Force to Advance depth and recovery, the clinical differences are
et al. 2016). minimal. One of the goals of pre‐medication
In cats pre‐medicated with acepromazine and use of injectable induction drugs is to
(0.05 mg/kg IM), sevoflurane and isoflurane decrease the animal’s requirements for these
had similar induction qualities, but time to agents; the alpha2‐adrenergic agents may
Total Injectable Anesthetic Protocols 163
0.2 ml. After a further 5 minutes, repeat these risk of airway obstruction. Intubation also
steps before removing the cat from the trap or allows assisted ventilation, which is more likely
administering further doses. Follow‐up studies in overweight and pregnant animals; anesthesia
with this drug combination recommend a dose for pregnant animals is discussed later in this
of 0.25 ml in most adult cats (Cistola et al. chapter. Based on pulse oximeter readings
2004), but slightly larger volumes (0.27– (recorded from the tongue), oxygen saturation
0.30 ml) are often given to large cats and preg- of hemoglobin (SpO2) was 92 ± 3% in males and
nant females. Recorded weights from one 90 ± 4% in females during anesthesia, but an
study were 1.9–3.9 kg for females and 2.2– SpO2 of less than 90% was recorded at least once
4.6 kg for males (Cistola et al. 2004). in most cats following administration of TKX
Over a four‐year period, 7502 cats were steri- (Cistola et al. 2004). The consequences of low
lized using this protocol with a total of 26 SpO2 readings are unknown in this population
deaths, 17 of which were deemed to be solely of cats. Other physiologic parameters reported
attributed to anesthesia (Williams et al. 2002). by Cistola and colleagues include indi-
This anesthesia mortality rate of 0.23% is simi- rectly measured mean blood pressures (aver-
lar to that reported by Brodbelt et al. (2007) age ± standard deviation [SD]) of 136 ± 30 mmHg
(0.24%) for owned cats undergoing anesthesia in males and 113 ± 29 mmHg in females, heart
at primary care and referral clinics. rates of 156 ± 19 beats per minute, and respira-
The TKX protocol provides sufficient depth tory rates of 18 ± 8 breaths per minute.
and duration of anesthesia to permit ear tip- After all procedures were completed, adult
ping, pre‐operative clipping and preparation, cats and kittens received 0.5 mg or 0.3 mg of
surgery, vaccination, and administration of the alpha2‐adrenergic antagonist yohimbine
various other medications (e.g. parasiticides IV, respectively, and were placed back in their
and antibiotics) in most cats. Based on other original trap to recover. As discussed earlier,
published studies, the expected duration of atipamezole (IM or SC) can be used for rever-
action of TKX is approximately 40 minutes (Ko sal of xylazine. Recovery from anesthesia fol-
et al. 1993). Cistola et al. (2004) reported that a lowing TKX is reported to be smooth but
single dose of TKX was sufficient to complete prolonged; the time from administration of
all procedures in 92% of cats; in the remaining yohimbine to the time cats regained sternal
8% an additional 0.15 ml of TKX was required recumbency was 72 ± 42 minutes (Cistola et al.
at the start of surgery. 2004). A slow recovery can be problematic, as
In the studies reported by Williams et al. it delays return to normal function including
(2002) and Cistola et al. (2004), cats were not eating, and community cats should not be
intubated and breathed room air. Recent studies released until fully recovered; this requires
suggest that not intubating cats for short proce- them to remain in traps, which may be stress-
dures (<30 minutes) may reduce peri‐operative ful. Reasons for these prolonged recovery times
deaths, most of which occur in the first include the fact that yohimbine is a non‐selec-
three hours after surgery and are frequently tive reversal agent and only serves to reverse or
related to airway dysfunction or obstruction partially reverse the effects of xylazine, and
that may be a result of trauma and swelling there are no clinically available reversal agents
caused by intubation (Brodbelt et al. 2007). for tiletamine or ketamine.
However, the equipment required for intuba- Hypothermia delays recovery from anesthe-
tion and ventilation should always be available sia and has negative consequences. Cistola
for use in specific cases and in the event of an et al. (2004) reported rectal temperatures of
emergency. Intubation is advised in pregnant 38.0 ± 0.8 °C (mean of 100.4 °F) in male cats
cats due to their increased risk of aspiration and and 36.6 ± 0.8 °C (mean of 97.8 °F) in females
in brachycephalic cats due to their increased at the time of reversal. Although TKX meets
Total Injectable Anesthetic Protocols 165
many of the unique requirements for trap, neu- midine and/or ketamine before they could be
ter, vaccinate, and return (TNVR) clinics, there removed from their trap. Eleven cats received
have been concerns about sufficient analgesia supplemental anesthesia with isoflurane
and prolonged recovery times. To rectify the administered via a face mask to complete the
analgesia concerns, an opioid, usually surgical procedure; in all of these cats the depth
buprenorphine, and/or an injectable NSAID of anesthesia did not become inadequate until
(meloxicam or robenacoxib) can be given 45 minutes after administration of MKB.
before returning the cat to the trap for recovery. Although SpO2 values were higher than those
Based on the limitations of TKX, other proto- reported for TKX, a value of less than 95% was
cols have and continue to be developed. recorded at least once in all cats. The time from
injection of atipamezole to sternal recumbency
was 33 ± 31 minutes and was not different
Medetomidine/Ketamine/
between males and females. These recovery
Buprenorphine (MKB 1)
times were faster than those reported for TKX,
Medetomidine is no longer commercially avail- despite rectal temperatures at the time of rever-
able in the United States, but it is sold in other sal being similar with both injectable protocols.
countries. Medetomidine can be compounded In some countries medetomidine is no longer
and many clinics do this because of the signifi- available but dexmedetomidine can be used
cant cost savings. A combination of medetomi- instead, at half of the medetomidine dose based
dine, ketamine, and buprenorphine has been on micrograms per kilogram. MKB can be used
evaluated in a TNVR clinic (Harrison et al. in dogs and is especially useful in puppies.
2011). The hypotheses were that this combina-
tion would result in shorter recovery times
Medetomidine/Ketamine/
because medetomidine is a more specific
Butorphanol (MKB 2)
alpha2‐adrenergic agonist than xylazine and a
specific antagonist (atipamezole) is available, MKB, with B representing butorphanol, is
and that buprenorphine would provide good widely used in both dogs and cats and results
peri‐operative analgesia. Following preliminary in a highly versatile TIMA. Butorphanol pro-
trials, a combination of medetomidine (100 μg/ vides more sedation than buprenorphine and
kg), ketamine (10 mg/kg), and buprenorphine has a faster onset of action, which has likely
(10 μg/kg) was chosen for the study, which led to the popularity and success of this tech-
included 101 cats (53 males and 48 females), nique. To provide longer analgesia, an NSAID
and administered IM; for a 3 kg cat the total vol- can be given after the procedure; some veteri-
ume injected was 0.7 ml. Atipamezole (125 μg/ narians also give buprenorphine at this time.
kg) was given SC at the end of surgery. In this Reversal of medetomidine with atipamezole
study the dose of atipamezole was lower than results in a fast recovery.
usually recommended and was given SC rather
than IM. These clinicians noted that when the
Dexmedetomidine/Ketamine/
suggested dose (half the volume of medetomi-
Butorphanol (DKB)
dine) and route (IM) were used, a significant
number of cats awoke very quickly and became Clinically there is no obvious difference when
hyperexcitable; the lower dose given SC resulted medetomidine is substituted with dexmedetomi-
in a better quality of recovery. dine. If the concentration of medetomidine used
Cats were not intubated and breathed room is 1 mg/ml and the dexmedetomidine 0.5 mg/ml,
air. Time to lateral recumbency was similar to the preparation of the mixture on a volume basis
that reported for TKX (four to five minutes). is identical (see Box 8.2). Butorphanol can be
Eleven cats required additional doses of medeto- replaced with buprenorphine, and again, when
166 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
(tiletamine/zolazepam), T = Torbugesic
Box 8.2 Instructions for Formulating
(butorphanol), and D = Dexdomitor (dexme-
the Combination of Dexmedetomidine,
detomidine). All three components are now
Ketamine, and Butorphanol (DKB)
available as generics, but the name TTD has
Drugs stuck. To minimize the volume for IM injec-
tion, the powdered tiletamine/zolazepam is
1) Dexmedetomidine 0.5 mg/ml (500 μg/ml) reconstituted with 2.5 ml of butorphanol
2) Ketamine 100 mg/ml (10 mg/ml) and 2.5 ml of dexmedetomidine
3) Butorphanol 10 mg/ml (0.5 mg/ml; Ko and Berman 2010). This
Draw up equal volumes (1 : 1 : 1) of each results in a total volume of 0.12 ml for surgical
drug and add them to a sterile vial using anesthesia in a 3 kg patient. This drug combi-
aseptic technique (wipe all rubber stoppers nation is equally useful in dogs and cats, and
with alcohol and allow it to evaporate at the same dose, simplifying clinic flow when
before inserting the needle into each vial). dogs and cats are being anesthetized at the
Each milliliter of the mixture contains: same time. Another attractive feature is that
by varying the dose, one can achieve mild,
0.167 mg (167 μg) of dexmedetomidine
moderate, or deep sedation, or surgical anes-
33.3 mg of ketamine
thesia (Ko and Berman 2010). As with other
3.3 mg of butorphanol
injectable protocols already described, rever-
Source: Based on Bushby and Griffin (2011). sal with atipamezole and additional analge-
sics can be given as deemed necessary.
Printable dosage charts (dogs and cats) are
butorphanol is 10 mg/ml and buprenorphine available (Ko and Berman 2010) and a detailed
0.3 mg/ml, a direct substitution by volume can feline chart giving dosage volumes in small
be done. weight increments from 1.0 to 6.4 kg is availa-
Dosing charts of the DKB combination for ble for download from the ASPCAPro website
dogs and cats (doses are different) can be down- (http://www.aspcapro.org/resource/spayneuter‐
loaded from an open access site (Bushby and clinic‐drug‐charts‐logs).
Griffin 2011; also see kitten and puppy dosing
charts available in Chapter 9). These can be
The Cat and Kitten “Quad” Protocol
printed off and laminated for easy access in the
induction area. In this author’s experience DKB This protocol combines medetomidine, keta-
alone is sufficient for feline ovariohysterectomies mine, midazolam, and buprenorphine and is
or ovariectomies and castrations and for canine widely used in the UK (Joyce and Yates 2011).
castrations; female dogs may require additional Doses are based on BSA to account for meta-
anesthesia, and this can easily be provided with bolic scaling and differences in BSA to mass
an inhalant agent or incremental doses of propo- ratios between very small kittens and adult
fol to effect. Reversal is at the discretion of the cats. The addition of midazolam, which is an
clinician, but should not be performed until excellent muscle relaxant, allows a lower dose
20 minutes after injection. An NSAID is recom- of medetomidine to be used, which may
mended to provide follow‐up analgesia. decrease cardiovascular side effects and also
shortens the duration of action. The authors
suggest that midazolam promotes early return
Tiletamine/Zolazepam/
to feeding. More details about this protocol
Butorphanol/Dexmedetomidine
including a dosing chart are discussed later in
This mixture is widely known as TTD based this chapter in the section on anesthesia for the
on the original drug names: T = Telazol young and old and in Chapter 9.
Perioperative Analgesia 167
The most commonly used perioperative opi- IM induction in cats in a variety of settings.
oids include butorphanol, buprenorphine, Nalbuphine is not a controlled substance
hydromorphone, methadone, and morphine. and is an agonist–antagonist opioid similar
Recommended doses are shown in Table 8.3. to butorphanol. A randomized clinical trial
in cats presented to a mobile TNR clinic
Butorphanol demonstrated non‐inferiority of nalbuphine
Butorphanol is one of only two opioids licensed compared to butorphanol (Kreisler et al.
for veterinary use in the United States and is 2019). The protocol used was a combination
unlikely to be affected by the FDA’s decision to of tiletamine–zolazepam (3 mg/kg), dexme-
decrease opioid production. Butorphanol is detomidine (7.5 μg/kg) and either butorpha-
classified as an agonist–antagonist opioid and nol or nalbuphine at 0.15 mg/kg given IM.
therefore reaches a ceiling effect where increas- The authors concluded that “nalbuphine is
ing doses (e.g. from 0.1 to 0.8 mg/kg) do not an effective substitute for butorphanol”
provide any further analgesia (Lascelles and (Kreisler et al. 2019). Record keeping and
Robertson 2004). In addition, it is a short‐acting safe storage of opioids are essential and the
agent – in a thermal threshold model it provided use of nalbuphine can reduce this burden.
antinociception for 90 minutes (Lascelles and
Robertson 2004) – and repeated dosing is time
Buprenorphine
consuming and costly. Despite its popularity,
Buprenorphine is a partial mu agonist which
butorphanol’s analgesic properties have been
can be used in cats and dogs, but is more widely
questioned for a long time (Wagner 1999).
used in cats.
Clinical studies have shown that when butor-
There are three different formulations of
phanol is the primary analgesic it does not pro-
buprenorphine currently available:
vide adequate pain relief for surgical procedures
such as ovariohysterectomy in cats (Taylor et al. 1) The “traditional” injectable product – in
2010; Warne et al. 2014). the United States the human formulation
However, a dismissal of butorphanol as a (brand name Buprenex®, generic formula-
component of anesthetic and analgesic proto- tions) is often used off‐label. In several
cols is unwarranted after careful scrutiny of countries there are veterinary‐approved
several studies that compare it to other opi- multidose products containing preserva-
oids. When studies were designed to compare tives. These formulations have a concentra-
butorphanol to buprenorphine (Taylor et al. tion of 0.3 mg/ml. Recommended dose rates
2010; Warne et al. 2014) or methadone (Warne are 0.02–0.04 mg/kg (IV and IM) in dogs
et al. 2013) in cats undergoing surgery and cats. The OTM route has been dis-
(predominantly ovariohysterectomy), no other cussed earlier and is an option, but when
analgesics were given. Rarely is an opioid the possible the IV and IM routes should be
only analgesic used in animals undergoing used. The SC route is not as efficacious for
surgery; a multimodal approach using keta- this formulation of buprenorphine due to
mine, NSAIDs, alpha2‐adrenergic agonist erratic absorption, which may be worse
drugs, and local anesthetic agents is com- when animals are cold or have received an
monly used and provides good intra‐ and alpha2‐adrenergic drug that causes periph-
post‐operative analgesia. eral vasoconstriction (Steagall et al. 2014).
The time to onset of action, peak effect,
Nalbuphine and duration of buprenorphine have been
Pre‐mixed combinations of an opioid, disso- investigated, but are often misunder-
ciative, and alpha2‐adreneric agonist (also stood. Based on research models and
known as “kitty magic”) are often used for clinical studies, onset of analgesia occurs
Table 8.3 Opioid drugs recommended for alleviation of acute pain in dogs and cats. The suggested frequency of administration is for guidance; patients may
require more or less frequent treatment and this is based on assessing their pain. Availability of opioids and market authorization for dogs and cats varies widely
in different countries.
Agonist‐antagonists
Butorphanol 0.2–0.4 0.2–0.4 IM, IV q 1–2 Drugs in this class have a ceiling effect and used alone
Nalbuphine 0.2–0.4 0.2–0.4 IM, IV q 1–2 are only sufficient for minor procedures. They are best
used in a multimodal plan or as part of a TIMA protocol
where other analgesics are used (e.g. NSAIDs, alpha2‐
adrenergic agonists, ketamine, tiletamine–zolazepam).
Butorphanol provides better sedation than other opioids.
Nalbuphine is a non‐scheduled drug in the United States.
Partial agonists
Buprenorphine 0.3 mg/ml 0.02–0.04 0.02–0.04 IM, IV, OTM q 4–8 OTM uptake may be less in dogs than cats; use the higher
end of the dose range if using this route.
Buprenorphine 1.8 mg/ml Not labeled for dogs 0.24 SC q 24 Buprenorphine 1.8 mg/ml (Simbadol) is currently FDA
(Simbadol®) approved only for use in cats. There are no generic
formulations.
Buprenorphine SR 0.03–0.06 0.12 SC q 72 Appropriate for use when handling of the patient after
(sustained release) recovery is not possible.
Agonists
Morphine 0.5–1.0 0.2–0.5 IM, IV* q 4–6 *IV administration may cause histamine releases; give
over 1–3 minutes. Likely to cause nausea and vomiting.
Methadone 0.5–1.0 0.3–0.5 IM, IV, OTM** q4 **Cats only. Vomiting is rare. Has N‐methyl‐d‐aspartate
(NMDA) receptor antagonist properties.
Sporadically available.
Oxymorphone 0.05–0.1 0.025–0.10 IM, IV Likely to cause nausea and vomiting.
Hydromorphone 0.1–0.2 0.05–0.10 IM, IV May cause hyperthermia in cats.
FDA, Food and Drug Administration; IM, intramuscular; IV, intravenous; NSAIDs, non‐steroidal anti‐inflammatory drugs; OTM, oral transmucosal; q, every;
SC, subcutaneous; TIMA, total intramuscular anesthetic.
neutering; however, cats were not given post‐ 2006; Posner et al. 2007, 2010). Hydromorphone
operative NSAIDs (Shah et al. 2018). When IM is the drug most often implicated, with one cat
medetomidine plus either buprenorphine or reaching a rectal temperature of 42.5 °C
methadone was compared to SC meloxicam fol- (108.5 °F; Niedfeldt and Robertson 2006); the
lowed by IM alfaxalone (for anesthesia induc- increased temperatures with hydromorphone
tion) and maintenance with isoflurane in cats were seen with doses of 0.05, 0.1, and 0.2 mg/kg
undergoing ovariohysterectomy, no significant (Posner et al. 2010). Posner et al. (2010) reported
differences in the anesthetic conditions or post‐ that morphine, butorphanol, buprenorphine,
operative pain scores were detected; no cats and hydromorphone alone or in combination
required rescue analgesia (Mahdmina et al. with ketamine or isoflurane can result in ele-
2019). This emphasizes once again the value of vated core body temperatures for four to
multimodal analgesia and the efficacy of five hours after administration; in that study
NSAIDs for acute post‐operative pain. temperatures did not exceed 40.3 °C (104.5 °F)
and resolved without intervention. Removing
Morphine heating devices, using a fan, and/or applying
Morphine has been used successfully for many cool water to the paws are recommended when
years in dogs and cats. As with hydromor- temperatures reach 40 °C (104 °F). Many clini-
phone, vomiting is often seen in healthy dogs, cians administer acepromazine to promote
but the incidence is decreased with the use of vasodilation and heat loss. In the one cat that
acepromazine or maropitant. Morphine can reached 42.5 °C (108.5 °F) reversal with nalox-
cause histamine release, so if given IV it should one was successful; this patient had not under-
be injected slowly (over two to five minutes) gone a painful procedure (Niedfeldt and
and avoided in animals with mast cell tumors. Robertson 2006). Opioid‐related hyperthermia
Historically people have avoided morphine does not seem to be NSAID responsive. If a
in cats due to reports of “morphine mania.” If painful procedure has been performed and
these studies are looked at closely, cats received reversal is deemed necessary, butorphanol (e.g.
20 mg/kg, which is at least 40 times a clinically 0.1 mg/kg) can be given if the causative opioid
relevant dose (Fertziger et al. 1974). Because of is a mu agonist. If naloxone is used, another
the fear of manic reactions which are now analgesic should be administered and the pat-
unfounded, low doses of morphine (e.g. ent assessed for pain. Opioid‐related hyperther-
0.2 mg/kg) were used in cats, with a lack of mia is also discussed in Chapter 10.
efficacy. Unlike most dogs and humans, cats
produce very little morphine‐6‐glucuronide Tramadol
which is an active metabolite, therefore they Tramadol has opioid (mu agonist) effects and
depend on the parent compound for analgesia. inhibits the reuptake of norepinephrine and
This means that doses greater than 0.2 mg/kg serotonin. Some of its analgesic effects depend
are recommended, and this author uses 0.5 mg/ on active metabolites, the primary one being
kg IM (Taylor et al. 2001; Robertson and Taylor O‐desmethyltramadol, also known as M1,
2004). Although opioid‐related vomiting is less which is produced in cats but produced only
common in cats than dogs, it still occurs, and minimally in dogs (Pypendop and Ilkiw 2008;
cats should be carefully observed after admin- Schutter et al. 2017). In the past, tramadol was
istration of any potential emetogenic drug. widely used in dogs for alleviation of acute and
chronic pain, despite limited evidence of its
Opioid-Related Hyperthermia in Cats efficacy. Well‐designed clinical and experimen-
Published studies and anecdotal reports indi- tal studies indicate that in dogs, tramadol used
cate that hyperthermia may occur with opioid alone does not provide sufficient antinocicep-
administration in cats (Niedfeldt and Robertson tion or analgesia and cannot be recommended
172 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
for peri‐operative use (Davila et al. 2013; be with the oral formulation (caplets, tablets,
Schutter et al. 2017). Cats do produce active or liquid).
tramadol metabolites and experimental studies This class of drugs should be used with cau-
demonstrate its antinociceptive properties, with tion in animals of unknown health status,
4.0 mg/kg orally (PO) having approximately a when renal or hepatic function is unknown,
six‐hour duration (Pypendop et al. 2009). After and in the face of dehydration, hypovolemia,
administration cats exhibit opioid‐related and hypotension. In the face of low perfusion
behavior, including sedation, pupil dilation, and pressure, renal prostaglandins are released to
euphoria. In cats undergoing ovariohysterec- preserve renal perfusion, a response that is
tomy, tramadol (2 mg/kg SC) combined with inhibited by the use of NSAIDs.
the NSAID vedaprofen (0.5 mg/kg PO) provided Several NSAIDs are labeled for peri‐operative
superior post‐operative analgesia than either use, including prior to surgery, but these drugs
drug alone (Brondani et al. 2009). are not anesthetic sparing so should be com-
In the United States, tramadol is a Schedule bined with sedatives, tranquilizers, opioids,
IV drug and is only available in an oral and local anesthetics. Pre‐operative adminis-
(tablet) formulation; it is on the Drug tration has some advantages over post‐operative
Enforcement Administration (DEA) list of use (Lascelles et al. 1998). The pre‐emptive
drugs that are of concern for diversion. The effects of NSAIDs are less than those of the
oral tablets are rarely found to be palatable in opioids, so if an opioid is on board prior to
cats, even after compounding with cat‐specific surgery, many practitioners choose to give
flavors. The product with the tradename NSAIDs in recovery when the patient is wak-
Ultracet® should never be used in cats because ing up and only if surgery was uneventful.
it contains acetaminophen (paracetamol). In Ketoprofen is not recommended for pre‐surgical
some countries an injectable product is avail- use based on reports of it causing increased
able and is popular in combination with an bleeding times in dogs (Grisneaux et al. 1999).
NSAID to provide analgesia for feline soft For recommended doses of NSAIDs, see
tissue procedures. Tables 8.4 and 8.5.
Table 8.4 Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) recommended for alleviation of acute pain
in dogs. Availability of NSAIDs and market authorization for dogs and cats vary widely in different
countries.
Table 8.5 Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) recommended for alleviation of acute pain
in cats. Injectable formulations can be given in the peri-operative period; ketoprofen and tolfenamic acid
are not recommended for pre-operative use. A few select oral formulations can be given post-operatively.
When repeated, the dosing interval for listed NSAIDs is 24 hours.
not inhibited by incisional infiltration of the (3 mg/kg) and incisional bupivacaine (“splash”
linea alba with lidocaine 1% (2 mg/kg) and application; 1 mg/kg after ovariohysterectomy
anesthesia of the mesovarium (0.5 ml of and before complete closure) over the IP tech-
lidocaine 2%; Bubalo et al. 2008). Therefore, nique alone; all dogs received morphine and
longer‐acting local anesthetics such as carprofen (Kalchofner Guerrero et al. 2016). IP
bupivacaine or ropivacaine should be used for administration of ropivacaine 0.75% (3 mg/kg)
these techniques. or bupivacaine 0.5% (3 mg/kg) provided similar
Published reports on the use of incisional post‐operative analgesia when administered in
anesthesia alone are conflicting. SC and IM combination with morphine and carprofen
infiltration of bupivacaine (0.25% 2 mg/kg) at (Lambertini et al. 2018).
the incision site before surgery was associated In summary, when performing abdominal
with significantly lower pain scores and less surgery in dogs, use bupivacaine or ropiv-
need for post‐operative opioids compared to acaine, and if only one technique is to be used,
post‐operative administration of incisional choose intraperitoneal administration. This
bupivacaine (splash block) or placebo in dogs technique should be considered for any
undergoing celiotomy, suggesting that timing intraabdominal procedure, including foreign
(pre‐emptive use) is important (Savvas et al. body removal and splenectomy. The WSAVA’s
2008). In contrast, benefits of incisional anes- Global Pain Council site provides links to vid-
thesia in dogs undergoing ovariohysterectomy eos of several local anesthetic techniques,
were not apparent in two other studies, and the including incisional and intraperitoneal anes-
reasons put forth were that when robust multi- thesia (http://www.wsava.org/Committees/
modal analgesia is used, additional benefits are Global‐Pain‐Council).
difficult to discern, and that recognizing pain
in the clinical setting is challenging (Fitzpatrick Feline Studies The pharmacokinetics, safety,
et al. 2010; McKune et al. 2014). and efficacy of IP bupivacaine have been
A recent study showed no benefits in dogs reported in cats (Benito et al. 2016a, b, 2018).
undergoing ovariohysterectomy of using IP When bupivacaine 0.25% (2 mg/kg) was placed
Perioperative Analgesia 175
received pre‐operative buprenorphine and car- part of a multimodal approach to pain manage-
profen. The isoflurane requirements were sig- ment and should be in addition to opioids and/
nificantly lower, as were pain scores at the time or NSAIDs, not a substitute for these drugs. This
of discharge (five to six hours post‐operatively) author recommends the use of lidocaine at a
in the lidocaine group. In another study all dogs dose of 1–2 mg/kg (2% solution), as it is readily
received pre‐operative morphine and meloxi- available worldwide, inexpensive, and has a
cam and either an intratesticular injection of greater margin of safety than bupivacaine (Neal
2 mg/kg of lidocaine or an equal volume of et al. 2010). The recommended technique is as
saline; dogs in the lidocaine group had signifi- follows and performed under sterile conditions:
cantly lower heart rates and mean arterial blood use a 22‐gauge 25 mm (1 in.) needle and appro-
pressure during surgery, indicating an antinoci- priate‐sized syringe to draw up the lidocaine; if
ceptive effect (Huuskonen et al. 2013). Although the drug is drawn up through a rubber stopper,
fewer dogs in the lidocaine group required post‐ use a separate needle for the intratesticular
operative rescue analgesia, this was not statisti- injection, since the rubber stopper blunts and
cally significant (Huuskonen et al. 2013). Perez deforms the tip of the needle. With the dog in
et al. (2013) compared three protocols for dogs dorsal recumbency, hold the testicle and insert
undergoing castration: hydromorphone and the needle at the caudal pole of the testicle and
carprofen alone; hydromorphone and carprofen direct it toward the spermatic cord, aspirate the
plus intratesticular bupivacaine (0.5 mg/kg per syringe to check for the absence of blood, then
testis); and hydromorphone and carprofen plus inject the calculated volume of lidocaine; the
epidural morphine (0.1 mg/kg). Dogs that testicle may become turgid, but the injection is
received intratesticular bupivacaine or epidural stopped prematurely only if there is marked
morphine required fewer intraoperative doses resistance to injection; repeat the procedure on
of fentanyl to obtund responses to surgery the other side. Occasionally some blood oozes
(changes in heart rate, mean arterial pressure, from the needle site, suggesting that a hema-
and respiratory rate), required less hydromor- toma may have formed or a small vessel has
phone post‐operatively, and had lower post‐ been damaged. After injection, surgery can
operative pain scores; there were no differences begin within one minute. The WSAVA’s Global
between the intratesticular bupivacaine group Pain Council site provides links to videos of sev-
and the epidural morphine group for these eral local anesthetic techniques, including
parameters. Serum cortisol values were also intratesticular blocks (http://www.wsava.org/
measured and were lowest in the intratesticular Committees/Global‐Pain‐Council).
group. Another study compared intratesticular
lidocaine (1 mg/kg) plus bupivacaine (1 mg/kg) Cats Intratesticular injections of lidocaine
to placebo (saline) in dogs that also received can be used in adult male cats and are
morphine and carprofen for castration (Stevens documented to reduce the nociceptive response
et al. 2013). All dogs in this study had low post‐ to castration under anesthesia, as measured by
operative pain scores, with no difference pulse rate, heart rate variability, and mean
between placebo and local anesthetic groups. arterial blood pressure (Moldal et al. 2012).
Dogs in the local anesthetic group were less The dose of lidocaine is 2 mg/kg, therefore
likely to produce a cremaster muscle twitch dur- 0.1 ml/kg of 2% (20 mg/ml) lidocaine is drawn
ing ligation than the placebo‐treated dogs. up; the technique described by Moldal and
Overall, there is good evidence to support the colleagues is as follows. One‐third of this is
use of intratesticular local anesthetics in dogs injected (using a 25‐ or 27‐gauge needle) into
undergoing castration. None of the studies dis- each testicle; with the cat in dorsal recumbency
cussed reported unacceptable adverse effects the injection is made in a craniodorsal location,
related to the procedure. This block should be directing the needle caudoventrally; and the
Perioperative Analgesia 177
remaining one‐third is injected SC where the amputations or following severe trauma (e.g.
incision will be made. fractures, burns, extensive wounds) and is
extremely economical. Ketamine has been
shown to reduce C‐reactive proteins in dogs
Ketamine
with pyometra and may have immunomodu-
Ketamine has traditionally been considered a lating effects in the face of endotoxemia
dissociative anesthetic, but its role as a poten- (DeClue et al. 2008; Liao et al. 2014).
tial analgesic, or antihyperalgesic agent, has
evolved over the years in human and veteri-
Other Strategies for Preventing or
nary medicine (Kohrs and Durieux 1998; Pozzi
Alleviating Pain
et al. 2006). Ketamine is a non‐competitive
NMDA receptor antagonist. Activation and The surgical technique itself can impact on
modulation of NMDA receptors by the excita- post‐operative pain. In cats, ovariohysterec-
tory neurotransmitter glutamate are thought tomy performed via the flank was more painful
to be the primary mechanism in the develop- than when performed via a midline abdominal
ment of central sensitization and secondary approach (Grint et al. 2006); however, no differ-
hyperalgesia. ences in post‐operative pain scores were noted
In a study of female dogs undergoing ovario- in cats undergoing ovariectomy via the flank or
hysterectomy, dogs received a sub‐anesthetic midline, with all cats receiving the same anes-
dose of ketamine (2.5 mg/kg IM) pre‐opera- thetic and analgesic protocol (Swaffield et al.
tively or post‐operatively (at extubation), or 2019). Kittens were less painful than adult cats
saline (Slingsby and Waterman‐Pearson following ovariohysterectomy (Polson et al.
2000a). Other analgesic agents were not given, 2013) and this could be related to the smaller
and pre‐medication was with acepromazine incisions required in pediatric patients, which
and anesthesia induced with thiopental. in turn produce less inflammation.
Mechanical nociceptive thresholds were The effects of providing good patient nurs-
measured, and pain scores recorded before ing care and reducing stress should never be
pre‐medication and post‐operatively for up to underestimated as adjuncts to pain manage-
18 hours after extubation. Dogs in the control ment strategies.
(saline) group required more rescue analge-
sics, showed more wound sensitivity, and had Cryotherapy
higher pain scores throughout the post‐opera- Cryotherapy or cold therapy is one of the most
tive period than those in the two ketamine underutilized analgesic techniques, yet it is
groups. Administration of ketamine before inexpensive and simple to provide. Cold
surgery was more effective than administra- reduces swelling and inflammation, slows
tion after surgery (Slingsby and Waterman‐ local metabolism, and decreases vascular per-
Pearson 2000a). Ketamine should not be the meability. Cold also activates specific transient
sole agent used to alleviate acute pain, but can receptor potential (TRP) ion channels in sen-
be used as part of a multimodal peri‐operative sory neurons that reduce pain after injury (Liu
anesthesia and analgesia plan. Ketamine can et al. 2013). Incisions can be iced with com-
also be a valuable addition to an anesthetic or mercially available cold packs or crushed ice in
analgesic plan when used at sub‐anesthetic zip‐lock bags wrapped in a thin towel. Use for
doses as an infusion (Wagner et al. 2002). It 10–20 minutes at a time and repeat every
decreases the requirements for inhalant agents 4–6 hours. To save on personal time, ice packs
(Muir et al. 2003) and provides protection can be held in place with wraps, such as 3M™
against central sensitization; this can be an Vetrap™ (3M, St. Paul, MN), elasticated band-
effective technique for major surgeries such as ages, and T‐shirts.
178 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
i nformation from other species, placing heav- during ovariohysterectomy is the transfer of
ily pregnant or obese animals in a reverse anesthetic drugs from the maternal circula-
Trendelenburg position (head elevated by tion across the placenta to the fetuses (White
15–30°) may enhance respiratory function. 2012). Based on the AVMA euthanasia guide-
This is likely due to decreased pressure on the lines and a commentary on this topic (White
diaphragm by the gravid uterus, and increased 2012), it is recommended that when pregnant
thoracic excursions and lung volumes (De Jong dogs and cats undergo ovariohysterectomy,
et al. 2014; Figure 8.1). the uterine blood vessels be ligated and the
The welfare of the in‐utero fetuses removed fetuses left undisturbed and in situ to ensure
from the dam must be considered and the fetal death without suffering. If for some rea-
most appropriate way to ensure their humane son the uterus is to be opened to remove the
death has been a concern for veterinarians fetuses, this should not be done for at least one
performing these procedures (White 2012). hour (White 2012).
Until recently there was a paucity of informa-
tion on whether or not fetuses could suffer,
Lactating Animals
leading to diverse opinions on what to do with
pregnant animals presented for ovariohyster- Secretion into milk would be enhanced if a
ectomy, ranging from injecting each fetus with drug was highly lipid soluble, non‐ionized, and
a euthanasia solution to refusing to perform had a low molecular weight. Little is known
the procedure (White 2012). about excretion of drugs into dog or cat milk,
The prerequisites for suffering are sentience but extrapolation from species where milk
and consciousness (Mellor and Diesch 2006). withholding is mandatory after the animal is
To perceive sensations animals must have a treated suggests that approximately 1–2% of
sufficiently developed neural system that can the maternal dose reaches the neonate. Opioid
receive and process incoming information and drugs are lipid soluble and more likely to reach
be conscious. If these sensations are painful or milk when compared to NSAIDs, which are
aversive, suffering may result (Mellor and highly protein bound and poorly lipid soluble.
Diesch 2006). Scientific research indicates that If opioids are given to the dam, the neonates
mammalian embryos and fetuses are uncon- should be observed for side effects such as
scious during gestation and the birth process. somnolence. Short‐term (one to two days’)
The moderately immature neurologic function treatment of lactating animals with NSAIDs
of dogs and cats at this life stage is thought to appears to be safe for offspring.
contribute to this unconscious state. In these
species, sentience is not achieved until several
Anesthesia for the Young and Old
days after parturition. Other factors including
chemical inhibitors such as adenosine, prosta- Anesthesia for dogs and cats at either end of
glandins, and allopregnalone contribute to the age spectrum deserves special considera-
unconsciousness or a neuro‐inhibited state tion. The unique needs of dogs and cats at
while in utero (Mellor and Diesch 2006; Mellor different life stages have led to the publication
2010; Aleman et al. 2017). Based on this data, of several excellent resources: American
the 2013 AVMA Guidelines for the Euthanasia Association of Feline Practitioners (AAFP)‐
of Animals state that “embryos and fetuses American Animal Hospital Association
cannot consciously experience feelings such as (AAHA) Feline Life Stages Guidelines (https://
pain or breathlessness” and Mellor and Diesch catvets.com/guidelines/practice‐guidelines/
(2006) also conclude that embryos and fetuses life‐stage‐guidelines); AAFP Senior Care
cannot suffer before birth. An additional fac- Guidelines (https://catvets.com/guidelines/
tor that protects unborn kittens and puppies practice‐guidelines/senior‐care‐guidelines);
Anesthesia for Special Populations 181
AAHA Senior Care Guidelines for Dogs and Anesthetic Mortality Related
Cats (https://www.aaha.org/globalassets/02‐ to Advancing Age
guidelines/senior‐care/senior‐care‐guidelines). Older cats were reported to have a higher anes-
Anesthesia and analgesia for pediatric thetic risk – cats older than 12 years were twice
patients are covered in Chapter 9; however, it as likely to die compared to cats aged 6 months
is worth reiterating that with many anes- to 5 years, independent from the American
thetic and analgesic drugs in very young and Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) status
therefore small animals, they may require (Brodbelt et al. 2007; see Chapter 7). No mean-
relatively larger doses of drugs because of ingful data is available for dogs because their
their grater BSA to body mass ratio (Bushby longevity depends on weight and breed. A 10‐
and Griffin 2011; Joyce and Yates 2011; year‐old dog could be at the very far end of its
Tables 8.6 and 8.7). expected life span or somewhere in the middle.
Dogs age at different rates, depending on However, aging results in a decrease in reserve
their breed and size; dogs may be considered capacity of all vital organs and a change in
“senior” when they have reached 75% of their body composition which affects drug distribu-
expected life span. Cats tend to age more uni- tion and metabolism.
formly and could be considered senior between
11 and 14 years of age and geriatric between 15 Age-Related Changes and Their
and 25 years of age. In human medicine, senior Influence on Anesthesia
is a term reserved for a specific age in a spec- The most important age‐related changes in
trum, but geriatric is more than just aging. cardiac function in older animals are decreased
Frailty is considered a distinct syndrome when ventricular compliance and cardiac reserve.
three or more of the following are present: This renders older animals less tolerant of
weakness, slowness, poor physical endurance, acute changes in intravascular volume – both
and unintended weight loss; this can be applied fluid loss and fluid overload.
to our veterinary patients, too (Chen et al. Older patients have a decreased respiratory
2014). It must be remembered that regardless reserve. Vital capacity is reduced, the chest
of age, a dog or cat’s physical status is impor- wall and lungs become less compliant, and
tant to consider when planning for anesthesia anatomic dead space increases, making them
and surgery. more susceptible to hypoxia and hypercapnia.
Table 8.6 The Kitten Quad protocol. Body surface area (BSA) is calculated using the formula BSA =
(10.4 × bodyweight in kg0.67)/100. 10.4 is a calculated constant (K) for cats. Dosing of drugs based on BSA:
medetomidine (600 microg/m2), ketamine (60 mg/m2), midazolam (3 mg/m2), and buprenorphine
(180 microg/m2) in very small (0.5–2.0 kg) kittens (Joyce and Yates 2011). For clinical use, the volumes
of each drug are also given in milliliters.
Bodyweight (BW), kg BW, lb BSA (m2) Volume of each drug (ml) Total volume (ml)
Notes: Drug concentrations medetomidine 1.0 mg/ml, ketamine 100 mg/ml, midazolam 5 mg/ml, buprenorphine 0.3 mg/ml.
The concentration of dexmedetomidine is 0.5 mg/ml and can be substituted in equal volume for medetomidine.
Ketamine, midazolam, and buprenorphine are controlled drugs and must be correctly logged.
182 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
Table 8.7 Suggested doses of dexmedetomidine, ketamine, and butorphanol for kittens less than 2 kg
(Bushby and Griffin 2011). Note the metabolic scaling used: the smaller the kitten, the more drug it receives
on a mg/kg basis.
Volume of each
Bodyweight (BW) kg BW lb drug (ml) Total volume (ml) rounded up
Notes: Drug concentrations dexmedetomidine 0.5 mg/ml, ketamine 100 mg/ml, butorphanol 10 mg/ml. See Box 8.2
for details on preparing this “premix.”
Ketamine and butorphanol are controlled drugs and must be correctly logged.
With a decrease in respiratory reserve, older and treat hypotension and to maintain normal
animals may rapidly become hypoxic in the fluid balance and organ perfusion.
immediate post‐induction period and for this Brain mass decreases with age as a result of
reason, pre‐oxygenation is recommended in neuronal loss, cerebral blood flow declines, and
older patients (McNally et al. 2009). the quantity of neurotransmitters is reduced.
As animals age, renal blood flow decreases, Specific age‐related changes indicative of neu-
as does glomerular filtration rate and the num- rodegeneration similar to those seen in aged
ber of functional glomeruli. Older animals people have been identified in the brain, brain
may have underlying renal pathology which is stem, and spinal cord of cats (Zhang et al. 2005;
well compensated for until they are stressed in Gunn‐Moore et al. 2006). In humans the
the peri‐operative period (fasting, fluid depri- requirements for inhalant agents decrease with
vation, and hypotension), therefore overt post‐ advancing age (Nickalls and Mapleson 2003)
anesthetic renal failure is a real concern. These and this has also been demonstrated in dogs
patients may be administered NSAIDs for (Magnusson et al. 2000; Yamashita et al. 2009).
chronic pain or be given them for the acute Because of the documented decrease in anes-
pain associated with surgical procedures. thetic requirements in older patients, the depth
These drugs block prostaglandin production, of anesthesia must be closely monitored.
which is important for maintaining renal blood Age can cause changes in drug concentra-
flow during periods of hypotension. If an tion at the site of action and also alter drug
NSAID is used in the peri‐anesthetic period, action per se. Some of these changes are related
great care must be taken to prevent, recognize, to altered body composition, blood flow, and
www.ajlobby.com
Anesthesia for Special Populations 183
organ perfusion, and some are a result of older patients than in younger ones. For
altered metabolism and excretion and changes pre‐medication, midazolam has an advantage
in the number and density of receptors in tar- over diazepam because it can be given IM.
get organs. In essence, advanced age can result These drugs are also reversible with flumazenil
in unpredictable drug effects, therefore careful should an adverse event occur or if recovery is
choice and administration are the key to a good prolonged. Opioids produce sedation and
outcome. It is prudent to choose drugs that are provide analgesia and should be a part of the
reversible, can be given “to effect,” and have a anesthetic protocols. Ketamine may cause a
short duration of action. significant increase in heart rate and blood pres-
As with all patients, a complete history sure, which may be detrimental to some older
(to the extent that can be obtained) and physi- patients. Propofol can be titrated slowly “to
cal examination are mandatory. Clinical find- effect” without causing excitement, and when
ings will dictate which pre‐anesthetic blood used after pre‐medication the dose required for
work and tests are undertaken; however, induction is significantly reduced. When pre-
hematologic and biochemical analyses of 101 ceded by intravenous diazepam or midazolam,
dogs aged over seven years resulted in 30 new induction is smooth and the dose can be signifi-
diagnoses and cancelation of surgery in 13 cantly reduced (Sanchez et al. 2013). Alfaxalone
patients (Joubert 2007). Therefore if the can also be used as described previously and has
resources are available, pre‐anesthetic blood a higher therapeutic index than propofol.
work is recommended in older patients. Although our older patients may be “more
One of the most commonly made mistakes delicate” and challenging to anesthetize, with
when anesthetizing older patients is to depend careful assessment and choice of anesthetic
primarily on inhalant agents and avoid pre‐ protocols a good outcome should be the rule
medicant agents, in the misunderstanding that and not the exception. The key points are that
inhalant agents are somehow “safer.” Sedation is they have less reserve capacity, and when
recommended to decrease anxiety and fear that possible anesthesia should be induced with
lead to increased catecholamine release, which injectable agents (IV) to effect, as they usually
predisposes to cardiac arrhythmias, peripheral require lower drug doses on a mg/kg basis.
vasoconstriction, increased cardiac work, and
decreased tissue perfusion. Acepromazine is not
Anesthesia of Non-socialized Cats
contraindicated in geriatric patients, although
dose requirements (on an mg/kg basis) may be The term “feral” as applied to cats is not well
decreased. Acepromazine is an antiemetic and defined, is used to mean different things within
antiarrhythmic, but one of its most important and between countries, and is sometimes
properties is its anesthetic‐sparing effect (Heard interchanged with the terms “free‐roaming,”
et al. 1986). Two studies have examined the “street,” or “community cat” (Gosling et al.
effects of acepromazine on systemic blood pres- 2013). See Chapter 25 in this text for more
sure and glomerular filtration rate (Newell et al. information on these cats and their life histo-
1997; Bostrom et al. 2003); acepromazine ries, and Chapter 35 for information on organ-
appears to protect renal function, at least in nor- izing feral cat clinics. It is important to
mal dogs, despite a decrease in blood pressure. understand the behavior of these cats when
Preserving renal blood flow and glomerular fil- working with them to safeguard both person-
tration rate is especially important in older nel and the welfare of the cats themselves. One
patients, who may have decreased renal reserve proposed definition is “a feral cat is one that is
or are receiving NSAIDs. unapproachable in its free‐roaming environ-
Benzodiazepines such as midazolam and ment and is capable of surviving with or with-
diazepam produce more reliable sedation in out direct human intervention, and may
www.ajlobby.com
184 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
additionally show fearful or defensive behavior no adverse effects were noted (Pankratz et al.
on human contact” (Gosling et al. 2013). One 2018). It is likely that cats would eat wet food
approach to population management is TNVR. containing gabapentin, but this should be care-
This may be done on a small or large scale and fully placed from outside the trap only after
the anesthetic protocol is essential to a success- they are captured; food should not be baited
ful outcome (Williams et al. 2002). Humane for trapping unless traps are visited on a regu-
traps are used to secure these cats and the cat lar basis (e.g. two‐hourly intervals), as some
remains in the trap during transport, for anes- cats become very somnolent and could become
thesia, and during recovery; at no time is the hypothermic.
cat outside the trap while conscious. Because The ideal anesthetic for this situation would
these cats cannot be handled while awake, no have a high therapeutic index or ratio, consti-
pre‐operative evaluation other than a visual tute a small volume, be suitable for males and
assessment of the cat within the trap can be females of all ages, produce a rapid onset and
made. Anesthesia must be achieved via IM predictable duration of surgical anesthesia, but
injection with the cat safely restrained in its allow cats to recover quickly, incorporate an
trap (Figure 8.2). analgesic agent, and be cost effective (Williams
The impact of fear on the welfare of feral et al. 2002; Harrison et al. 2011). The section
cats, and on anesthetic and surgical proce- on total IM anesthesia discusses several proto-
dures, has been a concern for many working in cols that would be suited to TNR clinics, for
this field. Administration of gabapentin (50 or example tiletamine/zolazepam/butorphanol/
100 mg) compounded into a liquid formulation dexmedetomidine and dexmedetomidine/ket-
and given to cats using a catheter (e.g. Tomcat amine/butorphanol.
catheter) attached to a syringe had beneficial
effects (Pankratz et al. 2018; see Chapter 6,
Figure 6.17). Feline stress scores decreased Monitoring Anesthetized
with both doses of gabapentin compared to Patients
placebo and peak effect occurred at two hours,
Monitoring individual cats in large‐scale clinics
where the throughput can be higher than 50
cats per hour presents some unique challenges
(Williams et al. 2002). The American College of
Veterinary Anesthesia and Analgesia (www.
acvaa.org/docs/Small_Animal_
Monitoring_2009.doc) and the Association of
Shelter Veterinarians (Association of Shelter
Veterinarians’ Veterinary Task Force to Advance
et al. 2016) have crafted guidelines for monitor-
ing of anesthetized patients, but in some situa-
tions adhering to these may not be possible.
Many clinics have limited personnel and moni-
toring equipment. However, trained, vigilant
staff and volunteers can recognize problems
rapidly and intervene. Mucus membrane color
and respiration can be monitored by observa-
tion. Pulse quality, rate, and rhythm can be
Figure 8.2 Correct restraint of an unsocialized cat
within a humane trap, using a comb for assessed by palpation and the heart can be aus-
intramuscular injection. cultated. Depth of anesthesia is judged on jaw
www.ajlobby.com
References 185
tone, eye position, and response to noxious anesthetic death in cats (Brodbelt et al. 2007).
stimuli. Purchasing of monitoring equipment is Doppler ultrasound is also valuable as it con-
highly recommended, but it should be carefully firms blood flow (circulation) and allows a pulse
chosen. The use of pulse oximetry is encour- rate to be counted when placed over an artery,
aged because this modality provides an objec- can be used on any size patient, and with the
tive auditory and visual means of determining addition of a sphygmomanometer and blood
the presence of a pulse, pulse rate, and adequacy pressure cuff allows systolic blood pressure to
of oxygenation; use of pulse oximetry moni- be measured. Further information on anes-
tors has been shown to decrease the risk of thetic monitoring can be found in Chapter 10.
References
Aleman, M., Weich, K.M., and Madigan, J.E. Boveri, S., Brearley, J.C., and Dugdale, A.H.
(2017). Survey of veterinarians using a novel (2013). The effect of body condition on
physical compression squeeze procedure in propofol requirement in dogs. Vet. Anaesth.
the management of neonatal maladjustment Analg. 40: 449–454.
syndrome in foals. Animals (Basel) 7: E69. Brodbelt, D.C., Pfeiffer, D.U., Young, L.E., and
Association of Shelter Veterinarians’ Veterinary Wood, J.L. (2007). Risk factors for anaesthetic‐
Task Force to Advance, S.‐N, Griffin, B., related death in cats: results from the
Bushby, P.A. et al. (2016). The Association of confidential enquiry into perioperative small
Shelter Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical animal fatalities (CEPSAF). Br. J. Anaesth. 99:
care guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. 617–623.
JAVMA 249: 165–188. Brodbelt, D.C., Pfeiffer, D.U., Young, L.E., and
Benito, J., Monteiro, B., Lavoie, A.M. et al. Wood, J.L. (2008). Results of the confidential
(2016a). Analgesic efficacy of intraperitoneal enquiry into perioperative small animal
administration of bupivacaine in cats. J. Feline fatalities regarding risk factors for anesthetic‐
Med. Surg. 18: 906–912. related death in dogs. JAVMA 233: 1096–1104.
Benito, J., Monteiro, B.P., Beaudry, F. et al. Brondani, J.T., Loureiro Luna, S.P., Beier, S.L. et al.
(2016b). Pharmacokinetics of bupivacaine (2009). Analgesic efficacy of perioperative use
after intraperitoneal administration to cats of vedaprofen, tramadol or their combination in
undergoing ovariohysterectomy. Am. J. Vet. cats undergoing ovariohysterectomy. J. Feline
Res. 77: 641–645. Med. Surg. 11: 420–429.
Benito, J., Monteiro, B., Beaudry, F., and Steagall, P. Brooks, V.L. and Keil, L.C. (1994). Hemorrhage
(2018). Efficacy and pharmacokinetics of decreases arterial pressure sooner in pregnant
bupivacaine with epinephrine or compared with nonpregnant dogs: role of
dexmedetomidine after intraperitoneal baroreflex. Am. J. Phys. 266: H1610–H1619.
administration in cats undergoing Bruniges, N., Taylor, P.M., and Yates, D. (2016).
ovariohysterectomy. Can. J. Vet. Res. 82: 124–130. Injectable anaesthesia for adult cat and kitten
Bortolami, E., Slingsby, L., and Love, E.J. (2012). castration: effects of medetomidine,
Comparison of two formulations of dexmedetomidine and atipamezole on
buprenorphine in cats administered by the recovery. J. Feline Med. Surg. 18: 860–867.
oral transmucosal route. J. Feline Med. Surg. Bubalo, V., Moens, Y.P., Holzmann, A., and
14: 534–539. Coppens, P. (2008). Anaesthetic sparing effect
Bostrom, I., Nyman, G., Kampa, N. et al. (2003). of local anaesthesia of the ovarian pedicle
Effects of acepromazine on renal function in during ovariohysterectomy in dogs. Vet.
anesthetized dogs. Am. J. Vet. Res. 64: 590–598. Anaesth. Analg. 35: 537–542.
www.ajlobby.com
186 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
Bushby, P.A. and Griffin, B. (2011). An overview Deutsch, J., Jolliffe, C., Archer, E., and Leece,
of pediatric spay and neuter benefits and E.A. (2017). Intramuscular injection of
techniques. dvm360 (1 February). http:// alfaxalone in combination with butorphanol
veterinarymedicine.dvm360.com/overview‐ for sedation in cats. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 44:
pediatric‐spay‐and‐neuter‐benefits‐and‐ 794–802.
techniques. Doebeli, A., Michel, E., Bettschart, R. et al.
Carpenter, R.E., Wilson, D.V., and Evans, A.T. (2013). Apgar score after induction of
(2004). Evaluation of intraperitoneal and anesthesia for canine cesarean section with
incisional lidocaine or bupivacaine for alfaxalone versus propofol. Theriogenology 80:
analgesia following ovariohysterectomy in the 850–854.
dog. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 31: 46–52. Dyson, D.H., Maxie, M.G., and Schnurr, D.
Chan, M.T., Mainland, P., and Gin, T. (1996). (1998). Morbidity and mortality associated
Minimum alveolar concentration of halothane with anesthetic management in small animal
and enflurane are decreased in early veterinary practice in Ontario. J. Am. Anim.
pregnancy. Anesthesiology 85: 782–786. Hosp. Assoc. 34: 325–335.
Chen, X., Mao, G., and Leng, S.X. (2014). Frailty Ferreira, T.H., Rezende, M.L., Mama, K.R. et al.
syndrome: an overview. Clin. Interv. Aging 9: (2011). Plasma concentrations and behavioral,
433–441. antinociceptive, and physiologic effects of
Cistola, A.M., Golder, F.J., Centonze, L.A. et al. methadone after intravenous and oral
(2004). Anesthetic and physiologic effects of transmucosal administration in cats. Am.
tiletamine, zolazepam, ketamine, and xylazine J. Vet. Res. 72: 764–771.
combination (TKX) in feral cats undergoing Fertziger, A.P., Stein, E.A., and Lynch, J.J. (1974).
surgical sterilization. J. Feline Med. Surg. 6: Letter: suppression of morphine‐induced
297–303. mania in cats. Psychopharmacologia 36:
Clarke, K.M. and Hall, L. (1990). A survey of 185–187.
anaesthesia in small animal practice. AVA/ Fitzpatrick, C.L., Weir, H.L., and Monnet, E.
BSAVA report. J. Vet. Anaesth. 17: 4–10. (2010). Effects of infiltration of the incision
Cohen, A.E. and Bennett, S.L. (2015). Oral site with bupivacaine on postoperative pain
transmucosal administration of and incisional healing in dogs undergoing
dexmedetomidine for sedation in 4 dogs. ovariohysterectomy. JAVMA 237: 395–401.
Can. Vet. J. 56: 1144–1148. Fudge, J.M., Page, B., Mackrell, A., and Lee, I.
Davila, D., Keeshen, T.P., Evans, R.B., and (2019). Evaluation of targeted bupivacaine for
Conzemius, M.G. (2013). Comparison of the reducing acute postoperative pain in cats
analgesic efficacy of perioperative firocoxib undergoing routine ovariohysterectomy.
and tramadol administration in dogs J. Feline Med. Surg. https://doi.org/10.1177/
undergoing tibial plateau leveling osteotomy. 1098612X19826700.
JAVMA 243: 225–231. Gin, T. and Chan, M.T. (1994). Decreased
De Jong, A., Futier, E., Millot, A. et al. (2014). minimum alveolar concentration of isoflurane
How to preoxygenate in operative room: in pregnant humans. Anesthesiology 81:
healthy subjects and situations “at risk”. Ann. 829–832.
Fr. Anesth. Reanim. 33: 457–461. Giordano, T., Steagall, P.V., Ferreira, T.H. et al.
DeClue, A.E., Cohn, L.A., Lechner, E.S. et al. (2010). Postoperative analgesic effects of
(2008). Effects of subanesthetic doses of intravenous, intramuscular, subcutaneous or
ketamine on hemodynamic and immunologic oral transmucosal buprenorphine administered
variables in dogs with experimentally induced to cats undergoing ovariohysterectomy.
endotoxemia. Am. J. Vet. Res. 69: 228–232. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 37: 357–366.
www.ajlobby.com
References 187
www.ajlobby.com
188 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
www.ajlobby.com
References 189
McKune, C.M., Pascoe, P.J., Lascelles, B.D., and ketamine, and morphine‐lidocaine‐ketamine
Kass, P.H. (2014). The challenge of evaluating drug combination on minimum alveolar
pain and a pre‐incisional local anesthetic concentration in dogs anesthetized with
block. PeerJ 2: e341. isoflurane. Am. J. Vet. Res. 64: 1155–1160.
McMillan, M.W., Seymour, C.J., and Brearley, Murrell, J. (2011). Clinical use of methadone in
J.C. (2012). Effect of intratesticular lidocaine cats and dogs. Companion Anim. 16: 56–61.
on isoflurane requirements in dogs Murrell, J.C. and Hellebrekers, L.J. (2005).
undergoing routine castration. J. Small Anim. Medetomidine and dexmedetomidine: a
Pract. 53: 393–397. review of cardiovascular effects and
McNally, E.M., Robertson, S.A., and Pablo, L.S. antinociceptive properties in the dog. Vet.
(2009). Comparison of time to desaturation Anaesth. Analg. 32: 117–127.
between preoxygenated and Neal, J.M., Bernards, C.M., Butterworth, J.F.t.
nonpreoxygenated dogs following sedation et al. (2010). ASRA practice advisory on local
with acepromazine maleate and morphine anesthetic systemic toxicity. Reg. Anesth. Pain
and induction of anesthesia with propofol. Med. 35: 152–161.
Am. J. Vet. Res. 70: 1333–1338. Nejamkin, P., Cavilla, V., Clausse, M. et al.
McSweeney, P.M., Martin, D.D., Ramsey, D.S., (2019). Sedative and physiologic effects of
and McKusick, B.C. (2012). Clinical efficacy tiletamine‐zolazepam following buccal
and safety of dexmedetomidine used as a administration in cats. J. Feline Med. Surg.
preanesthetic prior to general anesthesia in https://doi.org/10.1177/1098612X19827116.
cats. JAVMA 240: 404–412. Newell, S.M., Ko, J.C., Ginn, P.E. et al. (1997).
Mellor, D.J. (2010). Galloping colts, fetal feelings, Effects of three sedative protocols on
and reassuring regulations: putting animal‐ glomerular filtration rate in clinically normal
welfare science into practice. J. Vet. Med. Educ. dogs. Am. J. Vet. Res. 58: 446–450.
37: 94–100. Nickalls, R.W. and Mapleson, W.W. (2003). Age‐
Mellor, D.J. and Diesch, T.J. (2006). Onset of related iso‐MAC charts for isoflurane,
sentience: potential for suffering in fetal and sevoflurane and desflurane in man. Br. J.
neonatal farm animals. Appl. Anim. Behav. Anaesth. 91: 170–174.
Sci. 100: 45–57. Niedfeldt, R.L. and Robertson, S.A. (2006).
Metcalfe, S., Hulands‐Nave, A., Bell, M. et al. Postanesthetic hyperthermia in cats: a
(2014). Multicentre, randomised clinical trial retrospective comparison between
evaluating the efficacy and safety of alfaxalone hydromorphone and buprenorphine. Vet.
administered to bitches for induction of Anaesth. Analg. 33: 381–389.
anaesthesia prior to caesarean section. Aust. O’Hagan, B., Pasloske, K., McKinnon, C. et al.
Vet. J. 92: 333–338. (2012a). Clinical evaluation of alfaxalone as
Moldal, E.R., Eriksen, T., Kirpensteijn, J. et al. an anaesthetic induction agent in dogs less
(2012). Intratesticular and subcutaneous than 12 weeks of age. Aust. Vet. J. 90: 346–350.
lidocaine alters the intraoperative O’Hagan, B.J., Pasloske, K., McKinnon, C. et al.
haemodynamic responses and heart rate (2012b). Clinical evaluation of alfaxalone as
variability in male cats undergoing castration. an anaesthetic induction agent in cats less
Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 40: 63–73. than 12 weeks of age. Aust. Vet. J. 90: 395–401.
Moon, P.F., Erb, H.N., Ludders, J.W. et al. (1998). Pankratz, K.E., Ferris, K.K., Griffith, E.H., and
Perioperative management and mortality rates of Sherman, B.L. (2018). Use of single‐dose oral
dogs undergoing cesarean section in the United gabapentin to attenuate fear responses in
States and Canada. JAVMA 213: 365–369. cage‐trap confined community cats: a
Muir, W.W. 3rd, Wiese, A.J., and March, P.A. double‐blind, placebo‐controlled field trial.
(2003). Effects of morphine, lidocaine, J. Feline Med. Surg. 20: 535–543.
www.ajlobby.com
190 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
Pascoe, P.J. and Moon, P.F. (2001). Periparturient Pypendop, B.H., Siao, K.T., and Ilkiw, J.E. (2009).
and neonatal anesthesia. Vet. Clin. North Am. Effects of tramadol hydrochloride on the
Small Anim. Pract. 31 (315–40): vii. thermal threshold in cats. Am. J. Vet. Res. 70:
Perez, T.E., Grubb, T.L., Greene, S.A. et al. 1465–1470.
(2013). Effects of intratesticular injection of Reed, R. and Doherty, T. (2018). Minimum
bupivacaine and epidural administration of alveolar concentration: key concepts and a
morphine in dogs undergoing castration. review of its pharmacological reduction in
JAVMA 242: 631–642. dogs. Part 1. Res. Vet. Sci. 117: 266–270.
Pettifer, G. and Dyson, D. (2000). Ribas, T., Bublot, I., Junot, S. et al. (2015). Effects
Hydromorphone: a cost‐effective alternative to of intramuscular sedation with alfaxalone and
the use of oxymorphone. Can. Vet. J. 41: butorphanol on echocardiographic
135–137. measurements in healthy cats. J. Feline Med.
Polson, S., Taylor, P.M., and Yates, D. (2013). Surg. 17: 530–536.
Effects of age and reproductive status on Robertson, S.A. and Taylor, P.M. (2004). Pain
postoperative pain after routine management in cats—past, present and
ovariohysterectomy in cats. J. Feline Med. future. Part 2. Treatment of pain—clinical
Surg. 16 (2): 170–176. pharmacology. J. Feline Med. Surg. 6: 321–333.
Posner, L.P., Gleed, R.D., Erb, H.N., and Ludders, Robertson, S.A., Lascelles, B.D., Taylor, P.M., and
J.W. (2007). Post‐anesthetic hyperthermia in Sear, J.W. (2005). PK‐PD modeling of
cats. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 34: 40–47. buprenorphine in cats: intravenous and oral
Posner, L.P., Pavuk, A.A., Rokshar, J.L. et al. transmucosal administration. J. Vet.
(2010). Effects of opioids and anesthetic drugs Pharmacol. Ther. 28: 453–460.
on body temperature in cats. Vet. Anaesth. Robertson, S.A., Wegner, K., and Lascelles, B.D.
Analg. 37: 35–43. (2009). Antinociceptive and side‐effects of
Pottie, R.G., Dart, C.M., and Perkins, N.R. (2008). hydromorphone after subcutaneous
Speed of induction of anaesthesia in dogs administration in cats. J. Feline Med. Surg. 11:
administered halothane, isoflurane, 76–81.
sevoflurane or propofol in a clinical setting. Rodrigo‐Mocholi, D., Escudero, E., Belda, E.
Aust. Vet. J. 86: 26–31. et al. (2018). Pharmacokinetics and effects of
Pozzi, A., Muir, W.W., and Traverso, F. (2006). alfaxalone after intravenous and
Prevention of central sensitization and pain intramuscular administration to cats. N. Z. Vet.
by N‐methyl‐D‐aspartate receptor antagonists. J. 66: 172–177.
JAVMA 228: 53–60. Sanchez, A., Belda, E., Escobar, M. et al. (2013).
Pypendop, B.H. and Ilkiw, J.E. (2008). Effects of altering the sequence of midazolam
Pharmacokinetics of tramadol, and its and propofol during co‐induction of
metabolite O‐desmethyl‐tramadol, in cats. J. anaesthesia. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 40: 359–366.
Vet. Pharmacol. Ther. 31: 52–59. Santos, L.C., Ludders, J.W., Erb, H.N. et al.
Pypendop, B.H. and Ilkiw, J.E. (2014). (2011). A randomized, blinded, controlled
Relationship between plasma trial of the antiemetic effect of ondansetron
dexmedetomidine concentration and sedation on dexmedetomidine‐induced emesis in cats.
score and thermal threshold in cats. Am. J. Vet. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 38: 320–327.
Res. 75: 446–452. Savvas, I., Papazoglou, L.G., Kazakos, G. et al.
Pypendop, B.H., Ilkiw, J.E., and Shilo‐Benjamini, (2008). Incisional block with bupivacaine for
Y. (2014). Bioavailability of morphine, analgesia after celiotomy in dogs. J. Am. Anim.
methadone, hydromorphone, and Hosp. Assoc. 44: 60–66.
oxymorphone following buccal administration Schutter, A.F., Tunsmeyer, J., and Kastner, S.B.R.
in cats. J. Vet. Pharmacol. Ther. 37: 295–300. (2017). Influence of tramadol on acute thermal
www.ajlobby.com
References 191
and mechanical cutaneous nociception in dogs. Steagall, P.V., Pelligand, L., Giordano, T. et al.
Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 44: 309–316. (2013). Pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic
Shah, M., Yates, D., Hunt, J., and Murrell, J. modelling of intravenous, intramuscular and
(2018). Comparison between methadone and subcutaneous buprenorphine in conscious cats.
buprenorphine within the QUAD protocol for Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 40: 83–95.
perioperative analgesia in cats undergoing Steagall, P.V., Taylor, P.M., Rodrigues, L.C. et al.
ovariohysterectomy. J. Feline Med. Surg. 21 (8): (2009). Analgesia for cats after
723–731. https://doi.org/10.1177/10986 ovariohysterectomy with either
12X18798840. buprenorphine or carprofen alone or in
Shih, A.C., Robertson, S., Isaza, N. et al. (2008). combination. Vet. Rec. 164: 359–363.
Comparison between analgesic effects of Stevens, B.J., Posner, L.P., Jones, C.A., and
buprenorphine, carprofen, and buprenorphine Lascelles, B.D. (2013). Comparison of the
with carprofen for canine ovariohysterectomy. effect of intratesticular lidocaine/bupivacaine
Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 35: 69–79. vs. saline placebo on pain scores and incision
Sinclair, M.D. (2003). A review of the site reactions in dogs undergoing routine
physiological effects of alpha2‐agonists related castration. Vet. J. 196: 499–503.
to the clinical use of medetomidine in small Swaffield, M.J., Molloy, S.L., and Lipscomb, V.J.
animal practice. Can. Vet. J. 44: 885–897. (2019). Prospective comparison of
Slingsby, L.S. and Taylor, P.M. (2008). Thermal perioperative wound and pain score
antinociception after dexmedetomidine parameters in cats undergoing flank vs
administration in cats: a dose‐finding study. midline ovariectomy. J. Feline Med. Surg.
J. Vet. Pharmacol. Ther. 31: 135–142. https://doi.org/10.1177/1098612X19837038.
Slingsby, L.S., Taylor, P.M., and Monroe, T. Tan, E.K. and Tan, E.L. (2013). Alterations in
(2009). Thermal antinociception after physiology and anatomy during pregnancy. Best
dexmedetomidine administration in cats: a Pract. Res. Clin. Obstet. Gynaecol. 27: 791–802.
comparison between intramuscular and oral Taylor, P.M., Chengelis, C.P., Miller, W.R. et al.
transmucosal administration. J. Feline Med. (2012). Evaluation of propofol containing 2%
Surg. 11: 829–834. benzyl alcohol preservative in cats. J. Feline
Slingsby, L.S. and Waterman‐Pearson, A.E. Med. Surg. 14: 516–526.
(2000a). The post‐operative analgesic effects of Taylor, P.M., Kirby, J.J., Robinson, C. et al.
ketamine after canine ovariohysterectomy‐‐a (2010). A prospective multi‐centre clinical
comparison between pre‐ or post‐operative trial to compare buprenorphine and
administration. Res. Vet. Sci. 69: 147–152. butorphanol for postoperative analgesia in
Slingsby, L.S. and Waterman‐Pearson, A.E. cats. J. Feline Med. Surg. 12: 247–255.
(2000b). Postoperative analgesia in the cat Taylor, P.M., Robertson, S.A., Dixon, M.J. et al.
after ovariohysterectomy by use of carprofen, (2001). Morphine, pethidine and
ketoprofen, meloxicam or tolfenamic acid. buprenorphine disposition in the cat. J. Vet.
J. Small Anim. Pract. 41: 447–450. Pharmacol. Ther. 24: 391–398.
Stathopoulou, T.R., Kouki, M., Pypendop, B.H. Thies, M., Bracker, K., and Sinnott, V. (2017).
et al. (2018). Evaluation of analgesic effect and Retrospective evaluation of the effectiveness
absorption of buprenorphine after buccal of xylazine for inducing emesis in cats: 48 cats
administration in cats with oral disease. (2011‐2015). J. Vet. Emerg. Crit. Care (San
J. Feline Med. Surg. 20: 704–710. Antonio) 27: 658–661.
Steagall, P.V., Monteiro‐Steagall, B.P., and Taylor, Tobias, K.M., Marioni‐Henry, K., and Wagner, R.
P.M. (2014). A review of the studies using (2006). A retrospective study on the use of
buprenorphine in cats. J. Vet. Intern. Med. 28: acepromazine maleate in dogs with seizures.
762–770. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 42: 283–289.
www.ajlobby.com
192 8 Anesthetic Protocols for Dogs and Cats
Tranquilli, W.J., Thurmon, J.C., Benson, G.J., and intravenous hydromorphone in cats. Vet.
Davis, L.E. (1986). Alteration in the Anaesth. Analg. 34: 132–138.
arrhythmogenic dose of epinephrine (ADE) White, S.C. (2012). Prevention of fetal suffering
following xylazine administration to during ovariohysterectomy of pregnant
halothane‐anesthetized dogs. J. Vet. animals. JAVMA 240: 1160–1163.
Pharmacol. Ther. 9: 198–203. Willey, J.L., Julius, T.M., Claypool, S.P., and
Valverde, A., Cantwell, S., Hernandez, J., and Clare, M.C. (2016). Evaluation and
Brotherson, C. (2004). Effects of acepromazine comparison of xylazine hydrochloride and
on the incidence of vomiting associated with dexmedetomidine hydrochloride for the
opioid administration in dogs. Vet. Anaesth. induction of emesis in cats: 47 cases (2007–
Analg. 31: 40–45. 2013). JAVMA 248: 923–928.
Wagner, A.E. (1999). Is butorphanol analgesic in Williams, L.S., Levy, J.K., Robertson, S.A. et al.
dogs and cats? Vet. Med. 94: 346–351. (2002). Use of the anesthetic combination of
Wagner, A.E., Walton, J.A., Hellyer, P.W. et al. tiletamine, zolazepam, ketamine, and xylazine
(2002). Use of low doses of ketamine for neutering feral cats. JAVMA 220: 1491–1495.
administered by constant rate infusion as an Yamashita, K., Iwasaki, Y., Umar, M.A., and
adjunct for postoperative analgesia in dogs. Itami, T. (2009). Effect of age on minimum
JAVMA 221: 72–75. alveolar concentration (MAC) of sevoflurane
Warne, L.N., Beths, T., Holm, M., and Bauquier, in dogs. J. Vet. Med. Sci. 71: 1509–1512.
S.H. (2013). Comparison of perioperative Zhang, J.H., Sampogna, S., Morales, F.R., and
analgesic efficacy between methadone and Chase, M.H. (2005). Age‐related
butorphanol in cats. JAVMA 243: 844–850. ultrastructural changes in hypocretinergic
Warne, L.N., Beths, T., Holm, M. et al. (2014). terminals in the brainstem and spinal cord of
Evaluation of the perioperative analgesic cats. Neurosci. Lett. 373: 171–174.
efficacy of buprenorphine, compared with Zilberstein, L.F., Moens, Y.P., and Leterrier, E.
butorphanol, in cats. JAVMA 245: 195–202. (2008). The effect of local anaesthesia on
Wegner, K. and Robertson, S.A. (2007). Dose‐ anaesthetic requirements for feline
related thermal antinociceptive effects of ovariectomy. Vet. J. 178: 214–218.
Resources
Global Pain Council Guidelines: guidelines for 2018 AAFP Feline Anesthesia Guidelines. Open
recognition, assessment and treatment of access at https://catvets.com/guidelines/
pain. The Global Pain Treatise is a practice‐guidelines/anesthesia‐guidelines.
downloadable, open access practical resource 2015 AAHA/AAFP Pain Management
to assist practitioners around the world by Guidelines for Dogs and Cats. Open access at
providing guidance in recognizing and https://catvets.com/guidelines/practice‐
assessing pain. It is available in multiple guidelines/pain‐management‐guidelines.
languages. http://www.wsava.org/WSAVA/ Association of Shelter Veterinarians’ 2016 Veterinary
media/Documents/Guidelines/Recognition‐ Medical Care Guidelines for Spay‐Neuter
Assessment‐and‐Treatment‐of‐Pain‐ Programs. Open access at https://avmajournals.
Guidelines.pdf. avma.org/doi/pdf/10.2460/javma.249.2.165.
193
Neutering of dogs and cats prior to adoption and susceptibility to the stress of handling and
and before puberty is an important strategy for separation from their dam, all puppies and
controlling pet overpopulation. Thus, in many kittens should be considered a special category
settings such as shelters or rehoming and of anesthesia patient until at least five or six
rescue organizations, 6–16 weeks of age has months of age. The risks of anesthesia are not
become the new conventional age for ovario‑ increased in young, healthy animals undergo‑
hysterectomy, ovariectomy, and castration, and ing elective procedures which are performed
these procedures are no longer considered as rapidly and efficiently (Levy et al. 2017). In con‑
“early‐age neutering.” As veterinarians become trast, a large study in general veterinary prac‑
more comfortable with the concept of pediat‑ tices found that the risk of anesthetic death in
ric spaying and neutering, pet dogs and cats cats weighing less than 2 kg was over 15 times
outside the shelter environment may also be greater than that of cats between 2 and 6 kg
neutered at an increasingly younger age. A dis‑ (Brodbelt et al. 2007). In addition, the risk of
cussion of the positive and potentially negative anesthetic death was higher in dogs weighing
health benefits of neutering prior to puberty <5 kg compared to dogs weighting 5–15 kg, sug‑
are discussed elsewhere in Chapter 26. gesting size is a risk factor that is independent of
In cats and dogs, the pediatric period can be age; these cats and dogs underwent a variety of
defined as the period between 6 weeks (which surgical or diagnostic procedures, with duration
marks the end of the neonatal period) and of anesthesia being an additional risk factor
12 weeks of age (Pettifer and Grubb 2007). (Brodbelt et al. 2008a, b). Therefore, kittens and
Puppies and kittens can be defined as dogs and puppies deserve special consideration both for
cats less than six months of age. Performing elec‑ their unique physiology and for their small size.
tive surgery at a young age is considered sound
practice due to advances in anesthesia care and
our increased understanding of the unique phys‑ Characteristics of Pediatric
iology of this age group. In addition, there is Patients: Physiology
some evidence, at least in cats, that it may be less
painful (Polson et al. 2014). With a few simple The unique physiologic features of pediatric
precautions, puppies and kittens as young as six cats and dogs have been reviewed (Grandy and
weeks can be successfully anesthetized. Dunlop 1991; Pettifer and Grubb 2007). Pediatric
Because of their relatively small size, lack patients have limited reserves of all body systems
of physiologic reserves, incomplete immunity, and a limited ability to respond to events that
194 9 Special Considerations for Anesthesia of Pediatric Patients
challenge homeostasis. The role of a high rest‑ bolic rate, a high oxygen demand, and high
ing basal metabolic rate in determining the baseline minute ventilation, the pediatric patient
pediatric patient’s response to anesthesia should is at high risk of becoming hypoxemic and is
not be underestimated. The pediatric heart is poorly able to adapt to decreases in oxygen deliv‑
relatively small for the size of the patient; ery. The heart is entirely dependent on aerobic
ventricular compliance is low and stroke vol‑ metabolism, therefore any decrease in oxygen
ume is relatively fixed. Low cardiac reserves are supply results in rapid decompensation. The
compounded by a high cardiac index (volume of nares and trachea of pediatric patients are small
blood pumped per minute indexed to body size: and susceptible to obstruction; the small airways
l/min/m2), leading to an overall decreased ability and alveoli are also prone to collapse (Grandy and
to compensate for or respond to fluid losses and Dunlop 1991). The extremely pliant rib cage
hypotension. Because the circulatory fluid vol‑ increases the work of breathing in pediatric
ume of a pediatric patient is relatively fixed, these patients, which can predispose them to ventila‑
patients are particularly dependent on heart rate tion fatigue and further increase the risk of hypox‑
for the maintenance of cardiac output (heart rate emia. Ventilation of pediatric patients should be
× stroke volume) and organ perfusion (Friedman monitored and supported when necessary.
1972; Grandy and Dunlop 1991). Any decrease in By eight weeks of age most physiologic pro‑
heart rate in a pediatric patient could therefore cesses related to renal and hepatic function
have serious consequences, and it should be should be relatively normal, although organ
noted that one of the most common causes of reserves may still be limited. After the age of
bradycardia is hypothermia. In addition to the six weeks there is no rationale for altering drug
lack of reserves, the autonomic nervous system, doses in animals to account for hepatic clear‑
especially sympathetic control, is thought to be ance (Papich 2013). However, hepatic glycogen
poorly developed in pediatric patients, leading to stores are low, which increases the risk for
poor vasomotor control and responses. In par‑ hypoglycemia, especially if the patient is fasted
ticular, the baroreceptor response to hypotension for more than a short period (see section on
may be incomplete, leading to an inadequate patient preparation in this chapter).
response in the face of a fall in blood pressure Perhaps the single most important feature of
(Grandy and Dunlop 1991). Lastly, persistent the pediatric patient that affects anesthesia is
fetal circulation may be present in some pediatric body composition. Pediatric patients have sig‑
patients, leading to shunting and hypoxemia. nificantly less body fat and muscle compared
Like the pediatric cardiovascular system, to adult animals and a high body water con‑
the pediatric respiratory system is also charac‑ tent; this may be as high as 85% in the neonate
terized by a lack of reserves. While tidal vol‑ compared to 60% in mature animals (Papich
umes (TV) are similar to those of the adult 2013). These features, in addition to a high
animal (10–15 ml/kg), the pediatric respira‑ body surface area to mass ratio and a limited
tory rate (RR) must be two to three times ability to vasoconstrict to conserve heat, con‑
higher in order to provide an appropriate min‑ tribute to a limited ability to thermoregulate,
ute ventilation (TV × RR) to meet the patient’s exposing them to the risks of hypothermia.
high oxygen demand (Parot et al. 1984). An
important clinical consequence of a faster RR
is a shorter induction time in neonates when Characteristics of Pediatric
inhalant agents are used, although this may be Patients: Anatomy
counteracted by their high cardiac output and
may be less obvious when using today’s less Anatomic characteristics of puppies and kit‑
soluble inhalant agents, such as isoflurane tens that are relevant to anesthesia include
and sevoflurane. With a high resting meta‑ their high body surface areas to mass ratio and
Patient Preparation 195
a high lean body mass compared to body fat. in this age group has not grown in parallel with
These features predispose the pediatric patient the availability of new compounds. The use of
to hypothermia, which is perhaps the most NSAIDs for perioperative pain management
devastating complication of anesthesia for continues to be evaluated (Morris et al. 2003;
young animals. In addition, the tissues of pup‑ Aranda et al. 2009).
pies and kittens are delicate and more friable As mentioned, most organ function has
and so gentle handling is essential. Airway reached adult capacity by the time many pup‑
anatomy can pose a challenge. The pediatric pies and kittens undergo elective surgery
patient has small nares and the tongue is pro‑ (Grandy and Dunlop 1991), but there are other
portionally very large for the size of the mouth. features of the pediatric patient that affect drug
Intubation can be difficult, and when per‑ distribution, including the large percentage of
formed, great care must be taken to avoid any body water, reduced plasma albumin levels, and
airway trauma resulting in post‐operative lower percentage of body fat. Pediatric patients
swelling and obstruction. However, the small are therefore considered to be more sensitive to
trachea creates an increased resistance to air‑ the effects of highly protein‐bound drugs such
flow and intubation and ventilatory support as barbiturates or NSAIDs. Adult levels of the
may be necessary. Finally, the blood–brain bar‑ P‐450 family of enzymes are not reached until at
rier is immature in young animals and there‑ least five weeks of age (Debracker 1986) and
fore profound sedative effects of drugs such as therefore repeated dosing of drugs may result
opioids and benzodiazepines may be noted. in accumulation of the drug in very young
animals. In general, many clinicians are com‑
fortable administering a single dose of a species‐
Characteristics of Pediatric approved NSAID to a well‐hydrated puppy or
Patients: Pharmacology kitten over eight weeks old. Clinicians must use
their discretion if their clinic protocol includes
While published guidelines exist for the use of the off‐label use of an NSAID for puppies and
medications in neonatal and pediatric human kittens, because of the absence of published
patients, there is little evidence‐based guidance data on NSAID use in this age group.
for pediatric dogs and cats. Many drugs com‑
monly used in veterinary patients for anesthesia
have not been approved for puppies and kittens. Patient Preparation
For example, while the non‐steroidal anti‐
inflammatory drug (NSAID) carprofen Pediatric patients are likely more susceptible to
(Rimadyl®, Zoetis, Parsippany, NJ) is labeled for the effects of stress than are adults. Studies in
dogs 12 weeks and older and robenacoxib is neonatal rat pups demonstrate that the
labeled for 16 weeks and older in cats, some increased plasticity of the neonatal brain may
other NSAIDs are not labeled for dogs or cats increase vulnerability to stress and anxiety dis‑
less than six months of age. Although NSAIDs orders later in life (Anand et al. 1999). Animals,
are used to promote closure of patent ductus particularly those living in shelters, may be
arteriosus in human neonates, there is concern presented for surgery during their critical
with using them for other purposes including socialization period. It is essential to protect
analgesia because of the important role of pros‑ these patients from the risk of fear imprinting,
taglandins in the neonatal development of since a bad experience at the time of spay or
numerous organs and their physiologic action neuter can translate to a lifetime of fearful or
in sleep cycles, cerebral blood flow, and renal fractious behavior during veterinary visits.
hemodynamics (Morris et al. 2003; Aranda et al. Puppies and kittens should be gently handled
2009). Data on the safety of this group of drugs when they present to the spay–neuter clinic.
196 9 Special Considerations for Anesthesia of Pediatric Patients
4 Do not fast
Figure 9.1 To ensure accurate dosing of drugs in
4–6 Maximum 1–2
small kittens and puppies, dilution of drugs and
6–12 Maximum 2–4 measurement with 1 ml tuberculin syringes or
>12 Maximum 6 insulin syringes is recommended.
a
Fasting times can be shorter if on an all milk and
liquid diet. large percentage of a very small patient’s
bodyweight, resulting in drug overdose and an
Littermates should be housed together during adverse response and outcome. To maintain dos‑
transport if possible and should be kept ing accuracy, drugs may need to be diluted and/
together in the cage until the time of pre‐medi‑ or administered with insulin or 1 ml (Tuberculin‐
cation. If still with their dam, they should not type) syringes (Figure 9.1).
be separated from her. See Chapter 6 for more
information about stress reduction in the spay–
neuter clinic. Suggested Anesthetic Protocols
Fasting times for younger animals should for Puppies and Kittens
be short to account for their decreased glyco‑
gen stores. Suggested fasting times are shown Many pediatric patients, especially kittens,
in Table 9.1. During the initial examination may weigh 1.0 kg or less at the time of surgery,
the puppy or kitten can be given a small making intravenous access challenging. For
amount of Nutri‐Cal™ (Tomlyn, a division of this reason, many protocols have been designed
Vétoquinol USA, Fort Worth, TX), or dextrose so that a balanced general anesthetic can be
50, which can be applied to the gums or delivered by a single intramuscular (IM) or
placed under the tongue, resulting in trans‑ subcutaneous (SC) injection. Balanced anes‑
mucosal uptake. If dextrose is to be given thesia provides unconsciousness, analgesia,
peri‐operatively during surgery, the concen‑ and muscle relaxation. An “all‐in‐one” proto‑
tration should be kept at 2.5% and the total col can be valuable in many settings, as it is less
rate should not exceed 0.5 g/kg/hr. time consuming so increases the number of
As with all surgery patients, a thorough pre‐ animals that can be managed in a given period
surgical physical exam should be conducted of time, requires less handling of the patient
prior to sedation or anesthesia. It is especially which decreases stress, requires less technical
important to perform a thorough auscultation skill, and does not depend on an anesthesia
in case cardiac murmurs have gone unde‑ machine fitted with a vaporizer. Some compo‑
tected. The animal should also be checked nents of the protocol may be reversible (e.g.
carefully for other congenital abnormalities medetomidine and dexmedetomidine), which
that might affect anesthesia or surgery, such as hastens recovery.
pectus excavatum, hernias (inguinal or umbili‑ Alternatively, induction of anesthesia with
cal), and undescended testicles. Lastly, an intravenous anesthetic agents (with or with‑
accurate weight is very important as all drugs out intravenous catheter placement) is used
should be dosed on a mg/kg or mg/m2 basis; in some settings and may or may not be fol‑
“guesstimates” of weight that are off by a small lowed by delivery of inhalant agents by mask
amount with respect to grams can represent a or endotracheal tube. Induction of anesthesia
Suggested Anesthetic Protocols for Puppies and Kittens 197
with inhalant agents delivered via a face works well for kittens and puppies for ovario‑
mask, whether as a sole technique or after hysterectomy, ovariectomy, and castration
sedation, is not recommended due to the haz‑ surgery and results in rapid recovery to nor‑
ards of exposing personnel to waste anes‑ mal function, with most kittens and puppies
thetic gases and the stress this technique eating within 30–60 minutes of the proce‑
poses to patients (also see Chapter 31 on sur‑ dure. An alternative protocol that is very pop‑
geon health for more information on avoiding ular is “TTDex,” which includes Telazol,
waste anesthetic gas). In dogs, Brodbelt et al. butorphanol (or pure opioid), and dexme‑
(2008b) reported that induction and mainte‑ detomidine. This combination is flexible and
nance with inhalant anesthetic agents has been found to be effective and predicta‑
increased the risk of peri‐operative death. ble for a wide variety of ages (Ko and Krimins
Several anesthetic protocols have been 2019). Finally, the “quad” protocol includes
described for use in pediatric patients (Fagella midazolam, medetomidine, ketamine, and
and Aronsohn 1993, 1994; Howe 1997; Root either butorphanol or buprenorphine (Polson
Kustritz 2002; Patel and Yates 2003; Robertson et al. 2012), and is very popular in the UK,
2007; Joyce and Yates 2011; Polson et al. 2012; and is suitable for cats of all ages.
Porters et al. 2015). Examples of total injectable protocols are
Opioids and benzodiazepines (e.g. diaze‑ given in Tables 9.2 and 9.3.
pam, midazolam) are generally well tolerated If not using a total injectable protocol,
and have the advantage of being reversible propofol, ketamine/midazolam, or Telazol®
with naloxone and flumazenil, respectively, (tiletamine and zolazepam, Zoetis) are all
should problems arise. Only midazolam acceptable for induction following sedation.
should be used for IM injection; systemic Alfaxalone (Alfaxan®, Jurox, Rutherford, NSW,
absorption of diazepam from muscle is unre‑ Australia), a synthetic neuroactive steroid
liable and injection is usually resented by the anesthetic, has been evaluated in pediatric
patient. Acepromazine should be used judi‑ cats and dogs (O’Hagan et al. 2012a, b) with
ciously and at a lower dose (0.01–0.02 mg/kg) good results. Examples of protocols that
than normally used in adults (up to 0.05 mg/ include sedation followed by IV induction are
kg), as pediatric patients appear to be more given in Tables 9.4 and 9.5.
sensitive to its effects, resulting in prolonged Historically, anticholinergic agents (atropine,
recoveries. In addition, the vasodilation pro‑ glycopyrrolate) have been used to support heart
duced by acepromazine may promote heat rate, especially in young human and animal
loss. Alpha2‐adrenergic agonists have been patients during anesthesia (Best 2001), but have
somewhat controversial for use in young ani‑ become less popular over time. The administra‑
mals because of their profound cardiac tion of atropine in conjunction with ketamine
effects; however, good results have been was standard of care for the sedation of pediat‑
reported with the combination of medetomi‑ ric patients, but critical evaluation has not
dine, ketamine, and buprenorphine in found it advantageous to include an anticholin‑
healthy 7‐ to 12‐week‐old kittens (Robertson ergic (Kye et al. 2012). Anticholinergic agents
et al. 2003). A total injectable protocol which are generally not used in combination with an
has included medetomidine and more alpha2‐adrenergic agonist agent.
recently dexmedetomidine in combination Prior to induction, pre‑oxygenation is rec‑
with ketamine and butorphanol (Bushby, ommended due to the vulnerability of this
personal communication, August 2, 2012; age group to hypoxia; if using injectable‐only
Bushby and Griffin 2011) has been used in protocols, supplemental oxygen is recom‑
several thousand puppies and kittens with mended during anesthesia. The pros and
very few anesthetic deaths. This protocol cons of intubation should be considered.
Table 9.2 Suggested total injectable protocols for puppies and kittens aged 6–16 weeks. Add 1 ml
dexmedetomidine (500 μgram/ml), 1 ml ketamine (100 mg/ml), and 1 ml butorphanol (10 mg/ml)
to a sterile vial, creating 3 ml of the DKB mixture. For cats and small dogs, inject in large muscle belly (of
your choice). Occasionally gaseous anesthetic is needed, especially if surgery takes more than 30 minutes.
Atipamezole can be used routinely or if the animal is slow to wake up (>30 minutes). Give equal volume
to the dexmedetomidine in dogs and half the volume in cats.
DOGS
1 0.066 0.20
1.1 0.073 0.22
1.2 0.079 0.24
1.3 0.086 0.26
1.4 0.092 0.28
1.5 0.099 0.30
1.6 0.106 0.32
1.7 0.112 0.34
1.8 0.119 0.36
1.9 0.125 0.38
2 0.132 0.40
2.5 0.132 0.40
3 0.132 0.40
3.5 0.154 0.46
4 0.176 0.53
4.5 0.198 0.59
5 0.220 0.66
CATS
Table 9.3 “Quad” protocol for kittens. Use equal volumes of medetomidine (1 mg/ml), ketamine (100 mg/
ml), midazolam (5 mg/ml), and buprenorphine (0.3 mg/ml). These can be mixed together in a sterile vial.
Medetomidine can be substituted with dexmedetomidine (0.5 mg/ml). Administration is intramuscularly.
Table 9.4 Some suggested anesthetic protocols for puppies aged 6–16 weeks: pre‐medication followed by
induction with intravenous anesthetic agents.
IM, intramuscularly; IV, intravenously; NSAIDs, non‐steroidal anti‐inflammatory drugs; SC, subcutaneously.
Intubation may not be necessary if surgery cases a face mask can be used (Figure 9.2). On
times are short (<30 minutes) and the patient the other hand, because pediatric patients are
is adequately ventilating. Studies that look at poorly tolerant of hypoxemia, and because
risks associated with anesthesia showed that, hypoventilation or apnea can occur, equip‑
at least in cats, intubation is associated with a ment should always be available to perform
higher mortality rate (Brodbelt et al. 2007) for intubation if needed. When intubating small
short (<30 minutes) procedures and in these patients, it is important to take great care to
200 9 Special Considerations for Anesthesia of Pediatric Patients
Table 9.5 Some suggested anesthetic protocols for kittens 6–16 weeks: pre‐medication followed by
induction with intravenous anesthetic agents.
Pre‐medication
All drugs are given IM Induction mg/kg Maintenance Analgesics Comments
IM, intramuscularly; IV, intravenously; NSAIDs, non‐steroidal anti‐inflammatory drugs; SC, subcutaneously.
avoid traumatizing the delicate airway tissues. placement (Figure 9.3). A eutectic mixture of
A laryngoscope should be used to ensure excel‑ lidocaine and prilocaine (EMLA™, 5%,
lent visualization and an adequate depth of AstraZeneca, Wilmington, DE; prescription
anesthesia achieved before attempting to intu‑ only) or lidocaine topical cream (LMX 4%;
bate. Puppies are intubated more commonly Ferndale Laboratories, Ferndale, MI; over the
than kittens, but face masks are also acceptable counter) can be used, and systemic absorption
for short procedures. All brachycephalic dogs is minimal (Wagner et al. 2006), although the
and cats should be intubated because of the time to onset can be up to one hour.
increased risk of airway obstruction. If IV fluids are given, crystalloids are used
A non‐rebreathing circuit should be used for and administered at a rate of 3 ml/kg/h in cats
patients under 3 kg to deliver oxygen and/or and 5 ml/kg/h in dogs, in accord with the
inhalant anesthetic agents. American Animal Hospital Association’s fluid
therapy guidelines (Davis et al. 2013).
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 9.3 If an intravenous catheter is to be placed in a small patient, the use of topical local anesthetics
is recommended. The cream is applied over the clipped and cleansed site (a); a plastic covering (e.g. cut
from packaging) and a flexible wrap are then used to cover the site (b–d). After the recommended time, the
wrapping is removed and the catheter can be placed with minimal response by the patient.
202 9 Special Considerations for Anesthesia of Pediatric Patients
(a) (b)
Figure 9.6 (a and b) Fluorescent or operating room lights can interfere with the function of pulse
oximeters, therefore the probe should be covered; in (b) a gauze sponge is placed over the probe and this
may be wetted to prevent drying of the tongue.
Prevention and Treatment
of Hypothermia
(a)
(b)
Figure 9.10 (a and b) A “recovery beach” is a set‐up where kittens and puppies can recover; blankets are
placed on the floor and a forced warm air system is used above the animals to rewarm them. Here they can
be monitored and given dextrose or high‐fructose corn syrup.
References
Allegaert, K., Tibboel, D., and van den Anker, J. Anand, K.J.S., Coskun, V., Thrivikraman, K.V.
(2013). Pharmacological treatment of neonatal et al. (1999). Long‐term behavioral effects of
pain: in search of a new equipoise. Sem. Fetal repetitive pain in neonatal rat pups. Physiol.
Neonatal Med. 18 (1): 42–47. Behav. 66 (4): 627–637.
206 9 Special Considerations for Anesthesia of Pediatric Patients
Aranda, J.V., Beharry, K.D., and Valencia, G.B. strategies: part 2: mother‐driven interventions.
(2009). Nonsteroidal anti‐inflammatory drugs Adv. Neonatal Care 11 (5): 312–318.
(NSAIDs) in the newborn – which ones? Cornell, H.N., Shaver, S.L., Semick, D.N. et al.
J. Matern. Fetal Neonatal Med. 22 (Suppl. 3): (2018). Effect of transmucosal corn syrup
21–22. application on postoperative blood glucose
Benito, J., Monteiro, B., Beaudry, F., and concentrations in kittens. J. Feline Med. Surg.
Steagall, P. (2018). Efficacy and 20 (4): 289–294.
pharmacokinetics of bupivacaine with Davis, H., Jensen, T., Johnson, A. et al. (2013).
epinephrine or dexmedetomidine after 2013 AAHA/AAFP fluid therapy guidelines
intraperitoneal administration in cats for dogs and cats. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 49
undergoing ovariohysterectomy. Can. J. Vet. (3): 149–159.
Res. 82 (2): 124–130. Debracker, P. (1986). Comparative neonatal
Benito, J., Monteiro, B., Lavoie, A.M. et al. pharmacokinetics. In: Comparative Veterinary
(2016). Analgesic efficacy of intraperitoneal Pharmacology, Toxicology and Therapy (eds.
administration of bupivacaine in cats. J. Feline A.S. Van Miert, M.G. Bogaert and M.
Med. Surg. 18: 906–912. Debrackert), 161–171. Boston, MA: MTP Press.
Best, P. (2001). Use of anticholinergics in Doufas, A.G. (2003). Consequences of
veterinary anaesthesia. Aust. Vet. J. 79 inadvertent perioperative hypothermia. Best
(1): 22–23. Pract. Res. Clin. Anaesthesiol. 17 (4): 535–549.
Brodbelt, D.C., Blissitt, K.J., Hammond, R.A. Fagella, A.M. and Aronsohn, M.G. (1993).
et al. (2008a). The risk of death: the Anesthetic techniques for neutering 6‐ to 14‐
confidential enquiry into perioperative small week‐old kittens. JAVMA 202 (1): 56–62.
animal fatalities. Veterinary Anaesthesia and Fagella, A.M. and Aronsohn, M.G. (1994).
Analgesia 35 (5): 365–373. Evaluation of anesthetic protocols for
Brodbelt, D.C., Pfeiffer, D.U., Young, L.E. et al. neutering 6‐ to 14‐week‐old pups. JAVMA 205
(2007). Risk factors for anaesthetic related death (2): 308–314.
in cats: results from the confidential enquiry Friedman, W.F. (1972). The intrinsic physiologic
into perioperative small animal fatalities properties of the developing heart. Prog.
(CEPSAF). Br. J. Anaesth. 99 (5): 617–623. Cardiovasc. Dis. 15 (1): 87–111.
Brodbelt, D.C., Pfeiffer, D.U., Young, L.E. et al. Grandy, J.L. and Dunlop, C.I. (1991). Anesthesia
(2008b). Results of the confidential enquiry of pups and kittens. JAVMA 198 (7):
into perioperative small animal fatalities 1244–1249.
regarding risk factors for anesthetic‐related Gray, L., Lang, C.W., and Poges, S.W. (2012).
death in dogs. JAVMA 233 (7): 1096–1104. Warmth is analgesic in healthy newborns.
Bushby, P. and Griffin, B. (2011). An overview Pain 153 (5): 960–966.
of pediatric spay and neuter benefits and Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al.
techniques. dvm360 (1 February). http:// (2016). The Association of Shelter
veterinarymedicine.dvm360.com/overview‐ Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical care
pediatric‐spay‐and‐neuter‐benefits‐and‐ guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. JAVMA
techniques. 249 (2): 165–188.
Buskila, D., Neumann, L., Ehud, Z. et al. (2003). Howe, L.M. (1997). Short term results and
Pain sensitivity in prematurely born complications of prepubertal gonadectomy in
adolescents. Arch. Pediatr. Adolesc. Med. 157 cats and dogs. JAVMA 211 (1): 57–62.
(11): 1079–1082. Huuskonen, V., Huges, J.M., Banon, E. et al.
Campbell‐Yeo, M., Fernandes, A., and Johnston, (2013). Intratesticular lidocaine reduces the
C. (2011). Procedural pain management for response to surgical castration in dogs. Vet.
neonates using non‐pharmacological Anaesth. Analg. 40 (1): 74–82.
References 207
Johnston, C.C., Fernandes, A.M., and Campbell‐ than 12 weeks of age. Aust. Vet. J. 90 (10):
Yeo, M. (2011). Pain in neonates is different. 346–350.
Pain 152: S65–S73. Papich, M.G. (2013). Treating animals in special
Joyce, A. and Yates, D. (2011). Help stop teenage situations: the old and the young: the sick and
pregnancy! Early‐age neutering in cats. J. debilitated. Proceedings of the 2013 Western
Feline Med. Surg. 13 (1): 3–10. Veterinary Conference, Las Vegas Nevada
Ko, J. and Krimins, R.A. (2019). Anesthesia in (17–21 February).
shelter medicine and high‐volume/high Parot, S., Bonora, M., Gautier, H. et al. (1984).
quality spay neuter programs. In: Small Developmental changes in ventilation and
Animal Anesthesia and Pain Management, 2e breathing patterns in unanesthetized kittens.
(ed. J.C. Ko), 419–427. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Resp. Physiol. 58 (3): 253–262.
Press/Taylor and Francis Group. Patel, C.M. and Yates, D. (2003). Evaluation of an
Kristiansson, M., Sraste, L., Soop, M. et al. anesthetic protocol for the neutering of eight
(1999). Diminished interleukin‐6 and C‐ to twelve week‐old puppies. Vet. Rec. 152 (14):
reactive protein responses to laparoscopic 439–440.
versus open cholecystectomy. Acta Pettifer, G. and Grubb, T. (2007). Neonatal and
Anaesthesiol Scandanavia 43 (2): 146–152. geriatric patients. In: Lumb and Jones’
Kye, Y.C., Rhee, J.E., Kim, K. et al. (2012). Veterinary Anesthesia, 4e (eds. W.J. Tranquilli,
Clinical effects of adjunctive atropine during J.C. Thurmon and K.A. Grimm), 985–991.
ketamine sedation in pediatric emergency Ames, IA: Blackwell.
patients. Am. J. Emerg. Med. 30 (9): Polson, S., Taylor, P.M., and Yates, D. (2012).
1981–1085. Analgesia after feline ovariohysterectomy
Levy, J.K., Bard, K.M., Tucker, S.J. et al. (2017). under midazolam‐medetomidine ketamine
Perioperative mortality in cats and dogs anaesthesia with buprenorphine or
undergoing spay or castration at a high‐ butorphanol, and carprofen or meloxicam: a
volume clinic. Vet. J. 224: 11–15. prospective, randomized clinical trial. J. Feline
Mathews, N.S., Hartke, S., and Allen, J.C. Jr. Med. Surg. 14 (8): 553–559.
(2003). An evaluation of pulse oximeters in Polson, S., Taylor, P.M., and Yates, D. (2014).
dogs, cats and horses. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 30 Effects of age and reproductive status on
(1): 3–14. postoperative pain after routine
Moldal, E.R., Eriksen, T., Kirpensteijn, J. et al. ovariohysterectomy in cats. J. Feline Med.
(2012). Intratesticular and subcutaneous Surg. 16: 170–176.
lidocaine alters the intraoperative Porters, N., deRooster, H., Moons, C.P.H. et al.
haemodynamic responses and heart rate (2015). Prepubertal gonadectomy in cats:
variability in male cats undergoing castration. different injectable anesthetic combinations and
Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 40 (1): 63–73. comparison with gonadectomy at traditional
Morris, J.L., Rosen, D.A., and Rosen, K.R. (2003). age. J. Feline Med. Surg. 17 (6): 458–467.
Nonsteroidal anti‐inflammatory agents in Robertson, S.A. (2007). Anaesthesia and
neonates. Paediatr. Drugs 5 (6): 385–405. analgesia for kittens and puppies. European
O’Hagan, B.J., Pasloske, K., McKinnon, C. et al. Veterinary Conference, Voorjaarsdagen,
(2012a). Clinical evaluation of alfaxalone as Amsterdam (27–29 April). http://www.ivis.
an anaesthetic induction agent in cats lets org/proceedings/voorjaarsdagen/2007/
than 12 weeks of age. Aust. Vet. J. 90 (10): comp_anim/Robertson3.pdf (accessed 17
395–401. August 2019).
O’Hagen, B.J., Pasloske, K.S., McKinnon, C. Robertson, S.A., Levy, J., Gunkel, C. et al. (2003).
et al. (2012b). Clinical evaluation of alfaxalone Comparison of isoflurane and butorphanol
as an anesthetic induction agent in dogs less with medetomidine, ketamine and
208 9 Special Considerations for Anesthesia of Pediatric Patients
10
Anesthetic Complications
Emily McCobb
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 10.1 Cat airway with (a) open glottis and (b) laryngospasm. Lidocaine can be applied on the
arytenoids (c) prior to intubation to reduce laryngospasm. Source: Photos courtesy of Cheryl Blaze.
of gastroprotectants in dogs and cats has not (Figure 10.3). This monitor will prove invalua
been shown to decrease the incidence of com ble for improving patient safety and decreasing
plications after regurgitation and is of ques the risk of a serious anesthetic complication.
tionable efficacy (Marks et al. 2018), although In the absence of capnography, intubated
they are generally given. patients should be observed carefully so that
While not often present in a high‐volume set any disconnections or other problems can be
ting, a capnograph is a very useful monitor for detected. The patient’s respiratory efforts
detecting problems with the anesthetic equip should not be excessive and the patient should
ment, particularly with the airway (Figure 10.2) be able to move the rebreathing bag and valves
Failure to properly intubate the patient, leaks easily. On 100% oxygen, the patient should sat
in the cuff, missing or stuck inspiratory one‐ urate at 100%.
way valves, and a disconnected or obstructed A final airway complication which can occur
endotracheal tube are all problems that can be is the patient biting through the endotracheal
easily detected with the use of capnography tube in recovery. This problem can be avoided
212 10 Anesthetic Complications
Figure 10.2 Common capnograph waveforms. CO2, carbon dioxide; ETCO2, end-tidal carbon dioxide;
ETT, endotracheal tube. Source: Reprinted with permission from Heidi L. Shafford, Veterinary Anesthesia
Specialists LLC.
by watching the patient carefully and extubat trachea, inflate the cuff of the smaller tube, and
ing after they begin to swallow. Should the then pull both tubes out together (Figures 10.4
patient bite through the tube, a useful trick is to and 10.5). It is worth mentioning that endotra
pass a second endotracheal tube of a smaller cheal tubes must be properly secured during
diameter into the lumen of the tube still in the anesthesia and surgery. String or rubber bands
Equipment-Related Problems 213
(a) (b)
Figure 10.3 (a and b) Material such as mucous can occlude the endotracheal tube and hamper the
patient’s ability to ventilate. If obstruction is detected or suspected, the endotracheal tube should be
immediately suctioned or, if that is not possible, replaced. Source: Photos courtesy of Catie Case.
Figure 10.6 Endotracheal tubes should be Figure 10.7 Inspiratory and expiratory valves on an
properly secured. Intravenous tubing provides anesthesia machine. These valves can accumulate
a soft, flexible tie that can be disinfected. moisture and stick, causing an obstruction in the
anesthesia circuit. Use of capnography can aid in
the early detection of this complication.
Leak checks as already described will detect
most problems and prevent any danger to the The most common and potentially cata
patient. Leaks are most often detected at the strophic equipment‐related complication is a
area of the rebreathing bag or Y piece, and pop‐off valve that has been inadvertently left
care must be taken to ensure that these closed. In fact, a closed pop‐off valve was the
components are replaced regularly and are most common cause of veterinary anesthetic
secure. Another common place for leaks is the death in at least one study (Waldrop et al. 2004).
CO2 absorber canister (Sodasorb™, Smiths This cause of arrest can be nearly eliminated
Medical, Dublin, OH), particularly after it has through the use of push‐button adjustable pres
been changed. Leaky anesthetic machines are sure‐limiting valves (pop‐off occlusion valves
hazardous to personnel and the environment available from Smiths Medical, https://m.
(see Chapter 31), and if the leak is significant smiths‐medical.com/products/veterinary/
enough it may be difficult to provide a reliable anesthesia/anesthesia‐accessories/pop‐off‐
plane of anesthesia at typical settings. occlusion‐valve), which prevent the pop‐off
The inspiratory and expiratory one‐way valve from being inadvertently screwed closed
valves (Figure 10.7) have a tendency to stick (Figure 10.8).
because this area of the anesthetic circuit can Failure of the oxygen delivery system can
accumulate moisture. A stuck valve is a threat occur if pipeline pressure becomes too low
to patient safety. Fortunately, like most equip (pipeline systems have alarms installed to alert
ment‐related problems, a stuck valve can be users if the oxygen supply is not sufficient to
detected by a characteristic pattern on the cap supply the working pressure of 42 Psi) or for
nograph (see Figure 10.2, rebreathing of CO2). those hospitals using oxygen tanks if the tank
Using a capnograph for intubated patients can runs empty. Failure of the oxygen supply can be
alert the anesthetist to many potential prob avoided by checking the tank level at the begin
lems with the machine or circuit and has ning of the work day and rechecking it fre
been demonstrated to increase patient safety quently. Oxygen concentrators generally can
(Haskins 2015; Duke‐Novakovski 2017). run on battery power for a number of hours
Patient disconnect (the patient coming dis (Burn et al. 2016). Patient safety can be enhanced
connected from the anesthesia machine) is a by using a pulse oximeter. Oxygen analyzers are
simple problem to remedy which can also be required by the Machine Safety Act which regu
detected through monitoring capnography. lates anesthesia delivery systems for people;
Drug-Related Problems 215
anesthesia of brachycephalic breeds are very laryngoscope. The soft palate most likely will
common and some high‐volume programs will need to be gently elevated away from the lar
not accept brachycephalic breeds for surgery. ynx using the tip of the endotracheal tube or a
Owners of brachycephalic breeds should be soft‐ended stylet. The patient’s head and neck
informed of the additional anesthetic risks at should be as straight and extended as possible
the time of admission to the clinic. While the during intubation. Most brachycephalic breeds
risks of complications are certainly increased will take a much smaller endotracheal tube
with these breeds, with proper handling they than would be expected for their size. In addi
can do quite well. Clinic staff should be trained tion, since the animal typically has a very short
and comfortable working with them. neck, care should be taken not pass the
Brachycephalic animals may be particularly endotracheal tube beyond the carina and into a
difficult to intubate. Because many brachyce single bronchus. The tube should be carefully
phalic animals have redundant soft tissues pre‐measured and placed only as far as the tho
such as an overly long palate, they may have racic inlet. In addition, the tube should be care
difficulty breathing once sedated. This phe fully secured to avoid inadvertent extubation
nomenon occurs because these individuals due to the patient’s short neck. Ideally, an end‐
must actively elevate the soft tissue of the tidal CO2 monitor can be used to verify that the
upper airway away from the trachea in order tube has been placed correctly and that it
to be able to breathe. Once they are sedated, remains in place during surgery. Alternatively,
the soft tissues collapse into the airway and signs that the tube is correctly placed include
the patient may develop an obstruction. movement of the bag as the patient takes a
Changes in posture that accompany sedation, breath, being able to hear clear lung sounds on
such as dropping the head and assuming each side of the patient’s chest, and a pulse oxi
a recumbent position, can exacerbate the meter reading of 98–100%. The cuff of the
mechanical obstruction, making the problem endotracheal tube should be carefully inflated
worse. Accordingly, brachycephalic patients to prevent aspiration.
should be closely observed from the time During anesthesia, the brachycephalic
they are pre‐medicated. Agents that can cause patient may have difficulty breathing if the
vomiting (such as morphine) should be portion of the endotracheal tube that extends
avoided in these patients. Butorphanol pre‐ beyond the nares is very long, as this will
medication followed by buprenorphine as an increase physiologic dead space. If an end‐tidal
analgesic should be considered. Alternatively, CO2 monitor is being used, this problem would
brachycephalic patients can be administered be detected by noting a rise in the inspiratory
Cerenia® (maropitant; Zoetis, Parsippany, NJ) CO2 concentration, and can be avoided by not
one hour before pre‐medication with mor using an overly long tube or by trimming the
phine or hydromorphone in order to decrease tube so that it does not extend far beyond the
the incidence of vomiting (Hay‐Kraus 2017). patient’s nares. Note that care must be used
If the patient appears to be in distress, oxy when trimming endotracheal tubes to ensure
gen should be administered. Because these that the adaptor will still be able to fit. In addi
patients can be difficult to intubate, oxygen tion, since many brachycephalic breeds are
should be administered through a tight‐fitting stocky in stature and have relatively small lung
mask prior to induction and intubation. fields compared to their body size, they often
Brachycephalic breeds should always be need support during anesthesia to prevent
intubated for surgery, as the risk of a mechani hypoventilation and will benefit from gentle
cal obstruction is too great. After pre‐oxygena intermittent positive pressure ventilation
tion, the patient should be intubated using (IPPV), taking care not to deliver more than
direct observation of the larynx with a 10 cmH2O to the patient’s lungs.
218 10 Anesthetic Complications
B1 receptors, leading to improved blood pres dogs, and a heart rate greater than 100–120 is
sure; and at high doses (greater than 10 μg/kg/ generally adequate for most cats. If the heart
min) dopamine has vasoconstrictive effects by rate drops below this level or the anesthetist
acting on alpha1 receptors. Vasoconstriction is believes the patient has hypotension that is
useful to improve blood pressure, but can also potentiated by bradycardia or other signs of
result in impaired organ perfusion. decreased perfusion, then an anticholinergic
(glycopyrrolate at 0.005–0.01 mg/kg or atro
Arrhythmias pine at 0.01–0.04 mg/kg) should be adminis
Bradycardia Bradycardia, a decrease in heart tered. Glycopyrrolate has a more gradual onset
rate, is commonly seen under anesthesia. of action and a longer duration of action than
Anesthesia can remove the patient’s sym atropine and so is generally preferred for
pathetic drive, resulting in an increase of the treatment of peri‐operative bradycardias,
parasympathetic tone and vagally mediated whereas atropine is the drug of choice for CPR.
bradycardia. Other things can also increase If possible, anticholinergic agents should be
vagal tone, such as drugs, patient positioning delivered IV. While glycopyrrolate can be given
(traction on the head or neck), and organ intramuscularly (IM), the onset of action with
manipulation. Opioids cause a vagally mediated IM administration is often much longer, up to
bradycardia and are one of the most common 30 minutes. In addition, while paradoxic brady
causes of slow heart rates in anesthetized cardia can be seen after any administration of
patients. Some patients naturally have a high an anticholinergic, it is more common to see it
resting vagal tone and are prone to a slow heart after IM administration.
rate under anesthesia. Examples of such Another common cause of bradycardia is the
patients include brachycephalic breeds of dogs use of alpha2 agonists in the anesthetic proto
and other breed types such as Dachsunds, West col. However, it is not generally recommended
Highland White terriers, Schnauzers, and to administer anticholinergics in conjunction
Scottish terriers, among others. Some pediatric with alpha2 agonists (Murrell and Hellebrekers
patients will also tend to have high resting vagal 2005). If the patient is believed to be compro
tone. Other causes of bradycardia may include mised due to decreased heart rate and cardiac
hypothermia, electrolyte abnormalities, or an output, reversal or partial reversal of the alpha2
underlying cardiac conduction abnormality. agonist should be considered.
It is important to keep in mind that the nor Occasionally other bradyarrhythmias can be
mal heart rate for an animal under anesthesia observed under anesthesia such as AV block.
will be somewhat lower than that of the awake Most are vagally mediated and are also treated
animal, depending of course on the anesthetic with an anticholinergic.
protocol that is being used. Bradycardia does
not necessarily need to be treated per se, unless Tachycardias Tachycardia, or an elevated
the associated drop in cardiac output is result heart rate, is caused by an elevation in
ing in decreased tissue perfusion, or if the sympathetic tone. In general, tachycardias are
patient is experiencing long pauses and/or usually secondary to a pre‐disposing cause
escape beats associated with first‐ or second‐ which is raising the sympathetic tone, and
degree atrioventricular (AV) block. In addi therefore initial treatment is usually directed
tion, since raising the patient’s heart rate will at the underlying cause. For example, pain,
cause an increase in myocardial workload, hypovolemia, inadequate or excessive anes
consideration should be given to how that thetic depth, hypercarbia, hypoglycemia,
might adversely affect the patient. A heart rate and hypothermia are all potential causes
greater than 60 beats per minute is generally of tachycardia. In addition, tachycardia is
adequate to maintain cardiac output for most sometimes associated with the anesthetic
Patient-Related Complications 221
decision is made to carry forward with spay– patients with suspected cardiac disease. Each
neuter surgery in the absence of additional spay–neuter surgeon and clinic must evaluate
information, the animal might be at elevated whether such special patients can be safely
anesthetic risk. accommodated in their setting or whether they
Standard spay–neuter protocols for anesthe would be better referred to a different facility.
sia have an excellent safety track record; how Whenever protocols are changed, efficiency is
ever, they are not particularly cardio friendly. compromised.
Most veterinary cardiologists recommend
avoiding alpha2 agonists entirely in patients
Hypothermia/Hyperthermia
with cardiac disease, and avoiding ketamine
and tiletamine in cats with hypertrophic car Temperature regulation is an important aspect
diomyopathy, or in any patient for whom tach of any anesthetic episode, particularly for pedi
ycardia has the potential to be harmful. A atric and geriatric patients. Preventing hypo
reasonable substitute protocol could include thermia and hyperthermia is essential to a
an opioid for pre‐medication with a benzodiaz smooth recovery and a good post‐surgical out
epine and propofol or alfaxalone for induction, come. Warming devices such as recirculating
followed by intubation and maintenance on warm water blankets and forced air heating
isoflurane or sevoflurane in oxygen. Judicious units should be used. However, electric heat
fluid administration, whether IV or subcutane ing pads can burn patients and should never be
ously (SC), is generally recommended for used (Figure 10.9). Many spay–neuter clinics
(a) (b)
Figure 10.9 Thermal burn on the back of a patient (a) at diagnosis and (b) after several months of
treatment. The burn occurred during surgery while the patient was on a v-tray with a reptile heating pad
adhered to the v-tray. A blanket had been placed between the patient and the heating source, but the spay
surgery was prolonged and the patient was compromised due to a necrotic fetus. Source: Photos courtesy
of Randi Roberts.
Procedure-Related Problems 223
employ heated rice bags, water bottles, or caused by excessive use of warming devices
heated discs as inexpensive methods of patient or by anesthetic medications or both. Some
warming. While these items can be useful to breeds of dogs such as Greyhounds are par
provide external heat, they have also been ticularly prone to hyperthermia. Appropriate
implicated in patient burns and pose a serious precautions including low‐stress handling,
safety risk. If they are used, they should be pre‐medication with acepromazine, and the
wrapped with other material (like a towel or administration of IV fluids peri‐operatively
bubble wrap) and never placed directly next to (when possible) can prevent problems with
patient skin. Whenever supplementary heat is hyperthermia. Bulldogs and other brachyce
provided, it is absolutely essential to monitor phalic breeds are also prone to hyperthermia,
the patient’s temperature so that overheating particularly if their ability to pant is impaired
can also be prevented, particularly with cats. by restraint. Malignant hyperthermia‐like syn
dromes have been reported in dogs, but occur
Hypothermia rarely.
Hypothermia is one factor that can reliably In the cat, several commonly used anesthetic
decrease the minimum alveolar concentration agents have been reported to be associated with
(MAC or anesthetic requirement) of inhalant. peri‐operative hyperthermia. Opioid medica
Patients who are hypothermic can be expected tions in particular have been implicated, as has
to be maintained on a lower dose of inhalant. ketamine (Posner et al. 2010). Remarkably high
Recovery can be prolonged as the metabolism temperatures can be seen in cats suffering post‐
of injectable medications is slowed. Shivering operative hyperthermia, with temperature
is a process used by the body to warm the readings as high as 108–109 °F (42–43 °C) hav
patient; however, shivering can lead to ing been recorded. Fortunately, morbidity is
increased oxygen demand, which can be detri limited if the hyperthermia is caught early, and
mental. Longer anesthesia and surgery times cats do not seem to suffer long‐term harm
can predispose patients to hypothermia, as can from having become acutely hyperthermic.
the use of a high oxygen flow rate. Oxygen flow Treatment is generally symptomatic and con
rates should be set at no more than 22 ml/kg/ sists of assuring vasodilation with aceproma
min for semi‐closed flow and no more than zine, administering IV or SC fluid therapy, and
200 ml/kg/min for non‐rebreathing systems. placing the cat on a cool surface. Cooling
Patients who are slow to wake up from anes should be stopped when the temperature
thesia should be assumed to be hypothermic reaches about 103 °F (39.5 °C) in order to avoid
until proven otherwise and should have their overshoot. Hyperthermic cats who have been
temperatures taken. Cold patients (tempera given opioid medication should have their opi
tures less than 98–99 °F, 36–37 °C) should be oids reversed. Cats should never be placed in a
warmed aggressively using warm water blan heated cage or warming device for recovery
kets or forced air heating units if they are avail without the opportunity to move away from the
able, although taking care not to overwarm the heat source if they become uncomfortable.
patient. In addition to prolonging anesthetic
recovery, other adverse effects associated with
peri‐operative hypothermia include decreased
immune function and wound healing as well
Procedure-Related Problems
as increased bleeding (Doufas 2003).
Hemorrhage
Hyperthermia Acute, severe peri‐operative hemorrhage is
Hyperthermia can be caused by patient‐related perhaps one of the most likely complications
factors, but is most often iatrogenic, being to occur in the high‐volume spay–neuter
224 10 Anesthetic Complications
s etting. While it is not an anesthetic‐related collected from the abdominal cavity (see
complication, the anesthetist must be prepared Chapter 17 for autotransfusion protocols).
to respond rapidly to acute hemorrhage. A
dropped pedicle or other source of bleeding
Vagal Responses
can quickly lead to life‐threatening blood loss,
particularly in a very small patient. The blood A vagal reaction can occur suddenly, such as
volume of a canine patient is about 90 ml/kg, with traction on the abdominal organs,
and the blood volume of a feline patient is resulting in a rapid decrease in heart rate.
about 50 ml/kg. A patient with a normal pre‐ Manipulation of the head and neck (such as
operative packed cell volume (PCV) can sus via placement of an esophageal stethoscope)
tain a blood loss of about 20% of total blood can also trigger a vagal response. Any brady
volume without the need for a blood transfu cardia that appears to adversely affect cardiac
sion. Typically blood loss of this volume or less output should be treated with glycopyrrolate
can be replaced with crystalloid fluid adminis (0.01 mg/kg) or atropine at 0.04 mg/kg. A sud
tration. A spay–neuter patient who is bleeding den drop in heart rate or appearance of AV
and who does not have an IV catheter in place block or worsening AV block should also
should have an IV placed as soon as possible. potentially be treated. An acute vagal response
Since crystalloid fluids do not stay in the vascu can progress to a cardiac arrest. Many factors
lar space for long, two to three times the can increase a patient’s vagal tone, such as the
volume of blood lost is usually administered. use of opioid medications, hypothermia, and
In some settings, “low‐volume” resuscitation excessive anesthetic depth. In addition, some
with colloids and hypertonic saline might be patients may inherently have higher resting
instituted; however, these techniques may not vagal tone, such as brachycephalic breeds, lit
be possible in an HQHVSN setting and evi tle white breeds, and younger animals. In such
dence for the superior efficacy of low‐volume cases the use of prophylactic anticholinergic
resuscitation in veterinary patients is limited. drugs might be considered.
High‐volume fluid resuscitation in the face of
acute hemorrhage can be life saving and is
Pain
unlikely to harm a young and healthy spay–
neuter patient, as long as the source of bleed With a balanced anesthetic protocol and con
ing is addressed. A volume of blood loss greater sistent surgical technique, most spay–neuter
than the 20% threshold or such that causes a patients would not be expected to experience
drop in PCV below critical levels will require a pain under anesthesia. However, all patients
blood transfusion. HQHVSN clinics could con are individuals and some may react more to
sider stocking a few units of packed red blood surgical stimulation than others. Pain should
cells for use in the rare emergency, or could always be considered as a potential root cause,
collect a unit or two from a healthy donor ani particularly for unexplained tachycardia. If
mal. Dogs do not form antibodies until about pain is suspected, small doses of additional
four days after the first transfusion and so analgesics should be given and should improve
blood typing in this setting is not necessary. the clinical picture. Small doses of dexmedeto
Cats, on the other hand, have pre‐formed midine (1–2 μg/kg) can be useful to smooth out
antibodies and so must always be typed. A the anesthesia of a patient experiencing an
useful technique for the high‐volume clinic is unexpected painful response and can be given
autotransfusion. Cell savers can be obtained IV, IM, or via the oral transmucosal route. In
from various suppliers and can easily be addition, local anesthetic techniques can be
used to autotransfuse a patient’s own blood very useful to ensure adequate analgesia.
References 225
References
Mitchell, S.L., McCarthy, R., Rudloff, E. et al. properties in the dog. Vet. Anesth. Analg. 32
(2000). Tracheal rupture associated with (3): 117–127.
intubation in cats: 20 cases (1996–1998). Posner, L.P., Pavuk, A.A., Rokshar, J.L. et al.
JAVMA 216: 1592–1595. (2010). Effects of opioids and anesthetic drugs
Mosley, C. (2015). Veterinary anesthesia on body temperature in cats. Vet. Anaesth.
apparatus checkout recommendations (table Analg. 37: 35–43.
3.4), anesthesia equipment. In: Veterinary Waldrop, J.E., Rozanski, E.A., Swanke, E.D.
Anesthesia and Analgesia, 5e (eds. K. Grimm, et al. (2004). Causes of cardiopulmonary
L. Lamont, W. Tranquilli, et al.), 63. Ames, IA: arrest, resuscitation management, and
Wiley‐Blackwell. functional outcome in dogs and cats
Murrell, J.C. and Hellebrekers, L.J. (2005). surviving cardiopulmonary arrest. J. Vet.
Medetomidine and dexmedetomidine a review Emerg. Crit. Care 14 (1): 22–29.
of cardiovascular effects and antinociceptive
227
11
Knowledge and practice of effective cardiopul- arrest rhythm reported in small animals is
monary resuscitation (CPR) techniques is ventricular asystole (Waldrop et al. 2004).
important to veterinarians, technicians, and
staff working in high‐quality high‐volume
spay–neuter (HQHVSN) or shelter animal Recognition and Treatment
practice. Most patients that develop cardiac of Hypoventilation and/or
arrest in this setting are anesthetized patients. Respiratory Arrest
Based on clinical studies (Kass and Haskins
1992; Waldrop et al. 2004; Hofmeister et al. Animals given injectable agents for anesthetic
2009), patients that arrested under anesthesia induction may develop apnea or respiratory
have a higher probability of successful resusci- arrest minutes after administration of the
tation compared to those that are awake at the drug(s), during surgery, and post‐operatively.
time of arrest. Most dogs and cats undergoing Early recognition and treatment of respiratory
anesthesia in a shelter setting are healthy, with arrest can forestall progression to cardiopul-
a potentially good outcome following an arrest, monary arrest and avert the need for CPR.
further emphasizing the importance of per- When breathing stops for longer than 30 sec-
sonnel who are well trained in resuscitation onds, the pulse should be checked immedi-
techniques. ately to rule out cardiopulmonary arrest; if no
The CPR technique performed differs pulse is identified, CPR should be initiated. If
among veterinary clinics due to differences in there is a pulse, immediate steps should be
access to equipment; for example, in many taken to support the ventilation of the patient.
shelter animal facilities an electrocardiograph For patients who are not intubated when apnea
(EKG) machine and electrical defibrillator is recognized, the mouth, pharynx, and larynx
will not be readily available. However, even should be inspected to ensure that there is no
without these tools, effective CPR can still be obstruction or foreign material interfering
performed. Since ventricular fibrillation, one with breathing. If the airway is clear, ventila-
of the abnormal rhythms during cardiac tion of the patient should be supported by intu-
arrest, has a low incidence in animals com- bating the patient, providing oxygen, and
pared with humans (Waldrop et al. 2004; squeezing the bag of the anesthetic breathing
Boller et al. 2012), the absence of an electrical circuit. If an anesthetic breathing circuit is not
defibrillator will only make a small difference available, an Ambu bag can be used to support
in the overall success rate. The most common ventilation until the patient attains spontaneous
228 11 Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in Shelter Animal Practice
pumping action. By performing basic life sup- recoil, which causes blood to move. The com-
port, the blood flow and oxygen supply to the pression rate should be at least 100 compres-
heart are restored momentarily, with the hope sions per minute (Feneley et al. 1988;
that the heart will return to spontaneous con- McMichael 2008; Boller et al. 2012). Higher
traction and relaxation. compression rates create better blood flow to
Basic life support consists of providing arti- the heart, but are difficult to maintain (Maier
ficial circulation and ventilation. Based on the et al. 1986; Newton et al. 1988). The compres-
current findings, the priority for basic life sup- sion must be forceful and hard in order to cre-
port is to provide circulation by immediate ate the required blood flow. In smaller patients
external chest compression (Berg et al. 2010). such as cats and dogs weighing less than 10 kg,
For patients over 10 kg, chest compression is the resuscitator’s hand can be placed around
performed with the patient in lateral recum- the sternum, and the heart is compressed
bency; right and left lateral recumbency are between the thumb and the other fingers.
both acceptable. The main force of compres- Using this technique, the cardiac pump mech-
sion is directed at the area of widest circum- anism is utilized (Figure 11.2). The compres-
ference and at the junction of the middle third sion rate will be similar to that used in larger
and dorsal third of the chest. This is the high- patients. A modification of this technique
est visible point of the chest with the animal involves one hand placed across the dorsal
positioned in lateral recumbency. The resusci- aspect of the chest and the other hand placed
tator typically stands on the dorsal or back across the sternum. Both hands will compress
side of the patient and applies the compres- the chest and the heart simultaneously
sion with hands together and the elbows (Figure 11.3). This circumferential chest com-
locked (Figure 11.1). The weight of the whole pression utilizes both the cardiac and thoracic
body, not just the arms, should be used to pump mechanisms (Boller et al. 2012).
compress the chest. The chest should be com- If the animal is not intubated when the car-
pressed by up to 30% of its circumference or diac arrest occurs, the patient should be intu-
width. The resuscitator should allow elastic bated after the initial chest compressions.
Figure 11.1 Chest compression techniques for dogs greater than 10 kg. This technique utilizes the thoracic
pump mechanism.
230 11 Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in Shelter Animal Practice
administration, the dose of epinephrine should complicate the decision‐making process dur-
be 10 times the IV dose and 0.9% saline or ster- ing resuscitation, when time is of the essence.
ile water is used as a diluent to increase the vol- Atropine is a parasympatholytic agent that
ume for administration. For medium‐sized may be administered during cardiac arrest. It
dogs (8–20 kg), 5 ml of diluent is used (Paret increases sinoatrial node automaticity and
et al. 1997; Rozanski et al. 2012). Since there is atrioventricular nodal conduction (Lemke
no published data for cats or small and large 2007; McMichael 2008). The main indication
dogs, 2–3 and 10 ml of diluent are suggested for for atropine is in patients that develop cardiac
small patients and large dogs, respectively. If arrest with very high vagal tone. It can be
the patient has no return of spontaneous circu- used if the cardiac arrest is manifested as ven-
lation, epinephrine should be re‐administered tricular asystole or pulseless electrical activity
every four minutes. Giving epinephrine every (Boller et al. 2012). The routine use of atro-
three to five minutes is a common recommen- pine during cardiac arrest is not recom-
dation (McMichael 2008); by giving it every mended in humans (Neumar et al. 2010);
four minutes, it is easier to remember to give it however, its use has not been associated with
after two of the two‐minute sessions of chest any detrimental effects and may be of minor
compression and ventilation (Figure 11.4). benefit in small animal patients (Blecic et al.
Vasopressin may be used to replace the first 1992; DeBehnke et al. 1995; Boller et al. 2012;
or second dose of epinephrine. It stimulates Fletcher et al. 2012). Atropine is administered
the V1 receptors, resulting in peripheral vaso- IV at 0.04 mg/kg (Boller et al. 2012). Higher
constriction (Lindner et al. 1992). The dose is doses of atropine should be avoided, because
0.8 u/kg given intravenously (Boller et al. they are associated with a worse outcome
2012). In a shelter animal situation, the author (DeBehnke et al. 1995). If used, it usually fol-
recommends the use of epinephrine, since lows the administration of epinephrine. It can
there is no conclusive evidence that vasopres- also be given intratracheally at a dose of two
sin is superior to epinephrine (Wenzel et al. to three times that given IV. It may be admin-
2004; Mukoyama et al. 2009). Vasopressin is istered once or repeated similar to epineph-
also more expensive than epinephrine and will rine. When there is a return to spontaneous
circulation and the heart rate is slow, atropine
is also indicated.
Fluids
Balanced electrolyte solutions not containing
dextrose can be administered IV during resus-
citation (McMichael 2008). Conservative
administration of crystalloid solution is pru-
dent if the patient is not dehydrated or hypov-
olemic. A suggested administration rate is
5.0 ml/kg/hour. Excessive fluid administration
will increase right atrial pressure, resulting in
reduced coronary and cerebral blood flow
(Voorhees et al. 1987; Gentile et al. 1991;
Yannopoulos et al. 2009), and can also result in
pulmonary edema. Patients with dehydration,
hypovolemia, or shock should be given fluids
Figure 11.4 Simplified cardiopulmonary
resuscitation (CPR) algorithm chart for shelter at a faster rate: 80–90 ml/kg/hour in dogs and
animal practice. IV, intravenous. 45–50 ml/kg/hour in cats (McMichael 2008).
232 11 Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in Shelter Animal Practice
arrest. Team practice should be done on a regu- blood results in more free oxygen radicals,
lar basis, with each member having the oppor- which are toxic to cells (Neumar 2011). Room
tunity to practice each of the different roles. air (21% oxygen) is sufficient if ventilation is
Rotation of roles during CPR is usually neces- adequate and gas exchange is normal, as
sary unless resuscitation is immediately suc- shown by a normal SpO2. Adequacy of ventila-
cessful, since performing chest compressions, tion is best determined using blood gas analy-
particularly on large patients, is physically sis and capnography if the patient is intubated.
taxing. Furthermore, such cross‐training will In a shelter animal setting, these tools may not
ensure that CPR can be performed successfully be available and adequacy of ventilation can be
regardless of which staff members are in subjectively judged by assessing mucous mem-
attendance when an arrest occurs. In order to brane color, number of breaths per minutes,
minimize confusion and time delays, CPR lack of respiratory effort, and adequate chest
charts should be prominently displayed where excursion.
they are most likely to be needed (Table 11.1).
Similarly, a fully stocked CPR kit (or “crash
Perfusion
cart”) should be kept in the anesthesia and sur-
gery area, and should be periodically inspected The highest cardiac output that can be pro-
to ensure that it is fully stocked at all times. vided by chest compression during CPR is
about 25–40% of normal (Voorhees et al. 1980;
Weil et al. 1985). Lactic acidosis develops as a
result of severe hypoperfusion. The cardiovas-
Post-cardiac Arrest Care
cular function of the patient following return
to spontaneous circulation should be sup-
Ventilation and Oxygenation
ported. If the patient was hypovolemic or
There are basic principles to follow when man- dehydrated before cardiac arrest occurred, flu-
aging patients following the return of sponta- ids should be administered post‐cardiac arrest.
neous circulation. When the patient is not Balanced electrolyte solutions are adminis-
breathing spontaneously, ventilation should be tered and based on the degree of hypovolemia
controlled manually or by using a mechanical and dehydration. If the blood glucose level is
ventilator. Carbon dioxide tension (PaCO2) within normal limits, crystalloid solutions
should be within normal limits (35–40 mmHg). without dextrose are used. Lactated Ringer’s
Severe hyperventilation should be avoided, as solution, Normosol®‐R (Hospira, Lake Forest,
it reduces cerebral blood flow. Controlled ven- IL), and Plasma‐Lyte (Baxter, Mississauga,
tilation can continue until the patient assumes Ontario, Canada) are good choices for fluid
spontaneous breathing or starts to take shal- administration. If the patient is not hypov-
low breaths necessitating tracheal extubation. olemic, maintenance fluid rates of 40–60 ml/
Both hyperoxemia and hypoxemia should be kg/day (DiBartola and Batement 2006) are
avoided post‐cardiac arrest. If a pulse oximeter recommended.
is available, and oxygen saturation (SpO2) The patient’s blood pressure should be mon-
readings of 94–98% are obtained, further oxy- itored and supported if needed. Following
gen supplementation is not required. However, CPR, varying degrees of left ventricular dys-
if the SpO2 is less than 94%, oxygen supple- function should be anticipated (Zia and Kern
mentation using a face mask is indicated 2011). Using the Doppler technique for meas-
(Fletcher et al. 2012). Based on recent findings, uring blood pressure, the systolic blood pres-
hyperoxemia following a successful resuscita- sure should be higher than 90 mmHg in dogs
tion is harmful. High oxygen tension in the and cats (McMichael 2008). If the patient is
Table 11.1 Cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) drug dosing chart for shelter animal practice.
Weight
(kg) 1 2 3 4 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Epinephrine IV 0.01 mg/kg 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40
1 mg/ml
Epinephrine IT 0.1 mg/kg 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0
Diluent (saline) 2 2 2 3 3 5 5 5 10 10 10 10
Vasopressin IV 0.8 u/kg 0.04 0.08 0.12 0.16 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6
20 u/ml
Atropine IV 0.04 mg/kg 0.07 0.15 0.22 0.30 0.37 0.74 1.10 1.50 1.80 2.20 2.60 3.0
0.54 mg/ml
Lidocaine IV 2 mg/kg 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0
20 mg/ml Dogs
Lidocaine IV 0.5 mg/kg 0.03 0.05 0.08 0.1 0.13
20 mg/ml Cats
Bicarbonate IV 1 mEq/kg 1 2 3 4 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
1 mEq/ml
Naloxone IV 0.04 mg/kg 0.13 0.27 0.40 0.53 0.67 1.3 2.0 2.7 3.3 4.0 4.7 5.3
0.4 mg/ml
Atipamezole IV 100 ug/kg 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.10 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8
5.0 mg/ml
External 4–6 J/kg 6 6 15 20 30 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
Defibrillationa
hypotensive, administration of a positive ino- with worse outcomes in critically ill patients. It
trope is indicated, with dopamine being the has been suggested that blood glucose levels
most common agent used in small animals. should be maintained at between 144 and
The dose rate for dopamine is 5–10 ug/kg/min- 180 mg/dl (Peberdy et al. 2010). If a glucose
ute. In patients with high vagal tone, adminis- monitoring device is available, blood glucose
tration of an anticholinergic is indicated if the should be measured post‐cardiac arrest. Mild
patient’s heart rate falls below the normal rest- to moderate hypoglycemia can be treated using
ing heart rate. Atropine or glycopyrrolate can crystalloids containing 2.5–5.0% dextrose. If
be administered IV at a dose of 0.02–0.04 mg/ severe hypoglycemia is present, 50% dextrose
kg and 0.01 mg/kg, respectively. at 1.0 ml/kg, diluted with an equal volume of
0.9% saline to prevent phlebitis, should be
administered slowly (Macintire et al. 2005). In
Body Temperature
a shelter animal practice, hyperglycemia will
Body temperature should be monitored post‐ be more difficult to manage, since this requires
cardiac arrest. Hyperthermia – body tempera- titrating insulin, which may not be readily
ture greater than 102.5 °F (39.2 °C) for dogs and available, to achieve normal blood glucose
greater than 103.0 °F (39.4 °C) for cats – should values. This also requires more intensive
be corrected by using available cooling meth- monitoring and can be dangerous to the patient
ods. An electric fan directed at the patient will if severe hypoglycemia results from insulin
help to decrease body temperature. Cool IV flu- administration.
ids can also be administered. Hyperthermia is
harmful because it further increases the oxy-
gen requirements of the brain, which in turn Conclusion
impairs brain recovery (Peberdy et al. 2010).
Mild hypothermia should not be corrected. CPR in a shelter animal practice can be sim-
However, close monitoring of body tempera- plified without decreasing its potential for
ture is indicated to prevent severe hypothermia. success. Effective basic life support is vital to
In humans, hypothermia (body temperature of a good outcome. Veterinarians, technicians,
89.6–93.2 °F, 32–34 °C) may be induced post‐ and staff members should master the tech-
cardiac arrest for 12 or 24 hours (Bernard et al. niques involved in basic life support. Recent
2002; Peberdy et al. 2010). This treatment recommendations have simplified CPR tech-
requires a well‐controlled environment and niques, emphasizing the importance of
advanced monitoring tools because of the pos- basic life support and using fewer drugs. The
sible adverse effects associated with severe absence of electrical defibrillators and EKG
hypothermia. Whole‐body hypothermia fol- machines further simplifies CPR techniques,
lowing cardiac arrest has not been instituted in resulting in less confusion among resuscita-
veterinary practice. It is also important to note tors. It must be remembered that CPR is a
that when an animal arrests during anesthesia, team effort and each member should know in
severe hypothermia will further delay the advance their role when a cardiac arrest
metabolism and excretion of anesthetic drugs. occurs. Team practice should be done on a
regular basis. CPR charts should be promi-
nently displayed where they are most likely
Blood Glucose Values
to be needed, and a CPR kit should be kept
When compared to euglycemia, both hypergly- fully stocked and placed in the anesthesia
cemia and hypoglycemia have been associated and surgery area.
236 11 Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in Shelter Animal Practice
References
Aufderheide, T.P. and Lurie, K.G. (2004). Death Feneley, M.P., Maier, G.W., Kern, K.B. et al.
by hyperventilation: a common and life‐ (1988). Influence of compression rate on
threatening problem during cardiopulmonary initial success of resuscitation and 24 hour
resuscitation. Crit. Care Med. 32 (Suppl): survival after prolonged manual
S345–S351. cardiopulmonary resuscitation in dogs.
Berg, R.A., Hemphill, R., Abella, B.S. et al. Circulation 77: 240–250.
(2010). Part 5: adult basic life support: 2010 Fletcher, D.J., Boller, M., Brainard, B.M. et al.
American Heart Association Guidelines for (2012). RECOVER evidence and knowledge
cardiopulmonary resuscitation and emergency gap analysis on veterinary CPR. Part 7: clinical
cardiovascular care. Circulation 122 (18 Suppl. guidelines. J. Vet. Emerg. Crit. Care 22 (Supp1.
3): S685–S705. 2): S102–S131.
Berg, R.A., Sanders, A.B., Kern, K.B. et al. Gentile, N.T., Martin, G.B., Appleton, T.J. et al.
(2001). Adverse hemodynamic effects of (1991). Effects of arterial and venous
interrupting chest compressions for rescue volume infusion on coronary perfusion
breathing during cardiopulmonary pressures during canine CPR. Resuscitation
resuscitation for ventricular fibrillation 22: 55–63.
cardiac arrest. Circulation 104: 2465–2470. Harrison, E.E. (1981). Intracardiac injections.
Bernard, S.A., Gray, T.W., Buist, M.D. et al. JAMA 245: 1315.
(2002). Treatment of comatose survivors of Hofmeister, E.H., Brainard, B.M., Egger, C.M.
out‐of‐hospital cardiac arrest with induced et al. (2009). Prognostic indicators for dogs
hypothermia. N. Engl. J. Med. 346: 557–563. and cats with cardiopulmonary arrest treated
Blecic, S., Chaskis, C., and Vincent, J.L. (1992). by cardiopulmonary cerebral resuscitation at a
Atropine administration in experimental university teaching hospital. JAVMA 235:
electromechanical dissociation. Am. J. Emerg. 50–57.
Med. 10: 515–518. Hopper, K., Epstein, S.E., Fletcher, D.J. et al.
Boller, M., Boller, E.M., Oodegard, S. et al. (2012). RECOVER evidence and knowledge
(2012). Small animal cardiopulmonary gap analysis on veterinary CPR. Part 3: basic
resuscitation requires a continuum of care: life support. J. Vet. Emerg. Crit. Care 22
proposal for a chain of survival for veterinary (Supp1. 2): S26–S43.
patients. JAVMA 240: 540–554. Jespersen, H.F., Granbord, J., Hansen, U. et al.
Davison, R., Barresi, V., Parker, M. et al. (1980). (1990). Feasibility of intracardiac injection of
Intracardiac injections during drugs during cardiac arrest. Eur. Heart J. 11:
cardiopulmonary resuscitation. JAMA 244: 269–274.
1110–1111. Kass, P.H. and Haskins, S.C. (1992). Survival
DeBehnke, D.J., Swart, G.L., Spreng, D. et al. following cardiopulmonary resuscitation in
(1995). Standard and higher doses of atropine dogs and cats. J. Vet. Emerg. Crit. Care 2:
in a canine model of pulseless electrical 57–65.
activity. Acad. Emerg. Med. 2: 1034–1041. Lemke, K.A. (2007). Anticholinergics and
DiBartola, S.P. and Batement, S. (2006). sedatives. In: Lumb & Jones’ Veterinary
Introduction to fluid therapy. In: Fluid, Anesthesia and Analgesia, 4e (eds. W.J.
Electrolyte, and Acid‐Base Disorders in Small Tranquilli, J.C. Thurmon and K.A. Grimm),
Animal Practice, 3e (eds. S.P. DiBartola and 203–239. Ames, IA: Blackwell.
K.A. Grimm), 325–344. Maryland Heights, Lindner, K.H., Strohmenger, H.U., Ensinger, H.
MO: Saunders Elsevier. et al. (1992). Stress hormone response during
References 237
Section Three
12
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 12.1 Restraint devices. (a) A simple restraint device can be made from an aluminum rod. Make
various sizes for different-sized dogs and cats. (b) Cat restraint devices. (c) Dog restraint devices. (d) A dog
with a restraint device. Source: Photos courtesy of Tom Thompson.
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
Figure 12.2 Paramedian incision. (a) Ventral midline skin incision. (b) Undermine to the right of the linea
alba. (c) Incise the muscle fascia without cutting rectus muscle. (d) Bluntly separate muscle fibers. (e)
Elevate and cut the peritoneum to enter the abdomen. (f) The peritoneum is incised, allowing entry into the
abdomen. Source: Photos courtesy of Tom Thompson.
right ovary than the left ovary. To equalize the midline. Undermine the subcutaneous tissue
difficulty of exteriorizing the two ovaries, one to the right of the linea alba. The external fas
of the authors (Bushby) prefers to make the cia is incised, being careful not to cut fibers of
entry into the abdomen through a right para the rectus abdominis muscle to avoid hemor
median incision (Figure 12.2). rhage. The fascial incision can be a little as
To perform a paramedian abdominal entry, 0.5 cm to the right of the linea in very small
incise the skin on the ventral abdominal dogs and as much as 1.5 cm to the right of the
244 12 Dog Spay/Cat Spay
linea in larger dogs. A hemostat is inserted passes of the spay hook to exteriorize the right
through the rectus abdominus muscle and uterine horn. If the right horn is not found
opened. This bluntly separates the fibers of the after several passes, the surgeon may use the
rectus abdominus muscle, exposing the peri hook on the left side. When using a spay hook,
toneum. The peritoneum is then grasped with especially on the left side, care should be taken
a thumb forceps and cut with a Metzenbaum to avoid damage to the spleen, mesentery, and
scissors. other abdominal structures.
Once the uterine horn is exteriorized, gentle
traction on the more cranial aspect of the uter
Exteriorizing the Uterus and Ovaries
ine horn will begin to expose the ovary. Place a
Upon entry into the abdominal cavity, a spay hemostat on the proper ligament of the ovary
hook can be used to locate and exteriorize the and apply upward tension. This tenses the sus
first uterine horn. The spay hook should be pensory ligament of the ovary, making palpa
passed into the abdominal cavity along the tion and visualization of the ligament much
right abdominal wall. Upon reaching the dor easier. It may also be helpful to press gently
sal lateral abdominal wall, the hook is then downward on the body wall at the incision to
swept toward the midline and elevated out of further expose the suspensory ligament. The
the abdominal incision. Depending on the suspensory ligament is then cut with a scissors
experience of the surgeon, it may take several (Figure 12.3) or a blade, or it may be torn. Tear
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 12.3 Incising the suspensory ligament. (a) Grasp the proper ligament with a hemostat. (b) Apply
upward tension, exposing the suspensory ligament. (c) Cut the suspensory ligament. Source: Photos courtesy
of Tom Thompson.
Canine Ovariohysterectomy 245
a window in the broad ligament caudal to the pared to ligation prior to transection. This
ovarian vessels to isolate the ovarian vessels in leads to a decreased chance of damage to the
the ovarian pedicle. pedicle during ligation or of inadvertent inclu
sion of inappropriate tissues in the ligature.
It is not necessary to crush the tissue that will
Ovarian Pedicle Ligation
be included in the pedicle ligation. However, it
Most veterinary students are taught to double‐ is essential to ensure that the ligature is not
ligate ovarian pedicles and uterine stumps and placed too close to the hemostat that secures
to ligate before transecting the ovarian pedi the pedicle, as the “fanning out” of tissue
cles. It is much more efficient to transect the immediately surrounding the hemostat may
ovarian pedicles prior to ligation and to single‐ prevent adequate tightening of the ligature.
ligate each pedicle (Bushby 2013). Transection One of the authors (Bushby) prefers the
prior to ligation enables the surgeon to place following technique of ligating and transect
the ligature with minimal manipulation of the ing ovarian pedicles in the dog or puppy
pedicle and with greater visibility when com (see Figure 12.4). Place three hemostats or
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 12.4 Ligating the ovarian pedicle with a modified Miller’s knot. (a) A window is torn in the broad
ligament to isolate the pedicle. (b) Three hemostats are placed: two on the pedicle, one on the proper
ligament. (c) The pedicle is transected distal to the second hemostat. (d) Begin the modified Miller’s knot:
pass suture under the hemostat (or Carmalt). (e) Pass suture under the hemostat (or Carmalt) again, creating
a loop, and pass the needle holder through the loop. (f) Wrap the long strand of suture once around the
needle holder. (g) Grasp the short strand of the suture with the needle holder. (h) Pull the needle holder
back out of the loop, creating the first throw of the knot. (i) Remove the most proximal hemostat (or
Carmalt) and pull the first throw tight into the crushed area from the first hemostat (or Carmalt). (j) Place
three or four more square knot throws, remove the remaining hemostat (or Carmalt), and check for
hemorrhage.
246 12 Dog Spay/Cat Spay
(e) (f)
(g) (h)
(i) (j)
Carmalts, the first proximal on the ovarian Before ligating, transect the ovarian pedicle
pedicle, the second several millimeters distal just distal to the second hemostat (between
to the first, but still proximal to the ovary, and the second hemostat and the ovary). Ligate
the third on the proper ligament between the with a modified Miller’s knot (see next sec
ovary and the uterine horn. Close the first tion). Place the ligature just proximal to the
hemostat one click, the second two clicks, most proximal hemostat and, before pulling
and the third three clicks. The purpose of the the ligature tight, remove the most proximal
1, 2, 3 clicks is to avoid completely crushing hemostat. This places the ligature in the tis
the tissue at the most proximal clamp, which sue compressed by the most proximal hemo
would predispose the pedicle to tearing. stat. A single ligature, appropriately placed
Canine Ovariohysterectomy 247
and tied securely and tightly, is all that is nec level of the uterine vessels. If the broad liga
essary on ovarian pedicles. ments are vascular it may be necessary to ligate
After ligation, the transected pedicle is the broad ligaments prior to transecting them.
grasped with a thumb forceps, the clamp A single ligature with a modified Miller’s
removed, and the pedicle observed for hemor knot is placed on the uterine body close to the
rhage prior to returning the pedicle to the cervix. The ligature should be tightened until
abdominal cavity. tissue blanching is observed under the liga
ture. It is not necessary to crush the uterine
tissue with a hemostat or Carmalt (see
Modified Miller’s Knot Figure 12.5); if the uterus is friable, crushing
The modified Miller’s knot is a very secure, may cause tearing of the uterus. A hemostat
self‐locking knot that can be placed either with or Carmalt is then placed distal to the liga
an instrument or with a hand tie (Figure 12.4). tures and the uterine body transected between
The modified Miller’s knot can be used on the ligatures and the hemostatic clamp, leav
spermatic cords, ovarian pedicles in dogs, and ing several millimeters of tissue distal to the
uterine bodies of dogs and cats (Bushby 2013). ligature to prevent slippage of the ligature.
To place a modified Miller’s knot, pass the When ligating the uterine body during ovari
suture under the tissue to be ligated, then bring ohysterectomy, it is not necessary to remove all
the suture back over the tissue and under the uterine tissue for fear of stump pyometra, as
tissue one more time. This creates a small loop pyometra will not occur without the presence
of suture above the tissue to be ligated. Position of ovarian hormones. It is also acceptable to
the needle holder through that small loop, ligate the two uterine horns separately if the
wrap the long strand once around the needle uterine body is difficult to exteriorize.
holder, grasp the short strand of suture with
the needle holder, and pull the needle holder
Closure
toward you while pulling the long strand of
suture away from you. Gentle upward tension The abdomen may be closed in two or three
while pulling this knot tight facilitates even layers. The holding layer for abdominal wall
tightening of the ligature. Complete the knot closure consists of the external rectus fascia.
by placing three or four additional square knot Selection of suture patterns and suture mate
throws (see Figures 12.4 and 12.5). rial is generally the surgeon’s preference, and
continuous, interrupted, or cruciate patterns
are all acceptable. The subcutaneous tissue
Second Pedicle and Uterine Body and the skin may be closed separately or in a
Ligation single layer. It is recommended that skin clo
Gentle traction on the uterine horn will allow sure is subcuticular such that suture removal is
exposure of the uterine body and the second not required.
uterine horn. Caudal traction on the second
uterine horn will expose the ovary. The second Aberdeen Knot
ovarian pedicle is ligated and transected in a If a continuous suture line is used in any of the
manner identical to that of the first ovarian closure layers, an alternative knot for ending
pedicle. the closure is the Aberdeen knot (Figure 12.6).
Following ligation and transection of both This knot is a self‐locking knot that can be
ovarian pedicles, the two uterine horns are used as an alternative to a square knot at the
reflected caudally, exposing the uterine body end of any continuous suture line (Regier et al.
and cervix. The broad ligaments on either side 2015). The Aberdeen knot is equally secure to a
of the uterine body are either torn or cut to the square knot but is less bulky, thus leaving less
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
(g)
Figure 12.5 Modified Miller’s knot on the uterine body. (a) Pass suture under the uterine body. (b) Pass
suture under the uterine body again, creating a loop. (c) Pass the needle holder through the loop. (d) Wrap a
long strand of suture around the needle holder. (e) Grasp a short strand of suture with the needle holder. (f)
Pull the needle holder toward the surgeon and the long strand away from the surgeon, tightening the first
throw. (g) Place three or four more square knot throws and cut the suture. Source: Photos courtesy of Tom
Thompson.
Canine Ovariohysterectomy 249
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
(g) (h)
Figure 12.6 An Aberdeen knot. This knot is used at the end of a continuous suture line. It begins with a
loop and an end, and can be tied with instruments or as a hand tie. A hand tie is used here for illustration
purposes. (a) Pick up the last suture loop. Place the fingers of one hand through the loop while holding the
needle end of the suture in the other hand. (b) Reach through the loop and grasp the suture. (c) Pull the
suture through without releasing the needle end, thus creating a new loop. (d) Tighten the previous loop
until it is flush with the patient. (e) Place the fingers through the new loop and repeat steps b–d at least
once more. (f) To finish the knot, on the final loop, release the needle end from the other hand so that the
end can be pulled through the loop. (g) Pull the end completely through the final loop. (h) Pull the end until
the knot is tightened.
250 12 Dog Spay/Cat Spay
suture material in the wound (Stott et al. 2007). pubis. Dissect subcutaneous tissue only to the
Being smaller, the Aberdeen knot may also be extent necessary to visualize the linea alba.
easier to bury at the end of a subcuticular or Grasp the linea alba with a thumb forceps, ele
intradermal suture line (Thomas and Saleeby vate it, and nick the linea with a scalpel blade.
2012; Regier et al. 2015). Figure 12.6 shows the With the linea still elevated, extend the inci
process of constructing an Aberdeen knot. The sion with either a scissors or a scalpel blade.
number of throws required depends on the tis
sue layer, with two throws adequate for an
Locating the Uterus
intradermal or subcuticular closure, and three
or four throws recommended for closing the Upon entry into the abdominal cavity, a spay
linea (Stott et al. 2007; Schaaf et al. 2009). hook is used to locate and exteriorize the first
uterine horn. The spay hook should be passed
Tattoo into the abdominal cavity along the right
Following closure, a tattoo should be placed in abdominal wall. Upon reaching the dorsal lat
or near the spay incision (see Chapter 16 for eral abdominal wall, the hook is then swept
information on applying a tattoo). After the toward the midline and elevated out of the
tattoo is applied, skin glue may be applied to abdominal incision. Depending on the experi
the closed incision if desired, making sure to ence of the surgeon, it may take several passes
avoid placing glue inside the wound. of the spay hook to exteriorize the right uterine
horn. If the right horn is not found after sev
eral passes, the surgeon may use the hook on
Feline Ovariohysterectomy the left side. When using a spay hook, espe
cially on the left side, care should be taken to
The basic technique for ovariohysterectomy in avoid damage to the spleen, mesentery, and
the cat is essentially the same as that of the other abdominal structures.
female dog, with the exception of the location
of the incision and the autoligation technique
Pedicle Tie
for ovarian pedicle ligation (described below).
In the cat spay a pedicle tie can be used for
hemostasis of the ovarian vessels (Figure 12.7;
Preparation
Bohling et al. 2010, Griffin and Bohling 2010,
The ventral abdominal skin should be clipped Bushby 2013, Porters et al. 2014, Miller et al.
of hair and aseptically prepped as described in 2016). The pedicle tie is a self‐ligature similar
Chapter 4. The patient is positioned in dorsal to the cord tie frequently used in cat and puppy
recumbency with the front legs left untied, or castrations. The ovarian pedicle in the cat con
secured along the lateral thoracic walls. tains very little fat, allowing exposure and iso
lation of the ovarian vessels. Pedicle ties are
appropriate for use in cats of any age and at
Location of Incision
any stage of pregnancy or estrus. Use of the
In cats and kittens, the ovaries are easily exteri pedicle tie is only appropriate in cats. The pres
orized, but the uterine body is more difficult to ence of fat in the adult dog or puppy ovarian
exteriorize. The incision, therefore, should be pedicle interferes with the security of the knot.
centered at the midpoint between the umbili There are several variations of the pedicle
cus and the anterior brim of the pubis. tie, depending on whether the surgeon is right
A 1–2 cm skin incision is made on the ventral or left handed and on which side of the surgery
abdominal midline at the midpoint between table the surgeon prefers to stand. Each of the
the umbilicus and the cranial brim of the variations creates the same effect.
Feline Ovariohysterectomy 251
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
Figure 12.7 Feline ovarian ligation with pedicle tie. (a) The suspensory ligament is located and
isolated from the ovarian vessels. (b) The suspensory ligament is cut. (c) A window is torn in the broad
ligament caudal to the ovarian vessels, thereby isolating the vessels. (d) A curved hemostat is placed to
begin the pedicle tie. The tip of the hemostat faces away from the surgeon. (e) Rotate the hemostat
counterclockwise. (f) Continue to rotate counterclockwise until the hemostat faces the surgeon. (g)
Open the hemostat and clamp the ovarian pedicle. (h) Transect the pedicle distal to the tip of the
hemostat, leaving a few millimeters of cut end. (i) The pedicle has been transected. (j) The vessels are
pushed off the end of the hemostat, tightened, and checked for hemorrhage prior to release into the
abdomen.
252 12 Dog Spay/Cat Spay
(g) (h)
(i) (j)
Preparing for the Pedicle Tie over the vessels and placed into the hole in the
Once the first uterine horn is exteriorized, gen broad ligament behind the ovarian vessels.
tle traction on the more cranial aspect of the With the hemostat closed and the tip of the
uterine horn will begin to expose the ovary. hemostat facing away from the surgeon, the tip
Place a hemostat on the proper ligament of the of the hemostat is directed above the vessels
ovary and apply upward tension. This tenses and the hemostat is rotated counterclockwise
the suspensory ligament of the ovary, making until the tip of the hemostat faces the surgeon.
visualization of the ligament much easier. It This causes the ovarian vessels to be wrapped
may also be helpful to press gently downward around the hemostat. The jaws of the hemostat
on the body wall at the incision to further should then be opened and used to clamp the
expose the suspensory ligament. Placing a fin ovarian vessels. Cut the ovarian vessels
ger behind the pedicle may help isolate the between the hemostat and the ovary and gen
suspensory ligament from the ovarian vessels. tly push the knot off the end of the hemostat.
The suspensory ligament is then cut with a Pull the knot tight before releasing the hemo
scissors or blade, or is torn. Tear a hole in the stat and observe the vessels for hemorrhage.
broad ligament caudal to the ovarian vessels to Alternatively, the pedicle tie may be per
isolate the ovarian vessels in the ovarian pedicle. formed with the uterine horn and ovary held
away from the surgeon, and the hemostat
Performing the Pedicle Tie held in front of the uterine horn and placed
With the uterine horn and ovary pulled toward through the hole in the broad ligament from
the surgeon, the tip of a hemostat is crossed the front.
Ovariohysterectomy via a Lateral Flank Approach 253
Second Pedicle and Uterine Body Selection of suture patterns and suture mate
Ligation rial is generally the surgeon’s preference, and
continuous, interrupted, or cruciate patterns
Gentle traction on the uterine horn will allow
are all acceptable. The subcutaneous tissue
exposure of the uterine body and the second
and the skin may be closed separately or in a
uterine horn. Caudal traction on the second
single layer. It is recommended that skin clo
uterine horn will expose the ovary. The sec
sure is subcuticular such that suture removal is
ond ovarian pedicle is ligated and transected
not required.
in a manner identical to that for the first ovar
Following closure, a tattoo should be placed
ian pedicle.
in or near the spay incision (see Chapter 16 for
Following ligation and transection of both
information on applying a tattoo). After the
ovarian pedicles, the two uterine horns are
tattoo is applied, skin glue may be applied to
reflected caudally, exposing the uterine body
the closed incision if desired, making sure to
and cervix. The broad ligaments on either side
avoid placing glue inside the wound.
of the uterine body are either torn or cut to the
level of the uterine vessels. If the broad liga
ments are vascular, it may be necessary to
ligate the broad ligaments prior to transecting
Ovariohysterectomy via
them. An autoligation similar to a pedicle tie a Lateral Flank Approach
may be used to ligate the broad ligaments.
A single ligature using a modified Miller’s The generally accepted approach for an ovario
knot (see description in the canine ovariohys hysterectomy in the dog and cat in the United
terectomy section and Figures 12.4 and 12.5) is States is through a ventral abdominal midline
placed on the uterine body close to the cervix. incision, while in many European countries an
The ligature should be tightened until tissue incision in the flank is the preferred approach
blanching is observed under the ligature. It is (McGrath et al. 2004, Griffin and Bohling 2010).
not necessary to crush the uterine tissue with a There are specific situations where a flank
hemostat or Carmalt, as in some cases crush approach for an ovariohysterectomy is indi
ing friable tissue may result in damage or tear cated. Cats with mammary hyperplasia
ing of the uterus. A hemostat or Carmalt is (Figure 12.8) and lactating queens or bitches are
then placed distal to the ligatures and the uter ideal candidates for flank spays (Levy and
ine body transected between the ligatures and Wilford 2013). Performing a flank spay avoids
the hemostatic clamp, leaving several millime damage to mammary tissue, preventing leakage
ters of tissue distal to the ligature to prevent
slippage of the ligature.
When ligating the uterine body during ovario
hysterectomy, it is not necessary to remove all
uterine tissue for fear of stump pyometra, as
pyometra will not occur without the presence of
ovarian hormones. It is also acceptable to ligate
the two uterine horns separately if the uterine
body is difficult to exteriorize.
Closure
The abdomen may be closed in two or three
Figure 12.8 A cat with mammary hyperplasia.
layers. The holding layer for abdominal wall This cat was spayed using a flank approach. Source:
closure consists of the external rectus fascia. Photo courtesy of Brenda Griffin.
254 12 Dog Spay/Cat Spay
of milk into the tissues. In the lactating patient connecting the stifle to the abdominal wall
a flank spay reduces the chances that nursing (Reece 2018). The incision length in dogs is
offspring would damage the incision site. One typically 2–3 cm.
should also consider performing a flank spay in After making the skin incision, dissect and if
feral cats or dogs (Reece et al. 2012) in trap–neu necessary excise any subcutaneous fat, expos
ter–return programs in which the patients are ing the external abdominal oblique muscle.
released back into their colony shortly after sur Bluntly separate fibers of the external abdomi
gery. There is considerably less chance of having nal oblique muscle to expose the internal
a surgical dehiscence through a flank incision abdominal oblique muscle. Muscle fibers of
than through a ventral midline incision (Levy the internal abdominal oblique can be bluntly
and Wilford 2013). separated, exposing the peritoneum. Often
Flank spay may be more difficult in larger, blunt separation of the internal abdominal
deep‐bodied dogs and obese patients. It is not a oblique muscle fibers penetrates the perito
recommended approach for pregnant animals neum, allowing entry into the abdominal cav
or those with pyometra due to limited expo ity. If the peritoneum has not been penetrated,
sure via the flank approach. A further disad it can be cut with a scissors exposing the
vantage of the flank approach is difficulty in abdominal contents. Once the abdomen has
retrieving dropped pedicles or achieving been entered, many surgeons find it useful to
hemostasis if unexpected hemorrhage occurs grasp the transverse abdominis muscle with
(McGrath et al. 2004). thumb forceps or Allis tissue forceps to retain
control of the body wall (McGrath et al. 2004;
Reece 2018).
Flank Spay Technique
If the incision is positioned properly, the
A flank spay may be performed with the right uterine horn or right ovary will be clearly
patient in left or right lateral recumbency. visible in the cat. With the more ventral
Generally, the surgeon stands on their accus approach to the dog that has been described,
tomed side of the table and the patient is posi these structures are likely not visible and will
tioned with feet toward the surgeon and spine be located dorsal to the incision (Reece 2018).
away from the surgeon. This patient position If these structures are not visible, they can be
ing determines the side of the approach. Left retrieved using a spay hook. Place the spay
lateral recumbency may be preferable, as it hook into the abdominal cavity at the ventral‐
minimizes the likelihood of encountering the most aspect of the incision and sweep dorsally
spleen. along the body wall to the transverse spinous
The skin incision may be made in a dorso‐ processes. Once the uterine horn is located, the
ventral direction, horizontally, or diagonally in ovaries and uterus are removed in a manner
a dorso‐cranial to ventro‐caudal direction. In identical to that done with a ventral midline
cats, the incision is placed two‐thirds to three‐ approach. The ovary can be exteriorized, the
quarters of the way back from the last rib suspensory ligament torn or cut, and a pedicle
toward the cranial aspect of the wing of the tie (in cats) or a modified Miller’s knot ligation
ilium, starting approximately 2 cm ventral to (in dogs) can be performed on the ovarian ves
the transverse spinous processes and creating a sels, with the ovarian pedicle transected
1.5–2 cm incision (Figure 12.9; McGrath et al. between the ligation and the ovary. Gentle
2004). In dogs, some surgeons place the inci retraction of the uterine horn allows delivery
sion in a proportionally similar location to of the uterine body into the incision, exposing
cats, while other surgeons prefer to make a the contralateral uterine horn. Traction on
horizontal incision and to place the incision the uterine horn exposes the ovary, and the
more ventrally, at the level of the fold of skin suspensory ligament can be torn or cut, the
Ovariohysterectomy via a Lateral Flank Approach 255
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
Figure 12.9 Flank spay in a cat. (a) The incision for a flank spay is made two-thirds of the way back from
the last rib to the crest of the ilium and just ventral to the transverse spinous processes. (b) The surgeon
palpates the locations of the last rib and iliac crest through the drape prior to placing the incision. (c) The
muscle fibers of the external abdominal oblique then internal abdominal oblique are bluntly separated, not
incised. First, the tip of a hemostat is placed between the muscle fibers. (d) The jaws of the hemostat are
then opened to separate the fibers. (e) The appearance of the abdominal entry wound. (f) Exteriorizing the
right ovary and the uterine horn.
pedicle ligated as on the first side, and the body is transected distal to the ligature and the
pedicle transected between the ligature and stump is checked for hemorrhage and returned
the ovary. The broad ligaments are torn or cut, to the abdominal cavity.
allowing exposure and ligation of the uterine In adult dogs, a three‐layer closure is
body with a modified Miller’s knot. The uterine performed, suturing the internal abdominal
256 12 Dog Spay/Cat Spay
oblique muscle, the external abdominal of the uterus is sufficient. If necessary, the uter
oblique muscle, and subcuticular tissue. In ine vessels can be ligated independently. Large
cats and puppies, three‐layer closure is also vessels in the broad ligament can be ligated
common, but some surgeons choose to close either with suture or with the pedicle tie.
all the muscle layers together in one or
two simple interrupted or cruciate sutures What to Do with the Gravid Uterus?
(McGrath et al. 2004; Reece 2018). When Once the gravid uterus has been removed from
using a three‐layer closure, placement of one the dam, no additional action is required to
cruciate suture in the internal abdominal ensure fetal death without fetal suffering or
oblique muscle and one cruciate suture in the consciousness (White 2012). The neurologic
external abdominal oblique muscle, followed immaturity of fetal cats, dogs, and rabbits,
by two buried simple interrupted subcuticu combined with the high concentrations of
lar sutures, is all that is necessary for closure. anesthetic drugs that cross the placenta and
hypoxia‐induced neuroinhibitors, prevent the
fetuses from becoming conscious.
Special Situations in The fetuses should remain in the closed
uterus after uterine removal from the dam. The
Ovariohysterectomy
uterus may be simply set aside and the fetuses
left undisturbed. It is not necessary to retain
The Pregnant Patient
clamps on the uterus as long as the fetuses
In the shelter and high‐volume spay–neuter remain in their amniotic sacs. Some veterinar
environment, surgeons may be presented with ians may elect to inject euthanasia solution
pregnant animals to spay. The technique for through the wall of the closed uterus into the
ovariohysterectomy in the pregnant female is fetal abdominal cavity to hasten fetal death.
virtually the same as that in the non‐pregnant Although this procedure is not necessary for
animal, with a few exceptions. Depending on the prevention of fetal suffering, it has no det
the stage of pregnancy, the incision may need rimental welfare effects and may stop the
to be larger. Finding the first uterine horn in spontaneous in‐utero fetal movements that
the pregnant patient is generally easier than some veterinarians and staff find troubling.
finding the non‐gravid uterus, simply because If the gravid uterus is to be opened after
the presence of the fetuses make the uterus ovariohysterectomy (for example, for educa
larger. The uterine tissue may be more friable, tional purposes), it has been recommended
so the uterus must be handled with care to (White 2012) that the uterus be left unopened
avoid tearing the uterine wall. This is espe and the fetuses undisturbed for a minimum of
cially important if an effort is made to exterior one hour after removal from the dam to pre
ize the gravid uterus though abdominal wall vent inadvertent fetal resuscitation. Fetal expo
and skin incisions that are too small. sure to air prior to fetal death may lead to the
Special attention should be paid to hemosta stimulation of respiration, loss of neuroinhibi
sis. Even though the vessels may be signifi tion, exhalation of inhalant anesthetic drugs,
cantly enlarged, the pedicle tie (see Figure 12.7) and perhaps even the potential for fetal con
is still an appropriate method for ligating the sciousness and suffering prior to euthanasia.
ovarian vessels in the cat. In the dog, pedicle
ligation may proceed as described for routine
Pyometra Spay
canine ovariohysterectomy. Generally, ligation
of the uterine body with a modified Miller’s Ovariohysterectomy is the surgical treat
knot placed near the cervix with the ligature ment for either open or closed pyometra
incorporating the uterine vessels on both sides (Hedlund 2007; MacPhail 2013). The patient
Special Situations in Ovariohysterectomy 257
with a pyometra, especially one with a closed the abdomen should be flushed with sterile
pyometra, may present with dehydration, saline as well. Prior to closure of the abdomen,
azotemia, and acid–base imbalances. These the sterile towels should be removed and gloves
should be corrected prior to surgery, but with and instruments should be changed.
out delaying surgery for more than a few hours
after diagnosis.
Uterus Unicornis
The surgical technique for ovariohysterec
tomy in the patient with a pyometra is similar Uterus unicornis is congenital absence of one
to that of the pregnant animal. The incision horn of the uterus, and may occur in both cats
will need to be larger than usual in order to and dogs (see Chapter 2). The broad ligament
avoid damage to the uterus during exterioriza and uterine vessels may be present or absent
tion. Uterine tissue may be friable and care on the involved side, but both ovaries will be
must be taken to prevent tearing the uterus. present in the normal location (Figure 12.10).
The uterus should be identified visually and Often the first indications that a patient may
gently elevated out of the abdominal cavity. have a unicornate uterus are either a difficulty
Use of a spay hook should be avoided due to in locating the horn of the uterus with the spay
the risk of tearing friable uterine tissue. If a hook on the first side, or a difficulty in reach
uterine torsion is present, do not attempt to ing the uterine horn bifurcation at the uterine
relieve the torsion, as this could lead to a body to access the second horn. In either case,
greater chance of the systemic release of bacte utilize the spay hook on the second side. In the
ria or bacterial toxins. case of the difficult‐to‐exteriorize uterine body,
Ligation of the ovarian pedicles can be per using the spay hook on the second side will
formed as described for routine ovariohyster allow the surgeon to find the second uterine
ectomy, using a pedicle tie in cats or a modified
Miller’s knot in dogs. Special attention should
be paid to hemostasis. Large vessels in the
broad ligament can be ligated either with
suture or with the pedicle tie.
In patients (especially dogs) with large or sig
nificant pyometra, prior to ligating and transect
ing the uterine body, sterile towels should be
packed around the uterus to protect the abdomi
nal cavity from contamination. Leakage of uter
ine contents can be minimized by placing a
ligature at the junction of the uterine body and
the cervix and occluding the uterine body with a
Carmalt, then transecting between the ligature
and the Carmalt. Alternatively, a ligature can be
placed at the junction of the uterine body and the
cervix and a second ligature on the uterine body,
transecting between the two ligatures. Also, if
necessary, the uterine vessels can be ligated
independently. With either approach, the uter
ine stump should be flushed with sterile saline Figure 12.10 Uterus unicornis. The left ovary is
located at the most cranial aspect of the left uterine
prior to returning it to the abdomen. Oversewing
horn. There is no right uterine horn, but the right
the stump is not recommended. If peritonitis is ovary is present (arrow). Source: Photo courtesy of
present or if abdominal contamination occurs, Julie Levy.
258 12 Dog Spay/Cat Spay
horn (if present) or the broad ligament (if the more fetuses (Uçmak et al. 2018). The pro
uterus is unicornate). lapsed uterine tissue may be ischemic or
The ovary on the involved side will be in the necrotic, depending on the duration of the pro
normal location and, if a broad ligament is pre lapse (Biddle and Macintire 2000). The pro
sent, simply trace the broad ligament cranially lapsed portion of the uterus should be palpated
until the ovary is encountered. If no broad liga to assess for the presence within it of addi
ment is present on the involved side, extend tional abdominal contents such as the urinary
the incision and use the biologic retractors to bladder or abdominal viscera (Deroy et al.
help localize the ovary. Grasping the descend 2015), particularly if amputation of the pro
ing duodenum and reflecting it to the left will lapsed tissue is being considered. If abdominal
expose the right side, allowing visualization of contents are present within the prolapsed
the right ovary. Grasping the descending colon uterus, open abdominal reduction will likely
and reflecting it to the right will expose the left be necessary to return these organs to the
side, allowing visualization of the left ovary. It abdomen prior to ovariohysterectomy or pro
should be noted that the kidney is often absent lapse amputation.
on the same side as the missing uterine horn. The patient should be assessed and stabi
lized. Patients with acute uterine prolapse may
be depressed, dehydrated, and in pain, may be
Uterine Prolapse
hyper‐ or hypothermic, and may appear to
Spay–neuter clinics and shelter clinics may be have difficulty urinating (Deroy et al. 2015;
presented with animals with uterine prolapse Sabuncu et al. 2017). If the uterine or ovarian
for “routine” spay or on an emergency basis artery was torn during the prolapse, hemor
(Figure 12.11). Uterine prolapse is rare, and rhage may have occurred and the patient may
occurs more frequently in cats than in dogs be hypovolemic or hypotensive and may
(Biddle and Macintire 2000). In most cases the require fluid support or transfusion (Biddle
prolapse occurs during delivery or miscar and Macintire 2000). In cases in which the
riage, or within the first 48 hours after delivery, uterus has been prolapsed for a more extended
although one case report describes prolapse duration, the patient may be bright and alert
three days after delivery (Sabuncu et al. 2017), with a normal appetite and no apparent dis
and another describes prolapse in a stray cat in tress resulting from the prolapse (Valentine
whom no pregnancy or delivery had been et al. 2016).
observed (Valentine et al. 2016). Some HQHVSN Antibiotic therapy should be initiated at or
veterinarians have described having cats with a before the time of surgery and continued dur
uterine prolapse of unknown duration and ing the post‐operative period.
cause present via TNR programs. While uterine
prolapse is considered an obstetric emergency Manual Reduction and Ovariohysterectomy
(Biddle and Macintire 2000), some HQHVSN If the uterus is not severely damaged, contami
veterinarians have encountered cases in which nated, or necrotic, the prolapsed tissue may be
the duration of the prolapse was known to have reduced, and a routine ovariohysterectomy can
been from a few days to up to a year. then be performed (Figure 12.12a and b).
General anesthesia with or without epidural
Assessment analgesia (see the anesthesia supplement to
Uterine prolapse may consist of one uterine Chapter 19) will be required to replace the
horn (Sabuncu et al. 2017) or both horns, and uterus. The prolapsed uterus should be cleaned
may be complete or partial. If the prolapse is thoroughly with an antiseptic solution and
partial and recent, it is possible that the non‐ lubricated prior to attempting reduction. It
prolapsed portion of the uterus contains one or may also be helpful to soak the tissue in a
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 12.11 Uterine prolapse in a cat. (a) A feral cat with unknown history presented with a uterine
prolapse. The cat was anesthetized, clipped, and surgically prepared from the vulva to the sternum. (b) An
abdominal incision was made and the ovaries and ovarian pedicles were identified. On both sides, the
suspensory ligament, pedicle, and broad ligament were each ligated using the pedicle tie technique and
were transected. The tips of the uterine horns were released into the abdomen. (c) Surgery then proceeded
to the prolapsed uterus. The surgeon cut along the top side of the bifurcation until the uterus could be
turned inside out to access the uterine arteries. A stick tie (transfixing ligature) was placed on each uterine
artery. (d) The uterine body was amputated and the uterine vessels transected distal to the ligatures. A
hemostat was introduced through the abdominal incision and out of the vaginal opening to grasp the
uterine stump. (e) The uterine stump was inverted and returned to the abdomen. (f) The uterine stump was
double-ligated using Miller’s knots. The abdomen was lavaged. Because the cat was feral and would receive
no follow-up care, an incisional vaginopexy was performed to attach the uterine stump to the abdominal
wall. The patient recovered well. Source: Photos courtesy of Brienne LeMay.
(e) (f)
(a) (b)
Figure 12.12 (a) This dog presented with a prolapse of a gravid uterine horn and the bladder, along with
vaginal hyperplasia. The fetus was removed from the prolapsed horn and the bladder and uterine horn
were returned to the abdomen, followed by a routine spay procedure. (b) The same dog during her recovery.
The vaginal prolapse resolved after ovariohysterectomy without further surgical intervention (see
Chapter 21 for more on treating this condition). Source: Photos courtesy of Patti Canchola.
Special Situations in Ovariohysterectomy 261
hyperosmotic solution such as 50% dextrose to in many cases the tissue will be in poor condi
attempt to reduce the size of the edematous tis tion, such that identification of the urethral
sue before reduction. Episiotomy may also be meatus is not possible. In these cases, perform
helpful in reducing the prolapsed uterus ing the amputation on the uterine body,
(Biddle and Macintire 2000). between the bifurcation and the cervix, will
Once the uterus is reduced into the ensure that the urethra is not damaged in the
abdomen, it is possible to perform a routine amputation.
ovariohysterectomy. If reduction of the uterus To perform external amputation of the pro
is not possible, prolapse amputation (external lapsed uterus, the uterine body may either be
hysterectomy) and ovariectomy are indicated. ligated en bloc with a circumferential suture or
modified Miller’s knot, or may be opened to
Ovariectomy and Prolapse Amputation allow individual uterine vessel ligation prior to
In cases in which the prolapsed uterine tissue amputation (see Figure 12.11c). The prolapsed
is too damaged, necrotic, or edematous to uterine tissue distal to the ligature(s) should be
return to the abdomen, it is possible to perform removed, and the remaining stump should be
an ovariectomy and amputate the prolapsed inverted and returned to the abdomen.
uterus (see Figure 12.11). The abdominal ova Oversewing of the stump prior to reduction
riectomy (or pedicle ligation without ovariec (Deroy et al. 2015) should be unnecessary, as
tomy) should be performed first, followed by additional transection and ligation may take
external amputation of the uterus and reduc place during the abdominal portion of the sur
tion of the uterine stump while the abdomen gery after reduction of the stump.
remains open (Deroy et al. 2015; Valentine Once the uterine stump is returned to the
et al. 2016). abdominal cavity, the surgery can be
When pedicle ligation (with or without ova approached abdominally. From within the
riectomy) is performed prior to uterine ampu abdominal cavity, the uterine body is ligated
tation and stump reduction, there is caudal proximal to any previously placed ligature. If
traction on the ovaries due to the stretching tissue is friable or engorged, individual uterine
resulting from the prolapsed tissues. Thus, the vessel ligation may be indicated, if it has not
ovaries are located more caudally than usual already been performed. If an en bloc ligation
and there is tension and elongation of the sus was performed when the uterus was external,
pensory ligament and ovarian vessels (Deroy the excess uterine stump including the previ
et al. 2015). However, a routine ovariectomy ous ligation is then removed (Valentine et al.
consisting of pedicle ties (in cats) or modified 2016). As with pyometra, oversewing the stump
Miller’s knots (in dogs) on the ovarian vessels is not recommended, but warm saline lavage of
and suture ligation of the uterine vessels the uterine stump and abdomen is beneficial to
should still be possible in these cases. Following reduce contamination prior to closing.
pedicle ligation with or without ovariectomy, Post‐operatively, urination should be moni
the tips of the uterine horns are released back tored, as swelling and pain can lead to urethral
into the abdomen. obstruction (Deroy et al. 2015).
When performing external amputation of
the prolapsed uterus, the surgeon should
Intersex Surgery
ensure that the urethral opening is not dam
aged, removed, or ligated during the amputa At times, patients who have both male and
tion. If the prolapsed tissue is not too damaged, female characteristics will present for surgery
it may be possible to identify the urethral (see Chapter 2). While numerous variations of
tubercle and preserve it. Urethral catheteriza intersex phenotypes exist, the goal of the spay–
tion may be beneficial in these cases. However, neuter veterinarian in any case is to remove
262 12 Dog Spay/Cat Spay
(a) (b)
Figure 12.13 Intersex. (a) This patient presented as a female with an enlarged clitoris. (b) Ovatestes
associated with a normal-appearing uterus.
the gonads, and generally to remove the tubu Goethem et al. 2006). The Association of
lar structures associated with them. The Shelter Veterinarians’ spay neuter guidelines
gonads can be located anywhere between the recognize both ovariohysterectomy and ova
caudal pole of the kidneys to the inguinal area riectomy as acceptable techniques and simply
to the subcutaneous tissue in the perineum state that “complete removal of both ovaries is
(Figure 12.13). required” (Griffin et al. 2016).
A fairly common intersex presentation is While some papers contend that ovariec
that of a female with an enlarged clitoris tomy is quicker than ovariohysterectomy (van
(Figure 12.13a). In this presentation, the ingui Goethem et al. 2006), others document that the
nal and perineal area should be palpated care two techniques are similar in length of time,
fully for the presence of gonads. If the gonads length of incisions, and incidence of complica
are in the perineum, the surgery is performed tions (Peeters and Kirpensteijn 2011). In these
as a castration. If no gonads are palpated in the authors’ experience, ovariectomy involves an
perineal or inguinal area, the surgery is per incision in the same location and of the same
formed as an ovariohysterectomy, as described length as that in an ovariohysterectomy and
previously (Bushby 2013). the two procedures take essentially the same
amount of time. Some surgeons find ovario
hysterectomy to be faster than ovariectomy
Alternatives to due to the necessity for an additional ligature
during ovariectomy.
Ovariohysterectomy
The surgical approaches for ovariectomy
are the same as for ovariohysterectomy
Ovariectomy
(Figure 12.14). Ovariectomy can be performed
Ovariectomy has been described as an accept through a ventral midline, right paramedian,
able alternative to ovariohysterectomy (DeTora or flank approach. Exteriorize the first uter
and McCarthy 2011; Peeters and Kirpensteijn ine horn and ovary and tear or cut the ovarian
2011). In many European countries ovariec suspensory ligament. In the dog, clamp, tran
tomy is considered the preferred method for sect, and ligate the ovarian pedicle, as
surgical sterilization of the female dog, while described prevoiusly for canine ovariohyster
ovariohysterectomy remains the more com ectomy. In the cat, perform the pedicle tie on
mon technique in the United States (van the ovarian pedicle, as described prevoiusly
Alternatives to Ovariohysterectomy 263
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 12.14 Ovariectomy. (a) Place two clamps proximal to the ovary on the ovarian pedicle and one
clamp distal to the ovary, between the ovary and the uterine horn. (b) Transect the ovarian pedicle proximal
to the ovary and ligate the ovarian pedicle. (c) Ligate the distal end of the uterine horn and uterine vessels
and excise the ovary. Source: Photos courtesy of Tom Thompson.
for feline ovariohysterectomy. Next, place one Once both ovaries are removed, the uterine
hemostat or Carmalt on the proper ligament horns with their intact broad ligaments
between the ovary and uterine horn. Place a are returned to the abdominal cavity and the
ligature on the distal‐most aspect of the uter surgical wounds are closed, just as in the
ine horn, proximal to the clamp, and transect ovariohysterectomy.
between the ovary and the clamp on the uter
ine horn, thereby removing the first ovary. In
Ovary-Sparing “Spay”
most cases, in order to ensure that the entire
ovary and fallopian tube is removed, a small Hysterectomy without ovariectomy (ovary‐
portion of the tip of the uterine horn is sparing spay) has been promoted as a means to
removed as well. sterilize dogs while leaving reproductive hor
Trace the first uterine horn to the uterine mones intact (Lissner 2013). There appears to
body to identify the second uterine horn and be little interest in this option for cats, probably
trace that second horn to the second ovary. due to the relative lack of data related to
The second ovary is removed and hemostasis adverse health consequences of ovary removal
obtained in a manner identical to the first in cats (see Chapter 26).
ovary. The broad ligaments should not be In order to avoid the risk of “stump pyome
incised and the uterine vessels should not be tra,” all uterine tissue must be removed.
ligated. Ligation and transection of the uterus at or
264 12 Dog Spay/Cat Spay
proximal to the cervix are required (Mattravers same disease risks and benefits as unaltered
2017), necessitating a longer incision and dogs, except for the risks of pyometra and pos
longer surgery time than required for the typi sible complications of pregnancy, which are
cal spay. Tying off the fallopian tubes (tubal eliminated by hysterectomy.
ligation) while leaving the uterus in place Dogs who have undergone this procedure will
leaves the dog at the same risk of pyometra as still experience estrus cycles and demonstrate
if she had not been spayed, and thus is not sug the same behaviors as intact females, a fact for
gested as a technique for ovary‐sparing spay. which pet owners must be prepared. At this
Hysterectomy may be an acceptable alterna time, hysterectomy without ovariectomy has
tive to ovariohysterectomy for pet owners who not been recommended as a technique in
oppose the removal of the ovaries, but do not shelter or HQHVSN practice, due to its failure
wish for their pets to reproduce. Female dogs to have achieved widespread awareness and
with hysterectomy are presumed to have the acceptance among veterinarians or pet owners.
References
Biddle, D. and Macintire, D.K. (2000). Obstetrical Internal Medicine, 6e (ed. J.R. August),
emergencies. Clin. Tech. Small Anim. Pract. 776–792. St. Louis, MO: Elsevier Saunders.
15: 88–93. Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al.
Bohling, M.W., Ridgon‐Brestle, Y.K., Bushby, (2016). The Association of Shelter
P.A., and Griffin, B. (2010). Veterinary Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical care
seminars in spay‐neuter surgeries: pediatrics. guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. JAVMA
In: Veterinary Seminars in Spay‐Neuter (ed. 249: 165–188.
R.‐B.Y. Karla). Asheville, NC: Humane Hedlund, C.S. (2007). Surgery of the
Alliance (DVD). reproductive and genital systems. In: Small
Bushby, P.A. (2013). Surgical techniques for spay/ Animal Surgery, 3e (ed. T.W. Fossum),
neuter. In: Shelter Medicine for Veterinarians 702–720. St. Louis, MO: Mosby Elsevier.
and Staff, 2e (eds. L. Miller and Z. Stephen), Levy, J.K. and Wilford, C.L. (2013).
625–646. Ames, IA: Wiley‐Blackwell. Management of stray and feral community
Deroy, C., Bismuth, C., and Carozzo, C. (2015). cats. In: Shelter Medicine for Veterinarians
Management of a complete uterine prolapse and Staff, 2e (ed. S.Z. Lila Miller), 669–688.
in a cat. J. Feline Med. Surg. Open Rep. 1: Ames, IA: Wiley‐Blackwell.
2055116915579681. Lissner, E. (2013). The pros of partial spay.
DeTora, M. and McCarthy, R.J. (2011). Innovative Veterinary Care (13 February).
Ovariohysterectomy versus ovariectomy for https://ivcjournal.com/the‐pros‐of‐partial‐spay
elective sterilization of female dogs and cats: (accessed 5 August 2018).
is removal of the uterus necessary? JAVMA MacPhail, C.M. (2013). Surgery of the
239: 1409–1412. reproductive and genital systems. In: Small
van Goethem, B., Schaefers‐Okkens, A., and Animal Surgery, 4e (ed. T.W. Fossum),
Kirpensteijn, J. (2006). Making a rational 780–855. St. Louis, MO: Mosby.
choice between ovariectomy and Mattravers, M. (2017). Ovary sparing spay in
ovariohysterectomy in the dog: a discussion of canines: an alternative to traditional
the benefits of either technique. Vet. Surg. 35: ovariohysterectomy. https://www.parsemus.
136–143. org/wp‐content/uploads/2017/09/Ovary‐
Griffin, B. and Bohling, M. (2010). A review of Sparing‐Spay‐review‐Mattravers‐2017.pdf
neutering cats. In: Consultations in Feline (accessed 5 August 2018).
References 265
McGrath, H., Hardie, R., and Davis, E. (2004). of square and Aberdeen termination knots
Lateral flank approach for ovariohysterectomy tied with 4–0 polyglyconate and used for
in small animals. Compend. Cont. Educ. Pract. termination of intradermal closures in canine
Vet. 26: 922–931. cadavers. JAVMA 247: 260–266.
Miller, K.P., Rekers, W., Ellis, K. et al. (2016). Sabuncu, A., Dal, G.E., Enginler, S.Ö. et al.
Pedicle ties provide a rapid and safe method (2017). Feline unilateral uterine prolapse: a
for feline ovariohysterectomy. J. Feline Med. description of two cases. İstanbul Üniv. Vet.
Surg. 18: 160–164. Fak. Derg. 43: 67–70.
Peeters, M.E. and Kirpensteijn, J. (2011). Schaaf, O., Glyde, M., and Day, R.E. (2009). A
Comparison of surgical variables and short‐ secure Aberdeen knot: in vitro assessment of
term postoperative complications in healthy knot security in plasma and fat. J. Small Anim.
dogs undergoing ovariohysterectomy or Pract. 50: 415–421.
ovariectomy. JAVMA 238: 189–194. Stott, P.M., Ripley, L.G., and Lavelle, M.A.
Porters, N., Polis, I., Moons, C. et al. (2014). (2007). The ultimate Aberdeen knot. Ann.
Prepubertal gonadectomy in cats: different Royal Coll. Surg. Engl. 89: 713–717.
surgical techniques and comparison with Thomas, J.A. and Saleeby, E.R. (2012). The
gonadectomy at traditional age. Vet. Rec. Aberdeen knot: a sliding knot for
175 (9): 223. dermatology. Dermatol. Surg. 38: 121–123.
Reece, J. (2018). Ovariohysterectomy–flank Uçmak, Z.G., Uçmak, M., Çetin, A.C., and Tek,
approach. In: Field Manual for Small Animal Ç. (2018). Uterine prolapse in a pregnant cat.
Medicine (eds. K. Polak and A.T. Kommedal). Turk. J. Vet. Anim. Sci. 42: 500–502.
Chichester: Wiley https://doi. Valentine, M.J., Porter, S., Chapwanya, A., and
org/10.1002/9781119380528.ch9b. Callanan, J.J. (2016). Uterine prolapse with
Reece, J., Nimesh, M., Wyllie, R. et al. (2012). endometrial eversion in association with an
Description and evaluation of a right flank, unusual diffuse, polypoid, fibrosing
mini‐laparotomy approach to canine perimetritis and parametritis in a cat. J. Feline
ovariohysterectomy. Vet. Rec. 171: 248. Med. Surg. Open Rep. 2: 2055116915626166.
Regier, P.J., Smeak, D.D., Coleman, K., and White, S.C. (2012). Prevention of fetal suffering
McGilvray, K.C. (2015). Comparison of during ovariohysterectomy of pregnant
volume, security, and biomechanical strength animals. JAVMA 240: 1160.
267
13
Cesarean Section
Sheilah Robertson and Sara White
In a shelter or high‐quality high‐volume spay– should receive fluids and dehydration should
neuter (HQHVSN) clinic setting, the goal of a be corrected before induction.
cesarean section (C‐section) may be to save the
life of the dam, the offspring, or both, and in
Maternal Considerations
most cases the bitch or queen will also undergo
an ovariohysterectomy. The surgical technique Aortocaval compression in the supine position
may be a “traditional” C‐section in which leading to maternal hypotension and fetal
delivery of the puppies or kittens by hysterot‑ depression is well documented in pregnant
omy precedes ovariohysterectomy, or be may women (Kinsella and Lohmann 1994). In
accomplished by an en bloc C‐section tech‑ dogs this may be less of a problem due to their
nique. In the latter, ovariohysterectomy is per‑ bicornuate uterus; pregnant Beagles and
formed before hysterotomy and removal of the Golden Retriever bitches remained normoten‑
neonates (Robbins and Mullen 1994). sive in both dorsal and lateral recumbency
Ovariohysterectomy at the time of C‐section (Probst et al. 1987; Probst and Webb 1983).
does not affect lactation or the dam’s ability to However, many C‐sections are performed on
care for her litter (Onclin and Verstegen 2008). large or giant breed bitches (Moon et al. 1998),
therefore the impact of dorsal positioning for a
specific case scenario is unpredictable. A sen‑
Anesthetic Considerations sible approach is to do as much of the pre‐inci‑
sional preparation as possible and place the
Anesthetic choices and peri‐operative man‑ bitch or queen in dorsal recumbency immedi‑
agement require careful consideration to ately before draping for surgery. Clipping and
achieve the chosen goal. Over half of canine preparing the surgical site prior to induction
C‐sections are emergency procedures (Moon of anesthesia decreases the time between
et al. 2000), resulting in higher puppy mortal‑ induction and delivery of the offspring; during
ity compared to an elective intervention. this time fluids and oxygen (see later) can be
When labor is prolonged, dehydration, hypov‑ administered.
olemia, sepsis, stress, exhaustion, and hypoc‑ The physiologic changes associated with
alcemia may be present, leading to worse pregnancy influence the choice of anesthetic
outcomes. Elective procedures should be con‑ and analgesic drugs for C‐section in queens and
sidered in some dogs such as brachycephalic bitches. Although there is more information
breeds. All animals undergoing a C‐section available on anesthetic protocols for C‐section
268 13 Cesarean Section
Many animals undergoing C‐section are alone followed by isoflurane; time to recovery
dehydrated and, even in elective situations, and suckling was significantly quicker when
fluid losses can be large. Therefore, intrave‑ isoflurane was used for maintenance (Conde
nous fluids are recommended and should be Ruiz et al. 2016). There is a lack of published
started prior to induction of anesthesia. information on kitten vitality after cesarean
There is some controversy regarding the delivery.
use of peri‐operative non‐steroidal anti‐
inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) in dams under‑
going surgery due to potential negative effects Anesthetic Protocols
(e.g. renal development) in the offspring. for Cesarean Section
Only a small percentage of the dam’s dose of
NSAID is secreted in milk and a single post‐ Different protocols for elective and emergency
operative dose is regarded as a suitable com‑ C‐section in dogs and cats based on differences
promise. NSAIDs should not be given in the on drug availability are given in detail in the
face of hypovolemia and hypotension; it may World Small Animal Veterinary Association’s
not be possible to correct all fluid deficits Global Pain Council Treatise on the recogni‑
prior to surgery and blood loss and hypoten‑ tion, assessment, and treatment of pain,
sion may occur during surgery. For these rea‑ released in 2014 (Mathews et al. 2014). An
sons, if NSAIDs are used they should be given example of an anesthetic protocol for a C‐sec‑
post‐operatively when these issues have been tion in a non‐compromised dog or cat is given
addressed. below. In this case the procedure may be
planned or intervention occurs early before
Neonatal Vitality any physiologic deterioration occurs.
many hemostats will be required both on the (Figure 13.4). Next, the broad ligaments are
dam and for each umbilical cord. It is recom‑ broken down or cut on both sides of the uterus
mended that several surgery packs be made from the ovarian pedicles to the cervix. This
available for use during the surgery, or that leaves the blood supply to the uterus and
additional sterilized surgical instruments are fetuses intact, but removes all uterine attach‑
available. Laparotomy sponges and sterile iso‑ ments except for the ovarian pedicles and uter‑
tonic fluid for lavage are also recommended ine body (Mullen 2014).
supplies for either surgical technique. Before proceeding with hemostat place‑
ment and ovariohysterectomy, the surgeon
should palpate the cervix and vagina to
Surgical Approach
locate any fetus that is lodged there and
Regardless of the technique chosen, the initial manipulate it back into the uterine body
approach to the abdomen is the same. A ven‑ (Mullen 2014).
tral midline incision is made extending from The goal now is to perform an ovariohys‑
near the umbilicus to the pubis. Since the linea terectomy as rapidly as possible in order to
alba is often stretched thin and the abdomen minimize fetal hypoxia (Von Heimendahl
distended, the surgeon must be careful not to and Cariou 2009), with a maximum time of
traumatize the uterus or other underlying 45–60 seconds between clamping the blood
organs when entering the abdomen (Gilson supply and delivery of the neonates. In the
2015). The uterus is carefully exteriorized, dog, two hemostats are placed on each ovar‑
extending the abdominal wall incision if ian pedicle, and three large hemostats
needed to exteriorize the uterus without tear‑ (such as Carmalts) are placed across the uter‑
ing, stretching, or otherwise traumatizing the ine body immediately distal to the cervix.
uterus. The incision is packed with moistened The pedicles and uterine body are divided
laparotomy sponges, and the uterine horns are between the hemostats, leaving one hemostat
laid out laterally to the incision (Mullen 2014; on each ovarian pedicle and two hemostats
Gilson 2015; Figure 13.3). on the uterine body. The gravid uterus is
handed to a team of assistants, who open the
En Bloc Resection uterus and begin resuscitation (see the subse‑
quent section on neonatal resuscitation;
Once the uterus has been exteriorized, the Mullen 2014). The ovarian pedicles and uter‑
suspensory ligaments should be cut or broken, ine stump are ligated according to the sur‑
but no clamps should be applied at this time geon’s preference; modified Miller’s knots
are recommended.
In the cat, the same technique is acceptable,
as is pedicle tie autoligation as described in
Chapter 12 (Miller et al. 2016). To use autoliga‑
tion during en bloc resection, the surgeon
places a clamp between the ovary and the
uterus (encompassing the proper ligament and
uterine vessel) on the first horn and completes
the pedicle tie on the first side, then clamps
between the ovary and the uterus on the second
side and completes the second pedicle tie. Once
both pedicle ties are completed, three clamps
are placed on the uterine body and the uterus is
Figure 13.3 The uterus is carefully exteriorized in divided between the distal two clamps and
preparation for a cesarean section. handed to the resuscitation team. The surgeon
Surgical Techniques 273
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 13.4 En bloc cesarean section. (a) The gravid uterus and ovaries are exteriorized and laid out
laterally to the abdominal incision and (b) the suspensory ligaments are broken down and the broad
ligament is divided. (c) The gravid uterus can be removed in 45–60 seconds by placing first two hemostats
on each ovarian pedicle and then three clamps on the uterine body and transecting between them as
shown. Source: Reprinted with permission from Bojrab: Current Techniques in Small Animal Surgery 5th
edition, Copyright 2014, Teton NewMedia, Inc., Jackson, Wyoming.
then ligates the uterine stump using a modi‑ Once the ovariohysterectomy is completed,
fied Miller’s knot. the abdomen is closed routinely as described in
When the resuscitation team receives the Chapter 12. Intradermal closure is recom‑
gravid uterus, it should immediately open mended to prevent neonates causing trauma to
the uterus with scissors or a scalpel blade, themselves or to the incision. The skin and nip‑
being careful to avoid cutting a fetus. The ples of the ventral abdomen should be cleaned
neonates should be removed rapidly and using antiseptic agents (Von Heimendahl and
resuscitated, ideally with one assistant per Cariou 2009), rinsed, and gently dried.
neonate (Mullen 2014). Each umbilical cord
should be clamped and cut approximately
“Traditional” Cesarean Section and Spay
2 cm from the umbilicus and resuscitation
begun (see the neonatal resuscitation section The exteriorized uterus is isolated from the
later in this chapter; Von Heimendahl and abdomen with moistened laparotomy sponges
Cariou 2009). to minimize contamination with fetal fluids
274 13 Cesarean Section
(a) (b)
Figure 13.6 Once the amniotic sac is opened, (a) the fetus is exteriorized and the umbilical vessels are
clamped 2–3 cm from the fetal abdominal wall using hemostats and (b) severed prior to handing off the
neonate.
If the dam is not to be spayed, the hysterot‑ 2–4 IU per cat (Von Heimendahl and Cariou
omy incision(s) must be closed. Closure can 2009). Beginning with the lower ends of these
consist of a single or double‐layer continuous dose ranges is recommended and is often suf‑
closure using 3‐0 or 4‐0 suture, even in canine ficient. Administration of oxytocin should
patients. Recommended suture patterns occur while the dam is anesthetized, as admin‑
include appositional patterns (Von Heimendahl istration in the awake animal and the subse‑
and Cariou 2009), inverting patterns such as quent uterine contraction can be painful.
Cushings or Lambert (Onclin and Verstegen Once the hysterotomy incisions are closed,
2008), or a two‐layer closure with an apposi‑ the uterus should be lavaged with warm
tional layer followed by an inverting layer saline or other isotonic fluids to remove fetal
(Gilson 2015). Regardless of pattern, closure fluids, blood clots, and other contaminants.
should pass through myometrium and submu‑ If the abdomen has been contaminated, it
cosa, but avoid penetrating the lumen. The should be lavaged copiously as well. Surgical
sutures should be tightened adequately to avoid gloves and instruments should be replaced if
leakage of uterine contents (Gilson 2015; contaminated (Von Heimendahl and Cariou
Onclin and Verstegen 2008). 2009). Once the lavage is complete, the abdo‑
If the uterus does not begin to involute dur‑ men may be closed routinely, as described in
ing closure or if hemorrhage is excessive, oxy‑ Chapter 12.
tocin may be injected. In dogs, 5–20 IU may be Intradermal closure is recommended to pre‑
given IM, or 0.5–1 IU may be injected directly vent neonates causing trauma to themselves or
into the uterine wall musculature (Gilson to the incision. The skin and nipples of the
2015). Alternatively, oxytocin may be given IV ventral abdomen should be cleaned using anti‑
at 1–5 IU per dog (Onclin and Verstegen 2008). septic agents (Von Heimendahl and Cariou
In cats, IM oxytocin dose is approximately 2009), rinsed, and gently dried.
276 13 Cesarean Section
a finger in the mouth) and they should “root,” Despite the fact that acidosis and elevated
meaning that when you cup your hand over lactate levels may be present, the use of sodium
their muzzle they push. Rubbing over the lum‑ bicarbonate is not advised. It is hyperosmolar
bar area should evoke a squeal and squeezing and generates carbon dioxide, and if this is not
the toes results in a head “bob.” If these reflexes expired by an increase in ventilation, respira‑
are weak or absent, check for the presence of tory acidosis leading to cerebral acidosis occurs.
hypothermia and hypoglycemia (see later in Expected blood glucose values in neonates
the chapter). range from 2.2 to 3.3 mmol/l (40–60 mg/dl),
but they have low reserves. Measurement of
blood glucose is a challenge and many com‑
Drug Therapy mercial monitors are inaccurate (Cohn et al.
2000), therefore it may be prudent to give all
Epinephrine at a “low dose” (0.01–0.03 mg/kg) neonates that are slow to respond to resuscita‑
into the umbilical vein, via an endotracheal tive efforts a dose of dextrose. A 50% dextrose
tube or by the intraosseous route (via place‑ solution dropped under the tongue or into the
ment of a hypodermic needle in the proximal cheek pouch will be absorbed through the
humerus or femur), should be used if there is mucus membranes; other popular choices are
no heartbeat and there is no response to physi‑ corn syrup and dextrose gels.
cal resuscitative efforts. The cause of brady A “treatment pyramid” is shown in
cardia in newborn puppies and kittens is Figure 13.7 to emphasize the importance of
primarily myocardial hypoxemia and hypo‑ each resuscitative technique.
thermia, therefore the use of anticholinergics Newborn puppy viability and short‐term
(atropine and glycopyrrolate) is not recom‑ survival prognosis can be predicted by per‑
mended as a first line of treatment. Neonates forming a physical examination and assigning
show little response to anticholinergic agents an Apgar score (Table 13.1) that has been mod‑
due to lack of vagal tone (Grundy 2006) and ified for puppies (Veronesi et al. 2009), but
this is compounded in the face of hypother‑ could also be applied to kittens. The Apgar
mia, which also inhibits the heart’s response to score is based on heart rate, respiratory rate,
atropine (Cookson and Dipalma 1955). response to a toe pinch, movement, and mucus
Naloxone (0.1 mg/kg, transmucosally, IV, via membrane color. Assigning an Apgar score to
an endotracheal tube, subcutaneously, IM, or each newborn will help identify those that
by the intraosseous route) should be adminis‑ need more attention. As soon as possible after
tered only if the puppies or kittens appear the dam’s recovery, the pups or kittens must be
depressed and the bitch or queen received placed with her so that maternal bonding can
intraoperative opioids prior to delivery. The occur and colostrum be consumed.
use of doxapram is controversial and its effi‑
cacy is not well established in human neonates
(Henderson‐Smart and Steer 2004). There are Neonatal Resuscitation Supplies
no placebo‐controlled reports of its efficacy in
Figure 13.8 shows a neonatal resuscitation cart
puppies and kittens in the veterinary litera‑
ready for use.
ture. Doxapram is thought to be a central stim‑
Supplies include:
ulant and its efficacy is profoundly diminished
when the brain is already hypoxic (Bamford ●● Warming equipment
et al. 1986). Given this information, doxapram –– Forced warm air
is unlikely to be of much benefit in the apneic, –– Heated mat
hypoxic newborn and its routine use to stimu‑ –– Hair dryer
late respiration is not recommended. ●● Warm towels
278 13 Cesarean Section
OXYGEN
VENTILATION
MASK, INTUBATION
CHEST
COMPRESSION
DRUGS
RARELY NEEDED
Parameter 0 1 2
●● Bulb syringes
●● Cotton‐tipped swabs
●● Oxygen source and masks
●● Dextrose or corn syrup
●● Doppler and probe
●● Laryngoscope
●● IV catheters to use as endotracheal tubes
●● Size 1 and 2 endotracheal tubes
●● Insulin syringes
●● Drugs
–– Epinephrine, atropine, glycopyrrolate,
naloxone Figure 13.8 A neonatal resuscitation cart ready
for use.
References 279
References
Bamford, O.S., Dawes, G.S., Hanson, M.A., and infants. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. (4):
Ward, R.A. (1986). The effects of doxapram on CD000074.
breathing, heart rate and blood pressure in Horn, E.P., Bein, B., Steinfath, M. et al. (2014).
fetal lambs. Respir. Physiol. 66: 387–396. The incidence and prevention of hypothermia
Brodbelt, D.C., Pfeiffer, D.U., Young, L.E., and in newborn bonding after cesarean delivery: a
Wood, J.L. (2008). Results of the confidential randomized controlled trial. Anesth. Analg.
enquiry into perioperative small animal 118: 997–1002.
fatalities regarding risk factors for anesthetic‐ Horn, E.P., Schroeder, F., Gottschalk, A. et al.
related death in dogs. JAVMA 233: 1096–1104. (2002). Active warming during cesarean
Cohn, L.A., Mccaw, D.L., Tate, D.J., and Johnson, delivery. Anesth. Analg. 94: 409–414.
J.C. (2000). Assessment of five portable blood Kinsella, S.M. and Lohmann, G. (1994). Supine
glucose meters, a point‐of‐care analyzer, and hypotensive syndrome. Obstet. Gynecol. 83:
color test strips for measuring blood glucose 774–788.
concentration in dogs. JAVMA 216: 198–202. Luna, S.P., Cassu, R.N., Castro, G.B. et al. (2004).
Conde Ruiz, C., Del Carro, A.P., Rosset, E. et al. Effects of four anaesthetic protocols on the
(2016). Alfaxalone for total intravenous neurological and cardiorespiratory variables
anaesthesia in bitches undergoing elective of puppies born by caesarean section. Vet. Rec.
caesarean section and its effects on puppies: a 154: 387–389.
randomized clinical trial. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. Mathews, K., Kronen, P.W., Lascelles, D. et al.
43: 281–290. (2014). Guidelines for recognition,
Cookson, B.A. and Dipalma, J.R. (1955). Severe assessment and treatment of pain: WSAVA
bradycardia of profound hypothermia in the Global Pain Council members and co‐authors
dog. Am. J. Physiol. 182: 447–453. of this document. J. Small Anim. Pract. 55:
Doebeli, A., Michel, E., Bettschart, R. et al. E10–E68.
(2013). Apgar score after induction of Mcnally, E.M., Robertson, S.A., and Pablo, L.S.
anesthesia for canine cesarean section with (2009). Comparison of time to desaturation
alfaxalone versus propofol. Theriogenology 80: between preoxygenated and
850–854. nonpreoxygenated dogs following sedation
Gilson, S.D. (2015). Cesarean section. In: Small with acepromazine maleate and morphine
Animal Surgical Emergencies (ed. L.R. Aronson), and induction of anesthesia with propofol.
391–396. Chichester: Wiley‐Blackwell. Am. J. Vet. Res. 70: 1333–1338.
Goericke‐Pesch, S. and Wehrend, A. (2012). New Miller, K.P., Rekers, W., Ellis, K. et al. (2016).
method for removing mucus from the upper Pedicle ties provide a rapid and safe method
respiratory tract of newborn puppies following for feline ovariohysterectomy. J. Feline Med.
caesarean section. Vet. Rec. 170: 289. Surg. 18: 160–164.
Grundy, S.A. (2006). Clinically relevant Moon, P.F., Erb, H.N., Ludders, J.W. et al. (1998).
physiology of the neonate. Vet. Clin. North Perioperative management and mortality rates
Am. Small Anim. Pract. 36: 443–459. of dogs undergoing cesarean section in the
Grundy, S.A., Liu, S.M., and Davidson, A.P. United States and Canada. JAVMA 213:
(2009). Intracranial trauma in a dog due to 365–369.
being “swung” at birth. Top. Companion Moon, P.F., Erb, H.N., Ludders, J.W. et al. (2000).
Anim. Med. 24: 100–103. Perioperative risk factors for puppies delivered
Henderson‐Smart, D. and Steer, P. (2004). by cesarean section in the United States and
Doxapram treatment for apnea in preterm Canada. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 36: 359–368.
280 13 Cesarean Section
Moon, P.F., Massat, B.J., and Pascoe, P.J. (2001). pressure in large full‐term pregnant bitches
Neonatal critical care. Vet. Clin. North Am. during general anesthesia. Vet. Surg. 16:
Small Anim. Pract. 31: 343–365. 471–473.
Moon‐Massat, P.F. and Erb, H.N. (2002). Probst, C.W. and Webb, A.I. (1983). Postural
Perioperative factors associated with puppy influence on systemic blood pressure, gas
vigor after delivery by cesarean section. J. Am. exchange, and acid/base status in the term‐
Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 38: 90–96. pregnant bitch during general anesthesia. Am.
Mullen, H.S. (2014). Cesarean section by J. Vet. Res. 44: 1963–1965.
ovariohysterectomy. In: Current Techniques in Robbins, M.A. and Mullen, H.S. (1994). En bloc
Small Animal Surgery, 5e (eds. M.J. Bojrab, ovariohysterectomy as a treatment for dystocia
D.R. Waldron and J.P. Toombs), 527–528. in dogs and cats. Vet. Surg. 23: 48–52.
Jackson, WY: Teton NewMedia. Traas, A.M. (2008). Resuscitation of canine
Onclin, K.J. and Verstegen, J.P. (2008). Cesarean and feline neonates. Theriogenology 70:
section in the dog. Clinician’s Brief (May), 343–348.
pp. 72–78. Veronesi, M.C., Panzani, S., Faustini, M., and
Probst, C.W. and Bebchuk, T.N. (2014). Cesarean Rota, A. (2009). An Apgar scoring system for
section: traditional technique. In: Current routine assessment of newborn puppy
Techniques in Small Animal Surgery, 5e (eds. viability and short‐term survival prognosis.
M.J. Bojrab, D.R. Waldron and J.P. Toombs), Theriogenology 72: 401–407.
524–526. Jackson, WY: Teton NewMedia. Von Heimendahl, A. and Cariou, M. (2009).
Probst, C.W., Broadstone, R.V., and Evans, A.T. Normal parturition and management of
(1987). Postural influence on systemic blood dystocia in dogs and cats. In Pract. 31: 254.
281
14
surgeon’s preference. The spermatic cord can that dogs would self‐mutilate if castration was
be ligated with a single ligature tied with a performed through a scrotal incision. There is,
modified Miller’s knot (see Chapter 12) or with however, no published data that confirms a
a circumferential ligature combined with a greater incidence of self‐trauma with scrotal
transfixation ligature. The ligatures can be castration as compared to pre‐scrotal castra-
placed prior to transecting the cord or hemo- tion. In a recent study (Woodruff et al. 2015)
stats can be placed on the cord, the cord tran- the incidence of post‐operative complications
sected, and then the ligature(s) placed in the was compared between scrotal and pre‐scrotal
area(s) of the spermatic cord crushed by the castration techniques. There was no significant
hemostats. The second testicle is displaced for- difference in the incidence of post‐operative
ward into the surgical incision and excised in a swelling, hemorrhage, or pain between the two
manner identical to the first testicle. approaches. However, the incidence of self‐
trauma was significantly greater in dogs cas-
trated with the pre‐scrotal approach than dogs
Open Castration
castrated with a scrotal incision (Woodruff
Alternatively, to perform an open castration, et al. 2015).
continue the initial incision through the sper- Scrotal castration is becoming the accepted
matic fascia and the parietal vaginal tunics, technique for castration of adult dogs in
exposing the testicle. Placing upward tension many high‐volume spay–neuter clinics and
on the testicle allows maximum exterioriza- can be performed more quickly and through
tion of the testicle. The ductus deferens and smaller incisions than pre‐scrotal castrations
the pampiniform plexus are ligated separately. (Woodruff et al. 2015).
Some surgeons will then place a second liga-
ture encircling both structures. The ductus def-
Technique in the Adult Dog
erens and pampiniform plexus are transected.
The tunic is separated from the ligament of the To perform a scrotal castration, carefully clip
epididymis by placing a hemostat on the tunic the hair on the scrotum, avoiding razor burns,
and applying traction on the tunic. In an open and prepare the scrotum aseptically. Sterile
castration it might be necessary to ligate the drapes should be placed leaving only the scro-
tunic if hemorrhage is observed from the tunic. tum exposed. Grasp the first testicle in one
The second testicle is displaced forward into hand, elevating the testicle so it is pressed
the surgical incision and excised in a manner against the scrotal skin at the median raphe.
identical to the first testicle. Incise the skin along the median raphe over the
displaced testicle. Extend the incision through
the subcutaneous tissue and the spermatic fas-
Closure
cia to exteriorize the testicle. To perform a closed
Close the subcutaneous tissue with a simple castration, avoid incising the parietal vaginal
continuous pattern and the skin with a subcu- tunic. For an open castration, the incision is
ticular or intradermal pattern. extended through the parietal vaginal tunic, as
described for open pre‐scrotal castration. The
tunica albuginea of the testicle should not be
Scrotal Approach to Castration incised. Using gentle traction, exteriorize the
testicle while stripping fat and fascia away from
Scrotal castration in the canine patient was the spermatic cord using a gauze sponge.
first published in 1974 (Johnston and Archibald In larger dogs, greater than 18 kg, one of the
1974). Since then, however, scrotal castration authors (Bushby) recommends double ligation
has fallen out of favor because of the perception of the spermatic cord. In dogs under 18 kg, a
www.ajlobby.com
Pediatric Canine Scrotal Castration 283
single ligature with a modified Miller’s knot A recent study evaluated the use of scrotal
(see Chapter 12) is sufficient. To double‐ligate, castration with autoligation in puppies aged
place three hemostats on the spermatic cord 2–5 months and weighing 2–25 lb (0.9–11.4 kg;
and transect the cord distal to the third hemo- Miller et al. 2018). In this study, there were
stat. Place a ligature with a modified Miller’s no major complications and only 3.5% of the
knot in the crushed area of the most proximal puppies had minor complications, including
hemostat and a transfixation ligature in the peri‐incisional dermatitis, skin bruising, or
crushed area of the second hemostat. To sin- swelling. No puppies experienced intraopera-
gle‐ligate, place two hemostats on the sper- tive hemorrhage‐related complications. In
matic cord and transect distal to the second addition to the low complication rate, the
hemostat. Place a ligature with a modified study found that scrotal castration with autoli-
Miller’s knot in the crushed are of the most gation was over three times faster than pre‐
proximal hemostat (Figure 14.1). The sper- scrotal castration with suture ligation.
matic cord is then replaced into the scrotum To date there has been no published research
and the remaining hemostat removed. on the maximum size or age of puppy or the
Exteriorize the second testicle through the size of testicle or scrotum in which the autoli-
same scrotal incision by incising the spermatic gation technique is appropriate. Many sur-
fascia over the second testicle and stripping fat geons choose to use this technique in all
and fascia away from the spermatic cord. puppies whose testicles are similar in size or
Ligation and transection of the second sper- smaller than the testicles of an adult tomcat
matic cord are performed in an identical man- and whose scrotum is not yet pendulous. This
ner as the first (Bushby 2013). includes most puppies under four to five
months of age, and some small breeds of dog
up to about a year of age. Some veterinarians
Closure
use autoligation for castration of larger, mature
There is no common consensus on the best dogs as well (White 2018), but the outcomes of
method for closure of a scrotal castration. this technique in mature dogs have not been
Scrotal incisions can be closed completely with evaluated.
skin glue, closed partially with a single buried
subcutaneous suture, or left open to heal by
Technique
second intention (Bushby 2013). There are no
research studies to date that indicate an advan- The puppy is placed in dorsal recumbency. The
tage of one technique over the other. If the scrotum is clipped of hair and aseptically pre-
scrotal incision is left open or partially open, pared. The use of sterile drapes is considered
the patient’s owner/caretaker should be optional depending on the skill and comfort
advised to expect serosanguinous drainage for level of the surgeon (Griffin et al. 2016).
a couple of days after surgery and to take The first testicle is grasped between the sur-
appropriate precautions. geon’s thumb and index finger (Bushby &
Griffin 2011; see Figure 14.2). A scrotal incision
is made over the testicle, exteriorizing the testi-
Pediatric Canine Scrotal cle with digital pressure. The castration may be
Castration performed open or closed (Miller et al. 2018).
Gentle traction is applied to the testicle and
Scrotal castration with autoligation is the spermatic cord while stripping the fat and fascia
technique most commonly used in puppies, from the spermatic cord. A hemostat tie is
and is performed in a similar manner to feline performed just as in cats (described later) by
castration. passing the tip of the hemostat under the
www.ajlobby.com
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
(g) (h)
Figure 14.1 Adult dog scrotal castration. (a) Incise the scrotum on or near median raphe. (b) Exteriorize
the testicle. (c) Place three clamps. (d) Transect spermatic cord distal to clamps. (e) Ligate the cord with a
modified Miller’s knot. (f) A second modified Miller’s knot can be placed distal to the first. (g) A single buried
subcutaneous suture is used for closure. (h) Appearance of the scrotum after closure.
www.ajlobby.com
Pediatric Canine Scrotal Castration 285
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
Figure 14.2 Puppy scrotal castration. (a) Incise the scrotum on or near median raphe. (b) Exteriorize the
testicle. (c) Pull the testicle toward the surgeon. (d) Pass a curved hemostat over the spermatic cord and
position the curved tip under the spermatic cord. (e) Rotate the hemostat counterclockwise. (f) Continue to
rotate counterclockwise until the hemostat faces the surgeon. (g) Open hemostat and clamp spermatic cord.
(h) Transect the cord distal to the tip of the hemostat, leaving 4–5 mm cut end. (i) The cord has been
transected. (j) Slide the knot off the end of the hemostat, tighten, and check for hemorrhage before
returning the spermatic cord to the scrotum. (k) The cord has been returned to the scrotum. (l) Surgical glue
is applied to the scrotal skin.
www.ajlobby.com
286 14 Dog Neuter/Cat Neuter
(g) (h)
(i) (j)
(k) (l)
s permatic cord and rotating the tip around the untied and the knot is pushed off the end of the
cord. The jaws of the hemostat are opened as hemostat. The knot should then be pushed off
the distal (testicle) end of the cord is advanced of the tip of the hemostat and tightened to
around and into the hemostat jaws, and the jaws ensure its security. The second testicle is pushed
are then clamped. The cord is transected into the skin incision, and the same procedure is
between the clamp and the testicle with a scal- repeated. The incision is left open to heal by sec-
pel blade or scissors, leaving a tag of 4–5 mm in ond intention (Bushby & Griffin 2011), or is
length to ensure that the knot does not come closed with surgical glue.
www.ajlobby.com
Feline Castration 287
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 14.3 Feline castration. (a) Position the cat with rear legs pulled forward. (b) Incise the scrotum.
(c) Exteriorize the testicle. (d) Pull the testicle toward the surgeon. (e) Pass a curved hemostat over the
spermatic cord and position the curved tip under the spermatic cord. (f) Rotate the hemostat
counterclockwise until the hemostat faces the surgeon. (g) Open the hemostat and clamp the spermatic
cord. (h) Transect distal to the tip of the hemostat leaving 4–5 mm cut end. (i) Slide the knot off the end of
the hemostat, tighten, and check for hemorrhage before returning the spermatic cord to the scrotum.
www.ajlobby.com
288 14 Dog Neuter/Cat Neuter
(e) (f)
(g) (h)
(i)
around the end of a hemostat and then per- and the second spermatic cord is ligated and
forming the cord tie. The spermatic cord is transected in an identical manner as the first
transected distal to the hemostat, leaving a tag (Bushby 2013).
of 4–5 mm to ensure that the knot does not After both testicles have been removed,
come untied and the knot is pushed off the end the skin of the scrotum should be gently
of the hemostat. Before removing the hemo- elevated to make sure the ligated spermatic
stat, the knot is tightened. After releasing the cords recede into the scrotum. The scrotal
hemostat, the spermatic cord is checked for incision(s) are left to heal by second
hemorrhage. The second testicle is exteriorized intention.
www.ajlobby.com
Surgical Approach to Cryptorchidism 289
www.ajlobby.com
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
(g) (h)
Figure 14.5 Subcutaneous cryptorchid cat. (a) Digital palpation of the cat’s inguinal fat pad reveals a
palpable subcutaneous testicle. (b) The testicle is isolated and held in place with the fingers of the
non-dominant hand. (c) An incision is made through the overlying skin directly over the testicle. (d) Gentle
digital pressure is applied to exteriorize the testicle. (e) It is sometimes necessary to bluntly or sharply
dissect fat to reach the testicle at this stage. (f) The testicle is exteriorized to expose the spermatic cord.
(g) The cord may be ligated with suture or via autoligation. (h) The incision is closed subcuticularly with
absorbable suture. Source: Photos courtesy of Brenda Griffin.
www.ajlobby.com
Surgical Approach to Cryptorchidism 291
course toward the inguinal canal. This anatomic ous tissue is then undermined to expose the
feature is consistent whether the testicle(s) are linea alba, and the abdominal cavity is entered
descended into the scrotum or not and facilitates through an incision in the linea alba. The spay
location of the cryptorchid testicle, either by hook technique can be used on both sides of
catching the ductus deferens with a spay hook the bladder to exteriorize and excise both
or visualizing the ductus deferens as it cross the abdominal testicles.
ureter dorsal to the bladder (Boothe 1993). In either unilateral or bilateral cryptorchid
dogs, if the spay hook technique fails, extend
Canine Abdominal Cryptorchidism the abdominal incision to expose and exterior-
Once it is determined which testicle is cryp- ize the urinary bladder. Caudal reflection of the
torchid, a skin incision is made in the caudal urinary bladder will expose the dorsal surface
abdominal skin just lateral to the prepuce on of the bladder, allowing visualization of both
the side of the cryptorchid testicle about half- ductus deferens. Gentle retraction of the ductus
way along the prepuce, or around the area of of the cryptorchid testicle(s) will allow delivery
the last nipple (Bushby 2013; see Figure 14.6). of the testicle into the surgical site, ligation of
With a unilateral abdominal cryptorchid testi- the testicular vessels, and excision of the testi-
cle, the abdominal cavity is entered through a cle (see Figure 14.7). Because this option is
paramedian incision, incising the external rec- sometimes necessary, it is always advisable to
tus fascia and separating rectus abdominis empty the urinary bladder prior to starting sur-
muscle fibers on the appropriate side. Initially gery for the removal of an abdominal testicle.
a very small incision is made in the abdominal
wall and a spay hook is passed in a cranial‐lat- Feline Abdominal Cryptorchidism
eral direction, starting just lateral to the neck The technique for finding and excising the
of the bladder. Often this maneuver will catch abdominal testicle(s) in the cat is essentially the
the ductus deferens, allowing exteriorization same as that in the dog, except the skin incision
and excision of the testicle. is made in the caudal abdominal skin on the
With a bilateral abdominal cryptorchid, an midline, about halfway between the umbilicus
incision is made in the caudal abdominal skin and the pubis (Bushby 2013). Entry into the
just lateral to the prepuce, in the same location abdomen is through an incision in the linea
as for a unilateral cryptorchid. The subcutane- alba, allowing exposure of the urinary bladder.
Figure 14.6 Abdominal cryptorchid – spay hook technique. (a) In the dog, paramedian in caudal abdominal
skin adjacent to the prepuce. Enter the abdomen through a paramedian incision (unilateral abdominal
cryptorchid) or through a linea incision (bilateral abdominal cryptorchid). (b) Pass a spay hook into the
abdomen just lateral to the neck of the bladder. Sweep the spay hook in a cranial-lateral direction,
exteriorizing the ductus deferens. (c) Tension on the ductus deferens exteriorizes the testicle.
www.ajlobby.com
292 14 Dog Neuter/Cat Neuter
Figure 14.7 Abdominal cryptorchid – under bladder technique. (a) Exteriorize the bladder – reflecting the
bladder caudally. (b) Visualize both ductus deferens dorsal to the bladder. Apply gentle traction to the
ductus of the cryptorchid testicle. (c) Exteriorize the abdominal testicle.
As in the dog, using a spay hook and sweeping Cryptorchid testicles are, however, often
in a cranial‐lateral direction from the neck of smaller than normal and it is possible that the
the bladder will often catch the ductus defer- cryptorchid testicle is in the subcutaneous tis-
ens. If this fails, caudal reflection of the urinary sue, but not palpable. In this situation, surgi-
bladder to expose the dorsal surface of the blad- cally entering the abdomen with a presumptive
der will allow visualization of both ductus def- diagnosis of abdominal cryptorchidism will
erens. Gentle retraction of the ductus of the fail to reveal the cryptorchid testicle. Further,
cryptorchid testicle will allow delivery of the the technique described of gently teasing apart
testicle into the surgical site, ligation of the tes- the musculature of the internal inguinal ring
ticular vessels, and excision of the testicle. and applying tension to the ductus will fail to
deliver the testicle back into the abdomen.
At times, applying gentle traction on the
Failure to Find the “Abdominal” Testicle
abdominal ductus will produce visible move-
Failure to palpate a cryptorchid testicle in the ment or dimpling of the skin where the subcu-
subcutaneous tissue leads to a presumptive ticular testicle is located. In this case, the
diagnosis of abdominal cryptorchidism. The original skin incision may be extended or
testicle, however, can be located in the abdom- undermined, or an additional incision created
inal cavity, trapped between the musculature to reach the testicle.
of the inguinal canal, or located in the subcuta- If traction fails to reveal the location of the
neous tissue, but not palpable. When the testi- subcutaneous testicle, undermine the skin
cle is not found in the abdomen, gentle traction between the skin incision and the external
on the ductus deferens will allow visualization inguinal ring, extending the incision if neces-
of the ductus deferens entering the inguinal sary to allow visualization of the inguinal ring.
canal. A curved mosquito hemostat can be Gentle traction on the abdominal ductus will
used to gently tease the musculature of the allow the surgeon to locate the ductus deferens
internal inguinal ring apart, and if the testicle as it exits the inguinal canal and will lead to
is trapped in the inguinal canal, gentle traction the cryptorchid testicle.
on the ductus will allow delivery of the testicle Once the cryptorchid testicle is located, it
back into the abdomen for removal of the testi- can be excised using any standard technique,
cle as described under abdominal cryptorchid and the abdominal and skin incisions are
(Bushby 2013). closed routinely.
References 293
References
Bierbrier, L. and Causanschi, H. (2018). Hamilton, K., Henderson, E., Toscano, M., and
Orchiectomy and ovariohysterectomy. In: Chanoit, G. (2014). Comparison of
Field Manual for Small Animal Medicine (eds. postoperative complications in healthy dogs
K. Polak and A.T. Kommedal), 201–228. undergoing open and closed orchidectomy. J.
Hoboken, NJ: Wiley‐Blackwell. Small Anim. Pract. 55: 521–526.
Birchard, S.J. and Nappier, M. (2008). Hedlund, C.S. (2007). Surgery of the
Cryptorchidism. Compendium (Yardley, PA) reproductive and genital systems. In: Small
30: 325–336; quiz 336–7. Animal Surgery, 3e (ed. T.W. Fossum),
Boothe, H.W. (1993). Testes and Epididymides. 702–720. St. Louis, MO: Mosby Elsevier.
In: Textbook of Small Animal Surgery, 2e (eds. Howe, L.M. (2006). Surgical methods of
D. Slatter and E.A. Stone), 1325–1326. contraception and sterilization.
Philadephia, PA: Saunders. Theriogenology 66: 500–509.
Bushby, P.A. (2013). Surgical techniques for spay/ Johnston, D. and Archibald, J. (1974). Male
neuter. In: Shelter Medicine for Veterinarians Genital System. In: Canine Surgery, 2e (ed. J.
and Staff, 2e (eds. L. Miller and Z. Stephen), Archibald), 703–749. Santa Barbara, CA:
625–646. Ames, IA: Wiley‐Blackwell. American Veterinary Publications.
Bushby, P. and Griffin, B. (2011). Pediatric Kendall, T.R. (1979). Cat population control:
scrotal castration in a puppy. dvm360 (8 vasectomized dominat males. Calif. Vet. 33:
February). http://veterinarymedicine.dvm360. 9–12.
com/pediatric‐scrotal‐castration‐puppy MacPhail, C.M. (2013). Surgery of the
(accessed 18 August 2018). reproductive and genital systems. In: Small
Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al. (2016). Animal Surgery, 4e (ed. T.W. Fossum),
The Association of Shelter Veterinarians’ 2016 780–855. St. Louis, MO: Mosby.
veterinary medical care guidelines for spay‐ McCarthy, R.J., Levine, S.H., and Reed, J.M.
neuter programs. JAVMA 249: 165–188. (2013). Estimation of effectiveness of three
294 14 Dog Neuter/Cat Neuter
15
companion small mammals, and therefore intraosseous catheters and are easily intubated
usage of these doses should be carefully con so that breaths can be given during the expected
sidered prior to administration. The European period of apnea (Aeschbacher and Webb 1993).
companion rabbit and rodent literature also Similarly, the small body size of these patients
tends to favor parenteral anesthetics, but can make intramuscular (IM) injections difficult
generally contains lower dosage recommenda without causing trauma to the small muscles.
tions. Multiple review papers and a few Both subcutaneous (SC) and IM injections of
studies have evaluated various parenteral irritant drugs can cause significant self‐
drug combinations for rabbits and rodents. mutilation at the injection sites. In an experi
For example, Telazol (tiletamine/zolazepam; mental study of rabbits, the administration of
Zoetis, Parsippany, NJ) at high doses is associ ketamine and medetomidine via IM and SC
ated with dose‐dependent renal tubular necro routes were found to be equally efficacious,
sis in rabbits and should be used with caution with the SC route causing less apparent dis
(Brammer et al. 1991). A number of combina comfort following injection (Williams and
tions of parenteral drugs have been recom Wyatt 2007). Careful intraperitoneal injections
mended by various sources and the choice is are often a viable delivery route in very small
primarily based on the clinician’s preferences. mammals. Placement of drugs into the nares for
Table 15.1 provides drug selections and dos sedation and partial induction has been recom
ages used by the authors. mended in rabbits, particularly prior to cham
ber induction (Robertson and Eberhart 1994).
Direct gas induction in an anesthetic chamber
Pre-medication
that is pre‐oxygenated is a common method of
Sedation and pre‐medication of rabbits and induction of small non‐domestic mammals
rodents may facilitate peri‐operative physical (Figures 15.3 and 15.4). Once the animal is placed
examination and often provides smoother inside the chamber, the anesthetic gas concentra
inductions. Intramuscular or intranasal mida tion is increased until the patient is in lateral
zolam or diazepam provides good pre‐anes recumbency and unconscious. The patient is
thetic sedation in rabbits. The routine use of removed from the chamber and a face mask with
parasympatholytics such as atropine is not anesthetic gas is placed over the nose and mouth.
recommended in rabbits and most other small At this point, the animal can be prepared for sur
mammals, because they can cause hypomotil gery or intubated. Direct mask induction of man
ity of the gastrointestinal tract and may con ually restrained, non‐sedated animals is generally
tribute to post‐surgical ileus. Additionally, considered to be stressful and is not recom
many rabbits have active atropine esterases mended for routine anesthetic induction.
that can negate the effects of atropine (Heard
2007a).
Anesthesia Maintenance
Isofluorane and sevofluorane are the gas anes
Induction
thetics of choice for rabbits and rodents. When
Due to their small size and temperament, used correctly they provide predictable and
options for routes of administration of induc rapid inductions, stable maintenance, and
tion anesthetics are often different in small smooth recoveries. Pre‐medication with seda
mammals from those in dogs and cats. Although tives and pain medication and assisted positive
an intravenous (IV) catheter is ideal, placing a pressure ventilation through an endotracheal
catheter in smaller or fractious species is often tube improve gas‐based anesthetic protocols.
technically impossible. The use of propofol is Consistent monitoring and recording of vital
limited to animals that have pre‐placed IV or signs are important in these very small species.
Table 15.1 Drugs and drug dosages commonly used by the authors.
Sedation Midazolam 1 mg/kg 1 mg/kg 2 mg/kg 1 mg/kg 1 mg/kg 0.3 mg/kg 0.3 mg/kg 0.3 mg/kg
IM, SC, IN IM, SC IP, SC IM, SC IM, SC IM, SC IM, SC IM, SC
Midazolam, 0.5 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 1 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 0.3 mg/kg 0.3 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg
buprenorphine 0.03 mg/kg 0.05 mg/kg 0.1 mg/kg 0.05 mg/kg 0.05 mg/kg 0.02 mg/kg 0.01 mg/kg 0.02 mg/kg
IM, IN IM IM IM IM IM IM IM
Induction Propofol 8 mg/kg 10 mg/kg 5 mg/kg 5 mg/kg 5 mg/kg
IV, to effect IV, to effect IV, to effect IV, to effect IV, to effect
Ketamine, 5 mg/kg 10 mg/kg 15 mg/kg 5 mg/kg 10 mg/kg 10 mg/kg 10 mg/kg 5 mg/kg
midazolam 1 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 1 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 0.3 mg/kg 0.3 mg/kg 0.3 mg/kg
IM, once IP, once IP, once IP, once IP, once IM, once IP, once IM, once
Ketamine, 5 mg/kg 10 mg/kg 15 mg/kg 5 mg/kg 5 mg/kg 3 mg/kg 3 mg/kg 5 mg/kg
dexmedetomidine 0.1 mg/kg 0.3 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 0.1 mg/kg 0.1 mg/kg 0.05 mg/kg 0.05 mg/kg 0.05 mg/kg
IM, once IM, once IM, once IM, once IM, once IM, SC, once IM, SC, once IM, once
Ketamine, 5 mg/kg
dexmedetomidine, 0.1 mg/kg
buprenorphine 0.01 mg/kg
IM, once
Local Lidocaine 1 mg/kg 1 mg/kg 1 mg/kg 1 mg/kg 1 mg/kg 1 mg/kg 1 mg/kg 1 mg/kg
SC, total SC, total SC, total SC, total SC, total SC, total SC, total SC, total
Bupivacaine 0.5 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg 0.5 mg/kg
SC, total SC, total SC, total SC, total SC, total SC, total SC, total SC, total
BID, twice a day; IM, intramuscular; IN, intranasal; IP, intraperitoneal; IV, intravenous; PO, oral; SC, subcutaneous; SID, once a day.
held in moderate hyperextension. The tube is Tracheal intubation of rodents and other
passed through the center of the oral cavity small mammals can be more challenging, but
until it is at the level of the larynx. Instead of similar methods have been adapted for these
listening for air passing during respiration, the species. Some practitioners have described the
fogging of the tube is visualized or a capno use of small flexible endoscopes or ridged lapa
graph is placed on the tube. Again, the respira roscopes as aids for intubation. A strong fiber
tions are timed and the tube is inserted during optic light source can be used on the ventral
inspiration, when the fog starts to clear from aspect of the cranial neck of a small rodent
the inside of the endotracheal tube (Morgan (Figure 15.7). The light passes through the skin
and Glowaski 2007). and illuminates the tracheal lumen. The light
For larger rabbits, a direct visualization exiting the larynx can be seen intraorally, and
method is used, where a modified long, thin, may be used to help place the endotracheal
pediatric laryngoscope blade is placed in the tube (Yasaki and Dyck 1991).
mouth to visualize the larynx. While visualiz If tracheal intubation is not possible or is
ing the laryngeal opening, a thin stylet is passed considered impractical, many small mammals
into the trachea. The free distal end of stylet is can be maintained under gas anesthesia with a
then threaded into the tip of the endotracheal mask on the nose or face (Figure 15.8). Guinea
tube, and the endotracheal tube is passed into pigs and chinchillas are considered particu
the trachea by following the stylet inside the larly difficult to intubate and, unlike most
endotracheal tube. Recently, laryngeal mask other rodents, they can regurgitate food mate
airway tubes originally designed for neonatal rial into the oropharynx (Heard 2007b). They
infants and now customized for rabbits and also have redundant pharyngeal soft tissues;
other small animals have been used success specifically, the lateral aspects of the soft palate
fully in rabbits (Bateman et al. 2005; Smith are fused to the base of the tongue, forming a
et al. 2004). Nasotracheal intubation has also palatal ostium. These species also produce
been described, where the rabbit is placed in copious saliva that prevents direct visualiza
dorsal recumbency and a 2.0–2.5 mm ID tion of the larynx. Glycopyrrolate can be used
endotracheal tube is passed through one of the pre‐operatively to control excessive salivation
nasal passages (Devalle 2009). in these species.
302 15 Neutering Procedures and Considerations in Rabbits and Other Small Mammals
be available very soon after surgery to stimu to unfamiliar anatomy are common. Inadver
late digestion and prevent prolonged post‐sur tent incision of gastrointestinal and urinary
gical anorexia and ileus. Once the animal is tract structures should be meticulously
standing, it can be offered hay or some other avoided. If noted during surgery, every effort
appropriate food item for the species. Syringe‐ should be made to repair the iatrogenic dam
feeding a dilute solution of a powered herbi age. The most important recommendations for
vore diet such as Oxbow Critical Care (Oxbow surgery in these species are gentle and efficient
Animal Health, Murdock, NE) is indicated in tissue manipulation and a thorough under
rabbits that do not begin eating spontaneously standing of the anatomy of the patient.
two to four hours after surgery. Consider the
use of supplemental pain control (NSAIDs and
Post-operative Complications
opioids) on all animals undergoing surgery,
and intestinal motility enhancers such as A limited number of studies have reported the
metoclopramide or cisapride for animals expe frequency of post‐surgical complications and
riencing post‐operative gastric hypomotility. mortality associated with elective OHE or cas
Avoid the unnecessary use of antibiotics dur tration in rabbits and rodents. One small study
ing the peri‐operative period, as they may of 50 rabbits described a complication rate of
interfere with motility and disrupt normal 24% (Millis and Walshaw 1992). These compli
intestinal flora. Monitor the recovering animal cations included self‐mutilation or overgroom
carefully to prevent licking of the surgical site, ing of the incision site (10%), post‐surgical
and also for signs of post‐operative hemor anorexia (8%), partial incisional dehiscence
rhage. The incision site should be monitored (6%), and conjunctivitis or ophthalmic injuries
and the skin sutures, if present, should be (4%). Although all of the surgeries in this study
removed 10–14 days following surgery. As with were performed by veterinary students, these
cats and dogs, all animals (males and females) types of complications can be expected regard
should be tattooed following the surgical pro less of the experience of the surgeon. Larger
cedure to identify them as being neutered. studies with longer follow‐up periods are
needed to understand the long‐term effects of
elective reproductive surgeries on companion
Peri-operative Complications
rabbits and rodents. Incomplete removal of the
Peri‐operative hemorrhage is a common and ovaries is a common error that may lead to a
potentially fatal surgical complication. Limiting return of estrus cycles, pyometra, and uterine
acute hemorrhage during surgery is critical in or mammary neoplasia (Hotchkiss 1995;
small mammals because of their body size. The Kottwitz 2006; Lightfoot et al. 2012).
blood volume of many species can be esti Many small mammals, and especially rab
mated to be approximately 6% of their total bits, have a strong tendency to form post‐surgi
bodyweight. Loss of more than 20% of blood cal adhesions of their abdominal viscera.
volume may result in shock and death. This Rabbits have been used as models for studying
corresponds to an acute blood loss of 4 ml of human intraabdominal adhesions, and adhe
blood during a procedure on a 350 g rodent, or sions can develop simply by abrading the sero
24 ml on a 2 kg rabbit (Bennett 2012a). With sal surfaces of the gut by wiping them with dry
these limitations in blood loss, the surgeon surgical gauze. Although no long‐term studies
should use effective and secure hemostasis have been conducted on the formation of
throughout the procedure. Similarly, the adhesions in rabbits following spay surgery, it
length of anesthesia and the time of surgery can be assumed that routine reproductive sur
should be minimized to avoid sepsis, hypother geries can result in adhesions at the uterine
mia, and anesthetic deaths. Surgical errors due stump, the ovarian pedicles, and the serosal
Rabbit Ovariohysterectomy and Ovariectomy 305
surfaces of the adjacent intestines. Using talc‐ these surgical procedures for each species type,
free surgical gloves or sterilely rinsing and wip with the most recommended method first.
ing the surgical gloves prior to surgery may
help limit the formation of adhesions. Several
studies in the rabbit have evaluated different Rabbit Ovariohysterectomy
drugs and intraabdominal implants to deter and Ovariectomy
mine if they limit the formation of intraab
dominal adhesions, but none has translated to The primary reason for neutering a female rab
practical recommendations for use in pet rab bit (Oryctolagus cuniculus) is to prevent
bits (Dunn and Mohler 1993; Jenkins 2012; unwanted reproduction. Uterine adenocarci
Legrand et al. 1995; Luciano et al. 1989; noma is the most common neoplasia in female
Nishimura et al. 1984; Whitfield et al. 2007). rabbits, and rabbits have a high likelihood
for developing uterine neoplasia if left intact
(Figure 15.9). Because of this, the current rec
Evidence-Based Surgical ommendation is to perform OHE in all non‐
Recommendations breeding pet rabbits. Although uterine neoplasia
is often subclinical, it can be associated with
Numerous published articles describing the reproductive failures, bloody vaginal discharge,
surgical procedures for neutering rabbits, as and chronic weight loss (Tonks and Atlas 2007).
well as for a wide variety of rodent species, exist If uterine neoplasia does occur, OHE is the
in the veterinary literature (Bennett 2012a, b; treatment of choice if discovered before meta
Harcourt‐Brown 2002; Hillyer 1994; Idris 2012; static spread.
Jenkins 2000, 2012; Olsen and Bruce 1986). Rabbit OHE can also prevent or resolve other
These descriptions range from short and suc types of uterine pathology, including endome
cinct descriptions to very detailed surgical tritis, endometrial hyperplasia, pyometra,
descriptions with informative step‐by‐step pho hydrometra, and uterine aneurysms. Several
tographs and illustrations. The surgeon should studies have reviewed the range and incidence
review these descriptions prior to attempting of uterine pathology from populations of rab
reproductive surgery in any unfamiliar species. bits (Saito et al. 2002; Walter et al. 2010).
It should be noted that each published descrip Although mammary cancer is relatively rare,
tion is somewhat unique, with multiple meth there are two major types described (Toft 1992;
ods and variations described for each procedure Weisbroth 1994). The more common type is
and species. This lack of consensus is further
confounded by the absence of any formal eval
uation of the surgical recommendations. Large
studies documenting complication rates, long‐
term survival for different surgical techniques,
or biologic consequences of neutering are gen
erally missing from the companion animal lit
erature. A few laboratory animal studies have
tracked surgical outcomes and histologic con
sequences, but usually only in the context of an
animal model and not from the typical pet pop
ulation. With only sparse relevant evidence, the
surgeon is forced to make choices based pri
marily on anecdotal recommendations of study Figure 15.9 Uterine adenocarcinoma in a female
authors. This section will describe several of rabbit.
306 15 Neutering Procedures and Considerations in Rabbits and Other Small Mammals
papillary adenocarcinoma, which is usually three years old, 20.8% from 259 females three
preceded by cystic mastopathy and is often to four years old, 63.3% from 71 females four to
linked to uterine cancer in rabbits. The second five years old, 79.1% from 24 females five to six
type is medullary carcinoma arising from years old, and 75% from 4 females six to seven
mammary acini. years old. It is important to note that the high
Intact female rabbits are also prone to prevalence rates in the older rabbit age groups
pseudo‐pregnancy that hormonally mimics a were calculated from relatively small numbers
true pregnancy. These rabbits undergo undesir of animals surviving to the respective ages. The
able behavioral changes typically seen during resulting statistics from those small denomina
pregnancy and parturition. Preemptive OHE tors are artificially inflated and statistically
can also decrease territorial aggression, bar unreliable. A similar study of another labora
bering, and territorial urine‐spraying behaviors tory population reported 28.5% prevalence in
in female rabbits. Although the positive 49 rabbits three to four years of age, and 58.9%
effects of OHE and ovariectomy (OVE) have prevalence in 73 rabbits four years or older
been documented in the literature, the nega (Ingalls et al. 1964). Both authors used these
tive biologic consequences of these surgeries age category‐based prevalence calculations to
are poorly studied. highlight that uterine cancer is correlated very
strongly with age, so those rabbits surviving to
old age are at higher risk for developing these
Uterine Neoplasia in Rabbits
cancers.
Current estimates of the population preva The important observation is that rabbit uter
lence of uterine neoplasia vary significantly in ine cancer is common in most rabbit popula
the literature and are controversial. Several tions, but the overall prevalence may be
sources report that up to 80% of all rabbits will significantly lower than the 60–80% commonly
develop uterine neoplastic lesions (see quoted in the literature for rabbits of all ages. In
Figure 15.9). Other authors more correctly fact, even in the two original papers reviewed,
state that in older rabbits the prevalence of the overall incidence of uterine cancer from
uterine cancer can be as high as 50–80%. All of the observed populations was only 17% of 849
these statistical statements stem from two female rabbits (Greene’s population) and 20%
studies that describe the prevalence of uterine of 1735 female rabbits (Ingall’s population).
neoplasia in large laboratory rabbit popula Several subsequent studies of overall neoplastic
tions followed for several years (Greene 1942; incidence in rabbits reported modest preva
Ingalls et al. 1964). However, the details of lence of 1.3–2.6% in populations of young
these studies are often overlooked and are laboratory rabbits (Weisbroth 1994). In two vet
therefore misquoted. Both studies reported a erinary teaching hospitals, only 4–6% of all rab
very high prevalence of cancer in older rabbits. bit admissions were due to uterine abnormalities,
Greene studied one rabbit colony for nine years including adenocarcinomas (Klaphake and
and reported the incidence of uterine cancer Paul‐Murphy 2012; Paré and Paul‐Murphy
by age and other epidemiologic factors (Greene 2003). Unfortunately, the true prevalence of
1942). His population of rabbits was monitored uterine neoplasia in large companion (pet) rab
throughout their natural life span; however, bit populations allowed to live their full life
his monitoring began at two years of age and spans has not been reported in the literature.
his study group consisted of a population that
was managed with intensive selective inbreed
Rabbit Female Anatomy
ing to study other hereditary diseases. From
this group, Greene reported a prevalence of Rabbits typically reach sexual maturity between
uterine cancer of 4.2% from 491 females two to four and nine months of age, depending on the
Rabbit Ovariohysterectomy and Ovariectomy 307
can be exacerbated if the urinary bladder is herbivorous mammals are usually located just
manually expressed while the animal is in dor under the abdominal wall. The linea incision
sal recumbency and under anesthesia or heavy should be extended far enough to provide ade
sedation. quate surgical access.
Generally, the rabbit uterus is easy to visual
ize in the caudal abdomen, just dorsal to the
Rabbit Ovariohysterectomy/
cranial pole of the urinary bladder with a dis
Ovariectomy Methods
tinctly pink coloration. Gentle retraction can
Rabbit Ovariohysterectomy be used to move the cecum or bladder aside to
The ventral midline approach is the most com locate the uterus if it is not initially visualized.
mon method of performing an OHE in female As mentioned previously, the use of a spay
rabbits (Capello 2005a; Jenkins 2012). Once hook to locate the uterus is contraindicated in
anesthetized, an area of the ventral abdomen is rabbits, due to the very real danger of punctur
clipped similar in size to an area prepared for a ing the thin‐walled cecum (Figure 15.14). Once
cat or kitten spay. The clipping must be done the uterus is identified, the cranial portion is
carefully, because rabbit skin is very thin and grasped with fingers or forceps and elevated
tears easily, yet fine rabbit hair is difficult to out of the abdomen (Figure 15.15). In rabbits it
clip. Aseptically prepare the surgical site by
alternating chlorhexidine or betadine scrubs
with alcohol or warmed sterile water. The skin
incision should be centered halfway between
the umbilicus and the pubis, about 2–4 cm cau
dal to the umbilicus and extending 1–3 cm cau
dally toward the pubis. A larger incision can be
made if more exposure is needed. Once the
subcutaneous tissues are cleared, the ventral
body wall and linea alba should be clearly
identified. The body wall is elevated and an
inverted scalpel (#15 blade is preferred) is used
to make the first incision through the linea Figure 15.14 Cecum (C) and uterus (U) in the
(Figure 15.13). This step is critical, as the thin‐ female rabbit under a plastic surgical drape.
walled cecum and the urinary bladder of
Figure 15.13 Elevation of the body wall prior to Figure 15.15 Elevation of the first uterus from
insertion of the scalpel blade is important to the abdominal cavity in a female rabbit. The ovary
prevent puncture of the cecum, which lies directly (Ov), suspensory ligament (S), and oviduct (Od) are
beneath the abdominal wall. easily identified.
Rabbit Ovariohysterectomy and Ovariectomy 309
Rabbit Castration
Figure 15.22 Initial incision into the rabbit Figure 15.24 During open castration, the ligament
scrotum. (L) between the inverted vaginal tunic (VT) and
testicle (T) must be manually broken down to expose
the testicle and associated vascular structures.
the vessels of the spermatic cord are ligated
and transected to remove the testicle and pad, current recommendations consider the fat
epididymis. An alternative method is to autoli pad as an important structure in the inguinal
gate the spermatic cord using a mosquito ring, helping to prevent visceral herniation in
hemostat, as has been described for cat castra both the intact and castrated male rabbit
tions. The remaining fat pad and the ligated (Capello 2005b; Jenkins 2012). The skin is
vessels are carefully replaced into the inguinal closed with tissue glue or left open.
canal, which is then closed as cranially as pos
sible by placing a ligature into the open tunics. Rabbit Scrotal Castration – Closed
Although some descriptions of the open cas The closed scrotal technique is similar to closed
tration specifically remove the epididymal fat castration in cats. The rabbit is placed
Rabbit Castration 313
around the tunics of the inguinal canal is now reduced the incidence of mammary tumors
pushed cranially toward the abdomen and tied from 47% to less than 4%, and concurrently
closed. The process is repeated for the other reduced the incidence of pituitary tumors from
testicle. The incision is closed in two layers. 66% to less than 4% (Hotchkiss 1995). These
The skin is closed with a subcuticular suture two neoplasias are consistently reported as the
pattern, surgical glue, traditional skin sutures, most common tumors in rat populations. The
or staples. One common complication of this long‐term negative consequences of OHE have
method is post‐operative edema within the not been evaluated in companion rodent popu
empty scrotal sacs. This may be due to tissue lations; however, OVE of rats has been associ
trauma to the retained parietal tunics and ated with bone loss and used as a reliable
obstructed lymphatics caused by the surgical rodent model of post‐menopausal bone loss in
ligation. Generally considered a cosmetic com humans (Idris 2012).
plication, the edema usually subsides within a Guinea pigs (Cavia porcellus) that are
week (Capello 2005b). allowed to breed should have their first litter
by six months of age to prevent the fusion of
Rabbit Abdominal Castration the pubic symphysis. Once fused, female
Abdominal castration is possible for rabbits, guinea pigs will suffer from dystocia if allowed
but is not commonly described or recom to give birth. Therefore, OHE or OVE can be
mended. The rabbit is placed in dorsal recum performed in older guinea pigs to eliminate the
bency and prepared for typical midline potential for pregnancies with possibly fatal
abdominal surgery. The abdomen is entered outcomes.
as described for rabbit OHE, except that the
incision is made closer to the pubis. The uri
Female Rodent Anatomy
nary bladder is gently elevated and retracted.
The ductus deferens is identified dorsally, lat Rodents have variable and species‐specific
eral to the bladder, and used to gently pull the onset of sexual maturity, with many small spe
testicle through the inguinal canal and into cies maturing quite early in life (Lennox and
the abdomen. The epididymis of the testicle is Bauck 2012). Most rodent species possess two
freed from its distal attachment to the parietal uterine horns and a single cervix, similar to the
tunic and fully elevated out of the abdomen. female reproductive anatomy of dogs and cats.
The structures of the spermatic cord are iden Rodents also have a shorter vaginal body than
tified and ligated to remove the testicle and that of the rabbit. The major differences
epididymis. A mattress suture is placed into between rodents and dog and cat reproductive
the now empty opening of the inguinal canal tracts are the small size of the reproductive
to close the inguinal ring from inside the structures, and the relative fragility of the
abdomen. The process is repeated for the reproductive tissues in rodents. As in the rab
other testicle and the abdomen is closed rou bit, the abdominal structures in obese pet
tinely (Capello 2005b). rodents can be difficult to identify and isolate.
The small ovaries in guinea pigs, chinchillas
(Chinchilla lanigera), and degus (Octodon
Rodent Ovariohysterectomy degus) are particularly difficult to locate in the
and Ovariectomy adipose tissues. Once identified, the ovaries
have relatively short ovarian suspensory liga
As in female rabbits, removal of the ovaries in ments that may tear easily during surgical ele
some species of rodents may result in lower vation. Large, multiple ovarian cysts are a very
incidences of certain cancers later in life. In common finding in guinea pigs, and are often
female domestic rats (Rattus norvegicus), OVE the reason for performing OHE or OVE in this
316 15 Neutering Procedures and Considerations in Rabbits and Other Small Mammals
species. Because ovarian disease is common subcutaneous tissue (if present) and intrader
and uterine disease relatively rare, OVE alone mal closure of the skin. Tissue adhesive may
can be performed. Similar to the limited stud be used as an alternative to suture.
ies in rabbits concerning the need for OHE to Alternatively, an OVE can be performed in
prevent uterine cancer, this recommendation rodents through a lateral flank approach.
for OVE has not been fully evaluated in a large With the patient in ventral recumbency, an
population of pet guinea pigs. approximately 0.5–2 cm incision (depending
on the species) is made on the midline just
caudal to the last rib. The subcutaneous tis
Surgical Procedures for Rodent
sues are dissected laterally to expose the flank
Ovariohysterectomy/Ovariectomy
ventral to the lumbar musculature. The
Rat, Mouse, Gerbil, and Hamster abdominal musculature is exposed and a
Ovariohysterectomy/Ovariectomy blunt hemostat or scissor is used to spread the
Because rodents are the prototypical labora muscle fibers to gain entry into the abdominal
tory animals, many surgeries, including OHE cavity. The ovary is located within a bundle of
and OVE, have been well described in the labo fat beneath the incision and is gently exterior
ratory animal medicine literature. The rat OHE ized. Alternatively, the surgeon can place gen
and OVE will be described as a model for mice tle pressure on the side of the abdomen to
(Mus musculus), Mongolian gerbil (Meriones allow the ovary to partially exit the abdominal
unguiculatus), Syrian hamster (Mesocricetus wall through the incision. The ovarian pedicle
auratus), and other rat‐like rodents. and uterine horn are ligated just proximal to
An OHE or OVE can be performed via a ven the ovary using 4‐0 absorbable monofilament
tral midline incision similar to the rabbit OHE/ suture or a hemoclip. Prior to release of the
OVE described earlier. The incision is made uterine horn, it is gently retracted caudally to
through the skin from just caudal to the umbil exteriorize the contralateral horn and ovary.
icus to just cranial to the rim of the pubis. The same procedure is repeated on the oppo
Rodents require relatively longer incisions to site side. The muscle wall is closed with
allow safe elevation of the fragile reproductive appropriately sized monofilament suture
structures (Jenkins 2000). The linea alba, material using a cruciate or simple inter
which is very thin, is identified and incised to rupted suture pattern (Idris 2012). The single
enter the abdomen. The intestines are gently skin incision is closed with an intradermal
manipulated to the side with moistened sterile pattern followed by tissue adhesive. A modifi
cotton swabs or a blunt surgical instrument. A cation of the flank approach using two sepa
sterile cotton swab can also be used to help rate flank skin incisions has been described
elevate the uterus and isolate the reproductive (Olsen and Bruce 1986).
tract. It is common for the abdomen of rats to
be abundant with fat regardless of the overall Guinea Pig, Degu, and Chinchilla
size or external appearance of the animal. The Ovariohysterectomy/Ovariectomy
ovarian vasculature is ligated using an appro Ventral midline OHE as previously described
priately sized hemoclip or monofilament for the rabbit has been described for guinea
suture material. The process is repeated on the pigs, chinchillas, and degus, but is generally
opposite side. If performing an OHE, the junc considered technically demanding due to the
tion of the uterine horns and cervix is located, short, deep abdomen and large intestinal vis
elevated, and double‐ligated using 4‐0 absorb cera that prevent easy identification of the
able monofilament suture. The abdominal uterine horns. This is further complicated by
wall is sutured in a simple continuous pattern, the relatively short suspensory ligaments
followed by a simple continuous closure of the and stronger mesometrium attachments to
Rodent Castration 317
References
Aeschbacher, G. and Webb, A.I. (1993). Propofol Capello, V. (2006a). Prescrotal approach to
in rabbits, determination of an induction elective orchiectomy in guinea pigs. Exot.
dose. Lab. Anim. Sci. 43 (4): 324–327. DVM 8 (5): 29–32.
Al‐Badrany, M.S. (2009). Laparoscopic ovariectomy Capello, V. (2006b). Flank approach to elective
in rabbits. Iraqi J. Vet. Sci. 23 (2): 51–55. ovariectomy in guinea pigs. Exot. DVM 8 (5):
Anderson, M. and Friomovitch, M. (1974). 33–37.
Simplified method of guinea pig castration. Devalle, S.J.M. (2009). Successful management
Can. Vet. J. 15 (4): 126–127. of rabbit anesthesia through the use of
Bateman, L., Ludders, J.W., Gleed, R.D., and Erb, nasotracheal intubation. J. Am. Assoc. Lab.
H.N. (2005). Comparison between facemask Anim. Sci. 48 (2): 166–170.
and laryngeal mask airway in rabbits during Divers, S.J. (2010). Clinical technique:
isoflurane anesthesia. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 32: endoscopic oophorectomy in the rabbit
280–288. (Oryctolagus cuniculus): the future of
Bennett, R.A. (2012a). Soft tissue surgery (guinea preventative sterilizations. J. Exot. Pet Med.
pigs, chinchillas, and degus). In: Ferrets, 19 (3): 231–239.
Rabbits, and Rodents: Clinical Medicine and Done, L.B., Deem, S.L., and Fiorello, C.V. (2007).
Surgery, 3e (eds. K.E. Quesenberry and J.W. Surgical and medical management of a
Carpenter), 326–338. St. Louis, MO: Elsevier uterine spindle cell tumor in an African
Saunders. hedgehog (Atelerix albiventris). J. Zoo Wildlife
Bennett, R.A. (2012b). Soft tissue surgery (small Med. 38 (4): 601–603.
rodents). In: Ferrets, Rabbits, and Rodents: Dunn, R.C. and Mohler, M. (1993). Effect of
Clinical Medicine and Surgery, 3e (eds. K.E. varying days of tissue plasminogen activator
Quesenberry and J.W. Carpenter), 373–391. St. therapy on the prevention of postsurgical
Louis, MO: Elsevier Saunders. adhesions in a rabbit model. J. Surg. Res. 54
Bielinska, M., Kiiveri, S., Parviainen, H. et al. (3): 242–245.
(2006). Gonadectomy‐induced adrenocortical Flecknell, P.A. (2001). Analgesia of small
neoplasia in the domestic ferret (Mustela mammals. Vet. Clin. Exot. Anim. Pract. 4 (1):
putorius furo) and laboratory mouse. Vet. 47–56.
Pathol. 43 (2): 97–117. Greene, H.S.N. (1942). Uterine adenomata in the
Brammer, D.W., Doerning, B.J., Chrisp, C.E. rabbit III. Susceptibility as a function of
et al. (1991). Anesthetic and nephrotoxic constitutional factors. J. Exp. Med. 73:
effects of Telazol in New Zealand White 273–292.
rabbits. Lab. Anim. Sci. 41 (4): 432–435. Hanley, C.S. (2013). The care of small
Brodbelt, D.C., Blissitt, K.J., Hammond, R.A. mammals in the animal shelter. In: Shelter
et al. (2008). The risk of death: the Medicine for Veterinarians and Staff, 2e (eds.
confidential enquiry into perioperative small L. Miller and S. Zawistowski), 185–200.
animal fatalities. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 35 (5): Ames, IA: Wiley‐Blackwell.
365–373. Harcourt‐Brown, F. (2002). Urogenital diseases.
Capello, V. (2005a). Surgical techniques for In: Textbook of Rabbit Medicine, 1e, 348–351.
neutering the female pet rabbit. Exot. DVM 7 Oxford: Butterworth Heinemann.
(5): 15–21. Hawkins, M.G. and Pascoe, P.J. (2012).
Capello, V. (2005b). Surgical techniques for Anesthesia, analgesia, and sedation of small
orchiectomy of the pet rabbit. Exot. DVM 7 mammals. In: Ferrets, Rabbits, and Rodents:
(5): 23–31. Clinical Medicine and Surgery, 3e (eds. K.E.
322 15 Neutering Procedures and Considerations in Rabbits and Other Small Mammals
Quesenberry and J.W. Carpenter), 429–451. St. prevention model. J. Invest. Surg. 8 (3):
Louis, MO: Elsevier Saunders. 187–194.
Heard, D. (2007a). Lagomorphs (Rabbits, Hares, Lennox, A.M. and Bauck, L. (2012). Basic
and Pika). In: Zoo Animal and Wildlife anatomy, physiology, and clinical techniques
Immobilization and Anesthesia (eds. G. West, (small rodents). In: Ferrets, Rabbits, and
D. Heard and N. Caulkett), 647–654. Ames, Rodents: Clinical Medicine and Surgery, 3e
IA: Blackwell Publishing. (eds. K.E. Quesenberry and J.W. Carpenter),
Heard, D. (2007b). Rodents. In: Zoo Animal and 339–353. St. Louis, MO: Elsevier Saunders.
Wildlife Immobilization and Anesthesia (eds. Lichtenberger, M. and Ko, J. (2007). Anesthesia
G. West, D. Heard and N. Caulkett), 647–654. and analgesia for small birds and mammals.
Ames, IA: Blackwell Professional. Vet. Clin. Exot. Anim. Pract. 10 (2): 293–315.
Hillyer, E.V. (1994). Pet rabbits. Vet. Clin. N. Am. Lightfoot, T., Rubinstein, J., Aiken, S., and
Small Anim. Pract 24 (1): 25–64. Ludwig, L. (2012). Soft tissue surgery. In:
Hotchkiss, C.E. (1995). Effect of surgical removal Ferrets, Rabbits, and Rodents: Clinical
of subcutaneous tumors on survival of rats. Medicine and Surgery, 3e (eds. K.E.
JAVMA 206 (10): 1575–1579. Quesenberry and J.W. Carpenter), 141–156. St.
Idris, A.I. (2012). Ovariectomy/Orchidectomy in Louis, MO: Elsevier Saunders.
rodents. In: Bone Research Protocols, Methods Luciano, A.A., Maier, D.B., Koch, E.I. et al.
in Molecular Biology, vol. 816 (eds. M.H. (1989). A comparative study of postoperative
Helfrich and S.H. Ralston), 545–551. Berlin: adhesions following laser surgery by
Springer Science and Business Media. laparoscopy versus laparotomy in the rabbit
Ingalls, T.H., Adams, W.M., Lurie, M.B., and model. Obstet. Gynecol. 74 (2): 220–224.
Ipsen, J. (1964). Natural history of Millis, D.L. and Walshaw, R. (1992). Elective
adenocarcinoma of the uterus in the Phipps castrations and ovariohysterectomies in pet
rabbit colony. J. Nat. Cancer Inst. 33 (5): rabbits. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 28: 491–498.
799–806. Morgan, T.J. and Glowaski, M.M. (2007).
Jenkins, J.R. (2000). Surgical sterilization in Teaching a new method of rabbit intubation.
small mammals: spay and castration. Vet. Clin. J. Am. Assoc. Lab. Anim. Sci. 46 (3): 32–36.
N. Am. Exot. Anim. Pract 3 (3): 617. Ness, R.D. and Johson‐Delaney, C.A. (2012).
Jenkins, J.R. (2012). Soft tissue surgery (rabbits). Sugar gliders. In: Ferrets, Rabbits, and Rodents:
In: Ferrets, Rabbits, and Rodents: Clinical Clinical Medicine and Surgery, 3e (eds. K.E.
Medicine and Surgery, 3e (eds. K.E. Quesenberry and J.W. Carpenter), 339–410. St.
Quesenberry and J.W. Carpenter), 269–278. St. Louis, MO: Elsevier Saunders.
Louis, MO: Elsevier Saunders. Nishimura, K., Nakamura, R.M., and Dizerega,
Klaphake, E. and Paul‐Murphy, J. (2012). G.S. (1984). Ibuprofen inhibition of
Disorders of the reproductive and urinary postsurgical adhesion formation: a time and
systems. In: Ferrets, Rabbits, and Rodents: dose response biochemical evaluation in
Clinical Medicine and Surgery, 3e (eds. K.E. rabbits. J. Surg. Res. 36: 115–124.
Quesenberry and J.W. Carpenter), 217–231. St. Olsen, M.E. and Bruce, J. (1986). Ovariectomy,
Louis, MO: Elsevier Saunders. ovariohysterectomy, and orchidectomy in
Kottwitz, J. (2006). Stump pyometra in a rodents and rabbits. Can. Vet. J. 27 (12):
chinchilla. Exot. DVM 8 (5): 24–28. 523–527.
Legrand, E.K., Rodgers, K.E., Girgis, W. et al. Paré, J.A. and Paul‐Murphy, J. (2003). Disorders
(1995). Comparative efficacy of nonsteroidal of the reproductive and urinary systems. In:
anti‐inflammatory drugs and anti‐ Ferrets, Rabbits, and Rodents: Clinical
thromboxane agents in a rabbit adhesion‐ Medicine and Surgery, 2e (eds. K.E.
References 323
Quesenberry and J.W. Carpenter), 183–193. St. Toft, J.D. (1992). Commonly observed
Louis, MO: Elsevier Saunders. spontaneous neoplasms in rabbits, rats,
Phaneuf, L.R., Barker, S., Groleau, M.A., and guinea pigs, hamsters, and gerbils. Semin.
Turner, P.V. (2006). Tracheal injury after Avian. Exot. Pet. Med. 1 (2): 80–92.
endotracheal intubation and anesthesia in Tonks, C.A. and Atlas, A.L. (2007). Clinical
rabbits. J. Am. Assoc. Lab. Anim. Sci. 45 (6): snapshot: uterine adenocarcinoma. Compend.
67–72. Cont. Educ. Vet. 29 (1): 49–51.
Robertson, S.A. (2001). Analgesia and analgesic Walter, B., Poth, T., Bohmer, E. et al. (2010).
techniques. Vet. Clin. N. Am. Exot. Anim. Uterine Disorders in 59 Rabbits. Vet. Rec. 166:
Pract. 4 (1): 1–18. 230–233.
Robertson, S.A. and Eberhart, S. (1994). Efficacy Weisbroth, S.H. (1994). Neoplastic diseases. In:
of the intranasal route for administration of The Biology of the Laboratory Rabbit, 2e (eds.
anesthetic agents to adult rabbits. Lab. Anim. P.J. Manning, D.H. Ringler and C.E.
Sci. 44: 159–165. Newcomer), 259–292. New York: Academic
Saito, K., Nakanishi, M., and Hasegawa, A. (2002). Press.
Uterine disorders diagnosed by ventrotomy in Whitfield, R.R., Stills, H.F., Huls, H.R. et al.
47 rabbits. J. Vet. Med. Sci. 64 (6): 495–497. (2007). Effects of peritoneal closure and
Sikoski, P., Young, R.W., and Lockard, M. (2007). suture material on adhesion formation in a
Comparison of heating devices for rabbit model. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 197: 644.
maintaining body temperature in anesthetized e1–644.e5.
laboratory rabbits (Oryctolagus cuniculus). J. Williams, A.M. and Wyatt, J.D. (2007).
Am. Assoc. Lab. Anim. Sci. 46 (3): 61–63. Comparison of subcutaneous and
Smith, J.C., Robertson, L.D., Auhll, A. et al. intramuscular ketamine‐medetomidine
(2004). Endotracheal tubes versus Laryngeal with and without reversal by atipamezole
Mask Airways in Rabbit Inhalation Anesthesia: in Dutch Belted rabbits (Oryctolagus
ease of use and waste gas emissions. J. Am. cuniculus). J. Am. Assoc. Lab. Anim. Sci. 46
Assoc. Lab. Anim. Sci. 43 (4): 22–25. (6): 16–20.
Szabo, Z., Bradley, K., and Cahalane, A.K. Yasaki, S. and Dyck, P.J. (1991). A simple
(2016). Rabbit soft tissue surgery. Vet. Clin. N. method for rat endotracheal intubation. Lab.
Am. Exot. Anim. Pract. 19: 159–188. Anim. Sci. 41: 620–622.
325
16
Figure 16.3 Inguinal area of a male dog Figure 16.5 Inguinal area of a neutered male dog.
immediately following surgical castration. Note the Note the presence of a green linear tattoo on the
application of a green linear tattoo in the pre- ventral midline in the pre-scrotal area.
scrotal area immediately lateral to the prepuce.
Figure 16.4 Green linear tattoo on the ventral Table 16.1 The Association of Shelter
abdomen of a cat. Depending on the individual Veterinarians’ recommendations for standard
animal’s tractability and hair coat, clipping the hair placement of green linear tattoos for identification
over the ventral midline area may be necessary to of neutered dogs and cats (Griffin et al. 2016).
ensure discovery and visualization of such tattoos.
Sex and
was formerly available and used by some pro- species Location of green linear tattoo
grams for chemical castration of dogs. The prod-
uct resulted in testicular atrophy and sterility in Female On or immediately lateral to the area
male dogs, but the testes remained present. In dogs and of the ventral midline incision; if a
order to identify these dogs as non‐surgically cats flank approach is used to spay a
female patient, the tattoo should be
sterilized, the letter Z was tattooed in the cau- placed in the area where a ventral
dolateral ventral abdomen (Griffin 2013). Since midline spay incision would have
the testicles were not removed, a unique form of been placed
standard identification was essential in order to Male dogs At the caudal aspect of the abdomen in
denote that the animal was non‐surgically neu- the pre‐scrotal incision or pre‐scrotal
area immediately lateral to the prepuce
tered. If other products become available for
non‐surgical sterilization in the future, it will be Male cats In the area where a ventral midline
spay incision would typically be placed
essential to develop simple means of permanent
328 16 Tattoo and Ear-Tipping Techniques for Identification of Surgically Sterilized Dogs and Cats
Figure 16.7 The tip of a paper sterility indicator Figure 16.8 Another option for applying ink to
strip from the surgical pack is dipped in tattoo the incision is to use a sterile cotton-tipped
ink in preparation for application to the incision. applicator. A tiny amount of ink is retrieved with
Note that only a tiny amount of ink is obtained the tip of the applicator, which is then gently
on one corner of the end of the strip. It is rolled along the cut skin edges. Note that the
desirable to avoid more liberal use of ink in order surgeon gently spreads the incision to ensure
to prevent the inevitable mess that is created adequate contact of the ink with the skin edges.
when ink is inadvertently deposited on the skin
around the incision, which occurs when it is too
heavily applied to the applicator.
(a) (b)
Figure 16.9 (a) A syringe and needle may also be used to deposit ink between the edges of the
incision to create a linear tattoo. (b) The final appearance of the tattooed incision following application
of a drop of tissue glue on top of the skin.
(d) (e)
Figure 16.10 (a) Green tattoo ink is applied to a separate incision adjacent to the surgery site using a
paper sterility indicator strip from the surgical pack. (b) The incision, which was made using a scalpel
blade to score full thickness through the dermis, is well coated with ink. (c) The edges of the incision are
gently opposed and closure is achieved using a drop of tissue glue on top of the skin. (d) Care is taken to
ensure that glue is only placed on top of the opposed incision and never in the incision itself. If glue is
placed in the incision itself it will act as a foreign body, delaying healing and possibly resulting in tattoo
failure. (e) The final appearance of the green linear tattoo on the ventral midline adjacent to the spay
incision.
Method 3: Intradermal Tattoo Method ●● With the needle attached to the syringe,
(Figure 16.12) insert it intradermally to its hub, and
then slowly inject ink as the needle is
●● Inject ink intradermally adjacent to the inci-
withdrawn.
sion using a tuberculin syringe with a
●● Use a new sterile needle for each patient.
25-gauge needle.
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 16.11 (a–d) A scoring tattoo is created using a needle and syringe to deposit the ink in the
incision. Note the tiny bubble of ink at the end of the needle. This is all that is required to fully paint
the inside of the small, full-thickness skin incision. Closure is achieved by applying a drop of surgical
glue on top of the skin as the edges of the incision are gently held in apposition.
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 16.12 Intradermal tattoo method. (a) A 25-gauge needle is inserted intradermally adjacent to
the surgical incision. (b) The needle is buried all the way to the hub. (c) A tiny amount of ink is injected
as the needle is withdrawn. (d) Final appearance of the intradermal tattoo.
332 16 Tattoo and Ear-Tipping Techniques for Identification of Surgically Sterilized Dogs and Cats
(a) (b)
Figure 16.15 (a and b) A female cat was anesthetized for ovariohysterectomy, but exploratory surgery
revealed that she was already spayed. Note the presence of a small ear notch, which unfortunately was not
recognized as an identifying mark since it did not adhere to the universal standard.
be used for ear‐tipping. The method used is which can involve the entire pinna. The most
according to the surgeon’s preference. In all important requirement is proper matching of
cases, instruments used for ear‐tipping must be energy setting to excision speed to prevent heat
thoroughly cleaned and disinfected or steri- buildup at the excisional margin. A simple plas-
lized between patients to prevent the spread of tic spring clamp may be placed across the excised
pathogens, and a new pair of clean exam gloves portion of the ear tip as a straight edge. This will
should be worn for each patient. facilitate a straight crop and make it easier to
A practical and commonly used method for maintain adequate excision speed to minimize
removal of the distal tip of the pinna is simple collateral thermal damage.
sharp excision. In most instances, this will be Certain patient safety measures must be
performed using a pair of hemostatic forceps taken with the use of electrosurgery. An impor-
and scissors (Box 16.2). Scissors are preferred tant requirement is to ensure full contact of the
over a scalpel blade because their crushing patient to the passive electrode (ground plate),
action aids hemostasis. Straight scissors and to prevent thermal burns on the body. These
straight hemostats should be used to make it occur when the patient makes poor contact
easier to crop the ear in a straight line. This is with the ground plate (usually firmly contact-
very important to ensure the desired visual ing only the cable connector). This allows all of
effect: the ear should have a distinct straight the energy to be channeled into a relatively
edge that is easy to recognize from a distance. small area of skin, with resultant heat buildup.
If available, an electrosurgical unit or surgical Ear‐tipping is often performed after the cat
laser may also be used for ear‐tipping; both has been anesthetized and reached a surgical
have the potential advantages of improved plane of general anesthesia, but before surgical
hemostasis and reduced opportunity for dis- sterilization. This sequence of events provides
ease transmission via surgical instruments. the advantage of allowing ample time for
If either of these methods is employed, care hemostasis to occur prior to anesthetic recovery.
must be taken to prevent collateral thermal dam- In contrast, some surgeons prefer to perform
age to the pinna, or severe pinnal necrosis may surgical sterilization prior to ear‐tipping. The
result. This damage is usually not obvious when advantage of this sequence is that it avoids any
it is first inflicted; if anything, only mild blanch- instance in which a cat could be ear‐tipped
ing may be seen at the time of surgery. However, without undergoing surgical sterilization if the
due to the coagulation of pinnal blood vessels, surgery had to be aborted for any reason.
severe necrosis ensues within four to seven days,
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 16.17 Ear-tipping procedure. (a) A straight hemostat is placed across the left pinna
perpendicular to its long axis, exposing proportionately one-third of the ear tip. (b) Straight surgical
scissors are used to remove the ear tip by cutting over the top of the hemostat in a straight line. (c)
The hemostat is left in place to allow adequate time for hemostasis of the pinna to occur. (d) Proper
appearance of the ear following removal of the hemostat. Note the distinctive straight edge that
will be easily recognizable from a distance.
Figure 16.18 Prior to removal of the hemostat, a silver nitrate stick may be rolled over the cut surface
of the pinna to aid in hemostasis.
336 16 Tattoo and Ear-Tipping Techniques for Identification of Surgically Sterilized Dogs and Cats
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 16.19 An open hemostat is gently held on various aspects of the pinna of an anesthetized cat in
order to illustrate both proper and improper clamp placement for ear-tipping. (a) Proper placement of
the hemostat perpendicular to the long axis of the ear, exposing proportionately one-third of the ear tip.
(b) Improper placement of the hemostat: here it is placed too high, exposing less than one-third of the
ear tip proportionately. Transecting the pinna here would result in an ear tip that is difficult to recognize
from a distance. (c) Improper placement of the hemostat: here it is placed too low, exposing
approximately half of the ear tip proportionately. Transecting the pinna here would result in skin
retraction and exposure of the pinnal cartilage, prolonging healing time and predisposing to surgical site
infection. (d) Improper placement of the hemostat: here it is not placed perpendicular to the long axis of
the ear. Transecting the pinna here would result in a pointed ear tip, making it difficult to recognize as a
tipped ear from a distance.
References 337
References
Bushby, P.A. (2013). Surgical techniques for spay/ Griffin, B. (2013). Nonsurgical sterilization. In:
neuter. In: Shelter Medicine for Veterinarians Shelter Medicine for Veterinarians and Staff, 2e
and Staff, 2e (eds. L. Miller and S. Zawistowski), (eds. L. Miller and S. Zawistowski), 689–696.
625–646. Aimes, IA: Blackwell. Aimes, IA: Blackwell.
338 16 Tattoo and Ear-Tipping Techniques for Identification of Surgically Sterilized Dogs and Cats
Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al. Griffin, B., DiGangi, B., and Bohling, M.A.
(2016). The Association of Shelter (2010). Review of neutering cats. In:
Veterinarians’ 2016 Veterinary Medical Care Consultations in Feline Internal Medicine VI
Guidelines for Spay‐Neuter Programs. JAVMA (ed. J.R. August), 776–790. St. Louis, MO:
249 (2): 165–188. Elsevier Saunders.
339
17
The focus of this chapter is a discussion of HQHVSN clinics and animal shelters, for two
surgical complications – their presentation, important reasons. The first is the widely held
treatment, prognosis, and, most importantly, view that spay and neuter are “simple” surgical
prevention. For a discussion of anesthetic procedures; yet, are they really? Consider this
complications, refer to Chapter 10. fact: spay and neuter involve the removal of an
Complications are “inevitable,” “an unavoid entire endocrine organ – this aspect should
able part of surgery” – or are they? The answer alone qualify the procedures as major. The mis
depends in large measure on what one accepts conception of spay and neuter as simple surgery
as inevitable and how one defines a complica is certainly the view of the vast majority of the
tion. For the purposes of this chapter, we will general public, and even within some members
define “surgical complications” as “any unex of the veterinary profession. After all, these pro
pected/unplanned/unwanted experience or cedures form the cornerstone of surgical train
outcome for the patient that causes either mor ing for veterinary students, and are described by
tality, or sufficient morbidity to require further educators as “basic” and “entry‐level” skills.
medical attention.” With this broad definition This terminology and attitude promote a view
of complications and the sheer numbers that spay and neuter are somehow inherently
involved in high‐quality high‐volume spay– safer and less at risk for complications com
neuter (HQHVSN) and shelter surgery, it is pared to other veterinary surgical procedures,
easy to see the enormous potential for compli with the implication that these procedures are
cations to occur and to accept a certain fre somehow less demanding of excellence. This
quency of complications as unavoidable. Of view may tend to promote a low value assign
course, the mindset of inevitability usually ment and a careless attitude on the part of
forms a rather poor basis for improve clients regarding their own pre‐ and post‐opera
ment – why work to improve that which we tive responsibilities. Yet, should something go
cannot influence? A better and more produc amiss, the backlash is likely to be all the more
tive approach would be to assume that all sur extreme – “But Doctor, how could you have
gical complications are at least theoretically if anything less than a perfect result with such a
not actually preventable. simple procedure?” However, along with the
This mindset – the idea that complications negative side of this view – the promotion of a
can and should be driven down to zero, or as complacent attitude, inviting problems – there
near to zero as possible – is particularly is also a positive side. This is the second reason:
applicable to spay and neuter surgery in namely, that this field is ripe for improvement.
340 17 Complications in Spay and Neuter Surgery
“style” of any spay surgeon. However, many into the abdomen; sometimes a small
experienced surgeons will have developed amount of subcutaneous tissue has been
their own successful methods to minimize risk inadvertently incorporated into the liga
of hemorrhage; therefore, the following tech ture, thus the pedicle is attached both at its
nical points should not be construed as the origin and at the subcutis and is under ten
“best” or “proper” way to perform spay, but sion. If the pedicle is released outside the
rather a set of guidelines for surgeons who are abdomen in this condition, the ligature may
relatively inexperienced or for those who have remain attached to the subcutis while the
had problems with operative hemorrhage. pedicle (now without a ligature) retracts to
the dorsal abdomen.
1) Obtain an adequate length of the ovarian
pedicle. An ovarian pedicle that is too short Besides suture ligation, other options exist
makes it more difficult to inspect the ligated for hemostasis of the ovarian and uterine pedi
pedicle, encourages excessive traction dur cles. One such option is the use of an electro
ing manipulations for ligation and/or surgical device to coagulate the vessels before
inspection, and may lead directly to a torn transection. Electrosurgical coagulation can be
pedicle. delivered via vessel‐sealing devices with feed
2) Place the ligature(s) far enough proximal back to limit collateral thermal damage, or via
on the pedicle so that after the pedicle is conventional bipolar electrosurgical forceps.
transected, several millimeters of pedicle Watts (2018) reported on the use of conven
(usually at least 5 mm) remains distal to the tional bipolar forceps in routine ovariectomy
ligature. of 1406 dogs and 859 cats; in addition, the for
3) Select the proper gauge of suture material ceps were used for ovariohysterectomy for
for the ligature, neither too small nor too pyometra or after cesarean section in another
large. Suture material of too small a gauge 89 dog and 55 cats. No instances of hemor
may break and tend to cut through the pedi rhage were observed during or after any of the
cle when tightened, particularly with obese ovariectomy or ovariohysterectomy surgeries;
patients in which the pedicle contains a however, skin burns from collateral heat dam
great deal of friable adipose tissue. On the age were observed, mainly during the early use
other hand, a suture material of too large a of the forceps, until it was found that this com
gauge may exhibit poor knot security and plication could be avoided by placement of a
be prone to slipping off the pedicle. gauze swab between the skin and the electro
4) Utilize proper ligation technique, paying surgical forceps.
special attention to ensuring that as the sec Tearing of the ovarian pedicle is the second
ond knot throw is placed, the first throw is common cause of acute intraoperative hemor
not inadvertently loosened. rhage. Pedicular tearing has been more com
5) Post‐ligation inspection of the pedicle monly associated with the right ovary than the
should be gentle and minimal, and the liga left; it is hypothesized that the more cranial
ture itself should never be grasped. location of the right ovary makes exposure more
Excessive manipulation of the pedicle after difficult, requiring a greater degree of traction
ligation may loosen a ligature, causing and thus an increased risk of tearing. The risk of
hemorrhage after the pedicle is returned to tearing can be minimized by proper placement
the abdomen. After inspection is com of the spay incision (not too caudal), and proper
pleted, the grasp on the pedicle should be technique to rupture the suspensory ligament.
retained as the pedicle is returned to its ana- “Proper technique” in this instance should not
tomic position in the dorsal abdomen. It be construed to mean that there is a single best
should not be merely released to fall back method, as a number of methods and variations
342 17 Complications in Spay and Neuter Surgery
exist to tear the suspensory ligament. To name a when done properly, and all can cause problems
few: digital pressure (“strumming”), grasping when performed incorrectly. Therefore, rather
the ligament between thumb and index finger than endorse one method, the author believes
and then turning (“twisting”) the wrist, tearing that the spay surgeon should become familiar
the ligament with hemostats, and cutting it with with several, choose a primary method accord
scissors or electrosurgery. In a small prospective ing to preference, and then become expert in the
case study of 30 shelter dogs, sharp transection application of that method. This should then be
of the suspensory ligament was compared to used as one’s primary method; after this exper
digital strumming with regard to surgical time, tise has been acquired, a secondary method
complications, and measures of intraoperative should be similarly developed for the unusual
and post‐operative pain (Shivley et al. 2019). case where the primary method is unusable or
Sharp transection was found to yield a 36‐sec not recommended in a particular situation.
ond shorter overall surgical time; however, no Another, much less common cause of frank
other significant differences were noted intraoperative hemorrhage is the laceration of
between the two methods. Thus, it would an abdominal vessel or organ. The most com
appear that various methods for suspensory lig mon abdominal organ to be unintentionally
ament transection can be performed safely lacerated is the spleen (see Figure 17.1). Several
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 17.1 (a) Splenic laceration caused by a spay hook. (b) Suture the splenic capsule at the site of the
laceration. (c) Absorbable hemostatic sponge placed over the repair.
Complications of Ovariohysterectomy 343
reports of this complication are found in the novice surgeons, and of having not a few
literature, and the author is aware of several complications referred for correction.
such cases; however, in each instance the hem
orrhage was controlled with the application of 1) Obtain adequate visualization. All too often
pressure on minor lacerations and mattress when an unexpected bleed occurs intraop
sutures on larger ones, and no mortality was eratively, the surgeon will attempt to use
reported. traction alone to locate the bleed, in an
Oozing hemorrhage can also originate from effort to avoid having to enlarge the inci
errors in ligation technique: partial loosening sion. Instead, when any significantly con
of a ligature may result in mild oozing rather cerning bleed occurs, the “small incision”
than massive bleeding. Oozing hemorrhage should be abandoned and immediately con
may also be patient related. Bitches who are verted to a large enough laparotomy to
either currently in heat or have recently been properly explore the caudal abdomen. This
in heat may have deficient clotting; endoge does not necessarily mean a full xyphoid‐
nous estrogens have been hypothesized to be at to‐pubis incision, but rather enough of an
least partly responsible. Anticoagulant roden enlargement to be able to get one’s hands
ticides may have been ingested in low doses and eyes into the abdomen without a feel
without causing signs. These patients usually ing of having to struggle for adequate room
respond to empirical treatment with vitamin to get a good view. Most often, the time
K. Certain breeds such as the Doberman saved by not struggling for visualization
pincher are more likely to present with inher will more than make up for the extra time
ited disorders of coagulation (von Willebrand’s spent in closure. More importantly, the
disease). The medical history will not always bleeding can be quickly and definitively
reveal these patients and screening tests (acti addressed, without creating undue risk of
vated clotting time, buccal mucosal bleeding causing yet another unintended complica
time) should be employed when the index of tion such as ureteral trauma.
suspicion is high. Blood products should 2) As soon as significant uncontrolled hemor
always be available. This does not necessarily rhage is recognized intraoperatively, a
mean that fresh whole blood must be kept on scrubbed‐in assistant should be utilized
hand (though it may be recommended in cer whenever possible. Particularly with the
tain situations); a supply of blood from a desig obese patient, an assistant can prove invalu
nated donor(s) may be perfectly adequate to able in aiding retraction and can also pro
meet any anticipated need, as long as blood vide suction to aid visualization. Also note
collection materials are kept in stock and there that the middle of a surgical emergency is a
is ready access to donors and an efficient, rather poor time to attempt to train an assis
timely, and well‐practiced protocol for blood tant in operating room technique and pro
collection. It is also wise to consider assem tocol – conduct regular training exercises
bling an autotransfusion kit for use in cases of with the technicians or volunteers who will
abdominal hemorrhage. be assisting you, so that they will be ready
to help when you need them.
Managing Intraoperative Hemorrhage The vast 3) If a scrubbed‐in assistant is not available, use
majority of intraoperative complications will self‐retaining retractors. Every HQHVSN
manifest as acute hemorrhage; as such, the clinic and shelter operating room should
treatment is simple: locate and correct the have a minimum of two sets of Balfour
source of the bleeding. The following retractors available: a large set for large and
recommendations have been gleaned from the medium dogs, and a small set for small dogs
experiences of teaching spay and neuter to and cats.
344 17 Complications in Spay and Neuter Surgery
(a)
Figure 17.2 (a and b) Emancipet protocol for autotransfusion. AST, assistant surgery technician; Sx, surgery.
3) If the hemoabdomen is severe, pooled syringe tip and begin to suction the blood.
blood will flow out as soon as the abdomen As the level of blood in the abdomen
is opened. Open the abdomen enough to decreases, the incision can be opened more
introduce the extension set (if used) or fully to provide visualization and access.
(b)
_____ 2 – Blood collection bag: Dry 600 ml bag with Luer attachment to donor animal and
single or dual “spike ports” to attach blood filtration set (for example, Jorgensen J0520C)
_____ 2 – Blood administration sets with standard blood filter (for example, Baxter 2C6700)
_____ 6 – Extension sets – 30″
_____ 2 – Three‐way stopcocks with two female and one male Luer Lock fittings (for example,
Jorgensen J0462)
_____ 2 – Liters NaCl (saline) 0.9% solution
_____ 2 – Sterile gauze packs
_____ 2 – Packs sterile sponges
_____ 2 – Sterile 60 cc syringes (Luer Lock)
_____ 4 – Sterile individual packets 3‐0 on taper needles
_____ 2 – Sterile packages of GelFoam
_____ 2 – Gelpi retractors
_____ 2 – Allis tissue forceps
_____ 2 – Strainers (stainless‐steel mesh drain strainer or tea strainer)
4) It is common for omentum and other 7) Blood for autotransfusion may be adminis
abdominal contents to occlude the suction tered IV at a rate of 5 ml per second, or at
tip. The use of a sterilized metal tea strainer the speed that the filter will allow.
to hold back the abdominal contents while
allowing the passage of blood toward the Iatrogenic Ureteral Trauma
suction tip can help avoid these blockages. This complication usually occurs during efforts
5) If a blood collection bag is to be used in the to recover a dropped or torn ovarian pedicle, as
process, follow the Emancipet protocol in the ureter is at risk for being traumatized dur
Figure 17.2. ing attempts to grasp the ovarian pedicle. As
6) If a blood collection bag is not being used, the with all complications, this problem is best
surgeon or an assistant can use a sterile 60 cc solved by anticipation and avoidance. Measures
syringe to withdraw pooled blood from the to ensure retention of the pedicle and to reduce
abdomen. It may be helpful to use a sterile the risk of tearing should be part of every sur
extension set attached to the syringe to facili geon’s technique. Although these measures
tate access to areas of pooled blood deep in will vary to a certain extent between surgeons,
the body cavity. Once the syringe is full of all are similar in that they are readily incorpo
blood or nearly so, it can be handed to a vet rated to become a natural part of every spay–
erinary technician who then administers the neuter surgical procedure.
blood through a blood filter (Hemo‐Nate®, Even for the highly experienced spay sur
Jorgensen Laboratories, Loveland, CO; or geon, a pedicle may occasionally be dropped or
other inline filter) into the IV catheter. This torn. In these instances, increasing the expo
may be repeated as many times as necessary sure and the availability of suction and self‐
with new sterile syringes, although if more retaining retractors can greatly improve
than two syringes of blood are salvaged from visualization and help reduce the risk of ure
the abdomen, managing the multiple syringes teral trauma. Every spay–neuter surgeon
will become cumbersome and use of a blood should be completely conversant with the basic
collection bag would be more appropriate. techniques for visualization of the ovarian
348 17 Complications in Spay and Neuter Surgery
pedicle via retraction of the mesoduodenum on patient with a serious ongoing bleed should be
the right side of the abdomen, and the mesoco returned to surgery so that the source of the
lon on the left. hemorrhage can be rectified. Once these
Some experienced spay–neuter surgeons patients return to surgery, the steps for address
have described retrieving a ureter with the ing the source of the hemorrhage are the same
spay hook during routine spay, or having a ure as if the bleeding was noted during the original
ter elevate along with a uterine horn, either surgery, including the possibility for autotrans
during retrieval or when following the first fusion (see previous sections).
horn past the bifurcation to the second horn. Recognition of post‐operative abdominal
This appears to be a particular risk in some bleeding is not always straightforward, and
puppies, as their ureters may be less taut and often does not result in bleeding from the
more tortuous than in the adult, and they may incision, especially in the early stages. The
have less retroperitoneal fat obscuring and pro index of suspicion for abdominal bleeding
tecting the ureter. The surgeons who have had should be increased in patients with unusu
this experience describe the tension, appear ally slow recovery (recumbent for longer than
ance, size, and retrieval location as being very expected), moderate hypothermia that is less
similar to those of a uterine horn. Failure to responsive to warming than expected, an ele
locate an ovary at the end of the ureter reveals vated heart rate without obvious other signs
the error, but in some cases the ureter breaks of pain or excitement, and pale mucous mem
due to the tension placed on it by the surgeon. branes. If blood pressure monitoring is avail
In these cases, removal of the affected kidney able, a low blood pressure – and particularly a
(nephrectomy) is often the most viable treat falling blood pressure – together with tachy
ment and one that can be performed in‐house, cardia prompts even greater suspicion of
whereas ureteral repair or reimplantation gen blood loss. Packed cell volume (PCV) is not a
erally requires referral to a specialist. sensitive indicator of recent hemorrhage
(Giger 2011), so should not be used to indicate
the presence or severity of hemoabdomen
Post‐operative Complications
during the first several hours. Blood loss into
Fortunately, most post‐operative complica the abdomen causes hypovolemia, not
tions are minor and easily handled. In this cat hemodilution, so except when aggressive IV
egory would be minor incisional issues such as fluid replacement has been attempted and the
poorly coapted edges, minor contusions, local intravascular volume has been restored, these
infections, exposed suture knots, and the like. patients may have minimal drop in PCV
Recognition and resolution of these problems despite having lost a substantial amount of
should already be well within the capability of blood into the abdomen.
the reader and so will not be covered. To assess for hemoabdomen, an abdomino
centesis can be performed in the recumbent ani
Early Post‐operative Hemorrhage mal with a 22‐gauge needle attached to a 3 cc
and Hemoabdomen syringe. The skin should be aseptically prepared,
In some cases, rather than becoming apparent and the needle introduced caudal to the umbili
during the surgery, intraabdominal bleeding cus near the midline or a few centimeters to the
occurs during the recovery and post‐operative right of the midline in order to avoid puncturing
period. Many of these cases become apparent the spleen. Draw back gently on the plunger of
within the first 12 hours after surgery: on the the syringe to create slight negative pressure. If
recovery beach, in the cage after surgery, or the blood flows easily into the syringe, this is
later the first evening, although some may take diagnostic for hemoabdomen; however, if the
longer to become obvious. Once recognized, a abdominocentesis does not produce blood,
Complications of Ovariohysterectomy 349
abdominal bleeding cannot be ruled out. In this method. Even with an intradermal closure,
case it is wise to continue monitoring the patient, self‐trauma can become a problem if the suture
giving fluids as needed, warming the patient, knot is too large (too many throws and/or too
and consider repeating the abdominocentesis if large a suture gauge) or otherwise buried too
clinical signs do not improve. shallowly, barely beneath the epidermis. In
these patients it is common for an inflamma
Dehiscence tory response to the irritation of the knot (a
Dehiscence (failure of the surgical closure) can “suture reaction”) to occur, inviting unwanted
have catastrophic consequences, although attention by the patient. Any time a patient has
thankfully it usually does not. Dehiscence may been demonstrated or is even suspected to be a
involve the skin and subcutis only, the muscu chewing/licking risk, they should be sent
lar body wall and its fascia, or full thickness home wearing an Elizabethan collar, rather
(see Figure 17.3). A common etiology for skin than the clinic waiting for a problem and hav
dehiscence (which often progresses to full ing to deal with it. These collars should be
thickness) is self‐trauma: the patient licks and/ available at all times in the practice, in a proper
or chews open the skin closure. This problem selection of sizes for all patients. In addition,
in turn usually has a root cause related to tech the staff must be trained how to properly fit
nical error in suturing, as a patient will gener one to the patient – few things are as discour
ally leave a comfortable closure alone. Skin aging as getting a dog back with a dehisced
sutures placed too tightly are commonly to incision, wearing an Elizabethan collar that
blame here. When skin sutures are placed, care was too short.
must be taken to avoid making them overly A second common cause of skin dehiscence
snug, which would cause the sutures to cut (particularly with continuous intradermal clo
into the skin as it swells post‐operatively (par sures) is due to faulty knot tying technique. Body
ticularly in dogs). Because of the risks of skin wall dehiscence is usually caused by failure to
sutures, and for patient comfort and client engage the external rectus sheath in each bite of
convenience, in most situations a continuous the body wall closure. Long ago, research has
(buried) intradermal closure is the preferred shown that the external rectus sheath, not the
Figure 17.3 Dehiscence. (a) Body wall dehiscence in a cat surrendered to a shelter about 1.5 years after
spay. It is unknown how long after the spay the body wall herniation occurred, but the skin appears well
healed over the defect. Poor knot technique in the original surgery was suspected as the cause. Source:
Photo courtesy of Kayla Beetham. (b) Full‐thickness dehiscence in a feral cat. The dehiscence was due to
poor knot technique in a simple interrupted suture closure. The cat was still in her trap when dehiscence
occurred, so treatment was prompt and the cat survived. Source: Photo courtesy of Julie Levy. (c) Full‐
thickness dehiscence in a puppy one day after spay. The dehiscence occurred because the sutures that were
intended to be in the linea alba were only in the subcutaneous layer, and the external rectus sheath had
not been engaged. Source: Photo courtesy of Brian DiGangi.
350 17 Complications in Spay and Neuter Surgery
peritoneum, is the strongest layer (“holding and can occur after orchiectomy as well as after
layer”) in abdominal wall closure. spay. Adherence to Halstead’s surgical princi
ples is the best plan for avoidance of incisional
Repair of Dehiscence Repair of dehiscence infections. This does not necessarily mean
with evisceration of abdominal contents can gowning and full surgical regalia, however.
be successful. In a study that included eight Attention to the creation of a healthy surgical
spay dehiscences (four dogs, four cats), all wound (gentle tissue handling, hemostasis,
survived to discharge (Gower et al. 2009). In minimization of dead space, reduction of anes
these patients, dehiscence and evisceration thetic and operative time, and use of only the
had occurred a median of four days (range one minimum number of sutures of the smallest
to six days) post‐spay. In half of the patients, possible gauge) should be the focus.
the evisceration had occurred during the night
when the patient was not observed; in these Reactions
patients, the incision may have been open for Reaction to buried sutures and/or surgical
many hours prior to repair. adhesives can be seen during the weeks fol
To repair a dehiscence with evisceration, lowing surgery (Figure 17.6). Generally one
patients will require anesthesia, lavage of the of two types of problems is encountered. The
exposed viscera, surgical exploration of the first is the so‐called suture reaction; the
abdomen, replacement of abdominal viscera author’s hypothesis is that in nearly all cases,
into the peritoneal cavity, and repair of the this is not, as the name implies, an immuno
body wall. In some cases, it may be necessary logic reaction to the suture material, but
to resect a portion of the intestine if damage rather an inflammatory response to the physi
has occurred to the intestine itself or to its cal characteristics of the closure. The evi
blood supply. Antibiotic therapy and support dence for this statement is that this problem is
ive care will also be required. seen exclusively (or nearly so) at the ends of
the closure, where the knots are located.
Incisional Infections Typically, a large‐gauge suture of a fairly stiff,
Of course surgical infections (Figures 17.4 and monofilament material has been used, and
17.5) occur for a variety of reasons, some of usually an excessive number of throws have
which are not under the control of the surgeon, been employed. Also it is quite common to
(a) (b)
Figure 17.4 Incisional infections after spay. (a) Incision infection without skin dehiscence in a dog. Source:
Photo courtesy of Sara White. (b) Incision infection and skin dehiscence in a cat following spay. Source:
Photo courtesy of Brian DiGangi.
Complications of Ovariohysterectomy 351
Figure 17.5 Infections following castration. (a) Infection following neutering in a cat – appearance on
presentation; (b) appearance after debridement. (c) Incision infection and skin dehiscence in a dog
following pre‐scrotal castration. Source: Photos courtesy of Brian DiGangi.
(a) (b)
Figure 17.13 (a) Hemoscrotum approximately four hours post‐castration. The scrotum is swollen to
several times its pre‐operative size. Surgical exploration revealed a bleeding spermatic cord, which was
re‐ligated. (b) A scrotal ablation was performed, and the dog was discharged the same day. Source: Photos
courtesy of Sara White.
patient factors, surgeon factors, and institu pedicle or other causes), was reported. In canine
tional factors. Therefore, in most if not all cases patients the reported complication rate was 16%
of major complications, it is advisable at least to (Shaver et al. 2019). The complication rates
consult with a surgical specialist, and in many reported in these studies are roughly compara
instances to refer the case if that option is open. ble and, based on comments by the authors of
the papers (“low,” “very encouraging”), these
rates were apparently seen in a generally posi
Complications tive light. However, these reported complication
and the Spay–Neuter rates of student‐surgeons do appear to be sig
Teaching Program nificantly higher than those seen in well‐run
shelter surgery programs that rely exclusively
No current chapter of complications in spay on shelter DVMs to perform all surgery.
and neuter surgery would be complete without In contrast, a large retrospective study of
a discussion of complications seen during the over 10 000 spay and neuter surgeries com
teaching of spay and neuter to veterinary stu pared the complication rates of DVM student‐
dents. This is true because of two major shifts surgeons and shelter veterinarians (Kreisler
in the surgical training of veterinary students: et al. 2018). The overall complication rates for
the first being the shift to spay and neuter sur student‐surgeons (1.63%) and shelter veteri
gery as the primary (and in many cases the narians (1.26%) were low, and no statistical dif
only) clinical vehicle to teach surgical skills to ference was seen. Careful case selection was
veterinary students; and the second, which fol stressed by the authors as one of the reasons
lows logically from the first, the increasing role for low complications among the student‐sur
of animal shelters as partners with veterinary geons in this study. Another review of 1880
colleges and schools to provide animals, facili spay surgeries found a direct correlation
ties, and expertise to help students acquire sur between increasing bodyweight and complica
gical skills. These changes mean that for many tion rate (Muraro and White 2014); perhaps
shelters, a significant proportion of the ani student‐surgeons should not be assigned obese
mals that are surgically sterilized are operated patients for spay surgery, or at least not with
upon by veterinary students rather than by out an experienced surgeon scrubbed in to
shelter doctor of veterinary medicine (DVM) assist.
surgeons. Although partnerships for student training
Several studies have been conducted at veteri offers benefits to the animal shelter and veteri
nary colleges which have reported on spay and nary college (Snowden et al. 2008), such rela
neuter complications seen with student‐sur tionships also impose significant burdens and
geons. In one retrospective study of shelter ani additional responsibilities on both parties
mals (301 cats and 201 dogs) spayed over a (Smeak 2008; Snowden et al. 2008). While
five‐year span at a veterinary teaching hospital most teaching/shelter partnerships share cer
by third‐year veterinary students, 3.3% major tain common features, there are also innumer
and 9.5% minor surgical complications were able small details that make each program
reported. The most common major complica unique, and broad advice is therefore of lim
tion (15/17) was abdominal wall dehiscence, ited value. One general recommendation that
and the most common minor complication was can be made is that the shelter and veterinary
seroma formation (35/49). In another retrospec school must make a diligent effort to discuss
tive review of 1288 gonadectomies performed and agree who will train, how much interven
by second‐year veterinary students, an overall tion and when, who will treat complications,
rate of 8.2% of intraoperative complications, all and who pays for them – and these are only a
relating to excessive hemorrhage (torn/dropped few of the details. Whether from the shelter’s
Prevention of Surgical Complications 357
There are two basic formats for checklists, by the same personnel every time. This means
the READ‐DO list and the DO‐CONFIRM list the same person (in most institutions probably
(Gawande 2010). The READ‐DO list is admin an anesthesia technician, not the surgeon)
istered just as the name states: each item is should ask the questions, although the
read from the list and then performed. This responses may not all come from one person.
type of list is most practical when the tasks on The logical time to perform the checklist is
the list are not needed until the list is read, and immediately prior to an event that would be
each task can be completed in a moment; an influenced by the results of the list; therefore,
example would be a pre‐flight checklist. The it is not surprising that with an important and/
DO‐CONFIRM form is appropriate when the or complicated undertaking with multiple crit
items on the list need to be performed in ical stages, more than one checklist is per
advance of the time the list is read, and/or formed. For example, the ground crew of an
when the items take a significant amount of aircraft will perform a final maintenance/read
time to perform; this format is a more practical iness checklist before the aircraft is released to
one for a surgical list. the flight crew, who in turn perform a pre‐
The specific details of a surgical checklist will flight checklist before taxiing to the runway. In
vary somewhat according to the institution; the same way, the benefit of checklists in a
however, every well‐designed checklist should high‐production surgical environment can
have certain basic features. The checklist only be maximized when a checklist is
should be brief, so as not to become burden employed at each strategic juncture. For this
some. In ordinary surgical situations in human reason, a “pre‐induction” checklist should be
medicine, it should take no more than one to performed just prior to induction, and then a
two minutes to run through the checklist. In final “pre‐surgical” checklist before the actual
the HQHVSN or animal shelter spay–neuter start of the procedure.
scenario, with a very limited number of surgi The following is an example of the items for
cal options and rapid turnaround of cases, a a pre‐induction checklist for an HQHVSN
more realistic time for a pre‐surgical checklist clinic or animal shelter that operates an exclu
would probably be closer to 30 seconds. Besides sively spay and neuter surgery service on a
being brief, the checklist must be relevant – only combination of client‐owned and shelter‐
items that will make a difference to the actions owned dogs and cats:
of the surgical team or that could affect the out
1) What is the name of the client and the
come are included. For example, verification of
name of the patient?
the sex of the patient is relevant, whereas exact
2) Has the surgical release form been signed?
knowledge and verification of the patient’s age
3) Has the sex of the patient been verified?
are probably not. The checklist must be clear
4) Has the patient been fasted for the appro
and simple. Each question or statement is to
priate length of time (shorter for a pediatric
worded so that it expresses a single, clear
patient)?
thought: What is the patient’s name/ID? Do we
5) Are there any other procedures besides spay–
have a signed authorization/waiver? and so on.
neuter to perform, such as microchipping?
There should be no ambiguous or open‐ended
6) What is the patient’s American Society of
questions, and most should be formatted
Anesthesiologists (ASA) status?
for yes/no or other single‐word responses.
7) Are there any special anesthetic or surgical
The checklist should be consistent in its admin
concerns or risks (e.g. cryptorchid,
istration. It should be used on every patient
Doberman – Von Willebrand, etc.)?
regardless of the perceived level of risk, just as
a pre‐flight checklist is used before every flight Once the patient is on the operating table,
regardless of distance or flying conditions usually after draping but before the start of
involved. The checklist should be administered the surgical procedure, a second and final
Final Comments – Toward Zero Complications 359
checklist is performed, which may contain this culture into the clinic and shelter staff.
questions such as these or similar ones: This is not an impossible or unreasonable
position. To the contrary, it is the only truly
1) Reconfirm patient/client name? (In a large,
reasonable position for any veterinarian who
high‐volume setting with multiple patients
performs surgery, for that push to perfection
being prepped and multiple surgeons work
not only fuels improvement, but also lends sig
ing at the same time, this is a good idea)
nificance to our work, because it is only
2) Reconfirm procedure(s)?
because each outcome is important that we
3) Reproductive status (females – e.g. estrus,
continue to strive for nothing less than a per
pregnant, pyometra)?
fect outcome, every time. And this attitude in
4) Special surgical concerns (such as unusual
surgery can and will certainly carry over into
bleeding anticipated)?
all other aspects of the clinic or animal shelter,
5) Surgical gauze sponge count verified?
so that it can become what inspires an average
For convenience, both checklists can be program to become good, and a good one to
printed on the same piece of paper. At this become great.
point it may seem redundant and burden How are these goals implemented?
some to go through not one but two check Because spay–neuter programs differ so
lists before each surgical procedure; however, widely with regard to the starting point in
remember that the checklist is very brief, and terms of performance, available resources,
once one is accustomed to its use, it becomes delivery model, and case load, the improve
almost automatic. The author uses a similar ment program must be individualized to the
checklist in the operating room and it takes individual practice. However, here are a few
no more than 10–15 seconds to go through general suggestions:
the list for most patients. In a fairly busy
HQHVSN surgical service in which each sur 1) Work on developing a cohesive surgical
geon may perform 20–30 procedures in a day, team. Hold regular short, informal meet
this only adds from 3 to 7 minutes of addi ings on relevant surgical topics – encourage
tional time over the course of the day – a everyone to contribute their thoughts. Keep
small price to pay for the security and confi it fun and positive.
dence of knowing that everything is correct 2) Invest your time in training the surgical
at the start. team. You are the expert, and they look to
you for information and leadership.
3) Cross‐train team members so that anyone
Final Comments – Toward can perform any function, but allow each
Zero Complications staff member to find their favorite role
(anesthetist, scrub nurse, post‐operative
This chapter began with a discussion of the care, etc.) and encourage them to develop
incidence of surgical complications in the busy in that area to their full potential.
spay–neuter operating room, how the sheer 4) Commit to conducting morbidity and mor
volume of procedures performed virtually tality rounds on a regular schedule (monthly
ensures that a certain number of complica is good). Required attendance, DVMs and
tions will occur each year, and yet the percep lay staff, non‐punitive environment.
tion and expectation are that nothing should 5) Require a post‐mortem exam on any patient
ever go wrong. How does the conscientious that dies in hospital.
HQHVSN surgeon reconcile these opposing 6) Insist that the clinic buy excellent quality
positions? Through adopting a personal atti surgical instruments – the best it can
tude of a continual push toward the perfect afford – and then insist that everyone
goal of zero complications, and inculcating respect and take good care of them.
360 17 Complications in Spay and Neuter Surgery
References
Cole, L.P. and Humm, K. (2019). Twelve Oszvald, Á., Vatter, H., Byhahn, C. et al. (2012).
autologous blood transfusions in eight cats “Team time‐out” and surgical safety‐
with haemoperitoneum. J. Feline Med. Surg. experiences in 12,390 neurosurgical patients.
21 (6): 481–487. Neurosurg. Focus. 33 (5): E6. https://doi.org/
Collins, S.J., Newhouse, R., Porter, J., and 10.3171/2012.8.FOCUS12261.
Talsma, A. (2014). Effectiveness of the surgical Pearson, H. (1973). The complications of
safety checklist in correcting errors: a ovariohysterectomy in the bitch*. J. Small
literature review applying Reason’s Swiss Anim. Pract. 14 (5): 257–266. https://doi.
cheese model. AORN J. 100 (1): 65–79.e5. org/10.1111/j.1748‐5827.1973.tb06457.x.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aorn.2013.07.024. Peeters, M.E. and Kirpensteijn, J. (2011).
Cray, M.T., Selmic, L.E., McConnell, B.M. et al. Comparison of surgical variables and short‐
(2018). Effect of implementation of a surgical term postoperative complications in healthy
safety checklist on perioperative and dogs undergoing ovariohysterectomy or
postoperative complications at an academic ovariectomy. JAVMA 238 (2): 189–194. https://
institution in North America. Vet. Surg. 47 (8): doi.org/10.2460/javma.238.2.189.
1052–1065. https://doi.org/10.1111/vsu.12964. Pollari, F.L. and Bonnett, B.N. (1996). Evaluation
Gawande, A. (2010). The Checklist Manifesto: of postoperative complications following
How to Get Things Right. New York: elective surgeries of dogs and cats at private
Metropolitan Books. practices using computer records. Can. Vet. J.
Giger, U. (2011). Managing bleeding disorders 37 (6): 672–678.
(Proceedings). dvm360 (1 October). http:// Robinson, D.A., Kiefer, K., Bassett, R., and
veterinarycalendar.dvm360.com/managing‐ Quandt, J. (2016). Autotransfusion in dogs
bleeding‐disorders‐proceedings (accessed 22 using a 2‐syringe technique. J. Vet. Emerg. Crit.
March 2019). Care 26: 766–774.
Gower, S.B., Weisse, C.W., and Brown, D.C. Shaver, S.L., Larrosa, M., and Hofmeister, E.H.
(2009). Major abdominal evisceration injuries (2019). Factors affecting the duration of
in dogs and cats: 12 cases (1998–2008). anesthesia and surgery of canine and feline
JAVMA 234: 1566–1572. gonadectomies performed by veterinary
Hamilton, K.H., Henderson, E.R., Toscano, M., students in a year‐long preclinical surgery
and Chanoit, G.P. (2014). Comparison of laboratory. Vet. Surg https://doi.org/10.1111/
postoperative complications in healthy dogs vsu.13163.
undergoing open and closed orchidectomy. J. Shivley, J.M., Richardson, J.M., Woodruff, K.A.
Small Anim. Pract. 55 (10): 521–526. https:// et al. (2019). Sharp transection of the
doi.org/10.1111/jsap.12266. suspensory ligament as an alternative to
Kreisler, R.E., Shaver, S.L., and Holmes, J.H. digital strumming during canine
(2018). Outcomes of elective gonadectomy ovariohysterectomy. Vet. Surg. 48 (2): 216–221.
procedures performed on dogs and cats by https://doi.org/10.1111/vsu.13121.
veterinary students and shelter veterinarians Smeak, D.D. (2008). Teaching veterinary
in a shelter environment. JAVMA. 253 (10): students using shelter animals. J. Vet. Med.
1294–1299. https://doi.org/10.2460/ Educ. 35 (1): 26–30. https://doi.org/10.3138/
javma.253.10.1294. jvme.35.1.026.
Muraro, L. and White, R.S. (2014). Complications Snowden, K., Bice, K., Craig, T. et al. (2008).
of ovariohysterectomy procedures performed Vertically integrated educational collaboration
in 1880 dogs. Tierarztl Prax. Ausg. K. Klientiere between a college of veterinary medicine and
Heimtiere. 42 (5): 297–302. a non‐profit animal shelter. J. Vet. Med. Educ.
References 361
18
Ovarian remnant syndrome (ORS) is the It has been demonstrated in cats that pieces
presence of functional ovarian tissue in a pre- of ovarian tissue sutured to the peritoneum
viously ovariohysterectomized bitch or queen will revascularize and become functional,
(Wallace 1991). The true incidence is not causing signs of estrus (Shemwell and Weed
reported, likely due to subtle clinical signs in 1970; DeNardo et al. 2001). There is no strong
some animals, lack of pursuit of veterinary correlation between likelihood of ORS as a
care by some owners, and lack of prospective complication of OHE and years of experience
studies. One retrospective study reported ovar- of the surgeon, age of the animal at the time of
ian remnants in 29 of 9976 (0.3%) of feline sub- OHE, or breed of the animal (Miller 1995; Ball
missions to a veterinary diagnostic laboratory et al. 2010). Exposure to estrogen‐containing
and 17 of 42 401 (0.04%) of canine submissions medications, including oral or topical estrogen
(Miller 1995). preparations used by the owner, may cause
clinical signs indicative of estrus (Schwarze
and Threlfall 2008). There is one report of signs
Causes of apparent ORS due to presence of a func-
tional adrenocortical carcinoma in a cat (Meler
Reported causes are surgeon error and pres- et al. 2011).
ence of ectopic or accessory ovarian tissue that
becomes functional after removal of the main
ovary; presence of such tissue has been Avoiding Ovarian Remnant
reported in humans, cows, and cats and is con- Syndrome
sidered very rare in domestic animals (McEntee
1990). However, one study (Altera and Miller This condition is at its root a surgical technical
1986) reported that all of the specimens of problem. This complication can be avoided by
parovarian nodules encountered during ovari- obtaining adequate exposure of the ovarian
ohysterectomy (OHE) of 17 healthy female pedicle to facilitate visual and/or palpable con-
cats aged six months to five years were identi- firmation of ovarian location before ligature
fied histologically as ectopic adrenocortical tis- placement. If the surgeon has anything less
sue (see Chapter 2), and a more recent study than 100% certainty of complete ovarian
also failed to find any ovarian tissue in 73 feline removal, before commencing closure the
ovarian pedicle nodules (Haase‐Berglund and removed reproductive tract should be inspected
Premanandan 2019). for two entire ovaries. If two complete ovaries
364 18 Ovarian Remnant Syndrome
are not confirmed to be excised, the abdomen Physical exam and history are important in
must be explored, beginning with the ovarian the assessment of whether ORS is likely and
pedicles as the most likely locations. If a pedi- whether further diagnostic testing and treat-
cle has been torn, an ovary or ovarian fragment ment are indicated. Owners or caretakers
may have torn free and be loose in the abdo- should be questioned regarding actual
men. Such fragments can become revascular- observed physical and behavioral signs to con-
ized and cause ORS; therefore, every effort firm that these signs are indicative of estrus.
must be made to locate and remove them. Not all owners are aware of the different signs
Although not technically ORS, related con- of estrus in different species; for example, cat
ditions worth noting are the rare develop- owners may believe that blood in the urine is a
mental anomalies of unicornate uterus and sign of feline estrus. Similarly, dog owners may
segmental agenesis. In these patients, an iso- mistake hematuria due to urinary tract infec-
lated ovary will very likely still develop on tion or urolithiasis for estrus despite lack of
the side which is lacking the uterine horn. vulvar swelling. History may also be useful in
This unattached ovary may be located as far determining whether exposure to exogenous
cranially as the diaphragm and is easy to miss hormones is possible. Owners may be able to
if a complete abdominal exploration is not indicate possible sources of exposure, and may
performed. also be able to comment on the cyclicity (or
lack of cyclicity) of the pet’s signs of estrus.
Surgical Treatment
Exploratory laparotomy can be performed
Figure 18.3 Large, cystic ovarian remnant from a
when the animal is in behavioral estrus, in cat with intermittent signs of behavioral estrus.
which case the surgeon is looking for follicular Source: Photo courtesy of Brenda Griffin.
tissue, or two to three weeks after spontaneous
or induced luteinization, in which case the sur- disagree as to the most common location of
geon is looking for luteal tissue. The advantage unilateral remnants; most studies report that
of the latter is that there may be less bleeding unilateral ovarian remnants are found more
during diestrus, due to lower serum estrogen consistently on the right side (Wallace 1991;
concentrations, and corpora lutea persist Miller 1995; Ball et al. 2010).
longer than follicles. However, most surgeons All ovarian tissue removed should be sub-
find it much easier to locate remnant ovarian mitted for histopathology. Reported findings
tissue when the exploratory surgery is carried include follicles and follicular cysts, solid and
out during behavioral estrus (Figure 18.3). The cystic corporea lutea, paraovarian cysts, and
residual tissue almost always is at one or both tumors including granulosa cell tumors, cys-
ovarian pedicles (Wallace 1991; Miller 1995; tadenomas, and teratomas (Wallace 1991; Ball
Evers et al. 1996; England 1997; Sangster 2005), et al. 2010; Gunzel‐Apel et al. 2012). If the
but may be found elsewhere in the abdomen or uterine stump is enlarged, it also should be
even in the body wall or subcutaneous layer of resected and submitted for histopathology.
the original incision. If no obvious ovarian tis- Reported findings at the uterine stump include
sue is present, granulation tissue at the ovarian cystic endometrial hyperplasia, pyometra, and
pedicles should be removed. Occasionally, neoplasia (Root Kustritz and Rudolph 2001;
entire ovaries may be found. Another reported Ball et al. 2010; Anderson and Pratschke 2011).
finding is absence of the kidney and ureter on Prognosis for decline in clinical signs after
the same side on which an ovary or remnant is complete removal of all abnormal tissue is
found (England 1997). Retrospective studies excellent.
References
Altera, K.P. and Miller, L.N. (1986). Recognition Axner, E., Gustavsson, T., and Strom Holst, B.
of feline parovarian nodules as ectopic (2008). Estradiol measurement after
adrenocortical tissue. JAVMA 189 (1): 71–72. GnRH‐stimulation as a method to diagnose
Anderson, C. and Pratschke, K. (2011). Uterine the presence of ovaries in the female
adenocarcinoma with abdominal metastases domestic cat. Theriogenology 70:
in an ovariohysterectomised cat. J. Feline Med. 186–191.
Surg. 13: 44–47.
368 18 Ovarian Remnant Syndrome
Ball, R.L., Birchard, S.J., May, L.R. et al. (2010). after an injection of a gonadotrophin as a test
Ovarian remnant syndrome in dogs and cats: for neutered bitches. Vet. Rec. 146: 599.
21 cases (2000–2007). JAVMA 236: 548–553. Kutzler, M. and Wood, A. (2006). Non‐surgical
Buijtels, J.J.C.W.M., DeGier, J., Kooistra, H.S. methods of contraception and sterilization.
et al. (2011). The pituitary‐ovarian axis in dogs Theriogenology 66: 514–525.
with remnant ovarian tissue. Theriogenology LeRoux, P.H. and VanDerWalt, L.A. (1977).
75: 742–751. Ovarian autograft as an alternative to
Burke, T.J. (1978). Mibolerone studies in the cat. ovariectomy in bitches. J. S. Afr. Vet. Assoc. 48:
Proceedings, Symposium on Cheque™ for 117–123.
canine estrus prevention, Augusta, MI. Lofstedt, R.M. and VanLeeuwen, J.A. (2002).
Davies, N.L. (1989). Complications of ovarian Evaluation of a commercially available
autotransplantation in bitches. J. S. Afr. Vet. luteinizing hormone test for its ability to
Assoc. 60: 145. distinguish between ovariectomized and
Demirel, M.A. and Acar, D.B. (2012). Ovarian sexually intact bitches. JAVMA 220:
remnant syndrome and uterine stump 1331–1335.
pyometra in three queens. J. Feline Med. Surg. Magtibay, P.M. and Magrina, J.F. (2006). Ovarian
14: 913–918. remnant syndrome. Clin. Obstetr. Gynecol. 49:
DeNardo, G.A., Becker, K., Brown, N.O. et al. 526–534.
(2001). Ovarian remnant syndrome: McEntee, K. (1990). The ovary. In: Reproductive
revascularization of free‐floating ovarian Pathology of Domestic Mammals (ed. M.
tissue in the female abdominal cavity. J. Am. McEntee), 31–51. San Diego, CA: Academic
Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 37: 290–296. Press.
England, G.C.W. (1997). Confirmation of ovarian Meler, E.N., Scott‐Moncrieff, C., Peter, A.T. et al.
remnant syndrome in the queen using hCG (2011). Cyclic estrous‐like behavior in a
administration. Vet. Rec. 141: 309–310. spayed cat associated with excessive sex‐
Evers, P., Kramek, B.A., and Root, M.V. (1996). hormone production by an adrenocortical
Intestinal pseudodiverticulosis in a cat. J. Am. carcinoma. J. Feline Med. Surg. 13: 473–478.
Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 32: 291–293. Miller, D.M. (1995). Ovarian remnant syndrome
Goericke‐Pesch, S. (2010). Reproduction control in dogs and cats: 46 cases (1988–1992). J. Vet.
in cats: new developments in non‐surgical Diagn. Invest. 7: 572–574.
methods. J. Feline Med. Surg. 12: 539–546. Olson, P.N., Mulnix, J.A., and Nett, T.M. (1992).
Gunzel‐Apel, A.‐R., Buschhaus, J., Urhausen, C. Concentrations of luteinizing hormone and
et al. (2012). Clinical signs, diagnostic follicle‐stimulating hormone in the serum of
approach and therapy regarding the ovarian sexually intact and neutered dogs. Am. J. Vet.
remnant syndrome in the bitch. Tierarztl. Res. 53: 762–766.
Prax. 40 (K): 35–42. Pacchiana, P.D. and Root Kustritz, M.V. (2002).
Haase‐Berglund, M.L. and Premanandan, C.L. Theriogenology question of the month:
(2019). Histologic evaluation of parovarian ovarian remnant in a dog. JAVMA 220:
nodules in the cat. Submitted to J. Feline Med. 1465–1467.
Surg. Perkins, N.R. and Frazer, G.S. (1995). Ovarian
Heffelfinger, D.J. (2006). Ovarian remnant in a remnant syndrome in a toy poodle: a case
2‐year‐old queen. Can. Vet. J. 47: 165–167. report. Theriogenology 44: 307–312.
Jeffcoate, I.A. (1991). Identification of spayed Petit, P.D.M. and Lee, R.A. (1988). Ovarian
bitches. Vet. Rec. 129: 58. remnant syndrome. Diagnostic dilemma and
Jeffcoate, I.A., McBride, M., Harvey, M.J. et al. surgical challenge. Obstetr. Gynecol. 71:
(2000). Measurement of plasma oestradiol 580–583.
References 369
Place, N.J., Hansen, B.S., Cheraskin, J.‐L. et al. test to distinguish between ovariectomized
(2011). Measurement of serum anti‐Mullerian and sexually intact queens. Proceedings,
hormone concentration in female dogs and ACVIM Forum, Charlotte, NC. http://www.
cats before and after ovariohysterectomy. J. vin.com/members/proceedings/proceedings.
Vet. Diagn. Invest. 23: 524–527. plx?CID=advim2003&PID=pr04197&0=VIN
Root Kustritz, M.V. and Rudolph, K.D. (2001). (accessed 3 January 2013).
Theriogenology question of the month: Schwarze, R.A. and Threlfall, W.R. (2008).
ovarian remnant in a cat. JAVMA 219: Theriogenology question of the month:
1065–1066. persistent estrus due to exposure to human
Root Kustritz, M.V. and Vizecky, K.L. (2002). topical estrogen preparation in a dog. JAVMA
Theriogenology question of the month: 233: 235–237.
determination of intact status of a dog. Shemwell, R.E. and Weed, J.C. (1970). Ovarian
JAVMA 221: 199–200. remnant syndrome. Obstetr. Gynecol. 36:
Sangster, C. (2005). Ovarian remnant syndrome 299–303.
in a 5‐year‐old bitch. Can. Vet. J. 46: 62–64. Wallace, M.S. (1991). The ovarian remnant
Scebra, L.R. and Griffin, B. (2003). Evaluation of syndrome in the bitch and queen. Vet. Clin. N.
a commercially available luteinizing hormone Am. Small Anim. Pract. 21: 501–507.
371
Section Four
While ovariohysterectomy and castration are surgical procedure. Cold sterilization should
the mainstay of shelter surgery for the purpose not be used for any surgical procedure.
of population control, many other surgical pro- Protocols must be in place to ensure proper
cedures may have a significant role in shelter cleaning and disinfection of the suite and
animal care. Procedures such as enucleation, equipment, and anesthetic and monitoring
cherry eye surgery, and amputation may not equipment appropriate for the surgeries to be
only make the patient more comfortable, but performed should be functional and routinely
may also make an unadoptable animal highly maintained. An up‐to‐date crash cart should
adoptable. Other procedures that can be per- be present and staff should be fully trained in
formed in a shelter surgery setting may save the use of emergency drugs and emergency
the animal’s life or significantly improve the procedures (Bushby 2013).
animal’s health. The types of surgeries that can be performed
Surgeries performed in the shelter environ- in the shelter environment are dependent
ment must, at a minimum, meet the standards upon the skill level of the veterinary surgeon,
described in the Association of Shelter the specialized equipment that is available,
Veterinarians’ 2016 Veterinary Medical Care and financial resources of the shelter. The sur-
Guidelines for Spay‐Neuter Programs (Griffin geries described in the following chapters are
et al. 2016). As for all surgeries, only medical‐ all considered to be surgeries that can be per-
grade suture should be used and separate ster- formed in the shelter setting.
ile instruments should be used for each
References
Bushby, P.A. (2013). Surgical techniques for Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al.
spay/neuter. In: Shelter Medicine for (2016). The Association of Shelter
Veterinarians and Staff, 2e (eds. L. Miller Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical care
and Z. Stephen), 625–646. Ames, IA: guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. JAVMA
Wiley‐Blackwell. 249: 165–188.
375
19
Amputation
Joseph P. Weigel
Amputation for management of fracture preserving blood volume. This can be helpful,
trauma in the shelter animal is a life‐saving especially if fluid loss is a potential risk.
option where primary treatment often Location and resection of regional lymph nodes
demands resources that are not available in are not an issue in the trauma case, but may be
most shelters. While the veterinarian may pre- important in the diseased or infected limb.
fer to treat the trauma and restore the animal Gait adaptation and function in the amputee
to full function, the reality is that amputation is always a concern for the veterinary surgeon.
has become an attractive alternative in the Fortunately, most animals will adapt well to a
shelter animal, where a homeless amputee missing limb. However, this is dependent on
generates more compassion from the general the health of the remaining limbs. Attention to
public than for a normal animal and is there- the condition of the contralateral limb is an
fore more likely to be adopted. However, the obvious concern, but the condition of the all
decision for amputation in the shelter environ- the limbs is important. After force platform
ment still relies heavily on humane concerns gait analysis of dogs with an amputated rear
and the expectation of a good quality of life. limb, Hogy et al. found increases in the peak
While there is increasing interest in the use breaking forces in the contralateral front limb
of limb prostheses, the current practice of and increased propulsive forces and impulses
limb replacement remains experimental, so in both the ipsilateral front limb and the
specialized amputation techniques do not remaining rear limb. Also, time to peak brak-
apply to this discussion. Therefore, techniques ing force was decreased, while the time to peak
described here are traditional, but are pre- propulsive force was increased in all remaining
sented in a condensed format with a logical limbs. Evaluation of spatial kinematic data by
dissection sequence that conserves time and Hogy et al. on rear limb amputees demon-
lessens post‐operative complications. strated an increase in the range of motion of
Since trauma is the most likely reason for an the remaining hock joint, the cervicothoracic
amputation, the level of amputation is deter- and thoracolumbar spine, and an increased
mined by convenience and cosmetics as extension of the lumbosacral spine (Hogy et al.
opposed to the extent of disease. Other consid- 2013).
erations such as the order of vessel ligation are In general, the loss of either a front or rear
not as important; however, as a general rule, limb results in greater ground reaction force
the ligation of the arterial before the venous and impulse in the remaining limbs and in
side allows for drainage of blood from the limb, changes in the body’s center of gravity, but
376 19 Amputation
IV
Figure 19.1 Skin incision for scapular disarticulation. Figure 19.2 Road map for scapular disarticulation.
378 19 Amputation
i nsertion of the omotransversarius muscle is border of the scapula, where the insertion of
incised from the spine of the scapula. This is the rhomboideus muscle is separated from
followed by identifying and incising the inser- the bone, which is followed by sub‐periosteal
tion of the trapezius from the scapular spine lifting of the insertion of the serratus ventra-
(Figure 19.3). lis muscle from the medial surface of the
scapula. The scapula can be abducted from
the chest wall, but it is insufficient for safe
Phase II: Dorsal Dissection
dissection of the axillary space until the latis-
The objective of this phase is to release the simus dorsi muscle is released several centim-
dorsal border of the scapula such that it can eters caudal to the teres tuberosity of the
be abducted from the chest wall, exposing the humerus. The dorsal border of the latissimus
anatomy of the deep axillary space dorsi muscle is located caudal to the scapula
(Figure 19.4). This phase begins at the dorsal and near the level of the dorsal border of the
scapula. This border of the muscle is followed
distally to the axillary space, where it is tran-
Trapezius sected near the teres tuberosity. Technically
the latissimus dorsi transection is not dorsal,
but it is included in the Phase II dissection
since the objective in this phase is full abduc-
I tion of the scapula, which requires the distal
Omotransversarius
myotomy of the latissimus dorsi muscle.
Included with this myotomy is the identifica-
tion of thoracodorsal artery and vein, which
are ligated and divided along with the thora-
codorsal nerve, which is infiltrated with local
anesthetic and divided. The axillary lymph
node is located in this general area and can be
removed if necessary. The neurovascular
Figure 19.3 Phase I: lateral dissection for structures of the axillary space are now ade-
scapular disarticulation. quately exposed for division.
Rhomboidius
II
Latissimus dorsi
Serratus ventralis
Thoracodorsal neurovascular bundle
Phase III: Medial Dissection across the axillary space, the axillobrachial and
brachial veins. Each vein must be isolated,
This phase involves the isolation and division
ligated, and divided. Two encircling ligatures
of the neurovascular structures to the front
of a synthetic absorbable suture are applied
limb (Figure 19.5). The major nerves from the
and the vein is divided between them. It is not
brachial plexus are infiltrated with local anes-
necessary to apply transfixing ligatures to these
thetic proximally and then sharply divided dis-
veins.
tal to the infiltration. The brachial artery is
identified and ligated with an encircling liga-
Phase IV: Ventral Dissection
ture of a synthetic absorbable suture, followed
just distally by a transfixing ligature. An addi- The road map for scapular disarticulation ends
tional encircling ligature is placed on the artery with incision of the insertion of the superficial
further distally. The artery is divided between and deep pectoral muscles and a mid‐belly
this most distal ligature and the transfixing division of the brachiocephalicus muscle
ligature. There are two major veins spanning (Figure 19.6).
Axillary vein
Brachial vein
Abduction of scapula
Brachial artery
Brachiocephalicus
IV
Deep pectoral
Superficial pectoral
Closure is preceded by a thorough inspection portion of the ventral border of the latissimus
of the wound for any active hemorrhage. Once muscle. The remaining brachiocephalicus
hemorrhage is controlled and the wound has muscle is brought caudally and attached to the
been lightly flushed, closure begins with the latissimus or pectoral muscles. Synthetic absorb-
objective of bringing the major muscles together able sutures are recommended.
closing dead space, apposing cut surfaces, and The subcutaneous layer, which is still con-
providing a tissue cushion for underlying bone nected to the skin, is closed in the pattern
and overlying skin. While the cut surfaces of the intended for the skin. In the case of scapular
muscles are apposed for quick healing, muscu- disarticulation, the subcutaneous layer can be
lar “anastomosis” is not the primary objective, closed in an inverted “T” pattern that parallels
because muscle function is not a consideration. the original skin incision, or as an alternative
Where tension is not present, the muscle can be the corner of the caudal flap can be brought
apposed in an interrupted or continuous invert- cranially, converting the incision into a “C”‐
ing pattern. The inverting pattern rolls the cut shaped pattern. The surgeon should choose a
surface of the muscle toward the deeper aspects pattern that has minimal tension and has the
of the wound. Serous exudation from the raw fewest sutured right angles (Figure 19.8).
edges of the incised muscles drains to the deeper
levels of the wound, where absorption is more
(a)
efficient than allowing serous fluid to drain
toward the skin and the surface, where seromas
form and drain through the skin incision.
Following amputation by scapular disarticula-
tion, the closure objective is to gently pull the
muscles across the axillary space, covering the (b)
severed neurovascular structures and the axillary
space (Figure 19.7). This is initiated by bringing
the latissimus dorsi muscle cranial and suturing
it to the omotransversarius and trapezius mus-
Figure 19.8 (a) The inverted “T” incision. (b) Bring
cles. The pectoral muscles are brought proximally the corners designated by red dots together,
and apposed to the scalenius and the available converting to a “C”-shaped closure.
Trapezius
Brachiocephalicus
Deep pectoral
Superficial pectoral
Synthetic absorbable sutures are also recom- ties as described for a shoulder disarticulation.
mended for this layer. Similar to the front limb, the most common
The skin can be closed with non‐absorbable indication for amputation is traumatic injury
suture in a variety of patterns, both continuous that cannot be physically repaired for reasona-
and interrupted. Simple interrupted sutures ble pain‐free function or would be cost prohib-
will provide a more accurate closure of the ited for treatment.
skin and are recommended. Skin closure can In the case of a mid‐thigh amputation, the
also be facilitated by placing single interrupted femur is transected where the proximal and
sutures at strategic points along the incision to middle thirds of the shaft meet. This will pro-
reduce tension, and will also help to prevent vide sufficient structure to the stump and allow
the accumulation of excess skin on one side or complete coverage of the bone by muscle flaps.
the other at the end of closure. It is also possible to extract the entire femur
from the stump by advancing the dissection
proximally up the shaft of the bone, severing the
Post-operative Care/Rehabilitation
attachments of the adductor, gluteal, pelvic
Rehabilitation of the post‐operative amputee association, and quadriceps muscle groups
involves protection of the incision, checking for directly from the bone. At the level of the hip
seroma formation, assisting the patient in early joint the capsule is sharply separated from the
ambulation, maintaining hydration, and con- bone, allowing the femoral head to be distracted
trolling pain. Cold therapy (ice packing), laser from the acetabulum. In this position the liga-
therapy, and ultrasound heat can be helpful in ment of the head of the femur can be transected
reducing post‐operative swelling and pain. The by a curved Mayo blunt scissors. In the author’s
services of a trained veterinary therapist would opinion there is no advantage to removal of the
be advantageous to the shelter, especially if the entire femur, unless there is the elimination of
surgery load is high. Therapists can shorten the an abnormality that could cause persistent pain
recovery period, which can speed up the adop- post‐operatively, such as a dislocated hip.
tion process. Also, the application of body A quadruped animal can compensate well
slings with handles will make movement of the following a single rear limb amputation, since
animal easier and less painful. These devices the balance of weight bearing is located toward
also assist in early ambulation, especially in the front end of the body. This compensation
those animals that are overweight or have oste- can be so efficient that some rear leg amputees
oarthritis in the other limbs. Also see chapter will successfully participate in canine athletic
19A for more information on intra- and post- events. However, the walk remains abnormal
operative analgesia for amputations. where the contralateral rear limb “jumps” for-
ward in order to advance the rear. This lame-
ness is not caused by pain, but by mechanical
Rear Limb Amputation adjustments necessary for effective motion.
Compensation is not only dependent on the
Amputation of the rear limb is common orthopedic soundness of the contralateral leg,
(Seguin and Weigel 2012), but fortunately the but also on the soundness of the front legs.
quadruped animal can easily adjust to a miss- Therefore, the prognosis should be determined
ing rear limb, especially when compared to the by an overall assessment of musculoskeletal
adjustment for a missing front limb. Division integrity and conditioning.
of the rear limb through the thigh is the easiest The skin incision for the mid‐thigh amputa-
and quickest route to a functional amputation. tion is made through the skin and subcutane-
Hip disarticulation is complicated and time ous tissue, beginning in the flank, and is curved
consuming, carrying with it the same difficul- distally to the patella, along the lateral stifle,
382 19 Amputation
and then redirected proximally toward the rius muscle is identified and transected at the
tuber ischium, to end at a point at the same same level as the skin incision. The gracilis mus-
level as the beginning point in the flank. A cle is transected parallel to the medial skin flap,
medial skin incision is made as a mirror image but slightly distal to the flap. The femoral artery
of the lateral flap, but extending no more than and vein are now exposed in the femoral triangle
halfway distal in the thigh (Figure 19.9). The and are ligated with an absorbable synthetic
lateral flap is thicker and with more hair than material and then divided. The artery is clamped
the medial flap and is better suited for expo- and ligated, first with a circumferential ligature,
sure to the exterior, so the lateral flap should be followed by a transfixation ligature applied just
long enough to be folded around the stump distal to the original ligature. The artery is ligated
and sutured to the medial flap. again with a circumferential suture distal to the
The road map for a mid‐thigh amputation is transfixing ligature and then divided between
circular, beginning on the medial side and pro- the transfixation ligature and the last, most dis-
gressing to cranial to lateral, and finally back to tal ligature. The vein is similarly ligated and
the medial side (Figure 19.10). transected, but without the transfixation liga-
ture. The pectineus muscle is transected through
its long tendon of insertion on the femur, com-
Phase I: Medial Dissection
pleting the medial dissection (Figure 19.11).
Once the skin is incised, the leg is abducted and
the medial dissection is begun. The caudal sarto- Phase II: Cranial Dissection
The caudal border of the cranial sartorius mus-
cle is identified and followed to the patella. The
stifle joint is then entered, exposing the patella
and the quadriceps insertion. The insertion is
incised through the parapatellar fibrocartilage
immediately proximal to the bone (Figure 19.12).
No muscle is cut, only the fibrous insertion. The
leg is adducted and Phase III, lateral dissection,
Medial thigh
is commenced.
Lateral thigh
II
Phase IV: Caudal Dissection
The semitendinosus, semimembranosus, and
Figure 19.10 Road map for mid-thigh amputation. adductor muscles are severed by a sharp
www.ajlobby.com
Rear Limb Amputation 383
Abduction of limb
Femoral artery
I
Caudal sartorius Femoral vein
Gracilis
Pectineus
II
Quadriceps and cranial
sartorius insertion transected
just proximal to the patella.
Patellar ligament
Patella
Quadriceps
and
cranial sartorius
Biceps femoris
Sciatic nerve
Patella
www.ajlobby.com
384 19 Amputation
Semitendinosus
Semimembranosus muscle
muscle
Adductor IV
muscle
Femur
Patella
Biceps femoris
muscle Semitendinosus
muscle
Semimembranosus
muscle
Adductor muscle
Quadriceps muscle
Gracilis muscle
Femur
www.ajlobby.com
Amputation of the Tail 385
Biceps femoris
muscle Semitendinosus
muscle
Semimembranosus
muscle
Adductor muscle
Quadriceps muscle
Gracilis muscle
Figure 19.16 Closure is initiated by bringing the quadriceps caudally and suturing to the adductor or the
semimembranosus or semitendinosus muscle.
Biceps femoris
muscle
Quadriceps muscle
Gracilis muscle
Figure 19.17 Closure is continued by bringing the gracilis to the biceps femoris muscle.
www.ajlobby.com
386 19 Amputation
the underlying soft tissue is lifted from the positioned over the end of the vertebra. There
bone, keeping the skin naturally attached to should be minimal tension; however, if the
the deep soft tissue layers. If the ventral coc- tension requires mattress sutures, the amputa-
cygeal artery is encountered and hemorrhage tion should be advanced to the next cranial
cannot be controlled with cautery, a single disc space without any additional incision or
circumferential ligature around the vessel is removal of soft tissue. Once the soft tissue
adequate for control. After lifting the soft tis- layer has been closed over the bone, the skin
sue to the target disc space, the tail is severed flaps are brought together and closed with
through the disc. The deep tissues are gently interrupted sutures.
References
Bone, D.L. and Aberman, H.M. (1988). Forelimb Kirpensteijn, J., van den Bos, R., van den Brom,
amputation in the dog. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. W.E., and Hazewinkel, H.A. (2000 Feb 5).
Assoc. 24: 525. Ground reaction force analysis of large breed
Gillette, R. (2004). Gait Analysis. In: Canine dogs when walking after the amputation of a
Rehabilitation and Physical Therapy (eds. D. limb. Vet. Rec. 146 (6): 155–159.
Millis, D. Levine and R.A. Taylor), 205. St. Leighton, R.L. and Borzio, F. (1975). Amputation
Louis, MO: Saunders. of the foreleg of the dog. In: Current Techniques
Hogy, S.M., Worley, D.R., Jarvis, S.L. et al. in Small Animal Surgery (ed. Bojrab MJ), 491.
(2013 Sep). Kinematic and kinetic analysis of Philadelphia, PA: Lea and Febiger.
dogs during trotting after amputation of a Seguin, B. and Weigel, J.P. (2012). Amputations.
pelvic limb. Am. J. Vet. Res. 74 (9): 1164–1171. In: Veterinary Surgery Small Animal (eds.
Jarvis, S.L., Worley, D.R., Hogy, S.M. et al. (2013 K.M. Tobias and S.A. Johnston), 1031–1034.
Sep). Kinematic and kinetic analysis of dogs St. Louis, MO: Saunders.
during trotting after amputation of a thoracic
limb 2nd. Am. J. Vet. Res. 74 (9): 1155–1163.
www.ajlobby.com
387
19A
Amputation of a limb or the tail may be indi- hypothermia, unless supportive measures are
cated following traumatic injury to soft tissue taken to counteract these adverse events. Fluid
or bone, as a result of severe congenital deform- shifts associated with amputation can be dra-
ity, or in the treatment of certain neoplastic dis- matic, especially with the removal of a limb,
eases. These procedures are invasive, painful, and clinically significant hemorrhage can also
and can be associated with clinically significant occur. With forelimb amputation, the possibil-
fluid and blood losses. Injuries requiring ampu- ity of hemorrhage into the chest cavity from
tation may be accompanied by damage to other the brachial artery should be considered. A
organ systems and trauma patients may require balanced isotonic fluid should be infused
stabilization prior to anesthesia. Pre‐anesthetic intravenously and blood pressure monitored
evaluation of the patient should include rigor- and maintained (mean arterial pressure
ous examination of the cardiac, respiratory, and >60 mmHg). Any blood loss should be esti-
nervous systems, as well as assessment of mated and acute hemorrhage ( 20% of calcu-
fluid balance and the patient’s level of pain. lated blood volume) may require transfusion of
Suggested minimum baseline hematologic blood products, in addition to crystalloid and
information should include packed cell volume artificial colloid administration (Table 19.1).
and total protein concentration. If possible, a The most accurate method for assessing blood
platelet count (or subjective evaluation of a loss is actually measuring volume and weigh-
blood smear) should be performed and electro- ing blood‐soaked gauzes (1 ml of blood weighs
lyte concentrations evaluated. If neoplasia is ~1 g). However, a blood‐soaked 4 in. × 4 in. (10
the reason for amputation or the patient is cm × 10 cm) gauze will hold 10–20 ml of blood
aged, more extensive diagnostics and clinical and a laparotomy sponge can absorb 50–100 ml.
staging should be considered. The recovery period following limb or tail
amputation requires close monitoring for fluid
and electrolyte balance and adequacy of
Anesthetic Concerns for Limb analgesia. Packed cell volume and total solids
and Tail Amputation should be compared to pre‐operative values
and intravenous fluids should be continued
Peri‐operative concerns for limb and tail ampu- until the animal is eating and drinking.
tation center on appropriate monitoring and Placement of a closed urinary collection sys-
supportive care. General anesthesia frequently tem for the first 12–24 hours will prevent urine
results in hypotension, hypoventilation, and soiling in animals that are not yet able to walk.
www.ajlobby.com
388 19A Amputation: Anesthesia Supplement
Table 19.1 Estimated blood volumes in a variety scoring system should be used frequently in
of species. the post‐operative period.
Table 19.2 Opioids for systemic analgesia in cats and dogs (N.B. high end of dosing ranges for full mu
agonists are used during general anesthesia with ability to control ventilation).
www.ajlobby.com
Analgesic Concerns for Limb and Tail Amputation 389
reducing the need for post‐operative opioid but the drug has not yet been marketed for
administration (Michelet et al. 2012), and these species (Rausch‐Derra and Rhodes 2016;
should be used in the peri‐operative period if De Vito et al. 2017)
possible. Patients that are volume depleted or
hypotensive should not be administered
Local Anesthetics
NSAIDs, because prostaglandins help to main-
tain renal blood flow in the face of renal Local anesthesia added to general anesthesia
hypoperfusion (Henrich et al. 1978; Khan decreases the peri‐operative stress response
et al. 1998). In addition, because general anes- (Teyin et al. 2006), reduces the incidence
thetics can cause vasodilation and relative of chronic pain (Kairaluoma et al. 2006),
hypovolemia, administration of NSAIDs may decreases post‐operative opioid requirements
be safest if confined to the post‐operative (Paul et al. 2010), improves patient satisfaction
period. Multiple studies have not demon- as reported by humans (Jeske et al. 2011), and
strated renal injury when label doses of may decrease the metastasis and recurrence of
NSAIDs are administered to healthy dogs certain tumors (Gottschalk et al. 2012). In
prior to anesthesia, as determined by creati- addition, effective local or regional anesthesia
nine and blood urea nitrogen concentrations, can reduce inhalational requirements, thereby
urine‐specific gravity, or glomerular filtration improving cardiopulmonary function during
rate (Ko et al. 2000; Crandell et al. 2004; Kay‐ general anesthesia. Provision of local anesthe-
Mugford et al. 2004; Bergmann et al. 2005). sia provides excellent analgesia in instances
However, these parameters do not directly where access to opioid analgesics is restricted.
measure the effects of acute changes in renal Fortunately, local anesthetics are inexpensive
blood flow, unless the clinical outcome is dis- and the drugs are not controlled.
astrous. In cats, clinical studies indicate simi- There are several local anesthetic techniques
lar uneventful renal outcomes when NSAIDs for amputation of the hindlimb and tail,
are administered prior to anesthesia (King whereas those for the forelimb are more lim-
et al. 2016); however, anecdotal evidence sug- ited. In the caudal half of the body, lumbosa-
gests that cats may be more sensitive to the cral epidural placement of local anesthetics is
renal effects of cavalier NSAID administration effective and easily performed. More advanced
and caution is warranted. The peri‐operative techniques include lumbar and sacral plexus
use of NSAIDs requires careful consideration blocks using a nerve locator, ultrasound visu-
in animals with pre‐existing renal disease and alization, or the combination of both tools to
may be best avoided. avoid entry into the central nervous system
Grapiprant is a relatively new anti‐inflamma- and allow the clinician to produce unilateral
tory agent labeled for control of osteoarthritis‐ motor blockade. Motor blockade of the limbs
related pain and inflammation in dogs. This can be avoided for tail amputations by access-
drug is an antagonist at the EP4 receptor, the ing the epidural space at the sacrocaudal junc-
natural ligand of which is prostaglandin E2. It tion, rather than at the lumbosacral space (see
has been suggested that the side effect profile is also Chapter 21A: Rectal and vaginal prolapse
less severe than traditional NSAIDs due to fact anesthesia supplement). For the forelimb,
that production of prostaglandins is not inhib- there are fewer described local anesthetic
ited. Evidence from laboratory species suggests techniques, though a cervical paravertebral
that grapiprant is effective in reducing surgi- brachial plexus block can provide anesthesia
cally induced acute pain and it may be a rea- distal to the shoulder joint.
sonable analgesic/anti‐inflammatory choice in Application of local anesthetics directly to
the peri‐operative time period. Safety and effi- the nerves intraoperatively or at the site of the
cacy studies in cats and rabbits are available, surgical wound may be the simplest method of
www.ajlobby.com
390 19A Amputation: Anesthesia Supplement
www.ajlobby.com
Analgesic Concerns for Limb and Tail Amputation 391
Can be combined
Drug Dose with Comments
Anti-hyperalgesics
Various IV and oral drugs (Table 19.4) can be
used peri‐operatively to reduce wind‐up,
central sensitization, and development of
chronic and persistent post‐operative pain.
Figure 19.20 A homemade wound or soaker Strong evidence for the effectiveness of these
catheter. The distal end of a 5-Fr red rubber urinary strategies is lacking in veterinary medicine,
catheter was sealed with a heated hemostat and a but studies are generally more encouraging
catheter cap was attached to the proximal end. A
27-gauge needle was used to make holes to allow
in human patients. IV lidocaine infusions in
local anesthetic to be delivered directly into the particular can improve recovery and imme-
surgical site. diate post‐operative analgesia, as well as the
incidence of chronic pain (Grigoras et al.
needle, such as those attached to an insulin 2012; Sun et al. 2012); however, IV infusions
syringe, is then used to make holes in the distal of lidocaine should be used cautiously in
end to the desired length; the catheter is filled cats due to the risk of cardiovascular depres-
with local anesthetic and placed in the wound sion at high doses (Pypendop and Ilkiw
during closure. All holes in the catheter should 2005).
www.ajlobby.com
392 19A Amputation: Anesthesia Supplement
References
Abelson, A.L., McCobb, E.C., Shaw, S. et al. Henrich, W.L., Anderson, R.J., Berns, A.S. et al.
(2009). Use of wound soaker catheters for the (1978). The role of renal nerves and
administration of local anesthetic for post‐ prostaglandins in control of renal
operative analgesia: 56 cases. Vet. Anaesth. hemodynamics and plasma renin activity
Analg. 36 (6): 597–602. during hypotensive hemorrhage in the dog.
Bergmann, H.M., Nolte, I.J., and Kramer, S. J. Clin. Invest. 61 (3): 744–750.
(2005). Effects of preoperative administration Jeske, H.C., Kralinger, F., Wambacher, M. et al.
of carprofen on renal function and hemostasis (2011). A randomized study of the
in dogs undergoing surgery for fracture repair. effectiveness of suprascapular nerve block in
Am. J. Vet. Res. 66 (8): 1356–1363. patient satisfaction and outcome after
Crandell, D.E., Mathews, K.A., and Dyson, D.D. arthroscopic subacromial decompression.
(2004). Effect of meloxicam and carprofen on Arthroscopy 27 (10): 1323–1328.
renal function when administered to healthy Kairaluoma, P.M., Bachmann, M.S., Rosenberg,
dogs prior to anaesthesia and painful P.H. et al. (2006). Preincisional paravertebral
stimulation. Am. J. Vet. Res 65: 1384–1390. block reduces the prevalence of chronic pain
De Vito, V., Salvadori, M., Poapolathep, A. et al. after breast surgery. Anesth. Analg. 103 (3):
(2017). Pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic 703–708.
evaluation of grapiprant in a carrageenan‐ Katz, J., Vaccarino, A.L., Coderre, T.J. et al.
induced inflammatory pain model in the (1991). Injury prior to neurectomy alters the
rabbit. J. Vet. Pharmacol. 40 (5): 468–475. pattern of autotomy in rats. Behavioral
Gottschalk, A., Brodner, G., Van Aken, H.K. evidence of central neural plasticity.
et al. (2012). Can regional anaesthesia for Anesthesiology 75 (5): 876–883.
lymph‐node dissection improve the prognosis Kay‐Mugford, P.A., Grimm, K.A., Weingarten,
in malignant melanoma? Br. J. Anaesth. 109 A.J. et al. (2004). Effect of preoperative
(2): 253–259. administration of tepoxalin on hemostasis and
Grigoras, A., Lee, P., Sattar, F. et al. (2012). hepatic and renal function in dogs. Vet. Ther. 5
Perioperative intravenous lidocaine decreases (2): 120–127.
the incidence of persistent pain after breast Khan, K.N., Venturini, C.M., Bunch, R.T. et al.
surgery. Clin. J. Pain 28 (7): 567–572. (1998). Interspecies differences in renal
Hanley, M.A., Jensen, M.P., Smith, D.G. et al. localization of cyclooxygenase isoforms:
(2007). Preamputation pain and acute pain implications in nonsteroidal antiinflammatory
predict chronic pain after lower extremity drug‐related nephrotoxicity. Toxicol. Pathol. 26
amputation. J. Pain 8: 102–109. (5): 612–620.
References 393
King, S., Roberts, E.S., and King, J.N. (2016). lidocaine administered IV in isoflurane‐
Evaluation of injectable robenacoxib for the anesthetized cats. Am. J. Vet. Res. 66 (4):
treatment of post‐operative pain in cats: results 661–668.
of a randomized, masked, placebo‐controlled Rausch‐Derra, L.C. and Rhodes, L. (2016).
clinical trial. BMC Vet. Res. 12 (1): 215. Safety and toxicokinetic profiles associated
Ko, J.C., Miyabiyashi, T., Mandsager, R.E. et al. with daily oral administration of grapiprant, a
(2000). Renal effects of carprofen administered selective antagonist of the prostaglandin E2
to healthy dogs anesthetized with propofol and EP4 receptor, to cats. Am. J. Vet. Res. 77 (7):
isoflurane. JAVMA 217 (3): 346–349. 688–692.
Michelet, D., Andreu‐Gallien, J., Bensalah, T. Sommer, M., de Rijke, J.M., van Kleef, M. et al.
et al. (2012). A meta‐analysis of the use of (2010). Predictors of acute postoperative pain
nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs for after elective surgery. Clin. J. Pain 26 (2):
pediatric postoperative pain. Anesth. Analg. 87–94.
114 (2): 393–406. Sun, Y., Li, T., Wang, N. et al. (eds.) (2012).
O’Hearn, A.K. and Wright, B.D. (2011). Perioperative systemic lidocaine for
Coccygeal epidural with local anesthetic for postoperative analgesia and recovery after
catheterization and pain management in the abdominal surgery: a meta‐analysis of
treatment of feline urethral obstruction. J. Vet. randomized controlled trials. Dis. Colon
Emerg. Crit. Care 21 (1): 50–52. Rectum 55 (11): 1183–1194.
Paul, J.E., Arya, A., Hurlburt, L. et al. (2010). Teyin, E., Derbent, A., Balcioglu, T. et al.
Femoral nerve block improves analgesia (2006). The efficacy of caudal morphine or
outcomes after total knee arthroplasty: a bupivacaine combined with general
meta‐analysis of randomized controlled trials. anesthesia on postoperative pain and
Anesthesiology 113 (5): 1144–1162. neuroendocrine stress response in
Pypendop, B.H. and Ilkiw, J.E. (2005). children. Paediatr. Anaesth. 16 (3):
Assessment of the hemodynamic effects of 290–296.
395
20
Surgery of the Eye
Susan Nelms
Many eye disorders can be painful, vision as some animals will develop discomfort from
threatening, or lead to an undesirable appear- chronic ocular discharge, secondary entropion,
ance of the eye that may render a shelter pet and chronic periocular dermatitis. The phthisi-
unadoptable or less likely to be adopted. The cal globe can serve as a nidus for chronic ocular
following eye surgeries can be done in a shelter inflammation (Ramsey and Fox 1977). In addi-
setting and at the time of spay or neuter sur- tion, these conditions can result in an undesired
gery. These ophthalmic surgeries can enhance cosmetic appearance (Figure 20.1). In cats,
the adoptability of a shelter pet. This chapter phthisis bulbi can lead to traumatic sarcoma
covers surgical techniques. For anesthesia and later in life. Because of this potential but rare
analgesia during eye surgery, see Chapter 20A. risk, enucleation is indicated for all blind cat
eyes with phthisis bulbi (Zeiss et al. 2003;
Figure 20.2).
Enucleation
Intraorbital Prosthesis
Enucleation is removal of the globe, third
eyelid, conjunctiva, and eyelids (Miller 2008, Following removal of the globe, an intraorbital
Ramsey and Fox 1977). prosthesis may be placed to improve the
cosmetic appearance post‐operatively (Hamor
et al. 1993; Nasisse et al. 1988). Providing a
Indications
space filler to take up the place of the enucle-
This surgery is indicated to provide comfort for ated globe prevents a “sunken” appearance
a blind, painful eye or removal of an eye with post‐operatively (Figures 20.3 and 20.4).
intraocular neoplasia that is not amenable to Implantation of a silicone orbital prosthesis
medical or other surgical treatments (Miller has been shown to be safe and inexpensive
2008, Ramsey and Fox 1977). Enucleation is (Hamor et al. 1993) and improves the cosmetic
indicated for the following eye conditions: appearance post‐enucleation. Enucleation in a
chronic glaucoma, severe penetrating or blunt young animal slows the growth of the orbit, as
trauma, traumatic proptosis with optic nerve the orbital contents stimulate normal growth
avulsion or scleral rupture, uncontrollable (Miller 2008). Replacement of orbital volume
endophthalmitis, or panophthalmitis (Ramsey with a prosthesis tends to result in an orbit
and Fox 1977; Miller 2008; Speiss 2007). that more closely approximates normal size
Enucleation may be indicated for phthisis bulbi, (Miller 2008).
396 20 Surgery of the Eye
Figure 20.1 Phthisis bulbi OD (right eye) in a pug Figure 20.4 Post-operative appearance with
resulting in chronic inflammation, ocular discharge, silicone orbital prosthesis.
secondary entropion, and an unattractive cosmetic
appearance.
and it provides the greatest exposure of the
optic nerve (Martin 2005; Miller 2008; Ramsey
and Fox 1977).
1) Perform a lateral canthotomy with scissors,
1–2 cm in length (Figures 20.5a and 20.6).
2) Grasp the conjunctiva near the limbus and
make a 360° perilimbal incision with scis-
sors (Figure 20.5b and 20.7).
3) Separate the conjunctiva from the sclera
with blunt dissection and sever the extraoc-
ular muscles close to their attachment to
the sclera (Figures 20.5c and 20.7).
Figure 20.2 Phthisis bulbi OD (right eye) in a cat.
Even though this cat is not showing signs of 4) Gently rotate the globe medially, but do not
discomfort, enucleation is indicated for this blind eye. put rostral traction on the globe (Figure 20.8).
5) Sever the optic nerve with scissors.
Approach from the lateral aspect of the
globe (Figure 20.5c).
a) Do not place traction on the optic nerve
and do not twist the optic nerve, as this
can cause optic nerve trauma to the chi-
asm and blindness in the contralateral
eye, especially in cats (Stiles 1993). Cats
are at increased risk due to the shorter
distance of the optic nerve to the
chiasm.
b) Control hemorrhage in the orbit with
Figure 20.3 Post-operative orbital depression compression. The orbit can be packed
following enucleation surgery.
with gauze sponges for approximately
three to five minutes. Alternatively, the
Surgical Technique
tissues in the orbital cone can be closed
Subconjunctival Enucleation with a ligature. It is not necessary to
This approach is most common and is recom- ligate the optic nerve in dogs and cats
mended, as more soft tissue is left in the orbit (Miller 2008). Applying pressure with
Enucleation 397
(a) (d)
(b)
(e)
(c)
(f)
(g)
Figure 20.5 Subconjunctival enucleation. Source: Miller (2008, p. 367), reproduced with permission of
Elsevier.
398 20 Surgery of the Eye
Figure 20.6 Lateral canthotomy. Figure 20.9 Third eyelid and gland excised.
Figure 20.7 Perilimbal incision with dissection of Figure 20.10 Orbit packed with gauze sponges to
conjunctiva from sclera and severing of extraocular control hemostasis. (Sponges removed prior to
muscle attachments to sclera. closure.) The eyelid margins are removed with
scissors.
bleeding from the incision or nose for a day or Ramsey and Fox 1977; Speiss 2007; Ward and
two. Post‐operative treatment may include: Neaderland 2011). Infection of the orbit is an
uncommon post‐operative complication and
1) Broad‐spectrum oral antibiotic.
most cases can be managed with systemic
2) Oral non‐steroidal anti‐inflammatory drugs
antibiotics. In brachycephalic breeds, orbital
(NSAIDs).
emphysema, a rare complication, can occur if
3) Oral tramadol or injectable butorphanol or
air leaks into the orbit via the nasolacrimal
buprenorphine.
duct (Bedford 1979; Martin 1971). Orbital
4) Feed soft food for a few days as chewing
depression or an undesired cosmetic appear-
may cause discomfort.
ance is common, especially for shorthaired
5) Suture removal in 10–14 days.
animals. This can be avoided by placement of
6) Elizabethan collar if needed to prevent rub-
an intraorbital prosthesis, as already dis-
bing/trauma to surgery site.
cussed. Complications of orbital implant
placement are uncommon and surgical infec-
Complications
tion and dehiscence rates are no greater in
The most common complication of enuclea- implanted orbits than in general surgical
tion surgery is hemorrhage with post‐opera- wounds (Hamor et al. 1993). Enteral or paren-
tive swelling (Martin 2005; Speiss 2007). teral antibiotic therapy is recommended to
Draining tracts or serous discharge accumula- reduce the risk of infection post‐operatively in
tion within the orbit can occur if there is all enucleation patients. Infection can also lead
incomplete excision of the secretory tissues to implant extrusion (Hamor et al. 1993). Table
during surgery (Martin 2005; Miller 2008; 20.1 summarizes enucleation complications.
Post-operative enucleation
complication Cause Treatment
Figure 20.17 Parallel incisions are made on Figure 20.19 The final anchoring knot can be
either side of the prolapsed gland. placed on the anterior surface of the third eyelid.
enophthalmos resulting from loss of orbital fat eyelid tacking is also indicated for patients
and subsequent lid laxity (Williams and Kim with spastic entropion that is likely to be tran-
2009). Conformational entropion is the most sient. This procedure involves temporarily
common form in dogs, and many breeds have a everting the eyelid margin with vertical mat-
genetic predisposition. Cicatricial entropion tress sutures (Johnson et al. 1988). The sutures
occurs secondary to an injury or contact with a are left in place as long as needed and may
caustic chemical that results in scarring and lid need to be replaced at two to four week inter-
contracture. vals, as they may break down as the puppy
Entropion causes pain and can lead to grows (Figures 20.22 and 20.23).
vision‐threatening complications such as cor-
1) Use 3‐0 to 5‐0 nylon or other non‐absorba-
neal ulceration, secondary infection, corneal
ble suture.
pigmentation, and scarring, therefore surgical
2) Place the needle 2–3 mm from the lid mar-
repair is indicated for shelter dogs and cats that
gin for the first bite.
are affected.
3) Engage 2–3 mm of skin and subcutaneous
tissue in the first bite.
Surgical Technique
4) Start the second bite 1–2 cm from the lid
Eyelid Tacking margin and incorporate the same amount
Eyelid tacking is indicated for temporary relief of tissue.
in puppies less than 12 weeks (most commonly 5) Tie the knot, applying enough tension to
Shar Pei and Chow Chow, but any breed can be evert the lid margin.
affected). This may be curative, allowing the 6) Place sutures to evert all areas of the lids
puppy to “outgrow” the entropion, or the tack- that are affected.
ing will provide relief from pain and corneal 7) Place as many sutures as needed to estab-
injury until the puppy is more mature and a lish a normal to slightly overcorrected lid
permanent surgery can be done. Temporary conformation.
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 20.22 Temporary “tacking” sutures to correct entropion in an immature animal or animals with a
transient cause for entropion. Source: Maggs (2008b, p. 117), reproduced with permission of Elsevier.
Entropion Repair 405
(a)
(c)
(b)
(d)
Figure 20.25 Hotz–Celsus procedure. Source: Maggs (2008b, p. 118), modified from Moore and
Constantinescu (1997). Reproduced with permission of Elsevier.
2) Incise the lid 2–3 mm from the lid margin with b) The widest portion of tissue resection
a #15 Bard Parker blade (Figure 20.25a): should be planned for the most inverted
a) Placement of this incision too far from area of eyelid (Maggs 2008b).
the lid margin is a common error that 6) The incised strip of skin is removed by
will not allow the eversion desired. sharp dissection.
b) Placement of this incision too close to 7) It is not necessary to remove the orbicularis
the lid margin will make closure muscle, and the conjunctiva should not be
difficult. incised (however, if these tissues are acci-
3) The incision is extended parallel to the lid dently incised, proceed with skin closure as
margin for the length of the entropion (lid described and the surgical wound should
inversion). heal without complication).
4) A second incision is made to create a cres- 8) The defect is closed with 4‐0 to 6‐0 suture in
cent shape and tapered laterally and medi- an interrupted pattern (non‐absorbable or
ally to meet the first incision (Figures 20.25a, absorbable suture may be used; Figure
20.26). 20.27). The author prefers absorbable
5) The distance between the two incisions suture, as it is less irritating if a suture tag
forming the crescent is estimated to correct were to contact the cornea. Also, the sutures
the degree of entropion present: do not have to be removed if the patient is
a) It is better to err on the side of undercor- fractious.
rection (except in cats where slight over- 9) The central aspect of the incision is closed
correction is needed). first using a split‐thickness technique (the
Wedge Resection for Eyelid Tumor Removal 407
Complications
Complications include overcorrection or
undercorrection, leading to a need for addi-
tional surgical repair and possible undesirable
cosmetic appearance (Figure 20.28). Wound
infection or dehiscence is uncommon with
appropriate aftercare.
Indications
Eyelid tumors involving up to one‐third of the
eyelid margin may be excised by full‐thickness
wedge resection (Maggs 2008b). Tumors
involving greater than one‐third of the eyelid
Figure 20.27 Appearance after closure with margin will require more extensive excision
interrupted absorbable sutures. and likely reconstructive techniques, therefore
referral may be indicated.
depth of the suture bites approximates
half the depth of the skin on each side of
the incision) with sutures spaced 2–3 mm
apart (Figure 20.25b).
10) Additional sutures are placed by splitting
the distance of the unsutured spaces
until the wound closure is complete
(Figure 20.25c and d).
Post-operative Care
1) Topical antibiotic ointment.
2) Oral NSAIDs for analgesia.
3) Elizabethan collar.
4) Suture removal in 10–14 days; absorbable
Figure 20.28 Incorrect suture placement (too far
sutures may be removed at this time or may from the lid margin), failing to evert the lid and
be left alone to dissolve. necessitating additional surgery.
408 20 Surgery of the Eye
Surgical Technique
Standard Two-Layer Closure
for Eyelid Wounds 1) 5‐0 to 6‐0 absorbable suture is buried in a
mattress pattern in the subcutaneous tissue
This technique is used for all eyelid wounds without penetrating the skin or conjunc-
or incisions that involve the eyelid margin tiva. This buried suture may be continued
(Maggs 2008b). All injuries that involve the from the eyelid margin to the apex of the
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
3
2
1 4
Figure 20.29 Two-layer closure technique for repair of all eyelid wounds or incisions that involve the
eyelid margin. Source: Maggs (2008b, p. 112), reproduced with permission of Elsevier.
References 409
Bedford, P.G. (1979). Orbital pneumatosis as an Hamor, R.E., Roberts, S.M., and Severin, G.A.
unusual complication to enucleation. J. Small (1993). Use of orbital implants after
An. Pract. 20: 551–555. enucleation in dogs, horses, and cats: 161
Hamilton, H.L., Whitley, R.D., McLaughlin, S.A. cases (1980–1990). JAVMA 203 (5): 701–706.
et al. (2000). Diagnosis and blepharoplastic Helper, L.C. (1970). The effect of lacrimal gland
repair of conformational eyelid defects. removal on the conjunctiva and cornea of the
Compend. Cont. Educ. Pract. Vet 22: 588–599. dog. JAVMA 157: 72–75.
410 20 Surgery of the Eye
Helper, L.C., Magrane, W.G., Koehm, J. et al. retropspective study of 89 cases (1980–1990).
(1974). Surgical induction of keratoconjunctivitis J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 29: 56–61.
sicca in the dog. JAVMA 165: 172–174. Nasisse, M.P., van Ee, R., and Munger, R. (1988).
Hendrix, D.V. (2007). Canine conjunctiva and Use of methyl methacrylate orbital prostheses
nictitating membrane. In: Veterinary in dogs and cats: 78 cases (1980–1986).
Ophthalmology, 4e (ed. K.N. Gelatt), 675–689. JAVMA 192: 539–542.
Ames, IA: Blackwell. Ramsey, D.T. and Fox, D.B. (1977). Surgery of
Johnson, B.W., Gerding, P.A., McLaughlin, S.A. the orbit. Vet. Clin. N. Am. Small Anim. Pract.
et al. (1988). Nonsurgical correction of 27 (5): 1247–1261.
entropion in Shar Pei puppies. Vet. Med. 83: Roberts, S.M., Severin, G.A., and Lavach, J.D.
482–483. (1986). Prevalence and treatment of palpebral
Maggs, D.J. (2008a). Third eyelid. In: Slatter’s neoplasms in the dog: 200 cases (1975–1983).
Fundamentals of Veterinary Ophthalmology, JAVMA 189: 1355.
4e (eds. D.J. Maggs, P.E. Miller and R. Onfri), Speiss, B.M. (2007). Diseases and surgery of the
151–156. St. Louis, MO: Saunders Elsevier. canine orbit. In: Veterinary Ophthalmology, 4e
Maggs, D.J. (2008b). Eyelids. In: Slatter’s (ed. K.N. Gelatt), 539–562. Ames, IA:
Fundamentals of Veterinary Ophthalmology, Blackwell Publishing.
4e (eds. D.J. Maggs, P.E. Miller and R. Onfri), Stades, F.C. and Gelatt, K.N. (2007). Diseases
107–134. St. Louis, MO: Saunders Elsevier. and surgery of the canine eyelids. In:
Martin, C.L. (1971). Orbital emphysema: a Veterinary Ophthalmology, 4e (ed. K.N.
compilcation of ocular enucleation in the dog. Gelatt), 563–617. Ames, IA: Blackwell
Vet. Med. Small Anim. Clin. 66: 986. Publishing.
Martin, C.L. (2005). Ophthalmic Disease in Stiles, J., Buyukmihci, N.C., and Hacker, D.V.
Veterinary Medicine. London: Manson (1993). Blindness from damage to optic
Publishing/Veterinary Press. chiasm. JAVMA 202: 1192.
Miller, P.E. (2008). Orbit. In: Slatter’s Ward, A. and Neaderland, M. (2011).
Fundamentals of Veterinary Ophthalmology, Complications from residual adnexal
4e (eds. D.J. Maggs, P.E. Miller and R. Onfri), structures following enucleation in three
352–373. St. Louis, MO: Saunders Elsevier. dogs. JAVMA 239: 1580–1583.
Miller, W.M. and Albert, R.A. (1988). Canine Williams, D.L. and Kim, J. (2009). Feline
entropion. Compend. Cont. Educ. 10 (4): entropion: a case series of 50 affected
431–438. animals (2003–2008). Vet. Ophthalmol. 12
Moore, C.P. and Constantinescu, G.M. (1997). (4): 221.
Surgery of the adnexa. Vet. Clin. N. Am. Small Zeiss, C.J., Johnson, E.M., and Dubielzig, R.R.
Anim. Pract. 27 (5): 1052–1058. (2003). Feline intraocular tumors may arise
Morgan, R.V., Duddy, J.M., and McClurg, K. from transformation of lens epithelium. Vet.
(1993). Prolapse of the third eyelid in dogs: a Pathol. 40: 355–363.
411
20A
Analgesic Concerns
cause slight proptosis of the intact globe, pro tures therein. A 25 g 5/8 in. needle is inserted
viding improved surgical exposure. at the superior temporal aspect of the orbital
Peribulbar placement of local anesthetics rim and advanced along the wall of the orbit
has largely replaced retrobulbar techniques to its full length. The syringe is aspirated to
in human ocular surgery due to an improved ascertain that the injection will not be into a
safety profile and has been described in dogs vessel and 0.7–1 ml/kg of diluted bupi
and cats (Shilo‐Benjamini et al. 2014, 2018). vacaine (maximum total dose ~2 mg/kg) is
With this approach, a larger volume of local administered. In dogs, the total local anes
anesthetic is deposited outside of the thetic dose is split between a superior tempo
extraocular muscle cone, avoiding possible ral and inferior lateral injection for more
needle‐based trauma of the sensitive struc reliable clinical effect.
References
Accola, P.J., Bentley, E., Smith, L.J. et al. (2006). into the retrobulbar space for postoperative
Development of a retrobulbar injection analgesia following eye enucleation in dogs.
technique for ocular surgery and analgesia in JAVMA 237 (2): 174–177.
dogs. JAVMA 229 (2): 220–225. Oliver, J.A. and Bradbrook, C.A. (2012).
Bentley, E. (2011). Pain management in ocular Suspected brainstem anesthesia following
disease. Western Veterinary Conference, Las retrobulbar block in a cat. Vet. Ophthalmol. 16
Vegas, NV (20–24 February). (3): 225–228.
Bohluli, B., Ashtiani, A.K., Khayampoor, A. et al. Rasmussen, M.L. (2010). The eye
(2009). Trigeminocardiac reflex: a MaxFax amputated – consequences of eye amputation
literature review. Oral Surg. Oral Med. Oral with emphasis on clinical aspects, phantom
Pathol. Oral Radiol. Endodontol. 108 (2): eye syndrome and quality of life. Acta
184–188. Ophthalmologica 88 (Thesis 2): 1–26.
Choi, S.H., Lee, S.J., Kim, S.H. et al. (2007). Schaller, B. (2004). Trigeminocardiac reflex. A
Single bolus of intravenous ketamine for clinical phenomenon or a new physiological
anesthetic induction decreases oculocardiac entity? J. Neurol. 251 (6): 658–665.
reflex in children undergoing strabismus Shilo‐Benjamini, Y., Pascoe, P.J., Maggs, D.J.
surgery. Acta Anaesthesiologica Scandanavica et al. (2014). Comparison of peribulbar and
51 (6): 759–762. retrobulbar regional anesthesia with
Lübbers, H.T., Zweifel, D., Grätz, K.W. et al. bupivacaine in cats. Am. J. Vet. Res. 75 (12):
(2010). Classification of potential risk factors 1029–1039.
for trigeminocardiac reflex in Shilo‐Benjamini, Y., Pascoe, P.J., Maggs, D.J.
craniomaxillofacial surgery. J. Oral Maxillofac. et al. (2018). Retrobulbar vs peribulbar
Surg. 68 (6): 1317–1321. regional anesthesia techniques using
Myrna, K.E., Bentley, E., and Smith, L.J. (2010). bupivacaine in dogs. Vet. Ophthalmol. 22 (2):
Effectiveness of injection of local anesthetic 183–191.
415
21
This chapter covers diagnosis and treatment; estrus, but when these effects are accentuated,
for anesthetic concerns see Chapter 21A, and vaginal fold prolapse may result. There have
for uterine prolapse see Chapter 12. also been reports of vaginal fold prolapse dur
ing diestrus and normal pregnancy, but this is
extremely rare (Johnston et al. 2001).
Vaginal Fold Prolapse True vaginal prolapse, involving the entire
vaginal wall (Nelissen 2015), leads to 360° pro
Vaginal fold prolapse is the protrusion of vagi trusion of the vaginal mucosa as with Type III
nal mucosa through the vulva due to edematous vaginal fold prolapse, but may also encompass
hypertrophy of the vaginal tissue (Fossum other organs, including the urinary bladder,
2002). Previous names for this condition include uterine body, or distal colon (McNamara et al.
vaginal prolapse, vaginal hypertrophy, vaginal 1997). Some cases of complete vaginal pro
hyperplasia, estral hypertrophy, vaginal ever lapse may involve the cervix as well (Fossum
sion, and vaginal protrusion (Nelissen 2015). 2002). Vaginal fold prolapse may also be
Vaginal fold prolapse can be categorized into caused by vaginal tumors or trauma (Arbeiter
three categories. Type I involves slight eversion and Bucher 1994; Williams 2005). Trauma
of the vaginal floor without complete protru may include forced separation during mating,
sion. Type II involves prolapse of the cranial and difference between size of breeding ani
floor and lateral walls of the vagina. In type III mals (Purswell 2000).
prolapse, the entire vaginal circumference pro Although vaginal fold prolapse can be seen in
trudes through the vulva and causes the distinct any breed of dog, large breed and brachycephalic
doughnut‐shaped appearance (Figure 21.1; dogs seem to be at an increased risk (McNamara
Johnston et al. 2001). Type III often involves et al. 1997). Occurrence is most common in dogs
exteriorization of the urethral orifice. under the age of two years, especially during their
Vaginal fold prolapse is an uncommon condi first three estrus cycles. Clinical signs at presenta
tion, but most commonly occurs at predictable tion may include a mass protruding from the
phases in the estrous cycle, usually proestrus vulva, vulvar discharge, or vulvar bleeding. There
and estrus, or shortly after parturition, as pro may also be other signs including pollakiuria,
gesterone levels decline and estrogen levels dysuria, or signs of vaginal/perineal discomfort
increase (Johnston et al. 2001; Fossum 2002). It such as licking or chewing (Fossum 2002).
is normal for vaginal mucosa to become hyper Other diseases with signs similar to vaginal
emic, edematous, and keratinized during fold prolapse should be ruled out. These most
416 21 Rectal and Vaginal Fold Prolapse
(a)
Line of excision
Urinary
catheter
Bladder
Vagina
Rectum
(b)
Horizontal
mattress suture
Cut internal and
external mucosal edges
Vaginal
lumen
Prolapsed ring of
tissue resected
Figure 21.2 Surgical treatment for a Type III vaginal fold prolapse. (a) The dog is placed in dorsal
recumbency and a urethral catheter is placed. A finger can be inserted into the center of the prolapsed
tissue. The dashed line indicates the intended line of resection. (b) A full-thickness circumferential incision
is made in a stepwise manner through the vaginal wall. Horizontal mattress sutures are placed to close the
incisional edges. Source: Nelissen (2015), reproduced with permission of John Wiley and Sons.
folds. The vagina is manually replaced or, if therapy. Cold compresses to the surgical site
manual replacement is not possible, the pro should be applied intermittently for 24 hours
lapsed tissue may be amputated. The episiot following surgery. Warm compresses should be
omy incision is closed with a three‐layer applied intermittently starting 24 hours post‐
closure (Figure 21.7; Fossum 2002). Ovariec operatively. An Elizabethan collar or other
tomy or ovariohysterectomy should be per method should be used to avoid self‐trauma.
formed to reduce the recurrence rate (Morrow The vulvar sutures should be removed five to
1986; Fossum 2002). seven days following prolapse repair if the tis
Post‐operatively, patients should be sup sue eversion and edema have regressed signifi
ported with analgesics and may need fluid cantly (Fossum 2002).
418 21 Rectal and Vaginal Fold Prolapse
Anus
Episiotomy
incision
Figure 21.3 Surgical treatment for a Type II vaginal fold prolapse. (a) Location of episiotomy incision for
better exposure to treat vaginal fold prolapse. (b) The tissue is lifted off the vestibular floor for
catheterization of the urethra. A transverse elliptical incision is made at the base of the mass. Care is taken
to avoid the urethral tubercle. (c) The defect in the vaginal wall is closed with a continuous suture using
absorbable material. The episiotomy incision is closed. Source: Nelissen (2015), reproduced with permission
of John Wiley and Sons.
Medical Management
An important step in any treatment, medical
or surgical, is the identification of the underly
ing cause (Popovitch and Holt 1994; Sherding
and Johnson 2006). Identification of the pri
mary cause may also help determine the prog
nosis for recovery without recurrence.
Medical management is an option for treat
Figure 21.7 Episiotomy closure. Source: Photo ment, especially in mild cases of prolapse, or
courtesy of Cory Fisher, DVM, MS, DACVS. Mississippi with acute prolapse. Following lavage with
State University College of Veterinary Medicine. warm saline and lubrication, manual reduc
tion and subsequent placement of a purse‐
Rectal Prolapse string suture around the anus may be adequate
to prevent recurrence. The purse‐string suture
Although uncommon, rectal prolapse is docu should be tight enough to prevent recurrence,
mented in both dogs and cats and is more com while allowing the passage of soft stool
mon in young animals. There does not appear (Fossum 2002). Low‐fiber diets and stool sof
to be any breed predisposition. Some resources teners are indicated while the purse‐string
argue that rectal prolapse may occur more suture is in place. The suture may be removed
commonly in Manx cats due to breed‐associ three to five days following manual reduction.
ated anal laxity (Fossum 2002).
Rectal prolapse must be differentiated from
Surgical Management
intussusception. To differentiate between the
two, a probe such as a thermometer or tubing Surgical treatment is warranted if the prolapse
should be gently inserted between the pro is non‐reducible or if the tissue involved in the
lapsed tissue and the rectal wall. If the mass is prolapse is severely traumatized. In this case,
the result of an intussusception, the probe can the traumatized tissue should be amputated
be easily passed. Conversely, if the mass is due (Fossum 2002).
420 21 Rectal and Vaginal Fold Prolapse
Prior to surgery, the perianal area should be and resection (Fossum 2002). This surgery
clipped and aseptically prepped. As with man should create an adhesion between the sero
ual reduction, the everted tissue should be lav sal surface of the colon and the abdominal
aged and lubricated. The animal should be wall. Two techniques are described, incisional
placed in ventral recumbency with the hind and non‐incisional, and both are considered
legs over the end of the table to allow easiest to be effective.
access to the prolapse, and gauze or similar For either technique, an incision is made on
material should be used tie the tail over the the midline caudal to the umbilicus to expose
back, away from the surgical site (Fossum the abdomen. The descending colon is deliv
2002). ered through the incision and manipulated
A probe should be inserted into the rectal cranially to reduce the prolapse. The anus
lumen and horizontal mattress sutures should should be visibly inspected to ensure that the
be placed in the rectal tissue cranial to the prolapse is sufficiently reduced.
surgical site at the 12, 5, and 8 o’clock posi For the incisional approach, a 3–5 cm inci
tions. The sutures should pass through all lay sion is made longitudinally along the anti
ers of the prolapse and enter the lumen to the mesenteric border of the distal colon through
point that they are deflected off the probe. the serosal and muscularis layers. Care must
Following the placement of the stay sutures, be taken not to penetrate the lumen of the
the traumatized tissue can be transected cau colon. An incision is made on the interior
dal to the sutures. It is recommended that the surface of the abdominal wall approximately
transection be done in sections, with each 2.5 cm (or less, relative to the size of the ani
section then being apposed at the cut edge mal) left of the midline. The incision should
with simple interrupted sutures approxi extend through the peritoneum and into the
mately 2 mm apart. Once the entire circum underlying muscle layer. The respective
ference of the prolapse has been transected edges of the incision in the colon and the
and anastomosed, the stay sutures can be abdominal incision should be apposed and
removed and the tissue can be placed back sutured using non‐absorbable sutures in
into the pelvic canal. In some cases an anal simple continuous or simple interrupted
purse‐string suture may be indicated, espe patterns.
cially if the underlying cause of the prolapse For a non‐incisional approach, an 8–10 cm
involved tenesmus (Fossum 2002). area on the antimesenteric border of the distal
For pain control, opioid epidurals may help colon should be scraped with a scalpel blade
to decreased or eliminate tenesmus. Systemic or abraded with a gauze sponge. The same
analgesics should be given as needed. If a should be done to the abdominal wall 2.5 cm
purse‐string suture is placed, a low‐fiber diet is left of the midline. Horizontal mattress sutures
indicated post‐operatively. Stool softeners should be pre‐placed between the two areas
should be administered for at least two weeks and the sutures should be tied to appose the
following amputation and resection. The scored surfaces (Fossum 2002). A 1994 study
purse‐string suture can be removed two days of 14 dogs and cats comparing the incisional
following resection. The anastomosis site and non‐incisional methods found that there
should be monitored for leakage following was no significant clinical difference in out
surgery (Fossum 2002). come between the two procedures (Popovitch
and Holt 1994).
A laparoscopic technique has been described
Colopexy
in which a 10/11 mm trocar‐cannula unit was
Colopexy is indicated if the prolapse recurs placed on the midline 2.5–5 cm caudal to the
following manual reduction or amputation umbilicus. A second trocar‐cannula unit was
References 421
References
Arbeiter, K. and Bucher, A. (1994). Traumatically Nelissen, P. (2015). Uterine and vaginal prolapse.
caused perineal prolapse of the vagina In: Small Animal Surgical Emergencies (ed.
followed by a retroflexion of the urinary L.R. Aronson), 420. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
bladder in the bitch. Tierärztl. Prax. 22: 78–79. Popovitch, C.A. and Holt, D. (1994). Colopexy as
Fossum, T.W. (2002). Small Animal Surgery, 2e, a treatment for rectal prolapse in dogs and
619–620. St. Louis, MO: Mosby. cats: a retrospective study of 14 cases. Vet.
Johnston, S., Kustritz, M.V., and Olson, P. (2001). Surg. 23: 115–118.
Canine and Feline Theriogenology. Purswell, B.J. (2000). Vaginal disorders. In:
Philadelphia, PA: W.B. Saunders. Textbook of Veterinary Internal Medicine:
Marjani, M., Ghaffari, M.S., and Moosakhani, F. Diseases of the Dog and Cat, vol. 1 and 2 (eds.
(2009). Rectal prolapse secondary to S.J. Ettinger and E.C. Feldman), 1566–1571.
antibiotic‐associated colitis in a dog. Comp. Philadelphia, PA: W.B. Saunders.
Clin. Pathol. 18: 473–475. Sherding, R.G. and Johnson, S.E. (2006). Diseases
McNamara, P.S., Dykes, N., and Harvey, H.J. of the Intestines. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier.
(1997). Chronic vaginocervical prolapse with Williams, J.M. (2005). Disorders of the perineum
visceral incarceration in a dog. J. Am. Anim. and anus. In: BSAVA Manual of Canine and
Hosp. Assoc. 33: 533–536. Feline Gastroenterology (eds. J.E. Hall, J.W.
Memon, M.A., Pavletic, M.M., and Kumar, M.S. Simpson and D.A. Williams), 213–221.
(1993). Chronic vaginal prolapse during Quedgeley: British Small Animal Veterinary
pregnancy in a bitch. JAVMA 202: 295–297. Association.
Morrow, D.A. (ed.) (1986). Current therapy in Zhang, S., Zhang, J., Zhang, N. et al. (2012).
theriogenology: Diagnosis, Treatment, and Comparison of laparoscopic‐assisted and open
Prevention of Reproductive Diseases in Small colopexy in dogs. B. Vet. I. Puawy 56: 415–417.
and Large Animals, 2e. Philadelphia, PA:
Saunders.
423
21A
Rectal prolapse may occur as a result of patients presenting with rectal prolapse in the
gastrointestinal or urogenital disease and sub- shelter setting; however, older patients may
sequent straining. The condition may be man- also suffer from rectal prolapse secondary to
aged by manual reduction of the prolapsed diseases such as prostatitis, cystitis, and related
tissue and placement of a purse‐string suture. to dystocia. General anesthetic considerations
Severe cases, or those in which conservative for neonatal and pediatric patients are pre-
management fails, will require a colopexy. sented in Chapter 15. Older patients should be
Animals should be carefully assessed to rule carefully screened for concurrent systemic dis-
out concurrent perineal hernias. ease prior to general anesthesia.
The list of differential diagnoses for a mass Most cases of vaginal fold prolapse will
protruding from the vulva includes vaginal require standard monitoring and supportive
hyperplasia, vaginal fold prolapse, uterine pro- care during anesthesia. Uterine prolapse
lapse, or neoplasia. Vaginal hyperplasia (edema patients may be nursing and many drugs will
of the vaginal wall mediated by estrogen) is be excreted in the milk. Use of non‐steroidal
common in certain breeds of dog, including anti‐inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) should be
Staffordshire Terriers and pugs, and also occurs limited in nursing patients; however a single
in cats. Treatment consists of reducing the tis- post‐operative dose of injectable NSAIDs is
sue and ovariohysterectomy (OHE) or ovariec- generally regarded as safe (Mathews 2005).
tomy. True vaginal fold prolapse is uncommon
in dogs and cats and may require resection of
the prolapsed tissue in addition to OHE/ova- Analgesic Concerns
riectomy. Uterine prolapse is rare in dogs and
cats and usually occurs post‐parturition (see In addition to systemic analgesics including
Chapter 12). In all cases, urethral patency must opioids and NSAIDs, epidural administration
be assessed and the urethra should be catheter- of analgesics should be considered for reduc-
ized to reduce the likelihood of surgical trauma. tion of rectal and vaginal fold prolapses. Local
anesthetics placed into the epidural space will
provide analgesia as well as motor blockade
Anesthetic Concerns that may facilitate reduction of the prolapse.
Epidural local anesthetic administration will
Pediatric cats and dogs with gastrointestinal prevent straining and may allow manual reduc-
parasite infestations may be the most common tion of a prolapse without general anesthesia.
424 21A Rectal and Vaginal Fold Prolapse: Anesthesia Supplement
References
Mathews, K.A. (2005). Analgesia for the pregnant, catheterization and pain management in the
lactating and neonatal to pediatric cat and dog. treatment of feline urethral obstruction. J. Vet.
J. Vet. Emerg. Crit. Care 15 (4): 273–284. Emerg. Crit. Care 21 (1): 50–52.
O’Hearn, A.K. and Wright, B.D. (2011).
Coccygeal epidural with local anesthetic for
425
22
Dental disease is a common source of pain in treat a painful tooth will lead to continued pain
middle‐aged and older animals, and is for the animal. Proper pain management and
frequently encountered in the shelter environ- extraction of diseased teeth, however, can be
ment. Animals in pain may become listless or accomplished successfully in the shelter
aggressive, or exhibit other behaviors that sig- environment.
nificantly decrease their adoptability. For This chapter will cover the basics of proper
example, many cats with tooth resorption will extraction technique, dental instrumentation,
react negatively to any form of touch, earning and pain management in the oral cavity.
them a label of “aggressive” or “unfriendly”
when they may simply need analgesics and
oral healthcare. Animals that are pain free will Indications and Equipment
be more interactive and less stressed, thus
healthier and overall more adoptable. Persistent primary (deciduous) teeth, periodon-
Most facilities will be able to provide anes- tal disease, and endodontic disease are the most
thesia, but may not have dental and oral radiol- common indications for extraction of a tooth.
ogy equipment. For those fortunate enough to Persistent primary teeth (Figure 22.1) should be
have the proper instruments and equipment, extracted as soon as the permanent tooth begins
dentistry can often offer an excellent return on to erupt, in order to reduce the likelihood of a
investment. developmental malocclusion and prevent peri-
Advanced procedures such as root canal treat- odontal disease associated with crowding.
ment and crown placement are available to save Additionally, any tooth that is fractured with
animals’ teeth. Lack of resources and difficulty pulp exposure should be treated, if not endo-
with adequate follow‐up care make advanced dontically, then by extraction (Figure 22.2). It is
procedures a less viable option for shelter prac- no longer acceptable practice to leave these
tices. However, cats and dogs generally manage teeth and “see what happens.” Invariably “what
quite well with the proper removal of teeth, and happens” is that they abscess and become pain-
many can live comfortable lives with few or no ful. Many owners and veterinarians see these
teeth at all. Removal of a tooth generally results teeth months or years after the initial trauma.
in a gap in the dentition that is rarely a problem They do not appear painful at that point, but
and canine and feline teeth do not often suffer many have gone through an acutely painful pro-
from “dental drift,” a potential consequence of cess that has subsequently become a chronic
tooth extraction in human dentistry. Failure to low‐grade pain and source of infection.
426 22 Dental Extractions in a Shelter Environment
Instrumentation
Extraction forceps are used in the final Access to the tooth is important. If needed,
extraction of the tooth. There is an old adage mesial and/or distal releasing incisions are
that says “the only extraction forceps needed made in the gingiva, extending beyond the
are your fingers,” which emphasizes the fact mucogingival junction (Figure 22.4b). The gin-
that the tooth must be very loose prior to using gival flap is then gently raised using a peri-
these forceps. Crowns are easily snapped off osteal elevator. (A flap may not be needed in all
when forceps are used improperly or with extractions; Figure 22.5a.) A pair of scissors
excessive force. A forceps that properly fits can be used to help undermine the flap and
onto the crown should be used to gently grasp release tension (Figure 22.5b).
the crown and slightly rotate the tooth or tooth Access to the tooth root can be obtained by
segment while applying gentle, controlled removing buccal alveolar bone using a round
traction. As with other surgical instruments, bur on a high‐speed handpiece with water
all dental instruments should be sterilized cooling (Figure 22.6). Care should be taken to
prior to use. remove bone only and not tooth material.
The typical dental unit (or “cart”) can be sta- When dealing with a multirooted tooth, the
tionary (mounted on the table or wall), or can tooth must be sectioned, starting at the furca-
be an actual cart that allows the user to move it tion and moving toward the crown
about in the clinic. A dental unit should (Figure 22.7).
include a low‐speed handpiece (for polishing), By working on alternating surfaces of the
a high‐speed handpiece (for bone removal dur- tooth and using various techniques, the perio-
ing surgical extractions), an air/water syringe, dontal ligament is fatigued and the tooth can
and a scaler. Follow manufacturer’s directions be lifted out of the alveolus. A periodontal ele-
for maintenance of equipment. vator is introduced into the periodontal liga-
ment space. Careful, controlled force is applied
in an apical direction (toward the root) around
Extraction Technique the entire tooth. Additionally, an elevator may
be introduced perpendicular to the axis of the
First, the epithelial attachment is severed tooth and between two adjacent portions of the
using a scalpel blade (#11 or #15; Figure 22.4a). sectioned tooth. Using gentle pressure, the
428 22 Dental Extractions in a Shelter Environment
(a) (b)
Figure 22.4 A scalpel blade is used to severe the epithelial attachment (a). Releasing incisions can be
made perpendicular to the sulcus and aid in releasing tension on the flap (b).
(a) (b)
Figure 22.5 A periosteal elevator is used to gently lift a full-thickness flap from the underlying alveolar
bone. Care must be taken to preserve the integrity of the flap, as it will be used to cover the defect
(a). Scissors may also be used to facilitate the release of tension on the flap (b).
(a) (b)
Figure 22.6 A high-speed handpiece (a) equipped with a bur can be used to remove buccal alveolar bone
in order to expose the tooth root surfaces (b).
e levator can be rotated until the two segments winged elevator for placing between adjacent
become loosened (Figure 22.8). One of the tooth segments.
authors (Eubanks) prefers a winged elevator The extraction site is curetted free of debris and
for the first approach and a regular or non‐ the alveolar edges are smoothed using a round or
Extraction Technique 429
(a) (b)
3) Sutures should be placed 2 mm apart. teeth are often small brachycephalic breed
Simple continuous suture patterns are dogs that require extra care related to main-
rarely recommended for oral surgery. taining a patent airway, especially in the recov-
4) The base of the flap should be at least as ery period. Small patients are more likely to
large as the apex (or larger) to preserve lose body heat precipitously and close atten-
blood supply. tion should be paid to active warming
5) Place edges of fresh epithelium adjacent to measures.
fresh epithelium (bleeding edges) with no The use of mouth gags has been linked to the
overlap or gaps. occurrence of post‐anesthetic blindness and
6) The caretaker should check the area daily, other neurologic deficits following anesthesia
but should be cautious about putting ten- in cats (Stiles et al. 2012; de Miguel Garcia
sion on the flap. et al. 2013). The maxillary artery, a branch of
the external carotid artery, is responsible for
Deciduous teeth can be approached in much
perfusion of the retina, inner ear, and much of
the same manner as adult teeth. They often
the cerebral cortex in cats, and spring‐loaded
have long, slender roots that may break easily
mouth gags can attenuate maxillary artery
(especially deciduous canines). If a deciduous
blood flow during anesthesia (Barton‐Lamb
canine tooth is not mobile, bone must be
et al. 2013). Spring‐loaded mouth gags should
removed on the buccal aspect in order to pre-
be avoided and, in adult cats when the mouth
vent the tooth from “snapping off” and leaving
is held open by any type of device, the intergin-
root behind. Every effort should be made to
gival distance between the upper and lower
remove all of the tooth material and to avoid
canine teeth should be less than 42 mm
damaging the underlying permanent tooth bud.
(Martin‐Flores et al. 2014). Vigilance in moni-
Feline teeth may also present a challenge as
toring blood pressure and oxygenation is also
they can be quite fragile, especially when they
required, as hypotension and hypoxemia may
are affected by tooth resorption. Buccal bone
compromise oxygen delivery to the retina and
removal will facilitate fracture‐free extractions.
brain even without the use of mouth gags.
In any species, care should be taken when
working on the mandibular teeth not to cause
an iatrogenic fracture, either at the mandibular
Analgesic Concerns
body or the symphysis. Pre‐operative radio-
graphs can help to identify osteomyelitis and
Dental extractions range in invasiveness and
areas of significant bone loss that may predis-
degree of post‐operative pain. Systemic analge-
pose a patient to fracture.
sia in the form of opioids and non‐steroidal
If a root breaks, additional alveolar bone can
anti‐inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) should be
be removed in an effort to reveal the root seg-
available for all patients undergoing invasive
ment and make retrieval easier. Dental radio-
procedures. Generally, opioids are adminis-
graphs can be of great value in this situation.
tered in the immediate peri‐operative period,
and may be continued post‐operatively if inva-
sive procedures including extractions are per-
Anesthetic Concerns formed. NSAIDs should also be considered for
post‐operative administration, once it is estab-
Standard peri‐anesthetic concerns apply to lished that renal function is normal and the
oral surgical procedures, including the need to patient is volume replete.
prevent, monitor for, and respond to hypother- Local anesthesia is easy to provide and
mia, hypotension, and hypoventilation. In extremely effective. Complete blockade of pain
addition, patients with retained deciduous impulses in the periphery reduces the amount
Analgesic Concerns 431
of inhalant anesthetic required (Snyder and CO) to prolong anesthesia. This local anes-
Snyder 2013), thereby improving cardiovascu- thetic has gained widespread acceptance in
lar parameters, as well as reducing the need for humans for dental procedures because of its
analgesics in the post‐operative period. reported superiority in penetration of bony
When performing a nerve block, a small vol- structures and lower risk of systemic toxicity.
ume of local anesthetic is placed in close prox- However, enhanced effectiveness may be site
imity to the nerve, using anatomic landmarks. dependent (mandibular versus maxillary nerve
Oral nerve blocks are easy to learn, inexpen- blockade) and controversy exists as to whether
sive to perform, have a relatively rapid onset of paresthesias may be more common with artic-
effect, and should be included in every bal- aine (Yapp et al. 2011).
anced anesthetic protocol where potentially Mixtures of short‐acting and long‐acting
painful dental procedures are to be local anesthetics have been advocated to pro-
performed. vide short onset time and longer‐lasting anes-
thesia. However, multiple studies, mostly in
humans, indicate that the combination of
Anesthetic Agents
short‐ and long‐acting local anesthetics pro-
Choice of local anesthetic determines onset vides minimal advantage in terms of speed of
and length of anesthesia (Table 22.1). Lidocaine onset and actually decreases the length of
and bupivacaine are the two most commonly anesthesia, compared to the long‐acting anes-
used local anesthetics in veterinary dental pro- thetic alone (Lawal and Adetunji 2009;
cedures, though mepivacaine, ropivacaine, lev- Gadsden et al. 2011).
obupivacaine, and articaine are also employed. Duration of efficacy of local anesthetics can
Lidocaine and mepivacaine are short‐acting be extended by the use of various adjuncts,
agents that, when administered alone, are typi- including vasoconstrictors (such as epineph-
cally effective for 1–2 hours. Bupivacaine, and rine), opioids, and alpha2 agonists (Table 22.2).
its enantiomer levobupivacaine, have an onset Adverse effects of local anesthesia can be
of action of around 10 minutes and effects can systemic or local. Systemic toxicity includes
last for 3–6 hours. Bupivacaine is available in a neurologic (drowsiness, seizures) and cardio-
variety of concentrations and in a long‐acting vascular complications (hypotension, dys-
DepoFoam® formulation (Pacira BioSciences, rhythmias, cardiac arrest). Attention must be
San Diego, CA) that can provide up to 72 hours paid to total local anesthetic dose and it should
of analgesia (Nocita®, Aratana Therapeutics, be noted when using combinations of local
Leawood, KS). The local anesthetic articaine is anesthetics that toxicity is additive. In addition,
available in dental cartridges mixed with epi- aspiration of the syringe before injection
nephrine (Septocaine®, Septodont, Louisville, should always be performed to avoid
Table 22.1 Local anesthetics commonly used in veterinary dental nerve blocks.
Table 22.2 Adjuvants to local anesthetics used in veterinary dental nerve blocks.
i nadvertent intravascular injection. Local medial canthus of the eye and the needle
adverse effects of local anesthetic blocks should never be advanced beyond this point (a
include temporary or permanent paresthesias, special concern in brachycephalic breeds and
infection, or hemorrhage. Dental blocks may all cats; Figure 22.10).
cause loss of sensation to the tongue or lips, Palpate the infraorbital foramen as a depres-
resulting in self‐mutilation, though this is not sion in the alveolar mucosa apical to the distal
common (Beckman 2006). Other rare compli- root of PM3 (Figures 22.10–22.12). While hold-
cations include direct nerve trauma, anaphy- ing the syringe and needle parallel to the nose,
lactic or anaphylactoid reactions to the agent, advance the needle into the canal. In brachyce-
and local hematoma formation. phalic dogs and cats, the angle of approach
toward midline is much greater than in dolico-
Materials cephalic or mesaticephalic breeds (45° vs.
10–20°). In addition, it is important in brachy-
The materials needed to perform a nerve block cephalic animals to keep the needle flat in the
are a 1–3 ml syringe and a 25–27‐gauge × 0.75– dorsoventral plane to avoid entering the globe
1.5 in. (1.9–3.8 cm) needle. Flexible intrave- or retrobulbar space. For a cranial infraorbital
nous (IV) catheters may be used for some nerve block, the needle should not be advanced
dental blocks. deeply. After injection, apply digital pressure
to the rostral opening of the canal for one
Technique minute (Rochette 2005; Reuss‐Lamky 2007).
References
Barton‐Lamb, A.L., Martin‐Flores, M., Scrivani, Martin‐Flores, M., Scrivani, P.V., Loew, E. et al.
P.V. et al. (2013). Evaluation of maxillary (2014). Maximal and submaximal mouth
arterial blood flow in anesthetized cats with the opening with mouth gags in cats: implications
mouth closed and open. Vet. J. 196 (3): 325–331. for maxillary artery blood flow. Vet. J. 200 (1):
Beckman, B.W. (2006). Pathophysiology and 60–64.
Management of Surgical and Chronic Oral Meechan, J.G. (2011). The use of the mandibular
Pain in dogs and cats. J. Vet. Dent. 23 (1): infiltration anesthetic technique in adults. J.
50–60. Am. Dent. Assoc. 142 (Suppl 3): 19S–24S.
Beckman, B. and Legendre, L. (2002). Regional Reuss‐Lamky, H. (2007). Administering dental
nerve blocks for oral surgery in companion nerve blocks. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 43:
animals. Compendium 24 (6): 439–444. 298–305.
de Miguel Garcia, C., Whiting, M., and Alibhai, Rochette, J. (2005). Regional Anesthesia and
H. (2013). Cerebral hypoxia in a cat following analgesia for Oral and dental procedures. Vet.
pharyngoscopy involving use of a mouth gag. Clin. N. Am. Small Anim. Pract. 35:
Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 40 (1): 106–108. 1041–1058.
Gadsden, J., Hadzic, A., Gandhi, K. et al. (2011). Snyder, C.J. and Snyder, L.B. (2013). Effect of
The effect of mixing 1.5% mepivacaine and mepivacaine in an infraorbital nerve block on
0.5% bupivacaine on duration of analgesia and minimum alveolar concentration of isoflurane
latency of block onset in ultrasound‐guided in clinically normal anesthetized dogs
interscalene block. Anesth. Analg. 112 (2): undergoing a modified form of dental
471–476. dolorimetry. JAVMA 242 (2): 199–204.
Krug, W. and Losey, J. (2011). Area of Stiles, J., Weil, A.B., Packer, R.A. et al. (2012).
desensitization following mental nerve block Post‐anesthetic cortical blindnessin cats:
in dogs. J. Vet. Dent. 28 (3): 146–150. twenty cases. Vet. J. 193: 367–373.
Lawal, F.M. and Adetunji, A. (2009). A Yapp, K.E., Hopcraft, M.S., and Parashos, P.
comparison of epidural anaesthesia with (2011). Articaine: a review of the literature. Br.
lignocaine, bupivacaine and a lignocaine‐ Dent. J. 210 (7): 323–329.
bupivacaine mixture in cats. J. S. Afr. Vet.
Assoc. 80 (4): 243–246.
437
Part Two
Fundamentals of HQHVSN
439
23
Fundamentals of HQHVSN
Sara White
This book is about high‐quality, high‐volume s terilization of large numbers of cats and dogs
spay–neuter (HQHVSN). The first part of the to reduce their overpopulation and subsequent
book has discussed clinical knowledge and euthanasia” (Griffin et al. 2016).
procedures focused on the individual patient, In order to understand more about
while this second part focuses on the HQHVSN HQHVSN, we need to consider several of the
program as a whole. The anesthetic and surgi terms used in this definition. We need to
cal procedures described in this book need not understand the meanings and implications of
be done in high‐volume settings, but the high‐ “high volume,” “accessible,” and “targeted.”
volume surgical setting is a special organiza
tional and logistical challenge that this book
What Is “High Volume”?
seeks to address and explain. A successful
HQHVSN program is more than just the sum The ASV task force that defined HQHVSN
of its parts and requires more than the knowl chose not to place a number on how many sur
edge of how to perform successful anesthetic geries are required to count as “high volume.”
and surgical procedures: it requires planning, This was to take into account the many differ
strategies, and protocols. This chapter intro ent models for providing efficient spay and
duces the core components of HQHVSN pro neuter services. Some high‐volume clinics
grams and serves as a guide to Part Two of this operate daily, while others may operate only
textbook. one day a month, and still others, like “in‐
clinic clinics” (see Chapter 36), may only oper
ate for a few hours a week within an existing
HQHVSN full‐service veterinary practice. This variability
made it impossible to choose a daily, weekly,
Throughout this book, authors have used the monthly, or annual number of surgeries that
acronym HQHVSN when talking about good would be required to qualify as high volume.
practices for programs focused on spaying and The more salient and distinctive characteris
neutering, and procedures performed by those tics that define the “high‐volume” in HQHVSN
programs. More specifically, the Association of are the singular focus and efficient flow of the
Shelter Veterinarians (ASV) “defines HQHVSN high‐volume surgery day. In veterinary general
services as efficient surgical initiatives that practice, spaying and neutering may be inter
meet or exceed veterinary medical standards spersed with other procedures and outpatient
of care in providing accessible, targeted visits, and staffing and protocols reflect this
440 23 Fundamentals of HQHVSN
a wide range of clients. Pet ownership is nearly both in preventing unwanted offspring as well
as common in households with low incomes as as preventing the surrender of existing com
in those with high incomes, and households panion animals. Targeting can be based upon a
with lower incomes are more likely to have variety of different characteristics of animals
more than one pet when compared to higher‐ or humans within the HQHVSN program’s ser
income households (Access to Veterinary Care vice area.
Coalition 2018). In addition, animals from low‐
income households are less likely to be altered Targeting by Income
than those from higher‐income households As mentioned in the previous section on acces
(Chu et al. 2009), so being able to price services sibility, low‐income pet owners are an impor
to allow access by low‐income owners is a key tant target of HQHVSN programs. Targeting
to accessibility. by owner income may not necessarily mean
income screening, as other clinic characteris
Other Factors in Accessibility tics such as geographic placement and adver
Accessibility encompasses more than just the tising campaigns may also target a lower‐income
cost of the service. Accessibility may also be clientele. Even without income screening, the
influenced or determined by geography and majority of clients who use HQHVSN clinics
transportation, by cultural norms, by language have below‐median income, and choose to use
barriers, or by sense of safety (Aday and the clinic based primarily on the cost of ser
Andersen 1974). For HQHVSN clinics, geo vices (White et al. 2018). Many of the pets visit
graphic accessibility may include transporta ing these clinics have never seen a veterinarian
tion services for pets, or may be achieved by before (Benka and McCobb 2016; White et al.
providing a mobile (mobile animal steriliza 2018).
tion hospital [MASH] or self‐contained mobile)
clinic. Cultural and language accessibility may Targeting Community Cats
be enhanced by hiring bilingual staff members Of equal importance is the provision of subsi
and by engaging volunteers within the dized spay–neuter services for community ani
community. mals. In the United States, free‐roaming and
Accessibility also requires that potential cli feral cats, or community cats, represent a
ents are aware of the services being provided. major source of feline overpopulation and may
The clinic may need to employ diverse adver produce up to 80% of the kittens born annually
tising strategies to reach the intended clientele, in the country (Levy and Crawford 2004; see
and multilingual advertisements may be Chapter 25). Targeting these cats (and in places
necessary. with community or free‐roaming dogs, target
ing those dogs) is important for population
control as well as for the welfare of the indi
What Is “Targeted”?
vidual animals and public health.
In order to maximize their impact, spay–neu
ter programs focus or “target” their efforts on Targeting by Geography
known sources of shelter impoundment and Geographic targeting is another strategy that
surplus cats and dogs in the community (see some HQHVSN programs have used, since not
Chapters 24 and 25). These include those cats all neighborhoods within a program’s service
and dogs that would otherwise be unlikely to area have equal needs. Geographic informa
be neutered, including both owned pets from tion system (GIS) mapping technology can
low‐income households and community ani allow programs to target services and outreach
mals. Since intact animals are more likely to be to areas with high shelter intake (Miller et al.
relinquished to shelters (New et al. 2000), tar 2014). Simpler techniques for geographic tar
geting spay and neuter services can be helpful geting such as zip code targeting can also be
442 23 Fundamentals of HQHVSN
useful for reaching the neediest communities use, in what space, with workers acting and
(Levy et al. 2014), although zip codes do not interacting in what ways? Without this plan
allow the same precision as GIS. See Chapter 24 ning, a program may be doing spay and neuter
for more information about geographic surgery, but it will not be doing so as efficiently
targeting. and effectively as it could be.
e fficiency, via the use of volunteer labor, or greater daily surgical capacity compared to
via the other sources of funding mentioned most mobile clinics, the ability to establish
earlier. relationships with local veterinary practices
and community members, and the possibility
Human Resources to hospitalize animals if necessary.
Human resources include the employees, Disadvantages include time and costs associ
independent contractors, and volunteers that ated with establishing and maintaining a com
allow the HQHVSN program to provide ser mercial facility and the potential for geographic
vices. Chapters 29 and 30 talk about finding limitation of the population in need of ser
and hiring employees for HQHVSN programs, vices. An alternative model of a stationary
and may also be useful when considering clinic that may counteract some of these disad
working with volunteers. vantages is the use of an existing veterinary
Volunteers are an essential part of some clinic hospital for regularly scheduled spay–neuter
models, and are used minimally if at all in other clinics. These “in‐clinic clinics” (Chapter 36)
clinic models. It is important to be realistic are especially valuable for serving the needs of
about expectations for using volunteers in a targeted populations in rural communities.
clinic setting. Do the available volunteers have Mobile spay–neuter clinics often take one of
the skills needed to contribute meaningfully to two forms: MASH‐style clinics (Chapter 34)
the program? Or, if the program is seeking and vehicles outfitted with surgical facilities
highly skilled volunteers such as veterinarians (Chapter 33). These models have the advan
and veterinary technicians, is it realistic to tages of being able to target any geographic
expect these people to provide their services at area in which services are needed and lower
no cost? In some circumstances the answer may overhead costs. Disadvantages include limited
be “yes” – large monthly MASH‐style commu animal housing and time constraints on spay–
nity cat clinics often rely on an all‐volunteer neuter efforts at a given location, leading to
workforce. But in most cases it is more realistic constraints on the number of animals served.
to assume that all highly skilled jobs will need to Client communication and emergency care
be performed by paid workers. protocols must be especially well planned, as
mobile clinics often move from an area after
Program Models completing surgeries for the day, potentially
A variety of program models have been leaving animals without the benefit of veteri
designed and implemented to serve as efficient nary care shortly after recovery and release to
surgical initiatives providing accessible, tar their owners. In some states, practice acts pro
geted sterilization to large numbers of cats and hibit or limit mobile neutering services.
dogs. The model that an HQHVSN program The final type of clinic is a community cat
chooses should be shaped by the available clinic (or feral cat clinic). This type of clinic
resources and need(s) that the program is try utilizes any one of the aforementioned models,
ing to address. These program models include but focuses exclusively on serving community
stationary and mobile spay–neuter clinics, cats. This type of clinic can offer greater safety
MASH‐style operations, feral cat programs, and efficiency, with all protocols geared toward
and services provided through private practi cats that cannot be handled, and with all sup
tioners. See Table 23.1 for a description of plies and equipment sized for feline patients.
these HQHVSN program models and their These clinics can be lower stress for cats since
attributes. Each of these clinic models is cov they will not be exposed to dogs. Chapter 35
ered in its own chapter later in the text. describes the policies and protocols that should
Stationary clinics (Chapter 32) offer many be considered when implementing a commu
advantages over mobile clinics, including nity cat clinic.
Table 23.1 HQHVSN clinic models.
Startup Surgical
Clinic model Description cost capacity Advantages Disadvantages Best uses
Stationary Clinic operates within High Highest Able to operate at the Requires adequate nearby Urban or suburban areas
a facility dedicated to highest capacity population to support full‐ with at least 250 000 human
providing spay–neuter Most efficient time service; transport population within 90 miles
services utilization of services may be needed to Programs wishing to target
veterinarians and bring in patients from specific geographic areas or
technicians surrounding areas neighborhoods that have
Ability to hospitalize Startup time is greater than adequate funding and
patients if needed other models? staffing to run this clinic type
Mobile clinic Clinic operates in a High Medium Ability to access target Expensive to buy and Locations where MASH
self‐contained mobile communities maintain clinics are not allowed or
unit Visibility: the vehicle is Lower capacity than where suitable spaces for
a mobile billboard for stationary clinics due to MASH clinics are not
the program limited space and travel time available
their operations. Two important ways that data measures. Chapter 24 describes using data to
tracking can be of use is for monitoring and design and evaluate the effectiveness of spay–
improving patient safety and for evaluating the neuter interventions.
effectiveness of the spay–neuter program in the
target community.
How to Learn More
Safety
Collection of morbidity and mortality data can
One of the most valuable things an aspiring or
allow programs to identify and track problems
experienced spay–neuter veterinarian, clinic
and improve clinic operations (Gerdin et al.
manager, or staffer can do to improve knowl
2011). It is important to understand the cir
edge, skills, and wellbeing is to connect with
cumstances surrounding major adverse events
others in the field. Professional associations,
(deaths and serious complications) in order to
online resources, and in‐person training are all
identify whether an error occurred, when and
available (see Box 23.1).
where an error happened, and what could be
For those considering starting a clinic or
changed to reduce the odds of the same error
hoping to improve or hone their existing clinic
occurring again. This information can be use
operations or surgical skills or simply to con
ful for staff training, allowing the surgical team
nect with others, there is great value in visiting
to focus vigilance in areas of greatest likeli
other HQHVSN clinics or programs. Seeing a
hood of complications and to change practices
clinic in action provides insight into clinic flow
that give rise to unnecessary risk.
and protocols and generates a picture of clinic
The use of computerized records can further
operations more comprehensive than words
improve patient care and safety by allowing
and pictures on paper can convey, and watch
analysis of trends in patient outcomes. With
ing another surgeon work can be inspiring and
computerized records, it can be simple to track
educational. Connections with other HQHVSN
types of complications by doctor or by animal
programs and other HQHVSN veterinarians
type, to recognize and evaluate changes in out
are also valuable for technical troubleshooting
comes, and to correlate these changes with any
and emotional support in the wake of compli
changes in protocols or standard operating
cations and unexpected events (White 2018).
procedures.
Effectiveness
Data tracking can also be useful for evaluating Conclusion
the effectiveness of the HQHVSN program. Is
it reaching its target population? Is the pro A successful HQHVSN program is a special
gram affecting local shelters or animals in the organizational and logistical challenge that
community as intended? Program effective requires much more than just excellent medi
ness can be measured in a variety of ways: via cal and surgical care and skills. It requires
local shelter intake and euthanasia numbers planning, strategies, and protocols to optimize
(White et al. 2010; Levy et al. 2014; Miller et al. the clinic’s operations and impact. This chap
2014), by nuisance complaints (Scarlett and ter has introduced the core components and
Johnston 2012), by cat colony size (Jones and considerations for HQHVSN programs and
Downs 2011) or kitten production (Hughes provides a background for those working to
and Slater 2002), by disease incidence (Reece establish or improve their HQHVSN program’s
and Chawla 2006), or by other meaningful practices and impact.
References 449
References
Access to Veterinary Care Coalition (2018). ASPCAPro (2018). Daily flow. https://www.
Access to Veterinary Care: Barriers, Current aspcapro.org/sites/default/files/asna_daily_
Practices, and Public Policy. Nashville, TN: flow.pdf (accessed 1 March 2019).
University of Tennessee College of Social Benka, V.A. and McCobb, E. (2016). Characteristics
Work. of cats sterilized through a subsidized, reduced‐
Aday, L.A. and Andersen, R. (1974). A cost spay‐neuter program in Massachusetts and
framework for the study of access to medical of owners who had cats sterilized through this
care. Health Serv. Res. 9: 208. program. JAVMA 249: 490–498.
450 23 Fundamentals of HQHVSN
Brodbelt, D. (2009). Perioperative mortality Levy, J.K., Bard, K.M., Tucker, S.J. et al. (2017).
in small animal anaesthesia. Vet. J. 182: Perioperative mortality in cats and dogs
152–161. undergoing spay or castration at a high‐
Chu, K., Anderson, W.M., and Rieser, M.Y. volume clinic. Vet. J. 224: 11–15.
(2009). Population characteristics and neuter Levy, J.K. and Crawford, P.C. (2004). Humane
status of cats living in households in the strategies for controlling feral cat populations.
United States. JAVMA 234: 1023–1030. JAVMA 225: 1354–1360.
Fletcher, D.J., Boller, M., Brainard, B.M. et al. Levy, J.K., Isaza, N.M., and Scott, K.C. (2014).
(2012). RECOVER evidence and knowledge Effect of high‐impact targeted trap‐neuter‐
gap analysis on veterinary CPR. Part 7: clinical return and adoption of community cats on cat
guidelines. J. Vet. Emerg. Crit. Care (San intake to a shelter. Vet. J. 201: 269–274.
Antonio) 22 (Suppl 1): S102–S131. Miller, G.S., Slater, M.R., and Weiss, E. (2014).
Gawande, A. (2010). The Checklist Manifesto: Effects of a geographically‐targeted
How to Get Things Right. New York: intervention and creative outreach to reduce
Metropolitan Books. shelter intake in Portland, Oregon. Open J.
Gerdin, J.A., Slater, M.R., Makolinski, K.V. et al. Anim. Sci. 4: 165.
(2011). Post‐mortem findings in 54 cases of Miller, K.P., Rekers, W., Ellis, K. et al. (2016).
anesthetic associated death in cats from two Pedicle ties provide a rapid and safe method
spay‐neuter programs in New York state. J. for feline ovariohysterectomy. J. Feline Med.
Feline Med. Surg. 13: 959–966. Surg. 18: 160–164.
Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al. Morche, J., Mathes, T., and Pieper, D. (2016).
(2016). The Association of Shelter Relationship between surgeon volume and
Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical care outcomes: a systematic review of systematic
guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. JAVMA reviews. Syst. Rev. 5: 204.
249: 165–188. New, J., John, C., Kelch, W.J. et al. (2004). Birth
Haynes, A.B., Weiser, T.G., Berry, W.R. et al. and death rate estimates of cats and dogs in
(2009). A surgical safety checklist to reduce US households and related factors. J. Appl.
morbidity and mortality in a global Anim. Welf. Sci. 7: 229–241.
population. N. Engl. J. Med. 360: 491–499. New, J.C., Salman, M., King, M. et al. (2000).
Hofmeister, E.H., Quandt, J., Braun, C., and Characteristics of shelter‐relinquished
Shepard, M. (2014). Development, animals and their owners compared with
implementation and impact of simple patient animals and their owners in US pet‐owning
safety interventions in a university teaching households. J. Appl. Anim. Welf. Sci. 3:
hospital. Vet. Anaesth. Analg. 41: 243–248. 179–201.
Hughes, K.L. and Slater, M.R. (2002). Norris, B., West, J., Anderson, O. et al. (2014).
Implementation of a feral cat management Taking ergonomics to the bedside – a multi‐
program on a university campus. J. Appl. disciplinary approach to designing safer
Anim. Welf. Sci. 5: 15–28. healthcare. Appl. Ergonom. 45: 629–638.
Hwang, T.G., Lee, Y., and Shin, H. (2011). Reason, J. (2000). Human error: models and
Structure‐oriented versus process‐oriented management. Br. Med. J. 320: 768–770.
approach to enhance efficiency for emergency Reece, J. and Chawla, S. (2006). Control of rabies
room operations: what lessons can we learn. J. in Jaipur, India, by the sterilisation and
Healthc. Manag. 56: 255. vaccination of neighbourhood dogs. Vet. Rec.
Jones, A.L. and Downs, C.T. (2011). Managing 159: 379–383.
feral cats on a university’s campuses: how Scarlett, J. and Johnston, N. (2012). Impact of a
many are there and is sterilization having an subsidized spay neuter clinic on
effect? J. Appl. Anim. Welf. Sci. 14: 304–320. impoundments and euthanasia in a
References 451
Section Five
24
There are two main questions that tend to arise depends on what the problem is. Are you deal-
when thinking about the topic of sterilizing ing with litters of puppies or with kittens? Only
dogs and cats to control their numbers. The neonatal kittens with moms? Spay–neuter may
first question is “how many do we need to do?” have the most impact on population size and
and the second is “which ones should we do?” on homelessness, particularly for animal shel-
It is critical to determine if the goal really is ters when the problem is litters and juveniles
population control or whether the goal is solely rather than adults. Another consideration is
individual animal welfare or other concerns that issues like nuisance complaints may
like nuisance complaints. In some instances, require somewhat different solutions than a
the impact of the populations on disease, nui- purely population control goal. For example,
sance, or welfare may be of primary or second- male cats may not be a good target for cat pop-
ary concern, and different types of data and ulation control, but sterilizing them is usually
modeling may be needed. This chapter will needed for welfare or nuisance abatement.
include some ideas, methods, and data to help
make clear which topics should be considered
in answering questions about impacting popu- How Many Cats or Dogs Do
lations, so that a logical plan can be developed
We Need to Sterilize?
to control population size in dogs and cats
through sterilization.
What Is Population Dynamics?
There are some general considerations that
influence the answer to these questions. First, Population dynamics is “a branch of knowl-
it depends on what species and sub‐group are edge concerned with the sizes of populations
of interest. Is it owned dogs? Feral cats? Cats and the factors involved in their maintenance,
and dogs? Owned and unowned? Each of these decline or expansion” (Merriam‐Webster, Inc.
can influence the answers to the questions 2013). A population is typically defined as a
above. The answers also depend on the loca- group of animals of the same species that live
tion and its culture. Are you in a warm or a together and reproduce. For the purposes of
very cold climate? An urban versus very rural this chapter, a population can be defined in
area? A country where owned dogs are com- many potentially useful ways: all owned cats
monly allowed to roam? The culture and allowed out on a street, all stray dogs entering
beliefs of the human residents are critical to a shelter from a particular neighborhood, a
include in planning for success. Further, it colony of cats, all intact dogs in a city, and so
456 24 Sterilization Programs and Population Control
on. Factors influencing the size of the popula- allow animals to enter and leave the popula-
tion include the age distribution, reproductive tion through a variety of ways.
rate, and the frequency of death, for example: The study of population dynamics makes it
(a) are there seasonal or age patterns to births possible to include whatever knowledge is
or deaths? (b) how often and how many kittens available about these four vital rates (birth and
or puppies are produced? and (c) how often death rates, immigration, and emigration) in
and how many juveniles and adults die? answering the “how many” question. With the
Targeting a clearly identifiable population right data, population dynamics modeling can
that is small enough to sterilize at high levels not only illustrate how many animals need to
becomes an essential component of using steri- be sterilized to stabilize or decrease the popu-
lization to control population size. In thinking lation size, but can also compare permanent
about how many animals one needs to sterilize, versus short‐term sterilization, how immigra-
keep in mind that the number of sterilizations tion and emigration influence the population
needs to be high enough to exceed the repro- of interest, and which vital rate has the most
ductive capacity of the animals (birth rate, fer- impact on the population being studied.
tility, or fecundity; Gotelli 2001). The ability to
get ahead of the breeding curve is also influ-
What Is Population Dynamics
enced by what age the animals can start bear-
Modeling and Why Should I Care?
ing offspring, by how long they live (death rate,
survival, or mortality rate), and by how long Understanding the general characteristics of
they are able to reproduce successfully. the population of interest is enormously help-
While sterilization programs clearly influ- ful in planning a successful sterilization cam-
ence the birth rate of the population, they may paign, and population dynamics modeling is a
also influence survival if sterilized adults live way to achieve this. A model is a way to repre-
longer than intact adults. One study reported sent a complex process with a simpler picture
that cats who were castrated or ovariohysterec- or description (Gotelli 2001; Boone 2015). A
tomized lived significantly longer than intact dynamic model is a model that shows the
cats or vasectomized male cats (Nutter 2005). changes that are inherent in animal popula-
In addition, unless the area is geographically tions. These changes include not just births,
isolated, like an island, dogs and cats from deaths, and the availability of food and shelter,
nearby areas are free to move into the area but also may include predation, local animal
where the sterilization is being done, may be control laws, and human attitudes, all of which
brought in by the people living there, or may be can impact a population. If one takes a verbal,
abandoned or lost in that location (immigra- pictorial, or written description of a population
tion; Gotelli 2001). Sometimes, cats or dogs model and finds equations to describe it, it
leave the area and are adopted into indoor becomes a mathematical model. The four vital
homes, picked up by animal control, or relo- rates (birth and death rates, immigration, and
cate to another location (emigration). emigration) form the core data that are neces-
Immigration and emigration are relative to the sary to develop a mathematical way to describe
defined population. For example, if one is a population. Important predictions are likely
looking at a colony of cats, emigration occurs to be how fast the population grows, how big it
when a cat moves away to a nearby location. can get, and, in the context of spay–neuter, how
That emigrant becomes an immigrant to a col- the size of the population can be decreased.
ony in the new location. Populations that have While the generation of these models is a
no immigration or emigration are called closed specialized task, people with expertise in popu-
(Gotelli 2001). Closed populations are easier to lation dynamics modeling may not be difficult
model, but in reality are rare. Open populations to find. Some zoos, wildlife conservation
How Many Cats or Dogs Do We Need to Sterilize? 457
One type of simulation modeling was used approaches used to examine the relative
to recreate the essential series of events during importance of each vital rate (Slater and Budke
the life cycles of cats (Miller et al. 2014b). This 2010). The choice of approach depends on
cat population dynamics model was explicitly what is being studied and which method is
modeled at the level of the individual – keep- most appropriate for the model.
ing track of each cat’s demographic character- Two additional concepts are important in
istics throughout his or her life span – and was understanding how populations are modeled.
therefore able to more realistically simulate The first is whether the model is deterministic
the application of alternative surgical and non‐ or stochastic (Gotelli 2001). Deterministic
surgical treatment methods, with specific models are simpler and use the one best num-
application to younger versus older individu- ber for each vital rate. The model then calcu-
als, males versus females, and so on. This lates one best estimate of the population size.
approach provided a powerful and flexible tool Stochastic models can incorporate natural var-
for analysis that may be absent from other iation in animal lives as well as environmental
modeling platforms. It is important to note influences (Slater and Budke 2010). Figure 24.1
that interpretation of an analysis like this is illustrates how predictions vary when the
highly dependent on an understanding of the model incorporates stochasticity. The graph
baseline model structure and the nature of the shows what 50 population growth curves
input data. would look like starting with a mix of five male
An important question that should be docu- and female cats in a closed population. For
mented in any model is which of the vital rates illustration, the maximum number of cats
contribute most toward the overall population allowed was set at 4000. The mean growth rate
growth (Owen‐Smith 2007). To do this, model- was 28.7% per year, but 8% of the time the pop-
ers will run either sensitivity or elasticity analy- ulation went quickly to extinction due to the
ses. Any model should have one of these two variability in vital rates.
4000
3500
Mean Population Abundance
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
0 10 20 30 40 50
Year of Simulation
Figure 24.1 A hypothetical example of output from an individual-based simulation model using five cats
(two females and three males) reported to have been originally left on Marion Island. Input data included
seasonal breeding: 92% high season, 48% off-season (standard deviation [SD] = 3% high season, 15%
off-season), kitten mortality (0–6 months old): 75/90% at high densities (SD = 15%), adult mortality per year:
10% (SD = 2%), no immigration or emigration, maximum cat age of 6.5 years. Source: Courtesy of Phil Miller.
How Many Cats or Dogs Do We Need to Sterilize? 459
In the real word, if one is dealing with free‐ Four studies in dogs use simple population
roaming cats or dogs, there are likely nearby dynamics models, one with a visual model in a
populations that interact with the population local situation in the United States (Patronek
of interest. Metapopulation is the term that et al. 1995) and one using a matrix model of
describes a set of interrelated populations that owned dogs in a region of Italy to determine
might serve as source populations for immigra- how many would need to be sterilized to stabi-
tion or emigration of dogs or cats. lize the owned dog population size (Di Nardo
et al. 2007; Figure 24.2). This study led to an
How Has Population Dynamics additional project which incorporated cost–
Modeling Helped Us to Understand benefit analyses for different approaches and
Dog and Cat Populations? considered dog welfare, nuisance, and direct
Dog Population Models While dog populations costs to the government (Høgåsen et al. 2013).
have long been studied, particularly in regard The last study used a visual and mathematical
to controlling rabies, there are few publications model examining the influence on spay–neu-
that address decreasing population size outside ter, adoption, or decreased abandonment pro-
of disease control. Early work on dog and cat grams on dog euthanasia in a region’s shelters
populations in urban North America used (Frank 2004), and reported that spay–neuter
variations on capture-mark-recapture to count was more effective generally than adoption at
animals (Anvik et al. 1974; Heussner et al. reducing euthanasia in shelters, but that the
1978). In the 1980s and 1990s, several full impact may take 30 or more years.
publications both presented methods to A more recent study performed more com-
measure population dynamics in dogs and cats plex population dynamics modeling in dogs on
as well as discussed the results (Nassar and the use of immunocontraception with rabies
Mosier 1982, 1986, 1991; Nassar et al. 1984; vaccination (Carroll et al. 2010). It compared
Nassar and Fluke 1991; Patronek et al. 1997). A rabies vaccination alone, rabies vaccination
more recent review of companion animal and a contraceptive, and culling. Only the
demographics in the United States summarized combination of vaccination and contraception
the data to date and described some of the controlled rabies due to the otherwise rapid
methods used in regional and national data‐ population growth rate and high population
gathering efforts (Clancy and Rowan 2003). turnover. Another recent study in both
Figure 24.2 Free-roaming dog nursing her puppies in Pompeii, Italy. Due to Italian laws, no dogs or cats
can be euthanized unless terminally ill or proven dangerous. Source: Photo courtesy of Leo Slater.
460 24 Sterilization Programs and Population Control
Indonesia and South Africa found that free‐ to be performed and published. Most studies
roaming owned dog populations showed no have examined the effects of trap–neuter–
growth or a decline across three years (Morters return (TNR) or trap and euthanize using
et al. 2014). It also discovered that a substantial matrix models. At its simplest, TNR includes
proportion of the dogs were immigrants humane trapping of the cat, sterilization,
brought in by pet owners. ear‐tipping for permanent identification,
Recent work has begun to combine the con- and, usually, vaccination against rabies
cepts of modeling with targeting populations in (Figure 24.3). The earliest publication used
some way to maximize impact. One recent study matrix modeling to compare TNR with trap
in Mexico used population dynamics modeling and euthanize (Anderson et al. 2004). Vital
to understand how existing spay–neuter rates were estimated from the published
resources could best be leveraged to control the literature. They reported that 50% of the
owned dog population (Kisiel et al. 2018). It was population would need to be trapped and
able to determine that targeting young dogs euthanized annually or >75% sterilized to
would control the population without increasing control the cat population. Changes in the
existing spay–neuter provision by the govern- percentage of the population euthanized
ment. Another study in Brazil modeled owned resulted in a greater change in growth rate
and stray dog populations and determined that than similar changes in sterilization. Another
the carrying capacity was the most important study used matrix modeling to compare
variable in controlling population size, leading non‐surgical three‐year contraception with
to a focus on interventions to reduce capacity by permanent sterilization using literature
environmental changes such as controlling food estimates and a closed population (Budke and
sources (Santos Baquero et al. 2016). Slater 2009). With a short three‐year mean life
span, >51% of adult and juvenile cats would
Cat Population Models In the past 15–20 years, require permanent sterilization each year to
cat population dynamics modeling has begun decrease the population size. A three‐year
Figure 24.3 Ear-tipping (usually on the left) is an international symbol for a sterilized cat. This cat was
sunbathing near the water in Israel near another cat and several people. Israel has recognized a problem
with free-roaming cats for decades. Source: Photo courtesy of Rama Santchi.
How Many Cats or Dogs Do We Need to Sterilize? 461
contraceptive in this same population would pared trap and remove with TNR, and immi-
require >60% to be contracepted annually. gration and emigration were included. Because
The article by Foley et al. (2005) used a of the small starting size of the individual col-
Ricker model and data from two TNR pro- ony modeled (15 cats) and the variability incor-
grams in California and from the literature to porated through a stochastic approach, there
determine what rate of sterilization would be was a 29% probability that the colony could go
needed to decrease those specific cat popula- extinct at some point during the 25 years of
tions. Under current sterilization rates, neither simulations. However, she also found that due
cat population was stabilized or decreased. The to immigration, those colonies re‐established
annual percentage of cats that would need to themselves in a few years, emphasizing the
be neutered and the overall level of neutering importance of immigration in contributing to
needed to stabilize the population were pre- population size. Annual removal of at least
sented in tables based on the original growth 60% of cats or an annual sterilization of >80%
rates of a population and mean life span. To was required for population declines.
stabilize the estimated cat populations of San Lessa and Bergallo (2012) used the same
Diego and Alachua counties, the annual rate of type of simulation modeling as Nutter, but
sterilization would need to be between 14 and used data obtained about owned and free‐
19%, leading to an overall sterilization rate of roaming cats on an island in Brazil. They com-
approximately 71 and 94%, respectively. pared no intervention with male only, female
Another publication used actual data in an only, and both sexes being sterilized as well as
open population in Australia to estimate how annual removal in a closed population. While
many cats would need to be removed to elimi- population sizes for all interventions declined
nate the cat population (Short and Turner over the 50 years modeled, the most dramatic
2005). With a population increase of 150% per declines were for the last three interventions,
year, they estimated that between 1.5 and 2.8 which also had a high probability of the popu-
cats/km would need to be removed per year for lation going extinct. They reported that 70% of
eradication. However, they noted that trapping female cats or 60% of male and female cats
efforts per cat trapped rose dramatically as cat would have to be sterilized or 70% removed for
numbers decreased. these population declines.
Another model also used some location‐ One article examined three potential meth-
specific data from a small town in Texas and ods of dispersal (baits, virus, and virus‐
included hypothetical immigration rates and infected baits) of immunocontraceptives in an
their effects on the population (Schmidt et al. island setting (Courchamp and Cornell 2000).
2009). In general, interventions needed to be It included hypothetical effects of density
applied to >50% of the population to decrease dependence where either reproduction
the population size. They also reported that increases or survival increases as the popula-
“no immigration,” “remove and euthanize,” tion declines, and found that both mecha-
“TNR,” and “50% removal/50% TNR” showed nisms led to similar results. They reported that
similar population declines. In the presence a system using viruses and baits was most
of immigration, remove and euthanize tended effective at decreasing the population size and
to show somewhat greater decreases in popu- concluded that immunocontraception was an
lation size. However, euthanasia required option for controlling cat populations on
more cats to be trapped than the other islands.
interventions. Another article used population dynamics
Nutter (2005) used simulation modeling of modeling and linked that to costs and benefits
individual cats through their lives using data comparing TNR and euthanasia in Hawaii
from her colonies in North Carolina. She com- (Lohr et al. 2012). The authors used some local
462 24 Sterilization Programs and Population Control
data and data from the literature for their vital sensitive to changes in survival at different life
rates. Hypothesized levels of abandonment stages than to fecundity, with adult (more
had large impacts on population size and time than six months old) survival showing the
to colony extinction. They estimated costs of greatest level of sensitivity (Miller et al.
TNR and trap and euthanize. However, they 2014b). Results from simulation models con-
also assigned a specific financial cost to a par- sistently showed that including metapopula-
ticular bird species death, making these results tions with dispersal between the surrounding
of limited utility and generalizability. neighborhood free‐roaming cat populations
A simulation model in cats incorporated and through abandonment of litters from
immigration and emigration and targeting col- households with owned and intact cats could
onies of different sizes with either trap–vasec- dramatically reduce the effectiveness of popu-
tomize/hysterectomize–return (TVHR) or lation management efforts. In particular, the
TNR (Ireland and Miller Neilan 2016). TVHR consistent addition of just a single litter of six‐
has been suggested as an alternative to TNR month‐old individuals led to a major increase
and is based on assumptions about male cat in overall population growth despite intensive
dominance and cat social systems which may management efforts. This insight has pro-
not always apply (McCarthy et al. 2013). found implications for the design of popula-
Ireland and Miller Neilan (2016) incorporated tion management programs.
not only the size of the population but also the To reduce the size of the cat populations
extent of nuisance reduction as important out- modeled, the simulation modeling efforts
comes. While TNR was substantially better suggested that a sterilization program focused
than TVHR at reducing nuisance issues, TVHR on adults (cats more than six months old), tar-
was moderately better at reducing population geting 50% of the intact individuals every six
size. This illustrates how modeling can be used months (or ~75% per year), could be effective
for an increasingly wider range of questions. in controlling free‐roaming cat populations
A more sophisticated population dynamics (Miller et al. 2014b). When directly compared
model used an individual‐based stochastic sim- against one another, a program of free‐roam-
ulation modeling approach to investigate the ing cat removal (whether for adoption or
impact of different population management euthanasia) demonstrated a larger reduction
strategies on free‐roaming cats in a variety of in population size compared to a sterilization
environments (Miller et al. 2014b). Populations program of equal intensity, consistent with
in resource‐rich environments where extra other models (Anderson et al. 2004; Schmidt
food and sufficient shelter were available (like et al. 2009). This is because the models were
many urban settings) were modeled as open all more sensitive to changes in survival than
populations including immigration and emi- fecundity. Since removal effectively shortens
gration, and contrasted to populations in com- survival while sterilization reduces fecundity,
paratively resource‐poor environments (no these results are not surprising. Under the
supplemental feeding, more limited shelter, structure and assumptions of this simulation
where no immigration or emigration occurred; model with a 6.5‐year cat life span, non‐
like some rural settings). The model also was surgical contraceptive methods with about a
focused on comparisons of management three‐year duration were much less effective
options included trapping individuals followed in achieving the desired outcome in most sit-
by removal, permanent sterilization, or non‐ uations. Non‐surgical contraception was
surgical temporary contraception. shown to be effective when immigration and
Sensitivity analysis of the demographic vari- emigration were extremely limited and when
ables used in these models indicated that free‐ treatment rates exceeded 40–50% of cats per
roaming cat population dynamics were more six‐month interval.
How Many Cats or Dogs Do We Need to Sterilize? 463
How Many Cats or Dogs Do We Need defecating, and mating, these are rarely pri-
to Sterilize to Decrease the mary drivers of dog population control in the
Population? United States. On the other hand, cat nuisance
problems such as yowling, fighting, urine
There is a number in the literature that states
spraying, and too many cats may be a primary
that 70% sterilization is needed to stabilize
motivator for municipalities in addressing
population size. This was popularized by both
free‐roaming cats. In addition, concerns about
Merritt Clifton and Marvin Mackie (Clifton
predation are more commonly expressed about
2002; Mackie 2003). They note that spay–neu-
cats; however, dogs can predate wildlife and
ter programs for owned pets in North America
injure fragile habitats. Both species are impli-
seem to stabilize the populations at about a
cated in public health complaints, with bites
70% frequency of sterilization. However, there
probably the most commonly discussed issue.
are wide ranges in reproductive capacity, sur-
Many different diseases may be of concern in
vival, immigration and emigration, and species
different locations and some, like toxoplasmo-
differences between dogs and cats, making any
sis, are more cat specific. However, rabies is a
single target number unlikely to be quite right
huge issue in many parts of the world where
in most situations. Differences by age or life
dogs are the reservoir (WHO Expert Committee
stage, nutrition, breeding, human neglect,
2004). In these countries, public health is often
local laws about picking up strays, and many
the primary concern relating to free‐roaming
other factors are potentially important to con-
dogs. In recent years, the welfare of the dogs or
sider. That is one reason why targeting particu-
cats themselves has been of increasing concern
lar sub‐populations of dogs or cats causing the
(Slater 2001; Totton et al. 2011). Uncontrolled
problems will often have the most impact
reproduction, poor juvenile survival, diseases,
(Hiby 2012). The population of interest and its
and injuries all contribute to concerns about
vital rates must be considered, and under-
free‐roaming or intact dog and cat welfare.
standing which vital rate is most influential on
The role and capabilities of the male in repro-
the model outcome (decreasing population
duction and in the modeling process are also
size) and how one might creatively influence
different for dogs and cats. Male cats can breed
that rate will be the most constructive way to
with many females (Kustritz 2005; Natoli et al.
approach the question.
2000). Most female cats do not choose which
males to breed with, although a few can have
preferences (Natoli et al. 2000). Queens also
How Are Dogs and Cat Populations
may share kitten‐rearing duties, where litters
Different?
from several females are mixed and all queens
The numbers of dogs versus cats that must be provide care (Deag et al. 2000). These behaviors
sterilized to cause a decrease in the population are in contrast with those of free‐roaming dogs.
are different, and the problems associated with There is often little assistance in rearing the
each species are different as well. In dogs, puppies by other dogs (although some owned
when considering population dynamics mod- dogs have been reported to assist by regurgitat-
eling, puppy survival is likely to be lower even ing food; Kustritz 2005; Boitani et al. 2007). In
than juvenile cats, and therefore overall repro- addition, inexperienced male dogs tend to
ductive success is poorer. Free‐roaming dogs mount bitches incorrectly, and there may be
tend to gather in small packs and are very visi- intermale aggression resulting in fewer mat-
ble. They can also be dangerous to runners, ings, particularly when many male dogs are
bikers, and children as well as livestock. While present. Mate preferences are more common,
nuisance behaviors may be a problem even if with familiar males being more successful
only one or two dogs are roaming, barking, (Daniels and Bekoff 1989; Kustritz 2005).
464 24 Sterilization Programs and Population Control
In cats, therefore, there are usually consid- ongoing work to develop effective methods to
ered to be enough male cats available except in access these owners and get them to use sterili-
very unusual circumstances to breed any avail- zation services (Pets for Life 2013).
able females. In the simulation model, steriliz- In developing countries there are rarely
ing only males showed no change in population physical shelters and free‐roaming dogs are the
size relative to no sterilization at all (Miller issue. Complaints, bite reports, or other meth-
et al. 2014b). Conversely, male dogs may be ods may be used to locate the higher‐risk loca-
somewhat more limited in their ability to ser- tions. Conducting dog counts is a common
vice all available females due to limitations of method for enumeration. The typical interven-
viable sperm or mating‐related behaviors. No tion for dogs that are not in a home or readily
models have been run to examine this hypoth- leashed or held by their owners is catch–neu-
esis, and more research is needed to see how ter–return (CNR). Like TNR in North America
male breeding ability could limit population and other countries (Slater 2004; International
growth in dogs. Companion Animal Management Coalition
2011), programs are in place to capture free‐
What Do We Know about Dog roaming dogs for sterilization (Jackman and
and Cat Populations around Rowan 2007). CNR consists of live capture of
the World? the dog, sterilization, permanent identifica-
tion, and return to the capture location (Reece
For those who will be conducting modeling and Chawla 2006; Hiby 2012). This can lead to
or working with modelers, it is vital to have a stable and healthy population of dogs if the
the data about the population in question. sterilization rate is high enough. However,
Up‐to‐date references containing such data can when many of the free‐roaming dogs are
be found online using search engines such as owned or loosely owned, this approach under-
Google Scholar. Readers are also referred to cuts the culture of asking “owners” to take
the International Companion Animal Manage responsibility for the care of the dog. CNR is
ment Coalition, which provides a dog popula- also not appropriate unless the free‐roaming
tion management monitoring and evaluation dogs are a major source of the next generation
literature review, available at https://www. of roaming dogs (Hiby 2012), and the environ-
icam‐coalition.org/download/literature‐ ment must be such that the dogs can have good
review (International Companion Animal welfare. Support of the local and national gov-
Coalition 2014). ernment is critical too for this approach to suc-
ceed. Like TNR in cats, CNR is designed to be
an interim solution to the problem by address-
Which Dogs or Cats Should ing the existing animals until the sources of
We Sterilize for the Most these dogs can be addressed.
Impact? For dogs, recommendations and guidance are
available for evaluating the impacts of interven-
For a sterilization campaign to be most effi- tions on population and welfare (International
cient, one would ideally like to be sterilizing Companion Animal Coalition 2015).
the animals who contribute most to the popu-
lation growth of the dogs and cats at highest
Why and How Should We Target
welfare risk. In developed countries, at‐risk
Sterilization?
dogs or cats may be owned or unowned and
free roaming and are likely to be identified Most spay–neuter programs work with a goal of
based on owner surveys or animal shelter data. “decreasing overpopulation” (Wenstrup 1999).
Interventions may be quite varied and there is This may be measured, though indirectly, by a
Which Dogs or Cats Should We Sterilize for the Most Impact? 465
and euthanasia. Some of the most persuasive there was no correlation between the steriliza-
research evaluated a TNR program targeting tion and shelter intake.
community cats from a single zip code with This research seems to suggest that simply
proportionally high shelter intake (Levy et al. targeting low‐cost surgeries to low‐income cli-
2014). At the end of a two‐year targeted TNR ents may not lead to high impact at the shelter
campaign, 54% of the projected community cat level. It is possible that this is due to lack of
population in the target area had been cap- saturation, so that if a higher percentage of the
tured and altered, and shelter cat intake from total pet population could be impacted with
the targeted zip code decreased by 66%, the sterilization services, intake would be
whereas shelter cat intake from non‐target influenced. It could also be that a more specific
areas decreased by only 12%. Much of the suc- target may need to be identified.
cess of this targeted intervention is likely due Targeting by location, by focusing on low‐
to the high proportion of the target population income towns, counties, or zip codes, can have
that was reached by the intervention. limited success if the spay–neuter program
Other programs discussed in the literature, only reaches a small portion of the animals in
while targeted, reached only a small propor- that geographic area, as seen in several of the
tion of the animals within their target popula- studies discussed. However, geographic target-
tion, and thus have demonstrated limited or ing with greater precision or greater saturation
mixed results. In New Hampshire, the initia- may be able to achieve a larger impact.
tion of a program targeting low‐income pet
owners and shelter adopters across the entire GIS Targeting
state was followed by a significant decrease in In 2010, a study was published focused on
cat intake and euthanasia during the years welfare for cats in neighborhoods in Boston,
after program onset, but the trend of decrease MA (Patronek 2010). Geographic information
had begun before the start of the program, systems (GIS) technology was used to map the
making causation ambiguous (White et al. shelter cat data for over 17 500 cats that had
2010). There was no effect on dog intake and entered the animal shelter organizations over
euthanasia. In Austin, a spay–neuter program a five‐year period. The technology allows the
targeting zip codes with high shelter intake ability to attach data to a specific location, and
found a lower rate of increase for dog and cat analysis of human demographics along with
intake and euthanasia in the program areas shelter animal demographics and specific
compared to non‐program areas (White et al. locations becomes possible. The shelter cat
2010). However, as baseline data was not read- origination address (where s/he was found or
ily available, the authors were unable to con- where her/his relinquisher lived) along with
firm if the trend started prior to the program’s outcome data for the cat were mapped. When
inception. In Transylvania County, NC, the analyzed, a very significant correlation
opening of a spay–neuter clinic open to all (R2 = 0.77) was discovered between where the
county residents was followed by a significant cats that died in the shelter (either euthanized
decrease in cat intake and euthanasia, but no or died in care) originated from, and where
change in dog intake (Scarlett and Johnston the highest human premature deaths origi-
2012). The authors, however, cautioned a con- nated. Where people were most at risk of
clusion of causation, as many factors could not death in the community was the source of the
be controlled. And finally, a study conducted cats who were most at risk of death in the
in 2007 (Frank and Carlisle‐Frank 2007) stud- shelter. The ability to find a strong and plausi-
ied data from five US communities and found ble correlation as one criterion to support cau-
that while low‐cost sterilization increased the sation was made possible by the use of precise
total number of surgeries in the communities, location data.
Which Dogs or Cats Should We Sterilize for the Most Impact? 467
Recent studies incorporate spatial analysis How Do We Tell How Many Cats or
with GIS techniques. One study in Jaipur, Dogs There Are (before and after
India, compared lethal and fertility control Sterilization)?
with spatial data from the city to determine the
To be able to plan an intervention or to deter-
best approach for free‐roaming dogs (Yoak
mine if the effort is working, some estimate of
et al. 2016). It found that lethal control skewed
numbers of animals involved before and after-
the population toward younger dogs, which
ward is needed. How to get those numbers
likely would increase the conflicts with people
depends on the population of interest. For
compared to older dogs.
dogs, there have been several useful publica-
The authors have been exploring the use of
tions that summarize the main methods that
GIS technology to map shelter data to identify
have been used to ascertain dog ownership
areas of higher risk. In many cases, steriliza-
and describe exactly how to go about counting
tion and other services are not being taken
free‐roaming dogs (International Companion
advantage of in the areas where the risk for
Animal Management Coalition 2007; Hiby
intake is highest (Figure 24.4). The use of GIS
et al. 2011). Getting data on owned cats can be
technology allows for a more precise target
done using similar surveys as described for
than the use of a zip code, as the high intake
dogs (International Companion Animal
within that zip code is likely coming from a
Management Coalition 2011; Hiby et al. 2011)
subset area within the zip code. Demographic
and at the same time if needed. Counting cats
information can help inform outreach meth-
uses similar principles as dogs, but because
ods, and the sterilization can be applied in a
cats are much more difficult to see and
more precise manner. One example was
approach than dogs during daytime hours,
reported in Portland, OR (Miller et al. 2014a).
they require some special considerations (see
Use of shelter data allowed for targeting inter-
later discussion).
ventions and documenting which interven-
tions appeared most effective at reducing
shelter intake. While use of this technology in Dog and Cat Population Data Sources
the animal welfare field is still limited, the In the United States, the owned dog and cat
power of visualizing where the animals at risk population is surveyed by the AVMA
of euthanasia are coming from, and the oppor- (American Veterinary Medical Association
tunity to measure the impact of a more pre- 2012) and the APPA (American Pet Products
cisely placed spay–neuter program, is already Association 2018). However, neither of these
proving to be advantageous to keep the goal of publications takes ownership numbers to a
decreased intake top of mind. small enough level of geography like city or
The idea of targeting animals at risk of county to be applicable to the populations in
euthanasia at the shelter can be easily which spay–neuter professionals are usually
extended to other animal‐related problems interested.
like nuisance complaints, bites, too many free‐ One less well‐known source for numbers of
roaming animals, and so on. Fine‐tuning the households owning one or two or more dogs
targeting process will allow for scarce and cats is through Esri statistical software,
resources to be applied where they will do the which has a set of data called Community
most good. Recent work has suggested that Analyst (Esri 2012). Community Analyst is an
knowledge of landscape use of cats and dogs add‐on to the ArcGIS software that maps data.
may also be helpful, since species survival and Both ArcGIS and Community Analyst are
population size are likely influenced by the often available to employees at colleges and
environment (Guttilla and Stapp 2010; universities, sometimes to employees of city
Bengsen et al. 2012). or county governments, and at substantial
468 24 Sterilization Programs and Population Control
Cat Spay/Neuter
Compared to Intake
SN_CAT_TOT/CAT_TOT
0.1–0.3
0.4–0.5
0.6–0.7
0.8–1.1
1.2–5.5
< 5 SN Cats
Figure 24.4 Spay–neuter surgery data in this community included the specific address from which the cat
came, as did cat intake. This map illustrates spay–neuter surgery numbers divided by total intake numbers
to create a ratio from 0.1 to 5.5 neuters per cat intake in a given census block. The red and peach areas
indicate potential areas to target with fewer than 0.5 cats neutered per cat entering the shelter in those
census blocks. White areas had fewer than 5 cats who were neutered.
Which Dogs or Cats Should We Sterilize for the Most Impact? 469
s avings to nonprofits. The last option is only has proven useful. And the reports do provide
going to be helpful if there is a person well an indication of precision or variability for
versed in GIS mapping technology available to many of the demographic characteristics.
work with you – check among your volun-
teers. A simple and free mapping program is Counting Free-Roaming Cats
available through Google (Google.com 2013). For the remainder of this section, the focus
This allows the user to upload a file in Excel will be on free‐roaming cat counts, since this is
with the address, city, state, and zip code and likely to be a larger issue than owned cats and
create a map with those locations. there is much less written about it. The tech-
Community Analyst provides data for any niques for counting animals in the environ-
geographic unit, including hand‐drawn ment have been well developed in the field of
boundaries. It includes data on dog and cat wildlife biology. The approach that is most
ownership, veterinary visits, and cat litter pur- helpful for identifying changes in free‐roaming
chases, as well as human demographic data. cat numbers is population monitoring (Boone
The information is based on a series of general and Slater 2014). This means that one system-
and in‐depth interviews with a sample of the atically and repeatedly measures the popula-
human population. Then these data are extrap- tion over time. Animals can be counted and
olated to geographic locations that are similar data on their estimated age, health status,
based on what are called Tapestry Segments. reproductive status, and so on can be recorded
Tapestry Segments classify US neighborhoods (Figure 24.5). Changes in the population with
into 65 different market segments that are cre- time or following interventions like steriliza-
ated based on socioeconomic and demographic tion can be identified and analyzed if the work
profiles using a cluster analysis. For example, a is done at regular intervals using consistent
segment called Cozy and Comfortable tends to methods (Boone 2015).
be middle‐aged married couples in single‐ Although it may seem daunting, there are
family homes in older neighborhoods. This two important reasons to justify spending the
segment would have a typical pet‐owning pro- resources on monitoring. First, there is no
file, which is obtained by linking survey data other way to evaluate or optimize population
from the GfK MRI Survey of the American control strategies without collecting monitor-
Consumer® (2013) to the Tapestry Segments. ing data. Over time, the relatively small
This survey is an initial in‐home interview of a amount of funding required to operate such a
random sample of a representative group of program will repay itself many times over in
adults 18 years of age and older living in pri- the form of more effective and efficient man-
vate households in the contiguous 48 states. agement plans. Second, funders of population
There is a second, self‐administered survey as control programs, whether large granting
well which goes into greater detail. The inter- organizations or the board of the spay–neuter
viewer explains how to fill out the question- clinic or shelter, increasingly require demon-
naire booklet and arranges for its return. Each stration of efficacy. A well‐designed monitor-
year 26 000 adult consumers in the 48 contigu- ing program provides metrics to demonstrate
ous states are interviewed, so that the data is efficacy that are scientifically defensible,
updated regularly. The limitation of this whole suitable for statistical analysis, and capable of
process is that if one is interested in relatively generating truly valuable insights that are
small geographic areas, say one square mile, otherwise unobtainable.
there is quite a bit of potential inaccuracy Building a free‐roaming cat population
when data from the survey is extrapolated. monitoring program requires some homework
However, this methodology has been used by and careful planning (Boone 2015). In addition,
consumers and businesses for many years and it is critical to have a clear statement of the
470 24 Sterilization Programs and Population Control
Figure 24.5 While monitoring free-roaming cat populations, reproductive status can often be determined.
This queen living in New York City has obviously been lactating. Source: Photo courtesy of Julie Kilgour.
Recent work has attempted to determine if sterilization intervention. If there are 5000
readily available data can be used to estimate dogs and 50 are sterilized, that is unlikely to
feral cat population size at the city level make a big impression on population growth.
(Flockhart et al. 2016). Initial work appeared However, if there are 200 problem dogs and 50
to be promising and led to a result that was are sterilized, that could have a substantial
consistent with an estimate obtained in a dif- influence on population growth. Is the prob-
ferent way. In evaluating additional cities, lem just too many dogs or cats, or are there also
seven Canadian cities demonstrated similar nuisance or public health or welfare concerns?
results (Flockhart and Coe 2018). However, the A pure population dynamics approach focuses
data for six US cities was not as accurate. on population size. If there are other goals of
Another study used existing spatial data from the program, they should be factored into the
one New Zealand city to project country‐wide design of the sterilization campaign. In addi-
estimates of feral cats (Aguilar and Farnworth tion, showing unambiguous success from ster-
2012). It estimated locations where free‐roam- ilization efforts will be much improved by
ing cats were likely to be found, which could defining and enumerating the target popula-
inform control programs. When refined, these tion appropriately. Being able to sterilize
types of approaches could have utility in enough of the right animals to decrease the
understanding free‐roaming cat population population and, if needed, attend to any addi-
sizes in specific locations without fieldwork. tional concerns will require careful reflection
and targeting of the correct population of
animals.
Conclusions Understanding the reasons for lack of sterili-
zation of dogs and cats is also helpful in provid-
It seems likely that to stabilize or decrease a ing effective solutions. Availability and safety
population of dogs or cats, a relatively high of sterilization, affordability, and removing bar-
proportion of the animal population will need riers that prevent owners from using the ser-
to be sterilized each year. The actual propor- vice, like issues with transportation, language,
tion is going to vary, depending on many fac- or knowledge of what the sterilization proce-
tors such as how high the birth and death rates dure entails, are all critical. If owners are ready
are and how common immigration is. Clearly to sterilize their animals and services are only
identifying both the problem of concern and offered at a distance or once a year for a few
the target population causing that problem days, it is unlikely that the owners will be able
will improve the likelihood of success of the to take full advantage of those services.
References
ACC&D (2013). Contraception and fertility American Pet Products Association (2018). APPA
control in dogs and cats. Portland, OR: National Pet Owners Survey 2017–2018.
Alliance for Contraception in Cats & Dogs. Greenwich, CT: American Pet Product
http://www.acc‐d.org/docs/default‐source/ Association.
Resource‐Library‐Docs/accd‐e‐book. American Veterinary Medical Association
pdf?sfvrsn=0 (accessed 2 February 2016). (2012). U.S. pet Ownership & Demographics
Aguilar, G.D. and Farnworth, M.J. (2012). Stray Sourcebook. Schaumburg, IL: American
cats in Auckland, New Zealand: discovering Veterinary Medical Association.
geographic information for exploratory spatial Anderson, M.C., Martin, B.J., and Roemer, G.W.
analysis. Appl. Geog. 34: 230–238. (2004). Use of matrix population models to
472 24 Sterilization Programs and Population Control
on owned dog population size in Central Italy. Heussner, J.C., Flowers, A.I., Williams, J.D. et al.
Prev. Vet. Med. 82: 308–313. (1978). Estimating dog and cat populations in
ESRI (2012). ArcGIS Community Analyst. an urban area. Anim. Regul. Stud. 1: 203–212.
http://www.esri.com/software/arcgis/ Hiby, E. (2012). Dog population management.
community‐analyst (accessed 22 March In: Dogs, Zoonoses and Public Health, 2e (eds.
2013). C.N.L. Macpherson, F.X. Meslin and A.I.
Flockhart, D.T.T. and Coe, J.B. (2018). Multistate Wandeler), 177–204. Wallingford: CABI.
matrix population model to assess the Hiby, L.R., Reece, J.F., Wright, R. et al. (2011). A
contributions and impacts on population mark‐resight survey method to estimate the
abundance of domestic cats in urban areas roaming dog population in three cities in
including owned cats, unowned cats, and cats Rajasthan, India. BMC Vet. Res. 7: 46.
in shelters. PLoS One 13 (2): 1–34. Hilker, F.M., Langlais, M., Petrovskii, S.V. et al.
Flockhart, D.T.T., Norris, D.R., and Coe, J.B. (2007). A diffusive SI model with Alee effect
(2016). Predicting free‐roaming cat population and application to FIV. Math. Biosci. 206: 61–80.
densities in urban areas. Anim. Conserv. 19 Høgåsen, H.R., Er, C., Di Nardo, A., and Dalla
(5): 472–483. Villa, P. (2013). Free‐roaming dog populations:
Foley, P., Foley, J.E., Levy, J.K. et al. (2005). a cost‐benefit model for different management
Analysis of the impact of trap‐neuter‐return options, applied to Abruzzo, Italy. Prev. Vet.
programs on populations of feral cats. JAVMA Med. 112 (3–4): 401–413.
227: 1775–1781. International Companion Animal Management
Frank, J. (2004). An interactive model of human Coalition (2007). Humane dog population
and companion animal dynamics: the ecology management guidance. https://www.icam‐
and economics of dog overpopulation and the coalition.org/wp‐content/uploads/2017/03/
human costs of addressing the problem. Hum. Humane‐Dog‐Population‐Management‐
Ecol. 32: 107–130. Guidance‐English.pdf (accessed 22 December
Frank, J.M. and Carlisle‐Frank, P. (2007). 2018).
Analysis of program to reduce overpopulation International Companion Animal Management
of companion animals: do adoption and low‐ Coalition (2011). Humane cat population
cost spay/neuter programs merely cause management guidance. https://www.icam‐
substitution of sources? Ecol. Econ. 62: coalition.org/wp‐content/uploads/2017/03/
740–746. Humane‐cat‐population‐English.pdf (accessed
GfK MRI (2013). The Survey of the American 22 December 2018).
Consumer®. https://mri.gfk.com/solutions/ International Companion Animal Management
the‐survey‐of‐the‐american‐consumerr/the‐ Coalition (2014). Dog population management
survey‐of‐the‐american‐consumerr (accessed monitoring and evaluation literature review.
20 August 2019). https://www.icam‐coalition.org/download/
Google.com (2013). Google Fusion Tables. literature‐review (accessed 22 December
https://www.google.com/fusiontables/DataSo 2018).
urce?dsrcid=implicit&redirectPath=data&usp International Companion Animal Management
=apps_start&hl=en&pli=1 (accessed 22 Coalition (2015). A guide to monitoring and
March 2013). evaluating dog population management
Gotelli, N.J. (2001). A Primer of Ecology, 3e. interventions. https://www.icam‐coalition.
Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates. org/wp‐content/uploads/2017/03/Are‐we‐
Guttilla, D.A. and Stapp, P. (2010). Effects of making‐a‐difference.pdf (accessed 22
sterilization on movements of feral cats at a December 2018).
wildland‐urban interface. J. Mammol. 91: Ireland, T. and Miller Neilan, R. (2016). A spatial
482–489. agent‐based model of feral cats and analysis of
474 24 Sterilization Programs and Population Control
population and nuisance controls. Ecol. Mod. shelter intake in Portland, Oregon. Open J.
337: 123–136. Anim. Sci. 4 (4): 165–174.
Jackman, J. and Rowan, A.N. (2007). Free‐ Miller, P.S., Boone, J.D., Briggs, J.R. et al.
roaming dogs in developing countries: the (2014b). Simulating free‐roaming cat
benefits of capture, neuter, and return population management option in open
programs. In: The State of Animals IV: 2007, demographic environments. PLoS One 9 (11):
4e (eds. D.J. Salem and A.N. Rowan), 55–78. 1–17.
Washington, DC: Humane Society Press. Morters, M.K., McKinley, T.J., Restif, O. et al.
Kisiel, L.M., Jones‐Bitton, A., Sargeant, J.M. (2014). The demography of free‐roaming dog
et al. (2018). Modeling the effect of surgical populations and applications to disease and
sterilization on owned dog population size in population control. J. Appl. Ecol. 51:
Villa de Tezontepec, Hidalgo, Mexico, using 1096–1106.
an individual‐based computer simulation Nassar, R. and Fluke, J. (1991). Pet population
model. PLoS One 13 (6): 1–22. dynamics and community planning for
Kustritz, M.V.R. (2005). Reproductive behavior animal welfare and animal control. JAVMA
of small animals. Theriogenology 64: 734–746. 198: 1160–1171.
Lessa, I.C.M. and Bergallo, H.G. (2012). Nassar, R. and Mosier, J.E. (1982). Feline
Modelling the population control of the population dynamics: a study of the
domestic cat: an example from an island in Manhattan, Kansas, feline population. Am. J.
Brazil. Braz. J. Biol. 72 (3): 445–452. Vet. Res. 43: 167–170.
Levy, J.K., Isaza, N.M., and Scott, K.C. (2014). Nassar, R. and Mosier, J.E. (1986).
Effect of high‐impact targeted trap‐neuter‐ Understanding the dynamics of your
return and adoption of community cats on cat community’s pet population. Veterinary
intake to a shelter. Vet. J. 201 (3): 269–274. Medicine 81: 1120–1125.
Lohr, C.A., Cox, L.J., and Lepczyk, C.A. (2012). Nassar, R. and Mosier, J. (1991). Projections of
Costs and benefits of trap‐neuter‐release and pet populations from census demographic
euthanasia for removal of urban cats in Oahu, data. JAVMA 198: 1157–1164.
Hawaii. Conserv. Biol. 27: 64–73. Nassar, R., Mosier, J.E., and Williams, L.W.
Mackie, W.M. (2003). Pet overpopulation and the (1984). Study of the feline and canine
70% rule. http://www.quickspay.com/article_ populations in the greater Las Vegas area. Am.
overpop.html (accessed 22 March 2013). J. Vet. Res. 45: 282–287.
Manning, A.M. and Rowan, A.N. (1992). Natoli, E., De Vito, E., and Pontier, D. (2000).
Companion animal demographics and Mate choice in the domestic cat (Felis silvestris
sterilization status: results from a survey in catus L.). Aggress. Behav. 26: 455–465.
four Massachusetts towns. Anthrozoös 5: New, J.C. Jr., Kelch, W.J., Hutchison, J.M. et al.
192–201. (2004). Birth and death rate estimates of cats
McCarthy, R.J., Levine, S.H., and Reed, M. and dogs in U.S. households and related
(2013). Estimation of effectiveness of three factors. J. Appl. Anim. Welf. Sci. 7: 229–241.
methods of feral cat population control by use Nutter, F.B. (2005). Evaluation of a trap‐neuter‐
of a simulation model. JAVMA 243: 502–511. return management program for feral cat
Merriam‐Webster, Inc. (2013). Population colonies: population dynamics, home ranges,
dynamics. http://www.merriam‐webster.com/ and potentially zoonotic diseases. PhD thesis.
dictionary/population%20dynamics (accessed University of North Carolina.
22 March 2013). OIE – World Organization for Animal Health
Miller, G.S., Slater, M.R., and Weiss, E. (2014a). (2011). Stray dog population control.
Effects of a geographically‐targeted Terrestrial Animal Health Code. Paris:
intervention and creative outreach to reduce OIE – World Organization for Animal Health.
References 475
25
Community Cats
Stephanie Janeczko
Cats occupy a unique role in the lives of people Free‐roaming cats may include owned pets
and in our environment. Cat ownership exceeds that are allowed outdoor access as well as stray
that of dogs, as does their intake to animal shel- cats, which include those cats that have
ters nationwide. Many animal shelters are fac- escaped their homes and are lost and those
ing increasing rates of intake for cats, which that have been abandoned (Figure 25.1). In
often surpasses the organization’s capacity for general, these stray cats can be distinguished
care. Compounding these challenges is the fact from feral cats, which are untamed and not
that many organizations receive large numbers socialized to humans. It is important to realize,
of free‐roaming cats and their offspring that however, that the level of socialization to
may be poorly socialized to people and are poor humans that is exhibited by free‐roaming cats
candidates for housing in a traditional shelter ranges from very high to non‐existent. This can
setting. These cats, known as community cats, best be thought of as a spectrum without dis-
are both a cause and a symptom of the feline tinct categories (Figure 25.2). At one end are
overpopulation problem. friendly, socialized pet or stray cats that will
Discussions on community cats are often interact with and approach humans. These
heated and many concerns exist, including socialized cats are in or are suitable for place-
those regarding the cats’ health and welfare, ment in a home. At the other end of the spec-
their role in disease transmission, environ- trum are unsocialized feral cats that will not
mental impacts, and predation on wildlife. allow any human contact or even tolerate close
This chapter will focus on the epidemiology of proximity, making them unsuitable for place-
cat populations and the unique features that ment in a home environment. Feral cats may
contribute to the surplus of cats, as well as pro- live in varying degrees of dependence on
viding an evidence‐based review of the contro- humans, but are defined on the basis of the
versies surrounding their management. socialization level, although this distinction is
not consistently used in the published litera-
ture (Schmidt et al. 2007).
Understanding Community Cats
Distinctions between the various sub‐groups
of free‐roaming cats are not necessarily perma-
Defining the Population
nent. Cats can change their “status” in terms
Cats not subject to confinement indoors may of ownership, socialization, and outdoor access
be generally defined as free roaming. However, throughout their lives, making it difficult to
this group represents a diverse population. define discrete populations. Such distinctions
478 25 Community Cats
are of less importance when considering that unowned free‐roaming cats that are present
all sources of cats may contribute to the free‐ within the community, regardless of socializa-
roaming population and must be considered in tion status and lifestyle. This term is more
any program to manage them. The term “com- reflective of society’s increased awareness of
munity cats” has been proposed to refer to unowned free‐roaming cats and animal wel-
fare’s recognition that the management of cats
in animal shelters cannot be considered in a
All domestic cats vacuum.
Because the offspring of all cats further con-
Indoor pet cats Free-roaming cats tributes to the population of community cats,
reproductive management of all free‐roaming
Pets allowed some outdoor access
cats (regardless of the various sub‐categories by
Lost or abandoned
which they may be categorized) is critical in
pets addressing feline overpopulation and reducing
the intake to and often subsequent euthanasia
Indoor-only pet cats Outdoor-only pet cats of cats in animal shelters in the United States.
Approximately 3.2 million cats are handled by
Feral cats animal shelters in the United States each year,
and a significant proportion are euthanized
(ASPCA 2019a). The precise magnitude of the
Figure 25.1 A visual representation of the various free‐roaming cat population remains unknown.
lifestyles of cats. Although this graphic shows Current estimates for owned cats in the United
distinct sub-groups of cats, the reader is reminded
that this is a fluid structure and that ownership,
States are in excess of 58 million, with 25% of all
socialization, and outdoor access may change households owning at least one cat (AVMA
multiple times during a cat’s lifetime. 2019). Many authors estimate that the number
Semi-feral,
loosely House pets
owned cats
Not Highly
socialized socialized
Feral cats
Lost or
abandoned
pets
Unsocialized cats too
frightened of humans
to live in a typical home
as pets
Figure 25.2 The level of socialization exhibited to humans can be best thought of on a spectrum
without distinct categories. Community cats may fall anywhere on this continuum. Source: Courtesy of
Dr. Katherine Miller.
Understanding Community Cats 479
of community cats is likely in the same range tens. Indeed, some authors have estimated that
(Levy and Crawford 2004; Robertson 2008; as many as 80% of the kittens born in the
AAFP 2012) in the United States alone. United States are to free‐roaming queens (Levy
and Crawford 2004).
Despite the environmental pressures many
Reproductive Biology
community cats face, they remain remarkably
Cats have a number of unique features that capable of reproducing even in environments of
allow them to reproduce at a high rate. Cats are limited resources. An average pregnancy rate of
seasonally polyestrous, induced ovulators. 15% was found in feral cats presented for ovario-
Under optimal conditions they are capable of hysterectomy in several studies (Gibson et al.
producing 2–3 litters each year. Significant sea- 2002; Foley et al. 2005; Wallace and Levy 2006).
sonality in births is seen. Most pregnancies However, looking at the peak reproductive
occur in the spring, with a smaller peak in late times of March, April, and May, that proportion
summer or early autumn. Gestation is rela- jumped as high as 70–80% in certain geographic
tively short, averaging 63–66 days in length. locations (Jones and Coman 1982; Nutter et al.
Lactation does not suppress estrus, and it is not 2004b; Wallace and Levy 2006). Other studies
uncommon to find lactating queens already have confirmed that pregnant cats could be
pregnant with another litter. Females reach identified in all months of the year despite cats’
sexual maturity by 3.5–5 months of age (Griffin seasonally polyestrous nature. With an average
2001), depending on the season and length of of 1.4 litters per year, 4–5 fetuses per pregnancy
day, and early‐maturing cats may give birth by (Jones and Coman 1982; Brothers et al. 1985;
six months of age. As a result, spay–neuter per- Nutter et al. 2004b; Wallace and Levy 2006), and
formed at the conventional age of six months three live births per litter, an unspayed female
or older is likely to result in a significant num- cat can easily produce 50–100 kittens in a life-
ber of accidental litters. time. Increasing availability of resources is asso-
Uncontrolled reproduction of community ciated with more frequent births, larger litters,
cats greatly contributes to their numbers. Pet and higher survival rates of kittens (Schmidt
cats that have not been sterilized or that have et al. 2007). This exponential rate of reproduc-
had a litter prior to being sterilized (Manning tion results in significant increases to the com-
and Rowan 1992) do contribute to the popula- munity cat population, despite high rates
tion of community cats. However, this is (50–75%) of mortality reported for kittens under
almost negligible compared to the numbers of six months of age (Nutter et al. 2004b); popula-
kittens born to unowned free‐roaming cats. tion growth rates as high as 150% have been
The spay–neuter status of pet cats varies reported (Short and Turner 2005).
geographically and with the socioeconomic
background of owners, but national averages
Diet and Environment
are estimated at approximately 80–85% (Levy
et al. 2003b; Chu et al. 2009). In contrast, it is Community cats are not confined and roam
typical to find that less than 5% of all commu- freely, often living in close proximity to one
nity cats in a given area to have been spayed or another. Despite previously accepted notions
neutered, unless they are found in a localized that cats are solitary creatures, much evidence
area conducting a trap–neuter–return (TNR) exists to show that cats will live in matriarchal
program (Scott et al. 2002a; Levy and Crawford groups known as colonies, particularly when
2004; Wallace and Levy 2006). Even allowing resources are abundant (Crowell‐Davis et al.
for the proportion of pet cats that have given 2004). These cats form complex social struc-
birth prior to being spayed, the community cat tures and show communal breeding and
population remains the primary source of kit- nursing behaviors (Figure 25.3). Cats can be
480 25 Community Cats
(a) (b)
Figure 25.3 (a and b) Affiliative behavior between two feral cats (in the foreground) in a managed colony.
Both cats have a slight notch in their right ear (arrow), rather than the more distinct and commonly used
ear tip.
found in and often thrive in extremely diverse caloric intake of some free‐roaming cats. The
environments, ranging from rural to urban in reader is directed to the section on predation in
subarctic to tropical climates. this chapter for additional information on the
The home‐range size of a cat may be sub- dietary habits of free‐roaming cats.
stantial and can vary significantly among
members of a given population. Cats typically
Concerns Regarding
show overlap of their home ranges, with few or
no cats having exclusive use of an area (Apps
Community Cats
1986). Females generally have smaller home
Welfare Concerns
ranges than males. Cats fed by humans have
been shown to have smaller movements than Welfare concerns regarding free‐roaming cats
those that were not; home ranges and distance are not insignificant and include concerns
roaming was reported to be closer in area to regarding the cats’ physical condition and
those seen in owned pet cats (Schmidt et al. health, rates and causes of mortality, quality of
2007). Availability of food or other resources, life, and eventual outcome. The welfare con-
such as suitable shelter in the form of aban- cerns that are likely to arise for a given popula-
doned buildings (Figure 25.4), may also affect tion of cats will be influenced at least in part by
cat density and dispersal (Calhoon and Haspel the environmental conditions and what, if any,
1989). management or care the cats are receiving. For
The diet of free‐roaming cats is varied and is example, climate is likely to be of greater con-
typically dependent on prey abundance and cern in extreme northern areas, such as Alaska,
availability in a particular environment. In than in most parts of the continental United
addition, food provided by humans (e.g. colony States. The welfare of some community cats
caregivers, individuals feeding unowned cats) may be very good, while that of others may be
may represent a significant proportion of the quite poor; variation is possible across locations
Concerns Regarding Community Cats 481
(a) (b)
Figure 25.4 Community cats will be found at higher densities where food and sufficient shelter is
available. (a) Dedicated cat shelters, such as the one shown here, may be provided for cats by caretakers.
(b) Abandoned buildings are frequently occupied by cats. This barn, located on a non-working dairy barn,
was utilized as the primary shelter for a colony of approximately 20 feral and semi-feral cats.
as well as among cats within a given geographic majority of people feel it is more humane to
area. An individual assessment of each situa- allow a cat to live out its life and die from trau-
tion and its unique circumstances as well as for matic causes in a relatively short period of time
each cat is necessary in deciding on the most than to remove the cat pre‐emptively for
appropriate management strategy. humane euthanasia (Chu and Anderson 2007).
The current literature suggests that while
Life Span, General Health, and Body deaths due to trauma, infectious disease, and
Condition various other causes do occur regularly, most
The body condition of younger cats has been free‐roaming cats that have made it to adult-
reported to be poorer than that of adult cats in hood can be expected to do well for several
the same population (Short and Turner 2005). years or longer. Prevalence rates for many
High mortality rates have been reported for infectious diseases and baseline health status
community cats, with up to 75% of kittens con- are generally similar in free‐roaming cats and
firmed dead or missing before six months of pet cats (Luria et al. 2004; Nutter et al. 2004a;
age (Nutter et al. 2004b). Common causes Stojanovic and Foley 2011). Feeding by humans
of death include motor vehicle trauma, dog has been associated with improved survival
attack, gunshots, infectious diseases, and and longer life spans in community cats
euthanasia by animal control; predation is sus- (Schmidt et al. 2007). Anecdotally, life spans
pected to be a likely cause as well (Nutter et al. for cats in managed colonies or otherwise
2004b; Schmidt et al. 2007). Although these cared for by humans may approach those
mortality rates are comparable to those seen in reported for owned pet cats, with more than
other wild carnivores such as foxes and bob- 80% of cats in one study still present on‐site
cats (Cypher et al. 2000), they are high and after six years of observation (Levy et al.
of significant concern when considering the 2003a). Disappearances from a colony location
welfare of free‐roaming cats. Interestingly, a or study site do occur, and were reported for
482 25 Community Cats
15% of the population over the several years of tions and pre‐surgical requirements in indi-
observation. These may be the result of death, vidual cats (Mitsuhashi et al. 2011). Feral cats
but could also be due to emigration to other are reported to often be in lean but adequate
locations or removal by humans for adoption body condition prior to surgery (Scott et al.
or transfer to an animal shelter (Wallace and 2002b), with weight gain and improvements in
Levy 2006). Confirmed death rates in free‐ body condition scores reported following spay
roaming cats have been reported to be low, or neuter (Figure 25.5; Hughes and Slater 2002;
with approximately 6% known to have died fol- Fischer et al. 2007). Longer life spans and
lowing return to the capture site in two sepa- increased survival rates of both adults and kit-
rate studies (Hughes and Slater 2002; Levy tens are also associated with sterilization of
et al. 2003a). community cats. This phenomenon is well
Data regarding euthanasia rates of commu- enough documented that it has actually been
nity cats for illness or injury are seldom used by some authors as an argument against
reported. The available information suggests TNR programs, because survival rates have a
that this occurs infrequently and often after a greater impact on population size than repro-
significant period of time, excluding those cats ductive rates do (McCarthy et al. 2013).
euthanized at the time of capture on the basis
of surveillance testing for feline leukemia virus Quality of Life and Outcomes
(FeLV) and/or feline immunodeficiency virus Strong differences in opinion often exist as to
(FIV) infection. In one population of cats on a the quality of life experienced by free‐roaming
university campus in Florida, only 4% were cats and what choice(s) is/are the most
euthanized for serious medical concerns after humane and appropriate. Some authors have
a median time on‐site of 5.1 years. Data from argued that high mortality rates and reduced
seven TNR programs in the United States indi- life expectancy are indicators of a poor quality
cates that only 0.4% of cats were euthanized of life, and that removal of the cats for eutha-
because of the presence of debilitating condi- nasia is a more humane choice (Clarke and
tions (Scott et al. 2002a). A retrospective analy- Pacin 2002), while others have argued the
sis of a single TNR program in Massachusetts
estimated that 5–10% of the cats trapped over a
30‐year period were euthanized due to serious
illness or injury, or a positive FeLV/FIV test
result, and that most euthanasias occurred in
the early months of the program (Spehar and
Wolf 2017).
A cat’s sterilization status can be expected to
influence its life span and overall physical con-
dition. Spay–neuter is likely to improve cats’
health through direct effects of surgery (e.g.
elimination of risk of pyometra) as well as
resultant behavioral changes that reduce the
risk of disease transmission (e.g. reduction in
fighting leading to less transmission of FIV).
There are also a number of metabolic changes Figure 25.5 Community cats, such as the one
seen here, are frequently in lean but adequate body
that occur subsequent to sterilization, includ- condition. Weight gain and improved body
ing a reduced energy requirement compared to condition scores are typically seen following
both National Research Council recommenda- sterilization.
www.ajlobby.com
Concerns Regarding Community Cats 483
(a) (b)
Figure 25.6 (a) Housing in many animal shelters is inadequate to maintain the physical and behavioral
health of cats. This is exacerbated for poorly socialized cats that are highly stressed by close proximity to
humans. Although modifications can be made to limit this stress, such as the use of a commercially
available feral cat den (b), prolonged housing of feral and semi-feral cats is not recommended.
opposite (Chu and Anderson 2007). The removal to an animal shelter. Shelter stays are
importance given to cats’ welfare when con- stressful for cats, particularly those who have
sidering the acceptability of various manage- been poorly socialized to human contact, and
ment strategies varies among surveys, with positive live release outcomes are far from
distinct differences having been shown based certain (Figure 25.6). Euthanasia in animal
on the respondent’s location (e.g. urban vs. shelters remains a leading cause of death for
rural), gender, and age, as well as affiliation cats in the United States. In many communi-
with cat or wildlife‐based groups. Differences ties it remains a virtual certainty for feral or
in the importance or priority ascribed to cat semi‐feral cats brought to the local animal
welfare have also been shown to differ depend- shelter. Removal of free‐roaming cats without
ing on the specific sub‐group (e.g. companion health issues for euthanasia raises ethical
cats, strays, feral cats) of the cats in question concerns and does not serve the welfare of the
(Farnworth et al. 2011). individual or the population.
Availability (or lack thereof) of various
options for the management and care of a
particular cat or group of cats will almost cer-
Infectious Diseases
tainly influence what strategy is judged to be
most effective in addressing welfare concerns. Another concern frequently expressed regard-
Surveys have indicated that people are ing community cat populations is their role in
opposed to trapping and impoundment of the transmission of infectious diseases to other
free‐roaming cats if they will most likely be animals (including domestic cats, native wild
euthanized, but they are similarly opposed to felids, and other wildlife) and/or people through
leaving cats outdoors without a plan for man- direct transmission or environmental contami-
agement or care (Dabritz et al. 2006). Sadly, nation. However, there is little existing data
cats’ welfare is not necessarily improved by upon which to base these claims.
www.ajlobby.com
484 25 Community Cats
Available data indicates that pathogen preva- range of species, but cats are the only definitive
lence rates may vary greatly among different hosts. Cats typically shed oocysts for a brief
populations of free‐roaming cats, as they do period of time following initial infection, but
for populations of pet cats. One study found will remain seropositive because of the organ-
that 75% of cats were positive for hookworms ism’s ability to persist in the form of tissue
(Anderson et al. 2003), while another study cysts. Exposure to the parasite is of particular
found no cats to be infected (Stojanovic and concern for pregnant women, as T. gondii
Foley 2011), but neither provided data on the infection may lead to abortion, still births, or a
prevalence in pet cats in the same geographic myriad of congenital defects, depending on the
area for comparison. Similar discrepancies stage of gestation when the mother became
in prevalence rates of other pathogens, such infected. Contamination of soil and water with
as Toxoplasma gondii, have been reported T. gondii‐laden cat feces is often noted to be of
(Nutter et al. 2004a) and in some studies the concern because of potential impacts on public
reported prevalence in feral cat populations has health and, to a lesser extent, on other species
actually been lower (Taetzsch et al. 2018). Not (e.g. Miller et al. 2002; Kreuder et al. 2003;
surprisingly, significant variation in disease Conrad et al. 2005).
prevalence may also be seen in different colo- Free‐roaming cats are often cited as the larg-
nies within a relatively confined area (Gibson est risk with regard to transmission of toxo-
et al. 2002). plasmosis, but the seroprevalence estimates
While prevalence extremes do exist, avail- reported have been similar to those for pet cats
able data often show that the frequencies of (Hill et al. 2000; Dubey et al. 2002; Luria et al.
many infectious diseases and parasitic infec- 2004; Stojanovic and Foley 2011; Taetzsch et al.
tions in free‐roaming cats are similar to those 2018). Furthermore, it has been estimated that
reported in pet cats. This suggests that the only ~1% of seropositive cats will be actively
former pose no greater risk to human or ani- shedding oocysts (Dabritz et al. 2007;
mal health than owned cats and do not serve Stojanovic and Foley 2011) and that commu-
as reservoirs for these conditions (Stojanovic nity cats are not the principal source of fecal
and Foley 2011). For example, free‐roaming contamination produced by cats (Dabritz et al.
cats studied in northern Florida had simi- 2006). Additionally, human infection is most
lar or lower prevalence rates compared to pet likely the result of inadvertent ingestion of
cats for FeLV, FIV, Bartonella henselae, oocysts that occurs when people fail to ade-
Dirofilaria immitis, T. gondii, and several quately wash vegetables, or through the inges-
other infectious diseases (Luria et al. 2004). tion of tissue cysts from undercooked meat
A similar study of feral cats trapped for sur- products.
gery on Prince Edward Island also found
prevalence rates to be relatively low. Cats in Rabies
both of these study populations were tested Perhaps the most commonly cited public health
following presentation by a caretaker for concern is the role of community cats in the
neutering. While they may not be representa- transmission of rabies. Rabies remains a sig-
tive of free‐roaming cats not receiving such nificant disease concern worldwide, with either
care, they arguably represent the population dogs or wildlife serving as the natural reser-
most likely to come into contact with humans voirs for the virus depending on the geographic
and transmit disease. location. In the United States rabies is detected
most frequently in wildlife, representing more
Toxoplasma Infection than 90% of all animals testing positive (Birhane
Infection with T. gondii, an obligate intracellu- et al. 2017; Ma et al. 2018). Cats are the most
lar protozoan parasite, is possible in a wide frequently reported domestic animal to test
www.ajlobby.com
Concerns Regarding Community Cats 485
positive for rabies, although the vast majority of stray or feral cats, this would represent at least
these cases have been confined to a relatively 18 732 doses each year. In contrast, 44% of the
small geographic area where the raccoon rabies 556 PEP doses given in Pennsylvania were the
virus variant is enzootic. result of cat exposure and 82% of those were
Concern regarding the risk of rabies posed the result of contact with a stray or feral cat for
by free‐roaming cats is legitimate. However, a total of 200 PEP doses. If this was representa-
numerous publications contain misleading, tive of the national pattern of administration,
unsubstantiated, or downright erroneous it would translate to 10 000 doses for exposure
statements regarding the risk of rabies posed to all cats (e.g. approximately half of what was
by community cats. For example, one review implied as an argument against TNR pro-
on the ethical and legal dilemmas of TNR grams). However, such an extrapolation is
programs noted that exposure to a kitten of likely an overestimate, as Pennsylvania has
unknown origin subsequently found to be previously been noted to be the state with the
rabid led to the treatment of more than 600 highest number of rabid cats in the entire
individuals (Barrows 2004). While this is cer- country (Blanton et al. 2012).
tainly a cause for concern, the author failed Regardless, rabies is a serious concern, and
to note that this kitten was actually pur- potential human exposure by cats (including
chased from a pet store with a health certifi- owned, stray, and feral) leads to the administra-
cate completed by a licensed veterinarian tion of thousands of doses of PEP each year.
(Noah et al. 1996). Surprisingly, concerns about rabies transmis-
The implications of misleading data can be sion are frequently cited as a reason to oppose
substantial. In the commentary “Critical TNR programs, despite the fact that such pro-
Assessment of Claims Regarding Management grams can reduce the number of at‐risk cats
of Feral Cats by Trap‐Neuter‐Return,” the through vaccination as well as through a reduc-
authors claimed that 80% of the post‐exposure tion in population. National guidelines for the
prophylaxis (PEP) administered to humans in vaccination of cats include immunization
the United States resulted from contact with against rabies using a product with a three‐year
stray or feral cats (Longcore et al. 2009). The duration of immunity as a core vaccine for all
cited reference provides data for Pennsylvania cats in TNR programs, with a recommendation
only (Moore et al. 2000). In that state, 75% of to re‐trap cats for administration of booster vac-
reported exposures involved dogs and 17.2% cinations one year later and then triennially
involved cats, with the remaining 17.8% com- thereafter (Scherk et al. 2013). Feral cats have
prising wildlife and other species. Cat expo- been shown to mount an adequate immune
sures were six times more likely to lead to response following administration of a single
administration of PEP compared to dog expo- rabies vaccine at the time of anesthesia and sur-
sures. However, this included exposure to all gery, providing evidence that even a single
cats (e.g. pet, feral, stray, and otherwise immunization may provide significant animal
unowned) and represented only 44% of the and public health benefits (Fischer et al. 2007).
total doses administered in the state for the An inverse association between free‐roaming
entire year. Of those, 82% were administered as cat population control interventions (i.e. TNR
a result of contact with a feral, stray, or unowned programs) and the number of animals submit-
cat (Moore et al. 2000). ted for rabies testing in Massachusetts counties
Precise estimates for annual PEP use are has been documented. While the magnitude
unknown, but it has been estimated that 23 415 of testing reduction was small, it does indi-
courses are used each year (Christian et al. cate that such programs can be successful
2009). If 80% of all PEP administered in the (McGonagle 2015). It is likely true that vaccina-
United States were the result of exposure to tion of cats in TNR programs may not change
www.ajlobby.com
486 25 Community Cats
practices regarding human exposure assess- iors that should be substantially reduced
ment and administration of PEP, because of the following sterilization of some or all of the ani-
difficulty in consistently documenting vaccina- mals. Published data indicate that fighting and
tion of the individual cats in question (Roebling vocalizations are reduced in neutered colony
et al. 2014). However, vaccination should still members (Finkler et al. 2011b), and significant
reduce the risk of rabies in these cats and thus (e.g. by 25%) reductions in the number of com-
the true risk they pose to humans and other plaints have been reported in different settings
animals. following implementation of a sterilization
program (Hughes and Slater 2002; Hughes
et al. 2002).
Nuisance Behaviors
The actual incidence of complaints regarding
Predation and Environmental Impacts
nuisance behaviors of free‐roaming cats is not
widely reported and likely varies among com- All cats, regardless of ownership status, social-
munities, depending on the population of cats, ization, habitat, or relationship with humans,
environment and proximity to people (e.g. have the potential to kill native and non‐native
rural vs. urban), and the tolerance of the wildlife, including birds, small mammals, rep-
human population. Complaints may be tiles, and invertebrates. Intake data from wild-
directed to animal shelters or even local law life rehabilitation facilities indicates that cat
enforcement, and include concerns regarding predation is not an uncommon occurrence in
the physical health and welfare of the cats (e.g. the population of animals served by such facil-
sick, injured, or deceased); yowling, caterwaul- ities (Jessup 2004; Sallinger 2008; Loyd et al.
ing, or fighting; and urine spraying or fecal 2017). Legitimate concerns exist with regard to
deposition in yards (Figure 25.7). A significant both individual animal welfare and the popu-
association between cat reproduction and cat‐ lation‐level impacts on wildlife that may arise
associated nuisances has been documented from predation.
(Gunther et al. 2015), and many of these com-
plaints stem from hormonally driven behav- Hunting Behavior
Cats are opportunistic hunters and will hunt
and kill a variety of species, with or without
consuming them. Natural prey is typically
related to abundance and availability (Liberg
1984). In general, small mammals such as
rodents or rabbits represent the vast majority of
a cat’s diet regardless of study location (Jones
1977; Jones and Coman 1981; Liberg 1984;
Churcher and Lawton 1987; Paltridge et al.
1997; Molsher et al. 1999; Woods et al. 2003;
Bonnaud et al. 2007). Numerous bird species,
reptiles, and invertebrates also may be preyed
upon by cats. While this is typically to a lesser
extent than predation on small mammals, at
Figure 25.7 Concerns about perceived property least one study found invertebrates, following
damage caused by community cats, such as
by amphibians and reptiles, to be the most
damage to or fecal deposition in gardens and
flower beds, may lead to the filing of a nuisance common type of prey captured (Hernandez
complaint. et al. 2018a).
www.ajlobby.com
Concerns Regarding Community Cats 487
www.ajlobby.com
488 25 Community Cats
It is also important to recognize that the role one uses an estimate that hundreds of mil-
cats play in an ecosystem is complex and sel- lions of birds are killed by cats each year, it is
dom well understood, even in those environ- still likely that window and building colli-
ments (e.g. islands) that could be considered sions remain a greater source of mortality
closed and relatively simple. Eradication of (Loss et al. 2013).
cats is often recommended, and proponents Any analysis of cat‐associated mortality, par-
cite examples of rebounding populations when ticularly in light of its potential impact at a
cats are removed from islands, but examples population level, must also consider the spe-
are limited and this is not always the outcome. cific animals that are being preyed upon. It is
There are well‐documented instances where unknown on a larger scale whether predation
removal of cats did not increase prey popula- by cats is additive or compensatory. In the case
tions, or where eradication actually had a neg- of additive predation, the animals killed are in
ative impact on wildlife populations and the addition to those that would have died from
overall condition of the environment (Hughes other causes, such as starvation. In compensa-
et al. 2008; Bergstrom et al. 2009). Mathematical tory predation, the prey killed would have died
modeling has demonstrated that the presence anyway. A study in Sweden showed that rabbits
of cats may have a positive effect on endemic comprised 93% of cats’ diets during a particu-
birds in insular ecosystems where rats are also larly harsh winter in which dead, dying, and
present (Courchamp et al. 1999b). That effect weak rabbits were commonly seen (Liberg
has been borne out in nature as well: the breed- 1984). Similarly, examination of birds killed by
ing success of Cooks Petrels was approximately cats found that they were in significantly
3.5 times higher when cats and rats were pre- poorer condition compared to those killed fol-
sent compared to rats alone (Rayner et al. lowing collisions (Baker et al. 2008). In both of
2007). This has been hypothesized to be due to these examples, cat predation was likely com-
a phenomenon known as “mesopredator pensatory, which could be expected to have
release.” Cats are the apex predator on many minimal additional effect on the population
islands where they were introduced, killing dynamics of the target species.
both target prey species as well as other, Neither the relative proportions of the differ-
smaller potential predators (e.g. rats) known as ent species killed by cats nor estimates for
“mesopredators.” When the number of apex wildlife population abundance are generally
predators is reduced, mesopredator popula- available in predation studies, thus making it
tions can increase dramatically and lead to difficult to determine which populations and
higher predation rates on small, vulnerable species are most vulnerable (Loss et al. 2013).
species like birds, creating a situation where Many publications on feline predation rely on
the prey species in question declines dramati- extensive extrapolations that have been based
cally or even becomes extinct (Courchamp on information obtained from a single study,
et al. 1999a; Zavaleta et al. 2001; Ritchie and which may in turn be based on observations of
Johnson 2009). only a handful of cats from a single colony, or
Numerous reasons for declining popula- even an estimate based on the available litera-
tions exist, including but not limited to habit ture at the time. Thus, this data, which often
loss, climate change, and other anthropogenic forms the foundation for modeling parameters
causes such as collisions with man‐made and broad extrapolations to entire countries,
structures or pesticide use (Dauphiné and may not be representative of larger popula-
Cooper 2009). It is important to consider all tions of cats or wildlife, different geographic
causes of mortality and population decline of areas, variations in climate or season, or
wildlife when determining what can be done numerous other factors influencing the origi-
to reduce losses and reverse the trend. Even if nal observations as previously discussed.
www.ajlobby.com
Concerns Regarding Community Cats 489
Despite these limitations, the information is management option for free‐roaming cats in
frequently used as the basis for meta‐studies, that community (Loyd and Hernandez 2012).
the publication of which sometimes garners In other cases, an increase in ownership laws
much public discussion and debate regarding (e.g. licensing and mandatory spay–neuter)
the number of animals killed by cat predation have been recommended to curb the number of
each year. For example, Loss et al. estimated free‐roaming cats (Dauphiné and Cooper 2009).
that free‐roaming cats were responsible for the Legislative attempts have also been considered
deaths of 1.4–3.7 billion birds and 6.9–20.7 bil- to remove existing protections for cats as a
lion mammals in the United States annually by domesticated species. In New Zealand, feral cats
conducting what the authors described as a were placed on the list of pest species in 2004,
data‐driven systematic review (Loss et al. thereby exempting them from the protections of
2013). Such numbers are startling, but the the Animal Welfare Act (Farnworth et al. 2010).
findings should be examined with a careful Approval of a proposal made by the Wisconsin
eye, as many limitations exist to arriving at an Conservation Congress would have defined
accurate estimate. Sensitivity analysis in this feral cats as an unprotected species, thereby
study indicated that both the population size allowing them to be legally hunted within the
and predation rates of the unowned cat popu- state (USA Today 2005). Although the measure
lation explained the greatest variation in total was never approved by the Wisconsin legisla-
mortality estimates. Unfortunately, the out- ture and signed into law, such extreme meas-
door cat population and predation rates were ures and their relative popularity with certain
based on estimates for which reliable data is segments of the population underscore the con-
minimal. tentious nature of community cat management.
Some communities have also faced emerging
and protracted legal challenges regarding
Legal Concerns
their handling of community cat populations.
Laws governing free‐roaming cats are typically For example, both the mayor and director of
local or state based in nature and vary signifi- the city’s Animal Welfare Department in
cantly between jurisdictions. Community cats Albuquerque, New Mexico, were named in a
are generally, but not always, protected through lawsuit alleging animal cruelty and abandon-
anti‐cruelty laws. Additional laws regarding ment of stray cats through a TNR program
their care and management can be much more (KOAT 2014). Although the initial suit and a
varied, ranging from prohibitions on feeding subsequent appeal were both rejected, allowing
cats in public parks or other outdoor locations the TNR program to continue (McKay 2016),
to clear support with or without funding for another lawsuit was filed approximately five
TNR programs. In some instances, additional years after the first and is still unresolved at the
legislation pertaining to the management of time of publication (Boetel 2018).
free‐roaming cats has been adopted to exempt International response to the management of
the cats and their caretakers from existing ani- free‐roaming cat populations also varies signifi-
mal legislation. Legislation introduced in cantly in terms of existing legislation. Australia
Athens, GA, in 2010, for example, allows the allows for lethal control of cats threatening
registration of cat colonies with the county and native wildlife (Farnworth et al. 2011), while
provides $10 000 in sterilization vouchers, eradication programs are only legal in Israel if
while exempting caretakers from an existing there is proof that the animal constitutes a true
law that defines anyone feeding stray cats as hazard to public health (Gunther et al. 2011).
the owners. Coupled with a policy change at In Italy there is a complete prohibition of
the local animal shelter, this legislative change euthanasia of feral cats (Natoli et al. 2006).
had the effect of mandating TNR as the only Further differences regarding management of
www.ajlobby.com
490 25 Community Cats
(a) (b)
Figure 25.8 (a) Feeding stations provide an enclosed, protected area for cats. (b) A feral cat inside a
feeding station during an evening meal. Source: Photos courtesy of Maggie O’Neil.
all or a proportion of the community cat popu- cats they provide care for, despite the fact that
lations may also exist depending on the specific it may not be possible to touch these cats or
language used in the laws. For example, New keep them as pets in a traditional home setting.
Zealand law allows lethal control of feral cats, Surveys have shown that as much as 26% of the
but requires that stray cats be relinquished to a population feeds unowned outdoor cats
nonprofit organization for assessment prior to (Centonze and Levy 2002; Lord 2008), even
placement or euthanasia. though a large proportion of these individuals
Various laws protect wildlife and birds espe- are not themselves cat owners (Figure 25.8).
cially, such as the Migratory Bird Treaty Act Many caretakers provide care well beyond
and, if applicable, the Endangered Species feeding and do so at high financial cost, invest-
Act. Additional state and local laws may also ing significant amounts of money to sterilize
exist. What, if any, implications such laws cats even when limited services are available
have for caretakers of community cats remains (Natoli et al. 2006). Interestingly, while care-
unclear. While it has been suggested that vet- taking generally emerges from the individu-
erinarians and caretakers participating in als’ strong empathy for the cats, some people
TNR programs may face legal liability under remain emotionally detached from the cats
wildlife protection laws (Barrows 2004), this (Finkler and Terkel 2011).
has not actually occurred to the best of the Available data generally suggests that people
author’s knowledge. recognize the need for effective management
of community cats, and in many instances a
majority of individuals surveyed are in favor of
Public Perception TNR programs (Dabritz et al. 2006; Chu and
of Community Cats Anderson 2007; Loyd and Hernandez 2012).
Despite only a minority of respondents indi-
Public perception surrounding community cating that cat welfare or prevention of cat
cats varies greatly, as do opinions on the most euthanasia was very important, euthanasia
appropriate methods for their management. was found to be the least acceptable option for
For many individuals, community cats repre- management by respondents. TNR was the
sent beloved and valued companions. Studies most popular choice for a management option
of feral cat caretakers consistently show a high funded either by tax dollars or charitable dona-
level of attachment between people and the tions. Ash and Adams (2003) reported similar
www.ajlobby.com
Public Perception of Community Cats 491
findings when surveying university faculty colony caretakers on opinions regarding the
and staff, with more than half of respondents impact of feral cats, efficacy of TNR programs,
selecting TNR programs over removal or no and which management strategies are most
control for management of cat populations on appropriate. Such polarization was found
campus. One survey found that the over- regardless of whether or not these individuals
whelming majority of people would rather see considered themselves to be “cat people,”
a free‐roaming cat left outdoors than for it to be “bird people,” or both. It has been hypothe-
captured and euthanized, even if they knew sized that the emerging conflicts may be the
that the cat would die of traumatic injury result of identity politics, data conflict, and/or
within two years (Chu and Anderson 2007). value conflicts pertaining to cats and wildlife
This evidence of positive public opinion (Peterson et al. 2012).
should not, however, be misinterpreted as con- Even among animal welfare organizations
sistent and universal support for the existence there may be disagreement about appropriate
of free‐roaming cat populations. Public per- strategies for the management of community
ception may differ with geographic area, socio- cats. Many national animal welfare organiza-
economic group, professional background, tions, such as the American Society of the
personal values and beliefs, and even the lan- Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) and
guage used to frame the particular questions the Humane Society of the United States
about cat control. New Zealanders were more (HSUS), are in favor of TNR programs and do
likely to favor non‐lethal control measures and not support efforts aimed at removal and
rate welfare concerns more highly when asked euthanasia (HSUS 2019; ASPCA 2019b). Others,
about management of stray cats than when such as People for the Ethical Treatment of
asked the same question about feral cats Animals (PETA), are of the opinion that the
(Farnworth et al. 2011). This may be due, in welfare of community cats is poor, TNR pro-
part, to the laws governing the control meth- grams are inhumane and akin to abandonment,
ods that may be employed for various groups and these cats should be removed from the envi-
of cats and the legal designation of feral cats as ronment and humanely euthanized (PETA
pests in that country. Categorizing an animal 2019). Similar disparity exists within the veteri-
as a “pest” has also been shown in other stud- nary profession, with the American Association
ies to be associated with lower concern for ani- of Feline Practitioners (AAFP) being in favor
mal welfare (Taylor and Signal 2009). of TNR programs, the Association of Avian
Many individuals and organizations are Veterinarians (AAV) being opposed, and the
strongly opposed to the presence of any cats American Veterinary Medical Association
outdoors and the management of free‐roam- (AVMA) taking a more neutral position (AAFP
ing cat populations by any means other than 2012; AAV 2019; AVMA 2019).
removal. Others likely fall somewhere in the It has been suggested that public policy
middle of such polarizing debates and may decisions regarding cat management have been
struggle to support one management option and will continue to be dictated by “loud and
over another (Loyd and Hernandez 2012). passionate advocacy groups.” Individuals and
Organizational membership has been signifi- organizations with opposing viewpoints engage
cantly associated with individual opinions in vehement and often emotional debate
regarding the prevention of cat euthanasia, regarding the best way to manage the existing
management through TNR programs, or des- population of free‐roaming cats. In many
ignation of cats as an invasive species (Loyd instances, claims are made that characterize
and Hernandez 2012). Research has shown the opposing viewpoints as being mutually
significant polarization between self‐identi- exclusive; supporters are in favor of either cat
fied bird conservation professionals and cat welfare or environmental protection and the
www.ajlobby.com
492 25 Community Cats
welfare of wildlife, but not both. TNR advo- consider public opinion and have the buy‐in of
cates have, in certain instances, been accused key stakeholders are most likely to succeed and
of having a commitment to cat population con- have a lasting impact. As discussed in the sec-
trol that ranges from “questionable to entirely tion on public perception, opinions on the
lacking” and even been compared to animal most appropriate method(s) for the manage-
hoarders (Dauphiné and Cooper 2009). ment of community cats vary significantly,
Regardless of one’s personal feelings on the although most people recognize the need for
issue, it is easy to see that such debate is coun- some type of intervention.
terproductive. Arguments such as these fail to
recognize the mutual goal that animal welfare
Do Nothing or “Wait and See”
organizations and wildlife conservation groups
both share: a reduction in the number of com- Perhaps the longest‐standing and most wide-
munity cats. By focusing on this common spread approach to the management of free‐
ground rather than on the differences, steps roaming cat populations is to “wait and see” or
can be taken to develop viable solutions that “do nothing.” Clearly, this approach is non‐
effectively address concerns regarding the productive and does nothing to address con-
health and welfare of community cats and cerns regarding cats (e.g. health and welfare,
their impacts on the environment, wildlife, population size) or their impacts on people,
and public health. It should then be possible to other animals, and the ecosystems in which
design intervention strategies that are coopera- they live. In some jurisdictions this approach
tive and inclusive in nature, without sacrific- may have arisen from a long‐term status quo
ing the values of either side. The reality is that and inertia or through the default of failing to
no management strategy, whether lethal or select an alternate strategy. In other jurisdic-
non‐lethal in nature, will be successful on a tions the “wait and see” approach may have
large scale without taking public opinion into resulted from a decision that ignoring the
consideration and securing the cooperation of management challenge posed by the free‐
key stakeholders. Detailed analyses of the roaming cat population is the least expensive
social, cultural, and economic costs and bene- option, because it does not cost anything to put
fits are necessary to increase the probability of in place. This rationalization, however, results
local community support for whatever pro- in a false economy. It fails to consider the vari-
gram is selected (Oppel et al. 2011). ety of expenses that may already be incurred as
More recently, some authors have focused a result of the unmanaged free‐roaming cat
instead on ways to improve the effectiveness population and that inaction will ultimately
of TNR (Boone 2015) or to implement it within require greater time and expense to address
a wider framework of social engagement management of cat populations. As a result of
(McDonald et al. 2018), as a means to enhance these factors and the common belief that some
these programs as a population management form of management is necessary for commu-
tool and drive long‐term behavioral changes nity cats, discussions regarding specific man-
that could better address feline overpopulation. agement strategies typically focus on removal
or sterilization programs.
Management Strategies
Removal-Based Programs
There is no single, one‐size‐fits‐all approach Removal‐based programs rely on the perma-
that is appropriate for the management of all nent removal of some or all of a population of
free‐roaming cats in all situations. In general, cats from a specific location. This may be
comprehensive multifaceted programs that accomplished through lethal control, where
Management Strategies 493
cats are killed either on‐site or removed to an a population of just 150 cats (Courchamp and
off‐site location (typically but not always an Sugihara 1999).
animal shelter). Removal may also be accom- Many of the methods utilized in island eradi-
plished by trapping cats and either relocating cation programs are not feasible for use in
them or rehoming them. other locations due to the presence of people
and other non‐target and domestic species.
On-Site Lethal Control Severe injuries in native foxes have been
Lethal control programs rely on a variety of reported with use of leg‐hold traps (Campbell
lethal methods to eliminate a population of et al. 2011) and it has been shown that toxic
cats at the location where they live. Various baits will be consumed by non‐target species as
techniques have been tried and, in some well as domestic cats (de Torres et al. 2011).
instances, are still promoted as a viable option The accidental deaths of nearly 40% of pet cats
for managing community cat populations. following ingestion of poison bait in a cat erad-
These include introduction of infectious dis- ication program on Ascension Island (Oppel
ease (e.g. panleukopenia), poisoning, shooting, et al. 2011) highlights the risk to owned cats.
hunting with dogs, and the use of leg‐hold It is generally agreed that the efforts required
traps. A variety of techniques are often for removal are inversely proportional to the
employed, with hunting and trapping almost number of cats remaining and tremendous
universally required to eradicate the last efforts in trapping and hunting are required to
remaining cats in a population. These cam- capture the last survivors in a population.
paigns are often unpopular and have typically Thus, the effort to remove a fixed number of
utilized inhumane methods. People may object animals each year increases substantially as
to eradication programs because of potential the population declines (Short and Turner
health hazards, inconvenience, financial bur- 2005). Failure to fully eliminate a population
dens, religious or cultural beliefs, or ethical can result in rapid rebound of the population.
and welfare concerns (Oppel et al. 2011). Preventing the reintroduction of cats is critical
On‐site lethal control methods are consid- if there is to be any long‐term effect with eradi-
ered to be unacceptable for widespread use in cation. Extensive efforts eliminated feral cats
the management of continental cat popula- from a fenced conservation reserve in Australia.
tions. They have most frequently been However, the population was quickly re‐estab-
applied in an attempt to eradicate cats from lished by the immigration of just two cats
island ecosystems. It has been reported that across an ineffective barrier. Effective control
the vast majority of islands on which eradica- for a sustained period of time was never estab-
tion has been successful are <5 km2 (Nogales lished in a 14‐year period (Short and Turner
et al. 2004). Sustained, aggressive methods 2005).
used in combination are typically required. Even if these lethal control methods were
One campaign often cited as a successful considered acceptable by the general public,
example of cat eradication took place on their use on mainland cat populations is highly
Marion Island, a small uninhabited island in unlikely to be effective. This is in large part due
the Southern Indian Ocean. This “success” to the sheer number of cats that will move in to
required extensive and inhumane efforts over occupy the temporarily vacated niche, but also
a 19‐year period, and included trapping, due to other factors. For example, disease intro-
hunting, poisoning, and disease introduction duction is particularly unlikely to be effective
to eliminate a population of approximately due to variations in natural immunity between
3600 cats (Bester et al. 2002). Even on small populations of cats on islands compared to con-
islands the effort expended is tremendous, in tinents; modeling has shown that FeLV could
one case requiring nearly 4 years to eliminate be effective on an island, but would be of
494 25 Community Cats
limited use in the reduction of cat numbers any- nize programs could ever be employed on a
where else (Courchamp and Sugihara 1999). large enough scale to have a significant impact
on community cat populations.
Trap–Remove–Euthanize
The traditional animal control approach of Trap–Neuter–Relocate
removal for euthanasia (frequently referred to Trap–neuter–relocate programs are similar in
by critics as “catch and kill”) is another method most aspects to trap–neuter–return programs
for the management of cat populations that as a means of non‐lethal management of
has been utilized for significant periods of time community cats. Cats are similarly trapped
in many jurisdictions. Although capture and and presented for veterinary care, steriliza-
euthanasia may be the most humane choice tion, and other medical services before being
for individual cats suffering from significant relocated to another outdoor location, rather
illness or injury, it is not a viable option on a than returned to their colonies or the location
large or long‐term scale for the management of from which they were trapped (Figure 25.9).
cat populations. Such efforts have been associ- While relocation is frequently cited as a
ated with disappointing results, significant desired outcome when nuisance complaints
expense, and often serious welfare concerns. are made, it is not routinely recommended as
Trap–removal–euthanize efforts rarely address a management strategy for community cat
the various factors that will influence cat den- management because of the time, expense,
sity and location, such as a food source or and myriad of challenges associated with it.
available shelter. In order to be effective, such Additionally, relocation rarely resolves the
campaigns must be conducted intensively and concerns surrounding the cats’ presence.
consistently in order to remove all of the cats Because there is likely to be an environmental
from an area, make the area unattractive to niche that makes the location attractive to
potential new residents, and monitor for any cats, new cats will typically move into the
new cats that might arrive or be abandoned area following removal of the existing popula-
and repopulate the location. Similar to eradica- tion unless efforts are made to prevent access
tion campaigns, the effort to remove the last and reduce desirability.
remaining members of a population can be In some instances relocation is necessary and
extremely labor intensive. If cats are removed appropriate. This includes situations where the
without any efforts made to reduce the carry-
ing capacity of the environment, birth rates
and survival rates will typically increase to
compensate for the reduction in population.
Efforts to trap and remove cats for euthana-
sia may also be met with a significant outcry,
the impact of which should not be underesti-
mated. Following a decision to begin removal
of a colony of cats being fed by volunteers,
approximately 50 cats were trapped and
brought to a local animal shelter over a two‐
year period. Some cats had to be trapped
repeatedly as volunteers went to the shelter,
adopted or reclaimed the cats, and then re‐ Figure 25.9 Two volunteers prepare humane traps
that will be used to capture cats in a trap–neuter–
released them on‐site (Winter 2004). Public
return program. Individuals will often volunteer to
opposition, welfare concerns, and cost makes assist with trapping for humane management
it extremely unlikely that trap–remove–eutha- programs, but not for trap–euthanize efforts.
Management Strategies 495
cats’ safety is of concern or severe ecologic con- and even when such criteria are met, available
cerns exist, such as a colony located in an envi- sanctuary space is extremely limited. This
ronmentally sensitive area or in close proximity capacity would be quickly overwhelmed
to the habitat of an endangered species. before even a fraction of the millions of unso-
Relocation must be carefully planned in such cialized free‐roaming cats could be placed in
cases. Finding a suitable location willing to sanctuaries.
accept the cats in a similar climate, with a reli- Despite these limitations, rehoming or sanc-
able food source and suitable shelter, away tuary placement remains popular in public
from heavily trafficked areas, and under the opinion as a method of control. Farnworth
supervision of a caretaker is extremely chal- et al. (2011) found that rehoming was strongly
lenging. Once they have been transported to supported as the main method of control of
the new location, the cats must be confined in free‐roaming cats in New Zealand, despite not
cages large enough to allow for humane care all cats being adequately socialized to make
for several weeks until they habituate to the this a suitable or humane option. Similarly,
new location and can be expected to remain on‐ Loyd and Hernandez (2012) found that place-
site once released. Failure to confine newly ment in sanctuaries was considered by
relocated cats will often result in attempts to respondents to be the most desirable option to
return to the original colony location and may reduce feral cat populations.
result in severe injury or death of the cats.
Sterilization Programs
Adoption and Sanctuary Placement
Rehoming or sanctuary placement may be an These programs rely on veterinary interven-
option for certain individual cats or particular tion to render some or all of a population of
circumstances, but it is not a viable manage- cats incapable of reproducing. This is almost
ment strategy for large populations of commu- always accomplished through traditional spay–
nity cats. Friendly, well‐socialized community neuter, but vasectomy of male cats has also
cats may be candidates for rehoming. However, been proposed and work remains ongoing in
shelter stays are stressful for cats and positive the development of a non‐surgical sterilant
outcomes are far from certain. Many commu- (see Chapter 27). Regardless of the specific
nities struggle to increase live outcomes as means by which sterility is achieved, cats are
higher adoption rates are offset by increased returned to the same location from which they
intake of cats, which would likely be exacer- were trapped or otherwise removed.
bated if cat intake was greatly increased in an There is general agreement that a high pro-
attempt to rehome a sizable portion of the portion of cats (either females only, or both
community cat population. Furthermore, the males and females) must be sterilized to stop
proportion of the free‐roaming cat population the continued growth of the population.
that is impounded by shelters in most commu- Estimates as high as 70% or even greater than
nities is low enough that it is likely to have a 90%, depending on the population dynamics
negligible impact on the size or wellbeing of and timing and targeting (e.g. juvenile or adult
the larger population (Hurley and Levy 2014). female cats) of the cat population in question,
Cats that are poorly socialized to people are have been suggested as necessary to stabilize
unsuitable for traditional placement in a home and ultimately reduce population size through
environment. Sanctuary care may be an option attrition (Foley et al. 2005; Budke and Slater
for some, provided that sufficient facilities, 2009; Miller et al. 2014). These estimates have
staffing, resources, and knowledge are availa- been proposed as goals, but the actual percent-
ble to ensure the humane care of the cats age necessary remains unknown. Furthermore,
throughout their lifetimes. This is a tall order this percentage is unlikely to be a constant
496 25 Community Cats
capacity of the niche is reached, which is Available data suggest that the cost of TNR
largely dependent on an adequate supply of programs is lower than traditional approaches
food. In order to control population growth, that involve impoundment and euthanasia of
one of two broad strategies must be used: feral cats, with the former costing only 40% of
reduce carrying capacity (generally through what would have been spent to respond to a
reduction of available food sources) or reduce cat‐related complaint with impoundment and
the number of intact female cats (Foley et al. sheltering costs. In one community, a change
2005). If efforts are made concurrent with TNR in policy from impounding and euthanizing
programs to reduce carrying capacity, it may be feral cats to TNR resulted in an estimated sav-
possible to gradually and humanely reduce the ings of over $650 000 in just 10 years (Hughes
population size through attrition. and Slater 2002). However, published claims
TNR programs have been shown to signifi- that TNR is less cost‐effective than other con-
cantly reduce complaints through the reduc- trol methods do exist. Investigators in one
tion of nuisance behaviors like spraying, study drew the conclusion that TNR programs
fighting, and mating. Individuals who per- were twice as expensive to implement as trap–
ceived cats as a nuisance were more likely to euthanize programs and did not convey as
choose removal over TNR as a means of con- great a benefit. Their model included a num-
trol; it is possible that these individuals would ber of questionable assumptions about the
change their opinion as to the more desirable fixed costs associated with TNR programs and
means of cat control if the cats’ behaviors the rates at which euthanasia could feasibly be
changed and they were no longer considered a performed, but perhaps most startling were
nuisance (Ash and Adams 2003). the assumptions made regarding the benefits
Early publications on TNR programs sug- of reduced predation. The model included an
gested one reason for the efficacy of steriliza- estimated predation rate of 21% with a mone-
tion was that an existing cat population would tary value of $1500 per bird, but no corre-
limit immigration of new cats to the area sponding monetary value for the life of a cat.
because of their territorial activity (Neville When the value per bird was reduced to $30,
and Remfry 1984). Such claims are often however, there was little difference in cost–
repeated as one of the main benefits of TNR benefit ratio between the two programs (Lohr
programs, but there appears to be little pub- et al. 2013).
lished data to support this effect on a consist- The cost effectiveness of various manage-
ent or significant level. Several case studies ment strategies, including trap–euthanize and
have directly refuted it. In a study of cats in a TNR, has been shown to be at least partially
TNR program in Florida, existing cat popula- dependent on the size of the population at the
tions failed to permanently prevent newly outset of the program (Loyd and DeVore 2010;
arrived cats from joining the colonies (Levy Lohr et al. 2013). Trapping costs will be spe-
et al. 2003a). Similar findings were reported in cific to individual colonies depending on the
Israel: high immigration of sexually intact cats traps and bait used, trapping protocol, and
and decreased emigration rates of neutered available personnel, but use of volunteers to
colony members were seen (Gunther et al. conduct the trapping activities can result in
2011). High rates of immigration have also significant savings. Estimates of a per‐night
been reported in colonies with intact males trapping cost have been reported to be $0.37/
and hysterectomized females, suggesting that trap/night, with a mean per‐cat cost using paid
preservation of hormone production may pro- staff ranging from $3.43 to $6.57 depending on
vide no benefit with regard to preventing a the length of the trapping period (Nutter et al.
“vacuum effect” when compared with gona- 2004c). While the cost of traps is a significant
dectomy (Mendes‐de‐Almeida et al. 2011). start‐up cost for TNR programs, the cost per cat
498 25 Community Cats
trapped can be quite low for large‐scale pro- at the longest time points prior to initiation of
grams conducted over a sustained period of the study. Although the success of the program
time. was limited by a high immigration rate (com-
Despite their popularity or perhaps because prised of abandoned cats and spontaneous
of it, TNR programs remain somewhat of a arrivals), a conspicuous reduction in total cat
controversial management strategy for com- number was still noted. Similar results have
munity cats. Much debate exists regarding been reported in other instances of TNR
their efficacy in reducing community cat popu- (Castillo and Clarke 2003), and the need to
lations, adequately addressing welfare con- address abandonment (regardless of the spe-
cerns, and alleviating public health risks and cific management strategy employed) is often
environmental concerns. Research is limited specifically recognized in position statements
and at times contradictory, and definitions of on community cat management (AAFP 2012;
success vary, with similar reductions in popu- AVMA 2019).
lation size alternatively described as a success Critics have argued that TNR programs do
or failure by different authors. not lead to the elimination of cat populations
Data does exist that supports TNR as a man- on islands, but it is perhaps more likely that
agement technique. Prior to implementation such programs have never been attempted in
of a TNR program at the University of Central favor of continued use of lethal control strate-
Florida, cats had been periodically trapped for gies; a thorough review of island eradication
euthanasia in response to increasing popula- programs indicates TNR was tried in only one
tion size or nuisance complaints, with appar- of 111 campaigns discussed (Campbell et al.
ently little change in need or long‐term impact 2011). Others have suggested that TNR is inef-
despite 30 years of the practice. Within four fective at controlling cat populations under
years of the start of the TNR program, no new prevailing conditions (Dauphiné and Cooper
kittens were born. A 66% reduction in cat pop- 2009) because of low implementation rates,
ulation size after a six‐year period was noted, inconsistent maintenance, and immigration of
including cats removed from the population new cats (Roebling et al. 2014). Several studies
for adoption or humane euthanasia as well as have, in fact, shown that the impact of TNR
those known to have died or disappeared (Levy programs was mitigated by the continued addi-
et al. 2003a). A TNR program conducted by the tion of new cats abandoned to the area.
Ocean Reef Cat Club led to the stabilization of However, these problems also plague the trap–
a sizable cat population within two years and removal programs to which TNR is most fre-
reduction by 50% within four years of the quently compared. Mathematical modeling
implementation of intense and targeted efforts suggests that under some conditions the rate of
(Winter 2004), and a neighborhood‐focused annual capture and removal of cats for eutha-
TNR program in Chicago, IL, resulted in aver- nasia or sterilization must be the same for
age declines to colony populations of 54% from either to result in a decrease in population size
entry to the program and 82% from peak levels (McCarthy et al. 2013). Interestingly, trap–
over a ten‐year period (Spehar and Wolf 2018a). remove–euthanize programs continue to be
A long‐standing TNR program in Rome, where recommended in place of TNR even by authors
euthanasia of free‐roaming cats is prohibited who point out that this has been the long‐term
by law, is reported to have stabilized or reduced (but unsuccessful) focus of traditional animal
the size of >70% of the colonies studied (Natoli control policy for more than 50 years (Roebling
et al. 2006). Not surprisingly, the authors found et al. 2014).
that sterilization took some time to impact col- It has been recommended to focus intense
ony size: the larger decreases in cat population TNR programs on well‐defined, geographically
were seen in colonies that began sterilization restricted populations rather than to spread
Management Strategies 499
efforts across a larger population of cats where on cats and their management with a focus
such diluted neutering rates are likely to be on reducing pet abandonment (Loyd and
less effective. Analysis of two county TNR pro- Hernandez 2012).
grams failed to show a consistent reduction in
per capita growth, the population multiplier Return-to-Field and Shelter–Neuter–Return
(which must be <1 for a population to decline), Historically, TNR programs have focused on
or the proportion of female cats that were preg- returning cats to managed colonies with spe-
nant (Foley et al. 2005). Each program had cific caretakers who provide daily feedings,
sterilized thousands of cats, but the total num- suitable shelter, surveillance for new cats, and
bers of cats trapped represented only 0.63% of veterinary care for medical conditions that
the estimated total feral cats in San Diego may arise. However, the focus on returning
county and 9.6% in Alachua county. This was cats to a specific caretaker or colony is chang-
far lower than the model‐estimated 14–19% ing as animal welfare organizations consider
annual neutering rate and 71–94% proportion new strategies to improve cat welfare, decrease
of neutered cats necessary to reduce popula- shelter intake, and reduce euthanasia rates.
tion growth. These programs are generally referred to as
There is widespread recognition, however, return‐to‐field (RTF), or occasionally shelter–
that ongoing efforts and education are neces- neuter–return (SNR) or Feral Freedom.
sary to address and ultimately control the pop- An early example of this type of program is
ulation of community cats; indeed, some feel one initiated in Jacksonville, FL. Despite years
that “efforts without an effective education of of spay–neuter, the local municipal shelter was
people to control the reproduction of house still receiving high numbers of unaltered com-
cats (as a prevention for abandonment) are a munity cats and had a live release rate of less
waste of money, time, and energy” (Natoli et al. than 10% (Levy and Wilford 2013). In a ground‐
2006). It has been documented that immigra- breaking policy shift, the shelter began trans-
tion of cats can result in the re‐establishment of ferring these cats, starting with ferals and
colonies that were previously eliminated if an quickly expanding to all community cats, to
environmental niche persists that is attractive the local HQHVSN clinic, where they were
to the cats (Nutter 2006), and several studies sterilized, vaccinated, treated for parasites as
have shown a reduction in the impact of man- needed, and ear‐tipped. After a period of over-
agement strategies (including both removal night observation, cats were then returned to
and TNR programs) due to the abandonment of the location from which they had originated
additional cats. Modeling suggests that a colony and door hangers were left at homes nearby to
supplemented with just 1% of the initial popu- explain the program.
lation each year can return to carrying capacity The community of Jacksonville saw a signifi-
within a decade (Lohr et al. 2013). Regardless cant reduction in euthanasia of cats at the
of the type of intervention employed to manage municipal shelter by replacing an impound–
the cat population, continued surveillance for euthanize control strategy with a TNR pro-
and attention to new arrivals (e.g. trapping gram, carried out at no extra expense to the
for sterilization and identification) will be nec- local government with a minimal number of
essary for successful outcomes. Numerous reported complaints (BFAS 2013). Because cats
organizations, ranging from the AVMA and the eligible for inclusion in the program were
AAFP to the American Bird Conservancy, rec- already those “doing well” without a caregiver
ognize the need to reduce the abandonment of in an outdoor environment, the expectation is
cats. Various studies on the perception of that the cats will continue to do as well or likely
free‐roaming cats and their management better following sterilization, vaccination, and
have also suggested that education is necessary treatment of minor medical conditions.
500 25 Community Cats
The popularity of RTF has increased sub- feline intake resulted in 37.6 and 84.1% reduc-
stantially in recent years, though there is sig- tions to cat intake and euthanasia rates at a
nificant variability in the recommendations on municipal animal shelter, respectively, at a
when and how such programs should be municipal animal shelter in Albuquerque,
implemented. For example, it is the ASPCA’s New Mexico. The number of calls to the city
position that RTF should be reserved for unso- about dead cats was also reported to have
cialized, unowned cats unlikely to be eligible declined (Spehar and Wolf 2018b). In Alachua
in a shelter’s adoption program, for whom an County, FL, a two‐year TNR program targeted
exact “found” address is available, and who to an area of historically high cat intake was
appear to have been thriving in their previous implemented with the goal of sterilizing at
environment without known threats to their least 50% of the community cats. More than
safety (ASPCA 2019b). The Million Cat 2000 cats were captured for the program over a
Challenges include RTF for healthy, unowned two‐year period, with 49% being returned to
shelter cats as an alternative to euthanasia as their original locations and 47% (mostly kittens
one of the five key initiatives (MCC 2019), <6 months old) adopted or transferred to res-
while others have highlighted RTF for friendly cue groups. During this time feline intake from
and feral community cats as a component of the target area decreased 66% from baseline,
recommended progressive sheltering practices compared to a 12% reduction in the non‐target
(Pizano 2019). area (Levy et al. 2014). Data on the impact of
In contrast to most of the published litera- RTF on overall community cat populations or
ture on TNR, the peer‐reviewed data on RTF colony size for this study or others is not
focuses largely on program impact to local available.
shelter intake and euthanasia rates for cats,
which can be dramatic and substantial. A ret- Trap–Vasectomy–Hysterectomy–Return
rospective analysis of the records for more Tra p –va s e c to my– hy s te re c to my– re t u r n
than 100 000 cats admitted to a large urban (TVHR) has been proposed as an alternative to
animal shelter in California found that the castration and ovariohysterectomy for sterili-
initiation of an RTF program was associated zation–return programs. Sterilization tech-
with a significant decrease in the number of niques that preserve hormone production have
cats admitted to the shelter over an eight‐year been suggested to be more effective than gona-
time period, despite continued human popu- dectomy for the reduction of size in commu-
lation growth in the area. The proportion of nity cat colonies, because hormone production
cats euthanized during that same period was is thought to be associated with less frequent
reduced almost by half, from 66.6 to 34.9%. immigration of new cats to a colony (Mendes‐
There was also a reduction in the percentage de‐Almeida et al. 2011).
of cats received as dead upon arrival to the There are a number of concerns with this
shelter, and few cats handled through the approach. It is likely that high rates of steriliza-
program were returned to the shelter as tion would be difficult to achieve with TVHR.
either dead or nuisance complaints. The pro- Vasectomies and hysterectomies typically take
portion of cats in the program remained longer to perform than castrations and ovario-
fairly stable during the time period evalu- hysterectomies and fewer veterinarians have
ated, and the relative distribution between received surgical training to perform such
kittens and adults (i.e. kitten intake exceeded techniques, increasing expense and limiting
adult intake) remained unchanged (Edinboro feasibility for large numbers of cats. Even if
et al. 2016). sufficiently high sterilization rates could be
The combination of RTF (~20%) and tar- achieved, significant welfare concerns exist.
geted TNR (~80%) in areas known to have high Female cats would still be at risk of mammary
Management Strategies 501
gland tumors and, if all uterine tissue were not the TVHR arm. Nevertheless, the actual
removed, stump pyometra. In a study of colony impact of TVHR on kitten survival rates has
cats at a zoo in Rio de Janeiro, hysterectomy of not been demonstrated in field studies.
female cats was associated with a dramatic Modeled efficacies of TNR and TVHR were
increase in infection with FeLV and FIV, likely similar at higher (>80%) annual capture rates,
due to ongoing fighting that resulted both from particularly when evaluated over longer peri-
the presence of intact male toms and the social ods of time.
instability of the colony (Mendes‐de‐Almeida Additionally, other factors must be consid-
et al. 2007). The high rates of both immigration ered when evaluating any control method for
and disappearance that were noted during the the management of community cats, including
relatively short study period, coupled with a the welfare of the cats themselves, decreases in
high prevalence of retroviral infection, suggest the size of the population, reduction of wildlife
that the reduction in the colony size may have and environmental concerns, economic viabil-
been achieved from a decreased life span and ity, and acceptability to members of the public
at the expense of cat welfare. TVHR programs and involved stakeholders. Reductions in pop-
would also be anticipated to have minimal ulation size without elimination of all cats can
change to or even exacerbate nuisance behav- have significant benefit. Based on the totality
iors of the cats, which often drive complaints of available data, it appears unlikely that
by the public, and would likely be less effective TVHR would be a more effective strategy for
than TNR in this regard. control than traditional TNR programs when
Data regarding the actual efficacy of TVHR considered in this holistic manner.
programs is lacking. Few clinical interventions
exist to assess the viability of TVHR under field Non-surgical Sterilization
settings. While hysterectomy of female cats has Great potential exists to increase sterilization
been shown in limited instances to preserve the rates and decrease the community cat popula-
social structure, maintain a male: female ratio tion with the development of non‐surgical con-
similar to that found in unsterilized colonies, traceptive products. Such agents could allow for
and reduce the overall size of the colony mass sterilization of cats without the time,
(Mendes‐de‐Almeida et al. 2007; Mendes‐de‐ expense, or need for expertise and specialized
Almeida et al. 2011), it is likely too impractical equipment and facilities that are currently
and comes at a significant cost to welfare for the
reasons previously mentioned. Furthermore, a
reduced rate of immigration, which is argued to Box 25.1 Characteristics of an Ideal
be the main reason that TVHR would be more Non-surgical Sterilant for Cats
effective than TNR as a humane, non‐lethal
control method, has not been proven by the lim- ●● Single dose
ited reports that exist. Higher numbers of immi- ●● Easy to store, transport, and administer
grant female cats were found in years following ●● Induces permanent sterilization*
hysterectomy of colony members than prior to ●● Safe and effective for both males and
any surgical intervention. females
The results of a single modeling study sug- ●● No age restrictions to use
gested that TVHR was more effective than ●● Known effects on health and behavior
TNR or lethal control in eliminating a popula- ●● Cost-effective
tion of 200 cats with lower capture rates. *Although permanent sterility is considered ideal,
However, this effect was partly due to the data suggests that a product which prevents repro-
duction for as little as three years may significantly
enhanced survivability of both kittens and reduce community cat populations.
adults in the TNR arm of the model but not in
502 25 Community Cats
required for surgical techniques. As a result, management challenges for the communities in
non‐surgical sterilization has the potential to which they reside. Significant concern exists
exponentially increase the number of cats that regarding the individual cats’ health and wel-
could be treated. Characteristics of an ideal fare, their role in disease transmission, nuisance
non‐surgical sterilant have been summarized by behaviors, and their impact on wildlife and the
others (Griffin 2013) and are shown in Box 25.1. environment. Public opinion on the cats and the
For more information on the current status of strategy most appropriate for their management
non‐surgical sterilization, see Chapter 27. remains divided and can be highly contentious.
While no single approach exists that will be
appropriate for the management of all commu-
Conclusion nity cats in all situations, comprehensive multi-
faceted programs are most likely to succeed.
The need for better management of community Traditional approaches of doing nothing or trap–
cat populations is clear, but remains a signifi- euthanize have been unsuccessful. Programs that
cant challenge. These sizable populations repre- involve sterilization followed by return of the cats
sent a diverse grouping of cats that vary in terms to their environment provide medical and behav-
of ownership, socialization to humans, and ioral benefits and improve the welfare of individ-
outdoor access. Cats’ unique and impressive ual animals. In addition, they represent a humane
reproductive capabilities, coupled with their form of cat management that has the potential to
ability to survive and even thrive in most envi- reduce population size and alleviate negative
ronments, have resulted in a population of mil- impacts that cats may have on people, other ani-
lions of outdoor cats that present a number of mals, or the environment.
References
catus in an urban area. Mammal Rev. 35 (3–4): on Macquarie Island. Wildlife Res. 12 (3):
302–312. 425–436.
Baker, P.J., Molony, S.E., Stone, E. et al. (2008). Budke, C.M. and Slater, M.R. (2009). Utilization
Cats about town: is predation by free‐ranging of matrix population models to assess a 3‐year
pet cats Felis catus likely to affect urban bird single treatment nonsurgical contraception
populations? Ibis 150 (s1): 86–99. program versus surgical sterilization in feral
Barrows, P.L. (2004). Professional, ethical, and cat populations. J. Appl. Anim. Welf. Sci. 12 (4):
legal dilemmas of trap‐neuter‐release. JAVMA 277–292.
225 (9): 1365–1369. Calhoon, R.E. and Haspel, C. (1989). Urban cat
Bergstrom, D.M., Lucieer, A., Kiefer, K. et al. populations compared by season, subhabitat
(2009). Indirect effects of invasive species and supplemental feeding. J. Anim. Ecol. 58
removal devastate World Heritage island. (1): 321–328.
J. Appl. Ecol. 46 (1): 73–81. Campbell, K.J., Harper, G., Algar, D. et al. (2011).
Best Friends Animal Society (BFAS) (2013). Save Review of feral cat eradications on islands. In:
lives with Feral Freedom. http://bestfriends. Island Invasives: Eradication and
org/uploadedFiles/Content/Resources/ Management, 1e (eds. C.R. Veitch, M.N. Clout
Resources_for_Rescuers%281%29/ and D.R. Towns), 37–46. Gland: IUCN.
Community_Cats/FeralFreedomGuide.pdf Castillo, D. and Clarke, A.L. (2003). Trap/neuter/
(accessed 26 April 2019). release methods ineffective in controlling
Bester, M.N., Bloomer, J.P., Van Aarde, R.J. et al. domestic cat “colonies” on public lands. Nat.
(2002). A review of the successful eradication Areas J. 23: 247–253.
of feral cats from sub‐Antarctic Marion Island, Centonze, L.A. and Levy, J.K. (2002).
Southern Indian Ocean. S. Afr. J. Wildlife Res. Characteristics of free‐roaming cats and their
32 (1): 65. caretakers. JAVMA 220 (11): 1627–1633.
Birhane, M.G., Cleaton, J.M., Monroe, B.P. et al. Christian, K.A., Blanton, J.D., Auslander, M.
(2017). Rabies surveillance in the United States et al. (2009). Epidemiology of rabies post‐
during 2015. JAVMA 250 (10): 1117–1130. exposure prophylaxis—United States of
Blanton, J.D., Dyer, J., McBrayer, J., and America, 2006–2008. Vaccine 27 (51):
Rupprecht, C.E. (2012). Rabies surveillance in 7156–7161.
the United States during 2011. JAVMA 241 (6): Chu, K. and Anderson, W.M. (2007). U.S. public
712–722. opinion on humane treatment of stray cats.
Boetel, R. (2018). Uptown residents sue city over Law & Policy Brief. Bethesda, MD: Alley Cat
cat program. Albuquerque Journal (25 Allies. https://4fi8v2446i0sw2rpq2a3fg51‐
December). https://www.abqjournal. wpengine.netdna‐ssl.com/wp‐content/
com/1261521/uptown‐residents‐sue‐city‐over‐ uploads/2014/08/USPublicOpinionOnHuma
cat‐program.html (accessed 25 April 2019). neTreatmentOfStrayCats.pdf (accessed 26
Bonnaud, E., Bourgeois, K., Vidal, E. et al. April 2019).
(2007). Feeding ecology of a feral cat Chu, K., Anderson, W.M., and Rieser, M.Y.
population on a small Mediterranean island. J. (2009). Population characteristics and neuter
Mammal. 88 (4): 1074–1081. status of cats living in households in the
Boone, J.D. (2015). Better trap–neuter–return for United States. JAVMA 234 (8): 1023–1030.
free‐roaming cats: using models and Churcher, P.B. and Lawton, J.H. (1987).
monitoring to improve population Predation by domestic cats in an English
management. J. Feline Med. Surg. 17 (9): village. J. Zool. 212 (3): 439–455.
800–807. Clarke, A.L. and Pacin, T. (2002). Domestic Cat
Brothers, N.P., Skira, I.J., and Copson, G.R. “Colonies” in Natural Areas: A Growing
(1985). Biology of the feral cat, Felis catus (L.), Exotic Species Threat. Nat. Area J 22: 155–159.
504 25 Community Cats
Conrad, P.A., Miller, M.A., Kreuder, C. et al. antibodies in domestic cats from rural Ohio. J.
(2005). Transmission of Toxoplasma: clues Parasit. 88 (4): 802–803.
from the study of sea otters as sentinels of Edinboro, C.H., Watson, H.N., and Fairbrother,
Toxoplasma gondii flow into the marine A. (2016). Association between a shelter‐
environment. Int. J. Parasitol. 35 (11–12): neuter‐return program and cat health at a
1155–1168. large municipal animal shelter. JAVMA 248
Courchamp, F., Langlais, M., and Sugihara, G. (3): 298–308.
(1999a). Control of rabbits to protect island Farnworth, M.J., Campbell, J., and Adams, N.J.
birds from cat predation. Biol. Conserv. 89 (2): (2011). What’s in a name? Perceptions of stray
219–225. and feral cat welfare and control in Aotearoa,
Courchamp, F., Langlais, M., and Sugihara, G. New Zealand. J. Appl. Anim. Welf. Sci. 14 (1):
(1999b). Cats protecting birds: modelling the 59–74.
mesopredator release effect. J. Anim. Ecol. 68 Farnworth, M.J., Dye, N.G., and Keown, N.
(2): 282–292. (2010). The legal status of cats in New
Courchamp, F. and Sugihara, G. (1999). Zealand: a perspective on the welfare of
Modeling the biological control of an alien companion, stray, and feral domestic cats
predator to protect island species from (Felis catus). J. Appl. Anim. Welf. Sci. 13 (1):
extinction. Ecol. Appl. 9 (1): 112–123. 180–188.
Crowell‐Davis, S.L., Curtis, T.M., and Knowles, Finkler, H. and Terkel, J. (2011). Dichotomy in
R.J. (2004). Social organization in the cat: a the emotional approaches of caretakers of
modern understanding. J. Feline Med. Surg. 6 free‐roaming cats in urban feeding groups:
(1): 19–28. findings from in‐depth interviews. Anthrozoos
Cypher, B.L., Warrick, G.D., Otten, M.R. et al. 24 (2): 203–218.
(2000). Population dynamics of San Joaquin Finkler, H., Hatna, E., and Terkel, J. (2011a). The
kit foxes at the Naval Petroleum Reserves in impact of anthropogenic factors on the
California. Wildlife Monogr.: 1–43. behavior, reproduction, management and
Dabritz, H.A., Atwill, E.R., Gardner, I.A. et al. welfare of urban, free‐roaming cat
(2006). Outdoor fecal deposition by free‐ populations. Anthrozoos 24 (1): 31–49.
roaming cats and attitudes of cat owners and Finkler, H., Gunther, I., and Terkel, J. (2011b).
nonowners toward stray pets, wildlife, and Behavioral differences between urban feeding
water pollution. JAVMA 229 (1): 74–81. groups of neutered and sexually intact free‐
Dabritz, H.A., Miller, M.A., Atwill, E.R. et al. roaming cats following a trap‐neuter‐return
(2007). Detection of Toxoplasma gondii‐like procedure. JAVMA 238 (9): 1141–1149.
oocysts in cat feces and estimates of the Fischer, S.M., Quest, C.M., Dubovi, E.J. et al.
environmental oocyst burden. JAVMA 231 (2007). Response of feral cats to vaccination at
(11): 1676–1684. the time of neutering. JAVMA 230 (1): 52–58.
Dauphiné, N. and Cooper, R.J. (2009). Impacts Foley, P., Foley, J.E., Levy, J.K. et al. (2005).
of free‐ranging domestic cats (Felis catus) Analysis of the impact of trap‐neuter‐return
on birds in the United States: a review of programs on populations of feral cats. JAVMA
recent research with conservation and 227 (11): 1775–1781.
management recommendations. In: Gibson, K.L., Keizer, K., and Golding, C. (2002).
Proceedings of the Fourth International A trap, neuter, and release program for feral
Partners in Flight Conference: Tundra to cats on Prince Edward Island. Can. Vet. J. 43
Tropics, 205–219. Washington, DC: Partners (9): 695–698.
in Flight. Griffin, B. (2001). Reproduction: Prolific Cats:
Dubey, J.P., Saville, W.J.A., Stanek, J.F. et al. The Estrous Cycle. Compend. Cont. Educ.
(2002). Prevalence of Toxoplasma gondii Pract. Vet. N. Am. 23 (12): 1049–1057.
References 505
Griffin, B. (2013). Nonsurgical sterilization of Humane Society of the United States (HSUS)
cats and dogs. In: Shelter Medicine for (2019). Our position on cats. https://www.
Veterinarians and Staff, 2e (eds. L. Miller humanesociety.org/resources/our‐position‐
and S. Zawistowski), 689–696. Ames, IA: cats (accessed 26 April 2019).
Wiley‐Blackwell. Hurley, K.F. and Levy, J.K. (2014). New
Gunther, I., Finkler, H., and Terkel, J. (2011). paradigms for shelters and community cats.
Demographic differences between urban https://vetmed‐maddie.sites.medinfo.ufl.edu/
feeding groups of neutered and sexually intact files/2014/07/New‐Paradigms‐for‐Shelters‐
free‐roaming cats following a trap‐neuter‐ and‐Community‐Cats.pdf (accessed 26 April
return procedure. JAVMA 238 (9): 1134–1140. 2019).
Gunther, I., Raz, T., Berke, O., and Klement, E. Hutchings, S. (2003). The diet of feral house cats
(2015). Nuisances and welfare of free‐roaming (Felis catus) at a regional rubbish tip, Victoria.
cats in urban settings and their association Wildlife Res. 30 (1): 103–110.
with cat reproduction. Prevent. Vet. Med. 119 Jessup, D.A. (2004). The welfare of feral cats and
(3–4): 203–210. wildlife. JAVMA 225 (9): 1377–1383.
van Heezik, Y., Smyth, A., Adams, A. et al. Jones, E. (1977). Ecology of the feral cat, Felis
(2010). Do domestic cats impose an catus (L.), (Carnivora: Felidae) on Macquarie
unsustainable harvest on urban bird Island. Wildlife Res. 4 (3): 249–262.
populations? Biol. Conserv. 143 (1): 121–130. Jones, E. and Coman, B.J. (1981). Ecology of the
Hernandez, S.M., Loyd, K.A.T., Newton, A.N. feral cat, Felis catus (L.), in South‐Eastern
et al. (2018a). The use of point‐of‐view Australia I. Diet. Wildlife Res. 8 (3): 537–547.
cameras (Kittycams) to quantify predation by Jones, E. and Coman, B.J. (1982). Ecology of the
colony cats (Felis catus) on wildlife. Wildlife feral cat, Felis catus (L.), in South‐Eastern
Res. 45 (4): 357–365. Australia II. Reproduction. Wildlife Res. 9 (1):
Hernandez, S.M., Loyd, K.A.T., Newton, A.N. 111–119.
et al. (2018b). Activity patterns and KOAT Albuquerque News (2014). Feral cat trap,
interspecific interactions of free‐roaming, neuter, return program met with lawsuit.
domestic cats in managed Trap‐Neuter‐Return http://www.koat.com/news/new‐mexico/
colonies. Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. 202: 63–68. albuquerque/feral‐cat‐trap‐neuter‐return‐
Hill, S.L., Cheney, J.M., Taton‐Allen, G.F. et al. program‐met‐with‐lawsuit/24787264
(2000). Prevalence of enteric zoonotic (accessed 25 April 2019).
organisms in cats. JAVMA 216 (5): 687–692. Kreuder, C., Miller, M.A., Jessup, D.A. et al.
Hughes, B., Martin, G.R., and Reynolds, S.J. (2003). Patterns of mortality in southern sea
(2008). Cats and seabirds: effects of feral otters (Enhydra lutris nereis) from 1998–2001.
Domestic Cat Felis silvestris catus eradication J. Wildlife Dis. 39 (3): 495–509.
on the population of Sooty Terns Onychoprion Lepczyk, C.A., Mertig, A.G., and Liu, J. (2004).
fuscata on Ascension Island, South Atlantic. Landowners and cat predation across
Ibis 150 (s1): 122–131. rural‐to‐urban landscapes. Biol. Conserv. 115
Hughes, K.L. and Slater, M.R. (2002). (2): 191–201.
Implementation of a feral cat management Levy, J.K. and Crawford, P.C. (2004). Humane
program on a university campus. J. Appl. strategies for controlling feral cat populations.
Anim. Welf. Sci. 5 (1): 15–28. JAVMA 225 (9): 1354–1360.
Hughes, K.L., Slater, M.R., and Haller, L. (2002). Levy, J.K., Gale, D.W., and Gale, L.A. (2003a).
The effects of implementing a feral cat spay/ Evaluation of the effect of a long‐term trap‐
neuter program in a Florida county animal neuter‐return and adoption program on a
control service. J. Appl. Anim. Welf. Sci. 5 (4): free‐roaming cat population. JAVMA 222 (1):
285–298. 42–46.
506 25 Community Cats
Levy, J.K., Isaza, N.M., and Scott, K.C. (2014). and rescue centers. Wildlife Soc. B. 41 (1):
Effect of high‐impact targeted trap‐neuter‐ 55–61.
return and adoption of community cats on cat Luria, B.J., Levy, J.K., Lappin, M.R. et al. (2004).
intake to a shelter. Vet. J. 201 (3): 269–274. Prevalence of infectious diseases in feral cats
Levy, J.K. and Wilford, C.L. (2013). Management in Northern Florida. J. Feline Med. Surg. 6 (5):
of stray and feral community cats. In: Shelter 287–296.
Medicine for Veterinarians and Staff, 2e (eds. Ma, X., Monroe, B.P., Cleaton, J.M. et al. (2018).
L. Miller and S. Zawistowski), 669–688. Ames, Rabies surveillance in the United States
IA: Wiley‐Blackwell. during 2016. JAVMA 252 (8): 945–957.
Levy, J.K., Woods, J.E., Turick, S.L. et al. (2003b). Manning, A.M. and Rowan, A.N. (1992).
Number of unowned free‐roaming cats in a Companion animal demographics and
college community in the southern United sterilization status: results from a survey in
States and characteristics of community four Massachusetts towns. Anthrozoos 5:
residents who feed them. JAVMA 223 (2): 192–201.
202–205. MCC (2019). Million Cat Challenge. https://
Liberg, O. (1984). Food habits and prey impact millioncatchallenge.org/about/the‐five‐key‐
by feral and house‐based domestic cats in a initiatives (accessed 22 August 2019).
rural area in southern Sweden. J. Mammal. 65: McCarthy, R.J., Levine, S.H., and Reed, M.
424–432. (2013). Estimation of effectiveness of three
Lohr, C.A., Cox, L.J., and Lepczyk, C.A. (2013). methods of feral cat population control by use
Costs and benefits of trap‐neuter‐release and of a simulation model. JAVMA 243 (4):
euthanasia for removal of urban cats in Oahu, 502–511.
Hawaii. Conserv. Biol. 27 (1): 64–73. McDonald, J.L., Farnworth, M., and Clements, J.
Longcore, T., Rich, C., and Sullivan, L.M. (2009). (2018). Integrating trap‐neuter‐return
Critical assessment of claims regarding campaigns into a social framework:
management of feral cats by trap–neuter– developing long‐term positive behaviour
return. Conserv. Biol. 23 (4): 887–894. change towards unowned cats in urban areas.
Lord, L.K. (2008). Attitudes toward and Front. Vet. Sci. 5: 258.
perceptions of free‐roaming cats among McGonagle, S. (2015). Effectiveness of trap‐spay/
individuals living in Ohio. JAVMA 232 (8): neuter‐return programs on free‐roaming cats
1159–1167. as a form of rabies prevention. PhD
Loss, S.R., Will, T., and Marra, P.P. (2013). The dissertation. University of Pittsburgh.
impact of free‐ranging domestic cats on McKay, D. (2016). Appeals court upholds ABQ’s
wildlife of the United States. Nat. Comm. 4: use of TNR programs for city’s feral cats.
1396. Albuquerque Journal (4 March). https://www.
Loyd, K.T. and DeVore, J.L. (2010). An abqjournal.com/735316/appeals‐court‐
evaluation of feral cat management options upholds‐abqs‐use‐of‐tnr‐programs‐for‐citys‐
using a decision analysis network. Ecol. Soc. feral‐cats.html (accessed 25 April 2019).
15 (4): 10. http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/ Mendes‐de‐Almeida, F., Labarthe, N., Guerrero,
vol15/iss4/art10. J. et al. (2007). Follow‐up of the health
Loyd, K.A.T. and Hernandez, S.M. (2012). Public conditions of an urban colony of free‐roaming
perceptions of domestic cats and preferences cats (Felis catus Linnaeus, 1758) in the city of
for feral cat management in the southeastern Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Vet. Parasit. 147 (1):
United States. Anthrozoos 25 (3): 337–351. 9–15.
Loyd, K.A.T., Hernandez, S.M., and McRuer, Mendes‐de‐Almeida, F., Remy, G.L., Gershony,
D.L. (2017). The role of domestic cats in the L.C. et al. (2011). Reduction of feral cat (Felis
admission of injured wildlife at rehabilitation catus Linnaeus 1758) colony size following
References 507
hysterectomy of adult female cats. J. Feline Nutter, F.B., Dubey, J.P., Levine, J.F. et al.
Med. Surg. 13 (6): 436–440. (2004a). Seroprevalences of antibodies against
Miller, M.A., Gardner, I.A., Kreuder, C. et al. Bartonella henselae and Toxoplasma gondii
(2002). Coastal freshwater runoff is a risk and fecal shedding of Cryptosporidium spp,
factor for Toxoplasma gondii infection of Giardia spp, and Toxocara cati in feral and pet
southern sea otters (Enhydra lutris nereis). domestic cats. JAVMA 225 (9): 1394–1398.
Int. J. Parasitol. 32 (8): 997–1006. Nutter, F.B., Levine, J.F., and Stoskopf, M.K.
Miller, P.S., Boone, J.D., Briggs, J.R. et al. (2014). (2004b). Reproductive capacity of free‐
Simulating free‐roaming cat population roaming domestic cats and kitten survival
management options in open demographic rate. JAVMA 225 (9): 1399–1402.
environments. PLoS One 9 (11): e113553. Nutter, F.B., Stoskopf, M.K., and Levine, J.F.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone. (2004c). Time and financial costs of programs
0113553. for live trapping feral cats. JAVMA 225 (9):
Mitsuhashi, Y., Chamberlin, A.J., Bigley, K.E., 1403–1405.
and Bauer, J.E. (2011). Maintenance energy Nutter, F.B. (2006). Evaluation of a trap‐neuter‐
requirement determination of cats after return management program for feral cat
spaying. Br. J. Nutrit. 106 (S1): S135–S138. colonies: population dynamics, home ranges,
Molsher, R., Newsome, A., and Dickman, C. and potentially zoonotic diseases. PhD
(1999). Feeding ecology and population dissertation. North Carolina State University.
dynamics of the feral cat (Felis catus) in https://repository.lib.ncsu.edu/bitstream/
relation to the availability of prey in central‐ handle/1840.16/3891/etd.pdf?sequence=1
eastern New South Wales. Wildlife Res. 26 (5): (accessed 22 August 2019).
593–607. Oppel, S., Beaven, B.M., Bolton, M. et al. (2011).
Moore, D.A., Sischo, W.M., Hunter, A. et al. Eradication of invasive mammals on islands
(2000). Animal bite epidemiology and inhabited by humans and domestic animals.
surveillance for rabies postexposure Conserv. Biol. 25 (2): 232–240.
prophylaxis. JAVMA 217 (2): 190–194. Paltridge, R., Gibson, D., and Edwards, G. (1997).
Natoli, E., Maragliano, L., Cariola, G. et al. Diet of the feral cat (Felis catus) in central
(2006). Management of feral domestic cats in Australia. Wildlife Res. 24 (1): 67–76.
the urban environment of Rome (Italy). People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals
Prevent. Vet. Med. 77 (3): 180–185. (PETA) (2019). The great outdoors? Not for
Nelson, S.H., Evans, A.D., and Bradbury, R.B. cats! http://www.peta.org/issues/companion‐
(2005). The efficacy of collar‐mounted devices animal‐issues/overpopulation/feral‐cats/
in reducing the rate of predation of wildlife by great‐outdoors‐cats (accessed 26 April 2019).
domestic cats. Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. 94 (3): Peterson, M.N., Hartis, B., Rodriguez, S. et al.
273–285. (2012). Opinions from the front lines of cat
Neville, P.F. and Remfry, J. (1984). Effect of colony management conflict. PLoS One 7 (9):
neutering on two groups of feral cats. Vet. Rec. e44616.
114 (18): 447–450. Pizano, S. (2019). The Best Practice Playbook for
Noah, D.L., Smith, M.G., Gotthardt, J.C. et al. Animal Shelters. Coral Springs, FL: Team
(1996). Mass human exposure to rabies in Shelter USA.
New Hampshire: exposures, treatment, and Rayner, M.J., Hauber, M.E., Imber, M.J. et al.
cost. Am. J. Public Health 86 (8, Pt 1): (2007). Spatial heterogeneity of mesopredator
1149–1151. release within an oceanic island system. Proc.
Nogales, M., Martín, A., Tershy, B.R. et al. Nat. Acad. Sci. 104 (52): 20862–20865.
(2004). A review of feral cat eradication on Ritchie, E.G. and Johnson, C.N. (2009). Predator
islands. Conserv. Biol. 18 (2): 310–319. interactions, mesopredator release and
508 25 Community Cats
biodiversity conservation. Ecol. Lett. 12 (9): Spehar, D. and Wolf, P. (2018a). A case study in
982–998. citizen science: the effectiveness of a trap‐
Robertson, S.A. (2008). A review of feral cat neuter‐return program in a Chicago
control. J. Feline Med. Surg. 10 (4): 366–375. neighborhood. Animals 8 (1): 14.
Roebling, A.D., Johnson, D., Blanton, J.D. et al. Spehar, D. and Wolf, P. (2018b). The impact of an
(2014). Rabies prevention and management of integrated program of return‐to‐field and
cats in the context of trap‐neuter‐vaccinate‐ targeted trap‐neuter‐return on feline intake
release programs. Zoonoses Public Health 61 and euthanasia at a municipal animal shelter.
(4): 290–296. Animals 8 (4): 55.
Sallinger, B. (2008). An unorthodox campaign to Stojanovic, V. and Foley, P. (2011). Infectious
reduce cat predation on native birds in the disease prevalence in a feral cat population on
Portland metropolitan area. In: 126th Stated Prince Edward Island, Canada. Can. Vet. J. 52
Meeting of the American Ornithologists’ Union. (9): 979.
Portland: OR. Taetzsch, S.J., Gruszynski, K.R., Bertke, A.S.
Scherk, M.A., Ford, R.B., Gaskell, R.M. et al. et al. (2018). Prevalence of zoonotic parasites
(2013). 2013 AAFP Feline Vaccination in feral cats of Central Virginia, USA.
Advisory Panel report. J. Feline Med. Surg. 15 Zoonoses Public Health 65 (6): 728–735.
(9): 785–808. Taylor, N. and Signal, T.D. (2009). Pet, pest,
Schmidt, P.M., Lopez, R.R., and Collier, B.A. profit: isolating differences in attitudes
(2007). Survival, fecundity, and movements of towards the treatment of animals. Anthrozoos
free‐roaming cats. J. Wildlife Manag. 71 (3): 22 (2): 129–135.
915–919. de Torres, P.J., Sutherland, D.R., Clarke, J.R.
Schmidt, P.M., Swannack, T.M., Lopez, R.R. et al. (2011). Assessment of risks to non‐target
et al. (2009). Evaluation of euthanasia and species from an encapsulated toxin in a bait
trap–neuter–return (TNR) programs in proposed for control of feral cats. Wildlife Res.
managing free‐roaming cat populations. 38 (1): 39–50.
Wildlife Res. 36 (2): 117–125. Tschanz, B., Hegglin, D., Gloor, S. et al. (2011).
Scott, K.C., Levy, J.K., and Crawford, P.C. Hunters and non‐hunters: skewed predation
(2002a). Characteristics of free‐roaming cats rate by domestic cats in a rural village. Eur. J.
evaluated in a trap‐neuter‐return program. Wildlife Res. 57 (3): 597–602.
JAVMA 221 (8): 1136–1138. USA Today (2005). Wisconsin is no place for cat‐
Scott, K.C., Levy, J.K., Gorman, S.P. et al. hunting, governor says. http://usatoday30.
(2002b). Body condition of feral cats and the usatoday.com/news/nation/2005‐04‐13‐cat‐
effect of neutering. J. Appl. Anim. Welf. Sci. 5 hunting_x.htm (accessed 26 April 2019).
(3): 203–213. Wallace, J.L. and Levy, J.K. (2006). Population
Short, J. and Turner, B. (2005). Control of feral characteristics of feral cats admitted to seven
cats for nature conservation. IV. Population trap‐neuter‐return programs in the United
dynamics and morphological attributes of States. J. Feline Med. Surg. 8 (4): 279–284.
feral cats at Shark Bay, Western Australia. Winter, L. (2004). Trap‐neuter‐release programs:
Wildlife Res. 32 (6): 489–501. the reality and the impacts. JAVMA 225 (9):
Silva‐Rodriguez, E.A. and Sieving, K.E. (2011). 1369–1376.
Influence of care of domestic carnivores on Woods, M., McDonald, R.A., and Harris, S. (2003).
their predation on vertebrates. Conserv. Biol. Predation of wildlife by domestic cats Felis catus
25 (4): 808–815. in Great Britain. Mammal Rev. 33 (2): 174–188.
Spehar, D. and Wolf, P. (2017). An examination Zavaleta, E.S., Hobbs, R.J., and Mooney, H.A.
of an iconic trap‐neuter‐return program: the (2001). Viewing invasive species removal in a
Newburyport, Massachusetts case study. whole‐ecosystem context. Trends Ecol. Evol. 16
Animals 7 (11): 81. (8): 454–459.
509
26
Ovariohysterectomy (OHE) and castration are c onsiderations, and life situation. But it is “life
the surgeries most commonly performed by situation” that has the biggest impact. For an
small animal practitioners in the United States individually owned animal living in a home,
(Greenfield et al. 2004). Exhaustive reviews of decisions should be based primarily on factors
the benefits and detriments of gonadectomy at that impact that animal’s individual health
various ages have been published (Root and the health and wellbeing of that house
Kustritz 2007; Reichler 2009; Root Kustritz hold, and secondarily on population control.
2012; Howe 2015; Houlihan 2017; Root But for the shelter animal facing possible
Kustritz et al. 2017). euthanasia if not adopted or potentially pro
The optimal age at which to perform OHE or ducing multiple litters if adopted, decisions
castration of dogs and cats is, however, not should be based primarily on population
defined by the veterinary literature. In the control.
United States, most veterinarians recommend
cats and dogs be spayed or castrated when
about six months of age, prior to puberty, which Population Control
is defined as acquisition of normal breeding
behavior and semen quality in males and first In the United States, a serious problem exists
estrus in females. In other countries, veterinar with the supply and demand for pet animals,
ians recommend that dogs and cats be spayed with a net result of pet homelessness. In some
after their first estrus, or do not recommend areas of the country, the spay–neuter message
elective surgical sterilization be performed at has been so successful that shelters have a
any age. Indeed, in some countries, elective hard time finding adoptable animals, whereas
gonadectomy is considered unethical and is in other parts of the country the supply sig
either strongly discouraged or illegal (Salmeri nificantly exceeds demand. The result of this
et al. 1991; Gunzel‐Apel 1998). For this discus imbalance is that over a million unowned
sion, it is assumed that the veterinarian is com dogs and cats are euthanized yearly in the
fortable with the ethics of elective gonadectomy United States (Nassar et al. 1992; National
and practices in a country in which such sur Council on Pet Population Study and Policy
gery is considered acceptable by professional 1994; ASPCA 2019). Some of these are feral
associations and society at large. animals, some are abandoned and brought to
The optimal time for spay–neuter depends the animal shelter as strays, and many are
on species, breed, intended use, financial relinquished. Intact animals are much more
510 26 Influence of Spay–Neuter Timing on Health
and Strandberg 1984; Berry et al. 1986; Lowseth morbidity may be high, although this is gener
et al. 1990). Again, morbidity generally is low. ally considered to be a curable condition with
Finally, several studies have documented surgery (Whitehair et al. 1993; Duval et al.
increased life span in castrated male dogs com 1999; Slauterbeck et al. 2004). Again, some
pared to intact males (Bronson 1982; Michell breeds, most notably large and giant breeds,
1999; Moore et al. 2001; Banfield 2013; are predisposed to CCL injury (Duval et al.
Hoffman et al. 2013). This may be due to 1999; Wilke et al. 2005; Harasen 2008; Torres
greater care by owners after the “investment” et al. 2013; Hart et al. 2016). Obesity is high in
of surgery has been made in that animal, or incidence, but morbidity can be controlled by
may be due to a decrease in sexually dimorphic the owner or guardian. Incidence of obesity in
behaviors that put the animal at increased risk, castrated dogs does not appear to be dependent
such as roaming. on age at castration, and the increased risk of
Detriments of castration in male dogs obesity is only significant for the first two years
include complications of surgery, increased after surgery (Lefebvre et al. 2013).
incidence of prostatic neoplasia (Obradovich The appropriate recommendation for castra
et al. 1987; Sorenmo et al. 2003; Bryan et al. tion of male dogs is less readily evident than
2007), transitional cell carcinoma (Norris et al. for male cats. Given that a male dog can be
1992; Knapp et al. 2000), osteosarcoma in cer responsible for producing many more offspring
tain breeds (Priester et al. 1980; Ru et al. 1998; than can a given bitch, one can argue that cas
Hart et al. 2016), and perhaps hemangiosar tration is necessary for population control. The
coma in certain breeds (Prymak et al. 1988; morbidity associated with castration as a
Ware and Hopper 1999; Hart et al. 2014, 2016), possible predisposing cause of the conditions
increased incidence of cranial cruciate liga described would suggest that castration not be
ment (CCL) injury (Whitehair et al. 1993; recommended when considering the animal as
Duval et al. 1999; Slauterbeck et al. 2004), obe an individual, although the increased life span
sity (Edney and Smith 1986; Crane 1991), and noted in numerous studies argues in favor of
possible increased incidence of diabetes melli castration, as does the high incidence of non‐
tus (Marmor et al. 1982). Reported incidence neoplastic prostatic disease seen in intact male
of post‐surgical complications in dogs neu dogs.
tered at a traditional age (greater than 6 Recommendations on whether or not to cas
months) is 6.1%, with most reported complica trate and when to castrate should be made on a
tions mild and self‐resolving (Pollari et al. case‐by‐case basis, evaluating the breed of the
1996a). The complication rate of puppy castra dog, his intended working life or activity level,
tion is reported lower at 3.5%, with all compli the ability of the owner to control reproduction
cations mild and self-limiting (Miller et al. in that animal, the owner’s wishes regarding
2018). No mortalities were reported in 20 800 use of that animal for breeding, and the own
male dogs castrated in one study (Levy et al. er’s level of concern over pet population con
2017). Prostatic neoplasia, transitional cell car trol. If owners ask for guidance regarding the
cinoma, osteosarcoma, and hemangiosarcoma age at which to castrate their dog, they may
generally are low in incidence but high in mor wish to consider that of the disorders likely to
bidity and mortality (Weaver 1981; Bell et al. occur in intact dogs, BPH occurs earlier in life
1991; Ware and Hopper 1999; Teske et al. 2002; than does testicular neoplasia, is not likely to
Poirier et al. 2004). No breed predisposition manifest clinically until the dog is at least
has been identified for prostatic neoplasia, but 2.4 years of age, and is curable by castration at
it does exist for the other cancers noted (Ru the time of diagnosis (Zirkin and Strandberg
et al. 1998; Chun and DeLorimier 2003; Henry 1984; Berry et al. 1986; Lowseth et al. 1990). An
2003; Smith 2003). The incidence of CCL alternative to castration is vasectomy, which
injury in dogs is relatively high at 1.8%, and sterilizes the dog while sparing testosterone.
Dogs and Cats with an Owner or Guardian 513
The procedure is reportedly quick, less inva time of clinical presentation is curative;
sive than castration, and not difficult for reported mortality ranges from 0 to 17% in
veterinarians to master (Brent and Kutzler dogs (Johnston et al. 2001). Owners should be
2018). The downsides to this form of steriliza aware of the acute (often insidious) onset and
tion are that testicular cancer, perianal gland presentation, and that an emergency pyome
tumor, and enlarged prostate may occur – but if tra OHE is more challenging and costly when
they arise later in life, they are typically treated compared to a routine OHE.
via castration. Hormones will also influence Detriments of OHE in female dogs include
the male dog’s behavior and interest in females complications of surgery, increased incidence
in heat. Another concern in animal welfare and of transitional cell carcinoma (Norris et al.
rescue/shelter communities is the rationale 1992; Knapp et al. 2000), osteosarcoma in cer
that dogs may display more intermale aggres tain breeds (Priester et al. 1980; Ru et al. 1998),
sion, urine marking, mounting, and roaming, hemangiosarcoma in certain breeds (Prymak
which may result in owners abandoning or et al. 1988; Ware and Hopper 1999), and cuta
returning their pets and thus increasing shelter neous mast cell tumor (White et al. 2006),
populations. (Brent and Kutzler 2018). increased incidence of CCL injury (Whitehair
et al. 1993; Duval et al. 1999; Slauterbeck et al.
2004), obesity and diabetes mellitus (Marmor
Female Dogs
et al. 1982; Edney and Smith 1986; Crane
Benefits of OHE in bitches include decreased 1991), a possible increase in aggression in at
incidence of mammary neoplasia, with the least one breed (Reisner 1993; Kim et al. 2006),
greatest benefit if spayed before the first heat, and possibly increased incidence of urethral
and the essentially eliminated incidence of sphincter mechanism incompetence (estro
ovarian or uterine neoplasia and pyometra gen‐responsive urinary incontinence; Stocklin‐
(Schneider et al. 1969). Mammary neoplasia Gautschi et al. 2001; Angioletti et al. 2004; Holt
is the most common tumor of female dogs, 2004; Beauvais et al. 2012). Reported incidence
with a reported incidence of 3.4%, and some of post‐surgical complications in dogs is 6.1%,
select populations reporting incidence as high with most reported complications mild and
as 13% by 10 years of age (Fidler and Brodey self‐resolving (Pollari et al. 1996). One recent
1967; Dorn et al. 1968a; Moe 2001; Richards study reported the peri‐operative mortality
et al. 2001). It is the most common malignant rate of female dogs undergoing OHE at 0.018%
tumor in female dogs, with 50.9% of mam (Levy et al. 2017).
mary tumors reported to be malignant; metas As in male dogs, the incidence of tumors
tases are found in about 75% of cases of reportedly associated with gonadectomy is low,
mammary carcinoma, with the lung the most but morbidity with these tumor types is high.
common site of metastasis (Cotchin et al. Breed predispositions exist for all three tumor
1951; Dorn et al. 1968a; Moulton et al. 1970; types. The incidence of obesity is high after
Brodey et al. 1983). A hormonal basis for OHE, but morbidity can be controlled by the
malignant transformation of mammary cells owner. The incidence of obesity after OHE
and progression of neoplasia is hypothesized does not appear to be dependent on age at sur
based on the decreasing benefit of OHE with gery, and the increased risk of obesity is only
increasing number of estrous cycles in the significant for the first two years after surgery
dog’s life prior to surgery. The other very com (Lefebvre et al. 2013). The incidence of CCL
mon disorder in female dogs when aged is injury in dogs is relatively high at 1.8%, and
pyometra, reported to occur in 15.2% of dogs morbidity may be high, although this is gener
by 4 years of age and in 23–24% of dogs by ally considered to be a curable condition with
10 years of age (Egenvall et al. 2001; Fukuda surgery. Again, some breeds, most notably
2001). Morbidity is high, although OHE at the large and giant breeds, are predisposed to CCL
514 26 Influence of Spay–Neuter Timing on Health
injury. Aggression after OHE has been reported Ovariectomy is an alternative to ovariohys
in English Springer Spaniels; there is some terectomy that offers essentially the same
suggestion that this effect may be more likely advantages and disadvantages. While some
in bitches that demonstrated aggressive ten authors (Van Goethem et al. 2006) suggest that
dencies prior to surgery (Reisner 1993). OHE is technically more complicated, time
Urethral sphincter mechanism incompetence consuming, and could be associated with
is a problem of spayed female dogs, especially greater morbidity (larger incision, more intra
those weighing more than 20 kg (Holt and operative trauma, increased discomfort) com
Thrusfield 1993). While morbidity is low and pared with OVE, it is unclear whether these
this is a disease easily controlled with medical differences in surgical time, incision length,
therapy in most female dogs, evidence exists and morbidity still hold true when high‐
suggesting incidence can be decreased by spay volume techniques are employed. The incision
ing bitches when greater than three months of lengths and surgery times for both procedures
age; this has not been rigorously supported by in studies of these techniques are greater than
meta‐analysis of the veterinary literature would be expected in a high‐quality high‐vol
(Spain et al. 2004b; Beauvais et al. 2012; Forsee ume spay–neuter (HQHVSN) clinic setting. No
et al. 2013). There is one paper reporting significant differences between techniques
increased life span associated with intact sta have been observed for the incidence of long‐
tus in a population of exceptionally long‐lived term urogenital problems, including endome
Rottweilers (Waters et al. 2009), whereas other tritis/pyometra and urinary incontinence,
studies have shown longer life span in spayed making OVE and OHE equally acceptable
Rottweilers despite higher osteosarcoma risk methods of gonadectomy in the healthy bitch.
(Cooley 2002); applicability of these findings to An alternative option for surgical sterilization
other dog populations is unknown. Several of female dogs is sometimes called an ovary-
studies report that sterilized female dogs have sparing spay or partial spay and involves per
a longer life expectancy. One study demon forming only a hysterectomy, removing the
strated a lifespan in spayed dogs 26.3% greater uterus and leaving the ovaries intact. It is impor
than that of intact female dogs (Hoffman et al. tant to remove all the uterus to ensure that
2013), and the 2013 analysis of Banfield medi stump pyometra does not occur (Brent and
cal records of 2.2 million dogs similarly dem Kutzler 2018). This complete removal of the
onstrated that sterilized female dogs lived 23% uterus requires a longer incision and longer sur
longer than intact female dogs (Michell 1999; gery time compared to OHE and OVH, poten
Banfield 2013). tially leading to the potential for greater
The appropriate recommendation for OHE postoperative discomfort. The objective of ovary‐
of female dogs is less readily evident than for sparing hysterectomy is to ensure that the dog is
female cats. Certainly, mammary neoplasia incapable of reproducing while maintaining her
and pyometra are of high incidence and high natural gonadal hormones. Ovary‐sparing hys
morbidity, and are greatly decreased in inci terectomy is relatively new and as of this writing
dence by OHE. However, possible predisposi there is little peer‐reviewed information in pub
tion to very high morbidity tumor types or CCL lication about it. Female dogs with hysterectomy
injury must be evaluated. As with male dogs, are presumed to have the same disease risks and
the recommendation should be made on a benefits as unaltered dogs, except for the risks of
case‐by‐case basis, evaluating the breed of the pyometra and possible complications of preg
dog, her intended working life or activity level, nancy, which are eliminated by hysterectomy.
and the owner’s wishes regarding use of that Dogs who have undergone this procedure will
animal for breeding, but in general it can be still experience estrus cycles and demonstrate
recommended that bitches be spayed prior to the same behaviors as intact females, a fact for
puberty. which pet owners must be prepared.
References 515
References
Alexander, S.A. and Shane, S.M. (1994). Angioletti, A., De Francesco, I., Vergottini, M.
Characteristics of animals adopted from an et al. (2004). Urinary incontinence after
animal control center whose owners complied spaying in the bitch: incidence and oestrogen‐
with a spaying/neutering program. JAVMA therapy. Vet. Res. Comm. 28 (Suppl 1):
205: 472–476. 153–155.
516 26 Influence of Spay–Neuter Timing on Health
ASPCA (n.d.). Shelter intake and surrender: pet as a risk factor for canine prostate cancer.
statistics. https://www.aspca.org/animal‐ Prostate 67: 1174–1181.
homelessness/shelter‐intake‐and‐surrender/ Chun, R. and DeLorimier, L.P. (2003). Update on
pet‐statistics (accessed 18 March 2019). the biology and management of canine
Banfield (2013). Banfield state of pet health 2013 osteosarcoma. Vet. Clin. N. Am. Small Anim.
report. Vancouver, WA: Banfield Pet Hospital Pract. 33: 491–516.
https://www.banfield.com/Banfield/media/ Cockcroft, P. and Holmes, M. (2003). Handbook
PDF/Downloads/soph/Banfield‐State‐of‐Pet‐ of Evidence‐Based Veterinary Medicine. Oxford:
Health‐Report_2013.pdf (accessed 20 August Blackwell.
2019). Cooley, D.M., Beranek, B.C., Schlittler, D.L. et al.
Beauvais, W., Cardwell, J.M., and Brodbelt, D.C. (2002). Endogenous gonadal hormone
(2012). The effect of neutering on the risk of exposure and bone sarcoma risk. Cancer
urinary incontinence in bitches – a systematic Epidemiol. Prevent. Biomark. 11 (11):
review. J. Small Anim. Pract. 53: 198–204. 1434–1440.
Bell, F.W., Klausner, J.S., Hayden, D.W. et al. Cotchin, E., Douglas, S.W., and Platt, H. (1951).
(1991). Clinical and pathologic features of Neoplasms in small animals. Vet. Rec. 63: 67–78.
prostatic adenocarcinoma in sexually intact Crane, S.W. (1991). Occurrence and
and castrated dogs: 31 cases (1970–1987). management of obesity in companion
JAVMA 199: 1623–1630. animals. J. Small Anim. Pract. 32: 275–282.
Belsito, K.R., Vester, B.M., Keel, T. et al. (2007). Dorn, C.R., Taylor, D.O., Frye, F.L. et al. (1968a).
Spaying affects blood metabolites and adipose Survey of animal neoplasms in Alameda and
tissue gene expression in cats. Proceedings of Contra Costa counties, California. I.
the Nestle Purina Nutrition Forum, St. Louis, Methodology and description of cases. J. Nat.
MO. Cancer Inst. 40: 295–305.
Berry, S.J., Strandberg, J.D., Saunders, W.J. et al. Dorn, C.R., Taylor, D.O., Schneider, R. et al.
(1986). Development of canine benign (1968b). Survey of animal neoplasms in
prostatic hyperplasia with age. Prostate 9: Alameda and Contra Costa counties,
363–373. California. II. Cancer morbidity in dogs and
Birchard, S.J. and Sherding, R.G. (eds.) (2006). cats from Alameda county. J. Nat. Cancer Inst.
Mammary gland neoplasia. In: Saunders 40: 307–318.
Manual of Small Animal Practice, 3e, 311–315. Duval, J.M., Budsberg, S.C., Flo, G.L. et al.
Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier. (1999). Breed, sex, and body weight as risk
Brent, L. and Kutzler, M. (2018). Alternatives to factors for rupture of the cranial cruciate
traditional spay and neuter – evolving best ligament in young dogs. JAVMA 215: 811–814.
practices in dog sterilization. Innovative Edney, A.T. and Smith, P.M. (1986). Study of
Veterinary Care (26 October). https:// obesity in dogs visiting veterinary practices in
ivcjournal.com/spay‐neuter‐alternatives the United Kingdom. Vet. Rec. 118: 391–396.
(accessed 21 March 2019). Egenvall, A., Hagman, R., Bonnett, B.N. et al.
Brodey, R.S., Goldschmidt, M.H., and Roszel, (2001). Breed risk of pyometra in insured dogs
J.R. (1983). Canine mammary gland in Sweden. J. Vet. Intern. Med. 15: 530–538.
neoplasms. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc. 19: Eno, M. and Fekety, S. (1993). Early age spay/
61–90. neuter: a growing consensus. Shelter Sense
Bronson, R.T. (1982). Variation in age at death of (1–7 November).
dogs of different sexes and breeds. Am. J. Vet. Fettman, M.J., Stanton, C.A., Banks, L.L. et al.
Res. 43: 2057–2059. (1997). Effects of neutering on bodyweight,
Bryan, J.N., Keeler, M.R., Henry, C.J. et al. metabolic rate and glucose tolerance of
(2007). A population study of neutering status domestic cats. Res. Vet. Sci. 62: 131–136.
References 517
Fidler, I.J. and Brodey, R.S. (1967). The biological Hoffman, J.M., Creevy, K.E., and Promislow,
behavior of canine mammary neoplasms. D.E. (2013). Reproductive capability is
JAVMA 151: 1311–1318. associated with lifespan and cause of death in
Forsee, K.M., Davis, G.J., Mouat, E.E. et al. companion dogs. PLoS One 8 (4): e61082.
(2013). Evaluation of the prevalence of Holt, P.E. (2004). Urinary incontinence in the
urinary incontinence in spayed female dogs: male and female dog or does sex matter?
566 cases (2003–2008). JAVMA 242: 959–962. World Small Animal Veterinary Association
Fukuda, S. (2001). Incidence of pyometra in World Congress Proceedings. https://www.vin.
colony‐raised beagle dogs. Exp. Anim. 50: com/apputil/content/defaultadv1.aspx?meta=
325–329. Generic&pId=11181&id=3852252 (accessed
Greenfield, C.L., Johnson, A.L., and Schaeffer, 20 August 2019).
D.J. (2004). Frequency of use of various Holt, P.E. and Thrusfield, M.V. (1993).
procedures, skills, and areas of knowledge Association in bitches between breed, size,
among veterinarians in private small animal neutering and docking, and acquired urinary
exclusive or predominant practice and incontinence due to incompetence of the
proficiency expected of new veterinary school urethral sphincter mechanism. Vet. Rec. 133:
graduates. JAVMA 224: 1780–1787. 177–180.
Gunzel‐Apel, A.R. (1998). Early castration of Houlihan, K.E. (2017). A literature review on the
dogs and cats from the point of view of animal welfare implications of gonadectomy of dogs.
welfare. Deut. Tierarztl. Woch. 105: 95–98. JAVMA 250: 1155–1166.
Hahn, K.A., VonDerHaar, M.A., and Teclaw, R.F. Howe, L.M. (1992a). Prepubertal gonadectomy
(1992). An epidemiological evaluation of 1202 in dogs and cats – part I. Comp. Cont. Educ.
dogs with testicular neoplasia. J. Vet. Intern. 21: 103–111.
Med. 6: 121. Howe, L.M. (1992b). Prepubertal gonadectomy
Hampe, J.F. and Misdorp, W. (1974). Tumours in dogs and cats – part II. Comp. Cont. Educ.
and dysplasias of the mammary gland. B. 21: 197–201.
WHO 50: 111–133. Howe, L.M. (1997). Short‐term results and
Harasen, G. (2008). Canine cranial cruciate complications of prepubertal gonadectomy in
ligament rupture in profile: 2002–2007. Can. cats and dogs. JAVMA 211: 57–62.
Vet. J. 49: 193–194. Howe, L.M. (2006). Surgical methods of
Hart, B.L., Hart, L.A., Thigpen, A.P. et al. (2014). contraception and sterilization.
Long‐term health effects of neutering dogs: Theriogenology 66: 500–509.
comparison of Labrador retrievers with Howe, L.M. (2015). Current perspectives on the
Golden retrievers. PLoS One 9: e102241. optimal age to spay/castrate dogs and cats. Vet.
Hart, B.L., Hart, L.A., Thigpen, A.P. et al. (2016). Med. Res. Rep. 6: 171–180.
Neutering of German shepherd dogs: Howe, L.M., Slater, M.R., Boothe, H.W. et al.
associated joint disorders, cancers and urinary (2000). Long‐term outcome of gonadectomy
incontinence. Vet. Med. Sci. 2: 191–199. performed at an early age or traditional age in
Hayes, H.M., Milne, K.L., and Mandel, C.P. cats. JAVMA 217: 1661–1665.
(1981). Epidemiological features of feline Howe, L.M., Slater, M.R., Boothe, H.W. et al.
mammary carcinoma. Vet. Rec. 108: 476–479. (2001). Long‐term outcome of gonadectomy
Henry, C.J. (2003). Management of transitional performed at an early age or traditional age in
cell carcinoma. Vet. Clin. N. Am. Small Anim. dogs. JAVMA 218: 217–221.
Pract. 33: 597–613. Johnston, S.D., Root Kustritz, M.V., and Olson,
Herron, M.A. (1972). The effect of prepubertal P.N. (2001). Disorders of the canine uterus
castration on the penile urethra of the cat. and uterine tubes (oviducts). In: Canine and
JAVMA 160: 208–211. Feline Theriogenology (eds. S.D. Johnston,
518 26 Influence of Spay–Neuter Timing on Health
M.V. Root Kustritz and P.N. Olson), 206–224. Mitsuhashi, Y., Chamberlin, A.J., Bigley, K.E.
Philadelphia, PA: Saunders. et al. (2011). Maintenance energy requirement
Kim, H.H., Yeon, S.C., Houpt, K.A. et al. (2006). determination of cats after spaying. Br. J. Nutr.
Effects of ovariohysterectomy on reactivity in 106: S135–S138.
German Shepherd dogs. Vet. J. 172: 154–159. Moe, L. (2001). Population‐based incidence of
Knapp, D.W., Glickman, N.W., DeNicola, D.B. mammary tumours in some dog breeds.
et al. (2000). Naturally‐occurring canine J. Reprod. Fert. Suppl. 57: 439–443.
transitional cell carcinoma of the urinary Mondelli, F., Prato Previde, E., Verga, M. et al.
bladder. Urol. Oncol. 5: 47–59. (2004). The bond that never developed:
Lefebvre, S.L., Yang, M., Wang, M. et al. (2013). adoption and relinquishment of dogs in a
Effect of age at gonadectomy on the rescue shelter. J. Appl. Anim. Welf. Sci. 7:
probability of dogs becoming overweight. 253–266.
JAVMA 243: 236–243. Moons, C.P., Valcke, A., Verschueren, K. et al.
Lekcharoensuk, C., Osborne, C.A., and Lulich, (2018). Effect of early‐age gonadectomy on
J.P. (2001). Epidemiologic study of risk factors behavior in adopted shelter kittens–the
for lower urinary tract diseases in cats. sequel. J. Vet. Behav. 26: 43–47.
JAVMA 218: 1429–1435. Moore, G.E., Burkman, K.D., Carter, M.N. et al.
Levy, J.K., Bard, K.M., Tucker, P.D. et al. (2017). (2001). Causes of death or reasons for
Perioperative mortality in cats and dogs euthanasia in military working dogs: 927
undergoing spay or castration at a high‐ cases (1993–1996). JAVMA 219: 209–214.
volume clinic. Vet. J. 224: 11–15. Moulton, J.E., Taylor, D.O., Dorn, C.R. et al.
Lowseth, L.A., Gerlach, R.F., Gillett, N.A. et al. (1970). Canine mammary tumors. Vet. Path. 7:
(1990). Age‐related changes in the prostate 289–320.
and testes of the beagle dog. Vet. Path. 27: Nassar, R., Talboy, J., and Moulton, C. (1992).
347–353. Animal Shelter Reporting Study 1990.
Manning, A.M. and Rowan, A.N. (1992). Englewood, CO: American Humane
Companion animal demographics and Association.
sterilization status: results from a survey in National Council on Pet Population Study and
four Massachusetts towns. Anthrozoos 5: Policy (1994). National Shelter Census: 1994
192–201. Results. Fort Collins, CO: NCCPPSP.
Marmor, M., Willeberg, P., Glickman, L.T. New, J.G., Salman, M.D., Scarlett, J.M. et al.
et al. (1982). Epizootiologic patterns of (2000). Shelter relinquishment: characteristics
diabetes mellitus in dogs. Am. J. Vet. Res. 43: of shelter‐relinquished animals and their
465–470. owners compared with animals and their
McCann, T.M., Simpson, K.E., Shaw, D.J. et al. owners in US pet‐owning households. J. Appl.
(2007). Feline diabetes mellitus in the UK: the Anim. Welf. Sci. 3: 179–201.
prevalence within an insured cat population New, J.C., Kelch, W.J., Hutchison, J.M. et al.
and a questionnaire‐based putative risk factor (2004). Birth and death rate estimates of cats
analysis. J. Feline Med. Surg. 9: 289–299. and dogs in U.S. households and related
Michell, A.R. (1999). Longevity of British breeds factors. J. Appl. Anim. Welf. Sci. 7: 229–241.
of dog and its relationships with sex, size, Norris, A.M., Laing, E.J., Valli, V.E. et al. (1992).
cardiovascular variables and disease. Vet. Rec. Canine bladder and urethral tumors: a
145: 625–629. retrospective study of 115 cases (1980–1985).
Miller, K.P., Rekers, W.L., DeTar, L.G. et al. J. Vet. Intern. Med. 6: 145–153.
(2018). Evaluation of sutureless scrotal Obradovich, J., Walshaw, R., and Goullaud, E.
castration for pediatric and juvenile dogs. (1987). The influence of castration on the
JAVMA 253: 1589–1593. development of prostatic carcinoma in the
References 519
dog: 43 cases (1978–1985). J. Vet. Intern. Med. hematoma in dogs: 217 cases (1985). JAVMA
1: 183–187. 193: 706–712.
Overley‐Adamson, B. and Baez, J. (2016). Feline Rand, J.S., Bobbermien, L.M., Hendrikz, J.K.
mammary carcinoma. In: August’s et al. (1997). Over representation of Burmese
Consultations in Feline Internal Medicine, vol. cats with diabetes mellitus. Aust. Vet. J. 75:
7 (ed. S. Little), 578–584. Philadelphia, PA: 402–405.
Saunders. Reichler, I.M. (2009). Gonadectomy in cats and
Patronek, G.J., Glickman, L.T., Beck, A.M. et al. dogs: a review of risks and benefits. Reprod.
(1996). Risk factors for relinquishment of dogs Domest. Anim. 44: 29–35.
to an animal shelter. JAVMA 209: 572–581. Reisner, I.R. (1993). Dominance‐related aggression
Poirier, V.J., Forrest, L.J., Adams, W.M. et al. of English springer spaniels: a review of 53
(2004). Piroxicam, mitoxantrone, and coarse cases. Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci. 37: 83–84.
fraction radiotherapy for the treatment of Richards, H.G., McNeil, P.E., Thompson, H.
transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder in et al. (2001). An epidemiological analysis of a
10 dogs: a pilot study. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. canine‐biopsies database compiled by a
Assoc. 40: 131–136. diagnostic histopathology service. Prevent. Vet.
Pollari, F.L. and Bonnett, B.N. (1996). Evaluation Med. 51: 125–136.
of postoperative complications following Root, M.V., Johnston, S.D., Johnston, G.R. et al.
elective surgeries of dogs and cats at private (1996a). The effect of prepuberal and
practices using computer records. Can. Vet. J. postpuberal gonadectomy on penile extrusion
37: 672–678. and urethral diameter in the domestic cat. Vet.
Pollari, F.L., Bonnett, B.N., Bamsey, S.C. et al. Radiol. Ultrasound 37: 363–366.
(1996). Postoperative complications of elective Root, M.V., Johnston, S.D., and Olson, P.N.
surgeries in dogs and cats determined by (1996b). Effect of prepuberal and postpuberal
examining electronic and paper medical gonadectomy on heat production measured by
records. JAVMA 208: 1882–1886. indirect calorimetry in male and female
Porters, N., de Rooster, H., Verschueren, K. et al. domestic cats. Am. J. Vet. Res. 57: 371–374.
(2014). Development of behavior in adopted Root Kustritz, M.V. (1996). Elective gonadectomy
shelter kittens after gonadectomy performed in the cat. Feline Pract. 24: 36–39.
at an early age or at a traditional age. J. Vet. Root Kustritz, M.V. (2007). Determining the
Behav. Clin. Appl. Res. 9: 196–206. optimal age for gonadectomy of dogs and cats.
Porters, N., Polis, I., Moons, C.P. et al. (2015). JAVMA 231: 1665–1675.
Relationship between age at gonadectomy and Root Kustritz, M.V. (2012). Effects of surgical
health problems in kittens adopted from sterilization on canine and feline health and
shelters. Vet. Rec. 176: 572. on society. Reprod. Domest. Anim. 47 (Suppl
Prahl, A., Guptill, L., Glickman, N.W. et al. 4): 1–9.
(2007). Time trends and risk factors for Root Kustritz, M.V., Slater, M.R., Weedon, G.R.
diabetes mellitus in cats presented to et al. (2017). Determining optimal age for
veterinary teaching hospitals. J. Feline Med. gonadectomy in the dog: a critical review of
Surg. 9: 351–358. the literature to guide decision making. Clin.
Priester, W.A. and McKay, F.W. (1980). The Theriogen. 9: 167–211.
occurrence of tumors in domestic animals. Ru, G., Terracini, B., Blickman, L.T. et al. (1998).
Nat. Cancer Inst. Mono. 54: 1–210. Related risk factors for canine osteosarcoma.
Prymak, C., McKee, L.J., Goldschmidt, M.H. Vet. J. 156: 31–39.
et al. (1988). Epidemiologic, clinical, Salmeri, K.R., Olson, P.N., and Bloomberg, M.S.
pathologic, and prognostic characteristics of (1991). Elective gonadectomy in dogs: a
splenic hemangiosarcoma and splenic review. JAVMA 198: 1183–1192.
520 26 Influence of Spay–Neuter Timing on Health
Scarlett, J.M., Salman, M.D., New, J.G. et al. Van Goethem, B., Schaefers‐Okkens, A., and
(1999). Reasons for relinquishment of Kirpensteijn, J. (2006). Making a rational choice
companion animals in U.S. animal shelters: between ovariectomy and ovariohysterectomy
selected health and personal issues. J. Appl. in the dog: a discussion of the benefits of either
Anim. Welf. Sci. 2: 41–57. technique. Vet. Surg. 35: 136–143.
Scarlett, J.M., Salman, M.D., New, J.G. et al. Verstegen, J. and Onclin, K. (2003). Mammary
(2002). The role of veterinary practitioners in tumors in the queen. Proceedings of the Society
reducing dog and cat relinquishments and for Theriogenology, Columbus, OH.
euthanasias. JAVMA 220: 306–311. Ware, W.A. and Hopper, D.L. (1999). Cardiac
Schneider, R., Dorn, C.R., and Taylor, D.O. tumors in dogs: 1982–1995. J. Vet. Intern. Med.
(1969). Factors influencing canine mammary 13: 95–103.
cancer development and postsurgical survival. Waters, D.J. (2011). In search of a strategic
J. Nat. Cancer Inst. 43: 1249–1261. disturbance: some thoughts on the timing of
Slauterbeck, J.R., Pankratz, K., Xu, K.T. et al. spaying. Clin. Theriogen. 3: 433–437.
(2004). Canine ovariohysterectomy and Waters, D.J., Kengeri, S.S., Clever, B. et al. (2009).
orchiectomy increases the prevalence of ACL Exploring mechanisms of sex differences in
injury. Clin. Orthoped. Rel. Res. 429: 301–305. longevity: lifetime ovary exposure and
Smith, A.N. (2003). Hemangiosarcoma in dogs exceptional longevity in dogs. Aging Cell 8:
and cats. Vet. Clin. N. Am. Small Anim. Pract. 752–755.
33: 533–552. Waters, D.J., Kengeri, S.S., Maras, A.H. et al.
Sorenmo, K.U., Goldschmidt, M., Shofer, F. et al. (2011). Probing the perils of dichotomous
(2003). Immunohistochemical binning: how categorizing female dogs as
characterization of canine prostatic carcinoma spayed or intact can misinform our
and correlation with castration status and assumptions about the lifelong health
castration time. Vet. Comp. Oncol. 1: 48–56. consequences of ovariohysterectomy.
Spain, C.V., Scarlett, J.M., and Houpt, K.A. Theriogenology 76: 1496–1500.
(2004a). Long‐term risks and benefits of Weaver, A.D. (1981). Fifteen cases of prostatic
early‐age gonadectomy in cats. JAVMA 224: carcinoma in the dog. Vet. Rec. 109: 71–75.
372–379. White, C.R., Hohenhaus, A.E., Kelsey, J. et al.
Spain, C.V., Scarlett, J.M., and Houpt, K.A. (2006). Cutaneous MCTs: associations with
(2004b). Long‐term risks and benefits of spay/neuter status, breed, body size, and
early‐age gonadectomy in dogs. JAVMA 224: phylogenetic cluster. J. Am. Anim. Hosp. Assoc.
380–387. 47: 210–216.
Stocklin‐Gautschi, N.M., Hassig, M., Reichler, Whitehair, J.G., Vasseur, P.B., and Willits, N.H.
I.M. et al. (2001). The relationship of urinary (1993). Epidemiology of cranial cruciate
incontinence to early spaying in bitches. J. ligament rupture in dogs. JAVMA 203:
Reprod. Fertil. Suppl. 57: 233–236. 1016–1019.
Teske, E., Naan, E.C., VanDijk, E.M. et al. Wilke, V.L., Conzemius, M.C., and Rothschild,
(2002). Canine prostate carcinoma: M.F. (2005). SNP detection and association
epidemiological evidence of an increased risk analyses of candidate genes for rupture of the
in castrated dogs. Molec. Cell. Endocrin. 197: cranial cruciate ligament in the dog. Anim.
251–255. Genet. 36: 519–521.
Torres, d.l.R.G., Hart, B.L., Farver, T.B. et al. Zirkin, B.R. and Strandberg, J.D. (1984).
(2013). Neutering dogs: effects on joint Quantitative changes in the morphology of
disorders and cancers in golden retrievers. the aging canine prostate. Anatom. Rec. 208:
PLoS One 8 (2): e55937. 207–214.
521
27
Non‐surgical Contraception
The State of the Field
Jessica Hekman
c ontraceptive delivery. Therefore, a long‐lasting tially target different levels of the reproductive
contraceptive is ideal, as a contraceptive that system. This system, known as the hypotha-
needs to be reapplied at regular intervals may be lamic–pituitary–gonadal (HPG) axis, originates
no more effective at population control than a in the hypothalamus, which releases gonado-
surgical intervention. Additionally, interven- tropin‐releasing hormone (GnRH) in a pulsatile
tions that require a visit to a veterinary clinic are fashion (see Figure 27.1). GnRH is transmitted
less desirable, as transportation logistics can sig- directly to the anterior pituitary gland through a
nificantly increase the cost of a sterilization venous portal system, where it stimulates the
campaign. Administration by a veterinarian also release of the gonadotropin hormones, follicle‐
increases cost. In the case of community cat stimulating hormone (FSH), and luteinizing
populations, for example, administration of a hormone (LH). These two protein hormones
contraceptive in the field by volunteers could are released into the systemic circulation by the
result in a significant increase in the number of anterior pituitary and stimulate release of the
animals contracepted, with a concomitant effect steroid reproductive hormones from the
on population reduction. In populations of large gonads – androgens and estrogens. Negative
wild animals, such as deer and horses, remote feedback from androgens and estrogens, as well
delivery of small volumes of the contraceptive as from progesterone (released by the corpus
is an important criterion for an approach’s suc- luteum), suppresses release of GnRH, FSH, and
cess (Kirkpatrick et al. 2011), due to the need LSH (Mastorakos et al. 2006). Therefore, inter-
for a contraceptive method that is easy to dis- ference with the axis at any of its three levels
tribute and does not require application by a (hypothalamus, anterior pituitary, and gonads)
veterinarian. has the potential to disrupt fertility.
The ideal non‐surgical temporary contracep- Contraceptive approaches have targeted dif-
tive for owned animals would last a shorter ferent levels of the HPG. The hypothalamus is
period of time, allowing a return to fertility for a particularly challenging target – it is difficult
potential future breeding, and be non‐invasive to approach directly via injection, as is any
to administer. Expense is less of an issue in this brain region; it is also difficult to approach via
population; while most owners prefer less the bloodstream, as it lies behind the blood–
expensive alternatives, managing intact animals brain barrier. However, GnRH may be targeted
through other means is an option when the after it has left the hypothalamus and crossed
expense is considered onerous. Owners of com- the blood–brain barrier. Gonadal targets
petitive sports dogs, for example, are typically include the zona pellucida, proteins expressed
prepared to devote considerable funds to on the ovulated egg to facilitate sperm recogni-
increasing their animal’s competitiveness. Some tion, and the thecal support cells of the ovaries
dog owners also use temporary contraception to and testes.
assess how their animal’s behavior might As previously discussed, ease of delivery to
change in the face of reduced levels of reproduc- the gonads differs markedly between sexes.
tive hormones, prior to committing to an irre- Delivery by injection directly to the testes has
versible surgery. These types of owners also tend been successfully applied with chemical con-
to be more willing to commit funds to their dog. traceptives such as zinc gluconate. Whether
safe and humane injection in this region of the
body requires chemical restraint has been a
Approaches to Non‐surgical matter of debate among practitioners. Direct
Contraception injection to the ovaries is indisputably imprac-
tical. However, both male and female gonads
While surgical approaches to contraception are accessible via the systemic circulation.
have traditionally focused on removal of the Blocking access to the gonads may be an
gonads, non‐surgical approaches can poten- alternative approach, as with an intrauterine
Solutions to Non‐surgical Contraception 523
Hypothalamus Hypothalamus
+ +
GnRH GnRH
Anterior Anterior
pituitary pituitary
+ –
– + – +
– + LH FSH
LH FSH
+ +
Ovaries
+ Testes
+
device (IUD). In veterinary species, this a given cell type, again at one or more levels of
approach is only practical for females. the HPG axis.
Calcium chloride can also be used to sterilize ucts. While advertised as being able to be
male dogs via intratesticular injection (Jana injected subcutaneously without anesthesia,
and Samanta 2007). As few efficacy and safety the process appears to be painful for the animal.
studies have been performed on this substance Suprelorin is used off‐label in the United States
for this use, anecdotally many veterinarians in zoo species for contraception, and to manage
hesitate to use it. ferret adrenal hyperplasia.
A novel approach to injection of a sterilant As a timed‐release formulation of Suprelorin
involves the use of saponin, a substance that is lasting longer than one year has not yet been
harmless in the bloodstream but toxic once developed, this approach is not appropriate for
taken into a cell. Injected distally, saponin may permanent sterilization. However, it functions
be carried in a lipid‐based nanoparticle and well as a temporary contraceptive, and has
guided to the gonads by an anti‐Mullerian II been used in companion animals in Europe.
receptor antibody. Once taken up by the
gonadal support cells, it will trigger apoptosis.
Intrauterine Device
This process has resulted in reduction in sperm
number and motility in male rats and in A canine IUD is currently marketed as
reduced estrous cycling in female rats (Ayres Dogspiral (Veterinary Research Centre,
et al. 2018). Studies in companion animals Rijkevoort, Netherlands). In humans, IUDs
have yet to be performed. change the environment of the uterus to pre-
In summary, chemical contraceptives are vent implantation of fertilized eggs, and are
currently in use as Esterisol in South and widely used. No peer‐reviewed safety or effi-
Central America in male dogs, but are other- cacy studies have been performed on IUDs in
wise not currently widely used due to lack of dogs. Theriogenologists have expressed con-
market demand. cern about canine IUD insertion, given the
shape of the canine cervix, as well as the
device’s safety once inserted (ACC&D 2017).
Hormonal Contraception
Hormonal contraception in veterinary species
Gene Delivery
typically functions through negative feedback
to the HPG. Deslorelin, a GnRH superagonist, Alteration of targeted genes in an animal’s
functions to reduce reproductive hormones and genome, or introduction of transgenes, could be
suppress fertility. After initial implantation, used to disrupt reproductive function. Alteration
deslorelin will initially stimulate, then sup- of genes may mean changes in gene sequence,
press, the release of androgens and estrogens. leading to proteins with disrupted function; it
As the implant’s effectiveness wanes, reproduc- could also mean changes in regulatory
tive hormone levels will again increase. This sequence, leading to increased or decreased
leads to an estrous cycle shortly after implanta- expression of targeted genes. For example, an
tion and at the end of effectiveness in females, increase in gene expression could lead to
and can lead to behavior changes in males. increased production of a particular antigen,
Because HPG axis function is highly conserved which could lead to a stronger immune response
across species, this approach has wide cross‐ and result in improved immunocontraception.
species efficacy (McKinnon et al. 1993; Gene delivery has been used on GnRH, a tar-
Bertschinger et al. 2001; Munson et al. 2001). get also used in contraceptive vaccines, in cats.
While not approved in the United States for use An adeno‐associated virus (AAV) vector was
in dogs or cats, deslorelin is currently marketed used to deliver anti‐GnRH antibodies. Antibody
in Europe as Suprelorin™ (Virbac, Glattbrugg, titer levels increased, but then returned to base-
Switzerland), in both 6‐ and 12‐month prod- line within one month of injection, presumably
526 27 Non‐surgical Contraception
due to immune system attack of the foreign in capture decisions in wild or feral animals,
anti‐GnRH antibody (Vansandt 2018). A novel and either last approximately as long as contra-
target of gene delivery is Mullerian‐inhibiting ception is expected to last, or contain encoded
substance (MIS), a ligand produced by the ova- information about contraception type and
ries which inhibits primordial follicle activa- when it was applied. Ear‐tagging has been
tion. Lifelong super‐physiological expression of explored (Benka 2015), but does not appear to
MIS would lead to permanent contraception in be an appropriate solution for dogs or cats due
females. This approach has been tested in cats, to the short time that tags remain on the ear
also using an AAV vector, and resulted in brief (Benka and Getty 2018). Another approach
(several‐month) ovarian suppression followed may be the application of a tattoo using ultra-
by a return to cyclicity. Research on MIS as a violet ink delivered through a microneedle
target is ongoing (Pepin 2018). patch. This approach may prove challenging in
Gene delivery is not yet in use as a veterinary animals with particular morphologies, such as
contraceptive, but shows promise for the future. dogs with flopped ears or cats with dark coat
colors (Benka and Getty 2018).
Marking of Contracepted
Animals Looking to the Future
In the US, many shelters mark dogs and cats While immunocontraceptives have proven use-
who have been surgically altered with a tattoo ful in the control of wild or feral populations of
to signal their non‐reproductive state. large animal species, convenient and long‐last-
Community cats are frequently subjected to ing contraceptives for small animals remain
removal of one ear tip (ear‐tipping) for easy elusive. Delayed‐release hormones are also not
identification of surgically altered cats from a a long‐lasting option for these populations, and
distance. These approaches may not be appro- are difficult to administer in a field setting.
priate for non‐surgical contraception, how- Novel approaches, however, hold out promise
ever. In the case of temporary contraceptives, for the future. Delivery of antibody‐guided tox-
such as current immunocontraceptives, marks ins to gonadal cells may provide lifetime con-
must also be temporary. In the case of owned traception. Current gene delivery research
animals in locations without traditions of vet- suggests that the immune system is competent
erinary care, ear‐tipping may not be societally at overcoming introduced foreign proteins,
acceptable, either by the animals’ caretakers or resulting in only brief contraception over sev-
by the funders of a contraceptive outreach pro- eral months. However, ongoing research is
gram. The ideal marker would be non‐ or mini- addressing this problem. The goal of producing
mally invasive, easy to apply in a field setting, long‐lasting injectable solutions to the problem
visible from a distance so that it could be used of animal overpopulation is still in sight.
References
the 2018 Alliance for Contraception in Cats and Gionfriddo, J.P., Eisemann, J., Sullivan, K. et al.
Dogs (ACCD) International Symposium on (2009). Field test of a single‐injection
Nonsurgical Methods of Pet Population Control, gonadotrophin‐releasing hormone
Boston, MA. immunocontraceptive vaccine in female
Benka, V.A.W. (2015). Ear tips to ear tags: white‐tailed deer. Wildlife Res. 36 (3): 177–184.
marking and identifying cats treated with Griffin, B., Baker, H., Welles, E. et al. (2005).
non‐surgical fertility control. J. Feline Med. Response of dogs to a GnRH‐KLH conjugate
Surg. 17 (9): 808–815. contraceptive vaccine adjuvanted with
Benka, V. and Getty, S. (2018). Marking and Adjuvac®. Proceedings of the 2004 Alliance
identifying free‐roaming dogs and cats. for Contraception in Cats and Dogs (ACCD)
Proceedings of the 2018 Alliance for International Symposium on Nonsurgical
Contraception in Cats and Dogs (ACCD) Methods of Pet Population Control,
International Symposium on Nonsurgical Denver, CO.
Methods of Pet Population Control, Boston, Hiller‐Sturmhöfel, S. and Bartke, A. (1998). The
MA. https://www.acc‐d.org/docs/default‐ endocrine system: a review. Alc. Health Res.
source/6th‐symposium‐proceedings/benka‐ World 22 (3): 153–164.
getty‐marking‐accd‐symposium‐ppt.pdf Jana, K. and Samanta, P.K. (2007). Sterilization
(accessed 5 November 2018). of male stray dogs with a single intratesticular
Bertschinger, H.J., Asa, C.S., Calle, P.P. et al. injection of calcium chloride: a dose‐
(2001). Control of reproduction and sex dependent study. Contraception 75 (5):
related behaviour in exotic wild carnivores 390–400.
with the GnRH analogue deslorelin: Kirkpatrick, J.F. and Turner, J.W. (1990).
preliminary observations. J. Reprod. Fertil. Remotely‐delivered immunocontraception in
Suppl. 57: 275–283. feral horses. Wildlife Soc. B. 18 (3): 326–330.
Curtis, P.D., Richmond, M.E., Miller, L.A., and Kirkpatrick, J.F., Lyda, R.O., and Frank, K.M.
Quimby, F.W. (2007). Pathophysiology of (2011). Contraceptive vaccines for wildlife: a
white‐tailed deer vaccinated with porcine review. Am. J. Reprod. Immun. 66 (1): 40–50.
zona pellucida immunocontraceptive. Vaccine Levy, J.K., Crawford, P.C., Appel, L.D., and
25 (23): 4623–4630. Clifford, E.L. (2008). Comparison of
Eade, J.A., Roberston, I.D., and James, C.M. intratesticular injection of zinc gluconate
(2009). Contraceptive potential of porcine and versus surgical castration to sterilize male
feline zona pellucida A, B and C subunits in dogs. Am. J. Vet. Res. 69 (1): 140–143.
domestic cats. Reproduction 137 (6): 913–922. Levy, J.K., Friary, J.A., Miller, L.A. et al. (2011).
Einarsson, S. (2006). Vaccination against GnRH: Long‐term fertility control in female cats with
pros and cons. Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica GonaCon™, a GnRH immunocontraceptive.
48 (1): S10. Theriogenology 76 (8): 1517–1525.
Fischer, A., Benka, V.A.W., Briggs, J.R. et al. Mahi‐Brown, C.A., Yanagimachi, R., Hoffman,
(2018). Effectiveness of GonaCon as an J.C., and Huang, T.T. Jr. (1985). Fertility
immunocontraceptive in colony‐housed cats. control in the bitch by active immunization
J. Feline Med. Surg. 20 (8): 786–792. with porcine zonae pellucidae: use of different
Forzán, M.J., Garde, E., Pérez, G.E., and adjuvants and patterns of estradiol and
Vanderstichel, R.V. (2014). Necrosuppurative progesterone levels in estrous cycles. Biol.
orchitis and scrotal necrotizing dermatitis Reprod. 32 (4): 761–772.
following intratesticular administration of Mastorakos, G., Pavlatou, M.G., and Mizamtsidi,
zinc gluconate neutralized with arginine M. (2006). The hypothalamic‐pituitary‐adrenal
(EsterilSol) in 2 mixed‐breed dogs. Vet. Path. and the hypothalamic‐pituitary‐gonadal axes
51 (4): 820–823. interplay. Pediatr. Endocrin. Rev. 3: 172–181.
528 27 Non‐surgical Contraception
McKinnon, A.O., Nobelius, A.M., del Marmol Methods of Pet Population Control,
Figueroa, S.T. et al. (1993). Predictable Boston, MA.
ovulation in mares treated with an implant of Shrestha, A., Srichandan, S., Minhas, V. et al.
the GnRH analogue deslorelin. Equine Vet. J. (2015). Canine zona pellucida glycoprotein‐3:
25 (4): 321–323. up‐scaled production, immunization strategy
Munson, L., Bauman, J.E., Asa, C.S. et al. (2001). and its outcome on fertility. Vaccine 33 (1):
Efficacy of the GnRH analogue deslorelin for 133–140.
suppression of oestrous cycles in cats. J. Vansandt, L. (2018). AAV‐vectored generation of
Reprod. Fertil. Suppl. 57: 269–273. GnRH‐binding immunoglobulins for non‐
Oliveira, E.C.S., Moura, M.R., de Sá, M.J. et al. surgical sterilization of domestic cats.
(2012). Permanent contraception of dogs Proceedings of the 2018 Alliance for
induced with intratesticular injection of a zinc Contraception in Cats and Dogs (ACCD)
gluconate‐based solution. Theriogenology 77 International Symposium on Nonsurgical
(6): 1056–1063. Methods of Pet Population Control, Boston, MA.
Pepin, D. (2018). Gene therapy with AAV9 Vansandt, L.M., Kutzler, M.A., Fischer, A.E. et al.
delivery of an MIS transgene inhibits estrus in (2017). Safety and effectiveness of a single and
female cats. Proceedings of the 2018 Alliance repeat intramuscular injection of a Gn RH
for Contraception in Cats and Dogs (ACCD) vaccine (GonaCon™) in adult female domestic
International Symposium on Nonsurgical cats. Reprod. Domest. Anim. 52: 348–353.
529
Section Six
28
Starting with Why
Know Your Purpose and Name Your Bottom Lines
BJ Rogers
Perhaps one of the biggest mistakes mission‐ belief statement. Not to be confused with a mis-
based organizations make time and again is sion statement (that’s what you do and we’ll get
charging head first into a program or practice there in a bit), a foundational belief statement
without having taken the time to clearly and speaks to why you exist. It answers the question:
accurately articulate their purpose. “What do you believe – so fervently and so spe-
As you set out to start a new organization, cifically – that it’s compelled you to give of your
program, or initiative, it’s critical that the key time, energy, and resources to embark on this
stakeholders (founders, board members, key effort?”
investors or funders) have a voice in drafting a If your foundational belief statement doesn’t
shared understanding of organizational or pro- start with the words “We believe…” then it’s
gram purpose. From the start – and down the just another sentence. At Emancipet, an
road – this will be the guiding light of your Austin, TX‐based organization with low‐cost
work; don’t short‐change this effort, it’s among spay–neuter and wellness clinics located
the most important conversations you can have. around Texas (and in Philadelphia, PA), the
According to author and speaker Simon Sinek, foundational belief statement is a driver for
it will also inform and drive the likelihood of values identification, establishing bottom lines,
your success. In his best‐selling book Start With clinic operations, hiring decisions, customer
Why: How Great Leaders Inspire Everyone to service; it doesn’t just drive what gets done, it
Take Action, Sinek (2009) posits: “People don’t profoundly informs how things get done. It
buy WHAT you sell, they buy WHY you do it.” simply reads:
According to this understanding, as you set
out to provide a service or sell a product, it’s We believe that people love their pets
vital not only that you know why you’re doing and will do what is best for them when
what you’re doing, but that you’re able to com- given the opportunity.
municate that purpose to those people you
hope to reach and serve. Opportunity can mean all sorts of things –
affordability, geographic access, a welcoming
environment, and so on – but the foundation of
Foundational Belief Statement the foundational belief statement is the belief
that people love their pets and will do what’s
The most explicit and powerful mechanism to best for them. While the work isn’t necessarily
communicate your organization or program’s easier as a result of a well‐articulated founda-
purpose is through the creation of a foundational tional belief, it’s unquestionably clearer.
532 28 Starting with Why
A clear and precise foundational belief state- least one thing that keeps people from doing
ment is also a filter – for program decisions, what is best for their pets is a lack of access to
hiring decisions, resource allocation, and a affordable spay–neuter and veterinary care/
host of other considerations. As you go about services. As you craft both a foundational
crafting your statement – and certainly once belief statement and a mission statement, be
it’s been formalized – it should be something sure to check those assumptions – and make
that everyone involved on your team buys into, sure they’re well founded.
hook, line, and sinker. If someone doesn’t Once approved (by an organization’s found-
ascribe to that belief, chances are there’ll be ers, board, or leadership team), both the foun-
persistent friction – and likely division that dational belief statement and the mission
will impact culture, organizational/program statement should figure prominently – liter-
success, and the overall efficacy of your work. ally and figuratively – in decision‐making and
organizational efforts moving forward.
Mission Statement
Drafting Your Statements:
Once a foundational belief statement has been Starting with Discovery
finalized, an organization should take the time
to translate it into the ever‐monolithic “mis- While it’s often apparent on one level or
sion” statement. More often than not, this hap- another what has driven people to convene
pens the other way around, or a mission around a particular cause (a neighborhood
statement is drafted but a foundational belief struggling with an overwhelming number of
statement is never articulated. A well‐crafted strays, overtaxed shelter systems, etc.), a cata-
mission statement should be a sentence – truly, lyst or an initial motivation isn’t the same as a
just one sentence – that tells people clearly clear purpose. Sometimes, the best way to get
(and reminds everyone in your organization) to an articulation of that purpose is through a
what it is you aim to do. In other words, “Our deliberate and facilitated discovery process.
mission is to…,” fill in the blank, or “We’re on a Whether lengthy and involved or brief and suc-
mission to…” At Emancipet, the translation of cinct, the process should be thorough, thought-
the foundational belief statement into a mis- ful, and rooted in the asking and answering of
sion reads: a series of probing questions that are aimed at
getting to the core of why a program or organi-
Emancipet is on a mission to make zation matters. In his book Ask More: The
high‐quality spay/neuter and veterinary Power of Questions to Open Doors, Uncover
care affordable and accessible to all pet Solutions and Spark Change, Frank Sesno
owners. (2017), former journalist and current director
of the School of Media and Public Affairs at
As you can likely see, the translation is fairly George Washington University, not only makes
direct: if one believes people love their pets and a compelling case for the power of asking
will do what is best for them when given the intentional questions, but outlines 11 types of
opportunity, then it follows that one may powerful questions – among them, diagnostic
endeavor to provide at least one “opportunity” and mission questions, both of which have a
(in this case, the provision of high‐quality, afford- powerful role to play in the discovery process.
able, and accessible spay–neuter and veterinary Far from complex, the types of questions you
care). Of course, there is also an assumption in might consider in the process of discovery
this translation – albeit one based on years of intended to produce foundational belief and
both hard data and experiential learning – that at mission statements might sound like this:
The Bottom Line: Operationalizing Your Beliefs and Mission 533
●● What problem(s) are we trying to solve? each person we interact with; that we believe
●● What do we care about most? unwaveringly – and behave accordingly, if
●● What’s calling for this effort at this particular with modesty – that our work is changing the
time? world; and that we approach each other and
●● What things are non‐negotiable or unwaver- our clients with kindness, generosity, and an
ing for us? assumption that people both are good and
●● What do we believe about the nature of the want to do good.
problem that others might not understand, Our values are those things we hold dear and
believe, or be aware of? they inform how we both receive and respond
●● What is our particular value proposition; to the world around us. They are an organiza-
what makes us uniquely positioned or quali- tional agreement that describes how we’ll
fied to embark on this effort? “show up” at work.
Our values drive our behavior and, when we
In asking – and gathering answers to – these
fail to take the time to articulate what they are,
questions, we begin to amass words, themes,
we run the very real risk of our behavior being
and understanding that speak to the heart of
driven by an individual’s personal values. More
our intention, desire, and dreams. Well cap-
often than not, the group will adopt the per-
tured, these keywords can and should find a
sonal values of the “loudest” member of the
home in your organization’s communications
team. This particular liability is what people
across departments – in fundraising material,
commonly mean when they refer to a “toxic”
job postings and descriptions, employee hand-
person on staff. While the term toxic is prob-
books, and so on. With a little wordsmithing
lematic when referring to a human being, what
and, to use a word favored by researcher and
people mean to say is that the values of a given
author Brene Brown, “rumbling,” you should
individual are out of alignment with the
be a whole bunch of steps closer to being able
desired culture of the organization, and they
to draft your foundational belief and mission
are influencing the behavior of others in nega-
statements.
tive ways.
At the same time, this process can and
The simple lesson? Take the time to discover
should also include the identification and
and articulate your values; it’s what makes liv-
refinement of your organization’s core values.
ing them possible.
While slightly more fluid in how they are
“lived,” an organization’s core values – like the
bottom lines that we’ll discuss below – should
be universally understood by members of your The Bottom Line:
team and, ideally, should be concepts that they Operationalizing Your
identify with personally.
Beliefs and Mission
Emancipet has four core values. They are:
about most. Staff, volunteers, and board mem- The translation of the concepts that you
bers should be well versed in each element. explore and articulate while crafting the ele-
Perhaps most importantly, when an individ- ments we’ve discussed is paramount. If you
ual interacts with your organization – regard- don’t live your values and beliefs, then they’re
less of the context, the medium, or the just meaningless words on a page – and that
time – they should recognize these key ele- will become quickly apparent to those you
ments of your organizational character and serve and those who work for you. These iden-
identity. In other words, if asked “Did you walk tity commitments set the stage for your organi-
away with the impression that this organiza- zational culture, and for how you recruit and
tion works hard in pursuit of the best possible retain team members who will behave in ways
outcome?” or “Does it seem to you that this that exemplify what your organization stands
organization strives to deliver the very best in for and believes.
veterinary care?” an individual should be able
to answer “Yes!” without pause.
References
Sesno, F. (2017). Ask more: The power of Sinek, S. (2009). Start with why: How great
questions to open doors, uncover solutions, and leaders inspire everyone to take action. New
spark change. New York: Amacom. York: Penguin.
537
29
If you work at a large organization, there’s a alignment or the time you spend “managing”
chance that the very mention of engaging someone’s behaviors (or ultimately, “manag-
Human Resources in a hiring process gives you ing them out”). And remember, unless you’re
pause – not because of the people in HR, but hiring for a hard‐to‐find and specific skill set,
because, in many cases, the systems that are there’s a good chance you can teach a new hire
meant to facilitate successful hires can also be what they need to know (which is much easier
time consuming and slow when put up against than trying to shape a person’s values or beliefs
a team’s urgent need to fill an opening. If to align with the team or organizational cul-
you’re a brand‐new organization, then the ture). Though that training may seem like a big
good news is that you’ve got some license to investment up front (and training is and should
decide how you’ll go about hiring. Either way, be a big investment!), you’ll realize the savings
it’s our experience that hiring well means hir- later, in increased output and impact and in a
ing for culture – and by hiring for culture we happier and more unified team.
mean taking into account an individual’s align- Hiring for culture is multiphased, collabora-
ment with your organization’s core values, tive, and intentional by design. Sometimes,
beliefs, and mission, and with how people in that means it can take a little longer – at least
your organization behave when they’re at their up front. Once you get the hang of it, though,
very best. this process can actually be faster than others,
Put simply, when you make a concerted and will consistently yield better results. It’s
effort to hire for culture, the likelihood of a not fool‐proof, but it’s worth whatever extra
good match for both parties increases. time it might take to get into a groove.
Understanding the culture of your team or
organization, then, is a critical asset in devel-
oping job postings and profiles, screening can-
didates, and making successful hires. On‐boarding and Training
Though skills and experience will always be
both necessary considerations and key require- Most of us tend to think that the hiring process
ments, to the extent possible, they should runs up to and including a signed offer let-
never come at the expense of culture fit. Hiring ter – and it’s that thinking that’s to blame for
a poor culture fit inevitably leads to losses in failed starts and the loss of precious resources
productivity, cohesion, and morale, either (namely time, productivity, and money). On‐
because of the strife that comes from the mis- boarding is the final phase of hiring, not only
538 29 Hiring for Impact, Hiring for Culture
because it’s how we transition individuals from your perception and reality are in sync. Though
applicants to employees, but because it’s also a intended for staff, this tool could be adapted for
bit of an insurance policy. Though most new volunteers, board, and other stakeholders if
hires are on their best behavior when they you’re a new or all‐volunteer organization.
start, sometimes a mishire shows itself early Once you’ve got some data, look for those
on. When it does, there’s some wisdom to the keywords and phrases that seem to appear
hire slow/fire fast adage. That’s not to encour- again and again across responses. These are
age snap judgments, only to remember that we the words that describe what it’s like to work at
sometimes get it wrong, and acknowledging or be a part of your organization, what some-
and acting on that mistake with some speed one can expect when joining your team, and
can save us from suffering future losses. the type of person you’re looking for.
If you commit yourself to hiring for culture, Remember, this is about culture fit – the “hard”
sometimes you’ll bring folks on whose skill skills you need someone to have are another
levels need some brushing up. Whether you’re consideration.
hiring internally, because you already know
someone is a great culture fit, or you’ve found
a real outside gem who seems like an ideal
Creating a Job Profile
match, one of the things that the luxury of hir-
ing for culture mandates is a commitment to
A job profile is neither a posting nor a job
skill development and training. Whether you
description. Instead, it is a one‐page capture
deliver that yourself through an in‐house pro-
that indicates the skills, abilities, and qualities
gram or outsource through professional devel-
that would make for a successful candidate.
opment training or seminars, robust training is
Job profiles allow you to think through all
the other side of the thoughtful on‐boarding
aspects of the position, assess the skill and
coin.
experience fit, and ascertain the culture fit.
Your success in hiring for culture depends
Effective job profiles also allow you to assess
on three key factors:
what skills you can train for and what skills
●● How well you understand and can describe you need someone to have on day one.
your own culture. The following are definitions of each section
●● How much you can learn about a candidate’s of the template in Figure 29.2:
values, beliefs, and behaviors.
●● Job relationships. This field details all team
How accurately you judge the alignment
members the position works with regularly.
●●
CULTURE QUESTIONNAIRE
Primary Questions:
1. What are the skills or qualities that seem to be the most valued and rewarded in employees at work?
____________________________________________________ _____________________________
____________________________________________________ _____________________________
5. What are the issues that divide us, or people disagree about at work?
______________________________________ ___________________________________________
____________________________________________________ _____________________________
6. What are the unwritten rules at work–the three most important rules of working here?
_________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________ _____________________________
Alternative/Additional Questions:
1. How would you describe the culture at work?
_________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________
_____________________________
2. What would another company need to offer you to make you leave us and go to work for them?
___________________________________________________ ______________________________
____________________________________________________ _____________________________
3. What role do you play in helping to fulfill the mission of the organization?
_________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________ _____________________________
achieve if executed successfully), the position individual in this role will be expected to
summary is a bulleted list of key responsi- engage in on behalf of the organization and
bilities articulated as achievement‐based its mission.
objectives; that is, they start with a verb ●● Key experience and requirements. This field
and represent the primary activities that an should capture, again in a bulleted list, the
540 29 Hiring for Impact, Hiring for Culture
Position Summary:
position requirements (e.g. education or tom lines (see Chapter 28), there are circum-
degree requirements, years of experience, stances in which a position may only be
technical skills or proficiencies, etc.). In accountable to one or two. For example, if
addition to the personal traits that are most high‐quality medical care is a bottom line
essential for success specifically for this posi- and you’re hiring a marketing professional, it
tion, be sure to also include the skills or traits may be that their role will be held accounta-
that are critical to the success of any person ble for other bottom lines (say, transforma-
working anywhere in your organization. tive service and sustainable finance in
●● Core values alignment. This is simply a place relation to Emancipet’s bottom lines). but
on the job profile (which is or should be a not that or those related to the delivery of
document you can share with candidates as medical care.
a one‐page snapshot of the role) where you
name your core values as a way of highlight-
ing what they are and that they matter. You Creating Effective Job
may consider also including your organiza- Postings
tion’s foundational belief statement (see
Chapter 28) if you do, in fact, plan to share Once you’ve got your profile constructed,
this profile with candidates. you’re ready to draft a posting and begin the
●● Bottom‐line responsibilities. While many recruiting process. In fact that’s easier said
roles may be accountable to all of your bot- than done; after all, making your opportunity
Employment Information Sessions 541
stand out – while also attracting candidates ●● Are genuinely curious about other people.
who have the skills and culture fit you’re look- ●● Are respected and admired by staff (and
ing for – is not always a simple task. embody the culture).
Effective job postings should: ●● Understand the organization’s culture and
feel protective of it.
●● Describe the organization and the phase you
are in – make it exciting!
Include all required skills (the ones you can’t
Employment Information
●●
N
O
S
S
TI
ER
TE
S
EN
TE
NO
TH
T
NO
AT
ER
G
?
G
G
IN
EW
G
G
IN
IN
G
DD
N
N
LP
IL
KI
KI
VI
YI
NAME IDENTIFIER
SM
NO
HE
TA
RE
PA
AS
●● Learning – look for asking questions, taking space to have one conversation centered around
notes. culture fit and one around skills/experience fit.
After the information session, participating
staff compile individual lists that are then Interviewing for Culture Fit
combined to create a final ranking. Using a tier
●● When possible, the whole hiring team
system, the lists might include:
should participate in the interview.
●● First tier – Candidates whose behavior indi- ●● The tone of the interview should be:
cates high culture fit and whose resumes ⚬⚬ Personal
indicate strong skill/experience fit. ⚬⚬ Conversational
●● Second tier – Candidates whose behavior ⚬⚬ A genuine dialog.
indicates high culture fit but whose resumes ●● The questions are focused on learning about
lack strong skill/experience fit (based on the candidate’s:
our ability to train for the specific position). ⚬⚬ Values
●● Third tier – Candidates whose resumes are ⚬⚬ Beliefs
stellar but who didn’t have high culture fit ⚬⚬ Behavior in certain situations.
scores. ●● Leave at least 30 minutes for their questions.
Sample questions
Your first‐tier candidates are those you want
–– How would your best friend describe you?
to schedule interviews with pronto! These are
–– Tell us about a time you were caught up in
folks who seem like just the people you want
a conflict with a co‐worker – what was it
on your team. Get those interviews scheduled
about and how did you resolve it?
and don’t let them get away!
Second‐tier candidates may still be individ-
uals you want to interview (particularly Interviewing for Skills/
depending on the size of your first‐tier group). Experience Fit:
These are people you think will fit great and
When possible, the whole hiring team should
may require a more significant investment in
●●
30
done close to that number. The recruiting 5) Unfair competition. Some private practition-
organization needs to be clear about expec- ers and veterinary associations argue that
tations, but reassure prospective candidates nonprofit HQHVSN programs take business
that, if the desire is there, surgical speed from private practices and are unfair
will come with training and practice. because of tax advantages. While there
Providing an opportunity to observe a good might be some truth to this, such operations
team in action will allow prospective candi- generally provide a one‐time service for cli-
dates to see at first hand what can be ents who would most likely never have their
achieved with a trained surgical team and pets altered in a private clinic. Additionally,
proper procedures in place. such operations provide a service in sharing
3) The one‐trick pony. Veterinarians consider- information with clients and encouraging
ing full‐time work as HQHVSN surgeons them to take their pets to private veterinary
may be concerned that they will become or clinics for routine care.
be perceived as unable to function in a clini-
cal practice situation. Address this concern
by offering continuing education and
encouraging involvement in local veteri-
Job Description
nary associations. They should be reminded
Creating a written job description will help
that HQHVSN surgeons still examine ani-
define the needs and expectations of the posi-
mals, diagnose diseases and conditions,
tion. The resulting document will become an
monitor patients, and improve lives.
important part of the interview process, giving
HQHVSN surgeons develop exceptional
both the interviewer and the prospective can-
soft tissue surgery, anesthesia, and time‐
didate specifics to discuss and reducing the
management skills, all of which are valua-
possibility of misunderstandings. As the job
ble in the veterinary market.
description is developed, the following should
4) Professional reputation. Some veterinarians
be considered:
may worry about how their colleagues will
view them if they work in a HQHVSN pro- 1) Organizational mission. It is critical to
gram. They may have heard the comments: make sure that any candidate for the posi-
“Reduced‐cost or free surgical sterilizations tion understands and is aligned with the
cheapen the value of such surgeries,” or mission of the organization (see Chapters
“Veterinarians in those jobs can’t make it in 28 and 29).
private practice.” While such comments are 2) Type of clinic. The veterinarian’s role
unfair and untrue, they cause some to worry should be defined in the specific context of
about their reputation or future employ- the type of clinic operation.
ment opportunities. This situation has 3) Client/patient profile. Most veterinarians
improved greatly in recent years with the have experience only with companion ani-
advances and interests in shelter medicine mals. If the clinic serves feral and/or shel-
and HQHVSN. Still, it is important that vet- ter animals, it will be important, during
erinarians working in HQHVSN programs the hiring process, to make this clear and
stay involved with organized veterinary to provide the candidate with resources to
medicine so the profession recognizes that learn about the unique challenges of deal-
price does not determine quality and that ing with these special populations.
they are current and competent. All veteri- 4) The team. It is very important to most vet-
narians should understand that efficiencies erinarians to have a strong support team in
and volume of procedures make the econo- place that functions well together to get the
mies of HQHVSN programs very different job done. A strong team culture with capa-
from those in a typical private practice. ble support staff allows both veterinarians
Compensation 547
and staff to apply their specialized knowl- While many veterinarians want to help
edge and experience and to trust in and homeless animals and end animal overpopula-
rely on the expertise of others on the team. tion, the reality is that the job description and
5) Chain of command. It is important to be recruiting message must do more than tug at
clear about whether the position will the heart strings or play to the conscience.
report to an Executive Director, Director Although the organization may be driven by
of Operations, Chief of Surgery, or directly mission, it must operate in a business‐like
to a Board of Directors. When the veteri- manner. The goal is to attract veterinarians to
narian reports to a non‐veterinarian HQHVSN by demonstrating that they will be
supervisor, it is important to clarify the fairly compensated (salary and benefits),
factors that impact clinic decisions, to treated professionally, and given the ability to
what extent the veterinarian is in control, have a real impact.
and who has the final say. Specific consid-
erations include whether current proto-
cols are guidelines or must be strictly Compensation
followed; who makes changes to protocols
and the procedure for making such The cost of a veterinary education is huge and
changes; who selects, evaluates, and disci- most veterinarians graduate with debt. The
plines the clinic staff; and the process for payback for typical educational debt takes sev-
selection and purchase of medical equip- eral years. The American Veterinary Medical
ment and supplies. Association (AVMA) routinely reports average
6) Scope of services summary. The job descrip- debt and the average starting salary for gradu-
tion should provide a summary statement ating veterinarians. It also issues an annual
to provide a general overview of responsi- report on the market for veterinarians (Hansen
bilities. Will the position be limited to et al. 2018), giving the average salaries for vet-
HQHVSN or will additional veterinary erinarians with varying years of experience in
services be required? different areas of employment. While averages
7) Essential duties and responsibilities. This is are good to know, it is more important to be
the heart of the job description. A list of competitive with total compensation for the
specific duties and responsibilities assigned position and location. There is great variation
to the veterinarian should be included. in the cost of living for different areas even
8) Additional skills. If the job requires certain within the same state. Knowing competitive
language, computer, or other skills, they salaries and benefits for the specific area is
should be identified. very important.
9) Certificates, licenses, registrations. In addi-
tion to a state veterinary license, list other
Salaries
requirements such as Drug Enforcement
Administration (DEA) registration, mal- Salaries for veterinarians are offered in several
practice insurance, etc. different methods. It may be a fixed salary, a
10) Work environment. Noise levels, exposure percentage of revenue generated, or a combi-
to anesthetic gases, and other environ- nation. An example of such a combination
mental factors intrinsic to the job should would be when the veterinarian is given the
be listed. greater of a “base rate” and/or a percentage of
11) Physical demands. The job might require production. This assures the veterinarian of a
that the veterinarian be able to perform reasonable salary, but also incentivizes them to
such physical tasks as lifting patients, be more productive. Other salary methods for
equipment, and supplies up to 50 lb in HQHVSN surgeons could be pay by the day or
weight. by the surgery.
548 30 Recruiting and Hiring HQHVSN Surgeons
Flexible schedules
offer the kind of benefits that a corporate or
●●
emergency duties
might be to use a professional employer organi-
Childcare assistance
zation (PEO). This works by becoming the legal
●●
supervisory responsibilities
roll, employee benefits, workers’ compensa-
Working with animals rather than with the
tion, and human resources. By aggregating the
●●
guardians of animals
employees of many businesses, a PEO can offer
Less “downtime”
better rates on health and workers’ compensa-
●●
working a minimum of two shifts a week may employee and the employer if appropriate
receive a percentage of the benefits, and those expectations and training are not estab-
working 32 hours and above typically receive lished beforehand.
full benefits. 3) State board and local associations. Most state
In addition to veterinarians only wanting to boards of veterinary medical examiners will
work part‐time, there might be able surgeons provide a list of all currently licensed veteri-
performing all types of surgeries at private narians for that state along with their
practices willing to work for HQHVSN pro- addresses. Many will provide the informa-
grams one or two days a week. Another option tion in an electronic form for a very reason-
might be veterinarians wanting to supplement able fee. With this information, a recruitment
their income by working on their days off from letter can be sent to every veterinarian
their primary employer. Part‐time veterinari- licensed in the state or the list can be sorted
ans may be paid by the hour, by the surgery, or to target specific zip codes for specific cities.
by the shift. Asking a member of the local association to
take fliers to a meeting or requesting time to
speak to the membership about the work of
the organization are other good ways to get
Recruiting
the word out. Careful attention to tone in
recruiting letters or fliers may be necessary
There are several methods for recruiting
to avoid backlash or controversy if the local
veterinarians.
veterinary community harbors doubts or
1) Advertising. While placing employment concerns about the HQHVSN clinic.
opportunities in veterinary journals is still a 4) Networking. Networking with other
common practice, it is slow, costly, and usu- HQHVSN programs can be an effective way
ally lacking in results. Most veterinary to recruit. These organizations likely work
schools have a website for postings. Local, with veterinarians in private practice and
state, and national veterinary associations might know of someone thinking about
and some national animal welfare organi- making a change. Colleagues and veteri-
zations have electronic classifieds that are nary distributor representatives may also be
faster and cheaper than print ads. The goal sources of candidates for the position.
is to reach a large number of potential can- Networking and word of mouth work best
didates in a short period of time. alongside a good reputation for quality
2) Veterinary schools. If the HQHVSN pro- work and being a good employer. Past and
gram has a good training veterinarian on currently employed veterinarians can often
staff who can mentor a new graduate and help recruit classmates and colleagues.
immediate high productivity is not an 5) Veterinary reception. One might consider
issue, the program might target the veteri- hosting an event for veterinarians at the
nary schools. They are generally very help- HQHVSN facility. Not only might this attract
ful in assisting senior students in finding veterinarians interested in the position, but
positions prior to graduation. With many it may also be a good way to educate local
of the schools now having shelter medicine veterinarians about quality operations and
programs, many new graduates are inter- help to dispel some misconceptions.
ested and eager to become HQHVSN sur-
geons. Make sure that your organization
has a mentorship program in place and is
Selling the Position
prepared to provide intensive surgery
training to new graduates, as it can be a In order to attract the attention of potential
frustrating experience for both the candidates for a position, it is necessary to
550 30 Recruiting and Hiring HQHVSN Surgeons
highlight the positive attributes of the position. lobby during check‐in and see how many pets
Here are some examples: and people they engage with. Or if you want to
assess their commitment to the mission, ask a
1) Recruiting message. A professional‐looking
question like: “How do you feel about owners
message for ads or postings will be needed.
that do not have enough money to have their
It should provide positive highlights of the
pet on heartworm prevention?” Pay attention
position, organization, and area. It is impor-
to “red flags”! For example, if a candidate
tant to portray and be a good place to work
expresses disapproval and concern about the
and live.
conventions and standards of HQHVSN, this
2) Be upbeat. Don’t depress candidates by
person will not be comfortable with the high
dwelling on the enormity of the overpopu-
pace that HQHVSN demands. You will end up
lation problem or the number of homeless
having to spend a lot time convincing them to
animals. Instead, tell the candidates how
do things the way that you need them to.
they can have a positive impact by working
It is important to have an organized and sys-
with the existing dynamic support team.
tematic plan for the interview. The interviewer
3) Tout strengths. If in a rural area with a lower
should thoroughly review the candidate’s
cost of living, recreational activities, and
resume before the interview. This will help in
good schools, use that as a selling point. If
developing interview questions and demon-
in an exciting city with great cultural oppor-
strate that the interviewer has taken the time
tunities, use that. The point is that every
to prepare for the interview. The interviewer
location and organization should offer
should ask open‐ended questions and listen
some special qualities. Find those and high-
carefully to the responses. Since it is illegal to
light them.
ask any question that does not pertain to the
4) Accentuate the positive. If the position offers
applicant’s ability to perform the job, the inter-
part‐time work with flexible hours and no
viewer should confine the questions to the fol-
emergency duties, mention that and get the
lowing topics:
attention of candidates looking for such
opportunities. If the position offers great ●● Why they want to work at your organization
benefits in addition to a competitive salary, ●● Background
that would be an attention grabber. ●● Education
●● Skill
●● Insight
The Interview ●● Personality
Before you do any interviewing, take some ●● Current situation
time to come up with a short list of non‐nego- ●● References
tiables for the position. Look at veterinarians
During the interview, the interviewer should
that are/were successful at your organization
ask the following questions:
and identify what they had that made them
work so well. It can be things like high energy ●● What shifts or hours is the candidate willing
level, excellent communication skills, flexibil- to work? Are they willing to work on week-
ity, and so on. Strong mission fit should always ends or take emergency work (if necessary)?
be one of the non‐negotiables. Do not compro- ●● What is their minimum salary requirement?
mise on these traits when looking at candi- Some applicants are reluctant to give this for
dates. Set up some questions or situations that fear of underselling their skills or exceeding
will help you assess these traits. For example, if the hiring salary limits. The interviewer
you want someone who is comfortable around should make them comfortable with a start-
clients and patients, walk them through the ing point for negotiations.
Recruiting 551
●● How far does the applicant live in relation to 2) Exempt position. The letter should indicate
the job for commuting or will they be mov- if the position is considered an exempt posi-
ing to the area? tion for purposes of federal wage and hour
●● Will they be working for another organiza- law, which means that the employee will
tion if given the position? not be eligible for overtime pay for hours
worked in excess of 40 in a given week.
The interviewer should remember that both
3) Conditions of employment. If employment
parties are evaluating each other and should
is contingent upon passing a drug test
treat the candidate accordingly. They should
within 24 hours of receipt of the letter and a
offer professional courtesies such as touring
background check, then the letter should
the facilities, the opportunity to speak to pro-
state such conditions of employment. The
spective team members, and the chance to ask
prospective employee should be told not to
questions. It is also professional courtesy to fol-
give notice to a current employer until they
low up with all interviewed candidates to let
have received confirmation that they have
them know whether they got the job and to
met the required conditions.
give closure to the process.
4) Documentation for employment. The letter
There should also be a surgical interview
should instruct the individual to bring appro-
whenever possible. The key indicators here are
priate documentation for completion of new
a willingness to learn new techniques and
hire forms, including proof they are eligible
accept feedback. It is also important that the
to work in the United States for I‐9 purposes
candidate has a talent for surgery and already
(or the equivalent in other countries).
has good tissue and instrument handling.
5) Contract or at will. The letter should state if
If the interview is successful and the inter-
employment is “at will” or a term contract.
viewer determines that they want to hire a can-
6) Summary of benefits. A summary of the
didate, the negotiation process begins. The
benefits offered should be included in or
interviewer needs to determine what the candi-
attached to the offer letter.
date requires to accept the position. Often, with a
7) Acceptance of the offer. The letter should
little creativity, a position offer can be put together
state that the offer will expire in seven days
that is mutually acceptable. It may mean that the
if not accepted in writing.
salary is increased and the candidate works more
shifts in order to make a required compensation
level. Or, it may mean that a moving allowance is Turnover
needed to help defray the cost of relocation. It is
Recruiting and hiring the right surgeon for the
very important that both parties enter the
position is such an important process because
arrangement on a positive note.
turnover can be a very costly event. If the per-
son selected is not a good fit for the position
The Offer and leaves, the entire process must be repeated,
causing stress, loss of production, and consid-
An offer letter is recommended so that the pro-
erable expense related to recruiting, hiring, and
spective employee understands the terms and
training the next person. The goal is to not only
conditions of the offer. The offer letter should
to hire a veterinarian who is a good fit for the
cover the following:
organization, but also to retain that person as a
1) Compensation. The letter should state the valued employee. Helping the new employee
rate and method of pay. For example, is it adjust to the new position with feedback and
$400 per shift, 22% of production, or the coaching is important, as is valuing their ideas
greater of two? Will they be paid weekly or and allowing their input in decision‐making.
every two weeks? A formal performance and development
552 30 Recruiting and Hiring HQHVSN Surgeons
review in the first three months and annually career goals, a need to be respected, and a
thereafter is a good policy to insure formal desire for personal satisfaction. Finding the
communication. right veterinary surgeon to meet the needs of
an organization requires a recruiting plan that
attracts qualified candidates, an interview pro-
Bottom Line cess that identifies the best candidate, a mutu-
ally agreeable offer, and real effort by both
Veterinarians must be viewed as highly skilled parties to make the employment agreement a
professionals with personal lives, bills to pay, success.
Reference
31
Most
effective Elimination Physically remove
the hazard
Replace
Substitution the hazard
Figure 31.1 Hierarchy of risk control. Control methods higher on the hierarchy are potentially more
effective and protective, leading to inherently safer systems with reduced risk of illness or injury. Source:
Reproduced with permission of National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH).
Anesthetic Gases
(albeit with these older agents and inadequate
Waste anesthetic gases are a potentially com scavenging) may include miscarriage (Molina
mon chemical exposure in HQHVSN work Aragones et al. 2016), pre‐term delivery
places. There is conflicting evidence for the (Shirangi et al. 2009), difficulty with balance
types and severity of health risks from trace lev and proprioceptive control (Vouriot et al. 2005),
els of anesthetic gases in the work environment hematologic and blood chemistry changes
(ACVAA 2013; Molina Aragones et al. 2016). In (Casale et al. 2014), and genotoxicity (damage
many cases, studies showing potential health to DNA) (Yılmaz and Çalbayram 2016).
risks from occupational anesthetic gas expo In addition to the possibility of individual
sure have looked at circumstances without health risks to workers, halogenated anesthetic
waste gas scavenging (Nilsson et al. 2005) or agents contribute to ozone depletion, and iso
using older anesthetic agents, including meth flurane has a global warming potential over a
oxyflurane, halothane, nitrous oxide, and enflu thousand times that of carbon dioxide
rane (Shirangi et al. 2009). Health risks reported (Ishizawa 2011). Since most anesthesia scav
to be associated with waste anesthetic gases enging systems simply exhaust the anesthetic
556 31 Health Considerations for the HQHVSN Surgeon
gas unchanged to the outdoors, these systems minimize staff exposure to these gases.
do nothing to reduce the global environmental Reducing exposure to waste anesthetic gas
impact of these gases. should be accomplished by use of scavenging
The only commonly used scavenging option systems and safe protocols, rather than relying
that does not release gas into the atmosphere is on personal protective equipment (PPE)
activated charcoal canisters, which adsorb the (OSHA 1999). Surgical masks or charcoal
anesthetic gas rather than releasing it; how masks are not effective at protecting workers
ever, these canisters are one of the least effec from anesthetic agents (Centers for Disease
tive methods of protecting staff from waste gas. Control 2017), nor are negative‐pressure high‐
Charcoal canisters are inconsistent in their efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filters
performance, with certain brands adsorbing (ACVAA 2013). Effective protection could be
waste gas more effectively than others (Smith achieved by use of respirator with a self‐con
and Bolon 2003). If canisters are used, canister tained air source (Centers for Disease Control
weight gain should be monitored and usage 2017), but these devices are expensive and
recorded daily so that canisters may be awkward and are unlikely to be a practical
exchanged when exhausted (ACVAA 2013). alternative (ACVAA 2013). See Box 31.2 for
It is essential that all practices that use vola techniques for decreasing anesthetic waste gas
tile anesthetic gases have a plan in place to exposure in the HQHVSN workplace.
●● Reduce the clinic’s use of anesthetic gases: ●● Minimize or eliminate procedures that
⚪⚪ Choose anesthetic protocols that mini- increase personnel exposure to anesthetic
mize or eliminate the use of inhalant gas:
anesthetics. ⚪⚪ Avoid chamber induction of patients.
⚪⚪ Choose the lowest appropriate gas flow ⚪⚪ Minimize use of masking with anesthetic
rates consistent with patient safety and agents, or ensure tightly fitting mask.
with the proper function of flow meters, ⚪⚪ Minimize use of uncuffed endotracheal
anesthetic gas contamination of the work thesia circuit while flowmeter or vapor-
environment: izer is on.
⚪⚪ Ensure proper maintenance of anesthe- ⚪⚪ Avoid turning on vaporizer before
sia machines and anesthetic circuits. patient is connected.
⚪⚪ Leak test anesthesia machines and ●● Implement procedures to limit gas escape
breathing circuits daily. into the work environment:
⚪⚪ Use a scavenging system (active or ⚪⚪ Use a well-fitting endotracheal tube
tems can help decrease the concentra- ⚪⚪ Eliminate residual anesthetic gas from
■■ Turn off the vaporizer prior to com- izers so those who want to avoid
pletion of the anesthetic procedure. exposure can leave the area.
Ideally, the vaporizer should be ⚪⚪ Be prepared in case of a spill:
turned off for five minutes prior to ■■ Spills of small amounts (several mil-
valve into the scavenger system peri- require ventilation and cleanup:
odically after the vaporizer has been ●● Ventilate the area (open windows
oxygen flow rate after the vaporizer into a container that can be sealed
has been turned off. and disposed of.
■■ Allow the patient to remain attached ●● If a spill occurs in the operating
are an appropriate time for vaporizer badges for individual staff members.
filling. Mail-in halogenated anesthetic gas
■■ In mobile and mobile animal steriliza- monitoring badges are available from
tion hospital (MASH) clinics, mornings many veterinary distributors as well as
prior to the beginning of anesthesia other online sources.
may be most appropriate in order to ●● Utilize personal protective equipment
minimize driving with full vaporizers. (PPE):
■■ Pregnant personnel or personnel try- ⚪⚪ Generally, PPE is not recommended dur-
ing to conceive should not be present ing routine use of anesthetic gases.
during filling. Staff should audibly ⚪⚪ Respirators are effective, but impractical
Patient Handling
risks to staff as well as patients (Yin 2009;
Patient handling presents one of the greatest Chapter 6 in this book). Lifting patients,
risks to HQHVSN clinic staff. The most fre whether awake and struggling or anesthetized
quent employee injuries in veterinary practices and limp, is a common strain. Use of equip
include animal bites, strains from lifting ani ment such as lift tables and stretchers, where
mals, and slips and falls (often occurring dur available, can reduce the strain of lifting. In
ing animal handling; Cima and Larkin 2018). situations without lifting equipment, a two‐
Educating staff in appropriate animal han person lift, using bent knees and a straight
dling is essential: low‐stress animal handling back, may reduce risk of injury when lifting
techniques using appropriate restraint meth large dogs (AVMA‐PLIT 2015). There is strong
ods and equipment can decrease stress and evidence that lumbar belts or supports do not
558 31 Health Considerations for the HQHVSN Surgeon
prevent or reduce work‐related low back pain spends in surgery (White 2013). This argues for
(Waddell and Burton 2001). efficiency – including skilled use of efficient
surgical techniques and streamlined work
flow – as well as for considering decreasing the
Physical Ergonomics number of hours per week in surgery for those
who find themselves experiencing MSD.
Surgeons use their bodies to perform work. Low job satisfaction and high work stress
Like athletes and musicians, surgeons engage are important risk factors for MSD in veteri
their entire body along with their mental con narians working in HQHVSN (White 2013) as
centration to produce skilled motor move well as in other practice areas (Smith et al.
ments to accomplish a goal. Unlike athletes 2009; Scuffham et al. 2010). It is important to
and musicians, surgeons are rarely taught the remember that pain is not entirely due to bio
biomechanics of the movements and postures mechanical factors. The experience of pain
used in their work, and are often unaware of may be influenced by psychosocial factors,
the way they use their bodies to perform. including job characteristics such as workload
and lack of social or managerial support
(Baird 2008), and by individual factors such as
Musculoskeletal Discomfort
life stress, coping, and beliefs about and fear
Musculoskeletal loads during work – includ of pain (Asmundson et al. 2004). This chapter
ing static postures, awkward postures, repeti will return later to the subject of workplace
tion, and force – are related to musculoskeletal stress.
discomfort (MSD) in the areas subjected to the Physical activity outside of work is known to
loads (McAtamney and Corlett 1993). Some be associated with lower prevalence of pain
HQHVSN surgeons have worked in the field (Morken et al. 2007; Holth et al. 2008), and sur
for decades without experiencing work‐related geons who are physically active experience less
pain, but most experience some MSD that they fatigue due to work (Rodigari et al. 2012). For
attribute, at least in part, to their work (White people experiencing low back pain, maintain
2013). The most common body regions in ing daily activities as much as possible is asso
which HQHVSN surgeons experience discom ciated with quicker recovery from symptoms
fort are the lower back, neck, and shoulders. (Waddell and Burton 2001). Staying physically
Hand regions with the greatest pain prevalence fit, maintaining friendships outside of work,
are the right thumb and wrist (White 2013). eating well, and maintaining a work–life bal
Low back pain is extremely common in the ance are all ways to reduce work‐related MSD
general population (Waddell and Burton 2001) and stress.
and occurs at similar rates in HQHVSN veteri Veterinarians who experience MSD that
narians. Neck and shoulder discomfort is more concerns them should seek medical attention
common in HQHVSN veterinarians than in early in the course of the problem, rather than
the general population (Hogg‐Johnson et al. allowing pain to become chronic. Some cumu
2008), and is likely exacerbated by the forward lative trauma disorders are completely reversi
bending of the neck during surgery (Esser ble if addressed early, but much more difficult
et al. 2007; Szeto et al. 2010). to address once they have persisted for months
Discomfort tends to be greater in those sur or years (Proctor and Van Zandt 2008). Medical
geons who spend more hours in surgery each providers and physical therapists can perform
week, and in those who work in HQHVSN for diagnostics, provide physical activity recom
more years. The actual number of surgeries mendations and, if necessary, medications,
each week is relatively unimportant; what and may be able to determine workplace fac
matters is the amount of time the surgeon tors that should be modified.
Physical Ergonomics 559
Physical Environment
Several factors in the physical environment
that are easy to change can influence the sur
geon’s posture and comfort and can reduce the
strains placed on the surgeon’s body during
work.
Figure 31.6 When sitting for surgery with a small patient (a) the surgeon is able to sit close to the table
and maintain relaxed upper body positioning, but with a large dog (b) the surgeon sitting on a standard
stool raises her shoulders and abducts her elbows to clear the patient’s body. She is unable to lower the
table or raise her stool, since her thighs are already in contact with the underside of the table. Using a
saddle‐shaped stool when operating on a large dog (c) allows the surgeon to achieve appropriate upper
body position while still remaining close to the surgery table.
Flooring and Footwear
Standing surgeons may experience less discom
fort and fatigue in the back and lower limbs
with the use of a floor mat (see Figure 31.8).
The best mats tend to be thick but firm and
elastic (Cham and Redfern 2001). Cushioned
shoes (Lin et al. 2012) and insoles (King 2002)
can also decrease fatigue during prolonged
standing, while a combination of cushioned
footwear and floor mat provides the best results.
Surgical Techniques
and Movements
Surgical tasks in HQHVSN require a combina
tion of repetitive movements that can at times
require force, or may be performed with awk
Figure 31.7 A saddle‐shaped stool that can be ward positioning of the hands and wrists. Alone,
purchased from a hairdressing supply store. This each of these factors (repetition, force, posture)
stool is adjustable in height and has brakes that
is only moderately associated with MSD of the
engage when a person is seated, preventing it from
rolling away from the table during surgery. Source: hand and wrist; when combined, the associa
Photo courtesy of Bernie Robe. tion with MSD is strong (Bernard 1997).
562 31 Health Considerations for the HQHVSN Surgeon
Repetitive Motions
Repetitive motion is inherent in any high‐vol
ume workplace that has a limited variability in
tasks. Fortunately, spay and neuter procedures
contain multiple steps – such as autoligation
(see Chapter 12), suture knot tying, and sutur
ing – each of which requires different hand
motions. The use of efficient high‐volume tech
niques will minimize the need for excessive
repetition of any of these motions in each pro
cedure. Short incisions require less suturing,
and autoligation in cats and male puppies will
require less suture knot tying. In addition, effi
cient techniques and shorter incisions result in
fewer overall movements per procedure, reduc
ing the cumulative number of repetitions
required for a given number of procedures.
This may be why MSD appears to be more
Figure 31.8 A surgical area with anti‐fatigue floor related to hours in surgery rather than num
mats and adjustable height tables. Source: Photo bers of surgeries. The number of movements
courtesy of Pamela Krausz. per hour may be the same for “fast” and “slow”
surgeons, but the “slow” surgeons require
To some extent, human bodies can adapt to more movements to complete each surgery.
these strains, given adequate time for rest,
recovery, and adaptation. Ligaments will Instrument Grips
increase in strength, size, and collagen content In addition to reducing the overall number of
with use (Solomonow 2009), so that the movements in a surgery, surgeons can reduce
HQHVSN surgeon in regular work may have repetition by varying their techniques during
greater resilience than the new recruit. and between surgeries, such as by using hand
Performing repeated, unaccustomed move ties for some suture ligations and instrument
ments with the hands can be a risk factor for ties for others. Another way to limit repetition
hand and wrist disorders (Proctor and Van is to use different grips when holding instru
Zandt 2008), so it may be valuable to introduce ments, such as by choosing a tripod grip for
new surgeons to HQHVSN with a lighter some portions of the surgery, and a palm grip
schedule, then work up to a full schedule once for others (see Figure 31.9). The tripod grip is
their bodies have become conditioned to the generally considered to be more precise
work. It is also worth remembering that there because the digits are used to control the
are safety risks associated with more mundane instrument (Toombs and Bauer 1993), whereas
tasks like computer work. Repetitive motions the palm grip relies more upon movements in
and sustained postures used while on the com the hand and forearm to provide control,
puter or while texting or using a tablet may although some research suggests that palm
exacerbate the risk of activities in surgery, so grasp may actually be more accurate (Seki
should be considered when looking at an indi 1988). Some HQHVSN surgeons report
vidual surgeon’s risk profile. decreased hand discomfort with the use of
This section will describe some of the ways palm grip, and others report increased strain
in which surgeons may reduce the risks from and discomfort in the area of the flexor ten
these factors. dons of the wrist when using the palm grip.
Physical Ergonomics 563
(a)
(b)
Figure 31.10 The pinch grip is used for thumb
forceps. This grip can be fatiguing and may
exacerbate discomfort in people with hand pain.
Forceful Motions
Figure 31.9 Methods for grasping the needle Fortunately, spay and castration procedures do
holder. (a) The tripod grip allows finer control and
uses muscles of the fingers and hands to
not often require the application of high forces
manipulate the instrument, and (b) the palm grip by the surgeon. The two main times when
relies more upon muscles of the hand and arm force is required is while tying knots with large
than upon the fingers. suture, and during adult dog castration.
Awkward Hand and Wrist Positions Suture Size and Knot Tying Force Secure knot
Awkward hand and wrist postures include tying (see Figure 31.11) requires that the surgeon
pinch grip, ulnar or radial deviation of the apply forces to the ends of the suture equivalent
wrist, and extreme wrist flexion or extension to 80% of that suture’s breaking strength
(Bernard 1997). An example of a pinch grip is (Mazzarese et al. 1997). For 3‐0 absorbable
the use of thumb forceps (see Figure 31.10). monofilament suture, breakage occurs at 3.9 lb
Some surgeons minimize the use of thumb for of force, whereas with size 1 suture, breakage
ceps, particularly when performing skin clo occurs at 11.2 lb (USP 2006). Thus, a secure knot
sure, both in order to reduce tissue trauma to with 3‐0 suture will require the surgeon to apply
the patient’s skin as well as to reduce the hand just over 3 lb of force with each throw, but a
strain from the sustained pinch grip. secure knot using size 1 suture requires nearly
In most cases, awkward postures with 9 lb of force on every throw. Human ligaments
extreme flexion, extension, or ulnar or radial are affected by cyclic loading, and a repeated
deviation are not necessary to perform load of 9 lb has been associated with ligament
HQHVSN, but surgeons may inadvertently use inflammation and muscle excitability (Solo
awkward grips and techniques. Since it can be monow 2009). Without adequate rest, this
difficult to observe one’s own movements dur chronic use and inflammation can lead to
ing surgery, it can be useful to record video or ligament damage and pain.
take photographs during surgery in order to By selecting appropriately sized suture, sur
evaluate hand motions and postures. Many geons can avoid the need to apply unnecessary
564 31 Health Considerations for the HQHVSN Surgeon
(a)
Applying Force in Dog Castration Many surgeons Figure 31.12 Exteriorization of the testicle
find that considerable hand and arm strength is during closed castration of large dogs requires
required to grasp and exteriorize the testis force. Grasping the testicle by hand (a) leads to an
during closed castration of large, mature dogs. awkward hand posture with ulnar deviation of the
surgeon’s wrist, and requires considerable grasping
Various techniques may decrease the force strength in the fingers due to the testicle’s shape
required to accomplish exteriorization of the and slippery texture. Using a hemostat across the
testes in these dogs. An open castration may be spermatic cord (b) allows the surgeon to maintain
performed instead of a closed castration, as the a straight position through the wrist, and enables a
more secure grip.
tissues present very little resistance during open
castration. If closed castration is preferred, the
fibrous attachments between the vaginal tunic fatigue. Fatigue during surgery leads to pain
and the subcutaneous tissue may be sharply after surgery (Rodigari et al. 2012).
dissected rather than broken by traction. “Micropauses” of 15–30 seconds taken multi
Further, once the spermatic cord is exposed, the ple times per hour (for example, between each
surgeon may use a hemostat to clamp the cord surgery, or for long surgeries, during the
just proximal to the testis to provide a more course of the surgery) are shown to reduce
favorable grip for applying traction, rather than MSD, especially if combined with stretches or
grasping the testis itself (see Figure 31.12). exercises (Barredo and Mahon 2007). Some
HQHVSN veterinarians do this by listening
Movement during the Surgery Day and moving to music, stretching during or
Being able to change position during an oper between surgeries, and taking brief breaks
ation or, by extrapolation, between successive between surgeries for stretching, yoga, or
short operations, is associated with decreased dancing (White 2013).
Physical Ergonomics 565
(a) (b)
Figure 31.13 Sometimes poor posture can be solved by improving surgery technique. When a continuous
subcuticular closure is performed from left to right by a right‐handed surgeon (a), the surgeon’s posture is
twisted and her arm is abducted. However, when the surgeon sutures the same incision from right to left
(b), she remains upright, with her only postural concern being the wrist extension and ulnar deviation of
her right wrist.
566 31 Health Considerations for the HQHVSN Surgeon
lubrication, repair, and sharpening will maintain It is worth noting that the light required by a
instrument quality and reliability, and avoid person to perform a given task increases with
placing increased strain on the surgeon using age (Schlangen 2010). This increased need for
them. If reusable needles are used, they should light may exacerbate vision trouble due to the
be disposed of when no longer sharp to prevent onset of presbyopia (see next section). Some
the need for the surgeon to apply increased HQHVSN surgeons may find that surgical
amounts of force to patient tissues (Patkin 1970) lighting that was once adequate must be
and to reduce tissue trauma. updated or supplemented as they age in order
to attain the levels of contrast they need to per
form surgery.
Be aware that the specifications of a light
Surgical Environment and the spectrum of wavelengths emitted may
affect color perception and may thus affect
Noise, ambient temperature, and lighting are
patient assessment and care. This is applicable
environmental factors that can affect staff
to room lighting as well as surgical and task
comfort and stress level, as well as the stress
lighting. “Warmer” lights with a lower Kelvin
and comfort level of patients (particularly
value produce yellow or orange color percep
cats). Minimizing noise from dogs in the sur
tion and “cooler” lights with a higher Kelvin
gery area can be accomplished by separating
value can create a bluish cast and even an
the kennel area from surgical areas whenever
appearance of cyanosis in patients. Either
possible. Temperature in surgery should be
extreme may cause inaccuracies in patient
kept at a comfortable room temperature, and
assessment. Recommended lighting in the sur
lighting should be adequate for clear visualiza
gical suite should have a color rendering index
tion without producing excessive glare.
(the ability to render color accurately) over 90
and should include a broad spectrum of wave
lengths, including those in the red spectrum
Vision and Lighting
over 600 nm, where the difference in spectral
Lighting in the Surgical Suite transmittance between oxyhemoglobin and
Lighting in the surgical suite should be ade reduced hemoglobin becomes maximal
quate for staff to observe and monitor patients (Schlangen 2010) in order to allow accurate
during induction through recovery. Task light assessment of cyanosis.
ing over surgical prep areas may be beneficial.
More muted lighting in kennels or post‐recov Corrective Lenses for Surgery
ery areas may help reduce stimulation and agi Some surgeons require the use of corrective
tation among kenneled patients and may assist lenses (glasses or contacts) throughout their
in smoothing recovery. career, while others only begin to need visual
The surgery lighting should be adequate to correction as they age. At around age 40, most
illuminate the surgical field without excessive people begin to lose the ability to focus on near
glare. Surgical lighting is accomplished in most objects, a condition called presbyopia (du Toit
stationary clinics by using ceiling or floor‐ 2006). At some point in their 40s, many sur
mounted surgical lights, while MASH clinics geons find that they can no longer focus clearly
and some stationary and mobile clinics may on the surgical field and that they require cor
use a table‐mounted lamp or headlamps for rective lenses during surgery. Surgeons who
this purpose. If a lamp is used, compact fluo use eyed needles and suture from a cassette
rescent or light‐emitting diode (LED) lights are may notice the need for corrective lenses
recommended, as they produce less heat (and sooner than those who use swaged‐on suture,
thus are less uncomfortable to stand near) than as needle‐threading is often performed at a
incandescent lights with similar brightness. shorter focal distance than the surgery itself.
Surgical Environment 567
Many HQHVSN surgeons use over‐the‐ LASIK) or cataract surgery, they should be sure
counter reading glasses for presbyopia correc to discuss their particular needs and preferred
tion during surgery. Those who need corrective focal distance(s) with their surgeon prior to the
lenses and for whom over‐the‐counter glasses surgery. While cataract surgery is not primarily
are unsuitable, inadequate, or uncomfortable performed to correct near‐ or far‐sightedness,
should work with an optometrist to select the this surgery involves the implantation of a new
appropriate vision correction. Some HQHVSN intraocular lens and thus can affect the ability to
veterinarians wear progressive lenses for sur focus at different distances. Some veterinarians
gery, but not all are happy with their everyday have reported dismay at discovering that their
progressive lenses for use during surgery. An post‐cataract surgery focal distance is inappro
optometrist can help select the appropriate priate for their work, and would have benefited
lens refractive power and regions of refractive greatly from prior discussion with their surgeon
power for the individual’s specific workplace about job tasks. Various types of intraocular
needs (Long 2003). lens implants are available and it should be pos
Some surgeons use contact lenses for vision sible to find one that suits one’s needs.
correction during surgery. For some, these are
their everyday contact lenses that allow for Ergonomics and Glasses From an ergonomics
near and far vision. This may be accomplished perspective, it is important to ensure that the
using multifocal contacts, or with contacts use of glasses, whether over the counter or
with one eye for near vision and one eye for far prescription, does not adversely affect the
vision. These configurations may be combined surgeon’s posture by influencing head and
with reading glasses for particularly fine tasks neck position (see Figure 31.14). Glasses
like ophthalmic surgery. Other surgeons frames that block the lowest portion of the
choose to have a set of contacts optimized for visual field, or that do not reach the lowest
near vision for use during surgery and similar portion of the visual field, will require the
tasks, and a different set of contacts for near surgeon to work with a greater head and neck
and far vision for driving and everyday use. angle, since the eyes can no longer be inclined
If an HQHVSN surgeon is contemplating downward at as great an angle as without
having a vision correction surgery (such as glasses (White 2018a). Wearing glasses low on
(a) (b)
Figure 31.14 Neck position during surgery may be influenced by the fit of glasses. (a) When glasses block
the lowest portion of the visual field, the surgeon’s neck angle is 40°, but (b) when the glasses are designed
to sit low enough on the nose to include the lowest portion of the visual field, the surgeon’s neck angle
decreases to 32°.
568 31 Health Considerations for the HQHVSN Surgeon
the nose if they are not designed to be worn on their own, important to the wellbeing of
this way is likely to be uncomfortable and may the veterinarian and staff. They are also impor
lead to the glasses slipping or falling off during tant in that they impact the severity and preva
surgery. Half‐glasses with a thin, lightweight lence of musculoskeletal pain, as described
frame that sit low on the nose or progressive previously.
lenses with a thin frame can allow the surgeon
to use the lowest portion of the visual field and
The HQHVSN Workplace
thus allow for a less extreme neck angle.
There is no single type of HQHVSN job or work
Fogged Lenses and Surgery Masks Those who place, but many share common features.
wear glasses and a face mask for surgery may HQHVSN surgeons often practice in relative iso
have experienced fogging of the lenses. Several lation from other veterinarians, making it chal
suggestions for decreasing fogging exist in the lenging for them to exchange concerns, advice,
literature and anecdotally, and work either by and information. Their work requires speed and
redirecting the breath away from the top of the precision. There are often resource limitations
mask, or by changing the surface properties of paired with high work demands. And, as in any
the lenses. To redirect the breath, some have workplace, there may be conflicts with other
suggested using a piece of adhesive tape over staff, with management, and with clients.
the bridge of the nose to divert breath away
from the lenses (Karabagli et al. 2006). Anti‐
Stress
fog surgical masks work on a similar concept
and use adhesive, foam, or film to keep “Stress” is an interaction between the pres
condensation from escaping out the top of the sures and demands placed upon a person
mask. Other authors suggest crossing the (stressors) and the person’s assessment of their
mask’s ties behind the head, such that the own ability to cope with those demands (Baird
upper ties are tied at the base of the skull, and 2010). For some veterinarians HQHVSN is not
the lower ties are tied atop the head, redirecting at all stressful, whereas others experience it as
the breath out the sides of the mask (Jordan extremely stressful (White 2013). HQHVSN
and Pritchard‐Jones 2014). This technique is surgeons may avoid some stressors noted in
not applicable to ear‐loop masks. Other authors general practice veterinarians, such as client
have suggested washing the lenses with soap interactions, but may have greater exposure to
and water prior to each donning, leaving a other stressors such as consciousness of time
surfactant layer that prevents fogging (Malik pressure (Smith et al. 2009).
and Malik 2011); some HQHVSN vets suggest In any workplace, high work demands paired
the use of cleaning/defogging solutions with low control or decision latitude is a recog
designed for scuba masks. nized source of strain (Bartram et al. 2009). In
some cases, HQHVSN veterinarians may feel as
though they do not have adequate control in
their job, and may be frustrated in situations in
Mental Health, Stress, which their managers are non‐veterinarians.
Wellbeing Veterinarians may find it particularly stressful
if they feel pressure to provide care to more ani
In addition to attending to physical workplace mals than they believe they can safely serve, or
health, the HQHVSN veterinarian, staff, and they feel that they are unable to provide high‐
management should be aware that there are quality care with the resources they have avail
psychosocial aspects that affect workplace able. Good communication between manager
health as well. These psychosocial factors are, and veterinarian is key, and each should work
Mental Health, Stress, Wellbeing 569
to recognize the pressures, demands, and point amount of intraoperative stress experienced.
of view of the other. Unlike workers in other industries in which
the safety of others is at stake, surgeons are not
typically trained in stress management or how
Mental Health
to mitigate the effects of stress on surgical per
Veterinarians overall appear to be no more at formance (Arora et al. 2010).
risk for mental illness than those in the general All veterinary practices that perform surgery
population, but certain sub‐groups of veteri experience peri‐operative complications and
narians – young, female veterinarians, and deaths. In HQHVSN, the high volume of surger
those who work alone rather than with oth ies performed means that, even in clinics with
ers – are at higher risk than other veterinarians exceptionally low mortality rates, some peri‐
for suicidal thoughts, mental health difficul operative deaths will occur. Peri‐operative deaths
ties, and stress (Platt et al. 2012). While there is can lead to feelings of guilt, responsibility, and
no published data about mental health in self‐blame, as well as grief and sadness (Lin et al.
HQHVSN veterinarians, shelter veterinarians 2012; White 2018b). When a patient death
(many of whose work consists primarily of occurs, fear, grief, or self‐doubt can make it diffi
spay–neuter) do appear to be at higher risk for cult to continue with the day’s scheduled surger
serious psychological distress (Nett et al. 2015). ies, but the schedule of many HQHVSN clinics
Also, many shelter and HQHVSN veterinari makes it difficult or impossible to interrupt the
ans are young and female (White 2013) and work schedule for debriefing and time away.
work apart from other veterinarians, placing After a serious adverse event or patient
them in a higher‐risk demographic. The sui death, HQHVSN veterinarians have described
cide rate published for the veterinary profes a variety of ways of coping with and moving
sion is approximately four times that of the past the incident. Once the acute emotional
general population, and twice that of other reactions subside, four factors appear impor
health professionals (Bartram and Baldwin tant for successful coping (White 2018b).
2010). While no one is certain of the reasons Technical learning can help veterinarians
for this, most authors propose that it is due to a decrease future occurrences of similar adverse
combination of personal characteristics, feel events and can improve the veterinarian’s and
ings of stress, and having medical knowledge team’s skills and boost confidence. Finding
and access to medications. perspective by placing the event in a larger con
Any veterinarian who is experiencing anxiety, text (such as the value the HQHVSN program
depression, thoughts of suicide, or other mental provides to the community, or the context of
health problems should seek the care of a health one’s religious faith) can help to mitigate the
professional. Box 31.1 contains resources for trauma of the event without minimizing its
crisis intervention and links to more informa importance. Seeking and receiving support
tion about veterinarians, mental health, and from colleagues can help in many ways, pro
suicide. Anecdotally, many HQHVSN surgeons viding technical help, psychological support,
report experiencing anxiety, stress, and/or and the knowledge that others have experi
depression at some point in their professional enced similar events. And finally, emotional
career, and many have been able to receive sup learning can help veterinarians learn how to
port and advice from their peers in the field. handle and support themselves through an
adverse event. Mindfulness training, psycho
therapy, and compassion fatigue training are
Complications and Stress
all examples of ways veterinarians can learn to
Performing surgery can be stressful, and events understand, accept, and manage their own
that occur while in surgery can increase the reactions and build resilience.
570 31 Health Considerations for the HQHVSN Surgeon
Managers and institutions also have a role in tronic listservs and other online forums can be
fostering open communication and creating a valuable resources that allow communication
workplace that allows for discussion of com with other HQHVSN surgeons (see Box 31.1
plications and error without blame, shame, for resources).
and fear. Candid discussion of deaths, errors,
mistakes, and mishaps can be taboo in medi
cine: surgeons often have the expectation that Conclusion
they should perform flawlessly (Wu 2000). In
HQHVSN, there appears to be more open dis HQHVSN is an exciting and rewarding field
cussion of complications and near misses than that presents physical, emotional, and mental
in many medical fields; however, HQHVSN challenges. With careful attention and good
veterinarians may still benefit from increased management, veterinarians, staff, and supervi
discussion of early recognition of danger, sors can minimize the risks presented by work
errors, decision‐making, expertise, and error in HQHVSN and provide a high‐quality, car
recovery (Patel et al. 2011). For those who ing, and humane environment for both ani
work in facilities without access to peers, elec mals and staff.
References
and Low Back. Cincinnati, OH: National Jordan, D.J. and Pritchard‐Jones, R. (2014).
Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Tying a surgical mask to prevent fogging. Ann.
US Department of Health and Human Services. Royal Coll. Surg. Engl. 96: 165–165.
Boothe, H.W. (1993). Suture materials, tissue Karabagli, Y., Kocman, E.A., Kose, A.A. et al.
adhesives, staplers and ligating clips. In: (2006). Adhesive bands to prevent fogging of
Textbook of Small Animal Surgery, 2e (ed. D. lenses and glasses of surgical loupes or
Slatter), 204–212. Philadelphia, PA: W. B. microscopes. Plast. and Reconstr. Surg. 117:
Saunders. 718–719.
Casale, T., Caciari, T., Rosati, M.V. et al. (2014). King, P.M. (2002). A comparison of the effects of
Anesthetic gases and occupationally exposed floor mats and shoe in‐soles on standing
workers. Environ. Toxicol. Pharmacol. 37: fatigue. Appl. Ergon. 33: 477–484.
267–274. Lin, Y.H., Chen, C.Y., and Cho, M.H. (2012).
Centers for Disease Control (2017). Reproductive Influence of shoe/floor conditions on lower
health and the workplace. Centers for Disease leg circumference and subjective discomfort
Control and Prevention. https://www.cdc.gov/ during prolonged standing. Appl. Ergon. 43:
niosh/topics/repro/anestheticgases.html 965–970.
(accessed 19 October 2018). Long, J. (2003). What every ergonomics needs to
Cham, R. and Redfern, M.S. (2001). Effect of know about … multiple focus spectacles.
flooring on standing comfort and fatigue. Ergon. Aust. 17: 10–13.
Hum. Factors 43: 381–391. Malik, S.S. and Malik, S.S. (2011). A simple
Cima, G. and Larkin, M. (2018). Hurt at work. method to prevent spectacle lenses misting up
JAVMA 253: 1096–1101. on wearing a face mask. Ann. Royal Coll. Surg.
Esser, A.C., Koshy, J.G., and Randle, H.W. Engl. 93: 168–168.
(2007). Ergonomics in office‐based surgery: a Mazzarese, P.M., Faulkner, B.C., Gear, A.J. et al.
survey‐guided observational study. Dermatol. (1997). Technical considerations in knot
Surg. 33: 1304–1313; discussion 1313‐4. construction. Part II. Interrupted dermal
Gadge, K. and Innes, E. (2007). An investigation suture closure. J. Emerg. Med. 15: 505–511.
into the immediate effects on comfort, McAtamney, L. and Corlett, E.N. (1993). RULA:
productivity and posture of the Bambach™ a survey method for the investigation of
saddle seat and a standard office chair. Work work‐related upper limb disorders. Appl.
29: 189–203. Ergonom. 24: 91–99.
Hignett, S., Wilson, J.R., and Morris, W. (2005). Molina Aragones, J.M., Ayora Ayora, A., Barbara
Finding ergonomic solutions – participatory Ribalta, A. et al. (2016). Occupational
approaches. Occup. Med. 55: 200–207. exposure to volatile anaesthetics: a systematic
Hogg‐Johnson, S., van der Velde, G., Carroll, L.J. review. Occup. Med. (Lond.) 66: 202–207.
et al. (2008). The burden and determinants of Morken, T., Mageroy, N., and Moen, B.E. (2007).
neck pain in the general population. Eur. Physical activity is associated with a low
Spine J. 17: 39–51. prevalence of musculoskeletal disorders in the
Holth, H.S., Werpen, H.K., Zwart, J.A., and Royal Norwegian Navy: a cross sectional
Hagen, K. (2008). Physical inactivity is study. BMC Musculoskelet. Disord. 8: 56.
associated with chronic musculoskeletal Nett, R.J., Witte, T.K., Holzbauer, S.M. et al.
complaints 11 years later: results from the (2015). Prevalence of risk factors for suicide
Nord‐Trondelag Health Study. BMC among veterinarians – United States, 2014.
Musculoskelet. Disord. 9: 159. Morb. Mortal. Wkly Rep. 64: 131–132.
Ishizawa, Y. (2011). Special article: general Nilsson, R., Björdal, C., Andersson, M. et al.
anesthetic gases and the global environment. (2005). Health risks and occupational
Anesth. Analg. 112: 213–217. exposure to volatile anaesthetics–a review
572 31 Health Considerations for the HQHVSN Surgeon
with a systematic approach. J. Clin. Nurs. 14: preterm delivery in female veterinarians.
173–186. Obstetr. Gynecol. 113: 1008–1017.
OSHA (1999). Anesthetic gases: guidelines for Smith, D.R., Leggat, P.A., and Speare, R. (2009).
workplace exposures. US Department of Musculoskeletal disorders and psychosocial
Labor. https://www.osha.gov/dts/osta/ risk factors among veterinarians in
anestheticgases/index.html (accessed 16 Queensland, Australia. Aust. Vet. J. 87:
March 2019). 260–265.
Patel, V.L., Cohen, T., Murarka, T. et al. (2011). Smith, J.C. and Bolon, B. (2003). Comparison of
Recovery at the edge of error: debunking the three commercially available activated
myth of the infallible expert. J. Biomed. charcoal canisters for passive scavenging of
Informat. 44: 413–424. waste isoflurane during conventional rodent
Patkin, M. (1970). Surgical instruments and anesthesia. J. Am. Assoc. Lab. Anim. Sci. 42:
effort referring especially to ratchets and 10–15.
needle sharpness. Med. J. Aust. 1: 225. Solomonow, M. (2009). Ligaments: a source of
Pheasant, S.T. and Steenbekkers, L.P.A. (2005). musculoskeletal disorders. J. Bodyw. Mov.
Anthropometry and the design of workspaces. Ther. 13: 136–154.
In: Evaluation of Human Work, 3e (eds. J.R. Szeto, G.P., Ho, P., Ting, A.C. et al. (2010). A
Wilson and N. Corlett), 715–728. Boca Raton, study of surgeons’ postural muscle activity
FL: Taylor & Francis. during open, laparoscopic, and endovascular
Platt, B., Hawton, K., Simkin, S., and Mellanby, surgery. Surg. Endosc. 24: 1712–1721.
R.J. (2012). Suicidal behaviour and du Toit, R. (2006). How to prescribe
psychosocial problems in veterinary surgeons: spectacles for presbyopia. Commun. Eye
a systematic review. Soc. Psychiatr. Psychiatr. Health 19: 12.
Epidemiol. 47: 223–240. Toombs, J.P. and Bauer, M.S. (1993). Basic
Proctor, R.W. and Van Zandt, T. (2008). Human operative techniques. In: Textbook of Small
Factors in Simple and Complex Systems. Boca Animal Surgery, 2e (ed. D. Slatter), 98–121.
Raton, FL: CRC. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders.
Rodigari, A., Bejor, M., Carlisi, E. et al. (2012). USP (2006). Absorbable surgical suture. United
Identification of risk factors for fatigue and States Pharmacopeial Convention. http://ftp.
pain when performing surgical interventions. uspbpep.com/v29240/usp29nf24s0_m80190.
G. Ital. Med. Lav. Ergon. 34: 432–437. html (accessed 26 December 2018).
Schlangen, L.J.M. (2010). The role of lighting in Vouriot, A., Gauchard, G.C., Chau, N. et al.
promoting well‐being and recovery within (2005). Chronic exposure to anesthetic gases
healthcare. Philips White Paper. Amsterdam: affects balance control in operating room
Koninklijke Philips Electronics NV. personnel. Neurotoxicology 26: 193–198.
Scuffham, A.M., Legg, S.J., Firth, E.C., and Waddell, G. and Burton, A.K. (2001).
Stevenson, M.A. (2010). Prevalence and risk Occupational health guidelines for the
factors associated with musculoskeletal management of low back pain at work:
discomfort in New Zealand veterinarians. evidence review. Occup. Med. 51: 124–135.
Appl. Ergon. 41: 444–453. White, S. (2013). Prevalence and risk factors
Seki, S. (1988). Suturing techniques of surgeons associated with musculoskeletal discomfort in
utilizing two different needle‐holder grips. spay and neuter veterinarians. Animals 3:
Am. J. Surg. 155: 250–252. 85–108.
Shirangi, A., Fritschi, L., and Holman, C.D.A.J. White, S. (2018a). Vision in surgery. ergovet.
(2009). Associations of unscavenged http://ergovet.com/vision‐in‐surgery
anesthetic gases and long working hours with (accessed 4 December 2018).
References 573
Section Seven
Clinic Models
577
32
Stationary Clinics
Karla Brestle
capable of meeting the need, energies and and technicians must spend part of their work-
resources may be better spent in a collabora- day traveling, stationary clinics with transport
tive effort. At the very least, an open discussion are able to serve a large area by allowing veteri-
between the proposed and existing organiza- narians and technicians to remain in a central-
tions is in order. ized location while animals are transported to
them. This greater efficiency is an advantage
both for budget and for the number of surger-
Budget
ies in a given workday.
When starting a stationary clinic, an organiza-
tion must have the ability to raise funds to sup- Initial Funding
port the procurement and remodel of a suitable Many stationary HQHVSN clinics operate
building and to purchase the necessary equip- under a nonprofit structure, while others are
ment and supplies. Additional funds will be operated by government entities such as
required for staff training, and it is advisable municipalities, and still others operate under a
that the organization acquires a minimum of for‐profit structure. For nonprofits and govern-
$35 000 reserve on opening day. ment entities, grant‐writing and community
fundraising are common sources of initial
Budgeting for Transport funding, whereas in for‐profit clinics, initial
In the initial planning phases of a stationary funding may be drawn from personal savings
clinic, a determination must be made as to or bank loans.
whether the clinic will provide services solely
as a stand‐alone facility or will include a Financial Sustainability
regional transport service. Transport is the act Meeting the budget is a challenge for any com-
of going into surrounding communities, pick- pany and is especially so when attempting to
ing up the animals scheduled for sterilization keep the cost of services dramatically lower
surgeries, transporting them to the stationary than those of full‐service for‐profit clinics.
clinic, and then returning them to the pick‐up However, meeting this challenge is feasible due
site to be reunited with their caretakers or to the “high‐volume” nature of these services.
owners. See later in this chapter for details on Furthermore, the fact that spay–neuter clinics
transport protocols. provide a service that is highly focused allows
Transport programs require the additional for a significant reduction in the amount of
initial expenses of procuring a suitable trans- overhead compared to a full‐service practice.
port vehicle and hiring a staff member to drive There is no need to carry the product inventory,
that vehicle. Ongoing expenses include vehicle invest in the array of equipment, or retain the
expenses (ongoing fuel costs to provide the large staff that a private general practice
transport, insurance, registration, mainte- requires. Thus, the HQHVSN clinic is capable
nance, and eventual replacement), as well as of functioning in a very efficient, cost‐effective
staff expense for a driver and, in larger pro- manner, and is capable of being self‐sustaining.
grams, a transport manager. In order for the organization to be self‐sus-
The advantages of transport include the abil- taining, the total yearly operating cost for the
ity to serve a larger area and to reach clients program should be determined, being sure to
with limited transportation access while also include wages and salaries (including for relief
maximizing the use of their veterinarians’ and veterinarians), benefits, taxes, insurance,
technicians’ time. Unlike mobile units and licenses, vehicle expenses, supplies, rent or
mobile animal sterilization hospital (MASH) mortgage, utilities, care at outside veterinari-
spay–neuter programs in which veterinarians ans, and equipment and property repair and
Stationary Clinic Requirements and Structure 579
maintenance. The clinic can then calculate the Facility Legal and Regulatory Issues
average surgery fee required in order to cover Prior to selecting a site for a stationary clinic,
the operating cost. For example, if it costs city and county code and zone restrictions
$400 000 per year to operate a clinic perform- must be researched to verify that a veterinary
ing 8400 surgeries and the clinic is open facility may be sited in the prospective loca-
48 weeks/year (240 days), the cost for each sur- tion. It is also important to review the veteri-
gery would need to be approximately $47 to nary practice act for the state in which the
break even (see Table 32.1). Computation of facility is to be located, to ensure that all
this figure enables the clinic to prepare for the requirements for facility inspection and per-
amount of funds that need to be raised to help mitting are properly addressed. A facility in
further subsidize the cost for those individuals the United States must comply with regula-
who cannot afford that charge. A sample tions set forth under the federal Americans
budget worksheet can be found in Figure 32.1. with Disabilities Act (ADA) in order to pro-
vide accessibility or accommodations for peo-
ple with disabilities (United States Department
Facility
of Justice Civil Rights Division 2010).
Although some clinics have elected to con- Additional areas that may be subject to regula-
struct a building, it is always not necessary to tion by veterinary practice act or by municipal
do so. Completion of a remodel on an existing code include air exchange and ventilation, as
building can very easily meet the needs of an well as solid waste disposal and drain
HQHVSN clinic by keeping a few key points in requirements.
mind. Location of the facility in close proxim-
ity to a major thoroughfare is exceedingly ben- Facility Size and Design
eficial both for the public and transport arms The ASPCA Spay/Neuter Alliance recom-
of the program. Other important features to mends 2000–3000 sq. ft. for a one‐vet practice,
consider include ample parking and a safe area and 3500–5000+ sq. ft. for a two‐vet practice.
to walk dogs. Overall, the floor plan must be designed in
such a way as to allow for the most efficient
flow of patients through the clinic. As much as
Table 32.1 Sample budget – one‐veterinarian possible, flow should be one way to avoid inef-
stationary clinic. ficiency as well as unnecessary cross‐contami-
nation. It is highly recommended that
Total Operating Expenses & $400 000.00
Cost of Services interested groups visit as many high‐volume
clinics as possible to see floor plans in func-
Days open/week 5
tioning clinics and how patient “flow” within
Weeks open/year 48
the facility is achieved (see sample floor plans
Days open/year 240
in Figure 32.2). For more detailed information
Revenue needed/year $400 000.00 about selecting, designing, and remodeling a
Revenue needed/week $8 333.33 clinic space, see https://www.aspcapro.org/
Revenue needed/day $1 666.67 sites/default/files/asna_building_resource_
Number of surgeries/day 35 guide.pdf.
Number of surgeries/week 175 Particular areas require consideration during
construction or remodel. Clinics must comply
Number of surgeries/year 8400
with appropriate ventilation and air exchange
Revenue needed/surgery $47.62
according to the veterinary practice act and city/
(average service fee)
county government code requirements for their
580 32 Stationary Clinics
(a)
Clinic A 1885 sq. feet
cage bank
Exam
Receiving Office RR RR Utility/ Laundry Dog Kennel
7'4" x 6'8"
13 x 9 Storage Area hs (capacity #20)
e 17 x 12
scale l
v
e
receiving counter Tech s R U N S
Station
Lobby O2 Tanks
recovery area
13 x 12 prep
table
Prep OR 10 x 16
bench anesth machs Cat Kennel
prep (capacity #24)
table OR table
11 x 13
Break Area
Director's surgery
Office light OR table
auto-
13 x 8 storage clave ref
(b)
Clinic B 2900 sq. feet
Director's
Break Area Vet storage shower
Office
9 x 14 Office 9x7 9x5
9 x 14
9 x 14
220 volt
Pharmacy
L 7 x 12 auto-
a
clave
u
Prep Area
n
d OR
r 15 x 16 women men
y
Restrooms
recovery
Exam
7x6
Lobby
400 sq. feet
Figure 32.2 (a) Sample floorplan for a 1‐veterinarian, 1800 sq. ft. stationary clinic. (b) Sample floorplan for
a 1–2‐veterinarian, 2900 sq. ft. stationary clinic.
582 32 Stationary Clinics
area, if any. Clinic designers should also be window through which waste gas can be piped
mindful of zones for heat, ventilation, and air‐ via transfer tubing. Passive exhaust ports
conditioning (HVAC), as kennels, surgery, and should be below the level of the anesthesia
administration areas may need to be on separate machine pop‐off valve to facilitate flow of the
controls. heavier‐than‐air anesthetic gases.
Proper and safe individual housing accom- Activated charcoal canisters (such as F/Air)
modation for each patient must be provided are a second method of passive waste gas scav-
(i.e. stainless‐steel cages, runs). Kennels enging. These canisters are affordable and do
should be positioned in a manner to separate not require access to an outside wall. However,
dogs and cats as much as possible, with special the canisters must be monitored and replaced
attention to community/feral cat holding. on a routine basis, are variable in their perfor-
Code requirements on drains (if used) should mance, and are not as effective at removing
be reviewed and implemented. A secure area waste gas as active or passive scavenging sys-
should be identified for housing of the con- tems that exhaust waste gas to the outdoors
trolled substance safe(s). (Smith and Bolon 2003).
Also during clinic construction or remodel, a Active scavengers rely on vacuum evacua-
decision must be made regarding oxygen deliv- tion to move waste gas from the anesthesia
ery (central oxygen, portable tanks, oxygen exhaust tubing to the outdoors. Advantages of
generator), as well as which gas scavenging active scavenging systems are that waste gas
system will be utilized. may be collected from multiple anesthesia
While small, portable “E” tanks are the machines and exhausted together in a single
least expensive oxygen setup option initially, location that may be distant from the anesthe-
they are the most expensive over time. For sia machines and does not rely on gravity and
this reason, E tanks are not generally recom- gas flow rates to push gas out of the building.
mended for full‐time stationary clinics. A Active scavenging units are useful for clinics
more cost‐effective option is central oxygen with anesthesia machines located away from
provided via large, refillable “H” tanks. The outside walls and where direct passive outdoor
initial cost of these systems is higher because exhaust is impractical. These systems are fairly
central oxygen lines to connect the tanks to permanent with no need for routine mainte-
the anesthesia machines must be installed by nance or replacement, but the initial cost is
a licensed company. However, ongoing oxy- relatively high and connecting pipes must be
gen purchase expenses are reduced compared installed to connect the scavenging unit to
to E tanks. each anesthesia machine.
Oxygen generators are most expensive ini- For both active and passive systems that rely
tially, but in the long run save money, as there is on outdoor exhaust, ensure that the waste gas
no ongoing need to purchase oxygen. One caveat is not being exhausted near open windows,
to the use of oxygen generators is that if power is doors, or air intake vents which may direct the
lost, oxygen will not be available. Thus, if using waste gas back into the building. For more
oxygen generators, it is prudent to have a small information on waste gas health and safety, see
amount of bottled oxygen (such as E tanks) Chapter 31.
available as an emergency backup option.
Waste anesthetic gas scavenging may be pas-
sive or active. Passive scavenging may be Transport
accomplished by directly exhausting waste gas
to the outdoors or via activated charcoal canis- As discussed earlier in this chapter, transport is
ters. Direct exhaust can be safe and very cost‐ the act of going into surrounding communi-
effective, but requires that the anesthesia ties, picking up the animals scheduled for ster-
machines are located near an outside wall or ilization surgeries, transporting them to the
www.ajlobby.com
Transport 583
stationary clinic, and then returning them to any way appear to be unhealthy to the driver,
the pick‐up site to be reunited with their care- he or she has the authority to decline transport
takers or owners. Transport to and from a facil- of that animal. This allows for the entire trans-
ity can be accomplished by either the host port population to be safeguarded by eliminat-
facility or the animal welfare groups that use ing a potentially detrimental exposure.
the clinic’s spay and neuter services. Equally essential is strict adherence to an
established schedule for cleaning and disinfec-
tion of the transport vehicle. In addition, travel
Transport Vehicle
kennels must be in good condition and must be
Transport requires its own set of policies to cleaned and sanitized between uses. These
ensure that the animals conveyed in the trans- kennels must allow the animal to be trans-
port unit will receive the same quality of care ported safely, prevent escape, and provide
during that phase as during their time in the accurate patient identification on both the ani-
clinic. The transport unit must be tailored to mal and the crate.
ensure animal safety. The truck in Figure 32.3 If a transport partner group experiences a
is actually the same type as a “box” ambulance. disease outbreak in its shelter or humane soci-
The rear compartment houses a separate cli- ety, it is essential that it notify the HQHVSN
mate control unit to provide ventilation, as well clinic so transport from that facility can be
as heat and air‐conditioning for patient com- canceled until the outbreak is under control.
fort on the trip. The animals travel in standard
travel crates that are secured to the wall of the
Transport Partner Requirements
unit by use of a rack system (Figure 32.4). The
driver is able to monitor the animals during the A local “Transport Coordinator” should be
trip via a “pass‐through” door that connects the identified who will take responsibility for
cab to the back. organizing all necessary components of the
process on‐site (at the pick‐up/drop‐off loca-
tion). This individual is the primary contact
Transport Infection Control
with the clinic and books the actual appoint-
and Safety
ments for the travel day. Transport partners
The driver is the first line of defense in moni- should contact the HQHVSN clinic three busi-
toring of patient health. Prior to loading the ness days prior to the travel date to confirm the
patients, the driver will do an inspection of the number of patients they have booked. This
patient inside its kennel. Should that animal in allows the clinic to add more appointments
www.ajlobby.com
584 32 Stationary Clinics
Patient Care dealing with the patient, including but not lim-
ited to anesthesia, analgesia, surgery, medical
The Association of Shelter Veterinarians’ records, physical examination, client commu-
(ASV) Spay Neuter Guidelines (Griffin et al. nication, infectious disease control, and pre‐,
2016) and the chapters in this textbook provide intra‐, and post‐operative care (Figures 32.6
excellent sources to draw upon to guide patient and 32.7). Box 32.1 describes a typical day at a
care. Patient care encompasses all aspects of stationary clinic.
www.ajlobby.com
Relationships with Area Veterinarians 585
7:00 a.m. Staff arrive and begin patient re-evaluation, incision inspection, and loading
transport animals from previous surgery day.
7:30 a.m. Clinic opens to public, verbal and written post-op instructions are given to
owners, and public animals from previous surgery day are released.
8:00 a.m. Public animal intake for the day. Pre-op physical examinations are
performed by clinic veterinarian(s).
9:00 a.m. Surgery schedule begins.
10:30 a.m. Transport arrives and is unloaded. If more than one vet, surgery continues
while the other vet(s) do intake and physical examinations. If only one vet,
that individual will stop surgeries and do physical examinations.
11:30 a.m. Return to surgery.
1:00 p.m. If only one vet, lunch break for 30 minutes; if more than one vet, staff cycle
through lunch break.
1:30 p.m. Return to surgery.
3:30 p.m. Surgery schedule complete, patients recovered, snack provided. Any
rechecks or other duties can be completed at this time.
www.ajlobby.com
586 32 Stationary Clinics
Figure 32.8 Post‐operative instructions encourage clients to establish care with a full‐service veterinary
practice.
veterinary staff. Many clinics do an open population through means other than euthana-
house when they begin, but it is a good idea sia. Any aspiration of this scope and magnitude
to continue to keep the invitation perpetual. can only be accomplished by securing the coop-
erative efforts of the veterinary community as a
It is vital to continue to foster these relation- whole. With that intention, the hope is to create
ships in order to further the HQHVSN mission a mutual spirit of cooperation with the veteri-
of reducing the unwanted companion animal narians in the region to encourage clients to
www.ajlobby.com
References 587
References
ASPCAPRO (2018). ASPCA Spay/Neuter anesthesia. J. Am. Assoc. Lab. Anim. Sci. 42:
Alliance. https://www.aspcapro.org/about‐ 10–15.
programs‐services/aspca‐spayneuter‐alliance Spay FIRST! (2017). Mini clinics. http://www.
(accessed 7 July 2018). spayfirst.org/programs/remote‐area‐
Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., Mccobb, E. et al. (2016). programs/spay‐pods (accessed 7 July 2018).
The Association of Shelter Veterinarians’ 2016 United States Department of Justice Civil Rights
veterinary medical care guidelines for spay‐ Division (2010). Americans with Disabilities
neuter programs. JAVMA 249: 165–188. Act: Public Accommodations and Commercial
Smith, J.C. and Bolon, B. (2003). Comparison of Facilities (Title III). https://www.ada.gov/
three commercially available activated ada_title_III.htm (accessed 18 November
charcoal canisters for passive scavenging of 2018).
waste isoflurane during conventional rodent
www.ajlobby.com
www.ajlobby.com
589
33
Mobile clinics are self‐contained units that mobile unit will require inspection, registra-
travel to or within various communities to per- tion, and insurance. Some units, depending on
form spays and neuters for cats and dogs. size, weight, or presence of air brakes, may
Surgery is performed on the unit and animals require the driver to possess a commercial
are discharged on the same day following driver’s license (CDL).
spay–neuter. Mobile clinics are utilized in
rural, suburban, and urban environments.
Some mobile clinics perform spay–neuter for Organizational Structure
one day at a particular site, while others remain Some not‐for‐profit organizations exist exclu-
on‐site for multiple days in a row. A major sively to operate a mobile spay–neuter clinic,
advantage of mobile spay–neuter clinics is that while other mobile clinics are operated by
they travel to targeted locations to provide vet- humane societies, municipal animal shelters,
erinary care to underserved animal popula- societies for the prevention of cruelty to ani-
tions and eliminate “transportation issues” as mals (SPCAs), stationary spay–neuter clinics,
a barrier to obtaining spay–neuter. or veterinary schools. Veterinarians may also
provide spay–neuter in addition to other vet-
erinary services aboard for‐profit mobile vet-
Mobile Clinic Requirements erinary clinics.
and Structure
Legal/Regulatory Issues Financial Considerations
Before considering implementation of a mobile When starting a mobile spay–neuter clinic, an
spay–neuter clinic, both state and local veteri- organization needs to raise funds to purchase
nary laws and regulations should be reviewed the unit and, if necessary, a truck to pull the
to ensure that operation of such a clinic is per- unit (or arrange for financing for these items).
mitted. One also needs to determine if any spe- Since a new program may not function at full
cific requirements need to be met. For example, capacity for the first few months, the program
does a veterinarian need to own the mobile should have adequate funds to cover opera-
spay–neuter clinic? Is a premise permit neces- tional costs (such as supplies and wages) dur-
sary to operate the clinic? Additionally, the ing this time.
www.ajlobby.com
590 33 Profile of the Mobile Spay–Neuter Clinic
Facilities
Mobile spay–neuter clinics vary greatly in their
size as well as in the number and configuration
of on‐board cages. Clinics may be contained Figure 33.1 Mobile spay–neuter clinic of Spay/
within a trailer that is pulled behind a truck or Neuter/Now, Hammond, NY. Total length of clinic is
27 ft., maximum number of cages is 12. Spays–
have a truck cab incorporated into the clinic
neuters owned cats/small dogs and free‐roaming
(see Figures 33.1–33.3). One advantage of a cats. Utilizes off‐board recovery as needed. Source:
pull‐behind clinic is that if the truck needs Photo courtesy of Kevin Mace.
www.ajlobby.com
Mobile Clinic Requirements and Structure 591
(a) (c)
(b)
(d)
Figure 33.2 Mobile spay–neuter clinic of The Fix Is In Spay/Neuter Clinic in Wisconsin. (a) The unit is a
26 ft. converted box truck from Magnum Mobile in Phoenix, AZ. (b) It has 4 shelves for cat carriers and 13
kennels. (c) Four pairs of kennels have a removable wall between them, so they can be converted to larger
cages for medium‐sized dogs. (d) This mobile unit utilizes two surgery tables (one regular surgery table and
one adjustable‐height utility cart) and saves space in the surgery area by positioning one side of each
surgery table against the wall. The mobile unit aims to perform 40+ surgeries per day and, due to size
constraints, works mostly with cats and small or medium dogs. Source: Photos courtesy of Brooke Groskopf.
www.ajlobby.com
592 33 Profile of the Mobile Spay–Neuter Clinic
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
Figure 33.3 Mobile unit utilized by Kansas State University College of Veterinary Medicine. (a) The unit is
a 32 ft. trailer pulled by a F350 truck. The unit travels with one faculty member, one registered veterinary
technician, and three students at a time, and serves shelter animals and community cats. (b) The trailer
contains a total of 12 cages, 6 on either side, stacked 3 high and 2 across. One side (6 cages) has the ability
to be heated. The bottom kennels on both sides can have the divider removed to be larger. Patients are
rotated on and off the trailer through the day, with early post‐operative recovery on board. (c) The unit
contains two surgery tables and a wet‐to‐dry prep table. Note the ample supply of latched drawers/cabinets
and the separate surgical suite. (d) The surgery tables are oriented to allow access to both sides of the table
for teaching purposes, and there is adequate space so that both tables may be used simultaneously. Source:
Photos courtesy of Kansas State University College of Veterinary Medicine.
building with electricity and running water is A disadvantage of this type of program is the
necessary. Such programs are considered to be need for animals to be moved between the
a hybrid between mobile spay–neuter and adjacent building and the clinic. Animals need
mobile animal sterilization hospital (MASH) to be sufficiently recovered on board before
programs. They allow veterinary staff to work they can be moved. Trained volunteers are
in a familiar and consistent setting while avoid- often utilized to move animals and provide
ing the loading/unloading of heavy medical adequate monitoring of animals who continue
equipment. Here, the program can purchase a their recovery in the off‐board location. If the
less expensive, cargo‐style trailer. Such units host organization does not provide crates for
should be insulated and retrofitted to include housing animals in the off‐board location, the
lights, a breaker box, and plumbing. An exam- hybrid program will need to travel with such
ple of an organization that utilizes this model is crates. (For instructions on how to clean and
Spay FIRST! (Figure 33.4). disinfect such crates, see Chapter 5).
Equipment 593
Scales
Obtaining an accurate weight for cats and dogs
will allow staff to determine appropriate anes-
thetic/analgesic drug volumes. A mechanical
baby scale may be used to weigh cats and a
digital platform scale is often used to weigh
dogs. In order to protect the weight receptors
in platform scales, they should be transported
on their side, adequately affixed to a wall, or
upside down lying on a blanket (Figure 33.8).
7:30 a.m.–8:00 a.m. Mobile spay–neuter clinic and staff arrive on site, greet clients,
set up clinic
8:00 a.m.–10:30 a.m. Patient admissions, physical examinations performed by veterinarian,
prepare drugs/medications
10:30 a.m.–11:00 a.m. Break
11:00 a.m.–3:00 p.m. Spays–neuters
3:00 p.m.–3:30 p.m. Monitor recovery, complete medical records, clean unit/equipment
3:30 p.m.–4:00 p.m. Break
4:00 p.m.–5:30 p.m. Discharge adequately recovered animal patients, finish cleaning/
disinfecting, run autoclave (if present on board mobile clinic)
5:30 p.m. Leave site
Note: The veterinarian should not leave the clinic until all patients are adequately recovered. If the driver is a
clinic staff member, he or she may be paid extra for driving the unit. Extra staff members may be necessary for
additional cleaning, laundry, and re‐stocking of the clinic.
References
34
MASH Clinics
Sara White
Mobile animal sterilization hospital or MASH practice acts and local regulations to be sure
clinics are a type of mobile spay–neuter pro- that MASH clinics are permitted. Some states
gram in which clinic staff transport surgical and provinces require premise permits for any
equipment to a venue and set up a temporary practice location, which may preclude MASH
surgical space in that location. Surgeries are clinics. However, in some cases, states or prov-
not performed in the MASH vehicle, but inces that require premise permits may allow
instead an existing space in the community is exemptions for MASH clinics if asked in
used. Examples of locations utilized by MASH advance.
clinics in various communities include animal
shelter buildings, church basements, animal
Location and Organization
care (grooming and boarding) facilities, fire
stations, town offices, school gymnasia, senior MASH clinics are adaptable and there are not
centers, and many more. specific prerequisites for regional population
MASH programs vary in the number of sur- density or shelter animal intake. They are suit-
geons, technicians, and support staff, the fre- able for rural areas where low population den-
quency of surgery days, the number of sity does not easily support a stationary clinic,
consecutive days at a single venue, and the as well as for densely populated urban areas.
mission and organizational structure. Some MASH clinics are valuable for local shelters
MASH programs work independently of other that wish to provide in‐house high‐quality
humane organizations (independent MASH high‐volume spay–neuter (HQHVSN), but
programs), while others conduct all their work either cannot afford to build and equip their
in collaboration with other humane organiza- own surgical suites, or have surgical areas but
tions (collaborative MASH programs). lack veterinary staff. MASH clinics are also
suitable for international and remote‐area
spay–neuter programs.
MASH Clinic Requirements For a veterinarian with surgery skills seek-
ing spay–neuter work, establishing a MASH
and Structure
clinic can be one of the fastest and lowest cost
ways of starting a HQHVSN clinic. In most
Legal
cases, veterinarians who choose this route
Before considering a MASH clinic, be certain to should be willing to operate the business
check any relevant state or provincial veterinary aspects of the clinic and be able and willing to
602 34 MASH Clinics
work with shelters and humane organizations personnel, consisting of two to five staff mem-
in their target region. bers or volunteers, while the MASH program
In some cases, programs with limited startup (or “surgery team”) provides the veterinarian,
funds may wish to offer surgery services before the technician, and all surgical supplies and
fundraising is complete or before a clinic site is equipment. The host organization is responsi-
located for a future stationary clinic. In this ble for scheduling, admitting, and discharging
case, a MASH clinic may serve as a temporary, patients, and for printing, preparing, and dis-
economical option during the development of tributing clinic paperwork such as medical
the HQHVSN program. Since any equipment record forms, liability releases, discharge
purchased for MASH can be used in other instructions, rabies certificates, and neuter
models, the MASH clinic provides the oppor- certificates. Host groups are often required to
tunity for quicker startup without loss of provide non‐medical supplies such as tables,
equipment investment. chairs, animal bedding, extra pet carriers, and
While MASH programs are diverse, this trash receptacles. In these collaborative pro-
chapter will focus on programs that utilize grams, the MASH group generally works with
paid veterinarian(s) and technician(s) and several different host organizations through-
operate within a prescribed region (as opposed out its service area to host clinic days. At times,
to national or international scope). However, more than one local humane group may work
many of the descriptions in this chapter may together to host a MASH clinic.
be adapted to MASH programs that operate Collaborative MASH programs empower
internationally and/or use volunteer veterinar- small humane organizations and shelters to
ians and technicians. For information on set- host their own “Spay Days,” affording them
ting up international or remote‐area MASH the chance to enhance their community rela-
clinics, the reader is referred to Susan Monger’s tions and outreach. The opportunity to host
chapter on operating a field spay–neuter clinic and assist with a MASH clinic enables staff
in the Field Manual for Small Animal Medicine and volunteers at host shelters to do some-
(Monger 2018). thing “fun” and different, compared to their
usual shelter duties. These collaborations also
allow opportunities for MASH clinic staff to
Independent versus Collaborative
share information and best practices for shel-
MASH Programs
ter medicine and HQHVSN with their host
MASH programs can operate their clinics inde- organizations.
pendently of other humane organizations in a Generally, it is the responsibility of the
region or may collaborate with other humane MASH organization to provide training and
or community organizations to host their clin- mentorship to new or potential new host
ics. Some MASH clinics may use a combina- organizations. Before hosting their first clinic,
tion of these two approaches. There are host organizations will need to know how to
advantages and disadvantages to each of these schedule the appropriate surgical load and
models. how to determine the number and skill level of
volunteers required. They need to understand
Collaborative MASH Programs the paperwork and be able to provide appropri-
Collaborative MASH programs are generally ate pre‐ and post‐operative instructions to cli-
small organizations that collaborate with vari- ents. An in‐person meeting between the MASH
ous local humane or community groups that organization and potential new hosts, along
act as their hosts in the communities within with written instructions on hosting protocols
their service area. These host groups (or and expectations, is recommended prior to the
“ground teams”) must provide the venue and first clinic.
MASH Clinic Requirements and Structure 603
(a) (b)
Figure 34.1 The arts and crafts area at a local elementary school (a) is transformed into a surgical suite
(b) in Cabrera, Dominican Republic. Source: Photo courtesy of Cristie Kamiya.
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 34.2 Animal housing at MASH clinics. (a) Dogs are housed in wire crates provided by the host
organization at a MASH clinic in New Hampshire. (b) Cats are housed in the carriers in which they
arrived. A shelter in Vermont has constructed a shelving unit to save floor space while housing cats.
(c) Cats may arrive in inappropriate containers and should be transferred to appropriate housing for
the day.
in their traps. It is wise to have additional crates c linics, and this organization exists solely for the
available in which to house cats who arrive in purpose of offering MASH clinics.
inappropriate or inadequate housing.
Financial Investments and Ongoing
Organizational Structure Costs
MASH clinics may be established within any Financial requirements for a MASH clinic are
organizational structure, including nonprofit, generally much lower than for a stationary
for‐profit, and government or tribal entities. clinic or self‐contained mobile unit. There will
In some cases, MASH clinics may represent a also be some differences in the initial invest-
single program within a large, diverse existing ments between MASH clinics following a
organization. For example, an animal shelter collaborative model versus an independent
with an in‐house spay–neuter clinic may develop model. In all MASH clinics, the major initial
a MASH program to reach certain communities costs will include acquisition of a vehicle,
in its service area. In others, a new organization surgical and anesthetic equipment, initial
is formed for the purpose of offering MASH consumable supplies (for example, drugs,
606 34 MASH Clinics
Equipment
Figure 34.3 MASH vehicle. This Kia Soul is used
Equipment requirements for a MASH clinic exclusively for MASH spay–neuter and transports
are similar to those in other clinic types, but all veterinarian, technician, and equipment to venues.
608 34 MASH Clinics
Figure 34.4 Tabletop anesthetic machine (a) with a Tec 4 vaporizer (b). Oxygen is supplied via an E
cylinder (c) in a wheeled oxygen cylinder cart, attached with a regulator and oxygen hose.
Figure 34.5 Passive anesthetic gas scavenging options (a) through a window; (b) through a hole made in
the wall; (c) via a charcoal absorber canister.
Protocols and Equipment 609
Figure 34.12 Volunteers admit patients to a MASH surgery day for cats at an American Legion Post in
New Hampshire. Most MASH clinics use the carriers in which the animals arrive at the clinic as animal
housing for the day, as built‐in clinic cages are generally not available.
be optimized, although not every venue will example in Box 34.3, the total day length for
lend itself to smooth flow between pre‐op, the veterinarian and technician may be
prep, surgery, recovery, and post‐op areas. 11 hours, whereas the surgery time is only
4–5 hours. Thus, more than half the staff’s
time is spent driving, setting up, and re‐pack-
Clinic Flow
ing the surgery area. This time budget may be
Clinic flow in a MASH program may be some- improved somewhat by changing clinic poli-
what slower than flow in a stationary clinic. cies: driving time may be reduced by restrict-
Typically, a MASH clinic has one surgery table ing the travel radius, and setup and takedown
per surgeon, such that the surgeon must wait time may be reduced if the clinic is located in
while patients are exchanged on the table. To the same venue for multiple days.
improve flow while working on cats, the sur- The time required for these additional
geon may alternate male and female cats, cas- tasks of driving, setting up, and packing
trating male cats on a side table or countertop means that MASH clinics are not the most
while female cats are exchanged on the surgery efficient clinic model in regard to use of the
table (see Figure 34.13). MASH clinics also veterinarian’s and technician’s professional
usually have only one prep station, which may time. A MASH that employs only one veteri-
be the rate‐limiting step during fast surgeries. narian and one technician may be operating
Also, since clinic layout and staffing vary “full‐time” (36–40 hours a week) with just
between locations, ideal flow may not be 3 clinics – or about 100 surgeries – per week,
achievable at each clinic site. if the technician is also preparing packs
between surgery days, and the veterinarian
is acting as administrator and business
Clinic Day
manager. However, despite achieving
The MASH clinic day includes travel, setup, fewer s urgeries per full‐time veterinarian,
and re‐packing, in addition to the usual tasks the lower overhead costs mean that the
related to operating a HQHVSN clinic such cost per surgery is equivalent to that of a
as performing patient exams, anesthetic stationary clinic. This allows MASH clinics
procedures, and surgery. As can be seen in the to pay hourly wages to the veterinarian and
References 613
Figure 34.13 Surgery area at a MASH surgery day for cats at an American Legion Post in New Hampshire.
Female cats are placed on the surgery table to the left in the photo, and male cat neuters take place on the
table on the right. At this clinic, the surgeon stands for cat spays and sits for cat neuters.
References
Griffin, B., Bushby, P.A., McCobb, E. et al. Medicine (eds. K. Polak and A.T. Kommedal).
(2016). The Association of Shelter Hoboken, NJ: Wiley https://doi.
Veterinarians’ 2016 veterinary medical care org/10.1002/9781119380528.ch5.
guidelines for spay‐neuter programs. JAVMA Scott, D.M. (1991). Performance of BOC Ohmeda
249: 165–188. Tec 3 and Tec 4 vaporisers following tipping.
Monger, S. (2018). Operating a field spay/neuter Anaesth. Intens. Care 19: 441–443.
clinic. In: Field Manual for Small Animal
615
35
successful trapping and support for humane, regarding the mission is whether to limit
safe care during transport and recovery after surgeries to feral cats, or whether to accept all
surgery. Clinics may accept the responsibility free‐roaming cats for surgery. Because all feral
for training, or they may refer people to the cats ultimately come from unaltered pet cats,
many resources available via the internet. the general wisdom is to achieve feral cat pre-
Collaborative clinics partner with rescue vention by accepting all community cats for
groups and experienced hobby trappers who spay–neuter. Furthermore, since a fractious
trap cats for other people. Hobby trappers typi- pet cat is indistinguishable from a feral cat,
cally have better success and fill more surgery restricting a clinic to feral cats is logistically
spaces than people who are new to trapping. In impossible.
addition, rescue groups may train volunteers to
trap cats. With this structure, the clinic simply
Core Services
allots a block of reservations per group or trap-
per. This simplifies reservations, streamlines The most basic community cat clinic must pro-
the check‐in and check‐out process, and vide certain core services: safe and sufficient
reduces no‐shows. anesthesia, high‐quality surgical sterilization
with absorbable suture, rabies vaccine, ear‐tip-
ping, appropriate recovery monitoring and
Financial Investments and Ongoing
care, and euthanasia when indicated.
Costs
The financial investment for community cat
Individual Health versus
clinics is similar to any other feline spay–neu-
Population Control
ter clinic. If the clinic also loans traps (dis-
cussed later), then the financial investment in Because cats may arrive at sterilization clinics
high‐quality traps can be substantial. The pur- with additional health issues, the clinic’s mis-
chase of a squeeze cage and a couple of capture sion needs to be clear as to whether the goal is
nets is advisable, but does not constitute a to improve the individual lives of all commu-
large investment. The ongoing cost that differs nity cats or to maximize surgical sterilization
from typical spay–neuter clinics is rabies vac- for population control. It is not possible for the
cine, which is administered free of charge to mission to be both unless human and financial
all community cats. resources are unlimited. The more services
performed per cat, such as retroviral testing,
vaccines, and flea control, the fewer resources
Mission Control remain for spay–neuter. Consequently, clinics
that maximize population control will mini-
Taking the time to identify the clinic’s mission mize additional services. A middle ground is to
before embarking on a community cat clinic offer a few additional services, such as FVRCP
saves time, money and headaches. The mission vaccines and flea control, at a nominal fee
functions as the clinic’s compass, offering either to cover the clinic’s cost or with a profit
guidance to stay on course. The mission is the margin to subsidize surgery costs.
ultimate goal and must be central to all clinic
functions and decisions (see Chapter 28 for
Surgery Only versus Trapping
more on purpose and mission).
Assistance
Community cat clinics can be limited to surgi-
Feral versus Tame
cal sterilization without becoming involved in
Because community cats usually range from trapping. At the other extreme, clinics may pur-
truly feral cats to pet cats, the first decision chase traps, train trappers, organize trapping,
Create Clear Policies 617
and handle every aspect of TNR. Between these often suggested, but in reality euthanasia
extremes lies the surgical clinic that limits trap- should be based on health. A debilitated cat
ping assistance to loaning traps and training with a negative retroviral test result should still
people in how to use them. be euthanized, if it cannot be treated.
Clinics that offer trapping assistance need Euthanasia decisions must be delegated to a
human and financial resources sufficient to trusted, qualified person, because the decision
support trapping in addition to maximizing is more often unclear than straightforward.
surgery. The organization must consider the Questions to consider are: Can this cat find
responsibility and liability of sending volun- shelter? Find food? Escape predators? Survive
teers to trap cats on private or public property. without suffering? These are the quality‐of‐
life requirements for any community cat.
Consulting caregivers about the recent history
Create Clear Policies of difficult cases may offer valuable insight to
simplify the decision.
Once the mission is defined, clear policies help
prevent mission drift. Exceptions are expected,
Ear‐Tipping
but policies provide the structure needed to
maintain the mission. Ear‐tipping, the surgical removal of approxi-
mately 1 cm from the tip of one ear (see
Chapter 16), is a worldwide, universal mark of a
Retroviral Testing
surgically sterilized cat (Figure 35.1). It should be
Screening every cat for feline leukemia and noted that an ear tip does not mean the cat is
feline immunodeficiency virus is costly and behaviorally feral or that it ever was, nor does an
detracts from the mission to reduce overpopu- ear tip indicate the cat has ever been rabies vac-
lation. If a community’s infection rate is 2%, cinated or that a rabies vaccine is current. A visi-
then the cost of identifying one positive cat ble ear tip is meant to prevent future trapping and
equals the cost of 50 tests. Furthermore, low unnecessary surgery; in essence, the ear tip pro-
disease prevalence combined with the specific- tects the cat. Ear tips also keep clinic reservations
ity and sensitivity of retroviral tests leads to and resources directed toward unsterilized cats.
false positives and potential euthanasia of
healthy, uninfected cats. The original feral cat
clinics in the 1980s and 1990s viral tested early
in their programs and later discontinued test-
ing, due to high cost and low disease preva-
lence. Experts agree with the current strategy
that resources should be prioritized for surgi-
cal sterilization.
Euthanasia
According to a large‐scale study of over 100 000
cats, an average of 0.4% cats presented to com-
munity cat clinics required euthanasia
(Wallace and Levy 2006). When a cat’s condi-
tion appears too poor to survive surgery and
live a humane lifestyle in its free‐roaming
Figure 35.1 Ear tips are the international
home, euthanasia must be considered. standard verifying surgical sterilization, but do not
Retroviral testing cats in poor condition is indicate the cat is feral or ever was.
618 35 Feral and Free‐Roaming Cat Clinics
Several ear‐tipping dilemmas should be paradigm spends more money per cat and
addressed in the ear‐tipping policy. One is performs fewer surgical sterilizations. Some
whether to ear tip feral kittens that may clinics provide dentals, all vaccines, viral test-
become adoptable after fostering. If the ear‐ ing, parasite treatment, grooming, and more.
tipped kittens become adoptable, the ear tip Ear mite treatment, flea control, deworming,
becomes unnecessary. In the author’s experi- and vaccination for panleukopenia, upper res-
ence, ear tips do not make kittens or cats less piratory viruses, and retroviruses are consid-
adoptable and are worth performing during ered optional, because they target individual
surgical sterilization in case the kittens must health.
return to their colony. Limiting additional procedures translates
Another policy issue is whether to ear tip into more surgical sterilizations; however, even
tame community cats believed not to have a basic spay–neuter clinic can perform some
owners. If they are unaltered, then ear‐tipping basic services in special circumstances without
seems a clear choice, but already altered tame significantly impacting resources or efficiency.
cats without a microchip or collar might have For example, benefits from the occasional tail
an owner. amputation, enucleation, abscess flush, basic
Ear‐tip size must be policy. All ear tips wound care, deeply positioned polydactyl nail
should be 1 cm, and proportionately less for declaw, or flea control for severely infested kit-
kittens. Caregivers often request small ear tips, tens or cats require minimal resources in addi-
but minimizing an ear tip for cosmetic pur- tion to surgical sterilization.
poses risks negating the entire goal: to protect Although there is an emotional reward for
the cat from repeated trapping, transport, treating external parasites, these infestations
anesthesia, and surgery. Small ear tips are are not cured with one treatment, and reinfesta-
much more likely to be overlooked once the tion occurs after return to a colony; conse-
ear heals and the hair regrows. quently, resources allocated for these services
would be better redirected toward spay–neuter.
Rabies Vaccination
Bite Injuries to People
Because of public health implications, all cats
presented to community cat clinics should be Protocols must be in place to prevent cat bite
vaccinated for rabies unless an owner is injuries, but nonetheless, bites will occur. Bite
located. Use of a three‐year vaccine is recom- victims should always seek medical care. The
mended, if it complies with local and state local public health department can assist with
legal requirements. Manufacturer’s recom- developing a protocol regarding the cat, which
mendations should be followed according to would either consist of quarantine or euthana-
the minimum age. Kittens too young to vacci- sia and rabies testing. Bites are typically pro-
nate may stay in foster until old enough to voked; that is, a conscious cat is frightened and
vaccinate. defensive, or the cat is not fully sedated when
being handled. Clinics should consider restrict-
ing involvement of volunteers or staff that
Additional Services
repeatedly break protocols and put themselves
In addition to core services, which additional and cats at risk.
services to provide depends on the financial
and human resources as well as the primary
Containment
mission: individual health or population con-
trol. When the health of each cat is the pri- Clinics must set a policy for whether cats can
mary mission and resources are finite, this be brought only in traps or in any other type of
Create Clear Policies 619
Bite Incidents
Safety Measures Anyone sustaining a bite or scratch should
immediately seek medical attention. Typically,
The primary difference between a community the local health department dictates whether a
cat clinic and a standard feline clinic is cat cat should be quarantined or euthanized and
Additional Equipment 621
(a) (b)
Figure 35.2 (a) The trap tipped on end and (b) using a trap divider to restrain the cat for injection.
Additional Equipment
Capture Net
While many protocols aim to prevent loose
cats, invariably a cat escapes. Using bare
hands, gloves, or a towel does not protect
against injury. Capture nets specific for
(b)
catching cats, such as the Freeman Cage net
(freemancanada.com), prevent injury to cats
and people. When one is used correctly, one
person can catch and restrain the cat, and
administer an anesthetic injection. Fishing
nets should not be used, because they are
insufficient for ideal restraint and the nylon
netting can injure the cats (Figure 35.3a and b).
(a) (b)
Figure 35.4 Transferring a cat from a carrier to a squeeze cage (a) provides safe restraint (b) for the
anesthetic injection.
Trap Divider/Comb
Trap dividers or combs are used to restrain the
cat for anesthetic induction (http://livetrap.
com). Dividers also contain the cat in order to Figure 35.5 Trap types: the trap on the left has
one trap door and one closed end. The style on the
remove food. right with one guillotine door and one trap door is
preferable.
Traps
and comforters work well. Fitted trap covers are
If a clinic elects to purchase traps for loaning
available commercially.
or for a trapping program, there are many
brands and styles available, all at different
costs. Some function more smoothly or are Protocols
more durable. Styles with a guillotine door on
one end are most useful for removing sedated Anesthesia
cats and transferring conscious cats into carri-
ers (Figure 35.5). Anesthetic Cocktails
To avoid handling a conscious cat, an intra-
muscular injectable regimen is required. A
Trap Covers
long‐acting combination of Telazol® (Zoetis,
Trap coverings should be inexpensive, washable, Parsippany, NJ; tiletamine 50 mg/ml and zolaz-
and easy to put on and take off. Sheets and tow- epam 50 mg/ml when reconstituted) reconsti-
els are sufficient. In colder climates, blankets tuted with 4 ml ketamine and 1 ml xylazine
Protocols 623
(100 mg/ml) instead of sterile water is used as Using a trap divider or comb further restrains
the sole anesthetic regimen (see Chapter 8) for the cat for the injection. (see Figures 35.2). The
clinics with lengthy processing of cats through squeeze cage has one movable side used to
all procedures. A shorter‐acting combination compress the cat against the opposite wall.
of Telazol reconstituted with 4 ml ketamine This provides humane and safe restraint for
and 1 ml xylazine (20 mg/ml), nicknamed injection (see Figure 35.3).
TKX20 by the author, works well for clinics in Any accessible muscle mass can be used for
which cats are processed more quickly. The injection; paralumbar and thigh muscles are
TKX20 cocktail is also ideal for induction fol- typically simplest. Before inducing anesthesia,
lowed by mask isoflurane. TKX20 for compro- all cats must be scrutinized for an ear tip on
mised cats may promote more rapid recovery, either ear. If they are ear tipped, anesthesia is
as well as for lactating queens when prompt not needed.
return to kittens is needed. Other injectable
cocktails are widely used in typical spay–neu-
Vomiting
ter clinics, but TKX is more cost effective and is
Xylazine can induce vomiting, thus close mon-
well established for its safety in community
itoring can literally be life‐saving, particularly
cats whose medical histories are unavailable
at induction. If vomiting begins, conscious cats
(Williams et al. 2002). In a study of over 100 000
should not be removed from the trap because
community cats, the death rate with TKX pro-
of bite risk. Instead, lowering the cat’s head by
tocols averaged 0.4% or 4/1000 cats (Wallace
tipping the trap or cage is safest. If the cat is too
and Levy 2006).
conscious to remove but too sedate to clear its
own mouth, a long spoon can be inserted
Anesthetic Dosing
through the trap to remove food from the cat’s
Since handling conscious cats is prohibited,
mouth. Once safely sedated, the cat can be
the anesthetic dose is an estimate, not a calcu-
removed and the mouth cleared with a spoon,
lation based on actual body weight. Many clin-
not fingers! Many bite wounds that occur in
ics simply categorize patients into small/kitten,
community cat clinics are from people insert-
medium/average, and large/tomcat and pre‐
ing their fingers into a cat’s mouth.
draw the anesthetic into three doses of 0.125,
0.25, and 0.3 ml, respectively. The relatively
low incidence of adverse reactions after esti- Supplemental Anesthesia
mated doses attests to the relative safety of For fast‐paced clinics, the TKX20 is ideal,
TKX at both concentrations. An alternative because cats recover sooner for earlier dis-
method is TKX20 dosed at 0.02 ml/lb estimated charge. If cats need additional anesthesia, then
body weight by 0.5 lb. People who estimate cat supplemental masking with isoflurane works
weights consistently develop skill and become well without putting staff at risk of being bitten
quite accurate. when intubating. If nasal breathing is compro-
Alternatively, some clinics know the actual mised, then endotracheal intubation should be
or approximate weight of the traps, so are able considered.
to weigh the cat in the trap and then subtract If gas anesthesia is unavailable, then one‐
the weight of the trap to determine the weight quarter to one‐third of the original dose of
of the cat for drug dosing purposes. TKX20 or TKX100 given subcutaneously or
intramuscularly is a good starting point to
Anesthetic Injection Technique lengthen anesthesia. Careful monitoring is
When using a trap or squeeze cage, anesthetic advised whenever subsequent injections are
administration is straightforward. By tipping required. Yohimbine can be used for reversal,
the trap on end, the cat is moderately confined. as needed.
624 35 Feral and Free‐Roaming Cat Clinics
Large tomcats are commonly presented. While Cats recover from TKX very well as a rule, but
the castration technique is the same as for post‐op monitoring must be rigorous. Delayed
younger male cats, the tunics and vessels in a recovery is most commonly caused by low body
large tomcat are more prone to loosening and temperature and/or higher relative dose of
bleeding. When using self‐tie techniques, sur- anesthesia. Close monitoring of breathing and
geons must ensure the knots are very tight, and consciousness reveals problems sooner, when
the cords are not cut too close to the knots. For treatment is more likely to be successful.
cryptorchid cats, absorbable suture is used for Recovering cats can be safely assessed and
skin closure. stimulated without direct handling by moving
the cage/trap or prodding with a dowel. If a cat
cannot be aroused, then it should be removed
Pain Relief from its trap/cage and evaluated, paying par-
Buprenorphine is a pain relief medication that ticular attention to body temperature, mucous
meets all the requirements of community cat membrane color, and pulse rate and quality.
clinics because of its efficacy and safety in Providing supplemental heat and stimulation,
cats with unknown medical histories. for example by moving the legs, flipping the cat
Buprenorphine may be administered by intra- over, patting its chest, and so on, usually
muscular injection. enhances recovery in the absence of more seri-
Non‐steroidal anti‐inflammatory drugs ous complications, such as hemorrhage.
(NSAIDs) are not advised for dehydrated
patients, thus their use in community cat clin-
Re‐anesthetizing
ics is undesirable or should be implemented
with caution. Some community cat clinics If a cat needs to be re‐anesthetized, a second
have successfully incorporated Onsior® (robe- dose of TKX can be used at one‐quarter the origi-
nacoxib; Elanco Animal Health, Greenfield, nal dose, or more depending on the cat’s level of
IN) injections into their community cat clinic consciousness. Netting the cat and masking with
protocols. gas anesthesia is an alternative; however, the
626 35 Feral and Free‐Roaming Cat Clinics
References
Wallace, J.L. and Levy, J.K. (2006). Population Williams, L.S., Levy, J.K., Robertson, S.A. et al.
characteristics of feral cats admitted to seven (2002). Use of anesthetic combination of
trap‐neuter‐return programs in the United tiletamine, zolazepam, ketamine and xylazine for
States. J. Feline Med. Surg. 8: 279–284. neutering feral cats. JAVMA 220 (10): 1491–1495.
627
36
In‐Clinic Clinics
Ruth Steinberger
Where Are In‐Clinic Clinics Best expected of them and must be able to commu-
Suited? nicate well with the other.
In‐clinic clinics are best suited to private
Many rural communities have a high propor-
practice veterinary hospitals that are reasona-
tion of low‐income households, yet lack the
bly well equipped for small animal surgery,
population or financial resources needed to
with a good surgery team, and with staff that
support full‐time HQHVSN programs. In areas
are on board and comfortable with animal wel-
with low population density or in communities
fare programs. Physical considerations include
in which a limited number of services are
whether the facility can handle the additional
needed (such as around college student hous-
animals one morning a week or on a day off,
ing), in‐clinic clinics can be an ideal way to
and whether existing equipment will work, at
eliminate pet overpopulation, change pet‐care
least during start‐up.
habits, and generate revenue.
An animal welfare organization that is a
In‐clinic clinics are ideal for:
nonprofit (as recognized by the Internal
●● Communities with populations under 25 000 Revenue Service) is the best partner. While vol-
people unteer teams can raise funds through bake
●● Providing spay–neuter prior to adoption or sales and car washes, gaining nonprofit status
release from local shelters should be the goal of an animal welfare part-
●● Programs that target specific populations, ner that does not already have that status.
for example feral cats. If there is a stand‐alone spay–neuter clinic
within the region, a visit to that clinic can help
the veterinarian and their staff get some ideas
How In‐Clinic Clinics Work for increasing their efficiency and implement-
ing high‐volume flow as they move forward.
The key to this clinic model lies in isolating the
time block for reduced‐cost surgeries from the
practice’s regular work time. In‐clinic clinics Benefits of In‐Clinic Clinics
operate during a dedicated time block that oth-
The benefits for the animal hospital include
erwise would be idle or slow time, or during
using isolated “downtime” to capture revenue
which the veterinary hospital would normally
not coming into any veterinary practice, to pro-
be closed, and thus do not compete with the
vide a positive community service, and possi-
veterinary hospital’s regular workload. During
bly to gain some future clients.
this dedicated time block, in‐clinic clinics
Benefits to the animal welfare organization
operate, as much as possible, in a high‐volume
include:
model, and extra surgeries can be scheduled to
compensate for probable no‐shows. ●● The surgery program is run by the veterinary
In‐clinic clinics have most of the same hospital itself, so it is easy for inexperienced
components as other spay–neuter programs. volunteers to do their part.
Overall, these tasks include outreach to clients, ●● No major capital fundraising is needed for
outreach to the community (advertising), and start‐up. Funds raised by the welfare group
the surgeries themselves, with the tasks mainly provide a sliding scale to clients una-
divided between the veterinary hospital and ble to afford the costs of the surgeries.
the organization. Each part of the team (the ●● Eliminates competing for weekends (or
veterinary hospital and the animal welfare other time slots) from a visiting mobile unit,
organization) has set responsibilities. Each if such services are even available in the
must have a clear understanding of what is community.
Organization 629
Whole Day or Partial Day? short time block within the normal day, so it is
less disruptive to everyone’s schedule. Most
The two models of in‐clinic clinics are:
veterinary hospitals can provide five to eight
●● Holding a clinic on a day in which the veteri- surgeries in a two‐hour block. The humane
nary hospital is otherwise closed (usually organization does the scheduling, income
monthly) and planning to do 35 surgeries on screening, and outreach. Although staff time is
that day. used, it is during the regular workday so over-
●● “Bunching” a few slower hours together head is not increased.
(usually one morning a week) and perform- A potential drawback to this model is that
ing up to 15 surgeries in that time. because it is on weekdays when the veterinary
hospital staff are likely to be responsible for
All‐Day Clinics on “Closed” Days check‐in, some staff may resent what they per-
Operating on a day that the veterinary hospital ceive as “extra” work and/or feel challenged by
would otherwise be closed enables busy veteri- a different clientele. If the staff are not on
nary hospitals that cannot make time within board, a weekend all‐day in‐clinic clinic pro-
their regular schedule to participate. The draw- gram that relies more heavily on volunteers
backs to holding clinics on a day the veterinary should be considered (see previous section).
hospital is otherwise closed include that staff
members lose a day off that they may count on
for family time, that at least one experienced Organization
staff person must be hired for the day, and that
volunteers must be on‐site throughout recov- No two veterinary hospitals are exactly alike
ery, check‐out, and clean‐up. This type of pro- and each in‐clinic clinic must be tailored to its
gram relies on heavily on volunteers, so home base.
committed and consistent volunteers are The duties in running an in‐clinic clinic pro-
required. gram are basically the same as in any other
Since all‐day clinics are often held monthly, type of spay–neuter program. What is most
this lower frequency makes it necessary to important is that the tasks must be clearly
make separate plans for pregnant animals. defined between the veterinary hospital and
Also, the longer people wait for services, the the volunteer base, with special attention paid
more likely they are to be a no‐show, no longer to communication between the two. The vol-
have the money, or no longer own the pet. unteer organization should assign one person
to be the program coordinator; this person will
Partial‐Day Clinics during the Work be the primary “go‐to” person for the veteri-
Week nary hospital’s communication needs. While
Scheduling smaller blocks of time during the the entire volunteer team should be familiar
regular work week (two to three hours) can be with the program, the point person should be
less disruptive than full‐day clinics. Although available for the veterinary hospital to reach
the in‐clinic clinic is held during the week, regarding necessary supplies, client issues, and
regular clients are not scheduled during those so on. Also, the veterinary hospital may find it
hours. While volunteers may be needed at helpful to have one person who oversees the
check‐in, the rest of the day is handled by the supplies that are used for the in‐clinic clinics
regular staff that are already on‐site. and primarily communicates with the volun-
Benefits to holding weekly clinics during teer point person. The greater the level of
regular hours include that a veterinary hospi- organization, the fewer misunderstandings
tal with some “downtime” can make use of a there will be.
630 36 In‐Clinic Clinics
Task Partitioning between Private eople who receive no public benefits. For the
p
Practice and Humane Organization programs in which the hospital staff check in
the clients, clients are reminded to bring proof
Some of the tasks (i.e. “who does what”)
of income.
change depending on whether the clinic is
The procedures should be streamlined when
held during the work week or on a day the vet-
it is possible to do so. For example, in an ani-
erinary hospital is closed. For example, in a
mal hospital that is fully computerized, the
clinic that is held one morning a week, volun-
animal welfare partner may complete the cli-
teers would not be expected to be on‐site to
ents’ intake “form” over the phone and email it
wash instruments or complete other on‐site
to the animal hospital receptionist the night
tasks.
before surgery. The client then simply brings
However, the animal welfare partner is
the pet and their proof of income. If the system
always responsible for advertising, contacting
is on paper, the check‐in can take place in the
social service and/or animal control agencies,
animal hospital or at off‐site locations such as
receiving calls and scheduling the surgeries,
a social services office.
income screening, and making reminder calls
with the pre‐op instructions. The animal wel-
fare partner is also responsible for fundraising Budget
for any sliding scale that is offered to clients.
A very limited amount of funding is needed to
The veterinary hospital is always responsible
start an in‐clinic clinic. Funds are needed for a
for developing the pre‐op instructions, exams,
dedicated phone line, advertising, postering,
the surgery, check‐out information, and after-
and paperwork. Having a separate phone num-
care if needed.
ber for spay–neuter appointments enables the
humane organization to advertise the program
Coordinating Client Booking
and prevents the veterinary hospital reception-
An online document system enables multiple
ist from having to discern which callers are
volunteers to schedule the clinic days without
seeking the low‐income services. This is vital
overbooking and enables the veterinary hospi-
unless the animal hospital itself is dedicated to
tal staff to see the appointments that are
taking over a portion of the animal welfare
booked for the upcoming clinic. In the absence
tasks.
of such an electronic system, the humane
The income from providing 10 surgeries per
organization will email or fax a list of clients to
week at $45 per surgery is $22 500 over the
the receptionist the evening before the clinic.
course of 50 weeks. Most clinics limit payment
for these services to cash, money orders, or
Income Screening credit cards. If a sliding scale is provided, the
Many in‐clinic clinics elect to screen client remainder is raised by the animal welfare
income. Income screening over the phone is partner.
simple and straightforward. Income screening
can be based on a household income level
Organizing Animals and Medical
(such as $35 000 per year) or those receiving
Records
Food Stamps, or eligible for the Special
Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Clear patient identification is vital, as it is easy
Infants and Children (WIC), Medicare, or to have confusion between patients (especially
Department of Housing and Urban cats) when a greater number of patients enter
Development (HUD) public housing. Using an the clinic than the staff is used to handling.
overall household income level enables the One way to achieve this is via a standard num-
program to include low‐income working bering system. The chart or intake paperwork
Common Pitfalls 631
(a) (b)
(c)
Figure 36.1 (a) Intake supplies are kept together in a plastic tub. (b) The tub will hold forms, aftercare
instructions, pens, paper collars, and other marking supplies. (c) Clipboards with intake forms are also made
available at the intake desk.
632 36 In‐Clinic Clinics
Pricing Transparency
Added or hidden charges are another major
pitfall for in‐clinic clinics. The total amount of
money that the client should expect to pay
should be included up front in the price that is
advertised. Clients who were asked to prove
Figure 36.2 A V‐tray atop a clinic tabletop can that they have a low income and are then hit
create an additional prep station. Ultimately, with extra charges often perceive this as a “bait
adding surgery packs, V‐trays, and a few other
items may be helpful in increasing capacity and and switch,” something that results in bad
facilitating flow. word of mouth. For the program to succeed,
low‐income clients must recommend it to
erceiving the clients as misusing the program
p friends. Poor attitude from staff or upselling to
(feeling that someone has too much money to get a few extra dollars from the clients will
use the program), and/or the humane organi- damage the program. The revenue should be
zation asking for discounts on additional ser- generated by volume and increased by increas-
vices. Staff dissatisfaction is the single greatest ing volume only.
obstacle to these programs. The animal welfare
partner can help diffuse some of the percep-
tion of extra work by recognizing the staff’s Conclusion
effort and planning a way to say thank‐you, for
example providing lunch for the veterinary In‐clinic clinics provide a model for coopera-
hospital staff on the last Friday of every month. tion between local private veterinary hospitals
This does not need to be an expensive lunch, and animal welfare organizations, and are
but it tells the staff that they are indeed appre- well suited to low‐population communities
ciated. Making sure they are aware that the that would be unable to support a full‐time
number of surgeries they did has an impact is HQHVSN clinic. In‐clinic clinics provide low‐
also important. cost services using existing resources and can
be a win–win for both the veterinary hospital
and the animal welfare group. With the use of
Judgments and Stereotypes
an in‐clinic clinic, a privately owned veterinary
Negative judgments or stereotypes about low‐ clinic, in combination with a group of volun-
income homes can create major pitfalls for in‐ teers or a small humane organization, can lead
clinic clinics. Unlike nonprofit spay–neuter the local effort to get pets spayed or neutered,
clinics, private practice animal hospitals are not while capturing income that might otherwise
established primarily in order to assist the poor. leave their community.
633
Index
contamination (cont’d) cruciate ligament 376, 512 deciduous teeth 425, 426, 430
during pyometra surgery Cryotherapy 177 see also cold defibrillation 227, 228,
257, 258 compresses 234, 235
of suture 59 cryptorchidism 5–8, 13–19, defogging solutions 568
of tattoo ink 328 30–37, 46, 62, 289–292, degu 298, 315–317
during uterine prolapse 317, 325, 353, 355, dehiscence 254, 304, 320,
surgery 261 358, 625 349–352, 356, 564
contraception 442, 459–462, diagnosis of cryptorchidism dehydration 96, 128, 139, 154,
501, 521–526 5, 8, 17, 289, 292 172, 179, 231, 233, 257,
contractility 219 surgical approach to 258, 267, 269, 624, 625
contusion see bruising cryptorchidism delayed recovery 143, 164,
convective heat loss 142 289–292 204, 348, 625
cord tie see autoligation crystalloid fluids 140, 200, delayed testicular descent 5, 8
corneal ulceration or injury 219, 221, 224, 231, 233, demographics 457, 459, 465,
156, 302, 403, 404, 409, 235, 271, 387 466, 470
411, 412 C‐section see cesarean section density dependent 457, 461
cornified vaginal epithelium CSF see cerebrospinal fluid dental disease 425, 624
20, 365 Cufflator 210 dental extractions 425–430
corn syrup 203–205, 277, 278 culture (bacterial) 74, 77 dental instrumentation
coronary perfusion 230–232 culture (organizational/team) 425–427
coronoid process of mandible 359, 447, 449, 455, dental luxators 426
433, 434 464, 521, 532–535, dental radiographs 430
corpora hemorrhagica 38 537–544, 546 dental unit 427
corpora lutea 367, 522 cumulative trauma 558, 562 depilatory cream 77
cost‐benefit analyses 459, 497 cutting instruments 53 DepoFoam 431 see also
cotton‐tipped swab 276, cutting needle 60 bupivacaine
278, 302, 303, 316, 328, cyanoacrylate see tissue depth of anesthesia 146,
329, 364 adhesive 155, 159, 162–165, 179,
counting free roaming animals cyanosis 228, 278, 566 182, 184, 200, 202,
see free‐roaming cat cylinders (oxygen) see oxygen 219–221, 228
counts supply, oxygen tanks deracoxib 173
Covault hook see spay hook cystic endometrial hyperplasia dermatitis 35, 37, 283,
CPiV see canine parainfluenza 40, 41, 367 395, 624
virus cystic ovaries 27, 38, 39, 315, desaturation of blood oxygen
CPR see cardiopulmonary 317, 367 133, 137, 268
resuscitation cystic rete ovarii 38 deslorelin 525
CPV see canine parvovirus cystitis 423 detergents 71, 74, 92, 95–97
crash cart 233, 373, 446, 609 deterministic models 458
crate see housing for animals d dexdomitor see alpha2‐
cremaster 176, 311 dead space 137, 138, 181, 217, adrenergic agonists;
CRI see constant‐rate infusion 350, 377, 380 dexmedetomidine
Crile hemostat 55, 61, 62 death rate dexmedetomidine 132, 133,
cross‐contamination 65, 69, in a clinic see perioperative 154–157, 161, 165, 166,
90, 112, 144, 579 mortality 168, 175, 178, 181, 182,
cross‐matching 271, 344 in a population 456, 457, 184, 196–199, 203, 224,
cross‐training 233, 359 471, 479, 481, 482, 496 228, 232, 268, 298, 391,
crowns (of teeth) 425, 427 debilitated patients 158, 482, 432 see also alpha2‐
CRT see capillary refill time 617, 626 adrenergic agonists
Index 639
dextrose 196, 203, 205, 231, dog spay see emotional reactions
233, 235, 261, 277, 278 ovariohysterectomy, dog of humans 447, 448, 490,
diabetes mellitus 366, dog spay pack see surgical packs 491, 553, 569, 570, 618
511–513 domitor see alpha2‐adrenergic of nonhuman animals
diazepam 154, 158–160, agonists; medetomidine 103–105, 107, 108, 113,
183, 197, 199, 232, 269, dopamine 219, 220, 235 114, 118, 119, 122, 132,
270, 297 Doppler 147, 185, 200, 233, 134, 376,
dihydrotestosterone 28, 29 276, 278 employee handbook 533, 548
disarticulation 376–381 doxapram 232, 277 en bloc cesarean section
discharge instructions 328, drain (kennel floor) 92, 267, 271–273
446, 598, 602 579, 582 endangered species 490, 495
discharge of fluid drainage see discharge of fluid endodontic disease 425
ocular 395, 396, 400, 415 draining tract 400 endotracheal intubation 130,
from surgical wound 283, drape, surgical 53, 54, 56, 61, 133, 137–139, 146, 164,
350, 353 62, 67, 69, 77, 78, 80, 81, 179, 195, 197–201
vulvar 20, 305, 364 267, 282, 283, 287, 308, in brachycephalic patients
postoperative vulvar 309, 358, 591, 604, 611 216–218
discharge 352 drug reaction 215 in community cat clinics 623
discharge of patients 107, 109, DSD see disorders of sexual during CPR 227–230, 233
355, 589, 591, 595, 596, development during C‐section 268, 270,
606, 626 ductus deferens 28, 29, 33, 276, 278
disease outbreaks 89, 583 282, 289, 291–293, 311, in rabbits 297, 300, 301
disease prevalence in free 314, 315, 318 visualization during
roaming cats 484, dynamic model 456 210–211
496, 617 endotracheal tube
disease transmission 65, 68, e bitten tube 211–213
89–91, 334, 457, 477, ear notching 12, 332, 333 complications with 210–214,
482, 502, 596 ear‐tipping 12, 325, 332–337, disinfection 70
disinfectants 69, 92–94, 96, 97, 460, 470, 480, 499, 526, during neonatal resuscitation
110, 553, 592 617–620, 623–625 276–278
disinfection 69, 70, 90–93, ecological fallacy 465 securing in place 214
96, 97, 202, 213, 214, ectopic fetuses 27, 41, 42, 44 size 210
326, 334, 373, 583, 596, ectopic or accessory ovarian enlarged clitoris see clitoral
598, 606 tissue see ovarian pedicle hypertrophy
disorders of sex nodules enophthalmos 404
chromosomes 31 EKG see electrocardiogram entropion 395, 396, 403–406
disorders of sexual development elasticity analyses 458 enucleation 139, 395–397,
11, 27, 29–33, 35, 37, 44, electrocardiogram 70, 202, 399, 400, 411, 412,
46, 261, 262 221, 227, 228, 235 618, 626
dissociative agent 113, 153, electrocautery see enveloped viruses 75, 93,
157, 160, 168, 177 electrosurgery 95–98
see also ketamine; electrosurgery 303, 320, 334, environmental impact of
tiletamine–zolazepam 341, 342, 386 anesthetic gas 556
distemper see canine distemper elizabethan collar 108, 349, 357, environmental management to
distichia 403 400, 402, 407, 409, 417 reduce stress 106, 107,
dividers for cat traps 622 emesis see vomiting 109, 118, 119, 121
DO‐CONFIRM checklists 358 emigration 456–459, 461–463, enzymatic cleaner 71, 110
dog neuter see castration, dog 482, 496, 497 ephedrine 271
640 Index
epididymal fat pad (in rabbits evisceration after feline leukemia virus 99, 482,
and rodents) 311, dehiscence 350 484, 493, 496, 501, 617
312, 318 exam gloves see glove, exam feline panleukopenia 96, 98, 99
epidural 176, 258, 269, 270, gloves feline spay see
388–391, 420, 423, 424 exogenous hormone exposure ovariohysterectomy; cat
epinephrine 173, 175, 14, 20, 45, 364 and kitten
230–232, 234, 271, 277, exploratory surgery 22, 23, 44, Feliway see feline facial
278, 431, 432 289, 325, 326, 333, 337, pheromones
episiotomy 261, 416–419 354, 367 FeLV see feline leukemia virus
eradication (of cats from an exponential population growth fentanyl 167, 176, 270, 388
ecosystem) 461, 488, 457, 479 feral cats see community cats
489, 493, 494, 498 extension set 344, 345, 347 ferrets 298, 318, 319, 388, 525
ergonomics 553, 557–568 external abdominal oblique fetal consciousness 256
erosion of uterine vessels 352 muscle 254–256 fetuses, ectopic see ectopic
esophageal stethoscope external genitalia see genitalia fetuses
147, 224 (external) FHV see feline herpesvirus
esophageal temperature external rectus fascia 247, 253, fibrillation see ventricular
143, 144 291, 349, 351 fibrillation
Esterisol see zinc gluconate external skin sutures see skin fighting (behavior) 13, 15,
intratesticular injection sutures 332, 463, 482, 486,
estradiol 22 extractions see dental extractions 497, 501
estrogen 28, 29, 38, 41, 319, 343, extraocular muscles 396, figure‐of‐eight suture eyelid
363–365, 367, 415, 416, 398, 413 repair 409
423, 513, 522, 523, 525 eyelid gland 400, 401, 403 finding the uterus see locating
estrous cycles 45, 264, 304, eyelid injuries 408 the uterus
307, 365, 366, 415, 511, eyelid tacking 404, 405 firocoxib 173
513, 514, 524, 525 eyelid tumor 407–409 fistulas 45, 352, 429
estrous secretions 40, 45, 366 FIV see feline
estrus (heat) 19, 20, 22, 23, 38, f immunodeficiency virus
41, 58, 250, 319, 343, f/air canister see charcoal canister flank spay 12, 21, 46, 177,
352, 359, 363–367, 415, fallopian tube see oviducts 253–255, 262, 316, 317,
416, 442, 479, 509, 510, fasting 182, 194, 196, 295, 326, 327, 625
513, 514, 625 358, 620 floorplan examples 581
estrus suppression 366 FCV see feline calicivirus fluid administration 139,
ethylene oxide 72 fecundity 456, 462 140, 219, 222, 224, 231,
ETT see endotracheal tube fees for service 443, 579, 597, 233, 271
euphoria (medication effect in 603, 606, 616 fluid therapy guidelines
cats) 167, 172 feline calicivirus 96–98 130, 139
euthanasia 333, 448 feline castration 58, 281, 283, flumazenil 183, 197, 232
at community cat clinics 287, 510 fogging of glasses 568
616–619, 621, 624, 626 feline facial pheromones 110, follicles 29, 364, 367, 526
of fetuses after pregnant spay 132, 162 follicle‐stimulating hormone
180, 256 feline herpesvirus 96, 98, 18, 522, 523
for population control 459, 99, 104 follicular cysts 38, 367
461, 462, 465–467, 478, feline immunodeficiency virus forced warm air device 134,
481–483, 489–491, 494, 457, 482, 484, 496, 144, 145, 204, 205, 222,
497–500 501, 617 223, 271, 276, 277
Index 641
foreign material, suture or glue gamma aminobutyric acid glycogen 194, 196
acting as 303, 330, 332, 118, 216 glycopyrrolate 144, 178, 197,
351, 352 gastric reflux 179, 210, 268 199, 220, 224, 235, 268,
formaldehyde 94 gastrointestinal hypomotility 277, 278, 301, 411
for‐profit business 443, 578, 297, 304 see also anticholinergics
589, 605 gastroprotectants 211 GnRH see gonadotropin‐
foundational belief Gelfoam see hemostatic sponge releasing hormone
531–534, 540 generator (gas or diesel) 591, golden retriever 267, 274,
foundational belief statement 595, 598 517, 520
531, 532, 534, 540 genitalia (external) 5–7, 15, GonaCon 524, 527, 528
FPV see feline panleukopenia 22, 27–33, 37, 296 gonadotropin‐releasing
fractured tooth 425, 426, 429 genital tubercle 28, 29 hormone 17, 22, 35,
frailty 181 geographic information system 365, 366, 416, 522–526
free‐roaming cats see also 441, 442, 466, 467, government: regulation,
community cats 469, 596 oversight and funding
counts 467, 469, 470 gerbils 316, 317 443, 457, 459, 460, 464,
free‐roaming dogs 441, 459, geriatric 132, 181, 183, 467, 489, 491, 499, 578,
463, 464, 467 216, 222 579, 590, 605
freeze behavior 105, 115 gestation see pregnant patients gown, surgical see surgical
frenulum, penile see penile gigli wire 384 attire‐surgical gowns
frenulum gingival flap 426, 427 gracilis 382–385
friable tissue 247, 253, 256, GIS see geographic information grant funding 443, 469, 577,
257, 261, 307, 310, 341 system 578, 590, 606
front limb amputation 376 glans penis 36, 37 granuloma 351, 352
frostbitten pinna (ears) 12, Glasgow Composite Measure grapiprant 389, 392, 393
332, 333, 624 Pain Scale 135 gravid uterus 180, 256, 260,
FSH see follicle‐stimulating glasses 566–568, 571 272, 273
hormone glaucoma 160, 170, 395, gravity displacement steam
fuel costs (mobile clinics) 578, 411, 412 sterilization 72, 73
590, 596, 603, 607 globe (eye) 170, 395, 396, green linear tattoo 11, 12,
functional residual capacity 398, 399, 401, 403, 412, 325–328, 330, 332
179, 268 413, 432 greyhounds 45, 223
funding 443–445, 469, 489, glomerular filtration rate 182, grief 569
490, 533, 577–579, 587, 183, 389 grimace scale, feline 135
589, 590, 602, 603, 606, glottis 211, 301 grip (on instrument) 562–564
627, 628, 630 gloves grooming behavior 20, 132,
fungal spores 91, 96 animal handling gloves 116, 135, 303
fungicidal 75, 93, 95, 96, 553, 609, 611, 621, 624 ground plate 334
98, 159 exam gloves 91, 334, 620 ground reaction force 375
furcation of tooth 427 powder‐free gloves 305 ground teams 602, 603
FVRCP 99, 616 sterile surgical gloves 67, gubernaculum 29
68, 74, 257, 275, 305, Guidelines, ASV Spay Neuter
g 390, 440, 447, 593, 609 see Association of
GABA see gamma aminobutyric glue see tissue adhesive Shelter Veterinarians,
acid glutamate (neurotransmitter) spay–neuter guidelines
gabapentin 107, 113, 114, 117, 136, 177 guillotine‐style door 115, 116,
118, 121, 132, 184, 392 glutaraldehyde 73, 94, 97 120, 622
642 Index
mathematical modeling 456, methadone 167–171, monitors 146, 147, 185, 200,
457, 459, 488, 498 268–270, 388 211, 217, 219, 221, 223,
matrix model 459, 460 metoclopramide 304 276, 277
Mayo–Hegar needle Metzenbaum scissors 54, 61, monoamine oxidase
holders 55 62, 244, 416, 418 inhibitors 118
Mayo scissors 54, 55, 61, 62, 381 mibolerone 45, 366 Monocryl 57
meconium 276 microchip 12, 325, 358, monofilament suture 56,
medetomidine 154–158, 165, 618, 624 57, 303, 309, 316, 350,
166, 170, 171, 175, 178, micropenis 34, 35, 37 429, 563
181, 196, 197, 199, 203, microsporum 91, 96, 97 monorchidism 13, 35
215, 268, 297 see also midazolam 154, 156–160, 166, morbidity and mortality rounds
alpha2‐adrenergic 170, 181, 183, 197, 199, 359, 448
agonists 232, 269, 270, 297, 298 Morgan pocket flap 401
medetomidine/ketamine/ mid‐thigh amputation morphine 159, 161, 167–169,
buprenorphine 165 381–384 171, 174, 176, 199, 200,
medetomidine/ketamine/ Miller’s knot 245–248, 217, 270, 388, 391
butorphanol 165 253–257, 259, 261, 272, mortality rate, perioperative
medial canthus 398, 432, 433 273, 282–284, 313, 352 65, 128, 129, 133, 143,
median raphe 282, 284, 285, minimum alveolar 147, 155, 164, 181,
287 concentration 179, 197, 199, 209, 510,
medical records 12, 128, 232, 204, 223 513, 569
446, 511, 514, 584, 595, mission (of an organization) in feral colonies see death
596, 598, 602, 606 357, 442, 465, 531–534, rate
Megestrol acetate 366 537, 539, 541, 542, 544, mosquito hemostats 55,
meloxicam 157, 165, 171, 546, 547, 550, 586, 601, 61, 62, 292, 309, 312,
173–176, 199, 200, 616–619 319, 405
299, 302 mission statement 531–534 motility, gastrointestinal 268,
memory (suture characteristic) MKB 1 see medetomidine/ 304 see also ileus
56, 57 ketamine/buprenorphine mouth gags 430
mental foramen 433, 434 MKB 2 see medetomidine/ MSD see musculoskeletal
mental health 553, 569 ketamine/butorphanol discomfort
mental nerve block 433 MLV see modified live virus Müllerian ducts see
mentorship 449, 549, 577, 587, vaccine paramesonephric
602, 603 mobile animal sterilization ducts
meperidine 268, 388 hospital see MASH clinics Müllerian‐inhibiting
mepivacaine 431 mobile unit (self‐contained substance 28
mesentery damage 244, 250 mobile clinic) 445, 578, multifilament suture 56, 57
mesocolon 348 see also 587, 589–595, 598, 605, see also braided suture
biologic retractor 606, 628 multimodal analgesia 113,
mesoduodenum 348 see also modeling populations 455– 114, 137, 147, 167–169,
biologic retractors 464, 488, 493, 496, 498, 171, 172, 174, 176, 177,
mesonephric ducts 28, 29, 39 499, 501 202, 205, 302, 412
mesonephric remnants 39 modified Hotz–Celsus 405 murmurs see cardiac murmurs
mesopredator release 488 modified live virus vaccine 98 musculoskeletal discomfort
metabolic scaling 154, 155, modified Miller’s knot 558, 561, 562, 564,
166, 182, 215 245–248, 253–257, 261, 565, 568
metapopulation 459, 462 272, 273, 282–284, 313 myometrium 275
Index 647
parvovirus see canine perineal position 416 PMDS see persistent Müllerian
parvovirus perineal urethrostomy duct syndrome
passive electrode 334 10, 11, 36 PO see oral administration
passive scavenging 582, 608 periodontal disease 425, 426 pocket‐flap technique 401, 403
passive warming 145 periodontal elevator 426, point‐of‐care LH test 18, 23
patella 381–384 427, 429 poliglecaprone 25 suture 57
pathogen prevalence rates periodontal ligament 426, 427, polydactyl 618, 624
in free‐roaming 429, 435 polydioxanone suture 57, 351
cats 484 perioperative mortality see polyestrous 479, 510
patient positioning 70, 220, mortality rate, polyglactin 910 suture 57
241, 254, 424 perioperative polyorchidism 35
patient preparation see periorbita 399, 400 polypropylene suture 58, 399
preparation periosteal elevator 426–428 pop‐off valve 129, 138, 140,
PCMX 75, 79 peritoneum 243, 244, 254, 141, 214, 215, 557, 582
PCV see packed cell volume 350, 363, 420 population (definition) 455
PDS see polydioxanone suture peroxide see accelerated population dynamics 455,
pectineus muscle 382, 383 hydrogen peroxide 456, 458–463, 471, 487,
pectoral muscle 379, 380 persistent Müllerian duct 488, 495
pedicle ligation syndrome 33, 34, population growth 456–462,
in cats 250–253 49, 51 464, 471, 479, 497,
complications during 340 persistent primary teeth 499, 500
in dogs 245–247 425, 426 population modeling 456, 459,
in flank spay 255 personal protective equipment 460, 496
during ovariectomy 263 91, 555–557 population monitoring
during pregnant spay 256 pet cats 12, 13, 478–481, 484, 469, 470
in rabbits 309 493, 615, 616 porcine zona pellucida see zona
during uterine prolapse pharynx 227, 276, 300, 301 pellucida vaccine
repair 261 phenolic compounds 73, 74, positive pressure ventilation see
pedicle tie see autoligation 79, 94, 97 intermittent positive
pedicle transection see phenylephrine 218 pressure ventilation
transecting the ovarian pheromones 107, 110, 132, 162 post‐anesthetic airway
pedicle phthisis bulbi 395, 396 obstruction 218
peel pouches see paper‐plastic physical examination 5, 13, post‐mortem exam 359
peel pouch 14, 16, 19, 20, 22, 41, 42, post‐operative
penile amputation 36 68, 104, 130, 131, 183, hemoabdomen 344
penile barbs see penile spines 196, 216, 221, 277, post‐operative
penile frenulum 35–37 295–297, 364, 387, 446, hyperthermia 223
penile spines 14, 15, 17, 18, 584, 585, 596, 613 post‐operative instructions
32, 35, 36, 624 physical layout see layout of 586, 602, 606, 607
penis 5–11, 14–16, 18, 28–30, clinic potassium peroxymonosuflate
33–37, 296, 311, 314, physical restraint 108, 133 94, 96
317, 320 pinna see ear‐tipping pouch, in sugar gliders 320
perfusion 144, 172, 182, 183, piroxicam 519 pouch, paper‐plastic peel 72,
194, 210, 218–220, 228, pituitary 18, 315, 522, 523 74, 80
230, 232, 268, 430 placenta 44, 178, 180, 256, povidone 75, 94, 97
peribulbar block 412, 413 268, 274 PPE see personal protective
perineal hernias 36, 419, 423 platelets 143, 387 equipment
650 Index
rectal prolapse 389, 419, retractors 258, 303, 343, 347 scrotal castration
421, 423 retrobulbar block 412, cats and dogs 281–285, 288
rectal sphincter 416, 418 413, 432 complications 353–355
rectal temperature 144, 171 return‐to‐field 443, 499, 500 rabbits, rodents, and others
rectal wall 419 revascularization of ovarian 311, 312, 314, 317, 319
rectovaginal fistula 45 remnant 363 scrotal hemorrhage 353–355
rectus abdominis 243, 244, 291 reversal agents 157, 164, 228 scrotal swelling 353–355, 510
rectus fascia 247, 253, 349, 351 see also atipamezole; scrub, surgical 67, 70, 74, 75,
referral 127, 164, 343, 348, flumazenil; naloxone; 77–80
352, 356, 407, 585, 619 yohimbine seasonally polyestrous 479
regurgitation 133, 179, 210, reverse Trendelenburg position seating 559–561, 567, 602,
211, 268, 301, 463 179, 180 604, 609, 613
rehabilitation 381, 384, 385 rhomboideus muscle 378 secondary hemorrhage 352
reliability 135, 447, 566 Ricker model 457, 461 secondary hyperalgesia
renal blood flow 182, 183, 195, ringworm 96, 97 136, 177
219, 389 Roccal‐D® 93, 94 segmental aplasia of uterus
renal tubular necrosis 297 Rochester–Carmalts see 40, 41, 364
reproductive capacity in Carmalt hemostats seizures 118, 154, 155, 158, 431
populations 456, 463 rodents 178, 295–297, self‐mutilation 282, 297, 304,
reproductive status 5, 22, 325, 301–305, 307, 315–317, 349, 357, 417, 432, 624
337, 359, 457, 469, 470 320, 486 self‐tie see autoligation
respiratory arrest 227, 412, 625 ropivacaine 173, 174, 431 semimembranosus 382,
respiratory depression 159, RTF see return‐to‐field 384, 385
160, 162, 216, 218 semitendinosus 382, 384, 385
respiratory obstruction 130, s sensitivity analysis 462, 489
133, 137 sacrococcygeal epidural 390 seromas 356, 377, 380, 381
respiratory rate 103, 134, 146, saddle‐shaped seat 560, 561 serotonin syndrome 118
147, 161, 164, 176, 194, sanitation 69, 70, 89, 90, 92, serratus ventralis 378
228, 269, 277 93, 110 Sertoli cell tumors 13, 16, 18,
restraint devices 108, 241, 242 sartorius muscle 382, 383 28, 35 see also neoplasia‐
control poles 108 scalpel blade 53, 61, 62 testicular neoplasia
nets 108, 116, 117, 611, 616, scalpel handle 53, 54, 61, 62 serum hormone levels 17, 18,
621, 622, 624, 626 scalpel injuries 53 22, 23, 35, 176, 179,
squeeze cages 108, 115, 116, scapula 376–379 364–367
609, 611, 616, 619–623 scapular disarticulation Setocaine 210
resuscitation 139, 179, 218, 376–380 sevoflurane 133, 162, 194, 199,
221, 224, 227–234, 411, scar, surgical 16, 20, 21, 23, 200, 222, 270, 297
446, 624 326, 332, 619 sex determination of patient
neonatal 269, 271–274, scavenger (anesthetic gas) 5, 7, 8, 27, 296
276–278 141, 555–557, 582, 594, sex differentiation of fetus
retained deciduous teeth 430 595, 608 27–30
retained testicles see scissors 53–55, 57, 61, 62 sex reversal 30, 37
cryptorchidism screening tests (preoperative) SGAD see supraglottic airway
retention cyst 403 see pre‐anesthetic blood device
retraction of the testing sheath see prepuce
mesoduodenum see scrotal ablation 320, 354, shelter intake 441, 442, 448,
biologic retractors 355, 524 465–467, 499, 500, 510
652 Index
surgical preparation 90, 281, tattoo 11, 12, 82, 250, 253, 304, tiletamine–zolazepam 115,
446, 608, 624 318, 319, 325–333, 526, 156, 158–161, 163, 164,
surgical site infection 65, 66, 619, 624 166, 168, 169, 184, 197,
83, 84, 86–88, 149, 204, tattoo gun 82, 326 199, 215, 216, 222, 297,
336, 337, 350, 400 see also tattoo ink 82, 328–332, 526 622, 623
surgical complications tattoo paste 328, 332 TIMA see total intramuscular
survival rates (in populations) teaching programs 343, anesthesia
456, 479, 482, 494, 356, 357 timing of spay‐neuter 509–515
496, 501 tearing of the ovarian pedicle tipped ear see ear‐tipping
survival rates of kittens see 246, 274, 307, “tipping” cassette suture 59
juvenile survival in 340–342, 347 tissue adhesive 250, 253, 283,
populations tearing of the uterus 247, 253, 285, 286, 303, 312–316,
suspensory ligament, breaking 256, 257, 272, 274 318, 329–332, 334, 337,
241, 244, 251, 252, 254, tea strainer 347 350, 351
259, 261, 262, 272, 273, Telazol see tiletamine– tissue drag 57
341, 342 zolazepam tissue forceps 54, 55, 61, 62,
in rabbits and rodents Tenon’s capsule 398–400 242, 244, 247, 250, 254,
307–309, 315, 316 testes 347, 405, 563
suture cassette 59 determining sex and neuter Adson–Brown 54, 61, 62
suture material 56–59, 67, status 5–10, 13–18, 296 Adson tissue forceps
82, 247, 250, 253, 303, development 27–37, 44 54, 55
316, 341, 350, 352, 405, local anesthesia of 175, Allis tissue forceps
429, 446 176, 202 254, 347
suture packets 58, 59, 328 removal (castration), dogs tissue reaction 56, 57
suture reaction 349–351 and cats 281–293 TKX see total intramuscular
suture size 58, 60, 350, 564 removal (castration), rabbits anesthesia
swaged‐on suture 58–60, 566 and small mammals TNR see trap–neuter–return
Syrian hamster 316 311–315, 317, 318, 320 TNVR see trap–neuter–
syringe‐feeding rabbits 304 as targets of nonsurgical vaccinate–return
syrup see corn syrup contraception 522–524 tolfenamic acid 173, 174
testicular descent 5–8, 13, topical anesthetic 200, 201,
t 29, 34, 35, 62, 258, 289, 210, 405
tachycardia 104, 132, 160, 291, 311 topical estrogen 363
175, 202, 216, 219–222, testosterone 13, 14, 17, 28, Torbugesic see butorphanol
224, 348 29, 33, 35, 293, 512, tortoiseshell male cat 32
tacking the eyelid 404, 405 523, 524 total intramuscular anesthesia
tail amputation 385, 387, 389, thermal burns 145, 222, 334, 113, 137, 153, 156, 157,
390, 618 341, 610 160, 163–165, 168, 169,
tank (of oxygen) see oxygen thermoregulation 134, 142, 184, 197, 623, 625
supply; oxygen tanks 194, 216, 276 see also towel clamps 56, 61, 62
tank induction see chamber hypothermia; toxicity of local anesthetics
induction hyperthermia 390, 412, 431
taper needle 60, 61, 347 thiopental 177, 269 toxoplasmosis 463, 484
targeting 439, 441–444, 456, third eyelid 395, 398, 400–403 tracheal injury during intubation
460, 462, 463, 465–467, thoracodorsal artery 378 137, 138, 210, 323
471, 495, 498, 500, 589, thumb forceps see tissue tracheal intubation see
590, 596, 627 forceps endotracheal intubation
654 Index