You are on page 1of 6

CLINICAL AND COMMUNITY STUDIES

ETUDES CLINIQUES ET COMMUNAUTAIRES

Birthing experience of adolescents at the Ottawa


General Hospital Perinatal Centre

Suji M. Lena, MD; Emily Marko, MD; Carl Nimrod, MD; Leonide Merritt, RN; Gilberte Poirier, RN;
Elizabeth Shein, MSW
Objective: To study the experiences of prenatal care, prenatal classes and birthing among
adolescents.
Design: Anonymous self-report questionnaire survey.
Setting: Ottawa General Hospital Perinatal Centre.
Patients: A total of 100 adolescents (aged less than 20 years) and 100 control subjects
(aged over 19 years) who gave birth at the Perinatal Centre from June 1989 to August
1990.
Main outcome measures: Prenatal experiences, attendance at prenatal classes, ex-
periences in labour and delivery, postpartum care.
Results: Only 26% of the adolescent patients sought prenatal care in the first trimester,
and only 27% attended prenatal classes, as compared with 87% and 91% of the control
subjects (p < 0.001). Most of the adolescents felt uncomfortable in the same waiting
room as adult women. During labour and delivery 50% of the adolescents had their
mothers with them for support, whereas 83% of the adults had their husbands with them
(p < 0.001). Over half (59%) of the adolescents stated that they were not prepared for
labour and delivery, as compared with 26% of the adults (p < 0.001). Of the adolescents
85% opted to care for their babies after birth.
Conclusion: Pregnant adolescents do not avail themselves adequately of the medical and
psychosocial services available to them through the health care system. Our findings
suggest features of prenatal clinics that would make them attractive and accessible to
such patients.

Objectif: Etudier les experiences de soins prenatals, de cours prenatals et de l'accouche-


ment chez les adolescentes.
Conception: Enquete par questionnaire d'autoevaluation anonyme.
Contexte: Centre perinatal de I'H6pital General d'Ottawa.
Patientes: Un total de 100 adolescentes (agees de moins de 20 ans) et de 100 sujets
temoins (ages de plus de 19 ans) qui ont accouche au Centre perinatal de juin 1989 a
aouit 1990.
Principales mesures des resultats: Experiences prenatales, participation aux cours
prenatals, experiences du travail et de l'accouchement, soins post-partum.
Resultats: Seulement 26 % des patientes adolescentes ont demande des soins prenatals
pendant le premier trimestre, et seulement 27 % ont suivi des cours prenatals, par

Dr. Lena is a clinical assistant professor in the Department ofPediatrics, University of Ottawa and Children's Hospital ofEastern Ontario
(CHEO), codirector of the Eating Disorder Clinic, Smyth Medical Centre, and a member ofthe Child and Adolescent Sexual Abuse
Management Team, CHEO, Ottawa, Ont. At the time ofwriting, Dr. Marko was a third-year resident in obstetrics and gynecology,
Ottawa General Hospital and University of Ottawa. Dr. Nimrod is professor ofobstetrics and gynecology, University of Ottawa.
Mrs. Merritt is retired; she was the head nurse in the Department ofObstetrics and Gynecology, Ottawa General Hospital. Ms. Poirier is
head nurse on the Postnatal Ward, Ottawa General Hospital. At the time ofwriting, Mrs. Shein was a medical social worker on the
Postnatal Ward and was in the Department of Social Services, Ottawa General Hospital.

Reprint requests to: Dr. Suji M. Lena, Smyth Medical Centre, 314-1929 Russell Rd., Ottawa, ON KIG 4G3

JUNE 15, 1993 CAN MED ASSOCJ 1993; 148 (12) 2149
comparaison avec 87 % et 91 % des sujets temoins (p < 0,001). La plupart des
adolescentes se sentaient mal a l'aise dans la meme salle d'attente que les femmes d'age
adulte. Pendant le travail et l'accouchement, 50 % des adolescentes ont eu le soutien de
leur mere, alors que 83 % des adultes etaient accompagnees de leur mari (p < 0,001).
Plus de la moitie (59 %) des adolescentes ont declare qu'elles n'ont pas ete preparees au
travail et a l'accouchement, par comparaison avec 26 % des adultes (p < 0,001). Au
total, 85 % des adolescentes ont choisi de s'occuper de leurs bebes apres la naissance.
Conclusion: Les adolescentes enceintes ne se prevalent pas adequatement des services
medicaux et psychosociaux qui leur sont offerts par l'entremise du reseau de soins de
sante. Nos constatations suggerent des caracteristiques qui rendraient les cliniques
prenatales interessantes et accessibles a ces patientes.

A dolescent childbearing is a public health con- The purpose of this survey was to (a) discover
cern because of the significant medical, psy- why pregnant adolescents fail to seek medical care
chologic and social risks to the mother and during the prenatal period, (b) review the birthing
her infant.'~' Poor outcomes have been attributed to experiences of adolescents and (c) identify ways to
inadequate prenatal care, low socioeconomic status, improve these experiences and make prenatal ser-
nutritional deficiencies, lifestyle, ethnic background vices more accessible.
and marital status.4-6
Unfortunately many pregnant teenagers are re- Methods
luctant to seek prenatal care until near the end of
their pregnancy or simply show up at the hospital in The Ottawa General Hospital, a teaching hospi-
labour.7 Because they are poorly prepared many have tal affiliated with the University of Ottawa, accepts
a difficult labour and delivery. patients referred from various practitioners and
Adequate prenatal care for adolescents improves university teaching staff. Adolescents choose this
nutrition, discourages substance abuse, identifies facility to give birth if it is close to their residence at
and treats gynecologic infections early and offers the onset of labour. Others choose it if it is the one
interdisciplinary support.8 It has been associated at which their family practitioner or obstetrician has
with delivery of infants of higher birth weight and privileges. Some are transferred there if they or their
later gestational age.9 Such care should be based on baby is at risk.
"age-appropriate" classes and should address the All 102 patients less than 20 years of age who
adolescent's struggle for identity and independence, gave birth at the Ottawa General Hospital Perinatal
nutritional issues, labour and delivery, parenting and Centre from June 1989 to August 1990 were asked to
social aspects such as completion of education, living complete a questionnaire during their postpartum
accommodations, financial aspects of independent period in hospital. For comparison, we asked 100
living and substance abuse.'0-12 women 20 years old and over who gave birth at the
Studies of adult women have shown that their centre during the same shifts to complete the ques-
use of antenatal care is diminished by lack of tionnaire. There were no exclusion criteria as long as
comfort, limited waiting space,'3 inconvenient clinic the age and timing of delivery were met.
hours, long waiting time,'4 language and cultural The sample size required for this study was
barriers,'5 depersonalized services, a change in phys- based on the following assumptions: (a) the propor-
ician at each visit, lack of child care, lack of tion of adult women expected to be satisfied with the
transportation and inadequate psychosocial care.'6'17 prenatal care that they received is 85%, (b) an
Little attention has been paid to the specific needs of important difference in the rate of satisfaction with
pregnant adolescents. Beliefs and teachings regarding prenatal care between the two groups is 20%, (c) the
adolescent childbearing have changed markedly in a error rate is 0.05 (two-tailed), and (d) the d error
the past three decades.'8 Studies in Sweden'9 and rate is 0.10 with a power of 90%. Therefore, we
Greece20 have shown that adolescents may actually required 190 subjects (95 per group). Allowing for a
have an easier labour with fewer complications and a nonresponse rate of 5%, we estimated that 200
lower cesarean section rate than adults. Statistical subjects (100 per group) would be appropriate.22
analyses have accounted for the effects on pregnancy Informed consent was obtained. Anonymity,
outcomes of confounding conditions such as parity, confidentiality and the option to participate in the
socioeconomic status, marital status, size and health study was assured. Approval was obtained from the
habits.2' Low maternal age was considered a cause of hospital's Human Experimental Procedures Com-
morbidity during pregnancy.2' However, it is now mittee. In a pilot study 10 pregnant adolescents were
known to be only a primary marker for an increased randomly selected 1 month before the study period
risk of obstetric complications and neonatal morbid- to complete the questionnaire and comment on the
ity. clarity of the questions.
2150 CAN MED ASSOC J 1993; 148 (12) LE 15 JUIN 1993
The questionnaire consigted of 36 questions In all, 89% of the adolescents and 80% of the
divided into four sections. There were several open- adults used the English questionnaire. The propor-
ended questions inviting participants to comment on tions of the patients who were primiparous were 91%
or suggest improvements in prenatal care and in and 83% respectively. Twelve of the adolescents
labour and delivery. The first section included were married at the time of admission to hospital, as
general questions about such characteristics as age, compared with 93 of the adults.
language, education level, ability to continue edu- The educational levels of the adolescent partici-
cation during pregnancy, living situation and finan- pants were as follows: 65 had completed grade 10 or
cial situation. 11, 20 had completed grade 8 or 9, and 5 had
In the second section, which pertained to prena- finished grade 12 or 13. Since becoming pregnant
tal care, participants were asked how they discovered only 36 were continuing their education: 67% of
they were pregnant, how soon they first started them requested home tutoring, 15% opted for corre-
receiving medical care, how often they returned for spondence courses, 12% remained in the same
visits and what information they received. They school, and 6% wished to drop out altogether.
were also asked about prenatal classes: how many Forty-three of the adolescent subjects continued
they attended, why they did not attend and wheth- to live with their parents, 30 lived with a boyfriend
er they felt prepared for labour and delivery. Most of or the father of the baby, 16 lived with another
the questions required a simple Yes or No answer or adolescent friend, and 10 lived alone.
were multiple choice. In all, 53% of the adolescents were supported
The third section involved questions about la- financially by their parents, 33% by social services
bour and delivery. Participants were asked about and 14% by the boyfriend or father of the baby.
episodes of false labour, the admitting routine, how
they felt about labour and delivery and how much Prenatal care
support they received.
The final section dealt with the postpartum Most (60%) of the adolescents found out they
period: what information participants received post were pregnant through their physician's diagnosis.
partum, how they felt in the same room as older This did not differ significantly from the rate in the
women (only the adolescents were asked this ques- control group.
tion), if they felt ready to go home and what plans The delay in seeking medical prenatal care was
they had for the baby. significantly longer in the adolescent group than in
The questionnaire was available in English and the adult group. Only 26% of the adolescents started
French. receiving such care within the first trimester, as
The data analysis consisted mainly of descrip- compared with 87% of the adults (p < 0.001) (Table
tive statistics and frequencies. Statistical significance 1). The largest group (47%) gave fear of going to
of differences between the two groups was deter- clinics as the reason for the delay. Other reasons
mined using the x2 test. The open-ended questions were not knowing where to go (given by 18%), no
were examined individually, and repetitive responses transportation (by 6%) and just not getting around to
and suggestions for improvement were documented it earlier (by 29%). Most (47%) of the adolescents
in the results. Each patient chart was reviewed by saw a family physician for prenatal care, whereas
one of us (E.M.) to compare entries made by health most (61%) of the adults saw an obstetrician (p <
care professionals during admission, labour and 0.001) (Table 1). When asked whether they felt
delivery with the information given by the patients. comfortable with older women in the waiting room
66% of the adolescents answered No.
Results Prenatal classes were specified as being group
sessions involving instruction, discussion and exer-
General information cises for labour and delivery. Only 27% of the
adolescents attended such classes, as compared with
A total of 200 patients (100 of the 102 adoles- 91% of the adults (p < 0.001) (Table 1). The reasons
cent patients and all of the adult patients) completed for not attending included "fear," "feeling uncom-
the questionnaire. The adolescent patients were from fortable with couples and older women," "everyone
14 to 19 years of age, the largest group comprising asking where my husband is," "people staring at me"
those 16 to 17 years (43 patients); 37 patients were and "no transportation." Of the adolescents 86%
18 to 19 years old, and 20 were 14 to 15 years old. stated that they did not feel comfortable with older
The mean age of the control subjects was 26 (ex- couples at the prenatal classes. Most of the ad-
tremes 21 and 42) years. The remainder of the olescents felt awkward about going to classes with-
results were analysed in relation to the final three out a partner. In all, 59% of the adolescents did
sections of the questionnaire. not feel prepared for labour and delivery, as com-
JUNE 15, 1993 CAN MED ASSOC J 1993; 148 (12) 2151
or-~5 5
f. _-'.A-'fW_
pared with 26% of the adults (p < 0.001) (Table 1). portional to the number of visits to prenatal
clinics and classes. Participation and cooperation by
Labour and delivery adolescents during delivery was directly propor-
tional to the number of visits to prenatal clinics
The participants were asked if they were ever and classes.
sent home from the hospital because of false labour:
46% of the adolescents and 35% of the adults Postpartum care
answered Yes.
During labour and delivery 50% of the adoles- In all, 59% of the adolescents stated that they
cents had their mother with them for support, were uncomfortable in the same room as adults
whereas 83% of the adults had their husband with during the postpartum period. The adolescents stat-
them (p < 0.001) (Table 2). ed that they received adequate instruction on breast-
The most common comments about the partici- feeding, infant care, contraception, breast care and
pants' experiences were about fear, not knowing nutrition. Surprisingly, 33% of the adolescents did
what to expect and being poorly prepared. Most not receive instruction about contraception, as com-
(63%) of the adolescents suggested that a prenatal pared with 1 1% of the adults.
class for teenagers would have been useful. Finally, of the 95 adolescents whose babies
The review of the charts revealed that fear of survived 85 responded that they were keeping them
what to expect during delivery was inversely pro- and 10 that they were giving them up for adoption.

dpIM '
At p vlue
... A^Mle p v*
13 30 < 0A01
12 57
Wr. 9 3
44 6
22 4
15 5 < 0.001
47
14 ;61
15 2
9 0
27 91
73 9

72
28 74
41 74 < `.Oe
.59 26

Gro-up;,.:.of h*
Per-on Adole"ttts Adults p val
M"eo50 2 <0001
-ather 2 1
17 .83 <aQ 1
Fr-of
X Sw 14 7
Ffrind 5 2
Noone 7 0

2152 CAN MED ASSOC J 1993; 148 (12) LE 15 JUIN 1993


All of the 98 adults whose babies survived stated
All of the 98 adults whose babies survived stated ways brought to the attention of a pregnant teen-
that they were keeping them. ager. When a teenager is found to be pregnant it
is vital to stay in contact with her, maintain con-
Chart review fidentiality and work with her toward coming in
for prenatal care and setting up other necessary sup-
The adolescents' answers, statements and sug- port services. The health care professional who
gestions from the open-ended questions coincided initially diagnoses the pregnancy must alert the
accurately with observations and information docu- community services.
mented in their charts at the time of admission and In 1979 the Committee on Adolescent Medicine
during labour and delivery. These entries were made of the Canadian Paediatric Society recommended
by nurses, physicians in training and attending staff. that transportation to and from prenatal clinics and
Of particular interest were the comments about classes be made available to all pregnant adolescents
preparedness for labour and delivery, lack of aware- and their partners.26 It also recommended that pre-
ness of anatomy and active participation in delivery. natal clinics and classes for adolescents be tailored to
The adolescents who had the least amount of expo- meet the educational, nutritional, social, obstetric,
sure to prenatal care and classes coped less well than pediatric and financial needs of adolescent parents
the others during their hospital stay. and their infants. More than 10 years later we found
that 6% of the adolescents in our study who delayed
Discussion seeking prenatal care did so because of a lack of
transportation, 18% did not know where to go, and
We found several interesting differences be- 47% feared going to adult-oriented clinics. It would
tween the two groups, mostly in terms of prenatal be useful to hold the clinics between 2 and 6 pm and
care and classes. Adult-oriented clinics and classes then provide supper and prenatal classes in the same
made the adolescents feel out of place and uncom- location. These facilities should be easily accessible,
fortable. The adolescents were uneasy at insensitive or else transportation should be provided. This
comments and attitudes of some staff during the service should be advertised regularly in high schools
admission procedures. and all public places that teenagers frequent.
In addition, we found that inadequate atten- The suggestion of prenatal classes specifically
dance at prenatal clinics and classes did not prepare designed for adolescents was made by 63 of the
the adolescents very well for recognizing the onset of adolescent participants. Since only 17% of the ado-
labour or for active participation in delivery. More lescents had their husband or boyfriend with them
of the adults than of the adolescents sought prenatal during labour and delivery, it makes sense to have a
care early, attended prenatal clinics regularly and friend or companion who is most likely to partici-
participated in prenatal classes. pate and be supportive attend the classes.
Many studies have shown that adequate prena- One-third of the adolescents did not receive
tal care for adolescents leads to the delivery of contraceptive information during the postpartum
infants of higher birth weight and later gestational period. Consideration should be given to a specific
age.9'20,23-25 Cartoof, Klerman and Zazueta9 suggested postpartum package for adolescents that includes
that the clinic environment, its attractiveness and information on contraceptive care, care of the new-
the way the adolescents feel about how they are born and resources for young mothers. Since most of
treated by staff and medical practitioners limit the the adolescents decided to keep their babies, post-
use of prenatal care by adolescents. partum care and follow-up are essential for this
Only 36 of the adolescents were able to continue high-risk group. The fetal death rate of 5% among
their education. Most chose home tutoring, which the adolescents was high but is still lower than the
gave them the chance to continue in a nonthreaten- rate among adult women.8,20,2'
ing, accessible, individually tailored program. How- Our findings have shown a need for prenatal
ever, home tutoring is excellent but expensive and care, prenatal classes and counselling, and postpar-
can be used only for a fixed period. tum care specifically designed to meet the needs of
In all, 44% of the adolescents postponed seeking adolescents. This should be established in a non-
prenatal care until the last trimester, and 22% never threatening, easily accessible environment that is
sought such care. No doubt the pregnant teenager is available to all pregnant teenagers.
scared, anxious, unsure and confused.
Seventy-seven percent of the adolescent preg- We thank Dr. Robert Stenstrom, Paediatric Research,
nancies were diagnosed by a physician or at a family Children's Hospital of Eastern Ontario, Ottawa, for his
planning clinic. There are many services and support help in planning the study and analysing the data. We also
groups in the community for pregnant adolescents. thank the labour and delivery staff and maternity ward
However, available services are apparently not al- staff of the Ottawa General Hospital Perinatal Centre.
JUNE 15, 1993 CAN MED ASSOC J 1993; 148 (12) 2153
References Conferences
continuedfrom page 2147
1. Orton MJ, Rosenblatt E: Adolescent Pregnancy in Ontario,
Planned Parenthood Ontario, Toronto, 1986 Sept. 9-13, 1993: Specialty Care in Crisis? - 62nd Annual
2. Repke JT: Adolescent pregnancy: Can we solve the problem? Meeting of the Royal College of Physicians and
Mayo Clin Proc 1990; 65: 1152-1154
3. Poole C: Adolescent pregnancy and unfinished developmental Surgeons of Canada
tasks of childhood. J School Health 1987; 57: 271-273 Vancouver
4. Isberner F, Wright WR: Comprehensive prenatal care for Anna Lee Chabot, head, meetings and assemblies section,
pregnant teens. Ibid: 288-292 Office of Fellowship Affairs, Royal College of Physicians
5. Elster AB, Lamb ME, Tavre J et al: The medical and and Surgeons of Canada, 774 Echo Dr., Ottawa, ON
psychosocial impact of comprehensive care on adolescent KI S 5N8; tel (613) 730-6233 or (613) 730-8177;
pregnancy and parenthood. JAMA 1987; 258: 1187-1192 fax (613) 730-8830
6. Burts HW: Prenatal care and pregnancy outcomes. J Adolesc
Health Care 1991; 12: 583-584 Sept. 10, 1993: Health Care Aide Clinic Day
7. Wells RD, McDiarmid J, Bayatpour M: Perinatal Health
Belief Scales. A cost-effective technique for predicting pre- North York, Ont.
natal appointment keeping rates among pregnant teenagers. Sybil Gilinsky, Continuing Education Department,
J Adolesc Health Care 1990; 11: 119-124 Baycrest Centre for Geriatric Care, 3560 Bathurst St.,
8. Olds DL, Henderson CR, Tatelbaum R et al: Improving the North York, ON M6A 2E1; tel (416) 789-5131,
delivery of prenatal care and outcomes of pregnancy: a ext. 2365
randomized trial of nurse home visitation. Pediatrics 1986;
77: 16-28 Sept. 20-22, 1993: Alzheimer's Disease International 9th
9. Cartoof VG, Klerman LV, Zazueta VD: The effect of source Annual Conference - Global Challenge, Local Action
of prenatal care on care-seeking behavior and pregnancy
outcomes among adolescents. J Adolesc Health Care 1991; 12: Toronto
124-129 Alzheimer Society of Canada, 201-1320 Yonge St.,
10. Chen SP, Fitzgerald MC, DeStefano LM et al: Effects of a Toronto, ON M4T 1X2; tel (416) 925-3552,
school nurse prenatal counselling program. Public Health fax (416) 925-1649
Nurs 1991; 8: 212-218
11. Marques PR, McKnight AJ: Drug abuse risk among pregnant Sept. 27-29, 1993: 1 st International Conference on
adolescents attending public health clinics. Am J Drug Alcohol Community Health Nursing Research
Abuse 1991; 17: 399-413 Edmonton
12. Kay FJ, Share DA, Jones K et al: Process, costs and outcomes Shirley Stinson or Karen Mills, c/o Edmonton Board of
of community-based prenatal care for adolescents. Med Care Health, 500-10216-124 St., Edmonton, AB T5N 4A3;
1991; 29: 531-542
13. Kalmuss D, Darabi KF, Lopez I et al: Barriers to Prenatal tel (403) 482-1965, fax (403) 482-4194
Care: an Examination of Use of Prenatal Care among
Low-Income Women in New York City, Community Service Oct. 6-8, 1993: Canadian Waste Management Conference
Society, New York, 1987: 122 - Innovative Waste Management Solutions: an Outlook
14. Institute of Medicine staff: Prenatal Care: Reaching Mothers, for the Future
Reaching Infants, Natl Acad Pr, Washington, 1988 Saint John, NB
15. Faller H: Perinatal needs among immigrant women. Public Susan Clarke, technical seminar coordinator, Technology
Health Rep 1985; 100: 340-343 Development Branch, Environment Canada, Unit 100,
16. Larson G, Spangberg L, Theorell T et al: Maternal opinion of
psychosocial support: evaluation of an antenatal programme. Asticou Centre, 241 Cite des Jeunes Blvd., Hull, PQ
J Adv Nurs 1987; 12: 441-449 KIA 0H3; tel (819) 953-5227, fax (819) 953-9029
17. Poland M, Ager JW, Olson JM: Barriers to receiving adequate
prenatal care. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1987; 157: 297-303 Du 6 au 8 oct. 1993: Conference canadienne sur la gestion
18. McAnarney ER: Commentary on teenage pregnancy: compar- des dechets - Solutions innovatrices en matiere de
ison with two groups of older pregnant women. J Adolesc gestion des dechets: Perspectives d'avenir
Health Care 1991; 12: 82-83 Saint-Jean, N-B
19. Wallace HM, Vienonen M: Teenage pregnancy in Sweden and Susan Clarke, coordonnatrice des seminaires techniques,
Finland. JAdolesc Health Care 1989; 10: 231-236
20. Creatsas G, Goumalatsos N, Deligeoroglou E et al: Teenage Direction du Developpement Technologique,
pregnancy: comparison with two groups of older pregnant Environnement Canada, Unite 100, Centre Asticou,
women. JAdolesc Health Care 1991; 12: 77-81 241, Cite des Jeunes, Hull, QC K1A OH3;
21. McAnarney ER: Young maternal age and adverse neonatal tel (819) 953-5227, fax (819) 953-9029
outcome. Am JDis Child 1987; 141: 1053-1059
22. Hulley SB, Cummings SR: Designing Clinical Research: an Oct. 7-10, 1993: 3rd Congress of the Asian Pacific Society
Epidemiologic Approach, Williams & Wilkins, Baltimore, Md, of Respirology (organized by the Singapore Thoracic
1988 Society)
23. Post S: Family centred maternity care: the Canadian picture.
Dimens Health Serv 1981; June: 25-31 Singapore
24. Barr L: Special considerations in the care of the pregnant and Secretariat, 3rd Congress of the Asian Pacific Society of
parenting adolescent. NAA COG Update Ser 1985; 3: 2-7 Respirology, 336 Smith St. 06-302, New Bridge Centre,
25. Lane C, Kemp J: Family planning needs of adolescents. Singapore 0105; tel 011-65-227-9811, fax 011-65-
JOGNNurs 1984; Mar-Apr: 61, 65 227-0257
26. Committee on Adolescent Medicine: The adolescent mother
and her baby. Can Paediatr Soc News Bull11979; 10: 5 continued on page 2159
2154 CAN MED ASSOC J 1993; 148 (12) For prescribing information see page 2212

You might also like