Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal - Event 1
Jurnal - Event 1
Abstract
While mega events substantially contribute to a hosting community’s economy and marketing appeal,
small-scale events might result in more positive effects because they operate within an existing infrastruc
ture, require a smaller budget, create a more manageable level of crowd congestion, and have high-impact
regional effects on the community. Despite the positive effects and prevalence of small-scale events, few have
examined their conceptual development. The purpose of this study was to investigate the hierarchical rela
tionship among event image, satisfaction, and behavioral intention (i.e., intention to revisit and recommend
the event to others) in the context of a small-scale m arathon event. A total of 297 valid questionnaires were
collected from participants at the Mercedes-Benz M arathon Event and the Publix M arathon Event, recur
ring small-scale m arathon events held in southeastern cities in the United States. Results from a confirma
tory factor analysis of the event image-satisfaction-behavioral intentions model indicated a good fit to the
data. The results of regression analyses demonstrated that event image and satisfaction were positively asso
ciated with behavioral intention and that satisfaction partially mediated the relationship between event
image and behavioral intention. In addition, the z-value provided by the Sobel test indicated that the indi
rect effect of event image on behavioral intention through satisfaction was significant. The findings offer
im portant implications for event organizers (i.e., marathon) that can be used to develop marketing strate
gies that attract participants to small-scale m arathon events.
Age 36.29
Gender Male 146 (49.2)
Female 150 (50.5)
Ethnicity Caucasian 192 (64.6)
African-American 55 (18.5)
Hispanic 16 (5.4)
Asian 30 (10.1)
Pacific Islander 1 (.3)
Other 2 (.7)
Household Income Less than $25K 29 (9.8)
$25K ~ $50K 53 (17.8)
$50K ~ $75K 105 (35.4)
$75K ~ $100K 61 (20.5)
$100K~ $150K 23 (7.7)
More than $150K 17 (5.7)
Education High School 29 (9.8)
College Degree 205 (69.0)
Graduate School 61 (20.5)
an indirect effect through satisfaction as well. In addi indicated that the average age was 36. In terms of gen
tion, this model illustrated that satisfaction would have der, 49.5% were male and 50.5% were female. Ethnicity
a positive effect on behavioral intention. was predominantly Caucasian (64.6%), followed by
African American (18.5%). The majority of respondents
Method
were highly educated; 69.0% held a college degree, and
20.5% held a graduate degree. With regard to annual
Participants
income, 35.4% of the respondents earned an annual
As this study attempted to offer im portant implica
income of $50,000-$75,000, followed by $75,000-
tions that can be used to develop marketing strategies
$100,000 (20.5%), and $25,000-$50,000 (17.8%).
at a small-scale m arathon event, data were collected
from participants at small-scale m arathon events held Instruments
in southeastern cities in the United States: (a) the Based on the literature review, a questionnaire was
Mercedes-Benz M arathon Event in Birmingham, AL, developed that consisted of four sections: (a) event
and (b) the Publix M arathon Event in Atlanta, GA. In image, (b) satisfaction, (c) behavioral intention, and
order to measure participant satisfaction specially, our (d) socio-demographics. The SEI scale, which consists
study included a screening question to distinguish par of 13 five-point semantic differential scale-type items,
ticipants from spectators at each event. Only respon was used to measure event image (Kaplanidou 8c Vogt,
dents who indicated that they had participated in the 2007). Satisfaction was measured using two items
m arathon event were included. A convenience sample adapted from Oliver (1980). The items were modified
was drawn, and the active participants were intercept as follows: “I truly enjoyed my visit to this m arathon
ed to fill in the questionnaire after the event. A total event” and “I am satisfied with the overall experience.”
num ber of 322 questionnaires were collected from the These items were measured on a 5-point Likert scale
m arathon events. Twenty-five questionnaires were ranging from 1 (“strongly disagree”) to 5 (“strongly
eliminated because they were incomplete or incorrectly agree”). Behavioral intention was measured using two
filled in. Consequently, 297 valid questionnaires were items: (a) likelihood of revisiting the event and (b)
accepted for subsequent analyses. willingness to recommend the event to significant oth
A list of the respondents’ demographics is provided in ers (Boulding et al., 1993). These items were measured
Table 1. The demographic profile of the respondents on a 5-point Likert scale ranging from 1 (“strongly dis-
Event Image
Stimulating/Unstimulating 4.01 .89 -1.13 1.71
Poor/Excellent 4.21 .82 -.76 -.18
Sad/Joyful 4.31 .78 -.69 -.73
H eal thy/Unheal thy 4.41 .86 -1.98 4.68
Gloomy/Cheerful 4.25 .85 -1.02 .73
Distressing/Relaxing 3.98 .93 -.71 .25
Inspiring/Uninspiring 4.01 .91 -.92 .66
Unsupportive/Supportive 4.13 .84 -.78 .40
Satisfaction
I truly enjoyed my visit to this marathon event 4.47 .63 -1.18 2.65
I am satisfied with the overall experience 4.42 .68 -1.01 1.12
Behavioral Intention
I am likely to revisit this marathon event 4.43 .72 -1.19 1.40
I am likely to recommend this marathon event 4.47 .69 -1.25 1.66
agree”) to 5 (“strongly agree”). Socio-demographic Upon the testing the measurement model, regression
information gathered in the study included age, gen analyses were employed to examine the impact of
der, ethnicity, education, and income level. Following event image and satisfaction on behavioral intention as
the development of the questionnaire, panel experts well as the impact of event image on satisfaction.
consisting of sport management and marketing profes Following Baron and Kenny’s (1986) guidelines, a
sors reviewed it for content validity. They were asked series of hierarchical regressions were also conducted
to assess the content relevance, representativeness, and to test the mediating role of satisfaction in the relation
clarity of the items. They also provided suggestions for ship between event image and behavioral intention. A
changing words and phrases to increase clarity. Acting variable serves as a mediator when it fulfills the follow
on the feedback derived from the panel experts, minor ing conditions: (a) the purported predictor (i.e., event
wording changes were made. image) is related to the mediator (i.e., satisfaction) and
the criterion variable (i.e., behavioral intention), (b)
Data Analysis the mediator has a significant unique effect on the cri
Procedures from the Statistical Package for the Social terion, and (c) upon the addition of the mediator to
Science (SPSS 19.0) were used to calculate descriptive the model, the magnitude of the predictor on the crite
statistics, central tendency (e.g., mean), measures of rion becomes either insignificant (fully mediating) or
variability (e.g., standard deviation), and data normality reduced (partially mediating). Finally, the Sobel test
(e.g., skewness and kurtosis). A Confirmatory Factor was conducted to examine the significance of the indi
Analysis (CFA) was conducted on the proposed model rect effect (Sobel, 1982).
to ensure the measurement model’s psychometric
properties. Various model fit indices were used, includ Results
ing standardized root mean square residual (SRMR),
root mean square error of approximation (RMSEA), Descriptive Statistics
Tucker-Lewis index (TLI), and comparative fit index Mean scores as well as standard deviations for event
(CFI). Additionally, convergent validity was assessed in image, satisfaction, and behavioral intention are shown
terms of factor loadings in the measurement model. in Table 2. The mean scores of the event image items
Furthermore, discriminant validity was assessed by ranged from 3.98 to 4.41 on the 5-point semantic dif
comparing squared correlations among the constructs. ferential scale. These scores suggest that most respon
Lastly, Cronbach’s alpha, Composite Reliability (CR), dents generally held a positive image of the
and Average Variance Extracted (AVE) were calculated Mercedes-Benz Marathon Event and the Publix
to assess inter-item reliability of the three constructs Marathon Event. The mean scores of the satisfaction
(Ffair, Anderson, Tatham, & Black, 1998). items ranged from 4.42 to 4.47, indicating that most
respondents felt a high level of satisfaction with the psychometric properties of the measurement model
two marathon events. The mean scores of the behav were good.
ioral intention items ranged from 4.43 to 4.47, suggest
ing that most respondents had positive behavioral Hypothesis Testing
intention toward future event participation. Regression analyses were conducted to examine the
impact of event image and satisfaction on behavioral
Psychometric Properties o f the Measurement Model intention as well as the impact of event image on satis
CFA was conducted on the proposed model to ensure faction. In detail, hypothesis la predicted that event
psychometric properties. The results indicate a good fit image would positively influence satisfaction. The
of the hypothesized model to the data (= 586.915; df= results indicate that event image had a significant
244; SRMR= .053; RMSEA = .069; TLI = .913; & CFI = influence on satisfaction (|3 = .55, p < .05), supporting
.923). In addition, convergent validity was assessed in hypothesis la. Hypothesis lb posited that event image
terms of factor loadings in the measurement model. would positively influence behavioral intention. The
Convergent validity is evidenced when factor loadings results also show that the influence of event image on
are equal to or greater than .50 (Hair et al„ 1998). As behavioral intention was significant ((3 = .54, p < .05),
shown in Table 3, factor loadings for each item ranged supporting hypothesis lb. Finally, hypothesis 2 pre
from .64 to .87, indicating that convergent validity was dicted that satisfaction would positively influence
established. Furthermore, comparison of squared cor behavioral intention. Satisfaction had a significant
relations among the constructs was used to measure effect on behavioral intention ((3 = .82, p < .05), sup
discriminate validity, which should be less than .85 porting hypothesis 2. The results of these regression
(Kline, 2010). The estimated correlations among the analyses are presented in Table 4.
exogenous latent constructs ranged from .51 to .82, Baron and Kenny’s (1986) guidelines were used in
confirming discriminant validity. Lastly, Cronbach’s this study for testing the mediating role of satisfaction
alpha, CR, and AVE were calculated to assess the relia in the relationship between event image and behavioral
bility of the three instruments. For items to be reliable, intention. The first step showed that the influence of
Cronbach’s alpha and CR should be greater than the event image on both satisfaction ((3 = .55, p < .05) and
suggested cut-off value of .70, and AVE should be behavioral intention ((3 = .54, p < .05) was significant,
greater than the recommended cut-off value of .50 and the second step indicated that satisfaction was sig
(Fornell & Larcker, 1981). As presented in Table 3, the nificantly related to behavioral intention ((3 = .82, p <
values for Cronbach’s alpha and CR were above .70, .05). The third step revealed that when satisfaction was
and the values for AVE were above .50. Therefore, the controlled, the influence of event image on behavioral
intention was still significant ((3 = .12, p < .05) but that
Volume 23 • Number 3 • 2014 • Sport Marketing Quarterly 133
Table 4
Regression Analyses (N = 297)
Table 5
Sobel Test (N = 297)
Path Z Probability Level
the magnitude of the beta coefficient was reduced, partially mediated the relationship between event
indicating that satisfaction partially mediated the rela image and behavioral intention at a small-scale
tionship between event image and behavioral intention m arathon event. Positive event image related to both
for participants at a small-scale m arathon event (see satisfaction and positive future behavioral intention for
Figure 1). In addition, the z-value provided by the participations of the small-scale m arathon events.
Sobel test was 2.44 (p < .05), indicating that the indi Previous studies have indicated that a more positive
rect effect of event image on behavioral intention image of a destination corresponded to higher levels of
through satisfaction was statistically significant. satisfaction, which, in turn, determined behavioral
intention (Chi & Qu, 2008). In line with those find
D iscu ssion ings, the current study provides additional support
This study focused on investigating the hierarchical through a series of hierarchical regressions. In other
relationship among event image, satisfaction, and words, event image was found to be a determ inant of
behavioral intention (i.e., intention to revisit and rec satisfaction and behavioral intention.
om mend the event to others) in the context of a small-
Marketing Implications
scale m arathon event. The results offered support for
The findings of this study provide a num ber of insights
the statistically significant relationship between event
and im portant implications for small-scale m arathon
image and behavioral intention. That is, participants
event organizers interested in developing marketing
with positive and favorable event image were likely to
strategies based on the identification of key elements of
have positive future behavioral intention toward a
participants’ decision making. First, m arathon event
small-scale m arathon event. This finding is consistent
organizers should consider building a positive event
with previous findings that event image has a positive
image and maintaining that image. For example,
influence on revisiting and recommending an event
m arathon event organizers should provide the partici
(Kaplanidou & Gibson, 2012). In addition, with refer
pants with positive experiences that enhance the orga
ence to the relationship between satisfaction and
nizational, environmental, emotional, social fulfillment,
behavioral intention, the regression analysis also indi
and physical activity aspects of the event (Kaplanidou &
cates that greater satisfaction with the m arathon event
Vogt, 2006). Event image appears to be a direct
made positive future behavioral intention more likely.
antecedent of satisfaction, as well as a major influence
This result is also consistent with previous studies that
on behavioral intention, even without the mediation of
recognized satisfaction as a good predictor of behav
satisfaction. This finding supports the position that
ioral intention (Bigne, Sanchez, & Sanchez, 2001; Chen
m arathon event organizers should develop and pursue
& Tsai, 2007). Following Baron and Kenny’s (1986)
an event image-development agenda by focusing on
guidelines, the current study found that satisfaction
event image attributes that influence satisfaction and marathon event, additional images, such as sponsor
behavioral intention. Second, enhancing satisfaction image (e.g., Mercedes-Benz and Publix) and destina
should be considered a strategic investment for event tion image, might give further insight into the out
organizers. The general view is that if participants are come variables. Thus, future research might include
satisfied, they will have positive behavioral intention those images to uncover additional relationships with
(i.e., engaging in positive word-of-mouth and returning the outcome variables. Thirdly, although event image
to the event site) in the future (Kaplanidou & Gibson, in this study was the only antecedent of satisfaction
2010). This study also provides empirical evidence sup and behavioral intention, additional factors, such as
porting the notion that satisfaction directly affects perceived value, could influence and interact with
behavioral intention at a small-scale marathon event. those variables. Because participants might weigh the
Furthermore, based on the finding that completing a costs against the perceived benefits of their experience
marathon race can enhance event satisfaction, at a small-scale marathon event, re-conceptualizing the
marathon organizers should consider hosting races of proposed model by including perceived value might
various distances (e.g., 5K and half marathon) to draw enhance our understanding of how event image and
participants with different levels of confidence and perceived value interact with satisfaction to influence
experience so that a greater number of participants will behavioral intention (i.e., revisit and word-of-mouth)
be able to complete their races. Lastly, as satisfaction in the context of small-scale marathon event. Fourth,
was found to play an important mediating role in the testing the moderating effect of a variable such as fre
relationship between event image and behavioral inten quency of participation (i.e., first-time vs. return par
tion, improving event image with satisfaction could ticipants) might also allow researchers and event
maximize positive outcomes in terms of participants’ organizers to better understand event consumption
behavioral intention. Therefore, marathon event organ behaviors toward small-scale marathon event. Lastly,
izers should develop a strategy for enhancing satisfac future studies could use structural equation modeling
tion through event image (i.e., linking participants’ (SEM) to estimate a conceptual model, a useful
emotions more closely to the event). method when the constructs are fully latent variables
measured with multiple indicators (Kline, 2010), for
Limitations and Suggestions for Future Research
SEM can take into consideration the measurement
As with all research investigations, several limitations
error variance associated with the indicators that rep
should be addressed. First, the data for this study were
resent the latent variables (Kline, 2010).
collected at only two small-scale marathon events held
in the southeast region of the United States. This nar References
row scope possibly means that the results are not gen- Baloglu, S., & McCleary, K. W. (1999). A model of destination image for
eralizable to all participants of small-scale marathon mation. Annals o f Tourism Research, 26, 868-897.
events in other parts of the country or the world. Baron, R. M„ & Kenny, D. A. (1986). The moderator-mediator variable
Additional data collection at small-scale marathon distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and
statistical considerations. Journal o f Personality and Social Psychology, 51,
events in other locations would increase the external 1173.
validity of the tested model. A second limitation is that Bigne, J. E., Sanchez, M. I., & Sanchez, J. (2001). Tourism image, evaluation
even though event image explained a good amount of variables and after purchase behaviour: inter-relationship. Tourism
satisfaction and behavioral intention at a small-scale Management, 22, 607-616.