You are on page 1of 4

2016 International Conference on Instrumentation, Control and Automation (ICA)

Institut Teknologi Bandung (ITB), Bandung, Indonesia, August 29-31, 2016

Characterization of a Water Level Measurement


System Developed Using a Commercial Submersible
Pressure Transducer

E. Yuliza1,3, R. A. Salam1,3, I. Amri1,3, E. D. Atmajati1,3, D. A. Hapidin1,3, I. Meilano2,3, M. M. Munir1,3,a, M.


Abdullah1, Khairurrijal1,3,b
1
Department of Physics, Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences,
2
Geodesy Research Division,
3
Research Center for Disaster Mitigation,
Institut Teknologi Bandung, Bandung 40132, Indonesia
a
miftah@fi.itb.ac.id
b
krijal@fi.itb.ac.id

Abstract – A water level measurement system employing a advantages and disadvantages for each data acquisition
commercial submersible pressure transducer was developed. The method, the hydrostatic pressure principle was selected due to
submersible pressure transducer consists of a piezoresistive mainly measurement environment as well as its accuracy,
sensor configured in a Wheatstone bridge, a signal conditioner, stability, linearity, time lag, and durability.
and a 4-20 mA transmitter. The measurement system is also
equipped with a 4-20 mA receiver for long wire transmission and This paper reports a water level measurement system that
an 8-bit ADC contained in an ATmega 16 microcontroller for was developed using a commercial pressure transducer. This
further processing and providing water level display. Based on system is intended to be used for monitoring and measurement
the characterization of the obtained measurement result, a linear of water level for an early warning system such as flood,
correlation between the water level and the sensor output was landslide, and tsunami. In order to minimize possible errors
obtained. It is shown that the pipe diameter and the position of that may occur in the field, the transducer was characterized
the sensitive part of the sensor do not affect the sensor output. extensively through experiments and performances of the
This implies that the change on the sensor output is only due to measurement system was examined.
the level of the water. It was also found that the submersible
water level sensor possesses high accuracy, sensitivity, stability,
linearity, and proper hysteresis characteristics. II. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
The development of water level measurement system or
Keywords—water level, hydrostatic pressure, submersible sensor reported in this paper makes use of the hydrostatic
pressure transducer pressure principle. Essentially, this principle describes that the
pressure P at each point in a water column is proportional to
I. INTRODUCTION liquid level according to the following hydrostatic equation:
Liquid level measurement is one of the most frequently
discussed topics in recent times due to its substantial role in P g h (1)
various applications such as food industry, pharmaceuticals,
drug manufacturing, chemical industry, power generation, and where ρ is the density of the liquid, g is the gravitational
various disaster management activities [1-7]. On the other acceleration, and h is the height of water surface level. In this
hand, due to the change in global climate and the increased study, a commercial submersible pressure transducer
frequency of rainfall which trigger the occurrence of various employing a piezoresistive sensor was used [13, 14]. The
disasters such as landslides and flood, reliable sensors that can sensor is designed as a hydrostatic transducer that measures
measure changes of water level is required to predict the the liquid height from bottom of the sensor to liquid surface.
occurrence of possible disasters. Fig. 1 shows the block diagram of the developed level
In general, there are two types of liquid level measurement measurement system, which consists of a commercial
systems that have so far been developed: continuous level submersible pressure transducer (dash line box), a 4-20 mA
measurement and point level measurement [1], whereas the receiver and a microcontroller. The submersible pressure
data acquisition methods include measurements based on transducer operates in the following way: when the water level
radar, electro-mechanical, capacitance, ultrasonic, optical, and changes, it causes the pressure received by the piezoresistive
hydrostatic pressure principles [1, 8-12]. Although there are sensor also changes. This results in a change of the resistance

978-1-5090-1335-7/16/$31.00 ©2016 IEEE


99
 
generated by the sensor in the Wheatstone bridge. The output acquired for every 40-cm water level change. To measure the
voltage of the Wheatstone bridge, which is result from any water level, a roll meter with a resolution of 1 mm was used.
change in the water level, is in the order of millivolts. Fig. 2 shows the schematics of the experiment. The
Therefore, it requires signal conditioner system which is measurement was started at a zero water level and continued
equipped with an amplifier. Afterward, the output of the signal with the increasing water level for pointed levels. The rise of
conditioning circuit is converted into electrical signal in the water level was performed by flowing water through the water
form of direct current ranging from 4 to 20 mA using a inlet until it reaches the pointed level. The excess of water
standard 4-20 mA transmitter circuit [14]. level was flown out through the water outlet.
In order to show that the resulting change is only due to
varying height, this measurement was conducted through two
treatments. The first treatment was done using various pipe
diameters of 2 inches and 3 inches. The sensor was inserted
through the bottom pipe of the system so that the sensitive
area of the sensor faces upward as shown in Fig. 2(a).
Furthermore, to investigate the effect of the sensitive area
of the sensor, another treatment was performed. In the first
treatment, the sensitive area was faced upward, while in the
second one, the sensitive area was positioned from the top of
  the pipe system, making the sensitive area faces downward as
Fig. 1. Block diagram of water level measurement system. depicted in Fig. 2(b). Similar to the first treatment, the pipe
diameter in the second treatment was also varied.
In addition, the transmission using the rated current is done
to avoid the loss of electrical signal and its possible III. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
attenuation due to utilization of long wires. The transmitted
current output is then converted into voltage in order to Although the employed sensor is commercial one, the
simplify the reading using a standard 4-20 mA receiver circuit. testing of its various characteristics still has to be done to gain
[15]. The resulting analog voltage output is then converted better understanding of its characteristics. The sensor was
into digital data using an 8-bit internal ADC of the ATmega tested through several steps of experiment treatments as
16 microcontroller. The digital data from the microcontroller described previously. In the first step, the submersible sensor
is finally sent to a personal computer (PC) to be displayed. was characterized to obtain several characteristics such as its
transfer function, hysteresis, and linearity.

Fig. 2. Experimental setup: (a) Treatment 1; (b) Treatment 2.

To explore the performance of the developed submersible


water level sensor, a laboratory scale sensor testing system
was designed. According to the principle of hydrostatic
pressure, the pressure in the water column is affected solely by
the height of the water around the sensor. To examine the Fig. 3. Transfer function curve of submersible sensor
ability of the conditioner on the sensor, the construction of the
testing system was designed with varying pipe diameters. The transfer function was obtained by observing the
Furthermore, the sensor was placed at different conditions to relationship between sensor input and output data (cf. Fig. 3).
investigate the sensor response under various circumstances, It was found that the sensor input is responded by the output in
i.e. facing downward and upward as shown in Figs. 2(a) and a linear manner according to the following relationship
2(b), respectively.
 V  0.12909 H  2.8 , R 2  0.997   
The measurement of the water level was conducted with
point level measurement technique. The output voltage was where V represents the output voltage and H is the water level.

100
This result shows a linear correlation between the current and
the water level with 0.6% error.

Fig. 4. Hysteresis curve of submersible water level sensor

Afterward, the characterization of the sensor equipped


Fig. 6. Calibration curve of the 4-20 mA receiver circuit
with the 4-20 mA transmitter circuit was done in order to get
the hysteresis curve. It was obtained by comparing the sensor
In the next step, the designed 4-20 mA receiver circuit was
response in forward mode and reverse mode. The forward
calibrated. The input of the receiver circuit is from output of
mode was done by determining the sensor response to the rise
the 4-20 mA transmitter circuit. It is found that there is a linear
of water level, whereas the reverse mode was achieved during
relationship between input and output of the receiver circuit as
the draining of the water to reduce the height of the level. It is
shown in Fig. 6. The aforementioned characteristics of the
evident that the characteristic curves for the addition and the
sensor with the 4-20 mA transmitter circuit along with the
reduction of water agreed each with each other and that the
calibration curve of the 4-20 mA receiver circuit show a
obtained hysteresis value of 0.15% as shown in Fig. 4. This
relatively ideal device performance due to the accurate output
implies that the sensor would yield constant current value for
of the sensor, adequately assembled instrument system with
every condition or there is no hysteresis on the sensor with a
proper output, and consistent testing setup.
4-20 mA transmitter circuit.

Fig. 7. Sensor response for variation of pipe diameter


Fig. 5. Linearity curve of submersible sensor

The linear characteristic of the sensor with the 4-20 mA The next step of the experiment was to investigate the
transmitter is shown in Fig. 5 with linear equation as in in (3). sensor output under different pipe diameters. Fig. 7 shows the
Therefore, the sensor with the 4-20 mA transmitter circuit sensor response at similar height but different pipe diameters.
fulfills the criteria needed for water level sensing. It can be seen that the output characteristics are similar
regardless of the pipe diameters. It is evident that the pressure
difference is only affected by the level of water and not
 I  0.00743H  4.067 , R 2  0.999   influenced by the volume of the water. According to the

101
hydrostatic theory, the output condition documented in Fig. 7 sensitivity, stability, linearity, and proper hysteresis
only applies for fluids with homogeneous density. For characteristics.
measurements in granular cases, pressure difference is
influenced not only by the liquid level but also the material ACKNOWLEDGMENT
diameter and density [12, 16].
This work was financially supported by “Program
Unggulan Perguruan Tinggi (PUPT)” Research Grant in the
fiscal year 2016.

REFERENCES
[1] K. Chetpattananondh, T. Tapoanoi, P. Phukpattaranont and N.
Jindapetch “A self-calibration water level measurement using an
interdigital capacitive sensor,” Sensor Actuat. A. Vol. 209, pp. 175-182,
2014.
[2] I. Kodeli and G. Bignan, “Water level monitoring after shutdown using
neutron and gamma flux measurement in PWR”, Ann. Nucl. Energy,
Vol. 24 no. 7, pp. 563-570, 1997.
[3] K. Termaat, J. Kops and K. Kobayashi, “Fabrication test of tricoth-type
reactor water level sensor”, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. Vol. 37 no. 2, pp.
1024 – 1031, 1990.
[4] L-C. Shen, J-C. Juang, C.-L. Tsai and C.-L. Tseng, “Monitoring water
level and current using reflected GPS carrier Doppler measurements and
coordinate rotation model”, IEEE Trans. Instrum. Meas. Vol. 59 no. 1,
pp. 153 – 163, 2010.
[5] T-H. Wang, M-C. Lu, C-C. Hsu, C-C. Chen and J-D. Tan, “Liquid level
measurement using a songe digital camera”, Measurement, Vol. 42 no.
Fig. 8. Sensor response for variation of sensing area
4, pp. 604-610, 2009.
[6] G.F.Wieczorek and J.B.Synder, “Monitoring slope movements”, in
Lastly, the influence of the sensing area position (facing Geological Monitoring, chap. 11, R. Young and L. Norby, Colorado:
downward or upward) on the output response was also Geological Society of America, 2009 pp. 245-271.
observed as given in Fig. 8. The experiment followed that [7] A. Bonaduce, N. Pinardi, P. Oddo, G. Spada and G. Larnicol, “Sea-level
described in Fig. 2. This measurement involved two wires variability in thr mediterranean sea from altimetry and tide gauges”,
Clim. Dyn., pp.1-16, 2016. DOI: 10.1007/s00382-016-3001-2
with different lengths which led to different output values in
[8] M. M. Munir, R.A. Salam, E. Widiatmoko, Y. Supriadani, A.
each of the edge of the wire. In the first treatment, a 5 meter- Rahmadhani, H. Latief and Khairurrijal, “Web-surface level measuring
length wire was employed while in the second treatment a 20 system employing ultrasonic sensors and GSM/GPRS based
meter-length was used. Additionally, the zero point of each communication”, Appl. Mech. Mater., Vol. 771, pp 42-45, 2015.
sensor was different. In this case, a difference of 1 cm in this [9] H. Golnabi, “Design and operation of a fiber optic sensor for liquid level
sensor with 5 m wire is equivalent to 0.032 mA current detection”, Optical and lasers in engineering. Vol. 4, pp. 801-812 2004.
difference, whereas with 20 m wire it is equivalent to 0.008 [10] S. Stuart, H. Sarah, Y. Marcus and K. Chuck, Water Level Sensor
Testing Summary, San Luis Obispo: ITRC California Polytechnic State
mA. This would lead to the difference in the reading until 4 University, 2004.
times for the same water level. One centimeter error due to [11] D. Sengupta, M. S. Shankar, P. S. Reddy, R. L. N. S. Prasad and K.
parallax reading would induce a different output voltage. Srimannarayana, “Sensing of hydrostatic pressure using FGB sensor for
However, according to the relation between the change of liquid level measurement”, microwave and optical technology letters.
water level and voltage difference, it is noticeable that both the Vol. 54 no.7, pp. 1679-1683, 2012.
sensors possessed similar increase. [12] C. Zet, C. Fosalau and D. Petrisor, “Pore water pressure for landslide
prediction”, IEEE Sensors, pp. 1-4, 2015. [IEEE Sensors 2015 Conf.
2015].
IV. CONCLUSION [13] L. A. Freeman, M. C. Carpenter, D. O. F. Rosenberry, J. P. Rousseau, R.
Unger and J. S. McLean, Use of submersible pressure transducers in
A submersible water level measurement system employing water-resources investigations. U.S. Geological Survey: Denver, 2004.
a piezoresistive sensor has been developed. The sensor output [14] User Manual Model No.:WLI100, Immersion hydrostatic liquid level
was a digital data after processed by an 8-bit ADC of an tranducers. King Pigeon GSM 3G automation Co.Ltd: Shenzhen
ATMEGA16 microcontroller for displaying the water level. [15] A. Surachman, A. Suhendi, M. Budiman, M. Abdullah, and Khairurrijal,
Based on the conducted characterization processes, a linier “A simple microcontroller-based 4-20 mA current loop receiver for
correlation between the water level and the sensor output was sensor with current transmitter”, J. Otom. Kontrol Instrum., Vol 2(1),
obtained. In addition, the pipe diameter and the position of the 2010.
sensitive part of the sensor is shown to not affect the sensor [16] F. V. Blasio, Introduction to the physics of landslides. Springer: New
York, 2011, pp. 136-138.
output. These characterization results suggest that the sensor
output only changes due to the water level. It was found that
this submersible water level sensor possesses high accuracy,

102

You might also like