Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INFORMATICA Pentru Grupele de Performanta CL 9
INFORMATICA Pentru Grupele de Performanta CL 9
3UHIDĠă
,1)250$7,&Ă $WXQFLFkQGDPSRUQLWODGUXPvQSURLHFWDUHDFRQĠLQXWXOXLDFHVWHLFăUĠLPDLvQWkLDWUH
EXLWVăUăVSXQGHPODRPXOĠLPHGHvQWUHEăULFXLVHDGUHVHD]ăDFHDVWăFDUWHFDUHVXQW
RELHFWLYHOHSHFDUHOHXUPăULPDWkWGLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHDOFRQĠLQXWXOXLFkWúLDODVSHF
WHORUGLGDFWLFH
(VWHLPSRUWDQWFDGHODvQFHSXWVăFODULILFăPXQDVSHFWLPSRUWDQWQXHVWHYRUEDGH
FODVDD,;D XQPDQXDORELúQXLWFDUHSHED]DXQHLSURJUDPHúFRODUHRIHUăFXQRúWLQĠHDFRSHULWRDUH
LQWUăvQGHWDOLLFDUHVXQWQHFHVDUHHOHYLORUSHQWUXDvQĠHOHJHúLDGREkQGLFRQFHSWHIXQ
GDPHQWDOH$FHDVWăFDUWHVHDGUHVHD]ăDFHORUFRSLLFDUHVXQWGRULWRULGHFXQRúWLQĠHVX
SOLPHQWDUH GRUHVF Vă vQYHĠH PDL UHSHGH úL Vă DWLQJă SHUIRUPDQĠH vQ LQIRUPDWLFă FX
SUHFăGHUHvQDOJRULWPLFăúLSURJUDPDUHÌQFRQVHFLQĠăFXQRúWLQĠHOHWHRUHWLFHVXQWSUH
$XWRUL ]HQWDWHVXPDUVXQWÄRULHQWDWH´VSUHVFRSXOFODUGHDFUHDGHSULQGHULOHQHFHVDUHSHQWUX
DÄDWDFD´FkWPDLUHSHGHSUREOHPHOHSURSXVHVSUHUH]ROYDUHGLQGRPHQLX
SURI6LPRQD+DLGX
ÌQYăĠăPkQWXO GH LQIRUPDWLFă GLQ 5RPkQLD D FXQRVFXW PXOWH VXFFHVH $EVROYHQĠLL
SURI'DQD9DLGD IRVWHORUOLFHHGHLQIRUPDWLFăvQILLQĠDWHvQD]LVXQWSURIHVRULXQLYHUVLWDULFHUFHWă
SURI(XJHQ,RQHVFX WRULFRQGXFăWRULGHILUPHFXXQFXYkQWRDPHQLGHVXFFHV$FHVWOXFUXVHGDWRUHD]ăúL
FDOLWăĠLLvQYăĠăPkQWXOXLGLQDFHVWHúFROLGDUúLIDSWXOXLFăLQIRUPDWLFDvLDWUăJHDSHFHL
PDLGRWDĠLWLQHUL(VWHODIHOúLD]LGDUvQYăĠăPkQWXOGHLQIRUPDWLFăSHGHRSDUWHVD
H[WLQV vQ VHQVXO QXPăUXOXL GH FRSLL FDUH vQYDĠă LQIRUPDWLFă vQ 5RPkQLD SH GH DOWă
&RRUGRQDWRUL SDUWHVDUHGXVDVFă]XWQXPăUXOGHRUHSHVăSWăPkQăDORFDWHGLVFLSOLQHLGHODOD
(VWHFODUFăQXVHSRDWHOXFUDÄSHUIRUPDQĠă´vQRUHFXWRĠLFRSLLLDúDFăDDSăUXWQH
OHFWRUXQLYGU&ODUD,RQHVFX FHVLWDWHDGHDRIHULFHORUSDVLRQDĠLúLGRULWRULGHSHUIRUPDQĠăXQFDGUXVXSOLPHQWDUXQ
GHVHSRWRFXSDFXFHHDFHvLLQWHUHVHD]ă
SURI$GLQD%ăODQ
(OHYLLGLQ5RPkQLDFăURUDOHSODFHSURJUDPDUHDSRWSDUWLFLSDODRVHULHGHFRQFXU
VXULVLPSR]LRDQHWDEHUHXQGHSRWvQYăĠDúLSRWDUăWDFHHDFHúWLX2OLPSLDGHOHGHLQ
IRUPDWLFă VXQW FX SUHFăGHUH GH DOJRULWPLFă úL SURJUDPDUH 3ULPD FRQGLĠLH SH FDUH XQ
HOHY WUHEXLH VR vQGHSOLQHDVFăSHQWUXDDYHDVXFFHVODDFHVWHROLPSLDGHHVWHVăILHvQ
VWDUHVăVHJkQGHDVFăVLQJXUVăVHFRQFHQWUH]HúLVăDLEăFXUDMSHQWUXLPSOHPHQWDUHD
XQHLVROXĠLLRULJLQDOH)LHFDUHSURLHFWGHDOJRULWPILHFDUHSURJUDPHVWHRFUHDĠLHQRXă
úLWUHEXLHVăvQGHSOLQHDVFăWRDWHFHULQĠHOHúLUHVWULFĠLLOHLPSXVHvQVSHFLILFDĠLLOHSUREOH
3UHIDĠă
PHORUGHUH]ROYDW3HQWUXDDMXQJHvQVLWXDĠLDUHVSHFWLYăHVWHQHYRLHGHPXOWHH[HUFLĠLL
GHPXOWHDQWUHQDPHQWH$FHVWHDELOLWăĠLVHSRWIRUPDGRDUUH]ROYkQGPXOWHIRDUWHPXO
WHSUREOHPH
ÌQFRQFOX]LHFDUWHDHVWHPDLPXOWRFXOHJHUHGHSUREOHPHGHFkWXQPDQXDOÌQFRQ 3URJUDPDúFRODUă
FHSĠLDDXWRULORUHDWRWXúLWUHEXLHSDUFXUVăvQVXFFHVLXQHDFDSLWROHORUDúDFXPVXQWHOH
vQúLUXLWHvQFDUWH5HFRPDQGăPDFHVWOXFUXGHRDUHFHFDUWHDQHILLQGRYHUVLXQHvPERJă
ĠLWăDXQXLPDQXDOHODERUDWFRQIRUPSURJUDPHLúFRODUHFXQRúWLQĠHOHGLQFDUWHGHSăúHVF *HQHUDOLWăĠL
FRQĠLQXWXODFHVWHLSURJUDPHHVWHQHYRLHGHRDERUGDUHWUHSWDWăDSUREOHPHORU$FFHQ
WXăPGHDVHPHQHDFăGDFăXQLLHOHYLDXGHMDFXQRúWLQĠHGHSURJUDPDUHGLQJLPQD]LX x &RQĠLQXWXO XUPăWRDUHL SURJUDPH GH]YROWDWH SHQWUX GRULWRULL GH FXQRúWLQĠH VROLGH
GHOD&OXEXO&RSLLORUHWFHLQXWUHEXLHFRQVWUkQúLGHH[HPSOXVăQXIRORVHDVFăVXE vQ SURJUDPDUH QX SUHFL]HD]ă OLPEDMXO GH SURJUDPDUH ÌQ IXQFĠLH GH FHULQĠHOH
SURJUDPHDQWHULRUFDSLWROXOXLvQFDUHVHSUH]LQWăDFHVWFRQFHSW$OWIHOVSXVRULFHSDV HOHYLORUúLGLVSRQLELOLWăĠLOHSURIHVRULORUWRDWHWHPHOHVHSRWWUDWDUHDOL]kQGDSOLFDĠLL
ÄvQDLQWH´HVWHSHUPLVFKLDUELQHYHQLWFXFRQGLĠLDFDUH]ROYLWRULLVăUHVSHFWHVSHFLILFD vQOLPEDMXOPascalúLVDXC++'HDVHPHQHDVHYRUIDFHDSOLFDĠLLúLvQFreePascal
ĠLLOHSUREOHPHL UHVSHFWLYgnu C(YLGHQWQXVXQWH[FOXVHQLFLPHGLLOHYL]XDOH'HOSKL9LVXDO&
3URIHVRUXOHVWHVIăWXLWVăOXFUH]HFXHOHYLLĠLQkQGFRQWGHvQWUHEăULOHúLGHUăVSXQVX 9LVXDO%DVLFVDX-DYD
ULOHORUVăúLPRGHOH]HDFWLYLWDWHDvQIXQFĠLHGHQLYHOXOJUXSXOXL'DFăDFWLYLWDWHDGH x &RQĠLQXWXOSURJUDPHLHVWHJUXSDWvQGHVăSWăPkQLSHSDUFXUVXOFăURUDDSUR[L
FXUJHIăUăSUREOHPHHYLGHQWVHSRDWHDYDQVDUHSHGHúLVHSRWVWXGLDúLSUREOHPHGLQ PDWLYGLQSDWUXvQSDWUXVăSWăPkQLVHYRURUJDQL]DÄPLQLFRQFXUVXUL´GLQGRPHQLXO
DOWHVXUVHVDXFKLDUGLQPDQXDOHOHFDUHFRQVWLWXLHFRQWLQXDUHDFHOXLGHIDĠă6HúWLHFă GRPHQLLOHGHFXQRúWLQĠHDERUGDWHGHMD(OHYLLYRUOXFUDvQFRQGLĠLLVLPLODUHYLLWRD
ODROLPSLDGHÄQXSUHD´VHĠLQHFRQWGHSURJUDPDúFRODUăLDUODROLPSLDGHOHLQWHUQDĠLR UHORU FRQFXUVXUL OD FDUH YRU SDUWLFLSD (YDOXDUHD VH YD IDFH DXWRPDW XWLOL]kQG
QDOHH[LVWăRVLQJXUăFDWHJRULHGHYkUVWăDQL VRIWZDUHXOGHHYDOXDUHFDUHYDILIRORVLWúLvQFHOHODOWHVăSWăPkQLSHQWUXDYHULILFD
OXFUăULOHHOHYLORUúLDHYDOXDPRGXOvQFDUHHLDYDQVHD]ă
5H]ROYăULOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVHVXQWSUH]HQWDWHVXEIRUPăGHH[SOLFDĠLLúLHYHQWXDO
SVHXGRFRGXODOJRULWPXOXL7H[WHOHVXUVăOHYHĠLSXWHDFRQVXOWDvQVRIWZDUHXOFDUHvQVR
ĠHúWHDFHVWHPDQXDOH1XDYHPSUHWHQĠLDFăvQWRWGHDXQDDPSURSXVFHDPDLHOHJDQWăúL 2ELHFWLYHJHQHUDOH
FHDPDLHILFLHQWăUH]ROYDUH'DFăQHFRQWDFWDĠLúLYHĠLILGHDFRUGFDVROXĠLLOHLQWHUHVDQ
WH úL RULJLQDOH DOH GXPQHDYRDVWUă Vă GHYLQă SXEOLFH DFHVWHD YRU IL vQJOREDWH vQ VRIW (OHYLLSDUWLFLSDQĠLYRUILFDSDELOL
ZDUHúLYRUILDGăXJDWHQRLORUHGLĠLLDOHPDQXDOHORU ± VăDQDOL]H]HHQXQĠXULGHSUREOHPHFDUHGHSăúHVFQLYHOXOSURJUDPHLúFRODUH
± Vă DOHDJă WLSXO GDWHORU Vă FUHH]H VWUXFWXUL GH GDWH DGHFYDWH vQ VFRSXO PRGHOăULL
9ăGRULPVXFFHV GDWHORUGHLQWUDUHúLGHLHúLUH
$XWRULL ± VăSURLHFWH]HDOJRULWPLGHUH]ROYDUHSHQWUXSUREOHPH
± VăLPSOHPHQWH]HDOJRULWPLLSURLHFWDĠLXWLOL]kQGXQOLPEDMGHSURJUDPDUH
± VăSUHOXFUH]HGDWHVWUXFWXUDWHODQLYHOGHFRPSRQHQWHúLODQLYHOGHVWUXFWXUă
± VăOXFUH]HFXGDWHRUJDQL]DWHvQILúLHUH
± VăOXFUH]HFXVXESURJUDPH
± VăDOHDJăDOJRULWPXOGHRUGRQDUHUHVSHFWLYGHFăXWDUHDGHFYDW
± VăIRORVHDVFăRSHUDWRULLSHELĠLvQYHGHUHDRSWLPL]ăULLSURJUDPHORU
± VăSUHOXFUH]HQXPHUHGHRULFHGLPHQVLXQH
± VăOXFUH]HUHFXUVLYvQVLWXDĠLDvQFDUHDFHVWOXFUXHVWHQHFHVDUúLQXDIHFWHD]ăWLPSXO
GHH[HFXWDUHDSURJUDPHORU
± VăUH]ROYHSUREOHPHDSOLFkQGPHWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ
3URJUDPDúFRODUă 3URJUDPDúFRODUă
FLWLUHDXQHLVHFYHQĠHGHQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDHLvQDOWILúLHU
FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHúLUXULGHFDUDFWHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDORUvQWUXQDOW
*UXSDUHDWHPHORUSHVăSWăPkQL ILúLHU
FLWLUHDXQXLQXPăUQDWXUDO1GLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDvQWUXQDOWILúLHUDWXWXURU
6ăSWăPkQLOH5HFDSLWXODUHDFXQRúWLQĠHORUDFXPXODWHvQ QXPHUHORUQDWXUDOHFXSULQVHvQWUHúL1FkWHXQXOSHROLQLH
JLPQD]LX FLWLUHDXQXLQXPăUQDWXUDO1GLQWUXQILúLHUúLD1QXPHDIODWHSHXUPăWRDUHOH
OLQLLDOHILúLHUXOXLúLVFULHUHDFHORU1QXPHvQWUXQDOWILúLHU
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
FRSLHUHDLQWHJUDOăDFRQĠLQXWXOXLXQXLILúLHUvQWUXQDOWILúLHU
$FHLHOHYLFDUHDXSDUWLFLSDWODDFWLYLWăĠLOHFHQWUXOXLGHH[FHOHQĠăODLQIRUPDWLFăvQ
JLPQD]LXVDXDXIRVWDWUDúLVSUHFRQFXUVXULGHSURJUDPDUHYRUHIHFWXDRUHFDSLWXODUH
VXEFRQGXFHUHDSURIHVRUXOXL'DUvQWRWGHDXQDH[LVWăúLHOHYLFDUHLDXFRQWDFWFXDOJR 6ăSWăPkQD&DOFXOHHIHFWXDWHSHúLUXULGHGDWH
ULWPLLúLFXSURJUDPDUHDGRDUvQFODVDDD$FWLYLWDWHDVHYDGHVIăúXUDvQDúDPDQLH IăUăSăVWUDUHDORUVXEIRUPăGHWDEORXUL
Uă vQFkW vQFHSăWRULL VăL DMXQJă GLQ XUPă SH FHL DYDQVDĠL FkW VH SRDWH GHUHSHGHÌQ 2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
DFHVWVFRSSHQWUXDFHúWLHOHYLFRQĠLQXWXOFDSLWROXOXLGHUHFDSLWXODUHVHYDHúDORQDSH (OHYLLYRUILFDSDELOLVăUHFXQRDVFăFODVDGHSUREOHPHvQFDUHDYkQGODGLVSR]LĠLH
WUHLSDWUXVăSWăPkQL(OHYLLFDSDELOLYRUUH]ROYDSUREOHPHOHSURSXVHvQDFHVWFDSLWRO RVHFYHQĠăGHGDWHFDUHWUHEXLHSUHOXFUDWHOLQLDUQXHVWHQHFHVDUăSăVWUDUHDORUVXE
SHQWUXDILHYDOXDĠLúLJUXSDĠLvQVXEJUXSHvQIXQFĠLHGHQLYHOXOGHFXQRúWLQĠH IRUPDVWUXFWXULORUGHGDWHvQPHPRULH'HDVHPHQHDYRUvQYăĠDVăDSOLFHÄWHRUHPDGH
x 6WUXFWXUDSURJUDPHORU3DVFDO9RFDEXODUXOOLPEDMXOXL SURJUDPDUH´FDUHSUHOXFUHD]ăVHFYHQĠHGHGDWHFDUHWUDQVPLWHUH]XOWDWXOXQRUGHFL
x &RQVWDQWHWLSXULVWDQGDUGGHGDWHYDULDELOHH[SUHVLL ]LL
x &LWLUHDúLVFULHUHDGDWHORU x ,QLĠLDOL]DUHDVXPHLSURGXVXOXLFXHOHPHQWXOQHXWUXDORSHUDĠLHL
x ,QVWUXFĠLXQL x (IHFWXDUHDXQRURSHUDĠLLvQSDUDOHOFXFLWLUHDGDWHORUvQFD]XOSUREOHPHORUFDUHQX
3UREOHPHSHQWUXvQFHSăWRULÌQYăĠDUHDDOIDEHWXOXL*KLRFHLúLYLRUHOH6HUYLFLXO QHFHVLWăSăVWUDUHDúLUXOXLGHGDWHvQPHPRULH
SHFODVăWăLHUHDFRSDFLORU/DVFăOGDW'UXPXOVSUHúFRDOă x 5HDOL]DUHD SURWHFĠLHL H[SOLFLWH GLQ LQWHULRUXO SURJUDPXOXL vQ FD]XO XQRU SRVLELOH
$YDQVDĠL1XPHUHSULPHFXGLYL]RUL0DWHPDWLFDSHFDOFXODWRU/DSHVFXLW GHSăúLULúLDXQRUGDWHFDUHQXFRUHVSXQGVSHFLILFDĠLLORUGLQHQXQĠ
([FHOHQĠL6HUYLFLXOGHJDUGă3ODVDUHDRJOLQ]LORU3DOLQGURP1XPHUHDSURSLDWH FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDVXPHLORUvQWUXQDOWILúLHU
FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDSURGXVXOXLORUvQWUXQDOWILúLHU
6ăSWăPkQD)LúLHUH FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDúLVFULHUHDPHGLHLDULWPHWLFHvQWU
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH XQDOWILúLHU
(OHYLLVHYRUIDPLOLDUL]DFXGDWHVWRFDWHSHVXSRUWHOHFWURQLF6HúWLHFăvQWLPSXO FLWLUHDXQRUFDUDFWHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUXQXOSHOLQLHúLVFULHUHDúLUXOXLGHFDUDF
UHDOL]ăULLSURJUDPHORUúLvQWLPSXOYHULILFăULLORUDFHVWHDVHWHVWHD]ăvQPRGUHSHWDW WHUHvQWUXQDOWILúLHU
SHQWUXGLYHUVHGDWHGHLQWUDUHFDUHGHUHJXOăVXQWIXUQL]DWHvQILúLHUH'HDVHPHQHD
GDWHOHGHLHúLUHUH]XOWDWHOHWUHEXLHSăVWUDWHvQIRUPDWHOHFWURQLF/DPDUHDPDMRULWD 6ăSWăPkQD'HWHUPLQDUHDPLQLPXOXLUHVSHFWLYDPD[LPXOXL
WHDFRQFXUVXULORUGHSURJUDPDUHGDWHOHGHLQWUDUHVXQWFLWLWHGLQILúLHUHLDUFHOHGH 2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
LHúLUHVXQWVFULVHvQILúLHUHPRWLYSHQWUXFDUHHOHYLLWUHEXLHVăVHIDPLOLDUL]H]HFXDFHVW (OHYLLIDPLOLDUL]DĠLFXGDWHVWRFDWHSHVXSRUWHOHFWURQLFYRUvQYăĠDFXPVHUHGHVFKL
DVSHFWvQFăGHODvQFHSXW GH XQ ILúLHU SHQWUXFLWLUHUHVSHFWLYSHQWUXVFULHUHDvQFRQWLQXDUHDXQRUUH]XOWDWHvQ
x 'HWDOLLJHQHUDOHGHVSUHILúLHUH DFHVWD 'H DVHPHQHD HL YRU IL FDSDELOL Vă UH]ROYH SUREOHPH GH PD[LP úL GH PLQLP
x $VLJQDUHGHVFKLGHUHSHQWUXVFULHUHFLWLUHvQFKLGHUH IXUQL]kQG GDFă SUREOHPD FHUH úL SR]LĠLD SR]LĠLLOH YDORULORU HJDOH FX DFHVWHD &X
FLWLUHDXQXLQXPăUGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDVDvQDOWILúLHU DFHDVWă RFD]LH VH IDPLOLDUL]HD]ă FX VHOHFĠLD VHOHFWDUHD WXWXURU HOHPHQWHORU DYkQG R
FLWLUHDWXWXURUQXPHUHORUGLQWUXQILúLHUFDUHFRQĠLQHFkWHXQQXPăUSHROLQLHúL SURSULHWDWHGDWăúLFXUHDOL]DUHDRSWLPăDDFHVWRUD
VFULHUHDORUvQDOWILúLHUFkWHXQXOSHROLQLH x 5HGHVFKLGHUHDILúLHUHORUDWXQFLFkQGHVWHQHFHVDU
FLWLUHD GDWHORU GLQWUXQ ILúLHU FDUH FRQĠLQH QXPHUH PDL PXOWH SH R OLQLH úL x 'HWHUPLQDUHDPLQLPXOXLPD[LPXOXLGLQWUXQúLUGHGDWH
VFULHUHDORUvQWUXQDOWILúLHUvQDFHHDúLIRUPă x ,QLĠLDOL]DUHDPLQLPXOXLPD[LPXOXLFXHOHPHQWXOQHXWUXVDXFXSULPXOHOHPHQW
3URJUDPDúFRODUă 3URJUDPDúFRODUă
FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDvQWUXQILúLHUDPLQLPXOXLORUSUH ÄYDORULILFDUHD´ORULPHGLDWăHYHQWXDOVFULLQGXOHLPHGLDWvQWUXQILúLHUIăUăSăVWUD
FXPúLDSULPHLSR]LĠLLSHFDUHDSDUHDFHVWPLQLP UHDDFHVWRUDvQPHPRULH
FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDvQWUXQILúLHUDPLQLPXOXLORUSUH x 9HULILFDUHDXQHLSURSULHWăĠLGDWHDXQXLQXPăU
FXPúLDXOWLPHLSR]LĠLLSHFDUHDSDUHDFHVWPLQLP YHULILFDUHDGDFăXQQXPăUHVWHSDU
FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDvQWUXQILúLHUDPLQLPXOXLORUSUH QXPăUDUHDGLYL]RULORUXQXLQXPăU
FXPúLDWXWXURUSR]LĠLLORUSHFDUHDSDUHDFHVWPLQLP GHVFRPSXQHUHDXQXLQXPăUvQIDFWRULSULPL
FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDvQWUXQILúLHUDPLQLPXOXLORUSUH FHOPDLPDUHGLYL]RUFRPXQDGRXăQXPHUHvQWUHJL
FXPúLDWXWXURUSR]LĠLLORUSHFDUHDSDUHDFHVWPLQLPXUPDWGHPD[LPXOORUúL YHULILFDUHDSULPDOLWăĠLLXQXLQXPăU
DWXWXURUSR]LĠLLORUSHFDUHDSDUHDFHVWPD[LP GHWHUPLQDUHDFHOXLPDLPLFQXPăUSULPPDLPDUHGHFkWXQQXPăUGDW
FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLDILúDUHDWXWXURUQXPHORUFDUHGLQSXQFWGH GHWHUPLQDUHDFHOXLPDLPDUHQXPăUSULPPDLPLFGHFkWXQQXPăUGDW
YHGHUHOH[LFRJUDILFVXQWÄPDLPDUL´GHFkWXOWLPXOQXPHGLQILúLHU GHWHUPLQDUHDSUHIL[HORUSULPHDOHXQXLQXPăU
GHWHUPLQDUHDVXIL[HORUSULPHDOHXQXLQXPăU
6ăSWăPkQD&RQFXUV, YHULILFDUHDDVSHFWXOXLGHÄYDOH´DXQXLQXPăU
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH YHULILFDUHDDVSHFWXOXLGHÄPXQWH´DXQXLQXPăU
6HYDWHVWDFDSDFLWDWHDHOHYLORUGHDXWLOL]DILúLHUHOHSHQWUXFLWLUHDúLVFULHUHDGDWH YHULILFDUHDDVSHFWXOXLGHÄYDOH´DXQXLFXYkQW
ORU9RUILWUHLSUREOHPHFDUHYRUILUH]ROYDWHvQGRXăRUH YHULILFDUHDDVSHFWXOXLGHÄPXQWH´DXQXLFXYkQW
GHWHUPLQDUHDVXEúLUXOXLDYkQGDVSHFWXOÄYDOH´UHVSHFWLYÄPXQWH´GLQWUXQúLU
GDW
6ăSWăPkQD1XPHUH,
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
(OHYLLYRUILFDSDELOLVăSUHOXFUH]HQXPHUHSHED]DFLIUHORUDFHVWRUDGDWHVXEIRU 6ăSWăPkQD1XPHUH,,,
PăGHFDUDFWHUHVDXQXPHUHúLYRUvQYăĠDVăDSOLFHVFKHPDOXL+RUQHU 2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
x 'HVFRPSXQHUHFRPSXQHUHQXPHUHvQGLQFLIUH (OHYLL YRU IL FDSDELOL Vă JHQHUH]H VHFYHQĠH GH QXPHUH DYkQG R SURSULHWDWH GDWă
DILúDUHDFLIUHORUXQXLQXPăU IăUăSăVWUDUHDORUvQPHPRULH
GHWHUPLQDUHDQXPăUXOXLGHFLIUHDOHXQXLQXPăU x *HQHUDUHDQXPHUHORUDYkQGRSURSULHWDWHFHUXWă
GHWHUPLQDUHDFHOHLPDLPDULPLFLFLIUHDXQXLQXPăU GHWHUPLQDUHDSULPHORU1QXPHUHSULPH
GHWHUPLQDUHD FHOHL PDL PDUL PLFL FLIUH D XQXL QXPăU úL D SR]LĠLLORU SH FDUH GHWHUPLQDUHDWXWXURUQXPHUHORUSULPHGLQWUXQLQWHUYDO
DSDUHDFHDVWD GHWHUPLQDUHDWXWXURUQXPHUHORUGHWLSÄYDOH´GLQWUXQLQWHUYDO
GHWHUPLQDUHDLQYHUVXOXLXQXLQXPăU GHWHUPLQDUHDWXWXURUQXPHUHORUGHWLSÄPXQWH´GLQWUXQLQWHUYDO
JHQHUDUHDXQXLQXPăUGLQWUXQúLUGHFDUDFWHUHFDUHVXQWFLIUHSURWHFĠLHvQFD] GHWHUPLQDUHD WXWXURU QXPHUHORU GH WLS ÄYDOH´ úL D WXWXURU GH WLS ÄPXQWH´
GHGHSăúLUHúLGHFDUDFWHUHFDUHQXVXQWFLIUH GLQWUXQLQWHUYDO
YHULILFDUHDIDSWXOXLFăXQQXPăUHVWHSDOLQGURP JHQHUDUHDWHUPHQLORUúLUXOXLOXL)LERQDFFL
GHWHUPLQDUHDWXWXURUQXPHUHORUSDOLQGURDPHGLQWUXQLQWHUYDOGDW QXPHUHSULHWHQH
FLWLUHDXQXLQXPăUUHDOGHIRUPD[\úLDILúDUHDQXPăUXOXL\[ DOWHQXPHUHVSHFLDOH
6ăSWăPkQD1XPHUH,, 6ăSWăPkQD1XPHUH,9
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH 2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
(OHYLLYRUILFDSDELOLVăUHFXQRDVFăSUREOHPHOHFDUHFHUVWDELOLUHDXQHLSURSULHWăĠL 0XOWH SUREOHPH FHU H[SOLFLW VDX LPSOLFLW FD XQ QXPăU VDX QXPHUHOH GDWH Vă VH
DOXQXLQXPăUGDW5ăVSXQVXULOHGDWHvQFD]XODFHVWRUSUREOHPHHVWHELYDOHQW'D1X FRQYHUWHDVFăvQWURDOWăED]ă$FHVWHRSHUDĠLLVHYRUUHDOL]DIăUăXWLOL]DUHGHWDEORXUL
GLQFDX]DDFHDVWDUH]ROYăULOHORUVHYRUWHVWDSHÄSDFKHWH´GHWHVWH'HDVHPHQHDvQ x &RQYHUVLLGHQXPHUHGLQWURED]ăvQDOWD
FD]XOvQFDUHVHFHUHJHQHUDUHDXQRUQXPHUHDYkQGRSURSULHWDWHFHUXWăYRUH[HUVD FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D
3URJUDPDúFRODUă 3URJUDPDúFRODUă
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D FLWLUHDD1úLUXULFXQXPăUGLIHULWGHHOHPHQWHúLLGHQWLILFDUHDúLUXOXLFDUHDUH
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D FHOHPDLPXOWHHOHPHQWH
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]DE
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DEvQED]D
6ăSWăPkQDùLUXUL,,±2UGRQăUL
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DDvQED]DE
2UGRQDUHD HVWH XQD GLQWUH RSHUDĠLLOH FHOH PDL IUHFYHQWH vQ DSOLFDĠLL (OHYLL YRU IL
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D
FDSDELOLFDvQIXQFĠLHGHSURSULHWăĠLOHGDWHORUVăDOHDJăPHWRGDGHRUGRQDUHFHDPDL
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D
SRWULYLWă0HWRGHGHRUGRQDUHPDLSHUIRUPDQWHVHYRUvQYăĠDGHRGDWăFXPHWRGDGLYL
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DDvQED]DE
GHHWLPSHUDUHVSHFWLYVWUXFWXULGHGDWHDYDQVDWH'HDVHPHQHDHOHYLLYRUIDFHGLV
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]DERULFkWGHPDUH
WLQFĠLHvQWUHYHULILFDUHDSURSULHWăĠLLXQXLHOHPHQWGLQúLUúLSURSULHWDWHDJOREDOăDúLUX
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DERULFkWGHPDUHvQED]D
OXL
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DDRULFkWGHPDUHvQED]DERULFkWGHPDUH
x 2UGRQDUHDúLUXULORU
YHULILFDUHDIDSWXOXLFăXQúLUHVWHRUGRQDW
6ăSWăPkQD&RQFXUV,, YHULILFDUHDIDSWXOXLFăHOHPHQWHOHXQXLúLUVXQWvQSURJUHVLHDULWPHWLFăJHRPH
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH WULFă
6H YD WHVWD FDSDFLWDWHD HOHYLORU GH D PDQLSXOD FLIUHOH XQXL QXPăU GH D YHULILFD RUGRQDUHFXPHWRGDEXOHORU
DQXPLWHSURSULHWăĠLDOHDFHVWRUDúLGHDJHQHUDQXPHUHFXDQXPLWHSURSULHWăĠL9RUIL VRUWDUHSULQVHOHFĠLH
FLQFLSUREOHPHVLPSOHFDUHVHYRUUH]ROYDvQGRXăRUH VRUWDUHSULQLQVHUĠLH
VRUWDUHSULQQXPăUDUH
6ăSWăPkQDùLUXUL,
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH 6ăSWăPkQDùLUXUL,,,±ùLUXULRUGRQDWH
(OHYLLYRUILFDSDELOLVăUHFXQRDVFăDFHOHSUREOHPHFDUHQHFHVLWăGHFODUDUHDXQRU 2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
WDEORXUL XQLGLPHQVLRQDOH vQ FRQVHFLQĠă SăVWUDUHD GDWHORU vQ PHPRULH SH SDUFXUVXO &ăXWDUHDHVWHRSHUDĠLDFDUHSRDWHILHIHFWXDWăFXDOJRULWPLPXOWPDLHILFLHQĠLGDFă
H[HFXWăULLSURJUDPXOXL(LVHYRURELúQXLFXSUHOXFUDUHDORU6HYRUUH]ROYDSUREOHPH GDWHOHVXQWRUGRQDWHVDXVXQWSăVWUDWHvQVWUXFWXULGHGDWHGHFăXWDUH(OHYLLYRUvQYă
FDUHSHOkQJăYHULILFDUHDSURSULHWăĠLLFHUúLUHWXUQDUHDDILúDUHDSR]LĠLHLSHFDUHVH ĠDDOJRULWPXOGHFăXWDUHELQDUHIăUăDvQYăĠDvQGHWDOLLPHWRGDGLYLGHHWLPSHUDúLVH
DIOăDFHVWDFHVWHHOHPHQWH YRUIDPLOLDUL]DFXUH]ROYăULOHSUREOHPHORUFDUHFHUGHWHUPLQDUHDFHOHLPDLOXQJLVHF
x 'HILQLUHDúLUXULORUFXDMXWRUXOWDEORXULORUXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUH]ROYDUHDSUREOHPH YHQĠHGHGDWHDYkQGHOHPHQWHFRQVHFXWLYHGHRSURSULHWDWHGDWăIRORVLQGDOJRULWPLOL
ORUGHILQLWHSHQWUXVăSWăPkQLOHúL QLDUL
GHWHUPLQDUHDVXPHLHOHPHQWHORUXQXLúLU x &ăXWDUHDvQúLUXULRUGRQDWH
GHWHUPLQDUHDPLQLPXOXLúLPD[LPXOXLXQXLúLU FăXWDUHELQDUă
GHWHUPLQDUHDSURSULHWăĠLLXQXLHOHPHQWGLQWUXQúLU LQWHUFODVDUHDGRXăúLUXUL
FăXWDUHDOLQLDUăDXQXLHOHPHQWvQWUXQúLU FăXWDUHELQDUăFXGHWHUPLQDUHDH[WUHPLWăĠLORUDSDULĠLLORU
FăXWDUHDOLQLDUăDXQXLHOHPHQWvQWUXQúLUúLGHWHUPLQDUHDWXWXURUDSDULĠLLORU LQVHUDUHDXQXLHOHPHQWvQWUXQúLURUGRQDWFXSăVWUDUHDRUGLQLL
FăXWDUHDOLQLDUăDXQXLHOHPHQWvQWUXQúLUúLHOLPLQDUHDOXL HOLPLQDUHDXQXLHOHPHQWvQWUXQúLURUGRQDWFXSăVWUDUHDRUGLQLL
FăXWDUHDOLQLDUăWXWXURUHOHPHQWHORUGLQWUXQúLUúLHOLPLQDUHDORU GHWHUPLQDUHDGLQWUXQúLUDGRXăVXEúLUXULSHED]DXQHLSURSULHWăĠLGDWHFUHkQG
GHWHUPLQDUHDGXEOXULORUvQWUXQúLUúLHOLPLQDUHDORU GRXăVXEúLUXULQRLFUHkQGXQVLQJXUVXEúLUQRXÄSHORF´
FLWLUHDDGRXăúLUXULFXQXPăUGLIHULWGHHOHPHQWHúLGHWHUPLQDUHDúLUXOXLFDUH GHWHUPLQDUHDGLQWUXQúLUDPDLPXOWRUVXEúLUXULSHED]DDPDLPXOWRUSURSULH
DUHVXPDHOHPHQWHORUPD[LPăPLQLPă WăĠLGDWH
FLWLUHDD1úLUXULFXQXPăUGLIHULWGHHOHPHQWHúLGHWHUPLQDUHDúLUXOXLFDUHDUH GHWHUPLQDUHDFHOHLPDLOXQJLVHFYHQĠHIRUPDWăGLQHOHPHQWHDYkQGRSURSULHWD
VXPDHOHPHQWHORUPD[LPăPLQLPă WHGDWă
3URJUDPDúFRODUă 3URJUDPDúFRODUă
GHWHUPLQDUHD FHOHL PDL OXQJL VHFYHQĠH FDUH HVWH IRUPDWă GLQ HOHPHQWH DYkQG GHWHUPLQDUHDVXPHORUHOHPHQWHORUDIODWHvQWULXQJKLXOGH16(úL9GHOLPLWDW
VXPDPD[LPă GHGLDJRQDOHOHPDWULFHL
6ăSWăPkQD3ROLQRDPH 6ăSWăPkQD7DEORXULPXOWLGLPHQVLRQDOH,,
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH 2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
8WLOL]DUHDWDEORXULORUQXHVWHDEVROXWQHFHVDUăSHQWUXDSUHOXFUDSROLQRDPH(OHYLL 7DEORXULOHVHSRWSDUFXUJHvQPXOWHIHOXUL(OHYLLVHIDPLOLDUL]DFXDFHVWHSDUFXU
YRUILFDSDELOLVăLPSOHPHQWH]HRSHUDĠLLSHSROLQRDPH JHUL IRUPkQGXúL GH[WHULWDWHD GH D VH ÄSOLPED´ vQWUR PDWULFH ELGLPHQVLRQDOă FRQ
x &DOFXOHFXSROLQRDPH IRUPFHULQĠHORU
FLWLUHDXQXLSROLQRPGDWSULQJUDGúLFRHILFLHQĠL x 3UHOXFUDUHDWDEORXULORUELGLPHQVLRQDOH
FLWLUHDXQXLSROLQRPGDWSULQPRQRDPH URWLUHDFXGHJUDGHDXQXLWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDO
GHWHUPLQDUHDYDORULLXQXLSROLQRPSHQWUXXQDUJXPHQWGDW GHWHUPLQDUHDPDWULFHLVLPHWULFHIDĠăGHGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDOăVHFXQGDUă
DGXQDUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH vQORFXLUHDHOHPHQWHORUGLQWULXQJKLXOGHQRUGFXFHOHGLQWULXQJKLXOGHYHVWúL
vQPXOĠLUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH YDULDQWH
vPSăUĠLUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH SDUFXUJHUHDSHGLDJRQDOHDXQHLPDWULFH
GHWHUPLQDUHDDFHOXLSROLQRPGLQWUH1SROLQRDPHFDUHSHQWUXXQDUJXPHQWGDW SDUFXUJHUHDvQVSLUDOăDXQHLPDWULFH
DUHYDORDUHPD[LPă GHWHUPLQDUHDSR]LĠLHLSXQFWXOXLÄúD´vQWURPDWULFH
FDOFXODUHDVXPHORUGHDOXQJXOODWXULORUPDWULFHORUSăWUDWLFH
YHULILFDUHDXQHLSURSULHWăĠLJOREDOHDXQXLWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDO
6ăSWăPkQD&RQFXUV,,,
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
6HYDWHVWDFDSDFLWDWHDHOHYLORUGHDOXFUDFXúLUXUL'HDVHPHQHDVHYDWHVWDFD 6ăSWăPkQD7DEORXULPXOWLGLPHQVLRQDOH,,,
SDFLWDWHDGHDDOHJHDOJRULWPXOGHVRUWDUHUHVSHFWLYFăXWDUHDGHFYDWSUHFXPúLPHWR 2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
GDDGHFYDWăGHVWRFDUHDXQXLSROLQRP9RUILWUHLSUREOHPHFDUHYRUILUH]ROYDWHvQ 7DEORXULOH ELGLPHQVLRQDOH VH FRPSXQ GH úLUXUL GH úLUXUL (OHYLL VH YRU RELúQXLVă
GRXăRUH VWDELOHDVFăFkQGDQXPHHVWHDYDQWDMRVVăSUHOXFUH]HWDEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOHIRORVLQG
DFHDVWăSURSULHWDWHDGLFăPDQHYUkQGúLUXUL
6ăSWăPkQD7DEORXULPXOWLGLPHQVLRQDOH, x 2SHUDĠLLFXPDWULFH
SURGXVXODGRXăPDWULFH
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
SURGXVXOD1PDWULFH
7HRULDPDWULFHORUVHvQYDĠăvQFODVDD;,DGHFLQXHVWHQHYRLHFDHOHYLLVăILHLQ
LQYHUVDUHDDGRXăOLQLLFRORDQH
WURGXúLvQFDSLWROXOUHVSHFWLYDOPDWHPDWLFLL7DEORXULOHGHQXPHUHVDXGHFDUDFWHUHVH
RUGRQDUHDOLQLLORUDVWIHOvQFkWHOHPHQWHOHGHSHGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDOăVHFXQGDUă
SRWSUHOXFUDIăUăDFHVWHFXQRúWLQĠH(OHYLLVHYRURELúQXLVăGHILQHDVFăWDEORXULELGL
VăILHvQRUGLQHFUHVFăWRDUHGHVFUHVFăWRDUH
PHQVLRQDOHVăSUHOXFUH]HHOHPHQWHOHDFHVWRUWDEORXULúLVăDFFHVH]HHOHPHQWHOHWDEOR
LQWHUFODVDUHDD1úLUXULRUGRQDWH
XULORUELGLPHQVLRQDOHIRORVLQGH[SUHVLLGHLQGLFL
YHULILFDUHDWULXQJKLXODULWăĠLLXQHLPDWULFHLQIHULRUVXSHULRUWULXQJKLXODUă
x &DOFXOHVLPSOHFXHOHPHQWHOHXQHLPDWULFH
VXPDHOHPHQWHORUXQHLPDWULFH
LGHQWLILFDUHDOLQLHLúLFRORDQHLSHFDUHVHDIOăPLQLPXOPD[LPXO 6ăSWăPkQD7DEORXULPXOWLGLPHQVLRQDOH,9
VXPDHOHPHQWHORUGHSHGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDOă 2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
VXPDHOHPHQWHORUGHSHGLDJRQDODVHFXQGDUă ÌQSUREOHPHSRWVăDSDUăúLWDEORXULFXPDLPXOWHGLPHQVLXQLGHFkW(OHYLLvúLYRU
VXPDHOHPHQWHORUGHGHDVXSUDGHGHGHVXEWXOGLDJRQDOHLSULQFLSDOH IRUPDDELOLWăĠLGHDSUHOXFUDDVHPHQHDWDEORXUL
VXPDHOHPHQWHORUGHGHDVXSUDGHGHGHVXEWXOGLDJRQDOHLVHFXQGDUH x 3UHOXFUDUHDWDEORXULORUDYkQGGLPHQVLXQHPDLPDUHGHFkW
GHWHUPLQDUHDVXPHLFHORURSWYHFLQLDLXQXLHOHPHQW VXPDHOHPHQWHORUXQXLWDEORXQGLPHQVLRQDO
3URJUDPDúFRODUă
3URJUDPDúFRODUă
LGHQWLILFDUHDFRRUGRQDWHORUXQXLHOHPHQWGDWWRDWHDSDULĠLLOHvQWUXQWDEORXQ x 'HILQLUHDXQRUVWUXFWXULGHGDWHGHWLSPXOĠLPHFXVHWvQ3DVFDOúLIăUăúLSUHOX
GLPHQVLRQDO FUDUHDORU
SDUFXUJHUHDXQXLWDEORXWULGLPHQVLRQDOGLQVSUHH[WHULRUvQVSUHLQWHULRU DILúDUHDUHXQLXQLLDGRXăPXOĠLPLGHQXPHUHOLWHUH
GHWHUPLQDUHDPDWULFHLGLQWUXQWDEORXWULGLPHQVLRQDOFDUHDUHVXPDHOHPHQWH DILúDUHDLQWHUVHFĠLHLDGRXăPXOĠLPLGHQXPHUHOLWHUH
ORUPD[LPă DILúDUHDGLIHUHQĠHLDGRXăPXOĠLPLGHQXPHUHOLWHUH
YHULILFDUHDDSDUWHQHQĠHLXQXLQXPăUXQHLOLWHUHODRPXOĠLPHGDWă
JHQHUDUHDFODVHORUGHHFKLYDOHQĠăSHED]DSHUHFKLORUGHQXPHUHFDUDFWHUHFDUH
6ăSWăPkQD&RQFXUV,9 VHDIOăvQWURUHODĠLHGDWă
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
6H YD WHVWD FDSDFLWDWHD HOHYLORU GH D OXFUD FX WDEORXUL PXOWLGLPHQVLRQDOH 9RU IL
SDWUXSUREOHPHFDUHYRUILUH]ROYDWHvQGRXăRUH 6ăSWăPkQD$ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
'DFăXQQXPăUGHXQDQXPLWWLSGHSăúHúWHFHOPDLPDUHQXPăUSRVLELOGHUHSUH
6ăSWăPkQD$UWLFROH ]HQWDWFXWRDWHFLIUHOHH[DFWHGDUSUREOHPDQHFHVLWăXQUH]XOWDWH[DFWRSHUDĠLLOHDULW
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH PHWLFHFDUHWUHEXLHHIHFWXDWHVHYRUVLPXODIRORVLQGúLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH$FHVWHSUHOX
$FHOHGDWHFDUHVHFRPSXQGLQPDLPXOWHFRPSRQHQWHDYkQGWLSXULGLIHULWHGHPXO FUăULQHFHVLWăFXQRDúWHUHDVXESURJUDPHORUGHILQLWHvQXQLWXOVWDQGDUGDOPHGLXOXLSH
WHRULVHVWUXFWXUHD]ăvQDUWLFROH(OHYLLYRUvQYăĠDFXPVHGHFODUăHILFLHQWúLFXPVH VWULQJXUL(OHYLLYRUUH]ROYDSUREOHPHvQFDUHHVWHQHFHVDUăLPSOHPHQWDUHDRSHUDĠLL
SUHOXFUHD]ăDVHPHQHDGDWH(LYRUUH]ROYDSUREOHPHDVHPăQăWRDUHFXFHOHGLQYLDĠD ORUDULWPHWLFHSHQXPHUHPDUL
FX]LGH]LDSOLFkQGIDFLOLWăĠLOHRIHULWHGHPHGLXOGHSURJUDPDUHDOHV x $ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL
x 'HILQLUHDXQRUVWUXFWXULGHGDWHGHWLSDUWLFROLQFOXVLYFXYDULDQWHúLSUHOXFUDUHD LPSOHPHQWDUHDRSHUDĠLLORUFXQXPHUHPDULDGXQDUHVFăGHUHvQPXOĠLUHvPSăU
ORU ĠLUHUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLvQWUHJLULGLFDUHODSXWHUHUDGLFDO
FUHDUHDXQXLFDWDORJSHQWUXRFODVă JHQHUDUHDSULPHORU11!WHUPHQLDLúLUXOXLOXL)LERQDFFL
DILúDUHDvQRUGLQHGHVFUHVFăWRDUHGXSăPHGLHDHOHYLORUDGPLúLúLDOIDEHWLFăD JHQHUDUHDYDORULL11!
HOHYLORUUHVSLQúLODXQH[DPHQ FDOFXODUHDYDORULLDE
DILúDUHDWXWXURUHOHYLORUFDUHDXGRPLFLOLXOvQWUXQDQXPLWRUDú
RUGRQDUHD HOHYLORU vQ IXQFĠLH GH vQăOĠLPH úL SHQWUX vQăOĠLPL HJDOH vQ RUGLQHD
JUHXWăĠLL 6ăSWăPkQD2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL
FUHDUHDXQXLILúLHUFDUHVăFRQĠLQăDUWLFROHSULYLQGFăUĠLOHGLQWURELEOLRWHFă 2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
FUHDUHDXQXLILúLHUFDUHVăFRQĠLQăDUWLFROHSULYLQGFăUĠLOHGLQWURELEOLRWHFăDVW (OHYLLVHYRUIDPLOLDUL]DFXXWLOL]DUHDRSHUDWRULORUFDUHSHUPLWSUHOXFUDUHDGDWHORU
IHOvQFkWvQFD]XOPDQXDOHORUVăVHVSHFLILFHGLVFLSOLQDFODVDSHQWUXFDUHHVWH SHELĠLÌQUH]ROYDUHDGHSUREOHPHXWLOL]DUHDDFHVWRUDPăUHúWHSHUIRUPDQĠHOHSURJUD
YDODELOPDQXDOXODXWRULLHWFLDUSHQWUXFăUĠLOHFDUHQXVXQWPDQXDOHQXPăUXO PHORU
DXWRULORUDXWRULLWLWOXOHGLWXUDHWFVHYDOXFUDFXvQUHJLVWUăULFXYDULDQWH x 8WLOL]DUHDRSHUDĠLLORUSHELĠLvQVFRSXODFFHOHUăULLDQXPLWRURSHUDĠLLGLQDOJRULWPL
FUHDUHD XQXL ILúLHU FX DUWLFROH SULYLQG UH]XOWDWHOH SDUWLFLSDQĠLORU OD ROLPSLDGD VFKLPEDUHDVHPQXOXLXQXLQXPăU
LQWHUQDĠLRQDOăGHLQIRUPDWLFă VFKLPEDUHDYDORULLXQXLELWGLQWUXQQXPăU
FRGLILFDUHDúLGHFRGLILFDUHDXQXLQXPăUSHED]DXQHLFKHL
LQWHUVFKLPEDUHDDGRXăQXPHUHIăUăYDULDELOăDX[LOLDUăIRORVLQGRSHUDĠLDxor
6ăSWăPkQD0XOĠLPLúLVLPXODUHDORU vQPXOĠLUHDúLvPSăUĠLUHDFXSXWHULDOHOXL
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH QXPăUDUHDELĠLORUDYkQGYDORDUHDVDXGLQUHSUH]HQWDUHDXQXLQXPăUvQED
0XOWHSUREOHPHQHFHVLWăHIHFWXDUHDRSHUDĠLLORUGLQWHRULDPXOĠLPLORUÌQIXQFĠLHGH ]D
PHGLXOGHSURJUDPDUHúLGHSURSULHWăĠLOHFRQFUHWHDOHGDWHORUDFHVWHDSRWILRUJDQL]D GHVFRPSXQHUHDXQXLQXPăUvQWUHJvQRFWHWXOGLQVWkQJDúLRFWHWXOGLQGUHDSWD
WHvQPXOĠLPLVDXVHSRWRUJDQL]DvQDOWHVWUXFWXULGHGDWHWDEORXULVLPXOkQGRSHUD REĠLQHUHDUHSUH]HQWăULLvQED]DDXQXLQXPăUvQWUHJIRORVLQGRSHUDĠLLSHELĠL
ĠLLOHUHVSHFWLYH URWLUHDFLIUHORUELQDUHDOHXQXLQXPăUvQWUHJ
3URJUDPDúFRODUă
3URJUDPDúFRODUă
VFKLPEDUHDFLIUHORUELQDUHHJDOHFXvQúLLQYHUV
JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUVXEPXOĠLPLORUPXOĠLPLL^«1` FDOFXOXOUHFXUVLYDOWHUPHQLORUXQXLúLUSHED]DXQHLUHODĠLLGHUHFXUHQĠă
JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUúLUXULORUFDUHFRQĠLQQXPDLYDORULOHúL JHQHUDUHDVXEPXOĠLPLORUPXOĠLPLL^«1`
GHWHUPLQDUHDRELHFWHORUGLQFDUHVHFRPSXQHRIRWRJUDILH
6ăSWăPkQD&RQFXUV9
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH 6ăSWăPkQD%DFNWUDFNLQJ,
6HYDWHVWDFDSDFLWDWHDHOHYLORUGHDOXFUDFXWLSXULOHDUWLFROúLPXOĠLPHSUHFXPúL 2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
FDSDFLWDWHDGHDXWLOL]DQXPHUHOHPDULúLRSHUDĠLLOHSHELĠL9RUILSDWUXSUREOHPHFDUH 8WLOLWDWHDPHWRGHLEDFNWUDFNLQJHVWHÄFRQWHVWDWă´vQOLWHUDWXUDGHVSHFLDOLWDWHWR
YRUILUH]ROYDWHvQGRXăRUH WXúLDYkQGvQYHGHUHFăH[LVWăPXOWHSUREOHPHSHQWUXUH]ROYDUHDFăURUDQXH[LVWăDOWă
PHWRGăPDLEXQăHOHYLLRYRUFXQRDVFăúLYRUvQYăĠDVRDSOLFHGDFăHVWHFD]XOVDX
GDFăQXJăVHVFQLFLRDOWHUQDWLYăYLDELOă(LYRUGHYHQLFDSDELOLVăLGHQWLILFHDFHDVWă
6ăSWăPkQD)XQFĠLLúLSURFHGXUL FODVăGHSUREOHPHúLVăLPSOHPHQWH]HUH]ROYăULGH]YROWDWHSHED]DPHWRGHL/DvQFHSXW
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH VHYRUWUDWHSUREOHPHFDUHSUHOXFUHD]ăúLUXULúLFHUIXUQL]DUHDWXWXURUVROXĠLLORU
(OHYLLDXIRORVLWGHMDPXOWHVXESURJUDPHSUHGHILQLWHGDUHLWUHEXLHVăILHFDSDELOL x 'HILQLUHD PHWRGHL úL LGHQWLILFDUHD FODVHL GH SUREOHPH FDUH VH UH]ROYă FX PHWRGD
VăLPSOHPHQWH]HUH]ROYDUHDXQRUVXESUREOHPHVXEIRUPăGHVXESURJUDPHSURSULL(L EDFNWUDFNLQJ
YRULPSOHPHQWDDOJRULWPLLGHUH]ROYDUHVXEIRUPăJHQHUDOL]DWăDVWIHOvQFkWDFHVWHDVă JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUSHUPXWăULORUúLUXOXLGHQXPHUH1
VH SRDWă UHXWLOL]D vQ UH]ROYDUHD PDL PXOWRU SUREOHPH 9D FUHúWH OL]LELOLWDWHD DúH]DUHDDUHJLQHSHWDEODGHúDKIăUăFDDFHVWHDVăVHDWDFH
SURJUDPHORUúLVHYDXúXUDGHSDQDUHD JHQHUDUHDSURGXVXOXLVFDODUDGRXăPXOĠLPL
x 8WLOL]DUHDIXQFĠLLORUúLSURFHGXULORUSUHGHILQLWHúLXWLOL]DWRU JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUDUDQMDPHQWHORUGH1OXDWHFkWH0
UH]ROYDUHDPDMRULWăĠLLSUREOHPHORUWUDWDWHIRORVLQGVXESURJUDPH JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUSHUHFKLORUGHSDUDQWH]HFDUHVHvQFKLGFRUHFW
UH]ROYDUHDXQRUSUREOHPHvQFDUHSUREOHPDLQLĠLDOăVHGHVFRPSXQHvQVXESUR JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUIXQFĠLLORULQMHFWLYHFXQRVFkQGPXOĠLPHDGHDUJXPHQWHúLFHD
EOHPH DYDORULORUIXQFĠLLORU
UH]ROYDUHD XQRU SUREOHPH vQ FDUH XQ DFHODúL VXESURJUDP VH DSHOHD]ă vQ PRG JHQHUDUHD WXWXURU IXQFĠLLORU VXUMHFWLYH FXQRVFkQG PXOĠLPHD GH DUJXPHQWH úL
UHSHWDWSHQWUXGDWHGLIHULWH FHDDYDORULORUIXQFĠLLORU
UHDOL]DUHDXQXLXQLWSURSULXFDUHFRQĠLQHWRDWHSUREOHPHOHUH]ROYDWHFXVXESUR JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUSDUWLĠLLORUXQXLQXPăUGDW
JUDPHúLVFULHUHDXQRUSURJUDPHFDUHIRORVHVFDFHVWXQLW JHQHUDUHDSDUWLĠLLORUPXOĠLPLL^«1`
JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUWXUQXULORUGHFXEXULvQIXQFĠLHGHDQXPLWHSURSULHWăĠLGDWH
6ăSWăPkQD5HFXUVLYLWDWH
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH 6ăSWăPkQD%DFNWUDFNLQJ,,
5HFXUVLYLWDWHDHVWHXQFRQFHSWGHVvQWkOQLWvQSURJUDPDUH(DWRWXúLWUHEXLHDSOLFD 2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH
WăFXJULMăIăUăFDIRORVLQGRVăVHPăUHDVFăLQXWLOFRPSOH[LWDWHDDOJRULWPLORU6XE (OHYLLYRUILFDSDELOLVăLGHQWLILFHFODVDGHSUREOHPHFDUHVHUH]ROYăFXPHWRGD
SURJUDPHOHUHFXUVLYHVXQWOL]LELOHFRPSDFWHúLVHDSOLFăPDLDOHVDVXSUDVWUXFWXULORU EDFNWUDFNLQJSHGDWHGHILQLWHvQGRXăGLPHQVLXQL
GHGDWHGHILQLWHUHFXUVLYVDXvQFD]XOSUREOHPHORUDOHFăURUPRGHOPDWHPDWLFHVWHGH x 'HILQLUHD PHWRGHL úL LGHQWLILFDUHD FODVHL GH SUREOHPH FDUH VH UH]ROYă FX PHWRGD
ILQLWvQWHUPHQLUHFXUVLYL6HYDUHYHQLODUHFXUVLYLWDWHvQFODVDD;DFkQGVHYRUvQYă EDFNWUDFNLQJvQGRXăGLPHQVLXQL
ĠDOLVWHúLDUERUL LHúLUHDGLQODELULQW
x 'HILQLUHDFRQFHSWXOXLúLUH]ROYDUHDXQRUSUREOHPHHQXQĠDWHvQWHUPHQLUHFXUVLY ODELULQWFXSHUHĠLLFHOXOHORUSăVWUDĠLSHELĠL
LQYHUVDUHDFLIUHORUGLQFRQILJXUDĠLDXQXLQXPăUGDWIăUăVWULQJXUL DUDQMDUHD XQRU SLHVH GH WHWULV DVWIHO vQFkW VH FRPSOHWHD]ă LQWHJUDO XQ GUHSW
LQYHUVDUHDQXPHUHORUGLQWUXQúLUGDWIăUăWDEORXUL XQJKLGHGLPHQVLXQLGDWH
FDOFXOXOUHFXUVLYDOIDFWRULDOXOXL
FDOFXOXOUHFXUVLYDOFHOXLPDLPDUHGLYL]RUFRPXQDGRXăQXPHUHvQWUHJL
&XSULQV
3UHIDĠă
3URJUDPDúFRODUă
3URJUDPDúFRODUă
5HFDSLWXODUH
6WUXFWXUDSURJUDPHORU3DVFDO
6ăSWăPkQD%DFNWUDFNLQJ,,, 9RFDEXODUXOOLPEDMXOXL
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH &RQVWDQWH
ÌQ FD]XULOH vQ FDUH VD KRWăUkW DSOLFDUHD PHWRGHL SHQWUX SUREOHPH FDUH QHFHVLWă 7LSXULVWDQGDUGGHGDWH
GHWHUPLQDUHDXQXLPLQLPSURJUDPXOSRDWHILRSWLPL]DW(OHYLLYRUILFDSDELOLVăLGHQ 9DULDELOH
WLILFHFODVDGHSUREOHPHvQFDUHDVHPHQHDRSWLPL]ăULVXQWSRVLELOHúLYRUvQYăĠDVăOH 'HILQLUHDFRQVWDQWHORU
([SUHVLL
LPSOHPHQWH]H'HDVHPHQHDHLYRUvQYăĠDPRGDOLWăĠLSULQFDUHSRWVăPăVRDUHWLPSXO &LWLUHDúLVFULHUHDGDWHORU
GHH[HFXWDUHDOSURSULXOXLSURJUDPúLVăORSUHDVFăvQPRPHQWXOvQFDUHDUXUPDFD ,QVWUXFĠLXQL
DFHVWDVăUXOH]HPDLPXOWGHFkWWLPSXOSHUPLV9RUvQYăĠDWHKQLFLGHRSWLPL]DUHFXP 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
DU IL VFULHUHD vQ ILúLHU D XQRU ÄSDFKHWH GH UH]XOWDWH´ JHQHUDUHD XQRU UH]XOWDWH DOH
SUREOHPHLvQWLPSXOOXFUXOXLúLLQWURGXFHUHDDFHVWRUDvQWDEORXULGHFRQVWDQWHHWF )LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH
x 'HILQLUHDPHWRGHLúLLGHQWLILFDUHDFODVHLGHSUREOHPHvQFDUHUH]ROYDUHDFXPHWR ([SORDWDUHDXQXLILúLHUGHWLSWH[W
GDEDFNWUDFNLQJQHFHVLWăúLSHUPLWHRSWLPL]ăUL 3UHOXFUăULVLPSOHDOHGDWHORUFLWLWHGLQILúLHUH
'HWHUPLQDUHDHOHPHQWXOXLPLQLPPD[LP
GHWHUPLQDUHDWXUQXOXLGHFXEXULGHvQăOĠLPHPLQLPă ,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
GHWHUPLQDUHDGUXPXOXLSHFDUHEURDVFDDMXQJHODOăFXVWăúLVHvQWRDUFHODORFXO 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
GHSkQGăSHVXSUDIDĠDXQXLODFvQJKHĠDWXQGHJKHDĠDVHUXSHvQXUPDHIHFWXăULL 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
VăULWXULORU
YL]LWDUHDXQHLPDWULFHGHGLPHQVLXQL0Â1DVWIHOvQFkWVHFUHHD]ăXQúLU$DOH 1XPHUH
FăUXL HOHPHQWH VXQW QXPHUHOH GLQ PDWULFH GRXă HOHPHQWH DIODWH SH SR]LĠLL 3UHOXFUăULDOHQXPHUHORU
FRQVHFXWLYHvQúLUXO$WUHEXLHVăILHYHFLQHvQPDWULFH6XPDÂ$Â$ ,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
«0Â1Â$0Â1WUHEXLHVăILHPLQLPă 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
6ăSWăPkQD&RQFXUV9, 1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
2ELHFWLYHVSHFLILFH 1XPHUHSHUIHFWH
1XPHUHSULHWHQH
6HYDWHVWDFDSDFLWDWHDHOHYLORUGHDIRORVLWHKQLFLUHFXUVLYHúLGHDUH]ROYDSUREOH
1XPHUHWULDQJXODUH
PHSULQPHWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ9RUILGRXăSUREOHPHFDUHYRUILUH]ROYDWHvQGRXăRUH 1XPHUHSăWUDWLFH
1XPHUHSLUDPLGDOH
1XPHUHSLWDJRUHLFH
1XPHUHSULPH
1XPHUH)LERQDFFL
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
Cuprins Cuprins
&RQYHUVLL ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH
6LVWHPHGHQXPHUDĠLH 2SHUDĠLLFXYDULDELOHGHWLSstring
&RQYHUVLLvQWUHGRXăED]HGHQXPHUDĠLH 6XESURJUDPHSUHGHILQLWHSHQWUXstringXUL
2SHUDĠLLFXQXPHUHQDWXUDOHvQGLYHUVHED]HGHQXPHUDĠLH ,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
&ULWHULLGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHvQGLYHUVHED]HGHQXPHUDĠLH 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU $ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL
&DOFXODUHDYDORULLn
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOH 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
$WULEXLUHD 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
6HOHFWDUHDXQHLFRPSRQHQWH
'HFODUDUHDWDEORXULORUXQLGLPHQVLRQDOH 7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
&LWLUHDWDEORXULORUXQLGLPHQVLRQDOH 'HILQLĠLH
$ILúDUHDWDEORXULORUXQLGLPHQVLRQDOH 2SHUDĠLLFXWDEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
3UHOXFUăULVLPSOHSHWDEORXUL &DUHXULPDJLFH
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH ,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
6XESURJUDPH 7DEORXULPXOWLGLPHQVLRQDOH
1RĠLXQHDGHPRGXO $SOLFDĠLLFXWDEORXULWULGLPHQVLRQDOH
'HFODUDUHDúLDSHOXOXQXLVXESURJUDP ,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
)XQFĠLLúLSURFHGXULvQ3DVFDO 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
'H]YROWDUHDSURJUDPHORU 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH 3ROLQRDPH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU 'HILQLUHDQRĠLXQLLGHSROLQRP
)RUPDDOJHEULFăDSROLQRDPHORU
6WLYD 5HSUH]HQWDUHDSROLQRDPHORUvQPHPRULDFDOFXODWRUXOXL
2SHUDĠLLFXVWLYH ,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
(YDOXDUHDH[SUHVLLORUDULWPHWLFH 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
0XOĠLPL
2UGRQăULúLFăXWăUL 7LSXOPXOĠLPH
$OJRULWPLGHRUGRQDUH 2SHUDĠLLOHSRVLELOHFXGDWHOHGHWLSPXOĠLPH
$OJRULWPLGHFăXWDUH 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
,QWHUFODVDUHDDGRXăWDEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOH 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH 7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU 'HFODUDUHDXQXLWLSvQUHJLVWUDUH
2SHUDĠLL
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
Cuprins
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
5HFDSLWXODUH &DSLWROXO
6WUXFWXUDSURJUDPHORU3DVFDO
2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL
9RFDEXODUXOOLPEDMXOXL
1RĠLXQLGHED]ă
&RQVWDQWH
5HSUH]HQWDUHDQXPHUHORUvQPHPRULH
7LSXULVWDQGDUGGHGDWH
2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL
9DULDELOH
'HILQLUHDFRQVWDQWHORU
ÌQPXOĠLUHFXRSHUDĠLLSHELĠL
([SUHVLL
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
&LWLUHDúLVFULHUHDGDWHORU
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
,QVWUXFĠLXQL
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
5HFXUVLYLWDWH
1RĠLXQHDGHUHFXUVLYLWDWH /LPEDMXO3DVFDODIRVWFRQFHSXWPDLDOHVvQVFRSGLGDFWLFXUPăULQGSUHGDUHDÄDUWHL
3URLHFWDUHDXQXLDOJRULWPUHFXUVLY SURJUDPăULL FDOFXODWRDUHORU´ FRQIRUP SULQFLSLLORU SURJUDPăULL VWUXFWXUDWH /LPEDMXO
([HFXĠLDDSHOXULORUUHFXUVLYH PRGHOHD]ăQDWXUDOFRQFHSWHGHED]ăvQSURJUDPDUHúLSHUPLWHLPSOHPHQWăULHILFLHQWH
5HFXUVLYLWDWHLQGLUHFWăvQFUXFLúDWă
*UHúHOLIUHFYHQWHvQVFULHUHDSURJUDPHORUUHFXUVLYH 6WUXFWXUDSURJUDPHORU3DVFDO
&kQGPHULWăVăXWLOL]ăPWHKQLFDUHFXUVLYLWăĠLL" ÌQGHVFULHUHDXQXLSURJUDP3DVFDOVHGLIHUHQĠLD]ăDFĠLXQLOHGHHIHFWXDWúLGHVFULHUHDGD
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH WHORUGHSUHOXFUDWÌQVWUXFWXUDXQXLSURJUDP3DVFDOLQWUă
3UREOHPHSURSXVH x DQWHWXO SURJUDPXOXL RSĠLRQDO ± FRQĠLQH FXYkQWXO UH]HUYDW XUPDW GH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU QXPHOHSURJUDPXOXL
x GHFODUDĠLHRSĠLRQDODQXPHORUXQLWXULORUFDUHVHYRUIRORVLvQSURJUDPLQWURGX
0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ VăGHFXYkQWXOUH]HUYDW
;
%DFNWUDFNLQJLWHUDWLY x SDUWHREOLJDWRULHIRUPDWăGLQWUXQEORFXUPDWGHFDUDFWHUXOSXQFW'.'
%DFNWUDFNLQJUHFXUVLY
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH 8QXQLWHVWHRFROHFĠLHGHGHFODUDĠLLGHFRQVWDQWHWLSXULYDULDELOHúLVXESURJUDPH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH 8QXQLWVHFRPSLOHD]ăúLVHXWLOL]HD]ăvQSURJUDPHOHvQFDUHVHGRUHúWHIRORVLUHDDFHV
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU WRU FRQVWDQWH WLSXUL YDULDELOH úL VXESURJUDPH )RORVLUHD XQLWXULORU SHUPLWH VFULHUHD
XQRUSURJUDPHPDULFDUHSRWGHSăúL.'LPHQVLXQHDXQXLSURJUDPFDúLFHDDXQXL
%LEOLRJUDILH XQLWQXSRDWHVăGHSăúHDVFă.8QLWXULOHVWDQGDUGRIHULWHGHPHGLXO%RUODQG3DVFDO
VXQW System Dos Graph CrtHWF8QLWXO SystemHVWHvQFRUSRUDWvQWRDWHSURJUD
PHOH3DVFDOIăUăVăILHQHFHVDUăLQFOXGHUHDGHFODUDĠLHL
$FHVWXQLWFXSULQGHSUR
FHGXULOHúLIXQFĠLLOHFHOPDLGHVIRORVLWH
5HFDSLWXODUH
5HFDSLWXODUH
%ORFXOHVWHFHDPDLLPSRUWDQWăSDUWHGLQWUXQSURJUDPúLFXSULQGHRVHFĠLXQHGHGH
FODUDĠLLRSĠLRQDOúLRVHFĠLXQHGHSURJUDP ÌQ VHFĠLXQHD
DP GHILQLW WLSXO GH GDWH pozitiv FX YDORUL PDUL DVWIHO SXWHP
'HFODUDĠLLOHVHSRWSUHFL]DvQRULFHRUGLQHSRWDOWHUQDúLVHSRWUHSHWD$FHVWHDVXQW FDOFXODSHULPHWUXOúLDULDXQXLWULXQJKLDYkQGOXQJLPLOHODWXULORUQXPHUHSR]LWLYHFDUH
VWUXFWXUDWHDVWIHO SRWGHSăúLYDORDUHDGHGRXăPLOLDUGHGDUWUHEXLHVăILHPDLPLFLVDXHJDOHFXYDORDUHD
± GHFODUDĠLLGHFRQVWDQWH FRQVWDQWHL MaxLongint21474836475H]XOWDWHOHOHYRPGHFODUDGHWLS RealGH
± GHILQLĠLLGHWLSXUL RDUHFHGRDUWLSXODFHVWDSHUPLWHSăVWUDUHDUH]XOWDWXOXLFX]HFLPDOHH[DFWH
± GHFODUDĠLLGHYDULDELOH 9DULDELOHOHGHFODUDWHvQVHFĠLXQHD VXQW a b c periúLDXWLSXO pozitivLDU
± GHFODUDĠLLGHHWLFKHWH spúLariaVXQWGHWLSXOReal,QVWUXFĠLXQLOHGLQSURJUDPDSDUvQWUHFXYLQWHOHUH]HUYD
± GHFODUDĠLLGHVXESURJUDPH WH
úL
úLVXQWVHSDUDWHSULQSXQFWúLYLUJXOă;7H[WHOHFXSULQVHvQWUHDFROD
,QVWUXFĠLXQLOHFDUHVHYRUH[HFXWDYRUILVFULVHvQVHFĠLXQHDGHSURJUDP$LFLVHSRW GH{}VXQWFRPHQWDULL
DSHODVXESURJUDPHGHFODUDWHDQWHULRUvQSDUWHDGHGHFODUDĠLLVDXvQXQLWXUL
,DWăXQH[HPSOXGHSURJUDP3DVFDO
9RFDEXODUXOOLPEDMXOXL
{ Intre acolade vom scrie comentarii. } 6HWXO GH FDUDFWHUH DO OLPEDMXOXL FXSULQGH OLWHUHOH PDULúL PLFL DOH DOIDEHWXOXL HQJOH]
{ Acestea sunt texte explicative care nu se compileaza. } FLIUHOHGLQED]DúLFDUDFWHUHOHVSHFLDOH+-*/^<>()[]{}.,:;
{ Enuntul problemei: } #$@_úLVSDĠLXOEODQFXO
{ Fie a, b si c lungimile laturilor unui triunghi oarecare. } ,GHQWLILFDWRULLVXQWIRUPDĠLGLQOLWHUHFLIUHúLFDUDFWHUXO '_'OLQLXĠDGHVXEOLQLHUH
{ Sa se calculeze perimetrul triunghiului si aria sa. }
{ Observatie: }
GDU SULPXO FDUDFWHU GLQWUXQ LGHQWLILFDWRU QX SRDWH IL R FLIUă (VWH LQGLFDW FD QXPHOH
{ a, b si c sunt numere naturale strict pozitive. } XQXL LGHQWLILFDWRU Vă ILH DOHV GXSă VHPQLILFDĠLD OXL vQ SURJUDP /XQJLPHD QXPHOXL
LGHQWLILFDWRUXOXL QX LQIOXHQĠHD]ă OXQJLPHD FRGXOXL RELHFW &RPSLODWRDUHOH 3DVFDO QX
triunghi; IDFGLVWLQFĠLHvQWUHOLWHUHOHPDULúLOLWHUHOHPLFL
pozitiv=1..MaxLongint; ,GHQWLILFDWRULLminmax2BSum13aprodVXQWDFFHSWDĠLGHFRPSLODWRUXO3DVFDOvQ
a,b,c,peri:pozitiv; VFKLPE a+b 5a z yQXVXQWLGHQWLILFDWRULSULPXOH[HPSOXHVWHRH[SUHVLHDOGRLOHD
sp,aria:Real; { sp ==> semiperimetrul triunghiului } vQFHSHFXFLIUăLDUDOWUHLOHDFRQĠLQHXQVSDĠLX
,GHQWLILFDWRULLSRWGHVHPQDQXPHGHSURJUDPHFRQVWDQWHWLSXULYDULDELOHVXESUR
JUDPHSDUDPHWULXQLWXULHWF,GHQWLILFDWRULLFDUHDXVHPQLILFDĠLHIL[DWăúLFDUHQXSRW
Write('Introduceti lungimea laturii a-->'); ReadLn(a);
Write('Introduceti lungimea laturii b-->'); ReadLn(b);
ILIRORVLĠLGHFkWvQFRQWH[WXOvQFDUHVXQWGHILQLĠLvQOLPEDMDOFăWXLHVFPXOĠLPHDFXYLQ
Write('Introduceti lungimea laturii c-->'); ReadLn(c); WHORUUH]HUYDWHDOHOLPEDMXOXL
a*b*c=0
,GHQWLILFDWRULLFUHDĠLúLUHIHULĠLGHXWLOL]DWRUWUHEXLHGHFODUDĠLvQSURJUDPvQWUROLQLH
WriteLn('Cel putin o latura are lungimea 0! Reluati!) VXUVăVFULVăDQWHULRUUHIHULULL
VXODOWIHOH[HFXĠLDVHWHUPLQă
Write('alta litera!!!')
; $VWIHOVHH[HFXWăUHSHWDWRLQVWUXFĠLXQHvQIXQFĠLHGHYDORDUHDGHDGHYăUDXQHLH[
SUHVLLORJLFH'DFăLQLĠLDOH[SUHVLDORJLFăHVWHIDOVăH[HFXĠLDLQVWUXFĠLXQLLUHVSHFWLYHQX
YDDYHDORFQLFLRGDWă
,QVWUXFĠLXQLUHSHWLWLYH
ÌQ3DVFDOH[LVWăWUHLLQVWUXFĠLXQLFDUHH[HFXWăUHSHWDWRLQVWUXFĠLXQHDFHVWHDVXQW &,QVWUXFĠLXQHD
úL
,QVWUXFĠLXQHD
SHUPLWH H[HFXĠLD UHSHWDWă vQ QXPăU QHFXQRVFXW GH SDúL D XQXL
JUXSGHLQVWUXFĠLXQL,QVWUXFĠLXQHDHVWHSRVWHULRUFRQGLĠLRQDWăúLDUHVLQWD[D
$,QVWUXFĠLXQHD
LQVWUXFĠLXQLFRQGLĠLH
$FHDVWă LQVWUXFĠLXQH H[HFXWă UHSHWDW vQ QXPăU FXQRVFXW GH SDúL R LQVWUXFĠLXQH vQ XQGHFRQGLĠLHHVWHRH[SUHVLHORJLFă6HPQLILFDĠLDLQVWUXFĠLXQLLHVWH
IXQFĠLHGHYDORDUHDXQXLFRQWRU(DDUHVLQWD[D 6HH[HFXWăLQVWUXFĠLXQLOHVFULVHvQWUHFXYLQWHOH
úL
Y:=OLPOLPLQVWUXFĠLXQH 6HHYDOXHD]ăH[SUHVLDORJLFăFRQGLĠLH
VDX 'DFă YDORDUHD H[SUHVLHL HVWH true DWXQFL H[HFXĠLD VH WHUPLQă DOWIHO VH UHYLQH OD
Y:=OLPOLPLQVWUXFĠLXQH SDVXO
5HFDSLWXODUH 5HFDSLWXODUH
2EVHUYDĠLL FRUHVSXQGHUHJXOLLGHVFULVH$ILúDĠLXQPHVDMFRUHVSXQ]ăWRU'DA'VDX 'NU'SUHFXP
x H[SUHVLDFRQGLĠLHQXVHUHFRPDQGăDILIRDUWHFRPSOLFDWăDYkQGvQYHGHUHFăVH úLSR]LĠLLOHYLRUHOHORU
HYDOXHD]ăODILHFDUHSDV
x FHOSXĠLQRYDULDELOăGLQH[SUHVLDORJLFăFRQGLĠLHWUHEXLHVăúLVFKLPEHYDORDUHD ([HPSOH
vQ PRG REOLJDWRULX DOWIHO H[LVWă SHULFROXO FD LQVWUXFĠLXQHD Vă VH WUDQVIRUPH vQ
ú
FLFOXLQILQLW n = 6 DA
V G V G G V
1 3 6
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
ú
3UREOHPHOHSURSXVHvQDFHDVWăVHFĠLXQHSRWILUH]ROYDWHvQFDGUXOXQHLHYDOXăULWHVWăUL n = 5 NU
G V G G V
HIHFWXDWHGHSURIHVRUGXSăUHFDSLWXODUHFXVFRSXOVWDELOLULLQLYHOXOXLGHFXQRúWLQĠHD
HOHYLORU3UREOHPHOHVXQWJUXSDWHSHQLYHOXUL
vQFHSăWRUL &6HUYLFLXOSHFODVă
DYDQVDĠL /DvQFHSXWXODQXOXLúFRODUGLULJLQWHOHDvQWRFPLWSODQLILFDUHDVHUYLFLXOXLvQFODVăILLQG
H[FHOHQĠL SODQLILFDĠLFkWHGRLHOHYLSHQWUXILHFDUH]L'HRDUHFHHOHYLLDXGHFODUDWFăGRUHVFVăILH
GHVHUYLFLXFkWHRIDWăúLXQEăLDWGLULJLQWHOHDVWDELOLWXUPăWRDUHDUHJXOăSULPDIDWă
GLQFDWDORJYDVWDFXSULPXOEăLDWDGRXDFXDOGRLOHDúLDúDPDLGHSDUWH'LULJLQWHOH
ÌQFHSăWRUL úWLHFăDUHQHOHYLvQFODVăGDUQXDQXPăUDWFkWHIHWHúLFkĠLEăLHĠLVXQWDúDFăVHSRDWH
vQWkPSODVăFRQVWDWHODVIkUúLWFăXQLLFRSLLDXUăPDVIăUăSHUHFKH
$ÌQYăĠDUHDDOIDEHWXOXL &LWLĠL QXPăUXO GH HOHYL QXPHOH úL JHQXO ORU 'f' SHQWUX IHWH 'b' SHQWUX EăLHĠL
&RSLLLGLQFODVHOHPLFLvQYDĠăGLQJUHXDOIDEHWXOSHFkQGFHLPDLPDULWUDJFKLXOXOÌQ DSRLVWDELOLĠLGDFăDXUăPDVHOHYLIăUăSHUHFKHúLFDUHVXQWDFHúWLD
FODVD,XQFRSLODÄSăFăWXLW´SHQWUXFăDvQFHUFDWVăYDGăFXPHVWHGDFăQXvúLvQYDĠă
OHFĠLD SHQWUX RUD YLLWRDUH ÌQYăĠăWRDUHD OD SHGHSVLW SXQkQGXO Vă VFULH Q OLWHUH PDUL ([HPSOX
SULQWUHFDUHDFHVWDWUHEXLHVăVFULHFHOSXĠLQRGDWăWRDWHOLWHUHOHPDULSHFDUHOHDvQYă
ú
SUHOXFUăULVLPSOH FHHD FH vQVHDPQă VXSUDVFULHUHD PDUFDMXOXL GH VIkUúLW GH ILúLHU DSRL FRQWLQXDUHD
VFULHULLvQUHJLVWUăULORUGRULWHvQILúLHU
([SORDWDUHDXQXLILúLHUGHWLSWH[W x
UHDOL]HD]ăvQFKLGHUHDILúLHUXOXL6FULHUHDHIHFWLYăDGDWHORUvQILúLHUXOGH
3UHOXFUăULVLPSOHDOHGDWHORUFLWLWHGLQILúLHUH LHúLUH VH UHDOL]HD]ă SH EORFXUL SkQă OD ÄXPSOHUHD´ XQXL EORF DFHVWHD VH SăVWUHD]ă
'HWHUPLQDUHDHOHPHQWXOXLPLQLPPD[LP WHPSRUDU vQ]RQHWDPSRQGHPHPRULH8OWLPHOHGDWHDGLFăEORFXOvQFHSXWúLQH
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
XPSOXWvQvQWUHJLPHVHVFULHHIHFWLYvQILúLHUODvQFKLGHUHDDFHVWXLD5H]XOWăFăGDFă
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU QXvQFKLGHPILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVDUSXWHDFDvQILúLHUVăVHWUDQVIHUHGRDURSDUWHGLQ
UH]XOWDWHVDXvQFD]XOvQFDUHDFHVWHUH]XOWDWHIăFHDXSDUWHGLQWUXQSULPEORFvQFH
SXWúLQHXPSOXWVăDYHPILúLHUYLG
8QILúLHUGHWLSWH[WHVWHRFROHFĠLHGHvQUHJLVWUăULXQGHvQUHJLVWUăULOHVXQWFDUDFWHUHVDX
úLUXULGHFDUDFWHUHVWUXFWXUDWHSHOLQLL/LQLLOHVXQWVHSDUDWHSULQPDUFDMHIRUPDWHGLQ
FDUDFWHUHOHÄVIkUúLWGHOLQLH´DGLFă/)&5
,QWUăUL,HúLUL
8QDVWIHOGHILúLHUVHSRDWHFUHDFXHGLWRUXOGLQPHGLXOGHSURJUDPDUHSULQSURJUDP 'LQWUXQvQWUXQILúLHUGHWLSWH[WVHSRWFLWLVDXVHSRWVFULHFDUDFWHUHúLUXULGHFDUDFWH
VDXFXRULFHDOWHGLWRUFXFDUHVHSRWFUHDILúLHUH$6&,, UH QXPHUH vQWUHJL úL QXPHUH UHDOH 6XESURJUDPHOH FDUH UHDOL]HD]ă FLWLUHD úL VFULHUHD
/XQJLPHDOLQLLORUILLQGYDULDELOăQXVHSRDWHUHDOL]DXQDFFHVGLUHFWODRDQXPLWăOL VXQW
QLHGLQILúLHU
x
DUHFDHIHFWFLWLUHDDQGDWHGLQILúLHU
x
DUHFDHIHFWFLWLUHDDQGDWHGLQILúLHUGXSăFDUHXUPă
([SORDWDUHDXQXLILúLHUGHWLSWH[W WRDUHDFLWLUHVHYDIDFHGHSHOLQLHQRXă
9DULDELODGHOXFUXFDUHVHDVRFLD]ăSULQSURJUDPXQXLILúLHUGHSHVXSRUWVHGHFODUăvQ
VHFĠLXQHDGHGHFODUDĠLL x
VHUHDOL]HD]ăVFULHUHDDQGDWHvQILúLHU
LGHQWLILFDWRU, x
VHUHDOL]HD]ăVFULHUHDDQGDWHvQILúLHUúLDPDUFDMX
OXLGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLH
3URFHGXUDSUHGHILQLWăFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăOHJăWXUDvQWUHRYDULDELOăGHWLSILúLHUúLILúLH
UXOH[LVWHQWSHVXSRUWHVWH
LGHQWLILFDWRUQXPHBILúLHUXQGHQXPHBILúLHUHVWHR x
UHGHQXPHúWHXQILúLHUODQLYHOIL]LFDGLFăSHVXSRUW
H[SUHVLHGHWLSúLUGHFDUDFWHUHHYLGHQWSRDWHILRYDULDELOăVDXRFRQVWDQWăGHWLSúLU x "
IXQFĠLH ERROHDQă FDUH UHWXUQHD]ă YDORDUHD GDFă XUPăWRUXO FDUDFWHU
GHFDUDFWHUH
FDUHDUXUPDVăILHFLWLWGLQILúLHUHVWHPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHUúL
DOWIHO
x "
IXQFĠLH ERROHDQă FDUH vQWRDUFH YDORDUHD GDFă XUPăWRUXO FDUDFWHU
'HVFKLGHUHÌQFKLGHUH
3URFHGXULOHSUHGHILQLWHFUHDWHSHQWUXDGHVFKLGHUHVSHFWLYvQFKLGHXQILúLHUGHWLSWH[W
FDUHDUXUPDVăILHFLWLWGLQILúLHUHVWHPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHVDXPDUFDMXOGH
LGHQWLILFDWSULQYDULDELOD
VXQW VIkUúLWGHILúLHUúL
vQFD]FRQWUDU
x
DSHOXODFHVWHLSURFHGXULDUHFDHIHFWFUHDUHDILúLHUXOXLVDXUHVFULHUHD
DFHVWXLDGDFăHOH[LVWăDOWIHOVSXVGDFăXQILúLHUGHWLS HVWHGHVFKLVFX
YRPSXWHDVFULHvQDFHVWD 3UHOXFUăULVLPSOHDOHGDWHORUFLWLWHGLQILúLHUH
3ULQSUHOXFUDUHVLPSOăYRPvQĠHOHJHFDOFXODUHDXQRUVXPHSURGXVHPHGLLDULWPHWLFH
VDXJHRPHWULFHFăXWDUHDXQXLHOHPHQWDYkQGRDQXPLWăSURSULHWDWHQXPăUDUHDHOH
PHQWHORUDYkQGRDQXPLWăSURSULHWDWH
)LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH
)LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH
6XPHúLSURGXVH
2ULFH VXPă WUHEXLH LQLĠLDOL]DWă FX HOHPHQWXO QHXWUX IDĠă GH DGXQDUH úL DQXPH FX 0HGLL
$SRLFXRSUHOXFUDUHVLPSOăVHFDOFXOHD]ăVXPD6LQJXUDSUREOHPăFDUHSRDWHVăDSDUă 3HQWUXDFDOFXODRPHGLHDULWPHWLFăPDLvQWkLVHFDOFXOHD]ăRVXPă'DFăQXPăUXOWHU
VHUHIHUăODIDSWXOFăPHGLLOHGHSURJUDPDUHQXQHDWHQĠLRQHD]ăFkQGRDVWIHOGHVXPă PHQLORU GLQ VXPă VH FXQRDúWH PHGLD VH FDOFXOHD]ă vPSăUĠLQG VXPD OD DFHVW QXPăU
VDXSURGXVGHSăúHúWHYDORDUHDPD[LPăSRVLELOăGHUHSUH]HQWDWvQFDGUXOWLSXOXLYDULD 'DUVHvQWkPSOăIUHFYHQWFăvQVXPăVHDGXQăGRDUDQXPLWHQXPHUHGHH[HPSOXGRDU
ELOHLVXPăÌQDQXPLWHPHGLLGHSURJUDPDUHH[LVWăWRWXúLSRVLELOLWDWHDGHDFHUHFRQWUR FHOHSR]LWLYH$FHVWHDVHYRUQXPăUDvQSDUDOHOFXFDOFXODUHDVXPHL6ăQXXLWăPVăvQ
ODUHDGHSăúLULL'HH[HPSOXGDFăvQFD]XOXUPăWRUXOXLSURJUDPVLPSOXSR]LĠLRQăPRS WUHEăP vQDLQWH GH vPSăUĠLUH GDFă QXPăUXO WHUPHQLORU GLQ VXPă QX FXPYD HVWH
ĠLXQHD2SWLRQV&RPSLOHU5DQJHFKHFNLQJSH21H[HFXĠLDDFHVWXLDVHYDvQWUHUXSHFX SHQWUXDHYLWDRvPSăUĠLUHQHSHUPLVă'HDVHPHQHDvQDFHVWFD]ILHDILúăPXQPHVDM
XQPHVDMGHHURDUH
%&%? DOWIHOVHDILúHD]ăXQUH]XOWDWHURQDWV ILHUHDOL]ăPVDUFLQLOHVSHFLILFDWHvQHQXQĠXOSUREOHPHL
IăUăQLFLRDWHQĠLRQDUH
JKJ &ăXWDUHDVHFYHQĠLDOă
JQXYKJ 3XWHPFăXWDXQHOHPHQWDYkQGRYDORDUHFXQRVFXWăVDXDYkQGRDQXPLWăSURSULHWDWH
J 5H]XOWDWXOYDILXQUăVSXQVÄGDODPJăVLW´VDXÄQXODPJăVLW´5HIHULWRUODDFHDVWă
JJQ\`KJ VXESUREOHPăGRULPVăDWUDJHPDWHQĠLDDVXSUDIDSWXOXLFăRYDORDUHFăXWDWăúLJăVLWăQX
JJJQ\JJ||JQ\~KJJ ^VQXYDÄvQFDSH´SHXQRFWHW` WUHEXLHFăXWDWăvQUHVWXOGDWHORU'UHSWFRQVHFLQĠăQXYRPFăXWDFX FLFXRVWUXF
JJ
J WXUăUHSHWLWLYăFXQXPăUQHFXQRVFXWGHSDúLÌQDOJRULWPXOXUPăWRUSUHVXSXQHPFăVH
J FDXWăRYDORDUHGDWăGHQXPLWăFăXWDWSULQWUHGDWHGHDFHODúLWLSFLWLWHGLQWUXQILúLHU
'DUXQSURJUDPFDUHVHvQWUHUXSHFXXQPHVDMGHHURDUHQXQHSRDWHPXOĠXPL&KLDU #J%ăQJ
GDFăQXVHSRDWHFDOFXODVXPDGHPDLVXVSURJUDPXOQRVWUXWUHEXLHVăVHILQDOL]H]HFD JJ
ú
J%ăJ
XQSURGXVIXQFĠLRQDOúLVăQHFRPXQLFHILHUH]XOWDWXOFRUHFWILHVăQHFRPXQLFHSULQWU JJ
ú
JJ
XQPHVDMSUHYă]XWSHQWUXDVHPHQHDFD]XULFăQXDIRVWSRVLELOăILQDOL]DUHDFDOFXOHORU JJ
JQXXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHUJúJzJ%ăJ
ă,JJ
3UREOHPDSURWHFĠLHLIDĠăGHGHSăúLULVHSRDWHvQOăWXUDGHFODUkQGYDULDELODVXPăGH JJJJ
ú
JJ
XQWLSGHGDWHÄVLJXU´'DUSHQWUXFD]XULOHvQFDUHDFHDVWăVROXĠLHQXHVWHODvQGHPkQă JJ ú
QHSXWHPIHULFXRGHFL]LHVLPSOă'HH[HPSOXVăSUHVXSXQHPFăvQFD]XOSURJUDPX ^DPLHúLWGLQFLFOXILHGLQFDX]DFăVDJăVLWHOHPHQWXOFăXWDW`
OXLGHPDLVXVYUHPVăúWLPFDUHHVWHYDORDUHDFHDPDLPDUHDYDULDELOHL[FDUHvQFăVH ^ILHGLQFDX]DFăXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHUvQFRQFOX]LH`
PDL SRDWH DGXQD IăUă Vă VH SURGXFă GHSăúLUH (IHFWXO SURJUDPXOXL XUPăWRU YD IL ^WUHEXLHVăDIOăPFDUHGLQFHOHGRXăFD]XULDFRQGXVODSăUăVLUHDFLFOXOXL`
DILúDUHDYDORULL JJăJJ\J%ăJJJ
JJJJ
JJ ăJ
JKJ JJ
JQXYKJ
JJ ăJ
JJJJQX
KJ úă
ú
JJQ\`KJQ\KJ J
JJQ\
KJ 'DFăDOHJHPYHUVLXQHDvQFDUHOXFUăPFXRYDULDELOăORJLFăFRPSDUDUHDHOHPHQWX
JJ
JJ\||JJ OXL FXUHQW FX FHO FăXWDWRIDFHPH[SOLFLWvQFRUSXOVWUXFWXULLUHSHWLWLYH'HDVHPHQHD
JJJJJJ\J||JJJ
J GDFăGLQWUXQPRWLYRDUHFDUHYUHPWRWXúLVăOXFUăPFX vQ3DVFDODYHPSRVLELOLWD
JJJJJJQ\~KJ WHDVăvQWUHUXSHPFăXWDUHDvQPRPHQWXOJăVLULLHOHPHQWXOXLFăXWDWDSHOkQGVXESURJUD
JJJJJJ
%J
PXOX?
JJJJ
JQ\KJ
JJJJ
J
JJJ
JJ
JJ
J
J
)LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH )LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH
PăUXO FXUHQW HVWH PDL PLFGHFkWPLQGHVFKLGHPILúLHUXOSHQWUXVFULHUHvQ3DVFDOFX
'HWHUPLQDUHDHOHPHQWXOXLPLQLPPD[LP úL VFULHP QRXD YDORDUHD D PLQLPXOXL úL QXPăUXO GH RUGLQH FRUHVSXQ]ăWRU
ÌQ IRDUWH PXOWH SUREOHPH LQWHUYLQH R VXESUREOHPă vQ FDUH VH FHUH GHWHUPLQDUHD FHOXL
$VWIHOSUDFWLFúWHUJHPYHFKLXOFRQĠLQXWDOILúLHUXOXLVFULLQGvQHOUH]XOWDWXOFDUHFRQ
PDL PLF VDX FHOXL PDL PDUH HOHPHQW GLQWUR PXOĠLPH GH GDWH &RQĠLQXWXO XQXL ILúLHU
IRUPVWDGLXOXLSUHOXFUăULLHVWHFRUHFWÌQILQDOYRPDYHDXQXOVDXPDLPXOWHQXPHUH
SRDWHILSULYLWFDILLQGRDVWIHOGHPXOĠLPHELQHvQĠHOHVFkWWLPSQHUHIHULPODXQFRQĠL
GHRUGLQHFDUHFRUHVSXQGHOHPHQWHORUHJDOHFXYDORDUHDPLQLPăVFULVăvQILúLHU
QXWIRUPDWGLQDFHODúLWLSGHGDWH
3UH]HQWDUHDDOJRULWPXOXLRYRPIDFHSHQWUXGHWHUPLQDUHDYDORULLPLQLPHGLQWUHPDL
PXOWHGDWHGHWLSvQWUHJFDUHVHFLWHVFGLQWUXQILúLHUGHWLSWH[W9DULDELODGHVHPQDWăVă ,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
UHĠLQăYDORDUHDPLQLPXOXLPLQYDILLQLĠLDOL]DWăILHFXSULPDYDORDUHFLWLWăGLQILúLHU 3HQWUXDYăIDPLOLDUL]DFXPRGXOvQFDUHWUHEXLHUH]ROYDWHSUREOHPHOHvQFDUHLQWHUYLQ
ILHFXRYDORDUHÄVWUăLQă´DOHDVăFXJULMăSHQWUXDQXULVFDVăILHFHDPDLPLFăvQFRP RSHUDĠLLFXILúLHUGHWLSWH[WYăVXJHUăPVăvQFHUFDĠLVăLPSOHPHQWDĠLDOJRULWPLSHQWUX
SDUDĠLHFXGDWHOHGLQILúLHU$FHDVWăDGRXDVROXĠLHVHUHFRPDQGăGRDUvQFD]XOvQFDUH FLWLUHDXQXLQXPăUGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDVDvQDOWXO
SULPDYDULDQWăQXHVWHSRVLELOăVDXHVWHPXOWSUHDDQHYRLRDVă FLWLUHD WXWXURU QXPHUHORU GLQWUXQ ILúLHU FDUH FRQĠLQH FkWH XQ QXPăU SH R OLQLH úL
ÌQDOJRULWPvQFRQWLQXDUHVHFLWHVFSHUkQGGDWHOHGLQILúLHUúLILHFDUHVHFRPSDUă VFULHUHDORUvQDOWILúLHUFkWHXQXOSHROLQLH
FXYDORDUHDFXUHQWăDYDULDELOHLPLQFDUHVHDFWXDOL]HD]ăGXSăFD] FLWLUHDGDWHORUGLQWUXQILúLHUFDUHFRQĠLQHQXPHUHPDLPXOWHSHROLQLHúLVFULHUHD
ORUvQWUXQDOWILúLHUvQDFHHDúLIRUPă
#J
QJJ
JJ
ú
J
J FLWLUHDXQHLVHFYHQĠHGHQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDHLvQDOWILúLHU
FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHúLUXULGHFDUDFWHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDORUvQWUXQDOWILúLHU
JJ
JmJ
J
FLWLUHDXQXLQXPăUQDWXUDO1GLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDvQWUXQDOWILúLHUDWXWXURUQX
JJ
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHUJ
ăQJ
JJJJ
ú
J
J PHUHORUQDWXUDOHFXSULQVHvQWUHúL1FkWHXQXOSHROLQLH
JJJJăJ
J
J
JJ FLWLUHDXQXLQXPăUQDWXUDO1GLQWUXQILúLHUúLD1QXPHDIODWHSHXUPăWRDUHOHOLQLL
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J DOHILúLHUXOXLúLVFULHUHDFHORU1QXPHvQWUXQDOWILúLHU
úă FRSLHUHDLQWHJUDOăDFRQĠLQXWXOXLXQXLILúLHUvQWUXQDOWILúLHU
ú
UHGHVFKLGHUHDILúLHUHORUDWXQFLFkQGHVWHQHFHVDU
úJ
3HQWUXDYăIDPLOLDUL]DFXSUHOXFUăULVLPSOHFXPVXQWFDOFXOXOVXPHORUGHWHUPLQD
ÌQFD]XOPD[LPXOXLYRPSURFHGDVLPLODUILLQGDWHQĠLODRSHUDWRUXOUHODĠLRQDOXWLOL UHDPLQLPXOXLPD[LPXOXLYăVXJHUăPVăvQFHUFDĠLVăLPSOHPHQWDĠLDOJRULWPLSHQWUX
]DW(VWHSRVLELOFDHQXQĠXOVăFHDUăúLQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOHOHPHQWXOXLPLQLPPD x FDOFXODUHDVXPHLSULPHORU1QXPHUHQDWXUDOH
[LPÌQDFHVWFD]SHUDPXUD GLQVWUXFWXUDDOWHUQDWLYăYRPDGăXJDúLDFWXDOL x FDOFXODUHDVXPHLXQRUGDWHSăVWUDWHvQWUXQILúLHUGHWLSWH[W
]DUHDQXPăUXOXLGHRUGLQHFDUHWUHEXLHLQLĠLDOL]DWăFXYDORDUHDGDFăSUHOXFUDUHDDvQ x GHWHUPLQDUHD PLQLPXOXLPD[LPXOXL GLQWUXQ úLU GH GDWH SăVWUDWH vQWUXQ ILúLHU GH
FHSXWFXHOHPHQWXOGHLQGLFHvQDLQWHGHDLQWUDvQVWUXFWXUDUHSHWLWLYă
ÌQ WLSWH[W
DFHVWIHOFKLDUGDFăvQILúLHUVHDIOăPDLPXOWHGDWHHJDOHFXYDORDUHDFHDPDLPLFăQX
x LQLĠLDOL]DUHDPLQLPXOXLPD[LPXOXLFXHOHPHQWXOQHXWUXVDXFXSULPXOHOHPHQW
PăUXOGHRUGLQHYDILDOSULPXOXLDVWIHOGHQXPăU
'DFăQLVHFHUHXOWLPXOQXPăUHJDOFXYDORDUHDPLQLPăWUHEXLHGRDUVăPRGLILFăP x FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDvQWUXQILúLHUDPLQLPXOXLORUSUHFXP
úLDSULPHLSR]LĠLLSHFDUHDSDUHDFHVWPLQLP
RSHUDWRUXOUHODĠLRQDO
vQt
'DFăWUHEXLHVăDILúăPWRDWHQXPHUHOHGHRUGLQHDOHGDWHORUFDUHVXQWHJDOHFXPL x FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDvQWUXQILúLHUDPLQLPXOXLORUSUHFXP
QLPXODWXQFLWUHEXLHVăUHFXUJHPODRDOWăWHKQLFă,PHGLDWGXSăLQLĠLDOL]DUHDYDULDELOHL úLDXOWLPHLSR]LĠLLSHFDUHDSDUHDFHVWPLQLP
PLQVFULHPYDORDUHDOXLúLQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH8UPHD]ăFRPSDUD x FLWLUHDXQRUQXPHUHGLQWUXQILúLHUúLVFULHUHDvQWUXQILúLHUDPLQLPXOXLORUSUHFXP
UHDFHORUODOWHGDWHFXPLQ'DFăQXPăUXOFXUHQWHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWPLQQXWUHEXLHVă úLDWXWXURUSR]LĠLLORUSHFDUHDSDUHDFHVWPLQLP
IDFHPQLPLFÌQFD]FRQWUDUYRPvQWUHEDGDFăQXPăUXOFXUHQWHVWHHJDOFXPLQÌQFD]
DILUPDWLYGHVFKLGHPILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHSHQWUXDGăXJDUHvQ3DVFDOFX
úLVFUL
HPvQHOQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOHOHPHQWXOXLFDUHDDYXWYDORDUHDHJDOăFXPLQ'DFăQX
$FHúWLDOJRULWPLVHYRUWUDWDGLQQRXvQFD]XOvQFDUHGDWHOHYRUILVWUXFWXUDWHvQWDEORXUL
)LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH )LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH &RQFDWHQDUHGHILúLHUH
6HFRQVLGHUăGRXăILúLHUHGHWLSWH[W -.&$úL -/&$6ăVHFUHH]HXQDOWUHLOHDILúLHU
GHWLSWH[W-0&'(!FDUHVăFRQĠLQăWRDWHGDWHOHGLQ-.&$DSRLvQWUHJFRQĠLQXWXOILúLH
1XPăUSDU UXOXL-/&$
6WDELOLĠLGDFăSULQWUHQXPHUHOHvQWUHJLVFULVHvQWUXQILúLHUGHWLSWH[WH[LVWăVDXQXFHO
SXĠLQXQQXPăUSDU 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
)LúLHUHOHVXQWVSHFLILFDWHSULQQXPHOHORU -.&$úL -/&$úLDXFRQĠLQXWXULRDUHFDUH
'DWHGHLQWUDUH SHFDUHOHYRPSULYLFDILLQGFDUDFWHUH$FHVWHDVHYRUFLWLvQFHSkQGFXSULPXOúLWHUPL
ÌQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH#"&$VHDIOăPDLPXOWHQXPHUHvQWUHJL QkQGFXXOWLPXOSkQăODPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
'DWHGHLHúLUH 'DWHGHLHúLUH
'DFăvQILúLHUH[LVWăFHOSXĠLQXQQXPăUSDUvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH #"&'(!VHYDVFULHJ )LúLHUXO-0&'(!YDILIRUPDWGLQGDWHOHGLQILúLHUXO-.&$DSRLROLQLHYLGăGXSăFDUH
DOWIHOVHYDVFULH XUPHD]ăGDWHOHGLQILúLHUXO-/&$
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x dQXPăUd x ROLQLHGLQILúLHUFRQĠLQHFHOPXOWGHFDUDFWHUH
([HPSOX ([HPSOX
#"&$J #"&'(!J
-.&$J -/&$J -0&'(!J
JJJ J
JJJ J%JJ
JJJ
JJ ăJăJ JJ
1XPHUHSDUHSăWUDWHSHUIHFWHvQILúLHU |J |J
ÌQWUXQILúLHUVXQWVFULVHPDLPXOWHQXPHUHQDWXUDOH$OHJHĠLQXPHUHOHSDUHFDUHVXQW OLQLHYLGă
J%JJ
SăWUDWHSHUIHFWHúLVFULHĠLOHvQWUXQDOWILúLHU
ăJă
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
1XPHUHOH VXQW VFULVH vQ ILúLHUXO GH LQWUDUH $(+"&$ SH PDL PXOWH UkQGXUL 3H XQ &DUDFWHUH
UkQGVXQWVFULVHXQQXPăURDUHFDUHGHQXPHUHVHSDUDWHSULQXQXOVDXPDLPXOWHVSDĠLL 6HFRQVLGHUăGRXăQXPHUHQDWXUDOHDúLEFDUHUHSUH]LQWăFDSHWHOHXQXLLQWHUYDOGHQX
PHUHvQWUHJLúLXQQXPăURDUHFDUHGHFDUDFWHUH$OHJHĠLGLQWUHDFHVWHFDUDFWHUHSHDFH
'DWHGHLHúLUH OHDFDUHDXFRGXULOH$6&,,FXSULQVHvQLQWHUYDOXO>DE@
1XPHUHOHSDUHFDUHVXQWSăWUDWHSHUIHFWHVHYRUVFULHFkWHXQXOSHOLQLHvQILúLHUXOGH
LHúLUH$(+"&'(! 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
3H SULPD OLQLH D ILúLHUXOXL #"#!"&$ VH DIOă QXPHUHOH D úL E VHSDUDWH SULQWUXQ
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL VSDĠLX3HILHFDUHGLQWUHXUPăWRDUHOHOLQLLVXQWVFULVHPDLPXOWHFDUDFWHUH
x dQXPăUd
'DWHGHLHúLUH
([HPSOX &DUDFWHUHOHFDUHFRUHVSXQGFHULQĠHLSUREOHPHLVHYRUVFULHvQILúLHUXO #"#!"&'(!
$(+"&$ $(+"&'(! SHDFHHDúLOLQLHVHSDUDWHSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLX
JJJJJJJJJJ J
``JJJJJJJ|J ``J 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
JJ`` ``
x dDdEd
)LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH )LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH
([HPSOX ([HPSOX
#"#!"&$ #"#!"&'(!J
-#!&$J -#!&'(!J
|`JJ J
JJJJJJJJJ |J `J
JJ`JJ J
9kUVWH
0HGLL 'LQWUXQILúLHUGHWLSWH[WVHFLWHVFQXPHUHQDWXUDOHUHSUH]HQWkQGDQLLGHQDúWHUHDXQRU
SHUVRDQH$ILúDĠLDQXOGHQDúWHUHúLQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOLQLHLGLQILúLHUSHFDUHVHDIOă
&XQRVFkQGPHGLLOHVHPHVWULDOHODGLVFLSOLQDLQIRUPDWLFăDOHXQRUHOHYLGLQWURFODVăVă
DQXOQDúWHULLDOFHOHLPDLWLQHUHSHUVRDQH3URFHGDĠLODIHOvQFD]XOFHOHLPDLYkUVWQLFH
VHGHWHUPLQHPHGLDVHPHVWULDOăDFODVHLODDFHDVWăGLVFLSOLQă
SHUVRDQH
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
ÌQILúLHUXO+%&$VXQWVFULVHPHGLLOHHOHYLORUFkWHXQQXPăUUHDOSHILHFDUHOLQLH
3HILHFDUHOLQLHDILúLHUXOXL #$&$VHDIOăXQQXPăUvQWUHJUHSUH]HQWkQGDQXOQDúWHULL
'DWHGHLHúLUH XQHLSHUVRDQH
0HGLD FODVHL VH YD VFULH vQ ILúLHUXO GH LHúLUH +%&'(! 'DFă GLQ QHIHULFLUHQXVH
'DWHGHLHúLUH
SRDWH FDOFXOD PHGLD GHRDUHFH WRĠL HOHYLL DX UăPDV FRULJHQĠL vQ ILúLHU VH YD VFULH
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLHúLUH #$&'(!VHYDVFULHDQXOGHQDúWHUHDFHOHLPDLWL
PHVDMXOJJJ%%J
QHUH SHUVRDQH 3H OLQLD D GRXD VH YD VFULH QXPăUXO GH RUGLQH D FHOHL PDL WLQHUH SHU
VRDQH3HDWUHLDOLQLHVHYDVFULHDQXOGHQDúWHUHDFHOHLPDLYkUVWQLFHSHUVRDQH3HD
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
SDWUDOLQLHVHVFULHQXPăUXOGHLGHQWLILFDUHDFHOHLPDLYkUVWQLFHSHUVRDQH'DFăvQWUXQ
x PHGLLOHVXQWQXPHUHUHDOHFXGRXă]HFLPDOHH[DFWH
DFHODúLDQVDXQăVFXWPDLPXOWHSHUVRDQHVHYRUIXUQL]DWRDWHQXPHUHOHGHRUGLQHFR
x dPHGLHd
UHVSXQ]ăWRDUHGHVSăUĠLWHSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLX
x PHGLLOHPDLPLFLGHFkWQXSDUWLFLSăODFDOFXOH
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
([HPSOX
+%&$J +%&'(!J x dDQd
([SOLFDĠLH
|J J 0HGLDQXSDUWLFLSăOD
([HPSOX
|`J FDOFXOH0HGLDDULWPHWLFă #$&$ #$&'(!
J
VDFDOFXODWGLQPHGLL J ``J
J
J JJ
```J J
)DFWRULDO ``J |JJ
6ăVHFDOFXOH]HSURGXVXOSULPHORU1QXPHUHQDWXUDOHIDFWRULDOXO J
J
'DWHGHLQWUDUH ``J
ÌQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH-#!&$HVWHVFULVXQVLQJXUQXPăUQDWXUDO
&DUDFWHUH
'DWHGHLHúLUH 6HFRQVLGHUăXQILúLHUGHWLSWH[WFDUHFRQĠLQHFDUDFWHUH$ILúDĠLvQRUGLQHDvQFDUHDSDU
9DORDUHDIDFWRULDOXOXLVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH-#!&'(! vQILúLHUDFHOHFDUDFWHUHFDUHVXQWPDLPDULGHFkWXOWLPXOFDUDFWHUGLQILúLHU
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
x d1d 3HILHFDUHOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH#"#!"&$VHDIOăXQFDUDFWHU
)LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH )LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH
'DWHGHLHúLUH 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVH
3H SULPD OLQLH D ILúLHUXOXL GH LHúLUH #"#!"&'(! VH YD VFULH XOWLPXO FDUDFWHU FLWLW
GLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH3HXUPăWRDUHDOLQLHVHYRUVFULHFDUDFWHUHOHFHUXWHVHSDUDWHSULQ
FkWHXQVSDĠLX 1XPăUSDU
$FHDVWăSUREOHPăFHUHVăVWDELOLPGDFăSULQWUHRPXOĠLPHGHQXPHUHDSDUHFHOSXĠLQ
([HPSOX XQQXPăUSDU
#"#!"&$J #"#!"&'(!J J
J J #J"ăQJ
J JJJJJ
JJ ăJmJIDOVJ
J JJ
QXDPDMXQVODVIkUúLWXOILúLHUXOXLú ăJ
ă,J
J JJJJ
ú
J
J ^FLWLPDOWQXPăU`
J
JJJJ ăJmJ ăJ J
HVWHSDUJ
J
JJ ú
J ă ăJ
J
J
J JJ
JJ
JJJJ
J
ú
3DUHLPSDUH
'LQWUXQILúLHUGHWLSWH[WVHFLWHVFPDLPXOWHQXPHUHQDWXUDOHGHSHILHFDUHOLQLH3HQ 'DFăYUHPVăHYLWăPIRORVLUHDYDULDELOHLORJLFH ăSXWHPSURFHGDvQIHOXOXU
WUXILHFDUHOLQLHGLQILúLHUDILúDĠLFHDPDLPLFăYDORDUHSDUăúLFHDPDLPDUHYDORDUHLP PăWRU
SDUăSUHFL]kQGúLQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOLQLHL
#J"ăQJ
JJ
ú
J
J
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
JJ
QXDPDMXQVODVIkUúLWXOILúLHUXOXLúQXPăUXOHVWHLPSDU
ă,J
)LHFDUHOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH *$&$FRQĠLQHQXPHUHQDWXUDOHVHSDUDWHSULQ
JJJJ
ú
J
J ^FLWLPDOWQXPăU`
FkWHXQVSDĠLX ú
JJăJQXDPDMXQVODVIkUúLWXOILúLHUXOXL
HVWHSDUJ
'DWHGHLHúLUH ^GDFăQXXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHUvQVHDPQăFăDPJăVLWXQQXPăU`
)LúLHUXOGHLHúLUH *$&'(!YDDYHDWRWDWkWHDOLQLLFkWHOLQLLH[LVWăvQILúLHUXOGHLQ ^SDUDOWIHOPDLHVWHSRVLELOFDQUGLQIDĠDPăUFLLGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHUVăILIRVWSDU`
WUDUH 3HILHFDUHOLQLHYRUILVFULVHGRXăQXPHUHFDUHUHSUH]LQWăFHOPDLPLFQXPăUSDU JJJJ
J
úLFHOPDLPDUHQXPăULPSDUGHSHOLQLDFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH JJ
JJ
JJJJ
J
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL úJ
x QXPăUd
x SHILHFDUHOLQLHGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHH[LVWăDWkWQXPHUHSDUHFkWúLLPSDUH 1XPHUHSDUHSăWUDWHSHUIHFWHvQILúLHU
9DULDELOHOH
úL GH WLS VH YRU DVRFLD ILúLHUHORU $(+"&$ UHVSHFWLY $(+1
([HPSOX "&'(!1XPHOHILúLHUHORUSUHFL]DWHvQHQXQĠVXQWGHFODUDWHVXEIRUPDXQRUFRQVWDQWH
*$&$J *$&'(!
JJJJ|JJJJ J|J VLPEROLFHODvQFHSXWXOSURJUDPXOXL%LQHvQĠHOHVDFHVWHFRQVWDQWHGHWLSúLUGHFDUDFWH
JJJJJJJJ JJ UHVDUILSXWXWVFULHFDSDUDPHWULDFWXDOLvQDSHOXOSURFHGXULORU
3ULPXOILúLHU
JJJ|JJJJ JJ VHGHVFKLGHFX
FHHDFHvQVHDPQăFăVHYDSDUFXUJHGHODvQFHSXWvQVFRSXO
JJJJ J FLWLULLGDWHORUVFULVHvQHO$OGRLOHDILúLHUVHGHVFKLGHFX SHQWUXVFULHUH
)LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH
6HSDUFXUJHSULPXOILúLHUFkWWLPSDFHVWDFRQĠLQHGDWHSkQăODVIkUúLWXOILúLHUXOXL )LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH
3HQWUXILHFDUHQXPăUFLWLWGLQILúLHUVHYHULILFăGDFăHVWHSăWUDWSHUIHFWúLGDFăHVWHSDU
'DFăDFHVWHFRQGLĠLLVXQWvQGHSOLQLWHQXPăUXOVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH #%
%
QJ
JXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHUvQ
J
ă,J
$OJRULWPXOFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăDFHVWHRSHUDĠLLHVWH JJJJ
JXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHvQ
J
ăJJ JJJJJJJJJJJ
JJJJJJ
ú
J%JJJ ^VHFLWHúWHXQFDUDFWHUGLQILúLHUXO
`J
#Jă
%QJ JJJJJJ
J%JJJ ^VHVFULHFDUDFWHUXOvQ
`J
JJJJ ú
J
JXUPHD]ăPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHUJ
ă,J
JJJJ
ú
JPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHvQ
J J
JJJJ
ú
J
JJ ^GLQILúLHU` JJJJ
JPDUFDMGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHvQ
JJ
JJJJăJ
HVWHQXPăUSDU ú
JJJJJJ
JmJJJ JJ
JPDUFDMGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHJvQ
VHODVăROLQLHYLGăJ
J
JJ
ă, 6HFRSLD]ăvQDFHHDúLPDQLHUăFRQĠLQXWXOILúLHUXOXL-/&$vQ-0&'(!
JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
J~JJJ ú
ú
ă
J\J
J
0HGLL
JJJJJJJJ
J
^vQILúLHU` 3UREOHPD FHUH GHWHUPLQDUHD XQHL PHGLL DULWPHWLFH ÌQ SDUDOHO FX FLWLUHD YRP QXPăUD
úă WHUPHQLLVXPHLSHED]DFăUHLDVHYDGHWHUPLQDPHGLDDULWPHWLFăGHRDUHFHQXFXQRDú
úă
WHP QXPăUXO GDWHORU 1X HVWH VXILFLHQW Vă QXPăUăP SXU úL VLPSOX GDWHOH GHRDUHFH
ú
J
HYHQWXDOHOH PHGLL PDL PLFL GHFkW QX LQWUă vQ FDOFXOH ÌQ ILQDO VXPD VH vPSDUWH OD
úJ
QXPăUXOWHUPHQLORUGDFăDFHVWQXPăUHVWHGLIHULWGH
9HULILFDUHD SURSULHWăĠLL GH SăWUDW SHUIHFW VH UHDOL]HD]ă JHQHUkQG SH UkQG SăWUDWHOH
#JQJ
QXPHUHORUQDWXUDOHvQFHSkQGGHODGHRDUHFHQXDUHURVWVăJHQHUăPSăWUDWHOHXQRU
JJJmJ`J ^HOHPHQWQHXWUXSHQWUXDGXQDUH`
QXPHUHLPSDUHDFHVWHDILLQGúLHOHLPSDUH&kWWLPSXQDVWIHOGHSăWUDWHVWHPDLPLF
JJ
JmJ`J ^QXPăUXOWHUPHQLORU`
GHFkWQXPăUXOJHQHUăPXUPăWRUXOSăWUDW'DFăDFHVWDQXHVWHPDLPLFSRDWHILHJDOFX
JQXXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ă,
QXPăUXOGDWVDXSRDWHILPDLPDUHGHFkWHOÌQFD]GHHJDOLWDWHVFULHPQXPăUXOvQILúL
ú
J ^PHGLDFXUHQWăvQILúLHU`J
HUXOGHLHúLUH JJJJăJJtJ|J^GRDUPHGLLOHPDLPDULVDXHJDOHFXLQWHUHVHD]ă`
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ ^FUHúWHQXPăUXOWHUPHQLORU`J
&RQFDWHQDUHGHILúLHUH JJJJJJJmJJ~JJJ ^DGXQăPWHUPHQXOFXUHQW`J
JJJJ úă
3ULQFLSDOHOHRELHFWLYHSHFDUHQLOHSURSXQHPvQUH]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHVXQW JJ ú
x IRORVLUHD FRUHFWă D VXESURJUDPHORU SUHGHILQLWH SHQWUX ILúLHUH
ă
JzJ`J ^GDFăDYHPFHOSXĠLQRPHGLHPDLPDUHVDXHJDOăFX`
JJJJ
J
^DILúăPPHGLDDULWPHWLFă`J
x SDUFXUJHUHDFRUHFWăDXQHLOLQLLúLFLWLUHDPDUFDMXOXLGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLH JJ
J
JJJJ
JJJJ%%J
x FLWLUHDúLVFULHUHDFRUHFWăGLQúLUHVSHFWLYvQWUXQILúLHUGHWLSWH[W ú
x UHDOL]DUHDVFULHULLXQHLOLQLLYLGHvQILúLHU
6HSDUFXUJSHUkQGFRQĠLQXWXULOHFHORUGRXăILúLHUHFDUDFWHUFXFDUDFWHU)LHFDUHFD
)DFWRULDO
UDFWHUFLWLWVHVFULHvQILúLHUXO-0&'(!&kQGVHvQWkOQHúWHPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHvQ ÌQDFHDVWăSUREOHPăYRPFLWLYDORDUHDOXLQúLSHED]DOXLFXDMXWRUXOXQHLLQVWUXFĠLXQL
ILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVHYDIDFHVDOWODOLQLHQRXă'XSăFHSULPXOGLQFHOHGRXăILúLHUHGH
YRPJHQHUDWRDWHQXPHUHOHQDWXUDOH
LQWUDUHDIRVWSDUFXUVvQvQWUHJLPHVHVFULHROLQLHYLGăvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH
3UH]HQWăPFLWLUHDGDWHORUGLQILúLHUXO-.&$úLVFULHUHDDFHVWRUDvQ-0&'(!SUHFXP
úLVFULHUHDOLQLHLYLGH9DULDELOD%HVWHGHWLSFDUDFWHU
)LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH )LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH
#J%QJJ ^vQSYRPREĠLQHYDORDUHDIDFWRULDOXOXL`J &DUDFWHUH
JJJmJJ ^HOHPHQWQHXWUXSHQWUXvQPXOĠLUH` ÌQDFHDVWăSUREOHPăvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHDYHPFDUDFWHUH$6&,,FDUHSRWILFLIUHOLWHUH
ú
J VDX DOWH VHPQH $YkQG vQ YHGHUH Fă GLQWUH DFHVWHD WUHEXLH Vă ÄFXOHJHP´ FDUDFWHUHOH
JJ
J\
J
ă,J
DYkQGFRGXO$6&,,vQLQWHUYDOXO>DE@YRPDQDOL]DILHFDUHFDUDFWHUFLWLWGLQILúLHUXOGH
JJJJJmJJJJJ ^vQPXOĠLPFXIDFWRUXOFXUHQW`J LQWUDUHúLGDFăDFHVWDDUHFRGXO$6&,,vQLQWHUYDOXOGDWvOFRSLHPvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH
JJ ú
)LHGHH[HPSOXFRQĠLQXWXOILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH#"#!"&$J
ú
|`J|J
JJ`JJ
'DUVăIDFHPDEVWUDFĠLHSHQWUXPRPHQWGHSUHFL]DUHDGLQHQXQĠFXSULYLUHODOLPLWH ,QWHUYDOXOHVWH>@6HSDUFXUJFDUDFWHUHOHGHSHDGRXDOLQLHúLVHFRPSDUăSH
OHOXLQ6ăYHULILFăPSURJUDPXOGHPDLVXVSHUkQGSHQWUXYDORULOH UkQG FRGXULOH $6&,, DOH FDUDFWHUHORU FLWLWH FX FDSHWHOH LQWHUYDOXOXL &RGXO $6&,, DO
SRDWH úL ÌQ IXQFĠLH GH WLSXO YDULDELOHL S VH SRW vQWkPSOD OXFUXUL LQWHUHVDQWH 'H XQXL FDUDFWHU % VH SRDWH REĠLQH vQ 3DVFDO IRORVLQG IXQFĠLD % 'H H[HPSOX
H[HPSOXGDFăUH]XOWDWXOHVWHGHFODUDWFDILLQGGHWLSXO XYYRPREĠLQH \`LDU \|
\`JHWF
\'DU DUWUHEXLVăILHHJDOFX `'DFăPRGLILFăPWLSXOOXLSGLQ XYvQ 3HQWUXILúLHUXOGDWFDH[HPSOXGRDUFDUDFWHUHOH ` úLFDUDFWHUXOVSDĠLXFDUH
úL UXOăP SURJUDPXO SHQWUX Q REĠLQHP `\` QXPăU DXFRGXULOH$6&,, UHVSHFWLY QXVHDIOăvQLQWHUYDOXOFHUXWÌQFRQFOX]LHvQ
QHJDWLYLDUSHQWUXQ |`\`'DFăRGHFODUăPSHSGHWLS SURJUDPXOVH ILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHYRPDYHDXUPăWRDUHOHFDUDFWHUHVHSDUDWHSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLX
vQWUHUXSHSHQWUXQ!FXPHVDMXOGHHURDUH
J
J
J
JJJJJJJJJ
6ăOXăPvQFRQVLGHUDUHVLWXDĠLDvQFDUHVHSUHIHUăFDUH]XOWDWXOVăILHGHWLS
(YLGHQWvQFHUFăULOHQHDXFRQYLQVFăvQFHSkQGFXRDQXPLWăYDORDUHDOXLQVH #%Q
SURGXFHGHSăúLUH0DLDOHVDWXQFLFkQGWUHEXLHFDOFXODWIDFWRULDOXOXQXLQFDUHFRQVWLWX
ú
LHXQUH]XOWDWFDOFXODWvQSURJUDPQHWUHEXLHÄXQLQVWUXPHQW´FDUHVăQHSURWHMH]HGH
XUPHD]ăPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHUvQ#"#!"&$
ă,J
QHSOăFHULFXPDUILREĠLQHUHDXQXLUH]XOWDWIDOV&HOPDLPDUHQXPăUGHWLSXO
XUPHD]ăPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHvQ#"#!"&$
ă,J
JJJJJJ
ú
J%J
SRVLELOGHUHSUH]HQWDWvQFDOFXODWRUHVWH UHĠLQXWGHFRQVWDQWDVLP
JJJJJJăJFRGXO$6&,,DOFDUDFWHUXOXL%túJJ
EROLFăDXQLWXOXL6\VWHPQXPLWăvQ3DVFDO
$UXUPDVăSXWHPSXQHRvQ
JJJJJJJJJJJFRGXO$6&,,DOFDUDFWHUXOXL%d
WUHEDUHGHJHQXO JJ
J
J
'DUHVWHDEVXUGVăvQWUHEăPGDFă
J%JJJ ^VFULHPvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH`
XQQXPăUHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWFHOPDLPDUHQXPăUSRVLELO
JJJJJJ úăJ
ÌQFRQVHFLQĠăYRPSXQHvQWUHEDUHDFXXQSDVvQDLQWHGHHIHFWXDUHDvQPXOĠLULLFXUHQ ú
WHFDUHDUSXWHDSURGXFHRGHSăúLUHvQIHOXOXUPăWRU JJJJ
ú
PDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHGLQ#"#!"&$J
J ú
J
JJQ\KJJ ú
JJQ\KJ
JJ
J
`JJ\
J
JJJJJJ
J
JJJ
JJ 9kUVWH
JJJJJJQ\`J 2ELHFWLYHOHSURSXVHvQDFHDVWăSUREOHPăVXQW
JJJJ
JJ x DIODUHDYDORULLPLQLPHúLPD[LPHGLQWUHYDORULOHSăVWUDWHvQWUXQILúLHUGHWLSWH[W
JJJJJJQ\KJJ x FăXWDUHD DFHVWRU YDORUL vQ ILúLHU úL UDSRUWDUHD SR]LĠLLORU SH FDUH YDORDUHD PLQLPă
JJJJJJ
%JJ
JJJJ
J UHVSHFWLYPD[LPăDSDUHvQILúLHU
JJ
x SDUFXUJHUHDILúLHUXOXLWH[WGHPDLPXOWHRULFHHDFHSUHVXSXQHvQFKLGHUHDúLGHVFKL
&&& GHUHDOXLvQPRGUHSHWDW
9DORDUHDOXLS VHYDWHVWDvQEORFXODSHODQWSHQWUXDGHFLGHGDFăVDSXWXWFDOFXOD $IODUHD FHOHL PDL WLQHUH SHUVRDQH VH UHGXFH OD DIODUHD PD[LPXOXL GLQ ILúLHU úL VH
IDFWRULDOXOFHUXWVDXQXGHRDUHFHVDUILSURGXVRGHSăúLUH UHDOL]HD]ăvQDOJRULWPXOXUPăWRU
)LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH )LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH
#JQJ &DUDFWHUH
ú
J
J
(WDSHOHUH]ROYăULLDFHVWHLSUREOHPHVXQW
JJJmJ
J
x FLWLUHDLQWHJUDOăDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUHúLVFULHUHDXOWLPXOXLFDUDFWHUFLWLWvQILúLHUXO
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ă,J
ú
J
J
GHLHúLUH
JJJJăJJJ
JJJ x GHVFKLGHUHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUHSHQWUXRDGRXDSDUFXUJHUH
JJJJJJJmJ
J x VFULHUHD vQ ILúLHUXO GH LHúLUH D WXWXURU FDUDFWHUHORU GLQ ILúLHUXO GH LQWUDUH FDUH VXQW
úăJ PDLPDULGHFkWXOWLPXOFDUDFWHUFLWLWSăVWUDWvQYDULDELODF
ú
J
JJJ 3HQWUXJăVLUHDFDUDFWHUHORUPDLPDULGHFkWFvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHDFHVWDVHGHVFKLGH
ú SHQWUXSDUFXUJHUH6HFLWHVFSHUkQGFkWHXQFDUDFWHUEGHSHILHFDUHOLQLHúLVHFRPSDUă
J FXF'DFăEHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWFDWXQFLDFHVWDVHVFULHSHDGRXDOLQLHvQILúLHUXOGH
'XSăFHVDVFULVSHSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLHúLUHYDORDUHDPD[LPXOXLXUPHD]ă LHúLUHXUPDWGHFDUDFWHUXOVSDĠLX
VăVHUHJăVHDVFăDFHDVWăYDORDUHvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH5HJăVLUHDVHUHDOL]HD]ăSULQUH
GHVFKLGHUHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUHSHQWUXSDUFXUJHUHúLFăXWDUHDYDORULLPD[LPH/DILH #%QJ
FDUHDSDULĠLHDPD[LPXOXLvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHVHVFULHYDORDUHDQXPăUXOXLGHRUGLQHD
JQXXUPHD]ăPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ă,J
OLQLHLSHFDUHVHDIOăRYDORDUHHJDOăFXYDORDUHDPD[LPăúLXQVSDĠLXVHSDUDWRUSHQWUX
ú
J%J
FD]XOvQFDUHVHYDPDLVFULHXQQXPăUGHRUGLQHvQILúLHU'XSăHSXL]DUHDHOHPHQWHORU ú
J
GLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHVHVFULHPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHSHQWUXFD
%JJ ^vQFDYHPXOWLPXOFDUDFWHUFLWLWGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH`J
VFULHUHDYDORULLPLQLPHVăVHUHDOL]H]HSHUkQGQRX
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ă,
ú
J
$OJRULWPXOHVWH ăJ%JJJ
JJJ^vQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVFULHPFDUDFWHUHOHÄPDLPDUL´GHFkWF`J
#J%Q úăJ
ú
JJJmJJJ ^QXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOOLQLHLvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH` ú
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ă,J
ú
J
J
ăJ
J\JJJJJ 3DUHLPSDUH
JJJJJJ
JJJJ 3UREOHPDFRQVWăvQWUDWDUHDVHSDUDWăDILHFăUHLOLQLLGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHvQLGHHDJăVL
úăJ ULLYDORULLPLQLPHSDUHúLDYDORULLPD[LPHLPSDUH
JJJJJmJJ~JJ
ú
#
,
ú
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ă,
JJJJ
JmJ
JJ ^VXQWHPVLJXULFăYRPJăVLXQXOPDLPLF`J
$OJRULWPXOSHQWUXPLQLPHVWHDQDORJFXFHOGHVFULVPDLVXVGDUVHSRDWHSURLHFWD
JJJJJmJ`JJ ^VXQWHPVLJXULFăYRPJăVLXQXOPDLPDUH`
XQDOJRULWPFDUHGHWHUPLQăYDORDUHDPLQLPăúLPD[LPăFXRVLQJXUăSDUFXUJHUHDILúL
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLH
ă,
HUXOXLGHLQWUDUH'DFăYRPOXFUDDVWIHOVWUXFWXUDUHSHWLWLYă
YDFRQĠLQHSUH
ú
OXFUăULOHDIHUHQWHPLQLPXOXLúLPD[LPXOXLXUPkQGFDUHJăVLUHDORUVăVHUHDOL]H]HVH ă
HVWHSDU
SDUDW GHRDUHFH QXPHUHOH GH RUGLQH FRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH PD[LPXOXL UHVSHFWLY PLQLPXOXL ă
JJ
WUHEXLHVăOHDILúăPJUXSDWH
JmJ
úă
1XPHUH &DSLWROXO
3UHOXFUăULDOHQXPHUHORU
&RQVWUXLUHDQXPăUXOXLvQWUHJGLQFDUDFWHUHFLIUH
6FKHPDOXL+RUQHU
'HVFRPSXQHUHDXQXLQXPăUGDWvQFLIUH
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
)LúLHUHGHWLSWH[WúLSUHOXFUăULVLPSOH 3UHOXFUăULDOHQXPHUHORU
$WXQFLFkQGVFULHPXQQXPăUFXFUHLRQXOVDXFXDMXWRUXOWDVWDWXULLDúH]ăPFLIUHXQD
ă
J
J OkQJăDOWDGDUVHPQLILFDĠLDúLUXOXLGHFLIUHHVWHFODUăSHQWUXWRDWăOXPHD1XQHYRP
JkQGLODFHHDFHYHGHPSHKkUWLHVDXSHPRQLWRUFDODXQúLUGHFLIUHFLFDODRVLQJX
JmJ
Uă HQWLWDWH DGLFă OD XQ QXPăU 'DFă QX DP VFULV úL YLUJXOD ]HFLPDOă VDX SXQFWXO
úă DYHPXQQXPăUvQWUHJ
úă
JJJ &RQVWUXLUHDQXPăUXOXLvQWUHJGLQFDUDFWHUHFLIUH
ú
6FKHPDOXL+RUQHU
ú
$WXQFLFkQGvQWUXQSURJUDPVHFLWHúWHXQQXPăUvQWUHJDXORFFkWHYDRSHUDĠLLDVFXQVH
ú GHRFKLLXWLOL]DWRUXOXLÌQSULPXOUkQGFLIUHOHFRQVWLWXLHFDUDFWHUHFDUHLPHGLDWGXSăFH
DXIRVWFLWLWHGLQILúLHUXOVWDQGDUGVDXXQXOFUHDWGHXWLOL]DWRUVXQWYHULILFDWHÄ1LPHQL
QXúWLH´GHGLQDLQWHFkWHFLIUHYDDYHDQXPăUXO'HDVHPHQHDQLPHQLQXúWLHGDFăGLQ
JUHúHDOăQXYDDSăUHDvQWUHGRXăFLIUHXQFDUDFWHUQHSHUPLV'DUFHDQXPHHVWHQHSHU
PLV" &DUDFWHUHOH VSDĠLX 7DE úL PDUFD GH VIkUúLW GH OLQLH FRQVWLWXLH VHSDUDWRUL $OWIHO
VSXVDSDULĠLDORUVHPQDOHD]ăIDSWXOFăQXPăUXOQXPDLDUHFLIUH'DUúLPDUFDGHVIkU
úLW GH ILúLHU VHPQDOHD]ă DFHODúL OXFUX GLIHUHQĠD IDĠă GH FHOH vQúLUDWH DQWHULRU HVWH Fă
PDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHUQXMRDFăUROGHÄVHSDUDWRU´FLGHÄWHUPLQDWRU´5HYHQLQGOD
FDUDFWHUHOHSHUPLVHúLQHSHUPLVHVHYRUUHVSHFWDUHJXOLOHVLQWDFWLFHDOHOLPEDMXOXLGH
SURJUDPDUHIRORVLW
ÌQ FHOH FH XUPHD]ă YRP UHDOL]DXQDOJRULWPSHQWUXFLWLUHDXQRUFDUDFWHUHGLQFDUH
YRPFUHDXQQXPăUvQWUHJGDFăDFHVWOXFUXYDILSRVLELO
1XPHUH 1XPHUH
([HPSOX ELĠLORUGLQVWkQJDVHSLHUG'DFăSHELWXOVHPQDMXQJHXQELWHJDOFXYRPDYHDXQ
)LHúLUXOGHFDUDFWHUHLQWURGXVGHODWDVWDWXUăúLGRULPFDDFHDVWăYDORDUH QXPăUQHJDWLYGDFăDFHVWDHVWHQXPăUXOHVWHSR]LWLYGDUGLQFDX]DELĠLORUVHPQLIL
VăLVHDWULEXLHYDULDELOHLQGHWLSvQWUHJUHSUH]HQWDWSHGRXăFXYLQWHvQOLPEDMXO3DV FDWLYL GH UDQJ FHO PDL PDUH SLHUGXĠL GLQ UHSUH]HQWDUHD QXPăUXOXL DYHP XQ ÄUH]XOWDW´
FDOWLSXOSUHGHILQLWHVWH
vQ&HVWH
ÌQFHOHFHXUPHD]ăYRPFRQWLQXD HURQDWYH]LSUREOHPDIDFWRULDOGLQFDSLWROXO
SUH]HQWDUHDFRQIRUPÄSRVLELOLWăĠLORU´GLQ3DVFDO 3UHVXSXQHP Fă Q HVWH GHFODUDW GH WLS
úL HVWH FLWLW FDUDFWHU GXSă FDUDFWHU
'XSă FH VH SUHLD SULPXO FDUDFWHU vQFă QX VH úWLH UDQJXO FLIUHL FRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH vQ GHWLS&SkQăODPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLH$OJRULWPXOvPEXQăWăĠLWHVWHXUPăWRUXO
QXPăUGDUHDWUHEXLHWRWXúLSUHOXFUDWă3HQWUXDvQĠHOHJHLGHHDFDUHSRDUWăGHQXPLUHD
ÄVFKHPDOXL+RUQHU´YRPVFULHQXPăUXOVXEIRUPDXQHLVXPH #J
QJ
JJ
JmJ`JJ ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDQXPăUXOXLQ`
JJJmJIDOV
$OJRULWPXOVHFRQWXUHD]ăPDLFODUGLQWDEHOXOXUPăWRU JJ%%ă
JmJIDOVJ
JJ
JJú%%ă
JúJJ
FLIUDFXUHQWă QXPăUvQFRQVWUXFĠLH J J J JXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLH
ă,
ú
%%JJJ ^FDUDFWHUXOFXUHQWGHODVWkQJDODGUHDSWD`J
JJJJăJ%%HVWHFLIUă
%
JmJYDORDUHDQXPHULFăDFDUDFWHUXOXL
ă
HVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWFHOPDLPDUHQXPăUvPSăUĠLWODJ
JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
`J~J%
J ^LQWURGXFHUHDFLIUHLvQQXPăUXOQ`J
JJJJJJ
J
JJJJJJJJJmJDGHYăUDWJ
úă
#J
QJ %%ă
JmJDGHYăUDW
JJ
JmJ`JJ ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDQXPăUXOXLQ` úăJ
JJ
PDLH[LVWăFLIUH
ă, ú
ú
%
JJJ ^FLIUDFXUHQWăGHODVWkQJDODGUHDSWD`J ăJJJ
JJJJ
JmJ
`J~J%
JJ ^LQWURGXFHUHDFLIUHLvQQXPăUXOQ`J JJJJ
2JJ
ú
JJ
J
ă%%ă
JJ
úJ JJ
2%J
J
JJJJ
J
JJJJJJ
J
J
$FHVW DOJRULWPQXHVWHvQVăVXILFLHQWGHSUHFLVGDUPDLDOHVQXHVWHÄSUHFDXW´ÌQ úăJ
SULPXOUkQGHOVHED]HD]ăSHIDSWXOFăvQPRGJDUDQWDWVHFLWHVFFLIUH'HFLDUWUHEXLVă úăJ
LQWURGXFHPúLYHULILFDUHDFDUDFWHUXOXLSHQWUXDILVLJXULFăYRPSUHOXFUDFLIUH úJ
$GRXDREVHUYDĠLHVHUHIHUăODFRQGLĠLDGLQLQVWUXFĠLXQHDUHSHWLWLYăWUHEXLHVăúWLP
FkQGVHWHUPLQăGHIDSWúLUXOGHFDUDFWHUHùLPDLDYHPRSUREOHPăVDUSXWHDFDQX
PăUXOQVăQXSRDWăILUHSUH]HQWDWSHVSDĠLXOUH]HUYDWvQPHPRULDFDOFXODWRUXOXLSHQWUX 'HVFRPSXQHUHDXQXLQXPăUGDWvQFLIUH
YDULDELOHGHWLSXOOXLQÌQFRQFOX]LHWUHEXLHVăQHSURWHMăPSURJUDPXOGHVXUSUL]HQH 2SHUDĠLDÄLQYHUVă´DGLFăIXUQL]DUHDFLIUHORUXQXLQXPăUHVWHQHFHVDUăRULGHFkWHRUL
SOăFXWHFDUHDUvQVHPQDFăXQQXPăUSR]LWLYvQPXOĠLWFXVăGHYLQăvQFDOFXODWRUQX GRULPVăUHDOL]ăPRSUHOXFUDUHFLIUăFXFLIUă3HQWUXDGHVFRPSXQHXQQXPăUvQWUHJvQ
PăUQHJDWLYVDXSR]LWLYGDUPDLPLFGLQFDX]DGHSăúLULLVSDĠLXOXLGHPHPRUDUHDOR FLIUHYRPIRORVLRSHUDĠLLOHGHvPSăUĠLUHvQWUHDJăúLGHWHUPLQDUHDUHVWXOXLvPSăUĠLULLvQ
FDW$SDULĠLDDFHVWRUHURULVHH[SOLFăSULQIDSWXOFăUHSUH]HQWDUHDQXPăUXOXLQXPDLvQ WUHJL3HQWUXDFHVWHGRXăRSHUDĠLLvQSVHXGRFRGYRPIRORVLQRWDĠLLOH>PQ@úLUHVW>PQ@
FDSHSHSR]LĠLLOHELQDUHDORFDWHúLXQELWVHPQLILFDWLYDMXQJHSHELWXOVHPQLDUUHVWXO
1XPHUH 1XPHUH
([HPSOLILFăPDOJRULWPXOSHQWUXDGHWHUPLQDGDFăQXPăUXOQGDWHVWHVDXQXSDOLQ 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
GURP8QQXPăUSDOLQGURPDUHDFHHDúLYDORDUHGDFăvOÄFLWLP´GHODGUHDSWDODVWkQJD
úLGHODVWkQJDODGUHDSWD$OWIHOVSXVXQQXPăUSDOLQGURPHVWHHJDOFXQXPăUXOIRUPDW
GLQFLIUHOHVDOHOXDWHvQRUGLQHLQYHUVăDFHVWDvQDOJRULWPHVWHQXPLW1LQYHUV 3ULPD]L
/RFXLWRULLGLQğDUDOXL3DSXUă9RGăRELúQXLDXVăúLSXQăSHFăVXĠHQXPHUHFLXGDWHúL
#J
QJ OXQJL3LWLFXO$úFKLXĠăDQJDMDWGHSUREăOD2ILFLXOSHQWUX(YLGHQĠD&OăGLULORU3XEOLFH
JJ
ú
J VD SXV SH WUHDEă vQFă GLQ SULPD ]L H[SHULPHQWkQG XQHOH PRGLILFăUL vQ QXPHURWDUHD
JJ
JmJ`JJ ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDQXPăUXOXL1LQYHUV` FOăGLULORU3HQWUXvQFHSXWHODHOLPLQDWFLIUDGLQQXPăUXOvQVFULVSHFOăGLUHDvQFDUH
JJJmJ
J OXFUD
JJ
JzJ`J
ă, ^FkWWLPSQPDLDUHFLIUH` 6FULHĠLXQSURJUDPFDUHFLWHúWHXQQXPăUQDWXUDOúLHOLPLQăGLQDFHVWDWRDWHDSDULĠLL
%
JmJ
`JJJ ^FLIUDFXUHQWăGHODGUHDSWDODVWkQJD`J OHFLIUHL
JJJJ
JmJ
`JJ ^HOLPLQăPXOWLPDFLIUăGLQQXPăUXOQ`J
JmJ
`J~J%
J J 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
J J J ^FRQVWUXLPQXPăUXO1LQYHUVFXVFKHPDOXL+RUQHU` 'LQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH3(#.&$VHYDFLWLXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQ
ú
ă
J\JJ 'DWHGHLHúLUH
2
2J ÌQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH3(#.&'(!VHYDVFULHQXPăUXOGLQFDUHVDXHOLPLQDWWRDWHFLIUHOH
JJ
JJ
JJJJ
J2JJ
2 HJDOHFX
úJ
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x dQd
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH x GDFăWRDWHFLIUHOHVXQWHJDOHFXUH]XOWDWXOYDILQXPăUXO
3HQWUXDYăIDPLOLDUL]DFXPRGXOvQFDUHWUHEXLHUH]ROYDWHSUREOHPHOHvQFDGUXOFăURUD
LQWHUYLQRSHUDĠLLFXFLIUHYăVXJHUăPVăvQFHUFDĠLVăLPSOHPHQWDĠLDOJRULWPLSHQWUX ([HPSOX
DILúDUHDFLIUHORUXQXLQXPăU 3(#.&$ 3(#.&'(!J
GHWHUPLQDUHDQXPăUXOXLGHFLIUHDOHXQXLQXPăU |J |J
GHWHUPLQDUHDFHOHLPDLPDULPLFLFLIUHDXQXLQXPăU
GHWHUPLQDUHDFHOHLPDLPDULPLFLFLIUHDXQXLQXPăUúLDSR]LĠLLORUSHFDUHDSDUH $GRXD]L
DFHDVWD $GRXD]LSLWLFXO$úFKLXĠăILLQGDQJDMDWGHSUREăOD2ILFLXOSHQWUX(YLGHQĠD&OăGLUL
GHWHUPLQDUHDLQYHUVXOXLXQXLQXPăU ORU3XEOLFHVDMXFDWGLQQRXFXFLIUDOXLSUHIHUDWăQXPăUkQGGHFkWHRULDSDUHFLIUD
JHQHUDUHDXQXLQXPăUGLQWUXQúLUGHFDUDFWHUHFDUHVXQWFLIUHSURWHFĠLHvQFD]GH vQWRWDOvQWRDWHQXPHUHOHFDVHORUGHSHVWUDGDVD
GHSăúLUHúLGHFDUDFWHUHFDUHQXVXQWFLIUH 5HDOL]DĠL XQ SURJUDP FDUH Vă QXPHUH GH FkWH RUL DSDUH FLIUD vQ WRDWH QXPHUHOH
YHULILFDUHDIDSWXOXLFăXQQXPăUHVWHSDOLQGURP H[LVWHQWHvQWUXQILúLHUGDW
GHWHUPLQDUHDWXWXURUQXPHUHORUSDOLQGURDPHGLQWUXQLQWHUYDOGDW
FLWLUHDXQXLQXPăUUHDOGHIRUPD[\úLDILúDUHDQXPăUXOXL\[ 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
GHWHUPLQDUHDWXWXURUQXPHUHORUGHWLSÄYDOH´GLQWUXQLQWHUYDO ÌQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH3(#/&$VHDIOăQXPHUHQDWXUDOHDúH]DWHFkWHXQXOSHROLQLH
GHWHUPLQDUHDWXWXURUQXPHUHORUGHWLSÄPXQWH´GLQWUXQLQWHUYDO
GHWHUPLQDUHDWXWXURUQXPHUHORUGHWLSÄYDOH´úLDWXWXURUQXPHUHORUGHWLSÄPXQWH´ 'DWHGHLHúLUH
GLQWUXQLQWHUYDO 1XPăUXOGHDSDULĠLLDOHFLIUHLVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH3(#/&'(!
1XPHUH 1XPHUH
([HPSOX 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
3(#/&$ 3(#/&'(!J 1XPăUXOQDWXUDOQVHFLWHúWHGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH3(#4&$
|J |J
||J 'DWHGHLHúLUH
`J
J
&LIUDUH]XOWDWăVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXO3(#4&'(!ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHQXPăUXOQXVHSRDWH
J UHGXFHODRFLIUăvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVHYDVFULHPHVDMXO
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
$WUHLD]L x dQdRVXWăGHPLOLRDQH
ÌQFHDGHDWUHLD]LGHOXFUXSLWLFXO$úFKLXĠăVDSOLFWLVLWúLVDKRWăUkWVăURWHDVFăFLIUH
OHQXPHUHORUFDVHORUWXWXURUYHFLQLORUVSUHGUHDSWD&XQRVFkQGQXPăUXOGHURWDĠLLHIHF ([HPSOH
WXDWHDVXSUDFLIUHORUSUHFXPúLQXPHUHOHFDVHORUYHFLQLORUGHSHVWUDGăDILúDĠLQXPH 3(#4&$ 3(#4&'(! 9DORULOHVXFFHVLYHDOHQXPăUXOXLSkQăOD
UHOHREĠLQXWHvQXUPDURWDĠLLORUFLIUHORU JJ J REĠLQHUHDUH]XOWDWXOXLVXQW
J J
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
5H]XOWDWXOILQDOHVWH
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXL3(#0&$VHDIOăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQUHSUH]HQWkQGQXPăUXO
GHURWDĠLLFDUHWUHEXLHHIHFWXDWHDVXSUDQXPHUHORUFăVXĠHORUYHFLQLORUGHSHVWUDGă3H
3(#4&$ 3(#4&'(! 9DORULOHVXFFHVLYHDOHQXPăUXOXLSkQăOD
XUPăWRDUHOHOLQLLVHDIOăQQXPHUHQDWXUDOHFkWHXQQXPăUSHROLQLH |J J J REĠLQHUHDUH]XOWDWXOXLVXQW
J J
'DWHGHLHúLUH J 5H]XOWDWXOILQDOHVWH
ÌQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH3(#0&'(!VHYRUVFULHQXPHUHOHURWLWHFkWHXQXOSHROLQLH J
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL 3(#4&$ 3(#4&'(!J 9DORULOHVXFFHVLYHDOHQXPăUXOXLSkQăOD
x dQd `J REĠLQHUHDUH]XOWDWXOXLVXQW
J «FLFOXLQILQLW
([HPSOX
J DFHVWQXPăUQXVHSRDWHUHGXFHODRFLIUă
3(#0&$ 3(#0&'(!J
J
|J
|J
|J
$FLQFHD]L
|J 'XSăFXPúWLPGHMDORFXLWRULLGLQğDUDOXL3DSXUă9RGăRELúQXLDXVăúLSXQăSHFăVX
J ĠHQXPHUHIRDUWHFLXGDWHúLOXQJL3LWLFXO$úFKLXĠăDQJDMDWOD2ILFLXOSHQWUX(YLGHQĠD
J
&OăGLULORU 3XEOLFH vQ FHD GHD FLQFHD ]L GH OXFUX VD DSXFDW GH IăFXW VWDWLVWLFL (O D
FăXWDWvQFD]XOXQXLQXPăUQFLIUHOHDYkQGFHDPDLPDUHIUHFYHQĠă
$SDWUD]L 6FULHĠLXQSURJUDPFDUHGHWHUPLQăIUHFYHQĠDPD[LPăGHDSDULĠLHDXQHLFLIUHúLFL
$SDWUD]LSLWLFXO$úFKLXĠăDOXDWKRWăUkUHDGHDVFXUWDQXPHUHOHFDVHORUGHRDUHFHLVH IUHOHFDUHDXDFHDVWăIUHFYHQĠăGHDSDULĠLHvQQXPăU
SăUHDXSUHDOXQJL(ODvQFHSXWVăH[SHULPHQWH]HLGHHDGHDvQORFXLILHFDUHFLIUăDQX
PăUXOXLFXFRPSOHPHQWXOFLIUHLUHVSHFWLYHIDĠăGHFHDPDLPDUHFLIUăGLQQXPăUHIHF 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
WXkQGDFHHDúLSUHOXFUDUHSHUH]XOWDWXOREĠLQXWHODREVHUYDWFăDQXPLWHQXPHUHVHUH 1XPăUXOQDWXUDOQVHFLWHúWHGLQILúLHUXO3(#5&$
GXFODRFLIUă
6FULHĠLXQSURJUDPFDUHUHGXFHXQQXPăUGDWODRFLIUăFXPHWRGDOXL$úFKLXĠăGDFă 'DWHGHLHúLUH
DFHVWOXFUXHVWHSRVLELO ÌQILúLHUXO3(#5&'(!VHYDVFULHIUHFYHQĠDPD[LPăXUPDWăGHVSDĠLXDSRLVHYDVFULH
FLIUDVDXFLIUHOHFDUHDXDFHDVWăIUHFYHQĠăGHDSDULĠLHvQQXPăU
1XPHUH 1XPHUH
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL ([HPSOX
x dQd 3(#6&$ 3(#6&'(!J
x &LIUHOHDYkQGIUHFYHQĠDPD[LPăVHYRUGHVSăUĠLSULQFkWHRYLUJXOă |JJ|JJ|J|J %QJ
JJJ %QJ
J QJ
([HPSOX QJ
3(#5&$ 3(#5&'(!J
%Q
|J JJ
$úDSWHD]L
$úDVHD]L ÌQFHDGHDúDSWHD]LOXL$úFKLXĠăvLWUHFXSULQPLQWHFăDUILPDLLQWHUHVDQWGDFăQXPH
$úDVHD]LSLWLFXO$úFKLXĠăDXPEODWSULQWRWUHJDWXOSHQWUXDIDFHRVWDWLVWLFăSULYLQG UHOHFDVHORUDUILvQXUPăWRDUHDVXFFHVLXQH
QXPăUXOGHFDVHFDUHVXQWQXPHURWDWHFXQXPHUHvQDVSHFWGHXUFXúFRERUkúGHDOVDX «
YDOH 6ăVHJHQHUH]HQQXPHUHGHFDVHFRQIRUPUHJXOLLOXL$úFKLXĠă
6SXQHPFăXQQXPăUDUHDVSHFWGHGHDOGDFăFLIUHOHVDOHVHVXFFHGvQWkLFUHVFăWRUúL
DSRLGHVFUHVFăWRUúLFRQVLGHUăPXQQXPăUFDDYkQGDVSHFWGHYDOHGDFăFLIUHOHVDOHVH 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
VXFFHG vQWkL GHVFUHVFăWRU úL DSRL FUHVFăWRU ÌQWUXQ QXPăU FX DVSHFW GH XUFXú FLIUHOH ÌQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH3(#7&$DYHPVFULVXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQ
DSDUvQRUGLQHFUHVFăWRDUHLDUvQWUXQXOFXDVSHFWGHFRERUkúvQRUGLQHGHVFUHVFăWRDUH
6ăVHVFULHXQSURJUDPFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăVWDWLVWLFDGRULWăGH$úFKLXĠă 'DWHGHLHúLUH
1XPHUHOHJHQHUDWHGXSăUHJXODGHPDLVXVYRUILVFULVHvQILúLHUXO3(#7&'(!FkWHXQ
'DWHGHLQWUDUH QXPăUSHILHFDUHOLQLH
ÌQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH3(#6&$VHDIOăPDLPXOWHQXPHUHQDWXUDOH
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
'DWHGHLHúLUH x dQd
ÌQILúLHUXO3(#6&'(!VWDWLVWLFDUH]XOWDWăYDILDILúDWăDVWIHO
([HPSOX
x SH SULPD OLQLH VH YD VFULH FXYkQWXO % XUPDW GH FDUDFWHUXO Q DSRL GH 3(#7&$ 3(#7&'(!J
QXPăUXOGHQXPHUHDYkQGDVSHFWGHXUFXú |J JJ
x SHDGRXDOLQLHVHYDVFULHFXYkQWXO%XUPDWGHFDUDFWHUXOQDSRLGHQX JJ
PăUXOGHQXPHUHDYkQGDVSHFWGHFRERUkú JJ
x SHDWUHLDOLQLHVHYDVFULHFXYkQWXOXUPDWGHFDUDFWHUXOQDSRLGHQXPăUXO JJ
||J
GHQXPHUHDYkQGDVSHFWGHGHDO
x SHDSDWUDOLQLHVHYDVFULHFXYkQWXO XUPDWGHFDUDFWHUXO QDSRLGHQXPă
UXOGHQXPHUHDYkQGDVSHFWGHYDOH 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
x GDFăvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHH[LVWăQXPHUHFDUHQXVHvQFDGUHD]ăvQQLFLXQDGLQWUHFH
OHSDWUXJUXSHSHDFLQFHDOLQLHVHYDVFULHFXYkQWXO%XUPDWGHFDUDFWHUXO 3ULPD]L
QDSRLGHQXPăUXOGHQXPHUHFRUHVSXQ]ăWRU )LHGHH[HPSOXQXPăUXOÌQWDEHOXOXUPăWRUFRORDQDQUFRQĠLQHYDORDUHDFX
UHQWăDQXPăUXOXLFDUHVHSUHOXFUHD]ăFRORDQDFLIUDUHĠLQHYDORDUHDFLIUHLDQDOL]DWHLDU
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL SXWHUH UHSUH]LQWă YDORDUHD SXWHULL OXL vQ SURFHVXO GH FRQVWUXLUH D UH]XOWDWXOXL ÌQ
x dQXPăUFLWLWd DFHDVWăSUREOHPăQXYRPDSOLFDVFKHPDOXL+RUQHUGHRDUHFHDSOLFDUHDHLDUFRQGXFH
ODXQQXPăUvQFDUHFLIUHOHDUILDúH]DWHvQRUGLQHLQYHUVă9DORDUHDYDULDELOHLSXWHUHQH
YDDMXWDFDvQPXOĠLQGQXPăUXOFXSXWHUHDOXLFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHVăDúH]ăPFLIUDH[DFW
SHSR]LĠLDDYkQGUDQJXOGRULW
1XPHUH 1XPHUH
QU FLIUD SXWHUH UH]XOWDW 5H]XOWDWXOREĠLQXWHVWHUHSUH]HQWkQGQXPăUXOFLIUHORUHJDOHFXvQWRWDOvQQXPă
UXO
#JQJ
JJ%JmJ`J
JJ
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ă,J
JJJJ
ú
J
J
JJJJ
J
JzJ`J
ă,J
JJJJJJ%
JmJ
` ^UHĠLQHPXOWLPDFLIUăGLQQXPăUXOGDW`
JJJJJJ
JmJ
`J ^ÄWăLHP´XOWLPDFLIUăGLQQXPăUXOGDW`J
JJJJJJăJ%
J\JJJ ^GDFăFLIUDHVWHRQXPăUăP`
9RPGHVFULHDOJRULWPXOFRQIRUPFăUXLDDPFRPSOHWDWWDEHOXOGHYDULDĠLH JJJJJJJJ%JmJ%J~JJ
JJJJJJ úă
#JQJ JJJJ ú
J
ú
J
J ú
JJJmJ`JJ^UH]XOWDWXOYDILXQQXPăUQRXFDUHVHFDOFXOHD]ăFDVXPăGH`
%
^WHUPHQLHOHPHQWQHXWUX`J ú
JJJmJJ^SXWHULOHOXLVHREĠLQvQXUPDXQRUvQPXOĠLULHOHPHQWQHXWUX`J
$WUHLD]L
JJ
J
JzJ`J
ă,J
JJJJ%
JmJ
` ^UHĠLQHPXOWLPDFLIUăGLQQXPăUXOGDW`
9RPFRQVLGHUDXQH[HPSOXSHFDUHYRPDQDOL]DSDúLLDOJRULWPXOXLGHUH]ROYDUH9UHP
JJJJ
JmJ
` ^WăLHPXOWLPDFLIUăGLQQXPăUXOGDW`J
VăURWLPQXPăUXOFXSR]LĠLLVSUHGUHDSWD2EVHUYăPFăQXPăUXOYDILURWLW
JJJJăJ%
JzJJJ^GDFăFLIUDUHĠLQXWăQXHVWHRDGăXJăPODUH]XOWDW`
RGDWăFRPSOHWúLFXvQFăWUHLSR]LĠLL
JJJJJJJmJJ~J%
J
3HQWUXILHFDUHQXPăUFLWLWWUHEXLHVă
JJJJJJJmJ`J ^SUHJăWLPSSHQWUXSDVXOXUPăWRU` x QXPăUăPFkWHFLIUHDUHQXPăUXOvQH[HPSOXFLIUH
JJJJ úă
JJ ú
x GHWHUPLQăPQXPăUXOGHURWDĠLLFDUHÄPHULWă´HIHFWXDWHREVHUYăPFăURWDĠLLOHFRP
SOHWHQXPRGLILFăFRQILJXUDĠLDFLIUHORUQXPHUHORUvQIXQFĠLHGHUHODĠLDGLQWUHQQX
ú PăUXO URWDĠLLORU úL QXPăUXO FLIUHORU QXPăUXOXL FDOFXOăP QXPăUXO GH URWDĠLL DVWIHO
vQFkWVăILHPDLPLFGHFkWQXPăUXOGHFLIUHDOHQXPăUXOXLREVHUYăPFăQXPăUBUR
WDĠLLBGHBHIHFWXDWHVWHUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLOXLQODQXPăUXOGHFLIUH
$GRXD]L x H[WUDJHPÄvQEORF´XOWLPHOHQXPăUBURWDĠLLBGHBHIHFWXDWFLIUHvQH[HPSOXH[WUDJHP
3HQWUXH[HPSOLILFDUHYRPFRQVLGHUDXQVLQJXUQXPăUúLYRPUHĠLQHDFĠLXQLOHFDUHWUH GHFLUHĠLQHPQXPăUXO
EXLHUHDOL]DWHDVXSUDQXPHUHORUSHQWUXDQXPăUDFLIUHOHHJDOHFXvQWRDWHQXPHUHOH
x FDOFXOăPODSXWHUHDQXPăUXOBFLIUHORU±QXPăUBURWDĠLLBGHBHIHFWXDWSHQWUXDGH
FLWLWH
SODVD FLIUHOH GH URWLW vQ IDĠD QXPăUXOXL SXWHUHD OXL GH FDUH DYHP QHYRLH vQ
QXPăU FLIUă FRQWRU H[HPSOXOQRVWUXHVWH
x FDOFXOăPVXPDGLQWUHQXPăUXOUăPDVúLFLIUHOHH[WUDVHvQPXOĠLWHFXSXWHUHDOXL
SUHJăWLWăSHQWUXH[HPSOXOQRVWUXUH]XOWDWXOHVWH
3UH]HQWăPDOJRULWPXOGHVFULVPDLVXVvQSVHXGRFRG
J
#JQJJJ
JJ
ú
J?JJ ^QXPăUXOURWDĠLLORUFHUXWHLQLĠLDO`J
1XPHUH 1XPHUH
JJ
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ă,J FLIHVWHFLIUDFXUHQWă
JJJJ
ú
J
J ^QXPăUXOFXUHQWvQFDUHYRPURWLFLIUHOH`J QRXOQHVWHQRXOQXPăUIRUPDW
JJJJ
%
JmJ`J ^QXPăUXOFLIUHORUvQQXPăUXOFXUHQWvQFDUHYRPURWLFLIUHOH`J FPD[HVWHFLIUDPD[LPăDQXPăUXOXL
JJJJJmJ
JJ ^FRSLHDOXLQGHRDUHFHXUPHD]ăVăOPRGLILFăP`J SHVWHRSXWHUHDOXLFDUHQHDMXWăvQIRUPDUHDQXPăUXOXLQRX
^SHGHDOWăSDUWHPDLDYHPQHYRLHGHYDORDUHDOXLQ`J
JJJJ
JJzJ`J
ă,JJ ^QXPăUăPFkWHFLIUHDUHQXPăUXO`J Q P FLI QRXOQ FPD[ S ([SOLFDĠLL
JJJJJJ
%
JmJ
%
J~JJ
FDOFXOFLIUăPD[LPă
JJJJJJJmJ`JJ ^FkWXOvPSăUĠLULLvQWUHJLDOXLQOD`J
ú
J J??JmJ?
%
JJ ^QXPăUXOURWDĠLLORUFDUHWUHEXLHHIHFWXDWH`JJ
J J J ^GHNRULJLQDOPDLDYHPQHYRLH`J
JJJJJmJJ ^H[WUDJHPvQEORFXOWLPHOHNFLIUH`
JJJJ
J\??J
ă,J
JJJJJJJmJ`J ^FDOFXOăPDNNDSXWHUHDOXL`
ú
±
JJJJJmJ
J ±
JJJJ
JmJ
±
^FHHDFHDUăPDVGLQQXPăUGXSăFHVHFYHQĠDÄGHPXWDW´DIRVWH[WUDVă`J ±
JJJJJmJJ ^FDOFXOăPSXWHUHDOXL` ±
JJJJ
J\
%
??J
ă,J ±
JJJJJJJmJ`J
ú
FDOFXOFLIUăPD[LPă
JJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ ^FRQVWUXLPUH]XOWDWXOvQQ`
JJJJ
J
J
ú
ú
$SDWUD]L
3HQWUXDGHWHUPLQDDOJRULWPXOGHUH]ROYDUHYRPFRQVLGHUDXQH[HPSOX9RPFRPSOH «
PHQWD FLIUHOH QXPăUXOXL IDĠă GH FLIUD PD[LPă $VXSUD UH]XOWDWXOXL DSOLFăP
DFHHDúLSUHOXFUDUHOXkQGvQFRQVLGHUDUHFLIUDPD[LPăDQXPăUXOXLREĠLQXWODSDVXOSUH
6HREVHUYăFăODILHFDUHFRPSOHPHQWDUHDPSDUFXUVFLIUHOHXQXLQXPăUGHGRXăRUL
FHGHQW
1HSXQHPSUREOHPDGHDIDFHRVLQJXUăSDUFXUJHUHÌQFHUFăPGHFLVăGHWHUPLQăPFLIUD
3HQWUXILHFDUHYDORDUHQRXăYRPHIHFWXDXUPăWRDUHOHRSHUDĠLL
PD[LPăvQFLFOXOGHFRPSOHPHQWDUHDQXPăUXOXL,QFRQYHQLHQWXOFDUHDSDUHvQDFHDVWă
x GHWHUPLQăPFLIUDGHYDORDUHPD[LPăGLQWUHFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXL VLWXDĠLHHVWHFăODSULPXOSDVQXDYHPQLFLRFLIUăFXFDUHVăSXWHPLQLĠLDOL]DYDULDELOD
x FRPSOHPHQWăPFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLIDĠăGHDFHDVWăFLIUă FDUHSăVWUHD]ăFLIUDPD[LPă'HFLILHGHWHUPLQăPSULPDFLIUăDQWHULRUGHVFRPSXQHULL
QXPăUXOXLvQFLIUHILHLQLĠLDOL]ăPYDULDELODFXFHDPDLPLFăFLIUă
ÌQDOJRULWPXOSURSXVYRPOXFUDFXXUPăWRDUHOHYDULDELOHDYkQGVHPQLILFDĠLLOHSUH 9RPIRORVLGRXăFRSLLDOHOXLQYHUVLXQHDPDLYHFKHDOXLQúLYHUVLXQHDDQWHULRDUă
FL]DWH D DFHVWXLD FDUH DMXWă OD GHSLVWDUHD VLWXDĠLHL vQ FDUH WUDQVIRUPDUHD WRWDOă D QXPăUXOXL
QHVWHQXPăUXOQDWXUDOGDW HVWHLPSRVLELOăGHRDUHFHVDUDMXQJHvQWUXQFLFOXLQILQLW'HH[HPSOXGDFăWUDQVIRU
PHVWHRYDULDELOăDX[LOLDUăvQFDUHYRPFRSLDYDORDUHDOXLQ PăPODSULPXOSDVVHREĠLQHLDUODDOGRLOHDGLQQRX
1XPHUH 1XPHUH
#JQJJJ $FLQFHD]L
JJ
ú
J
J
9RP FăXWD Vă GHVFRSHULP DOJRULWPXO GH UH]ROYDUH SRUQLQG GH OD XQ H[HPSOX Vă VH
JJ
JmJ`J
GHWHUPLQHFLIUHOHFXQXPăUPD[LPGHDSDULĠLLvQQXPăUXOÌQUHSUH]HQWDUHD
JJJmJIDOVJ
DOJRULWPXOXLYRPIRORVLXUPăWRDUHOHQRWDĠLL
JJ%JmJ`J ^YDORDUHLQLĠLDOăSHQWUXFLIUDGHYDORDUHPD[LPă`
QUHVWHQXPăUXOGDW
JJJmJ
J ^PHVWHFRSLDOXLQGHQPDLDYHPQHYRLH`
JJ
JJzJ`J
ă,J ^VWDELOLPFLIUDGHYDORDUHPD[LPă` FRSLHYDSăVWUDYDORDUHDQXPăUXOXLSHQWUXDOSXWHDVWXGLDvQFD]XOILHFăUHLFLIUHFLI
JJJJ%
JmJ`J ^FLIUDFXUHQWă` FLIYDILFLIUDDFăUHLIUHFYHQĠăGRULPVăRGHWHUPLQăP
JJJJăJ%
J
J%JJJ FLIFXUHQWăUHSUH]LQWăFLIUDGLQQUFXFDUHYRPFRPSDUDFLIUDFLI
JJJJJJ%JmJ%
JJ ^DFWXDOL]DUHDFLIUHLPD[LPH` DSDUFXUHQWUHSUH]LQWăQXPăUXOGHDSDULĠLLDOHFLIUHLFLIvQQU
úă DSDUPD[UHSUH]LQWăQXPăUXOPD[LPGHDSDULĠLL
JJJJJmJ`J
ú
$QDOL]kQG SRVLELOLWăĠLOH GH D QXPăUD DSDULĠLLOH XQHL FLIUH REVHUYăP Fă DWkWD WLPS
JJ
J
JJúJJ
ă,J ^FRPSOHPHQWDUH` FkWQXPăUXOPDLDUHFLIUHYDWUHEXLVăGHVSULQGHPGLQQXPăUXOWLPDFLIUăúLYDWUHEXL
JJJJJmJ
J Vă R FRPSDUăP FX YDORDUHD FLIUHL FLI JHQHUDWă FX
'DFă FHOH GRXă FRLQFLG
JJJJJmJJ PăULPFRQWRUXODSDUFXUHQW$VWIHOSDUFXUJkQGFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLSXWHPFRQWRUL]DILH
JJJJ%&JmJ
J ^ÄYHFKH´HVWHYHUVLXQHDPDLYHFKHDOXLQ` FDUHFLIUăvQWUHúL'HDVHPHQHDVHSRDWHDFWXDOL]DúLYDORDUHDFRQWRUXOXLPD[LP
JJJJ
JmJ
J ^ÄDQWHULRU´HVWHYHUVLXQHDDQWHULRDUăDOXLQ`J DSDUPD['DUQHL]ELPGHXUPăWRDUHDSUREOHPăvQHQXQĠQLVHFHUHVăVFULHPvQIL
JJJJ
JmJ`J ^QXPăUQRX`J úLHUWRDWHFLIUHOHDYkQGIUHFYHQĠDGHDSDULĠLHPD[LPă'HFLVăSUHVXSXQHPFăDPJăVLW
JJJJ
%JmJ`J GHMDvQQUGRLGHGDUQXúWLPGDFăWUHEXLHVăVFULHPDFHDVWăYDORDUHvQILúLHUVDXQX
JJJJ
JJzJ`J
ă,J GHRDUHFH QX úWLP GDFă GH H[HPSOX GLQ FLIUD YRP JăVL PDL PXOWH DSDULĠLL VDX QX
JJJJJJ%
JmJ%JJ` ^FRPSOHPHQWăPXOWLPDFLIUăGLQQXPăU` 6ROXĠLDHVWHVLPSOăYRPVFULHvQILúLHUYDORDUHDSUHVXSXVăPD[LPăúLFLIUD'DFă
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J~J%
J ^FRQVWUXLPQXPăUXO` FLIUDDSDUHRVLQJXUăGDWăQXPRGLILFăPQLPLF'DFăQXPăUXOHLGHDSDULĠLHHVWHHJDO
JJJJJJJmJ`J FX GHVFKLGHP ILúLHUXO SHQWUX DGăXJDUH úL vO VFULHP úL SH 'DFă vQVă QXPăUXO GH
JJJJJJJmJ`J ^XUPăWRDUHDSXWHUHDOXL` DSDULĠLH HVWH PDL PDUH GHFkW GHVFKLGHP ILúLHUXO SHQWUX VFULHUH vQ 3DVFDO FX
JJJJJJăJ%
J
J
%JJJ DVWIHODQXOkQGFRQĠLQXWXOOXLYHFKLúLVFULHPQXPăUXOPD[LPGHDSDULĠLLvP
J J JJJ
%JmJ%
J ^DFWXDOL]DUHDFLIUHLPD[LPHSHQWUXSDVXOXUPăWRU`J SUHXQăFXFLIUDFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH
úă
ú
#J|QJ
JJJJ%JmJ
%J JJ
ú
J
JJ ^QXPăUXOGDW`J
JJJJăJ
J\J%&JJ JJ%JmJ
J ^FRSLHDOXLQU`
JJJJJJJmJDGHYăUDWJ ^DPLQWUDWvQFLFOXLQILQLW` JJJmJ` ^LQLĠLDOL]ăPIUHFYHQĠDGHDSDULĠLHPD[LPă`
JJ
J%
\`J
ă,J ^JHQHUăPFLIUHOHSRVLELOHvQFLI`
JJJJJJJmJIDOV JJJJ%
JmJ`J ^LQLĠLDOL]ăPIUHFYHQĠDFLIUHLFLI`
ú
JJJJ
J
JzJ`J
ă,J ^FkWWLPSvQQUPDLDYHPFLIUH`
JJăJJJ
JJJJ
JJ JJJJJJ%
%
ăJmJ
` ^XOWLPDFLIUăGLQQU`
JJ
JJ JJJJJJ
JmJ
` ^RWăLHPGLQQU`
JJJJ
J
J JJJJJJăJ%
%
ăJ\J%
J
% ^GDFăFLIUDFXUHQWăHVWHHJDOăFXFLI`
úă JJJJJJJJ%
JmJ%
J~J ^FUHúWHPIUHFYHQĠDFLIUHLFLI`
ú JJJJJJ úă
JJJJ ú
^DPSDUFXUVFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLQU`
1XPHUH 1XPHUH
JJJJăJJJ%
JJJ ^GDFăDYHPXQPD[LPQRX` JJ
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ă,J
JJJJ
ú
J
J J
JJJJJJJmJ%
J ^DFWXDOL]ăPPD[LPXO`J
J J J ^FkWWLPSXOWLPHOHGRXăFLIUHVXQWLGHQWLFHHOLPLQăPXOWLPDFLIUă`
JJJJJJGHVFKLGHPILúLHUXOGDFăDDYXWFRQĠLQXWXQPD[LPPDLPLFDFHVWDVHSLHUGH JJJJ
J
J
JJúJ
`J\J
``J
ă,J
JJJJJJ
JJ%
J ^VFULHPPD[LPXOúLFLIUDFLI` JJJJJJ
JmJ
`J
JJJJ
J JJJJ ú
JJJJJJăJJ\J%
JJJ ^DYHPRIUHFYHQĠăHJDOăFX`
JJJJ?JmJ`J ^QXPăUXOVFKLPEăULORUGHGLUHFĠLH`
^DSDUPD[FDUHGHMDHVWHVFULVvQILúLHUvPSUHXQăFXRYDORDUHFLI` JJJJJmJ`J ^GLUHFĠLD`J
JJJJJJJJGHVFKLGHPILúLHUXOSHQWUXDGăXJDUH
JJJJăJ
J
JJ^GDFăQXPăUXOUăPDVHVWHIRUPDWPăFDUGLQGRXăFLIUH`J
JJJJJJJJ
J%
^VFULHPFLIUDFLIDYkQGDFHHDúLIUHFYHQĠă`
JJJJJJăJ
`J
``JJ ^LQLĠLDOL]ăPGLUHFĠLD`J
JJJJJJ úă
JJJJ úă JJJJJJJJJmJ
JJJJ
JmJ%J ^UHIDFHPQUSHQWUXDSXWHDFăXWDvQHOXUPăWRDUHDFLIUăFLI` JJJJJJ
JJ ^QXSRWILHJDOHGHRDUHFHDPHOLPLQDWFLIUHOHHJDOHGHODvQFHSXW`
JJ ú
JJJJJJJJJmJJ
ú JJJJJJ úăJ
JJJJJJ
JmJ
` ^UHQXQĠăPODXOWLPDFLIUă`
JJJJJJ
J
J
JJ
ă,J ^FkWWLPSPDLH[LVWăFHOSXĠLQFLIUHvQQ`
$úDVHD]L ^GDFăGLUHFĠLDFXUHQWăúLGLIHUHQĠDXOWLPHORUGRXăFLIUHQXDXDFHODúLVHPQ`
,GHHDGHUH]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHHVWHGHDQXPăUDQXPăUXOVFKLPEăULORUvQVHQVXO JJJJJJJJăJJJ`JúJ
`J
J
``J J
RUGRQăULLúLUXOXLFLIUHORUQXPăUXOXL JJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
J`JúJ
`JJ
``JJJ
9RPSăVWUDvQWURYDULDELOăGGLUHFĠLDLQLĠLDOăFUHVFFLIUHOHVDXGHVFUHVF"DRUGRQă JJJJJJJJJJ?JmJ?J~JJ ^VFKLPEDUHGHGLUHFĠLH`
ULLFLIUHORUQXPăUXOXL'HRDUHFHQHHVWHPDLXúRUVăDQDOL]ăPXOWLPDFLIUăGLQQXPăU JJJJJJJJJJJmJJ
DFHDVWăGLUHFĠLHYDILFDOFXODWăGLQGLIHUHQĠDGLQWUHXOWLPDúLSHQXOWLPDFLIUăDQXPăUX JJJJJJJJ úă
OXLGDW'HFLGVHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăFX
`JJ
`` JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
`J
ÌQFRQWLQXDUHQHYDLQWHUHVDGRDUVHPQXOVDX±DOYDULDELOHLG JJJJJJ ú
JJ
x 'DFă vQ ILQDO QXPăUXO VFKLPEăULORU GLUHFĠLHL HVWH HJDO FX úL GDFă G ! DWXQFL JJJJ úăJJ
DYHPXQQXPăUFXDVSHFWGHXUFXúH[HPSOXQ G ± !LDUGDFă JJJJăJ?J\J`JJ
GDWXQFLDYHPFRERUkúH[HPSOXQ G ± ± JJJJJJăJJ\J`JJ
%JmJ
%J~JJ ^N G `J
JJJJJJ
JJ
x 'DFăG FLIUHOHVXQWLGHQWLFHGHFLWUHEXLHVăFDOFXOăPGSHED]DSULPHORUFLIUH
JJJJJJJJăJ
J`J
%JmJ
%J~J ^N G!`J
GLVWLQFWHDOHQXPăUXOXL
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
%JmJ
%J~J ^N G`J
x 'DFăQXPăUXOVFKLPEăULORUGLUHFĠLHLHVWHHJDOFXúLG!DWXQFLDYHPXQQXPăU JJJJJJJJ úă
FXDVSHFWGHYDOHH[HPSOXQ ± !LDUGDFăGDWXQFLDYHP úă
XQGHDOH[HPSOXQ ± ± JJJJ
J
x 1XPHUHOHFDUHQXLQWUăvQQLFLXQDGLQWUHDFHVWHFDWHJRULLVXQWFRQVLGHUDWHRDUHFDUH JJJJJJăJ?J\JJJ
GHH[HPSOX JJJJJJJJăJJJ`J
JmJ
J~JJ ^N G`
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
J
JmJ
J~JJ ^N G!`
#JQJJJ JJJJJJJJ úăJJ
JJ
%JmJ`J JJJJJJ
J
JJ
%JmJ`J JJJJJJJJăJ?J
JJJ
%JmJ
%J~JJ ^N!`
JJ
JmJ`J JJJJJJJJ úă
JJ
JmJ`J úă
úă
JJ
%JmJ`J ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDFRQWRDUHORU` ú
1XPHUH 1XPHUH
JJ
J%Q
%J ^DILúDUH` #JQJ
JJ
J%Q
%J JJ
ú
J
J
JJ
JQ
J JJ
JmJJ
JJ
JQ
J JJ
ăJmJJ
JJ
J%Q
%J JJ
J\
J
ă,J
ú JJJJ
J
ăJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ^SUHJăWLPYDORDUHDYDULDELOHL
SHQWUXSDVXOXUPăWRU`
$úDSWHD]L JJJJ
ăJmJ
ăJ~J
J
JJJJăJ
ă`J\J`JJ
(QXQĠXO SUREOHPHL QH FHUH Vă JHQHUăP SULPLL Q WHUPHQL DL úLUXOXL
J J J ^GDFăDYHPFD]XO VDX `
««
JJJJJJ
ăJmJ
ăJ~JJ ^ `J
6ăDQDOL]ăPFkWHYDPRGDOLWăĠLGHDERUGDUHDSUREOHPHL3ULPLLGRLDOJRULWPLSRWIL JJJJJJ
JmJ
`J~JJ
JJJJ úă
XWLOL]DĠL SHQWUX Q d FD] vQ FDUH XOWLPXO WHUPHQ vQ úLU HVWH QXPăUXO IRUPDW GLQ ú
FLIUHHJDOHFX ú
x 2LGHHDUILVăIRUPăPQXPHUHOHGLQFLIUHGLQúLGLQúL
J x 'DFăVHGRUHúWHUH]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHSHQWUXQ!YRPVFULHvQILúLHUSXU
#JQJ
JJ
ú
J
J
úL VLPSOX FLIUH DOăWXUDWH 1XPăUXO FLIUHORU GLQWUXQ QXPăU VH JHQHUHD]ă FRQIRUP
UHJXOLLJHQHUăULLQXPHUHORUGLQúLU
JJ%
JmJJ
JJ
%
JmJJ #JQJ
JJ
J\
J
ă,JJ ^VHIRUPHD]ăQQXPHUHGLQQUBFLIUHHJDOHFXFLI` JJ
ú
J
JJ
JJJJ
ăJmJ%
J JJ
JmJJJ ^OXQJLPHDLQLĠLDOăDQXPHUHORU`J
JJJJ
J\
%
J
ă,J
JJ%JmJJJJJJJ ^SULPDFLIUăHVWH`
JJJJJJ
ăJmJ
ă`J~J%
J
JJ
J\
J
ăQJJ ^JHQHUăPQWHUPLQLvQúLU`J
JJJJ ú
JJJJ
J
ăJ JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ ^WLSăULUHDHOHPHQWXOXLFXUHQWGLQúLU`
JJJJJJ
J%J
JJJJăJ%
JJJ ^SUHJăWLPFLIUDúLQUBFLIUHSHQWUXSDVXOXUPăWRU`JJ JJJJ ú
JJJJJJ%
JmJ%
J~JJ JJJJăJ%J\JJJJ J
JJJJ
JJ
JJJJJJJ%JmJJJ ^XUPHD]ăGLQQRXXQQXPăUIRUPDWGLQFLIUHHJDOHFX`
JJJJJJ%
JmJJ
JJJJJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ ^FUHúWHQXPăUXOGHFLIUHvQQXPăU`J
JJJJJJ
%
JmJ
%
J~JJ JJJJ
J
JJJJ úă
JJ ú
JJJJJJ%JmJ%J~JJ ^XUPăWRDUHDFLIUă`J
JJJJ úă
ú
JJ ú
ú
x 2DOWăLGHHPDLVLPSOăHVWHGHDDGXQDODILHFDUHQXPăUIRUPDWGLQGRXăFLIUHYD
ORDUHDODILHFDUHQXPăUIRUPDWGLQWUHLFLIUHYDORDUHDúLDúDPDLGHSDUWHÌQ
DFHVWFD]úLUXODUSXWHDILSULYLWDVWIHO «
9DULDELODGHBDGXQDWYDDYHDVXFFHVLYYDORDUHDDSRLúLDúDPDLGHSDUWH
J
J
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
([LVWăPXOWHPRWLYHSHQWUXFDUHFHUFXOUHSUH]LQWăRLPDJLQHPDLDGHFYDWăXQXLQX
PăUFDUHVHGLYL]HD]ăvQSăUĠLÌQDFHVWFD]QXPăUXOVDUSXWHDUHSUH]HQWDDVWIHO
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH &DSLWROXO
1XPHUHSHUIHFWH
1XPHUHSULHWHQH
1XPHUHWULDQJXODUH
1XPHUHSăWUDWLFH
1XPHUHSLUDPLGDOH
1XPHUHSLWDJRUHLFH
8QLWDWHDGLQQXPăUXOVHUHJăVHúWHGHDVHPHQHDFDXQLWDWHvQQXPHUHOHGRLúLWUHL
1XPHUHSULPH GLYL]RULDLOXLSHFkQGXQLWDWHDGLQVHUHJăVHúWHGRDUSHQWUXVLQHvQVXúLFăFLFLQFL
1XPHUH)LERQDFFL QXHVWHPXOWLSOXOQLFLXQXLDGLQWUHQXPHUHOHFDUHvOSUHFHG
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
'DFă vO SULYLP DúD FLQFL SRDWH IL QXPLW ÄSULPXO QXPăU´ QXPăU SULP FXP vO QX
PLPQRL$FHHDúLGHQXPLUHOHHVWHDSRLDWULEXLWăúLFHORUODOWHQXPHUHFDUHQXDXDOĠLGL
ÌQDQWLFKLWDWHQXPHUHOHHUDXDSUHFLDWHvQSULPXOUkQGSHQWUXFDOLWăĠLOHORUúLDELDGXSă
DFHHDSHQWUXFDQWLWDWHDSHFDUHRUHSUH]LQWă$VWIHOILHFDUHQXPăUDIRVWSULYLWFDRLQ YL]RULGHFkWSHúLSHHLvQúLúL
GLYLGXDOLWDWH GLVWLQFWă 5XGROI 6WHLQHU QH H[SOLFă WHRULD FRQIRUP FăUHLD XQ QXPăU VH $QDOL]kQGQXPăUXOREVHUYăPFăDGXQkQGGLYL]RULLVăLQXPHUHOHúLDMXQ
SRDWHREĠLQHGLQvQWUHJSULQWUXQSURFHVGHvPSăUĠLUHGLYL]LXQHDVHPăQăWRUSURFHVHORU JHPGLQQRXODQXPăUXO
QDWXUDOH GH GLYL]LXQH FHOXODUă &HOăODOW SURFHGHX GH REĠLQHUH D XQXL QXPăU DU IL SULQ
DGXQDUH&HOHGRXăSURFHGHHVHSRWSUH]HQWDFRPSDUDWLYDVWIHO
2SHUDĠLHGHvPSăUĠLUH2SHUDĠLHGHDGXQDUH
1XPHUHSHUIHFWH
9HFKLLJUHFLDYHDXXQUHVSHFWGHRVHELWSHQWUXDFHVWHQXPHUHúLOHQXPHDXÄDULWKPRV
WHOHLRV´DGLFăÄQXPăUXOOLPLWDWODHOvQVXúL´vQWUDGXFHUHDDFWXDOăQXPăUSHUIHFW
6HVSXQHFă(XFOLGDUILDUăWDWFăGDFăQ ±HVWHQXPăUSULPDWXQFLQ±Q±
HVWHQXPăUSHUIHFW3kQăvQSUH]HQWQXVDJăVLWQLFLXQQXPăUSHUIHFWFDUHVăQXYHULIL
FHFRQGLĠLDOXL(XFOLG
8QLWDWHD VH FRQVLGHUD PDPD WXWXURU QXPHUHORU ILLQG VXSHULRDUă RULFăUXL QXPăU Q Q± 3ULPDOLWDWH Q±Q± 6XPDGLYL]RULORU
1XPHUHOHVHFDUDFWHUL]DXSULQGHSHQGHQĠDORUIDĠăGHDOWHQXPHUHFXFDUHIRUPHD]ăR
± SULP
vQOăQĠXLUH'HH[HPSOXQXPăUXOVDUSXWHDUHSUH]HQWDDVWIHO
± SULP
± QX
± SULP
± QX
± SULP
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
3ULPDSHUHFKHGHQXPHUHSULHWHQHHVWHFX6XPDGLYL]RULORUOXLHVWH
$OWHSURSULHWăĠLDOHQXPHUHORUSHUIHFWH LDUVXPDGLYL]RULORUOXL
7RDWHQXPHUHOHSHUIHFWHVHWHUPLQăFXFLIUDVDXFXFLIUDGXSăFXPVHSRD HVWH
WHREVHUYDGLQWDEHOXOXUPăWRU 0DWHPDWLFLDQXODUDE7DELWLEQ.RUUDVHFROXO;DJăVLWXQDOJRULWPGHJHQHUDUHD
XQRUSHUHFKLGHQXPHUHSULHWHQH$FHVWDOJRULWPDIRVWSXEOLFDWIăUăGHPRQVWUDĠLHGH
Q Q± Q± Q±Q± FăWUH'HVFDUWHVvQDQXO
3UH]HQWăPvQFRQWLQXDUHDOJRULWPXOUHĠHWDOXL7DELWvQIRUPDvQFDUHVHFXQRúWHD
vQDFHOHYUHPXUL
3DVXO6HSOHDFăGHODQXPăUXO
3DVXO6HFRQVWUXLHúWHSULQGXEOăULVXFFHVLYHúLUXO
3DVXOÌQFRQWLQXDUHVHLDXSHUkQGGLQDFHVWúLUSHUHFKLVXFFHVLYH([HPSOXúL
úLúL«
3DVXO)LHFăUHLSHUHFKLGHQXPHUHLVHDGDXJăXQDOWUHLOHDQXPăUFDUHFRQĠLQHDPELL
PHPEULDLGXDOLWăĠLLDGLFăSURGXVXOORU6HREĠLQDVWIHO
«
3DVXO6HVFDGHGLQILHFDUHGLQFHOHWUHLQXPHUH6HREĠLQH
«
1XPHUHOHGHIRUPDQ±VHQXPHVFQXPHUH0HUVHQQH
3DVXO6HFRQVWUXLHúWHVHULDGXEOXULORUSHQWUXQXPăUXOFDUHVH
VFULHVXEQXPHUHOHREĠLQXWHODSDVXODQWHULRU
3ULPHOHSDWUXQXPHUHSHUIHFWHvQUHSUH]HQWDUHELQDUăVXQW
«
1XPHUHSHUIHFWH 5HSUH]HQWDUHELQDUă
3DVXOÌQFHSkQGFXDFHVWSDVQHLQWHUHVHD]ăQXPDLWULSOHWHOHGHQXPHUHSULPHÌQFD
]XOQRVWUXVHSăVWUHD]ă
'DFăIDFHPRFRPSDUDĠLHvQWUHXQQXPăUúLVXPDGLYL]RULORUVăLREVHUYăPFăDYHP
3DVXO/DDFHVWSDVVHvQPXOĠHVFFHOHGRXăQXPHUHDOHSHUHFKLLúLVHREĠLQH
WUHLVLWXDĠLL
x 'DFăVXPDGLYL]RULORUHVWHHJDOăFXQXPăUXOVSXQHPFăQXPăUXOHVWHSHUIHFW
x 'DFăVXPDGLYL]RULORUHVWHPDLPLFăGHFkWQXPăUXOVSXQHPFăQXPăUXOHVWHGHILFLHQW
3DVXO ÌQ ILQDO FHOH GRXă QXPHUH VFULVH GHDVXSUD PXOWLSOLORU OXL VH vQPXOĠHVF FX
x 'DFăVXPDGLYL]RULORUHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWQXPăUXOVSXQHPFăQXPăUXOHVWHERJDW PXOWLSOXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRU6HREĠLQDVWIHOSHUHFKLGHQXPHUHSULHWHQH
1XPHUHSULHWHQH
3HUHFKLOHGHQXPHUHFDUHVHÄDFRSHUă´UHFLSURFVHEXFXUDXGHXQPDUHLQWHUHVvQYH
2EVHUYDĠLH
FKHD*UHFLHúLHUDXQXPLWHÄSKLORLDULWKPRL´DGLFăQXPHUHSULHWHQHvQXQHOHVXUVHOH
$OJRULWPXO OXL 7DELW QX JHQHUHD]ă WRDWH SHUHFKLOH GH QXPHUH SULHWHQH (O D JăVLW
JăVLPFXQXPHOHGHQXPHUHDPLDELOH$LFLSULQÄDFRSHULUH´vQĠHOHJHPSURSULHWDWHDFă
GRDURUHJXOăGHDJHQHUDDQXPLWHQXPHUHSHUIHFWH
ILHFDUHGLQWUHFHOHGRXăQXPHUHDUHVXPDGLYL]RULORUHJDOăFXFHOăODOWQXPăU
ÌQFRQWLQXDUHSUH]HQWăPDOWHQXPHUHFăURUDDQWLFLLOHDFRUGDXRGHRVHELWăDWHQĠLH
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH 1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
1XPHUHWULDQJXODUH 1XPHUHSULPH
8Q QXPăU SULP DUH H[DFW GRL GLYL]RUL 5H]XOWă LPHGLDW Fă QX HVWH SULP úL VLQJXUXO
QXPăUSULPSDUHVWH9HULILFDUHDSULPDOLWăĠLLVHSRDWHUHDOL]DVLPSOXSRUQLQGGHOD
GHILQLĠLHGDUVHSRWVFULHúLDOJRULWPLPDLSHUIRUPDQĠLFDUHVHYRURSULLPHGLDWGXSăFH
VDJăVLWXQGLYL]RUSURSULX'HDVHPHQHDSXWHPHYLWDFăXWDUHDXQRUGLYL]RULFDUHVXQW
QXPHUH SDUH vQ FD]XO vQ FDUH QXPăUXO GDW HVWH LPSDU YH]L UH]ROYDUHD SUREOHPHL
*HQHUDUHDQXPHUHORUSULPHPDLPLFLGHFkWXQQXPăUGDWLDSUHRFXSDWúLSHPDWH
PDWLFLHQLLGLQ*UHFLDDQWLFă6WUDWHJLDOXL(UDWRVWHQHúLDVWă]LHVWHXQÄDOJRULWP´DSOL
FDW(ODVFULVSHXQSDSLUXVvQFHSkQGGHODXQúLUGHQXPHUHQDWXUDOHFRQVHFXWLYH
$SRLODPDUFDWSHFDILLQGSULPúLDWăLDWWRDWHQXPHUHOHGLYL]LELOHFX$SURFHGDW
8QQXPăU[VHQXPHúWHWULDQJXODUGDFăH[LVWăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQDVWIHOvQFkWVX ODIHOFX3HQXODPDLÄJăVLW´SULQWUHQXPHUHDFHVWDILLQGWăLDWGHFLDFRQWLQXDW
PDSULPHORUQQXPHUHQDWXUDOHHVWHHJDOăFXQXPăUXOGDW[ FXÌQILQDOSHSDSLUXVDXUăPDVQHWăLDWHGRDUQXPHUHOHSULPH
«Q QQ [
5HODĠLLvQWUHQXPHUHOHSHUIHFWHúLFHOHWULDQJXODUH 1XPHUH)LERQDFFL
ùLUXOQXPHUHORUFDUHSRDUWăQXPHOHFHOHEUXOXLPDWHPDWLFLDQ)LERQDFFLDUHIRDUWHPXO
'DFăVHSULYHúWHúLUXOQXPHUHORUWULDQJXODUHVHREVHUYă
WHSURSULHWăĠLLQWHUHVDQWH
FăvQúLUDSDUQXPHUHOHSHUIHFWHúL(VWHXúRUGHGHPRQVWUDWFăRULFHQXPăUSHUIHFW
HVWH WRWRGDWă úL QXPăU WULDQJXODU /ăVăP SH VHDPD FLWLWRULORU YHULILFDUHD DFHVWHL
*HQHUDUHDWHUPHQLORUPDLPLFLVDXHJDOLFXXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQ!GDWDLDFHVWXLúLU
REVHUYDĠLLĠLQkQGFRQWGHLSRWH]DFăRULFHQXPăUSHUIHFWDUHIRUPDQ±Q±
HVWHRSUREOHPăVLPSOăúLVHUHDOL]HD]ăFXXUPăWRUXODOJRULWP
#J
%%QJ
1XPHUHSăWUDWLFH JJ
ú
J
JJ ^YDORDUHDFHDPDLPDUHDXQXLWHUPHQ`J
8QQXPăU[VHQXPHúWHSăWUDWLFGDFăH[LVWăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQDVWIHOvQFkWQXPăUXO
GDW[VăILHHJDOFXVXPDSULPHORUQQXPHUHQDWXUDOHLPSDUH JJJmJJ ^SULPXOWHUPHQ`J
«Q± Q JJJmJJ ^DOGRLOHDWHUPHQ`J
JJ%JmJJ~JJ ^DOWUHLOHDWHUPHQ`J
^GHRDUHFHQ!SULPLLGRLVHSRWVFULH`J
1XPHUHSLUDPLGDOH
JJ
JJJ
JJ
%JdJ
J
ăQJJ ^FkWWLPSVXPDFHORUGRLWHUPHQLDQWHULRUL`J
8Q QXPăU VH QXPHúWH SLUDPLGDO GDFă SRDWH IL VFULV FD VXPă GH QXPHUH WULDQJXODUH JJJJ
J%J ^VDWLVIDFHFHULQĠDRVFULHP`J
FRQVHFXWLYH JJJJJmJJ ^QRXODYDILYHFKLXOE`J
JJJJJmJ%J ^QRXOEYDILYHFKLXOF`J
JJJJ%JmJJ~JJ ^FDOFXOăPQRXOWHUPHQ`J
ú
úJ
1XPHUHSLWDJRUHLFH 2SUREOHPăLQWHUHVDQWăFDUHVHSRDWHIRUPXODHVWHXUPăWRDUHDGDWILLQGXQQXPăU
5HODĠLDFDUDFWHULVWLFăODWXULORUXQXLWULXQJKLGUHSWXQJKLFFXQRVFXWăHPSLULFúLGHHJLS QDWXUDOVăVHVWDELOHDVFăGDFăDFHVWDHVWHVDXQXQXPăU)LERQDFFLúLvQFD]QHJDWLYVă
WHQLHVWH VHVFULHQXPăUXOVXEIRUPăGHVXPăGHQXPăUPLQLPGHQXPHUH)LERQDFFL
[\ ]
1XPHUHOHFDUHUHVSHFWăRDVWIHOGHUHODĠLHVHQXPHVFQXPHUHSLWDJRUHLFH
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH ,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3HQWUXDYăIDPLOLDUL]DFXPRGXOvQFDUHVHUH]ROYăSUREOHPHOHvQFDUHYHULILFDUHDGLYL
9RP JHQHUD FX DOJRULWPXO GH PDL VXV QXPHUH )LERQDFFL úL QH YRP RSUL vQ PR
]LELOLWăĠLLDUHUROLPSRUWDQWYăVXJHUăPVăvQFHUFDĠLVăLPSOHPHQWDĠLDOJRULWPLSHQWUX
PHQWXOvQFDUHXOWLPXOWHUPHQHVWHPDLPDUHVDXHJDOFXQXPăUXOGDW'DFăXOWLPDYD
QXPăUDUHDJHQHUDUHDGLYL]RULORUXQXLQXPăU
ORDUHDYDULDELOHLFHVWHQXPăU)LERQDFFLDOJRULWPXOVHWHUPLQăÌQFD]FRQWUDUDILúăP
GHVFRPSXQHUHDXQXLQXPăUvQIDFWRULSULPL
FHOPDLPDUHQXPăU)LERQDFFLPDLPLFVDXHJDOFXQXPăUXOGDWGLVSRQLELOvQYDULDEL
GHWHUPLQDUHDIDFWRUXOXLSULPDOXQXLQXPăUGDWFDUHHVWHODSXWHUHDFHDPDLPDUH
ODEúLVFăGHPGLQQXPăUXOGDWYDORDUHDDFHVWXLD'DFăEDIRVWHJDOFXQXPăUXOGDW
FHOPDLPDUHGLYL]RUFRPXQDGRXăQXPHUHvQWUHJL
DOJRULWPXOVHWHUPLQăvQFD]FRQWUDUUHOXăPDOJRULWPXOGHYHULILFDUH&kWWLPSQGLQ
FHOPDLPLFPXOWLSOXFRPXQDGRXăQXPHUHvQWUHJL
FDUH PHUHX VH VFDGH QXPăUXO )LERQDFFL E FDUH VH DILúHD]ă HVWH SR]LWLY GHWHUPLQăP
YHULILFDUHDSULPDOLWăĠLLXQXLQXPăU
FkWHXQQXPăU)LERQDFFLEPDLPLFVDXHJDOFXYDORDUHDDFWXDOăDOXLQSHFDUHRVFă
GHWHUPLQDUHDFHOXLPDLPLFQXPăUSULPPDLPDUHGHFkWXQQXPăUGDW
GHPGLQQúLRDILúăP GHWHUPLQDUHDFHOXLPDLPDUHQXPăUSULPPDLPLFGHFkWXQQXPăUGDW
GHWHUPLQDUHDSUHIL[HORUSULPHDOHXQXLQXPăU
#Jă
%%QJ
GHWHUPLQDUHDVXIL[HORUSULPHDOHXQXLQXPăU
JJ
ú
J
JJ ^YDORDUHDGDWă`
GHWHUPLQDUHDSULPHORUQQXPHUHSULPH
JJJmJJ
GHWHUPLQDUHDWXWXURUQXPHUHORUSULPHGLQWUXQLQWHUYDO
JJJmJJ
GHWHUPLQDUHDSULPHORUQQXPHUHSHUIHFWH
JJ%JmJJ~JJ GHWHUPLQDUHDSULPHORUQQXPHUHSHUIHFWHIRORVLQGLGHHDOXL(XFOLG
JJ
J%JJ
J
ăQJJ
GHWHUPLQDUHDSULPHORUQSHUHFKLGHQXPHUHSULHWHQH
JJJJJmJJ
JHQHUDUHDSHUHFKLORUGHQXPHUHSULHWHQHIRORVLQGDOJRULWPXOOXL7DELWLEQ.RUUD
JJJJJmJ%J
DILúDUHDQXPHUHORUWULDQJXODUHGLQWUXQúLUGHQXPHUHQDWXUDOH
JJJJ%JmJJ~JJ DILúDUHDQXPHUHORUWULDQJXODUHFDUHVXQWSăWUDWHSHUIHFWHúLVXQWPDLPLFLVDXHJDOH
ú
J ^DFXPEHVWHFHOPDLPDUHQXPăU)LERQDFFLdQ` FXXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQGDW
JJăJ%J\J
JJ DILúDUHDQXPHUHORUSăWUDWLFHGLQWUXQúLUGDWGHQXPHUHQDWXUDOH
JJJJ
JJ
%%J
JJ
J
DILúDUHDQXPHUHORUSăWUDWLFHFDUHVXQWSăWUDWHSHUIHFWHúLVXQWPDLPLFLVDXHJDOH
JJJJ
J
\J FXXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQGDW
JJJJ
JmJ
JJJ JHQHUDUHDSULPHORUQSHUHFKLGHQXPHUHSLWDJRUHLFH
JJJJ
J
J
J`J
ăQJJ ^FkWWLPSPDLDYHPUHVW` JHQHUDUHDWHUPHQLORUúLUXOXL)LERQDFFLPDLPLFLGHFkWXQQXPăUQDWXUDOGDW
JJJJJJ
JJ
J
J
ăQJJ JHQHUDUHDSULPLORUQWHUPHQLDLúLUXOXL)LERQDFFL
JJJJJJJJ%JmJJ VFULHUHDXQXLQXPăUQDWXUDOQVXEIRUPăGHVXPăGHQXPHUH)LERQDFFL
JJJJJJJJJmJJ
JJJJJJJJJmJ%JJJ
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
JJJJJJ ú
JJ ^DFXPEHVWHFHOPDLPDUHQXPăU)LERQDFFLdQ`J
JJJJJJ
J~J
JJJJJJ
JmJ
JJJ 'LYL]RUL
ú
6ă VH VFULH XQ SURJUDP FDUH GHWHUPLQă FHO PDL PLF QXPăU FDUH DUH H[DFW N GLYL]RUL
úăJ XQGHNHVWHXQQXPăUQDWXUDOGDWJ
ú
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
1XPăUXOQDWXUDONVHFLWHúWHGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH$(+#"&$
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH 1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
'DWHGHLHúLUH 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
3ULPXOQXPăUQDWXUDODYkQGH[DFWNGLYL]RULVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXO$(+#"&'(! x dRULFHQXPăUGDWd
x GXSăXOWLPXOQXPăUH[LVWHQWvQILúLHUXUPHD]ăLPHGLDWPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x dNd ([HPSOX
!"&$ !"&'(! " !&'(!
JJ||JJ`J J||JJ`J J
([HPSOX
$(+#"&$ $(+#"&'(!J
J $SOLFDĠLHODQXPHUHOHWULDQJXODUH
7LPSPD[LPGHH[HFXĠLHVHFXQGH 6HFRQVLGHUăúLUXOGHQXPHUH«
6ăVHFDOFXOH]HYDORDUHDFHOXLGHDONOHDHOHPHQWGLQúLUNQXPăUQDWXUDOGDWIăUă
1XPHUHSHUIHFWH VăVHJHQHUH]HúLUXOGHHOHPHQWH
6ăVHJHQHUH]HWRDWHQXPHUHOHSHUIHFWHSRVLELOHGHUHSUH]HQWDWFXXQQXPăUGHWLSvQ
WUHJSHGRXăFXYLQWH,PSOHPHQWDĠLDOJRULWPXOVXJHUDWGH(XFOLGSHQWUXREĠLQHUHDQX 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
PHUHORUSHUIHFWH 1XPăUXOQDWXUDONVHFLWHúWHGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH "&$
'DWHGHLHúLUH 'DWHGHLHúLUH
1XPHUHOHSHUIHFWHPDLPLFLGHFkWFHOPDLPDUHQXPăUvQWUHJSRVLELOGHUHSUH]HQWDWVH 9DORDUHD FRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH FHOXL GHDO NOHD HOHPHQW GLQ úLU VH YD VFULH vQ ILúLHUXO GH
YRUVFULHvQILúLHUXO"-!&'(! LHúLUH "&'(!
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
1XPHUHSULHWHQH x dNd
6ă VH JHQHUH]H SHUHFKL GH QXPHUH SULHWHQH SRVLELOH GH UHSUH]HQWDW FXQXPHUHGHWLS
vQWUHJSHGRXăFXYLQWH,PSOHPHQWDĠLDOJRULWPXOOXL7DELW ([HPSOX
"&$ "&'(!J
'DWHGHLHúLUH |
3HUHFKLOHGHQXPHUHSULHWHQHVHYRUVFULHSHFkWHROLQLHDILúLHUXOXL"!$&'(!
$OWHQXPHUHVSHFLDOH
1XPHUHWULDQJXODUH 1RWăPFX QNF N F^`QXPHUHOHQDWXUDOHIRUPDWHGLQFFLIUH
6HFRQVLGHUăPDLPXOWHQXPHUHQDWXUDOHVFULVHvQWUXQILúLHU6ăVHFRSLH]HvQWUXQDOW
ILúLHUWRDWHQXPHUHOHWULDQJXODUHúLvQWUXQDOWUHLOHDDFHOHDFDUHQXVXQWWULDQJXODUH LGHQWLFHúLHJDOHFXN1RWăPVXPDFLIUHORUVN FN6HúWLHFăH[LVWăPDLPXOWHQX
PHUHQUDVWIHOvQFkWVHSRDWHJăVLRYDORDUHFSHQWUXFDUH
'DWHGHLQWUDUH VNQU QNF N
1XPHUHOHQDWXUDOHVHYRUFLWLGHSHSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXL!"&$ 6ăVHVFULHXQSURJUDPFDUHGHWHUPLQăWRDWHSHUHFKLOHQUFDYkQGSURSULHWDWHDGH
VFULVă
'DWHGHLHúLUH
1XPHUHOHFLWLWHGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHFDUHVXQWWULDQJXODUHVHYRUVFULHSHSULPDOLQLHD 'DWHGHLHúLUH
ILúLHUXOXL !"&'(!GHVSăUĠLWHSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLXLDUFHOHFDUHQXVXQWWULDQJXODUHVH 3HILHFDUHOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLHúLUH$(+#"&'(!VHYRUVFULHGRXăQXPHUHQDWXUDOHVH
YRUVFULHSHSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXL" !&'(! SDUDWHSULQWUXQVSDĠLXUHSUH]HQWkQGQXPăUXOQUúLQXPăUXOFGHFLIUHLGHQWLFHSHQWUX
FDUHSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWăHVWHDGHYăUDWă
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
ÌQ FRQFOX]LH YRP FăXWD GLYL]RUL SkQă OD UăGăFLQD SăWUDWă D QXPăUXOXL GHRDUHFH
3ULP FKLDU GDFă H[LVWă GLYL]RUL PDL PDUL GHFkW DFHDVWă YDORDUH DFHúWLD VXQW HJDOL FX FkWXO
6WDELOLĠLGDFăXQQXPăUGDWHVWHSULPVDXQX vPSăUĠLULLvQWUHJLDLXQXLGLYL]RUPDLPLFGHFkWUăGăFLQDSăWUDWăÌQFRQFOX]LHSHQWUX
ILHFDUHGLYL]RUJăVLWPăULPFRQWRUXOGLYL]RULORUFXRGDWăSHQWUXGLYL]RUXO
'DWHGHLQWUDUH úLvQFăRGDWăSHQWUXGLYL]RUXO
6ăREVHUYăPFăGDFăQXPăUXOHVWHSă
ÌQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH"+&$HVWHVFULVXQVLQJXUQXPăUQDWXUDO WUDW SHUIHFW GLYL]RUXO HVWH HJDO FX GLYL]RUXO
GHFLvQFD]XO
QXPHUHORU FDUH VXQW SăWUDWH SHUIHFWH vQ ILQDO YRP PLFúRUD FX QXPăUXO GLYL]RULORU
'DWHGHLHúLUH FRQWRUL]DĠLJ
'DFăQXPăUXOFLWLWGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHHVWHSULPvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH"+&'(!VH
YDVFULHDOWIHOVHYDVFULH #Q
JJ
ú
J?J
([HPSOX JJ
JmJJ
"+&$J "+&'(!J JJ
ă
J J JJJJ
JmJ
J~JJJ ^GDFăN DWXQFLFHOPDLPLFQXPăUFXGLYL]RULHVWH`
^RULFHQXPăUDUHGRLGLYL]RULSURSULL`
JmJJJ
JJJJ
J\SDUWHvQWUHDJăGLQUăGăFLQDSăWUDWăDOXL
J
ăQJ
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVH JJJJJJăJ
J\J`JJJ
JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
J~JJJ ^QXPăUăPGLYL]RULLOXLQU`
JJJJJJ úă
'LYL]RUL JJJJ ú
J
3HQWUXDDQDOL]DPRGXOGHUH]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHYRPSURLHFWDDOJRULWPXOSHQ JJJJăJ
HVWHSăWUDWSHUIHFWJ
WUXXQH[HPSOX)LHN 9RPGHWHUPLQDGLYL]RULLQXPHUHORUQDWXUDOHvQFHSkQGFX JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
JJJ
úLWHUPLQkQGvQPRPHQWXOvQFDUHDPJăVLWSULPXOQXPăUFDUHDUHH[DFWNGLYL]RUL JJ
ăJ
J\J?JJ ^SkQăFkQGREĠLQHPNGLYL]RUL`
JJ
J
J
([HPSOX úJ
DUHGLYL]RULúL J
DUHGLYL]RUL
DUHGLYL]RULúLGHFLQHRSULP1XPăUXOFăXWDWHVWH 1XPHUHSHUIHFWH
ÌQHQXQĠXOSUREOHPHLQLVHFHUHVăJHQHUăPWRDWHQXPHUHOHSHUIHFWHPDLPLFLGHFkWXQ
$QDOL]kQGH[HPSOXOGDWDúDSDUHFăGLYL]RULLVXQWQXPHUHSULPHGDUWUHEXLHVăILP QXPăUGDWQ'XSăFXPVDVXJHUDWvQHQXQĠYRPIRORVLFRQGLĠLDQHFHVDUăHQXQĠDWăGH
DWHQĠL'HH[HPSOXQXPăUXODUHGHGLYL]RUL FăWUH(XFOLGSUH]HQWDWăDQWHULRU
GHFLSULQWUHGLYL]RULDYHPQXPHUHSULPHúLSXWHULDOHORUUHVSHF &RQGLĠLDVSXQHFăGDFăQXPăUXOP±HVWHSULPDWXQFLQXPăUXOP±P±HVWH
WLYSURGXVHGHGRXăVDXPDLPXOWHQXPHUHSULPH SHUIHFW
$VWIHOFHOPDLVLPSOXSURFHGHXHVWHGHDGDSHUkQGYDORULOXLPúLvQFD]XOvQFDUH
ÌQGHVFULHUHDXUPăWRUXOXLDOJRULWPQRWăPFXQUQXPăUXOQDWXUDOFXUHQWFXGLYL]RU QXPăUXOP±HVWHSULPGHDDILúDQXPăUXOSHUIHFWP±P±
YDORDUHDFXFDUHHIHFWXăPvPSăUĠLUHDúLFXQUBGQXPăUXOGLYL]RULORUOXLQU$FHVWDOJR J
#J
%QJ
ULWP JHQHUHD]ă QXPHUH QDWXUDOH úL vQFHSkQG FX QXPăUXO GHWHUPLQă WRĠL GLYL]RULL JJ
ú
J
J
DFHVWRUDQXPăUkQGXOH*HQHUDUHDQXPHUHORUVHRSUHúWHvQPRPHQWXOvQFDUHVDJăVLW
JJ%JmJ ^SULPDSXWHUHDOXL`J
SULPXOQXPăUDYkQGNGLYL]RUL'DFăvQVăQXVXQWHPDWHQĠLúLQXFăXWăPSRVLELOLWăĠLGH JJ
ă
RSWLPL]DUHSURJUDPXOQRVWUXYDUXODSHQWUXN PXOWPDLPXOWWLPSGHFkWSHUPLWH
JJJJ%JmJ%J ^ODSXWHUHDP`J
UHVWULFĠLDSULYLQGWLPSXOGHH[HFXĠLH
JJJJJmJDGHYăUDW ^YHULILFăPGDFă%JJHVWHSULP`J
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH 1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
JJJJ
J\SDUWHvQWUHDJăGLQUăGăFLQDSăWUDWăDOXL%J JJJJ
J
ăQJ JJJJJJJmJ ^HIHFWXăPSURGXVXOGHRDUHFHQXYRPDYHDGHSăúLUH`
JJJJJJăJ%J\J`JJ úă
JJJJJJJJJmJIDOV JJJJJmJDGHYăUDWJ ^QHSUHJăWLPVăVWDELOLPSULPDOLWDWHDOXLD`J
JJJJJJJJLHúLUHIRUĠDWăGLQ
J JJJJJmJDGHYăUDWJ ^úLDOXLSURG`J
úă JJJJJmJJ
ú
JJJJ
JJúdUăGăFLQDSăWUDWăDOXL
ăQJJ
JJJJăJJJ JJJJJJăJJ\J`JJ
JJJJăúJmJIDOV ^QHIHULPGHRvQPXOĠLUHFDUHDUSURYRFDGHSăúLUH` JJJJJJJJJmJIDOV
JJJJJJJJăFDOFXODUHDYDORULL%%DUSURGXFHGHSăúLUH úăJJ
J JJJJJJăJJ\J`JJ
JJJJJJJJJJăúJmJDGHYăUDWJ JJJJJJJJJmJIDOV
JJJJJJJJ
J úăJJ
JJJJJJJJJJJ
J%%J JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
úă JJJJ ú
JJ
JJ
ăJăúJ JJJJ%
JmJ%
J ^SUHJăWLPXUPăWRUXOPXOWLSOXDOOXLSULQGXEODUH`
ú
J ^GDFăD±E±SHUHFKHDúLSURG±VXQWQXPHUHSULPH`
JJJJăJJúJJúJJJ
1XPHUHSULHWHQH JJJJJJ
J%
J%
J
JJ
ăJăúJ
1LVHFHUHLPSOHPHQWDUHDXQXLDOJRULWPGHVFULVúLH[HPSOLILFDW$FHVWDOJRULWPJHQH
ú
UHD]ăXQHOHSHUHFKLGHQXPHUHSULHWHQHFRQIRUPXQXLPRGHOGHVFULVGH7DELW
J
ÌQDOJRULWPDPQRWDWFHOHGRXăQXPHUHGLQSHUHFKHDFXUHQWăFXDúLFXEPXOWLSOL 1XPHUHWULDQJXODUH
OXLúLFXSURGSURGXVXOORU9DULDELOHOHORJLFHSULPDSULPEúLSULPSURGSăVWUHD]ă &HULQĠDODDFHDVWăSUREOHPăHVWHVăVHHOLPLQHQXPHUHOHWULDQJXODUHGLQWUXQúLUGHQX
YDORDUHDGHDGHYăUSULYLQGSULPDOLWDWHDQXPHUHORUD±E±úLSURG±&XFRHIVD PHUHGDWH5HDPLQWLPFăXQQXPăUVHQXPHúWHWULDQJXODUGDFăVHSRDWHREĠLQHSULQvQ
QRWDWYDORDUHDFXUHQWăDPXOWLSOLORUOXLSULQvQPXOĠLUHFX'HVFULHUHDDOJRULWPXOXL VXPDUHDXQXLQXPăUGHQXPHUHQDWXUDOHFRQVHFXWLYHvQFHSkQGFXQXPăUXO
vQSVHXGRFRGHVWHXUPăWRUXO $OJRULWPXOGHUH]ROYDUHSUH]HQWDWvQFRQWLQXDUHYHULILFăSHUkQGGDFăQXPHUHOHGLQ
J ILúLHUVXQWWULDQJXODUHVFULLQGvQILúLHUXOUH]XOWDWDFHOHQXPHUHFDUHQXYHULILFăDFHDVWă
#J
%&
KJ SURSULHWDWH
JJ%
JmJ^YDORDUHLQLĠLDOăSHQWUXGXEOLLOXLvLYRPREĠLQHSULQvQPXOĠLUHFX`
JJJmJ ^SULPXOQXPăUGLQSULPDSHUHFKH` #J
QJ
JJJmJDGHYăUDWJ ^YDORDUHLQLĠLDOăQHFHVDUăODSULPXOSDV`J JJ
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ă,J
JJăúJmJIDOVJ JJJJ
ú
JJ
JJ
ăJ JJJJm` ^YHULILFăPGDFă[HVWHWULDQJXODU`
^SULPXOQXPăUvQSHUHFKHDFXUHQWăHVWHDOGRLOHDQXPăUGLQSHUHFKHDSUHFHGHQWă` JJJJ
m ^SULPXOQXPăUQDWXUDOvQVXPă`J
JJJJJmJJ JJJJ
ăJ
JJJJJmJJ ^DOGRLOHDQXPăUvQSHUHFKHDFXUHQWăHVWHGXEOXOSUHFHGHQWXOXL` JJJJJJmJ~J
J
^SULPDOLWDWHDFHOXLGHDOGRLOHDQXPăUGLQSHUHFKHDSUHFHGHQWă`J JJJJJJ
m
J~J ^FUHúWHYDORDUHDWHUPHQXOXL`J
JJJJJmJ JJJJ
ăJJdJJ
JJJJăJDUSURGXFHGHSăúLUH ^QHIHULPGHRSRVLELOăGHSăúLUH`J JJJJăJJzJJJ J
JJJJJJăúJmJDGHYăUDWJJ JJJJJJ
JJ ^GDFă[QXHVWHWULDQJXODUvOFRSLHPvQ" !&'(!`J
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH 1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
JJJJ
J
$OWHQXPHUHVSHFLDOH
JJJJJJ
JJJJJ ^GDFă[HVWHWULDQJXODUvOFRSLHPvQ!"&'(!`J 8QH[HPSOXGHQXPăUFDUHvQGHSOLQHúWHDFHDVWăSURSULHWDWHHVWH
úă
ú
ú
$SOLFDĠLHODQXPHUHOHWULDQJXODUH
3HQWUXDvQĠHOHJHPDLELQHDFHDVWăSUREOHPăVHXUPăULPvQWDEHOXOGHPDLMRVPRGXO
GHFRQVWUXLUHDúLUXOXLGDW
J
N «
(OHPHQWHOHúLUXOXL « $OJRULWPXOVXJHUDWYDFăXWDSHQWUXILHFDUHOXQJLPHFGHODODQXPăUXOFDUHvQ
GHSOLQHúWHSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWăSHQWUXRULFHQXPăUDYkQGFLIUHLGHQWLFHSHOXQJLPHDF
1XPăUWULDQJXODU 6HFUHWXOFRQVWăvQDREVHUYDFăQXPăUXOFăXWDWHVWHGHIDSWXQFkWFRPXQvQFD]XOFHORU
1XPăUWULDQJXODU QXPHUHvPSăUĠLWHODUkQGXOORUODVXPDFLIUHORUFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH
$P QRWDW YDULDELOHOH DYkQG VHPQLILFDĠLLOH GLQ HQXQĠ YHFKL UHSUH]LQWă YDORDUHD QU
1XPăUWULDQJXODU REĠLQXWăODSDVXOSUHFHGHQW
J
#J%QJ
JJ
J%\J
ăQ ^QXPHUHGHOXQJLPLFXSULQVHvQWUHúL`
JJJJ?JmJDGHYăUDWJ
JJJJ?JmJJ
6WXGLLQGWDEHOXOGHPDLVXVSXWHPWUDJHFkWHYDFRQFOX]LL JJJJ
J?JdJJúJ?J
ăQJ ^FRQVWUXLPQXPăUXOGLQFFLIUH`J
x 2EVHUYăPFăSHQWUXXQQXPăUGHRUGLQHNYDORDUHDHOHPHQWXOXLSRDWHILGHWHUPL JJJJJJ
ăJmJ`J
QDWăSULQFDOFXODUHDQXPăUXOXLWULDQJXODUFHOPDLDSURSLDWGHN JJJJJJ
J\%J
ăQ ^FRQVWUXLPQXPăUXOGLQFFLIUH`
x 9DORDUHDFăXWDWăYDILHJDOăFXXOWLPXOQXPăUQDWXUDOSHFDUHODPDGăXJDWQXPă JJJJJJJJ
ăJmJ
ă`J~J?J
UXOXLWULDQJXODU JJJJJJ ú
$SOLFkQGREVHUYDĠLLOHGHPDLVXVDOJRULWPXOHVWHXUPăWRUXOYăUHFRPDQGăPVăUHD JJJJJJJmJ%?J
JJJJJJăJ
ă\`JJ
OL]DĠLRUH]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHIRORVLQGVXPDSULPHORUQQXPHUHQDWXUDOH
J ^QXPăUXOFăXWDWWUHEXLHVăILHFkWXOvQWUHJGLQWUHQXPăUXOIRUPDW`
#J|QJ JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
ă ^GLQFFLIUHLGHQWLFHúLVXPDFHORUFFLIUH`
ú
J?J JJJJJJJJăJ?J
JJ ^GDFăN vQFăQXDYHPYHFKL`J
JJJmJJ JJJJJJJJJJăJ
J\J%&JJJ
JJJmJJ JJJJJJJJJJJJ?JmJDGHYăUDWJ ^GDFăDPREĠLQXWDFHODúLQXPăUYRPFRQWLQXD`
JJJ?J
ăJ JJJJJJJJJJ
J
J JJJmJJ~JJ JJJJJJJJJJJJ?JmJIDOVJJ
J JJJmJJ~JJ JJJJJJJJJJ úă
ú
J JJJJJJJJ úă
JJJ JJJJJJJJ%&JmJ
J
úJ JJJJJJJJ?JmJ?J~JJ
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
JJJJJJ
J
JJJJJJJJ?JmJIDOVJ
úă
JJJJJJăJ?JJ
JJJJJJJJ
J
%J
úăJ
ú
JJ ú
ú
1XPHUHVSHFLDOH
3ULP JJ
J
ÌQWURSULPăDERUGDUHSRUQLPGHODGHILQLĠLDQXPăUXOXLSULPXQQXPăUSULPDUHH[DFW JJJJă
JHVWHQXPăUSDUJJ ^QXPHUHSDUH`
GRLGLYL]RULúLHOvQVXúLÌQFRQFOX]LHYRPYHULILFDGDFăQXPăUXOGDWDUHYUHXQGLYL JJJJJJJmJ
\JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ ^VLQJXUXOQXPăUSDUSULPHVWH`
]RUSULQWUHQXPHUHOHQ± JJJJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ ^QXPHUHLPSDUH`J
JJJJJJJmJJ ^SULPXOGLYL]RUSRVLELODOXQXLQXPăULPSDU`J
#JQ JJJJJJJmJSDUWHvQWUHDJăGLQUăGăFLQDSăWUDWăDOXL
J
JJ
ú
J
J ^QXPăUXOGHYHULILFDW`J J J J J ^FDOFXOăPUDGLFDOXORVLQJXUăGDWăvQDIDUDVWUXFWXULLUHSHWLWLYH`J
JJJmJJ ^SULPXOGLYL]RUGLIHULWGH`J JJJJJJJmJDGHYăUDWJ ^SUHVXSXQHPFăQXPăUXOHVWHSULP`J
JJ
JJdJ
JúJ
JzJ`J
ă, JJJJJJ
JJdJJúJJ
ă,J
JJJJJmJJ~JJ JJJJJJJJăJ
\`JJ
ú
JJJJJJJJJJJmJIDOVJ ^DPJăVLWXQGLYL]RUGHFLQUQXHVWHSULP`J
JJăJJ
J
JJ^GDFăQXDPJăVLWQLFLXQGLYL]RUPDLPLFGHFkW`J JJJJJJJJ
JJ
JJJJJmJDGHYăUDW ^
QXPăUXOHVWHSULPvQFD]FRQWUDUQXHVWH`J JJJJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ J
JJ
JJ J J J J ^XQQXPăULPSDUVHSRDWHGLYLGHGRDUFXQXPHUHLPSDUH`J
JJJJJmJIDOVJ úă
úăJ ú
J
JJDILúDUH JJJJ úăJ
ú JJ úăJ
JJDILúDUHJ
$OJRULWPXOSRDWHILvPEXQăWăĠLWFRQVLGHUDELOGDFăWUDWăPVHSDUDWFD]XODFHORUQXPH úJ
UHFDUHQXQHFHVLWăQLFLRvPSăUĠLUHSHQWUXVWDELOLUHDSURSULHWăĠLL$FHVWHDVXQWQXPăUXO
úLQXPHUHOHSDUHÌQUHVWSURSULHWDWHDGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHRYRPYHULILFDGRDUFXQXPHUH
LPSDUHúWLLQGFăXQQXPăULPSDUQXSRDWHDYHDQLFLXQGLYL]RUSDUÌQSOXVQXYRP
JHQHUD GLYL]RUL PDL PDUL GHFkW UăGăFLQD SăWUDWă D QXPăUXOXL GHRDUHFH GLYL]RULL PDL
PDULDXIRVWÄJăVLĠL´GDFăH[LVWăVXEIRUPDXQXLFkWDOvPSăUĠLULLQXPăUXOXLFXXQGL
YL]RUPDLPLF
#JQ
JJ
ú
J
J
JJăJ
J\JJJJ
JJJJJmJIDOVJ ^QXHVWHSULP`J
J
&RQYHUVLL
$VWIHOXQHOHQXPHUHDYHDXRUHSUH]HQWDUHIRDUWHOXQJăúLSHQWUXDOHVFXUWDVDLQ
WURGXVYDULDQWDGHUHSUH]HQWDUHSULQGLIHUHQĠă'DFăXQDGLQFLIUHOH 9VDX VHDIOă
vQDLQWHDXQHLFLIUHFXYDORDUHPDLPDUHDWXQFLYDORDUHDFLIUHLUHVSHFWLYHYDILVFă]XWă
GLQYDORDUHDFLIUHLPDLPDUL
&RQYHUVLL &DSLWROXO ([HPSOH
8 ± 9 ± 9* ±
6LVWHPHGHQXPHUDĠLH
&RQYHUVLLvQWUHGRXăED]HGHQXPHUDĠLH $FHVWHIRUPHGHUHSUH]HQWDUHVXQWVXSXVHFkWRUYDUHVWULFĠLLFDUHDVLJXUăXQLFLWDWHD
2SHUDĠLLFXQXPHUHQDWXUDOHvQGLYHUVHED]HGH UHSUH]HQWăULLXQXLQXPăU'HH[HPSOX
QXPHUDĠLH &LIUHOH9VDX+QXVHSRWUHSHWDSHPDLPXOWGHWUHLSR]LĠLLFRQVHFXWLYH
&ULWHULLGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHvQGLYHUVHED]HGHQXPHUDĠLH
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH &LIUHOH8*úL%QXVHSRWUHSHWD
3UREOHPHSURSXVH 1XPDLFLIUHOH9úLSRWILVFă]XWH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU 1XPDLYDORDUHDXQHLVLQJXUHFLIUHSRDWHILVFă]XWăGHH[HPSOXQXPăUXO 8QX
H[LVWă
&LIUDVFă]XWăWUHEXLHVăDLEăRYDORDUHGHFHOSXĠLQR]HFLPHGLQFLIUDGLQFDUHVH
6LVWHPHGHQXPHUDĠLH VFDGHGHH[HPSOXQXPăUXO%QXH[LVWă
3ULQVLVWHPGHQXPHUDĠLHvQĠHOHJHPDQVDPEOXOUHJXOLORUGHJUXSDUHDHOHPHQWHORUXQHL
PXOĠLPLILQLWHFXVFRSXOQXPăUăULLORUúLDUHJXOLORUGHUHSUH]HQWDUHVLPEROLFăDQXPă &HOPDLPDUHQXPăUSHFDUHvOSXWHPUHSUH]HQWDIRORVLQGDFHVWHVLPEROXULúLUHV
UXOXLREĠLQXW SHFWkQG UHJXOLOH GH PDL VXV HVWH ++++99 'DWRULWă IDSWXOXL Fă QXPHUHOH
6LPEROXULOHVHPQHOHJUDILFHFXDMXWRUXOFăURUDVHUHSUH]LQWăQXPHUHOHVHQXPHVF
URPDQHVXQWIRDUWHOXQJLRSHUDĠLLOHFXQXPHUHDVWIHOUHSUH]HQWDWHVHHIHFWXHD]ăJUHRL
FLIUH
ÌQIXQFĠLHGHPRGXOGHJUXSDUHúLGHRUGRQDUHDVHPQHORUFDUHVHIRORVHVFSHQWUX 2EVHUYăPFăRFLIUăGLQFDGUXOXQXLDVWIHOGHQXPăUDUHDFHHDúLYDORDUHDEVROXWă
UHSUH]HQWDUHDVLPEROLFăDQXPHUHORUGHRVHELPVLVWHPHOHDGLWLYHGHVLVWHPHOHSR]LĠLR LQGLIHUHQWGHSR]LĠLDSHFDUHRRFXSă
QDOH
3ULQWUHVLVWHPHOHGHQXPHUDĠLHDGLWLYHVHQXPăUăVLVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLHHJLSWHDQúL &HOPDLUăVSkQGLWVLVWHPGHQXPHUDĠLHvQ]LOHOHQRDVWUHHVWHVLVWHPXO]HFLPDOFDUH
VLVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLHURPDQ
XWLOL]HD]ă]HFHVLPEROXULQXPLWHFLIUHDUDEH
6LVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLHURPDQIRORVHúWHúDSWHVHPQHGLVWLQFWHQXPLWHFLIUHURPDQH
1XPăUXOVLPEROXULORUUHSUH]LQWăED]DVLVWHPXOXLGHQXPHUDĠLH
8 9 * % + 6LVWHPXO]HFLPDOHVWHXQVLVWHPGHQXPHUDĠLHSR]LĠLRQDODGLFăSR]LĠLDXQHLFLIUHvQ
. 5 .: 5: .:: 5:: .::: QXPăULQGLFăUDQJXODFHVWHLD9DORDUHDUDQJXOXLSUHFL]HD]ăFXFHSXWHUHDOXLVHYD
vQPXOĠLFLIUDSHQWUXDGHWHUPLQDYDORDUHDQXPăUXOXL
'LQWUHFHOHúDSWHFLIUHOH 9 úL +QXVHSRWUHSHWDVFULLQGDOăWXUDWGHPDLPXOW 3HQWUXDQXVHSURGXFHFRQIX]LLvQWUHGRXăQXPHUHVFULVHvQVLVWHPHGHQXPHUDĠLH
GHWUHLRULvQGHVFULHUHDXQXLQXPăU
,QLĠLDOVLVWHPXOGHIRUPDUHDQXPHUHORUURPDQHHUDED]DWVWULFWSHDGXQDUH&LIUHOH
SR]LĠLRQDOHGLIHULWHVDFRQYHQLWFDILHFăUXLQXPăUVăLVHDWDúH]HXQLQGLFHFRUHVSXQ
XQXL QXPăU VH DúH]DX vQ RUGLQH GHVFUHVFăWRDUH D YDORULORU LDU YDORDUHD QXPăUXOXL VH ]ăWRUED]HLGHQXPHUDĠLHvQFDUHHVWHVFULV
FDOFXODSULQvQVXPDUHDWXWXURUYDORULORUFLIUHORU
([HPSOX
([HPSOX
+%99 VHYDFLWLGRXăVXWHúDSWH]HFLúLWUHL
2ULFHQXPăUQDWXUDOQSRDWHILVFULVvQVLVWHPXO]HFLPDOvQPRGXQLFvQIRUPD
Q DQDQ ± «DXQGHDLL QVXQWFLIUHGLQPXOĠLPHD^«`LDU
YDORDUHDOXLQHVWHGDWăGHVXPDDQQDQ±Q±«D
&RQYHUVLL
&RQYHUVLLvQWUHGRXăED]HGHQXPHUDĠLH
&RQYHUVLL
&RQYHUVLDXQXLQXPăUGLQWURED]ăGDWăvQED]D
3HQWUXDGHILQLXQVLVWHPGHQXPHUDĠLHVHGHVFULHPXOĠLPHDGHVLPEROXULIRORVLWăvQ
UHSUH]HQWDUHUHJXOLOHGHJUXSDUHDVLPEROXULORUvQQXPăUúLVHSUH]LQWăRSHUDĠLLOHGHIL
$$OJRULWPGHFRQYHUVLHSHQWUXQXPHUHvQWUHJL
QLWHSHPXOĠLPHDQXPHUHORUUHSUH]HQWDWHvQVLVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLHUHVSHFWLY
(IHFWXkQGFDOFXOHOHFHUXWHGHGHVFRPSXQHUHDGXSăSXWHULOHED]HLSXWHPREĠLQHvQFD
]XORULFăUXLVLVWHPGHQXPHUDĠLHYDORDUHQXPăUXOXLGDWvQED]D
ÌQ VLVWHPXO GH QXPHUDĠLH ]HFLPDO SHQWUX D QXPăUD RELHFWHOH DFHVWHD VH JUXSHD]ă
FkWH1XPăUXOJUXSXULORUUHSUH]LQWăGHFkWHRULVHFXSULQGHvQQXPăU$FHVWHD ([HPSOX
JUXSDWHGLQQRXFkWH]HFHQHGDXQXPăUXOVXWHORUHWFÌQPRGVLPLODUvQWUXQVLVWHP
SR]LĠLRQDODYkQGED]DERELHFWHOHVHYRUJUXSDFkWHE5HJXOLOHGHUHSUH]HQWDUHDXQXL
QXPăUvQRULFHVLVWHPGHQXPHUDĠLHSR]LĠLRQDOVXQWVLPLODUHUHJXOLORUFDUHIXQFĠLRQHD
]ăvQVLVWHPXO]HFLPDO
6LVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLHELQDUHVWHFDUDFWHUL]DWGH 7UDJHPFRQFOX]LDFăSHQWUXDREĠLQHUHSUH]HQWDUHDvQED]DDXQXLQXPăUQDWXUDO
x %D]DVLVWHPXOXLGHQXPHUDĠLHHVWH UHSUH]HQWDW vQWUR ED]ă E WUHEXLH Vă GHVFRPSXQHP QXPăUXO GXSă SXWHULOH ED]HL úL Vă
x 0XOĠLPHDGHVLPEROXULFDUHVWăODED]DVLVWHPXOXLHVWH^` HIHFWXăPFDOFXOHOHvQED]D
'HH[HPSOXQXPăUXOUHSUH]LQWăYDORDUHD
%$OJRULWPGHFRQYHUVLHSHQWUXSDUWHDIUDFĠLRQDUăDXQXLQXPăU
6LVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLHRFWDODUHXUPăWRDUHOHFDUDFWHULVWLFL 3HQWUXDFRQYHUWLXQQXPăUIUDFĠLRQDUGLQWURED]ăEvQED]DDSOLFăPDFHODúLDOJR
ULWPFDúLSHQWUXSDUWHDvQWUHDJăGH]YROWăPQXPăUXOFLIUăFXFLIUăGXSăSXWHULOHED]HL
x %D]DVLVWHPXOXLHVWH
úLDSRLHIHFWXăPFDOFXOHOHvQED]D
x 0XOĠLPHDGHVLPEROXULFDUHVWăODED]DVLVWHPXOXLHVWH^`
'HH[HPSOXQXPăUXOUHSUH]LQWăYDORDUHD ([HPSOX
8QDOWVLVWHPGHQXPHUDĠLHIUHFYHQWXWLOL]DWvQOXPHDFDOFXODWRDUHORUHVWHVLVWHPXO
GHQXPHUDĠLHKH[D]HFLPDO&DUDFWHULVWLFLOHDFHVWXLDVXQW &RQYHUVLDGLQED]DvQWURDOWăED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLH
x %D]DVLVWHPXOXLHVWH
x 9DORULOHFXFDUHOXFUHD]ăDFHVWVLVWHPGHQXPHUDĠLHVXQWQXPHUHOHGHODOD'H $$OJRULWPGHFRQYHUVLHSHQWUXQXPHUHvQWUHJL
RDUHFHQXPHUHOHPDLPDULGHFkWVXQWFRPELQDĠLLGHVLPEROXULVSUHH[HPSOX &RQYHUVLDXQXLQXPăUQDWXUDOUHSUH]HQWDWvQED]DvQWURDOWăED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHEVH
VHIRUPHD]ăGLQúLGLQHOHQXSRWILXWLOL]DWHODUkQGXOORUFDVLPEROXUL([LVWă IDFHSULQvPSăUĠLULVXFFHVLYHODEYDORDUHDQXPăUXOXLILLQGvQORFXLWăODILHFDUHSDVSULQ
vQVăRFRQYHQĠLHSULQFDUHVHIRORVHúWHOLWHUD$SHQWUXYDORDUHDOLWHUD%SHQWUX FkWXOvPSăUĠLULL5HVWXULOHVFULVHvQRUGLQHLQYHUVăUHSUH]LQWăFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLFăXWDW
YDORDUHDúLDúDPDLGHSDUWHÌQDFHVWHFRQGLĠLLVLPEROXULOHFDUHVWDXODED]DDFHV
WXLVLVWHPGHQXPHUDĠLHVXQW$%&'(úL) ([HPSOX
GHFL
&RQYHUVLL &RQYHUVLL
%$OJRULWPGHFRQYHUVLHSHQWUXSDUWHDIUDFĠLRQDUăDXQXLQXPăU $$OJRULWPGHFRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]DN
&RQYHUVLDXQXLQXPăUIUDFĠLRQDUUHSUH]HQWDWvQED]DvQWURED]ăEVHIDFHSULQvQ 3HQWUXDFRQYHUWLGHH[HPSOXQXPăUXOvQED]D VHFRPSOHWHD]ăQX
PXOĠLULVXFFHVLYHFXE/DILHFDUHSDVSDUWHDvQWUHDJăDUH]XOWDWXOXLvQPXOĠLULLQHGăFk PăUXOFXXULQHVHPQLILFDWLYHvQVWkQJDúLvQGUHDSWDSkQăFkQGDYHPJUXSXULFRPSOH
WHRFLIUăGLQUH]XOWDWvQPXOĠLUHDFRQWLQXkQGFXSDUWHDIUDFĠLRQDUăDUH]XOWDWXOXL$OJR WHGHFkWHWUHLFLIUH*UXSXULOHGHFLIUHVHIRUPHD]ăSRUQLQGGHODYLUJXOD]HFLPDOăVSUH
ULWPXOYDDYHDDWkĠLDSDúLFkWHFLIUH]HFLPDOHGRULPVăGHWHUPLQăP VWkQJDUHVSHFWLYVSUHGUHDSWD1XPăUXOGHYLQH/DSDVXOXUPăWRUvQOR
FXLPILHFDUHJUXSGHFkWHWUHLFLIUHELQDUHFXVLPEROXOED]HLFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHJUXSX
([HPSOX OXLYH]LYDORULOHGLQWDEHOúLREĠLQHPQXPăUXOFRQYHUWLWvQED]DFDILLQG
9RPFRQYHUWLQXPăUXOGLQED]DvQED]DFXWUHL]HFLPDOH
*HQHUDOL]DUH
1XPăUvQED]D &DOFXO 3URGXV 1XPăUvQED]D 3HQWUXDFRQYHUWLXQQXPăUVFULVvQED]DvQWURED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHGHIRUPDN VH
FRPSOHWHD]ăQXPăUXOFXFLIUHDVWIHOvQFkWDWkWQXPăUXOGHFLIUHDOSăUĠLLvQWUHJLFkWúL
QXPăUXOGHFLIUHDOSăUĠLLIUDFĠLRQDUHVăILHPXOWLSOXGHNDSRLDFHVWHJUXSXULGHFkWHN
FLIUHELQDUHVHvQORFXLHVFFXVLPEROXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUGLQWDEHOXOGHFRGLILFDUH
%$OJRULWPGHFRQYHUVLHGLQED]DNvQED]D
$OJRULWPGHFRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQWURED]ăGHIRUPDN 3HQWUX D FRQYHUWL XQ QXPăU UHSUH]HQWDW vQ ED]D N vQ UHSUH]HQWDUHD FRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH
ED]HLVHHIHFWXHD]ăRVLPSOăvQORFXLUHDVLPEROXULORUED]HLNFXJUXSXOGHNFLIUH
úLLQYHUV ELQDUH FDUH FRUHVSXQGH VLPEROXOXL FRQIRUP WDEHOXOXL SUH]HQWDW $WXQFL FkQG vQ WDEHO
3HQWUX D DUăWD FRUHVSRQGHQĠD GLQWUH QXPHUHOH VFULVH vQ VLVWHPXO ELQDU úL VLPEROXULOH QXVXQWWUHFXWHNFLIUHELQDUHUHSUH]HQWDUHDVHYDFRPSOHWDFXXULvQIDĠăSkQăODRE
VLVWHPHORUGHQXPHUDĠLHFXED]DNSUH]HQWăPXUPăWRUXOWDEHO ĠLQHUHDDH[DFWNFLIUHÌQILQDOXULOHQHVHPQLILFDWLYHYRUILLJQRUDWH
YDORDUH N N N N ([HPSOX
]HFLPDOă ED]D ED]D ED]D ED]D $
$
2EVHUYDĠLH
8QQXPăUGDWvQED]DESRDWHILFRQYHUWLWGLUHFWvQED]DEDPEHOHED]HILLQGGLIH
ULWHGHED]DIăUăDVHLQWHUPHGLDWUHFHUHDSULQED]DGHQXPHUDĠLH$OJRULWPXOHV
WH DFHODúL FD vQ FD]XO FRQYHUVLHL vQ ED]D FX GHRVHELUHD Fă WRDWH FDOFXOHOH VH YRU
HIHFWXDvQED]DE
2SHUDĠLLFXQXPHUHQDWXUDOHvQGLYHUVHED]HGH
$ QXPHUDĠLH
%
& $GXQDUHD
' 3HQWUXDDGXQDGRXăQXPHUHQDWXUDOHVFULVHvQWURED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHEYRPDGXQDFL
( IUHOH GH DFHODúL UDQJ GH OD GUHDSWD OD VWkQJD 'DFă QXPăUXO UH]XOWDW GLQ DGXQDUHD D
) GRXăFLIUHVHUHSUH]LQWăFXRVLQJXUăFLIUăDWXQFLDPREĠLQXWFLIUDUH]XOWDW'DFăUH]XO
WDWXODGXQăULLHVWHIRUPDWGLQGRXăVLPEROXULDWXQFLUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLODEHVWHFLIUDUH
]XOWDWúLYRPDYHDFLIUăGHWUDQVSRUWvQFD]XODGRXăQXPHUHDFHDVWDHVWHHJDOFX
&RQYHUVLL
&RQYHUVLL
([HPSOX
$GXQăPFLIUHOHGHUDQJ ÌPSăUĠLUHD
&LIUDHVWHFLIUDGHUDQJvQUH]XOWDWHVWHFLIUăGHWUDQVSRUW 3HQWUXHIHFWXDUHDvPSăUĠLULLDGRXăQXPHUHVFULVHvQED]DEYRPXWLOL]DDFHOHDúLUHJXOL
$GXQăPFLIUHOHGHUDQJ GLQVLVWHPXO]HFLPDOĠLQkQGFRQWGHWDEODvQPXOĠLULLúLWDEODDGXQăULLvQED]DE
&LIUDHVWHFLIUDGHUDQJvQUH]XOWDWQXDYHPFLIUăGHWUDQVSRUW
$GXQăPFLIUHOHGHUDQJ ([HPSOX
&LIUDHVWHFLIUDGHUDQJvQUH]XOWDWHVWHFLIUăGHWUDQVSRUW VHFXSULQGHvQGHRUL
$GXQăPFLIUHOHGHUDQJ ±
&LIUDHVWHFLIUDGHUDQJvQUH]XOWDWQXDYHPFLIUăGHWUDQVSRUW VHFRERDUăXUPăWRDUHDFLIUăvQVHFXSULQGHGHRUL
VHPDLFRERDUăRFLIUăvQVHFXSULQGHGHRUL
6FăGHUHD
2SHUDĠLD GH VFăGHUH VH HIHFWXHD]ă DVHPăQăWRU VFăGHULL vQ ED]D FX GHRVHELUHD Fă
XQLWDWHDvPSUXPXWDWăYDFRQĠLQHEVXEXQLWăĠLúLQX
([HPSOX &ULWHULLGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHvQGLYHUVHED]HGH
± &DOFXOăPFLIUDGHUDQJFDVăSXWHPHIHFWXD±vPSUXPXWăPGLQ QXPHUDĠLH
FLIUDGHUDQJREĠLQHP± &RQVLGHUăPFDILLQGLPSRUWDQWăFXQRDúWHUHDúLXWLOL]DUHDFULWHULLORUGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHvQ
&DOFXOăPFLIUDGHUDQJ±± SUHJăWLUHD HOHYLORU SHQWUX FRQFXUVXULOH úFRODUH GH SURJUDPDUH PRWLY SHQWUX FDUH DP
&DOFXOăPFLIUDGHUDQJFDVăSXWHPHIHFWXD±vPSUXPXWăPGLQ LQFOXVDFHDVWăSUH]HQWDUH5H]XOWDWHOHDXIRVWSUHOXDWHIăUăGHPRQVWUDĠLLOHDIHUHQWHGLQ
FLIUDGHUDQJREĠLQHP± OXFUDUHD6LVWHPHGHQXPHUDĠLHDXWRU,OLH'LDFRQX(GLWXUD6WXGLXP&HLFDUH
&DOFXOăPFLIUDGHUDQJ±± GRUHVFVăDSURIXQGH]HDFHDVWăWHPăSRWFRQVXOWDELEOLRJUDILDGHVSHFLDOLWDWH
ÌQFHOHFHXUPHD]ăQRWăPFXERED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHRDUHFDUH
ÌQPXOĠLUHD
ÌQPXOĠLUHDDGRXăQXPHUHVFULVHvQWURED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHEVHHIHFWXHD]ăDVHPăQăWRU 'LYL]LELOLWDWHDFXQXPăUXOE±
vQPXOĠLULLvQED]DGDUVHYDĠLQHFRQWGHWDEODDGXQăULLúLvQPXOĠLULLvQED]DE 8QQXPăUQDWXUDOVFULVvQED]DEVHGLYLGHFXE±GDFăúLQXPDLGDFăVXPDFLIUHORU
VDOHHVWHXQQXPăUPXOWLSOXGHE±
([HPSOX
7DEODvQPXOĠLULLvQED]DVHFRPSOHWHD]ăHIHFWXkQGFDOFXOHOHvQED]D'HH[HP
'LYL]LELOLWDWHDFXE
SOX 8QQXPăUQDWXUDOVFULVvQED]DEVHGLYLGHFXEGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăGLIHUHQĠDGLQWUH
VXPDFLIUHORUGHRUGLQLPSDUúLVXPDFLIUHORUGHRUGLQSDUHVWHPXOWLSOXGHE
'LYL]LELOLWDWHDFXEvQED]HGHIRUPDEN
8QQXPăUQDWXUDOVFULVvQED]DENVHGLYLGHFXEGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăVXPDFLIUH
ORUVDOHHVWHXQQXPăUPXOWLSOXGHE
9RPFDOFXODu
u &DOFXOăPFLIUDGHUDQJ VFULHPWUDQVSRUW 'LYL]LELOLWDWHDFXEvQED]HGHIRUPDEN±
&DOFXOăPFLIUDGHUDQJ VFULHPWUDQVSRUW 8QQXPăUQDWXUDOVFULVvQED]DEN±VHGLYLGHFXEGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăGLIHUHQĠD
&DOFXOăPFLIUDGHUDQJ
VFULHPWUDQVSRUW GLQWUHVXPDFLIUHORUGHRUGLQLPSDUúLVXPDFLIUHORUGHRUGLQSDUHVWHPXOWLSOXGHE
DGXQkQGFXREĠLQHP
&RQYHUVLL &RQYHUVLL
'LYL]LELOLWDWHDFXEEE«vQED]DE &ULWHULXOGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHFXvQGLYHUVHED]HGH
8QQXPăUQDWXUDOVFULVvQED]DEVHGLYLGHFXEEE«GDFăúLQXPDLGDFăQXPăUXO QXPHUDĠLH
VHWHUPLQăFXGRLGH« 1XPăUXOQDWXUDOQ DQDQ«DD VFULVvQED]DEVHGLYLGHFXvQVLVWHPHOHGHQXPH
UDĠLHFXED]D
'LYL]LELOLWDWHDFXEvQED]HGHIRUPDEN E NN1
GDFăúLQXPDLGDFăXOWLPDFLIUăVHGLYLGHFX
8QQXPăUQDWXUDOVFULVvQED]DENVHGLYLGHFXEGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăXOWLPDFLIUăD E NN1
GDFăúLQXPDLGDFăVXPDWXWXURUFLIUHORUVHGLYLGHFX
QXPăUXOXLHVWHXQPXOWLSOXGHE E NN1
GDFăúLQXPDLGDFăD±DD ±«D±DD±«VH
GLYLGHFX
E NN1
GDFăúLQXPDLGDFăD±DD ±«D±DD±«VH
'LYL]LELOLWDWHDFXEN±VDXENvQED]DE GLYLGHFX
8QQXPăUQDWXUDOVFULVvQVLVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLHDYkQGED]DEVHGLYLGHFXEN± E NN1
GDFăúLQXPDLGDFăD±DD ±«±DDD«VH
ENGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăVXSULPkQGXLXOWLPDFLIUăúLVFă]kQGUHVSHFWLYDGXQkQG GLYLGHFX
GHNRULFLIUDVXSULPDWăVHREĠLQHXQQXPăUGLYL]LELOFXEN±UHVSHFWLYEN
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
&ULWHULXOGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHFXvQGLYHUVHED]HGH 3HQWUXDYăIDPLOLDUL]DFXPRGXOvQFDUHVHUH]ROYăSUREOHPHOHvQFDUHLQWHUYLQLPSOH
QXPHUDĠLH PHQWăULDOHFRQYHUVLLORUYăVXJHUăPVăvQFHUFDĠLVăUHDOL]DĠLDOJRULWPLSHQWUX
8QQXPăUQDWXUDOHVWHGLYL]LELOFXvQED]DGHQXPHUDĠLH FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D
D E NGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăXOWLPDVDFLIUăHVWHPXOWLSOXGH FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D
E E NGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăVXPDFLIUHORUVDOHHVWHPXOWLSOXGH FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DúL
vQED]D
&ULWHULXOGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHFXvQGLYHUVHED]HGH FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]DE
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DEvQED]D
QXPHUDĠLH FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DDvQED]DE
8QQXPăUQDWXUDOHVWHGLYL]LELOFXvQED]DGHQXPHUDĠLH FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D
D E NGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăXOWLPDVDFLIUăHVWHPXOWLSOXGH FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D
E E NGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăVXPDFLIUHORUVDOHHVWHPXOWLSOXGH FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DDvQED]DE
F E N±GDFăúLQXPDLGDFăGLIHUHQĠDGLQWUHVXPDFLIUHORUGHRUGLQLPSDUúLVXPD FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]DERULFkWGHPDUH
FLIUHORUGHRUGLQSDUHVWHPXOWLSOXGH FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DERULFkWGHPDUHvQED]D
FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DDRULFkWGHPDUHvQED]DERULFkWGHPDUH
&ULWHULXOGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHFXvQGLYHUVHED]HGH
QXPHUDĠLH
8QQXPăUQDWXUDOHVWHGLYL]LELOFXvQED]DGHQXPHUDĠLH
D E NGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăXOWLPDVDFLIUăHVWHPXOWLSOXGH
E E NGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăVXPDFLIUHORUVDOHHVWHPXOWLSOXGH
F E NGDFăúLQXPDLGDFăVXPDGLQWUHGXEOXOSHQXOWLPHLFLIUHúLXOWLPDFLIUă
HVWHPXOWLSOXGH
G E N±GDFăúLQXPDLGDFăGLIHUHQĠDGLQWUHVXPDFLIUHORUGHRUGLQLPSDUúLVXPD
FLIUHORUGHRUGLQSDUHVWHPXOWLSOXGHFLIUHOHVHFRQVLGHUăQXPăUDWHGHODGUHDSWDOD
VWkQJD
6HSRWDPkQDGXSăvQYăĠDUHDSUHOXFUăULLúLUXULORUGHFDUDFWHUH
&RQYHUVLL &RQYHUVLL
'DWHGHLHúLUH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH 5H]XOWDWXORSHUDĠLHLVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXO'"&'(!
&RQYHUVLH 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
6ăVHFRQYHUWHDVFăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQVFULVvQWURED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHEvQWURDOWăED x dQXPăUQXPăUdE
]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHEÌQDLQWHGHDVHHIHFWXDFRQYHUVLDVHYDYHULILFDGDFăQXPăUXOGDW x QXPăUtQXPăU
HVWHFRUHFWVFULVvQVFULHUHDOXLVDXIRORVLWFLIUHSHUPLVHGHED]DGHQXPHUDĠLHvQFDUH x dEd
VHSUHVXSXQHFăDIRVWVFULV
([HPSOX
'DWHGHLQWUDUH '"&$ '"&'(!J
&HOHGRXăED]HGHQXPHUDĠLHEúLEVHFLWHVFGHSHSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH J ``
'$8&$3HOLQLDXUPăWRDUHVHDIOăQXPăUXOQDWXUDOFDUHWUHEXLHFRQYHUWLW J
~J
'DWHGHLHúLUH
1XPăUXOFRQYHUWLWVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXO '$8&'(!ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHQXPăUXOQXHVWH
FRUHFWVFULVvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVHYDVFULHPHVDMXO
J
%% &ULWHULLGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHvQWURED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHGDWă
6HFRQVLGHUăRED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHEúLXQQXPăUQDWXUDOVFULVvQDFHDVWăED]ă6ăVHYH
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL ULILFHGDFăQXPăUXOGDWHVWHGLYL]LELOFXúLXWLOL]kQGFULWHULLGHGLYL]LELOLWDWH
x QXPHUHOHYRUDYHDFHOPXOWFLIUHvQDPEHOHED]HEúLE
x dEEd 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH $"&$VHDIOăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOEUHSUH]HQWkQG
([HPSOH ED]DGHQXPHUDĠLH3HOLQLDXUPăWRDUHVHDIOăQXPăUXOFDUHXUPHD]ăVăILHDQDOL]DW
'$8&$ '$8&'(!J
JJ | 'DWHGHLHúLUH
````
ÌQILúLHUXO $"&'(!VHYRUVFULHFLIUHOHúLVDXvQFD]XOvQFDUHQXPăUXOGDWHVWH
GLYL]LELO FX DFHVWHD ÌQ VLWXDĠLD vQ FDUH QXPăUXO HVWH GLYL]LELO FX GRXă VDX PDL PXOWH
'$8&$ '$8&'(!J
|JJ
J
%% QXPHUH GLQWUH FHOH HQXPHUDWH DFHVWHD YRU IL VHSDUDWH SULQ FkWH XQ VSDĠLX 'DFă
``| QXPăUXOQXHVWHGLYL]LELOFXQLFLXQXOGLQWUHQXPHUHOHúLvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH
VHYDVFULH
2SHUDĠLLvQWURED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHGDWă 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
6ăVHHIHFWXH]HRSHUDĠLDGHDGXQDUHVDXGHVFăGHUHFRQIRUPFHULQĠHLGLQILúLHUXOGHLQ x dQdE
WUDUHDGRXăQXPHUHQDWXUDOHGDWHUHSUH]HQWDWHvQWURED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHGDWăEIăUă x dEd
VăVHHIHFWXH]HFRQYHUVLLvQED]D
([HPSOH
'DWHGHLQWUDUH $"&$ $"&'(!J
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH'"&$VHDIOăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOEUHSUH]HQWkQG J J|
ED]DGHQXPHUDĠLHvQFDUHVHYDHIHFWXDRSHUDĠLD3HXUPăWRDUHOHOLQLLDOHDFHOXLDúLIL `
úLHUVHDIOăSULPXOQXPăUDSRLRSHUDWRUXOVDX±LDUSHXOWLPDOLQLHVHDIOăFHOGHDO $"&$ $"&'(!
GRLOHDQXPăU `J
&RQYHUVLL &RQYHUVLL
6LVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLH)LERQDFFL $OJRULWPXO GHVFULV vQ SVHXGRFRG IRORVHúWH SULPD PHWRGă 'DFă ED]D E HVWH ED]D
&LIUHOHVLVWHPXOXLGHQXPHUDĠLH)LERQDFFLVXQWúLÌQDFHVWVLVWHPGHQXPHUDĠLHVH QXHVWHQHFHVDUăFRQYHUVLDQXPăUXOXLGLQED]DEvQED]DúLVLPLODUGDFăEHVWH
SRW UHSUH]HQWD QXPHUHOH DVHPăQăWRU VLVWHPXOXL ]HFLPDO 1XPăUXO P FQFQ«FFF HJDOFXQXHVWHQHYRLHVăFRQYHUWLPUH]XOWDWXOSDUĠLDO
VFULVvQED]D)LERQDFFLvQVLVWHPXO]HFLPDODUHYDORDUHDFQDQ«FF J
#J
QJ
XQGHDLVXQWQXPHUH)LERQDFFL
6ăVHVFULHXQSURJUDPFDUHFRQYHUWHúWHXQQXPăUGDWvQED]DvQED]D)LERQDFFL JJ
ú
J ^VHFLWHVFFHOHGRXăED]HGHQXPHUDĠLH`J
úLXQQXPăUGDWvQED]D)LERQDFFLvQVLVWHPXO]HFLPDO JJ
ú
J
ă ^VHFLWHúWHQXPăUXOGDW`
^VHYHULILFăGDFăQXPăUXOHVWHVFULVFRUHFWvQED]DGDWă`
'DWHGHLQWUDUH JJJmJDGHYăUDWJ ^SUHVXSXQHPFăQXPăUXOHVWHFRUHFWVFULV`
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH -'&$VHDIOăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOPUHSUH]HQWDW JJ
JmJ
ăJ ^FRSLHDQXPăUXOXLGDW`
vQED]D)LERQDFFL3HOLQLDXUPăWRDUHVHDIOăXQQXPăUvQED]D JJ
JúJ
JzJ`J
ăQJ
JJJJăJ
`JtJJJ J
'DWHGHLHúLUH JJJJJJJmJIDOV ^QXPăUXOFRUHFWVFULVDUHGRDUFLIUHPDLPLFLGHFkWE`J
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXL-'&'(!VHYDVFULHUHSUH]HQWDUHDSULPXOXLQXPăUGLQILúL JJJJ úăJJ
HUXOGHLQWUDUHUHSUH]HQWDWvQED]D3HFHDGHDGRXDOLQLHVHYDVFULHUHSUH]HQWDUHD JJJJ
JmJ
`J
FHOXLGHDOGRLOHDQXPăUvQED]D)LERQDFFL JJ ú
JJăJJJJ
JJJJ
J
J
%%J
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL JJ
x dQUQUd ^FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DEvQED]D`J
JJJJăJJ\J`JJ
([HPSOH JJJJJJĠJmJ
ăJ
-'&$ $"&'(!J JJJJ
````J |J
| ````
^GDFăE QXHVWHQHFHVDUăHWDSDGHFRQYHUVLHvQED]D`J
JJJJJJĠJmJ`J ^UH]XOWDWXOSDUĠLDODOFRQYHUVLHLGLQEvQ`
JJJJJJJmJJ ^SSăVWUHD]ăSXWHULOHED]HL`J
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVH JJJJJJ
J
ăJzJ`J
ăQJ
ÌQDLQWHGHDSUH]HQWDUH]ROYăULOHSUREOHPHORUGRULPVăFODULILFăPXUPăWRDUHOHvQFDO JJJJJJJJ%
JmJ
ă`J
FXODWRURULFHQXPăUHVWHUHSUH]HQWDWvQED]DLDUÄLPDJLQHD´SHFDUHRYHGHPDILúkQG JJJJJJJJ
ăJmJ
ă`J
XQDVWIHOGHQXPăUHVWHXQQXPăUUHSUH]HQWDWvQED]DÌQFRQFOX]LHDWXQFLFkQGvQ JJJJJJJJĠJmJĠJ~J%
J
DFHVWH UH]ROYăUL YRUELP GHVSUH FRQYHUVLL GH IDSW FRQVWUXLP ÄLPDJLQHD´ QXPHUHORU JJJJJJJJJmJJ
IRUPDWHGLQFLIUHFRQIRUPVLVWHPXOXLGHQXPHUDĠLH'LQDFHVWPRWLYvQFRQWLQXDUHSULQ ú
FRQYHUVLL vQĠHOHJHP FRQVWUXLUHD QXPHUHORU vQ ED]D FDUH ÄDUDWă´ FD úL FXP DU IL vQ JJJJ úă
ED]DE JJJJăJJ\J`JJ ^GDFăE QXHVWHQHFHVDUăFRQYHUVLD`J
JJJJJJJmJĠJ
&RQYHUVLH JJJJ
^FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]DE`J
3HQWUXDFRQYHUWLXQQXPăUGLQWURED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHvQDOWDH[LVWăvQSULQFLSLXGRXă JJJJJJJmJ`J
SRVLELOLWăĠL JJJJJJJmJ ^SSăVWUHD]ăSXWHULOHED]HL`J
x VHFRQYHUWHúWHQXPăUXOvQED]DúLDSRLDFHVWDVHFRQYHUWHúWHvQED]DGRULWă JJJJJJ
ăJ
x VHFRQYHUWHúWHQXPăUXOvQED]DGHQXPHUDĠLHGRULWăSULQDSOLFDUHDDOJRULWPXOXLGH JJJJJJJJ%
JmJĠJ
FRQYHUVLHFODVLFFXFRQGLĠLDFăWRDWHFDOFXOHOHVHYRUHIHFWXDvQED]DVSHFLILFDWă JJJJJJJJĠJmJĠJ
&RQYHUVLL &RQYHUVLL
JJJJJJJJJmJJ~J%
J JJ
JmJ`J ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDFLIUHLGHWUDQVSRUW`J
JJJJJJJJJmJ`J JJJmJJ ^SVHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăFXODSXWHUHD`J
JJJJJJ
ăJĠJ\J`J JJ
J
ăJzJ`J J
ăJzJ`J
ăQJ
JJJJ úă JJJJJJJ ^FkWPDLH[LVWăFLIUHFHOSXĠLQvQWUXQQXPăU`
JJJJ
JJ JJJJăJJ\J~JJ
úăJJ J J ^VHDGXQăXOWLPHOHFLIUHDOHFHORUGRXăQXPHUH`
úJ
JJJJJJĠJmJ
J~J
ă`J~J
ă`J
J JJJJJJăJĠJtJJJ
2SHUDĠLLvQWURED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHGDWă JJJJJJJJĠJmJĠJJJ
ÌQIXQFĠLHGHRSHUDĠLDVSHFLILFDWăvQILúLHUDGXQDUHVDXVFăGHUHDOJRULWPXOYDWUHEXL JJJJJJJJ
JmJJ
Vă HIHFWXH]H VXPD VDX GLIHUHQĠD QXPHUHORU GDWH RSHUDĠLLOH HIHFWXkQGXVH vQ ED]D GH JJJJJJ
J
JmJ`J
QXPHUDĠLHvQFDUHDXIRVWVFULVHQXPHUHOH JJJJJJ úă
6HYRUXUPăULDFHVWHRSHUDĠLLSHXQH[HPSOX
^VHVFDGXOWLPHOHFLIUHDOHFHORUGRXăQXPHUH`J
)LHE QXPăU úLQXPăU JJJJJJĠJmJ
ă`JJ
JJ
ă`J
JJJJJJăJĠJJ`JJ ^HVWHQHYRLHGHvPSUXPXW`J
'DFăRSHUDWRU ~J JJJJJJJJĠJmJĠJ~JJ
J JJJJJJJJ
JmJJ
RSHUDĠLD WUDQVSRUWYHFKL FDOFXOH FLIUăUH]XOWDWăJ WUDQVSRUWJ JJJJJJ
J
JmJ`J
/.://0; : :;/0;.0<0.:<.:0 : . JJJJJJ úă
/:..0 . .;/0;.0<4.:<..0 . . JJJJ úăJ
.::..:0 . .;:0;:0<..:<.0 . : JJJJJmJJ~JĠJ
: :;.0;/0<0.:<.:0 : . J J ^FLIUDREĠLQXWăVHDGDXJăODUH]XOWDW`
J . .;/0;:0<0.:<.:0 : .
. .;:0;:0<..:<.0J . : JJJJJmJ` ^VHSUHJăWHúWHSXWHUHDSHQWUXSDVXOXUPăWRU`J
JJJJ
ăJmJ
ă`J ^VHWUHFHODXUPăWRDUHDFLIUă`J
'DFăRSHUDWRU JJJJ
ăJmJ
ă`J
ú
JJăJ
J
J`JJ
RSHUDĠLD vPSUXPXW FDOFXOH FLIUDUH]XOWDWă WUDQVSRUW
/.://01 :.: :.:;/01.0<.0 .0 : JJJJJmJJ~JJ ^XOWLPDFLIUăGHWUDQVSRUW`J
úăJ
/:..0 :.: :.:;/01.0<.0 .0 :
JJ
JJ
./:..0 :.: :.:;:01:0<:0 :0 :
ú
0.: 0.:;.01/0</0 /0 :
J :.: :.:;=/01.0><.0 .0 1. J
&ULWHULLGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHvQWURED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHGDWă
$OJRULWPXOFDUHGHVFULHDFHVWHRSHUDĠLLHVWHSUH]HQWDWvQFRQWLQXDUHJ 3URJUDPXOSRDWHILUHDOL]DWYHULILFkQGFULWHULLOHGHGLYL]LELOLWDWHFXúLFULWHULL
J FDUH DX IRVW SUH]HQWDWH vQ VXSRUWXO WHRUHWLF DO OHFĠLHL &RQGLĠLLOH DX IRVW JUXSDWH GXSă
#JĠQJJJJJJJJJJJ IRUPDED]HLGHQXPHUDĠLHGHRDUHFHVHREVHUYăVLPLOLWXGLQLvQGHILQLUHDDFHVWRUFULWHULL
JJ
ú
JJ ^ED]DGHQXPHUDĠLHvQFDUHVHHIHFWXHD]ăRSHUDĠLD`J 'HH[HPSOXDWXQFLFkQGED]DGHQXPHUDĠLHHVWHPXOWLSOXGHFLIUDWRDWHFULWHULLOHFHU
JJ
ú
J
ăJ
FRQGLĠLDFDXOWLPDFLIUăDQXPăUXOXLVăILHPXOWLSOXGHFLIUDVDQRWDWFXFLIUDYDORDUHD
JJ
ú
JJ ^~VDX`
VDX'HDVHPHQHDvQFD]XOvQFDUHED]DGHQXPHUDĠLHHVWHGHIRUPDNFLIUD
JJ
ú
J
ăJ
WRDWHFULWHULLOHSXQFRQGLĠLDFDVXPDFLIUHORUQXPăUXOXLVăVHGLYLGăODFLIUD
JJJmJ`J ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDUH]XOWDWXOXL`J
&RQYHUVLL &RQYHUVLL
6HGHVFULHvQFRQWLQXDUHXQDOJRULWPGHUH]ROYDUHGLIHULWGHFHOSUH]HQWDWPDLVXVÌQ JJJJJmJJJ
VXEDOJRULWP YRP WUDWD GRDU GLYL]LELOLWDWHD FX D XQXL QXPăU UHSUH]HQWDW vQ ED]D E JJJJJmJJJ
GHRDUHFHFULWHULXOSUH]HQWDWvQSDUWHDWHRUHWLFăHVWHYDODELOGRDUSHQWUXED]HPDLPDUL JJJJ%JmJJ~JJ
VDXHJDOHFX1XYRPJHQHUDQXPăUvQED]DGRDUXOWLPDFLIUăQHLQWHUHVHD]ăGDU JJJJ
J
J
J`J
ăQJJ ^FkWWLPSPDLDYHPFLIUH`
FDOFXOHOHWUHEXLHVăOHHIHFWXăPvQED]DGHRDUHFHED]DHVWHPDLPLFăGHFkW JJJJJJ%
JmJ
`J
JJJJJJăJ%
J\JJ
J
ăQJ ^FLIUDDGXFHXQQXPăU)LERQDFFLvQYDORDUHDQXPăUXOXLQ`
JJ
JmJ
ăJ JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
J~J%J
JJJmJJ úăJ
JJ
J
J
JJ
ăQJJ ^WUDYHUVăPFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLúLSUHJăWLP`J JJJJJJJJJmJJJ
JJJJ
JmJ
JmJ
`J
JJ%
ăJmJ
ăJ JJJJ ú
J
JJ
JJ
J`J
ăQJ^WUDYHUVăPFLIUHOHGHODVWkQJDODGUHDSWD`J JJ úă
JmJ` ú J
JJJJ%
ăJmJ%
ăJ~J
ă`JJ
ú
6XEDOJRULWPXOXUPăWRUWUDQVIRUPăXQQXPăU]HFLPDOvQQXPăUUHSUH]HQWDWvQVLVWH
ă%
ăJ\J` %
ăJ\J|J PXO GH QXPHUDĠLH )LERQDFFL 'DFă QXPăUXO GDW HVWH QXPăU )LERQDFFL vQVHDPQă Fă
JJJJ
JJJJ%J|J DFHVWDWLVDREĠLQXWDGXQkQGGRLWHUPHQLFRQVHFXWLYLWLúLWLGLQúLUÌQDFHVWFD]WL
JJ úă QX DUH R UHSUH]HQWDUH XQLFă GHRDUHFH SRDWH IL VFULV úL VXE IRUPD P XQGH
ú QXPăUXO XULORU HVWH HJDO FX QXPăUXO QXPHUHORU )LERQDFFL PDL PLFL GHFkW QXPăUXO
GDW GDU úL VXE IRUPD XQGH QXPăUXO XULORU HVWH HJDO FX QXPăUXO QXPHUHORU
6LVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLH)LERQDFFL )LERQDFFLPDLPLFLGHFkWWL6XEDOJRULWPXOYDGHWHUPLQDSULPXOPRGGHDILúDUH
$OJRULWPXOGHFRQYHUVLHVHED]HD]ăSHGHVFRPSXQHUHDXQXLQXPăUQDWXUDOvQVXPăGH
J
`¡
%%
QJ
QXPHUH)LERQDFFLSUH]HQWDWvQFDSLWROXO
6XEDOJRULWPXOXUPăWRUWUDQVIRUPăXQQXPăUGDWvQVLVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLH)LERQDFFL JJ
JmJJJ ^GDFăQHVWHHJDOFXúLQQYDIL`J
QQvQQXPăU]HFLPDOQ9RPFăXWDvQQXPăUXOQQFLIUHHJDOHFXGHRDUHFHHOHUH JJăJ
JzJJ
SUH]LQWăSUH]HQĠDvQVXPDFDUHUHSUH]LQWăQXPăUXOQDXQXLQXPăU)LERQDFFLÌQQX JJJJJmJJ ^vQFHSHPJHQHUDUHDQXPHUHORU)LERQDFFL`J
PăUGRDUDQXPLĠLWHUPHQLGLQúLUSDUWLFLSăGDUWUHEXLHVăLJHQHUăPSHWRĠLSkQăFkQG JJJJJmJJ
vPSăUĠLUHDFXVHILQDOL]HD]ăFXXQFkWHJDOFX JJJJ%JmJJ~JJ
JJJJJmJJ
J
¡
`
QJJ J JJJJ
JJJ
J
ăQJJ
J J J J ^QQQXPăUvQVLVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLH)LERQDFFLQQXPăUvQED]D` JJJJJJJmJJ
JJ
JmJJ JJJJJJJmJ%J
JJăJ
JmJ
`J JJJJ
JmJJ
J J
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOH
&DSLWROXO
$WULEXLUHD
6HOHFWDUHDXQHLFRPSRQHQWH
'HFODUDUHDWDEORXULORUXQLGLPHQVLRQDOH
&LWLUHDúLDILúDUHDWDEORXULORUXQLGLPHQVLRQDOH
3UHOXFUăULVLPSOHSHWDEORXUL
&RQYHUVLL ,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
JJJJăJ%JzJ
J 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
^GDFăQQXHVWHQXPăU)LERQDFFLvOGHVFRPSXQHPvQVXPăGHQXPHUH)LERQDFFL`J
JJJJJJ
JmJ
JJJ
JJJJJJ
J
J
J`J
ăQJ ^FkWWLPSPDLDYHPUHVW`J 3HQWUXDGHILQLVWUXFWXUDGHGDWH WDEORXFRQVLGHUăPRPXOĠLPH0GHYDORULRDUHFDUH
JJJJJJJJ
JJ
J
J
ăQJ $SOLFDĠLD I ^ Q` o 0 DWDúHD]ă ILHFăUXL LQGLFH L ^ Q` XQ HOHPHQW
JJJJJJJJJJ%JmJJ PL0(DGHILQHúWHXQWDEORXXQLGLPHQVLRQDO7QQXPLWYHFWRUVDXúLUDYkQGHOHPHQ
JJJJJJJJJJJmJJ WHOHP IP IPQ IQ
ÌQPHPRULDLQWHUQăHOHPHQWHOHDFHVWXLWDEORXYRURFXSDvQRUGLQHORFDĠLLVXFFHVLYH
JJJJJJJJJJJmJ%JJJ
GHPHPRULH3UHVXSXQkQGFăSULPXOHOHPHQWDOWDEORXOXLHVWHPHPRUDWODDGUHVDDúL
JJJJJJJJJJJmJ`J FăXQHOHPHQWRFXSăOORFDĠLLDGUHVDUHODWLYăDLIDĠăGHvQFHSXWXOWDEORXOXLDORFDĠLHL
JJJJJJJJ ú
RFXSDWHGHHOHPHQWXOLYDIL
JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
WHQWăvQúLUúLGHRDUHFHGHUHJXOăSUHOXFUăPúLUXULOHvQFHSkQGFXSULPXOHOHPHQWFHO 6HREVHUYăFăSHQWUXSăVWUDUHDUH]XOWDWXOXLDPDYXWQHYRLHGHXQWDEORXQRXvQFD
PDLILUHVFHVWHFDvQLQLĠLDOL]DUHDUHVSHFWLYăVăIRORVLPDFHDVWăYDORDUH ]XOFăUXLDQXFXQRDúWHPH[DFWFkWHHOHPHQWHYDFXSULQGH'DUGLQPRPHQWFHQXHVWH
8WLOL]kQGDFHVWDOJRULWPYRPREĠLQHLQGLFHOHSULPXOXLHOHPHQWDYkQGYDORDUHDPD H[FOXVFDILHFDUHHOHPHQWDOúLUXOXLGDWVăDLEăSURSULHWDWHDGDWăDFHVWDYDILGHFODUDW
[LPă PLQLPă 'DFă QL VDU FHUH XOWLPXO DVWIHO GH HOHPHQW DWXQFL DU IL VXILFLHQW Vă DYkQGDWkWHDHOHPHQWHFkWHDUHúLUXOGDW0RGHOXOGHPDLVXVÄDGXQă´LQGLFLLHOHPHQ
VFKLPEăPRSHUDWRUXOUHODĠLRQDOÄ´vQÄd´ WHORUDYkQGSURSULHWDWHDSUHFL]DWăvQYHFWRUXO\úLWRWRGDWăREĠLQHúLQXPăUXODFHVWRUD
vQEXF'DFăQXDYHPQHYRLHGHHOHPHQWHOHUHVSHFWLYHFROHFĠLRQDWHvQYHFWRUXO\GH
ÌQFRQWLQXDUHSUH]HQWăPRDOWHUQDWLYăLQWHUHVDQWăFDUHSRDWHILXWLOăvQFD]XOXQXLúLU RDUHFHWUHEXLHGRDUVăOHIXUQL]ăPFDUH]XOWDWDOJRULWPXOHVWHúLPDLVLPSOX
ÌQDWUHLDYDULDQWăDDFHVWXLDOJRULWPFRQVLGHUăPFăGXSăVHOHFWDUHDHOHPHQWHORUFă
JJ
JmJJ ^
HVWHLQLĠLDOL]DWFXLQGLFHOHSULPXOXLHOHPHQW`J
XWDWHQXPDLDYHPQHYRLHGHúLUXOGDW'HFLvQORFVăIRORVLPXQDOGRLOHDúLUSHQWUX
JJ
J\?
J
ă,J
JJJJăJ
JJJJJ HOHPHQWHOHVHOHFWDWHYRPIRORVLFKLDUúLUXOGDW,GHHDHVWHGHDVXSUDVFULHHOHPHQWHOH
GHODvQFHSXWXOúLUXOXLGDWFXFHOHVHOHFWDWH9DULDELODEXFUHĠLQHOXQJLPHDDFHVWXLúLU
JJJJJJ
JmJJ ^LQGLFHOHHOHPHQWXOXLPD[LP` ÄQRX´3VHXGRFRGXODFHVWXLDOJRULWPHVWHXUPăWRUXO
JJJJ úă
ú
#%QJ
JJDILúDUHUH]XOWDWH JJFLWLUHGDWH
ú JJ%JmJ`J
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJJJăJJDUHSURSULHWDWHDFăXWDWăJJ
6HOHFWDUHDHOHPHQWHORU JJJJJJ%JmJ%J~J
$PYă]XWFăDOJRULWPXO %ĠGHWHUPLQăSR]LĠLDXQXLVLQJXUHOHPHQWDYkQGSUR JJJJJJ%JmJ ^VDXLvQIXQFĠLHGHFHULQĠH`J
úă
SULHWDWHD GDWă 'DFă GRULP Vă UHĠLQHP WRDWH SR]LĠLLOH SH FDUH VH DIOă HOHPHQWH DYkQG
ú
DFHDSURSULHWDWHYRPDSOLFDXQDOJRULWPGHWLS%FDUHSHGHRSDUWHVHDPăQă JJDILúDUHUH]XOWDWH
FXFăXWDUHDOLQLDUăSHGHDOWăSDUWHFXQXPăUDUHD'DFăúLUXOSR]LĠLLORUQHHVWHQHFH ú
VDU vQ FRQWLQXDUH vQ UH]ROYDUHD SUREOHPHL YRP FUHD XQ WDEORX \ vQ FDUH YRP UHĠLQH
DFHVWHSR]LĠLL&RQWRUL]DUHDHOHPHQWHORUGLQDFHVWDRUHDOL]ăPFXYDULDELODEXF
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL 7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
6HSRDWHREVHUYDFăvQFD]H[WUHPILHFDUHHOHPHQWDUHSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWăFHHDFH #JĠ
QJ
YDFRQGXFHODXQúLUÄQRX´[LGHQWLFFXFHOGDW JJFLWLUHGDWHJ
JJ%YJmJ`J
'DFăVHFHUHSăVWUDUHDHOHPHQWHORUFDUHQXDXDFHDVWăSURSULHWDWHYRPQHJDFRQGL JJ%JmJ`J
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
ĠLDGLQ ă'DFăYUHPVăSăVWUăPDFHVWHHOHPHQWHSHSR]LĠLLOHRULJLQDOHvQúLUXOGDW
JJJJăJJDUHSURSULHWDWHDFăXWDWăJJ
SXWHPDQXODSUH]HQĠDDFHVWRUHOHPHQWHVXSUDVFULLQGXOHFXRYDORDUHVSHFLDOăDOHDVă
vQDFHVWVFRS$VWIHOYRPDYHDXQDOJRULWPFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăRVHOHFWDUHSHORF$FHDVWă JJJJJJ%YJmJ%YJ~JJJ ^HOHPHQWHOHFDUHDXSURSULHWDWHDGDWă`JJ
VROXĠLHYDILDYDQWDMRDVăGRDUGDFăÄHYLWDUHD´SUHOXFUăULLDFHVWRUHOHPHQWHDYkQGYD JJJJJJY%YJmJJJ ^OHDúH]ăPvQúLUXO\`J
ORDUHDVSHFLDOăYDILPDLVLPSOXGHUHDOL]DWGHFkWYHULILFDUHDSURSULHWăĠLL JJJJ
JJ
JJJJJJ%JmJ%J~JJJ ^HOHPHQWHOHFDUHQXDXSURSULHWDWHDGDWă`J
#J%QJ JJJJJJ%JmJJJ ^OHDúH]ăPvQúLUXO]`J
JJFLWLUHGDWHJ úă
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ ú
JJJJăJJDUHSURSULHWDWHDFăXWDWăJJ JJDILúDUHUH]XOWDWH
úJ
JJJJJJJmJ%ăJJ ^RYDORDUHFRQYHQĠLRQDOVWDELOLWă`
úă
ú
'DFăYUHPVăHFRQRPLVLPVSDĠLXOULVLSLWFXRDVWIHOGHVROXĠLHSXWHPXWLOL]DXQVLQ
JJDILúDUHUH]XOWDWH JXU úLU (OHPHQWHOH VHOHFĠLRQDWH OH UHĠLQHP vQ DFHVWD DúH]kQGXOH GH OD vQFHSXW VSUH
ú VIkUúLWLDUFHOHUăPDVHGHODXOWLPXOHOHPHQWVSUHSULPXO(YLGHQWQXH[LVWăSHULFROXO
J VăÄQHFLRFQLP´GHRDUHFHDYHPH[DFWQHOHPHQWHFDUHWUHEXLHDúH]DWHSHQORFXUL
6ăREVHUYăPFăDFHDVWăUH]ROYDUHQHIXUQL]HD]ăúLUXOHOHPHQWHORUQHVHOHFWDWHvQRU
3DUWLĠLRQDUHDXQXLúLUvQGRXăVXEúLUXUL GLQHLQYHUVăIDĠăGHSR]LĠLLOHHOHPHQWHORUVDOHvQúLUXOGDW
ÌQVHFĠLXQHDSUHFHGHQWăDPSUH]HQWDWPDLPXOĠLDOJRULWPLFXFDUHUH]ROYăPSUREOHPH
vQFDUHVHGăXQúLUúLVHFHUHVHOHFWDUHDPDLPXOWRUHOHPHQWHDYkQGRDFHHDúLSURSULH #JĠ
QJ
WDWHGDWă6HSXQHvQWUHEDUHDFHVHvQWkPSOăFXHOHPHQWHOHQHVHOHFWDWH" JJFLWLUHGDWHJ
(YLGHQWYRUILSUREOHPHvQFDUHVHYDFHUHGHVFRPSXQHUHDXQXLúLUvQGRXăVDXPDL JJ%YJmJ`J
PXOWHVXEúLUXUL JJ%JmJ`J
3ULPD SDUWLFXODULWDWH D DFHVWRU SUREOHPH FRQVWă vQ IDSWXO Fă VH Gă XQ úLU úL VH FHU
\
J
ă,
PDL PXOWH 3UDFWLF YD WUHEXL Vă HIHFWXăP XQD GXSă DOWD PDL PXOWH VHOHFWăUL ĠLQkQG JJJJăJJDUHSURSULHWDWHDFăXWDWăJJ
FRQW GH SURSULHWăĠLOH SUHFL]DWH 0DL vQWkL YRP VHOHFWD DFHOH HOHPHQWH FDUH DX SULPD JJJJJJ%YJmJ%YJ~JJJJ ^HOHPHQWHOHFDUHDXSURSULHWDWHDGDWă`J
SURSULHWDWHDSRLGLQúLUXOHOHPHQWHORUSXVHGHRSDUWHUăPDVHGXSăVHOHFWDUHVHOHFWăP JJJJJJY%YJmJJJ ^OHDúH]ăPvQúLUXO\vQFHSkQGFXSULPDSR]LĠLH`J
HOHPHQWHOHDYkQGFHDGHDGRXDSURSULHWDWHúLDúDPDLGHSDUWH5H]XOWăFăDOJRULWPXO JJJJ
JJ ^HOHPHQWHOHFDUHQXDXSURSULHWDWHDGDWă`J
FRQVWăGLQDSOLFDUHDUHSHWDWăDSDUWLĠLRQăULLvQGRXăúLUXULDúLUXOXLGDW'DFăSDUWLĠLRQD
JJJJJJ%JmJ%J~JJ
UHDVHIDFHvQGRXăVXEúLUXULHVWHFODUFăHOHPHQWHOHQHVHOHFĠLRQDWHSHQWUXSULPXOúLU
JJJJJJY
%Y~JmJJJ ^OHDúH]ăPWRWvQ\vQFHSkQGFXXOWLPDSR]LĠLH`J
YRUIRUPDSHFHOGHDOGRLOHD úă
$FHVWWLSGHSUREOHPăVHSRDWHUH]ROYDSHED]DPDLPXOWRUPRGHOHÌQSULPDYDUL ú
DQWăHOHPHQWHOHDYkQGSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWăúLFHOHFDUHQXDXDFHDVWăSURSULHWDWHOHYRP JJDILúDUHUH]XOWDWH
DúH]D vQ GRXă úLUXUL QRL $FHVWH úLUXUL OH YRP GHFODUD DYkQG GLPHQVLXQHD úLUXOXLGDW ú
GHRDUHFHQXVHSRDWHDQWLFLSDQXPăUXOH[DFWGHHOHPHQWH(VWHSRVLELOFDWRDWHHOHPHQ
WHOHVăILHVHOHFWDWHvQSULPXOúLUVDXDFHVWDVăQXDLEăQLFLXQHOHPHQW ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHGXSăSDUWLĠLRQDUHQXDYHPQHYRLHGHúLUXOGDWvQIRUPDVDRULJLQDOă
ÌQDOJRULWPXOXUPăWRUYDULDELOHOHEXF\úLEXF]UHSUH]LQWăQXPăUXOHOHPHQWHORUDúH SDUWLĠLRQDUHDH[DFWFDVHOHFWDUHDSRDWHILUHDOL]DWăIRORVLQGVSDĠLXODORFDWúLUXOXLGDW
]DWHvQúLUXO\UHVSHFWLYúLUXO]úLUXULQRLUH]XOWDWHvQXUPDSDUWLĠLRQăULL DGLFăSHORF
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL 7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
1HSXWHPLPDJLQDRVROXĠLHFDUHDUIRORVLXQDOJRULWPFRQIRUPFăUXLDDPDYDQVDvQ 0XOĠLPLUHSUH]HQWDWHFXúLUXUL
úLUSkQăODGHVFRSHULUHDSULPXOXLHOHPHQWFDUHQXDUHSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWăúLODPLQWHU 'HRFDPGDWă QH YRP ED]D SH FXQRúWLQĠHOH SULYLQG PXOĠLPLOH GREkQGLWH OD GLVFLSOLQD
VFKLPEDFXSULPXOFDUHDUHSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWă PDWHPDWLFă6HúWLHFăRPXOĠLPHILHHVWHYLGăILHFRQĠLQHXQQXPăURDUHFDUHGHRELHF
WHÌQDFHVWVHQVGDFăRPXOĠLPHHVWHUHSUH]HQWDWăFXDMXWRUXOXQXLúLUHOHPHQWHOHVDOH
$FHDVWă VROXĠLH QHILLQG VXILFLHQW GH HILFLHQWă SURSXQHP XUPăWRUXO DOJRULWP SX WUHEXLHVăILHGLVWLQFWHXQDFHODúLÄRELHFW´HVWHSUH]HQWRVLQJXUăGDWă
QHPSULPXOHOHPHQWGHRSDUWHSăVWUkQGXLYDORDUHDvQWURYDULDELOăDX[LOLDUăúLFăXWăP
XQHOHPHQWDYkQGSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWăSRUQLQGGHODFDSăWXOGLQGUHDSWDDOúLUXOXLúLvO $6WDELOLUHDSURSULHWăĠLLGHÄPXOĠLPH´
SXQHP SH ORFXO HOLEHUDW OD vQFHSXWXO úLUXOXL $FXP YRP FăXWD SRUQLQG GH OD DFHDVWă 1HSXQHPvQWUHEDUHDFXPVWDELOLPFăGHH[HPSOXXQúLUGHQXPHUHUHDOHFRQVWLWXLH
SR]LĠLHVSUHGUHDSWDXQHOHPHQWFDUHQXDUHSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWăúLvODúH]ăPSHORFXO VDXQXRPXOĠLPH"$OWIHOVSXVFXPYHULILFăPGDFăHOHPHQWHOHXQXLúLUGDWVXQWGLVWLQFWH"
HOLEHUDWGHODVIkUúLWXOúLUXOXL&RQWLQXăPDFHVWSURFHGHXSkQăFkQGvQXUPDDYDQVăULL
vQFHOHGRXăGLUHFĠLLQHYRPvQWkOQL #JĠQJ
ÌQDOJRULWPYDULDELODVWDUWUHĠLQHLQGLFHOHFXUHQWDOHOHPHQWXOXLFDUHDUHSURSULHWDWHD JJFLWLUHGDWH
FHUXWăSDUFXUJkQGúLUXOGHODVWkQJDVSUHGUHDSWDLDUVWRSUHĠLQHLQGLFHOHFXUHQWDOHOH JmJJ
PHQWXOXLFDUHQXDUHSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWăSDUFXUJkQGúLUXOGHODGUHDSWDVSUHVWkQJD JJĠJmJDGHYăUDWJ
JJ
JĠJúJJJ
J
ă,J
#JĠ
QJ
JJJJJmJJ~JJ
JJFLWLUHGDWHJ
JJJJ
JJdJ
JúJJzJJ
ă,J
JJJmJJ
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJJ
JJJmJ
J ú
JJJmJJ
JăJJ!J
JĠJmJDGHYăUDWJ
JJ
JJJJJ
úDUHSURSULHWDWHDFăXWDWă,J JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
JĠJmJDGHYăUDWJ
úăJ
JJJJJJJmJJJJ
JJJJ ú
JJJJJmJJ~JJ
JJJJăJJJJJ ú
JJJJJJJmJJJ JJDILúDUHUH]XOWDWH
ú
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
J
JJJJJJ
JJJJúJJDUHSURSULHWDWHDFăXWDWăQJ
%(OLPLQDUHDGXEOXULORU
JJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
7UDQVIRUPDUHD XQXL úLU DVWIHO vQFkW Vă GHYLQăPXOĠLPHvQVHDPQăHOLPLQDUHDGXEOXUL
ú
ăJJJJJ ORU7UHEXLHVăILPDWHQĠLFDGXSăGHSLVWDUHDúLHOLPLQDUHDXQHLGXEOXUL[MDOOXL[LVă
JJJJJJJJJmJJJ
QXDYDQVăPFXLFLVăHIHFWXăPvQFăRFăXWDUHGHGXEOXULSHQWUXDFHODúL[L'XSăILHFD
UHHOLPLQDUHGHXQHOHPHQWOXQJLPHDúLUXOXLYDVFăGHDFX
JJJJJJJJJmJJJJ
úă
úă #JĠQJ
ú
J JJFLWLUHGDWH
JJJmJJ JmJJ
JJăJJDUHSURSULHWDWHDFăXWDWăJJ%JmJJ JJ
JJJ
J
ă,J
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
J%JmJJJJ JJJJJmJJ~JJ
úă JJJJ
JJdJ
JúJJzJJ
ă,J
JJDILúDUHUH]XOWDWH JJJJJJJmJJ~JJJ
úJ ú
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
JăJJdJ
JJ
JJJJJJJmJ
JJ ^VXSUDVFULHPGXEOXUDFXXOWLPXOHOHPHQW`J JJJJJJ%JmJJJ
úă
JJJJJJ
JmJ
JJJ ^VFXUWăPúLUXO`J ú
JJJJ
J
JJDILúDUHUH]XOWDWH
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ ú
úă
ú
J
'5HXQLXQHD
JJDILúDUHUH]XOWDWH 'DFă YUHP VăUH]ROYăPSUREOHPHFDUHSUHOXFUHD]ăPXOĠLPLLPSOHPHQWDWHFXDMXWRUXO
ú
úLUXULORUWUHEXLHVăWUDWăPúLSUREOHPDUHXQLXQLL
J
6HPQLILFDĠLDYDULDELOHORUvQDOJRULWPXOXUPăWRUHVWHDFHODúLFDPDLvQDLQWHÌQUH]RO
&,QWHUVHFĠLD
YDUHPDLvQWkLYRPFRSLDWRDWHHOHPHQWHOHGLQúLUXO[vQúLUXO]LQLĠLDOL]kQGOXQJLPHD
$PYă]XWFXPVHSURFHGHD]ăDWXQFLFkQGVHGăXQúLUúLWUHEXLHFUHDWHPDLPXOWHúLUXUL
EXF FX OXQJLPHD DFHVWXL úLU $SRL YRP VHOHFWD GLQ úLUXO \ DFHOHHOHPHQWHFDUHQXVH
SHED]DXQHLSURSULHWăĠLFDUHSHUPLWHSDUWLĠLRQDUHDúLUXOXL(YLGHQWVHSRDWHSXQHvQWUH
DIOăvQ[
EDUHDFXPSURFHGăPFkQGVHGDXPDLPXOWHúLUXULúLWUHEXLHVăFUHăPXQVLQJXUúLUFDUH
VăFRQĠLQăLQWHUVHFĠLDORU$LFLSULQLQWHUVHFĠLHvQĠHOHJHPúLUXOFDUHFRQĠLQHHOHPHQWHOH #J
QJ
FRPXQH WXWXURU úLUXULORU GDWH $YHP GHFL R SUREOHPă vQ FDUH VH LPSXQH VHOHFWDUHD JJFLWLUHGDWHJ
DQXPLWRUHOHPHQWHSHED]DSURSULHWăĠLLGHDILSUH]HQWHvQILHFDUHúLUGDW JJJmJJ
JJ%JmJ
J
(YLGHQW vQ GLYHUVH OLPEDMH GH SURJUDPDUH DFHDVWă SUREOHPă VH UH]ROYă vQ IXQFĠLH JJ
J\J
ă,J
GHLQVWUXPHQWHOHSHFDUHDFHVWDOHSXQHODGLVSR]LĠLDSURJUDPDWRULORU'HH[HPSOXvQ
JJJJJmJJ
3DVFDOH[LVWăWLSXO
YRPvQYăĠDGHVSUHDFHVWWLSPDLWkU]LXFDUHSRDWHVLPSOLILFD
JJJJ
JdJ
JúJJzJYJ
ă,J
PXOWHIHFWXDUHDDFHVWHLRSHUDĠLLGDFăWLSXOGHED]ăúLGRPHQLXOYDORULORUHOHPHQWHORU
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJJ
SHUPLWGHFODUDUHDGDWHORUFDILLQGGHDFHVWWLS$FXPQHDPSURSXVVăWUDWăPSUREOH ú
PDHQXQĠDWăvQFRQGLĠLLJHQHUDOHLQGHSHQGHQWGHOLPEDMXOGHSURJUDPDUHDOHVGRDUGLQ JJJJăJJ
J
JJJ
SXQFWGHYHGHUHDOJRULWPLF'HDVHPHQHDSUHVXSXQHPFăILHFDUHúLUFRQĠLQHHOHPHQWH JJJJJJ%JmJ%J~JJJ
GLVWLQFWHúLFăDFHVWHúLUXULQXVXQWRUGRQDWH
JJJJJJ%JmJYJJ
úă
3UH]HQWăP XQ DOJRULWP JHQHUDO FDUH VWDELOHúWH VXEúLUXO DFHORU HOHPHQWH GLQúLUXO[ ú
FDUHVHJăVHVFúLvQúLUXO\'LPHQVLXQLOHúLUXULORUVXQWQUHVSHFWLYPLDUGLPHQVLXQHD JJDILúDUHUH]XOWDWH
úLUXOXLLQWHUVHFĠLH]YDILEXF úJ
#J
%ĠQJ
JJFLWLUHGDWHJ ,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
JJ%JmJ`J 3HQWUXDYăIDPLOLDUL]DFXPRGXOvQFDUHVHDERUGHD]ăSUREOHPHOHvQFDUHVHSUHOXFUHD
JJ
J
J
ă,J ]ăWDEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHYăVXJHUăPVăLPSOHPHQWDĠLDOJRULWPLSHQWUX
JJJmJJ GHWHUPLQDUHDVXPHLHOHPHQWHORUXQXLúLU
JJJJ
JJdJJúJJzJYJ
ă,J GHWHUPLQDUHDPLQLPXOXLúLPD[LPXOXLXQXLúLU
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJJ YHULILFDUHDH[LVWHQĠHLDFHOSXĠLQXQXLHOHPHQWDYkQGRSURSULHWDWHGDWăGLQWUXQúLU
ú
FăXWDUHDOLQLDUăDXQXLHOHPHQWvQWUXQúLU
JJJJăJJdJJJJ FăXWDUHDOLQLDUăDXQXLHOHPHQWvQWUXQúLUúLGHWHUPLQDUHDWXWXURUDSDULĠLLORU
JJJJJJ%JmJ%J~JJJ
FăXWDUHDOLQLDUăDXQXLHOHPHQWDYkQGRSURSULHWDWHGDWăvQWUXQúLUúLHOLPLQDUHDOXL
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL 7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
FăXWDUHDOLQLDUăDWXWXURUHOHPHQWHORUDYkQGRSURSULHWDWHGDWăvQWUXQúLUúLHOLPLQD ([HPSOX
UHDORU (+#&$ (+#&'(!J
FLWLUHDDGRXăúLUXULFXQXPăUGLIHULWGHHOHPHQWHúLGHWHUPLQDUHDúLUXOXLFDUHDUH |J |``J
VXPDHOHPHQWHORUPD[LPăPLQLPă J
FLWLUHD D Q úLUXUL FX QXPăU GLIHULW GH HOHPHQWH úL GHWHUPLQDUHD úLUXOXL FDUH DUH `J
J
VXPDHOHPHQWHORUPD[LPăPLQLPă
J
FLWLUHDDQúLUXULFXQXPăUGLIHULWGHHOHPHQWHúLLGHQWLILFDUHDúLUXOXLFDUHDUHFHOH
PDLPXOWHHOHPHQWH
YHULILFDUHDSURSULHWăĠLLGHPXOĠLPHDXQXLúLU J
GHWHUPLQDUHDGXEOXULORUvQWUXQúLUúLHOLPLQDUHDORU 3HUHFKL
GHWHUPLQDUHDUHXQLXQLLDGRXăPXOĠLPLUHSUH]HQWDWHFXúLUXUL 6HFRQVLGHUăQQXPHUHvQWUHJL6ăVHDILúH]HQXPHUHOHGHRUGLQHDOHSHUHFKLORUGHHOH
GHWHUPLQDUHDLQWHUVHFĠLHLDGRXăPXOĠLPLUHSUH]HQWDWHFXúLUXUL PHQWHIRUPDWHGLQGRXăQXPHUHvQWUHJLHJDOH
HOLPLQDUHDXQXLHOHPHQWGLQWUXQúLUFXSăVWUDUHDRUGLQLL
GHWHUPLQDUHD GLQWUXQ úLU D GRXă VXEúLUXUL SH ED]D XQHL SURSULHWăĠL GDWH FUHkQG 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
GRXăVXEúLUXULQRLDSRLFUHkQGVXEúLUXULQRLÄSHORF´ 3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXL "@&$VHDIOăQXPăUXOQDWXUDOQ3HILHFDUHOLQLHGLQ
XUPăWRDUHOHQOLQLLVHDIOăXQQXPăUvQWUHJ
3UREOHPHSURSXVH 'DWHGHLHúLUH
ÌQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH "@&'(!VHYRUVFULHSHFkWHROLQLHSHUHFKLOHGHQXPHUHGH
6XPă RUGLQHVHSDUDWHSULQWUXQVSDĠLXDOHHOHPHQWHORUFRQVHFXWLYHHJDOHDOHúLUXOXL
6HFRQVLGHUăSQXPHUHvQWUHJL6ăVHFDOFXOH]HVXPD
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
6 x dQd
Q Q QS x dQULdL Q
'DFăH[LVWăL^«S`DVWIHOvQFkWQL WHUPHQXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUQXVHFDOFX
OHD]ă7RWRGDWăVăVHQXPHUHYDORULOHHJDOHFXSULQWUHQXPHUHOHGDWH ([HPSOX
"@&$J "@&'(!J
'DWHGHLQWUDUH J J
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXL (+#&$VHDIOăVFULVQXPăUXOQDWXUDOS3HXUPăWRDUHOHS J
J
OLQLLVHDIOăFkWHXQQXPăUvQWUHJ
'DWHGHLHúLUH
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLHúLUH (+#&'(!VHYDVFULHVXPDFDOFXODWăLDUSHDGRXD 5DSRUW
QXPăUXOQXPHUHORUHJDOHFX 6HFRQVLGHUăQQXPHUHvQWUHJL6ăVHGHWHUPLQHUDSRUWXOGLQWUHQXPăUXOQXPHUHORUSDUH
úLQXPăUXOQXPHUHORULPSDUHGDWH
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x dSd 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
x dQLdL S 3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH "#'"!&$VHDIOăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQ8UPăWRD
UHOHQOLQLLFRQĠLQILHFDUHFkWHXQQXPăUvQWUHJ
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL 7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
'DWHGHLHúLUH SHFWLYQXHVWHEXQODQLPLFúLSHQWUXDILFRQYLQJăWRUvOvQWUHDEăGDFăSRDWHVăVSXQă
)LúLHUXOGHLHúLUH "#'"!&'(!YDFRQĠLQHRVLQJXUăOLQLHSHFDUHVHYDVFULHUDSRUWXO FkWHSHUVRDQHQăVFXWHDQWHULRUDQXOXLWUăLHVFvQFRPXQDOXL"
FHUXWFXGRXă]HFLPDOHH[DFWH'DFăvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHQXH[LVWăQLFLXQQXPăULP 6FULHĠLXQSURJUDPHILFLHQWFDUHUăVSXQGHODvQWUHEDUHDúHIXOXLúLvQSOXVFUHHD]ăXQ
SDUvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVHYDVFULHPHVDMXOJJ
J ILúLHUQRXvQFDUHVHYRUDIODDQLLGHQDúWHUHPDLPLFLGHFkW
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
x dQd 3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH -&$VHDIOăQXPăUXOQUHSUH]HQWkQGQXPăUXO
x dQULdL Q ORFXLWRULORUGLQFRPXQDQDWDOăDDQJDMDWXOXL3HXUPăWRDUHOHQOLQLLVHDIOăQXPHUHQD
WXUDOHUHSUH]HQWkQGDQXOQDúWHULLDOORFXLWRULORU
([HPSOX
"#'"!&$J "#'"!&'(!J 'DWHGHLHúLUH
|J ` 3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLHúLUH -&'(!VHYDVFULHQXPăUXOSHUVRDQHORUQăVFXWH
J DQWHULRUDQXOXL3HXUPăWRDUHOHOLQLLVHYRUDIODDQLLGHQDúWHUHUHVSHFWLYL
J
J
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
J
| x dQd
x GDFăQXVHJăVHúWHQLFLRSHUVRDQăQăVFXWăDQWHULRUDQXOXLvQILúLHUVHYDVFULH
PHVDMXO
7HPSHUDWXUL x ILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHQXWUHEXLHVăFRQĠLQăQXPHUHGLVWLQFWH
3HGXUDWDOXQLLLXQLHVDPăVXUDWWHPSHUDWXUDDSHL0ăULL1HJUHúLYDORULOHVDXVFULVvQ
WUXQILúLHU6WDELOLĠLGDFăDSDPăULLVDvQFăO]LWvQFRQWLQXXVDXQX ([HPSOX
-&$ -&'(!
'DWHGHLQWUDUH |J J
ÌQ ILúLHUXO GH LQWUDUH !+&$ VH DIOă GH QXPHUH UHDOH UHSUH]HQWkQG WHPSHUDWXUD `J `J
DSHL ```J |J
J |
|J
'DWHGHLHúLUH
|
'DFăWHPSHUDWXULOHIRUPHD]ăXQúLUPRQRWRQFUHVFăWRUvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH !+&'(!
VHYDVFULHDOWIHOVHYDVFULH
'LULJLQWD
([HPSOX /DVIkUúLWXODQXOXLGLULJLQWDFODVHLWUHEXLHVăFRPSOHWH]HXQIRUPXODUvQFDUHHVWHvQWUH
!+&$J "+&'(!J ([SOLFDĠLH EDWăFkĠLHOHYLGLQFODVăDXPHGLDILQDOăvQWUHúLLQFOXVLYFkĠLDXPHGLDvQWUHúL
J J $LFLQXVXQWPHQĠLRQDWHWRDWHFHOHGHWHP LQFOXVLYHWF'DUFXPQXvLSODFHVăOXFUH]HFXVWDWLVWLFLOHYăURDJăVăVFULHĠLXQSUR
|J SHUDWXULGLQPRWLYHGHVSDĠLXGDUHVWHFODU JUDPFDUHvLYDOLVWDGDWHOHQHFHVDUHÌQSOXVHDYăVROLFLWăFDOLVWDVăFRQĠLQăúLPHGLLOH
J
FăWHPSHUDWXULOHQXDXFUHVFXWPRQRWRQ GLQILHFDUHFDWHJRULH
J
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
ÌQWUHEDUHDúHIXOXL 3HSULPDOLQLHGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH %")&$VHDIOăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQUHSUH]HQ
5HFHQWVDUHDOL]DWUHFHQVăPkQWXOSRSXODĠLHLGLQ5RPkQLD8QDQJDMDWFXULRVDFUHDWXQ WkQGQXPăUXOHOHYLORUGLQFODVă3HXUPăWRDUHOHQOLQLLVHDIOăvQRUGLQHDGLQFDWDORJ
ILúLHUvQFDUHDSăVWUDWGRDUDQXOQDúWHULLSHUVRDQHORUFDUHORFXLHVFvQFRPXQDVDQDWDOă PHGLLOHJHQHUDOHDOHORU0HGLLOHVXQWQXPHUHUHDOHVFULVHFXGRXD]HFLPDOHH[DFWH
ùHIXOOXLREVHUYkQGFăSLHUGHWLPSXOFXOXFUXULQHLPSRUWDQWHvODFX]ăFăILúLHUXOUHV
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
'DWHGHLHúLUH
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
ÌQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH%")&'(!YHĠLVFULHVWDWLVWLFDVXEXUPăWRDUHDIRUPă
x Qd
x 3HSULPDOLQLHVHYDVFULHWH[WXOJ
J
J`QJXUPDWGH
QU XQGH QU UHSUH]LQWă QXPăUXO HOHYLORU DYkQG PHGLD JHQHUDOă vQWUH úL LQ ([HPSOX
FOXVLY3HXUPăWRDUHDOLQLHYHĠLVFULHPHGLLOHHOHYLORUGHVSăUĠLWHSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLX )$"#"&$ )$"#"&'(!
vQRUGLQHDGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHDSDUĠLQkQGFDWHJRULHLUHVSHFWLYH
x 9HĠLSURFHGDODIHOvQFD]XOILHFăUHLFDWHJRULLPHGLLJHQHUDOHvQWUHúLLQFOXVLY
vQWUHúLLQFOXVLYvQWUHúLLQFOXVLYUHVSHFWLYvQWUHúLLQFOXVLY
6XSUDSXQHUH
x 'DFăQXPăUXOPHGLLORUGLQWURFDWHJRULHHVWHOLQLDFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHPHGLHLUăPk 6HFRQVLGHUăXQWDEORXXQLGLPHQVLRQDO$FDUHFRQĠLQHQQXPHUHQDWXUDOHúLXQDOWWD
QHYLGăvQILúLHU
EORX%DYkQGHOHPHQWHHJDOHFXGHOXQJLPHNXQGHNdQ3ULQVXSUDSXQHUHDWDEOR
XOXL%SHVWHWDEORXO$HOHPHQWHOHDFRSHULWHGLQ$vúLPLFúRUHD]ăYDORDUHDFXRXQLWDWH
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
6ăVHVWDELOHDVFăGDFăHVWHSRVLELOFDSULQDSOLFăULVXFFHVLYHDOHWDEORXOXL%SHVWHWD
x PHGLLd EORXO$VăVHREĠLQăvQ$QXPDLYDORULHJDOHFX
x vQDFHDVWăFODVăQXVXQWFRULJHQĠL
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
([HPSOX 'DWHOHGHLQWUDUHVHFLWHVFGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH ("#&$vQFDUHSHSULPDOLQLHHVWH
%")&$ %")&'(!
|J J
J
J`QJJ VFULVQXPăUXOQDWXUDOQSHDGRXDOLQLHHVWHVFULVQXPăUXOQDWXUDONLDUSHDWUHLDOLQLH
|J JJJJJ VXQWFHOHQHOHPHQWHGLQWDEORXO$
J J
J
JQJJ
J J``JJ 'DWHGHLHúLUH
||J J
J
JQJ`J 'DWHOHGHLHúLUHVHYRUVFULHvQILúLHUXO ("#&'(!'DFăSUREOHPDQXDGPLWHVROXĠLH
``J J vQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVHYDVFULHPHVDMXO DOWIHOVHYDVFULHRVXFFHVLXQH
J
J
JQJJ GHLQGLFLDLúLUXOXL$SHVWHFDUHVHDSOLFăSR]LĠLDGHvQFHSXWDWDEORXOXL%
J|JJ
J
J
J|QJJ
J||J 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x dQd
x dNdQ
*HQHUDUHúLU
6H FRQVLGHUă XUPăWRUXO úLU FRQVWUXLW DVWIHO vQFkW ILHFDUH HOHPHQW DO OXL FX H[FHSĠLD
x dDLd
SULPXOXLVHREĠLQHGLQFHOSUHFHGHQW5HJXODGHJHQHUDUHD x RVXSUDSXQHUHHVWHSRVLELOăGDFăvQWUHJWDEORXO%ÄvQFDSH´vQ$
WHUPHQLORUHVWHXUPăWRDUHD
([HPSOH
x VHQXPăUăGHODVWkQJDODGUHDSWDFkWHFLIUHH[LVWăvQWHUPHQXOSUHFHGHQW ("#&$J ("#&'(!J
x vQWHUPHQXOQRXVHWUHFHSHQWUXILHFDUHFLIUăQXPăUXOGHDSDULĠLLDFLIUHLúLFLIUD J J
6ăVHGHWHUPLQHDOQOHDHOHPHQWGLQúLU J J
JJJJ`J`J`J`J J
'DWHGHLQWUDUH J
1XPăUXOQDWXUDOQVHFLWHúWHGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH)$"#"&$J ("#&$J ("#&'(!J
J `J JJJJJ
J
'DWHGHLHúLUH
JJJJJJJ`J`J`JJJJJJJJ`J`J`
$OQOHDWHUPHQGLQúLUVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXO)$"#"&'(!J
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL 7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
JJ
J\
J
ăQ ^HFKLYDOHQWFX
J\
J%ăQ`
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU JJJJăJ\~J ^%ăJ\J
%`
JJJJJJ
JJ~J
6XPD úă
6HFLWHúWHGLPHQVLXQHDSDúLUXOXL6XPDVVHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăvQDFHDVWăSUREOHPăFXYD ú
úJ
ORDUHDFRQIRUPH[SUHVLHLGDWHLDUFRQWRUXO]HURXULORUFX
)LHFDUHQXPăUGLQúLUVHYHULILFăSHQWUXDSXWHDGHFLGHGDFăSDUWLFLSăODVXPăVDX
ILLQGVHPăUHúWHFRQWRUXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUYDORULORUQXOH'DFăQXPăUXOFLWLWHVWHQXO 5DSRUW
DWXQFLQXSDUWLFLSăODVXPăGHRDUHFHQXSXWHPHIHFWXDvPSăUĠLUHFXÌQILQDOVHVFULH 1RWăPFXQUSDUHQXPăUXOQXPHUHORUSDUHúLFXQULPSDUHQXPăUXOQXPHUHORULPSDUH
YDORDUHDVXPHLvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHSUHFXPúLQXPăUXOHOHPHQWHORUHJDOHFX JăVLWH$PEHOHYDULDELOHVHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăFX
8UPHD]ă R SUHOXFUDUH VLPSOă D HOHPHQWHORU úLUXOXL vQ FDUH FRQWRUL]ăP QXPHUHOH
#QJ LPSDUHúLSDUH
JJ
ú
JJ ÌQILQDODQWHULRUFDOFXOăULLúLDILúăULLUDSRUWXOXLWUHEXLHVăYHULILFăPGDFăDPvQWkOQLW
\J
ă,
FHOSXĠLQXQQXPăULPSDUSHQWUXDQXULVFDVăvPSăUĠLPFXÌQFD]XOvQFDUHQXDH[LV
JJJJ
ú
J
JJ
JJ ú
JJ WDWQLFLXQQXPăULPSDUvQILúLHUVFULHPPHVDMXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRU
J
JJJmJ` ^QXPăUXO]HURXULORU`J #JQJ
JJJmJJ ^LQLĠLDOL]ăPVXPDFXFRQIRUPH[SUHVLHLGDWH`J
ú
J
JJJ
\J
ă, JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJJJ
ú
J
JJ JJJJ
ú
JJ
JJJJăJ
JzJ`JJJ ú
JJJJJJJmJJ~J
JJ JJ
JmJ`J
JJJJ
J JJ
JmJ`
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
úăJJ JJJJăJHVWHJJJ
JJ ú
JJ
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ
JJ
JJJ
JJJJ
JJ
úJ
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ
úă
3HUHFKL ú
J
'XSă FLWLUHD GLPHQVLXQLL úLUXOXL úL D HOHPHQWHORU VDOH SUHOXFUDUHD VH UHDOL]HD]ă FX R JJăJ
J
J`JJ
VWUXFWXUăUHSHWLWLYăGHWLS
ÌQDFHDVWăLQVWUXFĠLXQHWUHEXLHVăILPDWHQĠLODYD JJJJ
J
J
ORDUHDILQDOăDFRQWRUXOXLSHQWUXDQXFRPSDUDXOWLPXOHOHPHQWFXXQDOQOHDFDUH JJ
J
JJJJ
JJJ
JJ
QXH[LVWă'DFăYRPDYHDXQFRQWRUFDUHSRUQHúWHFXYDORDUHDDWXQFLYDORDUHDILQDOă
úăJJ
YDILQ±GDFăSRUQLPFXYDORDUHDILQDOăYDILQÌQSULPXOFD]YRPFRPSDUDHOH úJJ
PHQWHOHGHLQGLFHLúLLvQDOGRLOHDFD]FRPSDUăPHOHPHQWHOHGHLQGLFHL±úLL
#J%&QJ 7HPSHUDWXUL
JJ
ú
J
^GLPHQVLXQHDúLUXOXL`J 9RPUH]ROYDSUREOHPDLPSOHPHQWkQGDOJRULWPXO %'XSăFLWLUHDúLUXOXLGH
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ WHPSHUDWXULYRPFRPSDUDHOHPHQWHOHGRXăFkWHGRXă
JJJJ
ú
JJJ ÌQDOJRULWPQXYRPFLWLGLPHQVLXQHDGHRDUHFHúWLPFăOXQDLXQLHDUHGH]LOH
ú
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL 7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
#JQJ ă
J\J`
2J
JJ
J\`J
ăQJ JJ
J ^QXPăUXOORFXLWRULORUQăVFXĠLDQWHULRUOXL`J
JJJJ
ú
JJ JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
ú
JJJJ
J
^DQLLGHQDúWHUH`J
JJmJ ú
^FkWWLPSvQDLD]LWHPSHUDWXUDHVWHPDLPLFăVDXHJDOăFXFHDGLQDLD]L`J ú
JJ
J`úJdJ~
ăQJJJJJJJ
JJJJmJ~JJ ^WUHFHPODXUPăWRDUHD]L`J
ú
'LULJLQWD
^GDFăYDORDUHDOXLLDDWLQVYDORDUHDvQVHDPQăFăSkQăDFXPWRDWH` 3UREOHPDIDFHSDUWHGLQFDWHJRULDDFHORUDFDUHVHUH]ROYăFXDOJRULWPXOGHSDUWLĠLRQDUH
^SHUHFKLOHVXFFHVLYHGHWHPSHUDWXULDXUHVSHFWDWSURSULHWDWHD` 9RPDOHJHPRGHOXO Ġ
FKLDUGDFăDFHDVWăSUREOHPăQXULGLFăSUREOH
JJăJJ\J`JJ PHGHVSDĠLXGHPHPRUDUHSHQWUXDRIHULXQPRGHOGHUH]ROYDUHSHQWUXSUREOHPHOHvQ
JJJJ
JJ FDUHPHWRGDQXSRDWHILRFROLWă
JJ
J ÌQDOJRULWPYRPDYDQVDFXSULPXOGHODVWkQJDODGUHDSWDvQFăXWDUHDPHGLLORUFDUH
JJJJ
JJ QXLQWUăvQFDWHJRULDFXUHQWăúLFXXOWLPGHODGUHDSWDODVWkQJDvQFăXWDUHDPHGLLORUFD
úă UHWUHEXLHVăLQWUHvQFDWHJRULDFXUHQWă&XYDULDELODOLPLWDGHILQLPFDWHJRULDGHPHGLL
ú
FDUHVHFDXWăLDUEXFUHSUH]LQWăLQGLFHOHXOWLPXOXLHOHPHQWFDUHIDFHSDUWHGLQVXEúLUXO
FXUHQWÌQEXFVHYDGHWHUPLQDOXQJLPHDVXEúLUXOXLFXUHQWQHFHVDUvQDILúDUH
ÌQWUHEDUHDúHIXOXL
3UREOHPDVHUH]ROYăFXXQDOJRULWPGHVHOHFWDUH'HRDUHFHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHPDLvQ #JQJ
WkLWUHEXLHVăVFULHPQXPăUXOSHUVRDQHORUVHOHFWDWHQXSXWHPVăLVFULHPGLUHFWvQILúL JJ
ú
J
^QXPăUXOHOHYLORUGLQFODVă`J
HUSHED]DSURSULHWăĠLLFLWUHEXLHVăFUHăPúLUXOORU JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
9RP FLWL úLUXO GDW úL vO YRP UHĠLQH LQWHJUDO vQ PHPRULH 3HQWUX úLUXO QXPHUHORU JJJJ
ú
J ^PHGLLOH`
ú
VHOHFWDWH QX SXWHP GHFODUD XQ DOW úLU GHRDUHFH vQ PHPRULH QX DP DYHD ORF úL SHQWUX
DFHVWDÌQFRQFOX]LHYRPOXFUDÄSHORF´DGLFăYRPSăVWUDvQDFHVWúLURULJLQDOHOHPHQ JJJmJJ ^SULPXOLQGLFHDOúLUXOXLFXUHQW`J
WHOHFDUHQHLQWHUHVHD]ă3XWHPÄVWULFD´úLUXOFLWLWGHRDUHFHúLUXOWXWXURUDQLORUGHQDú JJJmJ
JJJ ^XOWLPXOLQGLFHDOúLUXOXLFXUHQW`J
WHUHUăPkQHQHDOWHUDWvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH
JQ\|J
ăQ ^PHGLLSRVLELOH`J
3ăVWUDUHDHOHPHQWHORUFDUHQHLQWHUHVHD]ăGLQúLUXOGDWVHSRDWHUHDOL]DvQPDLPXOWH JJJJJmJJJJ ^YDULDELOăDX[LOLDUăUHĠLQHSULPXOLQGLFHDOúLUXOXLFXUHQW`
IHOXULGDUGHRDUHFHQLVDFHUXWXQSURJUDPUDSLGQXYRPHIHFWXDWUDQVODWăUL JJJJJmJ ^SULPDPHGLHRSXQHPGHRSDUWH`
JJJJ
JJJJ
ăQJ
#%QJ ^FăXWăPSULPXOHOHPHQWDYkQGSURSULHWDWHDGHODGUHDSWDVSUHVWkQJD`
JJ
ú
J
^QXPăUXOORFXLWRULORUGLQFRPXQă`J JJJJJJ
JJúJJ
J
ă,JJ
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ JJJJJJJJJmJJJJ
JJJJ
ú
J
^DQLLGHQDúWHUH`J ^DUHSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWăvOVFULHPSHVWH`
ú
JJJJJJ ú
J
JJ
JmJ` ^GHRFDPGDWăQXDPJăVLWQLFLXQDQPDLPLFGHFkW`J JJJJJJăJJJJ
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ JJJJJJJJJmJJ
JJJJăJ
JJJJ JJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J~ ^FUHúWHQXPăUXODQLORUPDLPLFLGHFkW` ^FăXWăPSULPXOHOHPHQWFDUHQXDUHSURSULHWDWHDGHODVWkQJDODGUHDSWD`J
JJJJJJ
JmJ
^SHVWHHOHPHQWXO
VHFRSLD]ăYDORDUHD
`J JJJJJJJJ
JJúJJ
J
ăQJJ
úă JJJJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
ú
JJJJJJJJ ú
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
^QXDUHSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWăvOVFULHPSHVWH`
JJJJJJJJăJJJ
J
9RP OXFUD FX DMXWRUXO D GRXă WDEORXUL GH FLIUH 8QXO GLQWUH WDEORXUL VH IRORVHúWH
SHQWUXDUHĠLQHFLIUHOHGLQFDUHVHIRUPHD]ăSULQDOLSLUHXOWLPXOWHUPHQJHQHUDWYHFKL
JJJJJJJJJJJmJJ
úLFHOăODOWSHQWUXWHUPHQXOFDUHVHJHQHUHD]ăSHED]DSUHFHGHQWXOXLQRX$PFRQYHQLW
JJJJJJJJJJJmJJJJ ^DYDQVăPGHODVIkUúLWVSUHvQFHSXW`J
FD QXPăUXO GH HOHPHQWH SHQWUX WDEORXO YHFKL Vă ILH UHĠLQXW vQ YDULDELOD NYHFKL LDU
JJJJJJJJ úăJ
JJJJJJ úăJ SHQWUXúLUXOQRXvQNQRX9RPOXFUDGRDUFXDFHVWHGRXăúLUXULGHRDUHFHQXGRULPVă
JJJJ ú
SăVWUăPWRDWHHOHPHQWHOHúLUXOXLDYkQGvQYHGHUHFăVHFHUHGRDUDOQOHDWHUPHQ'XSă
JJJJJmJJJ ^HOHPHQWXOSXVvQVHSXQHSHORFXOÄOLEHU` FRQVWUXLUHD WHUPHQXOXL QRX WHUPHQXO YHFKL LD YDORDUHD WHUPHQXOXL QRX SUHFXP úL
^GDFăHOHPHQWXOFDUHDIRVWvQDUHSURSULHWDWHDFHUXWă` NYHFKLVHVXEVWLWXLHFXNQRXXUPkQGVăVHJHQHUH]HXQDOWWHUPHQQRX
^IDFHSDUWHGLQVXEúLUXOFXUHQW` #J
QJ
JJJJăJJ
JJJJ
JJ%&JmJJJ ^SULPXOWHUPHQVHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăúLGHYLQHLPHGLDWÄYHFKL´`J
^LQGLFHOHXOWLPXOXLHOHPHQWFDUHIDFHSDUWHGLQVXEúLUXOFXUHQW`J
JJ?%&JmJJ ^OXQJLPHDúLUXOXLDFXPHVWH`J
JJJJJJ%JmJJ J
JJJJ
JJ?JmJJJ ^FRQWRUSHQWUXWHUPHQLLúLUXOXL`J
JJ
J?JJ
J
ă,
^JIDFHSDUWHGLQVXEúLUXOFDUHVHYDSDUWLĠLRQDvQFRQWLQXDUH`
J J ^DOJRULWPXOVHWHUPLQăFkQGDPGHWHUPLQDWDOQOHDWHUPHQ`
JJJJJJ%JmJJJJ
úă JJJJ?
JmJ`JJ ^GHRFDPGDWăQXDYHPQLFLRFLIUăvQQRXOWHUPHQ`
JJJJJmJJJ
J%JJJ~JJJ ^QXPăUXOHOHPHQWHORUGLQVXEúLUXOFXUHQW`
JJJJ
J\%J
ăQJ
JJdJ?%&J
ă, ^YRPSDUFXUJHFLIUHOHYHFKLXOXLWHUPHQ`
JJJJJJ
JJ JJ JJJJ%
JmJJ ^vQ%
VHQXPăUăWRDWHHOHPHQWHOHHJDOHFX%&`
JJJJJmJ%J~JJ^LQGLFHOHGHvQFHSXWDOVXEúLUXOXLFDUHVHYDSDUWLĠLRQD`
JJJ?%&JúJ%&J\J%&~J
ă,
%
JmJ%
J~JJ
JmJ
JJ ^UHIDFHPYDULDELODSHQWUXRQRXăSUHOXFUDUH`J
ú
J JJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
ú ú
J
J JJJJJJ?
JmJ?
J~JJJ ^úLUXOYDDYHDFXXQWHUPHQPDLPXOW`J
$FHDVWăUH]ROYDUHUHVSHFWăvQWRFPDLFHULQĠHOHSUREOHPHLUHVSHFWLYPHGLLOHHOHYLORU JJJJJJ
?
JmJ%
J ^VHWUHFHvQúLUXO
QXPăUXOFLIUHORUFXUHQWH`J
VXQWDILúDWHvQRUGLQHDGLQúLUXOGDW'DFăQXDUILH[LVWDWDFHDVWăFHULQĠăúLUXOGHPHGLL JJJJJJ?
JmJ?
J~JJJ ^PDLDYHPQHYRLHGHRSR]LĠLH`J
SXWHDILRUGRQDW JJJJJJ
?
JmJ%&JJ ^SHQWUXFLIUDFXUHQWă`J
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ ^WUHFHPODXUPăWRDUHDFLIUăGLQWHUPHQXOYHFKL`J
ú
J
*HQHUDUHúLU JJJJ%&JmJ
J
'HRDUHFHUHJXODGHJHQHUDUHDHOHPHQWHORUVDGDWvQHQXQĠYRPFRQVLGHUDXQH[HP JJJJ?%&JmJ?
J
SOXúLYRPGHVFULHDOJRULWPXOGHUH]ROYDUH JJJJ?JJmJ?J~JJ
6ă SUHVXSXQHP Fă GRULP DILúDUHD FHOXL GHDO OHD WHUPHQ DO úLUXOXL *HQHUăP SH ú
UkQGWRĠLWHUPHQLLSkQăODDOOHD JJ
J\?
J
ăQJ
x 7 FRQĠLQHRVLQJXUăFLIUăGHGHFL7 JJJJ
J
J
ú
x 7FRQĠLQHGRXăFLIUHGHDYHP7 ú
x 'HRDUHFHvQ7DYHPRFLIUăGHúLXQDGHUH]XOWă7
x ÌQ7DYHPXQRFLIUăDSRLGRXăFLIUHGHFL7
6XSUDSXQHUH
x ÌQ7YRPDYHD7 GHRDUHFHvQ7DPDYXWGHGHúLXQ 3HSDUFXUVXODOJRULWPXOXLYRPILDWHQĠLFDSULQWURVXSUDSXQHUHGHFLGHFUHPHQWDUHD
YDORULORUHOHPHQWHORUVXFFHVLYHGLQ$VăQXDSDUăHOHPHQWHQHJDWLYH
7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL 7DEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHúLUXUL
([HPSOX JJJmJ`J
Q N LDUWDEORXO$HVWH JJJmJDGHYăUDW ^LQLĠLDOWRDWHQXPHUHOHGLQ$VXQWQHQHJDWLYH`
$ ^FkWWLPSQXPHUHOHGLQ$VXQWQHQHJDLWLYHúL%ÄvQFDSH´vQ$`
JJúJJdJ
?~J
ăQJJ
6HUHDOL]HD]ăSULPDVXSUDSXQHUHvQFHSkQGGHODSR]LĠLD ^GDFăHOHPHQWXOFXUHQWHVWHGLIHULWGHYRPUHDOL]DRVXSUDSXQHUH`J
$ J JJăJJzJ`J
JJJJJJJmJJ
ÌQWDEORXOUH]UHĠLQHPSULPDSR]LĠLHGHVXSUDSXQHUH JJJJJJJmJJ~JJJ ^YRPDYHDXQHOHPHQWQRXvQUH]`J
D!GHFLVHUHDOL]HD]ăRVXSUDSXQHUHGHODSR]LĠLD JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
úă ^DOWIHOvQFHUFăPRQRXăVXSUDSXQHUHvQFHSkQGFXSR]LĠLDL`J
$ JJ ú
J
1RĠLXQHDGHPRGXO vQWUR LQWHUIDĠă D VXESURJUDPXOXL FX H[WHULRUXO QXPLWă OLVWD SDUDPHWULORU IRUPDOL
'HFODUDUHDúLDSHOXOXQXLVXESURJUDP 5HVWXOGDWHORUGDWHORFDOHVXQWDVFXQVHSHQWUXH[WHULRU
)XQFĠLLúLSURFHGXULvQ3DVFDO
'H]YROWDUHDSURJUDPHORU 'DWHOHGHILQLWHvQVXESURJUDPVHQXPHVFÄORFDOH´úLYRUWUăLFkWWLPSVXESURJUDPXO
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH UHVSHFWLYHVWHDFWLYGLQPRPHQWXODFWLYăULLDSHOăULLSkQăODH[HFXĠLDXOWLPHLLQVWUXFĠL
3UREOHPHSURSXVH XQLDVXESURJUDPXOXL
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU 'DWHOH GHILQLWH vQ SURJUDPXO SULQFLSDO VH QXPHVF ÄJOREDOH´ úL YRU IL ÄYă]XWH´ FX
H[FHSĠLDFHORUUHGHFODUDWHvQVXESURJUDPXOUHVSHFWLYvQWRDWHVXESURJUDPHOHGHRDUHFH
SURJUDPXOSULQFLSDOHVWHSULPXOEORFFDUHVHDFWLYHD]ăúLXOWLPXOFDUHVHGH]DFWLYHD]ă
0RGXO /LVWDSDUDPHWULORUIRUPDOLHVWHGHFODUDWăvQDQWHWXOVXESURJUDPXOXLúLFRQĠLQHSDUD
1RĠLXQHDGHVXESURJUDPDDSăUXWGLQQHFHVLWDWHDGHDGLPLQXDFRPSOH[LWDWHDXQXLSUR PHWULGHÄLQWUDUH´úLVDXSDUDPHWULGHÄLHúLUH´
JUDPSULQGHVFRPSXQHUHDDFHVWXLDvQVXESURJUDPH$SOLFDUHDDFHVWXLFRQFHSWUHIOHFWă ÌQ SULQFLSLX XQ SDUDPHWUX FDUH GHVHPQHD]ă GDWH VWULFW GH LQWUDUH SHQWUX VXESUR
ODXQDQXPLWQLYHOSULQFLSLXOSURJUDPăULLPRGXODUH&RQIRUPDFHVWXLSULQFLSLXDOLQ JUDP VH YD WUDQVPLWH SULQ YDORDUH LDU FHO FDUH HVWH GH LHúLUH GLQ VXESURJUDP VH YD
JLQHULHLSURJUDPăULLDOJRULWPLLVHSURLHFWHD]ăDVWIHOvQFkWDFHúWLDVăIRORVHDVFăPRGX WUDQVPLWHSULQUHIHULQĠă
OH XQGH SULQ PRGXOvQĠHOHJHPRXQLWDWHVWUXFWXUDOăGHVLQHVWăWăWRDUHSURJUDPVXE
SURJUDPVDXXQLWDWHGHSURJUDP)LHFDUHPRGXOWUHEXLHVăDLEăXQUROELQHGHWHUPLQDW
úLVăILHFRQFHSXWDVWIHOvQFkWVăSRDWăILIRORVLWODQHYRLHúLvQFDGUXOXQXLDOWSURJUDP
IăUăDILPRGLILFDW2ULFHPRGXOSRDWHILODUkQGXOVăXFRQVWUXLWGLQDOWHPRGXOH 'HFODUDUHDúLDSHOXOXQXLVXESURJUDP
6WUXFWXUDXQXLVXESURJUDPVHDPăQăFXVWUXFWXUDXQXLSURJUDP
3ULQWUH DYDQWDMHOHSURJUDPăULLPRGXODUH GHFDUHEHQHILFLD]ăúLFRQFHSWXOGHVXE
SURJUDPDPLQWLP 7LSB6XESURJUDP1XPHOLVWDSDUDPHWULORUIRUPDOL ^DQWHWXOVXESURJUDPXOXL`
x VLPSOLWDWHDúLFODULWDWHDSURJUDPXOXL GHFODUDĠLLOHGDWHORUORFDOH
x PRGXOHOHVXQWPDLXúRUGHGHVFULVGHWHVWDWGHFRUHFWDWúLHYHQWXDOGHPRGLILFDW
RSWLPL]DUHDXQXLSURJUDPVHSRDWHUHDOL]DDGHVHDGRDUSULQvQORFXLUHDXQXLPRGXO
LQVWUXFĠLXQHFRPSXVă ^GHVFULHUHDDOJRULWPXOXLGHUH]ROYDUHDVXESUREOHPHL`
LQHILFLHQWFXDOWXOPDLSHUIRUPDQW
x VHHYLWăUHVFULHUHDXQXLDOJRULWPGHFkWHRULHVWHQHYRLHGHDFHVWD XQGH SULQ 7LSB6XESURJUDP vQĠHOHJHP SUHFL]DUHD WLSXOXL VXESURJUDPXOXL vQ 3DVFDO
x XQPRGXORGDWăSXVODSXQFWYDIXQFĠLRQDODIHOGHELQHúLvQWUXQDOWSURJUDPFDUH IXQFĠLHVDXSURFHGXUă&RUSXOVXESURJUDPXOXLHVWHIRUPDWGLQGHFODUDĠLLOHORFDOHDOH
DUHQHYRLHGHHO VDOHúLRLQVWUXFĠLXQHFRPSXVă
x VHFUHHD]ăSUHPLVHOHUHDOL]ăULLXQRUDSOLFDĠLLPDULSULQPXQFDvQHFKLSăDPDLPXO $SHOXOVXESURJUDPXOXLVHIDFHvQSDUWHDGHDFĠLXQLDPRGXOXOXLDSHODQW'DFăVXE
WRUSURJUDPDWRUL
SURJUDPXOUHWXUQHD]ăRVLQJXUăYDORDUHDYHPVXESURJUDPGHWLSIXQFĠLHDSHOXOSRDWH
6XEOLQLHP Fă HVWH LPSRUWDQW Vă VH XUPăUHDVFă FUHúWHUHD LQGHSHQGHQĠHL VXESURJUD VăDSDUăvQWURH[SUHVLHRULXQGHVLQWD[DOLPEDMXOXLSHUPLWHSUH]HQĠDXQHLH[SUHVLL'D
PHORUSHQWUXDPăULúDQVHOHUHXWLOL]ăULLORUvQFkWPDLPXOWHSURJUDPH FăXQVXESURJUDPFDOFXOHD]ăPDLPXOWHYDORULvQ3DVFDODYHPVXESURJUDPGHWLSSUR
FHGXUă DSHOXO VXESURJUDPXOXL DUH ORF vQ LQVWUXFĠLXQHD SURFHGXUDOă YD IL vQ VLQH R
DFĠLXQHúLYDDSăUHDRULXQGHSRDWHVăDSDUăRLQVWUXFĠLXQH
ÌQSULQFLSLXXQDSHOVHVFULHSUHFL]kQGQXPHOHVXESURJUDPXOXLXUPDWvQWUHSDUDQ
WH]HGHOLVWDSDUDPHWULORUDFWXDOL(IHFWXODSHOXOXLFRQVWăvQDFWLYDUHDVXESURJUDPXOXL
úLWUDQVIHUXOH[HFXĠLHLSURJUDPXOXLODSULPDLQVWUXFĠLXQHH[HFXWDELOăGLQVXESURJUDP
6XESURJUDPH
6XESURJUDPH
ODODSXQFWXOFRUHVSXQ]kQGDSHOXOXLGHVXESURJUDPLDUSXQFWXOSULPHLLQVWUXF
ÌQSUHDODELOYDORULOHSDUDPHWULORUDFWXDOLWUDQVPLúLSULQYDORDUHVHFRSLD]ăvQYDULDELOH ĠLXQLGHGXSăDSHO6XESURJUDPXOHVWHUHSUH]HQWDWGHVHJPHQWXOYHUWLFDODYkQGODFDSH
OHFDUHVXQWSDUDPHWULIRUPDOLDFHúWLDVHSăVWUHD]ăvQWLPSXOH[HFXWăULLVXESURJUDPX WHSXQFWHOHSULPDLQVWUXFĠLXQHDVXESURJUDPXOXLúLXOWLPDLQVWUXFĠLXQH/LQLLOH
OXLvQVWLYDGHH[HFXĠLHLDUFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUSDUDPHWULORUWUDQVPLúLSULQUHIHULQĠăVHFR FXVăJHĠLDUDWăRUGLQHDGHH[HFXĠLHDLQVWUXFĠLXQLORUGLQFHOHGRXăXQLWăĠLGHSURJUDP
PXQLFăDGUHVHOHSDUDPHWULORUDFWXDOL2ULFHPRGLILFDUHGHYDORDUHDVXSUDSDUDPHWUX
OXL IRUPDO GH WLS UHIHULQĠă GH WLS DGUHVă VH YD HIHFWXD GH IDSWDVXSUDSDUDPHWUXOXL 3URJUDPXOSULQFLSDO 6XESURJUDP8QXOLVWDSDUDPHWULORUIRUPDOL
DFWXDO FRUHVSXQ]ăWRU 3HQWUX FD DFHVW OXFUX Vă ILH SRVLELO SDUDPHWUXO DFWXDO DIHUHQW YDULDELOHJOREDOHDEF [WUDQVPLVSULQYDORDUH\SULQUHIHULQĠă
XQXLSDUDPHWUXIRUPDOGHWLSUHIHULQĠăWUHEXLHVăILHRYDULDELOă YDULDELOăORFDOă]
/LVWDSDUDPHWULORUDFWXDOLWUHEXLHVăDLEăWRWDWkĠLDSDUDPHWULFDúLOLVWDSDUDPHWULORU Dm
IRUPDOLúLSHUHFKLOHFRUHVSRQGHQWHGHSDUDPHWULWUHEXLHVăILHFRPSDWLELOHFDWLS Em[m
Fm\m
6ăSăWUXQGHPDFXPPDLDGkQFvQSURFHVXODSHOăULLXQXLVXESURJUDP $SHO8QXDE]m
3HQWUX JHVWLRQDUHD VLPSOă úL QDWXUDOă D H[HFXĠLHL VXESURJUDPHORU VH XWLOL]HD]ă R
]RQăVSHFLDOăDPHPRULHLQXPLWăVWLYăGHH[HFXĠLH6WDFN
$PLQWLPFăvQJHQHUDOVHQXPHúWHVWLYăRVWUXFWXUăGHGDWHFXGRXăFDSHWHED]ăúL
YkUI,QWURGXFHUHDFkWúLH[WUDJHUHDGHGDWHvQGLQWURVWLYăHVWHSRVLELOăGRDUODXQXO
GLQWUHFDSHWHQXPLWYkUIXOVWLYHL6WLYDGHH[HFXĠLHHVWHR]RQăGHPHPRULHvQFDUHVH 3HQWUXDSUH]HQWDPRGXOGHOXFUXFXVWLYDGHH[HFXĠLHYRPXUPăULFRQĠLQXWXODFHV
GHSXQúLGLQFDUHVHH[WUDJGDWHFRQIRUPDFHVWXLSULQFLSLX WHLDvQFHOHSXQFWHPRPHQWHPDUFDWH9DULDELOHOHJOREDOHDEúLFQXVHDORFăSH
VWLYă FL vQ VHFĠLXQHD GH GDWH H[LVWHQW OD GLVSR]LĠLD SURJUDPXOXL SULQFLSDOGDUOHYRP
ÌQXUPDDSHOXOXLXQXLVXESURJUDP SUHFL]DYDORULOHvQFHOHPRPHQWH
x VHvQWUHUXSHH[HFXWDUHDPRGXOXOXLDSHODQW
x VHVDOYHD]ăSHVWLYDGHH[HFXĠLHXUPăWRDUHOHLQIRUPDĠLL 0RPHQW 9DULDELOHJOREDOH &RQĠLQXWXOVWLYHL
DGUHVDLQVWUXFĠLXQLLODFDUHVHYDUHYHQLGXSăH[HFXĠLDVXESURJUDPXOXOXLDSHODW QHGHWHUPLQDWH YLG
YDORULOHSDUDPHWULORUWUDQVPLúLSULQYDORDUH D E F YLG
DGUHVHOHSDUDPHWULORUGHWLSUHIHULQĠă D E F [ DGUHVDOXL\ ]QHGHWHUPLQDW
x VHDORFăVSDĠLXSHVWLYăYDULDELOHORUORFDOH D E F [ DGUHVDOXL\ ]
x VHDFWLYHD]ăVXESURJUDPXOVHSUHGăFRQWUROXOSULPHLLQVWUXFĠLXQLDDFHVWXLD D E F YLG
x VHH[HFXWăLQVWUXFĠLXQLOHVXESURJUDPXOXL
2EVHUYăPGLQWDEHOFăLQVWUXFĠLXQHDGHDWULEXLUH[mQXDUHHIHFWDVXSUDSDUDPH
ÌQPRPHQWXOWHUPLQăULLH[HFXĠLHLVXESURJUDPXOXLVHHOLPLQăGHSHVWLYăWRDWHLQIRU WUXOXLDFWXDODGHRDUHFHDIRVWWUDQVPLVSULQYDORDUHvQVFKLPEEGHYLQHGHRDUHFH
PDĠLLOHFDUHVDXGHSXVGXSăDSHOXODFHVWXLDúLFRQWUROXOUHYLQHSULPHLLQVWUXFĠLXQLGH DFĠLXQHDDVXSUDSDUDPHWUXOXLIRUPDO\WUDQVPLVSULQUHIHULQĠăVDHIHFWXDWDVXSUDSDUD
GXSăDSHOGLQPRGXOXODSHODQW PHWUXOXLDFWXDOE
([HPSOX ÌQOLPEDMXO3DVFDOvQWUXQSURJUDPSULQFLSDOVDXVXESURJUDPYRPDYHD
)LH WUHL YDULDELOH D E úL F GHFODUDWH vQ SURJUDPXO SULQFLSDO $FHVWH YDULDELOH VXQW
LQLĠLDOL]DWHFXúLVHDSHOHD]ăVXESURJUDPXO8QX'XSăUHYHQLUHDGLQVXESURJUDPVH 2SDUWHGHGHILQLĠLLúLGHFODUDĠLL
DILúHD]ăYDORULOHDEúLF
&&& ^GHILQLĠLLGHWLS`
6XESURJUDPXO8QXDUHGRLSDUDPHWULIRUPDOL[HVWHSDUDPHWUXWUDQVPLVSULQYDORD &&& ^GHILQLĠLLGHFRQVWDQWH`
UH LDU \ HVWH SDUDPHWUX GH WLS UHIHULQĠă ÌQ VXESURJUDP VH GHFODUă YDULDELOD ORFDOă ] &&& ^GHFODUDĠLLGHYDULDELOH`
$FHVWVXESURJUDPDWULEXLHFHORUWUHLYDULDELOH[\úL]YDORDUHD
&&& ^GHFODUDĠLLGHVXESURJUDPH`
ÌQXUPăWRDUHDILJXUăSURJUDPXOSULQFLSDOHVWHVLPEROL]DWSULQVHJPHQWXOYHUWLFDOGH &&&
6XESURJUDPH
6XESURJUDPH
9DORDUHD UHWXUQDWă GH R IXQFĠLH ĠLQkQG FRQW GH IDSWXO Fă DFHDVWD UHWXUQHD]ă SULQ
2SDUWHGHDFĠLXQLRLQVWUXFĠLXQHFRPSXVă
&&& LGHQWLILFDWRUXOHLRVLQJXUăYDORDUHSRDWHILGRDUGHXUPăWRDUHOHWLSXUL
LQVWUXFĠLXQL x RULFHWLSvQWUHJ
& x RULFHWLSUHDO
'HFODUDĠLLOH vQ OLVWD SDUDPHWULORU IRUPDOL VXQW VHSDUDWH SULQ K $WXQFL FkQG DYHP J
%Q
Q
KJJ ^DQWHWXOIXQFĠLHL`J
PDL PXOĠL SDUDPHWUL GH DFHODúL WLS DFHúWLD VH VHSDUă SULQ YLUJXOă ÌQ XUPăWRUXO JQ
KJJ ^YDULDELOHORFDOH`J
H[HPSOXDGHúLIVXQWSDUDPHWULGHLHúLUHWUDQVPLúLSULQUHIHULQĠăEHVWHSDUD JJJJQ
KJ
PHWUXWUDQVPLVSULQYDORDUH
JJQ
KJQ&KJJ
QKJ
([LVWăIXQFĠLLFDUHUHWXUQHD]ăXQSRLQWHUYRPvQYăĠDvQFODVDD;D
3DUDPHWULLDFWXDOLPHQĠLRQDĠLvQDSHOVXQWVHSDUDĠLSULQYLUJXOă
$VWIHODPDYHDXQDSHOUHFXUVLYYH]LFDSLWROXO
6XESURJUDPH
6XESURJUDPH
JJ
JJQ\KJJ ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDIDFWRULDOXOXL`J 6HREVHUYăFăYDORDUHDYDULDELOHLJOREDOHLVDPRGLILFDWÄGLQJUHúHDOă´vQVXESUR
JUDP 3HQWUX D HYLWD DVWIHO GH JUHúHOL VH YD XUPăUL FD YDULDELOHOH IRORVLWH GH VXESUR
JJJQ\JJJQ\KJ ^FDOFXODUHDIDFWRULDOXOXL`J
JUDPVăILHvQWRWGHDXQDGHILQLWHORFDOVXESURJUDPXOXLvQFDUHVHIRORVHVF
JJ
%Q\J ^DWULEXLUHLGHQWLILFDWRUXOXLIXQFĠLHL`J
KJ
3HQWUXDREĠLQHUH]XOWDWHOHGRULWHvQSURJUDPXOGHPDLVXVVHYDDGăXJDvQSDUWHDGH
GHFODUDĠLLORFDOHDIXQFĠLHLGHFODUDĠLDJQ
J
JJ
?KJ
JJ
%
%?
%
?J 'H]YROWDUHDSURJUDPHORU
'DFăvQSURFHVXOSURLHFWăULLDOJRULWPLORURSUREOHPăVHGHVFRPSXQHvQVXESUREOHPH
úLDFHVWHDVHGHVFRPSXQODUkQGXOORUvQDOWHVXESUREOHPHSkQăFkQGVHREĠLQVXESUR
([HPSOXO EOHPH FDUH QX QHFHVLWă FRQWLQXDUHD SURFHVXOXL GH GLYL]DUH VSXQHP Fă DYHP XQ
6HFRQVLGHUăXUPăWRUXOSURJUDP&HDILúHD]ăDFHVWD" SURJUDP GH]YROWDW GHVFHQGHQW WRS GRZQ $FHDVWă WHKQLFă FRUHVSXQGH PRGXOXL vQ
J"KJ FDUH X]XDO VH SURLHFWHD]ă DOJRULWPLL IRORVLQG VXEDOJRULWPL 7HKQLFD GH SURLHFWDUH vQ
JQ
KJ FDUHVHSRUQHúWHGHODXQHOHSURJUDPHLQLĠLDOHDFHVWHDILLQGIRORVLWHSHQWUXDFRQVWUXL
PRGXOH GLQ FH vQ FH PDL VRILVWLFDWH FDUH DVDPEODWH Vă UH]ROYH SUREOHPDVHQXPHúWH
J
J
Q
Q
KJ
JQ
KJ ERWWRPXS
JJ
JJQ\`KJ
JJJQ\JJ|JJ 'H]YROWDUHDDVFHQGHQWăERWWRPXS
JJJJQ\~
KJ 8QSURJUDPGH]YROWDWDVFHQGHQWYDDYHDWRDWHVXESURJUDPHOHGHFODUDWHXQXOGXSăDOWXO
JJQ\J vQ SURJUDPXO SULQFLSDO 2 DVWIHO GH DERUGDUH DUH FD DYDQWDM IDSWXO Fă VXESURJUDPHOH
KJ VXQWPDLXúRUGHWHVWDWúLGHFRQWURODW
J
J 3URJUDPSULQFLSDO
JJJQ\JJ|J
J
JJJJJKJ
JJJJJKJ
6XESURJUDP$
JJJJ
J
JJ
J
6XESURJUDP%
J
6ăXUPăULPYDULDĠLDYDULDELOHORU
6XESURJUDP&
x SURJUDPXOSULQFLSDOvQFHSHFXFLFOXOSULPDYDORDUHDYDULDELOHLLHVWH
x VHDILúHD]ă
x VHDSHOHD]ăVXESURJUDPXOFXSDUDPHWUXODFWXDOLDFăUXLYDORDUHVHFRSLD]ăvQQ ,QVWUXFĠLXQHDFRPSXVăD
GHRDUHFHHVWHWUDQVPLVSULQYDORDUH SURJUDPXOXLSULQFLSDO
x vQVXESURJUDPVHFDOFXOHD]ă6FDUHYDDYHDYDORDUHD
x VHDWULEXLHYDORDUHDLGHQWLILFDWRUXOXLGHIXQFĠLH
x VHDILúHD]ăYDORDUHD 7UHEXLHPHQĠLRQDWIDSWXOFăILHFDUHVXESURJUDPYDSXWHDDSHODQXPDLVXESURJUDPH
x XUPHD]ăRDOWăDILúDUHDYDULDELOHLLúLVXUSUL]ăVHDILúHD]ăXOWLPDYDORDUHDOXL GHFODUDWH DQWHULRU SURSULHL GHFODUDĠLL 'LQ DFHDVWă UHVWULFĠLH GH YL]LELOLWDWH GHFXUJH úL
LFRQIRUPFLFOXOXL GLQVXESURJUDPFHHDFHFRQGXFHúLODWHUPLQDUHDLQVWUXF GH]DYDQWDMXODFHVWXLVWLOGHOXFUXFDUHFRQVWăvQGHSHQGHQĠDVXESURJUDPHORUGHXQHOH
ĠLXQLLGLQSURJUDPXOSULQFLSDO VXESURJUDPHGHILQLWHDQWHULRU
6XESURJUDPH 6XESURJUDPH
'H]YROWDUHDGHVFHQGHQWăWRSGRZQ 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
ÌQWUXQSURJUDPGH]YROWDWGHVFHQGHQWILHFDUHVXESURJUDPYDDYHDvQSURSULD]RQăGH
GHILQLĠLLúLGHFODUDĠLLVXESURJUDPHOHSHFDUHOHIRORVHúWHÌQFD]XOVXESURJUDPHORULP &LIUHFRPXQH
EULFDWHXQXOvQFHOăODOWIXQFĠLRQHD]ăDFHOHDúLUHJXOLFDvQWUHXQLWDWHDGHSURJUDPSULQFL
6ăVHDILúH]HFLIUHOHFRPXQHDGRXăQXPHUHQDWXUDOHGDWH
SDOúLVXESURJUDPDGLFăHQWLWăĠLOHGHFODUDWHGHH[HPSOXFRQIRUPILJXULLXUPăWRDUHvQ
VXESURJUDPXO$VHÄYăG´vQVXESURJUDPHOH%&úL'$VWIHOGHUHJXOăOLVWDSDUDPH
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
WULORUVHVFXUWHD]ă
&HOHGRXăQXPHUHVHFLWHVFGHSHSULPHOHGRXăOLQLLDOHILúLHUXOXL'+($&$
3URJUDPSULQFLSDO
'DWHGHLHúLUH
&LIUHOHFRPXQHDOHFHORUGRXăQXPHUHVHYRUVFULHvQILúLHUXO '+($&'(!GHVSăUĠLWH
6XESURJUDP$
SULQFkWHXQVSDĠLXÌQFD]XOvQFDUHQXH[LVWăQLFLRFLIUăFRPXQăvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH
VHYDVFULHJJ%
J%
6XESURJUDP%
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
6XESURJUDP&
x dQXPăUQXPăUd
6XESURJUDP' ([HPSOH
'+($&$ '+($&'(!J
|J J
,QVWUXFĠLXQHDFRPSXVăD
VXESURJUDPXOXL% J
'+($&$ '+($&'(!
,QVWUXFĠLXQHDFRPSXVăD |J JJ%
J%
J
VXESURJUDPXOXL$ J
,QVWUXFĠLXQHDFRPSXVăD 3ULPHúLÄLQYHUVHOH´ORUSULPH
SURJUDPXOXLSULQFLSDO 6ăVHJHQHUH]HWRDWHSHUHFKLOHGHQXPHUHSULPHIRUPDWHGLQWUHLFLIUHFDUHDXSURSULH
WDWHDGHDILXQXOLQYHUVXOFHOXLODOW$LFLSULQÄLQYHUV´vQĠHOHJHPQXPăUXOIRUPDWGLQ
FLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLGDWvQRUGLQHLQYHUVă
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
'DWHGHLHúLUH
ÌQVFRSXOIRUPăULLGHSULQGHULORUGHDOXFUDFXVXESURJUDPHYăUHFRPDQGăPVă
ÌQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH "+&'(!VHYRUVFULHSHUHFKLOHGHQXPHUHFkWHXQDSHILHFDUH
UH]ROYDĠL PDMRULWDWHD SUREOHPHORU WUDWDWH SkQă DFXP vQ FDUH SUREOHPD LQLĠLDOă VH
OLQLHGHVSăUĠLWHSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLX
GHVFRPSXQHvQVXESUREOHPHIRORVLQGVXESURJUDPH
UH]ROYDĠLSUREOHPHvQFDUHXQDFHODúLVXESURJUDPVHDSHOHD]ăvQPRGUHSHWDWSHQ
WUXGDWHGLIHULWH ([HPSOX
"+&'(!
UHDOL]DĠLXQXQLWSURSULXFDUHFRQĠLQHWRDWHSUREOHPHOHUH]ROYDWHFXVXESURJUDPHúL `J`J
VFULHUHDXQRUSURJUDPHFDUHIRORVHVFDFHVWXQLW `J`J
JJ
JJ
J
6XESURJUDPH 6XESURJUDPH
(OLPLQDUHGHQXPHUHSHUIHFWHúLSULHWHQH 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVH
6HFRQVLGHUăXQúLUGHQXPHUHQDWXUDOH6ăVHHOLPLQHGLQDFHVWúLUWRDWHQXPHUHOHSHU
IHFWHSUHFXPúLSHUHFKLOHGHQXPHUHSULHWHQHDIODWHSHSR]LĠLLFRQVHFXWLYH
&LIUHFRPXQH
9HUVLXQHDGHDOJRULWPSUH]HQWDWăvQFRQWLQXDUHVHED]HD]ăSHRSHUDĠLLOHFXPXOĠLPLÌQ
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
DFHVWFD]HVWHQHFHVDUXQVXESURJUDPFDUHVăFRQVWUXLDVFăRPXOĠLPHGLQFLIUHOHXQXL
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXL "&$VHDIOăHOHPHQWHOHúLUXOXLVHSDUDWHSULQVSDĠLL
QXPăU6XESUREOHPHOHFDUHYRUILLPSOHPHQWDWHFXVXESURJUDPHvQFD]XODFHVWHLSUR
EOHPHYRUIL
'DWHGHLHúLUH
x FLWLUHDQXPHUHORU
(OHPHQWHOH UăPDVH vQ úLU GXSă HOLPLQDUH VH YRU VFULH vQ ILúLHUXO "&'(! VHSDUDWH
x FUHDUHD PXOĠLPLL GH FLIUH PXOĠLPLOH OH LPSOHPHQWăP FX DMXWRUXO úLUXULORU GDU
SULQFkWHXQVSDĠLX
GXSă FH VH YD vQYăĠD WLSXO
vQ 3DVFDO VH UHFRPDQGă FD H[HUFLĠLX LPSOH
PHQWDUHDSURJUDPXOXLIRORVLQGDFHVWWLSGHVWUXFWXUăGHGDWH
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x DILúDUHDFLIUHORUDSDUĠLQkQGLQWHUVHFĠLHLGHPXOĠLPL
x dQUd J
ÌQ3DVFDOGHFODUDĠLDúLUXOXLFDUHUHSUH]LQWăPXOĠLPHDYDIL
([HPSOH
"&$ "&'(!J
J%
\`JJX
KJ
JJJJ`JJJ JJJ JX
Q%
KJ
*HQHUDUHDFXYkQWXOXLGHOXQJLPHPD[LPă 'DFă GH H[HPSOX YDORDUHD HOHPHQWXOXL HVWH DGHYăUDW vQVHDPQă Fă FLIUD J
6ăVHGHWHUPLQHFXYkQWXOGHOXQJLPHPD[LPăFDUHSRDWHILFRQVWUXLWGLQOLWHUHOHXQXL IDFHSDUWHGLQPXOĠLPHD
WH[W DVWIHO vQFkW FDUDFWHUHOH FXYkQWXOXL Vă ILH vQ RUGLQH DOIDEHWLFă úL Vă ILH FXOHVH GLQ J
WH[WH[DFWvQRUGLQHDvQFDUHVHDIOăvQFXYkQWQXQHDSăUDWSHSR]LĠLLVXFFHVLYH JĠ
ăQJJ ^VXESURJUDPWLSSURFHGXUă`J
JJ
J%
\`J
ăQJ ^GHRFDPGDWăPXOĠLPHD0HVWHYLGă`
'DWHGHLQWUDUH JJJJ%
JmJIDOV
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH(8&$VHDIOăWH[WXOGDW ú
JJ
JJ
J
ăJzJ`J
ăQJ
'DWHGHLHúLUH JJJJ%
JmJ
ă`J
&XYkQWXOGHWHUPLQDWFDUHDUHOXQJLPHPD[LPăVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXO(8&'(! JJJJ%
JmJDGHYăUDWJ ^FLIUD%
H[LVWăvQQXPăU`
JJJJ
ăJmJ
ă`J
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL ú
J
ú
x WH[WXODUHFHOPXOWGHFDUDFWHUH
J
x vQWH[WH[LVWăFXYLQWHIRUPDWHGLQOLWHUHPLFLDOHDOIDEHWXOXLHQJOH]úLVSDĠLL
,QWHUVHFĠLDPXOĠLPLL FX XHVWHXQúLUGHYDORULORJLFHXQGHXQHOHPHQWDUHYDORD
UHDDGHYăUDWGDFăFLIUDFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHVHUHJăVHúWHúLvQúLvQX
([HPSOX
(8&$ (8&'(!J
JJ% J
%ĠX
QJJ ^VXESURJUDPWLSSURFHGXUă`J
^GHRFDPGDWăLQWHUVHFĠLDHVWHYLGă`J
JJ
J%
\`J
ăQJ
JJJJ
%
JmJIDOV
ú
JJ
J
J
6XESURJUDPH 6XESURJUDPH
JJ
J%
\`J
ăQJ ^GDFăVDJăVLWFHOSXĠLQXQGLYL]RU!QXPăUXOQUQXHVWHSULP`
JJJJăJ%
JúJX%
JJ^GDFă%
VHDIOăúLvQ$úLvQ%`J JJăJJ\JJJJmJDGHYăUDWJ
JJJJJJ
%
JmJDGHYăUDWJ JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
JJmJIDOVJ
úă JJ úă
ú
JJ ú
ú J
J 'HWHUPLQDUHDQXPăUXOXLIRUPDWGLQFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLGDWvQRUGLQHLQYHUVăRSXWHP
3HQWUXDILúDUHYHULILFăPDSDUWHQHQĠDFLIUHLFLIUDFLIUD ODPXOĠLPHDLQ UHDOL]DFXVXEDOJRULWPXO
FDUHvQ3DVFDOYDILRIXQFĠLHFDUHYDUHWXUQDYDORD
WHUVHFĠLH
'DFăPXOĠLPHDHVWHYLGăDILúăPPHVDMXOFHUXWvQHQXQĠ UHDQXPăUXOXLQRX
J
ú
QJJ ^VXESURJUDPWLSSURFHGXUă`J
J
QJJ ^VXESURJUDPWLSIXQFĠLH`J
JJăJmJIDOVJ
JJ
J%
\`J
ăQJ JJ
JmJ`J
JJJJăJ
%
JJ JJ
J
JzJ`J
ă,
JJJJJJ
J%
J JJJJ%
JmJ
`J
JJJJJJăJmJDGHYăUDWJ ^DPJăVLWRFLIUăFRPXQă` JJJJ
JmJ
`J~J%
J
JJJJ úă JJJJ
JmJ
`J
ú
JJ ú
JJăJăJJ JJ
JmJ
J
JJJJ
JJJ%
J%
J ú
JJ úăJJ
ú JJ
#JQJ ^DOJRULWPXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUSURJUDPXOXLSULQFLSDO`J
3URJUDPXO SULQFLSDO YD DSHOD VXESURJUDPHOH vQ RUGLQHD ORU ILUHDVFă FLWLUH FUHDUH
J
ă\`J
ă,J
PXOĠLPH$FUHDUHPXOĠLPH%GHWHUPLQDUHLQWHUVHFĠLHúLDILúDUHDLQWHUVHFĠLHL JJJJăJ
ăJúJ
ăJ
J
ă
JJ
JJJJ úă
3ULPHúLÄLQYHUVHOH´ORUSULPH ú
2SULPăLGHHGHUH]ROYDUHDUILGHDJHQHUDSHUkQGWRDWHQXPHUHOHGHWUHLFLIUHGHOD ú
OD HYHQWXDO GH OD ODúLGHDYHULILFDGDFăDWkWQXPăUXOFkWúLDFHO
QXPăUFDUHFRQĠLQHFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLGDWvQRUGLQHLQYHUVăVXQWVDXQXQXPHUH SULPH ÌQXUPDH[HFXWăULLSURJUDPXOXLFDUHLPSOHPHQWHD]ăDFHVWDOJRULWPREVHUYăPFăIL
ÌQFD]DILUPDWLYDFHVWHDOHDPVFULHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH HFDUHSHUHFKHHVWHDILúDWăGHGRXăRUL'DFăGRULPVăHYLWăPDILúDUHDGXEOăHVWHQHFH
2EVHUYăPFăSHQWUXILHFDUHQXPăUVWXGLDWVXQWHPQHYRLĠLVăYHULILFăPGHGRXăRUL VDUăPRGLILFDUHDDOJRULWPXOXL
GDFăXQQXPăUHVWHSULPRGDWăSHQWUXQXPăUXOGDWDGRXDRDUăSHQWUXQXPăUXOJHQH 'DFăSXQHPFRQGLĠLDFDSULPDFLIUăDSULPXOXLQXPăUVăILHPDLPLFăVDXHJDOăFX
UDWGLQFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLOXDWHvQRUGLQHLQYHUVă$FHVWDHVWHXQPRWLYVXILFLHQWGHSX XOWLPDFLIUăDSULPXOXLQXPăUYRPHYLWDDILúăULOHGXEOH$OGRLOHDQXPăUVHFRQVWUX
WHUQLFSHQWUXDVFULHXQVXEDOJRULWPSHQWUXYHULILFDUHDSULPDOLWăĠLLXQXLQXPăU6XESUR LHúWHvQWRWGHDXQDGLQSULPXOúLGHFLQXHVWHQHFHVDUVăSXQHPFRQGLĠLLDVXSUDOXL1X
JUDPXOYDILDSHODWRGDWăSHQWUXQXPăUXOGDWúLDSRLSHQWUXÄLQYHUVXO´VăX PHUHOHGLQSHUHFKLDVWIHOFRQVWUXLWHYRUILJHQHUDWHFUHVFăWRU,QVWUXFĠLXQHDDOWHUQDWLYă
J
GLQVWUXFWXUDGHWLS
VDUSXWHDVFULHDVWIHO
J
QJJ ^VXESURJUDPWLSIXQFĠLH`J ă
ă``JdJ
ă`J&&&J
JJJmJSDUWHvQWUHDJăGLQUăGăFLQDSăWUDWăDOXLQUJ ÌQDFHVWDOJRULWPLQVWUXFĠLXQHD
VHYDUHOXDGH± RUL
JJJmJJ
JJ
J
QXVHvPSDUWHH[DFWODJ
ă,J ÌQWURDOWăDERUGDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHJHQHUăPSULPXOQXPăUGLQFLIUHOHDEúLFúL
JJJJJmJJJJ DOGRLOHDGLQDFHOHDúLFLIUHGDUvQRUGLQHLQYHUVăĠLQkQGFRQWWRWRGDWăúLGHFRQGLĠLDFD
ú
J
SULPDFLIUăVăILHPDLPDUHVDXHJDOăFXDWUHLD$FHDVWăYDULDQWăDUHúLDYDQWDMXOGHD
6XESURJUDPH 6XESURJUDPH
HYLWDJHQHUDUHDGXEOXULORUIăUăDIRORVLRFRQGLĠLHVXSOLPHQWDUă'HDVHPHQHDQXYRP 3URSULHWăĠLOHQXPHUHORUFDUHWUHEXLHHOLPLQDWH
OXD vQ FRQVLGHUDUH FD SRVLELO QXPăU DYkQG SURSULHWDWHD VROLFLWDWă GHFkW QXPHUHOH x QXPăUSHUIHFWHVWHHJDOFXVXPDGLYL]RULORUPDLPLFLGHFkWHOvQVXúL
LPSDUH8QQXPăULPSDUDUHXOWLPDFLIUăLPSDUăGHFLvQFLFOXO FDUHJHQHUHD]ăD x QXPHUHSULHWHQHSHUHFKLGHQXPHUHvQFDUHXQQXPăUHVWHHJDOFXVXPDGLYL]RULORU
WUHLDFLIUăVHYRUFRQVWUXLQXPHUHGRDUFXFHOHFLIUHLPSDUH FHOXLODOWPDLPLFLGHFkWDFHVWDúLLQYHUVYH]LFDSLWROXO
$VWIHOQXPăUXOH[HFXWăULORUFRUSXOXLFLFOXOXLHVWH FDUHHVWHPDL
PLFGHFkWQXPăUXOH[HFXWăULORUvQFD]XOSULPHLYDULDQWHÌQSOXVDFHDVWăYDULDQWă 6HREVHUYăFăvQDPEHOHVLWXDĠLLHVWHQHYRLHGHVXPDGLYL]RULORUSURSULLSOXVDL
QXQHFHVLWăDSHOXOVXEDOJRULWPXOXL
GHRDUHFHLQYHUVXOQXPăUXOXLSRDWHILFRQ QXPăUXOXL'HFLYDILXWLOVăVFULHPXQVXESURJUDPFDUHFDOFXOHD]ăDFHDVWăVXPă
VWUXLWSULQWURVLPSOăDWULEXLUH6XEDOJRULWPXOGHYHULILFDUHDSULPDOLWăĠLLVHYDH[HFXWD
J
ăQJJ ^VXESURJUDPWLSIXQFĠLH`J
GRDUGHGHRULGHRDUHFHGDFăGHVSUH
ăVHFRQVWDWăFăQXHVWHSULPQXPăUXO JJJmJJJ ^vQDFHDVWăVXPăVHDGDXJăúL`
QXVHPDLYHULILFă JJ
J\
ăJ
ă,J
JJJJăJ
ăJ\J`JJ
#Jú
QJ JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
JJ
J\J
ă,J ^SULPDFLIUăGLQQXPăUQXSRDWHIL`J JJJJ úă
JJJJ
J\`JJJ
ă,J JJ ú
^XOWLPDFLIUăWUHEXLHVăILHFHOSXĠLQHJDOăFXSULPDFLIUă` JJJmJJ
JJJJJJ
J%\JJJ
ă,JJ úJ J
JJJJJJJJăJ%HVWHQXPăULPSDU^OLPLWăPJHQHUDUHDODQXPHUHLPSDUH`J J
JJJJJJJJJJ
ăJmJ``J~J`J~J%J &HOH GRXă VXESURJUDPH FDUH YHULILFă GDFă XQ QXPăU HVWH SHUIHFW UHVSHFWLY GDFă
JmJ%``J~J`J~JJ GRXăQXPHUHGDWHVXQWSULHWHQHYRUUHWXUQDRYDORDUHGHDGHYăUDGHYăUDWVDXIDOV
ăJ
ăJúJ
J
J
ă
JJ J
%
ăQJ ^VXESURJUDPWLSIXQFĠLH`J
úă JJăJ
ăJ\J
ăJJJ
úă JJJJ
%JmJDGHYăUDWJ
ú
JJ
JJ
ú
JJJJ
%JmJIDOVJ
ú
J JJ úă
ú ú
J
ă
ăQJJ ^VXESURJUDPWLSIXQFĠLH`J
(OLPLQDUHGHQXPHUHSHUIHFWHúLSULHWHQH ă
ăJ\J
ăJú
&HULQĠDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHHVWHGHDHOLPLQDGLQWUXQúLUQXPHUHOHSHUIHFWHVDXSHUHFKLOH
ăJ\J
ăJJJ
GHQXPHUHSULHWHQHDIODWHSHSR]LĠLLFRQVHFXWLYHvQúLU6HREVHUYăFăDFĠLXQHDSULQFL JJJJ
JmJDGHYăUDWJ
SDOăHVWHGHDHOLPLQDXQXOVDXGRXăHOHPHQWHGLQWUXQúLUSHED]DXQHLFRQGLĠLLGDWH JJ
J
JmJIDOVJ
6XEDOJRULWPXO"
YDHOLPLQDHOHPHQWXODYkQGLQGLFHOHSR]LĠLHGLQúLUXODúLYD JJ úă
UHWXUQDúLUXOPRGLILFDWSUHFXPúLGLPHQVLXQHDDFWXDOL]DWăDDFHVWXLD ú
J"
ĠQJJ ^VXESURJUDPWLSSURFHGXUă`J
JJ
\Ġ
J
ă, ^VHGHSODVHD]ăHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXL` *HQHUDUHFXYkQWGHOXQJLPHPD[LPă
JJJJJmJ~JJ ^FXRSR]LĠLHODVWkQJDvQFHSkQGFXĠJ~J` ÌQUH]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHDYHPQHYRLHGHGRXăWDEORXULGHOXFUX
JJ ú
x (OHPHQWHOHúLUXOXL/YRUILOXQJLPLGHFXYLQWH/LSăVWUHD]ăOXQJLPHDFHDPDLPDUH
JJ
JmJ
JJJJ ^QXPăUXOGHHOHPHQWHVFDGH` SRVLELOăDFXYkQWXOXLFDUHvQFHSHFXOLWHUDFDUHvQWH[WVHDIOăSHSR]LĠLDL$FHVWH
ú FXYLQWHWUHEXLHVăUHVSHFWHFHULQĠDFDOLWHUHOHGLQFRPSRQHQĠDORUVăILHvQRUGLQH
J DOIDEHWLFă
6XESURJUDPH 6XESURJUDPH
x 7DEORXOXUPvOFRQVWUXLPSHQWUXDDVLJXUDSRVLELOLWDWHDGHDDILúDFHOPDLOXQJFX J J J J % J J J J
J
YkQWJăVLWXUPLYDFRQĠLQHSHQWUXDLDOLWHUăGLQFHOPDLOXQJFXYkQWLQGLFHOHvQ
%J J J | J ` J J
WH[WXOGDWDOLWHUHLXUPăWRDUHvQFXYkQW J J J J J J J J J J `J J J J
J J J J J J J J J `J J `J
7H[WXOGDWvOYRPSDUFXUJHGHODVIkUúLWVSUHvQFHSXWFHHDFHvQVHDPQăFăYRPLQLĠL
DOL]DYDORDUHD/QFXDYkQGVHPQLILFDĠLDFăFHOPDLOXQJFXYkQWFDUHvQFHSHFXDQD /LWHUD QXSRDWHILSXVăvQIDĠDOXL vQVFKLPESRDWHILSXVăvQIDĠDOXL úL
OLWHUă GLQ WH[W DUH OXQJLPHD 'H DVHPHQHD SXWHP LQLĠLDOL]D úLYDORDUHDHOHPHQWXOXL 3URFHGăPFXOLWHUD ODIHOFXPDPSURFHGDWFX/LWHUHOHúLQXSRWILSXVHvQIDĠD
XUPQFXGHRDUHFHúWLPFăGXSăXOWLPXOHOHPHQWQXSRDWHXUPDQLFLXQXO QLFLXQHLDGLQWUHOLWHUHOHOXDWHvQFRQVLGHUDUHSkQăDFXPGHFLYDORULOHFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH
ORUVXQWvQúLUXO/úLvQúLUXOXUP/LWHUD%SRDWHILSXVăvQIDĠDWXWXURUFDUDFWHUHORU
J J J J % J J J
J DOHJHPDFHDSRVLELOLWDWHFDUHGăQDúWHUHODXQFXYkQWPDLOXQJ$FHDVWDHVWH &RQWL
%J J J | ` J J QXkQGDFHVWSURFHGHXSkQăODHSXL]DUHDúLUXOXLDMXQJHPODXUPăWRDUHOHYDORULvQFHOH
J J J J J J J J J J J J J J GRXăúLUXUL/úLXUP
J J J J J J J J J J J J J `J
J J J J J % J J J J J
J
ÌQFHOHFHXUPHD]ăYRPFăXWDVăGHWHUPLQăPDFHOFHOPDLOXQJFXYkQWvQIDĠDFăUXLD
%J J J J | J J ` J J
HVWHSHUPLVVăDOLSLPDLDOLWHUăGLQWH[WXOGDW(YLGHQWDFHDVWDGDFăHVWHSHUPLVQX J |J J |J ` J J `J J J J
SRDWHILODDFHVWSDVGHFkWXOWLPDOLWHUăÌQFRQFOX]LH/YDILHJDOFXFHOPDLOXQJ J |J J |J ` ` ` `J J `J
FXYkQWFDUHvQFHSHFXDDOLWHUăGLQWH[WDUHOXQJLPHDLDUXUPYDILGXSăD
DOLWHUăXUPHD]ăDD 'XSăFHDPFRQVWUXLWDFHVWHGRXăúLUXULOXQJLPHDFHOXLPDLOXQJFXYkQWHVWHHJDO
FXYDORDUHDHOHPHQWXOXLPD[LPGLQúLUXO/'HRDUHFHQRLWUHEXLHVăDILúăPQXOXQJL
J J J J % J J J
J PHD FL FXYkQWXO YRP SURFHGD vQ IHOXO XUPăWRU $ILúăP DFHO FDUDFWHU GLQ WH[W FDUH
%J J J | ` J J DUHLQGLFHOHHJDOFXLQGLFHOHHOHPHQWXOXLPD[LPGLQúLUXO/FXDFHDVWăOLWHUăvQFHSHFHO
J J J J J J J J J J J J J J PDLOXQJFXYkQW(OHPHQWXOúLUXOXLXUPDYkQGDFHVWLQGLFHFRQĠLQHLQGLFHOHOLWHUHLXU
J J J J J J J J J J J J J `J PăWRDUHFDUHVHDILúHD]ă8UPăULQGDVWIHOFRQĠLQXWXOúLUXOXLXUPDILúăPOLWHUHOHFHOXL
PDL OXQJ FXYkQW SkQă OD VIkUúLWXO DFHVWXLD YDORDUHD FRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH XOWLPHL OLWHUH vQ
6WXGLHPOLWHUD $FHDVWDQXSRDWHILSXVăvQIDĠDOLWHUHL GHRDUHFHvQFDOFăFHULQĠD úLUXOXUPHVWH
SULYLQG RUGRQDUHD DOIDEHWLFă GDU VH SRDWH SXQH vQ IDĠD OLWHUHL
'HFL FHO PDL OXQJ
JJJJJJăJJzJJJúJJzJJJúJJ 6WLYDRVWUXFWXUăGHGDWHVSHFLDOă
J J J JJJJ 2SHUDĠLLFXVWLYH
(YDOXDUHDH[SUHVLLORUDULWPHWLFH
JJJJJJJJăJJ
JJJ ^GLQWUHOLWHUHOHvQIDĠDFăURUDVHSRDWH` 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
^SXQHDLDOLWHUăRDOHJHPSHFHDFXFDUHvQFHSHFHOPDLOXQJFXYkQW` 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
JJJJJJJJJJJmJJ
JJJJJJJJJJ
%JmJJ
JJJJJJJJ úă
JJJJJJ úă 'HILQLĠLH
JJJJ ú
3ULQVWLYăvQĠHOHJHPRVWUXFWXUăOLQLDUăGHGDWHvQFDUHDWkWRSHUDĠLLOHGHLQWURGXFH
ăJzJJ UHFkWúLFHOHGHH[WUDJHUHVHHIHFWXHD]ăQXPDLODXQXOGLQWUHFDSHWHQXPLWYkUI9
^FHOPDLOXQJFXYkQWFDUHvQFHSHFXDLDOLWHUăHVWHHJDOăFXOXQJLPHDFHOXLPDL`J 3HFHOăODOWFDSăWvOQXPLPED]ă%
JJJJJJJmJJ~J^OXQJFXYkQWvQIDĠDFăUXLDSXQHPDLDOLWHUă` 0RGXOvQFDUHLQWUăúLLHVHOHPHQWHOHGLQVWLYăMXVWLILFăúLGHQXPLUHDGHOLVWă/,)2
JJJJ
/DVW,Q±)LUVW2XW
JmJ`J ^GDFăDPDYXWFDUDFWHUVSDĠLX`
úăJ 9 9
JJJJJmJ
%J ^vQ
%DPĠLQXWPLQWHvQIDĠDFăUHLOLWHUHRSXQHP`
m YI
ú
HOHPHQWQRX HOHPHQWHOLPLQDW
JJJJJJJJJJJ ^FăXWăPOXQJLPHDPD[LPăGLQ/` m YI
JJ%J
ú
ÌQVXEDOJRULWPXOGHDILúDUHLQGLFHUHSUH]LQWăLQGLFHOHHOHPHQWXOXLPD[LPvQúLUXO/ % %
J%QJ 3UHOXFUDUHDXQHLVWLYHQHFHVLWăSăVWUDUHDúLJHVWLRQDUHDXQXLLQGLFDWRUGHVWLYăYI
2VWLYăVHQXPHúWHYLGăGDFăQXFRQĠLQHQLFLXQHOHPHQWYI %
JJ
J
%J ^DILúăPOLWHUDFXFDUHvQFHSHFHOPDLOXQJFXYkQW` 2VWLYăVHQXPHúWHSOLQăGDFăVSDĠLXOGHPHPRULHUH]HUYDWDFHVWXLDHVWHXWLOL]DW
JJJJJmJ
%J ^LQGLFHOHOLWHUHLXUPăWRDUH` vQvQWUHJLPHYI 9
JJJJ
JJ
J`J
ăQJJ ^FkWWLPSH[LVWăXUPăWRU`
JJJJJJ
JJ 2LPDJLQHVXJHVWLYăDXQHLVWLYHvQWkOQLWăvQYLDĠDGH]LFX]LHVWHFHDDXQHLVWLYH
GH Oă]L FX PHUH Oă]LOH VXQW DúH]DWH XQD SHVWH DOWD $FHVWHD ILLQG IRDUWH JUHOH QX
JJJJJJJmJJ ^LQGLFHOHOLWHUHLFDUHXUPHD]ăGXSăFHDDILúDWă` SHUPLW GHFkW H[WUDJHUHD Oă]LL GH GHDVXSUD VWLYHL VDX DGăXJDUHD XQHL Oă]L SHVWH FHOH
ú
GHMDH[LVWHQWH
ú
6XESURJUDPHOH úL %IDFSDUWHGLQ]RQDGHGHFODUDĠLLDVXESURJUDPXOXL
$VWIHO WRDWH YDULDELOHOH GHFODUDWH vQ VXQW DFFHVLELOH GLQ VXESURJUDPHOH
úL%DFHVWHDQHDYkQGDVWIHOQHYRLHGHSDUDPHWUL
6WLYD 6WLYD
,PSOHPHQWDUHDVWLYHORUVHSRDWHUHDOL]DXúRUSULQXWLOL]DUHDXQXLWDEORXXQLGLPHQ 'DFă GRULP Vă DGăXJăP XQ HOHPHQW QRX vQ VWLYD VW PDL vQWkL YRP FUHúWH QXPăUXO
VLRQDOvQFD]XOFăUXLDYRPGHFODUD HOHPHQWHORUYIDúLUXOXLFDUHLPSOHPHQWHD]ăVWLYDúLDGăXJăPSHDFHDVWăSR]LĠLHYD
' ORDUHD GH LQWURGXV FH ÌQDLQWH GH DGăXJDUHD XQXL HOHPHQW WUHEXLH Vă YHULILFăP GDFă
LP6WLYăRFRQVWDQWăFDUHUHSUH]LQWăGLPHQVLXQHDPD[LPăDVWLYHL VWLYDQXFXPYDHVWHGHMDSOLQă$FHDVWăYHULILFDUHRUHDOL]ăPvQXQLWDWHDGHSURJUDP
V FDUHDSHOHD]ăVXEDOJRULWPXOGHDGăXJDUHSHQWUXDHYLWDvQFHUFDUHDLQWURGXFHULLXQXL
W YD IL R VWLYă GHFODUDWă VXE IRUPD XQXL WDEORX XQLGLPHQVLRQDO DYkQG HOHPHQWH HOHPHQWQRXvQFD]GHVWLYăSOLQă
LQGH[DWHGHODOD'LP6WLYă
Y Jă ¡
ă
%QJJ
ILQGLFDWRUXOGHVWLYăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOFXSULQVvQWUHúL'LP6WLYă JJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ
JJJJ
JmJ%J
ú
2SHUDĠLLFXVWLYH
([WUDJHUHDXQXLHOHPHQWGLQVWLYă
9HULILFDUHDGDFăVWLYDHVWHYLGă ÌQXUPDH[WUDJHULLXQXLHOHPHQWGLQWURVWLYăREĠLQHPILHRVWLYăYLGăGDFăDPH[WUDV
$FHDVWă RSHUDĠLH R YRP UHDOL]D FX VXEDOJRULWPXO ă£ă
FDUH UHWXU XOWLPXOHOHPHQWILHXQDFDUHDUHXQHOHPHQWPDLSXĠLQIDĠăGHVLWXDĠLDDQWHULRDUăH[
QHD]ăYDORDUHDDGHYăUDWvQFD]XOvQFDUHVWLYDHVWHYLGăúLIDOVvQFD]FRQWUDU WUDJHULL'HDVHPHQHDvQYDULDELODFHYRPDYHDFRQĠLQXWXODFHVWXLHOHPHQWvQGHSăUWDW
GLQYkUIXOVWLYHL$FHDVWăRSHUDĠLHQXSRDWHILHIHFWXDWăGHFkWGDFăVWLYDQXHVWHYLGă
Jă£ă
QJJ ^VXEDOJRULWPGHWLSIXQFĠLHERROHDQă`J
GLIHULW GH FRQGLĠLH FDUH VH YD YHULILFD vQ XQLWDWHD GH SURJUDP DSHODQWă DO
JJăJ
J\J`J VXESURJUDPXOXL"
ă
%
JJJJă£ăJmJDGHYăUDW
JJ
J"
ă
%QJJ
JJJJă£ăJmJIDOVJJJ JJ%JmJ
J
JJ úJă JJ
JmJ
JJJ
ú ú
J
5HSUH]HQWDUHDFHDPDLVXJHVWLYăDXQHLVWLYHVHIDFHSHYHUWL
9HULILFDUHDGDFăVWLYDHVWHSOLQă FDOăED]DVWLYHLILLQGMRVLDUYkUIXOFDSăWXOvQFDUHSXWHPDFĠLR
3HQWUXDUHDOL]DDFHDVWăRSHUDĠLHYRPIRORVLVXEDOJRULWPXO ă
ăFDUHGHDVH QDILLQGVXVDúDFXPVHYHGHvQILJXUDDOăWXUDWă
PHQHD UHWXUQHD]ă YDORDUHD DGHYăUDW vQ FD]XO vQ FDUH VWLYD HVWH SOLQă úL IDOV vQ FD] 6WLYD RYRPSăVWUDvQWUXQWDEORXXQLGLPHQVLRQDOED]DVWLYHL
FRQWUDU ILLQGFDSăWXOGLQVWkQJDLDUYkUIXOILLQGUHSUH]HQWDWvQFDSăWXOGLQ
Jă
ă
QJ GUHDSWD
JJăJ
J\JăJ
JJJJă
ăJmJDGHYăUDW
([HPSOX
JJ
$P GHFODUDW XQ úLU DYkQG HOHPHQWH LQGH[DWH GH OD OD ED]D
,QLĠLDOL]DUHDVWLYHLFRQVWăvQLQLĠLDOL]DUHDYkUIXOXLYI
JJJJă
ăJmJIDOVJJJ
JJ úJă YI ,QWURGXFHPvQVWLYăQX YI
ú
PăUXOFH DFXPYI
ÌQFHOHFHXUPHD]ăYDORDUHDGLQYkUIXOVWLYHLYDILUHIHULWăSULQ
,QWURGXFHPvQVWLYăFH
,QWURGXFHUHDXQXLHOHPHQWvQVWLYă DFXPYI
6WLYD
YI ,QWURGXFHPvQVWLYăQX YI
PăUXOQU DFXPYI
([WUDJHPHOHPHQWXOGLQYkUIXOVWLYHLREĠLQHPFH úLDFXPYI
YDULDELOHORUFLWLWHGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH 2EVHUYăPFăUH]XOWDWXOGRULWHVWHFRQVWUXLWSULQFXOHJHUHDUHVWXULORUvQRUGLQHLQYHU
ÌQ FD]XO vQ FDUH H[SUHVLD QX HVWH FRUHFW VFULVă ILúLHUXO GH LHúLUH YD FRQĠLQH QXPDL VăÌQFRQFOX]LH
PHVDMXO"J
%%ă
3HQWUXDUHDOL]DFRQYHUVLDXQXLQXPăUGLQWURED]ăvQDOWDDPSXWHDIRORVLRYDULD
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL ELOăvQFDUHDPSăVWUDSXWHUHDOXLFDUHFRUHVSXQGHUDQJXOXLDFHOHLFLIUHDSRLODILH
x H[SUHVLDFLWLWăDUHFHOPXOWGHFDUDFWHUH FDUHSDVDPDGXQDODUH]XOWDWFLIUDvQPXOĠLWăFXDFHDVWăSXWHUH
x WRDWHYDORULOHYDULDELOHORUVXQWQXPHUHvQWUHJL
x H[SUHVLDQXFRQĠLQHRSHUDWRULXQDUL ([HPSOX
5HVW 3 5H]XOWDW
([HPSOH
9" &$ 9" &'(!
~J ~J
J|
6WLYD 6WLYD
'DFă UHVWXO vPSăUĠLULL U HVWH PDL PLF GHFkW FDUDFWHUXO FLIUă FRUHVSXQ]ăWRU YD
DYHDFRGXOHJDOFXFRGXOFDUDFWHUXOXL`SOXVUHVWXOREĠLQXWGLQvPSăUĠLUH
2VROXĠLHPXOWPDLQDWXUDOăDUFRQVWDvQSăVWUDUHDFLIUHORUvQWUXQYHFWRUSHPăVXUă FDUDFWHU `J |
FHDFHVWHDVHREĠLQDILúDUHDFLIUHORUIăFkQGXVHGXSăWHUPLQDUHDDOJRULWPXOXLvQRUGL FRG J J |`J |J |J |J |J ||J |J |J
QHLQYHUVăDREĠLQHULLORUÌQIXQFĠLHGHFHULQĠăGLQúLUXOFLIUHORUSDUFXUVGHODVIkUúLW
VSUHvQFHSXWVDUSXWHDFRQVWUXLúLQXPăUXOIRORVLQGVFKHPDOXL+RUQHU 'H H[HPSOX SHQWUX U FRGXO FDUDFWHUXOXL HVWH HJDO FX FRGXO FDUDFWHUXOXL
`SOXVUÌQOLPEDMXO3DVFDODFHDVWăH[SUHVLHVHVFULHDVWIHO
([HPSOX &`~
,QWURGXFHUHDFLIUHORU ÌQPRPHQWXO ÌQ PRG VLPLODU GDFă UHVWXO vPSăUĠLULL HVWH PDL PDUH VDX HJDO FX DFHVWVXUSOXV
vQWLPSXOFRQYHUVLHL WHUPLQăULL SHVWHHVWHDGXQDWODFRGXOFDUDFWHUXOXL REĠLQkQGXVHFRGXOOLWHUHLFRUHVSXQ]ă
FRQYHUVLHL WRDUHUHVWXOXL
([HPSOX
3HQWUXU VXUSOXVXOHVWH&RGXOOXLHVWH|DGXQăPúLREĠLQHPFDUH
UHSUH]LQWăFRGXOFDUDFWHUXOXL"
$ILúDUHDFLIUHORU ÌQ DOJRULWPXO SURSXV SHQWUX UH]ROYDUHD DFHVWHL SUREOHPH DP QRWDW FX QU QXPăUXO
REĠLQXWH
vQWUHJFDUHWUHEXLHFRQYHUWLWFXEED]DGHQXPHUDĠLHvQFDUHVHIDFHFRQYHUVLDFXUH]
úLUXOGHFDUDFWHUHvQFDUHREĠLQHPUH]XOWDWXOFRQYHUVLHL
J
2DVWIHOGHVWUXFWXUăvQFDUHDGăXJăPúLH[WUDJHPHOHPHQWHQXPDLODXQFDSăWVH J
QJ
QXPHúWHVWLYăÌQFD]XOvQFDUHVWLYDHVWHUHSUH]HQWDWăIRORVLQGXQúLURSHUDĠLLOHGHDGă JJJJmJJ
XJDUHúLH[WUDJHUHVXQWXúRUGHUHDOL]DWSULQDGăXJDUHDXQXLHOHPHQWQRXGXSăXOWLPXO JJ
ăJ
H[LVWHQWUHVSHFWLYSULQHOLPLQDUHDXOWLPXOXLHOHPHQWDGăXJDW JJJJ%JmJ
JJ ^FDOFXOăPFkWXOúLUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLODED]ă`
JJJJJmJ
JJ ^GLQFRQVWUXLPFLIUDFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHvQED]DE`J
([HPSOXODQDOL]DWDQWHULRUDIRVWUHDOL]DWSHQWUXRED]ăGHQXPHUDĠLHPDLPLFăGH JJJJăJJJ¥`¦JJJ
FkW6ăFRQVLGHUăPXQH[HPSOXQRXXQGHED]DGHQXPHUDĠLHVăILHPDLPDUHGHFkW JJJJJJ%JmJ&`J~JJ
&LIUHOHED]HLYRUDYHDYDORULOH2EVHUYăPFă JJJJ
JJJ
úL VXQW QXPHUH IRUPDWH GLQ PDL PXOWH FLIUHvQFRQFOX]LHQXSRWILXWLOL]DWHFD JJJJJJ%JmJ&J~JJJ`J
FLIUH DOH QXPăUXOXL UH]XOWDW ÌQ ORFXO ORU YRP IRORVL VLPEROXUL OLWHUH DOH DOIDEHWXOXL JJJJ úă
FRQIRUPXQHLFRQYHQĠLLELQHFXQRVFXWH JJJJ
JmJ%JJ ^VFKLPEăPYDORDUHDOXL
SHQWUXSDVXOXUPăWRU`J
YDILVLPEROL]DWSULQOLWHUD$ JJJJJmJ%J~JJJJJJ ^DGăXJăPFLIUDODUH]XOWDWRDOLSLP`
YDILVLPEROL]DWSULQOLWHUD% JJ
ă
J\J`J
ú
ÌQFD]XOXQRUED]HGHQXPHUDĠLHPDLPDULGHFkWYRUDSăUHDúLDOWHOLWHUHvQIXQF
ĠLHGHQXPăUXOGHYDORULFDUHVWDXODED]DVLVWHPXOXLGHQXPHUDĠLHUHVSHFWLYÌQHQXQĠ 7LMDFXELOH
VDVSHFLILFDWFăED]DGHQXPHUDĠLHHVWHPDLPLFăGHFkWGHFLFHDPDLPDUHSRDWHIL 'LQHQXQĠXOSUREOHPHLVHREVHUYăFăVHGRUHúWHXWLOL]DUHDDGRXăVWUXFWXULGHWLSVWLYă
FDUHQHFHVLWăGHVLPEROXULGHODFLIUDODÄFLIUD´3HQWUXFLIUHOHDFHVWHLED]H SHQWUXILHFDUHGLQFHOHGRXăWLMHÌQDFHDVWăVLWXDĠLHQHVXQWH[WUHPGHXWLOLVXEDOJRULW
YRPIRORVLFDUDFWHUHOHGHODODFDUDFWHUHúLGHOD$OD=FDUDFWHUH/LWHUD PLLGHLQWURGXFHUHvQVWLYăUHVSHFWLYH[WUDJHUHGLQVWLYăVXEDOJRULWPLDFăURUXWLOL]DUH
$FRUHVSXQGHÄFLIUHL´úL=ÄFLIUHL´ XúXUHD]ăPXOWvQWUHJXODOJRULWP$FHúWLVXEDOJRULWPLDXIRVWGHVFULúLvQSDUWHDWHRUHWLFă
3HQWUXUH]ROYDUHDSUREOHPHLHQXQĠDWHIRORVLPFDVWLYăXQúLUGHFDUDFWHUHGHRDUHFH DFDSLWROXOXLúLYRUILXWLOL]DĠLH[DFWvQDFHHDúLIRUPăúLvQXUPăWRDUHOHDSOLFDĠLLFXVWLYH
FLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLUH]XOWDWYRUILFDUDFWHUHFLIUHVDXOLWHUH 3HQWUXUHSUH]HQWDUHDVWUXFWXULLGHGDWHGHWLSVWLYăYRPGHFODUDXQWLSWDEORXXQLGL
6WLYD 6WLYD
PHQVLRQDODYkQGHOHPHQWHQXPHUHvQWUHJL9kUIXOVWLYHLYDILFRQVLGHUDWWRWWLPSXOLQ JJ
J
J
J`J
ăQJ J
GLFHOHXOWLPXOXLHOHPHQWDOúLUXOXL JJJJ"
ă
J
6XEDOJRULWPXOGHFUHDUHDVWLYHLFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHWLMHL JJJJă ¡
ă
J
J ú
Jă
QJ ^'LP6WLYD `J ú
JJ
JmJ`J ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHVWLYD`
^FLWLUHDQXPHUHORUúLFUHDUHDVWLYHLFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHWLMHL` 3HQWUX D SXWHD DILúD ELOHOH GH SH WLMD FRQIRUP FHULQĠHL GH OD YkUI VSUH ED]ă YD
JJ
JJ
%JJQJJ WUHEXLVăOHPXWăPGLQQRXSHWLMD'HILHFDUHGDWăFkQGYRPOXDvQPkQăRELOăYRP
JJJmJ`JJ ^YDULDELOăDX[LOLDUă`J VFULHQXPăUXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH
JJ
ILúLHUXOQXHVWHJROúJJJ
ă,J J
JJJJ
ú
J
J J
ú
QJJ
JJ
JJJJQJJ
JJJJJmJJ~JJ
JJJJ
J
JJ JJ
JmJ`J
JJJJă ¡
ă
J JJ
J
J
J`J
ă,J
ú
JJJJ"
ă
J
JJăJILúLHUXOQXHVWHJROJJJ ^QXDPSXWXWFLWLvQWUHJXOILúLHUGHLQWUDUH`J JJJJ
J
J ^VFULHUHDvQILúLHUDELOHORUUăPDVH`J
JJJJ
JJJ
J JJJJă ¡
ă
J
ú
JJJJ2SULUHIRUĠDWăDOJRULWP ú
JJ úăJ
ú J
6XEDOJRULWPXOvQFDUHVHUHDOL]HD]ăFăXWDUHDELOHLDYkQGHWLFKHWD[úLFUHDUHDVWLYHL %LOHFRORUDWH
FRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHWLMHL 5H]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHQHFHVLWăXWLOL]DUHDXQXLúLUGHQVWLYHvQFDUHYRUILSăVWUD
WHQXPHUHOHGHRUGLQHDOHELOHORUUHSDUWL]DWHSHFXORUL6XQWIRORVLWHGLQQRXSURFHGXUL
JăX
QJ OHFODVLFHGHLQWURGXFHUHvQVWLYăúLH[WUDJHUHGLQVWLYă
JJ
JmJ`J ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHVWLYD` 9RPGHFODUDWLSXOvQIHOXOXUPăWRU
JJ
JJ QJ ^H[WUDJHUHDGHSHWLMDDELOHORUSkQăOD`
^vQWkOQLUHDELOHLDYkQGFDHWLFKHWăQXPăUXOFăXWDW`J
J\JJXYKJ
JJ
J
J
J`JúJ
JzJJ
ă,J XQGHHVWHHJDOFXQXPăUPD[LPGHELOH
JJJJ"
ă
J
JJJJ
J
J ÌQVXEDOJRULWPLLGHUH]ROYDUHDPQRWDWFXVWLYHXQúLUGHVWLYHDYkQGFHOPXOW
JJJJă ¡
ă
J GHHOHPHQWHQXPăUXOPD[LPGHFXORULHVWH9kUIXULOHFHORUQVWLYHVXQWSăVWUDWH
JJ ú
J
vQúLUXOGHQXPHUHQDWXUDOHYkUIXUL6WLYDVWGHYkUIYkUIFXSULQGHLQLĠLDOFXORULOHWXWX
JJăJ
J\JJJ ^DPDMXQVODELODFăXWDWăFDUHVHHOLPLQă`J
URUELOHORUFLWLWH1XPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOELOHLFXUHQWHHVWHQUBELOD
JJJJ"
ă
J
JJJ%J%&J J
QJJ ^VHFUHHD]ăVWLYDLQLĠLDOăFXWRDWHELOHOH`J
úă JJ
JmJ`J
ú JJ
ú
J
JJJ ^QXPăUXOELOHORUúLFXORULORU`
JJ
\J
ă,J
%LOHOHUăPDVHSHWLMDOHYRPPXWDvQDSRLSHWLMD JJJJ
ú
J%JJ ^FXORDUHDELOHL`
JJJJă ¡
ă
%J
Jă
QJ ú
J J ^ELOHOHGHSHWLMDVXQWSXVHODORFSHWLMD` ú
6WLYD 6WLYD
^YDULDELOăDX[LOLDUăODVIkUúLWYDORDUHDHLVHDWULEXLHLGHQWLILFDWRUXOXLGHIXQFĠLH`J
6XEDOJRULWPXOGHUH]ROYDUHDSUREOHPHL JJ%JmJDGHYăUDW
J
J
QJ
JJăJ\JJJ ^SULPXOFDUDFWHUvOWUDWăPVHSDUDW`J
JJJJ%&JmJ%&J~JJ
JJ
J\
J
ă, ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDFHORUQVWLYH`
JJ úă
JJJJ
JmJ`J JJăJJ\JJJJ
ú
JJ
JJJJ%JmJIDOVJ
^OXăPELOHOHGHSHWLMDLQLĠLDOăúLOHGLVWULEXLPSHVWLYHFRQIRUPFXORULORU`J JJ úă
JJ
ăJmJJJ J
^VăQXvQFHDSăVDXVăQXVHWHUPLQHFXRSHUDWRU`
JJ
J
J`J
ă,J
JJJJ"
ă
%J JJăJHVWHRSHUDWRUJ J
HVWHRSHUDWRUJJ
JJJJă ¡
ă%
%
ăJ JJJJ%JmJIDOVJ
JJJJ
ăJmJ
ăJJJ úă
ú
JmJJ
ú JJ
JJdJ
JúJ%J
ă,J
J ăJJHVWHOLWHUăúHVWHRSHUDWRUúHVWHSDUDQWH]ăJJ
$ILúDUHDVWLYHORUOHYRPUHDOL]DFXDMXWRUXOVXEDOJRULWPXOXL"
ă JJJJJJ%JmJIDOVJ
6XEDOJRULWPXOGHDILúDUHvOFRQFHSHPSHQWUXDILúDUHDXQHLVLQJXUHVWLYHúLvOYRPDSHOD úăJJ
GLQSURJUDPXOSULQFLSDOSHQWUXFHOHQFXORUL'DFăYRUILVWLYHYLGHRDQXPLWăFXORDUH
OLSVHúWHvQVXEDOJRULWPXO"
ăYRPDILúDXQPHVDMFRUHVSXQ]ăWRU
J
úă
QJ ^GDFăQXPHOHXQHLYDULDELOHHVWHIRUPDWGLQPDLPXOWHOLWHUH`
J
J
J`J
ă,J JJJJăJHVWHOLWHUăJúJHVWHOLWHUăJ
JJJJ"
ă
ăKJ
%JmJIDOVJ
JJJJ
J
ăJ
JJJJ úă
ú
ú ^VDXGDFăH[LVWăGRLRSHUDWRULFHVHVXFFHGH[SUHVLDQXHVWHFRUHFWă`
JJJJăJHVWHRSHUDWRUJúJHVWHRSHUDWRUJJ
JJJJJJ%JmJIDOVJ
9DORDUHDXQHLH[SUHVLLDULWPHWLFH úă
ÌQSUH]HQWDUHDWHRUHWLFăVXVĠLQXWăFXH[HPSOHVHFRQWXUHD]ăWUHLHWDSHQHFHVDUHHYDOX JJJJăJJ\JJJJ ^VHQXPăUăSDUDQWH]HOHFkQGVHGHVFKLG`J
ăULLXQHLH[SUHVLL JJJJJJ%&JmJ%&J~JJ
x YHULILFDUHDFRUHFWLWXGLQLLH[SUHVLHL ^GDFăvQDLQWHDXQHLDYHPRYDULDELOăVDXH[SUHVLDQXHVWHFRUHFWă`
x WUDQVIRUPDUHDH[SUHVLHLvQWURIRUPăIăUăSDUDQWH]H ăJJHVWHOLWHUăJ JJ\JJJJ
x HYDOXDUHDSURSULX]LVăDH[SUHVLHL JJJJJJJJ%JmJIDOVJ
JJJJJJ úă
$OJRULWPLL GH UH]ROYDUH DOH FHORU WUHL VXESUREOHPH vL YRP GHVFULH VHSDUDW vQ WUHL JJJJ úă
VXEDOJRULWPL JJJJăJ\JJJ ^VHvQFKLGHRSDUDQWH]ăGHVFKLVă`J
JJJJJJăJ%&JdJ`JJJ ^GDFăVHvQFKLGHXQDQHGHVFKLVă`J
D9HULILFDUHDFRUHFWLWXGLQLLXQHLH[SUHVLL JJJJJJJJ%JmJIDOVJ
JJJJJJ
JJ
J%ăQJ JJJJJJJJ%&JmJ%&JJJ
JJ
JmJOXQJLPHDúLUXOXLGHFDUDFWHUHJ JJJJJJ úă
JJ%&JmJ`J ^GDFăvQIDĠDXQHLSDUDQWH]HvQFKLVHHVWHXQRSHUDWRU`
6WLYD 6WLYD
JJJJJJăJHVWHRSHUDWRUJJ ^RSHUDWRULLFXSULRULWDWHPDLPDUHVHVFRWGLQRSHUúLVHLQWURGXFvQSRORQ`
JJJJJJJJ%JmJIDOVJ JJJJJJ
JzJ`Jú
JJJJJJ úă
JJJ
ă,
úă JJJJJJJJ"
%J
JmJJ~J JJJJJJJJ
%J
ú
JJJJJJ ú
%%ăJmJ% JJJJJJ
JJ ^VHDGDXJăRSHUDWRUXOVDX±`
ú JJ úă
^FDUDFWHUXOFXUHQWHVWHSDUDQWH]ăvQFKLVăVHPXWăWRĠLRSHUDWRULL`
E$GXFHUHDH[SUHVLHLODIRUPDSRORQH]ăSRVWIL[DWă ^GLQRSHUvQSRORQSkQăODvQWkOQLUHDSDUDQWH]HLGHVFKLVHFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH`
9RPUHDOL]DRLPSOHPHQWDUHFDUHIRORVHúWHFHOHGRXăVWLYHSUH]HQWDWHvQVXSRUWXOWHR ^SDUDQWH]DGHVFKLVăVHHOLPLQăGLQRSHU`
UHWLF DO OHFĠLHL ÌQ YDULDELOD V FLWLP H[SUHVLD GDWă FX SDUDQWH]H LDU UH]XOWDWXO VH YD ăJJ\JJ ^H[SUHVLDGLQWUHGRXăSDUDQWH]HGHVFKLVH`
FRQVWUXL vQ UH]XOW DPEHOH YDULDELOH ILLQG GH WLS &HOH GRXă VWLYH RSHU úL ^VHPXWăvQSRORQúLVHHOLPLQăGLQRSHUSDUDQWH]DGHVFKLVă`
SRORQDXYkUIXULOHvQYIRSHUúLYISRORQ JJJJJJ
J
JzJJ
ă,J
JJJJJJJJ"
%J
J
ăQJ JJJJJJJJ
%J
JJ
JmJ`JJ JJJJJJ ú
JJ
JmJ`JJ JJJJJJ"
%JJ ^HOLPLQăPJ`J
JJĠJmJ¥¦JJ ^IRUPăPPXOĠLPHDQXPHORUGHYDULDELOHGLQH[SUHVLH` JJJJ úă
J\OXQJLPHDOXL
ă,^SUHOXFUăPILHFDUHFDUDFWHUDOH[SUHVLHL`J JJ ú
^FDUDFWHUXOOLWHUăVDXSDUDQWH]ăGHVFKLVăVHLQWURGXFHvQSRORQúLVHDGDXJăOD` ^WRWFHHDFHDUăPDVvQRSHUVHPXWăvQSRORQ`
^PXOĠLPHDGHOLWHUHGHFDUHYRPDYHDQHYRLHSHQWUXDFLWLYDORULOHYDULDELOHORU`
J
JzJ`J
ă,J
JJJJ"
%J
ăJHVWHOLWHUăJ
JJJJ
%J
JJJJJJ
JJ ^VHDGDXJăvQSRORQ` ú
JJJJJJĠJmJĠJJJ ú
úă J
ăJJ\JJ F(YDOXDUHDXQHLH[SUHVLLDIODWHvQIRUPăSRORQH]ăSRVWIL[DWă
JJJJJJ
JJ ^VHDGDXJăvQRSHU` 3HQWUXvQFHSXWVHFRQVWUXLHúWHXQúLUYGLQYDORULOHYDULDELOHORUGLQH[SUHVLHvQRUGLQHD
úă vQFDUHDSDUvQH[SUHVLH3R]LĠLLOHFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHRSHUDWRULORUVDXSDUDQWH]HORUVHLQL
^FDUDFWHUXORSHUDWRUVHLQWURGXFHvQRSHU` ĠLDOL]HD]ăFXYDORDUHD
^GRLRSHUDWRULFRQVHFXWLYLGHDFHHDúLSULRULWDWHVHLQYHUVHD]ă` ([SUHVLDILLQGvQIRUPăSRORQH]ăSRVWIL[DWăODILHFDUHSDVFăXWăPSULPXORSHUDWRU
ăJJ\JJ JJ\JJ JJ\J¤J SHQWUXDHIHFWXDvQWkLDFHDRSHUDĠLH
ăJ
JzJ`Jú ÌQDOJRULWPQRWăPFXQOXQJLPHDH[SUHVLHLGHFLúLDúLUXOXLYLDUvQUH]FDOFXOăP
J\JJ
YDORDUHDH[SUHVLHL9DULDELODORJLFăJDWDYDSULPLYDORDUHDDGHYăUDWvQPRPHQWXOvQ
JJJJJJJJ"
%J
JJJJJJJJ
%J FDUH VD WHUPLQDW FDOFXODUHD YDORULL H[SUHVLHL 'XSă HIHFWXDUHD XQHLRSHUDĠLLVHúWHUJH
úă XQXOGLQWUHRSHUDQ]LGHH[HPSOXDOGRLOHDSUHFXPúLRSHUDWRUXOHIHFWXDWDWkWGLQH[
JJJJJJ
J SUHVLHFkWúLGLQúLUXOY9DORDUHDFDOFXODWăVHDúHD]ăvQúLUXOYSHSR]LĠLDFRUHVSXQ]ă
úă WRDUHYDULDELOHLSăVWUDWH
^RSHUDWRULLFXSULRULWDWHPLFăVHPXWăGLQRSHUvQSRORQSkQăFkQG` &kQGúLUXOHYDOXăULORUVDvQFKHLDWDYHPRVLQJXUăYDULDELOăDFăUHLYDORDUHHVWHYD
^vQYkUIXOVWLYHLRSHUQXVHYDPDLDIODXQRSHUDWRUVDX¤` ORDUHDH[SUHVLHLGDWH2EVHUYăPFăLGHQWLILFDWRUXOYDULDELOHLQXDUHQLFLRVHPQLILFDĠLH
ăJJ\J~J JJ\JJJ SHQWUXUH]XOWDW
6WLYD
JQJ ^UHWXUQHD]ăXQvQWUHJ`
JJ
J\
J
ă,J
JJJJăJHVWHOLWHUăJ
JJJJJJJmJYDORDUHDQXPHULFăDYDULDELOHLDYkQGLGHQWLILFDWRUXOvQJJJ
JJJJ
JJ
JJJJJJJmJ`J
JJJJ úă
JJ ú
JJ
ă ^FăXWăPSULPXORSHUDWRUSHQWUXDHIHFWXDvQWkLDFHDRSHUDĠLH`J
JJJJJmJJ
JJJJ
JJzJ~JúJJzJJúJzJJúJJ
J JzJJúJJz¤J JJ
J
ă,JJ
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
JJJJ ú
J ^HIHFWXăPRSHUDĠLD`
JJJJăJJ\J~JJJmJJ~JJ 6WLYD
JJJJJJăJJ\JJJJmJJJJ JJJJ úă
JJJJJJ
JJJ JJ
ă
JJJJJJJJăJJ\JJJJmJJ ^DPUăPDVFXRVLQJXUăYDULDELOăFDUHFRQĠLQHYDORDUHDH[SUHVLHL`
JJJmJJ
JJJJJJJJJJăJ\JJJmJJ ú
JJJJJJJJJJ
JJJJJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJăJJ\J¤JJJmJJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJ úăJ
JJJJJJJJJJ úă
úă
úă
JJJJ úă
JJJJăJJ\J
JúHVWHOLWHUăJJ JmJDGHYăUDWJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
J JmJIDOVJJ
JJJJăJJ J
^úWHUJHPXQXOGLQWUHRSHUDQ]LúLRSHUDWRUXOHIHFWXDWGLQH[SUHVLHúLGLQúLUXOY`
VHúWHUJGLQGRXăFDUDFWHUHvQFHSkQGFXSR]LĠLDJ
^YDORDUHDFDOFXODWăGHYLQHvQúLUXOYYDORDUHDYDULDELOHLSăVWUDWH`
JJJJJJJmJJ
^úWHUJHPGLQYGRXăHOHPHQWHvQFHSkQGFXSR]LĠLD`J
JJJJJJ
J?\
J
ă,
JJJJJJJJ?JmJ?~J
JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
JJJ
JJJJJJ ú
2UGRQăULúLFăXWăUL
JJJJJJJJJmJ~J
JJJJJJJJ~JmJJ
JJJJJJ úă
ú
ăJ?J
ú J
2UGRQăULúLFăXWăUL &DSLWROXO
)LHGHH[HPSOXWDEORXO$DYkQGHOHPHQWHQXPHUHUHDOHúL
$OJRULWPLGHRUGRQDUH
$OJRULWPLGHFăXWDUH
,QWHUFODVDUHDDGRXăWDEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOH 3ULPDSDUFXUJHUHDWDEORXOXLRNHVWHLQLĠLDOL]DWFXDGHYăUDW
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH D D D D D RN
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
IDOV
IDOV
2UGRQăUL UăPkQ QHVFKLPEDWH ! OH LQWHUVFKLPEăP 'HRDUHFH
)LH$ DDDQXQWDEORXXQLGLPHQVLRQDOFXQHOHPHQWH$RUGRQDVRUWDWDEORXO DYDQVăPúLFRQVWDWăPFă!GHFLGLQQRXDYHPLQWHUVFKLPEDUHÌQFRQVHFLQĠă
vQVHDPQăDRUGRQDFUHVFăWRUVDXGHVFUHVFăWRUHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXL ODLHúLUHGLQVWUXFWXUD
RNHVWHIDOV2EVHUYăPFăDDMXQVSHORFXOOXLGHIL
ÌQFDUWHDOXL'.QXWKÄ$UWDSURJUDPăULLFDOFXODWRDUHORU´YRO,,,&ăXWăULúLRUGR QLWLY8UPHD]ăDGRXDSDUFXUJHUHDWDEORXOXLRNSULPHúWHGLQQRXYDORDUHDDGHYăUDW
QăULVXQWSUH]HQWDWHGHPHWRGHGHRUGRQDUH'LQWUHDFHVWHDYRPvQYăĠDGRDUFkWHYD
D D D D D RN
0HWRGDEXOHORU IDOV
6ăSUHVXSXQHPFăGRULPRRUGRQDUHFUHVFăWRDUHDúLUXOXL$OJRULWPXOFRQVWăvQSDUFXU
JHUHDWDEORXOXL$GHPDLPXOWHRULSkQăFkQGGHYLQHRUGRQDW/DILHFDUHSDVVHFRP $PDYXWLQWHUVFKLPEDUHúLGHGDWDDFHDVWDGHFLLHúLPFXRN IDOV/DDFHVWSDV
SDUăGRXăHOHPHQWHDOăWXUDWH'DFăDL!DL L Q±DWXQFLFHOHGRXăYD DDMXQVSHORFXOVăXGHILQLWLY$WUHLDSDUFXUJHUHDWDEORXOXLvQFHSHFXUHLQLĠLDOL]DUHD
ORULVHLQWHUVFKLPEăvQWUHHOH&RQWUROXODFĠLXQLLUHSHWLWLYHHVWHGDWGHYDULDELODERROHD
QăRNFDUHODILHFDUHUHOXDUHDDOJRULWPXOXLSULPHúWHYDORDUHDLQLĠLDOăDGHYăUDWFDUHVH
OXLRNFXYDORDUHDDGHYăUDW
VFKLPEăvQIDOVGDFăVDHIHFWXDWRLQWHUVFKLPEDUHGHGRXăHOHPHQWHDOăWXUDWHÌQPR
PHQWXOvQFDUHWDEORXO$VDSDUFXUVIăUăVăVHPDLHIHFWXH]HQLFLRVFKLPEDUHRNUă D D D D D RN
PkQHFXYDORDUHDLQLĠLDOăDGHYăUDWúLDOJRULWPXOVHWHUPLQăGHRDUHFHWDEORXOHVWHRU IDOV
GRQDW
,QWHUVFKLPEDUHDDGRXăHOHPHQWHVHUHDOL]HD]ăSULQLQWHUPHGLXOYDULDELOHLDX[LOLDUH $PLQWHUVFKLPEDWFXFHOGLQXUPăDVWIHODDMXQVSHORFXOVăXvQúLUXORUGR
DX[FDUHDUHDFHODúLWLSFDúLHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXL QDW$SDWUDSDUFXUJHUHDWDEORXOXLVHILQDOL]HD]ăFXYDORDUHDRN DGHYăUDWGHRDUHFH
J
J
QJ QXDPHIHFWXDWQLFLRLQWHUVFKLPEDUHFHHDFHvQVHDPQăFăSURFHVXOGHRUGRQDUHVDvQ
ă FKHLDW
JJJJ?JmJDGHYăUDWJ
J\
J
ă, D D D D D RN
ăJJ
J~J
JJJJJJJJ?JmJIDOVJ
DGHYăUDW
JJJJJJJJJmJJ
2EVHUYDĠLDFXSULYLUHODIDSWXOFăODILHFDUHSDUFXUJHUHDDMXQVFHOSXĠLQXQHOHPHQW
SHORFXOVăXGHILQLWLYvQúLUXORUGRQDWSRDWHILIUXFWLILFDWăGHRDUHFHFRQVWDWăPFăDVW
IHOODXUPăWRUXOSDVQXPDLVXQWQHFHVDUHYHULILFăULOHvQFDUHLQWHUYLQHDFHVWHOHPHQWúL
FHOHFDUHVHDIOăGXSăHOvQúLU5H]XOWăFăODILHFDUHSDUFXUJHUHDPSXWHDPLFúRUDFX
QXPăUXOHOHPHQWHORUYHULILFDWH'DUHVWHSRVLELOFDODRSDUFXUJHUHVăDMXQJăPDLPXOWH
2UGRQăULúLFăXWăUL
2UGRQăULúLFăXWăUL
HOHPHQWH vQ ORFXOORUGHILQLWLY5H]XOWăFăYRPĠLQHPLQWHLQGLFHOHXOWLPXOXLHOHPHQW 6RUWDUHVWDELOLQGSR]LĠLDGHILQLWLYăSULQQXPăUDUH
FDUH D LQWHUYHQLW vQ LQWHUVFKLPEDUH úL YHULILFăULOH OH YRP HIHFWXD GRDU SkQă OD DFHVW $FHDVWăPHWRGăFRQVWăvQFRQVWUXLUHDXQXLQRXWDEORX%FDUHDUHDFHHDúLGLPHQVLXQHFD
HOHPHQW 6LPLODU VH SRDWH UHVWUkQJH úL LQGLFHOH SULPXOXL HOHPHQW FDUH D LQWHUYHQLW vQ úLWDEORXO$vQFDUHGHSXQHPHOHPHQWHOHGLQ$RUGRQDWHFUHVFăWRU
LQWHUVFKLPEăUL$VWIHODMXQJHPODXUPăWRUXOVXEDOJRULWPvPEXQăWăĠLWFDSHUIRUPDQĠă 9RPDQDOL]DILHFDUHHOHPHQWúLvOYRPFRPSDUDFXILHFDUHDOWHOHPHQWGLQúLUSHQWUX
DSXWHDUHĠLQHvQYDULDELOD NQXPăUXOHOHPHQWHORUFDUHVXQWPDLPLFLGHFkWHOHPHQWXO
JX¡
ăăĠ
QJ FRQVLGHUDW$VWIHOYRPDIODSR]LĠLDSHFDUHWUHEXLHVăOSXQHPSHDFHVWDvQúLUXO%'D
JJ%&JmJJ ^PDUJLQHDGLQVWkQJDDVXEúLUXOXLFDUHXUPHD]ăVăILHYHULILFDW`J Fă vQ SUREOHPă DYHP QHYRLHGH úLUXORUGRQDWWRWvQWDEORXO$YRPFRSLDvQ $vQWUHJ
JJ%&JmJ
JJJ ^PDUJLQHDGLQGUHDSWD`J WDEORXO%
JJ
ăJ
ă
QJ
JJJJ?JmJDGHYăUDWJ ^SUHVXSXQHPFăúLUXOHVWHRUGRQDW`J
\
ă,
JJJJJmJ`J ^LQGLFHOHXOWLPXOXLHOHPHQWLQWHUVFKLPEDW` JJJJ?JmJ`J
J ^YHULILFăPHOHPHQWHOHGLQVXEúLUXOFXUHQW`J
\
J
ă,
JJJJ
J\%&%&J
ăQJ ăJtJJúJzJJ
JJJJJJăJJ
J~JJ
J?JmJ?J~JJ ^QXPăUăPFkWHHOHPHQWHVXQWPDLPLFLVDXHJDOHFX`J
JJJJJJJJ
%&~J úă
JJJJJJJJ?JmJIDOVJ ú
JJJJJJJJăJJ
JJJJ ^DPLQWHUVFKLPEDWHOHPHQWXOGHLQGLFHL`J JJJJ?~JmJ ^SHvOSXQHPSHXUPăWRDUHDSR]LĠLHGLQE`J
JJJJJJJJJJJmJJ ^LQGLFHOHXOWLPXOXLHOHPHQWLQWHUVFKLPEDW`J ú
JJJJJJJJ úă JJJmJJ ^FRSLHPSHVWHúLUXODvQWUHJúLUXOE`J
JJJJJJ úă ú J
JJJJ ú
J
JJJJăJJ?JJ ^DDYXWORFRLQWHUVFKLPEDUH`J ([HPSOX
JJJJJJ%&JmJJ ^DFWXDOL]ăPPDUJLQHDGLQGUHDSWD`J )LHWDEORXO$FXHOHPHQWH±
JJJJJJJmJ
J ^PDUJLQHDGLQVWkQJD`
L M 5HODĠLD N EN
J ^YHULILFăPHOHPHQWHOHGLQVXEúLUXOFXUHQWDYDQVkQGGLQGUHDSWDVSUHVWkQJD`J
JJJJJJ
J\%&%&J
ăQJ L M
JJJJJJJJăJJ
J~JJ !
JJJJJJJJJJ
%&~J !
JJJJJJJJJJ?JmJIDOVJ !± EJmJ
JJJJJJJJJJăJJJJJ ^DPLQWHUVFKLPEDWHOHPHQWXOGHLQGLFHL`J
JJJJJJJJJJJJJmJJJJ ^LQGLFHOHSULPXOXLHOHPHQWLQWHUVFKLPEDW`J L M
JJJJJJJJJJ úă
JJJJJJJJ úă !± EJmJ
JJJJJJ ú
JJJJJJ%&JmJJ ^DFWXDOL]ăPPDUJLQHDGLQVWkQJD`J !
JJJJ úăJ
L M
ăJ?J
ú !± EJmJ
±
0HWRGDEXOHORUQXHVWHFHDPDLSHUIRUPDQWăPRGDOLWDWHGHDRUGRQDXQúLUFXPXOWH ±
HOHPHQWHGDUvQFD]XOúLUXULORUÄDSURDSHRUGRQDWH´FXRSWLPL]ăULOHGHPDLVXVSRDWH ±
GHYHQLPDLHILFLHQWăGHFkWDOWHPHWRGH L M EJmJ±
2UGRQăULúLFăXWăUL 2UGRQăULúLFăXWăUL
6RUWDUHSULQVHOHFĠLHGLUHFWă 6RUWDUHDSULQLQVHUĠLHGLUHFWă
0HWRGDSUHFHGHQWăDUHGH]DYDQWDMXOFăQHFHVLWăGHGRXăRULPDLPXOWăPHPRULHGHFkW ,GHHDDOJRULWPXOXLHVWHGHDFRQVLGHUDSHUkQGILHFDUHHOHPHQWDOWDEORXOXLúLGHDOLQ
WDEORXO$'DFăGRULPVăHYLWăPDFHDVWăULVLSăSXWHPDSOLFDPHWRGDGHRUGRQDUHSULQ VHUDvQVXEWDEORXORUGRQDWSkQăODPRPHQWXOUHVSHFWLYSHORFXOVăX$FHVWORFVDUSX
VHOHFWDUHDXQXLHOHPHQWúLSODVDUHDOXLSHSR]LĠLDVDILQDOă WHDVăQXILHGHILQLWLYGHRDUHFHHVWHSRVLELOFDXUPăWRUXOHOHPHQWVăVHLQVHUH]HXQGH
'HH[HPSOXvQFD]GHRUGRQDUHFUHVFăWRDUHSRUQLQGGHODSULPXOHOHPHQWVHFDXWă YDvQIDĠDDFHVWXLD
YDORDUHDPLQLPăGLQWDEORX$FHDVWDVHDúHD]ăSHSULPDSR]LĠLHSULQWURLQWHUVFKLPED 'DFăVDDMXQVODHOHPHQWXODMM QúLWRDWHHOHPHQWHOHDDDM±DX
UH vQWUH HOHPHQWXO GH SH SULPD SR]LĠLH úL HOHPHQWXO PLQLP $SRL VH UHLD DOJRULWPXO IRVWRUGRQDWHvQVHDPQăFăWUHEXLHVăOLQVHUăPSHDMvQWUHDFHVWHHOHPHQWHÌOFRPSD
SRUQLQGGHODDGRXDSR]LĠLHúLVHFDXWăPLQLPXOvQWUHHOHPHQWHOHDDQ $FHVWDVH UăPSHUkQGFXDM±DM±SkQăFkQGDMXQJHPODXQSULPHOHPHQWDLDYkQGSURSULHWD
LQWHUVFKLPEăFXDOGRLOHDGDFăHVWHFD]XO3URFHGHXOVHFRQWLQXăSkQăODXOWLPXOHOH WHDDLDM3ULQXUPDUHDMVHLQVHUHD]ăGXSăDL$FHDVWăLQVHUDUHSURYRDFăGHSODVDUHD
PHQW HOHPHQWHORUFDUHOVXFFHGSHDLFXRSR]LĠLHVSUHGUHDSWD
3VHXGRFRGXODOJRULWPXOXLGHVRUWDUHSULQVHOHFĠLDPLQLPXOXLHVWH
Ġ
Q
%Ġ
,
J\
J
ă,
\
J
ă, JJJJ%JmJJJ^VDOYăPDOLOHDHOHPHQWVDUSXWHDSLHUGHFXWUDQVODWăULOH`J
JJJJ
JmJJ JJJJJmJ`J ^vQSYRPDYHDLQGLFHOHXQGHvOYRPSXQH`
J\~
J
ă,J
JJJJJmJJJ ^YRPFăXWDORFXOSULQWUHHOHPHQWHOHGLQIDĠDOXL`
ăJ
J
JJJ
JJJJ ăJmJIDOVJ
JJJJJJJJ
JmJJ
JJJJ
JJtJJúJ ăJ
ăQJ
JJJJJJJJ?JmJJ
úăJ ăJJdJ%JJ
ăJ
JzJJ JJJJJJJJJmJJ ^GDFăJdJDLFLWUHEXLHVăOSXQHP`
JJJJJJJJJmJJ JJJJJJJJ ăJmJDGHYăUDW ^DPJăVLWORFXO`
JJJJJJJJJmJ?J
JJJJJJJJ~JmJ^SkQăQXDPJăVLWORFXOPXWăPHOHPHQWHOHODGUHDSWD`
JJJJJJJJ?JmJJ
JJ úă
úăJ
ú
J JJJJJJJmJJJJ
ú
J ú
J
ú J JJJJ~JmJ% ^vOSXQHPSHSHORFXOÄHOLEHUDW´`
ú
J
$OJRULWPXO VH SRDWH VFULH úL SULQ GHWHUPLQDUHD YDORULORU PD[LPH úL PXWDUHD ORU vQ ú J
WDEORXGHODGUHDSWDODVWkQJDDVWIHOUH]XOWkQGGHDVHPHQHDXQúLURUGRQDWFUHVFăWRU
J ([HPSOX
([HPSOX )LHWDEORXO$
)LHWDEORXO$
L M L± FRSLH DL 5HODĠLH JăVLW S $
3DV 7DEORXO$ (OHPHQWPLQLP 3R]LĠLDPLQLPXOXL 1RXOWDEORX$ IDOV
d DGHYăUDW
IDOV
d DGHYăUDW
! IDOV
! IDOV
2UGRQăULúLFăXWăUL 2UGRQăULúLFăXWăUL
! IDOV JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJJJ
%JmJ
%J~JJ
! IDOV ú
! IDOV ?JmJ`J
! IDOV JJ
J\YJ
ăQJ
DGHYăUDW JJJJ
J\
%J
ăQJ
JJJJJJ?JmJ?J~JJ
JJJJJJ?JmJJ
6RUWDUHSULQQXPăUDUHDDSDULĠLLORUJ ú
$OJRULWPLLSUH]HQWDĠLDQWHULRUVXQWUHODWLYPDULFRQVXPDWRULGHWLPS'HH[HPSOXSHQ ú
WUXDRUGRQDXQúLUGHGHHOHPHQWHQXPăUXOFRPSDUDĠLLORUSHFDUHOHYDH[HFXWD ú
RULFDUHGLQWUHDOJRULWPLLSUH]HQWDĠLYDILDSUR[LPDWLYGHPLOLRQÌQFODVDDDYRP
)LH úLUXO±±±±3HQWUXDFHVWDGHFODUDĠLDFHDPDLÄVWUkQVă´vQ
vQYăĠDDOWHPHWRGHGHRUGRQDUHFXXQWLPSGHH[HFXĠLHPDLEXQ'DUFRQVLGHUăPLP
3DVFDOHVWH
SRUWDQWVăVHvQYHĠHúLFHOSXĠLQRPHWRGăGHRUGRQDUHFDUHVHLPSOHPHQWHD]ăFXXQDO JQJJ
KJ
JRULWPOLQLDU8QDOJRULWPOLQLDUH[HFXWăXQQXPăUGHRSHUDĠLLSURSRUĠLRQDOFXQXPăUXO JJJJ
%QJJXYKJ
HOHPHQWHORUDGLFăSHQWUXDRUGRQDGHHOHPHQWHYRUILQHFHVDUHFGHRSHUD
ĠLLXQGHFHVWHRFRQVWDQWă ùLUXOGHIUHFYHQĠHYDIL
'DFăDYHPXQúLUGHHOHPHQWHGHWLSRUGLQDOFDUHVXQWGLQWUXQLQWHUYDOGHFDUGLQDOL &RUHVSXQ]ăWRUXOWLPHLVHFYHQĠHGLQDOJRULWPVHYRUVFULHWUHLYDORUL±FRQVHFXWLYH
WDWHQXIRDUWHPDUHYRPSXWHDUHDOL]DRRUGRQDUHOLQLDUă&RUHVSXQ]ăWRUILHFăUHLYD vQDDSRLHOHPHQWYDILHJDOFX±XUPHD]ăWUHLEXFăĠLGHXUPDWGHRYDORDUH
ORULvQWkOQLWHvQúLUvQWLPSXOSUHOXFUăULLPăULPFXYDORDUHDHOHPHQWXOXLDYkQGLQGLFH ±±±±
OHvQDFHVWúLUGHFRQWRDUHHJDOFXYDORDUHDHOHPHQWXOXLvQúLUXOGHRUGRQDWÌQILQDO
YRPVXSUDVFULHvQúLUXOGDWDWkWHDHOHPHQWHFXYDORULDLLQGLFLORUHOHPHQWHORUGLIHULWHGH
FkWHVWHYDORDUHDHOHPHQWXOXLvQDFHVWúLUDQXPHUHORUGHDSDULĠLL $OJRULWPLGHFăXWDUH
,PSRUWDQWHVWHVăUHĠLQHPSDUWLFXODULWăĠLOHSHFDUHWUHEXLHVăOHDLEăúLUXOGDWSHQWUX
FDDFHDVWăPHWRGăVăVHSRDWăDSOLFD
YDORULOHHOHPHQWHORUWUHEXLHVăILHGHWLSRUGLQDO
&ăXWDUHVHFYHQĠLDOă
6HGăXQWDEORXXQLGLPHQVLRQDO$ DDDQúLRYDORDUHS6HSXQHSUREOHPDVă
QXPăUXO HOHPHQWHORU PXOĠLPLL GLQ FDUH úLUXO SULPHúWH YDORUL WUHEXLH Vă ILH UHODWLY YHULILFăPGDFăYDORDUHDSVHDIOăvQWUHHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXLVDXQX
PLFGDFăvQSURJUDPQXH[LVWăDOWHVWUXFWXULGHGDWHGLQFHL.%DLPHPRULHL 'DFăúLUXOQXHVWHRUGRQDWWUHEXLHVăvQFHSHPFăXWDUHDFRPSDUkQGSULPXOHOHPHQW
VFăGHPVSDĠLXOQHFHVDUúLUXOXLGHRUGRQDWúLSXWHPFDOFXODVSDĠLXOSHFDUHvODYHP GLQúLUFXHOHPHQWXOFăXWDWúLVăFRQWLQXăPILHSkQăFkQGvOJăVLPILHDMXQJHPODVIkU
ODGLVSR]LĠLH úLWXOúLUXOXLDúDFXPDPvQYăĠDWvQFDSLWROXO'DFăWUHEXLHVăDIOăPWRDWHSR]LĠLLOHGLQ
YDORULOHSRVLELOHvQúLUXOGHRUGRQDWWUHEXLHVăILHGLQLQWHUYDOXO>[\@XQGH\±[ úLUSHFDUHVHDIOăYDORDUHDFăXWDWăYDWUHEXLVăvOSDUFXUJHPvQvQWUHJLPH
YDILGLPHQVLXQHDúLUXOXLGHFRQWRDUH
([HPSOX &ăXWDUHELQDUă
JQ````JJ
KJJ ^FHOPXOWGHQXPHUH` 'DFăWDEORXO$HVWHVRUWDWvQRUGLQHFUHVFăWRDUHDWXQFLvQVFKLPEVHSRDWHUHDOL]DRFă
JJJJ
%Q|``|``JJ
KJ^YDORULSRVLELOHvQWUHúL` XWDUHPDLUDSLGă3UHVXSXQHPDúDGDUFăHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXL$VXQWDUDQMDWHvQRUGLQH
FUHVFăWRDUH
J
%ù%
Ġ
YQJ ÌQWUHHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXL$DYHPUHODĠLLOHDdDddDP±dDPdDPdDQ
JJ
J\YJ
ăQJJJ XQGHDPUHSUH]LQWăHOHPHQWXOGLQPLMORFSR]LĠLHFDOFXODWăFXIRUPXODP >Q@
JJJJ
%JmJ`J 9DORDUHDFăXWDWăHVWHS'HDVHPHQHDFRQYHQLPVăQRWăPFXVH[WUHPLWDWHDVWkQJăúL
ú
FXGH[WUHPLWDWHDGUHDSWăDLQWHUYDOXOXLvQFDUHHIHFWXăPFăXWDUHD,QLĠLDOV úLG Q
2UGRQăULúLFăXWăUL 2UGRQăULúLFăXWăUL
&RPSDUăPYDORDUHDSFXYDORDUHDHOHPHQWXOXLGLQúLUGHSHSR]LĠLDGLQPLMORFP ([HPSOX
'DFăS DPDWXQFLFăXWDUHDVHvQFKHLHFXVXFFHV'DFăSzDPDWXQFLYRPGHFLGHvQFDUH )LHWDEORXOGHQXPHUHvQWUHJLúLS
SDUWHDúLUXOXLvPSăUĠLWGHDPvQGRXăVXEúLUXULYRPFRQWLQXDFăXWDUHD'DFăSDP V G P S DP S" 5HODĠLDGLQWUHDPúLS HVWH
DWXQFLFăXWDUHDVHYDFRQWLQXDvQSULPDMXPăWDWHDúLUXOXLLDUGDFăS!DPDWXQFLFăXWD
DP zS SDPWUHFHPvQVXEúLUXOVWkQJ IDOV
UHDVHWUDQVIHUăvQDGRXDMXPăWDWHDWDEORXOXL$VWIHOHOLPLQăPXQQXPăUFRQVLGHUDELO
DP S S DP FăXWDUHFXVXFFHV DGHYăUDW
GHFRPSDUDĠLLúLWLPSXOGHOXFUXDOSURJUDPXOXLVHUHGXFH
6ăSUHVXSXQHPFăSDPÌQDFHVWFD]SDUWLFXODUL]ăPFDSHWHOHLQWHUYDOXOXLvQFDUH 9RPFăXWDvQDFHODúLWDEORXYDORDUHDS
YRPFăXWDvQFRQWLQXDUHDVWIHOV úLG P±ĠLQkQGFRQWGHIDSWXOFăHOHPHQWXODP
JJ
ú
J
J
JJ
ú
JJ 2SHUDĠLLFXYDULDELOHGHWLS
JJJmJJ ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDVXPHLPD[LPH` 6XESURJUDPHSUHGHILQLWHSHQWUXstringXUL
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
JJ%JmJJ ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDVXPHLFXUHQWH` 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
JJ
%JmJJ 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
JJ
úJmJJ
JJ§
%JmJJ
JJ
J\
J
ăQJJ ^FRQWLQXăPFLWLUHDQXPHUHORU`J
JJJJ
ú
JJ 7LSXO úLU GH FDUDFWHUH VH LGHQWLILFă vQ 3DVFDO SULQ WHUPHQXO VWULQJ GHRDUHFH vQ DFHVW
JJJJăJ%JJ`J
ăQJ ^GDFă%HVWHQHJDWLYă`J OLPEDMGHSURJUDPDUHH[LVWăWLSXOSUHGHILQLW SHQWUXWDEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOH
JJJJJJ%JmJJ ^DFHDVWDVHUHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăFX7`J FDUHDXHOHPHQWHFkWHXQFDUDFWHU'LIHUHQĠHOHLPSRUWDQWHGLQWUHXQúLUGHFDUDFWHUHúL
XQVWULQJVHGHVSULQGGLQXUPăWRDUHOHREVHUYDĠLL
JJJJJJ
%JmJJ ^QRXOVXEúLUSRVLELOvQFHSHvQSR]LĠLDL`J
x 8QXL WDEORX L VH VSHFLILFă GH OD vQFHSXW QXPăUXO PD[LP GH FRPSRQHQWH SH FDUH
JJJJ
J
SRDWHVăOHFRQĠLQăSHFkQGRYDULDELOăGHWLS DUHLPSOLFLWFHOPXOWGH
JJJJJJ%JmJ%J~JJ ^OXL%LVHDGDXJă7`J HOHPHQWH
JJJJJJăJJdJ%J ^VHDFWXDOL]HD]ă` x 'DFăODGHFODUDUHVHVSHFLILFăSHQWUXGLPHQVLXQHDPD[LPăDXQHLYDULDELOHGHWLS
JJJJJJJJăJJJ%J XQQXPăUPDLPLFGHFkWYDILYDODELOăGHFODUDĠLDIăFXWăH[SOLFLW
JJJJJJJJJJJmJ%J x 8QVWULQJVHPHPRUHD]ăSHDWkĠLDRFWHĠLFkWHFDUDFWHUHVXQWVSHFLILFDWHvQGHFODUD
JJJJJJJJJJ§
%JmJ
%J UHODFDUHVHDGDXJăXQRFWHWvQFDUHVHPHPRUHD]ăOXQJLPHDVWULQJXOXL$FHVWOX
FUXQXVHvQWkPSOăODWDEORXULOHGHFDUDFWHUHFDUHVHPHPRUHD]ăSHH[DFWDWkĠLDRF
JJJJJJJJJJ
úJmJJ WHĠLFkWHFDUDFWHUHDSDUvQGHFODUDUH
JJJJJJJJ
^vQFD]GHHJDOLWDWH`J
JJJJJJJJJJăJ§
%J\J
%JJ Declararea variabilelor de tip
JJJJJJJJJJJJ
úJmJJ &XWRDWHFăWLSXOGHVFULHRVWUXFWXUăúLUGHFDUDFWHUHQXHVWHREOLJDWRULXVăSUHFL]ăP
úă RDQXPLWăOXQJLPHGDUGDFăGRULPVăGHFODUăPXQVWULQJPDLVFXUWGHFkWOXQJLPHDLP
úă SOLFLWăDWXQFLDFHVWOXFUXHVWHSRVLELO
úă
([HPSOX
úă
J
Q KJ ^YDULDELOD
DUHFHOPXOWGHFDUDFWHUH`J
ú
JJJJ%Q `KJ ^YDULDELOD%SRDWHDYHDFHOPXOWGHFDUDFWHUH`J
JJ
JJ
JJ
J§
%J
úJ
ú
ÌQFHOHFHXUPHD]ăDWXQFLFkQGYRPVFULHVWULQJvQDFHVWPDWHULDOQHUHIHULPODXQúLUGHFD
UDFWHUH$WXQFLFkQGYRPVFULH HVWHYRUEDGHWLSXOSUHGHILQLWvQOLPEDMXO3DVFDO
ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH
2SHUDĠLLFXYDULDELOHGHWLS 'DFăYDORDUHDOXL \DWULEXLUHD Q\~|`KVHYDILQDOL]DFXYD
ORDUHD|SHQWUX
&LWLUHD &RQFDWHQDUHD
2YDULDELOăGHWLS VHSRDWHFLWLvQ3DVFDOVSHFLILFkQGXLQXPHOH$YDQWDMXOID
&RQFDWHQDUHDVHSRDWHUHDOL]DXWLOL]kQGRSHUDWRUXO~GDUvQ3DVFDOH[LVWăúLRSURFH
ĠăGHWDEORXULFRQVWăvQIDSWXOFăQXWUHEXLHVăúWLPH[DFWQXPăUXOFDUDFWHUHORUÌQPR
GXUăSUHGHILQLWăvQDFHVWVFRS
%
PHQWXOvQFDUHDPDSăVDW(QWHUVDXvQFD]GHFLWLUHGLQWUXQILúLHUGHWLSDWXQFL J
FkQGXUPHD]ăFDUDFWHUXOVIkUúLWGHOLQLHVWULQJXOÄVDWHUPLQDW´úLSULPDFRPSRQHQWă ([HPSOX
DYDULDELOHLFHDFXLQGLFHSULPHúWHRYDORDUHHJDOăFXQXPăUXOFDUDFWHUHORUFLWLWH
Q\J~JKJ ^GDFăJ\JúLJ\JDWXQFLYDORDUHDOXLYDIL`J
Q\J~JJ~JK ^YDORDUHDOXLYDIL`J
([HPSOX
JQ KJ
JJJJQ |KJ 6ă REVHUYăP Fă XQ VWULQJ SRDWH IL ÄFRQVWUXLW´ SULQ DGăXJDUH GH FDUDFWHUH OD XQ
J VWULQJLQLĠLDOYLG
JJ
KJ
JJ
KJ ([HPSOX
J Q |K
J JJJJQXYKJ
'DFăSHQWUXVúLSHQWUXVVLQWURGXFHPúLUXOGHFDUDFWHUH XYDORDUHDDPEHORU
YDULDELOH YD IL X 'DFă SHQWUX VV LQWURGXFHP XX YDORDUHD OXL VV YD IL JJQ\KJJ ^VWULQJXOYLG`
XXDGLFăVHYRUSăVWUDFHOPXOWDWkWHDHOHPHQWHFkWHSHUPLWHGHFODUDĠLD JJQ\`KJ
|J
JJJJ
%KJ
$ILúDUHD JJJJQ\J~JJ
$ILúDUHDVHUHDOL]HD]ăVSHFLILFkQGRH[SUHVLHGHWLS
JJ
`KJ ^FRPSRQHQWDFDUHSăVWUHD]ăOXQJLPHDVWULQJXOXL`J
([HPSOX JJ
J ^VHYDDILúD`J
JQ KJ &
JJJJQ |KJ
J
JJ
XXKJ 2SHUDĠLLUHODĠLRQDOH
JJ
~K ^GDFă úL
VHYDDILúD
`J ÌQFD]XOH[SUHVLLORUGHWLS VHSRWIRORVLRSHUDWRULLUHODĠLRQDOLFXQRVFXĠL
J \
\\J
5H]XOWDWXODGRXăFRPSDUDĠLLHVWHRFRQVWDQWăORJLFăDGHYăUDWVDXIDOV
$WULEXLUHD ([HPSOX
8QHL YDULDELOH GH WLS L VH SRDWH DWULEXL YDORDUHD XQHL H[SUHVLL FDUH DUH WLSXO JQ KJ
'DFăYDULDELODDUHXQWLSFDUHSUHFL]HD]ăROXQJLPHPDLPLFăGHFkWVWULQJXO $YkQGGHFODUDĠLLOHGHPDLVXVvQWDEHOXOXUPăWRUSUH]HQWăPFkWHYDH[HPSOHGHH[
GLQH[SUHVLHFDUDFWHUHOHFDUHGHSăúHVFOXQJLPHDYDULDELOHLVHSLHUG SUHVLLUHODĠLRQDOHGXSăHIHFWXDUHDXUPăWRDUHORURSHUDĠLLGHDWULEXLUH
([HPSOX Q\KJ
)LHGHFODUDĠLD Q\XKJ
Q |K Q\J~JKJ
ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH
([SUHVLH 5H]XOWDW 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
J\J JVDFRPSDUDWFX
J
JXJ
JVDFRPSDUDWXFXX
JJXJ VDFRPSDUDW XFX XúL /LWHUH
JJXSHFHDGHDGRXDSR]LĠLH )LHXQWH[WFLWLWGLQWUXQILúLHU6ăVHDILúH]HDFHOHFXYLQWHGLQWH[WvQFRPSRQHQĠDFăUR
UDQXPăUXOPDMXVFXOHORUHVWHVWULFWPDLPDUHGHFkWQXPăUXOOLWHUHORUPLFL
JJJ JVDFRPSDUDWFXJ
J
\JJ JVDFRPSDUDWXFXJ
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
)LúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH*!"&$FRQĠLQHWH[WXOVFULVSHPDLPXOWHOLQLL
$FFHVXOODRFRPSRQHQWă
&RPSRQHQWDUHSUH]LQWăDOOHDFDUDFWHUGLQYDULDELODGHWLS 'DWHGHLHúLUH
&XYLQWHOHVHYRUVFULHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH *!"&'(!SHOLQLLGLVWLQFWHILHFDUHFX
YkQWILLQGVFULVSHFkWHROLQLHQRXă
6XESURJUDPHSUHGHILQLWHSHQWUXstringXUL
8QLWXO6\VWHPGLQ%RUODQG3DVFDOFRQĠLQHPDLPXOWHVXESURJUDPHSUHGHILQLWHFDUH 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
SRWILXWLOL]DWHvQSUHOXFUDUHDVWULQJXULORU)LHVúLVVYDULDELOHGHWLS x FXYLQWHOHVXQWVHSDUDWHSULQVSDĠLLúLVDXFDUDFWHUHGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLH
x )XQFĠLDUHWXUQHD]ăYDORDUHDSR]LĠLHLvQFHSkQGGHODFDUHVHUHJăVHúWHVV x ILúLHUXOQXFRQĠLQHOLQLLYLGH
vQVGDFăVVQXVHJăVHúWHvQVDWXQFLLLDYDORDUHD x OLQLLOHFRQĠLQFXYLQWHQHGHVSăUĠLWH
x )XQFĠLD YUHWXUQHD]ăVXEVWULQJXOGLQVFDUHvQFHSHODSR]LĠLDLúLDUHM x SHROLQLHVXQWVFULVHFHOPXOWGHFDUDFWHUH
FDUDFWHUH'DFăvQVQXH[LVWăMFDUDFWHUHvQFHSkQGFXSR]LĠLDLVHYRUUHWXUQDDWkWHD x XQFXYkQWSRDWHDYHDFHOPXOWGHFDUDFWHUH
FkWHVXQW x FXYLQWHOHFRQĠLQQXPDLOLWHUHPDULúLPLFL
x )XQFĠLD
&UHWXUQHD]ăOXQJLPHDVWULQJXOXLQXPăUXOFDUDFWHUHORUGLQV
x 3URFHGXUDDUHFDHIHFWúWHUJHUHDGLQVvQFHSkQGGHODSR]LĠLDLDM ([HPSOX
*!"&$ *!"&'(!
FDUDFWHUH'DFăvQVQXH[LVWăMFDUDFWHUHvQFHSkQGFXSR]LĠLDLVHYRUúWHUJHDWkWHD
J£"JJJJJJJJJJ £"J
FkWHVXQW JJ"JJ J
x 3URFHGXUD
LQVHUHD]ă FDUDFWHUHOH GLQ VWULQJXO VV vQ V vQFHSkQG J
J¨JJ "J
GHODSR]LĠLDL ¨J
([SOLFDĠLL
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH x
DUHGRXăOLWHUHPLFLúLXQDPDUHGHFLQXVHVFULH
3HQWUXDYăIDPLOLDUL]DFXSUHOXFUăULOHúLUXULORUGHFDUDFWHUHLPSOHPHQWDĠLSURJUDPHOH x £"DUHSDWUXOLWHUHPDULúLQLFLXQDPLFăGHFLVHVFULH
DIHUHQWHXUPăWRDUHORUH[HUFLĠLL
FLWLUHDXQXLQXPăUFDUDFWHUFXFDUDFWHU
x DUHWUHLOLWHUHPDULúLGRXăPLFLGHFLVHVFULH
FLWLUHDXQXLFXYkQWFDUDFWHUFXFDUDFWHU x DUHROLWHUăPDUHúLWUHLPLFLGHFLQXVHVFULH
QXPăUDUHDOLWHUHORUGLQWUXQWH[WGDW x "DUHSDWUXOLWHUHPDULúLROLWHUăPLFăGHFLVHVFULH
QXPăUDUHDFXYLQWHORUGLQWUXQWH[WGDW x DUHROLWHUăPDUHúLWUHLOLWHUHPLFLGHFLQXVHVFULH
QXPăUDUHDSURSR]LĠLLORUGLQWUXQWH[WGDW x
QXDUHQLFLROLWHUăPDUHGHFLQXVHVFULH
GHVFRPSXQHUHDvQFXYLQWHDXQXLWH[WGDW
RUGRQDUHDXQXLúLUGHFXYLQWH x ¨DUHOLWHUHPDULúLWUHLOLWHUHPLFLGHFLVHVFULH
HOLPLQDUHDVSDĠLLORUGXEOHGLQWUHFXYLQWHOHXQXLWH[WGDW
ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH
VăOHFDXWHvQGLFĠLRQDU'LQDFHVWHFXYLQWHYDDOFăWXLROLVWăXUPkQGFDXOWHULRUVăOH
7H[W vQORFXLDVFăvQWH[W
6HFLWHVFPDLPXOWHSURSR]LĠLLGLQWUXQILúLHU6HFHUH
x VăVHDILúH]HQXPăUXOGHFXYLQWHGLQILHFDUHSURSR]LĠLH 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
x VăVHGHWHUPLQHSHQWUXILHFDUHSURSR]LĠLHQXPăUXOFXYLQWHORUGLVWLQFWH 3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXL !"#%( &$VHDIOăWH[WXOHOHYXOXLLDUSHILHFDUHGLQWUHXU
x VăVHDILúH]HFXYLQWHOHFDUHVHUHSHWăvQFDGUXODFHOHLDúLSURSR]LĠLL PăWRDUHOHOLQLLVHDIOăXQFXYkQWvQOLPEDURPkQăXUPDWGXSăXQVSDĠLXGHFRUHVSRQ
GHQWXOVăXvQOLPEDHQJOH]ă
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
3URSR]LĠLLOHVXQWVFULVHvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH !9!&$SHPDLPXOWHOLQLL'RXăSURSR 'DWHGHLHúLUH
]LĠLLVXQWVHSDUDWHSULQFDUDFWHUHOH© 7H[WXOWUDGXVvPSUHXQăFXVHPQHOHGHSXQFWXDĠLHH[LVWHQWHvQWH[WXOGDWvQILúLHUXOGH
LQWUDUHVHYDDILúDvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH!"#%( &'(!
'DWHGHLHúLUH
5H]XOWDWHOHVHYRUVFULHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH !9!&'(!. 3HOLQLDLGLQILúLHUVHDILúHD]ă 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
GDWHOHUHIHULWRDUHODDLDSURSR]LĠLH$FHVWHGDWHVHYRUVHSDUDSULQVSDĠLXúLYRUDSăUHD x WH[WXOvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHWUHEXLHVăFRQĠLQăFHOPXOWGHFDUDFWHUH
vQ RUGLQHD QXPăUXO FXYLQWHORU GLQ SURSR]LĠLH QXPăUXO FXYLQWHORU GLVWLQFWH OLVWD FX x VHSDUDWRULLIRORVLĠLvQWH[WSRWILJ
YLQWHORUFDUHQXVXQWGLVWLQFWHvQFDGUXOSURSR]LĠLHL x WH[WXOGLQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHYDDYHDH[DFWDFHHDúLVHSDUDWRULFDúLFHOGHLQWUDUH
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL ([HPSOX
x GLQFXYLQWHSRDWHVăIDFăSDUWHFDUDFWHUXO !"#%( &$J
x GRXăFXYLQWHVHVHSDUăSULQFDUDFWHUHOHJQ
J&J
YJJJ&JJ
JJ&JJJ
J&J
JJ
x SRWH[LVWDVHSDUDWRULLQXWLOL JJ
x QXPăUXOPD[LPGHFXYLQWHSHQWUXILHFDUHSURSR]LĠLHHVWH J?%J
x vQWH[WH[LVWăOLWHUHPDULúLPLFL
J
!"#%( &'(!J
([HPSOX
J&J
YJJJ&JJ
JJ&J?%JJJ&
!9!&$
J
J J%
JJ%JJJ
J
JJ&J
%JJJ
JJJ
J%JJ
%J &XORUL
JJ%
J
J
JJ%JJJJ /DRJUăGLQLĠăVHYDUHDOL]DXQVSHFWDFROXQGHFRSLLLWUHEXLHVăILHvPEUăFDĠLvQFRVWX
J J %J
J J
J
J KJ J
PH GH FXORUL GLIHULWH )LHFDUH FRSLO vúL VSXQH FXORDUHD SUHIHUDWă LDU vQYăĠăWRDUHD IRU
%
%J J %
%J J
J
J
J J
J
J
JJJJ%
%JJ%J%JJJ
%©J PHD]ăJUXSXULGHFRSLLvPEUăFDĠLvQFRVWXPHGHDFHHDúLFXORDUH3HVFHQăFRSLLLVHYRU
DúH]DvQJUXSXULDVWIHOvQFkWFHOPDLQXPHURVJUXSYDVWDvQIXQGDOvQIDĠDDFHVWRUDYD
!9!&'(! VWDJUXSXOGLQFDUHIDFSDUWHPDLSXĠLQLFRSLLHWFLDUvQIDĠăJUXSXOFHOPDLSXĠLQQX
JJJ%J PHURV
`J`J
`JJ
JJ%
%JJ
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
'DWHOHGHLQWUDUHVHFLWHVFGLQILúLHUXO(*'"&$JFDUHDUHXUPăWRDUHDVWUXFWXUă
7UDGXFHUH x SHSULPDOLQLHVHDIOăQXPăUXOQDWXUDOQUHSUH]HQWkQGQXPăUXOGHFRSLL
8QHOHYDUHGHVFULVXQWH[WvQOLPEDHQJOH]ăGDUQXFXQRDúWHGHVWXOGHELQHDFHDVWă x SHXUPăWRDUHOHQOLQLLVXQWVFULVHQXPHOHúLSUHQXPHOHFRSLLORUQXPHOHHVWHVHSDUDW
OLPEă6HKRWăUăúWHVăODVHFXYLQWHOHSHFDUHQXOHSRDWHWUDGXFHvQOLPEDURPkQăDSRL GHSUHQXPHSULQWUXQVSDĠLX
ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH
ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVH
x SHXUPăWRDUHDOLQLHHVWHVFULVQXPăUXOQDWXUDOPUHSUH]HQWkQGQXPăUXOGHFXORUL
x SH XUPăWRDUHOH Q OLQLL VXQW WUHFXWH FXORULOH SUHIHUDWH DOH FHORU Q FRSLL VXE IRUPD /LWHUH
XQRU QXPHUH QDWXUDOH GLQ LQWHUYDOXO > P@ FX FDUH VDX FRGLILFDW FXORULOH ILHFDUH 9RPFLWLFkWHXQVWULQJGHSHROLQLHGLQILúLHUúLvOYRPSDUFXUJHvQIHOXOXUPăWRUYRP
FRSLODOHJHRVLQJXUăFXORDUH LJQRUDVSDĠLLOHSkQăODDSDULĠLDSULPXOXLFDUDFWHUGLIHULWGHVSDĠLX$SRLYRPFRQVWUXL
GLQFDUDFWHUHFRQVHFXWLYHOLWHUHXQFXYkQWQXPăUkQGvQSDUDOHOúLPDMXVFXOHOHÌQPR
'DWHGHLHúLUH PHQWXOvQFDUHDSDUHSULPXOVSDĠLXVDXDPDMXQVODVIkUúLWXOVWULQJXOXLSUHOXFUăPFX
'DWHOHGHLHúLUHVHVFULXvQILúLHUXO(*'"&'(!SHPOLQLL)LHFDUHOLQLHFRQĠLQHFRGXO YkQWXOUHVSHFWLYGHFLGHPGDFăWUHEXLHVăOVFULHPvQILúLHUVDXQX5HOXăPDOJRULWPXO
FXORULLXUPDWGHQXPHOHFRSLLORUFDUHSUHIHUăFXORDUHDUHVSHFWLYă1XPHOHYRUILGHV SHQWUXUHVWXOFDUDFWHUHORUGLQVWULQJXOFLWLWDSRLSHQWUXUHVWXOOLQLLORUGLQILúLHU
SăUĠLWHSULQWUXQVSDĠLX1XPăUXOQXPHORUYDILFHOPDLPDUHSHSULPDOLQLHPDLPLF J
JQJ
SHOLQLDDGRXDúLFHOPDLPLFSHXOWLPDOLQLH
JJ
JXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHUJ
ă,J
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL JJJJ
ú
JJ ^FLWLPROLQLHGLQILúLHU`
x dQd JJJJJmJJ ^YRPSDUFXUJHVWULQJXOFLWLW`J
JJJJ
JJdJOXQJLPHDWH[WXOXLJ
ă,J
x dPd
JJJJJJ
JJdJOXQJLPHDWH[WXOXLJúJ\JJ
ă,J
x ILHFDUHFXORDUHGLQWUHFHOHPYDILSUHIHUDWăGHFHOSXĠLQXQFRSLO
JJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ ^VSDĠLLOHOHLJQRUăP`J
x vQFD]XOvQFDUHH[LVWăGRXăVDXPDLPXOWHFXORULSUHIHUDWHGHXQQXPăUHJDOGHFR
SLLDWXQFLRUGLQHDvQFDUHJUXSXULOHFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHVHYRUDúH]DSHVFHQăQXFRQ JJJJJJ%JmJ ^YRPFRQVWUXLFXYkQWXOFXUHQW`J
WHD]ă JJJJJJJmJ`J
JJJJJJ
JJdJOXQJLPHDWH[WXOXLJúJJzJJJ
ă,J
([HPSOX JJJJJJăJJtJJúJJdJJJJ ^PDMXVFXOă`J
(*'"&$ (*'"&'(! JJJJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
J J%JJJ
JJJ úă
J&J JJ&J
J
J JJJJJJJJ%JmJ%J~JJ^FRQFDWHQăPFDUDFWHUXOFXUHQWvQFXYkQWXOFXUHQW`
J
J JJ
J
J
JJ JJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
J
J JJJJ ú
JJ
%JJ JJJJJJăJJ
JOXQJLPHDFXYkQWXOXL%J
J
J JJJJJJJJ
J%J
JJ úăJJ
J
J JJ ú
JJ
J JJ ú
JJ
J ú
J
J
J 7H[W
J 9RPUHĠLQHILHFDUHSURSR]LĠLHvQWUXQúLUGHFDUDFWHUHúLYRPFRQVWUXLúLUXOFXYLQWHORU
J
FDUHIDFSDUWHGLQHDSHQWUXDIDFLOLWDFăXWDUHDFXYLQWHORUFDUHQXVXQWXQLFHvQFDGUXO
SURSR]LĠLHL
'LQFDX]DFăRSURSR]LĠLHVHSRDWHFRQWLQXDvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHSHPDLPXOWHOLQLL
YRPIRUPDSURSR]LĠLLOHFLWLQGGLQILúLHUFDUDFWHUH1RWăPFXSUúLUXOGHFDUDFWHUHFDUH
UHĠLQH SURSR]LĠLD FXUHQWă úL FX F FDUDFWHUXO FLWLW GLQ ILúLHU ,QLĠLDOL]ăP SURSR]LĠLD FX
ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH
VWULQJXOYLGúLFDUDFWHUHOHFLWLWHOHFRQFDWHQăPvQSUSkQăODDSDULĠLDXQXLVHSDUDWRUVDX J
Q ^DQDOL]ăPRSURSR]LĠLH`J
DPDUFDMXOXLGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLH VXSUDVFULHPVHSDUDWRULLFXVSDĠLL
x ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHSURSR]LĠLDVHvQFKHLHDDSăUXWXQVHSDUDWRUvQORFXLPVHSDUDWRUXO HOLPLQăPVSDĠLLOHvQSOXV
DGăXJkQGODVIkUúLWXOYDULDELOHLSUXQVSDĠLXSHQWUXDVLPSOLILFDvPSăUĠLUHDSHFX FăXWăPFXYLQWHOHUHĠLQHPvQúLUXO%
úLOHúWHUJHPGLQSURSR]LĠLH
YLQWH7UHFHPODDQDOL]DSURSR]LĠLHL JJ
J
JJJ ^QXPăUXOFXYLQWHORUGLQSURSR]LĠLH`J
x 'DFăSHSDUFXUVXOFLWLULLDDSăUXWPDUFDMGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHIăUăFDSURSR]LĠLDVăVH JJ
%%
J ^DSHOăPVXEDOJRULWPXO
%`J
WHUPLQHDFHVWDVHFLWHúWHGLQILúLHUFRQWLQXkQGFLWLUHDFDUDFWHUHORUúLFRQFDWHQDUHD JJ
JJJ
J\
J
ă,
ORUvQDFHHDúLSURSR]LĠLHGHSHOLQLDXUPăWRDUH
JJJJJmJJ ^QXPăUXOFXYLQWHORUFDUHQXVXQWGLVWLQFWH`J
ăJ%
JzJJJ
$OJRULWPXOFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăIRUPDUHDXQHLSURSR]LĠLLHVWH
JJJJJJ
J\~
J
ă,
JJJJJJJJăJ%
J\J%
J
#JQJ
^XQFXYkQWHVWHvQORFXLWFXVSDĠLXODDGRXDDSDULĠLH`
JJmJ ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDSULPHLSURSR]LĠLHL`J
JJJJJJJJJJ%
JmJJJ
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ă,J
JJJJ
ú
J%J JJJJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
JJJJJJJJ úăJ
ă%QXHVWHVHSDUDWRUGHSURSR]LĠLLú JJJJJJ ú
J
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHJJ JJJJJJăJJ
JJ ^FXYkQWXOQXHVWHGLVWLQFW`
JJJJJJJJJmJJ~J%J ^DOLSLPFDUDFWHUXOFXUHQWSURSR]LĠLHL`J JJJJJJJJ
JJJ
JJJJJJ
JJJJJJ úăJ
ăJ%JHVWHVHSDUDWRUGHSURSR]LĠLL JJJJ úăJ
JJJJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJJ ^VXSUDVFULHPVHSDUDWRUXOFXVSDĠLX`J ú
JJJJJJJJJJ
J ^DQDOL]DSURSR]LĠLHL`J ú J
JJJJJJJJJJ
PDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHJ
JJJJJJJJJJJmJJ ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDXUPăWRDUHLSURSR]LĠLL`J ÌQDOJRULWPXOFDUHFDOFXOHD]ăQXPăUXOGHFXYLQWHFDUHDSDURVLQJXUăGDWăvQSURSR
JJJJJJJJ
JJ ]LĠLDSUVHQXPăUăDSDULĠLLOHILHFăUXLFXYkQWvQúLUXOFXYLQWHORU'DFăDFHVWDDSDUHRVLQ
JJJJJJJJJJ
ú
JPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHJ JXUăGDWăVHLQFUHPHQWHD]ăFRQWRUXOFXYLQWHORUGLVWLQFWH
úă
JJJJJ úăJ
%%
J
ú
J JJJmJ`J
ú JJ
J\
J
ă,J
JJJJĠJmJ`J
$QDOL]DSURSR]LĠLHLUHĠLQXWHvQúLUXOGHFDUDFWHUHSUvQFHSHFXvQORFXLUHDVHSDUDWRUL JJJJ
\
J
ăQJ
ORUFXVSDĠLLDSRLVHHOLPLQăVSDĠLLOHLQXWLOHúLVHIRUPHD]ăWDEORXOGHFXYLQWH6HVFULH JJJJJJăJ%
J\J%
JJ
QXPăUXOQDOFXYLQWHORUGHSLVWDWHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH$OJRULWPXO
DSH JJJJJJJJĠJmJĠJ~JJ
JJJJJJ úă
OHD]ăVXEDOJRULWPXO
%%
FDUHQXPăUăFXYLQWHOHFDUHDSDUR ú
J
VLQJXUăGDWăvQSURSR]LĠLHúLVFULHDFHVWQXPăUvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH JJJJăJĠJ\JJ ^GDFă%
DDSăUXWRVLQJXUăGDWă`
'HDVHPHQHDVHĠLQHúLHYLGHQĠDFXYLQWHORUFDUHVHUHSHWăúLvQFHSkQGGHODDGRXD
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ ^DYHPXQFXYkQWGLVWLQFW`J
DSDULĠLHVHvQORFXLHVFFXVSDĠLXSHQWUXDQXOHPDLOXDvQFDOFXO úăJ
'XSăVFULHUHDFHORUGRXăQXPHUHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVHWUHFHODFăXWDUHDFXYLQWHORU ú
J
FDUHVHUHSHWă6HQXPăUăILHFDUHDSDULĠLHúLVHvQORFXLHúWHGXEOXUDOXLFXVSDĠLX'DFă ú J
VHJăVHVFFXYLQWHFDUHVHUHSHWăDFHVWHDVHYRUVFULHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH
ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH
JJJJJmJWUDGXFHUHDOXL%
UHWXUQDWGHVXEDOJRULWPXOă%
7UDGXFHUH
'LILFXOWDWHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHFRQVWăvQIDSWXOFăGLQWH[WXOLQLĠLDOQXPDLDQXPLWHFX JJJJăJJzJJJ ^GDFăH[LVWăWUDGXFHUH`J
YLQWH VH vQORFXLHVF &HOH FDUH WUHEXLH vQORFXLWH úL WUDGXFHULOH ORU DSDU vQ ILúLHUXO GH JJJJJJLQVHUăPWUDGXFHUHDFXYkQWXOXLvQvQFHSkQGFXSR]LĠLDL
LQWUDUHvQFHSkQGGHSHOLQLDDGRXD JJJJJJúWHUJHPFXYkQWXOGHWUDGXVGLQJ
JJJJJJJmJJ~OXQJLPHDFXYkQWXOXLJJOXQJLPHDFXYkQWXOXL%
J~JJ
6HSDUFXUJHWH[WXOLQLĠLDOWúLVHUHĠLQSHUkQGFXYLQWHOHvQYDULDELODFXYkQW3HQWUX J ^UHFDOFXOăPSR]LĠLDGLQFDUHFRQWLQXăPSUHOXFUDUHDOXL`
ILHFDUHFXYkQWFXYkQWVHYHULILFăGDFăDFHVWDDSDUHSULQWUHFXYLQWHOHFDUHVXQWVFULVHvQ JJJJJJ%
JmJ^UHLQLĠLDOL]ăP%
SHQWUXDILXWLOSHQWUXXQFXYkQWQRX`
GLFĠLRQDU'DFăDFHVWDH[LVWăvQGLFĠLRQDUVHUHĠLQHWUDGXFHUHDOXLXUPkQGFDDFHDVWDVă JJJJ
J
VXEVWLWXLHFXYkQWXOvQWH[WXOLQLĠLDO JJJJJJJmJ~ ^DYDQVăPFXYkQWXOQXWUHEXLHWUDGXV`
&ăXWăPFXYkQWXOFXYkQWvQILúLHUXOFDUHFRQĠLQHGLFĠLRQDUXOFXXUPăWRUXOVXEDOJR JJJJJJ%
JmJJ
ULWP úă
ú
Jă%
QJ ú JJ
ú
PDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLHGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHJ
JJ
QXXUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ăQJ &XORUL
JJJJFLWLPvQ%ROLQLHGLQILúLHURSHUHFKHGHFXYLQWHJ ÌQ UH]ROYDUH YDULDELOD QXP UHSUH]LQWă WDEORXO FDUH FRQĠLQH QXPHOH FHORU Q FRSLL vQ
JJJJFăXWăPFXYkQWXO%
vQ%J WDEORXO SUHI SăVWUăP WDEORXO FDUH FRQĠLQH QXPăUXO GH RUGLQH D FXORULL SUHIHUDWH GH
JJJJăODPJăVLWvQFHSkQGFXSR]LĠLDJJJJ FRSLLLDUFXOHVWHWDEORXOvQFDUHVHUHĠLQHQXPăUXOGHDSDULĠLLDILHFăUHLFXORUL
JJJJJJúWHUJHPGLQSHUHFKHDGHFXYLQWHRULJLQDOXO
JJJJJJUHWXUQăPWUDGXFHUHD ([HPSOX
JJJJJJLHúLPIRUĠDWGLQ
)LHWDEORXOQXP 3RS0LKDL3RSDQ$QD3RSD,RQ3RSHVFX0DULXV5XV$QGUHL
JJJJ
J 5XVX7HRGRU7ULI,RQXW3UHVXSXQHPFăH[LVWăFXORULP LDUúLUXOFXORULORUSUH
JJJJJJUHWXUQăPVWULQJXOYLG IHUDWHGHFRSLLvQRUGLQHDQXPHORUGLQWDEORXOQXPHVWHSUHI
JJJJ úă (OHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXLFXOVHGHWHUPLQăvQSDUDOHOFXFLWLUHD$FHVWDYDFRQĠLQHSHSR
JJ ú
JJ ]LĠLDLQXPăUXOFRSLLORUFDUHSUHIHUăFXORDUHDLGHFLFXO FXVHPQLILFDĠLDFX
ú
ORDUHDDSDUHGHSDWUXRULFXORDUHDDSDUHRGDWăFXORDUHDDSDUHGHGRXăRUL
ÌQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHSULPDOLQLHHVWHRFXSDWăGHWH[WXOFDUHWUHEXLHWUDGXV'HILHFD J
%QJ
UHGDWăFkQGVHFDXWăWUDGXFHUHDXQXLFXYkQWvQILúLHUWUHEXLHVăVHUHDOL]H]HVDOWXOSHVWH JJ
ú
J
J
SULPDOLQLHGHFLVHFLWHúWHGRDUPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLH JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJJJ
ú
J
J
6HOHFWDUHDFXYLQWHORUFDUHVHFDXWăvQGLFĠLRQDUVHIDFHvQIHOXOXUPăWRU JJ úJ
JJ
JJ
ú
JJ
J%QJ JJ
J\J
ăQJ
JJ%
JmJJ JJJJ%JmJ`J
JJJmJJ úJ
JJ
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJdJOXQJLPHDWH[WXOXLJJ
ă, JJJJ
ú
J
J
JJJJ
JHVWHOLWHUă
ăQJ JJJJ%
JmJ%
J~JJ
JJJJJJ%
JmJ%
J~JJ ^vQ%
FRQVWUXLPFXYLQWHGLQWH[W`J J J ^FXORDUHD
DDSăUXWvQFăRGDWă`J
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ JJ úJ
JJ
ú
J úJ JJ
ùLUXULGHFDUDFWHUH
ÌQDOJRULWPYRPFăXWDYDORDUHDPD[LPăvQDFHVWúLUDSRLSHDFHLFRSLLFDUHDXDOHV
FXORDUHDLXQGHLHVWHSR]LĠLDSHFDUHVDJăVLWYDORDUHDPD[LPăÌQH[HPSOXYDORDUHD $ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORU &DSLWROXO
PD[LPăvQWDEORXOFXOHVWHHJDOFXúLVHJăVHúWHSHSR]LĠLDSR] $FHDVWăYDULDELOă
DVWIHOUHĠLQHFRGXOXQHLFXORUL6HFDXWăvQWDEORXOSUHILQGLFLLHOHPHQWHORUHJDOHFX PDUL
VHOHFWDUH$FHúWLDVXQW3RS0LKDL3RSDQ$QD3RSD,RQ3RSHVFX0DULXV
&DOFXODUHDYDORULLn
$GXQDUHD
$FXPWUHEXLHVăJăVLPJUXSXOvQFDUHVXQWPDLSXĠLQLFRSLLGDUFDUHGXSăFHDP 6FăGHUHD
SXVSULPXOJUXSGHRSDUWHVXQWFHLPDLQXPHURúLÌQVHDPQăFăQHLQWHUHVHD]ăÄDOGRL ÌQPXOĠLUHD
OHDPD[LP´GLQWDEORXOFXO3HQWUXDXúXUDJăVLUHDDFHVWXLDYRPvQORFXLvQWDEORXOFXO 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
YDORDUHDFX/DSDVXOXUPăWRUPD[LPXOGLQWDEORXOFXO HVWHSHSR]LĠLD 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
DGLFăFXORDUHDÌQWDEORXOSUHIVHFDXWăWRĠLLQGLFLLFRSLLLHOHPHQWHORUGHYDORDUH
SR]$FHúWLDVXQW5XV$QGUHL5XVX7HRGRU ÌQSUREOHPHOHGHFRQFXUVSRWVăDSDUăFHULQĠHFDUHLPSXQSUHOXFUDUHDDQXPLWRUQXPHUH
6HvQORFXLHúWHYDORDUHDFXGHFLFXO $FXPPD[VHJăVHúWHSHSR]LĠLD vQWUHJLÄPDUL´FDUHQXSRWILUHSUH]HQWDWHFXWRDWHFLIUHOHORUH[DFWHIRORVLQGWLSXULOH
úLHVWHHJDOFX6HFDXWăSHED]DWDEORXOXLSUHIWRĠLFRSLLLFDUHSUHIHUăFXORDUHD vQWUHJLFXQRVFXWHGHOLPEDMHOHGHSURJUDPDUH5HSUH]HQWDUHDORUFDUHDOHQXHVWHRVR
$FHúWLDVXQW7ULI,RQXĠ OXĠLHGHRDUHFHQLFLvQWLSXULOHUHDOHQXSXWHPOXFUDFXXQQXPăUPDUHGHFLIUHH[DFWH
'DFăWUHEXLHVăHIHFWXăPFDOFXOHFXDFHVWHQXPHUHúLFHULQĠHOHVXQWGHDúDPDQLHUăvQ
6HvQORFXLHúWHYDORDUHDFXvQWDEORXOFXODFHVWDGHYHQLQGFXO úLSUR FkW WUHEXLH GHWHUPLQDWH WRDWH FLIUHOH H[DFWH DOH QXPăUXOXL WUHEXLH Vă LPSOHPHQWăP
FHVXOVHvQFKHLH ÄDULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL´
J
úQJ
JJ
J?\J
ăQ ^FRSLLLVHJUXSHD]ăvQPJUXSXUL`J &DOFXODUHDYDORULLn
9RP SUH]HQWD DFHDVWă WHKQLFă vQ FD]XO GHWHUPLQăULL YDORULL OXL Q XQGH Q Qd
JJJJ%J ^PD[LPXOGLQúLUXOFXOVHDIOăSHSR]LĠLDSR]`J HVWHQXPăUQDWXUDOSR]LWLY
JJJJ
J?JJ ^FRGXOFXORULL`J
JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ ([HPSOX
JJJJJJăJ
J\JJJ^DILúăPFRSLLLFDUHSUHIHUăFXORDUHDSR]` Q Q
JJJJJJJJ
J
JJ
JJJJJJ úă ÌQFHOHFHXUPHD]ăSHQWUXDH[HPSOLILFDWHKQLFDGHLPSOHPHQWDUHDRSHUDĠLLORUGH
JJJJ ú
JJ DFHVWIHOYRPSUH]HQWDPRGXOvQFDUHVHVLPXOHD]ăFDOFXODUHDOXL
,GHHD HVWH GH D OXFUD SH FLIUH úL GH D ĠLQH HYLGHQĠD WUDQVSRUWXOXL REĠLQXW vQ XUPD
JJJJ%JmJ`J ^HOLPLQăPXOWLPXOPD[LP`J HIHFWXăULLRSHUDĠLHL5H]XOWDWHOHSDUĠLDOHDOHHIHFWXăULLRSHUDĠLLORUSHFLIUHOHYRPUHĠLQH
JJ ú
JJ vQWUXQWDEORXUH]
ú JJ
J N
J N
UH]
$ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL $ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL
6HREVHUYăFăvQWDEORXOUH]DPDGăXJDWHOHPHQWHSHPăVXUăFHVDXUHDOL]DWvQPXO 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
ĠLULOHFX3HQWUXDDILúDYDORDUHDQYRPSDUFXUJHWDEORXOUH]GHODGUHDSWDVSUHVWkQ
JD'HRDUHFHODILHFDUHSDVVHJHQHUHD]ăUH]XOWDWXOSULQvQPXOĠLUHDFLIUăFXFLIUăDUH
]XOWDWXOXL REĠLQXW OD SDVXO DQWHULRU FX WLPSXO GH OXFUX HVWH PLF PDL DOHV GDFă vQ $GXQDUHDQXPHUHORUPDUL
3DVFDOvQORFGHvQPXOĠLUHHIHFWLYăOXFUăPFXRSHUDWRUXO 6ăVHUHDOL]H]HDGXQDUHDDGRXăQXPHUHvQWUHJLPDULFDUHDXPDLPXOWGHFLIUHILH
6ă SUHVXSXQHP Fă VD UHDOL]DW FDOFXOXO OXL N úL WDEORXO UH] DUH GLP WHUPHQL 8U FDUH
PHD]ă Vă HIHFWXăP R QRXă vQPXOĠLUH FX SHQWUX DO REĠLQH SH N 3HQWUXILHFDUHHOH
PHQWGLQúLUXOUH]XOWDWUH]LL GLPHIHFWXăPvQPXOĠLUHDFX'DFăUH]XOWDWXO 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
vQPXOĠLULLHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWDWXQFLvQUH]LVHUHĠLQHGRDUFLIUDXQLWăĠLORULDUFLIUD 9DORULOHFHORUGRXăQXPHUHVHFLWHVFGLQILúLHUXO$(+&$GHSHGRXăOLQLLGLVWLQFWH
]HFLORUWUDQVSRUWXOVHGHSXQHvQDOWăYDULDELOăUHVWXUPkQGVăILHDGXQDWăODWHUPH
QXOXUPăWRU 'DWHGHLHúLUH
'DFăGXSăHIHFWXDUHDFHORUGLPvQPXOĠLULYDULDELODUHVWHVWHGLIHULWăGHXOWLPDvQ 5H]XOWDWXODGXQăULLVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXO$(+&'(!
PXOĠLUHDJHQHUDWFLIUăGHWUDQVSRUWDWXQFLVHPDLDGDXJăXQDOGLPOHDHOHPHQWvQ
WDEORX 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x QXPHUHOHDXFHOPXOWGHFLIUH
$OJRULWPXOFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăDFHDVWăvQPXOĠLUHUHSHWDWăHVWHXUPăWRUXO
([HPSOX
J¡
Ġ
QJ $(+&$ $(+&'(!
JJJmJ`J |`J |`|J
JJJmJJ ^DYHPRFLIUă`J |
JJJmJJ ^DFHDVWDHVWH`
ă
6FăGHUHDQXPHUHORUPDUL
JJJJJmJ`J ^vQYRPGHWHUPLQDODILHFDUHSDVFLIUDGHWUDQVSRUW`J
J\J
ă 6ăVHUHDOL]H]HVFăGHUHDDGRXăQXPHUHvQWUHJLPDULFDUHDXPDLPXOWGHFLIUHILH
FDUH
JJJJJJ
JmJJ~J ^FDOFXOăPFLIUDFXUHQWăGLQ`J
^vQORFGHvQ3DVFDOSXWHPIRORVL `J
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
JJJJJJJmJ
JJ`JJ ^FDOFXOăPWUDQVSRUWXO`J
9DORULOHFHORUGRXăQXPHUHVHFLWHVFGLQILúLHUXO$(+&$GHSHGRXăOLQLLGLVWLQFWH
JJJJJJJmJ
JJ`JJ ^úLFLIUDFXUHQWăGLQ`J
ú
JJ
'DWHGHLHúLUH
ăJJzJ`J
5H]XOWDWXOVFăGHULLVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXO$(+&'(!
^GDFăH[LVWăFLIUăGHWUDQVSRUWvQQHWUHEXLHvQFăXQHOHPHQW`J
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ J
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
JJJJJJJmJJ ^vQDFHVWHOHPHQWSXQHPFLIUDGHWUDQVSRUW`J
JJJJ úăJ
x QXPHUHOHDXFHOPXOWGHFLIUH
JJJJJmJJ~JJ ^DPHIHFWXDWRvQPXOĠLUHFXFUHúWH`
([HPSOX
^SkQăFkQGVHDWLQJHYDORDUHDGDWăvQ
`J $(+&$ $(+&'(!
ăJJ\J
JJ J |`J ||||
ú |
$ILúDUHD UH]XOWDWXOXL vQ ILúLHUXO GH LHúLUH VH IDFH WLSăULQG úLUXO UH] GH GLPHQVLXQH
GLPvQRUGLQHLQYHUVă
$ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL $ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL
QU
ÌQPXOĠLUHDQXPHUHORUPDUL QU
6ăVHUHDOL]H]HvQPXOĠLUHDDGRXăQXPHUHvQWUHJLPDULFDUHDXPDLPXOWGHFLIUHILH
QU
FDUH
/DSULPXOSDV GDUvQQUQXYRPSXWHDDYHDGHFkWHOHPHQWHDYkQG
'DWHGHLQWUDUH YDORDUHPDLPLFăGHFkW5HĠLQHPvQHOHPHQWXOGHSHSR]LĠLDFXUHQWăUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULL
9DORULOHFHORUGRXăQXPHUHVHFLWHVFGLQILúLHUXO$(+&$GHSHGRXăOLQLLGLVWLQFWH vQWUHJLODDDFHVWHLVXPHLDUvQHOHPHQWXOSUHFHGHQWFLIUDGHWUDQVSRUW
QU QU
([HPSOX QU QU
$(+&$ $(+&'(! QU QU
J |J
J J
QU QU
QU QU
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVH QU QU
\`J
ă, ^UHVWXOFLIUHORUVHFRPSOHWHD]ăFX` QU /DSULPXOSDV± QU
JJJJ
JmJ`J QU QU
ú
QU QU
ú
/DDOGRLOHDSDVDUWUHEXLVăVFăGHPGLQ$GăXJăPODLDUGLQGHSHSR]L
$OJRULWPXOFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăDGXQDUHDHVWH ĠLDVXWHORUVFăGHP6FăGHPGLQREĠLQkQG
J
QJ QU 6FăGHPGLQ QU
JJ
J\`
J
ă,JJ QU REĠLQHP QU
JJJJ
JmJ` ^LQLĠLDOFLIUHOHUH]XOWDWXOXLVXQWHJDOHFX` QU QU
ú
$FXPVFăGHPGLQ 8UPHD]ă±
^DGXQăPFLIUHOHGHUDQJQGLQFHOHWUHLQXPHUH`
JJ
J\
J
ă,JJ QU QU
JJJJJmJ
J~J
J~J
QU QU
JJJJăJJJ`JJ ^GDFăVXPDFLIUHORUHVWHGLQLQWHUYDOXO>@`J QU QU
JJJJJJ
JmJJ ^FLIUDFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHGLQ
YDILDFHDVWăVXPă` 8OWLPDVFăGHUH±
JJJJ
J^vQFD]FRQWUDUFLIUDSUHFHGHQWăSULPHúWHYDORDUHDFLIUHLGHWUDQVSRUW`
JJJJJJ
JmJJ ^FkQGL DYHPXOWLPXOWUDQVSRUW` QU
^FLIUDFXUHQWăSULPHúWHUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLvQWUHJLDVXPHLOD` QU
JJJJJJ
JmJJJ`JJ QU
JJJJ úăJ 5H]XOWDWXOREĠLQXWHVWH
JJ ú
J
úJ J ÌQSURJUDPDVHPăQăWRUDGXQăULLQXPăUXOIRUPDWGLQPDLSXĠLQHFLIUHGHFkWFHOăODOW
VHYDFRPSOHWDFXFLIUHGH
$ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL $ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL
$OJRULWPXOFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăDFHDVWăFRPSOHWDUHFX]HURXULHVWHVLPLODUFXFHOIRORVLW /DILHFDUHVFăGHUHYHULILFăPGDFăYDORDUHDGHVFă]XWXOXLHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWYDORD
vQSURJUDPXOFDUHUHDOL]DDGXQDUHD UHDVFă]ăWRUXOXLÌQFD]DILUPDWLYUHDOL]ăPVFăGHUHDúLUHĠLQHPUH]XOWDWXOvQFLIUDFRUHV
SXQ]ăWRDUHDOXLQUÌQFD]FRQWUDUvPSUXPXWăPGHODHOHPHQWXOGLQVWkQJDvOGH
J
KJ FUHPHQWăPSHDFHVWDúLHIHFWXăPVFăGHUHD
JJJmJ
JJJ $ILúDUHDvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVHIDFHvQVXEDOJRULWPXOGHPDLMRV
JJ
J\
~J
ă,JJ J
JJJJ
JmJ
J J
ú
QJ
JJ ú
J JJJmJJ
JJJmJ
J
J
J\J`J
ă,JJ ^ULOHGHODvQFHSXWQXOHYRPDILúD`J
JJ
\J
ă JJJJJmJJ~JJJ
JJJJ
JmJ`J ú
J
JJ ú
J ăJJ
J
JJJ J
ú J ^GDFăQXPHUHOHVXQWHJDOHWDEORXO
FRQĠLQHQXPDLYDORULQXOH`
JJ
J` ^VHYDVFULHGRDUXQVLQJXU`
$OJRULWPXOGHPDLVXVVHDSOLFăGXSăFHVHVWDELOHúWHFDUHWDEORXWUHEXLHFRPSOHWDW
FX]HURXUL$FHDVWăGHFL]LHVHLDvQDOJRULWPXOGHPDLMRV JJJJ
JJdJ
J
ă,
JJJJJJ
J%J
J%
QJ
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
ăJ
JtJJJJ JJJJ ú
J
JJJJ
J úăJ
JJJJ%
J ú
JJ
JJ
J J ^GDFăDOGRLOHDQXPăUHVWHPDLPDUHGHFkWSULPXOHOYDILGHVFă]XWXO`J
JJJJ
ÌQPXOĠLUHDQXPHUHORUPDUL
JJJJJm
KJ
JmJ
KJ
JmJ 3UH]HQWăPXQH[HPSOXGHvQPXOĠLUHDGRXăQXPHUH9RPUHĠLQHFHOHGRXăQXPHUHvQ
JJJJ?JmJ
KJ
JmJKJJmJ?J WDEORXULOHGHFLIUHQUúLQU5H]XOWDWXOVHYDPHPRUDvQWDEORXOGHFLIUHQU
JJJJ%
J
úăJJ )LHQU úLQU 3URGXVXOORUHVWH
ú J
1XPăU &LIUDGH &LIUDGH &LIUDGH &LIUDGH &LIUDGH ([SOLFDĠLL
$OJRULWPXOFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăVFăGHUHDHVWH UDQJ UDQJ UDQJ UDQJ UDQJ
QU FLIUHOHSULPXOXLQXPăU
J%
QJ
J\
J
ă, QU FLIUHOHFHOXLGHDOGRLOHD
ăJ
JJ
JJ UH]XOWDWXOSDUĠLDOGXSă
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J~J`J vQPXOĠLUHDFXFLIUD
JJJJJJ
JmJ
JJ
J UH]XOWDWXOSDUĠLDOGXSă
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J vQPXOĠLUHDFXFLIUD
JJJJ
QU UH]XOWDWXOvQPXOĠLULLGXSă
JJJJJJ
JmJ
JJ
J DGXQDUHDUH]XOWDWHORUSDU
J JJ úăJ ĠLDOH
ú
J
ú J
$ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL
8UPHD]ăSUHOXFUDUHDÄFLIUHORU´UH]XOWDWXOXL3HQWUXILHFDUHHOHPHQWPDLPDUHGHFkW
GHWHUPLQăPUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLDFHVWXLDODFLIUDFDUHYDvQORFXLQXPăUXOUHVSHFWLY
úLFkWXOFDUHUHSUH]LQWăWUDQVSRUWXOFDUHVHYDDGXQDODXUPăWRUXOQXPăUGLQúLU
1XPăU &LIUDGH &LIUDGH &LIUDGH &LIUDGH &LIUDGH
UDQJ UDQJ UDQJ UDQJ UDQJ
QU >@
UHVW>@ >@ >@ >@
UHVW>@ UHVW>@ UHVW>@
QU
$ULWPHWLFDQXPHUHORUPDUL
5H]XOWDWXOvQPXOĠLULLHVWH
J%
Q
6HREVHUYăFăVHUHDOL]HD]ăvQPXOĠLUHDFHORUGRXăQXPHUHFLIUăFXFLIUăFDvQDULW
J\
~J
ă,
PHWLFă 5H]XOWDWHOH vQPXOĠLULL SRW IL QXPHUH IRUPDWH GLQ XQD VDX GRXă FLIUH VH ăJ
JJ`JdJJ
SăVWUHD]ăvQWDEORXO
vQRUGLQHLQYHUVăDGLFăGHODVWkQJDODGUHDSWDúLIăUăVăVH JJJJJJ
~JmJ
~J~J
JJ`J
UHDOL]H]HWUDQVIHUXOFLIUHL]HFLORUODILHFDUHSDV$FHVWHUH]XOWDWHSDUĠLDOHVHYRUSăVWUD JJJJJJ
JmJ
JJ`J
vQ WDEORXO
DVWIHO vQFkW UH]XOWDWHOH vQPXOĠLULORU FXUHQWH VH YRU DGXQD LPHGLDW OD úăJ
ú
HOHPHQWXODQWHULRUGHSODVkQGXQHFXRSR]LĠLHODGUHDSWDODILHFDUHvQPXOĠLUHFXRFLIUă
ú
QRXăGLQvQPXOĠLWRU
J
/D VIkUúLWXO DGXQăULORU SUHOXFUăP WDEORXO
DVWIHO vQFkW DFHVWD Vă FRQĠLQă FLIUH
ùLUXOFLIUHORUVHDILúHD]ăvQRUGLQHLQYHUVă
SRUQLPGHODVWkQJDODGUHDSWDvQHOHPHQWXOFXUHQWSăVWUăPUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLvQWUHJLOD
DDFHVWXLDLDUSDUWHDvQWUHDJăDvPSăUĠLULLODDGXQăPODHOHPHQWXOXUPăWRU
ú
Q
Jm
~J
ă,
$OJRULWPXOFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăDFHDVWăvQPXOĠLUHHVWH
JJJJ
J
J
J¡
Ġ
QJJ ú
J
ú
JJ?JmJ`JJ ^NYDFRQĠLQHYDORDUHDFXFDUHVHGHSODVHD]ăUH]XOWDWHOHSDUĠLDOH`
^vQIXQFĠLHGHQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOFLIUHLFXUHQWHGLQvQPXOĠLWRU`
J\J
ă,
J\
J
ă,
J ^FDOFXODUHDSURGXVXOXL`
JJJJJJ
~~?JmJ
~~?J~J
J
JJJJ ú
J J ^GXSăFHVDvQPXOĠLWvQWUHJúLUXOFXRFLIUăVHWUHFHODXUPăWRDUHD`
^UH]XOWDWXOFDUHVDUVFULHVXEFHODQWHULRUHVWHGHSODVDWVSUHGUHDSWDFXRSR]LĠLH`J
JJJJ?JmJ?J~J
ú
ú
5H]XOWDWXOGLQWDEORXO
VHSUHOXFUHD]ăGHRDUHFHFRQĠLQHQXPHUHúLQXFLIUH
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
0HGLLOHWXWXURUHOHYLORUXQHLFODVHODWRDWHGLVFLSOLQHOHVWXGLDWHSRWILSăVWUDWHvQWUR
VLQJXUăVWUXFWXUăGHGDWHvQFDUHYDORULOHVXQWDUDQMDWHOLQLDUSHOLQLLúLFRORDQHROLQLH
FRUHVSXQGHXQXLHOHYRFRORDQăFRUHVSXQGHXQHLGLVFLSOLQHVWXGLDWHÌQH[HPSOXOGH
PDLVXVOLQLDFRUHVSXQGHHOHYXOXL%DQvQFRORDQDVXQWVFULVHPHGLLOHODHGXFDĠLH
IL]LFă
7DEORXUL &DSLWROXO
7DEORXOELGLPHQVLRQDOHVWHRVWUXFWXUăGHGDWHvQFDUHILHFăUXLHOHPHQWvLHVWHDVRFL
ELGLPHQVLRQDOH DWăRSHUHFKHGHLQGLFLSULPXOSUHFL]kQGQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOOLQLHLvQFDUHVHDIOăHOH
PHQWXOLDUFHOGHDOGRLOHD±QXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOFRORDQHL0HGLDDIODWăSHOLQLDLúL
'HILQLĠLH FRORDQDMVHYDQRWDFX0HGLH>LM@úLUHSUH]LQWăPHGLDHOHYXOXLLODGLVFLSOLQDM2ULFă
2SHUDĠLLFXWDEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH UXLWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDOLVHDORFăVSDĠLXGHPHPRULHvQWUR]RQăFRQWLQXăGHPHPR
&DUHXULPDJLFH ULHHOHPHQWHOHDIOkQGXVHvQORFDĠLLVXFFHVLYHGHPHPRULHDúH]DWHOLQLHGXSăOLQLH
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU ([HPSOX
8QWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDODYkQGWUHLOLQLLúLSDWUXFRORDQHVHYDUHSUH]HQWDvQPHPR
ULHDVWIHO
$P Yă]XW Fă vQWUXQ WDEORX XQLGLPHQVLRQDO VH SRW SăVWUD PDL PXOWH YDORUL GH DFHODúL
WLS )LH GH H[HPSOX PHGLLOH JHQHUDOH DOH WXWXURU HOHYLORU XQHL FODVH 7RDWH PHGLLOH
QXPHUHUHDOHVHGHQXPHVFFXDFHODúLLGHQWLILFDWRUGHH[HPSOX0HG*HQLDUXQHOH
PHQWvQDFHDVWăJUXSDUHVHJăVHúWHSHED]DSR]LĠLHLRFXSDWHvQJUXSXOGHYDORULDUDQMD
WHOLQLDU'DFăSULYLPúLUXOQXPHORUDFHVWHDODUkQGXOORUIRUPHD]ăXQDOWúLUvQFDUH
ILHFDUHHOHPHQWHVWHXQúLUGHFDUDFWHUH /LQLD/LQLD/LQLD
([HPSOX
0HG*HQ
3R]LĠLH 9RPGDGHILQLĠLDWDEORXOXLELGLPHQVLRQDO
vQFD]JHQHUDO
9DORDUH
1XPH
3R]LĠLH
9DORDUH $OEX %DQ =HFLX
'HILQLĠLH
)LH0 ^P`úL1 ^«Q`PXOĠLPHDSULPHORUPUHVSHFWLYQQXPHUHQD
&RUHVSXQ]ăWRUDFHVWXLH[HPSOXQHSXWHDPUHIHULODQRWDXQXLHOHYSULQ0HG*HQ>QU@ WXUDOHQHQXOH&RQVLGHUăPRPXOĠLPHGHHOHPHQWH(DOHFăURUWLSGHED]ăHVWH7
XQGHQUHVWHQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHGLQFDWDORJDOHOHYXOXLUHVSHFWLY$FHDVWăYDORDUHHVWH 6HQXPHúWHWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDOGHGLPHQVLXQHPuQDYkQGHOHPHQWHGHWLSXO7
LQGLFHOHHOHPHQWXOXLvQúLU RIXQFĠLH$0u1ĺ(
1HSURSXQHPVăUHIHULPWRDWHPHGLLOHSHGLVFLSOLQHDOHILHFăUXLHOHYSULQWURVLQJX
UăYDULDELOă&RQIRUPFDWDORJXOXLFXQRVFXWGLQúFRDOăDYHPXUPăWRDUHOHGDWH 1RWăP HOHPHQWHOH FX DLM XQGH L 0 M 1 $FHVWH HOHPHQWH VXQW DUDQMDWH SH P
OLQLLúLQFRORDQHDVWIHOvQFkWDFHOHHOHPHQWHFDUHDXLQGLFHOHGHOLQLHLVXQWSODVDWHSH
/LPEDURPkQă 0DWHPDWLFă (GXFDĠLHIL]LFă DFHHDúLOLQLHLLDUFHOHDYkQGDFHODúLLQGLFHGHFRORDQăMSHDFHHDúLFRORDQăM
$OEX
%DQ § D D DQ ·
¨ ¸
D D D Q ¸
=HFLX $ ¨
¨ ¸
¨D ¸
© P D P D PQ ¹
1RĠLXQHDGHWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDOGHULYăGLQQRĠLXQHDGHPDWULFHFXQRVFXWăGLQPDWHPDWLFă
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH 7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
&D]XULSDUWLFXODUH
x ÌQPRGVLPLODUúLUXOGHHOHPHQWHDQDQDQ IRUPHD]ăGLDJRQDODVHFXQGDUă
'DFăQ DYHPXQWDEORXGHGLPHQVLXQLP uFDUHVHQXPHúWHWDEORXFRORDQăúL DWDEORXOXLÌQFD]XODFHVWRUDLQGLFLLHOHPHQWHORUUHVSHFWăUHODĠLDLM Q
HVWHGHIRUPD
x ÌQ FD]XO HOHPHQWHORU DIODWH GHDVXSUD GLDJRQDOHL VHFXQGDUH LQGLFLL DX SURSULHWDWHD
§ D · LMQLDUFHOHFDUHVHDIOăVXEGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDOăDXLQGLFLFXSURSULHWDWHD
¨ ¸
¨ D ¸ LM!Q
$
¨ ¸
¨D ¸ 2EVHUYăPFăSHQWUXDSDUFXUJHGRDUHOHPHQWHOHGHVXEGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDOăLQGLFLL
© P ¹ GH OLQLH úL GH FRORDQă YDULD]ă DVWIHO vQFkW Vă DFRSHUH XQ ÄWULXQJKL GUHSWXQJKLF´ GLQ
'DFăP WDEORXOGHGLPHQVLXQHuQVHQXPHúWHWDEORXOLQLHúLHVWHGHIRUPD WDEORX$FHVWWULXQJKLDUHLSRWHQX]DVXEGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDOăúLFHOHGRXăFDWHWHVXQW
$ DD«DQ FRORDQDúLOLQLDQÌQFRQFOX]LHODDFHVWWULXQJKLGHSHOLQLDLYRUSDUWLFLSDHOHPHQWHOH
GHSHFRORDQHOHL±
'DFăP QDYHPXQWDEORXGHGLPHQVLXQHQuQQXPLWWDEORXSăWUDWLF
([HPSOX 2SHUDĠLLFXWDEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
)LHXQWDEORXSăWUDWLFGHGLPHQVLXQHP Q ÌQ DOJRULWPL YRP SUHOXFUD WDEORXUL ELGLPHQVLRQDOH vQ FHOH PDL YDULDWH PRGXUL 9RP
L MLM IDFH GLVWLQFĠLH vQWUH RSHUDĠLL FDUH DFFHVHD]ă WDEORXO FD SH XQ vQWUHJ úL RSHUDĠLL FDUH
D D D D D D DFFHVHD]ăHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXL'DUvQDLQWHGHWRDWHXQWDEORXWUHEXLHGHFODUDW
D D D D D D 'HFODUDUHDWDEORXULORUELGLPHQVLRQDOH
'HFODUDĠLDDUHXUPăWRDUHDIRUPăJHQHUDOă
D D D D D D
\WLSBLQGLFHWLSBLQGLFHWLSBGHBED]ăKJ
QK
D D D D D D XQGHSULQWLSBLQGLFHWLSBLQGLFHVHvQĠHOHJHWLSXOYDORULORUGLQFDUHVHDOLPHQWHD]ăLQ
GLFLLHVWHREOLJDWRULXXQWLSRUGLQDOLDUWLSBGHBED]ăHVWHWLSXOHOHPHQWHORUWDEORXOXL
$FHVWWLSGHED]ăSRDWHILRULFHSXWHPDYHDHOHPHQWHGHRULFHWLSQXPHULFGHFDUDFWH
D D D D D D
UHVDXúLUXULGHFDUDFWHUHYDORULERROHHQHvQUHJLVWUăULYH]LWLSXO
WDEORXULGH
FHOHPDLGLYHUVHWLSXULHWF
D D D D D D WLSBLQGLFHWLSBLQGLFHSRWILLGHQWLILFDWRULGHWLSSUHGHILQLWVDXGHILQLWGHXWLOL]DWRU
úLGHDVHPHQHDSRWILH[SUHVLLFXPHQĠLXQHDFăvQDFHVWHDSRWLQWHUYHQLGRDUFRQVWDQ
L!M WHúLFRQVWDQWHVLPEROLFH
x (OHPHQWHOH vQ FD]XO FăURUD LQGLFHOH GH OLQLH FRLQFLGH FX LQGLFHOH GH FRORDQă D ([HPSOX
DDQQIRUPHD]ăGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDOăDWDEORXOXL
\|K
x 3DUDOHOHOHODGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDOăDWDEORXOXLYRUDWLQJHDFHOHHOHPHQWHvQFD]XOFă J\
JJXYKJ
URUDL MNXQGH±QNQ±3HQWUXILHFDUHYDORDUHDOXLNYDULLQGMREĠL JJJJ\X
XYJJ
KJ
QHPRSDUDOHOăODGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDOă
'DFăVWUXFWXUDXQXLWDEORXHVWHGHVFULVăvQVHFĠLXQHD DWXQFLHOYDDYHDXQWLS
x (OHPHQWHOH GH GHDVXSUD GLDJRQDOHL SULQFLSDOH VDWLVIDF SURSULHWDWHD L M LDU FHOH
FDUHVHVLWXHD]ăVXEGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDOăDXSURSULHWDWHDFăLQGLFLLORUVDWLVIDFUHOD DQRQLP$VRFLLQGWLSXOXLUHVSHFWLYXQLGHQWLILFDWRUGHWLSvQWURGHFODUDĠLH
DFHVWD
ĠLDL!M YDSXWHDILIRORVLWvQSURJUDPRULXQGHYUHPVăUHIHULPDFHVWWLS
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH 7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
5HDPLQWLPFăGRXăWDEORXULGHFODUDWHvQGRXăGHFODUDĠLLDQRQLPHGLIHULWHYRUILGH $WULEXLUHD
WLSXULGLIHULWHFKLDUGDFăvQHOHVDGHVFULVDFHHDúLVWUXFWXUă $WULEXLUHDODQLYHOGHWDEORXHVWHSHUPLVăGRDUGDFăLGHQWLILFDWRULLPHQĠLRQDĠLvQSDUWHD
([HPSOX VWkQJăúLFHDGUHDSWăDRSHUDĠLHLGHDWULEXLUHDXDFHODúLWLS'HH[HPSOXFRQIRUPGH
J\`|JJXYKJ FODUDĠLLORUGLQH[HPSOXOPHQĠLRQDW[SRDWHSULPLYDORDUHDOXL\LDUESRDWHOXDYDORD
JYQKJ UHDOXLF3XWHPVFULHvQSURJUDPQ\YKúLQ\%KGDUQXSXWHPVFULHQ\K
JJJJQ`|JJXYKJ
JJJJ%Q`|JJXYKJ ğLQkQGFRQWGHIDSWXOFăvQPXOWHDSOLFDĠLLYDILQHFHVDUăHIHFWXDUHDXQRURSHUDĠLLFX
HOHPHQWHOHWDEORXULORUELGLPHQVLRQDOHDVHPăQăWRURSHUDĠLLORUGLQWHRULDPDWULFHORUvQ
ÌQ SURJUDPXO FDUH FRQĠLQH DFHVWH GHFODUDĠLL WDEORXULOH [ úL \ YRU IL FRQVLGHUDWH GH PDWHPDWLFăYRPSUH]HQWDFkWHYDGLQDFHVWHRSHUDĠLL
DFHODúLWLSEúLFGHDVHPHQHDYRUDYHDXQWLSFRPXQDQRQLPLDUDYD
ILGHWLSDQRQLPGLIHULWGHUHVSHFWLYGHWLSXODQRQLPDOOXLEúLF
$GXQDUHDPDWULFHORU
)LH$úL%GRXăPDWULFHGHGLPHQVLXQHPuQ
&LWLUHDWDEORXULORUELGLPHQVLRQDOH $ DLMdLdPdMdQ
ÌQSURJUDPHGHUHJXOăSULPDRSHUDĠLHYDILFLWLUHDXQXLDVWIHOGHWDEORXÌQOLPEDMHOH % ELMdLdPdMdQ
3DVFDOúL&QXVHSRDWHFLWLRYDULDELOăGHWLSWDEORX$FHDVWăRSHUDĠLHVHYDUHDOL]DHOH 'HILQLPPDWULFHD
PHQWFXHOHPHQW & FLMdLdPdMdQ
J
QJ
DOHFăUHLHOHPHQWHVXQWGDWHGHHJDOLWăĠLOH
FLM DLMELM
JJ
ú
J
JJ ^WDEORXO[DUHPOLQLLúLQFRORDQH`J
J\J
ă,JJ RULFDUHDUILL «PM «Q
JJJJ
J\
J
ă,J 0DWULFHD&VHQXPHúWHVXPDGLQWUHPDWULFHOH$úL%úLVHQRWHD]ă
JJJJJJ
ú
JJ & $%
ú
ÌQSURJUDPYRPUHDOL]DDGXQDUHDHOHPHQWFXHOHPHQWFRQIRUPIRUPXOHL
ú
0HQĠLRQăPFăDGXQDUHDDGRXăPDWULFHHVWHFRPXWDWLYă$% %$úLHVWHDVR
ú FLDWLYă$%& $%&0DWULFHDHOHPHQWQHXWUXIDĠăGHDGXQDUHVHQXPHú
WHPDWULFHQXOăúLDUHWRDWHHOHPHQWHOHHJDOHFX6HYDQRWDPQ
2PDWULFHIRUPDWăGLQHOHPHQWXOPDLSXĠLQSHGLDJRQDODSULQFLSDOăXQGHDUHQX
$ILúDUHDWDEORXULORUELGLPHQVLRQDOH PDLYDORULHJDOHFXVHQXPHúWHPDWULFHXQLWDWHúLVHQRWHD]ăFX,Q
$ILúDUHD WDEORXULORU VH UHDOL]HD]ă DVHPăQăWRU 'DFă GRULP Vă UHDOL]ăP R DILúDUH OLQLH
GXSă OLQLH D WDEORXOXL GH WLSXO DYkQG OLQLL úL
FRORDQH vQ 3DVFDO YRP
VFULHSURFHGXUDvQIHOXOXUPăWRU 0DWULFHDRSXVă
J 2ULFDUHDUILPDWULFHD$H[LVWăRPDWULFHQRWDWăFX±$DVWIHOvQFkW
J
ú
QXYKJQKJ $±$ ±$$ PQ
JQ\JJJJ
J
JJJJJQ\JJ
JJ
JJJJJJJKJ
&DUHXULPDJLFH
([LVWă R ERJDWă WUDGLĠLH D SăWUDWHORU PDJLFH 5HIHULULOH OD SULPHOH SăWUDWH PDJLFH VH
JJJJ
JJ ^WUHFHPODOLQLHQRXă`J
J SLHUGvQQHJXUDWLPSXULORU
'HILQLĠLH
8QFDUHXGHGLPHQVLXQHQFDUHFRQĠLQHQXPHUHGHODODQVHQXPHúWHPDJLFGDFă
VXPDQXPHUHORUGHSHRULFDUHOLQLHDFDUHXOXLHVWHHJDOăFXVXPDQXPHUHORUGHSHRUL
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
([HPSOX
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
Q SDúLL SDúLLSkQăODSDVXO
FDUHFRORDQăúLVXQWHJDOHFXVXPDQXPHUHORUDIODWHSHRULFDUHGLQWUHFHOHGRXăGLDJR
QDOH$FHDVWăYDORDUHVHQXPHúWHVXPăPDJLFăúLVHFDOFXOHD]ăFXIRUPXOD
VXPăBPDJLFăQ QQ
3UH]HQWăP WUHL DOJRULWPL GLIHULĠL SHQWUX JHQHUDUHD SăWUDWHORU PDJLFH vQ IXQFĠLH GH
SURSULHWDWHDOXLQ
D QHVWHLPSDU
E QHVWHPXOWLSOXGH
F QHVWHSDUGDUQXHVWHPXOWLSOXGH
3ăWUDWXOPDJLFGHRUGLQPXOWLSOXGH
3ăWUDWXOPDJLFGHRUGLQLPSDU 3HQWUXDJHQHUDXQSăWUDWPDJLFGHRUGLQQQPXOWLSOXGHVHDSOLFăXUPăWRULLSDúL
ÌQFDUWHDOXL)HQJ6KXL$UWDYLHĠLLvQDUPRQLHFXQDWXUDSUHFXPúLvQFDUWHDOXL<L x 6HJHQHUHD]ăSăWUDWXOGHGLPHQVLXQHQvQFDUHDúH]ăPQXPHUHOHGHODODQvQRU
-LQJ&DUWHDVFKLPEăULORUDXWRULLFRQVLGHUăFăSăWUDWXOPDJLFGHVFRSHULWGH:X+VLD GLQHSHOLQLL
DIRVWLPDJLQDWSHFDUDSDFHDXQHLEURDúWHĠHVWRDVH$FHVWSăWUDWPDJLFHVWHDWULEXLWFL x (OHPHQWHOHDIODWHSHOLQLLDYkQGQXPăUGHRUGLQHSHQWUXFDUHUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLOD
YLOL]DĠLHLFKLQH]HGLQWUHDQLL±vQDLQWHGH&KULVWRV HVWHVDXúLFRORDQHFDUHQXDXDFHDVWăSURSULHWDWHVDXSHFRORDQHDYkQGQXPăU
GHRUGLQHSHQWUXFDUHUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLODHVWHVDXúLOLQLLFDUHQXDXDFHDVWă
SURSULHWDWHYRUILVFKLPEDWHFXHOHPHQWHOHDIODWHvQSR]LĠLLVLPHWULFHIDĠăGHPLMOR
FXOFDUHXOXLDúDFXPVHSRDWHREVHUYDGLQILJXUDXUPăWRDUH
J
ă,J
HVWHúLPDLLPSRUWDQWGHREVHUYDWVHUHIHUăODIDSWXOFăDWXQFLFkQGYRPSDUFXUJHXQ
JJJJJmJJ~JJJ ^FUHúWHFRQWRUXOSăWUăĠHOHORURFXSDWH`J ÄFHUF´ LQWHULRU LPHGLDW XUPăWRU H[WHULRUXOXL WRDWH OLPLWHOH GH vQFHSXW FUHVF FX LDU
JJJJ
J?J ^vOVFULHPSHNvQILúLHU`J OLPLWHOHGHVIkUúLWVFDGFXÌQFRQVHFLQĠăYRPLQLĠLDOL]DGRXăYDULDELOHFX
JJJJJmJSDUWHvQWUHDJăGLQUăGăFLQDSăWUDWăDOXLNJ úL FX
FDUHvúLYRUVFKLPEDYDORULOHGXSăvQFKLGHUHDXQXLÄFHUF´DVSLUDOHL
JJJJăJ?JHVWHQXPăUSDUJJJ
mmJJ
JJJJJJJmJJJ
JJJJ
'LQREVHUYDĠLDUH]XOWăFăYRPvQFHSHDúH]DUHDQXPHUHORUGLQILúLHULQGLIHUHQWGH
SDULWDWHDOXLQSDUFXUJkQGHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXLSHOLQLDGHLQGLFHSULPXOVSUHGUHDSWD
JJJJJJJmJJ ^FHOPDL0,&GLYL]RUDOOXLN`J
$UXUPDSDUFXUJHUHDGHVXVvQMRVDFRORDQHLGHLQGLFHXOWLPXOGDUDFHDVWăSDUFXUJHUH
JJJJJJ
J?JJJzJ`JúJJdJJ
ă,
QXvQWRWGHDXQDHVWHSRVLELOăQHFHVDUăúLDQXPHGDFăQHVWHLPSDUGXSăRDVHPHQHD
JJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ ^GLYL]RULLPSDUL`J
JJJJJJ ú
SDUFXUJHUHVHWHUPLQăSUHOXFUDUHD6XEDOJRULWPXOFDUHFUHHD]ăĠLQWDHVWHXUPăWRUXO
úăJ
Jğ
ă
Ġ
QJ
JJJJăJJdJJ ^DYHPXQGLYL]RU`J
JJmJ
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ ^QHSUHJăWLPVăVFULHPXQQXPăUvQILúLHU`J
JJJJJJăJJdJ
J
ă,
JJ ú
J ^vQYDULDELOD
QXPăUăPSR]LĠLLOHSUHOXFUDWHSHĠLQWă`J
ú JJJJJJSDUFXUJHPFRORDQDGHLQGLFHGHVXVvQMRV
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH 7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
JJJJJJSDUFXUJHPOLQLDGHLQGLFHGHODGUHDSWDODVWkQJDJ 9RPGHILQLGRXăúLUXULGHFkWHSDWUXHOHPHQWHvQFDUHYRPSăVWUDYDORULOHFDUHWUH
JJJJJJSDUFXUJHPFRORDQDGHLQGLFHGHMRVvQVXVJ EXLHDGXQDWHFRRUGRQDWHL[UHVSHFWLYFRRUGRQDWHL\SHQWUXDQHGHSODVDSHRGLUHFĠLH
GDWăG'HSODVDUHDvQFHOHSDWUXGLUHFĠLLOHSXWHPFRGLILFDvQIHOXOXUPăWRU
JJJJJJmJ
JJJJJJmJJJ G
JJJJJJSDUFXUJHPOLQLDGHLQGLFHGHODVWkQJDODGUHDSWDJ
JJ ú
J
HVWHQXPăULPSDUJ SR]LĠLDFXUHQWă LM LM LM LM
JJSDUFXUJHPXOWLPDFRORDQăGHVXVvQMRV QRXDSR]LĠLH L±M LM LM± L±M±
JJSDUFXUJHPXOWLPDOLQLHGHODGUHDSWDODVWkQJDJ VFDGHOLQLD FUHúWHOLQLD FUHúWHOLQLD VFDGHOLQLD
JJ
J
JJ
J
ă, FUHúWHFRORDQD FUHúWHFRORDQD VFDGHFRORDQD VFDGHFRORDQD
^vQYDULDELOD
QXPăUăPSR]LĠLLOHSUHOXFUDWHSHĠLQWă`J '[ ± ±
JJJJSDUFXUJHPFRORDQDGHLQGLFHGHMRVvQVXVJ '\ ± ±
JJJJmJ
/D ILHFDUH SDV FRRUGRQDWHOH L úL M VH PRGLILFă vQ L '[>G@ UHVSHFWLY M '\>G@
JJJJmJJJ
$FHVWPRGGHUHSUH]HQWDUHQHYDXúXUDJHVWLRQDUHDVFKLPEăULORUGHGLUHFĠLH
JJJJSDUFXUJHPOLQLDGHLQGLFHGHODVWkQJDODGUHDSWD
JJJJSDUFXUJHPFRORDQDGHLQGLFHGHVXVvQMRV
2EVHUYăPFăODvQWkOQLUHDXQHLPDUJLQLDPHVHLFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHXQHLPDUJLQLYHU
JJJJSDUFXUJHPOLQLDGHLQGLFHGHODGUHDSWDODVWkQJDJ
ú
WLFDOHvQWDEORXGLUHFĠLDGHGHSODVDUHVHPRGLILFăDVWIHO
úă
ú
GLUHFĠLDVHWUDQVIRUPăvQGLUHFĠLDúLLQYHUV
3DUFXUJHULOHPHQĠLRQDWHPDLVXVQXVXQWSUREOHPDWLFH7UHEXLHGRDUVăDYHPJULMă
VăQXSUHOXFUăPXQDFHODúLHOHPHQWGHGRXăRULGHRDUHFHDVWIHODPVXSUDVFULHDQXPLWH
YDORULúLvQILQDOQXQHDUDMXQJHQXPHUHOHJHQHUDWHvQILúLHU3HQWUXH[HPSOLILFDUHVă
YHGHPSDUFXUJHUHDGHMRVvQVXV
«
QJ
JJ
J\~J
ă, ^SDVXOHVWH±` GLUHFĠLDVHWUDQVIRUPăvQGLUHFĠLDúLvQ
JJJJ
m
J
JJJJ
ú
J
JJ ^VHFLWHúWHQXPăUXOFXUHQWGLQILúLHUXOGHPDQHYUă`J
JJJJĠ
ăm
J
J J ^HOHPHQWXOGHSHOLQLDúLFRORDQDvQWDEORXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUĠLQWHL`J
ú
/DvQWkOQLUHDXQHLPDUJLQLDPHVHLFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHXQHLPDUJLQLRUL]RQWDOHvQWD
ú EORXGLUHFĠLDVHVFKLPEăvQGLUHFĠLDúLvQLDUGLUHFĠLDVHWUDQVIRUPăvQúL
vQ9RPDVLJXUDVFKLPEDUHDGLUHFĠLHLFXRVWUXFWXUăGHWLS
ăFDUHVHYDH[HFX
WDSkQăFkQGELODLHVHSULQWUXQFROĠVDXLQWUăvQFLFOX
%LOLDUG ÌQ VXEDOJRULWPXO XUPăWRU vQ YDULDELOD SDV JHQHUăP YDORDUHD FDUH PDUFKHD]ă PR
5H]ROYDUHDSUREOHPHLQHFHVLWăVLPXODUHDDQXPLWRUGHSODVăULGHDOXQJXOXQRUOLQLLFDUH PHQWXOvQFDUHELODWUDYHUVHD]ăXQDQXPLWSXQFWGHSHPDVă'DFăPLQJHDDUXUPDVă
VXQW SDUDOHOH FX GLDJRQDOHOH SăWUDWXOXL ÄGHFXSDW´ GH PLúFDUHD ELOHL GLQ WDEORXO ELGL úLUHLDWUDVHXOúLDVWIHOVăLQWUHvQFLFOXLQILQLWYDULDELODERROHDQăLQILQLWSULPHúWHYDORD
PHQVLRQDO GUHSWXQJKLXODU FRUHVSXQ]ăWRU PHVHL úL R VWăSkQLUH FRUHFWă D VFKLPEăULORU UHD DGHYăUDW 3HQWUX D DYHD FRQWURO DVXSUD PRPHQWXOXL vQ FDUH ELOD LHVH GH SH PDVă
GHGLUHFĠLHDWXQFLFkQGELODVHORYHúWHGHPDUJLQHDPHVHL DMXQJHvQWUXQFROĠQHIRORVLPGHRIXQFĠLHERROHDQă
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH 7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
J
ăQJJ $ILúDUHDWDEORXOXLDFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUPHVHLGHELOLDUGHVWHSUHFHGDWăGHYHULILFDUHD
JJ
ăJmJJ\JJ JJ\JJúJJ\JJ JJ\J
J YDULDELOHLLQILQLWSHQWUXDVWDELOLGDFăVHYDVFULHPHVDMXOUHIHULWRUODPLúFDUHDELOHL
ú
J
úQ
5H]ROYDUHDSUREOHPHLFRQVWăvQVLPXODUHDPLúFăULLELOHL$QWHULRUDSHOXOXLVXEDOJR JJăJ
JJ
ULWPXOXLú%VDXFLWLWGDWHOHGHLQWUDUHúLVDLQLĠLDOL]DWWDEORXODFXHOHPHQWHQXOH JJJJ
J
J
JJJJJJ
J úăJJ
Jú%
QJ JJ
J\J
ăQJ
JJJmJJ JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJYJmJYJ JJJJJJ
JJ
ú
JJ
JJJmJ ^FRQWRUXOSHQWUXPDUFDUHDSR]LĠLLORUVWUăEăWXWH`J JJ ú
JJ
JJJmJJ ú
JJăJmJIDOVJJ J
JJ
JmJIDOVJJ
JJ
PLQJHDQXDLHúLWDIDUăúJJ
J
ăQJ
3XQFWHúD
6XESUREOHPHOHvQFDUHGHVFRPSXQHPDFHDVWăSUREOHPăVXQW
JJJJJmJJ~J ^FUHúWHFRQWRUXOGHSR]LĠLL`J
FLWLUHDWDEORXOXL
JJJJJmJJ~J ^GHSODVDUHSHGLUHFĠLDSkQăODvQWkOQLUHDXQHLPDUJLQL`
GHWHUPLQDUHDPLQLPXOXLSHROLQLHDWDEORXOXL
JJJJJmJJ~JYJ
GHWHUPLQDUHDPD[LPXOXLSHRFRORDQăDWDEORXOXL
JJJJăJJ\J`J JJ
JJ^ELODVDORYLWGHRPDUJLQHRUL]RQWDOă`J
GHWHUPLQDUHDPD[LPXOXLSHROLQLHDWDEORXOXL
JJJJJJJmJJ GHWHUPLQDUHDPLQLPXOXLSHRFRORDQăDWDEORXOXL
JJJJJJJmJ~J FRPSDUDUHDUH]XOWDWHORUREĠLQXWHODSXQFWXOúL
JJJJ úă
FRPSDUDUHDUH]XOWDWHORUREĠLQXWHODSXQFWXOúL
JJJJăJJ\J`J JJ
J
J^ELODVDORYLWGHRPDUJLQHYHUWLFDOă`J
JJJJJJYJmJYJ 2EVHUYăPFăWUHEXLHVăFăXWăPXQPLQLPVDXXQPD[LPvQWUROLQLHUHVSHFWLYvQ
JJJJJJJmJJ~JYJ WUR FRORDQă GLQ PDWULFH $FHDVWă REVHUYDĠLH QH VXJHUHD]ă Vă ÄWUDQVIRUPăP´ WDEORXO
JJJJ úă ELGLPHQVLRQDOvQWUXQúLUGHOLQLLIRORVLQGXQHGHGHFODUDĠLLOHGHWLSúLGHYDULDELOH
JJJJăJ\`J ^GDFăDFHDVWăSR]LĠLHQXDIRVWVWUăEăWXWăvQFă`J
J
\JJ
KJ
JJJJJJJăJmJIDOVJ JJJJJ\JJ
KJ
JJJJJJJmJ ^RPDUFăP`J JQKJ
JJJJ
^GDFăDFHDVWăSR]LĠLHDPDLIRVWPDUFDWăúLHVWHSHRPDUJLQH`J JJJJQ
KJ
JJJJJJăJăJúJJ\JJJ J
$VWIHOOLQLDLGLQWDEORXOWVHYDSXWHDWUDQVPLWHFDSDUDPHWUXGHWLS
VXESUR
JJJJJJJ
mDGHYăUDW ^ELODDLQWUDWvQPLúFDUHFLFOLFăGHRDUHFH`
JUDPHORUFDUHGHWHUPLQăPLQLPXOUHVSHFWLYPD[LPXOGLQOLQLDUHVSHFWLYă'LQSăFDWH
^GLQSR]LĠLDPDUFDWăFXDDMXQVvQSR]LĠLDPDUFDWăFX`
JJJJJJ
JJ QXSXWHPSURFHGDODIHOvQFD]XOFRORDQHORUGHFkWGDFăOHWUDQVIRUPăPWHPSRUDUFXXQ
JJJJJJJJăJJ\JJJJ VXESURJUDPVLPSOXvQúLUGHWLS
JJJJJJJJJJăJmJDGHYăUDW
J
ă?úQJ
JJJJJJJJ
JăJmJIDOVJ
JJJJJJJJ úăJ J ^WUDQVIRUPăFRORDQDNGLQWDEORXvQúLUGHWLSOLQLH`
JJJJJJ úăJJ JJ
J\J
ăQJ ^FRORDQHOHDXPHOHPHQWH`J
JJJJ úăJ JJJJúJmJ?J
JJ ú
JJ ú
ú J ú
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH 7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
)XQFĠLLOH
ú úL
ú GHWHUPLQă YDORDUHD PD[LPă 5DPHGHVXSUDSXV
UHVSHFWLY PLQLPă GLQWUXQ úLU UHWXUQkQG WRWRGDWă úL SR]LĠLD XQGH VD JăVLW PD[LPXO $OJRULWPXO XUPăWRU WUDVHD]ă UDPHOH SH UkQG FX OLWHUHOH PDUL DOH DOIDEHWXOXL HQJOH]
UHVSHFWLYPLQLPXO vQFHSkQGFXOLWHUD úLOHGHSXQHvQWUXQWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDOGHFDUDFWHUH7DEORXO
ÌQDOJRULWPYRPWUDYHUVDWDEORXOOLQLHGXSăOLQLH3HQWUXILHFDUHOLQLHLYRPGHWHU YDILvQSUHDODELOLQLĠLDOL]DWFXFDUDFWHUXOVSDĠLX
PLQDPLQLPXOPLQLPúLSR]LĠLDOXLSHOLQLHSR]PLQDSRLYRPWUDQVIRUPDFRORDQDGH ÌQ LPSOHPHQWDUHD SURSXVă GHVHQăP SULPD UDPă vQ VSDĠLXO GH GHSR]LWDUH DSRL vQ
LQGLFH SR]PLQ vQ úLU úL YRP FăXWD PD[LPXO OXL PD[LP 'DFă FHOH GRXă YDORUL VXQW DFHODúLWDEORXGHVHQăPDGRXDUDPă1XHVWHQHYRLHGHYHULILFăULFDUDFWHUXOFFXUHQW
HJDOHPLQLP PD[LPDILúăPLQGLFHOHOLQLHLLúLLQGLFHOHFRORDQHLSR]PD[3URFH ILHVXSUDVFULHXQFDUDFWHUVSDĠLXILHXQFDUDFWHUDSDUĠLQkQGXQHLUDPHDúH]DWHGHMD
GăPODIHOFăXWkQGPD[LPXOSHOLQLHúLPLQLPXOSHFRORDQDSHFDUHDPJăVLWPD[LPXO
JQJ
J
#J
%ùQJ JJ%JmJJ
JJ
J?\J
ăQJ
JJ&LWLUHDGDWHORUGHLQWUDUHPQW
JJ ăJmJIDOVJ
JJJJ
ú
JYJ ^LQGLFHOHGHOLQLHúLGHFRORDQăDFROĠXOXLVWkQJDVXV`J
JJ
J\J
ăQJ JJJJ
ú
JYJ ^OXQJLPLOHODWXULORUUDPHLFXUHQWH`J
JJJJ
JmJ
J JJJJYJmJYJ~JYJJJ ^LQGLFHOHGHOLQLHDFROĠXOXLGUHDSWDMRV`
J ^PLQLPXOSHOLQLDLVHDIOăSHFRORDQDSR]PLQ`J JJJJJmJJ~JJJJ ^LQGLFHOHGHFRORDQăDFROĠXOXLGUHDSWDMRV`J
JJJJ
ă
ú ^WUDQVIRUPăPFRORDQDSR]PLQvQúLU` JJJJăJJdJ
JúJYJdJJJ
JJJJJmJúJ ^PD[LPXOGHSHFRORDQDSR]PLQ` JJJJJJ
J\YYJ
ăQJ ^GHVHQăPUDPD`J
JJJJăJ
J\JJJ JJJJJJJJJmJ%J ^YHUWLFDODGLQVWkQJD`J
JJJJJJ
JJJ JJJJJJJJJmJ%J ^YHUWLFDODGLQGUHDSWD`J
JJJJJJ ăJmJDGHYăUDWJJ JJJJJJ ú
JJJJ úă JJJJJJ
J\~J
ăQJ
JJJJJmJ
J JJJJJJJJYJmJ%J ^RUL]RQWDODGHVXV`J
^PD[LPXOSHOLQLDLVHDIOăSHFRORDQDSR]PD[` JJJJJJJJYJmJ%J ^RUL]RQWDODGHMRV`J
JJJJ
ăúJ ^WUDQVIRUPăPFRORDQDSR]PD[vQúLU` JJJJJJ ú
JJJJ
JmJ
ú
J ^PLQLPXOGHSHFRORDQDSR]PD[` JJJJ úă
JJJJăJJ\J
JJ ^FDUDFWHUXOFXFDUHVHYDWUDVDXUPăWRDUHDUDPă`
JJJJJJ
JJJ JJJJ%JmJVXFFHVRUXOFDUDFWHUXOXL%J
JJJJJJ ăJmJDGHYăUDWJJ ú
úă ú
ú
JJă ăJJ
JJJJ
JJJ
%JJ
5DPHVXSUDSXVH
úă 3UREOHPDHVWHGHVFRPSXVăvQVXESUREOHPHGXSăFXPXUPHD]ă
úJ x &LWLUHDGDWHORUGHLQWUDUHGLPHQVLXQLOHVSDĠLXOXLGHGHSR]LWDUHúLWDEORXOGH
FDUDFWHUH
9DULDELODJăVLWSULPHúWHYDORDUHDDGHYăUDWGDFăDPJăVLWXQSXQFWúD$IRVWQHYRLH x 'HWHUPLQDUHDFRRUGRQDWHORUFROĠXULORUUDPHORU
GHUHĠLQHUHDIDSWXOXLFăDPUHXúLWVăGHWHUPLQăPXQUH]XOWDWSHQWUXDVFULHPHVDMXOVROL x 'HWHUPLQDUHDSR]LĠLLORUUHODWLYHDUDPHORUVXSUDSXQHULOH
FLWDWvQFD]XOvQFDUHQXH[LVWăSXQFWúDvQWDEORX x $ILúDUHDFDUDFWHUHORUFXFDUHVDXGHVHQDWUDPHOHvQRUGLQHDvQFDUHDFHVWHDVHSRW
ULGLFD
1RWăPFXPLQ[LPLQ\LPD[[LPD[\LFRRUGRQDWHOHFROĠXOXLVWkQJDVXVúLDFHOXLGLQ
GUHDSWDMRVDFHOHLGHDLDUDPH$FHVWHYDORULVHSRWLQLĠLDOL]DFXFRRUGRQDWHOHVSDĠLX
OXLGHGHSR]LWDUHGHRDUHFHVLJXUYRPJăVLFHOSXĠLQRUDPăPDLPLFăGHFkWVSDĠLXO
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
J
YYQJ
JJ
J%\J
ăQJJ JJJJJJăJ%&JzJ%JJ ^GDFăvQWkOQLPFKvQGHVHQXOUDPHLGHVHQDWHFXF`
JJJJ
%JmJ
J ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHDFRRUGRQDWHORUFROĠXULORU` J J ^UDPDGHVHQDWăFXFKHVWHGHDVXSUDUDPHLGHVHQDWHFXF`
JJJJ
Y%JmJJ JJJJJJJJ%%&JmJDGHYăUDWJJ
úă
JJJJ%JmJ`J
JJJJJJ%&JmJ%J
JJJJY%JmJ`J
ú
JJJJJJăJ%&JzJ%JJJ
JJ
J\J
ăQJ ^GHWHUPLQDUHDFRRUGRQDWHORUFROĠXULORU`J JJJJJJJJ%%&JmJDGHYăUDWJJ
JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ úăJJ
JJJJ ú
JJ
J J ^GHWHUPLQăPFRRUGRQDWHOHFROĠXULORUUDPHLGLQFDUHIDFHSDUWHSR]LĠLDFXUHQWă`J
JJJJ
J\
%~%J
ăQJ
JJJJJJ%JmJJ
JJJJJJ%&JmJ
Y%J
JJJJJJăJ
%J
JJJ
JJJJJJăJ%&JzJ%JJJ
JJJJJJJJ
%JmJJ
JJJJJJ úăJJ JJJJJJJJ%%&JmJDGHYăUDWJJ
JJJJJJăJ
Y%J
JJJ úăJJ
JJJJJJJJ
Y%JmJJ JJJJJJ%&JmJY%J
JJJJJJ úăJJ JJJJJJăJ%&JzJ%JJJ
JJJJJJăJ%JJJ JJJJJJJJ%%&JmJDGHYăUDWJJ
JJJJJJJJ%JmJJ úăJJ
JJJJJJ úăJJ JJJJ ú
JJ
JJJJJJăJY%JJJ JJ ú
JJ
JJJJJJJJY%JmJJJ ú J
JJJJJJ úăJJ J
JJJJ ú
JJ $ILúDUHD vQ DFHDVWă SUREOHPă QHFHVLWă FkWHYD YHULILFăUL vQ SOXV 'H DVHPHQHD YD
JJ ú
JJ WUHEXLVăĠLQHPHYLGHQĠDUDPHORUDILúDWHGHMDvQúLUXOGHDILúDWDYkQGYDORULERROHHQH
ú J SHQWUXDHYLWDDILúDUHDORUUHSHWDWă$FHVWúLUVHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăFXIDOV'DFăRUDPăQX
J
DUHQLFLXQDGHDVXSUDHLSRDWHILULGLFDWăúLGHFLDILúDWă9RPFRQWLQXDDILúăULOHFkW
3HQWUXDGHWHUPLQDSR]LĠLLOHUHODWLYHDOHUDPHORUYRPFRQVWUXLXQWDEORXGHFRQV WLPSPDLH[LVWăUDPăQHDILúDWă'XSăDILúDUHDUDPHLGHVHQDWHFXFDUDFWHUXO\ULGLFDUHD
WDQWHORJLFHSHVWHvQFDUHYDORDUHDHOHPHQWXOXLSHVWH[\YDILDGHYăUDWGDFăUDPDGHVH HLYDvQVHPQDPRGLILFDUHDYDORULLOXLSHVWH[\FDUHYDGHYHQLIDOV
QDWăFXFDUDFWHUXO\HVWHGHDVXSUDUDPHLGHVHQDWHFXFDUDFWHUXO[$FHVWWDEORXVHLQLĠL
DOL]HD]ăFXIDOVSHQWUXWRDWHUDPHOHWRDWHFDUDFWHUHOHFXFDUHHVWHSRVLELOăGHVHQDUHD J
ú
YYQJ
XQHLUDPH9RPUHDOL]DFăXWăULSHQWUXILHFDUHFDUDFWHUSRVLELOvQWUHOLPLWHOHGLPHQVLX JJ
J%\J
ăQJJ
QLORUUDPHLGHVHQDWHFXFDUDFWHUXOFXUHQW&ăXWăULOHWUHEXLHHIHFWXDWHvQDPEHOHGLUHFĠLL J J ^GDFăJ
J`vQVHDPQăFăH[LVWăUDPăGHVHQDWăFXF`J
RUL]RQWDOăúLYHUWLFDOă JJJJăJ%J
J`JJJ
J
JJJJJJ
ú%JmJDGHYăUDWJ ^GHFLWUHEXLHDILúDWă`
Ġ
YYYQ
JJ
J%\J
ăQ
JJJJ
J%&\J
ăQJ JJJJJJ
ú%JmJIDOVH
úăJJ
JJJJJJ%%&JmJIDOV ^GHRFDPGDWăQXDPGHVFRSHULWQLFLRVXSUDSXQHUH`J
JJ ú
JJ
JJJJ ú
JJ
JJ ú
JJ JJ
úJmJDGHYăUDWJJ
JJ
J%\J
ăQJ ^GHWHUPLQăPVXSUDSXQHULOH` JJ
J
úJ
ăQJ^FkWWLPSDYHPUDPHGHDILúDWOHDILúăP`
JJJJ
J\
Y%Y%J
ăQJJ^UDPDGHVHQDWăFXFDUDFWHUXOF`J JJJJ
úJmJIDOVJ
JJ
JJJJJJ%&JmJ
% ^FDUDFWHUGLQGHVHQXOUDPHLGHVHQDWHFXF`J
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH 7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
JJJ
J%Q\J
ăQJ J
J
JJJJJJăJ
ú%JJ
J\J
ă,J
JJJJJJJJ?JmJDGHYăUDWJJ JJJJ
J\J
ă,J
JJJJJJJJ%&JmJJ JJJJJJJmJJJ
JJJJJJJJ
J?JúJ%&JdJJ
ăQJ ú
^YHULILFăPGDFăUDPDGHVHQDWăFXFSRDWHILULGLFDWă` ú
JJJJJJJJJJăJ%%&JJ ú
JJJJJJJJJJJJ?JmJIDOVJJ
J
úăJ %5RWLUHDWDEORXOXLFXvQVHQVXODFHORUGHFHDVRUQLF
JJJJJJJJJJ%&JmVXFFHVRUXOOXL%&J 3HQWUXDURWLWRDWHHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXLWUHEXLHVăOXăPSHUkQGILHFDUHHOHPHQWúLVăO
JJJJJJJJ ú
J DúH]ăP vQWUXQ DOW WDEORX ELGLPHQVLRQDO SH SR]LĠLD SRWULYLWă 'H]DYDQWDMXO DFHVWHL
JJJJJJJJăJ?JJ ^GDFăGDRDILúăPúLRULGLFăP` YDULDQWH GH DOJRULWP HVWH FRQVXPXO H[FHVLY GH VSDĠLX GH PHPRULH 6H SUH]LQWă vQ
JJJJJJJJJJ
J%J FRQWLQXDUH R YDULDQWă PDL HFRQRPLFRDVă FDUH VH ED]HD]ă SH URWLUHD VXFFHVLYă D FHORU
JJJJJJJJJJ
J%&\J
ăQJ SDWUXSXQFWH
JJJJJJJJJJJJ%&%JmJIDOVJJ 'DFă SHQWUX XQ HOHPHQW VH DUDQMHD]ă SDWUX
úăJ DLM HOHPHQWHODORFXOORUIRORVLQGRYDULDELOăDX[LOL
JJJJJJJJJJ
ú%JmJIDOVJ ^QXPDLWUHEXLHDILúDWă` DUăvQVHDPQăFăWUHEXLHUHSHWDWăDFHDVWăRSHUD
JJJJJJJJJJ
úmJDGHYăUDWJJ ĠLHGRDUSHQWUXRSăWULPHGLQHOHPHQWHOHWDEORX
JJJJJJJJ úăJ OXL 6H SDUFXUJH GH H[HPSOX QXPDL WULXQJKLXO
JJJJJJ úă VXSHULRU GLQWUH GLDJRQDOH LQFOXVLY GLDJRQDOD
ú
J SULQFLSDOă(OHPHQWXODLMVHVDOYHD]ăvQYDULDELOD
JJ ú
J DX[LOLDUă GXSă FDUH VH HIHFWXHD]ă FHOH WUHL DWUL
ú J
EXLULHYLGHQĠLDWHSHILJXUă
3UHOXFUDUHLPDJLQH ([HPSOH
ÌQWUXFkWFHULQĠHOHDFHVWHLSUREOHPHVXQWIRUPXODWHSHVXESXQFWHVHSDUDWHVHGHVFULXvQ P D D D D P D D D D D
FRQWLQXDUHDOJRULWPLVHSDUDĠLSHQWUXILHFDUHWUDQVIRUPDUHvQSDUWH$PQRWDWFXDWDEOR D D D D D D D D D
XOELGLPHQVLRQDOSăWUDWLFFRQĠLQkQGLPDJLQHDLDUFXPGLPHQVLXQHDDFHVWXLD D D D D D D D D D
D D D D D D D D D
$,QYHUVDUHDYDORULORUFXYDORULúLYLFHYHUVD D D D D D
ÌQPRGQRUPDOLQYHUVDUHDYDORULORUVHIDFHSDUFXUJkQGWDEORXOLDUGDFăHOHPHQWXODUH
YDORDUHDDFHDVWDVHVFKLPEăvQúLLQYHUV
x P DVHYDvQORFXLFXDFDUHVHYDvQORFXLFXDFDUHVHYDvQORFXLFXD
ăJ\JJJJmJ`J
x P DVHYDvQORFXLFXDFDUHVHYDvQORFXLFXDFDUHVHYDvQORFXLFXD
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
JJmJJ
$FHDVWăVFKLPEDUHGHYDORDUHVHSRDWHH[SULPDVLQWHWLFDSOLFkQGRSHUDWRULLSHELĠL
ÌQFRQFOX]LHLQGLFHOHGHOLQLHGHYLQHLQGLFHGHFRORDQăLDULQGLFHOHGHFRORDQăQH
DVWIHOJmJJ([SULPăULOHVXQWHFKLYDOHQWHGHRDUHFH
DMXWăODFDOFXODUHDQRXOXLLQGLFHGHOLQLHP±IRVWXOLQGLFHFRORDQă
`J\JúLJ\J`
JJJJJJJmJJJ ^VHSăVWUHD]ăHOHPHQWXOGHSRUQLUH` ÌQ DOJRULWPXO FDUH YD DSHOD VXEDOJRULWPLL SUH]HQWDĠL DPQRWDWFXWUDQVIRUPDUHFD
JJJJJJ
J?\J
ă, UDFWHUXOFDUHFRQĠLQHFRGXOWUDQVIRUPăULLFXUHQWH
JJJJJJJJJmJJJJ~JJJ ^VHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăLQGLFLLGHXQGHVHLDYDORDUHD` #J%QJ
JJJJJJJJJmJJ &&& ^VHFLWHVFGLPHQVLXQHDúLHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXLGDW`
JJJJJJJJJmJ ^PXWDUH` JJ
JVDDMXQVODVIkUúLWXOILúLHUXOXL
ă,J
JJJJJJJJJmJJJ ^VHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăLQGLFLLXQGHVHYDSXQHYDORDUHD`J JJJJ
ú
J
JJJJJJJJJmJJJ ^ODXUPăWRDUHDLWHUDĠLH` JJJJă
J\JJJJ
JJJJJJ ú
JJJJJJ
J
JJJJJJJmJ JJJJ
ú
JJJJJJă
J\JJJJ
ú
JJJJJJJJúJ
ú JJJJJJ
JJ
ă
J\JJJJ
JJJJJJJJJJJ
&'XEODUHDLPDJLQLL=RRP JJJJJJJJ úă
3HQWUX D H[WLQGH WDEORXO SH XQ WDEORX GH GRXă RUL PDL PDUH VH YRU FRQVWUXL vQ QRXO úă
WDEORXFkWHSDWUXHOHPHQWHFXDFHDYDORDUHDúH]DWHvQIRUPDXQHLPDWULFHSăWUDWLFHGH úă
GLPHQVLXQH ú
J
'HH[HPSOXXQHOHPHQWDYkQGYDORDUHDvQPDWULFHDLQLĠLDOăVHvQORFXLHúWHFX &&& ^VHDILúHD]ăWDEORXOELGLPHQVLRQDOREĠLQXW`
úJ
`
1HSURSXQHPvQFRQWLQXDUHVăGHWHUPLQăPPRGDOLWDWHDvQFDUHVHREĠLQLQGLFLLHOH
PHQWHORUPDWULFHLPăULWHGLQPDWULFHDLQLĠLDOă &DUHX0DJLF
J J J J LQGLFLGHOLQLH J $OJRULWPXOGHUH]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHvQFHSHSULQDWHVWDGLPHQVLXQHDFDUHXOXLGH
LQGLFLGHOLQLH LQGLFLGH ` ` J JHQHUDWÌQIXQFĠLHGHSURSULHWDWHDSHFDUHDFHVWQXPăURDUHLPSDUSDUPXOWLSOXGH
LQGLFLGH J ` FRORDQă ` ` J VDXSDUIăUăDILPXOWLSOXGHDSOLFăPDOJRULWPXOSUH]HQWDWODWHRULH
FRORDQă J ` ` ` J 6ăXUPăULPGHVFULHUHDLPSOHPHQWăULORUSHQWUXILHFDUHGLQWUHFHLWUHLDOJRULWPL
J J J J ` ` J
(OHPHQWXOXLDvLFRUHVSXQGHOHPHQWHOHDDDD(OHPHQWXOXLDvLFRUHV D'UXPXOÌPSăUDWXOXL9HQVDXJHQHUDUHDSăWUDWHORUPDJLFHGHRUGLQLPSDU
SXQGHOHPHQWHOHDDDD*HQHUDOL]kQGFHOHREVHUYDWHHOHPHQWXOXLDLMvLFRUHV 'HVFULHPvQFRQWLQXDUHRYDULDQWăGHJHQHUDUHDXQXLSăWUDWPDJLFGHRUGLQLPSDUFDUH
SXQGHOHPHQWHOHDL±M±DL±MDLM±DLM UHVSHFWă GUXPXO ÌPSăUDWXOXL 9HQ &DUHXO PDJLF vO JHQHUăP vQ WDEORXO D $OJRULWPXO
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH 7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
J %QJ
DWULEXLHSHUkQGYDORULOHFXSULQVHvQLQWHUYDOXO>Q@YDULDELOHLQUXUPkQGFDDFHDVWă
JJ
JmJJ
YDORDUHVăVHDWULEXLHHOHPHQWHORUFDUHXOXLSHED]DUHJXOLORUSUHFL]DWH
J JJ
JmJ
J~JJ
J£
QJ JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJYJmJ
J
JJJJJJăJJdJJJJdJJJ
JJJmJ
~J
JJJJJJJJJmJ
JJ
J
JJ
JmJJ JJJJJJ
J
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJJJJJJJJmJ
J
JJJJYJmJ
J úă
JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJJJJJăJJ\JJ JJJJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ
ú
JJJJJJJJJmJ
J ú
JJJJJJ
J
ú
JJJJJJJJJmJJJJ J
úă
JJJJJJăJYJ\JJ
F3ăWUDWPDJLFGHRUGLQQXQGHQ PúLPHVWHQXPăULPSDU
JJJJJJJJYJmJ
J
6ăXUPăULPSDúLLDOJRULWPXOXLGHJHQHUDUHDXQXLSăWUDWPDJLFGHRUGLQQXQGHQ P
JJJJJJ
J úLPHVWHQXPăULPSDU7UHEXLHVăvPSăUĠLPFDUHXOvQFDUHXULPLFLGHGLPHQVLXQH
JJJJJJJJYJmJYJJJ DVXSUD FăURUD GHFLGHP vQ FH IRUPă VH YRU FRPSOHWD $FHDVWă IRUPă VH VWDELOHúWH vQ
úă VXEDOJRULWPXOY
DSHODWGHVXEDOJRULWPXOXUPăWRU
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ
JJJJJJYJmJ
J J %QJ
JJJJ ú
JJ
JmJ
J
JJJJăJYJ\J
J JJYJmJJ
JJJJJJYJmJJ JJJmJ
~J
JJJJ
J JJ
JmJJ
JJJJJJYJmJYJ~JJ JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
úă JJJJY
J
JJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ
ú
JJJJJJăJJ\JJJJ
ú JJJJJJJJJmJ
J
JJJJJJ
JJ
E&DUHXOPDJLFGHGLPHQVLXQHSDUăQ P JJJJJJJJJmJJJJ
3HQWUX D JHQHUD FDUHXO PDJLF GH GLPHQVLXQH SDUă SRUQLP GH OD PDWULFHD GH RUGLQ Q úă
IRUPDWăFXQXPHUHOH«QDúH]DWHvQRUGLQHSHOLQLL JJJJJJăJYJ\JJJJ
'LQGHVFULHUHDDOJRULWPXOXLVHGHVSULQGHFăHOHPHQWHOHDIODWHSHOLQLLDYkQGQXPăU JJJJJJJJYJmJ
J
JJJJJJ
GHRUGLQHSHQWUXFDUHUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLODHVWHVDXúLFRORDQHFDUHQXDXDFHDVWă
YJmJYJJJ
SURSULHWDWHVDXSHFRORDQHDYkQGQXPăUGHRUGLQHSHQWUXFDUHUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLODHVWH
úă
VDXúLOLQLLFDUHQXDXDFHDVWăSURSULHWDWHWUHEXLHVFKLPEDWHFXHOHPHQWHOHDIODWHvQ JJJJJJY
J
SR]LĠLLVLPHWULFHIDĠăGHPLMORFXOFDUHXOXL$FHDVWăSURSULHWDWHSULYLQGSR]LĠLDHOHPHQ ú
J
WXOXLRYRPH[SULPDIRORVLQGRSHUDWRUXOORJLF 6FKLPEDUHDFXHOHPHQWXOVLPHWULF JJJJăJYJ\J
JJJ
VHDVLJXUăIRORVLQGYDORDUHDYDULDELOHLQQ JJJJJJYJmJJ
7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
JJJJ
YJmJYJ~JJ
JJJJ úă
ú
JJ
JmJ
J
ú
JY
QJ
JJăJYJ
J
J~JJJJ
JJJJ¨Y
J ¥J¨¨¨¨¨J¦J
JJ
J
JJJJăJYJ\J
J~JJJJ ¥JJ¦J
JJJJJJăJJ\J
~JJJ
JJJJJJJJY
J
JJJJJJ
JJ
JJJJJJJJY
J
JJJJJJ úă
J 7DEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
JJJJJJăJYJ\J
J~JJJJ ¥JJ¦J
JJJJJJJJăJJ\J
J~JJJJ J¨Y
QJ
JJJJJJJJJJY
J JJYJmJ
J~JJ
JJJJJJJJ
JJ JJYJJJmJ
J~JJ
JJJJJJJJJJY
J
JJJJJJJJ úăJ
JJYJJJmJ
J~JJ
JJJJJJ
JJ JJYJJJJJmJ
J
JJJJJJJJY
J ¥JJ¦J ú
JJJJJJ úă
úă
úăJ
JJ
JmJ
J~JJ
ú J
J
JY
QJ
JJYJmJ
J~JJ
JJYJJJmJ
J~JJ
JJYJJJmJ
J
JJYJJJJJmJ
J~JJ
ú J
J
JY
QJ
JJYJmJ
J~JJ
JJYJJJmJ
J~JJ
JJYJJJmJ
J~JJ
JJYJJJJJmJ
J
ú J
7DEORXULWULGLPHQVLRQDOH
9RP QXPL DFHVW WDEORX UHJLVWUX 8Q WDEORX WULGLPHQVLRQDO VH UHSUH]LQWă vQ VSDĠLX
SULQWUXQSDUDOHOLSLSHGGUHSWXQJKLFDFFHVXOODXQHOHPHQWDOVăXQHFHVLWkQGSUHFL]DUHD
YDORULORUDWUHLLQGLFLFkWHXQXOSHQWUXILHFDUHGLPHQVLXQH
ÌQWDEORXOSUH]HQWDWFDH[HPSOXYDORDUHDXQXLHOHPHQWHVWHRPHGLHúLHVWHORFDOL
]DWFXWUHLLQGLFL
x SULPXOLQGLFăHOHYXOQXPăUGHRUGLQHGLQFDWDORJ
7DEORXUL &DSLWROXO x DOGRLOHDLQGLFHSUHFL]HD]ăPDWHULDGHvQYăĠăPkQWODFDUHDIRVWREĠLQXWăDFHDVWă
PXOWLGLPHQVLRQDOH PHGLHQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOGLVFLSOLQHL
x DOWUHLOHDLQGLFHFRUHVSXQGHDQXOXLGHVWXGLXvQFDUHHOHYXODREĠLQXWDFHDPHGLH
$SOLFDĠLLFXWDEORXULWULGLPHQVLRQDOH ODGLVFLSOLQDSUHFL]DWă
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH 'H H[HPSOX UHJLVWUX>@ UHSUH]LQWă PHGLD REĠLQXWă GH HOHYXO %DQ OD /LPED úL
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
OLWHUDWXUDURPkQăvQFHOGHDOWUHLOHDDQGHOLFHX
$PYă]XWFăvQWUXQWDEORXXQLGLPHQVLRQDOVHSRWSăVWUDPHGLLOHJHQHUDOHDOHHOHYLORU ÌQPRGVLPLODUVHSRWLPDJLQDVLWXDĠLLDFăURUUHSUH]HQWDUHVHSUHWHD]ăODVWUXFWXUL
XQHLFODVH0HG*HQQRWDXQXLHOHYILLQGUHIHULWăSULQFRQVWUXFĠLD0HG*HQ>QU@XQGH FXVDXPDLPXOWHGLPHQVLXQL*HQHUDOL]kQGSXWHPVSXQHFăvQWUXQWDEORXQGL
QUHVWHQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHGLQFDWDORJDOHOHYXOXLUHVSHFWLY PHQVLRQDOXQHOHPHQWVHUHJăVHúWHSUHFL]kQGQXPHOHWDEORXOXLSUHFXPúLYDORULOHFHORU
0HG*HQ QLQGLFL
QXPHUHGHRUGLQHo
PHGLLo «
0HGLLOHSHGLVFLSOLQHDOHILHFăUXLHOHYVHSRWSăVWUDvQWUXQWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDO $SOLFDĠLLFXWDEORXULWULGLPHQVLRQDOH
3RSXODĠLHYLUXVDWă 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVH
6H XUPăUHúWH HYROXĠLD vPEROQăYLULL XQHL SRSXODĠLL FX XQ YLUXV SH SDUFXUVXO D S ]LOH
,QLĠLDOSRSXODĠLDHVWHGDWăvQWUXQWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDO5HIHULWRUODYLQGHFDUHDLQGLYL 3RSXODĠLHYLUXVDWă
]LORUEROQDYLVDXvPEROQăYLUHDFHORUVăQăWRúLIXQFĠLRQHD]ăXUPăWRDUHOHUHJXOL ÌQDFHDVWăDSOLFDĠLHWDEORXOWULGLPHQVLRQDOHVWHGHILQLWFDúLUGHWDEORXULELGLPHQVLRQDOH
x 8QLQGLYLGVăQăWRVDYkQGFHOSXĠLQWUHLYHFLQLLQIHVWDĠLvQMXUVHvPEROQăYHúWHúLHO DVWIHO vQFkW ILHFăUHL ]LOH VăL FRUHVSXQGă FkWH XQ WDEORX ELGLPHQVLRQDO SULYLQG VWDUHD
x 8QLQGLYLGEROQDYvQFRQMXUDWQXPDLGHEROQDYLVHPRELOL]HD]ăúLVHYLQGHFă VăQăWăĠLLGLQ]LXDUHVSHFWLYă
x 2ULFHLQGLYLGEROQDYSHGXUDWDDFHOSXĠLQGH]LOHVHvQVăQăWRúHúWH $OJRULWPXOGHUH]ROYDUHFRQĠLQHVXEDOJRULWPLSHQWUXUH]ROYDUHDVXESUREOHPHORU
3ULQ YHFLQL VH vQĠHOHJ QXPDL LQGLYL]LL DIODĠL vQ LPHGLDWD DSURSLHUH SH DFHHDúL OLQLH
VDXSHDFHHDúLFRORDQăFXXQDQXPLWHOHPHQWFRQVLGHUDW &RQVWUXLUHD WDEORXOXL WULGLPHQVLRQDO SRUQLQG GH OD WDEORXO ELGLPHQVLRQDO GDW SH
6ăVHJHQHUH]HWDEORXOWULGLPHQVLRQDOFXSULQ]kQGHYROXĠLDSRSXODĠLHLvQFHOHS]LOH ED]DUHJXOLORUGHWUDQVPLWHUHDEROLLVDXGHVWRSDUHDHL3ULPXOSDVvQDERUGDUHDDFHV
WHLVXESUREOHPHHVWHFLWLUHDGLPHQVLXQLORUWDEORXOXLWULGLPHQVLRQDOFDUHVHYDFRQVWUXL
6ăVHGHWHUPLQH]LXDVDX]LOHOHvQFDUHQXPăUXOLQGLYL]LORUEROQDYLDIRVWPD[LPă
úLDWDEORXOXLFXLQIRUPDĠLLOHSULYLQGVWDUHDGHVăQăWDWHGLQSULPD]L
6ăVHDILúH]HFRRUGRQDWHOHLQGLYL]LORUFDUHDXIRVWEROQDYLSHvQWUHDJDSHULRDGăGHS
]LOH J
QJ
JJ
ú
J
JJ ^GLPHQVLXQLOHWDEORXOXLWULGLPHQVLRQDO`
'DWHGHLQWUDUH JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXL 8"( &$VHDIOăGLPHQVLXQLOHWDEORXOXLELGLPHQVLRQDOP JJJJ
J\
J
ă,J
QXUPDWHGHQXPăUXOGH]LOHSSHFDUHVHHIHFWXHD]ăVWXGLXO3HXUPăWRDUHOHPOLQLL JJJJJJ
ú
JJJ ^FLWLUHDWDEORXOXLFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUSULPHL]LOH`
VH DIOă HOHPHQWHOH WDEORXOXL LQLĠLDO FXSULQ]kQG VWDUHD LQGLYL]LORU vQ SULPD ]L 7DEORXO JJJJ ú
FRQĠLQHYDORULúLDYkQGVHPQLILFDĠLDXQXLLQGLYLGVăQăWRVLDUvQVHPQkQGXQLQ JJ ú
GLYLGDWLQVGHYLUXV ú
J
'DWHGHLHúLUH *HQHUDUHDWDEORXOXLWULGLPHQVLRQDOVHUHDOL]HD]ăFRQVWUXLQGWDEORXULOHELGLPHQVLR
3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXL 8"( &'(!VHYRUVFULH]LOHOHvQFDUHQXPăUXOvPEROQăYLUL QDOHFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH]LOHLSRUQLQGGLQVLWXDĠLDFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH]LOHLSUHFHGHQWH
ORUDIRVWPD[LP3HXUPăWRDUHOHOLQLLVHYRUVFULHSHUHFKLGHQXPHUHQDWXUDOHUHSUH
]HQWkQGFRRUGRQDWHOHDFHORULQGLYL]LFDUHDXIRVWEROQDYLvQWRDWăSHULRDGDFHORUS]LOH
7RDWHQXPHUHOHVFULVHSHDFHHDúLOLQLHVHYRUVHSDUDSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLX
7DEORXULWULGLPHQVLRQDOH 7DEORXULWULGLPHQVLRQDOH
J
ă
QJ ^SHQWUXDQHSXWHDUHIHULúLODYHFLQLLXQXL` JăQJ
^HOHPHQWDIODWSHPDUJLQHERUGăPPDWULFHDLQLĠLDOăFX` ^UHWXUQHD]ăQXPăUXOGH]LOHGHERDOăFRQWLQXăDOHSHUVRDQHLGHSHSR]LĠLDLM`
JJ
J\`~J
ăQJ JJ?JmJJJJ
JJJJ`JmJ`J JJ
?J
JJúJ?J\JJ
ăQJ
JJJJ
~JmJ`J JJJJ?JmJ?JJJ
JJ ú
JJ ú
JJ
J\`
~J
ă,J JJ
ăJmJJJ?J~JJ
JJJJ`JmJ`J ú
JJJJ~JmJ`J
JJ ú
5H]ROYDUHDSULPHLFHULQĠHGLQHQXQĠQHFHVLWăFRQVWUXLUHDvQSUHDODELODXQXLúLUFRQ
^JHQHUDUHDSURSULX]LVă` ĠLQkQGQXPăUXOWRWDOGHSHUVRDQHYLUXVDWHSHILHFDUH]L$FHDVWDVHSRDWHUHDOL]DDSH
JJ
J\J
ăQJJ ^SHQWUXILHFDUH` OkQGSHQWUXILHFDUH]LRIXQFĠLHFDUHvQVXPHD]ăFD]XULOHGHERDOăSHED]DXQXLDOJRULWP
JJJJ
J\J
ăQJ FDUHvQVXPHD]ăHOHPHQWHOHXQXLWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDO
JJJJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ^SHQWUXILHFDUHHOHPHQWDOPDWULFHLGLQ]LXD` J
QJJ
^VHQXPăUăYHFLQLLYLUXVDĠLGLQ]LXDSUHFHGHQWă` JJJmJ`JJ ^UHWXUQHD]ăVXPDHOHPHQWHORUXQXLWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDO`J
JJJJJJJJ
ăJmJJ~J~J~JJ~JJ
J\
J
ă
J J J ~KJ
J\
J
ăJ
^DGDFăQXHUDYLUXVDWGDUDUHFHOSXĠLQWUHLYHFLQLYLUXVDĠLVHYLUXVHD]ăúLHO` JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
JJJJJJJJăJJ\J`JJ ú
JJJJJJJJJJăJ
ăJtJJJJmJJ ú
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
JJmJ`J JJJmJJ
JJJJJJJJJJ úă ú J
^EGDFăHUDYLUXVDWúLHVWHvQFRQMXUDWGLQWRDWHSăUĠLOHGHYLUXúLVHvQVăQăWRúHúWH` J
JJJJJJJJ
J ^HUDYLUXVDWJ\J`J 'HWHUPLQDUHDPD[LPXOXLGLQúLUXOVXPHORURUHDOL]ăPFXVXEDOJRULWPXOFXQRVFXW
J
JJJJJJJJJJăJ
ăJ\JJJJ
J
QJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJmJ`J
JJJJJJJJJJ
JJ ^UHWXUQHD]ăYDORDUHDFHOXLPDLPDUHHOHPHQWGLQWUXQúLUGHQXPHUH`
JJJmJJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJmJJ
J\
J
ă
úă
JJJJăJJJJJJ
úă
JJJJJJJmJJ
^FGDFăHUDYLUXVDWGHGH]LOHVHvQVăQăWRúHúWH`
úă
JJJJJJJJăJJtJ`JúJ\JJú JJ ú
ăJ\J`JJJ
JJJmJJ
JJJJJJJJJJJmJ`J J ú
úă
ú
'XSă FH QXPăUXO PD[LP GH vPEROQăYLUL D IRVW GHWHUPLQDW QX UăPkQH GHFkWVăVH
ú
ú
DILúH]H]LOHOHvQFDUHDFHDVWăYDORDUHPD[LPăDIRVWDWLQVăYH]LDOJRULWPXOSULQFLSDO
ú
3HQWUXDUH]ROYDFHOGHDOGRLOHDVXESXQFWWUHEXLHVăYHULILFăPSHQWUXILHFDUHLQGL
$FHVWVXEDOJRULWPDSHOHD]ăXQDOWVXEDOJRULWPFDUHSRUQLQGGHOD]LXD]LFDOFXOHD YLGGDFăDIRVWFRQWLQXXEROQDYSHSDUFXUVXOFHORUS]LOH$FHDVWăFHULQĠăHVWHUH]ROYDWă
]ăGHFkWH]LOHSHUVRDQDLGHQWLILFDWăSULQFRRUGRQDWHOHLMHVWHEROQDYă3UH]HQWăPvQ vQDOJRULWPXOSULQFLSDOvQFDUHDPQRWDWFXVúLUXOVXPHORUGHLQGLYL]LEROQDYLSHILH
FRQWLQXDUHDFHVWVXEDOJRULWP FDUH]LJ
7DEORXULWULGLPHQVLRQDOH
#J£QJ
JJ
QJ 3ROLQRDPH &DSLWROXO
^JHQHUDUHDWDEORXOXLWULGLPHQVLRQDOFXSULQ]kQGHYROXĠLDYLUXVăULORU`
JJ
ă
KJ 'HILQLUHDQRĠLXQLLGHSROLQRP
^VHFRQVWUXLHúWHúLUXOQXPăUXOXLWRWDOGHLQGLYL]LYLUXVDĠLSHQWUXILHFDUH]L` )RUPDDOJHEULFăDSROLQRDPHORU
JJ
J\J
ăQJ 5HSUH]HQWDUHDSROLQRDPHORUvQPHPRULDFDOFXODWRUXOXL
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
JJJJJmJ
J 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
JJ ú
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
^VHGHWHUPLQăQXPăUXOPD[LPGHLQGLYL]LYLUXVDĠL`
JJ
ăJmJJ
^VHDILúHD]ă]LOHOHvQFDUHVDDWLQVJUDGXOPD[LPGHYLUXVDUH` 'HILQLUHDQRĠLXQLLGHSROLQRP
JJ
J\J
ăQJ )LHPXOĠLPHDúLUXULORULQILQLWHGHQXPHUHFRPSOH[HI DDDDQFDUHDX
JJJJăJJ\J
ăJJJ QXPDLXQQXPăUILQLWGHWHUPHQLQHQXOLDGLFăH[LVWăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOPDVWIHOvQFkW
JJJJJJ
JJ DL SHQWUXRULFHL!P
JJJJ úă
ú
([HPSOH
^FăXWăPSHUVRDQHEROQDYHQXPDLGDFăQXPăUXOSGH]LOHHVWHPDLPLF` úLUXOI DUHWUHLWHUPHQLQHQXOL
úLUXOJ DUHGRLWHUPHQLQHQXOL
^GHFkWQXPăUXOPD[LPGH]LOHvQFDUHYLUXVXOWUăLHúWH`
JJăJJJ`JJ 3HDFHDVWăPXOĠLPHVHGHILQHVFGRXăRSHUDĠLLDOJHEULFH
JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJJJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ $GXQDUHD
JJJJJJJJ£JmJDGHYăUDWJJ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHPDUFăPLQGLYLGXOFDILLQGYLUXVDW` IJ DEDEDE
JJJJJJJJ
J\J
ăQJ
JJJJJJJJJJăJJ\J`JJJ ÌQPXOĠLUHD
JJJJJJJJJJJJ£JmJIDOV^GDFăFHOSXĠLQR]LQXDIRVWYLUXVDWvOGHPDUFăP` IJ FFFXQGH
úă F DE
JJJJJJJJJJăJ£JJJ F DEDE
JJJJJJJJJJJJ
JJJ F DEDEDE
úă
ú
DU DEUDEU±DEU±DUE
ú
6HREVHUYăFăVXPDIJúLSURGXVXOIJDSDUĠLQDFHOHLDúLPXOĠLPL
ú
úă 'HILQLĠLH
ú )LHFDUHHOHPHQWDOPXOĠLPLLGHILQLWHDQWHULRUSHFDUHVXQWGHILQLWHFHOHGRXăRSHUD
ĠLLVHQXPHúWHSROLQRP
3ROLQRDPH 3ROLQRDPH
'DFăI DDDDQHVWHXQSROLQRPQXPHUHOHDDDVHQXPHVFFRH ÌQPXOĠLPHDSROLQRDPHORUFXFRHILFLHQĠLFRPSOHFúLVHGLVWLQJXUPăWRDUHOHVXEPXO
ILFLHQĠLLOXLI ĠLPLLPSRUWDQWH
5>;@ PXOĠLPHDSROLQRDPHORUFXFRHILFLHQĠLUHDOL
$3URSULHWăĠLDOHDGXQăULLSROLQRDPHORU 4>;@ PXOĠLPHDSROLQRDPHORUFXFRHILFLHQĠLUDĠLRQDOL
)LHIJúLKWUHLSROLQRDPH =>;@ PXOĠLPHDSROLQRDPHORUFXFRHILFLHQĠLvQWUHJL
$GXQDUHDHVWHFRPXWDWLYăIJ JI
$GXQDUHDHVWHDVRFLDWLYăIJK IJK
(OHPHQWQHXWUXSHQWUXDGXQDUHDSROLQRDPHORUHVWHSROLQRPXOFRQVWDQW 5HSUH]HQWDUHDSROLQRDPHORUvQPHPRULD
$YHPI I I FDOFXODWRUXOXL
2ULFHSROLQRPDUHXQRSXVQRWDWFX±IDVWIHOvQFkWI±I ±II
%3URSULHWăĠLDOHvQPXOĠLULLSROLQRDPHORU 5HSUH]HQWDUHDSULQúLUXOFRHILFLHQĠLORU
ÌQPXOĠLUHDHVWHFRPXWDWLYăIJ JI &RHILFLHQĠLLXQXLSROLQRPVHYRUSăVWUDvQWUXQWDEORXXQLGLPHQVLRQDOvQRUGLQHFUHVFă
ÌQPXOĠLUHDHVWHDVRFLDWLYăIJK IJK WRDUHVDXGHVFUHVFăWRDUHGXSăSXWHUHDOXL;1XPLPJUDGXOSROLQRPXOXLSXWHUHDFHD
(OHPHQWQHXWUXSHQWUXvQPXOĠLUHDSROLQRDPHORUHVWHSROLQRPXOFRQVWDQW PDLPDUHDOXL;SHQWUXFDUHFRHILFLHQWXOHVWHGLIHULWGHÌQFRQFOX]LHúLUXOFRUHV
SXQ]ăWRUFRHILFLHQĠLORUYDDYHDFHOSXĠLQDWkWHDHOHPHQWHSHQWUXWHUPHQXOOLEHU
$YHPI I I
FkWHVWHJUDGXOSROLQRPXOXL
ÌQPXOĠLUHDHVWHGLVWULEXWLYăIDĠăGHDGXQDUHIJK IJIKúL
$FHVWPRGGHUHSUH]HQWDUHDUHDYDQWDMXOFăvQFD]XODGRXăSROLQRDPHFRHILFLHQĠLL
$YHPIJK IKJK DFHORUDúLSXWHULDOHOXL;VXQWDúH]DĠLvQFHLGRLYHFWRULSHSR]LĠLLFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH
'DFăIúLJVXQWSROLQRDPHQHQXOHDWXQFLSURGXVXOORUHVWHXQSROLQRPQHQXOIz
úLJzIJz
3RVLELOLWDWHD VLPSOLILFăULL FX XQ IDFWRU QHQXO GDFă I J úL K VXQW SROLQRDPH DVWIHO ([HPSOXGHDGXQDUHúLVFăGHUHDGRXăSROLQRDPH
vQFkWIJ IKúLIzDWXQFLJ K )LH3; ;±;;±;
úL3; ;±;;;±
33; ;±;;±;;±;;;±
)RUPDDOJHEULFăDSROLQRDPHORU ;±;;±;
3ULQFRQYHQĠLHYRPQRWDSROLQRPXOFX;úLvOYRPFLWLQHGHWHUPLQDWD; 3±3; ;±;;±;±;;±;±;
ÌQXUPDvQPXOĠLULLSROLQRDPHORUYDUH]XOWD ;±;;±;
; ;;
; ;; 5HSUH]HQWkQGSROLQRDPHOHVXEIRUPăGHWDEORXULXQLGLPHQVLRQDOHvQFDUHDPDúH]DW
FRHILFLHQĠLLvQRUGLQHFUHVFăWRDUHGXSăSXWHULOHOXL;DGXQDUHDúLVFăGHUHDVHHIHFWXHD
;Q ;;Q± ]ăDVWIHO
LQGLFH
Q±Q 3 ± ±
3 ± ±
33 ± ±
)RORVLPvQPXOĠLUHDúLDGXQDUHDSHQWUXDVFULHI DD;D;DP;PXQGH
DDDDPVXQWFRHILFLHQĠLLSROLQRPXOXLI 3±3 ± ±
3ROLQRDPHOHGHIRUPD D;QXQGHD&PXOĠLPHDQXPHUHORUFRPSOH[HúLQHVWH ([HPSOXGHvQPXOĠLUHDGRXăSROLQRDPH
XQQXPăUQDWXUDOVHQXPHVFPRQRDPH )LH3; ;±;
úL3; ;±
3ROLQRDPH
3ROLQRDPH
3 ±
;±;;±
3 ±
;±;; ([HPSOX
±;;± 3; ± )LH3; ;±;;± ;±;;±;± ;±
;±;;± 3± ± ± úL3; ;± ±;;
±;;±
33 ± ± ;±
;±
9DORDUHDXQXLSROLQRP 2EVHUYDĠLH
3ULQGHILQLĠLHQXPăUXOIĮ DDĮDĮDQĮQVHQXPHúWHYDORDUHDSROLQRPX 'DFăFHOHGRXăSROLQRDPHDXFRHILFLHQĠLQXPHUHvQWUHJLúLFRHILFLHQWXOWHUPHQXOXL
OXLIvQĮ GHJUDGPD[LPDOvPSăUĠLWRUXOXLHVWHrDWXQFLFkWXOúLUHVWXOVXQWSROLQRDPHFXFRHIL
FLHQĠLvQWUHJL
([HPSOX
9DORDUHDSROLQRPXOXL3; ;±;vQSXQFWXO; HVWH )LHIúLJGRXăSROLQRDPH6SXQHPFăSROLQRPXOJGLYLGHSROLQRPXOIVDXIHVWH
3 ± ± ± GLYL]LELOSULQJVDXJHVWHXQGLYL]RUDOOXLIVDXIHVWHXQPXOWLSOXDOOXLJGDFăH[LVWă
XQSROLQRPKDVWIHOvQFkWI JK
6DGHPRQVWUDWFăFHDPDLUDSLGăPHWRGăGHDFDOFXODYDORDUHDXQXLSROLQRPHVWH
FHDED]DWăSHVFKHPDOXL+RUQHU )LHIXQSROLQRPQHQXOFXFRHILFLHQĠLGHWLSFRPSOH[8QQXPăUFRPSOH[DHVWHUă
3ROLQRPXO3;VHVFULHVXEIRUPD GăFLQăDSROLQRPXOXLIGDFăID
3; DQ[DQ±[D[D[D
úL VH DSOLFă XQ DOJRULWP VLPSOX vQ FDUH [ HVWH DUJXPHQWXO SHQWUX FDUH VH FDOFXOHD]ă 7HRUHPDOXL%p]RXW
YDORDUHDSROLQRPXOXL3GHFRHILFLHQĠLDLúLJUDGQ )LHIzXQSROLQRPQHQXO1XPăUXOD&HVWHUăGăFLQăDSROLQRPXOXLIGDFăúL
QXPDLGDFă;±DvOGLYLGHSHI
J
QJ
JJJmJ
J 7HRUHPă
JJ
J\
`J
ăQJ )LHI DD;D;DQ;QXQSROLQRPFXDQzQt'DFă[[[Q
JJJJJmJJ~JJ VXQWUăGăFLQLOHOXLIDWXQFLI DQ;±[;±[;±[QúLvQSOXVDFHDVWă
ú GHVFRPSXQHUHDOXLIvQIDFWRULOLQLDULHVWHXQLFă
ÌPSăUĠLUHDSROLQRDPHORU 7HRUHPă
3UH]HQWăPvQFRQWLQXDUHRVHULHGHGHILQLĠLLúLWHRUHPHDFăURUFXQRDúWHUHHVWHQHFHVDUă 5HVWXOvPSăUĠLULLXQXLSROLQRPIzSULQELQRPXO;±DHVWHHJDOFXYDORDUHDIDD
vQUH]ROYDUHDSUREOHPHLSURSXVHODVIkUúLWXODFHVWXLFDSLWRO
SROLQRPXOXLIvQD
$7HRUHPDvPSăUĠLULLFXUHVW 6FKHPDOXL+RUQHURIHUăXQSURFHGHXGHDIODUHDFkWXOXLúLDUHVWXOXLvPSăUĠLULLSR
)LLQGGDWHGRXăSROLQRDPHRDUHFDUHFXFRHILFLHQĠLLFRPSOHFúLIúLJXQGHJzDWXQFL OLQRPXOXLISULQELQRPXO;±DÌQFD]XOvQFDUHUHVWXOvPSăUĠLULLHVWHDHVWHUăGăFLQă
H[LVWăGRXăSROLQRDPHFXFRHILFLHQĠLGHWLSFRPSOH[TúLUDVWIHOvQFkWI JTUXQ DSROLQRPXOXL2ULFHUăGăFLQăDSROLQRPXOXLHVWHGLYL]RUDOQXPăUXOXLDDQGLQXOWLPD
GHJUDGXOSROLQRPXOXLUHVWHPDLPLFGHFkWJUDGXOSROLQRPXOXLJ UHODĠLHDOXL9LpWH
3ROLQRDPHOHTúLUVXQWXQLFHGDFăVDWLVIDFDFHDVWăSURSULHWDWH
ÌQWDEHOXOXUPăWRUSUH]HQWăPVFKHPDOXL+RUQHUSHQWUXvPSăUĠLUH
)LHDLFRHILFLHQĠLLSROLQRPXOXL3(IHFWXăPvPSăUĠLUHDODPRQRPXO;±Y
&HL FDUH VLPW QHYRLD XQXL VWXGLX DSURIXQGDW SRW FRQVXOWD ELEOLRJUDILH GH VSHFLDOLWDWH GH
H[HPSOXPDQXDOXOGHPDWHPDWLFăSHQWUXFODVDD;D
3ROLQRDPH 3ROLQRDPH
SXWHUHD Y
SXWHULOHQHGHWHUPLQDWHL Q Q± Q± FRHILFLHQĠL ± ±
HVWHUăGăFLQă ± ± ± ± ± ±
FRHILFLHQĠL DQ DQ± DQ± D D GDUQXGXEOă ±
± ±
FRHILFLHQĠLLFkWXOXL DQ DQ±YEQ± DQ±YEQ± DYE DYE QXHVWHUăGăFLQă ± ±± ± ±± ±± ±
vLQRWăP EQ± EQ± EQ± E U HVWHUăGăFLQă ± ±
QXHVWHUăGăFLQă
$FHVWWDEHOVHFRPSOHWHD]ăDVWIHO ± ± ± ±±
x vQUkQGXOGRLDOWDEHOXOXLVHVFULXFRHILFLHQĠLLSROLQRPXOXLI
± ± ± ±±
x XUPăWRDUHDOLQLHDWDEHOXOXLYDFRQĠLQHFRHILFLHQĠLLEúLVHIRUPHD]ăDVWIHO
EQ±SULPHúWHYDORDUHDDQ ± ± ± ±±
SHFHOHODOWHFRORDQHGHODQ±ODHOHPHQWHOHELVHFDOFXOHD]ăFXIRUPXOD
EL DLYEL &RHILFLHQĠLLSROLQRPXOXLFkWVXQW
x 'DFă D YE HVWH vQVHDPQă Fă Y HVWH UăGăFLQă D SROLQRPXOXL &kWXOvPSăUĠLULL
SROLQRPXOXLGDWODDFHVWPRQRP;±YHVWHSROLQRPXODLFăUXLFRHILFLHQĠLVXQWFR QXHVWHUăGăFLQă ; ; ;
HILFLHQĠLLELQHQXOLGRDUFXXQJUDGPDLPLFLDUUHVWXOHVWHDYE
([HPSOX ÌQFRQFOX]LH;±;;±; ;;;±;±
ÌPSăUĠLPSROLQRPXO;±;±;OD;±
SXWHUHD Y 5HSUH]HQWDUHDSROLQRDPHORUSULQPRQRDPHOHVDOH
FRHILFLHQĠL ± ± 'DFăXQSROLQRPDUHPXOĠLFRHILFLHQĠLHJDOLFXUHSUH]HQWDUHDSULQúLUXOFRHILFLHQĠLORU
FkWXOE ± ± ± ± ±± ± ± ± QXPDLHVWHDYDQWDMRDVăÌQDFHVWFD]VHSUHIHUăUHSUH]HQWDUHDSULQúLUXOPRQRDPHORU
E E E E U 'HDVHPHQHDGDFăDFHVWHPRQRDPHQXVXQWDFFHVLELOHvQRUGLQHDFUHVFăWRDUHVDXGHV
FUHVFăWRDUHDSXWHULLOXL;QXYRUDSăUHDSUREOHPHGHRDUHFHvQFD]XOILHFăUXLPRQRP
VHSUHFL]HD]ăGRXăLQIRUPDĠLLYDORDUHDFRHILFLHQWXOXLúLJUDGXOWHUPHQXOXL5HSUH]HQ
&kWXOvPSăUĠLULLHVWH;±;±;±LDUUHVWXOHVWH±
WDUHDSULQPRQRDPHVHSRDWHUHDOL]DFXPDLPXOWHWLSXULGHVWUXFWXULGHGDWH
3HQWUXDGHVFRPSXQHXQSROLQRPFXFRHILFLHQĠLvQWUHJLVXEIRUPăGHSURGXVGHEL x FX GRXă úLUXUL XQXO SHQWUX FRHILFLHQĠLL GLIHULĠL GH DL SROLQRPXOXLúLXQXOSHQWUX
QRDPHVHDSOLFăVFKHPDOXL+RUQHUSHQWUXILHFDUHGLYL]RUSRVLELODOOXLDDQ ÌQFD]XO JUDGHOHFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHDOHWHUPHQLORU
vQFDUHDFHVWDHVWHUăGăFLQăDSROLQRPXOXLVHUHĠLQHúLVHFRQWLQXăSURFHGHXOFXSROLQR x FXXQúLUGHDUWLFROH
PXOFkWÌQILQDOSHQWUXILHFDUHUăGăFLQăGHWHUPLQDWăDYHPXQPRQRP'DFăUHVWXOHV x FXDMXWRUXOXQHLOLVWHOLQLDUHDORFDWăGLQDPLF
WHXQSROLQRPQHQXOvQVHDPQăFăDFHVWDQXVHSRDWHGHVFRPSXQHvQSURGXVGHPRQRD
PHvQPXOĠLPHDQXPHUHORUvQWUHJL
([HPSOX
6ăVHGHVFRPSXQăSROLQRPXO;±;;±;
6HGHWHUPLQăUăGăFLQLOHvQWUHJLSRVLELOHGHFLGLYL]RULLOXL±±±±
$SOLFăP VFKHPD OXL +RUQHU SHQWUX DFHVWH YDORUL 3RW H[LVWD UăGăFLQL PXOWLSOH DGLFă
7LSXO
VHYDvQYăĠDODVIkUúLWXOFODVHLDD
SXWHPJăVLRYDORDUHSHQWUXFDUHSROLQRPXOVăVHGLYLGăOD[±YNXQGHN!
$ORFDUHDGLQDPLFăRYRPvQYăĠDvQFODVDDD
3ROLQRDPH 3ROLQRDPH
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH 3HQWUXFDOFXOXOYDORULLXQXLSROLQRPYDORDUHDQXPHULFăvQWUHDJăSHQWUXFDUHVHFH
3HQWUXDYăIDPLOLDUL]DFXLPSOHPHQWDUHDRSHUDĠLLORUFXSROLQRDPHYăUHFRPDQGăPVă UHFDOFXODUHDYDORULLSROLQRPXOXLVHYDFLWLGHSHDGRXDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLSHOLQLDDWUH
UH]ROYDĠLXUPăWRDUHOHH[HUFLĠLLSULQFDUHVăUHDOL]DĠLRSHUDĠLLOH LDDIOkQGXVHFRHILFLHQĠLLSROLQRPXOXLGDW
FLWLUHDXQXLSROLQRPGDWSULQJUDGúLFRHILFLHQĠL 'DFăRSĠLXQHDHVWH FRHILFLHQĠLLSROLQRPXOXLGHGHVFRPSXVVHDIOăSHDGRXD
FLWLUHDXQXLSROLQRPGDWSULQPRQRDPH OLQLHDILúLHUXOXL
YDORDUHDXQXLSROLQRPSHQWUXXQDUJXPHQWGDW &RHILFLHQĠLLSROLQRDPHORUVHYRUFLWLGLQILúLHUXO'*&$vQRUGLQHFUHVFăWRDUHGX
DGXQDUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH Să SXWHULOH QHGHWHUPLQDWHL $VWIHO DYkQG úL FRHILFLHQĠLL QXOL JUDGXO SROLQRPXOXL VH
vQPXOĠLUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH YDGHWHUPLQDSHED]DQXPăUXOXLFRHILFLHQĠLORU
vPSăUĠLUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH
GHWHUPLQDUHDDFHOXLSROLQRPGLQWUHQSROLQRDPHFDUHSHQWUXXQDUJXPHQWGDWDUH 'DWHGHLHúLUH
YDORDUHPD[LPă ÌQILúLHUXO'*&'(!VHYDVFULHvQIXQFĠLHGHRSHUDĠLDVROLFLWDWă
x SHQWUXRSHUDĠLLOH ~ úL VHYDDILúDSROLQRPXOUH]XOWDWvQXUPDHIHFWXăULL
RSHUDĠLHLUHVSHFWLYH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH x vQXUPDRSHUDĠLHLGHvPSăUĠLUHYRUUH]XOWDGRXăSROLQRDPHFkWXOúLUHVWXOFRHIL
FLHQĠLLDFHVWRUSROLQRDPHVHYRUVFULHSHSULPDFkWXOúLUHVSHFWLYDGRXDOLQLHDIL
2SHUDĠLLFXSROLQRDPH úLHUXOXLUH]XOWDWUHVWXO
ÌQIXQFĠLHGHFHULQĠDSUHFL]DWăvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHVHYDHIHFWXDXQDGLQWUHXUPăWRDUH x YDORDUHD XQXL SROLQRP FX FRHILFLHQĠL vQWUHJL vQWUXQ SXQFW GDW QXPăU vQWUHJ HVWH
OHRSHUDĠLLDVXSUDXQRUSROLQRDPHFXFRHILFLHQĠLvQWUHJL XQQXPăUvQWUHJFDUHYDILVFULVvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH
x DGXQDUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH x vQ XUPDGHVFRPSXQHULLXQXLSROLQRPFDSURGXVGHELQRDPHUH]XOWăRH[SUHVLHGH
x VFăGHUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH IRUPDSROLQRPSROLQRPSROLQRPN
x vQPXOĠLUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH
3ROLQRDPHOH VH YRU DILúD vQ IRUPă DOJHEULFă vQ RUGLQHD GHVFUHVFăWRDUH D JUDGHORU
x vPSăUĠLUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH
WHUPHQLORU3XWHULOHOXL;VHYRUDILúDVXEIRUPD
x FDOFXODUHDYDORULLXQXLSROLQRPvQWUXQSXQFWQXPăUvQWUHJGDW
x GHVFRPSXQHUHDXQXLSROLQRPvQSURGXVGHELQRDPH
;SXWHUHGDFăSXWHUH!
;VHYDDILúD;
'DWHGHLQWUDUH ;QXVHYDDILúDDSDUHGRDUFRHILFLHQWXO
'HSHSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH '*&$VHFLWHúWHXQFDUDFWHUFDUHFRPXQLFă WHUPHQLLDLFăURUFRHILFLHQĠLVXQWQXVHYRUVFULHH[FHSĠLHIăFkQGSROLQRPXOQXO
RSHUDĠLDFDUHWUHEXLHHIHFWXDWă&DUDFWHUHOHSRVLELOHVXQW
x ~VHVROLFLWăDGXQDUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x VHVROLFLWăVFăGHUHDFHOXLGHDOGRLOHDSROLQRPGLQSULPXO x WRDWHSROLQRDPHOHDXFRHILFLHQĠLvQWUHJL
x GDWHOHGHLQWUDUHVXQWFRUHFWHúLFRQIRUPHFXGHVFULHUHDGLQHQXQĠ
x VHVROLFLWăSURGXVXODGRXăSROLQRDPH
x FRHILFLHQWXOWHUPHQXOXLGHJUDGPD[LPDSROLQRPXOXLvPSăUĠLWRUvQFD]XORSHUDĠLHL
x VHVROLFLWăFkWXOúLUHVWXOGXSăFHSULPXOSROLQRPVDvPSăUĠLWODDOGRLOHD HVWH
x VHVROLFLWăFDOFXODUHDYDORULLXQXLSROLQRPvQWUXQSXQFWGDW
x VHVROLFLWăGHVFRPSXQHUHDSROLQRPXOXLvQELQRDPH ([HPSOH
'*&$ '*&'(!J
ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHVHGRUHúWHRRSHUDĠLHDULWPHWLFăFRHILFLHQĠLLFHORUGRXăSROLQRDPH ~J ¨~¨¨
VHYRUDIODSHOLQLLOHDGRXDúLUHVSHFWLYDWUHLDDILúLHUXOXL JJ`JJ
JJ
3ROLQRDPH
3ROLQRDPH
J
Q
KJ QXYKJJ QKJ
'*&$ '*&'(!J
J ¨¨¨~ J J ^DILúHD]ăXQSROLQRPvQIRUPDVDDOJHEULFă`
J
JJ`JJ
JJQ
KJ QXYKJJ QXYKJ
JJ
J J ^FRPSOHWHD]ăSROLQRPXOSFXXULSkQăODQRXOJUDG`
'*&$J '*&'(!J J
J ¨|¨¨~¨~¨
J
JQ
KJ QXYKJ
JJ`JJ J J ^LQLĠLDOL]HD]ăFRHILFLHQĠLLSROLQRPXOXLSGHJUDGJFXXUL`
JJ J
J
J¨JQ
KJJ QXYKJ
'*&$J '*&'(!J J J ^vQPXOĠHúWHSROLQRPXOSFX;`
J
J ¨~J
JJ`JJ
J
%%JQ
KJ QXYKJJ
JJJ J J %
Q
KJ
J ^UHWXUQHD]ăSROLQRPXOUH]XOWDWGLQvQPXOĠLUHDOXLFXRFRQVWDQWă`
'*&$ '*&'(!J J
J
Q
KJ QXYKJJQ
KJJ
J
J J J QXYKJ
|J
JJ`JJ ^DGXQDUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPHSúLSGHJUDGJUHVSHFWLYJ`
J
J%Q
KJ QXYKJJQ
KJJ
'*&$ '*&'(!J
J J J QXYKJ
J ¨~¨~J¨J¨
J`JJJ ^HIHFWXHD]ăVFăGHUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPHSúLSGHJUDGJUHVSHFWLYJ`
J
J
Q
KJ QXYKJJQ
KJJ
J QXYKJ
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVH
J J
^UHWXUQHD]ăSROLQRPXOUH]XOWDWGLQvQPXOĠLUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH`
J
JQ
KJ QXYKJJ
2SHUDĠLLFXSROLQRDPH J J J%Q
KJJ % QXYKJ
&RPSOH[LWDWHDDFHVWHLDSOLFDĠLLREOLJăODXWLOL]DUHDVXESURJUDPHORUXQHOHGLQWUHHOHIL ^UHWXUQHD]ăSROLQRPXOFkWúLUHVWUH]XOWDWHGLQvPSăUĠLUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH`
LQGQHFHVDUHvQFD]XOUHDOL]ăULLPDLPXOWRURSHUDĠLL'LQVXESURJUDPHOHFDUHSUHOXFUHD J
]ăSROLQRDPHOHDPFRQVWUXLWXQXQLWÌQDFHVWXQLWDPGHILQLWWLSXO
úLVXESUR
J%
Q
KJ QXYKJJ QK
JUDPHOHFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăRSHUDĠLLOHGHFDUHYRPDYHDQHYRLH8QHOHVXESURJUDPHVXQW ^GHVFRPSXQHSROLQRPXOvQSURGXVGHELQRDPH`
DSHODWHGRDUGHVXESURJUDPHúLÄQXVHYăG´GLQSURJUDPXOXWLOL]DWRUDOXQLWXOXL
,QWHUIDĠDDFHVWXLXQLW 6XEDOJRULWPXO úFLWHúWHGHSHOLQLDFXUHQWăDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUHFRHILFLHQ
ĠLLXQXLSROLQRPúLGHWHUPLQăJUDGXODFHVWXLDvQIXQFĠLHGHQXPăUXOGHFRHILFLHQĠL
J
J Jú QJ
J
\``JJ
KJ JJ JmJ`J
J JJ
XUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLH
ăQJ
J£Q
KJ QXYKJQ
Q
KJ JJJJ
ú
J J
^FDOFXOHD]ăYDORDUHDSROLQRPXOXLSvQWUXQSXQFWGDW[FXVFKHPDOXL+RUQHU` JJJJ JmJ ~J
J ú
J%JQ
KJJ QXYKJJ
QKJ JJ JmJ JJJ
^UHWXUQHD]ăSROLQRPXOFLWLWGLQILúLHUúLJUDGXOOXL` ú
3ROLQRDPH 3ROLQRDPH
JJJJăJ`J
J`JJ
ÌQVXEDOJRULWPXOFDUHDILúHD]ăXQSROLQRPVXEIRUPăDOJHEULFăúLFRQIRUPFHULQĠH
ORUHQXQĠDWHVDXVHSDUDWXUPăWRDUHOHVLWXDĠLL JJJJJJ
J~`J ^DILúDUHDWHUPHQXOXLOLEHU`
JJJJ úăJ
x GDFăSROLQRPXODUHJUDGVHDILúHD]ăWHUPHQXOOLEHU JJJJăJ`JJ`JJ
x GDFăSROLQRPXODUHJUDGPDLPDUHGHFkW JJJJJJ
J`J
VHDILúHD]ăSULPXOWHUPHQGHJUDGPD[LP JJ úăJ
VHDILúHD]ăWHUPHQLLGHJUDG ú
VHDILúHD]ăWHUPHQXOOLEHU 8UPHD]ă DFXP SUH]HQWDUHD VXEDOJRULWPLORU FDUHFRUHVSXQGRSĠLXQLORUSRVLELOHGLQ
ILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH
'HDVHPHQHD
x vQIDĠDFRHILFLHQĠLORUSR]LWLYLYRPVFULH ~DYHPGHDILúDWRVXPăGHPRQRDPH 2SĠLXQHD22
SHFkQGvQIDĠDFHORUQHJDWLYLVHPQXO VHDILúHD]ăLPSOLFLWQXHVWHFD]XOVăVH J£ J
DGDXJHQLPLF ^FDOFXOHD]ăYDORDUHDSROLQRPXOXLSvQWUXQSXQFWGDW[FXVFKHPDOXL+RUQHU`
x GDFăFRHILFLHQWXOHVWHWHUPHQXOUHVSHFWLYQXVHDILúHD]ă JJJmJ`J
JJ
J\ `J
ăQJ
J
úă
Q JJJJJmJJ~JJ
JJăJ J\J`J
J JJ ^DYHPQXPDLWHUPHQOLEHU`J ú
JJ
J JJ£JmJJ
JJJJăJ J\JJ
J ^WHUPHQGHWLSXOÄ´`J ú J
JJJJ
J J
JJJJJJăJ JzJJ ^WHUPHQGHWLSXOÄ
´`J 2SĠLXQHD2;2
JJJJJJJJ
J J ÌQYHGHUHDDGXQăULLDGRXăSROLQRDPHSGHJUDGJúLSGHJUDGJDFHVWHDPDL
úă vQWkLVHDGXFODDFHHDúLOXQJLPHDFHOXLGHJUDGPD[LP FXVXEDOJRULWPXO
JJJJăJ J
JJ ^WHUPHQGHWLSXOÄ?´`J ă $FHVW OXFUX vQVHDPQă DGăXJDUH GH XUL SkQă OD OXQJLPHD
JJJJJJ
J¨ J
PDL PDUH FRHILFLHQĠL GH UDQJ PDL PDUH GHRDUHFH úLUXO FRHILFLHQĠLORU HVWH RUGRQDW
JJJJ
J
J¨J ^WHUPHQGHWLSXOÄ´`J FUHVFăWRUGXSăSXWHULOHOXL;ÌQFRQWLQXDUHDGXQDUHDFRQVWăvQWURVLPSOăDGXQDUHDúL
úăJ
JJJJ
J\ J
ăQJ
UXULORUFRHILFLHQĠLORU
JJJJJJăJJzJ`J ^GDFăWHUPHQXODUHFRHILFLHQWQHQXO` Jă QJ
JJJJJJJJăJJ\JJJ
JJ
JJJJJJJJ
J J J ^FRPSOHWHD]ăSROLQRPXOSFXXULSkQăODQRXOJUDG`
JJ
J\ ~ J
ăQJ
JJJJJJJJJJăJJ\JJ
J~J
JJJJJJJJJJ
J JJJJJmJ`J
JJJJJJJJJJJJăJJ
JJJ
J~J ú
JJJJJJJJJJJJ
J
JJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJ úă J
ă J
úă ^VHFRPSOHWHD]ăFXXULSROLQRPXOPDLVFXUWSkQăODOXQJLPHDFHOXLODOW`
úă J J ^úLVHGHWHUPLQăJUDGXOUH]XOWDWXOXL`
JJJJJJJJăJJ
JJJ
J¨J JJăJ J
J JJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
J
J¨J JJJJ JmJ J
úăJ JJJJă J
JJJJJJ úăJ JJ
J
JJJJ ú
J JJJJ JmJ J
3ROLQRDPH 3ROLQRDPH
JJJJă J ^GDFăvQXUPDVFăGHULLFHORUGRXăSROLQRDPHVDUHGXVJUDGXO`
úă ^SROLQRPXOXLUH]XOWDWVHPRGLILFăJUDGXOSROLQRPXOXLGLIHUHQĠă`
JJ
J\` J
ăQJ
J J
J`JúJ J\J`J
ăQJ
JJJJJmJJ~JJ ^VHDGXQăWHUPHQFXWHUPHQ` JJJJ JmJ J
^GDFăvQXUPDDGXQăULLFHORUGRXăSROLQRDPHVDUHGXVJUDGXO` ú
JJ
^SROLQRPXOXLUH]XOWDWVHPRGLILFăJUDGXOSROLQRPXOXLVXPă` ú J
JJ
J J
J`JúJ J\J`J
ăQJ J
JJJJ JmJ JJ 2SĠLXQHD2B2
ú
JJ ÌQPXOĠLUHDSRDWHILSULYLWăFDDGXQDUHDSROLQRDPHORUREĠLQXWHGLQvQPXOĠLUHDOXLS
ú J FXFkWHXQPRQRPGHDOOXLS3ROLQRPXOÄSURGXV´vOYRPLQLĠLDOL]D
'DFăYUHPVăHYLWăPDFHDVWăRSHUDĠLHGHFRPSOHWDUHFXXULFDUHFDX]HD]ăFUHúWH J
Ġă QJ
UHDRSHUDĠLLORUHOHPHQWDUHGHDGXQDUHSXWHPSURFHGDvQIHOXOXUPăWRU ^LQLĠLDOL]HD]ăFRHILFLHQĠLLSROLQRPXOXLSGHJUDGJFXXUL`
J JJ
J\` J
ăQJ
J
ă QJ JJJJJmJ`J
J J ^DGXQăPFX` ú
JJ
JJăJ JJ JJJ ú J
J
JJJJ
J\`
J
ăQJ
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
0RQRDPHOHFXFDUHVHYDvQPXOĠLSOHREĠLQHPGLQSVXEIRUPăGHFRHILFLHQĠLÌQ
ú
FRQVHFLQĠăQHWUHEXLHXQVXEDOJRULWPFDUHvQPXOĠHúWHXQSROLQRPFXXQQXPăUvQWUHJ
J
JmJJ J¡
Ġú%% %
QJ
JmJ J ^UHWXUQHD]ăSROLQRPXOUH]XOWDWGLQvQPXOĠLUHDOXLFX%
`
JJ
J\` J
ăQJ
JJJJ
J\`
J
ăQJ
JJJJJmJ%
J
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ ú
JJ
ú
ú J
JmJJ
JJJJ JmJ J ÌQ VXEDOJRULWPXO ¡
Ġú YRP XWLOL]D WUHL SROLQRD
úăJ
PHGHOXFUXGHJUDG
úL
3ROLQRPXOSULPHúWHYD
ú
J ORDUHD SROLQRPXOXL S vQ
ÄVWUkQJHP´ SROLQRPXO UH]XOWDW S LDU vQ
$FHDVWăUH]ROYDUHDUHGH]DYDQWDMXOFăvOPRGLILFăSHSUHVSHFWLYSHSGXSăFD]
SăVWUăPWHPSRUDUSROLQRPXOFDUHODILHFDUHSDVVHvQPXOĠHúWHFX;'HDVH
'DFăvQVăLDPWUDQVPLWHSULQYDORDUHGXSăUHYHQLUHDGLQDSHOLDPUHJăVLQHPRGLIL PHQHDODILHFDUHSDVvQQXPăUGHFkĠLWHUPHQLVXQWvQSYRPvQPXOĠLSFXFRHILFLHQ
FDWH WXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUGLQSúLUH]XOWDWXOVHDGXQăODSSăVWUDWvQ
J¡
Ġú QJ
2SĠLXQHD212
J J ^UHWXUQHD]ăSROLQRPXOUH]XOWDWGLQvQPXOĠLUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH`
6FăGHUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPHSRDWHILSULYLWăFDRDGXQDUHDSULPXOXLSROLQRPFXSR
JJ JmJ J~J J
OLQRPXOUH]XOWDWGLQvQPXOĠLUHDFHOXLGHDOGRLOHDSROLQRPFX±
JJ
Ġă J ^VHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăUH]XOWDWXO`
S±S S±S
JJJmJJ ^JJ\JSROLQRPGHOXFUX`J
J% Q JJ JmJ J
JJ¡
Ġú%% J ^VHDGXQăODILHFDUHSDVSROLQRPXOODSROLQRPXOUH]XOWDW`J
JJ
ă KJ J
3ROLQRDPH 3ROLQRDPH
JJ
J\` J
ăQJ ^SHQWUXILHFDUHFRHILFLHQWDOSROLQRPXOXL` J¡ % % QJ
JJJJ
JmJJ ^UHWXUQHD]ăSROLQRPXOFkWúLUHVWUH]XOWDWHGLQvPSăUĠLUHDDGRXăSROLQRDPH`
JJJJ
JmJJ JJ %JmJ JJ ^JUDGXOSROLQRPXOXLFkWHVWHGLIHUHQĠDJUDGHORUSROLQRDPHORU`
JJJJ¡
Ġú%%
J ^VHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăFRHILFLHQĠLLSROLQRPXOXL%FX`
JJJJ
ă
J JJ
Ġă% %J
JJJJ¨ J ^VHSUHJăWHúWHSHQWUXSDVXOXUPăWRU` ^FkWXOúLUHVWXOYRUILSROLQRDPHFXFRHILFLHQĠLvQWUHJL`J
JJ ú
JJăJ J\JJ J J\JJ
ú ^JUDGXOGHvPSăUĠLWXOXLtJUDGXOvPSăUĠLWRUXOXL`J
JJJJ
J JtJ J
ăQJ
(IHFWXOVXEDOJRULWPXOXL ¨ HVWHÄHFKLYDOHQW´FXvQPXOĠLUHDSROLQRPXOXL ^FRHILFLHQWXOWHUPHQXOXLGHJUDG YDILUH]XOWDWXOvPSăUĠLULL`
SFX;'HIDSWVHGHSODVHD]ăFRHILFLHQĠLLvQúLUFXRSR]LĠLHODGUHDSWDHOLEHUkQGDVWIHO JJJJJJ% JmJ J
ORFXOWHUPHQXOXLOLEHUFDUHVHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăFXúLvQILQDOVHPăUHúWHJUDGXOSROLQRPX JJJJJJ¡
Ġú% J
OXLFX JJJJJJ% J
JJJJJJJmJJ ^VHUHSHWăSURFHVXOvPSăUĠLQGUHVWXODFWXDOOD`J
J¨ QJ JJJJJJ JmJ J
J J ^vQPXOĠHúWHSROLQRPXOSFX;` ú
JJ
J\ `J
ăQJ^VHGHSODVHD]ăFRHILFLHQĠLLFXRSR]LĠLHVSUHGUHDSWD`J úăJ
ú J
JJJJ~JmJJ
JJ ú
J
2SĠLXQHD22
JJ`JmJ`J 3HUkQGSHQWUXILHFDUHSRVLELOGLYL]RUVHFRQVWUXLHúWHSROLQRPXOSFRQIRUPVFKHPHL
JJ JmJ J~JJ OXL+RUQHU
ú
J%
,
'DFă vQWUR SUREOHPă DP DYHD QHYRLH GH XQ VXEDOJRULWP VLPSOX GH vQPXOĠLUHDP JJăJ` J\J`JJ ^QXPDLGDFăDUHFRHILFLHQĠLvQWUHJL`
SXWHDIRORVLXUPăWRUXO JJJJ
JmJ` ^VHLQWURGXFvQúLUXOGLYL]RULLOXL``J
J JJJJ
J\`J
ăQJ
J¡
Ġú QJ
JJJJJJăJ`J\J`J^úLVHLQWURGXFvQúLUXOGLYL]RULORU`J
JJ JmJ J~J J
JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
~J
JJ
Ġă ^VHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăUH]XOWDWXO`J JJJJJJJJ
JmJJ
JJ
J\` J
ăQJ
JJJJ
J\` J
ăQJ JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
~J
JJJJJJJJ
JmJJ
JJJJJ~JmJ~J~JJ
JJJJJJ úă
ú
ú
ú
ú JJJJ JmJ ^YDULDELOăDX[LOLDUăvQFDUHVHSăVWUHD]ăJUDGXOSROLQRPXOXL`
JJJJ?JmJJJ ^LQGLFHvQúLUXOGLYL]RULORU`J
2SĠLXQHD2C2J JJJJ
ăJmJ`JJ ^QXPăUXOUăGăFLQLORUJăVLWH`J
'HRDUHFHDFHDVWăDSOLFDĠLHGHWHUPLQăFkWXOúLUHVWXODGRXăSROLQRDPHFXFRHILFLHQĠL JJJJ
ăJ ^VHFRQVWUXLHúWHSROLQRPXOFRQIRUPVFKHPHLOXL+RUQHU`
vQWUHJL FRQIRUP XQXL UH]XOWDW SUH]HQWDW vQ VXSRUWXO WHRUHWLF DO OHFĠLHL FRHILFLHQWXO GH JJJJJJ JmJ J ^FRHILFLHQWXOWHUPHQXOXLGHJUDGPD[LP`
JUDGPD[LPDOSROLQRPXOXLvPSăUĠLWRUWUHEXLHVăILHVDX± JJJJJJ
J\ `J
ăQJ
JJJJJJJJJmJJ~J~?J
ú
3ROLQRDPH
JJJJJJăJ`J\J`JJ ^?HVWHUăGăFLQăDOXL`J
JJJJJJJJ
ăJmJ
ăJ~JJ
JJJJJJJJă
ăJmJ?JJJJ ^SăVWUăPUăGăFLQDvQúLUXOUăGăFLQLORU`
JJJJJJJJ
J\ J
ăQJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJmJJ
ú
J
JJJJJJJJ JmJ JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ ^VFDGHJUDGXOSROLQRPXOXL`J 0XOĠLPL &DSLWROXO
JJJJJJ
J
JJJJJJJJ?JmJ?J~JJ 7LSXOPXOĠLPH
2SHUDĠLLOHSRVLELOHFXGDWHOHGHWLSPXOĠLPH
úăJ
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
JJJJ
ăJ?J
J
J J
ăJ\J J 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
^SkQăFkQGQXPDLVXQWGLYL]RULVDXDPJăVLWWRDWHUăGăFLQLOH`
JJJJ
úăX
JJ úăJ
ú
6XEDOJRULWPXOGHPDLVXVDSHOHD]ăRSURFHGXUăVSHFLDOăGHDILúDUH3URFHGXUDIDFH 7LSXOPXOĠLPH
0XOĠLPHDHVWHRVWUXFWXUăVWDWLFăGHGDWHFXDMXWRUXOFăUHLDVHSRDWHUHSUH]HQWDRFR
SDUWHGLQ]RQDGHGHFODUDĠLLDVXESURJUDPXOXL%
OHFĠLH ILQLWă GH HOHPHQWH &DUDFWHUXO ILQLW QH SHUPLWH LQGH[DUHD HOHPHQWHORU VDOH
0 ^PPPQ` FHHD FH vQVHDPQă Fă OD QLYHOXO UHSUH]HQWăULL LQWHUQH PXOĠLPHD
úăX
Q SRDWHILDVLPLODWăFXXQúLUPPPQ
^VHDILúHD]ăSURGXVXOGHSROLQRDPHGHWHUPLQDW` 3HQWUXDSXWHDSUHFL]DPRGXOvQFDUHVHYRUHIHFWXDRSHUDĠLLOHFXPXOĠLPLYRPGHIL
JJăJ J
J`JJ QLVWUXFWXUDGHVXEPXOĠLPH$FHDVWDVHSRDWHUHDOL]DFXDMXWRUXOXQXLYHFWRUIRUPDWGLQ
J J ^VHDILúHD]ăFDUHQXPDLDUHUăGăFLQLvQPXOĠLPHDQXPHUHORUvQWUHJL` YDORULOHIXQFĠLHLFDUDFWHULVWLFHDVRFLDWHVXEPXOĠLPLL
JJJJ
JJ GDFă PL 6
YV VVVQXQGH VL ®
JJJJ
úă J ¯ GDFă PL 6
JJJJ
JJ )LH660úL Y V Y V YHFWRULLORUFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUL$WXQFL
úă
JJ
J?\
J
ăQJ D 6 6YDILFDUDFWHUL]DWăGHYHFWRUXOYREĠLQXWGLQ YV úL YV HIHFWXkQGRSHUDĠLD
JJJJ`JmJă?J ORJLFăVDXHOHPHQWFXHOHPHQW
JJJJJmJJ E 6 6YDILFDUDFWHUL]DWăGHYHFWRUXOYREĠLQXWGLQ YV úL YV HIHFWXkQGRSHUDĠLD
JJJJ
JJ ORJLFăúLHOHPHQWFXHOHPHQW
JJJJ
úă J 2ULFDUHDOWHRSHUDĠLLFXVXEPXOĠLPLOHXQHLPXOĠLPLSRWILLPDJLQDWHFDRSHUDĠLLORJL
JJJJ
JJ FHDVXSUDYHFWRULORUDWDúDĠL
JJ ú
7LSXOPXOĠLPHHVWHXQWLSVWUXFWXUDWGLIHULWGHFHOHODOWHWLSXULVWUXFWXUDWHHOFRUHV
úJ
SXQGHQRĠLXQLLGHPXOĠLPHGLQPDWHPDWLFă
2YDORDUHDXQXLWLSPXOĠLPHHVWHRVXEPXOĠLPHDYDORULORUXQXLWLSRUGLQDOVWDQ
$FHVWHVXESURJUDPHVXQWWRDWHvQFRUSRUDWHvQXQLWXOSăVWUDWvQILúLHUXO GDUGVDXGHILQLWGHXWLOL]DWRUQXPLW WLSXOGHED]ăDOPXOĠLPLL'HH[HPSOXvQOLPED
FDUHWUHEXLHLQFOXVvQSURJUDPXOFDUHvOYDXWLOL]D3URJUDPXOSULQFLSDOFXSULQGHFLWLUHD MXO 3DVFDO WLSXO GH ED]ă DO PXOĠLPLL DUH FHO PXOW GH YDORUL YDORULOH RUGLQDOH DOH
DFHVWRUDWUHEXLHVăDSDUĠLQăLQWHUYDOXOXL>@
FDUDFWHUXOXLFDUHFRGLILFăRSHUDĠLDGHHIHFWXDWÌQIXQFĠLHGHYDORDUHDDFHVWXLFDUDFWHU
VH H[HFXWă VHFYHQĠD GH LQVWUXFĠLXQL FDUH FLWHúWH GDWHOH GH LQWUDUH HIHFWXHD]ă RSHUDĠLD
SUHFL]DWăúLDILúHD]ăUH]XOWDWHOHvQIRUPDVROLFLWDWăúLVXQWSROLQRDPHGH
JUDGH úLUHVSHFWLY
J
0XOĠLPHD 0XOĠLPHD
8QWLSPXOĠLPHDUHDWkWHDYDORULFkWHVXEPXOĠLPLDGPLWHPXOĠLPHDYDORULORUWLSXOXL ăJ
\JX
GHED]ăúLPXOĠLPHDYLGăUHVSHFWLYQVXEPXOĠLPLGDFăWLSXOGHED]ăDUHQYDORUL
JJ
%JJX
úă
ăJ X
2SHUDĠLLOHSRVLELOHFXGDWHOHGHWLSPXOĠLPH
J J%JX
úă
$WULEXLUHD ăJ
JX
JJ
JJX
8QHLYDULDELOHGHWLSPXOĠLPHLVHDWULEXLHYDORDUHDXQHLH[SUHVLLGHDFHODúLWLSPXOĠLPH
úă
([HPSOH3DVFDO
F7HVWGHDSDUWHQHQĠăDXQXLHOHPHQWODRPXOĠLPH
Q\K ^LQLĠLDOL]DUHFXPXOĠLPHDYLGă`
XQ\|KJ 6HIRORVHúWHRSHUDWRUXOUHODĠLRQDO
Q\"KJ
([HPSOH
'HFODUDUHDWLSXOXLPXOĠLPH3DVFDO ă
J
JJ
J
JJ
QXPHBWLS
WLSBGHBED]ă
úă
JLGHQWLILFDWRUBYDULDELOăQQXPHBWLS ă
J
XQGHWLSBGHBED]ăHVWHWLSXOGHED]ăDOPXOĠLPLLúLDUHFHOPXOWGHYDORUL
J
JJ
J
JJ
úă
([HPSOH
\
XYK ^QXPHUHvQWUHJLPDLPLFLGHFkW` G&LWLUHDXQHLYDULDELOHGHWLSPXOĠLPH
\
`K ^PXOĠLPHGHFLIUH` ÌQOLPEDMXO3DVFDOQXHVWHSHUPLVăFLWLUHDXQHLYDULDELOHGHWLSPXOĠLPHÌQFRQFOX]LH
\
& ^PXOĠLPHGHFDUDFWHUH` VHYDSURFHGDVLPLODUFXFLWLUHDXQHLYDULDELOHGHWLSWDEORXFLWLQGFRPSRQHQWHOHPXO
\
K ^PXOĠLPHDOLWHUHORUPLFL` ĠLPLLXQDFkWHXQD
2SHUDĠLLFXPXOĠLPL ĠQ
2SHUDĠLLOH FXQRVFXWH GLQ WHRULD PXOĠLPLORU ± VH LPSOHPHQWHD]ă vQ IXQFĠLH GH LQVWUX JJJmJJ ^vQ3DVFDOPXOĠLPHDYLGăVHQRWHD]ăFXDMXWRUXOFRQVWUXFWRUXOXL`
PHQWHOHOLPEDMXOXLGHSURJUDPDUH
PDLH[LVWăHOHPHQWH
ă,
ú
J
D2SHUDWRULELQDUL ^
WUHEXLHVăILHGHDFHODúLWLSFXWLSXOGHED]ăDOPXOĠLPLL`
5HXQLXQHDDGRXăPXOĠLPL~ JJJJJmJJ~J
JJ
,QWHUVHFĠLDDGRXăPXOĠLPL ^RSHUDĠLDGHUHXQLXQHVHHIHFWXHD]ăvQWUHGRLRSHUDQ]LGHWLSPXOĠLPH`
úă
'LIHUHQĠDDGRXăPXOĠLPL ú
E2SHUDWRULUHODĠLRQDOL H6FULHUHDXQHLYDULDELOHGHWLSPXOĠLPH
dLQFOX]LXQHtLQFOXGHSH\HJDOLWDWH
GLIHULWH ÌQ OLPEDMXO 3DVFDO QX HVWH SHUPLVă VFULHUHD XQHL YDULDELOH GH WLS PXOĠLPH ùL GH GDWD
DFHDVWDVHYDSURFHGDVLPLODUFXVFULHUHDXQHLYDULDELOHGHWLSWDEORXVFULLQGFRPSR
([HPSOH QHQWHOHPXOĠLPLLXQDFkWHXQD
ăJ\JX
JJ
%JJX
úă ÌQVXEDOJRULWPXOXUPăWRUSUHVXSXQHPFăPXOĠLPHDDUHWLSXOGHED]ăXY
0XOĠLPHD 0XOĠLPHD
%ĠQ ([HPSOX
\`||J
ă, $(+"&$ $(+"&'(!
^JHQHUăPILHFDUH
FDUHDSDUĠLQHWLSXOXLGHED]ăDOPXOĠLPLL` J`JJ JJJ
ă
JJJ ^GDFă
DSDUĠLQHPXOĠLPLL` JJ|||J J
^DWXQFLvOVFULHP` |
úă
ú
ú $JHQGD
9DVLOHúLDFXPSăUDWRDJHQGăQRXăúLúLDQRWDWvQHDQQXPHUHGHWHOHIRQDOHFXQRú
2EVHUYDĠLH WLQĠHORUVDOHvQWURRUGLQHGRULWăGHHO&KLDUGDFăDUHDJHQGă9DVLOHDUYUHDVăÄvQYHĠH´
1XRULFHVWUXFWXUăGHGDWHGHWLSPXOĠLPHSRDWHILLPSOHPHQWDWăFXXQWLSSUHGHILQLW WRDWHQXPHUHOHGHWHOHIRQQRWDWH'HRDUHFHHODREVHUYDWFăFHOPDLXúRUVHSRWSăVWUD
vQOLPEDMXOGHSURJUDPDUHUHVSHFWLY'HH[HPSOXFKLDUGDFăvQ3DVFDOH[LVWăSRVLEL vQPLQWHDFHOHQXPHUHGHWHOHIRQFDUHDXXQQXPăUPLQLPGHFLIUHGLVWLQFWHvúLSURSX
OLWDWHDIRORVLULLWLSXOXL
DFHVWDQXHVWHXWLOL]DELOvQFD]XOXQHLPXOĠLPLDYkQGFDUGL QHVăOHvQYHĠHPDLvQWkLSHDFHVWHD$SRLDUXUPDQXPHUHOHGHWHOHIRQGLQFHOHUăPDVH
QDOLWDWHPDLPDUHGHFkWVDXvQFD]XOvQFDUHHOHPHQWHOHXQHLPXOĠLPLQXVXQWGH FDUHDFXPDXQXPăUPLQLPGHFLIUHGLVWLQFWHúLDúDPDLGHSDUWH
WLSRUGLQDOÌQDFHVWHFD]XULYRPLPSOHPHQWDXQWLSPXOĠLPHSURSULXDSHOkQGODWLSXO 6FULHĠLXQSURJUDPFDUHVWDELOHúWHFDUHVXQWQXPHUHOHGHWHOHIRQGLQFHOHH[LVWHQWH
WDEORXÌQFD]XOLPSOHPHQWăULORUSURSULLYDWUHEXLVăFUHăPVXEDOJRULWPLLFDUH vQDJHQGDOXL9DVLOHSHFDUHOHYDÄvQYăĠD´vQSULPD]LDSRLFDUHVXQWFHOHSHFDUHOH
DVLJXUăRSHUDĠLLOHVSHFLILFHFXPVXQWUHXQLXQHDúLLQWHUVHFĠLDYH]LFDSLWROXO YDUHĠLQHvQDGRXDHWF
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH 'LQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH#)$%#&$VHFLWHVFQXPHUHOHGHWHOHIRQGHSHOLQLLGLVWLQFWH
'DWHGHLHúLUH
&LIUHFRPXQH ÌQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH#)$%#&'(!VHYRUVFULHSHDFHHDúLOLQLHVHSDUDWHSULQVSDĠLXQX
'LQWUXQILúLHUWH[WVHFLWHVFQXPHUHvQWUHJL$ILúDĠLFLIUHOHFRPXQHWXWXURUQXPHUHORU PHUHOHGHWHOHIRQDYkQGDFHODúLQXPăUGHFLIUHGLVWLQFWHOLQLDvQFKHLQGXVHFXQXPăUXO
FLWLWHúLFLIUHOHFDUHQXDSDUvQFRPSRQHQĠDQLFLXQXLQXPăUGLQILúLHU GHRUGLQHDO]LOHLvQFDUHVHPHPRUHD]ăDFHOHQXPHUH
'DWHGHLQWUDUH 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
)LúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH $(+"&$FRQĠLQHXQQXPăURDUHFDUHGHOLQLLSHFDUHVXQWVFULVH
x XQQXPăUGHWHOHIRQDUHFHOPXOWFLIUH
XQQXPăURDUHFDUHGHQXPHUHvQWUHJLVHSDUDWHSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLX
x dQd
'DWHGHLHúLUH
([HPSOX
ÌQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH $(+"&'(!VHYRUVFULHFLIUHOHFRPXQHSHSULPDOLQLHvQRUGLQH #)$%#&$ #)$%#&'(!
FUHVFăWRDUHGRXăFLIUHILLQGVHSDUDWHSULQWUXQVSDĠLX&LIUHOHFDUHQXDSDUvQFRPSR |J JJ
QHQĠD QLFL XQXL QXPăU VH YRU VFULH SH D GRXD OLQLH vQ RUGLQH FUHVFăWRDUH GRXă FLIUH |J JJ
ILLQGVHSDUDWHSULQWUXQVSDĠLX'DFăQXH[LVWăFLIUHFDUHVăILHFRPXQHWXWXURUQXPHUH J JJ
ORUGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHSHSULPDOLQLHGLQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVHYDVFULHPHVDMXO J J |J|JJ
J %
J %
'DFă WRDWH FHOH FLIUH DSDU vQ VFULHUHD QXPHUHORU GLQ |J |JJ|J|
|J
ILúLHUvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVHYDVFULHPHVDMXOJJ%
J
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x QXPHUHOHGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHDXFHOPXOWFLIUHILHFDUH
0XOĠLPHD 0XOĠLPHD
,QGLYL]L 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
ÌQWUXQJUXSGHQLQGLYL]LVHVWDELOHVFUHODĠLLGHSULHWHQLHGLUHFWăúLLQGLUHFWăSULQLQWHU 3HSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH'*)&$VHDIOăQXPăUXOQDOSHUHFKLORUGHQX
PHGLXODOWRULQGLYL]L'kQGXVHSHQWUXILHFDUHLQGLYLGSULHWHQLLOXLGLUHFĠLDILúDĠLSHQ PHUHQDWXUDOHFDUHLGHQWLILFăGRXăSHUVRDQHFDUHDXIRVWFROHJLGHDQ3HXUPăWRDUHOHQ
WUXXQDQXPLWLQGLYLGWRĠLSULHWHQLLOXLLQGLUHFĠL OLQLL VH DIOă SHUHFKL GH QXPHUH QDWXUDOH GHVSăUĠLWH SULQWUXQ VSDĠLX UHSUH]HQWkQG GRL
FROHJLGHDQ
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
'HSHSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH $%83&$VHFLWHúWHQXPăUXOGHLQGLYL]L 'DWHGHLHúLUH
Q'HSHXUPăWRDUHOHQOLQLLVHFLWHVFSULHWHQLLGLUHFĠLDLILHFăUXLLQGLYLGLQGLYL]LLGLQ )LúLHUXO GH LHúLUH '*)&'(! YD FRQĠLQH DWkWHD OLQLL FkWH JUXSXUL VDX IRUPDW GLQ
JUXS VXQW VLPEROL]DĠLSULQQXPHUHGHODODQÌQFDGUXOILHFăUHLOLQLLDFHVWHQXPHUH QXPHUHOHGHRUGLQHDOHSHUVRDQHORUGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH3HILHFDUHGLQXUPăWRDUHOH
VXQWVHSDUDWHSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLX3HXOWLPDOLQLHHVWHWUHFXWQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOLQGL OLQLLVHYRUVFULHQXPHUHOHGHRUGLQHDSDUĠLQkQGXQXLDVWIHOGHJUXSGHVSăUĠLWHSULQFkWH
YLGXOXLFăUXLDWUHEXLHVăLVHJăVHDVFăSULHWHQLLLQGLUHFĠL XQVSDĠLX
'DWHGHLHúLUH 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
)LúLHUXOGHLHúLUH $%83&'(!YDFRQĠLQHRVLQJXUăOLQLHvQFDUHVHYRUVFULHQXPH x SHUVRDQHOHVXQWLGHQWLILFDWHSULQQXPHUHGHRUGLQHvQWUHúL
UHOHGHRUGLQHDOHSULHWHQLORULQGLUHFĠLDLLQGLYLGXOXLGDW$FHVWHQXPHUHVHYRUVHSDUD x dQd
SULQWUXQVSDĠLX x GLQWUXQJUXSQXIDFSDUWHPDLPXOWGHGHSDUVRDQH
'DFăXQLQGLYLGQXDUHSULHWHQLLQGLUHFĠLDWXQFLvQILúLHUVHYDVFULHPHVDMXO
([HPSOX
'*)&$ '*)&'(!
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
J JJJ
x UHODĠLDGHSULHWHQLHQXHVWHFRPXWDWLYăDGLFăGDFăLQGLYLGXOLHVWHSULHWHQFXLQGL JJ J|JJ
YLGXOMDWXQFLQXvQVHDPQăFăLQGLYLGXOMHVWHSULHWHQFXLQGLYLGXOL JJ
x GDFăOLQLDLHVWHYLGăvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHDFHVWOXFUXvQVHDPQăFăLQGLYLGXO |JJ
DYkQGQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHLQXDUHSULHWHQLGLUHFĠL J
([HPSOX
$%83&$ $%83&'(! 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVH
J JJJJ
JJ &LIUHFRPXQH
JJ
|J ÌQUH]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHYRPIRORVLWUHLPXOĠLPL
J|J ±PXOĠLPHDFRPXQHYDUHĠLQHFLIUHOHFRPXQHWXWXURUQXPHUHORU
J ±PXOĠLPHDWHPSYDSăVWUDFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLFLWLWODSDVXOFXUHQW
JJ ±PXOĠLPHDQXVXQWYDSăVWUDFLIUHOHFDUHQXDSDUvQQLFLXQXOGLQWUHQXPHUHOHGDWH
([HPSOX
)LHFRQĠLQXWXOILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH
ÌQWkOQLUH J|J
ÌQWUXQOLFHXVHRUJDQL]HD]ăRvQWkOQLUHFXIRúWLLDEVROYHQĠL'LQSăFDWHSHUVRDQDFDUH J
DUHVDUFLQDVăWULPLWăLQYLWDĠLLOHDUHODGLVSR]LĠLHGRDULQIRUPDĠLLGHJHQXOSHUVRDQD[D `J|J
IRVWFROHJGHDQFXSHUVRDQD\SHUVRDQD]DIRVWFROHJGHDQFXSHUVRDQD[HWF 0XOĠLPHDFRPXQHúLPXOĠLPHDQXVXQWVHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăFXPXOĠLPHDFLIUHORUVLVWHPX
6WDELOLĠLOLVWDLQYLWDĠLORUSHED]DLQIRUPDĠLLORUGHWLSXOFHORUGHVFULVHvQDúDIHOvQFkW OXL]HFLPDO
FROHJLLGHDQVăILHJUXSDĠL FRPXQH ^`
0XOĠLPHD
0XOĠLPHD
QXVXQW ^`
ăJ
JzJJJJ ^GDFăH[LVWăHOHPHQWHvQPXOĠLPHD
`
1XPHUHOHVHFLWHVFSHUkQGGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH3UHOXFUDUHDXQXLQXPăUvQVHDPQă ^H[LVWăFLIUHFDUHQXDXDSăUXWvQFRPSRQHQĠDQLFLXQXLQXPăU`
GHVFRPSXQHUHDOXLvQFLIUHúLGHSXQHUHDDFHVWRUDvQPXOĠLPHDWHPS'HFLvQFD]XOQX JJJJ
J\`J
ăQJJ^DFHVWHDVHVFULXSHFHDGHDGRXDOLQLHvQILúLHU`J
PăUXOXLQ PXOĠLPHDWHPSYDIL^` JJJJJJăJJJ
JJ
JJJJJJJJ
JJ
0XOĠLPHD FRPXQH VH WUDQVIRUPă vQ LQWHUVHFĠLD GLQWUH HD vQVăúL úL PXOĠLPHD WHPS
JJJJJJ úJăJ
DGLFăYDFRQĠLQHGXSăDFHDVWăSULPăFLWLUHGRDUFLIUHOHSULPXOXLQXPăUGLQILúLHU JJJJ úJ
J
FRPXQH FRPXQHWHPSGHFLFRPXQH ^` JJ
JJ ^GDFăPXOĠLPHD
HVWHYLGă`J
'LQPXOĠLPHDQXVXQWFDUHFRQĠLQHDLQLĠLDOWRDWHFLIUHOHVHVFDGFLIUHOHJăVLWHvQSUL JJJJ
JJJ%
J^VHVFULHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHPHVDMXOFHUXW`
PXOQXPăU JJ úăKJ
QXVXQW QXVXQW±WHPSGHFLQXVXQW ^` úJ J
3URFHGHXOFRQWLQXăFXFLWLUHDXUPăWRDUHORUQXPHUH,OXVWUăPvQWDEHOXOGHPDLMRV
FRQĠLQXWXOFHORUWUHLPXOĠLPLSHQWUXILHFDUHQXPăUFLWLWvQFD]XOH[HPSOXOXL ÌQSURJUDPXO3DVFDOPXOĠLPLOHIRORVLWHDXFDWLSGHED]ăVXEGRPHQLXO`GHRDUH
FHYRUFRQĠLQHFLIUH1XPHUHOHSHFDUHOHFLWLPGLQILúLHUVXQWGHWLS
úLOHYRP
Q Q Q Q Q 5H]XOWDWH UHĠLQHILHFDUHQXPăUFLWLWvQYDULDELOD
'HDVHPHQHDDPLQWLPFăvQ3DVFDORPXOĠLPH$
FRPXQH ^` ^` ^` ^` ^` VHFUHHD]ăFXDMXWRUXOFRQVWUXFWRUXOXL$ >DDDN@XQGHDLL NUHSUH
QXVXQW ^` ^` ^` ^` ^` ]LQWăHOHPHQWHOHPXOĠLPLL
WHPS ^` ^` ^` ^` ^`
$JHQGD
J
QJ
9RPvQFHSHGLVFXĠLDSULYLQGUH]ROYDUHDSUREOHPHLFXXQH[HPSOX
JJ
XUPHD]ăPDUFDGHVIkUúLWGHILúLHU
ăQJ
ÌQWDEORXOQUDYHPFHOHQQXPHUHGHWHOHIRQFLWLWHGLQILúLHU
JJJJ
ú
J
J
QU
JJJJJmJJ
&UHăPXQWDEORXGHPXOĠLPLFLIvQFDUHFLILYDFRQĠLQHFLIUHOHGLVWLQFWHGLQQXPăUXO
JJJJ
J
J
J`J
ăQJ
GHWHOHIRQQUL
JJJJJJJmJJJ
`J
FLI ^`^`^`^`^`
JJJJJJ
JmJ
`J ^`^`^`
JJJJ úJ
J
ÌQWDEORXOFkWHSăVWUăPQXPăUXOGHFRPSRQHQWHFDUGLQDOLWDWHDILHFăUHLPXOĠLPLFLIL
JJJJ%
JmJ%
JJJ ÌQH[HPSOXOFRQVLGHUDWFkWH
JJJJ
JmJ
J®JJ ÌQIXQFĠLHGHFRQĠLQXWXOWDEORXOXLFkWHYRPDOHJHvQWLPSXODILúăULLQXPăUXOGHWHOH
JJ úJ
J IRQQULDYkQGODSDVXOUHVSHFWLYQXPăUPLQLPGHFLIUH$FHDVWăFHULQĠăRUHDOL]ăPJH
^GXSăFHVDXFLWLWWRDWHQXPHUHOHGLQILúLHUVHYHULILFă` QHUkQGFDUGLQDOLWăĠLOHSRVLELOHDOHPXOĠLPLORU$FHVWHDVXQWQXPHUHFXSULQVHvQPXOĠL
^FRQĠLQXWXOPXOĠLPLORU%
úL
J` PHD^`SUHVXSXQkQGFăvQWUXQQXPăUGHWHOHIRQSXWHPDYHDWRDWHFLIUHOH
^GDFăPXOĠLPHD%
QXHVWHYLGăH[LVWăFLIUHFRPXQH`J HJDOHFD]XOVDXWRDWHFLIUHOHGLVWLQFWHGHIDSWFRQIRUPHQXQĠXOXL
JJăJ%
JzJJJJ ÌQDLQWHGHDGHVFULHSDúLLDOJRULWPXOXLGHUH]ROYDUHYRPREVHUYDFăXQQXPăUGH
JJJJ
J\`J
ăQ ^VHVFULXHOHPHQWHOHPXOĠLPLLvQILúLHU`J WHOHIRQ SRDWH Vă vQFHDSă úL FX FLIUD $FHDVWă REVHUYDĠLH HVWH LPSRUWDQWă GHRDUHFH
JJJJJJăJJJ%
JJ GDFăQXPHUHOHGHWHOHIRQOHDPFLWLFDSHQLúWHQXPHUHDFHDFLIUăGHODvQFHSXWVDU
JJJJJJJJ
JJ SLHUGH ÌQFRQFOX]LHDOHJHPFDPRGDOLWDWHGHUHSUH]HQWDUHSHQWUXQXPHUHOH
JJJJJJ úJăJ GHWHOHIRQúLUXOGHFDUDFWHUHVWULQJXO
JJJJ úJ
J ÌQ SURJUDP YRP OXFUD FX WLSXO UHSUH]HQWkQG úLUXUL GH FDUDFWHUH DYkQG FHO
JJ
JJ ^DOWIHOVHVFULHPHVDMXOFHUXWvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH`J PXOW FDUDFWHUH FRUHVSXQ]ăWRU UHVWULFĠLHL GLQ HQXQĠ 1XPHUHOH GH WHOHIRQ OH YRP
JJJJ
JJJ%
J%
SăVWUDvQWUXQWDEORXDYkQGHOHPHQWHGHWLS GHRDUHFHYRPDYHDQHYRLHGHvQWUHJ
JJ úJăJ
0XOĠLPHD 0XOĠLPHD
WDEORXO vQ PRPHQWXO vQ FDUH YRP GRUL Vă RUGRQăP QXPHUHOH GH WHOHIRQ vQ IXQFĠLH GH ÌQVFRSXODILúăULLQXPHUHORUGHWHOHIRQvQRUGLQHFUHVFăWRDUHGXSăQXPăUXOFLIUHORU
QXPăUXOFLIUHORUGLVWLQFWHvQFRPSRQHQĠDORU GLVWLQFWHGLQFRPSRQHQĠDORUYRPFăXWDSHUkQGQXPHUHGHWHOHIRQDYkQG
3HQWUXDREĠLQHFLIUHOHGLVWLQFWHGLQWUXQQXPăUGHWHOHIRQGLQFLIUHOHILHFăUXLQX FLIUHGLVWLQFWH
PăUvQSDUWHYRPFUHDFkWHRPXOĠLPH$VWIHOYRPJHQHUDXQWDEORXGHPXOĠLPL
J J
ú
%QJ
J
Ġ%
QJ
JJJmJ`J
^GHVFRPSXQHPILHFDUHQXPăUGHWHOHIRQ
vQPXOĠLPHDGHFLIUH%
` JJ
J\J
ăQJ
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJJJ ăJmJIDOVJ
JJJJ%
JmJJ
JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJJJJJJJJJJJJ^VWXGLHPILHFDUHQXPăUGHWHOHIRQ`
JJ úJ
JJJ
JJJJJJăJ\%J
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
^GDFăDPJăVLWXQQXPăUGHWHOHIRQDYkQGLFLIUHGLVWLQFWH`J
JJJJ
\OXQJLPHDOXL
ăQ ^GHODSULPDFLIUăSkQăODXOWLPD`JJ
JJJJJJJJ ăJmJDGHYăUDW
^DOMOHDFDUDFWHUGLQDOLOHDQXPăUGHWHOHIRQ`J
JJJJJJJJ
J
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ^vOVFULHPvQILúLHU`
JJJJJJ%
JmJ%
JJ¥
¦JJ JJJJJJ úJăJ
JJJJ úJ
J JJJJ úJ
J
JJ úJ
J
úJ J ^GDFăDPJăVLWFHOSXĠLQXQQXPăUGHWHOHIRQDYkQGFXPDLPXOWH`
J J J ^FLIUHGHFkWFHOHSURSXVHVSUHvQYăĠDUHSHQWUX]LXDSUHFHGHQWă`
6WDELOLPFDUGLQDOLWDWHDPXOĠLPLORUGHFLIUHGLQILHFDUHPXOĠLPH%
vQ%J ^FUHúWHPQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDO]LOHLúLvOVFULHPvQILúLHU`J
J JJJJăJ ăJJ
J
%QJ JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ JJJJJJ
JJJ
JJJJJmJ`J JJJJ úJăJ
JJJJ
J\`J
ăQJ JJ úJ
J
JJJJJJăJJJ%
JJ úJ J
JJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
JJJJJJ úJăJ
JJJJ úJ
J
,QGLYL]L
9RPvQFHSHDQDOL]DSUREOHPHLFXXQH[HPSOXÌQDFHVWH[HPSOXQHSURSXQHPDILúDUHD
JJJJ%JmJJ
JJ úJ
J SULHWHQLORULQGLUHFĠLSHQWUXLQGLYLGXODYkQGQXPăUXOGHRUGLQH
úJ J
LQGLYL]LL
2UGRQăPQXPHUHOHGHWHOHIRQúLPXOĠLPLOHGHFLIUHFUHVFăWRUGXSăFDUGLQDOLWDWH SULHWHQLGLUHFĠL ^` ^` ^` ^` ^` ^`
J SULHWHQLLQGLUHFĠL ^` ^` ^` ^` ^` ^`
J
%
%
QJ ^` ^` ^` ^` ^` ^`
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
^` ^` ^` ^` ^` ^`
JJJJ
J\~
J
ăQJ
JJJJJJăJ%J
J%JJ ^` ^` ^` ^` ^` ^`
JJJJJJJJJmJ
KJ
JmJ
KJ
JmJKJ ^` ^` ^` ^` ^` ^`
JJJJJJJJJmJ%
KJ%
JmJ%
KJ%
JmJKJ VHVFDGSULHWHQLLGLUHFĠL ^` ^` ^` ^` ^` ^`
JJJJJJJJJmJ%KJ%JmJ%KJ%JmJJ VHVFDGHSHUVRDQDS ^` ^` ^` ^` ^` ^`
JJJJJJ úJăJ
JJJJ úJ
J 3HUVRDQDvODUHFDSULHWHQGLUHFWSHDOOHD$GăXJăPODPXOĠLPHDSULHWHQLORUGL
JJ úJ
J UHFĠLFDUHGHDFXPvQFRORvLYDFRQĠLQHúLSHFHLLQGLUHFĠLPXOĠLPHDSULHWHQLORUGLUHFĠL
úJ J DLFHOXLGHDOOHD0XOĠLPHDGHYLQH^`
0XOĠLPHD 0XOĠLPHD
$OOHDvODUHFDSULHWHQGLUHFWSHDOOHD$GăXJăPODPXOĠLPHDFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
JJ
J
OXLPXOĠLPHDFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHFHOXLGHDOOHD0XOĠLPHDDFXPGHYLQH^` JJJJJJ úJă
ÌQPXOĠLPHDUH]XOWDWăDSDUHLQGLYLGXOGHFLVHYRUDGăXJDúLSULHWHQLLDFHVWXLDOD úJ
OLVWDGHSULHWHQLLQGLUHFĠLDLOXL0XOĠLPHDHVWH^` úJ
ÌQPXOĠLPHDUH]XOWDWăDSDUHLQGLYLGXOGHFLVHYRUDGăXJDúLSULHWHQLLDFHVWXLDOD ^vQILQDOGLQPXOĠLPHDSULHWHQLORUGLUHFĠLúL`
OLVWDGHSULHWHQLLQGLUHFĠLDLOXL0XOĠLPHDHVWH^` ^LQGLUHFĠLH[WUDJHPPXOĠLPHDSULHWHQLORUGLUHFĠLLDPSăVWUDWvQ`J
'LQ DFHDVWă PXOĠLPH VH VFDGH PXOĠLPHD SULHWHQLORU GLUHFĠL DL OXL úL VH REĠLQH JJ
JmJ
JJJJJ
PXOĠLPHD^`DSRLVHVFDGHúLSHUVRDQD JJ
JmJ
JJJ ^vOH[WUDJHPúLSHS`
8QD GLQWUH IDFLOLWăĠLOH OLPEDMXOXL 3DVFDO HVWH IDSWXO Fă QH SXQH OD GLVSR]LĠLH WLSXO ^GDFăPXOĠLPHDSULHWHQLORULQGLUHFĠLQXHVWHYLGă`J
FDUHSRDWHILXWLOL]DWSHOkQJăPXOWHDOWHOHFDWLSGHED]ăvQWUXQWDEORX JJăJ
JzJJJJ J
JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ ^DILúăPPXOĠLPHDSULHWHQLORULQGLUHFĠL`
3UREOHPDGDWăHVWHUH]ROYDELOăSULQXWLOL]DUHDXQXLWDEORXGHPXOĠLPL7DEORXODUHQ JJJJJJăJJJ
JJ
HOHPHQWHILHFăUXLLQGLYLGLL «QvLFRUHVSXQGHRSR]LĠLHvQWDEORX9DORDUHD JJJJJJJJ
JJ
SULHWHQLLHVWHPXOĠLPHDIRUPDWăGLQSULHWHQLLGLUHFĠLDLOXLL JJJJJJ úJăJ
JJJJ úJ
J
,QLĠLDOWDEORXOHVWHIRUPDWGLQQPXOĠLPLYLGH$FHVWHDVHFRPSOHWHD]ăFXQXPHUHOH JJ
J
JJ
GHRUGLQHDLSULHWHQLORUGLUHFĠL úJ
J
QJ
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ ÌQWkOQLUH
JJJJ
JmJJJJ ^vQFăQXDPGHVFRSHULWSULHWHQLLQLFLXQHLSHUVRDQH` 2EVHUYăPFăGDFăDDIRVWFROHJFXEDWXQFLúLEDIRVWFROHJFXDFRPXWDWLYLWDWH'H
JJ úJ
J DVHPHQHDGDFăDDIRVWFROHJFXEúLEDIRVWFROHJFXFDWXQFLDDIRVWFROHJúLFXF
JJ
J\
J
ăQ ^SHQWUXILHFDUHSHUVRDQăL`J DVRFLDWLYLWDWH$PLQWLPúLSURSULHWDWHDFăvQRULFHVLWXDĠLHDHVWHFROHJFXD
JJJJ
J
XUPHD]ăPDUFDMXOGHVIkUúLWGHOLQLH
ăQJ
JJJJJJ
ú
JJJJJJJJJJJJ ^SHUVRDQDLvODUHSULQWUHSULHWHQLLGLUHFĠLSHS` J
QJ
JJJJJJ
JmJ
JJ¥¦J JJ
ú
J
J
JJ
J\
J
ăQJJJ
J J ^DGăXJăPSODPXOĠLPHDSULHWHQLORUGLUHFĠLDLOXLL`
JJJJ úJ
J JJJJ
ú
J ^FLWLPSHUHFKLOHGHQXPHUH`J
JJ úJ
J JJJJ JmJ¥¦ ^IRUPăPFkWHXQJUXSGLQILHFDUHSHUHFKHFLWLWă`
JJ
ú
JJ ^QXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOSHUVRDQHLLQYHVWLJDWH` JJ ú
J
ú J
J J ^vQSăVWUăPPXOĠLPHDSHUVRDQHORUSULHWHQHGLUHFWFXS`
J
JJJmJ
J
,J
JJ
J\
J
ăQJJ ^OXăPSHUkQGSHUVRDQHOH` JJ
J\
J
ăQJ
JJJJăJJJ
JJ^GDFăSHUVRDQDLHVWHSULHWHQGLUHFWFXS` JJJJ
J\~
J
ăQJ
JJJJJJ
JmJ
JJ
J J J J ^GDFăLQWHUVHFĠLDDGRXăJUXSXULQXHVWHYLGă`
J J ^DGăXJăPPXOĠLPHDSULHWHQLORUGLUHFĠLDLDFHVWXLDPXOĠLPLLSULHWHQLORUOXLS` JJJJJJăJ JJ JzJJJJJ
JJJJ úJăJ JJJJJJJJ JmJ JJ ^XQLPJUXSXULOHvQDOGRLOHDJUXS`
JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJJJ ^OXăPvQFăRGDWăSHUVRDQHOHSHUkQG` JJJJJJJJ JmJJ ^úLSHSULPXOJUXSvOIDFHPYLG`J
^GDFăMHVWHSULHWHQGLUHFWVDXLQGLUHFWFXSDGăXJăP` JJJJJJ úăJ
JJJJJJăJJJ
JJ ú
^ODPXOĠLPHDSULHWHQLORUGLUHFĠLúLLQGLUHFĠLDLOXLSVHDGDXJă` ú
ú J
^PXOĠLPHDSULHWHQLORUGLUHFĠLDLDFHVWXLD`
0XOĠLPHD
7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH &DSLWROXO
Jă
QJ 'HFODUDUHDXQXLWLSvQUHJLVWUDUH
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ ^HOLPLQăPJUXSXULOHYLGH` 2SHUDĠLL
JJ
JmJ`J ,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
JJ
J\
J
ăQJ 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
JJJJăJ JzJJJJJ
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ
JJJJJJ
JmJ J
JJJJ úăJ $UWLFROXOvQUHJLVWUDUHDUHSUH]LQWăUHXQLXQHDXQXLQXPăUIL[VDXYDULDELOGHFRPSR
ú
J QHQWHQXPLWHFkPSXULGHUHJXOăDYkQGWLSXULGLIHULWHFDUHFRQVWLWXLHORJLFRXQLWDWH
JJ
JmJ
JJJJJJJ ^OXQJLPHDQRXăIăUăJUXSXULYLGH` GHSUHOXFUDUH7LSXULOHGLIHULWHDOHFkPSXULORUGLQFRPSRQHQĠDVDGDXDUWLFROXOXLFDUDF
ú J WHUXOGHVWUXFWXUăQHRPRJHQă'DFă/LHVWHOXQJLPHDFkPSXOXLLL QDWXQFL
J YDORDUHDDGUHVHLFkPSXOXLLHVWHDL D///L
J
ú
QJ &DUDFWHUXOQHRPRJHQDODUWLFROXOXLSUHFXPúLOLSVDXQHLUHODĠLLOLQLDUHvQWUHQXPăUXO
JJ
J
J GHRUGLQHDOFkPSXOXLúLDGUHVDDFHVWXLDIDFFDUHJăVLUHDXQXLFkPSVăVHUHDOL]H]HFX
DMXWRUXOXQXLLGHQWLILFDWRUDVRFLDWFkPSXOXLUHVSHFWLYODGHILQLUHDDUWLFROXOXL
JJ%JmJIDOVJ
JJ
J\
J
ăQJJJ FkPSFkPS FkPSL FkPSQ
¥
¥
¥
¥
JJJJ
J\`||J
ăQJ D D DL DQ
/ / /L /Q
JJJJJJăJJJ JJJJ
JJJJJJJJ
JJ 7LSXODUWLFROvQUHJLVWUDUHHVWHRVWUXFWXUăVWDWLFăGHGDWHIOH[LELOăGDWRULWăIDSWXOXL
FăVSUHGHRVHELUHGHWLSXOWDEORXFXSULQGHXQQXPăUIL[VDXYDULDELOGHFRPSRQHQWH
JJJJJJJJ%JmJDGHYăUDWJ FDUHSRWILGHWLSXULGLIHULWH&RPSRQHQWHOHQXVHLQGH[HD]ăSULQWURH[SUHVLHFDvQFD
JJJJJJ úă ]XOWDEORXULORUFLVHVHOHFWHD]ăSULQLQWHUPHGLXOLGHQWLILFDWRULORUGHFkPSFDUHVHGHIL
ú
J QHVFODGHFODUDUHDWLSXOXL
JJJJăJ%JJ
JJJJJJWUHFHPODOLQLHQRXă ^GDFăDPDILúDWXQJUXSWUHFHPODOLQLHQRXăvQILúLHU`
úăJ 'HFODUDUHDXQXLWLSDUWLFROvQOLPEDMXO3DVFDO
JJJJ%JmJIDOV )RUPDJHQHUDOăDGHILQLĠLHLXQXLWLSvQUHJLVWUDUHIL[ăHVWH
LGHQWLILFDWRUBWLS
JJ ú
J
QXPHBFkPSQWLSKJ
ú
QXPHBFkPSQWLSK
J
QXPHBFkPSQQWLSQ
7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH
7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH
([HPSOX
J QJJ
J\
J
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJQ%%QKJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJ
Q KJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJQ%QKJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJQKJ JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJQ
%Q KJQJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJăQ``J JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
KJ
JJJJJJJJJJ
KJ JQ
KJ
JQKJ
7LSXOXQXLLGHQWLILFDWRUGHFkPSSRDWHILODUkQGXOOXLWRWDUWLFRO 2SHUDĠLL
([HPSOX
J
\
J $WULEXLUHD
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJQ
J 8QHLYDULDELOHGHWLSvQUHJLVWUDUHLVHDWULEXLHYDORDUHDXQHLDOWHYDULDELOHGHDFHODúLWLS
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJQ KJ vQUHJLVWUDUH)LLQGGDWHGRXăYDULDELOHGHWLSvQUHJLVWUDUHDúLEFDUHDXDFHODúLWLSVH
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
QXYJ SRDWHUHDOL]DRSHUDĠLDGHDWULEXLUHDmJEFHHDFHvQVHDPQăFăYDORULOHFkPSXULORUOXLD
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
KJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJQ J
VHVXEVWLWXLHFXYDORULOHGLQE
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
KJ
JQ
KJ 6HOHFWDUHDXQXLFkPS
/DXQFkPSDOXQHLYDULDELOHGHWLSvQUHJLVWUDUHQHUHIHULPSULQQXPHOHYDULDELOHLXU
8QLGHQWLILFDWRUGHFkPSWUHEXLHVăILHXQLFvQFDGUXOSURSULXOXLWLSvQUHJLVWUDUH
PDWGHSXQFWDSRLQXPHOHFkPSXOXL
'DFăVHGRUHúWHLQFOXGHUHDvQVWUXFWXUDDUWLFROXOXLDXQRULQIRUPDĠLLFDUHGHSLQGGH ([HPSOX
R DOWă LQIRUPDĠLH GHMD SUH]HQWă vQ VWUXFWXUă VH IRUPHD]ă FHD GHD GRXD FDWHJRULH úL
DQXPHGDWHGHWLSvQUHJLVWUDUHFXYDULDQWH
2DVWIHOGHVFULHUHHVWHJUHRDLHúLSHQWUXHYLWDUHDVSHFLILFăULLLGHQWLILFDWRUXOXLGHWLS
'HFODUDUHDXQXLWLSvQUHJLVWUDUHFXYDULDQWHvQOLPEDMXO3DVFDO vQUHJLVWUDUHvQIDĠDILHFăUXLFkPSFDUHLQWHUYLQHvQSUHOXFUDUHvQ3DVFDOVHSRDWHIRORVL
LGHQWLILFDWRUBWLS
LQVWUXFĠLXQHDFDUHVLPSOLILFăPRGXOGHVFULHUHDVHOHFWăULLFRPSRQHQWHORU
QXPHBFkPSQWLSKJ
QXPHBFkPSQWLSK ([HPSOX
J JJJ
QXPHBFkPSQQWLSQ JJ2JJKJ
FkPSBVHOHFWRUWLSBVHOHFWRU
FRQVWFkPSYBWLSYBFkPSYBWLSB ÌQFD]XOvQUHJLVWUăULORUFXYDULDQWHSHQWUXGHFODUDĠLLOHGLQH[HPSOXOSUH]HQWDWVHSRW
FRQVWFkPSYBWLSYBFkPSYBWLSB
IDFHXUPăWRDUHOHDWULEXLULGHGDWHSHQWUXFkPSXULOHYDULDELOHLD
Q\22KJJ
&&&
Q\KJJ
%Q\2
%ă2KJJ
([HPSOX Q\```KJ
J\KJJ ^WLSHQXPHUDUH`J VDX
JJJJJ
\
J Q\KJ%%Q\`J
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
Q KJ
/DXQPRPHQWGDWHVWHDFWLYăRVLQJXUăYDULDQWă
7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH 7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH x QXPăUXOGHvQUHJLVWUăULHVWHFHOPXOW
3HQWUXDYăIDPLOLDUL]DFXSUHOXFUDUHDGDWHORUGHWLSvQUHJLVWUDUHVHUHFRPDQGăHIHFWXD
x QXPHOHHVWHIRUPDWGLQFHOPXOWGHOLWHUHSULQWUHFDUHQXH[LVWăQLFLXQVSDĠLX
UHDXUPăWRDUHORUH[HUFLĠLL
FUHDUHDXQXLFDWDORJSHQWUXRFODVă x ILHFDUHQXPăUGHWHOHIRQvQFHSHFXFLIUD
DILúDUHDvQRUGLQHGHVFUHVFăWRDUHGXSăPHGLHDHOHYLORUDGPLúLúLDOIDEHWLFăDHOHYL x ODILHFDUHDFWXDOL]DUHVHYDVXEVWLWXLILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHFXFHOGHLHúLUH
ORUUHVSLQúLODXQH[DPHQ x SURJUDPXOYDFRQĠLQHXQPHQLXGLQFDUHXWLOL]DWRUXOYDSXWHDVHOHFWDRSHUDĠLDSHFD
DILúDUHDWXWXURUHOHYLORUFDUHDXGRPLFLOLXOvQWUXQDQXPLWRUDú UHGRUHúWHVRHIHFWXH]H
RUGRQDUHDHOHYLORUvQIXQFĠLHGHvQăOĠLPHúLSHQWUXvQăOĠLPLHJDOHvQRUGLQHDJUHXWă x SHUVRDQHOHVXQWLQWURGXVHvQDJHQGăvQRUGLQHDOIDEHWLFăRSHUDĠLLOHGHLQWURGXFHUHD
ĠLL XQHLSHUVRDQHQRLúLúWHUJHUHDXQHLSHUVRDQHQXWUHEXLHVăPRGLILFHRUGRQDUHD
FUHDUHDXQXLILúLHUFDUHVăFRQĠLQăDUWLFROHSULYLQGFăUĠLOHGLQWURELEOLRWHFă x FăXWDUHD XQHL SHUVRDQHWUHEXLHVăVHSRDWăUHDOL]DODFHUHUHGXSăQXPHVDXGXSă
FUHDUHD XQXL ILúLHU FDUH Vă FRQĠLQă DUWLFROH SULYLQG FăUĠLOH GLQWURELEOLRWHFăDVWIHO QXPăUGHWHOHIRQ
vQFkW vQ FD]XO PDQXDOHORU Vă VH VSHFLILFH GLVFLSOLQD FODVD SHQWUX FDUH HVWH YDODELO x GDFăQXPHOHXQHLSHUVRDQHVHJăVHúWHvQDJHQGăvQWLPSXORSHUDĠLHLGHLQWURGXFHUH
PDQXDOXO DXWRULL HWF LDU SHQWUX FăUĠLOH FDUH QX VXQW PDQXDOH QXPăUXO DXWRULORU VH YD RIHUL SRVLELOLWDWHD PRGLILFăULL QXPăUXOXL GH WHOHIRQ vQ FD] Fă QX VH GRUHúWH
DXWRULLWLWOXOHGLWXUDHWFVHYDOXFUDFXvQUHJLVWUăULFXYDULDQWH PRGLILFDUHDVHYDLQWURGXFHQXPăUXODOWIHOQRXOQXPăU
FUHDUHDXQXLILúLHUFXDUWLFROHSULYLQGUH]XOWDWHOHSDUWLFLSDQĠLORUODROLPSLDGDLQWHU
QDĠLRQDOăGHLQIRUPDWLFă ([HPSOXPHQLX
JJ%
J
J
JJ
%J
J
J
J
3UREOHPHSURSXVH JJ J
J
J
JJ%JJ
J
|JJ%JJ
J
$JHQGă JJJ
8QHOHYDFUHDWRDJHQGăGHWHOHIRQvQFDUHDLQWURGXVQXPHOHúLQXPăUXOGHWHOHIRQDOH
JJQ
FXQRúWLQĠHORU VDOH 'H DVHPHQHD HOHYXO GRUHúWH Vă SRDWă HIHFWXD DVXSUD DJHQGHL VDOH
FkWHYDRSHUDĠLLGHIRUPD ([SR]LĠLH
x FRQVXOWDUHDDJHQGHLFXDILúDUHDvQWUHJXOXLFRQĠLQXW 2UJDQL]DWRULLXQHLH[SR]LĠLLGHSLFWXUăGRUHVFVăDLEăRHYLGHQĠăDILHFăUXLWDEORXúLD
x LQWURGXFHUHDXQHLQRLSHUVRDQHvQDJHQGă DUWLúWLORUFDUHDXFUHDWDFHVWHWDEORXUL2UJDQL]DWRULLDXDGXQDWGDWHOHGHVSUHWDEORXULúL
x úWHUJHUHDXQHLSHUVRDQH OHDXVFULVvQWUXQILúLHU3HQWUXILHFDUHWDEORXVHFXQRDúWHQXPHOHDUWLVWXOXLWLWOXOWD
x FăXWDUHGXSăQXPH EORXOXLDQXOvQFDUHDIRVWUHDOL]DWSUHĠXOGHYkQ]DUHSUHFXPúLSUHPLLOHREĠLQXWHOD
x FăXWDUHSHED]DFXQRDúWHULLQXPăUXOXLGHWHOHIRQ H[SR]LĠLLORFDOHQDĠLRQDOHúLLQWHUQDĠLRQDOH
6FULHĠLXQSURJUDPFDUHVăUHDOL]H]HRSHUDĠLLOHFHUXWHGHHOHY ([SR]LĠLLOH VH FRGLILFă SULQ FDUDFWHUHOH / ORFDOH 1 QDĠLRQDOH úL ( HXURSHQH
5HIHULWRUODILHFDUHSUHPLXH[LVWăLQIRUPDĠLLGXSăFXPXUPHD]ă
'DWHGHLQWUDUH x DQXOúLSUHPLXOvQFD]XOH[SR]LĠLLORUORFDOH
)LúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH#)$%#&$FRQĠLQHSHILHFDUHOLQLHGDWHOHXQHLFXQRúWLQĠHvQIRUPD x DQXOSUHPLXOúLORFDOLWDWHDvQFD]XOH[SR]LĠLLORUQDĠLRQDOH
QXPHQXPăUGHWHOHIRQ x DQXOSUHPLXORUDúXOúLĠDUDvQFD]XOH[SR]LĠLLORULQWHUQDĠLRQDOH
$FWXDOL]DUHDDJHQGHLVHYDIDFHSHED]DXQRUGDWHLQWURGXVHGHODWDVWDWXUă $YkQG OD GLVSR]LĠLH DFHVWH GDWH RUJDQL]DWRULL vúL SURSXQ Vă UHDOL]H]H XQ SURJUDP
FDUHVăFUHH]HXUPăWRDUHOHOLVWH
'DWHGHLHúLUH OLVWDOXFUăULORUSUHPLDWHSHFDWHJRULLvQRUGLQHDORFDOHQDĠLRQDOHúLHXURSHQH
1XYRPDYHDXQILúLHUGHLHúLUHFRPSOHWQRX)LúLHUXO#)$%#&'(!YDDYHDFRQĠLQXWXO OLVWDWDEORXULORUvQRUGLQHFUHVFăWRDUHDSUHĠXULORUGHYkQ]DUH
ILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUHúLvQUHJLVWUăULOHQRLFRQIRUPDFWXDOL]ăULORUHIHFWXDWHJ OLVWDDUWLúWLORUFDUHDXREĠLQXWSUHPLXOODFHOSXĠLQXQFRQFXUVLQGLIHUHQWGHWL
SXODFHVWXLD
7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH 7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH
'DWHGHLQWUDUH ([HPSOX
9'&$
)LúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH 9'&$FRQĠLQHDWkWHDOLQLLFkWHWDEORXULVDXH[SXV3HILHFDUHOL
J
JJ``````JJJJ
QLHHVWHGHVFULVFkWHXQWDEORX5HIHULWRUODXQWDEORXSHROLQLHvQILúLHUDYHPXUPă JJ``J|``````J"J``JJ£
JJ
WRDUHOHGDWHGHVSăUĠLWHSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLX J%JJ|`````JJ```JJXJ
x QXPHBDUWLVW %JJ```J|`````JJ```J
x WLWOXBWDEORX
* !#.&'(!
x DQ %QJJ
JJJ
x SUHĠ %QJ%JJ```JJ
x QUBSUHPLL
QJJ%J```JJXJ
x WLSBH[SR]LĠLH "
QJJJ``JJ£
JJ
J
x DQ * !#/&'(!
x SUHPLX J%J|`````J
J
J``````J
'DFă XQ WDEORX D IRVW SUHPLDW GH PDL PXOWH RUL FHOHODOWH SUHPLL VXQW GHVFULVH vQ %JJ|`````J
FRQWLQXDUHSHDFHHDúLOLQLH JJ|``````J
J
* !#0&'(!
'DWHGHLHúLUH J
JJ
6HYRUFUHDWUHLILúLHUHGHLHúLUH* !#.&'(!* !#/&'(!úL* !#0&'(!ÌQWRDWH %JJJ
FHOHWUHLILúLHUHROLQLHFRQĠLQHGDWHUHIHULWRDUHODXQVLQJXUWDEORXÌQILúLHUHVSHFLILFD
WRUXOWLSBH[SR]LĠLHYDILQRWDWFX/RFDOă1DĠLRQDOăVDX"(XURSHDQă
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUUH]ROYDWH
)LúLHUXOGHLHúLUH * !#.&'(!FRQĠLQHOLVWDOXFUăULORUSUHPLDWH6WUXFWXUDXQHLOLQLL
HVWHXUPăWRDUHD $JHQGD
WLSBH[SR]LĠLHJQJQXPHBDUWLVWJWLWOXBWDEORXJWLSBH[SR]LĠLHJFDUDFWHULVWLFLJ 'DWHOHUHIHULWRDUHODSHUVRDQHVHSăVWUHD]ăvQWURVWUXFWXUăGHWLSvQUHJLVWUDUHGHIRUPD
XQGH FDUDFWHULVWLFL vQVHDPQă GDWHOH VSHFLILFH ILHFăUXL WLS GH H[SR]LĠLH GHVFULVH vQ
%
\
HQXQĠ$FHVWHDYRUILVHSDUDWHSULQWUXQVSDĠLX JJJJJJJJJJJ
Q J
KJ
)LúLHUXO * !#/&'(!FRQĠLQHWDEORXULOHvQRUGLQHFUHVFăWRDUHDSUHĠXULORU)LHFDUH /DRUXODUHDSURJUDPXOXLGDWHOHVHSUHLDXGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH #)$%#&$úLVH
OLQLHDUHIRUPD GHSXQ vQ WDEORXO D GH WLSXO `` %
7RDWH SUHOXFUăULOH FHUXWH vQ
QXPHBDUWLVWJWLWOXBWDEORXJSUHĠ HQXQĠVHYRUUHDOL]DDVXSUDWDEORXOXLD/DILQDOXOH[HFXĠLHLSURJUDPXOXLVHIRUPHD]ă
J XQILúLHUWHPSRUDU#)$%#&'(!FDUHFRQĠLQHWDEORXOGXSăDFWXDOL]ăUL)LúLHUXOGHLQ
)LúLHUXO* !#0&'(! YDFRQĠLQHGDWHGHVSUHDUWLúWLúLDUHIRUPD WUDUH #)$%#&$VHúWHUJHLDUILúLHUXO #)$%#&'(!VHUHGHQXPHúWHvQ #)$%#&$
QXPHBDUWLVWJWLWOXBWDEORXWLSBH[SR]LĠLHJJ DVWIHOvQFkWODXUPăWRDUHDUXODUHDSURJUDPXOXLGDWHOHGHLQWUDUHVăVHJăVHDVFăFXFRQ
ÌQILúLHUDUWLúWLLYRUILRUGRQDĠLDOIDEHWLF ĠLQXWXODFWXDOL]DW
JJ 1XPăUXOvQUHJLVWUăULORUGLQWDEORXODHVWHQ
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL &LWLUHDGDWHORUGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHúLPHPRUDUHDORUvQWDEORXODVHIDFHvQPRGXO
x QXPăUXOGHWDEORXULHVWHFHOPXOW XUPăWRU
x GDWHOHGHWLS DXFHOPXOWGHFDUDFWHUH x FLWLPROLQLHGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHvQWUXQúLUGHFDUDFWHUHV
x GHRDUHFHILHFDUHQXPăUGHWHOHIRQvQFHSHFXFDUDFWHUXO`FăXWăPSR]LĠLDDFHVWXLD
vQúLUXOGHFDUDFWHUH
7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH 7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH
FLWHúWHúLQXPăUXOGHWHOHIRQSHQWUXDLQWURGXFHSHUVRDQDvQDJHQGă'HRDUHFHDJHQGD
x FRSLHPFDUDFWHUHOHGHODvQFHSXWXOúLUXOXLGHFDUDFWHUHIăUăVSDĠLXOGHVSăUĠLWRUGLQ
FRQĠLQH QXPHOH SHUVRDQHORU RUGRQDWH DOIDEHWLF VXEDOJRULWPXO
J
WUHQXPHúLQXPăUXOGHWHOHIRQvQFkPSXO
DOHOHPHQWXOXLFXUHQWGLQúLUXOD
?HVWHDVWIHOUHDOL]DWvQFkWYDUHWXUQDúLYDORDUHDYDULDELOHLLFDUHvQFD]GHFă
x úWHUJHPDFHVWHFDUDFWHUHLQFOXVLYVSDĠLXOGLQúLUXOGHFDUDFWHUH
XWDUHFXVXFFHVUHSUH]LQWăLQGLFHOHHOHPHQWXOXLGLQúLUXODFDUHFRQĠLQHGDWHOHFăXWDWH
x FHHDFHDUăPDVvQúLUXOGHFDUDFWHUHHVWHQXPăUXOGHWHOHIRQ
J LDUvQFD]FRQWUDUUHSUH]LQWăLQGLFHOHHOHPHQWXOXLXQGHDUWUHEXLVăVHDIOHSHUVRDQDFX
3ULPDDFĠLXQHSRVLELOăGHVROLFLWDWGHHOHYHVWHDILúDUHDGDWHORUGLQILúLHUPHPRUDWH QXPăUXOGHWHOHIRQFăXWDWÌQFRQFOX]LHDFHDVWăSHUVRDQăQRXăWUHEXLHVăDMXQJăSHSR
GHMDvQWDEORXOD ]LĠLDL3HQWUXDSXWHDUHDOL]DDFHVWVFRSvQSUHDODELOPăULPGLPHQVLXQHDúLUXOXLDSRL
WUDQVODWăP HOHPHQWHOH DYkQG LQGLFHOH HJDO VDX PDL PDUH FXL FX R SR]LĠLH OD GUHDSWD
,QWURGXFHUHDXQHLSHUVRDQHQRLvQDJHQGăVHUHDOL]HD]ăDVWIHO $SRLVFULHPGDWHOHvQHOHPHQWXOGHLQGLFHL
x FLWLPQXPHOHúLQXPăUXOGHWHOHIRQSHFDUHGRULPVăOHvQUHJLVWUăPvQDJHQGă
?
QJ
x DSHOăPVXEDOJRULWPXOGHFăXWDUH
?FDUHYDUHWXUQDvQ JJ
?J
YDULDELODRNRYDORDUHGHDGHYăU ăJ?JJ ^SHUVRDQD
QXH[LVWăvQDJHQGă`
x GDFăYDORDUHDOXLRNHVWHDGHYăUDWvQVHDPQăFăDPJăVLWQXPHOHSHUVRDQHLDGLFă JJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ ^PăULPGLPHQVLXQHDúLUXOXL`J
DFHDVWD H[LVWă GHMD vQ DJHQGă GXSă UHYHQLUHD GLQ DSHOXO VXESURJUDPXOXL
J JJJJ
J\
~J
ăQJ ^HOLEHUăPSR]LĠLDLWUDQVODWkQGUHVWXO`
DILúăPXQPHVDMFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUúLRIHULPSRVLELOLWDWHDPRGLILFăULLQXPăUXOXLGHWH JJJJJJJmJJ ^HOHPHQWHORUFXRSR]LĠLHODGUHDSWD`
OHIRQDFHVWOXFUXHVWHSRVLELOGHRDUHFHvQYDULDELODLDYHPLQGLFHOHHOHPHQWXOXLGLQ ú
úLUXODFDUHFRQĠLQHGDWHOHSHUVRDQHLUHVSHFWLYH JJJJ
JJJ
QJJ
JJJJ
ú
JJ
'DFă VD LQWURGXV RSĠLXQHD FRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH LQWURGXFHULL XQHL QRL vQUHJLVWUăUL vQ JJJJ
JmJ
J ^GDWHOHUHVSHFWLYHVHFRSLD]ăSHSR]LĠLDL`
VXESURJUDPXO
Ġ
VH YD VHOHFWD VHFYHQĠD GH SURJUDP vQ FDUH VH JJJJJmJJ
DSHOHD]ăVXESURJUDPXO
?
úă
ú
&&& J
Q2 &ăXWDUHDVHUHDOL]HD]ăFXVXEDOJRULWPXOFXQRVFXWYH]LFDSLWROXO
ú
J
?
J
?QJ
ă? ^FăXWDP
vQDJHQGăGDFă?\ODPJăVLWSHSR]LĠLDL`
J
JJJ
J
^GDFă?\
QXODPJăVLWDUILWUHEXLWVăILHSHSR]LĠLDL`
%JJJ%&J
JJ
JJ
JJJmJJ
J J
%
%J
J
%J`
JdJ
JúJ
JJ
J
ăQJ
QJ JJJJJmJJ~JJ
ú
JJăJ
\
JJ
ăJzJ` ^QXPHUHOHGHWHOHIRQVXQWVWULQJXUL` JJJJ?JmJDGHYăUDWJ
JJJJJJJmJJ
úăJ JJJJ?JmJIDOV
úă ú
&&&
ùWHUJHUHDXQXLHOHPHQWGLQDJHQGăVHHIHFWXHD]ăGDFăRSĠLXQHDGHDFWXDOL]DUHVSH
6XEDOJRULWPXO
?
vQFHSH FX DSHODUHD DOWXL VXESURJUDP FLILFă FRGXO SHQWUX FDUH VH H[HFXWă XUPăWRDUHD VHFYHQĠă GLQ VXESURJUDPXO
FDUHYDFăXWDQXPHOHSHUVRDQHLLQWURGXVH'DFăDFHVWQXPHVHJăVHúWHGHMDvQDJHQGă $SHODUHD VXESURJUDPXOXL ù
?
VHILQDOL]HD]ăILHFX úWHUJHUHDHOH
VHUHYLQHGLQVXEDOJRULWPFXYDORDUHDYDULDELOHLRNHJDOăFXDGHYăUDWÌQFD]FRQWUDUVH PHQWXOXLFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUGLQúLUILHFXXQPHVDMSHED]DYDORULLSDUDPHWUXOXLRNJ
7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH
J
JJ
JQJJ
JJ
ú
J
J
JJù
?
J
ăJ?JJ
JJJJ
J
J
J
JJ
J
J
JJ úă
&&&
6XEDOJRULWPXO ù
?
DSHOHD]ă OD UkQGXO VăX VXEDOJRULWPXO
? vQ PRG VLPLODU FX VXEDOJRULWPXO
?J
ù
?
Q
JJ
?J 7LSXOvQUHJLVWUDUH
JJăJ?J ^SHUVRDQD
H[LVWăvQDJHQGă`J
JJJJ
J\
J
ăQJ ^HOLPLQăPHOHPHQWXOGHSHSR]LĠLDL`J &UHDUHDSULPHLOLVWHFHUXWHvQSUREOHPăVHUHDOL]HD]ăGXSăYDORULOHFkPSXOXLVHOHF
JJJJJJJmJ~ ^WUDQVODWkQGUHVWXOHOHPHQWHORUFXRSR]LĠLHODVWkQJD`J WRUH[SR6HSDUFXUJHWDEORXODúLVHDOHJGRDUDFHOHHOHPHQWHFDUHDXFkPSXOVHOHFWRU
ú
HJDOFX/6HSURFHGHD]ăDQDORJSHQWUXFHOHODOWHGRXăWLSXULLGHQWLILFDWHFX1úL(
JJJJ
JmJ
JJJ ^PLFúRUăPGLPHQVLXQHDúLUXOXL`J &UHDUHD FHOXL GHDO GRLOHD ILúLHU GH LHúLUH SUHVXSXQH RUGRQDUHD FUHVFăWRDUH D vQUH
úă JLVWUăULORU GLQ WDEORX GXSă FkPSXO SUHĠ 6HSRDWHIRORVLRULFDUHDOJRULWPGHRUGRQDUH
ú FXQRVFXW
&ăXWDUHDQXPăUXOXLGHWHOHIRQHVWHLGHQWLFăFXFHDDQXPHOXLGLIHUăGRDUFkPSXO 3HQWUXSăVWUDUHDRUGLQLLDOIDEHWLFHvQFD]XOFHOHLGHDWUHLDFHULQĠHDSUREOHPHLVHUH
DQDOL]DWGLQHOHPHQWHOHúLUXOXL DOL]HD]ăRRUGRQDUHFUHVFăWRDUHDvQUHJLVWUăULORUGXSăFkPSXOQXPHDSRLVHFRPSOHWHD
]ăFHOGHDOWUHLOHDILúLHUGHLHúLUHFXDUWLúWLLFDUHDXREĠLQXWSUHPLXOVSHFLILFkQGúLWL
([SR]LĠLH SXOH[SR]LĠLHL
6HFUHHD]ăVWUXFWXUD
J`\ `KJ
JJJJJ\
J
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
Q`KJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
Q
KJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJQ`KJ
JQ"JJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJQ
Q
KJQ&KJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJQ
Q
KJ
Q&KJ%Q`KJ
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ"Q
Q
KJQ&KJ%Q`J
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
KJ
JJJJJ\`J
JKJ
'DWHOHOHYRPSUHOXDGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUHúLYRPFRPSOHWDILHFDUHvQUHJLVWUDUHvQ
IXQFĠLHGHYDULDQWHOHVDOHùLUXOGDWHORUDDUHPHOHPHQWH
2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL
5HSUH]HQWDUHDQXPHUHORUvQPHPRULH
$YkQG vQ YHGHUH Fă PHPRULD SRDWH UHĠLQH GRDU FLIUH ELQDUH úL QXPHUHOH YRU IL
SăVWUDWHSHRULFHVXSRUWPDJQHWLFvQVLVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLHFXED]D
5HSUH]HQWDUHDQXPHUHORUQDWXUDOH
2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL &DSLWROXO 3HQWUXDUHSUH]HQWDXQQXPăUWUHEXLHVăFXQRDúWHPWLSXODFHVWXLDILHFăUXLWLSGHGDWă
1RĠLXQLGHED]ă
ILLQGXLFDUDFWHULVWLFXQDQXPLWQXPăUGHRFWHĠLSHQWUXUHSUH]HQWDUH
5HSUH]HQWDUHDQXPHUHORUvQPHPRULH
2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL ÌQOLPEDMXO3DVFDO ÌQOLPEDMXO&
ÌQPXOĠLUHFXRSHUDĠLLSHELĠL
WLS QXPăURFWHĠL WLS QXPăURFWHĠL
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH XY RFWHW
J& RFWHW
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU RFWHĠL
J
J RFWHĠL
J
J RFWHĠL
1RĠLXQLGHED]ă 6ăGHWHUPLQăPDFXPFDUHQXPHUHQDWXUDOHSRWILUHSUH]HQWDWHSHXQRFWHW
3kQăvQSUH]HQWPHPRULLOHXWLOL]DWHGHFDOFXODWRDUHVXQWFRQVWUXLWHGLQPDWHULDOHPDJ 8QRFWHWHVWHIRUPDWGLQELĠLSR]LĠLLOHELQDUHSHFDUHOHRFXSăVXQWQXPHURWDWHGH
QHWL]DELOHDYkQGGRXăVWăULFăURUDSULQFRQYHQĠLHOLVHDVRFLD]ăYDORULOHELQDUHúL ODVWkQJDODGUHDSWD%LWXOFLDUHUDQJXOLvQFRPSRQHQĠDUHSUH]HQWăULL
8QLWDWHDGHPHPRULHFDUHSRDWHÄvQPDJD]LQD´RYDORDUHGHVDXVHQXPHúWHbLt
biQDU\GLJLt
,QIRUPDĠLLOHUHSUH]HQWDWHFXELĠLVXQWJUXSDWHvQPHPRULHFkWHIRUPkQGRFWHĠL
3R]LĠLLELQDUH
0HPRULDHVWHSULYLWăFDRvQúLUXLUHGHRFWHĠLDFHúWLDILLQGLGHQWLILFDĠLSULQWURDGUH F F F F F F F F
Vă2FWHĠLLGHPHPRULHVXQWJUXSDĠLODUkQGXOORUSHSDJLQLGHPHPRULH
([HPSOX
'HH[HPSOXGHVSUHSULPXOELWGLQVWkQJDVSXQHPFDHVWHELWXOGHSHSR]LĠLDúLDUH
0HPRULD5$0RDQGRPAFFHVVMHPRU\ UDQJXO
&HOPDLPLFQXPăUQDWXUDOFDUHSRDWHILUHSUH]HQWDWSHELĠLHVWH
3DJLQD
3DJLQD
3DJLQD
RFWHW &HOPDLPDUHQXPăUQDWXUDOFDUHSRDWHILUHSUH]HQWDWSHELĠLHVWH
1XPăUXOGHRFWHĠLDLPHPRULHLLQWHUQHH[SULPăFDSDFLWDWHDGHPHPRULHDDFHVWHLD 3HQWUXDFDOFXODYDORDUHDDFHVWXLQXPăUvQVLVWHPXO]HFLPDODSOLFăPDOJRULWPXOGH
$OWHXQLWăĠLGHPHPRUDUHIRORVLWHvQH[SULPDUHDFDSDFLWăĠLLGHPHPRUDUHVXQW FRQYHUVLHGLQED]DvQED]D
x .LORE\WHQRWăP.%.% RFWHĠLE\WHV
x 0HJDE\WHQRWăP0%0% .%
x *LJDE\WHQRWăP*%*% 0% VDXPDLVLPSOXIRORVLQGRSHUDĠLLOHGLQED]DQXPăUXOVFULLQGXVHFD
± ±
3XWHPWUDJHFRQFOX]LDFăSHELĠLVHSRWUHSUH]HQWDQXPHUHvQWUHúL±
2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL 2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL
3ULQDQDORJLHSHELĠLRFWHĠLVHSRWUHSUH]HQWDQXPHUHQDWXUDOHFXSULQVHvQWUH 5HSUH]HQWDUHDQXPHUHORUSR]LWLYHVHUHDOL]HD]ăODIHOFDúLSHQWUXQXPHUHOHQDWXUD
úL± OHGDUOXQJLPHDGHUHSUH]HQWDUHHVWHPDLPLFăFX
3HQWUXDUHSUH]HQWDXQQXPăUQDWXUDOSHXQQXPăUGDWGHRFWHĠLVHYRUHIHFWXDXU
PăWRDUHOHRSHUDĠLL 3HQWUXDUHSUH]HQWDXQQXPăUQHJDWLYVHDSOLFăXUPăWRULLSDúL
6HFRQYHUWHúWHQXPăUXOvQED]D 3DVXO6HUHSUH]LQWăQXPăUXOvQED]DFDúLFXPDUILSR]LWLY
6HDOLQLD]ăELĠLLGLQFRPSRQHQĠDQXPăUXOXLODGUHDSWDDSRLvQVWkQJDSULPHLFLIUH 3DVXO1XPăUXOREĠLQXWVHVFDGHGLQNXQGHNHVWHOXQJLPHDUHSUH]HQWăULLvQELĠL
VHPQLILFDWLYHUHSUH]HQWDUHDVHFRPSOHWHD]ăFXGDFăHVWHFD]XO 3DVXO6HUHSUH]LQWăQXPăUXOREĠLQXWODSDVXOSHNELĠLFDvQDOJRULWPXOSUHFHGHQW
([HPSOX
([HPSOH
6ăVHUHSUH]LQWHQXPăUXO±SHXQRFWHWN
D6ăVHUHSUH]LQWHQXPăUXOSHRFWHĠL
3DVXO
3DVXO1XPăUXOVHUHSUH]LQWăvQED]D
3DVXO±
$SOLFăPDOJRULWPXOFXQRVFXWúLREĠLQHP
3DVXODOLQLHPFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLvQED]DODGUHDSWDSHELĠLRFWHĠLFRPSOH
WkQGODVWkQJDFXXUL
3DVXO
$OWHUQDWLYăSUDFWLFăSHQWUXSXQFWXO
E6ăVHUHSUH]LQWHQXPăUXOSHRFWHW 6HSRDWHGHPRQVWUDFăGDFăVHFRPSOHPHQWHD]ăQXPăUXOELWFXELWRSHUDĠLHGHQH
3DVXO1XPăUXOvQED]D JDUHSHELWúLDSRLODFHHDFHVDREĠLQXWVHDGXQăYRPDMXQJHODDFHODúLUH]XOWDW
3DVXO5HSUH]HQWăPDFHVWQXPăUSHXQRFWHW QHJDWELWFXELWGHYLQH
6HREVHUYăFăVDSLHUGXWFLIUDFHDPDLVHPQLILFDWLYăDQXPăUXOXLFHHDFHvQVHDP
QăFăQXSRDWHILUHSUH]HQWDWSHRFWHW7LSXOGHGDWăWUHEXLHDOHVvQGHSOLQăFRQ
FRUGDQĠăFXPăULPHDYDORULORUúLGHFLOXQJLPHDvQELĠLDDFHVWRUD 5HSUH]HQWDUHDQXPHUHORUUHDOH
5HSUH]HQWDUHDQXPHUHORUUHDOHVHUHDOL]HD]ăvQFRQYHQĠLDYLUJXOăPRELOă
5HDPLQWLPFăXQQXPăUUHDOVHSRDWHVFULHVXEIRUPDFFFF(±SXQGHFXFDP
5HSUH]HQWDUHDQXPHUHORUvQWUHJLFXVHPQ QRWDWFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLLDUSHVWHIRUPDWGLQXQDVDXGRXăFLIUHúLUHSUH]LQWăSXWHUHDOD
J `
([HPSOX ` `
6ăVHUHSUH]LQWHQXPăUXOSHRFWHĠL
3DVXO7UHFHPQXPăUXOGLQED]DvQED]D
GLUHFWDVXSUDUHSUH]HQWăULLELQDUHIăUăDILQHYRLHGHFRQYHUVLL J `
'HRDUHFHRSHUDWRULLSHELĠLVHH[HFXWăPDLUDSLGGHFkWRSHUDWRULLDULWPHWLFLvQLP ` ` `
SOHPHQWDUHDDOJRULWPLORUVHSUHIHUăIUHFYHQWXWLOL]DUHDORUvQVFKLPEXOFHORUDULWPHWLFL
`
1RWDĠLLJJvQOLPEDMXO3DVFDOúLJ±JvQOLPEDMXO&
1HJDUHD
([HPSOX
1HJDUHDHVWHXQRSHUDWRUXQDUFDUHDFĠLRQHD]ăDVXSUDXQXLVLQJXURSHUDQGGHWLSvQWUHJ
6ăVHFDOFXOH]HYDORDUHDH[SUHVLHLJJSHQWUXD úLE
DYkQGFDHIHFWVFKLPEDUHDILHFăUXLELWDOUHSUH]HQWăULLQXPăUXOXLGLQvQúLGLQvQ
1RWDĠLLvQOLPEDMXO3DVFDOúL¯vQOLPEDMXO& 9DORDUH]HFLPDOă 5HSUH]HQWDUHSHRFWHW
J
([HPSOX J
6ăVHFDOFXOH]HYDORDUHDOXLJSHQWUXD JJVDXJ±J
2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL
2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL
Ä6DXH[FOXVLY´ ÌQPXOĠLUHFXRSHUDĠLLSHELĠL
6DXH[FOXVLYHVWHXQRSHUDWRUELQDUFDUHDFĠLRQHD]ăDVXSUDDGRLRSHUDQ]LvQWUHJLELWFX
3UH]HQWăPXQDOJRULWPFDUHHIHFWXHD]ăvQPXOĠLUHDDGRXăQXPHUHvQWUHJLDEd
ELWDYkQGFDHIHFWVHWDUHDELWXOXLUH]XOWDWSHGDFăFHLGRLELĠLQXDXDFHHDúLYDORDUHúL
IăUăFDvQLPSOHPHQWDUHVăILHQHYRLHGHRSHUDWRUXOvQPXOĠLUH
SHvQFD]FRQWUDU7DEODGHRSHUDUHDRSHUDWRUXOXLVDXH[FOXVLYSHELWHVWH
J J #J¡
ĠQJ
J ` JJ
zJ`
ăQJJ
` `
` JJJJăJELWXOFHOPDLGLQGUHDSWDJ\JJJJ
JJJJJJJmJJ~J
1RWDĠLLJJvQOLPEDMXO3DVFDOúLJJvQOLPEDMXO& JJJJ úJăJ
JJJJJmJJJ ^vOYRPLPSOHPHQWDFX `
([HPSOX JJJJJJmJJ ^vOYRPLPSOHPHQWDFX `
6ăVHFDOFXOH]HYDORDUHDOXLJJSHQWUXD úLE úJ
úJ
J 9DORDUH]HFLPDOă 5HSUH]HQWDUHSHRFWHW
ÌQLQVWUXFĠLXQHD ăVHIDFHUHIHULUHODXOWLPXOELWGLQSULPXORSHUDQG$FHVWDVH
J SRDWHDFFHVDVLPSOXHIHFWXkQGRSHUDĠLDvQWUHDúLFRQVWDQWDIăUăVăILHQHYRLHGH
J XWLOL]DUHDvPSăUĠLULLvQWUHJLOD$LFLMRDFăUROGHPDVFă
JJVDXJJ 2PDVFăHVWHXQQXPăUFRQVWUXLWvQDúDIHOvQFkWVăSHUPLWăWHVWDUHDYDORULLXQXLD
VDXDPDLPXOWRUELĠLDLXQXLQXPăUGDW
5RWLULSHELĠL 6ăFRQVLGHUăPXQH[HPSOXFRQFUHWúLVăXUPăULPSDúLLDOJRULWPXOXLSHQWUXD
([LVWăGRLRSHUDWRULXQXOSHQWUXURWLUHDELĠLORUVSUHGUHDSWDLDUFHOăODOWSHQWUXURWLUHD úLE
ELĠLORUVSUHVWkQJD$FHúWLDVXQWRSHUDWRULELQDULSULPXORSHUDQGILLQGQXPăUXODLFăUXL
ELĠLYRUILURWLĠLLDUFHOGHDOGRLOHDUHSUH]LQWăQXPăUXOGHURWDĠLLÌQORFXOELĠLORUGHSOD D E D UH]XOWDW
VDĠLGLQPDUJLQHQXPăUXOVHFRPSOHWHD]ăFXXUL
1RWDĠLL SHQWUXURWLUHODVWkQJDShLIWLHIWúL SHQWUXURWLUHODGUHDSWDShLIW
RLJKW
([HPSOX
6ăVHFDOFXOH]HYDORDUHDOXLJ JúLDOXLJ JSHQWUXD
'HH[HPSOXVăOXăPvQFRQVLGHUDUHVLWXDĠLD
J 9DORDUH]HFLPDOă 5HSUH]HQWDUHSHRFWHW (FKLYDOHQWFX VDXXUPăWRDUHD 5H]XOWăFODUFă
DVWIHOSXWHPREĠLQHLQIRUPDĠLDGRULWăGHVSUHYDORDUHDXOWLPXOXLELWDOXLD
J
J
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3HQWUXDYăIDPLOLDUL]DFXXWLOL]DUHDRSHUDWRULORUFDUHSHUPLWSUHOXFUDUHDGDWHORUSHELĠL
2EVHUYDĠLL
SURSXQHPUH]ROYDUHDXUPăWRDUHORUH[HUFLĠLL
6HREVHUYăFăRULFHURWLUHWUDQVODWDUHODVWkQJDFXRSR]LĠLHHVWHHFKLYDOHQWăFXR
VFKLPEDUHDVHPQXOXLXQXLQXPăU
vQPXOĠLUHDQXPăUXOXLFXúLRULFHURWLUHODGUHDSWDFXRSR]LĠLHHVWHHFKLYDOHQWăFXR
VFKLPEDUHDYDORULLXQXLELWGLQWUXQQXPăU
vPSăUĠLUHDQXPăUXOXLOD
2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL 2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL
FRGLILFDUHDúLGHFRGLILFDUHDXQXLQXPăUSHED]DXQHLFKHL ([HPSOX
vQPXOĠLUHDúLvPSăUĠLUHDFXSXWHULDOHOXL %#!&$ %#!&'(!J
QXPăUDUHDELĠLORUDYkQGYDORDUHDVDXGLQUHSUH]HQWDUHDXQXLQXPăUvQED]D ` |~
GHVFRPSXQHUHDXQXLQXPăUvQWUHJvQRFWHWXOGLQVWkQJDúLRFWHWXOGLQGUHDSWD
URWLUHDFLIUHORUELQDUHDOHXQXLQXPăUvQWUHJ ,QYHUVDUH
VFKLPEDUHDFLIUHORUELQDUHHJDOHFXvQúLLQYHUV 6HFRQVLGHUăGRXăQXPHUHvQWUHJLDúLE6ăVHLQYHUVH]HFRQĠLQXWXOYDULDELOHLDFX
JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUVXEPXOĠLPLORUPXOĠLPLL^«1` FRQĠLQXWXOYDULDELOHLEIăUăXWLOL]DUHDXQHLYDULDELOHDX[LOLDUH
JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUúLUXULORUFDUHFRQĠLQQXPDLYDORULOHúL
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
&HOHGRXăQXPHUHVHDIOăSHSULPDOLQLHDILúLHUXOXLGHLQWUDUH$8" &$
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
'DWHGHLHúLUH
$ILúDUHvQED]D &HOH GRXă QXPHUH VH YRU VFULH GXSă FH FRQĠLQXWXULOH ORU VDX LQYHUVDW vQ ILúLHUXO GH
6FULHĠLXQSURJUDPFDUHFLWHúWHXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQúLDILúHD]ăFLIUHOHUHSUH]HQWăULLEL LHúLUH$8" &'(!
QDUHDQXPăUXOXL
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
'DWHGHLQWUDUH x dDEd
1XPăUXOQDWXUDOQVHFLWHúWHGLQILúLHUXO$"&$
([HPSOX
'DWHGHLHúLUH $8" &$ $8" &'(!
1XPăUXOUHSUH]HQWDWvQED]DVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXO$"&'(! `JJ J`J
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x dQd 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVH
J
([HPSOX $ILúDUHvQED]D
$"&$ $"&'(!J
` ```` 3HQWUXDDILúDUHSUH]HQWDUHDELQDUăDQXPăUXOXLYDWUHEXLVăWHVWăPSHUkQGELĠLLDFHVWX
LD ([LVWă PDL PXOWH PRGDOLWăĠL GH D IDFH DFHVW OXFUX 3UH]HQWăP vQ FRQWLQXDUH GRXă
GLQWUHHOH
6XPăGHSXWHULDOHOXL
6ăVHGHVFRPSXQăXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQFDVXPăGHSXWHULDOHOXL D6ROXĠLHFDUHURWHúWHPDVFD
3HQWUXDWHVWDWRĠLELĠLLYDWUHEXLVăUHSHWăPGHRULWHVWDUHDGDFăQXPăUXOHVWHUHSUH
'DWHGHLQWUDUH ]HQWDW SH ELĠL OD ILHFDUH SDV GHSODVkQG ELWXO GH WHVW FX R SR]LĠLH 'H GDWD DFHDVWD
1XPăUXOQDWXUDOQVHFLWHúWHGLQILúLHUXO%#!&$ YUHPVăDILúăPYDORDUHDELĠLORUvQFHSkQGFXELWXOGHFLPDVFDVHYDLQLĠLDOL]DFXYD
ORDUHD
'DWHGHLHúLUH
'HVFRPSXQHUHDQXPăUXOXLQFDVXPăGHSXWHULDOHOXLVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH /DILHFDUHSDVURWLPPDVFDODGUHDSWDFXRSR]LĠLH
%#!&'(!2SHUDĠLDGHULGLFDUHODSXWHUHYDILUHSUH]HQWDWăSULQFDUDFWHUXO
([HPSOX
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x dQd
2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL 2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL
L QU PDVFD QUPDVFD UH]XOWDW DILúăP
\J
ă,J
ăJ
JJ%JzJ`JJJ
JJ
JJJJJJ%
ă
%ăJmJDGHYăUDWJ
JJJJ
ăJ%
ă
%ăJ
J` ^XULOHQHVHPQLILFDWLYHQXVHYRUDILúD`
úă
3H XUPăWRDUHOH WUHL SR]LĠLL DILúăP 'HFL SH SDUFXUVXO H[HFXWăULL SURJUDPXOXL VH
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J JJJ ^URWLPQXPăUXOFXRSR]LĠLHODVWkQJD`
DILúHD]ă JJJJ úă
JJ ú
E6ROXĠLHED]DWăSHURWLUHDQXPăUXOXLGDW ú
ÌQDFHDVWăDERUGDUHvQORFVăVHPRGLILFHSR]LĠLDELWXOXLGHWHVWGLQPDVFăVHYDURWL
QXPăUXOGDWELWFXELWWHVWkQGXVHODILHFDUHSDVDFHHDúLSR]LĠLHSULPXOELW5RWLULOHúL
WHVWăULOHVHYRUUHSHWDGHDWkWHDRULFkĠLELĠLDUHUHSUH]HQWDUHDQXPăUXOXLQ&LIUHOHGLQ 6XPăGHSXWHULDOHOXL
IDĠDQXPăUXOXLQXYRUILDILúDWH ÌQPRGDVHPăQăWRUSUREOHPHLDQWHULRDUHVHYRUWHVWDELĠLLQXPăUXOXLQGHGDWDDFHDVWD
vQVăDFHúWLDYRUILSDUFXUúLGHODGUHDSWDVSUHVWkQJDFHHDFHQHYDSHUPLWHVăSăVWUăP
([HPSOX vQWUXQFRQWRUSDVUDQJXOILHFăUXLELW$WXQFLFkQGXQELWYDDYHDYDORDUHDFRQWRUXO
)LHQ úLPDVFD UHSUH]HQWDWHSHELĠL YDDUăWDSXWHUHDOXLFDUHFRUHVSXQGHDFHOXLELW
/D ILHFDUH SDV VH URWHúWH QXPăUXO Q OD VWkQJD SHQWUX FD XUPăWRUXO ELW ELWXO GHSH
SR]LĠLDVăDMXQJăvQSR]LĠLDGHWHVWDUH ([HPSOX
ÌQ SURJUDPXO FX FDUH LPSOHPHQWăP DFHVWDOJRULWPDPLQWURGXVRYDULDELOăORJLFă Q
FLIUăBVHPQLILFDWLYă FDUH YD SULPL YDORDUHD DGHYăUDW GXSă JăVLUHD úL DILúDUHD SULPHL
FLIUHVHPQLILFDWLYHDVWIHORIHULQGSRVLELOLWDWHDGHDHYLWDDILúDUHDFLIUHORUHJDOHFXvQ 3DV Q 8OWLPXOELW $ILúăP
IDĠDSULPHLFLIUHVHPQLILFDWLYH
3DV QU PDVFD QUPDVFD UH]XOWDW FLIUăBVHPQLILFDWLYă DILúăP
IDOV A
IDOV
DGHYăUDW A
DGHYăUDW
DGHYăUDW
6HREVHUYăFăODILHFDUHSDVDIRVWWHVWDWXOWLPXOELWFHHDFHQHDUDWăFăPDVFDYD
ÌQXUPăWRULLWUHLSDúLVHYDDILúDYDORDUHD WUHEXLVăDLEăXOWLPXOELWHJDOFXLDUFHLODOĠLELĠLHJDOLFX'HFLPDVFDYDILLQLĠLDOL
]DWăFX
#J
úQJ ÌQDOJRULWPXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUYRPIRORVLYDULDELODERROHDQăSULPXOFDUHQHYDDUDWă
ú
J
J GDFăVXQWHPVDXQXODSULPXOWHUPHQDOVXPHLSHQWUXDúWLGDFăYRPDILúDXQVDXQX
JJ%JmJJJ ^VHFRQVWUXLHúWHRPDVFăSHGHELĠLFDUHYDDYHD`
JJ%JmJ%J JJJ ^SULPXOELWUHVWXOELĠLORUILLQG` #J%
ăQJ
ú
J
J
%
ă
%ăJmJIDOV
JJ%JmJJ
JJJmJ`J
2SHUDĠLLSHELĠL
JJJmJăJ
JJ
J
JzJ`J
ă, ^FkWWLPSPDLH[LVWăELĠLHJDOLFXvQQXPăU`
JJJJăJ
JúJ%JzJ`J
ăJJJJJ
^GDFăDPJăVLWXQELWHJDOFX`J
5HFXUVLYLWDWH &DSLWROXO
JJJJJJJJ
J~J
JJ 1RĠLXQHDGHUHFXUVLYLWDWH
3URLHFWDUHDXQXLDOJRULWPUHFXUVLY
JJJmJ
JJ ([HFXĠLDDSHOXULORUUHFXUVLYH
úă 5HFXUVLYLWDWHLQGLUHFWăvQFUXFLúDWă
JJJ ^DILúăPSXWHUHDOXLFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH` *UHúHOLIUHFYHQWHvQVFULHUHDSURJUDPHORUUHFXUVLYH
J JJ úă &kQGPHULWăVăXWLOL]ăPWHKQLFDUHFXUVLYLWăĠLL"
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
J JJ
JmJ
JURWLWODGUHDSWDFXSR]LĠLH ^WUHFHPODXUPăWRUXOELW` 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
J JJJmJJ~JJ 6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
JJ ú
ú
1RĠLXQHDGHUHFXUVLYLWDWH
,QYHUVDUH 1RĠLXQHDGHUHFXUVLYLWDWHGLQSURJUDPDUHGHULYăvQPRGQDWXUDOGLQQRĠLXQHDPDWHPD
9RP IRORVL RSHUDWRUXO FDUH DSOLFDW GH GRXă RUL FRQVHFXWLY vúL DQXOHD]ă ÄDFĠLX WLFă FXQRVFXWă VXE QXPHOH GH UHFXUHQĠă 'DU úL YLDĠD GH ]L FX ]L RIHUă QHQXPăUDWH
QHD´ 'DFă VH DSOLFă vQWUH FHOH GRXă QXPHUH vQWUHJL GDWH DSRL DVXSUD UH]XOWDWXOXL FX H[HPSOH$WXQFLFkQGQHDSXFăPGHIăFXWWHPHOHGHVFKLGHPRFDUWHFLWLPGLQHDGDU
SULPXOXPăUúLODIHOFXDOGRLOHDFRQĠLQXWXOFHORUGRXăYDULDELOHVHLQYHUVHD]ă OD XQ PRPHQW GDW QH WUHEXLH R DOWă FDUWH ÌQWUHUXSHP VWXGLXO GLQ SULPD FDUWH úL FLWLP
GLQ FHDODOWă (VWH SRVLELO Vă DYHP QHYRLH vQ FRQWLQXDUH GH DOWH FăUĠL 9D VRVL vQVă úL
)LHD úLE PRPHQWXO FkQG QH vQWRDUFHP OD XOWLPD FDUWH vQWUHUXSWă FRQWLQXăP VDX QX Vă FLWLP
J GLQHDDSRLQHvQWRDUFHPODSUHFHGHQWDúLvQILQDOODSULPD$WXQFLFkQGDPWHUPLQDW
J J J WHPDRvQFKLGHPúLSHDFHDVWD
J 3UH]HQWăP vQ FRQWLQXDUH FkWHYD H[HPSOH FODVLFH GH IXQFĠLL GHILQLWH UHFXUHQW 2
JJJ J JJ JJJ IXQFĠLHHVWHUHFXUHQWăGDFăHVWHGHILQLWăSULQVLQHvQVăúL
([HPSOH
'HFLDYHPvQEYDORDUHDLDUvQDYDORDUHD 'HILQLĠLDQXPHUHORUQDWXUDOHFRQIRUPD[LRPHORUOXL3HDQR
x HVWHQXPăUQDWXUDO
#
,J
x 2ULFHVXFFHVRUDOXQXLQXPăUQDWXUDOHVWHXQQXPăUQDWXUDO
JJ
ú
JJ
JJJmJJJJ 6HFĠLXQHDGHDXU
JJJmJJJJ ^YDORDUHDSULPXOXLQXPăUDMXQJHvQDOGRLOHD`J 6HFĠLXQHD GH DXU VHJPHQWXO GH DXU VDX SURSRUĠLD GLYLQă UHSUH]LQWă WRDWH DFHODúL
JJJmJJJJ ^YDORDUHDFHOXLGHDOGRLOHDQXPăUDMXQJHvQSULPXO` OXFUXDGLFăFHDPDLDUPRQLRDVăvPSăUĠLUHSURSRUĠLRQDUHGLYLQăDILJXULORUJHRPHWULFH
JJ
JJJ ÌQFăGLQDQWLFKLWDWH6HFĠLXQHDGHDXUHUDFXQRVFXWăFDILLQGVROXĠLDHFXDĠLHL
JJ
JJJ [±[±
ú
5HFXUVLYLWDWH 5HFXUVLYLWDWH
)UDFWDOL
5H]ROYkQGHFXDĠLDREĠLQHP [ FHHDFHvQVHDPQăDSUR[LPDWLY
)UDFWDOLLVXQWIRUPHJHRPHWULFHGHILQLWHUHFXUHQWSULQvPSăUĠLUHDXQXLVHJPHQWVDXD
XQHLVXSUDIHĠHvQEXFăĠLGXSăRSURSRUĠLHGDWă)LHFDUHEXFDWăDXQXLIUDFWDOHVWHRFR
SLHODVFDUăUHGXVăDvQWUHJXOXL
$FHDVWăFRQVWDQWăHVWHSUH]HQWăvQWRWFHHDFHHVWHYLXFXPDUILUDSRUWXOGLQWUHGH
JHWúLSDOPăUDSRUWXOGLQWUHSDOPăúLDQWHEUDĠúLDúDPDLGHSDUWHPRWLYSHQWUXFDUHD 'LQSXQFWGHYHGHUHDOPRGHOXOXLGHJHQHUDUH
IRVWDGHVHDIRORVLWGHPDULLDUWLúWLGHODFRQVWUXFĠLDSLUDPLGHORUúLSkQăODSLFWXUDUH DIUDFWDOLORUDFHúWLDSRWILvPSăUĠLĠLvQIUDFWDOLQD
QDVFHQWLVWă1XPHURDVHVFULHULDXIRVWFRQVDFUDWHVHFĠLXQLLGHDXUOHJLORUVDOHúLSDUWL WXUDOL úL IUDFWDOL DUWLILFLDOL )UDFWDOLL QDWXUDOL VXQW
FLSăULLVDOHODVWUXFWXUDUHDQDWXULLúLDDUWHL6XEQXPHOHGHÄGLYLQHSURSRUWLRQH´RJă FHLH[LVWHQĠLvQQDWXUăVDXFDUHVXQWFUHDĠLvQXUPD
VLPOD/XFD3DFLROLSULHWHQúLFRODERUDWRUDOOXL/HRQDUGRGD9LQFLVXEIRUPăGHIUDF XQRUSURFHVHQDWXUDOH1RULLPXQĠLLFRSDFLLPD
ĠLHFRQWLQXăLQILQLWă OXULOH SRW IL FRQVLGHUDĠL IUDFWDOL QDWXUDOL 'H DVH
PHQHDVLVWHPXOQHUYRVúLVLVWHPXOGHUDPLILFDĠLHD
[ EURQKLLORUVXQWH[HPSOHGHIUDFWDOLQDWXUDOLÌQQD
WXUă FHO PDL DGHVHD vQWkOQLP SURSRUĠLD GLYLQă FD
IDFWRUGHSURSRUĠLRQDOLWDWHDOIUDFWDOLORU
3URLHFWDUHDXQXLDOJRULWPUHFXUVLY
IRUPăQXPLWăúLÄFRPELQDUHDXQLWăĠLLFXLQILQLWXO´ ÌQSURJUDPDUHYRUELPGHVSUHVXESURJUDPUHFXUVLYGDFăDFHVWDVHDXWRDSHOHD]ă$OWIHO
VSXVvQFRUSXOVXESURJUDPXOXLDSDUHXQDSHODOVXESURJUDPXOXLvQVXúLvQWLPSFHDFHV
ùLUXOOXL)LERQDFFL WD HVWH DFWLY 3HQWUX FD DSHOXO Vă QX VH UHDOL]H]H OD LQILQLW HVWH QHFHVDUă H[LVWHQĠD vQ
6HFRQVLGHUăFăGHILQLUHDúLUXOXLDDSăUXW VXESURJUDPDXQHLFRQGLĠLLFRUHFWHGHRSULUHDDFHVWRUDSHOXUL
vQDQXOúLDFHVWDVHJHQHUHD]ăFXIRUPXOHOH 8QDOWSXQFWGHOLFDWvQUHDOL]DUHDXQXLVXESURJUDPUHFXUVLYHVWHGHVFULHUHDPRGHOX
I I IL IL±IL±SHQWUXL! OXL([LVWăSUREOHPHvQFDUHSXWHPDSOLFDRIRUPXOăGHUHFXUHQĠăGDWăGDUúLSUREOHPH
$FHVWDHVWHGDWRUDWOXL/HRQDUGRGD3LVDILXOOXL%RQDFFLRFDXUPDUHDIRUPXOăULL vQFDUHDFHDVWăUHODĠLHWUHEXLHGHWHUPLQDWăSHED]DHQXQĠXOXL
XQHLSUREOHPHSULYLQGvQPXOĠLUHDLHSXULORU
3ULPXOWHUPHQHVWHXUPăWRULLGRLWHUPHQLDLúLUXOXLVXQWLDUILHFDUHWHUPHQGH 3UH]HQWăPvQFRQWLQXDUHGRXăH[HPSOHGHSURLHFWDUHDXQRUDOJRULWPLUHFXUVLYL
LQGLFHPDLPDUHGHFkWHVWHHJDOFXVXPDXOWLPLORUGRLWHUPHQLFDUHvOSUHFHG D 'DFăIRUPXODUHFXUHQWăHVWHFXQRVFXWăDOJRULWPXOYDGHVFULHDFHDVWăIRUPXOă
2EVHUYDĠLH ([HPSOX
3HPăVXUăFHúLUXOFRQWLQXăUDSRUWXOGLQWUHGRLWHUPHQLFRQVHFXWLYLVHDSURSLHGH 9RPVFULHXQVXESURJUDPUHFXUVLYFDUHFDOFXOHD]ăYDORDUHDOXLDQXQGHDHVWHXQQX
YDORDUHDQXPăUXOGHDXU PăUUHDOLDUQHVWHQXPăUQDWXUDOGLIHULWGH
ÌQFRQWLQXDUHYRPHQXPHUDFkWHYDSURSULHWăĠLLQWHUHVDQWHDOHWHUPHQLORUúLUXOXLOXL )RUPXODUHFXUHQWăGHFDOFXODUHDIXQFĠLHLSXWHUHHVWH
)LERQDFFL GDFă Q
DQ ® Q
IQ IQ±IQ±Q ¯ D D GDFă Q z
IQ±IQ IQ±IQ±Q
$FHDVWăIRUPXOăVHSRDWHUHVFULH
IIIQ IQ±±
IIIQ± IQ GDFă Q
3XWHUH D Q ®
IIIQ IQIQ ¯D 3XWHUH D Q GDFă Q z
5HFXUVLYLWDWH
2YDULDQWăGHVXESURJUDPUHFXUVLYFDUHFRUHVSXQGHDFHVWHLGHVFULHULHVWH 5HFXUVLYLWDWH
J
QJJ ^GHWLSIXQFĠLHUHWXUQHD]ăXQQXPăUUHDO`
ăJ
J\JJJJ ([HFXĠLDDSHOXULORUUHFXUVLYH
JJJJJmJJ $úDFXPVDSUHFL]DWvQFDSLWROXO6XESURJUDPHRULFHDSHOGHVXESURJUDPFKLDUúL
JJ
JJ DWXQFLFkQGHVWHYRUEDGHDXWRDSHODUHFDHIHFWVDOYDUHDSHVWLYDFDOFXODWRUXOXLDDGUH
JJJJJmJJJ
J VHLGHUHYHQLUHDYDORULORUSDUDPHWULORUWUDQVPLúLSULQYDORDUHúLDDGUHVHLSDUDPHWULORU
úă WUDQVPLúLSULQUHIHULQĠăSUHFXPúLDORFDUHDGHVSDĠLXSHVWLYăSHQWUXYDULDELOHOHORFDOH
ú DOHVXESURJUDPXOXL
J ÌQ FRQWLQXDUH YRP VLPXOD PRGXO vQ FDUH VH H[HFXWă VXESURJUDPXO %
E 'DFăIRUPXODUHFXUHQWăQXHVWHGDWăDFHDVWDWUHEXLHVăILHGHGXVă SUH]HQWDWPDLVXVSHQWUXD úLE XUPăULQGXVHSDVFXSDVDSHOXULOHVXFFHVL
YHDOHVXESURJUDPXOXLSUHFXPúLYDORULOHH[LVWHQWHSHVWLYă
([HPSOX
KJ
J UHFXUVLYHHVWHPDLDQHYRLRDVăGHFkWDFHORULWHUDWLYH
5HFXUVLYLWDWH 5HFXUVLYLWDWH
3ULQFLSDOXODYDQWDMDOXWLOL]ăULLWHKQLFLLUHFXUVLYHHVWHFăSHUPLWHRGHVFULHUHFRQFLVă 1XPăUPD[LP
DDOJRULWPXOXLRJOLQGLQGSHUIHFWGHILQLĠLDUHFXUHQWăDUHVSHFWLYHLQRĠLXQL7H[WXOVXUVă 6FULHĠL XQ SURJUDP FDUH FLWHúWH XQ QXPăU QDWXUDO Q úL XQ QXPăU GH FLIUH N PDL PLF
DOXQXLDVWIHOGHDOJRULWPHVWHGHUHJXOăPXOWPDLVFXUWúLPDLFODUGHFkWDOWHYDULDQWH GHFkW QXPăUXO GH FLIUH DOH QXPăUXOXL Q úL GHWHUPLQă QXPăUXO PD[LP FDUH VH SRDWH
GHDOJRULWPL$FHVWPRGGHVFULHUHSHUPLWHRGLYL]DUHXúRDUăDSUREOHPHLvQVXESUREOH REĠLQHGLQQSULQHOLPLQDUHDDNFLIUH&LIUHOHQXPăUXOXLUH]XOWDWvúLYRUSăVWUDRUGLQHD
PHGHDFHODúLWLS vQQXPăU
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH &HOHGRXăQXPHUHQDWXUDOHVHYRUFLWLGLQILúLHUXO+#9+&$
3HQWUX D Yă IDPLOLDUL]D FX LPSOHPHQWDUHD VXESURJUDPHORU UHFXUVLYH Yă UHFRPDQGăP
VăUHDOL]DĠLXUPăWRDUHOHH[HUFLĠLL 'DWHGHLHúLUH
LQYHUVDUHDFLIUHORUGLQFRQILJXUDĠLDXQXLQXPăUGDWIăUăVWULQJXUL 1XPăUXOREĠLQXWSULQHOLPLQDUHDFHORUNFLIUHVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXO+#9+&'(!
LQYHUVDUHDQXPHUHORUGLQWUXQúLUGDWIăUăWDEORXUL
FDOFXOXOUHFXUVLYDOIDFWRULDOXOXL 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
GHVFRPSXQHUHDUHFXUVLYăDOXQXLQXPăUGDWvQIDFWRULSULPL x QXPăUXOQDWXUDOQSRDWHDYHDFHOPXOWGHFLIUH
FDOFXOXOUHFXUVLYDOWHUPHQLORUXQXLúLUSHED]DXQHLUHODĠLLGHUHFXUHQĠH x dNdQXPăUXOGHFLIUHDOHQXPăUXOXLGDWQ±
JHQHUDUHDVXEPXOĠLPLORUPXOĠLPLL^«Q`
GHWHUPLQDUHDRELHFWHORUGLQFDUHVHFRPSXQHRIRWRJUDILH ([HPSOX
+#9+&$ +#9+&'(!J
J
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
6XPăGHQXPHUH)LERQDFFL
&LIUDPD[LPă 6FULHĠLXQSURJUDPFDUHGHVFRPSXQHXQQXPăUQDWXUDOQFDVXPăGHQXPăUPLQLPGH
6FULHĠLXQSURJUDPFDUHFLWHúWHXQQXPăUQDWXUDOúLGHWHUPLQăFHOPDLPLFUDQJDOFLIUHL QXPHUH)LERQDFFLXWLOL]kQGSHQWUXDFHDVWDXQVXESURJUDPUHFXUVLY
PD[LPHGLQQXPăUXWLOL]kQGXQVXESURJUDPUHFXUVLY
'DWHGHLQWUDUH
'DWHGHLQWUDUH 1XPăUXOQDWXUDOQVHYDFLWLGLQILúLHUXO (+#&$
9DORDUHDQXPăUXOXLQDWXUDOVHFLWHúWHGLQILúLHUXO-"#&$
'DWHGHLHúLUH
'DWHGHLHúLUH ÌQ ILúLHUXO GH LHúLUH (+#&'(! VH YD VFULH QXPăUXO GDW XUPDW GH VHPQXO \ úL GH
&LIUDPD[LPăúLUDQJXOHLVHSDUDWHGHXQVSDĠLXYRUILVFULVHvQILúLHUXO-"#&'(! WHUPHQLLVXPHLGHQXPHUH)LERQDFFL
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x dQXPăUXOGDWd x dQd
([HPSOX ([HPSOX
-"#&$ -"#&'(!J (+#&$ (+#&'(!
| J ` `\||~~~
5HFXUVLYLWDWH
/DFXOHV 5HFXUVLYLWDWH
8QIHUPLHUDUHROLYDGăGUHSWXQJKLXODUăúLGRUHúWHVăFXOHDJăIUXFWHOHFkWPDLXúRU8Q
YHFLQELQHYRLWRUVHRIHUăVăODMXWHFXXQFDPLRQGDUDUHGRDURVLQJXUă]LODGLVSR]L
ĠLH FHHD FH vQVHDPQă Fă SRDWH IDFH R VLQJXUă SDUFXUJHUH D OLYH]LL /LYDGD VH DIOă vQ 1XPHUHURPDQH
SDQWăúLPDúLQDSRDWHVăVHGHSODVH]HQXPDLVSUHGUHDSWDúLvQMRV&DPLRQXOLQWUăvQ 6FULHĠL XQ SURJUDP FDUH DILúHD]ă XQ QXPăU GDW vQ VLVWHPXO GH QXPHUDĠLH ]HFLPDO FX
OLYDGă vQ FROĠXO VWkQJDVXV DO FDURLDMXOXL FRUHVSXQ]ăWRU OLYH]LL úL YD LHúL vQ FROĠXO GLQ FLIUHDUDEHvQVLVWHPGHQXPHUDĠLHURPDQXWLOL]kQGXQVXESURJUDPUHFXUVLY
GUHDSWDMRV
&XQRVFkQGFHOHGRXăGLPHQVLXQLDOHOLYH]LLúLQXPăUXOGHPHUHGLQILHFDUHSRPVă 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
VHJăVHDVFăXQGUXPRSWLPSRVLELOSHQWUXFDPLRQDVWIHOvQFkWSkQăODLHúLUHDGLQOLYD 1XPăUXOQDWXUDOGDWFXFLIUHDUDEHVHYDFLWLGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH"'+#$&$
GăVăILHFXOHVHFkWPDLPXOWHPHUH
'DWHGHLHúLUH
,QWUDUH ùLUXOGHFDUDFWHUHUHSUH]HQWkQGQXPăUXOURPDQVHYDVFULHvQILúLHUXO"'+#$&'(!
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
x dQXPăUXOGDWd
,HúLUH ([HPSOX
"'+#$&$ "'+#$&'(!J
'DWHGHLQWUDUH | ¨£
&HOHGRXăQXPHUHQDWXUDOHPúLQUHSUH]HQWkQGGLPHQVLXQLOHOLYH]LLVHFLWHVFGHSH
SULPD OLQLH D ILúLHUXOXL *8#%#&$ 'H SH XUPăWRDUHOH P OLQLL DOH DFHOXLDúL ILúLHU VH
YRUFLWLFkWHQQXPHUHQDWXUDOHGHVSăUĠLWHSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLXUHSUH]HQWkQGQXPăUXOGH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORUSURSXVH
PHUHGLQILHFDUHSRPDOUkQGXOXLUHVSHFWLYGLQOLYDGă
&LIUăPD[LPă
'DWHGHLHúLUH 3UH]HQWăPDFHDVWăSUREOHPăFDH[HUFLĠLXGHVFULHUHDXQXLVXESURJUDPUHFXUVLYUH]RO
ÌQILúLHUXO *8#%#&'(!VHYDVFULHXQúLUGHFDUDFWHUH úL «XQGH DUHVHP YDUHDLWHUDWLYăXWLOL]kQGXQFLFOX
HVWHPDLVLPSOăúLPDLUDSLGă
QLILFDĠLDGUHDSWDLDU «vQVHDPQăGLUHFĠLHGHGHSODVDUHvQMRVOLWHUHFDUHFRUHVSXQG
GHSODVăULORUVXFFHVLYHSHFDUHOHYDDYHDFDPLRQXOSHGUXPXORSWLPJăVLW $P SXWHD GHWHUPLQD vQWkL FLIUD PD[LPă GLQ QXPăU úL DSRL SULPD SR]LĠLH SH FDUH
DFHDVWD DSDUH 'DU DFHVWH GRXă RELHFWLYH SRW IL DWLQVH SULQWUR VLQJXUă SDUFXUJHUH D
5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL FLIUHORUQXPăUXOXL
x dPQd
,GHHDGHUHDOL]DUHUHFXUVLYăDUVXQDDVWIHOGDFăDYHPPDLPXOWGHRFLIUăvQQXPăU
([HPSOX FLIUD PD[LPă YD IL FHD PDL PDUH FLIUă GLQWUH XOWLPD FLIUă D QXPăUXOXL FXUHQW úL FLIUD
*8#%#&$ *8#%#&'(!J PD[LPăDQXPăUXOXLGLQFDUHDPHOLPLQDWXOWLPDFLIUă'DFăQXPăUXOFXUHQWDUHRFL
|JJ «««« IUăDFHDVWDHVWHFLIUDPD[LPă
J`J|J`J
`J|`J`JJ
3UH]HQWăP vQ FRQWLQXDUH R VFKHPă GH DSOLFDUH D DFHVWXL DOJRULWP UHFXUVLY SHQWUX
`J||J`JJ
JJ`JJ QXPăUXO
`J|JJ
5HFXUVLYLWDWH 5HFXUVLYLWDWH
$SHOXULUHFXUVLYH5HYHQLUHDGLQDSHOXUL 2EVHUYDĠLH
YPD[ LPD[ $OJRULWPXOVHSRDWHvQFKHLDPDLUHSHGHvQFD]XOvQFDUHVHJăVHúWHRFLIUăGHRDUH
QXPăUXOFXUHQW QU L FLIUD SR]LĠLD FHQXPDLSRDWHH[LVWDDOWDPDLPDUHGHFkWHD
PD[LPă FLIUHL
1XPăUPD[LP
6ăSUHVXSXQHPFăQXPHUHOHFLWLWHVXQWúL1XPăUXOGHFLIUHDOHUH]XOWDWX
OXL YD IL HJDO FX QXPăUXO FLIUHORU QXPăUXOXL GDW PLQXV QXPăUXO GH FLIUH FDUH WUHEXLH
HOLPLQDWGHFL±
ÌQDOJRULWPXOSURSXVYRPGHWHUPLQDODILHFDUHSDVFkWHRFLIUăGLQUH]XOWDW
3DVXO
/DSULPXOSDVVHGHWHUPLQăSULPDFLIUăFHDGHUDQJPD[LPDUH]XOWDWXOXL$FHDVWă
FLIUăVHDOHJHGLQWUHFLIUHOHQXPăUXOXLGDWH[FHSWkQGXOWLPHOHGRXăFLIUHDFHVWHDQXDX
FXPVăILHSHSULPDSR]LĠLHDXQXLQXPăUGHWUHLFLIUHGHRDUHFHWUHEXLHSăVWUDWăRUGL
QHDFLIUHORUvQQXPăUXOGDWÌQH[HPSOXOFRQVLGHUDWFLIUDPD[LPăDQXPăUXOXL
HVWHFLIUăSHFDUHRSXQHPvQUH]XOWDW
3HQWUXDSUHJăWLSDVXOXUPăWRUYRPúWHUJHGLQQXPăUXOLQLĠLDOWRDWHFLIUHOHGHODvQ
FHSXWúLSkQăLQFOXVLYODSULPDDSDULĠLHDFLIUHLGHWHUPLQDWHFLIUHOHúLGHRDUHFH
6XEDOJRULWPXOWUHEXLHVăGHWHUPLQHGRXăYDORULPRWLYSHQWUXFDUHDFHVWDYDILGH DFHVWHDQXPDLSRWIDFHSDUWHGLQQXPăUXOUH]XOWDW1XPăUXOUăPDVHVWH
WLSSURFHGXUăúLDFHVWHYDORULYRUILSDUDPHWULWUDQVPLúLSULQUHIHULQĠă3VHXGRFXGXOGH
PDLMRVUHSUH]LQWăDOJRULWPXOVXJHUDW$YHPXUPăWRDUHOHVHPQLILFDĠLLDOHYDULDELOHORUJ 3DVXO
± QUHVWHQXPăUXOGDW /D SDVXO GRL VH GHWHUPLQă D GRXD FLIUă D UH]XOWDWXOXL XUPăULQG DFHODúL DOJRULWP
± LSăVWUHD]ăUDQJXOFLIUHLFXUHQWH 9RP FăXWD FLIUD PD[LPă GLQ QXPăUXO OăVkQG OD R SDUWH FLIUă GH OD VIkUúLW
± YPD[FRQĠLQHYDORDUHDFLIUHLPD[LPHSkQăvQSUH]HQW GHRDUHFHGDFăDPOXDRúLSHDFHDVWDvQFRQVLGHUDUHVDUSXWHDvQWkPSODVRDOHDJăúL
± LPD[SăVWUHD]ăUDQJXOFLIUHLYPD[ GXSă HOLPLQDUHD HL UHVSHFWLY D FLIUHORU FDUH R SUHFHG QX DP PDL DYHD FLIUă SHQWUX D
J FRPSOHWDUH]XOWDWXOFRQIRUPFHULQĠHL6HJăVHúWHFLIUDFDUHVHDGDXJăODUH]XOWDWúLVH
J
ă
QJ UHQXQĠăGLQQRXODFLIUHOHFDUHQXSRWDSăUHDODSDVXOXUPăWRUGHRDUHFHVXQWDQWHULRDUH
JJăJ
J
JJ ^GDFăQXPăUXODUHPDLPXOWHFLIUH` FLIUHLJăVLWH6HúWHUJHVHFYHQĠDSkQăODSULPDDSDULĠLHDFLIUHLPD[LPHLQFOXVLY
^VHDSHOHD]ăUHFXUVLYGHWHUPLQDUHDFLIUHLPD[LPHGLQUHVWXOFLIUHORUQXPăUXOXL`J GLQQXPăU
JJJJ
ă
`~J 1XPăUXOUăPDVDFXPHVWH
JJJJăJ
`J
JJ^GDFăXOWLPDFLIUăDQXPăUXOXLHVWH`
^PDLPDUHGHFkWFLIUDPD[LPăGHSkQăDFXP`JJ 3DVXO
JJJJJJJmJ
`JJ ^VHSăVWUHD]ăFLIUD` /DSDVXOWUHLFLIUDFăXWDWăHVWHLDUQXPăUXOUăPDVGXSăHOLPLQDUHDOXLHVWH
JmJJJ ^úLUDQJXO` 1XPăUXOPD[LPFăXWDWHVWHGHFL
JJJJ úă J
^FkQGDPDMXQVODFLIUDGHUDQJPD[LP` ÌQVXEDOJRULWPXOUHFXUVLYFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUDFHVWXLDOJRULWPDYHPXUPăWRDUHOHVHPQL
JJJJJJJmJ
JJ ^VHLQLĠLDOL]HD]ăFLIUDPD[LPă` ILFDĠLLDOHYDULDELOHORUJ
JJJJJJJmJJJ ^úLUDQJXOFLIUHLPD[LPH`J ± QUHVWHQXPăUXOGDWVXEIRUPăGHúLUGHFDUDFWHUH
JJJJ úă ± FkWHSăVWUHD]ăQXPăUXOFLIUHORUUăPDVHGHDOHVSHWUXUH]XOWDW
JJ úă ± UH]XOWDWHVWHQXPăUXOFDUHVHFDXWă
ú ± SĠLQHHYLGHQĠDQXPăUXOXLFLIUHORUFDUHVHSRWDOHJH
5HFXUVLYLWDWH 5HFXUVLYLWDWH
J
ú
QJ Jă
QJ
JJăJJ
J`JJ ^UHWXUQHD]ăSR]LĠLDSHFDUHDSDUHQXPăUXO
vQúLUXO)LERQDFFL`
JJJJJmJJJ ^FRQVLGHUăPSULPDFLIUăFDILLQGPD[LPă` JJ
J
J
J
J
ă,J
J
J\OXQJLPHDQXPăUXOXL
JJJ~JJ
ă, JJJJ
JmJ
J
^VHGHWHUPLQăFLIUDPD[LPăGHSHSR]LĠLLOHÄSHUPLVH´` JJ ú
JJJJJJăJ
J
J
JJJ JJăJmJ
J
JJJJJJJJJmJJJ ú J
JJJJJJ úă
JJJJ ú
&XDFHVWHSUHFL]ăULSUHOLPLQDULLVXESURJUDPXOUHFXUVLYSURSXVSHQWUXDILúDUHDGHV
JJJJJmJJ~J
JJ ^VHSăVWUHD]ăFLIUDJăVLWă` FRPSXQHULLXQXLQXPăUvQVXPăGHQXPHUH)LERQDFFLHVWH
JJJJVHúWHUJFLIUHOHFDUHQXPDLSRWIDFHSDUWHGLQUH]XOWDW J
J J ^GHWHUPLQăPXUPăWRDUHDFLIUăDVROXĠLHL` J%
QJ
JJJJ
ú
J JJ?JmJă
JJ ^VHGHWHUPLQăLQGLFHOHDFHOXLQXPăU)LERQDFFL`
JJ úă JJ
J
?JJ ^FDUHHVWHFHOPDLDSURSLDWGHQXPăUXO
`
ú JJăJ
JzJ
?JJ
JJJJ
J~J
6XPăGHQXPHUH)LERQDFFL JJJJ%
?J
JJ úă
6ROXĠLDSUH]HQWDWăvQFRQWLQXDUHGHWHUPLQăFHOPDLDSURSLDWQXPăU)LERQDFFLGHQXPă ú J
UXOGDWGXSăFDUHDOJRULWPXOUHSHWăUHFXUVLYDFHHDúLDFĠLXQHSHQWUXGLIHUHQĠDGLQWUHQX
PăUXOGDWúLQXPăUXO)LERQDFFLJăVLW J ÌQSURJUDPXOSULQFLSDOVXQWGHVFULVHXUPăWRDUHOHDFĠLXQL
ÌQYDULDQWDUHFXUVLYăDDOJRULWPXOXLGHUH]ROYDUHYRPLQLĠLDOL]DvQSUHDODELOHOHPHQ ± VHFLWHúWHQXPăUXOGDW
WHOHúLUXOXLOXL)LERQDFFLSkQăODFHOPDLDSURSLDWQXPăUGHQXPăUXOGDW$VWIHOYRP ± VHDSHOHD]ăLQLĠLDOL]DUHDFDUHGHWHUPLQăúLLQGLFHOHFHOXLPDLDSURSLDWQXPăU)LER
HYLWD UHFDOFXODUHD UHSHWDWă D XQRU WHUPHQL GLQ úLUXO OXL )LERQDFFL FHHD FH DU vQFHWLQL QDFFLPDLPLFVDXHJDOFXQXPăUXOGDW
H[HFXĠLDSURJUDPXOXL ± VHDILúHD]ăQXPăUXOGDWXUPDWGHVHPQXO\
± VH DSHOHD]ăVXESURJUDPXOUHFXUVLYSRUQLQGGHODFHOPDLPDUHQXPăU)LERQDFFL
J
Ġ
QJ GLQGHVFRPSXQHUHDQXPăUXOXLGDW
^JHQHUăPLWHUPHQLDLúLUXOXLOXL)LERQDFFLXOWLPXOWHUPHQJHQHUDWHVWH`
^FHOPDLDSURSLDWQXPăU)LERQDFFLPDLPLFVDXHJDOFXQXPăUXOGDW`
JJ
JmJJ /DFXOHV
JJ
JmJJ 5H]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHvQVHDPQăJăVLUHDUăVSXQVXOXLODGRXăFHULQĠH
JJJmJJ D GHWHUPLQDUHD QXPăUXOXL PD[LP GH PHUH FDUH SRW IL FXOHVH SULQWUR SDUFXUJHUH
JJ
J
JJ
J
ăJ FRQIRUPHQXQĠXOXL
JJJJJmJ~J EGHWHUPLQDUHDGUXPXOXLFDUHDFRQGXVODVROXĠLDRSWLPă
JJJJ
JmJ
J~J
J
JJ ú
DğLQkQGFRQWGHIDSWXOFăGHSODVDUHDVHSRDWHIDFHGRDUSHGRXăGLUHFĠLLQXPăUXOPD
JJ
JmJJ [LPGHPHUHFDUHSRWILFXOHVHVHSRDWHGHWHUPLQDSkQăvQRULFHSXQFWDOOLYH]LL$FHVWH
ú LQIRUPDĠLLVHYRUFRQVWUXLSDVFXSDVúLVHYRUVWRFDvQWUXQWDEORXELGLPHQVLRQDOE
3ULPXOHOHPHQWDOWDEORXOXLEYDILE>@FDUHYDILLQLĠLDOL]DWFXQXPăUXOGHPHUH
8QDOWVXESURJUDPXWLOvQUH]ROYDUHDSUREOHPHLHVWHFHOFDUHGHWHUPLQăLQGLFHOHGLQ DOHSULPXOXLSRPD>@DIODWSHGLUHFĠLDGHSRUQLUHÌQFRQWLQXDUHYRPSXWHDFRP
úLUXO)LERQDFFLFDUHFRUHVSXQGHXQXLQXPăU)LERQDFFLGDW SOHWDSULPDOLQLHGDFăSăVWUăPGLUHFĠLDGHSRUQLUHSkQăODFDSăWXOOLYH]LLúLSULPDFR
J ORDQăDWDEORXOXLELGLPHQVLRQDOGDFăVHXUPHD]ăGLUHFĠLDvQMRV6ăXUPăULPDFHúWLSDúL
SHH[HPSOXOGDWvQHQXQĠ
5HFXUVLYLWDWH 5HFXUVLYLWDWH
J`J|J`J úLDúDPDLGHSDUWHSkQăFkQGVDXFDOFXODWWRDWHHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXLELGLPHQVLRQDOE
`J|`J`JJ 9DORDUHD GLQ FROĠXO GUHDSWD MRV E>P Q@ YD IL HJDOă FX QXPăUXO PD[LP GH PHUH
`J||J`JJ FDUHSRWILFXOHVHODRSDUFXUJHUHDOLYH]LL
JJ`JJ
$OJRULWPXOHVWHVLPLODUFHOXLGHPDLVXV FXUVLYă
J J^FUHDUHDSULPHLFRORDQH` 0RGDOLWDWHDGHUHJăVLUHDGUXPXOXLSHFDUHDIRVWGHWHUPLQDWăYDORDUHDPD[LPăVH
J
J\J
ă, ^VHDGXQăODQXPăUXOPD[LP` SRDWHLQWXLGLQWDEHOXODQWHULRU6HSRUQHúWHGHODHOHPHQWXOE>PQ@úLVHYHULILFăGDFă
ODDFHDYDORDUHDPDMXQVGHODHOHPHQWXOGHGHDVXSUDVDXGHODHOHPHQWXOGLQVWkQJDVD
JJJJmJ~JJ ^GHPHUHGHSHSR]LĠLDGHGHDVXSUDSR]LĠLHL`
&DOFXOăP± úL± 'HRDUHFHD>PQ@ VHWUDJHFRQFOX]LD
ú
^FXUHQWHQXPăUXOGHPHUHGLQSRPXOFXUHQW`
J
FăDPDMXQVvQE>PQ@GLQE>PQ±@ÌQYHFWRUXOUH]XOWDWLQWURGXFHPFDUDFWHUXO
GHRDUHFHDPDYDQVDWvQDFHDVWăSR]LĠLHPHUJkQGVSUHGUHDSWD
'LQDFHVWPRPHQWVHSRDWHvQFHSHFRPSOHWDUHDUHVWXOXLWDEORXOXLSHOLQLLvQFHSkQG ÌQPRGVLPLODUVHUHIDFHWRWGUXPXO5HVWXOFDUDFWHUHORUOHDOLSLPPHUHXvQIDĠDúL
FXOLQLDVDXSHFRORDQHvQFHSkQGFXFRORDQDFDOFXODUHDYDORULLILHFăUXLHOHPHQW UXOXL UH]XOWDW FRUHVSXQ]ăWRU XQXL SDV FDUH SH GUXP HVWH PDL DSURDSH GH SXQFWXO GH
QHDSăUDWvQRUGLQHVHYDIDFHSULQDOHJHUHDQXPăUXOXLPD[LPGHSRPLvQWUHYDORDUHD VWDUW
GHGHDVXSUDúLFHDGLQVWkQJDFDUHVXQWGHMDFDOFXODWHSOXVQXPăUXOGHPHUHGLQSR ÌQFD]XOVXESURJUDPHORUUHFXUVLYHHVWHHVHQĠLDOVăVHGHWHUPLQHFRUHFWFRQGLĠLDGH
PXOODFDUHQHDIOăP RSULUHúLIRUPXODUHFXUHQWăGXSăFDUHVHIDFHDXWRDSHOXOÌQFD]XOGHIDĠăQHYRPRSUL
'HH[HPSOX DWXQFLFkQGDPDMXQVODHOHPHQWXOGHLQGLFH2EVHUYăPFăvQWRWGHDXQDVHYDDMXQJH
E>@ PD[LP^`D>@ vQDFHDVWăSR]LĠLHDWDEORXOXLGHRDUHFHDFHVWDDIRVWSXQFWXOGHSOHFDUHvQSULPDSDUWHD
E>@ PD[LP^`D>@ DOJRULWPXOXL$FXPVHUHIDFHGUXPXORSWLPSHFDUHVDDMXQVGLQE>@vQE>PQ@
5HFXUVLYLWDWH 5HFXUVLYLWDWH
2EVHUYDĠLH 'DFăFLIUDGHUHSUH]HQWDWHVWHVDXVHIRORVHúWHYDULDQWDDGLWLYăúL
ÌQ DOJRULWPXO GHVFULV DP DSOLFDW PHWRGD SURJUDPăULL GLQDPLFH
6H REVHUYă FHOH DOLSLPVLPEROXULOH,;úL&VDX0
GRXăID]HDOHDOJRULWPXOXLVSHFLILFHDFHVWHLPHWRGHDXIRVW 'DFăYDORDUHDFLIUHLGHUHSUH]HQWDWvQFHSHFXVDXVHIRORVHúWHWRWYDULDQ
&RQVWUXLUHDVROXĠLHLRSWLPH WDDGLWLYăSULQDOLSLUHDVLPEROXULORU9/VDX'úLGXSăFD]FXDOLSLUHDVXSOLPHQ
5HIDFHUHDGUXPXOXLSHFDUHDIRVWREĠLQXWăDFHDVWăVROXĠLH WDUăDVLPEROXULORU,;VDX&vQQXPăUXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRU
'DFăYDORDUHDFLIUHLGHUHSUH]HQWDWvQFHSHFXVHIRORVHúWHYDULDQWDSULQGLIHUHQĠă
6XEDOJRULWPXOUHFXUVLYFDUHUHJăVHúWHGUXPXOSHFDUHDIRVWFRQVWUXLWăVROXĠLDRSWL IDĠăGHVLPEROXO9/VDX'
PăHVWH 'DFăYDORDUHDFLIUHLGHUHSUH]HQWDWvQFHSHFXVHIRORVHúWHYDULDQWDSULQGLIHUHQĠă
IDĠăGHVLPEROXO;&VDX0
JQJ
ăJJzJJJzJJJ ÌQYDULDQWHOHSULQGLIHUHQĠăIRUPXODGHFDOFXOGLIHUăvQIXQFĠLHGHPRGXOvQFDUHVH
JJJJăJJ\JJ~JJJ vQGHSOLQHVFFRQGLĠLLOHúL'HH[HPSOXQXPăUXOVHFDOFXOHD]ăFDGLIHUHQĠăvQWUH
JJJJJJJmJJ~JJ úLGHRDUHFHHVWHHJDOFXR]HFLPHGLQ5HSUH]HQWDUHDURPDQăDQXPăUXOXLHVWH
JJJJJJJ ,;1XPăUXOQXVHSRDWHFDOFXODFDGLIHUHQĠăvQWUHúLFXPDPILvQGUHSWăĠLĠL
JJJJ úă VăVSHUăPSHQWUXFăHVWHPDLSXĠLQGHR]HFLPHGLQÌQDFHVWFD]DSOLFăPFHDODO
JJ
WăYDULDQWăvQFDUHH[SULPăPFDGLIHUHQĠăvQWUHúLFHHDFHHVWHSHUPLVXU
JJJJăJJ\JJ~JJJ PkQGVăUHOXăPDOJRULWPXOSHQWUXGLIHUHQĠDUăPDVă± ÌQILQDOQXPăUXOvQ
JJJJJJJmJ«J~JJ UHSUH]HQWDUHDURPDQăHVWH;&,;
JJJJJJJ
JJJJ úă
JJ úă $P DOHV Vă GHVFULHP DFHVW DOJRULWP vQ YDULDQWD UHFXUVLYă GHRDUHFH PRGDOLWDWHD
ú SUDFWLFăGHUH]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPHHVWHGHILQLWăUHFXUHQWVHGHWHUPLQăROLWHUăUR
J PDQăGXSăFDUHDOJRULWPXOVHDSOLFăLGHQWLFúLSHQWUXQXPăUXOUăPDV
1XPHUHURPDQH ÌQYDULDQWDXUPăWRDUHIRORVLPGRXăFRQVWDQWHGHWLSYHFWRUXQDFRQĠLQkQGYDORULOH
'XSăFXPVHúWLHH[LVWăGRXăPHWRGHGHVFULHUHDXQXLQXPăUvQVLVWHPXOGHQXPHUDĠLH FRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHFLIUHORUURPDQHLDUFHDODOWăFRQĠLQkQGFKLDUOLWHUHOHIRORVLWHvQVFULH
URPDQXQDDGLWLYăúLXQDSULQGLIHUHQĠăDPEHOHPHWRGHDYkQGWRWXúLOLPLWăULGHDSOL UHDURPDQă(VWHGHvQĠHOHVFăSHQWUXRULFHLQGLFHYDORDUHDGLQSULPXOYHFWRUYDFRUHV
FDUH SXQGHOLWHUHLGLQFHOGHDOGRLOHDYHFWRUDVWIHO
ÌQYDULDQWDDGLWLYăGHH[HPSOXQXSXWHPVFULHPDLPXOWGHWUHLOLWHUHFRQVHFXWLYH
LGHQWLFH9DULDQWDSULQGLIHUHQĠăDDSăUXWSHQWUXDSUHVFXUWDQXPHUHOHFDUHDOWIHOHUDX \J¨£KJJ ^YHFWRUGHFDUDFWHUH`J
PXOWSUHDOXQJL3HQWUXFDVFULHUHDVăILHWRWXúLXQLFăVDXHPLVXUPăWRDUHOHUHJXOL
JJJJJJ\```````|````|``|KJJ ^YHFWRUGHQXPHUH`J
1XPDLFLIUHOH,;úL&SRWILVFă]XWH
'RDUYDORDUHDXQHLVLQJXUHFLIUHSRDWHILVFă]XWăQXVHSHUPLWHVFăGHUHDXQXLJUXS (OHPHQWXOGHLQGLFHDUHRYDORDUHQHVHPQLILFDWLYăSHQWUXVLPSOLWDWHDUH]ROYăULL
GHOLWHUH
1XPăUXOFDUHVHVFDGHWUHEXLHVăDLEăRYDORDUHPDLPDUHVDXHJDOăFXR]HFLPHGLQ 'HWHUPLQDUHDRUGLQXOXLGHPăULPHDFLIUHLURPDQHFRUHVSXQ]kQGXQXLQXPăUGDWVH
GHVFă]XW UHDOL]HD]ăvQXUPăWRUXOVXEDOJRULWP
([HPSOX J%
ăQJ
Q &';/,;&' ± DSRL;/ ± úL,; ± ^HVWHRUGLQXOGHPăULPHPD[LPFRUHVSXQGHOLWHUHL,DYkQGYDORDUHD`J
'HFLvQWRWDO JJ
JmJJJ J
'HRVHELPXUPăWRDUHOHVLWXDĠLL JJ
J
JdJ
ăJ
ă,J
JJJJ
JmJ
JJJ
0HWRGDSURJUDPăULLGLQDPLFHVHYDVWXGLDvQFODVDD;D JJ ú
5HFXUVLYLWDWH 5HFXUVLYLWDWH
JJăJ%
ăă
ăJ\JJJJ ăJ%
ăHVWHJ
JJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ JJJJJJăJ
JJ
ăJJ¥```¦JúJ
úă
J J
J
ăJtJ
`J
ú
JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
J
ăJ~J
J
JJJJJJ
3HQWUXQXPHUHOHFDUHvQFHSFXFLIUDVHHIHFWXHD]ăRFRUHFĠLHDVWIHOUDQJXOUHWXUQDW
JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
J~J
J~JJ
YDFRUHVSXQGHVLPEROXULORUGHVFă]XW,;VDX&GXSăFD]vQORFGH9/VDX' J J
ăJJ%
J
JJJJJJ úă
8UPăWRUXOVXEDOJRULWPUHFXUVLYGHWHUPLQăQXPăUXOURPDQFXSDPQRWDWXQúLUGH úă
FDUDFWHUHvQFDUHDPDOLSLWOLWHUHOHLGHQWLFHDWXQFLFkQGDFHVWHDWUHEXLHVăVHUHSHWH úăJ
J ú
J
ăQJ
JJăJ
ăJ\J`JJJ
ÌQvQFKHLHUHÄQXSXWHPUH]LVWDWHQWDĠLHL´úLYăSUH]HQWăPúLRDOWHUQDWLYăLWHUDWLYă
JJJJJmJJ
SHQWUXUH]ROYDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPH&XDUDEDPQRWDWQXPăUXODUDEFXURPDQQXPă
JJ
JJJJ%
ăJ UXOURPDQÌQVXEDOJRULWPXO
VH
JJJJ%
ăJmJ
ă
J FDXWăSăUĠLGLQQXPăUXODUDEDSDUĠLQkQGDQXPLWRULQWHUYDOH$FHVWHDVHVFDGGLQQXPă
^YDULDQWăDGLWLYăFDUHIRORVHúWHOLWHUHOH,;&VDX0` UXODUDEúLvQQXPăUXOURPDQVHDOLSHVFOLWHUHOHFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH SRDWHIL
JJJJăJ%
ăJHVWHVDXJ VDX LDU FDUDFWHUHOH DX YDORUL FRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH RUGLQXOXL GH
JJJJJJJmJJ PăULPHDOXL¨¨£
JJJJJJ
J\%
ăJ
ă,J J
J
QJ
JJJJJJJJJmJJ~J
J
JJJJJJ ú
JJ
JtJJ
ă,J
JJJJJJJmJJ~J
ăJJ%
ă
J JJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ
JJJJ úă JJJJJmJJJJ
^YDULDQWăDGLWLYăvQFDUHFLIUDFXUHQWăVHVFULHIRORVLQGOLWHUD9/VDX'` JJ ú
J
JJJJăJ%
JHVWHVDXJJ JJăJJtJ`JJ
JJJJJJJmJJ JJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ~JJ
JJJJJJ
J\%
ăJ
ă,J JJJJJmJJJ`J
JJJJJJJJJmJJ~J
~J JJ
ú
ăJtJJJ
JJJJJJJmJ
J~JJ~J
ăJJ%
ă
J JJJJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ
úJăJ JJJJJJJmJJJJ
^YDULDQWDSULQGLIHUHQĠă` JJJJ
JJJJăJ%
ăHVWHJ ăJ
J`JJ
JJJJJJăJ
JJ
ăJJ¥```¦JúJ JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ~JJ
JJJJJJJJJJJ
JJ
ăJtJ
`J JJJJJJJJJmJJJ`J
JJJJJJ úăJ
JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
J
ăJ~J
J
úă
JJJJJJ
úăJ
JJJJJJJJ
JmJ
J~J
~J ú J
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
ăJJ%
J
0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ &DSLWROXO
%DFNWUDFNLQJLWHUDWLY
%DFNWUDFNLQJUHFXUVLY
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH
3UREOHPHSURSXVH
6ROXĠLLOHSUREOHPHORU
5HFXUVLYLWDWH
0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJHVWHRPHWRGăGHSURJUDPDUHFXDMXWRUXOFăUHLDVHUH]ROYăSUR
&&& EOHPHOHvQFDUH
JJ
JmJJ x VROXĠLDVHSRDWHUHSUH]HQWDVXEIRUPDXQXLWDEORX; [[«[QFX[0
JJ
```J [0HWF000QILLQGPXOĠLPLILQLWHDYkQGVVVQHOHPHQWH
JJ
``¨J x vQWUHHOHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXL;H[LVWăDQXPLWHOHJăWXULLPSXVHvQHQXQĠ
JJ
`¨£J
J
JJ
\JJ
ă,J^FHHDFHDUăPDVGLQDUDEVHVFULHFXFLIUH,`J &RQGLĠLLLQWHUQH
ÌQILHFDUHSUREOHPăVXQWGDWHDQXPLWHUHODĠLLFDUHWUHEXLHVăH[LVWHvQWUHFRPSRQHQ
JJJJ
JmJ
J~JJ
WHOH[[[QDOHYHFWRUXOXL;QXPLWHFRQGLĠLLLQWHUQH
JJJJJmJJJJ
JJ ú
J 6SDĠLXOVROXĠLLORUSRVLELOH
&&J 0XOĠLPHD0u0uu0QVHQXPHúWHVSDĠLXOVROXĠLLORUSRVLELOH
&RQGLĠLLGHFRQWLQXDUH
'DFăODSDVXONFRQGLĠLLOHLQWHUQHVXQWVDWLVIăFXWHDOJRULWPXOVHFRQWLQXăvQIXQFĠLH
GHFHULQĠH'DFăPDLWUHEXLHFăXWDWHFRPSRQHQWHGHRDUHFHQXPăUXOORUVHFXQRDúWHúL
vQFăQXOHDPREĠLQXWSHWRDWHVDXFRPSRQHQWHOHvQFăQXFRQVWLWXLHRVROXĠLHSHED]D
XQRUSURSULHWăĠLFRQGLĠLLOHGHFRQWLQXDUHYRUSHUPLWHFRQWLQXDUHDDOJRULWPXOXL
6ROXĠLLUH]XOWDW
$FHOH VROXĠLL GLQWUH VROXĠLLOH SRVLELOH FDUH VDWLVIDF FRQGLĠLLOH LPSXVH GH SUREOHPă
FRQGLĠLLOH LQWHUQH úL FRQGLĠLLOH GH FRQWLQXDUH QX FHU FRPSRQHQWH vQ SOXV VH QXPHVF
VROXĠLLUH]XOWDW
2 PHWRGă GH UH]ROYDUH D DFHVWHL FDWHJRULL GH SUREOHPH DU IL GHWHUPLQDUHD WXWXURU
VROXĠLLORUSRVLELOHúLDSRLFăXWDUHDDFHORUDFDUHVDWLVIDFFRQGLĠLLOHLQWHUQH'H]DYDQWDMXO
HVWHXúRUGHREVHUYDWGHRDUHFHWLPSXOFHUXWGHDFHDVWăFăXWDUHHVWHIRDUWHPDUH
0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ 0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ
0RGXOGHOXFUXDOPHWRGHLEDFNWUDFNLQJ
J?JYDORDUHPD[LPăSHUPLVăJúJJ?J
ă,
x (OHPHQWHOHGLQWDEORXO;SULPHVFSHUkQGYDORULDGLFăOXL[NLVHDWULEXLHRYDORDUH ^PDLVXQWYDORULQHWHVWDWHvQPXOĠLPHGHFLOXL?LVHDWULEXLHRDOWăYDORDUH`
QXPDLGDFăDXIRVWGHMDDWULEXLWHYDORULHOHPHQWHORU[[[N± JJJJJJ?JmJ?J~JJ
x ÌQSOXVOXL[NLVHDWULEXLHRYDORDUHQXPDLGDFăSHQWUXYDORULOH[[[N±úLYD JJJJJJ?JJmJ?J ^SRDWHDPJăVLWYDORDUHSRVLELOăSHQWUX?`J
ORDUHDSURSXVăSHQWUX[NVXQWvQGHSOLQLWHFRQGLĠLLOHLQWHUQHúLFHOHGHFRQWLQXDUHLP ú
J
SXVHGHSUREOHPăÌQFD]XOvQFDUHDFHVWHFRQGLĠLLQXVXQWvQGHSOLQLWHRULFXPDP ăJJ?JJJ
DOHJHXUPăWRULLWHUPHQL[N[QQXYRPDMXQJHODRVROXĠLHvQFDUHFRQGLĠLLOHLQ ^GDFăQXVHGHFUHPHQWHD]ă?SHQWUXDDOHJHRYDORDUHQRXăSHQWUXDFHDVWD`J
WHUQHVăILHVDWLVIăFXWH JJJJJJ?JmJ?JJJJ
x 'DFăODSDVXONFRQGLĠLLOHGHFRQWLQXDUHQXVXQWvQGHSOLQLWHWUHEXLHVăVHIDFăRDOWă JJJJ
^GDFăDPDMXQVODVIkUúLWXOJHQHUăULL`
DOHJHUHSHQWUX[NGLQPXOĠLPHD0N ăJ?J\JQXPăUXOGHHOHPHQWHFHUXW ^VDXDOWăFRQGLĠLH`
x 'DFăPXOĠLPHD0NDIRVWHSXL]DWăVDXWHVWDWWRDWHYDORULOHGLQPXOĠLPHVHGHFUH JJJJJJJJVFULHVROXĠLD JJ
PHQWHD]ăNúLVHvQFHDUFăRDOWăDOHJHUHSHQWUX[N±GLQPXOĠLPHD0N± JJJJJJ
JJJJJJJJ?JmJ?J~JJJ ^WUHFHPODXUPăWRUXOHOHPHQWGLQVROXĠLH`J
2EVHUYDĠLL JJJJJJJJ?JmJ`JJ ^LQLĠLDOL]ăPQRXOHOHPHQWGLQWDEORXOVROXĠLH`
± $FHVWHL GHFUHPHQWăUL D OXL N L VH GDWRUHD]ă QXPHOH PHWRGHL H[SULPkQG IDSWXO Fă JJJJJJ úăJ
DWXQFLFkQGQXSXWHPDYDQVDVHDYDQVHD]ăvQVHQVLQYHUVvQDSRLvQVHFYHQĠDFX JJJJ úă
UHQWăDVROXĠLHL ú
J
ú J
± ÌQWUHFRQGLĠLLOHLQWHUQHúLFHOHGHFRQWLQXDUHH[LVWăRVWUkQVăOHJăWXUă2EXQăDOHJH
UHDFRQGLĠLLORUGHFRQWLQXDUHDUHFDHIHFWUHGXFHUHDQXPăUXOXLGHFDOFXOH
%DFNWUDFNLQJUHFXUVLY
%DFNWUDFNLQJLWHUDWLY $OJRULWPXO SRDWH IL LPSOHPHQWDW úL UHFXUVLY IXQFĠLD ? DUH IRUPD SUH]HQ
&RQGLĠLLOH LQWHUQH YRU IL YHULILFDWH vQ VXEDOJRULWPXO ? $FHVWD UHWXUQHD]ă WDWă
DGHYăUDW GDFă DGăXJDUHD FRPSRQHQWHL [N D úLUXOXL VROXĠLH HVWH SRVLELOă úL IDOV vQ FD] X%??QJ
FRQWUDU
JJ\JYDORDUHDPD[LPăLPSXVăGHSUREOHPă
ă,
?QJ JJJJ?JmJJ
JJJJăJ?JJJ
ăJFRQGLĠLLOHLQWHUQHVXQWvQGHSOLQLWHJJ
^GDFăDPDMXQVODVIkUúLWXOJHQHUăULL`
JJJJJmJIDOV
ăJJ?J\JQXPăUXOGHHOHPHQWHFHUXW
JJJJLHúLUHIRUĠDWăJ
úăJ ^VDXDOWăFRQGLĠLHGHFRQWLQXDUH`
JJJJJJJJVFULHVROXĠLD?J
JJJmJDGHYăUDWJ
JJJJJJ
ú J
JJJJJJJJX%??~J
úăJ
*HQHUDUHDVROXĠLLORUVHUHDOL]HD]ăFXVXEDOJRULWPXOX%? úăJ
ú
J
X%?QJ ú
JJ?JmJJ
JJ?JmJ`J 'DFă vQ FRQGLĠLD GH FRQWLQXDUH H[SUHVLD HVWH IRUPDWă GLQ VXEH[SUHVLL ORJLFH
J?J
J`J
ă, UHODĠLRQDOH úL FRQGLĠLD QX HVWH vQGHSOLQLWă SH UDPXUD
YD WUHEXL Vă GHFLGHP
JJJJ?JmJIDOVJJ PRWLYXO SHQWUX FDUH FRQGLĠLD QX HVWH vQGHSOLQLWă 'DFă GH H[HPSOX QXPăUXO GH HOH
0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ 0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ
PHQWHFHUXWVDDWLQVGDUGLQDOWHPRWLYHVROXĠLDREĠLQXWăQXHVWHFRUHFWăúLGHFLQXVH
VFULHDWXQFLHYLGHQWQXDSHOăPVXEDOJRULWPXOX%?SHQWUXYDORDUHDNFLYRPLHúL 3UREOHPHSURSXVH
GLQVXESURJUDPDVLJXUkQGWRWRGDWăUHYHQLUHDODSDVXOSUHFHGHQWúLFăXWDUHDXQHLYDORUL
QRLSHQWUXN± 1XPHUH
6HGăXQWDEORXXQLGLPHQVLRQDOGHQQXPHUHvQWUHJL6ăVHJHQHUH]HWRDWHWDEORXULOHDO
2EVHUYDĠLH WHUQDQWHúLUXULvQFDUHGXSăILHFDUHHOHPHQWVWULFWSR]LWLYXUPHD]ăXQXOVWULFWQHJDWLYúL
$OJRULWPLL GH UH]ROYDUH D SUREOHPHORU FX PHWRGD EDFNWUDFNLQJ vQ SULQFLSLX YRU GXSăILHFDUHHOHPHQWVWULFWQHJDWLYXUPHD]ăXQXOVWULFWSR]LWLYFDUHVăFRQĠLQăHOHPHQ
UHVSHFWDIRUPDJHQHUDOăGHPDLVXVGDUGHILHFDUHGDWăYRPFăXWDSRVLELOLWăĠLOHGHRS WHGLQúLUXOGDWvQRUGLQHDLQLĠLDOăDORU
WLPL]DUHúLLPSOHPHQWăULFkWPDLVXJHVWLYH8QFD]VSHFLDOvOUHSUH]LQWăDFHOHSUREOHPH
vQFDUHVROXĠLDVHFRPSXQHGLQGRXăVDXPDLPXOWHúLUXULFDUHGHVFULXGHH[HPSOX 'DWHGHLQWUDUH
FRRUGRQDWHvQSODQ (OHPHQWHOHWDEORXOXLVHDIOăvQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH$(+"&$XQQXPăUSHROLQLH
'DWHGHLHúLUH
,PSOHPHQWăULVXJHUDWH 6ROXĠLLOHVHYRUVFULHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUH $(+"&'(!2VROXĠLHXQúLUDOWHUQDQWVH
3HQWUXDYăIDPLOLDUL]DFXDQDOL]DSUREOHPHORUFDUHVHUH]ROYăFXPHWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ YDVFULHSHROLQLHÌQFDGUXODFHVWRUúLUXULGRXăQXPHUHYRUILVHSDUDWHSULQWUXQVSDĠLX
SUHFXP FX LPSOHPHQWDUHD SURJUDPHORU GH UH]ROYDUH Yă UHFRPDQGăP Vă vQFHUFDĠL Vă
UH]ROYDĠLXUPăWRDUHOHSUREOHPH 5HVWULFĠLLúLSUHFL]ăUL
JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUSHUPXWăULORUúLUXOXLGHQXPHUHQ x dQdVHGHWHUPLQăSHED]DQXPăUXOXLQXPHUHORUGLQILúLHUXOGHLQWUDUH
DúH]DUHDDUHJLQHSHWDEODGHúDKIăUăFDDFHVWHDVăVHDWDFH x 'DFă GLQ WDEORXO GDW QX VH SRDWH IRUPD QLFL XQ VXEúLU FDUH vQGHSOLQHúWH FHULQĠHOH
JHQHUDUHDSURGXVXOXLVFDODUDGRXăPXOĠLPL SUREOHPHLvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHVHYDVFULHPHVDMXO
JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUDUDQMDPHQWHORUGHQOXDWHFkWHP
JHQHUDUHDWXWXURUSHUHFKLORUGHSDUDQWH]HFDUHVHvQFKLGFRUHFW ([HPSOH
$(+"&$ $(+"&'(!
JHQHUDUHD WXWXURU IXQFĠLLORU LQMHFWLYH FXQRVFkQG PXOĠLPHD GH DUJXPHQWH úL FHD D
J`JJ
YDORULORUIXQFĠLLORU
JJJmJDGHYăUDW J &&&
ú J ăJ£
JJ
J²\
J
ă,
$ILúDUHD XQHL VROXĠLL VH UHDOL]HD]ă VFULLQG HOHPHQWHOH WDEORXOXL D FRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUH JX%?²J
JJJJ ú
J
LQGLFLORUGDĠLvQúLUXO['HRDUHFHúLUXULOHVROXĠLHDXOXQJLPHYDULDELOăWUHEXLHWUDQVPLV JJ
J
JJ
FDSDUDPHWUXúLOXQJLPHDNDORU úă
&&&
0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ 0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ
ăJ?J\JJJ%?J
5HFKL]LWH JJJJJJ
'HRDUHFHvQSUREOHPăVHFHUWRDWHPRGDOLWăĠLOHGHFKHOWXLUHDVXPHL6RYRPUH]ROYD ^H[LVWăvQWRWDORELHFWHGLQFDUHHOHYXOvúLIDFHFXPSăUăWXULOH`
SULQPHWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ3UREOHPDUHYLQHODDVFULHXQQXPăUvQWUHJVXEIRUPDXQHL JJJJJJJJJ?JJJJJ J
VXPHGHWHUPHQLQXPHUHvQWUHJLDGLFăVXPD6GDWăWUHEXLHGHVFRPSXVăvQIXQFĠLHGH JJJJJJJJJJX%??~KJ
UHVWULFĠLLOHLPSXVHvQHQXQĠXOSUREOHPHL JJJJJJJJ úăJ
7DEORXOVROXĠLH[YDFRQĠLQHSHSR]LĠLDLQXPăUXOGHRELHFWHGHSDSHWăULHGHWLSXOL JJJJJJ úăJ
SHFDUHHOHYXOOHFXPSăUăFXDOWHFXYLQWHLUHSUH]LQWăLQGLFHOHGLQWDEORXOGHDUWLFROH JJJJ úăJ
JJ ú
J
GHSDSHWăULHúL[LUHSUH]LQWăFDQWLWDWHDGLQDUWLFROXODYkQGLQGLFHOHL ú J
ÌQUH]ROYDUHIRORVLPXQVXEDOJRULWPFDUHFDOFXOHD]ăFRVWXOWRWDODOSURGXVHORUFXP
SăUDWHSkQăODLQFOXVLYSDVXOFXUHQWN 'DFăQXVHSRDWHVFULHQLFLRVROXĠLHvQILúLHUVHYDVFULHPHVDMXO
J?QJ
JJJmJ`J ([SUHVLL
J\?J
ă, 3UREOHPDVHUH]ROYăSULQPHWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJGHRDUHFHGRULPVăREĠLQHPWRDWHVROX
J J ^EXFăĠLGLQSURGXVXOFDUHFRVWă
`J ĠLLOHFDUHUHVSHFWăFHULQĠHOHSUREOHPHL3HQWUXDFHDVWDDPUHĠLQXWYDORULOHRSHUDQ]LORUvQ
JJJJJmJJ~JJJ
J WDEORXOD9RPJHQHUDWRDWHWDEORXULOH[FDUHFRQĠLQRSHUDWRULFRGLILFDĠLDVWIHO
úE
J DGXQDUH
JJJmJJ VFăGHUH
ú vQPXOĠLUH
vPSăUĠLUH
ÌQDOJRULWPVHYHULILFăODILHFDUHSDVGDFăFKHOWXLHOLOHUHDOL]DWHSkQăODSDVXOFXUHQW 9RPJHQHUDXQúLUGHRSHUDWRULúLODILHFDUHDGăXJDUHDXQXLRSHUDWRUvQúLUXO[YRP
QXGHSăúHVFVXPDGHEDQLSHFDUHRDUHHOHYXOODGLVSR]LĠLH$FHVWWHVWVHUHDOL]HD]ăvQ FDOFXODUH]XOWDWXOFXUHQWDOH[SUHVLHL'DFăRSHUDWRUXOSHFDUHODPDGăXJDWSHSR]LĠLDN
FDGUXOXQXLVXEDOJRULWPGHYDOLGDUH HVWHDGLFăXUPHD]ăVăHIHFWXăPRvPSăUĠLUHYHULILFăPGDFăUH]XOWDWXOREĠLQXWHVWHXQ
QXPăUvQWUHJVDXQX
JQJ 3HQWUXUH]ROYDUHDYHPQHYRLHGHXQVXEDOJRULWPFDUHFDOFXOHD]ăYDORDUHDH[SUHVLHL
JJJmJ?JdJJ LQFOXVLYODSDVXOFXUHQWN
ú
J%?QJ
6XEDOJRULWPXOFDUHLPSOHPHQWHD]ăPHWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJDUHFkWHYDSDUWLFXODULWăĠL JJJmJJ
x )LHFDUH HOHPHQW GLQ úLU UHSUH]HQWkQG FDQWLWăĠL GH SURGXVH SRDWH DYHD FD YDORDUH
J\?J
ă,
PD[LPăYDORDUHDFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHGLQúLUXO
% JJJJăJ\JJJmJJ~J~J
x 'LQPRPHQWFHQXHVWHREOLJDWRULXVăVHFXPSHUHGLQILHFDUHRELHFWHVWHSRVLELOăúL JJJJ
J
FDQWLWDWHD JJJJJJăJ\JJJmJJJ~J
JJJJJJ
J
x 'DFăODXQDQXPLWSDVFRVWXORELHFWHORUGHMDFXPSăUDWHHVWHHJDOFXVXPDGHĠLQXWă
JJJJJJJJăJ\JJJmJJJ~J
GHHOHYDWXQFLDFHDVWDVHFRQVLGHUăDILRVROXĠLHúLVHVFULHvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHDOW
JJJJJJJJ
JJmJJJ~J
IHOVHvQFHDUFăFXPSăUDUHDDvQFăXQXLRELHFW
JJJJJJJJ úă
JJJJJJ úă
X%??QJ
JJJJ úăJ
J\`
%?J
ă ^FDQWLWăĠLSRVLELOHvQWUHQLPLFúLPD[LP` JJ ú
JJJJ?JmJJ JJ%JmJJ
ăJ?J ú
0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ 0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ
ÌQSURJUDPXO3DVFDOYDULDELODORFDOăVúLIXQFĠLD%?YRUILGHWLSGLQ 0DúLQXĠH
FDX]DFăYRPIRORVLRSHUDWRUXO $FHDVWăSUREOHPăVHUH]ROYăSULQPHWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJGHRDUHFHWUHEXLHJHQHUDWHWRDWH
&RQGLĠLLOH LQWHUQH vQ DFHDVWă SUREOHPă DX IRVW GHILQLWH vQ HQXQĠ WRDWH UH]XOWDWHOH VROXĠLLOHÌQDFHDVWăLGHHYRPUHDOL]DXUPăWRDUHDFRGLILFDUHDGDWHORU
SDUĠLDOHWUHEXLHVăILHQXPHUHvQWUHJL6XEDOJRULWPXO?YDUHWXUQDDGHYăUDW x [YDILúLUXOVROXĠLHúLYRPSăVWUDvQ[LQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOFXWLHLvQFDUHSXQHP
vQFD]DILUPDWLYúLIDOVHvQFD]FRQWUDU PDúLQXĠDL
x vQúLUXOQULSăVWUăPQXPăUXOFDQWLWDWHDPDúLQXĠHORUSXVHvQFXWLDL
J?QJ x vQúLUXOSXVLYRPDYHDYDORDUHDDGHYăUDWGDFăPDúLQXĠDLDIRVWSXVăGHMDvQVROXĠLD
JJJmJJ?J\JJúJJ FXUHQWăLDUvQFD]FRQWUDUSXVLYDDYHDYDORDUHDIDOV
J J %??~JzJ%??~J
ú ([HPSOX
)LHQ úLP
$OJRULWPXOGHEDFNWUDFNLQJDUHFkWHYDSDUWLFXODULWăĠL [ FXVHPQLILFDĠLDFăDWkWPDúLQXĠDFkWúLPDúLQXĠDVHLQWURGXFvQFXWLD
x (OHPHQWHOHGLQVROXĠLD[YRUDYHDYDORULGHODODGHRDUHFHFHLSDWUXRSHUDWRULV [ PDúLQXĠDVHLQWURGXFHvQFXWLDúLPDúLQXĠDvQFXWLD
DXFRGLILFDWFXFLIUH [ PDúLQXĠDVHLQWURGXFHvQFXWLDúLPDúLQXĠDvQFXWLD
x *HQHUDUHDVHvQFKHLHDWXQFLFkQGVDDMXQVODSDVXOQ±úLYDORDUHDH[SUHVLHLHVWH [ DPEHOHPDúLQXĠHVHLQWURGXFvQFXWLD
HJDOăFXP
x 9DORDUHD H[SUHVLHL VH FDOFXOHD]ă DSHOkQG VXEDOJRULWPXO %? GHVFULV PDL 3HQWUXUH]ROYDUHDSUREOHPHLDYHPQHYRLHGHXQDOJRULWPFDUHYHULILFăFRQGLĠLLOHGH
VXV FRQWLQXDUH$PSXWHDQXPăUDDSDULĠLLOHILHFăUHLFXWLLSkQăODSDVXOFXUHQWNúLDPSXWHD
x 'DFăQXVDDMXQVODSDVXOQ±VHFRQWLQXăJHQHUDUHD YHULILFD DSRL GDFă QXPHUHOH REĠLQXWH QX VXQW FXPYD PDL PDUL GHFkW P 5HQXQĠăP OD
DFHDVWăLGHHúLYRPYHULILFDODILHFDUHSDVNGDFăPDúLQXĠDNQXHVWHSXVăGHMDvQYUHR
X%??QJ FXWLHúLGDFăFXWLDvQFDUHYUHPVRSXQHPQXHVWHGHMDSOLQăIRORVLQGXQHGHúLUXULOH
JJ
J\J
ă, ^DYHPRSHUDWRULSRVLELOL`J SXVúLQU
JJJJ?JmJJ ^SXQHPXQRSHUDWRUvQúLUXOVROXĠLH`J J
JJJJă?J ^YHULILFăPFRQGLĠLLOHLQWHUQH` J?QJ
^GDFăDPREĠLQXWRVROXĠLH` JJJmJ
JJJúJJ?J
JJJJJJăJ?J\J
JúJ%?J\JJJJ J ú J
JJJJJJJJ
úJ ^RDILúăP`J
JJJJJJ
$ILúDUHD FHUXWă vQ HQXQĠ DUH XQ IRUPDW VSHFLDO DGLFă WUHEXLH Vă VFULHP FXYkQWXO
ăJ?JJ
JJJ ^GDFăPDLDYHPRSHUDQ]L`J ÄFXWLD´DSRLQXPăUXOGHRUGLQHDOFXWLHLúLGXSăQJQXPHUHOHPDúLQXĠHORUFDUHVXQW
JJJJJJJJJJX%??~J ^vQFHUFăPVăOHSODVăPvQH[SUHVLH`J vQDFHDFXWLHVHSDUDWHSULQFkWHXQVSDĠLX6XEDOJRULWPXOSULQFDUHREĠLQHPDILúDUHDFH
úăJ UXWăHVWH
úăJ
JJJJ úăJ J
úQJ
JJ ú
J
J\
J
ă,J
ú J JJJJ
J%JQJ2
\
J
ă,J
ÌQHQXQĠXODFHVWHLSUREOHPHVHFHUHFDvQFD]XOvQFDUHSHQWUXH[SUHVLDJHQHUDWăQX JJJJJJăJJ\JJJ
JJJ
JJJJJJ úăJ
VH SRDWH REĠLQH UH]XOWDWXO P SULQWUR FRPELQDĠLH GH RSHUDWRUL Vă VH DILúH]H PHVDMXO ú
J
$WXQFLFkQGDILúăPRVROXĠLHVFKLPEăPYDORDUHDYDULDELOHLERROHHQH JJ ú
J
JOREDOH vQ DGHYăUDW XUPkQG FD vQ SURJUDPXO SULQFLSDO Vă YHULILFăP YDORDUHD ú J
DFHVWHLYDULDELOHúLVăVFULHPvQILúLHUXOGHLHúLUHPHVDMXOUHVSHFWLY
0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ
0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ
`J`J`J`J`J`J`J`J`JJ 2
$OJRULWPXOGHEDFNWUDFNLQJvQIRUPăUHFXUVLYăHVWH `JJ`J`J`J`J`JJJ`J
`JJ`J`JJ`J`JJJ`J 2 2 2
X%??QJ `J`J`J`JJ`J`J`J`J`JJ ) 2 2 2
JJ
J\
J
ă, ^SXWHPDOHJHGLQWUHQFXWLL` `JJ`J`J`J`J`J`J`J`JJ 2
JJJJ?JmJJ ^vQFHUFăPVăSXQHPPDúLQXĠDNvQFXWLDL` `JJ`JJ`JJJJ`J`JJ
2
JJJJăJ?JJJ ^GDFăHVWHSRVLELO` `JJ`JJ`J`J`JJ`J`JJ
`JJJJ`JJ`J`J`J`J 2 2 0 2 )
JJJJJJ?JmJDGHYăUDW ^RSXQHPGHFLPDúLQXĠDNHVWHSXVă` `J`JJ`J`J`JJJ`J`JJ 2 2 2
JJJJJJ
JmJ
J~J ^FUHúWHQXPăUXOPDúLQXĠHORUvQFXWLDL` `JJ`JJ`J`J`J`J`J`J
JJJJJJăJ?J\J
J ^GDFăDPSXVúLDQDPDúLQXĠă` 2 ) 2 )
JJJJJJJJ
ú ^DYHPRVROXĠLHRDILúăP` 2 2 2
JJJJJJ
J 2 2 (
JJJJJJJJX%??~ ^vQFD]FRQWUDUvQFHUFăPVăSODVăPXUPăWRDUHDPDúLQXĠă`
úăJJJJJ ÌQ ILJXUă VXQW PDUFDWH FRPSDUWLPHQWHOH 2
JJJJJJ?JmJIDOV ^ODUHYHQLUHVFRDWHPPDúLQXĠDNGLQFXWLDL` LQFHQGLDWHFRPSDUWLPHQWHOHvQFDUHVHDIOă 2 2 2 2 2
JJJJJJ
JmJ
JJ ^GHFLGHVFUHúWHQXPăUXOPDúLQXĠHORUvQFXWLDL` REVWDFROH ORFXO XQGH VH DIOă PDJD]LRQHUXO 2 ) 2 2 2 2
JJJJ úă úLLHúLUHD
JJ ú
J 2 2 2 2
(QXQĠXO SUREOHPHL SUHFL]HD]ă Fă QX VH
ú J 2 2 2 2
SRDWH WUHFH SULQ ]RQHOH YHFLQH LQFHQGLXOXL
=RQH YHFLQH FX IRFXO SH ED]D HQXQĠXOXL 2 2 0 2 ) 2
ÌQDFHDVWăLPSOHPHQWDUHDPHWRGHLEDFNWUDFNLQJDPvQORFXLWWUDYHUVDUHDúLUXOXLVR
VXQWWRDWHFăVXĠHOHvQYHFLQDWHSHRUL]RQWDOă 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
OXĠLHLFXVFRSXOGHDYHULILFDGDFăRDQXPLWăFRPSRQHQWăQXHVWHGHMDSUH]HQWăvQVROX
YHUWLFDOăúLGLDJRQDOă3ULQXUPDUHYRPPDU 2 ) 2 2 ) 2
ĠLHSULQXWLOL]DUHDúLUXOXLGHYDORULORJLFHÌQSOXVSHQWUXRPDLXúRDUăYHULILFDUHD
FDDFHVWH]RQHFDILLQGRFXSDWHGHÄREVWDFR 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
VSDĠLXOXLRFXSDWvQFXWLLQHDPIRORVLWGHúLUXO
&HHDFHDSDUHFDHOHPHQWQRXGLQ OH´'HSR]LWXODUDWăDFXPvQIHOXOXUPăWRU
DFHDVWăFDX]ăVHSRDWHIRUPXODvQIHOXOXUPăWRUvQPRPHQWXODOHJHULLXQHLFRPSRQHQ 2 2 (
WHGLQVSDĠLXOVROXĠLLORUSRVLELOHSHQWUXVROXĠLDFXUHQWăWRDWHHQWLWăĠLOHFDUHVXQWÄDWLQ
VH´ GH DFHDVWă DOHJHUH VH PRGLILFă vQ PRG FRUHVSXQ]ăWRU ? GHYLQH DGHYăUDW ÌQVHFYHQĠDGHDOJRULWPFDUHUHDOL]HD]ăDFHDVWăSUHOXFUDUHDGHSR]LWXOXLIRORVLPúLUXO
2 FOX]LDFăWUHEXLHVăJăVLPRPRGDOLWDWHFDUHQXH[HFXWăLQWHJUDOSURFHGXUDFDUHLPSOH
2VROXĠLHSHQWUXH[HPSOXOFRQVLGHUDW 2 2 2 2 2 PHQWHD]ăPHWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJGHGRXăRUL
HVWHYL]XDOL]DWăvQILJXUDXUPăWRDUH2E 2 ) 2 2 2 2 0DLvQWkLQHSURSXQHPVăJăVLPRUH]ROYDUHvQFDUHVRH[HFXWăPRVLQJXUăGDWă
VHUYăP Fă WUDVHXO WUHFH LQXWLO SULQSR]L 2 2 2 2 'DFăDPSXWHDVWDELOLPLQLPXOúLUXOXLWUDYHUVkQGXORVLQJXUăGDWăDPJăVLWVLPSOLIL
ĠLLOH ± GDU DFHVW OXFUX QX FRQVWLWXLH 2 2 2 2 FDUHDSHFDUHQHDPSURSXVR
JUHúHDOă GLQ PRPHQW FH QX VDX FHUXW 2 2 2 ) 2 ÌQXUPăWRUXODOJRULWPSUHVXSXQHPFăVHFDXWăPDLVLPSOXWRDWHSR]LĠLLOHGLQúLUXO
WUDVHHGHOXQJLPHPLQLPă 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 [ SH FDUH VH DIOă YDORDUHD PLQLPă D úLUXOXL [ 5H]XOWDWXO VH YD IXUQL]D SURJUDPXOXL
2 ) 2 2 ) 2 DSHODQWvQúLUXOUH]GHOXQJLPHM
2 2 2 2 2 2 2 J
2 2 J
QJ
JJ
JmJJ
JJJmJJ
&DOúLQHEXQSHWDEODGHúDK JJJmJJ
ÌQILJXUDGHPDLMRVVXQWKDúXUDWHSR]LĠLLOHSHFDUHEDWHQHEXQXOFkQGVHDIOăSHSR]LĠLD
JJ\JJ
J
ăJ
1DYkQGFRRUGRQDWHOH&DOXOVHDIOăLQLĠLDOvQSR]LĠLDGHVWDUWPDUFDWăFX& JJJJăJ
J
JJJ
úLWUHEXLHVăDMXQJăvQSR]LĠLDILQDOă)(ODUHGRXăWUDVHHGHDFHHDúLOXQJLPHPL JJJJJJJmJJ
QLPăSHQWUXDDMXQJHvQSR]LĠLDILQDOăVLDQXPH JJJJJJJmJJ
JJJJJJ
JmJJ
JJJJ
JJ
JJJJJJăJ
J\JJJ
JJJJJJJJJmJJ~JJ
& 1 JJJJJJJJJmJJJ
úă
úă
ú
) ú
'DUvQFD]XOQRVWUXWUHEXLHUHĠLQXWHVROXĠLLFDUHVXQWúLUXULGHFRRUGRQDWHúLQXGRDU
LQGLFL $OHJHP DOWă FDOH GH UH]ROYDUH 9RP VFULH UH]XOWDWXO FXUHQW vQ ILúLHU úL DWXQFL
3ULPDREVHUYDĠLHSHFDUHRIDFHPVHUHIHUăODIDSWXOFăvQHQXQĠVHFHUWRDWHVROXĠLLOH FkQGJăVLPXQXOFDUHFRUHVSXQGHDFHOXLDúLPLQLPGHVFKLGHPILúLHUXOFX
úLvO
SUREOHPHLFDUHFRUHVSXQGFHULQĠHORUÌQDFHVWPRPHQWúWLPFăPHWRGDGHUH]ROYDUHYD VFULHPLDUFkQGJăVLPRVROXĠLHFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHXQXLPLQLPPDLPLFGHFkWFHOFXUHQW
ILEDFNWUDFNLQJ$QDOL]kQGFHULQĠHOHFRQVWDWăPFăWUHEXLHVăGHWHUPLQăPXQPLQLPÌQ GHVFKLGHPILúLHUXOFXDVWIHOvQFHSkQGVFULHUHDJUXSXOXLQRXGHVROXĠLL
DFHDVWăSUREOHPăPLQLPXOQXHVWHGRDUXQQXPăUFDUHGHDOWIHOQLFLQXWUHEXLHDILúDW 6H SRDWH REVHUYD Fă SH OkQJă DFHDVWă PRGDOLWDWH PDL H[LVWă úL DOWHOH FDUH UH]ROYă
ODLHúLUHFLXQúLUGHFRRUGRQDWHGHSHWDEODGHúDKFDUHFRUHVSXQGWUDVHXOXLGHOXQJL SUREOHPD'HH[HPSOXSXWHPÄSUHVXSXQH´FăWUDVHXOPLQLPDUHOXQJLPHDPLQLPă
PHPLQLPăÌQSOXVVHFHUWRDWHDFHVWHúLUXUL $SHOăPSURFHGXUDX%?úLFăXWăPWUDVHHDYkQGDFHDVWăOXQJLPH'DFăJă
0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ 0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ
VLPXQDVWIHOGHWUDVHXvOVFULHPvQILúLHUGDFăQXDWXQFLPăULPYDORDUHDPLQLPXOXLOD UHFHQXDUHVHQVVăGHWHUPLQăPVROXĠLLFDUHFRQGXFODROXQJLPHPDLPDUHGHFkWFHD
úLFăXWăPWUDVHHDYkQGDFHDVWăOXQJLPH$OJRULWPXOVHRSUHúWHHYLGHQWDWXQFLFkQG SURSXVăGLQPRPHQWFHDFHVWHDQXVHYDORULILFă
DP JăVLW FHO SXĠLQ R VROXĠLH FDUH FRUHVSXQGH PLQLPXOXL SUHVXSXV OD SDVXO UHVSHFWLY ÌQFRQFOX]LHDOJRULWPXOUHFXUVLYFDUHLPSOHPHQWHD]ăPHWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJHVWHXU
6XQWHPVLJXULFăDVWIHOJăVLPVROXĠLLOHFRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHPLQLPXOXLGHRDUHFHDPOXDWvQ PăWRUXO
FRQVLGHUDUHYDORULOHSRVLELOHvQRUGLQHFUHVFăWRDUH$FHVWDOJRULWPHVWHXUPăWRUXO
JX%?QJ
QJ JJ
J?\J
ă,J
JJ
JmJJ JJJJJmJJ~J? ^LQGLFHOHGHOLQLHDSR]LĠLHLQRL`
JJ?JmJIDOVJ JJJJJmJJ~J? ^LQGLFHOHGHFRORDQăDSR]LĠLHLQRL`
JJ
ăJ ^GDFăSR]LĠLDDOHDVăHVWHSHWDEOă`
JJJJX%?`Y`
?J JJJJăJJJ¥
¦JúJJJ¥
¦J
JJJJ
JmJ
J~J JJJJJJăJ¨¸JzJ¨Y¸JúJJ\J`JJ
JJ
ăJ?J ^GDFăSR]LĠLDQXVHDIOăSHWUDLHFWRULLOHQHEXQXOXLúL`
ú ^vQDFHDVWăSR]LĠLHQXDPWUHFXWODXQSDVDQWHULRU`
JJJJJJJJJmJJ ^HIHFWXăPSDVXOPDUFăPSR]LĠLD`
6ROXĠLDRYRPFRGLILFDvQWUXQWDEORX FRUHVSXQ]ăWRUWDEOHLGHúDKLQLĠLDOL]kQGXL ^GDFăDPDMXQVvQSR]LĠLDILQDOă`
HOHPHQWHOHFX$WXQFLFkQGvQFăXWDUHDVROXĠLHLHIHFWXăPXQSDVSHUPLVvQWURDQXPL JJJJJJJJăJJ\JJúJJ\JYJ
Wă SR]LĠLH YDORDUHD DFHOXL HOHPHQW YD IL HJDOă FX QXPăUXO GH RUGLQH DO SDVXOXL (YL ^GDFăQXPăUXOSDúLORUHIHFWXDĠLHVWHHJDOFXPLQLPXO`
GHQWODUHYHQLUHYRPDYHDJULMăVăUHVWDELOLPYDORDUHDLQLĠLDOăDHOHPHQWXOXLUHVSHFWLY JJJJJJJJJJăJJ\J
JJJ
SHQWUXFDvQWLPSXOJHQHUăULLXQHLVROXĠLLQRLVăSXWHPHIHFWXDXQSDVvQDFHDVWăSR]LĠLH JJJJJJJJJJJJ
úJ
ÌQSURFHGXUD X%?YRPJHQHUDSR]LĠLLOH FRUHVSXQ]ăWRDUHSD JJJJJJJJJJJJ?JmJDGHYăUDWJ
úLORU QRL SH FDUH XQ FDO OH SRDWH HIHFWXD GLQWUR SR]LĠLH FXUHQWă FX DMXWRUXO D JJJJJJJJJJ úă
JJJJJJJJ
J
GRXă úLUXUL GH FRQVWDQWH úL Y FDUH UHSUH]LQWă GHSODVDPHQWHOH OLQLLORU UHVSHFWLY JJJJJJJJJJăJJJ
J
FRORDQHORUFHORUSR]LĠLLvQFDUHSRDWHVăULXQFDO ^GDFăQXPăUXOSDúLORUHIHFWXDĠLHVWHPDLPLFGHFkWPLQLPXOFXUHQW`
JJJJJJJJJJJJX%?~JJ ^FRQWLQXăPGUXPXO`
\JJKJ
úă
JQ\KJJ
úăJ
JJJJJJQ\KJ
JJJJJJJJJmJ`J
J ^úWHUJHPXUPDSDVXOXLHIHFWXDWGHRDUHFHDPUHYHQLWODRVWDUHDQWHULRDUă`
3HQWUXILHFDUHDVWIHOGHSR]LĠLHQRXăYRPYHULILFDGDFăHDVHDIOăVDXQXSHWDEODGH úă
úDKJJJ
JJJJ
úă
ú
'DFăQHDIOăPSHWDEOăYRPYHULILFDGDFăDFHDVWăSR]LĠLHHVWHvQDIDUDEăWăLLQHEX ú
QXOXLDIODWvQSR]LĠLDYFXLQVWUXFĠLXQHDJJ
JY7RW
RGDWăYHULILFăPúLHOHPHQWXOFRUHVSXQ]ăWRUGLQWDEORXO 'DFăDFHVWHOHPHQWDUHYD $ILúDUHDUH]XOWDWXOXLVHUHDOL]HD]ăSHED]DYDORULORUGLIHULWHGH]HURGLQWDEORXO
ORDUHDvQVHDPQăFăvQFăQXDIRVWLQFOXVvQWUDVHXGHFLSXWHPHIHFWXDXQSDVDLFL 'HRDUHFHúWLPFăQXPăUXODFHVWRUHOHPHQWHHVWH
DFFHVLELOăGHRDUHFHDOJRULWPXO
$FXPYRPYHULILFDGDFăDFHDVWăSR]LĠLHQXHVWHFXPYDFHDILQDOăFD]vQFDUHXUPHD]ă VD WHUPLQDW FkQG DP JăVLW XQ WUDVHX DYkQG FHD PDL PLFă YDORDUH vQ WDEORXO YRP
VăQHFRQYLQJHPFăOXQJLPHDWUDVHXOXLHVWHHJDOăFXOXQJLPHDPLQLPăSURSXVă FăXWDYDORULFXSULQVHvQWUHúL
vQDFHDVWăRUGLQHDILúkQGLQGLFLLGHOLQLHúLGHFR
'DFăDPDWLQVSR]LĠLDILQDOăúLQXPăUXOSDúLORUHVWHHJDOFX
DPREĠLQXWRVROX ORDQăDDFHVWRUD
ĠLHúLRSXWHPDILúDÌQFD]FRQWUDUYRPFRQWLQXDWUDVHXOvQFHSXWGDUQXPDLGDFăQX
PăUXOGHRUGLQHDOSDVXOXLFXUHQWHVWHPDLPLFGHFkWOXQJLPHDPLQLPăSURSXVăGHRD
%LEOLRJUDILH
>$QDV@ 'RUX 3RSHVFX $QDVWDVLX &XOHJHUH GH SUREOHPH GH LQIRUPDWLFă
(GLWXUD$OO%XFXUHúWL
>&HUFD@ (PDQXHOD &HUFKH] &XOHJHUH GH SUREOHPH GH LQIRUPDWLFă (GLWXUD
0HWRGDEDFNWUDFNLQJ 3ROLURP,DúL
>&HUFE@ (PDQXHOD &HUFKH] 0DULQHO ùHUEDQ ,QIRUPDWLFD SHQWUX JLPQD]LX
J
úQJ (GLWXUD3ROLURP,DúL
JJ?JmJJ >&LRU@ $QGUHL &LRURLDQX 3URJUDPH 7XUER 3DVFDO vQ GHWDOLX (GLWXUD 7HRUD
JJ
J?JdJ
J
ăJ %XFXUHúWL
JJJJ
J\
J
ăJ >/RJR@ 'RLQD+ULQFLXF/RJRIăWX&3UREOHPHUH]ROYDWHúLDOJRULWPL(GL
JJJJJJ
J\
J
ăJ WXUD3ROLURP,DúL
JJJJJJJJăJJ\J?J >7KRP@ 7KRPDV+&RUPHQ&KDUOHV(/HLVHUVRQ5RQDOG55LYHVW,QWUR
JJJJJJJJJJ
JJ GXFHUH vQ DOJRULWPL (GLWXUD &RPSXWHU /LEULV $JRUD &OXM1DSRFD
JJJJJJJJJJ?JmJ?J~JJ
JJJJJJJJ úă *D]HWDGHLQIRUPDWLFă±(GLWXUD$JRUD0HGLD7kUJX0XUHú
ú
ú
J
JJ ú
ú J
J