Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SR EN 17181 (2019e
SR EN 17181 (2019e
ICS 75.100
SR EN 17181
sa
rzi
nte
Titlu Lubrifianți
uz intern
ai
soluție apoasă, a lubrifianților complet
re
formulați
ce
Metodă de încercare bazată pe producerea de
du
CO2 ro
ep
dégagement de CO2
AS
el
td
© ASRO Reproducerea sau utilizarea integrală sau parțială a prezentului standard în orice
publicații și prin orice procedeu (electronic, mecanic, fotocopiere, microfilmare etc.) este
interzisă dacă nu există acordul scris prealabil al ASRO
ICS 75.100
English Version
sa
degradation of fully formulated lubricants in an aqueous
rzi
solution - Test method based on CO2-production
nte
Bio-lubrifiants - Détermination de la biodégradabilité Schmierstoffe - Bestimmung der aeroben biologischen
uz intern
ai
aérobie, en solution aqueuse, de lubrifiants Abbaubarkeit ausformulierter Schmiermittel in
complètement formulés - Méthode basée sur le wässrigem Medium - Testmethode basierend auf CO2-
re
dégagement de CO2 Bestimmung
ce
This European Standard was approved by CEN on 14 December 2018.
du
CEN members are bound to comply with the CEN/CENELEC Internal Regulations which stipulate the conditions for giving this
ro
European Standard the status of a national standard without any alteration. Up-to-date lists and bibliographical references
concerning such national standards may be obtained on application to the CEN-CENELEC Management Centre or to any CEN
ep
member.
-R
This European Standard exists in three official versions (English, French, German). A version in any other language made by
translation under the responsibility of a CEN member into its own language and notified to the CEN-CENELEC Management
Centre has the same status as the official versions.
RO
CEN members are the national standards bodies of Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia,
Finland, Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania,
AS
Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland,
Turkey and United Kingdom.
ru
uc
uz intern
el
n td
me
cu
Do
© 2019 CEN All rights of exploitation in any form and by any means reserved Ref. No. EN 17181:2019 E
worldwide for CEN national Members.
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
Contents Page
European foreword....................................................................................................................................................... 3
Introduction .................................................................................................................................................................... 4
1 Scope .................................................................................................................................................................... 5
2 Normative references .................................................................................................................................... 5
3 Terms and definitions ................................................................................................................................... 5
4 Principle ............................................................................................................................................................. 8
sa
5 Test environment ............................................................................................................................................ 8
rzi
6 Reagents ............................................................................................................................................................. 8
nte
7 Apparatus........................................................................................................................................................... 9
uz intern
8 Procedure........................................................................................................................................................ 10
ai
8.1 Preparation of mineral medium ............................................................................................................. 10
re
8.2 Preparation of the test volumes ............................................................................................................. 10
8.2.1 Test sample .................................................................................................................................................... 10
ce
8.2.2 Reference compound .................................................................................................................................. 11
8.2.3
8.2.4 du
Inhibition control ......................................................................................................................................... 11
Elimination control ..................................................................................................................................... 11
ro
8.3 Preparation of the inoculum .................................................................................................................... 11
ep
8.3.3 Pre-conditioning........................................................................................................................................... 11
8.3.4 Pre-exposure ................................................................................................................................................. 11
RO
el
10.2.2 Repeatability.................................................................................................................................................. 15
me
2
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
European foreword
This document (EN 17181:2019) has been prepared by Technical Committee CEN/TC 19 “Gaseous and
liquid fuels, lubricants and related products of petroleum, synthetic and biological origin”, the
secretariat of which is held by NEN.
This European Standard shall be given the status of a national standard, either by publication of an
identical text or by endorsement, at the latest by August 2019, and conflicting national standards shall
be withdrawn at the latest by August 2019.
sa
rzi
Attention is drawn to the possibility that some of the elements of this document may be the subject of
patent rights. CEN shall not be held responsible for identifying any or all such patent rights.
nte
uz intern
This document has been prepared under a mandate given to CEN by the European Commission and the
ai
European Free Trade Association.
re
According to the CEN-CENELEC Internal Regulations, the national standards organisations of the
ce
following countries are bound to implement this European Standard: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria,
Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia,
du
France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta,
ro
Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland,
Turkey and the United Kingdom.
ep
-R
RO
AS
ru
uc
uz intern
el
n td
me
cu
Do
3
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
Introduction
Existing test methods for determination of aerobic biodegradation of organic substances in an aqueous
medium (e.g. numerous ISO and OECD test methods) are widely used. Moreover, all actually existing
ecolabels, international and national regulations and recommendations are working with them.
Testing of organic substances requires a broad scope of preparation tools to maintain comparable
results for all different materials appearing liquid, solid, water-soluble, non-water-soluble or
emulsifiable.
sa
In consequence of this, results may differ regarding the choice of test method, preparation procedure or
inoculum thus leading to low levels of reproducibility and repeatability.
rzi
Fully formulated lubricants (oils or greases or emulsions) are complex mixtures of mostly organic
nte
compounds that are mainly water insoluble. Based on ISO 9439 (resp. OECD 301B) this test method has
been aligned by modifying sample preparation and test procedure for such complex mixtures in order
uz intern
ai
to achieve improved significance of test results. The test method described in this document, however,
was not assessed for greases. The precision statement therefore only applies for lubricating oils.
re
Finally, from customer’s point of view a biodegradation test method for the final product of improved
ce
significance will result in better market transparency, enhanced reputation of “bio-lubricants” and
du
confidence of the customer in this product group. ro
ep
-R
RO
AS
ru
uc
uz intern
el
n td
me
cu
Do
4
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
1 Scope
This document specifies a procedure for determining the degree of aerobic degradation of fully
formulated lubricants. The organic material in a fully formulated lubricant is exposed in a synthetic
aqueous medium under laboratory conditions to an inoculum from activated sludge.
Biodegradation resulting in mineralisation of the organic material can be determined by measuring
released CO2 in a total organic carbon (TOC) analyser. In contrast to existing test methods measuring
released CO2 this method uses a precise preparation procedure for non-water soluble organic material.
sa
The above mentioned method applies to fully formulated lubricants which
rzi
a) are water-soluble, non-water soluble or emulsifiable, and
nte
b) are not toxic and not inhibitory to the test microorganisms at the test concentration.
uz intern
ai
The presence of inhibitory effects is determined as specified in this document.
re
This test method is focused on fresh water as test medium. Tests in sea water are currently not included
in this method, but may be introduced later.
ce
2 Normative references
du
ro
The following documents are referred to in the text in such a way that some or all of their content
ep
constitutes requirements of this document. For dated references, only the edition cited applies. For
undated references, the latest edition of the referenced document (including any amendments) applies.
-R
ISO 9439, Water quality — Evaluation of ultimate aerobic biodegradability of organic compounds in
aqueous medium — Carbon dioxide evolution test
RO
For the purposes of this document, the following terms and definitions apply.
ru
ISO and IEC maintain terminological databases for use in standardization at the following addresses:
uc
el
3.1
n
organic material
me
3.2
aerobic biodegradation
Do
3.3
primary biodegradation
first structural change (transformation) of an organic chemical compound by microorganisms resulting
in the change of a specific property
5
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
3.4
mineralisation
aerobic biodegradation of organic material by microorganisms to yield carbon dioxide, water and
mineral salts of any other elements present and new biomass
3.5
activated sludge
biomass produced in the aerobic treatment of wastewater by the growth of bacteria and other
microorganisms in the presence of dissolved oxygen
sa
3.6
concentration of suspended solids of an activated sludge
rzi
amount of solids obtained by filtration or centrifugation of a known volume of activated sludge and
nte
drying at about 105 °C to constant mass
uz intern
3.7
ai
inoculum
re
sample of activated sludge for the purpose of this test method used in degradation procedures
described in this method
ce
du
3.8
reference compound
ro
organic compound of known biodegradability with a degradation degree of more than 60 %
ep
3.9
-R
part of the organic carbon in water which cannot be removed by specified phase separation
Note 1 to entry For example by centrifugation at 4 000 rpm for 15 min or by membrane filtration using
AS
3.10
total inorganic carbon
uc
TIC
uz intern
el
total amount of inorganic carbon in a water sample arising from carbon dioxide and carbonates
td
3.11
dissolved inorganic carbon
n
DIC
me
part of the inorganic carbon in water which cannot be removed by specified phase separation
cu
Note 1 to entry For example by centrifugation at 4 000 rpm for 15 min or by membrane filtration using
Do
3.12
theoretically released amount of carbon dioxide
ThCO2
theoretical maximum amount of carbon dioxide released from a chemical compound, calculated from
TOC content
Note 1 to entry Expressed in this case as milligrams of carbon dioxide evolved per milligram or gram of test
compound.
6
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
3.13
total organic carbon
TOC
amount of carbon bound in an organic compound
3.14
biochemical oxygen demand
BOD
sa
mass concentration of dissolved oxygen consumed under specified conditions by the aerobic biological
oxidation of a chemical compound or organic matter in water
rzi
Note 1 to entry Expressed in this case as milligrams oxygen uptake per milligram or gram of test compound.
nte
uz intern
3.15
ai
chemical oxygen demand
COD
re
mass concentration of oxygen equivalent to the amount of a specified oxidant consumed by a chemical
ce
compound or organic matter when a water sample is treated with that oxidant under defined
du
conditions ro
Note 1 to entry Expressed in this case as milligrams oxygen consumed per milligram or gram of test compound.
ep
3.16
-R
Note 1 to entry Expressed in this case as milligrams of oxygen uptake per milligram or gram of test compound.
3.17
ru
lag phase
uc
time from the start of a test until adaptation and selection of the degrading microorganisms are
uz intern
achieved and the biodegradation degree of a chemical compound or organic matter has increased to
el
3.18
maximum level of biodegradation
cu
3.19
biodegradation phase
time from the end of the lag phase of a test until about 90 % of the maximum level of biodegradation
has been reached
7
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
3.20
plateau phase
time from the end of the biodegradation phase when the maximum level of biodegradation is reached
until the end of the test
3.21
pre-conditioning
pre-incubation of an inoculum under the conditions of the subsequent test in the absence of the test
chemical compound or organic matter, with the aim of improving the performance of the test by
acclimatization of the microorganisms to the test conditions
sa
3.22
rzi
pre-exposure
nte
pre-incubation of an inoculum in the presence of the test chemical compound or organic matter under
test, with the aim of enhancing the ability of the inoculum to biodegrade the test material by adaptation
uz intern
ai
re
4 Principle
ce
Biodegradation is followed over a specified period by measuring the production of carbon dioxide CO2.
du
The evolution of carbon dioxide (CO2) is determined and compared with the theoretical carbon dioxide
ro
evolution (ThCO2) using the CO2 evolution test as in ISO 9439.
ep
The mineralisation process of a fully formulated lubricant (see also Annex A) is determined using
aerobic microorganisms in a static aqueous test system. The test system contains of a mineral medium,
-R
activated sludge obtained from a waste water treatment plant of mainly domestic waste as the
inoculum and the organic material (the sole source of carbon and energy).
RO
This mixture is stirred in test flasks and aerated using CO2-free air for a maximum time of 28 days. The
amount of carbon dioxide evolved from biological degradation will be collected in external flasks,
AS
If a substance-specific analytical method is available then information on the primary degradability may
be obtained additionally for water-soluble, non-volatile lubricants only.
uc
uz intern
el
5 Test environment
td
Incubation shall take place in the dark or diffused light, at a temperature within a range 20 °C to 25 °C
n
6 Reagents
cu
6.1 Water, preferably of distilled or de-ionized quality, with a DOC content of less than 1 mg/l.
8
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
Stock solution (a)
sa
Dissolve in water and make up to 1 l. The pH of the solution should be 7,4.
rzi
Stock solution (b)
nte
Calcium chloride, anhydrous, CaCl2 27,50 g
uz intern
ai
or
Calcium chloride dihydrate, CaCl2⋅2H2O 36,40 g
re
ce
Dissolve in water and make up to 1 l.
du
Stock solution (c)
ro
Magnesium sulphate heptahydrate, MgSO4⋅7H2O 22,50 g
ep
NOTE Stock solution a) can be stabilized by the addition of one drop of concentrated HCl per litre. If any
uc
precipitate is formed during storage the stock solution is replaced by a freshly prepared one.
uz intern
el
7 Apparatus
td
Ensure that all glassware is thoroughly cleaned and free from organic or toxic matter.
n
me
7.1 Test flasks, allowing aeration, containing hose coupling impermeable to carbon dioxide, and a
method for agitation of the test sample such as shaking of the flasks or stirring inside the flasks.
cu
7.2 Water-bath or constant temperature room (to comply with Clause 5);
Do
7.3 Equipment for production of CO2-free air in order to constantly aerate all test flasks with a
flow rate of approximately 50 ml/min to 100 ml/min air for a maximum of 3 l medium;
7.4 Equipment for measurement of evolved carbon dioxide, consisting of a suitable instrument or
analytical process of sufficient sensitivity, e.g. CO2- or DIC-analysers or titrimetric determination of CO2
after absorption in alkaline solution.
7.5 Centrifuge or device for filtration, capable of producing an acceleration of 4 000 rpm.
9
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
The filtration apparatus shall be equipped with filter material which do not adsorb or release organic
carbon. The pore size shall exhibit a nominal aperture diameter of 0,2 μm to 0,45 μm.
7.6 pH meter, optional
7.7 Equipment for measurement of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) (optional), of sufficient
sensitivity.
Only for sufficiently water-soluble organic material, removal of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) may be
determined (optionally) by measuring the concentration of DOC at the beginning and the end of
incubation to obtain additional information on the biodegradability.
sa
8 Procedure
rzi
nte
8.1 Preparation of mineral medium
uz intern
ai
Mix 10 ml of solution (a) with 800 ml water, then add 1 ml of solutions (b), (c) and (d) and make up to
1 l with water.
re
8.2 Preparation of the test volumes
ce
du
8.2.1 Test sample ro
Add a suitable amount of the lubricant to the test flasks to obtain an organic carbon concentration of
ep
completely, e.g. acetone, toluene, preferably hexane with regard to the complete removal of the
solvent.
RO
The stock solution in the solvent is slowly applied to glass fibre filters (diameter < 50 mm) under a
continuous air stream. The glass fibre filters should be washed with solvent before use in order to
AS
solution) the filter is incubated for 3 h at 40 °C to remove any traces of the solvent. Blank and reference
uc
vessels are treated in the same way by only applying solvent to the glass fibre filters. The filters are
directly applied in the test solutions. The concentration in the stock solution should be as such that
uz intern
el
NOTE 1 A comparison of several preparation procedures is listed in Annex B. For further details please see
DIN 51828-1 [4] or EN ISO 10634.
n
me
Depending on the properties of the test sample and the purpose of the test, other concentrations may be
used. In any case of deviation the added amount needs to be determined precisely and stated in the
cu
report.
Do
Lubricants containing volatile compounds should be tested using closed respirometer method, provided
that suitable conditions are used. Additionally, the content of volatile compounds may be determined
using methods like e.g. ASTM D 5800 [1] or Noack-test DIN 51581 [2].
NOTE 2 ISO 9439 allows organic carbon concentrations between 10 mg/l and 40 mg/l. In case of fully
formulated lubricants, 10 mg/l can result in too low organic material in the test sample, but 40 mg/l can impede
the formation of homogenous test solutions with regard to limited water solubility of most lubricants.
10
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
8.2.2 Reference compound
In order to check the procedure, a reference compound of known biodegradability should be tested in
parallel. Sodium benzoate or aniline may be used when testing water-soluble test compounds; for
poorly soluble test substances High Oleic Reference Oil (HORO) should be used. See Annex C for
detailed information.
Add the reference compound in the mineral medium (6.3) using the same procedure as for the organic
material in the test sample (8.2.1).
8.2.3 Inhibition control
sa
If the organic material is suspected to have toxic potential, use a solution of organic material (8.2.1) and
rzi
reference compound (8.2.2) each at preferably a concentration of organic carbon of 20 mg/l in mineral
medium (8.1).
nte
8.2.4 Elimination control
uz intern
ai
If required (e.g. chemical compounds suspected of hydrolysis or photolysis or volatile compounds etc.
re
are present in a lubricant) use a solution containing test sample (8.2.1) but no inoculum (8.3). The
ce
solution needs to be sterilized by using a suitable toxic substance to avoid microbial activity.
8.3 Preparation of the inoculum
8.3.1 General du
ro
ep
Prepare the inoculum to obtain a microbial population that offers sufficient biodegradation activity.
Validate the activity of the inoculum using a suitable reference compound (8.2.2).
-R
Take a sample of activated sludge collected from the aeration tank of a waste-water treatment plant
dealing predominantly domestic sewage. If necessary, concentrate the sludge by settling, so that the
AS
volume of sludge added to the test assay is minimal but nevertheless fulfils the criteria of 8.2.1.
Mix well and determine the concentration of suspended solids of the activated sludge (e.g. using
ru
ISO 11923).
uc
If it is suspected that the sludge contains inhibiting matter, centrifuge, wash with mineral medium (8.1),
uz intern
el
centrifuge again and suspend in the medium. Keep the sample under aerobic conditions and use
preferably on the day of collection. Use a suitable volume to obtain 30 mg/l of suspended solids with
td
— the quantity of dissolved organic carbon provided by the inoculum should be less than 10 % of the
initial concentration of organic carbon introduced by the test compound.
8.3.3 Pre-conditioning
It may be helpful to precondition the inoculum to reduce the influence of the blank, e.g. by aerating it up
to one week before use.
8.3.4 Pre-exposure
11
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
8.4 Test
Set up the equipment for CO2-free air (7.3) and assemble a sufficient number of test flasks in order to
have
— at least 2 test flasks (FT) for the test sample (8.2.1);
— at least 2 test flasks (Fc) for positive control (8.2.2) containing the reference compound;
— at least 2 test flasks (FB) for blank control containing mineral medium (8.1) and inoculum (8.3.2)
sa
only;
rzi
and optionally, if needed,
nte
— 1 test flask (FI) for inhibition control (8.2.3);
uz intern
ai
— 1 test flask (FS) for abiotic elimination control (see 8.2.4).
re
Table 1 gives an overview on the desired final test matrix.
ce
Add appropriate amounts of mineral medium (8.1) and inoculum (8.3) to the test flasks to obtain the
du
desired final test volume as shown in Table 1. Other test volumes than 3 l are acceptable, in that case all
ro
relevant parameters as well as calculation need to be adjusted. Connect the test flasks with the
equipment for the production of CO2-free air.
ep
Test flask
8.1 8.2.1 8.2.2 8.3
AS
Test sample
FT1 + + - +
ru
FT2 + + - +
uc
Reference control
uz intern
el
Fc1 + - + +
td
Fc2 + - + +
n
me
Blank control
F B1 + - - +
cu
F B2 + - - +
Do
Place all test flasks in a constant temperature room, allow them to reach the desired temperature and
aerate them for 24 h using CO2-free air in order to flush out CO2 already present in the vessels. Seal the
flasks and agitate constantly by either shaking or stirring. In case foaming is observed, keep on agitating
12
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
without flushing with CO2-free air. After the pre-aeration process, connect the air exit of each flask with
the equipment to trap CO2 for further determination.
Add the test compound (8.2.1) and the reference compound (8.2.2) at the desired concentrations to the
respective flasks in accordance with Table 1 and start the test by bubbling CO2-free air through each
flask at a rate of between 50 ml/min and 100 ml/min.
Measure CO2 production using an appropriate analytical procedure. If a nearly constant level of CO2
production is attained (plateau phase) and no further biodegradation is expected, the test is considered
to be completed. Usually the maximum test period shall not exceed 28 days. Optionally the
sa
measurement period can be extended to 35 days or 42 days, if degradation has obviously started but
not reached a plateau phase.
rzi
Determine the pH of all test flasks on the last day of test, acidify all the bottles with between 1 and 10 ml
nte
of concentrated hydrochloric acid to decompose the carbonates and bicarbonates. Continue aeration for
another 24 h, followed by the determination of CO2 for each flask.
uz intern
ai
9 Calculation and reporting of results
re
ce
9.1 Theoretical amount of CO2 released from test sample
du
The theoretical amount of released CO2 (ThCO2) in mg shall be calculated according to Formula (1):
ro
44
ep
ThCO 2 = ρ ⋅ c ⋅ V L ⋅ (1)
12
-R
where
RO
ρc is the concentration of organic carbon of the test sample in sample FT in mg / l, either measured
or calculated from the stock solution of the test sample (8.2.1);
AS
ThCO2 from reference sample and inhibition solution shall be calculated in the same manner.
uc
el
The percentage biodegradation Dm (%) shall be calculated for each test flask FT for every test period
td
∑ mTt − ∑ mBt
me
Dm = (2)
ThCO 2
cu
where
Do
∑ mTt is the mass of carbon dioxide in mg released between start and testing time t;
∑ mBt is the average mass of carbon dioxide in mg in the blank control released between start and
testing time t;
The percentage degradation of reference compound and, if included, abiotic elimination control and/or
inhibition control, shall be calculated in the same manner.
13
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
9.3 Expression of results
Compile a table of measured CO2 release (ΣmTt and ΣmBt) and the percentages of biodegradation Dm
for each test flask and for each measuring interval. Plot a biodegradation curve, in percent, as a function
of time, and indicate lag phase and degradation phase. If comparable results are obtained for the
duplicate test flasks FT (8.4), plot a mean curve, otherwise plot curves for each flask. Similarly plot a
biodegradation curve of the reference compound Fc and, if included, of the abiotic elimination check FS
and the inhibition control FI.
An example of degradation curves is given in Annex D.
sa
Determine the mean value of percent biodegradation in the plateau phase or use the highest value, e.g.
rzi
when the curve decreases in the plateau phase, and indicate this maximum level of biodegradation as
“degree of biodegradation of the test sample” in the test report.
nte
Information on the toxicity of the test sample may be useful in the interpretation of test results showing
uz intern
ai
a low biodegradation. If in flask FI the degradation percentage is < 25 % and insufficient degradation of
the test sample is observed in flasks FT, it can be assumed that the test sample is inhibitory. In this case
re
the test shall be repeated using a lower test concentration. If in the flask FS (abiotic elimination check if
ce
included) a significant amount (> 10 %) of CO2 release is observed, abiotic degradation processes may
have taken place.
du
ro
10 Validity and precision
ep
10.1 Validity
-R
a) the percentage degradation of the positive control Fc is greater than 60 % and not higher than
110 % after 28 d in case of HORO as reference compound
AS
or
ru
the positive control Fc is greater than 60 % after the 14th day in case sodium benzoate or aniline is
uc
el
b) the CO2 production in the blank control FB at the end of the test, which is usually at around
td
If either a) or b) is not met, the test should be repeated using another freshly-prepared inoculum.
For water-soluble formulations the test is considered valid if:
cu
c) the amount of DIC does not exceed 5 % of the organic carbon content of the test compound at the
Do
If c) is not met, verify that the air for aerating the flasks is definitely free from CO2.
If inhibition control FI (if included) shows degradation lower than 25 % at the end of the test, the test
sample is assumed to be inhibiting. In this case, it is advisable to repeat the test with a lower
concentration of test sample.
If pH value is out of the range of 6 to 8,5 at the end of the test and the percentage degradation of the test
sample is less than 60 %, it is advisable to repeat the test with a lower concentration of the test sample,
and either using a non-nitrifying activated sludge or increasing buffer capacity of the mineral medium.
14
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
10.2 Precision
10.2.1 General
The precision data have been obtained by statistical examination in accordance with the EN ISO 4259
series of interlaboratory test results from a European study organized in 2017.
10.2.2 Repeatability
The difference between two independent results obtained in the normal and correct operation of the
same method, for test material considered to be the same, within a short interval of time, under the
sa
same test conditions, that is expected to be exceeded with a probability of 5 % due to random variation,
shall not be greater than:
rzi
r = 16, 73
% (3)
nte
10.2.3 Reproducibility
uz intern
ai
The difference between two independent results obtained in the normal and correct operation of the
re
same method, for test material considered to be the same, under different test conditions, that is
ce
expected to be exceeded with a probability of 5 % due to random variation, shall not be greater than:
du
R = 35, 90
% ro (4)
11 Test report
ep
c) all measured and calculated data obtained, as well as the degradation curve;
el
f) the concentration, ThCO2 and/or DOC of the test sample (see 9.1) and the reference compound
td
used;
n
g) the name of the reference compound used and the degradation obtained with this compound;
me
h) the source, the characteristics, the concentration of the volume of the inoculum used and
cu
15
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
m) if determined, the percentage of degradation in flask FI (inhibition check) and a statement on the
toxicity of the test compound;
n) the reasons in the event of the rejection of the test (see 10.1);
o) any alteration of the standard procedure or any circumstance that may have affected the results.
sa
rzi
nte
uz intern
ai
re
ce
du
ro
ep
-R
RO
AS
ru
uc
uz intern
el
n td
me
cu
Do
16
uz intern EN 17181:2019 (E)
Annex A
sa
(informative)
rzi
nte
Comparison table of most common mineralisation methods
eai
er
This annex provides an overview of widely used test methods for evaluation of ultimate aerobic biodegradation of organic compounds in an
aqueous medium, including a summary of advantages and disadvantages.
c
du
OECD 301B OECD 301C OECD 301F OECD 310 OECD 306
ro
Latest version 07.07.1992 17.07.1992 17.07.1992 23.03.2006 17.07.1992
ep
Interlaboratory 1988 1988 1988 1997 1987
Study (ILS)
-R
uz intern
Repeatability 5 % to 10 %
Reproducibility 12 % to 16 %
RO
Organic compound as single Organic compound as single Organic compound as single Organic compound as Parallel to OECD 301D,E but
source for biodegradation source for biodegradation source for biodegradation single source for using sea water instead of
AS
biodegradation stock solution/ inoculum
Test principles (DOC inoculum < < DOC test (DOC inoculum < < DOC test (DOC inoculum < < DOC test Headspace as oxygen Degradation = f(DOC) or
substance) substance) substance) reservoir f(dissolved O2)
Degradation = f(CO2) ru
Degradation = f(O2 loss) Degradation = f(O2 loss) Degradation = f(CO2)
luc
Suitable for: Suitable for: Suitable for: Suitable for: Suitable for:
- Water-soluble - Water-soluble - Water-soluble - Water-soluble - Water-soluble
de
- poorly water-soluble - poorly water-soluble - poorly water-soluble - poorly water-soluble Moderately suitable:
Test compound
- adsorbing - adsorbing - adsorbing - adsorbing - volatile compounds
nt
Not suitable: Moderately suitable: Moderately suitable: Moderately suitable: - poorly water-soluble
me
Concentration
TOC/l ThOD/l 40 mg Carbon/l) (solubility > 2 mg/l)
Do
17
uz intern EN 17181:2019 (E)
sa
OECD 301B OECD 301C OECD 301F OECD 310 OECD 306
rzi
Poorly soluble: Solvent and emulsifier Poorly soluble: Poorly soluble: Water soluble:
- direct addition forbidden - direct addition - direct addition - direct addition
nte
- use emulsifier - direct addition - use emulsifier - use ultra-sonic - stock solution
- use solvent - use ultra-sonic - use solvent - use emulsifier Poorly soluble:
Preparation of
ai
test compound - use solid carrier - finely solid carrier - use solid carrier - use solvent - ultrasonic
(but not for adsorbing
e
Adsorbing: Adsorbing: - use solid carrier - others ? (not stated)
material)
er
- do not use solid carrier - do not use solid carrier Adsorbing:
c
do not use solid carrier
du
- activated sludge - mixture of sewage effluent - activated sludge - activated sludge Pure sea water
from 10 sites
ro
- sewage effluent - sewage effluent - sewage effluent No inoculum
Inoculum - surface water - exact preparation - surface water - surface water (necessity to add N and P for
ep
source - soil - exact preconditioning - soil - soil diet)
- limited
-R
or mixture of above or mixture of above or mixture of above
uz intern
- store life
Colony
RO
102 to 103 CFU/ml (final
Formung Units 107 to 108 107 to 108 107 to 108 ???
(CFU) mixture)
AS
Test conditions
Temperature 22 °C ± 2 °C 25 °C ± 1 °C 22 °C ± 2 °C 20 °C ± 1 °C 15 °C to 20 °C
pH 7,4 ± 0,2 7 ru 7,4 ± 0,2 7,4 ± 0,2 ?
luc
Pre-adaption No No No No No
Pre-
Allowed Unnecessary Allowed Allowed Yes
de
conditioning
Controlling
nt
18
uz intern EN 17181:2019 (E)
sa
OECD 301B OECD 301C OECD 301F OECD 310 OECD 306
rzi
CO2 determination step-wise O2 loss continuously by O2 loss continuously by CO2 determination step- Dissolved O2 determination
as IC from trapped CO2 in manometric respirometer manometric respirometer wise as IC from treatment step-wise chemically or
nte
BaOH with NaOH or with acid electrochemically
% degradation % degradation % degradation % degradation % degradation
ai
Data and ICtest − ICinoculum
Reporting ICtest − ICinoculum BOD
test − BOD inoculum BOD
test − BOD inoculum = BOD
test − BOD inoculum
= = = =
( ) ( )
e
ThCO 2
or TOC ThOD * ThOD or COD * TOC ThOD (
or COD * )
c er
*COD less accurate due to *COD less accurate due to
du
*Calculation via DOC possible incomplete oxidation
incomplete oxidation
ro
- IC test substance < 5 % TC - c(O2) in blank not to exceed - c(O2) in blank not to exceed - % degradation - O2 depletion in blank not
at beginning reference > 60 % after
ep
60 mg/l in 28 d 60 mg/l in 28 d to exceed 30 %
- CO2 from blank 14 d TIC
- Difference in % - residual O2 > 0,5 mg/l - Reference degradation
blank < 3 mg/l at the
-R
control < 40 mg/l at end degradation < 20 % compliant with ring test
uz intern
RO
degradation < 20 % aniline > 40 % after 7 d - % degradation
between 2 flasks and > 65 % after 14 d reference > 60 % after
AS
- % degradation 14 d
reference > 60 % after
14 d
CO2 production easily related ru
Inoculum mixture probably Continuous measurement of Uses head-space – Using seawater:
luc
to carbon content of test leading to less variation in O2 – less error-prone than improves collection of "real" approach
substance (TOC) results detection of CO2 CO2; CO2 detection in
Closed-bottle-method easy
Easy-to-handle procedure Continuous measurement of liquid and gaseous phase to handle, even for volatiles;
de
insoluble material
Methods of preparation
me
19
uz intern EN 17181:2019 (E)
sa
OECD 301B OECD 301C OECD 301F OECD 310 OECD 306
rzi
Detection of CO2 influenced Preparation of inoculum Using chemical oxygen Too many preparation No "unique" sea water
by adsorption, volatilisation, cumbersome: demand (COD) leads to wrong methods for water- definition
nte
precipitation or hydrolysis - complex mixture difficult to degradation due to less insoluble material with No inoculum used – results
prepare and store carbon found in this analytics respect to variation of not comparable to other
Also microbial or non-
compared to TOC results OECD methods
ai
biological reaction - resulting inoculum mix
more or less inactive High complexity of test Method difficult for non-
Measurement is cumbersome,
e
equipment; water-soluble test samples,
General despite problem of sealing Test medium completely
er
different to other methods If not tested in-line, a lot especially formulations
disadvantages
of bottles necessary – Shake-flask-method needs
c
Single use in Japan
limited number of test C-analyser, inhibitory effects
du
rigs; problem of sealing of possible due to high content
bottles of test substance
ro
Low demand for this test Closed-bottle-method shows
ep
lack of agitation, probably
nitrification
-R
uz intern
ISO 9439 (1999) None ISO 9408 (1999) ISO 14593 (1999) ISO 16221 (2001)
- More test substance - Optimized test substance
RO
possible concentration 100 mg/l
(10 mg/l to 40 mg/l) ThOD
AS
- Inoculum better defined - Inoculum better defined
- Adoption of different - Adoption of different
kinetics (no 10-d window) kinetics (no 10-d window)
ISO 14852 (1999) ru ISO 14851 (1999)
luc
Corresponding - Similar to OECD 301B - Similar to
ISO methods /ISO 9439 but for testing OECD 301F/ISO 9408 but
of plastics for testing of plastics
de
hydroxy-butyrate hydroxylbutyrate
- More test compound - More test substance
cu
20
uz intern EN 17181:2019 (E)
sa
OECD 301B OECD 301C OECD 301F OECD 310 OECD 306
rzi
D5864–11 (2011) none D6731–01 (2011) none D6691 (2009)
- Suggestion of low erucic - Suggestion of low erucic - For testing of plastics
nte
acid rapeseed oil as acid rapeseed oil as - Evaluation of
reference to water- reference to water- biodegradation in
insoluble material insoluble material
ai
respirometer and
- Reference material should - Reference material should determination of CO2
e
be added in same manner be added in same manner
- Other reference materials:
er
as test substance as test substance
cellulose, chitin or Kraft
Corresponding - Sonication allowed as - ThOD of test substance not
c
paper
ASTM methods sample preparation less than 50 mg O2/l but
du
- Pre-adaption allowed not higher than
ro
D6139–11 (2011) 200 mg O2/l;
ep
- Modification of medium - Optimum: 50 mg/l to
- Special flask type 100 mg/l
-R
- Sonication allowed as
uz intern
- Pre-adaption allowed
sample preparation
- Only direct addition
- Pre-adaption allowed
RO
allowed
AS
ru
luc
de
nt
me
cu
Do
21
uz intern EN 17181:2019 (E)
Annex B
sa
(informative)
rzi
nte
Sample insertion
e ai
er
This annex provides an overview of possible preparation procedures for non-water-soluble lubricants, including a summary of advantages and
disadvantages.
c
du
Adsorption on an inert
Direct insertion using an Production of Production of
Direct insertion carrier (fibre mat, silica
ro
Direct insertion inert carrier (glass fibre, dispersion using dispersion using
using a solvent gel, silica sand, amorphous
aluminium plate etc.) ultra-sonic sound emulsifiers
ep
spherical nanoparticles)
Advantage No adulteration of Proper dosage Dosage easier to handle Better dispersion oft e test Proper dosage and Proper dosage achievable
-R
uz intern
results due to achievable compared to direct sample in the test flask bio-availability Test sample will
biodegradation of insertion Sample spread over a large possible as long as a homogeneously be
impurities stable dispersion is
RO
Weighted sample record surface dispersed in the test
more precise formed volume
case 1: creation of a
AS
pre-solution using
ultra-sonic sound
case 2: preparation
ru of the whole sample
luc
short before
addition of inoculum
Disadvantage Dosage of test Low volatility of a Reduced bio-availability of Low bio-availability due to Stability of Choice of feasible
de
sample difficult to biodegradable ingredients due to low strong adsorption or dispersion probably emulsifiers quite difficult.
handle. solvent might water solubility absorption not satisfying. Question of comparability
nt
Reduced bio- influence Glass plates might stick on Insoluble ingredients might Test substance of results regarding the
degradation test
me
availability of the flask wall remain unabsorbed. might modify under use of different
ingredients due to results using influence of shearing emulsifiers.
Potential loss of Silica gel of high porosity
low water solubility respirometric forces.
lubricants, which show should not be used for
cu
methods.
extraordinary wetting on greases and possibly for oil
glass surfaces samples.
Do
Determination of CSB
difficult for greases.
22
uz intern EN 17181:2019 (E)
sa
Adsorption on an inert
Direct insertion using an Production of Production of
Direct insertion carrier (fibre mat, silica
Direct insertion inert carrier (glass fibre, dispersion using dispersion using
rzi
using a solvent gel, silica sand, amorphous
aluminium plate etc.) ultra-sonic sound emulsifiers
spherical nanoparticles)
nte
Standard Measurement of Assure to work with Inert carrier shall be free Strong adsorption on porous Applicable only in Content of emulsifier
proceedings weight needs to be real solution, stable of residual carbon. carrier shall be avoided. combination with should not exceed 10
ai
done with sufficient suspension or stable Perform blind test. Result Inert carrier shall be free of emulsifiers or mass-% of test sample
precision. dispersion. of blind test shall not solvents. quantity.
e
residual carbon. Perform
Applicable only for No use of aliquots. exceed the limit of the blind test. Result of blind test Duration and energy Resulting emulsion
er
liquid samples by Total amount of correspondent test shall not exceed the limit of input need to be should be dilutable with
c
use of differential solvent and sample procedure. the correspondent test defined. water in any ratio.
du
measurement of is added. procedure. Stability of Emulsion should be
weight. In case of clear, Test material need to be dispersion need to stable during the whole
ro
transparent, homogeneously dispersed on be ensured test procedure. (control
ep
possibility to use inert carrier. Concentration using turbidimetry)
aliquots (ensure of aliquot of test sample
transparency by use should be done using CSB,
-R
uz intern
RO
respirometric be overheated during
methods: grinding process.
Ensure complete
AS
evaporation of
solvent.
Direct insertion Direct insertion ru
Direct insertion using an
inert carrier (glass fibre,
Adsorption on an inert
carrier (fibre mat, silica gel,
Production of
dispersion using
luc
using a solvent
aluminium plate etc.) silica sand, amorphous ultra-sonic sound
spherical nano-particles)
de
nt
me
cu
Do
23
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
Annex C
(informative)
This annex provides a quality definition of a high oleic reference oil (HORO). HORO in the sense of this
standard means a blend of 99,7 % High Oleic Sunflower Oil and 0,3 % (1,4-Di-tert.-butyl-hydroxy-
sa
toluene (BHT). HORO fulfils the following minimum specifications:
rzi
Analytical Test Characteristic Specification limits Units
Method
nte
lower upper
uz intern
EN ISO 3675 /
kg/m3
ai
Density at 15 °C 900,0 930,0
EN ISO 12185
re
EN ISO 3104 Kinematic viscosity at 40 °C 36,0 44,0 mm2/s
ce
EN 14111 or EN 16300 Iodine number — 90,0 g Iodine / 100 g
EN 14104 Acid number —
du 0,2 mg KOH / g
ro
Fatty acid distribution:
ep
EN ISO 20884 or
Sulfur content — 10,0 mg/kg
EN ISO 20846
uz intern
el
Certificate of Analysis for material stored in unopened containers and stored in cool dry conditions
cu
under exclusion of light should be valid in the moment of using the material as reference for in the
biodegradation method.
Do
The HORO is available from company FUCHS Schmierstoffe GmbH, Mannheim, Germany, or can be
obtained from other suppliers providing it meets the specification described above. Alternatively, if
desired, HORO meeting the above minimum specification can be prepared in-house.
The quality of the HORO is checked prior to use:
a) if the indicated shelf life is exceeded, or
c) if the in-house produced HORO was prepared more than 12 months before use.
24
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
Annex D
(informative)
sa
rzi
nte
uz intern
ai
re
ce
du
ro
ep
-R
RO
AS
ru
uc
uz intern
el
n td
me
Key
cu
2 lag phase
3 biodegradation phase
4 plateau phase
X duration (days)
Y degradation rate (%)
high biodegradation rate
low biodegradation rate
25
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
Bibliography
[1] ASTM D 5800, Standard test method for evaporation loss of lubricating oils by the Noack method
[2] DIN 51581, Testing of lubricants — determination of evaporation loss of lubricating oils (Noack
test)
[3] DIN 51627-6, Automotive Fuels — Test methods — Part 6: Direct determination of trace elements
sa
in vegetable oils by inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectroscopy (ICP OES)
rzi
[4] DIN 51828-1, Testing of lubricants and related products — Determination of the rapid
nte
biodegradability — Part 1: General working principles
uz intern
EN 14104, Fat and oil derivatives - Fatty Acid Methyl Esters (FAME) - Determination of acid value
ai
[5]
re
[6] EN 14111, Fat and oil derivatives - Fatty Acid Methyl Esters (FAME) - Determination of iodine
value
ce
[7]
stability (accelerated oxidation test) du
EN 14112, Fat and oil derivatives - Fatty Acid Methyl Esters (FAME) - Determination of oxidation
ro
ep
[8] EN 16300, Automotive fuels - Determination of iodine value in fatty acid methyl esters (FAME) -
Calculation method from gas chromatographic data
-R
[9] EN ISO 3104, Petroleum products - Transparent and opaque liquids - Determination of kinematic
RO
[10] EN ISO 3675, Crude petroleum and liquid petroleum products - Laboratory determination of
AS
[11] EN ISO 12966-4, Animal and vegetable fats and oils — Gas chromatography of fatty acid methyl
esters — Part 4: Determination by capillary gas chromatography (ISO 12966-4)
uc
uz intern
el
[12] EN ISO 12185, Crude petroleum and petroleum products - Determination of density - Oscillating U-
tube method (ISO 12185)
td
[13] EN ISO 12937, Petroleum products - Determination of water - Coulometric Karl Fischer titration
n
me
[14] EN ISO 20846, Petroleum products - Determination of sulfur content of automotive fuels -
cu
[15] EN ISO 20884, Petroleum products - Determination of sulfur content of automotive fuels -
Wavelength-dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometry (ISO 20884)
[16] ISO 3960, Animal and vegetable fats and oils — Determination of peroxide value — Iodometric
(visual) endpoint determination
[17] ISO 8245, Water quality — Guidelines for the determination of total organic carbon (TOC) and
dissolved organic carbon (DOC)
26
EN 17181:2019 (E)
uz intern
[18] EN ISO 10634, Water quality - Guidance for the preparation and treatment of poorly water-soluble
organic compounds for the subsequent evaluation of their biodegradability in an aqueous medium
(ISO 10634)
[19] EN ISO 4259-1, Petroleum and related products - Precision of measurement methods and results -
Part 1: Determination of precision data in relation to methods of test (ISO 4259-1)
[20] ISO 11923, Water quality — Determination of suspended solids by filtration through glass-fibre
filters
sa
[21] ISO 14851, Determination of the ultimate aerobic biodegradability of plastic materials in an
aqueous medium - Method by measuring the oxygen demand in a closed respirometer
rzi
[22] ISO 14852, Determination of the ultimate aerobic biodegradability of plastic materials in an
nte
aqueous medium — Method by analysis of evolved carbon dioxide
uz intern
ai
[23] ISO 9408, Water quality — Evaluation of ultimate aerobic biodegradability of organic compounds
re
in aqueous medium by determination of oxygen demand in a closed respirometer
ce
[24] ISO 9439, Water quality — Evaluation of ultimate aerobic biodegradability of organic compounds
du
in aqueous medium — Carbon dioxide evolution testro
[25] ISO 14593, Water quality — Evaluation of ultimate aerobic biodegradability of organic
compounds in aqueous medium — Method by analysis of inorganic carbon in sealed vessels (CO2
ep
headspace test)
-R
[26] ISO 16221, Water quality — Guidance for determination of biodegradability in the marine
environment
RO
[27] ASTM D5864, Standard Test Method for Determining Aerobic Aquatic Biodegradation of
AS
[28] ASTM D6139, Standard Test Method for Determining the Aerobic Aquatic Biodegradation of
Lubricants or Their Components Using the Gledhill Shake Flask
uc
uz intern
el
[29] ASTM D6731, Standard Test Method for Determining the Aerobic, Aquatic Biodegradability of
Lubricants or Lubricant Components in a Closed Respirometer
td
[30] ASTM D6691, Standard Test Method for Determining Aerobic Biodegradation of Plastic Materials
n
in the Marine Environment by a Defined Microbial Consortium or Natural Sea Water Inoculum
me
[31] OECD, Test No. 301: Ready Biodegradability, OECD Publishing, Paris
cu
Do
[32] OECD, Test No. 306: Biodegradability in Seawater, OECD Publishing, Paris
[33] OECD, Test No. 310: Ready Biodegradability - CO2 in sealed vessels (Headspace Test), OECD
Publishing, Paris
27