Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AH2 % AH- + H +
Ka Manuscript recelved January 31, 1977; reowion received April 17, and
AH- + Cu2+ [Cu(II)AH]+ accepted May 3, 1977.
SCOPE
The removal of sulfur dioxide from gas mixtures by con- agar-agar gel containing sodium hydroxide or sodium sul-
tacting the gases with an aqueous alka!i hydroxide solution fite at very long exposure times of the liquid in the range
is an important industrial absorption process for control of 900 to 9 000 s. They studied mainly the behavior of the
air pollution. However, there have been very few studies of reaction-plane movement by observing the position of the
the mechanism of chemical absorption for the SO,-OH- color change plane in the gel solution containing a indica-
ions system. Goettler (1967) discussed the chemical absorp- tor. The experimental results for the sulfur dioxide-sodium
tion mechanism for the sulfur dioxide-sodium hydroxide hydroxide system were found to agree with the penetration
system in his thesis which reported the results of a theoreti- theory predictions based on the two reaction plane model
cal and experimental investigation of simultaneous absorp- proposed by Hikita et al. (1972).
tion of sulfur dioxide and carbon dioxide into aqueous SO- The purposes of the study described in this paper are to
dium hydroxide solutions flowing over a single sphere. A obtain reliable data on the absorption rate of sulfur
model based on the assumption that the reaction between dioxide into aqueous sodium bisulfite, sodium hydroxide,
the dissolved sulfur dioxide and OH- ions is a two-step and sodium sulfite solutions at the short exposure times en-
instantaneous reaclion and two reaction planes are formed countered in industrial absorbers, to check for the ex-
within the liquid phase was proposed, and a film theory istence of interfacial turbulence in these absorption sys-
solution for the reaction factor was presented. However: tems, to propose reasonable methods of predicting the
the direct experimental confirmation of this model was not phys.ica1 properties of the present systems, and to test the
attempted. Onda et al. (1971) absorbed sulfur dioxide into applicability of the two reaction plane model presented by
Correspondence concerning this paper should be addressed to Haruo Hikita et al. (1972) to the sulfur dioxide-sodium hydroxide
Hikita. system.
Page 538 July, 1977 AlChE Journal (Vol. 23, No. 4)
CONCLUSIONS AND SIGNIFICANCE
Experiments have been carried out on the absorption of of absorption observed in the case of the solution without
pure sulfur dioxide into aqueous sodium bisulfite, sodium surface active agent may be attributed to interfacial tur-
hydroxide, and sodium sulfite solutions with and without a bulence, presumably produced by surface tension gradients
surface active agent using a liquid jet column. during the chemical absorption process. For the sulfur
For the sulfur dioxide-sodium hydroxide system, the rate dioxide-sodium bisulfite and sulfur dioxide-sodium-sulfite
of absorption into the solution without surface active agent systems, on the oherhand, both rates of absorptioninto
is higher than that into the solution with surface active
the solutions with and without surface active agent are the
agent, and the difference between both rates of absorption
becomes larger as the sodium hydroxide concentration and Same for each indicating the absence of the aPPre-
the exposurg time of the liquid increase. This higher rate ciable interfacial turbulence.
The absorption rates obtained for the present system action in this case is
under the conditions of no interfacial turbulence have been
compared with the theoretical predictions based on the SOz + S 0 3 2 - + H20 + 2HS03- (5)
penetration theory. The absorption of sulfur dioxide into
Therefore, the reactions which affect the rate of absorp-
aqueous sodium bisulfite solutions is essentially physical,
tion of sulfur dioxide into aqueous alkaline solutions are
and the absorption rate can be represented by the well- reaction ( 2 ) and the forward part of reaction ( 1 ) .
known Higbie equation. The absorption of sulfur dioxide
In a previous paper, Hikita et al. (1972) considered the
into aqueous sodium hydroxide solutions is accompanied problem of gas absorption accompanied by an instantane-
by a two-step instantaneous reaction between the dis- ous two-step reaction
solved sulfur dioxide and OH- ions in the solution, and the
absorption rate data agree well with the theoretical pre- A+BeC (6)
followed by
dictions based on the two reaction plane model pro-
posed by Hikita et al. (1972). The absorption of sulfur
C+BeE (7)
dioxide into aqueous sodium sulfite solutions is accom- where the equilibrium constants of reaction steps ( 6 ) and
panied by an instantaneous irreversible reaction between (7) are also designated as K1 and K2 and are very large.
sulfur dioxide and s0s2- ions in the solution, and the They presented a theoretica1 analysis based on the pene-
absorption rate results are in good agreement with the tration theory and found that the mechanism of chemical
theoretical equation derived by Danckwerts (1950). absorption in this case depends on the equilibrium constant
ratio K1/K2. In the limiting case of K d K 2 + w , it was
CHEMICAL ABSORPTION MECHANISM shown that two reaction planes are formed within the
When sulfur dioxide is absorbed into aqueous alkaline
liquid, and the reaction A + +E 2C [the sum of reac-
tions ( 6 ) and ( 7 ) in the reverse direction] and reaction
solutions, the following two reactions should be considered:
(7) takes place irreversibly at the first reaction plane
SO2 + OH- + HSO3- (1) (which is located closer to the gas-liquid interface) and at
the second reaction plane, respectively.
HS03- + OH- + s03'- + HzO (2) The average rate of absorption N A of the solute gas A
The values of the equilibrium constants for reactions ( 1 ) for this case can be represented by
and ( 2 ) are designated as K1 and Kz and they are given,
respectively, as NA=@(2AidD~/~t) (8)
The reaction factor for the present problem can be ob-
tained from the following equations (Hikita et al., 1976) :
Interface I
1 ,,,,i ,
1st reaction-plane
,2nd reaction-plane
0 Distance
Fig. 2. Schematic diagram of concentration profiles for the ab-
sorption of sulfur dioxide into aqueous sodium sulfite solution.
0
0 Distance
TABLE
1. COMPOSITIONS
OF SOLUTIONSUSED
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of concentration profiles for the absorp- Concentration of reactant, g-moles/l
tion of sulfur dioxide into aqueous sodium hydroxide solution.
With surface Without surface
Solution active agent activeagent
Here, u1 and r2are the constants representing the dimen-
Aq. NaHSOs 2.0 2.0
sionless positions of the first and second reaction planes, 0.125
Aq. NaOH 0.125
and qB,qE, rB, rc, r E 2 , and r E 3 are the dimensionless param- 0.25 0.25
eters defined by 0.5 0.5
1.0 1.0
q B = Bo/Ai q E = Eo/Ai (12) 1.3
rB = D B / D A rC = D c / D A (134 - 1.6
2.0 2.0
= DEZ/DA
T E ~ rE3 = D E B / D A (13b) A q NaS03 - 0.069
where the subscripts 2 and 3 for D E denote the values in
- 0.259
0.960 0.960
region 2 (the region between the first and second reac-
tion planes) and region 3 (the region from the second re- EXPERIMENTAL
action plane to infinite depth of the liquid phase), respec-
tively. This absorption mechanism is called the two reac-
Apporotus and Procedure
tion plane model (Hikita et al., 1972).
When the species B is not present in the liquid phase, Absorption experiments were carried out with a liquid jet
region 3 does not exist, and only the reaction A +
E z= 2C
column which was similar to that used by Hikita et al. (1968,
1973, 1976) in previous work. The laminar liquid jet was
proceeds irreversibly at a single reaction plane. In this formed by a bell shaped glass nozzle with an exit diameter
case, Equations (10) and (11) reduce to of 1.00 mm. The liquid flow rate was kept constant at about
4.3 cm3/s, and the exposure time of the liquid to the gas was
varied from 0.0008 to 0.017 s by changing the jet length from
0.5 to 8 cm. Absorption rate was determined volumetrically by
means of a soap-film meter. All the experiments were conducted
at atmospheric pressure and at 25°C.
(14) The gas phase was pure sulfur dioxide saturated with water
vapor, and the absorbents used were aqueous solutions of
from which the constant r1 can be determined. Therefore,
sodium hisulfite, sodium hydroxide, and sodium sulfite with
the reaction factor in this case is the same as that for the and without 0.05 vol % of a surface active agent, Emulgen 147
infinitely rapid irreversible reaction represented by A E + (Kao-Atlas Co.). The compositions of the solutions are shown
+2c. in Table 1.
As stated above, the values of the equilibrium constants
of reactions ( I ) and ( 2 ) , K1 and K 2 , are 1.7 x 10l2 and Results
6.2 x 106 I/g-mole, respectively. Hence, the equilibrium Sulfur dioxide-sodium bisuljite system. Experimental results
constant ratio kl/K2 is 2.7 x lo5. Therefore, the chemical obtained on the physical absorption of sulfur dioxide into 2.0
absorption theory described above may be applicable to g-moles/I aqueous sodium bisulfite solution with and without
surface active agent at 25°C are shown in Figure 3, where the
the present system. According to this theory, the concen- average absorption rate N A * of sulfur dioxide is plotted against
tration profiles of each species for the Sop-OH- and S 0 2 - the exposure time t on logarithmic coordinates. The straight
s o 3 2 - systems will be similar to those shown in Figures 1 line in this figure represents the theoretical line for physical
and 2. In the case of the S02-OH- system, the irreversible absorption, calculated from the well-known Higbie equation
reactions (5) and ( 2 ) may take place at the first and
second reaction p!anes, respectively. On the other hand, NAO = 2AivD~/Zt (15)
in the case of the s o 2 - s o 3 2 - system, only the irreversible where the physical solubility Ai and the liquid-phase diffusivity
reaction (5) may occur at the single reaction plane, DA of sulfur dioxide into 2.0 g-moles/l aqueous sodium bisul-
a 8 $ 40
i 6 u)
aJ
a 20
X
F0
-
* 4
= 2 "b 10
06 1.0 2 4 6 810 20 40
x 8
t x lo3 , s
kig. 9. Absorption rate of sulfur dioxide into 2.0 9-moles/l aqueous f 6
sodium bisulfite solution a t 25°C.
4
0.6 10 2 4 6 8 10 20 40
80 t 103 ,
60 Fig. 4. Absorption rate of sulfur dioxide into aqueous sodium hy-
droxide solutions with surface active agent a t 25°C.
100
80
h
60 without surface-active
tn v
UI
- 10 U
40
0.960 with surface-active
2 8
X
6 20
z'
4
Predictions of the environmental effects of man-made ical concentrations and exposure times likely to result
chemicals is increasingly being recognized as a responsi- from an inadvertent spill is needed.
bility of the manufacturer of the chemical. A significant Spill mechanisms have been verified in our laboratory.
number of hazardous chemicals transported upon water These observations along with previous developments in
routes are more dense than water and come to rest upon chemical engineering science have been focused upon a
the bottom following accidents. Dissolution commences partial solution of this complex problem. Information avail-
immediately, and the rate determines the in-stream cup- able on liquid droplet formation from nozzles and coal-
mixing concentration of the spilled chemical. In the escence in liquid-liquid extraction provides a fundamental
interest of protecting stream biota and downstream water understanding of the mechanism that will produce a
users from excessive exposure, a means of predicting chem- bottom residing interface (Meister and Scheele, 1969,