Professional Documents
Culture Documents
103-122
https://journal.unpak.ac.id/index.php/jimfe P-ISSN: 2502-1400, E-ISSN: 2502-5678
ABSTRACT
This article examined the effect of STIFIn-based HR Management Practices on Job Performance. This
research is a quantitative study with hypothesis testings using the PLS-SEM approach and analyzed using
WarpPLS software. Hypothesis testings are carried out with two models; Model-1 investigates the
relationship of the variables in STIFIn HR Management, namely selection and retention of performance.
Model-2 investigates the relationship between the overall STIFIn HR management practices and overall job
performance. This research was conducted at companies that have implemented STIFIn-based HR
Management. The sample was determined by purposive sampling method. This study found a significant
effect of STIFIn-based HR Management namely selection and retention practices on employee performance
both in task performance and contextual performance. While the results of the model-2 analysis show that
STIFIn's overall HR practice is also significant on performance with higher impact than if those HR STIFIn are
implemented individually both of selection or retention. The results of this study will provide new insights
into the previous research on the effect of HR management practices on performance, and specifically on
HR management practices based on employee’s personality types.
ARTICLE INFORMATIONS
Article history: submitted: May 15, 2020; revised: June, 10 2020; accepted: June 15, 2020
JEL Classifiction: J53, M54
How to cited: Hadiyat, Y., et al. (2020). Applying The Theory of STIFIn Personality: Investigating The Effect of
HR Management Practices on Job Performance. JIMFE (Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Fakultas Ekonomi), 6(1),
103-122. https://doi.org/10.34203/jimfe.v6i1.2025
Copyright©2020. JIMFE (Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Fakultas Ekonomi) Universitas Pakuan
103
Yayan Hadiyat: Applying The Theory of …
the methods used by companies to manage The use of personality traits of the Big
their workforce have a positive impact on Five and MBTI models which is based on
company performance. These are similar to behavioral characteristics is not a consistent
the results of researches by Becker and predictor of job performance, hence the need
Huselid (1998), Delery and Shaw (2001), as for further study of personality factors on
well as Wright and Boswell (2002). Personality employee performance based on personality
is an antecedent factor of employee behavior types that are naturally possessed by genetics.
in the workplace which will then affect their STIFIn personality types are based on human
other work attitudes such as job satisfaction, genetic factors. Several studies that have been
organizational commitment, work, intention conducted show consistent results of the
to quit, and their performance (Truxilo, 2016). influence of personality factors on employee
Several studies have clarified the benefits of performance. Researches conducted by
using personality variables to predict Rafianti and Pudjiastuti (2017), Mundiri
employee performance. (2017), Arifin and Gunadi (2017), and Alindra
Other studies show that personality (2018) have proven that the use of the STIFIn
construction is indeed related to work personality scheme can consistently produce
performance (Barrick and Mount, 1991; better performance. This study was conducted
Hough, 1992; Salgado, 1997; Tett, et al, 1991). to investigate HR management practices
Previous studies that used personality types based on STIFIn's personalities (Sensing,
on the relationship between personality types Thinking, Intuiting, Feeling, and Instinct),
and performance provided a review of especially on job performance. STIFIn's
inconsistent results; The study that used the personality is based on the theory that a
concept of "The Big Five" personality reports person will show consistent performance and
only personality conscientiousness that has productivity if they work according to the type
high validity to predict performance (Barrick of personality that is permanently carried
and Mount, 1991; Hurtz and Donovan (2000), from birth.
while the Salgado study (1997) reports that
conscientiousness and emotional stability are LITERATURE REVIEW AND HYPOTHESIS
predictors of performance. The research on Personality Type and Job Performance
MBTI personality types which is conducted in If a company manages its employees
two different cultures, namely in Europe and according to their personality types and their
China, showed the cultural differences seen potential abilities, then productivity and
impacted MBTI personality, but it was not quality can be improved. Although perhaps
related to job performance. This means that research into the type of MBTI personality
there was a relationship between personality, continues to be a predictor of job
management style, and management efficacy performance, it seems to have quite a lot of
that may be very different in various cultures, influence (Da Cunha, 2007), as well as the Borg
but there was not a relationship with job (1996) study using the MBTI personality type
performance (Furnham and Stringfield, 1993). shows that personality types have an
The research on MBTI personalities also important influence on student success.
reported that only Intuitive personality and Students whose temperament type matches
perceiving structures that outperformed the class instructor's temperament have
preferences for Sensing and Judging, and even significantly better performance results than
the Thinking and Feeling dimensions did not students whose temperament type does not
affect the performance of the four service match the instructor’s. Similarly, Bradely and
categories (Carr et al, 2002). Herbert (1997) and Mazni, et al, (2010)
provide evidence that personality types are
104
JIMFE (Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Fakultas Ekonomi) Vol. 6 No. 1, Juni 2020, Hal. 103-122
https://journal.unpak.ac.id/index.php/jimfe P-ISSN: 2502-1400, E-ISSN: 2502-5678
105
Yayan Hadiyat: Applying The Theory of …
analytical psychologist, who states that among about human intelligence, provides a thesis
all basic human functions or intelligence that every person has a single dominant
machines, there is only one dominant. intelligence that has been carried out since
According to Jung, the basic functions of birth (Poniman, 2009). The theory relies
human personality are divided into four types, scientifically on the analytical psychological
namely; sensing function (Sensing, approach pioneered by Jung (1946), compiled
abbreviated S), mind function (Thinking with the theory of The Whole-Brain Theory
abbreviated T), feeling function (Feeling from Ned Herrmann (1989) and the Triune
abbreviated F), intuition function (Intuiting Brain theory developed by Paul McLean. The
abbreviated I), and in the STIFIn theory initial paradigm used is analytical psychology.
(Poniman and Amalia, 2020) added the Forging one's people uses a humanistic
Instinct intelligence machine, abbreviated as behavioral approach. Humans are considered
‘In’, which focuses on instinctive and to have extraordinary genetic potential. When
spirituality functions. this potential gets the right and planned
This research, which has been environment and ‘forging’, the results that
conducted for three years from 2006 to 2019, come out, in the end, will be extraordinary.
The theory of STIFIn Personality by tend to fall into all the four categories of
Poniman and Amalia (2020) that the four basic personality traits offered by Jung and Ned
functions of Jung are related to Ned Herrman's Herrman or other researchers. This tendency
creative thinking theory of the brain quadrant, dominantly uses other hemispheres, namely
so the four basic functions are nothing but the instinctive brain that is located in the
character traits that are eternal, unchanging, middle or bottom (hindbrain and midbrain),
which are sourced from the most commonly and it is directly connected to the spine. The
used hemispheres. The left quadrant of the fifth intelligence—Instinct (I), lies in the
cerebrum (left neocortex) is both the combined function of the cerebellum,
intelligence and personality characteristics of medulla, midbrain, pons, and the brain
Thinking (T). The right big brain (right organization (The Functional Organization of
neocortex) is Intuiting (I). The left quadrant of the Brain), which response quickly to
the cerebellum (left limbic) is both the something.
intelligence and personality characteristics of In the STIFIn theory, there is something
Sensing (S). The right small brain (right limbic) called ‘the steering wheel’, namely introvert
is both intelligence and Feeling (F) personality and extrovert. The introvert’s direct
character. Thus, Jung's basic function has intelligence from the inside to outside,
similarities to Ned Herrman's brain quadrant. whereas the extroverts direct intelligence
Meanwhile, the fifth intelligence, instinct, from the outside to inside. In addition to
arises because there are people who do not Instinct (In) intelligence, each intelligence has
106
JIMFE (Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Fakultas Ekonomi) Vol. 6 No. 1, Juni 2020, Hal. 103-122
https://journal.unpak.ac.id/index.php/jimfe P-ISSN: 2502-1400, E-ISSN: 2502-5678
two steerings; Sensing (S) consists of actions such as react immediately when they
Introverted Sensing (Si) and Extroverted encounter injustice, judge objectively, accepts
Sensing (Se); Thinking consists of Introverted people's arguments with logic, they are
Thinking (Ti) and Extroverted Thinking (Te); systematic in working and enjoy formality.
Intuiting and Feeling each consists of People with Introverted-Intuiting personality,
Introverted Intuiting (Ii), Extroverted Intuiting among others, are more concerned with
(Ie), Introverted Feeling (Fi), and Extroverted quality, rather than quantity. They always
Feeling (Fe). So there are nine types of emphasize perfection. They are satisfied with
personality that come from four intelligence things that are new or innovative. They are
machines after being affixed by the steering stubborn and always fight for their wills
wheel plus the Insting (I) intelligence machine. because they have an optimistic outlook.
The nine personality types are Si, Se, Ti, Te, Ii, Everything is seen from whether it provides
Ie, Fi, Fe, and In. benefits or not. While people with
Each type of personality has its main Extroverted-Intuiting type have personalities,
characteristics. People who have the which are reflected in actions such as; always
personality of the Introverted Sensing can take risks, they have many ideas. They are
remember that exceeds eight other romantic and inspire the environment. As for
personalities. Their personality is based on five people with Introverted-Feeling types have
senses. They have strong stamina, they work personalities which are reflected in actions
efficiently, they are disciplined, and show such as; they are visionary, bossy, helper,
details, they are also frugal, if they are asked sociable, smart to say, idealistic and
to help, they will prefer to spend their energy sensitive—they get hurt quickly. On the other
rather than money. This happens maybe hand, people who have the Extroverted-
because people who have this personality Feeling type, if compared to people with other
collect money little by relying on volume, not intelligence, have social spirit. They can
from the margin. While People who have galvanize people, they are subjective, brave,
Extroverted-Sensing intelligence have a more always take risks. They are highly tolerant, and
generous personality and they tend to be they have empathy. People who have the last
more extravagant, more relaxed and like to intelligence—the Instinct (In) intelligence, do
have fun, they also like to show off or not like conflicts. They are sincerely sacrificing
demonstrative. Their ability to remember is for others. Their way of thinking is simple and
extraordinary, and they can visualize it in accommodating.
detail. They like gifts or sources of motivation Everyone has a single dominant
in the form of gifts. intelligence that has been carried out since
As for People who have the Introverted- birth. Humans are considered to have
Thinking intelligence, they have independent extraordinary genetic potential. The left
personalities, focus on work, and impose high quadrant of the cerebrum (left neocortex) is
standards on work results. They are not a the intelligence of the Thinking (T) personality
mediocre type. If they pursue something, they type. The right big brain (right neocortex) is
will focus until they reach the level of expert— the intelligence of the Intuiting personality
they do not want to work halfway through. In type. The left quadrant of the cerebellum (left
general, they have good analytical skills. They limbic) is the intelligence of the Sensing (S)
love to read—which makes them always personality type. The right small brain (right
dominate the problem. On the other hand, limbic) is the intelligence of the Feeling (F)
people who have the Extroverted-Thinking personality type. The fifth intelligence does
type have personalities that are reflected in not belong to all the four categories of
107
Yayan Hadiyat: Applying The Theory of …
personality traits, but predominantly uses performance, and Kim and Han's research
another brain hemisphere, namely the (2014) which showed that the level of
instinctive brain in the middle or bottom academic achievement and student
(hindbrain and midbrain)—which is directly satisfaction differed according to their MBTI
connected to the spine. The fifth intelligence is personality types. Ciorbea and Pasarica (2012)
called as the ‘Instinct (I)’. It lies in the state that understanding big five personality
combined function of the cerebellum, traits accurately has a profound effect on
medulla, midbrain, pons, and brain functions academic performance and has broad
(The Functional Organization of the Brain). implications for the world of education.
People with the Instinct (I) personality type Another study of personality trait as a
are more responsive—they are faster in moderating variable "honesty-humility trait"
responding to problems. or Hexaco model of personality on the
relationship between job insecurity and
HR STIFIn Management and Job Performance counter-productive works behavior
There have been many studies conducted on (Chirumbolo, 2014).
the effect of HR Management systems and However, research conducted by
practices on company performance (firm Furnham (1993) on MBTI personality failed to
performance), as well as on employee produce a large correlation with performance.
performance. Glaister, et al, (2016) which The MBTI does not appear to be related to a
examines HR management strategies and strong and multi-factorial measure of
business alignment, reports the influence of management performance. As an addition to
HR strategy in improving company the MBTI, the personality theory of "The Big-
performance. However, this influence does Five Personality", although some literature
not become an essential component proves the personality of "The Big Five" as a
concerning talent management practices and predictor of job performance (Bhatti, et al.,
job performance. HR management practices 2013), by many researchers that personality
on employee performance are more measures do not predict job performance
influenced by individual character and consistently. Like Barrick and Mount (1991)
personality. Bowen and Ostroff (2004) in his and Hurtz & Donovan (2000) who examined
article "Understanding HRM-Firm the relationship between the personality of
Performance Linkages: The role of the "The Big Five Personality" and job
strength of the HR system", reports that the performance, found only one dimension,
HR management system can explain how the namely conscientiousness that was associated
accumulation of individual employee consistently with job performance. This study
attributes influences organizational will investigate the practice of HR
effectiveness. management using the STIFIn personality type
The study of the relationship between developed by Poniman (2009) on improving
personality traits and job performance has job performance.
been done by several researchers, among The Management of HR STIFIn, as
others, namely, the research of Lado and defined in the STIFIn HR Management Book
Alonso (2017), who investigated the (Poniman and Hadiyat, 2015), is the practice of
relationship between personality traits and job human resource management using the
performance by using job complexity scheme of intelligence machines or STIFIn
moderating variables. Then, Leena and personality types in the three main activities
Kirupa’s study (2016); Askarian and Eslami of human resource management, namely 1)
(2013) who conducted a study of the influence Selection, which includes in planning labor, as
of personality type characteristics on job well as employee recruitment and selection
108
JIMFE (Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Fakultas Ekonomi) Vol. 6 No. 1, Juni 2020, Hal. 103-122
https://journal.unpak.ac.id/index.php/jimfe P-ISSN: 2502-1400, E-ISSN: 2502-5678
109
Yayan Hadiyat: Applying The Theory of …
career development. Hassan (2016) revealed defines job performance as the extent to
that there is a positive and significant which employees carry out their duties and
relationship between human resource responsibilities, and the results are measured
management practices on compensation, by the criteria of quantity of work and quality
career planning, performance appraisal, of work.
training, and employee engagement with This construction of job performance
employee performance. The proposition of will be used in this study, which then uses the
Poniman and Hadiyat (2015) proposes that the dimensions and indicators that will be derived
application of training and development in the items from the Koopmans et al (2014)
programs, as well as employee career study, namely: 1) Task Performance; and 2)
development based on employee personality Contextual Performance. The dimensions of
types, will improve employee productivity and Counter-productive Work Behavior are not
performance. In this study, development used in this study with the consideration that
activities are not hypothesized by themselves it is not suitable for cultural conditions in
but are combined into retention activities. Indonesia, where a person may not be very
Job performance is defined as the comfortable if he has to fill out a survey
completion of tasks with the application of questionnaire containing negative statements
knowledge, skills, and abilities. The article of so that there will be bias in the survey results.
Ramawickrama, et al (2017), namely "The Borman and Motowidlo (1993) define Task
behavioral outcome of an employee which Performance as the effectiveness used by
points out employee is showing positive officeholders to carry out activities that
attitudes towards his or her organization" said contribute to the organization's technical core,
that the results of an employee's behavior either directly by implementing part of the
show a positive attitude towards the technological process, or indirectly by
organization ". Based on literature studies, job providing needed materials or services, such
performance (job performance) has been as tasks performance on Sales jobs which are
widely researched and defined. Porter and product knowledge, closing the sale, time
Lawler (1974) define job performance as a management. Whereas contextual
function of the abilities, skills, and effort of a performance relates to the contribution to the
person or individual in a situation. Then effectiveness of the organization in ways that
Campbell (1990) defines job performance as a shape the organizational, social, and
behavior or action from someone relevant to psychological context that catalyzes the
organizational goals, and Opata (2015), activities and processes of carrying out tasks.
110
JIMFE (Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Fakultas Ekonomi) Vol. 6 No. 1, Juni 2020, Hal. 103-122
https://journal.unpak.ac.id/index.php/jimfe P-ISSN: 2502-1400, E-ISSN: 2502-5678
111
Yayan Hadiyat: Applying The Theory of …
responsibility" and add new statement items towards the construct of employee
that fit the context of the intelligence performance in the form of multidimensional.
machines through the mechanism of expert
approval of the questionnaire compilation. RESULT AND DISCUSSION
Examples of these items are "I can use the Characteristics of Respondents
potential intelligence engine that I have to The purpose of this analysis is to find out the
work well in this organization/company". characteristics of respondents in general,
While the variable measurements of the STIFIn where the respondents in this study are
HR Practice modify the measurements of High- employees who work for companies that have
Performance Human Resource Practice practiced HR STIFIn. Out of the total of 100
Perceptions developed by Kehoe and Wright respondents who were asked to fill out the
(2010). An example of this item is "The questionnaire, only 50 people were willing to
recruitment and selection process is carried fill in (response rate 50%), after the selection,
out with the STIFIn scheme". only 41 answers were obtained that were
The data analysis technique uses Partial feasible to analyze. Based on data which were
Least Square Structural Equation Modeling obtained from 41 respondents, it was found
(PLS-SEM). The selection of PLS-SEM is that the majority of respondents were male
because this study is more predictive, and it (61%), and the majority of respondents were
explains latent variables rather than testing a Thinking personality type (26.8%). The
theory. The number of samples in this study is majority of respondents had controllers (the
not high and anticipates if the data is steering) of extroverted personality (63.4%),
distributed abnormally (Hair et al., 2014). This the majority of respondents have S1 education
study uses two research models, where model (63.4%), the majority of respondents are aged
1 aims to examine the effect of each between 36-45 years (34.1%), the majority of
dimension of the STIFIn HR Practice on the respondents have a tenure of 1-5 years
dimensions of employee performance (53.7%), the majority of respondents are
partially. While model 2 aims to examine the married (75.6 %), and the majority of
influence of the constructs of the HR STIFIn respondents work for companies that have
Practice in a multidimensional manner applied STIFIn HR for 1-5 years (48.8%).
112
JIMFE (Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Fakultas Ekonomi) Vol. 6 No. 1, Juni 2020, Hal. 103-122
https://journal.unpak.ac.id/index.php/jimfe P-ISSN: 2502-1400, E-ISSN: 2502-5678
113
Yayan Hadiyat: Applying The Theory of …
Based on the results of processing the the correlation between variables with the
data, Tabel 3. shown that all items forming the square root of variance extracted (the value of
latent construct are valid, with the resulting the square root AVE). Table 4 below describes
factor loading value > 0.7. Furthermore, in discriminant validity from this study (model 1).
convergent validity, the AVE (average variance From table 4. it can be seen that all
extracted) value for each dimensional correlation values between variables (latent
construct is very good at > 0.5 so that it meets constructs) are below the AVE square root
the convergent validity criteria. Likewise, with value (see with a diagonal line, marked’*’).
internal consistency, the composite reliability Thus, it can be concluded that all variables
value produced by each dimensional construct meet discriminant validity criteria, and can be
is also very good, namely> 0.7 and the value of said to be a very good model. A high
Cronbach's Alpha (α) is between 0.835 - 0.955, discriminant validity value provides evidence
which means that the reliability value that a construct is unique and completely
generated by each latent construct is also very different from other constructs, and can
good > 0.7, thus meeting internal consistency capture the measured phenomenon. In short,
reliability. The value of Full Collinearity VIF for the measurement model successfully passed
each latent construct is also very good, which some rigorous analyzes, namely convergent
is <3.3 so there is no collinearity problem in validity, discriminant validity, reliability, and
the model. Furthermore, reflective indicators multicollinearity. The results of the CFA
forming latent constructs in the study will also analysis reveal that the model does not have a
be tested by discriminant validity. One way to data measurement problem because it has
look at discriminant validity is by comparing fulfilled the criteria of validity which have
114
JIMFE (Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Fakultas Ekonomi) Vol. 6 No. 1, Juni 2020, Hal. 103-122
https://journal.unpak.ac.id/index.php/jimfe P-ISSN: 2502-1400, E-ISSN: 2502-5678
been widely accepted and thus, the data can be analyzed further.
Inner Model Results (Model-1) AFVIF = 2,966 (<3,3), which means that there
Based on the results of the general result of is no multicollinearity problem between each
the SEM-PLS using WarpPLS 6.0 software, it is indicator and between each exogenous
known that the model has a good fit, where variable. The result of GoF is 0.649 > 0, 36
the P-value values for Average Path Coefficient which means that the model fit is good. For
(APC), Average R-squared (ARS), and Average the Symson's Paradox (SPR) index, R-squared
Adjusted R-squared ( AARS) < 0.001 with APC Contribution Ratio (RSCR), Statistical
value = 0.430, ARS = 0.608, and AARS = 0.587. Suppression Ratio (SSR), and Nonlinear
Likewise, with the Average block value of VIF Bivariate Causality Direction Ratio (NLBCDR)
(AVIF) and Average Full Collinearity VIF produce values equal to 1, which means that
(AFVIF), the ideal value is AVIF = 1,646, and there are no causality problems in the model.
The results showed that the adjusted R- 0.516 (51.6%), which means that 2 selection
squared was 0.658 (65.8%), this means that and retention variables can explain contextual
large dependent latent variables (task performance variations of 51.6%, the
performance) were explained at 65.8% by 2 remaining 48.4% is explained by other
independent latent variables (selection and variables outside the model. The Q-squared
retention) and the remaining 34.2% is value (Q2) produced for each dependent
explained by other variables outside the variable (endogenous) > 0, namely Q2
model. Meanwhile, the Adjusted R-squared selection = 0.674 and Q2 retention = 0.536,
coefficient for contextual performance is
115
Yayan Hadiyat: Applying The Theory of …
which means that the model has predictive that it supports the hypothesis H1 and H2.
relevance. Furthermore, retention affects positive and
Figure 2 and table 5 explain the results significant task performance (β = 0.369, p <
of hypothesis testing (path analysis), which 0.001) which means confirming the H2
shows that the election results have a positive hypothesis. Retention has a positive and
and significant effect on task performance (β = significant effect on contextual performance
0.345, p = 0.017), toward the contextual (β = 0.369, p < 0.001), thus the H4 hypothesis
performance (β = 0.369, p = 0.003), this means is also accepted.
The results support the proposition of STIFIn- Karanja, 2016). Likewise, a research conducted
based HR management, namely to recruit and by Hozler et al., (2004) reported that
select employees based on the personality differences in personality characteristics of
type which is inherent in a person. Thus, they workers are related to performance and
feel what is done and the work is suitable and retention. The placement of workers based on
in accordance with their character and personality types will affect their survival to
personality type (Poniman and Hadiyat, 2015). stay involved and work in a program or
The placement of employees by the activity. The study of Paradis and Usui (1987)
personality type will result in high productivity on hospital nurses reported that volunteers
and performance. This is because the who scored well on tests which measure
employee feels comfortable and there is a empathy, anxiety tendencies and
match between his/her work and personality "euthanasia", significantly predicted
type. This study is also in line with the results volunteers' ability to help patients, as well as
of the study of Jounda, et al., (2016) where the ability to understand dying patients and
recruitment and selection can significantly their families, as well as the desire to continue
predict employee performance (Jouda, et al., to participate in the program voluntarily.
2016). Specifically related to the application of In applying STIFIn personality types,
STIFIn's personality type in predicting employee selection and retention adjusted to
performance, the study is in line with personality types significantly influence both
Rafianti’s research, et al. (2016) where STIFIn task performance and contextual
intelligence types can predict results in high performance. For this reason in the workforce
school students' mathematical abilities. planning, all types of work need to be mapped
Several studies related to systems and and grouped based on STIFIn personality
practices of human resource management characteristics, so that the search or
that consider aspects of personality have recruitment of workers is tailored to the
proven to have a significant effect on placement that needs workers who have been
employee’s performance (Wambua and mapped to the needs of STIFIn personality
116
JIMFE (Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Fakultas Ekonomi) Vol. 6 No. 1, Juni 2020, Hal. 103-122
https://journal.unpak.ac.id/index.php/jimfe P-ISSN: 2502-1400, E-ISSN: 2502-5678
types. Further, the companies can provide second level confirmatory factor analysis
appropriate retention programs according to (second CFA order). Based on the results of
their personality types. the second-order confirmatory factor analysis
below, it can be seen that the forming
Model 2 indicators (dimensions) of all latent constructs
Outer Model Test Results are valid with the resulting factor loading
In the next step, the researcher analyzes value of > 0.7. Furthermore, the AVE value for
model 2, which is an analysis of the second- each very good latent construct > 0.5 means
order construct indicator. It means the that it meets the criteria for convergent
analysis is carried out from latent constructs validity.
and dimensions. Table 6 is the result of the
From table 7, it can be seen that the meet discriminant validity criteria and can be
correlation value between variables (latent said to be a very good model.
construct) is below the AVE square root value
(see with a diagonal line, marked and * ’). Inner Model Results (Model-2)
Thus, it can be concluded that all variables Based on the results of the general result of
SEM-PLS, it is known that the model has a
117
Yayan Hadiyat: Applying The Theory of …
good fit, where the P-value for Average Path is good. For the Symson's Paradox (SPR) index,
Coefficient (APC), Average R-squared (ARS), R-squared Contribution Ratio (RSCR),
and Average Adjusted R-squared (AARS) < Statistical Suppression Ratio (SSR), and
0.001 with the value APC = 0.788, ARS = 0.622, Nonlinear Bivariate Causality Direction Ratio
and the value of AARS = 0.612. Likewise, with (NLBCDR) produce values equal to 1, which
the value of Average Full Collinearity VIF means there are no causality problems in the
(AFVIF), the ideal value is AFVIF = 2.643 (< 3.3), model.
which means that there are no
multicollinearity problems. The resulting GoF
is 0.726 > 0, 36 which means that the model fit
The results showed that the adjusted R- variables outside the model. The Q-squared
squared was 0, 612 (61.2%), which means that value (Q2) is generated for the dependent
the large dependent latent variable (job variable (endogenous) > 0, which is Q2 =
performance) was explained at 61.2% by 0.617, which means that the model has
independent latent variables (HR STIFIn) and predictive relevance.
the remaining 38.8% explained by other
Figure 3 and table 8 explain the results of (Caldwell, Chatman and O'Reilly, 1990).
hypothesis testing (path analysis model 2), Organizational commitment itself is a
which shows that the STIFIn HR results have a predictor of employee performance (Khan, et
positive and significant effect on job al., 2010; Lam, et al., 2013; Memari, et al.,
performance (β = 0.788, p <0.001), thus the 2013; and Cesario and Chambel, 2017). Direct
results support the hypothesis H5. The studies on the effect of effective HRM
research is in line with other previous practices on job performance reported
researches where the implementation of HR significant influences on recruitment and
management practices is very important to selection, training, employee involvement,
improve organizational results. Recruitment employee retention, and work relationship
and selection practices, career management completion, but there was no significant effect
and promotion, teamwork, employee on service management functions (Tabiu and
responsibilities, autonomy, complaint Nura, 2013). The results of testing in Model 2
resolution mechanisms, and benefit plans for in this study can provide a reference for the
employees, are reported to be positively implementation of HR management practices,
related to organizational commitment especially those using personality type
118
JIMFE (Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Fakultas Ekonomi) Vol. 6 No. 1, Juni 2020, Hal. 103-122
https://journal.unpak.ac.id/index.php/jimfe P-ISSN: 2502-1400, E-ISSN: 2502-5678
119
Yayan Hadiyat: Applying The Theory of …
120
JIMFE (Jurnal Ilmiah Manajemen Fakultas Ekonomi) Vol. 6 No. 1, Juni 2020, Hal. 103-122
https://journal.unpak.ac.id/index.php/jimfe P-ISSN: 2502-1400, E-ISSN: 2502-5678
Holzer, H. J., et al. (2004). Job Performance Koch, M.J., and R.G.McGrath. (1996).
and Retention among Welfare Improving labor productivity: Human
Recipients. Social Service Review, 78(3), Resource Management Policy do
343–369. doi:10.1086/421917 Matter?. Strategic Management
Hassan, S. (2016) Impact of HRM Practices on Journal, 17, 335-354 (I 996).
Employee’s Performance. International Lado, M., and Alonso, P. (2017). The Five-
Journal of Academic Research in Factor Model and Job Performance in
Accounting Finance and Management Low Complexity Jobs: A Quantitative
Sciences, 6(1), 15–22. Synthesis. Revista de Psicología Del
Hair, J. F., et al. (2014). A Premier Partial Least Trabajo y de Las Organizaciones, 33(3),
Squares Structural Equation Modeling 175–182.
(PLS-SEM). Los Angeles: SAGE doi:10.1016/j.rpto.2017.07.004.
Publications, Inc Leena, P., and Kirupa, M. (2016). The Impact of
Herrmann, N. (1989). The Creative Brain. Lake Personality Traits on Job Performance in
Lure. Volume25 Number 4 Fourth the Context of Mobile Social
Quarter. NC: BrainBooks. Networking. International Journal of
Huselid, M.A. (1995). The impact of human Research in IT and Management (IJRIM),
resource management practice on 6(7), 41-48.
turnover, productivity, and corporate Lado, A.A., Wilson, M.C.. (1994). Human
financial performance. Academy of Resource Systems and Sustained
Management Journal, 38(3), 635-672. Competitive Advantage: A Competency-
Hough. (1992). The 'Big Five' Personality Based Perspective. Academy of
Variables--Construct Confusion: Management Review, 19(4), 699-727.
Description Versus Prediction. Human Latan, H., and Ghozali, I. (2017). Partial Least
Resource, 5(1&2), 139-155. Squares (Konsep, Metode dan Aplikasi
Hiltrop, J.M., (1996). The impact of human Menggunakan Program WarpPLS 5.0).
resource management on organisational Third Edition. Semarang: Badan Penerbit
performance: Theory and research. Universitas Diponegoro.
Jouda, Ali A., et al. (2016). The Impact of Mi-Ran Kim, M.R., and Han, S.J. (2014).
Human Resource Management Practices Relationships between the Myers-Briggs
on Employees Performance: The Case of Type Indicator Personality Profiling,
Islamic University of Gaza in Palestine. Academic Performance and Student
International Review of Management Satisfaction in Nursing Students.
and Marketing, 6(4), 1080-1088. International Journal of Bio-Science and
Jung, C.G. (1946). Psychologycal Type or The Bio-Technology, 6(6), 1-12.
Psychology of Individual. London: http://dx.doi.org/10.14257/ijbsbt.2014.
International Library of Psychology, 6.6.01.
Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co, Ltd. MacLean, P. (1990). The Triune Brain in
Kehoe, R. R., and Wrigth, P. M. (2010). The Evolution: Role in Paleocerebral
Impact of High-Performance Human Functions. New York and London:
Resource Practices on Employees’ National Institute of Mental Health
Attitudes and Behaviors. Journal of Bethesda, Mryland, Plenum Press.
Management, 20(10), 1-26. MacDuffie, J.P. (1995). Human Resource
Koopmans, L. (2014). Measuring Individual Bundles and Manufacturing
Work performance. Netherlands: CPI Performance: Organizational Logic and
Koninklijke Wohrmann, Zutphen. Flexible Production Systems in the
121
Yayan Hadiyat: Applying The Theory of …
122