Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Series 36 - Pirana Satpanth's Religious Head Is A Muslim
Series 36 - Pirana Satpanth's Religious Head Is A Muslim
Series 36 -Updated
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5HDO3DWLGDUPDLO#UHDOSDWLGDUFRP!
5HDO3DWLGDUPDLO#UHDOSDWLGDUFRP!
7RUHDOSDWLGDUUHDOSDWLGDU#JRRJOHJURXSVFRP!
0RQ$XJDW30
1RWHWV
1DPHRIQHZVSDSHULQZKLFKWKHQHZVRIGHDWKZDVSXEOLVKHGKDVEHHQQRZUHFWLILHG
FRUUHFWO\WR*XMDUDW6DPDFKDU
(DUOLHUZURQJO\PHQWLRQHGDV.XWFK0LWUD
kK^hSd\hIh^JhXh\h5\h5ZpdRhWje^hSJhXah\h58ajeSjSpahSWpkVh^WhEah\h5
k5
8ajJp Xe_h5 l_TjDJi\_Eh:Fke
5
-XO
__K]_\jWh^h]R____-D\/D[PLQDUD\DQ__
e\RhTsPhUadXe_h5K?N_pShxyk _h:zxyyWhXj^hRhdSX5TWhVhi\DkXj^
k 5WjIp\hRpJp SpBdSX5TdWhSWaqUD
bhkWZhahEhDWsU eh5ST]sJp Sp\kYs
5
V\WhFhUWhy|\h5ah^dUh^FhUXiSeSh
)HZGD\VEDFNLHRQ-XO3LUDQD6DWSDQWK
V3LUDQGUHOLJLRXVKHDG6KUL
6KDPVKXGGLQ%DZD.KDNLH[SLUHG+LVSKRWRJUDSKVLVJLYHQEHORZ+HZDVWKKHLUWR
WKHVHDWRI6DWSDQWK6DQDWDQ9DLGLN'KDUP
Sp\Wh\^RXJSp\WhUD^hB?ZpdRhWje^EZ^kK^hSd\hIh^\h5JXhajeSj
WjIp\hRpJp
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Page 1 of 7
www.realpatidar.com
mail@realpatidar.com
$IWHUKLVGHDWKKLVVRQVKDGSXEOLVKHGDQDGYHUWLVHPHQWLQ*XMDUDW6DPDFKDUQHZV
SDSHURQ-XO3DJH%KXM(GLWLRQZKLFKLVJLYHQEHORZ
;X^KRhap_e^EZ^\h5Rah_h]Dk]ksJp dSX5TdWhSWaqUDV\WhXj^
jXj^LhUhdq]UbkWZhahdheZEhD
8Ws7T?\Jp DXj^jXj^LhUh dq]UbkWZhahdheZEhD?ZjDs:We
XRdSX5TdWhSWaqUDV\WhXj^kJp
,PSRUWDQWSRLQWVZRUWKQRWLQJIURPWKHDERYHDGYHUWLVHPHQWLVWKDW6DWSDQWK6DQDWDQ
9HGLF5HOLJLRQ
V3LULVQRQHRWKHUWKDQ3LU]DGD6DL\\DG6KDVXGGKLQ%DZD6DKHE
.KDNL
]h^ZhUSh^Dxk _h:zxyyWh dSX5TdWhSWaqUDV\Wh7k]h]jB 7Wp
iWD_5DWh^h]R[FahWWhh_sB??Dh5K_DJi\\h5JXhajeSjWjIp
\hRpJp
7KHUHDIWHURQ-XOIROORZHUVRI6DWSDQWK6DQDWDQ9HGLF5HOLJLRQDQG
%HOLHYHUVRI1LVKNDODQNL1DUD\DQ%KDJZDQKDGSXEOLVKHGWKHLUFRQGROHQFHVLQ.XWFK
0LWUD1HZV3DSHU%KXM(GLWLRQ3DJHZKLFKLVDVXQGHU
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Page 2 of 7
www.realpatidar.com
mail@realpatidar.com
;X^ZShap_e^EZ^\h5S\pdhYKs:bDsJsD dSX5TdWhSWaqUDV\Wh
%XWWKHUHDIWHURQ-XORQFHDJDLQLQ.XWFK0LWUDQHZVSDSHURI%KXMHGLWLRQRQ
SDJHD'LVFODLPHULVSXEOLVKHGE\..36DWSDQWK6DQDWDQ6DPDMZKLFKLV
UHSURGXFHGEHORZ
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Page 3 of 7
www.realpatidar.com
mail@realpatidar.com
;X^ZShap_e^^U]sWh\UUTjKWShWd\?asd5Ubs\sD_ahWjDsibbD^ah\h5
8ajJp RpdSX5TV\7WpXj^bhkWZhahWsDs:d5ZV
5 WTj
5HDGLQJWKHDERYHGLVFODLPHUDQ\QRUPDOUHDGHUZRXOGJHWDQLPSUHVVLRQWKDW6DWSDQWK
5HOLJLRQDQG3LU6KDPVXGGLQ%DZDKDYHQRFRQQHFWLRQUHODWLRQ
k5
XR]hWTjah5]hZhUSp7]]WD^?Ssd\:8ap
bD;X^KRhap_e^
]sFWs8?Dd^dUhE_sJp SpWhDh^Rs8\hRpJp
+RZHYHUDIWHUFDUHIXOUHDGLQJDQGDQDO\VLQJLWZLOOEHFRPHYHU\FOHDUWKDWWKH'LVFODLPHU
SXEOLVKHGZDVMXVWWRIRROSHRSOHDQGKDVQRVXEVWDQFHWRLW7KLVLVDYHU\JRRGH[DPSOH
RIXVHRI7DTL\\DWRFRQIXVHSHRSOH7KHUHDVRQVIRUDUH
jDDXhdSX5TdWhSWd\hShxxzxyyWhDJ i\\h5^U]s8]sJp
k5
Vj:\h\bheZhah^sLhd5ThWD\jNN7WpSpk 5
XF_h5XpThXp_jJp SpWh\Jp
^ N^ bWW5Jp :{
6KUL..36DWSDQWK6DQWDQ6DPDMKDVQREDVLFDQGPRUDOULJKWWRLVVXHWKH
GLVFODLPHUSXEOLVKHGRQ-XOLQ.XWFK0LWUDQHZVSDSHU6XFKULJKWLVYHVWHGRQO\
ZLWKWKHKLJKHVWDQGPRWKHULQVWLWXWLRQRIDOO3LUDQD6DWSDQWKLV7KLVLQVWLWXWLRQZDV
IRUPHGE\WKHRUGHURIWKHFRXUWDQGLVFDOOHG7KH,PDP6KDK%DZD5R]D6DQVWKDQ
&RPPLWWHH7UXVWKDYLQJUHJLVWUDWLRQQRDV(
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Page 4 of 7
www.realpatidar.com
mail@realpatidar.com
D^ahWs7iVDh^Vj:\h\bheZhah^sLhd5ThWD\jNNWpJp 8N\h5XhNUh^
[h:BJp 7Wp{dq]U[h:BJp Sp\KV\Whk]DhDheh_pjWhWDUdDhDhkk
k k da[FSXj^LhUhdhTpD^dWDhDh7WpdaDhDhWs
D^dWUhdDhDh7WpSp\Wh
YsNsXRKs:bDbs Ip^\pWXU es]Jp 8\k `yyNB8N\h5Jp 8eDDSTj
dhYT:]Jp Ddq]U[h:B7WpXhNUh^[h:BaIpdSX5TV\ZhZSpacTj
d5ZV
5 Jp 7Wp?d5ZV
5 Xj^kk7Wpk^Us7k]h]jBWsd5ZV
5 Jp
6KUL..36DWSDQWK6DQDWDQ6DPDMLVD6RFLDO2UJDQLVDWLRQ:LWKUHVSHFWWR
6DWSDQWK5HOLJLRQLWGRHVQRWKDYHDQ\ULJKWWRLVVXHDQ\NLQGRIFODULILFDWLRQ 6XFKULJKW
LVYHVWHGRQO\ZLWK7KH,PDP6KDK%DZD5R]D6DQWKDQ&RPPLWWHH7UXVW 7KLVWUXVW
FRQVLVWVRIWUXVWHHVIURP3DWLGDUFRPPXQLWHHDQGWUXVWHHVIURP6DL\\HG
FRPPXQLW\7KHLQFXPEHQWPDLQ.DNDLVWKHFKDLUPDQRIWKHWUXVWZKRDW
SUHVHQWKDSSHQVWREH1DQDNGDV.DNDJXUX.DUVDQ.DNDDQGKLVJXUX6DYML.DND
<RXFDQVHHWKHSKRWRRI3LU]DGDZLWK.DUVDQ.DNDDQG6DYML.DND,QWKLVZD\
WKHUHDUHLQWRWDOWUXVWHHV:LWKWKLVIDFWLWEHFRPHVDPSO\FOHDUWKDW6DL\\HGVDQG
3DWLGDUVVKDUHVRPHNLQGRIFRPPRQUHODWLRQVKLS)RUKXQGUHGVRI\HDUVQRZWKH\
VKDUHGWKHUHODWLRQVKLSRID3LUJXUXZLWKWKDWRIIROORZHUVEHOLHYHUV
k 5XRS\pWjIpKs:bDsJs\h5D^dWDhDh7WpSp\Whk
k5
Sp\Whd5ZV
5 Ubh a?DYs
daDhDh Xj^bkWdhTpJp Xj^bhkWaIpZpOhJp
)URPWKHSKRWREHORZ\RXFDQVHHWKDW3LU]DGD6KDPVXGGKLQ.KDNLLVVLWWLQJLQWKH
PLGGOHDQG.DUVDQ.DNDOHIWDQGKLV*XUX6DYML.DNDULJKWDUHVWDQGLQJRQHLWKHU
VLGHV
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Page 5 of 7
www.realpatidar.com
mail@realpatidar.com
k_\saFp^GRjhiSWh_sDs\hWpJp DDXhdSX5Td\hKSsYSDJ\h5^eSh5DPah
XhNUh^sWj?DWhWjdh\hKDd5ThJp ?D:ZjdSX5Tj[h:BaSjTjiWapUW^U]s
W8XjbDDDXhdSX5TdWhSW d\h8Xp_^U]hkDs:ak
5
UWTj\S_ZWTj
2QDGLIIHUHQWQRWHWKHIROORZHUVRI6DWSDQWK6DQDWDQ9HGLF5HOLJLRQDUHQRW
FRQILQHGWRSHRSOHIURP..3.XWFK.DGYD3DWLGDUFRPPXQLW\RQO\3HRSOHIURP
FRPPXQLWLHVOLNH5DEDUL/RKDQD.KRMD%UDKPDQ*XMMDU.ROL3DWHO0XVOLPVHWF
EHOLHYHLQ6DWSDQWKUHOLJLRQ..36DWSDQWK6DQDWDQ6DPDMLVDYHU\VPDOORUJDQLVDWLRQ
RI.DGYD3DWLGDUVRI.XWFKUHJLRQ,WFDQQRWJLYHDQ\FODULILFDWLRQRISHRSOHIURPRWKHU
FRPPXQLWLHV7KHGLVFODLPHUSXEOLVKHGE\..36DQWSDQWK6DQDWDQ6DPDMKDVQRWUHDO
PHDQLQJDQGKDVDEVROXWHO\QRVWDQGLQJDWDOO
Ss8ahd5KsFs\h5jDDXhdSX5TdWhSWd\hKh^h?kiWap
5
UWD^kD
5 dSX5T
dWhSWaqUDV\Wh7k]h]jB7WpiWD_5DWh^]R[FahWWhVhBWpXj^j
,QOLJKWRIWKHDERYHWKHGLVFODLPHUSXEOLVKHGE\..6DWSDQWK6DQWDQ6DPDMWKDW
IROORZHUVRI6DWSDQWK6DQDWDQ9HGLFUHOLJLRQDQGEHOLHYHUVRI1LVKNDODQNL1DUD\DQ
%KDJZDQKDYHQRWKLQJWRGRZLWK3LU6KUL3UL]DGD6DL\\DG6KDPVKXGGLQLVQRWKLQJ
EXWGHIDPLQJWKH3LUWRKXUWWKHIHHOVRIKLVIROORZHUVDQGVRPHWKLQJRWKHUWKDQWUXWK
7KXVDIWHUXQGHUVWDQGLQJWKHDERYHIDFWVLWEHFRPHVYHU\FOHDU
WKDWWKHUHOLJLRXVKHDGRI3LUDQD6DWSDQWKUHOLJLRQDOLDV
6DWSDQWK6DQDWDQ9HGLF5HOLJLRQLVD0XVOLP6DL\\HG$W
SUHVHQWQDPHRIWKHSHUVRQVLWLQJRQWKHVHDWWKHWKKHLU
6DMMDG1DVKLQLV3LU6KUL3LU]DGD6DL\\HG6DOODXGGLQ
6KDPVKXGGLQ%DZD.KDNL
_sDsXj^hRhdSX5TWjdIh:TjahDY^eSpWh\hN 8:\p:_\sD_ah\h58]sJp
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Page 6 of 7
www.realpatidar.com
mail@realpatidar.com
7KLVHPDLOKDVEHHQFLUFXODWHGWRPDNHSHRSOHDZDUHDERXWWKHWUXHIDFWVRI3LUDQD
6DWSDQWK
5HDO3DWLGDU
ZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRP
9LHZVH[SUHVVHGKHUHDUHIRUWKHVDNHRIGLVFXVVLRQDQGNQRZOHGJHRQO\
7RIXOO\XQGHUVWDQGWKHFRQWHQWVRIWKLVHPDLO\RXPD\EHUHTXLUHGWR
UHDGKWWSZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPDUFKLYHVVHULHV
7RNQRZPRUHYLVLWZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPRUVHQGDUHTXHVWPDLOWR
PDLO#UHDOSDWLGDUFRP
7RUHFHLYHHPDLOVVHQGDUHTXHVWWRPDLO#UHDOSDWLGDUFRPRUMRLQJRRJOH
JURXSKWWSJURXSVJRRJOHFRPJURXSUHDOSDWLGDU
9LHZVH[SUHVVHGKHUHDUHQRWQHFHVVDULO\RI5HDO3DWLGDURUVXEVFULEHGE\5HDO3DWLGDU
%(:$5(%(:$5(3KLVKLQJDWWDFNV
UHDOSDWLGDU#JRRJOHJURXSVFRPUHDOSDWLGDUU#JPDLOFRP
UHDOSDWLGDDU#JPDLOFRP
DUH127UHODWHGWRWKHZZZUHDOSDWLGDUFRPWKHRULJLQDO5HDO3DWLGDU
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Page 7 of 7
www.realpatidar.com
mail@realpatidar.com