Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Relationship of Dropout and Psychopathology in A High School Sample in Mexico
Relationship of Dropout and Psychopathology in A High School Sample in Mexico
Edited by: School dropout has significant consequences for both individuals and societies. Only 21%
Boris Lorberg, University of
of adults in Mexico achieve the equivalent of a high school education. We examined the
Massachusetts School of Medicine,
USA relationship between school dropout and self-reported psychiatric symptoms in a middle
Reviewed by: school in a suburb of Mexico City. We used binomial logistic regression to examine the
Lynsay Ayer, University of Vermont, odds ratio (OR) of school dropout associated with students’ self-reported psychopathol-
USA ogy. Two-hundred thirty-seven students participated in the study. Psychosis [OR = 8.0
Constance Moore, University of
(95% confidence interval, CI: 1.7–37.2)], depression [OR = 4.7 (95% CI: 2.2–9.7)], tic disor-
Massachusetts Medical School, USA
ders [OR = 3.7 (95% CI: 1.4–9.5)], ADHD [OR = 3.2 (95% CI: 1.5–6.4)], and social phobia
*Correspondence:
Pablo J. Chalita, Instituto Nacional de [OR = 2.6 (95% CI: 1.2–5.8)] were associated with increased risk of school dropout after
Psiquiatría “Ramón de la Fuente controlling for age and gender as covariates. Our study suggested that students’ self-
Muñíz”, Calzada México Xochimilco reported psychopathology is associated with increased school dropout in Mexico. ADHD
Num. 101, Col. San Lorenzo Huipulco,
and depression may be particularly useful childhood psychiatric disorders to target with
Tlalpan, C.P. 14370 Distrito Federal,
Mexico. public health interventions because they explain the greatest amount of the variance in
e-mail: pchalita@gmail.com school dropout of child psychiatric disorders.
Keywords: student dropout, child psychiatry, Mexico
INTRODUCTION school education in the USA; OECD, 2010). Increased drug use
School dropout has significant consequences for both individ- has been associated with poor school attendance and dropout
uals and societies. Little has been written about the impact of rates (Tavares et al., 2001). Among Mexican middle school stu-
school dropouts in Mexico. According to published data from the dents, poor academic performance was associated with increased
United States, high school dropouts are twice as likely to be unem- depressive symptomatology (de la Peña et al., 1999). Roughly one
ployed as high school graduates (KewalRamani et al., 2007). For in five Mexican children experiences a significant child psychiatric
those high school dropouts fortunate enough to work, pay is con- illness in his lifetime (Sauceda, 1994). In both the United States and
siderably lower. The average high school dropout in the United Mexico, improving high school graduation rates continues to be
States earns just 37 cents for every dollar that is earned by a a formidable educational and public health challenge (Ream and
high school graduate (Rumberger and Thomas, 2000). Eighty- Rumberger, 2008). Childhood psychopathology represents both a
eight percent of adults in the United States of America have possible predictor of future school dropout and a potential area
achieved at least a secondary level of education (OECD, 2003). for intervention.
However, graduation rates among underrepresented minority stu- The purpose of this study is to examine the association
dents, particularly Latinos and African Americans, are even lower between self-reported childhood psychopathology and school
(KewalRamani et al., 2007). Only slightly more than half of dropout by the end of the school year in a cohort of Mex-
these student populations graduate from high school on time. ican middle school students. Our goals are to determine the
U.S. Latinos have the highest dropout rate of all the major child symptoms suggestive of a psychiatric disorder that seem
racial/ethnic groups, and youths of Mexican descent are especially to be most strongly associated with future school dropout and
susceptible to not completing school (Valencia, 2002; Calderón to determine which child symptoms suggestive of a psychi-
et al., 2009). Because the lack of information on this subject atric disorder accounted for the greatest number of school
from Mexico, it is difficult to draw conclusions from this last dropouts.
statement.
In Mexico, much less is known about school dropouts, but it MATERIALS AND METHODS
is clear the problem is quite dire. More than half of the adults SELECTION
in Mexico have at most a primary level education (equivalent Subjects were recruited from the Technical Middle – High School
to grade school education in the USA). Only 21% of adults in Num. One hundred sixteen “Netzahualpilli” in the town of Tex-
Mexico have a secondary level of education (equivalent to a high coco, Mexico, located in the metropolitan area of Mexico City. The
Frontiers in Psychiatry | Child and Neurodevelopmental Psychiatry March 2012 | Volume 3 | Article 20 | 2
Chalita et al. Mexican school dropout and psychopathology
Table 1 | Odds ratio for dropouts unadjusted. Table 3 | Dropout overall logistic regression model.
Table 2 | Odds ratio for dropouts adjusted for age and gender. (SSA, 2001). In our study we found that the presence of self-
reported psychiatric symptoms is associated with increased risk for
Symptoms suggestive OR 95% CI 95% CI p
school dropout. Self-reported symptoms of psychosis, depression,
of the following disorder (LE) (UE)
ADHD, tics, social phobia, and other anxiety disorders were specif-
Psychosis 7.957 1.701 37.208 0.010 ically associated with future school dropout. School dropout has
Depression 4.651 2.226 9.718 0.001 profound negative consequences in Mexico and worldwide. Fail-
Tic disorder 3.666 1.414 9.503 0.008 ure to graduate is associated with greater lifetime unemployment
ADHD 3.136 1.531 6.426 0.002 and lower anticipated wages. The natural history of many of these
Social phobia 2.617 1.190 5.754 0.017 child psychiatric disorders (particularly depression, ADHD, and
Smoking 2.447 0.807 7.421 0.113 social phobia), can be altered dramatically with proper treatment
Alcohol use 2.303 0.682 7.777 0.179 (March et al., 2004, 2009; Kratochvil et al., 2009; Molina et al., 2009;
Separation anxiety 2.046 0.943 4.438 0.070 Reinecke et al., 2009). With early intervention, the developmental
Panic attacks 2.026 0.993 4.135 0.053 impact of all of these disorders can be minimized (Birmaher et al.,
Generalized anxiety 1.547 0.758 3.156 0.231 1996; Graham et al., 2006). Thus, our data suggests that in many
Drug use 1.394 0.438 4.430 0.574 cases the self-reported screening strategies may be able to identify
School anxiety 1.225 0.390 3.848 0.728 individuals with high likelihood of having child mental issues that
OCD 1.204 0.566 2.562 0.629 are associated with school dropout and that children appear will-
ing to endorse symptoms on self-report measures. This data also
ADHD, Attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder, OCD, obsessive–compulsive suggests that not only educational interventions but interventions
disorder. designed to improve overall childhood mental health in Mexico
may decrease school dropout rates. Of course, these hypothe-
EXPLORATORY BEST-FIT MODEL FOR EXPLAINING DROPOUT AND ses need to be analyzed in larger, multi-school studies that use
CHILD PSYCHOPATHOLOGY structured assessment for clinical psychiatric diagnoses and mea-
Table 3 depicts the best-fit model for explaining school dropout sure important covariates like intelligence, parental education, and
based on child symptoms suggestive of a psychiatric disorder. socio-economic status.
Among all children, increased school dropout was associated with Population based surveys of physicians who treat children and
male gender and severity of self-reported ADHD and depression adolescents reveal that the rate and proportion of office visits asso-
symptoms. These variables explained only 13% of the variance in ciated with ADHD are high, and have increased during the past
overall dropout rates. We also found that among females, increased decade. They also show that until recent years clinical guidelines
ADHD and depression symptoms were significantly associated were not available for country-specific populations (Ulloa et al.,
with increased dropout and among males ADHD symptoms were 2005). According to the Pan-American Health Organization, Latin
associated with dropout. America’s and the Caribbean’s access to health services is restricted
to less than 30% of the general population, with access to mental
DISCUSSION health services being even worse, and potentially generating severe
Epidemiological studies suggest that approximately 15% of chil- stigma, and economic and social problems (Acuña and Bolis,
dren in Mexico have a significant mental illness by age 14 2005). Our logistic regression model suggests that ADHD and
depression may be particularly useful childhood psychiatric dis- number of school dropouts. There are already certain teen screen-
orders to target with public health interventions because they (1) ing programs designed to target adolescent suicide in the US, and
explain the greatest amount of the variance in school dropout of these programs have been highly successful at screening for depres-
child psychiatric disorders and (2) they respond well to treatment. sion using self-report measures (Shaffer et al., 1998; Aseltine and
In light of our findings, this study has several limitations. We DeMartino, 2004; Levitt et al., 2004; Gould et al., 2005). Improve-
relied on childrens’ self-reported measures of psychiatric illness, ments in screening and treatment of these childhood mental
without using formal structured clinical assessments to confirm disorders in Mexico may lead, not only to improved overall men-
these diagnoses. Our screening tools involved the use of many rat- tal well-being in children, but also to decreased academic failure.
ing scales that have not been validated in the Spanish language Future studies exploring the feasibility, possible methodologies,
and our analysis relied on un-validated cutoff points in many of and potential impact of child mental health screening in Mexico
the scales. Thus, we can only conclude from our data that specific are needed. By enhancing child mental health education, screen-
self-reported psychiatric symptoms are associated with dropout, ing, and treatment, we will very likely see an improved quality of
not necessarily the disorders themselves. Another limitation of this life and mental health for these individuals, as well as the overall
study is that our data came exclusively from one middle school in health, education, and economy of the Mexican society.
Mexico. This school was chosen by convenience and because we Finally, it is important for parents and school authorities to be
thought it would be likely to be representative of urban educa- aware and in constant communication about the issues of mental
tion in Mexico. We do not know how well the results from this health of children and adolescents, since early detection of child
school can be generalized to the rest of Mexico or the developing psychiatric disorders has the potential to lead to better overall
world. Further studies need to examine the generalizability of our child mental health, academic performance and future quality of
results. Additionally, we did not measure potentially important life (Kessler et al., 1995).
confounders in the study population including intelligence, read-
ing level, socioeconomical status, and parental education. Finally, ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
only 31% of students completed self-report measures. Students The authors acknowledge the National Institute of Mental Health
who participated in this study were more likely to be female and support of the Yale Child Study Center Research Training Program
have better academic performance than those who chose not to (MHB), the National Institutes of Health Loan Repayment Pro-
participate. Thus, we cannot say that these populations did not gram (MHB), the support of the Tourette’s Syndrome Association
differ in additional unmeasured variables Inc. (MHB), the APIRE/Eli Lilly Psychiatric Research Fellowship
Despite the limitations our study suggested that several differ- (MHB), the AACAP/Eli Lilly Pilot Research Award (MHB), the
ent types of child symptoms suggestive of a psychiatric disorder Trichotillomania Learning Center (MHB) and NARSAD (MHB).
(ADHD, depression, psychosis, tics, and social phobia) are associ- Academic Committee, Scholarship Committee and Education
ated with increased rate of school dropout in Mexico. We also Department at the National Institute of Psychiatry “Ramón de
found that children are willing to self-report most psychiatric la Fuente Muñíz”, México, DF. Thanks to Prof. Gerardo Gallardo,
symptoms. This is a very significant finding, as these self-report Alicia Chalita and Fernanda Perez Tagle for their administrative
screening strategies may be very useful in helping decrease the support.
REFERENCES adolescent depression: a review of Norms, and Clinical Interpretation. KewalRamani, A., Gilbertson, L., Fox,
Acuña, C., and Bolis, M. (2005). La the past 10 years. Part I. J. Am. New York, NY: Guilford Press. M. A., and Provasnik, S. (2007).
estigmatización y el acceso a la Acad. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry 35, Gould, M. S., Marrocco, F. A., Klein- Status and trends in the education
atención de salud en América Latina: 1427–1439. man, M., Thomas, J. G., Mostkoff, of racial and ethnic minorities.
Amenazas y perspectivas. Available at: Calderón, J. M., Robles, R. R., Reyes, J. K., Cote, J., and Davies, M. (2005). NCES 2007-039. Available at:
http://www.paho.org/Project.asp? C., Matos, T. D., Negrón, J. L., and Evaluating iatrogenic risk of youth http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2007/minor
SEL=TP&LNG=ENG&ID=216 Cruz, M. A. (2009). Predictors of suicide screening programs: a ran- itytrends/ind_4_17.asp.
Aseltine, R. H., and DeMartino, R. school dropout among adolescents domized controlled trial. JAMA 293, Kratochvil, C. J., May, D. E., Silva, S.
(2004). An outcome evaluation of in Puerto Rico. P. R. Health Sci. J. 28, 1635–1643. G., Madaan, V., Puumala, S. E.,
the SOS Suicide Prevention Pro- 307–312. Graham, E., Kratochvil, C., Vitiello, B., Curry, J. F., Walkup, J., Kepley,
gram. Am. J. Public Health 94, de la Peña, F., Estrada, A., Almeida, L., Silva, S., Mayes, T., McNulty, S., H., Vitiello, B., and March, J. S.
446–451. and Páez, F. (1999). Prevalence of Weller, E., Waslick, B., Casat, C., (2009). Treatment response in
Birmaher, B., Khetarpal, S., Brent, D., depressive disorders and low aca- Walkup, J., Pathak, S., Rohde, P., depressed adolescents with and
Cully, M., Balach, L., Kaufman, demic achievement in junior high Posner, K., March, J., and Colum- without co-morbid attention-
J., and Neer, S. M. (1997). The school students. Salud Ment. 22, bia Suicidality Classification Group; deficit/hyperactivity disorder in
Screen for Child Anxiety Related 9–13. TADS Team. (2006). Treatment the Treatment for Adolescents
Emotional Disorders (SCARED): de la Peña, F., Lara, M. C., and Cortes, for Adolescents with Depression with Depression Study. J. Child
scale construction and psycho- J. (1996). Traducción al español Study (TADS): safety results. J. Am. Adolesc. Psychopharmacol. 19,
metric characteristics. J. Am. y validez de la escala de Birleson Acad. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry 45, 519–527.
Acad. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry 36, (DSRS) para el trastorno depre- 1440–1455. Levitt, J. M.,WonPat-Borja,A., Buffered,
545–553. sivo mayor en la adolescencia. Salud Kessler, R. C., Foster, C. L., Saun- S., and Jensen, P. (2004). Imple-
Birmaher, B., Ryan, N. D., Williamson, Ment. 3, 17–23. ders, W. B., and Stang, P. E. (1995). menting Evidence-Based Assessment
D. E., Brent, D. A., Kaufman, J., DuPaul, G. J., Power, T. J, Anastopou- Social consequences of psychiatric Strategies in Schools. Honolulu, HI:
Dahl, R. E., Perel, J., and Nel- los, A. D., and Reid, R. (1998). disorders, I: educational attainment. American Psychological Associa-
son, B. (1996). Childhood and ADHD Rating Scale – IV: Checklists, Am. J. Psychiatry 152, 1026–1032. tion.
Frontiers in Psychiatry | Child and Neurodevelopmental Psychiatry March 2012 | Volume 3 | Article 20 | 4
Chalita et al. Mexican school dropout and psychopathology
March, J., Silva, S., Curry, J., Wells, Molina, B. S., Hinshaw, S. P., Swan- J. Clin. Child Adolesc. Psychol. 53, hiperactividad en niños y adoles-
K., Fairbank, J., Burns, B., Domino, son, J. M., Arnold, L. E., Vitiello, B., 761–767. centes. Salud Ment. 28, 1–10.
M., Vitiello, B., Severe, J., Riedal, Jensen, P. S., Epstein, J. N., Hoza, Rumberger, R. W., and Thomas, S. L. Valencia, R. R. (ed.). (2002). Chicano
K., Goldman, M., Feeny, N., Find- B., Hechtman, L., Abikoff, H. B., (2000). The distribution of dropout School Failure and Success: Past,
ling, R., Stull, S., Baab, S., Weller, E. Elliott, G. R., Greenhill, L. L., New- and turnover rates among urban and Present and Future, 2nd Edn. Lon-
B., Robbins, M., Weller, R. A., Jes- corn, J. H., Wells, K. C., Wigal, T., suburban high schools. Sociol. Educ. don: Routledge Falmer.
sani, N., Waslick, B., Sweeney, M., Gibbons, R. D., Hur, K., Houck, P. 73, 39–67.
Dublin, R., Walkup, J., Ginsburg, G., R., and MTA Cooperative Group. Sauceda, J. M. (1994). Normalidad y psi-
Kastelic, E., Koo, H., Kratochvil, C., (2009). The MTA at 8 years: prospec- copatología en la adolescencia. Rev. Conflict of Interest Statement: The
May, D., LaGrone, R., Vaughan, B., tive follow-up of children treated for Mex. Pediatría 61, 153–157. authors declare that the research was
Albano, A. M., Hirsch, G. S., Pod- combined-type ADHD in a multi- Shaffer, D., Restifo, K., Garfinkel, R., conducted in the absence of any com-
niesinki, E., Chu, A., Reincecke, M., site study. J. Am. Acad. Child Adolesc. Wilcox, H., Ehrensaft, M., and Mun- mercial or financial relationships that
Leventhal, B., Rogers, G., Jacobs, R., Psychiatry 48, 484–500. fakh, J. (1998). Screening for Young- could be construed as a potential con-
Pathak, S., Wells, J., Lavanier, S. A., OECD. (2003). Online Education Data- Adult Suicidality and Mood Disor- flict of interest.
Danielyan, A., Rohde, P., Simons, base (Internet; cited 2010). Available ders in High School. Anaheim, CA:
A., Grimm, J., Frank, S., Emslie, at: http://www.oecd.org/document/ AACAP. Received: 27 September 2011; accepted:
G., Kennard, B., Hughes, C., Mayes, 54/0,3343,en_2649_39263238_3808 SSA. (2001). “Programa de accion en 25 February 2012; published online: 13
T. L., Rosenberg, D., Benazon, N., 2166_1_1_1_37455,00.html#9 salud mental,” in Diagnostico Epi- March 2012.
Butkus, M., and Bartoi, M. (2009). OECD. (2010). StatExtracts. Available demiologico, ed. Secretaria de Salud Citation: Chalita PJ, Palacios L, Cortes
The Treatment for Adolescents With at: http://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx? Mexico (Mexico), 29–51. JF, Landeros-Weisenberger A, Panza KE
Depression Study (TADS): out- DatasetCode=RPOP. Suarez, A. (1999). Diseño y determina- and Bloch MH (2012) Relationship of
comes over 1 year of naturalistic Palacios, L. (2003). Escala de evalua- cion de la estructura factorial de la dropout and psychopathology in a high
follow-up. Am. J. Psychiatry 166, cion de problemas externalizados para Escala Dimensional de Psicopatología school sample in Mexico. Front. Psychia-
1141–1149. adolescentes y adultos jovenes (EPE- para Adolescentes (EDPA). UNAM: try 3:20. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2012.00020
March, J., Silva, S., Petrycki, S., Curry, AA). M. S. Thesis, UNAM, Mexico. Mexico. This article was submitted to Frontiers in
J., Wells, K., Fairbank, J., Burns, B., Ream, R. K., and Rumberger, R. W. Tavares, B. F., Béria, J. U., and Child and Neurodevelopmental Psychia-
Domino, M., McNulty, S.,Vitiello, B., (2008). Student Engagement, Peer Silva de Lima, M. (2001). Drug try, a specialty of Frontiers in Psychiatry.
Severe, J., and Treatment for Adoles- Social Capital, and School Dropout use prevalence and school per- Copyright © 2012 Chalita, Palacios,
cents with Depression Study (TADS) Among Mexican American and formance among adolescents. Rev. Cortes, Landeros-Weisenberger, Panza
Team. (2004). Fluoxetine, cognitive- Non-Latino White Students. Sociol. Saúde Pública 35, 150–158. and Bloch. This is an open-access article
behavioral therapy, and their combi- Educ. 81, 109–139. Ulloa, R. E., Arroyo, E., Ávila, J. M., Cár- distributed under the terms of the Cre-
nation for adolescents with depres- Reinecke, M. A., Curry, J. F., and March, denas, J. A., Cruz, E., Gómez, D., ative Commons Attribution Non Com-
sion: Treatment for Adolescents with J. S. (2009). Findings from the Treat- Higuera, F., Rivera, F., Santos, G., mercial License, which permits non-
Depression Study (TADS) random- ment for Adolescents with Depres- Velásquez, V., De Peña, F. (2005). commercial use, distribution, and repro-
ized controlled trial. JAMA 292, sion Study (TADS): what have we Algoritmo del tratamiento para el duction in other forums, provided the
807–820. learned? What do we need to know? trastorno por déficit de atención con original authors and source are credited.