Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Determination of Residual Stress and Design of ProcessParameters For Com...
Determination of Residual Stress and Design of ProcessParameters For Com...
Research Article
Determination of Residual Stress and Design of Process
Parameters for Composite Cylinder in Filament Winding
Chao Kang ,1 Yaoyao Shi,1 Bo Deng,1 Tao Yu,1 and Pengcheng Sun2
1
The Key Laboratory of Contemporary Design and Integrated Manufacturing Technology, Ministry of Education,
Northwestern Polytechnical University, Xi’an, Shaanxi 710072, China
2
Institute of Applied Optics, Xi’an, Shaanxi 710065, China
Copyright © 2018 Chao Kang et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
As there is increasing usage of composite components with a closed-end shape, filament winding technology has been applied
extensively in engineering practice. However, the residual stresses are readily caused by process parameters in composite
manufacturing process. Hence, it is necessary to design the reasonable process parameters for obtaining the expected residual
stresses. This study proposed a reverse derivation method to design the winding tension based on the residual stress model of the
composite cylinder. To analyze the development of residual stresses, the thermal deformation behavior and a micromechanics
model of resin shrinkage are considered to calculate thermal strains and instantaneous shrinkage strains of the hoop wound
cylinder during the curing process. Combining the contribution of winding tension to the stresses, the simple model of residual
stresses is established based on the superposition principle. Then inversely solving the analytic model, the design method of
winding tension is illustrated to guarantee that the hoop wound cylinder with an inner liner has a uniform residual hoop stress.
The model accuracy of residual stresses is validated by the destructive slitting experiment. The result indicates that the present
model can be used to estimate the residual stresses and design the winding tension for the hoop wound cylinder.
Velocity + +
+
Pressure
Mandrel Curing oven
Incoming prepreg Air cylinder Tension measuring
Hot compaction mechanism
roller
Consolidated substrate
(a) (b)
Figure 1: Manufacturing process of the composite wound cylinder. (a) Winding process. (b) Curing process.
residual stresses has become more meaningful. Kim et al. 2. Filament Winding Process
[19] and Lee et al. [20] proposed a smart cure method to
reduce the residual stresses in the thick wound compos- The residual stresses of wound cylinder depend on the
ite cylinder by using finite element method. Ren et al. manufacturing parameters and material characteristics [15].
addressed a finite element strategy for simulating the Especially the stress state of composite cylinder is mainly
winding process of the wound vessel with a metal liner. affected by winding tension and curing processing param-
Then, the iterative search method was established to eters. Figure 1 displays the general manufacturing process of
calculate the initial winding tension of any winding layer the fabricating composite component. The whole process
for ensuring the residual hoop stress uniform [21]. Wu includes the winding process and curing process. In the
and Zhang adopted the neural network method to deter- winding process, the prepreg tape is tightened through
mine the initial winding tension for ensuring the re- a magnetic powder brake controlled by a closed-loop system.
sidual hoop stress of each layer consistency [22]. Xu Then, the tape is heated and compressed by the hot com-
et al. studied the residual hoop stress caused by winding paction roller. Subsequently, the hot-melted prepreg tape is
tension and temperature. Based on the mix-mode method wrapped onto the rotating mandrel. In the curing process,
of elastic modulus, the design method of process param- the degree of curing varies as the temperature of composite
eters was addressed for the composite cylinder with a hot component changes. The whole manufacturing process is
core [23]. incomplete until the curing reaction is finished, and the
As can be observed from the previous studies, the temperature of composite component drops to the envi-
residual stresses of composite component have received ronment temperature.
tremendous attention. Besides, how to design process pa-
rameters has also been a crucial issue. However, it is noticed 3. Establishment of Residual Stresses
that most studies about the parametric design only involved
the winding process or the curing process. Although a few Through the above description of the prepreg tape winding
works considered the whole manufacturing process, their process, it can be seen that the key parameters include
models assumed composite as the isotropy material [23]. winding tension, winding temperature, and pressure. Among
In order to improve the accuracy of the model of residual these parameters, the winding tension affects the residual
stresses, the wound cylinder is assumed as the transversely stresses significantly. The temperature can cause the thermal
isotropic material in this article. Adopting the plane stress stress when the prepreg tape is heated by the hot compaction
assumption and the micromechanics model, the analytic roller in the winding process. However, the thermal stress is
model of residual stresses for hoop wound cylinder with an released rapidly due to the viscous flow state of resin. Al-
inner liner is established by considering the shrinkage stress though the pressure is applied to improve the interface
and thermal stress. Subsequently, the residual stresses of bonding strength, the pressure will be zero when the hot
composite cylinder after mandrel removal are determined compaction roller gets back. Thus, assuming the residual
according to the stress equilibrium. Then, the destructive stress induced by pressure will not be taken into account. In
slitting experiment is performed to measure the residual the curing process, it is found that the temperature gradient
stresses. The results show that the experimental data are leads to thermal stress, and the shrinkage of composite
consistent with the simulated value. Moreover, based on the volume causes chemical shrinkage stress [24]. Therefore, the
theoretical model, the design method of the winding tension influences of winding temperature and pressure on residual
is proposed to ensure that the composite cylinder with an stresses can be ignored. The residual stresses, namely, the final
inner liner has a uniform residual hoop stress through the stress state of the composite cylinder, can be derived
filament wound section. according to the procedure shown in Figure 2. The first step is
Advances in Materials Science and Engineering 3
Cylinder after
Thermal stress σth Residual stress σRs
mandrel removal
Curing process
Chemical Sress
shrinkage stress σch reequilibrium
to obtain the total stress of composite with a mandrel in the Winding tension F(rj)
filament winding process. It can be expressed as
rj
σ total � σ wt + σ th + σ ch , (1)
b P
total
where σ is the total stress of composite with mandrel and
σ wt th
i is the stress caused by the winding process. σ i and σ i
ch
where c1 and c2 are determined by the boundary conditions. Based on the superposition principle, the total hoop
Inverting (6) and introducing (9) and (5) into it, the stress of the ith layer in the composite cylinder is the sum of
stresses of the composite cylinder are derived as stresses caused by all of layers wrapped from the ith to nth
σ r � c1 S1 rβ−1 − c2 S2 r−β−1 , (10a) layer after the winding process is completed. Thus, the final
hoop stress of the composite cylinder induced by winding
σ θ � c1 S3 rβ−1 + c2 S4 r−β−1 . (10b) tension can be established as follows:
The coefficients are derived from the following
F ri
equations: σ wt
θ ri , rn � + σ θ (i, i + 1) + · · · + σ θ (i, n)
h
β + vθ n (15)
S1 � E, F ri
1 − vr vθ r �
h
+ ∑ σ θ (i, j),
j�i+1
β − vθ
S2 � E,
1 − vr vθ r where h is the thickness of the prepreg tape and F(ri) denotes
(11) the winding tension per width for the ith layer.
1 + βvr
S3 � E, Since the thickness of the prepreg tape is too thin, the
1 − vr vθ θ
numerical integration method is adopted to simplify (15),
1 − βvr and then (14b) is substituted into it. The hoop stress of the
S4 � E.
1 − vr vθ θ composite cylinder can be derived as
1 m ξ β F(ξ)
σ wt
θ (x) � F(x) + H S
1 4 − H S
2 3 (x) 2β
(x)
−β−1
2β
dξ , (16a)
h x H1 S2 + H2 S1 ξ
Advances in Materials Science and Engineering 5
where ξ is the dummy variable of integration, m � rn/b, and Based on the superposition principle and combining (14a),
x � ri/b. the final radial stress of the composite cylinder can be given as
1 m ξ β F(ξ)
σ wt (x) � − H S + H S (x) 2β
(x)
−β−1
dξ. (16b)
r
h 1 2 2 1
x H1 S2 + H2 S1 ξ
2β
S6 x −β−1 β−1 x
2β
σ th
r (x) � S 1 S2 (m) − H1 S2 − S1 S2 (m)β−1 − H2 S1 (x)2β
H1 S2 + H2 S1 (m)2β m m
bKΔT f1 − f2 x −2β
+ 2β
(x)−β−1 − 1 + S6 ,
H1 S2 + H2 S1 m Er − Eθ m
(26)
S6 x −β−1 β−1 2β β−1 x
2β
σ th
θ (x) �− −H 1 S 4 − S 1 S4 (m) + H2 S 3 (x) − S2 S3 (m)
H1 S2 + H2 S1 (m)2β m m
bKΔT f1 − f2 x −2β
− 2β
(x)−β−1 S1 S4 + S2 S3 + S5 .
H1 S2 + H2 S1 m Er − Eθ m
The parameters are defined by the following equations: where Δα is the increment of degree of curing with
2 2 temperature gradient and V sh is the volume shrinkage
f1 β 1 + vr − f2 1 + β vr
S5 � ΔT, ratio.
1 − vr vθ 1 − β2 Effective chemical shrinkage strains in the composite are
(27) calculated according to the micromechanics model. The
f1 vθ + β2 − f2 1 + vθ
S6 � ΔT. incremental shrinkage strains of composite can be calculated
1 − vr vθ 1 − β2 as follows [24]:
Δεc Ec 1 − Vf
Δεch
θ � ,
3.2.2. Chemical Shrinkage Stress. The resin shrinkage mainly E f V f + Ec 1 − V f
depends on the degree of cure and the total volumetric
shrinkage of the cured resin. Since the resin is a kind of Δεch ch
r � Δεc + vc Δεc 1 − Vf − vr Vf + vc 1 − Vf Δεθ .
isotropic material, the contraction for a unit cell in resin is (29)
uniform in each direction. The incremental shrinkage strain
of resin can be calculated as follows [24]: Thus, analogously to the method for calculating the
���������� thermal stress, the chemical shrinkage stress can be de-
Δεc � 3 1 + Δα · Vsh − 1, (28)
termined as
S8 x −β−1 β−1 x
2β
Δσ ch
r (x) � S1 S 2 (m) − H1 S2 − S1 S2 (m)β−1 − H2 S1 (x)2β
H1 S2 + H2 S1 (m)2β m m
bK g1 − g2 x −2β
+ 2β
(x)−β−1 − 1 + S8 ,
H1 S2 + H2 S1 m Er − Eθ m
(30)
S8 x −β−1 β−1 2β β−1 x
2β
Δσ ch
θ (x) �− −H 1 S4 − S 1 S 4 (m) + H 2 S3 (x) − S 2 S3 (m)
H1 S2 + H2 S1 (m)2β m m
bK g1 − g2 x −2β
− 2β
(x)−β−1 S1 S4 + S2 S3 + S7 .
H1 S2 + H2 S1 m Er − Eθ m
The parameters are defined by the following equations: 3.3. Residual Stresses of the Composite Cylinder. Through the
stress analysis in the above sections, the total stress σ total of
g1 � Δεch ch
θ vθ + Δεr Er , the composite cylinder with mandrel is composed of stress
σ wt, thermal stress σ th, and chemical shrinkage stress σ ch. It is
g2 � Δεch ch
r vr + Δεθ Eθ ,
well known that the wound components include two types:
g1 β2 1 + vr − g2 1 + β2 vr (1) for the composite cylinder with an inner liner, the liner is
S7 � , (31) considered as the important part of the product. In this case,
1 − vr vθ 1 − β2
the inner liner is regarded as the mandrel. Therefore, the
g1 vθ + β2 − g2 1 + vθ corresponding residual stress equals to the total stress σ total.
S8 � . (2) For the composite cylinder after mandrel removal, the
1 − v r v θ 1 − β2 inner radius of the composite cylinder becomes a free surface
Advances in Materials Science and Engineering 7
Table 2: Epoxy resin kinetic parameters. manufacturing process, the winding temperature and en-
vironment temperature are 50°C and 16°C. The winding
Ea (KJ/mol) A (s−1) n tension and pressure of hot compaction roller are set to
67.4 2.2 × 104 1.2 6.8 N/mm and 1000 N. The curing temperature is 174°C, the
volumetric shrinkage of the epoxy resin is 1%, the winding
pattern adopts hoop winding, the total number of layers is
and the radial stress vanishes. In this situation, the negative 70, and the thickness of the woven prepreg tape is set to
of the existing radial stress in the first layer is used as an 0.25 mm.
internal pressure on the inner surface. The stress in the
composite cylinder resulting from this internal stress is
superimposed on the existing stress state in the layers. The 4.2. Sample Preparation. The test specimen is fabricated by
solution can be calculated by choosing the constants in (10a) the robot winding machine as shown in Figure 4. The po-
and (10b) to match the boundary conditions σ rM � −σ total r1
sitional accuracy is controlled by the Kuka robot system, and
at r � b and σ rM � 0 at r � rn. It can be expressed as the mandrel is rotated at 5 rpm to wrap the prepreg tape. In
addition, the process parameters such as winding tension,
mβ−1 σ total
r1 x β−1 m β+1
σ rM (x) � − , temperature, and pressure are controlled by SIMATIC S7-
m2β − 1 m x 1200 PLC. In the curing process, it is well known that the
(32)
mβ−1 σ total S x β−1 S m β+1 stiffness of composite is affected by the instantaneous
σ θM (x) � 2β r1 3 + 4 , temperature of the composite cylinder. In order to measure
m − 1 S1 m S2 x
the variation of instantaneous temperature, the thermo-
where σ total
r1 is the total radial stress of the first layer in the
couples are embedded into the interlayer when the prepreg
composite cylinder with mandrel. Thus, the residual stresses tape is wrapped on the mandrel. The thermocouples are
of the composite cylinder are obtained by adding this stress linked to the multichannel temperature acquisition unit
to the total stress σ total. Then, the residual stresses are written (ADAM4118). The temperature data are collected and saved
as follows: by the upper computer through the RS-485 bus.
σ Rs total
r (x) � σ r (x) + σ rM (x),
(33) 4.3. Measurement Method. In this experiment, a widely used
σ Rs total
θ (x) � σ θ (x) + σ θM (x). slitting method is adopted to measure the actual residual
stresses [28]. The method measures a relative hoop strain
4. Model Verification either on the inner surface or on the outer surface caused by
the relief of the residual hoop stress on the slitting section of
4.1. Material and Parameter Setting. In order to verify the the composite cylinder. The approach assumes that the cut
accuracy of the developed model, the experimental in- cylinder can be returned to its original shape by a pure
vestigation is performed to compare with the numerical moment. Thus, the residual stresses are equated as the
analysis. The material selected in this study is the glass/epoxy stresses in the cut cylinder using curved beam bending
prepreg tape. The parameters are listed in Table 1. Epoxy theory. For the composite cylinder with homogeneous
resin kinetic parameters are listed in Table 2. In the material, the residual stresses are written as follows [28, 29]:
4Mr −a2 b2 b r a
σθ � − 2 r2
log + b2 log + a2 log + b2 − a2 ,
(b 2 − a2 ) 2 2 2
− 4a b (log(b/a)) a b r
(34)
4Mr a2 b2 b 2 r 2 a2
σr � − log + b log + a log ,
(b2 − a2 )2 − 4a2 b2 (log(b/a))2 r2 a b r
where a and b are inner and outer radius of the cylinder and The opposite residual moment −Mr can be calculated
Mr is the residual moment per width. from the boundary conditions of (34) at the inner surface
8 Advances in Materials Science and Engineering
Partial adjust
K-Thermocouple
mechanism
Winding tension
Composite cylinder
Mandrel
Prepreg tape
Spindle
Hot compaction
roller
equations [29]:
σ θ (a) � Eθ Δεa , 40
(35)
σ θ (b) � Eθ Δεb ,
20
where Δεa and Δεb are the measured relative hoop strains on
the inner and outer surfaces and Eθ is the elastic constant. 0
–20
4.4. Results and Discussion. In order to verify the residual 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
stresses of the composite cylinder after mandrel removal, the Radial coordinate, r/b
residual stress distribution of the composite wound cylinder Hoop stress
with an inner liner should be calculated first based on the
Radial stress
model. The numerical results are shown in Figure 5. The
residual radial stress increases as the radial coordinate is Figure 5: Residual stress distribution of the composite cylinder
increased from the inner radius to outer radius. The max- with an inner liner.
imum value of the compressive stress occurs at the inner
radius. Similar to the radial stress, the maximum value of the
corresponding hoop stress is also at the inner radius, and the experimental result shows that the composite cylinder was
hoop stress is tensile. Moreover, these stresses are more than closed, and the change of displacement was about 2.1 mm.
one order of magnitude higher than those in the radial The value of measured strain on the inner surface was
direction. −701 microstrain (μm/m). Based on (34) and (35), the
In this investigation, the strain gages were mounted on residual moment Mr can be obtained, and its value is
the center of inner surface in the hoop direction. The 1401 N. Then, the residual stresses measured by the slitting
opposite side of gage was cut along the radial line by method can be obtained based on (34). The values are
a hacksaw as shown in Figure 6. When the −Mr was large shown in Figures 7 and 8. Based on the simulated results
to close the cylinder, another cut was performed to in Figure 5, the corresponding numerical results of re-
remove a small slice of the composite cylinder so that the sidual stresses can be calculated according to (33) after the
slitting section was free. After the composite cylinder was mandrel is removed.
separated from the clamping fixture, the hoop strain was Figure 7 displays the comparison of the residual hoop
measured during the slitting experiment. Considering end stress in the composite wound cylinder after mandrel re-
face of slit maybe touch, the slice was set to 5 mm. The moval between the experimental results and the predicted
Advances in Materials Science and Engineering 9
Strain gage
Strain indicator
2.0
1.0
0.5
Hacksaw
0.0
Figure 6: A slitting experiment for measuring residual stress. 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Radial coordinate, r/b
Present model
40 Experiment
30
Figure 8: Residual radial stress of the composite wound cylinder
Residual hoop stress (MPa)
10
0 30 70
–10 68
25
H2 S3 (x)2β − H1 S4 m − x H1 S4 − H2 S3 x2β th ch th ch
F(x) � h1 + S − σ r + σ r + σ θ + σ θ . (37)
H2 S1 (x)2β + H1 S2 x H2 S1 (x)2β + H1 S2
Here, the residual radial stress can be determined by the the present model since the specific formulas of
residual hoop stress. Thus, the residual hoop stress is only stresses induced in the whole process have been
considered to design the winding tension. The desired re- given. In addition, the winding tension designed
sidual hoop stress S is assumed as 60 MPa, and the values of based on the present model can be obtained directly
process parameters mentioned in the previous section are rather than using iteration or search algorithm.
adopted. In this study, the winding tension designed based
on (37) is plotted in Figure 9. As depicted, the winding Conflicts of Interest
tension rises gradually as the radial coordinate is increased
from the inner radius to outer radius. Figure 9 also shows the The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.
corresponding numerical result of the hoop stress. The re-
sidual hoop stress increases steadily to 60 MPa along the Acknowledgments
radial direction. Moreover, the minimum residual hoop
This work was supported by the National Natural Science
stress is 59.4 MPa which satisfies the desired value within 1%
Foundation of China (Grant no. 51375394).
of error. The result indicates that the method can be adopted to
adjust the residual hoop stress through changing the winding
tension along the thickness of the composite cylinder.
References
[1] B. Jiang, S. He, Y. D. Huang, and H. T. Pan, “Investigation of
the kinetics of curing reaction for the resin matrix polymer
6. Conclusion composite based on near-infrared spectroscopy,” Applied
Spectroscopy Reviews, vol. 50, no. 8, pp. 627–640, 2015.
The residual stresses of the composite wound cylinder are
[2] A. Kojima and S. Furukawa, “Recycling of resin matrix
highly sensitive to the winding and curing process. Based on composite materials VII: future perspective of FRP recycling,”
the plane stress assumption, the analytic method is Advanced Composite Materials, vol. 6, no. 3, pp. 215–225, 1997.
addressed to investigate the stress state of the composite [3] J. Q. Amado, “Manufacture and testing of lightweight tubes for
cylinder. The results could be drawn as follows: rocketry and centrifuges,” Lightweight Composite Structures in
Transport: Design, Manufacturing, Analysis and Performance,
(1) Based on the winding and curing process, the ana-
pp. 421–438, 2016.
lytical model of residual stresses is established. This [4] Y. Y. Shi, H. Tang, and Q. Yu, “Key technology of the NC tape-
model can be applied to analyze the stress state of the winding machine,” Acta Aeronautica et Astronautica Sinica,
composite cylinder before and after mandrel removal. vol. 29, no. 1, pp. 233–239, 2008.
(2) The variations of shrinkage strains and coefficient of [5] P. P. Parlevliet, H. E. Bersee, and A. Beukers, “Residual stresses
thermal expansion are introduced to develop the in thermoplastic composites–a study of the literature. Part III:
residual stresses model. The numerical simulation effects of thermal residual stresses,” Composites Part A: Applied
and slitting experiment for the composite wound Science and Manufacturing, vol. 38, no. 6, pp. 1581–1596, 2007.
[6] K. L. Thunhorst, A. M. Hine, P. Sedgwick et al., Nanosilica
cylinder after mandrel removal are investigated. The
Concentration Effect on Epoxy Resins and Filament Wound
analysis reveals that the maximal difference of radial Composite Overwrapped Pressure Vessels, Society for the
stress between the model and experiment is 0.14 MPa Advancement of Material and Process Engineering, Long
around the neutral axis. The maximal difference of Beach, CA, USA, 2011.
hoop stress is 2.6 MPa which occurs at the outer [7] N. H. Mostafa, Z. N. Ismarrubie, S. M. Sapuan et al., “Fibre
radius. Besides, the corresponding errors of hoop prestressed composites: theoretical and numerical modelling
and radial stress at the maximal difference positions of unidirectional and plain-weave fibre reinforcement forms,”
are 9.0% and 7.7%, respectively. The result indicates Composite Structures, vol. 159, pp. 410–423, 2017.
that the present model can be used to predict the [8] S. Y. Lee and G. S. Springer, “Filament winding cylinders I.
residual stresses. Process model,” Journal of Composite Materials, vol. 24,
no. 12, pp. 1270–1298, 1990.
(3) The design method of the winding tension is pro- [9] Z. Cai, T. Gutowski, and S. Allen, “Winding and consoli-
posed according to the residual stresses model. To dation analysis for cylindrical composite structures,” Journal
obtain the desired residual hoop stress of the com- of Composite Materials, vol. 26, no. 9, pp. 1374–1399, 1992.
posite wound cylinder with an inner liner, the [10] E. A. Kempner and H. T. Hahn, “Effect of radial stress relaxation
designed winding tension is determined through on fibre stress in filament winding of thick composites,”
inverting the residual stresses model. The numerical Composites Manufacturing, vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 67–77, 1995.
analysis is performed, and the maximum error was [11] J. A. Guemes, “Curing residual stresses and failure analysis
less than 1%. The result indicates that the method is in composite cylinders,” Journal of Reinforced Plastics and
Composites, vol. 13, no. 5, pp. 408–419, 1994.
feasible to design the winding tension.
[12] M. A. Stone, I. F. Schwartz, and H. D. Chandler, “Residual
(4) The residual stress profile of the composite wound stresses associated with post-cure shrinkage in GRP tubes,”
cylinder can be calculated conveniently by adopting Composites Science & Technology, vol. 57, no. 1, pp. 47–54, 1997.
Advances in Materials Science and Engineering 11
Advances in Advances in
Chemistry
Hindawi
Physical Chemistry
Hindawi
www.hindawi.com Volume 2018 www.hindawi.com Volume 2018
Engineering
Journal of
Journal of International Journal of Advances in Journal of
Chemistry
Hindawi
Biomaterials
Hindawi
High Energy Physics
Hindawi Hindawi
Nanotechnology
Hindawi
www.hindawi.com Volume 2018 www.hindawi.com Volume 2018 www.hindawi.com Volume 2018 www.hindawi.com Volume 2018 www.hindawi.com Volume 2018