11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

Subscribe Premium LOGIN

TOP STORIES NEWS UPDATES COLUMNS INTERVIEWS ENVIRONMENT RTI

KNOW THE LAW VIDEOS SPONSORED ROUND UPS PODCAST LAW EXAMS

JOB UPDATES BOOK REVIEWS EVENTS CORNER LAW FIRMS SC JUDGMENTS लाइव लॉ हिंदी LAW SCHOOLS IBC TAX A

 Search... 

Home / Top Stories / Listing Of...

TOP STORIES

Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam

Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench
Attracts Controversy
LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK 18 Nov 2022 12:19 PM

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 1/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

The listing of the petitions filed by the Enforcement Directorate(ED) in

relation to the Nagrik Apurti Nigam (NAN) scam in Chhattisgarh has

attracted a controversy, with the Chhattisgarh Government taking objection

to the bench led by Justice MR Shah hearing it.

The matter was being heard by a bench comprising the previous Chief

Justice of India UU Lalit, Justice Ajay Rastogi and Justice S Ravindra Bhat.

The previous hearings in the case had created news after the ED made a

serious allegation that the accused in the case were in touch with the Chief

Minister and a High Court judge. Solicitor General of India Tushar Mehta had

also handed over certain sealed cover documents to the bench led by CJI

Lalit to corroborate the allegations. On October 20, the said bench could not

hear the matter due to the paucity of time and directed for the listing of the

matter on November 14 before the "appropriate bench".

Also Read - Why LiveLaw Premium Subscription Is A Must For Your Legal

Research And Practice

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 2/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

On November 14, the matter was listed before a bench comprising Justices

MR Shah and Hima Kohli. Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for the

State of Chattisgarh, raised an objection that the matter should be heard by

benches led by either Justices Rastogi or Justice Bhat, who are the

remaining members of the previous bench after the retirement of CJI Lalit.

The matter was then adjourned to November 21.

Also Read - Union Law Minister Kiren Rijiju Criticises Lawyers' Protests;

Says Not Good To Question Every Collegium Decision Which Has Govt

Support

In this backdrop, the matter was listed before the Chief Justice of India today

by the Solicitor General. CJI Chandrachud then said, "The Registrar J1 says

that I have already passed orders orders yesterday assigning the matter to

the bench presided over by Justice Ajay Rastogi". If the matter is to be

assigned to a combination of Justices Rastogi and Bhat, then two benches

will have to be broken, as both of them are heading separate benches, the CJI

added.

Also Read - FIR Registered In 1990 ; Trial Not Complete Even After Three

Decades : SC Directs Kolkata Court To Complete Trial Within 6 Months

"I just followed an objective criteria, to assign to the next senior most judge

available", CJI stated.

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 3/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

At this juncture, SG said that he wanted to say something. "First of all, I

cannot choose a bench, I cannot avoid a bench. I am saying this with a

degree of seriousness".

"You know Mr.Solicitor, I could have taken this up, since Chief Justice Lalit

was taking it up. But if I take it up, three benches will be broken, my bench,

Justice Rastogi's bench and Justice Bhat's bench. So because of these

practical issues, I said the second most senior judge available will take it up",

CJI said.

Also Read - Contractual Expressions Must Be Understood As Intended By

The Parties To The Contract : Supreme Court

"At the outset, I cannot select a bench or avoid a bench. Whatever your

lordships have read, prima facie, something was told to the bench...", SG said.

The CJI then replied that he has not read the files and has only seen orders.

"No, I just saw the orders. There was absolutely no time to read the files", CJI

said.

SG then gave a brief background : "The learned judges said we have not gone

into the sealed covers and asked me to point out. When I pointed out, the

learned judges put to me how much time will be needed for arguments and I

said substantial time needed. The earlier Chief Justice had no time and it

was de-listed. So it was listed, possibly after marking, before Court No.

5(bench led by Justice Shah). There a request was made(by respondents)

that you should not hear and it should go before the earlier bench. That is not

only avoiding the bench but also choosing the bench".

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 4/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

Hearing the SG's statement that the previous CJI might have marked the

matter to Court no.5, CJI Chandrachud said : "One second, if it was listed by

the former Chief Justice before Court No.5, let me check", CJI stated. "What I

will do is this, I will ask the Registrar to check up if there is any order", he

added.

Sibal then interjected to say that the order only says "Registry is directed to

list the matter before the appropriate bench". CJI said he will ask the

Registrar to check if there was any direction by the former Chief Justice to

mark the matter to Court No.5. "If there is none, my order will stand", he said.

Solicitor General then said : "Please allow me to say. I have only this forum

and no other forum. Even if it does not go in Court 5, I have absolutely no

difficulty. My worry is on a larger scale. This is happening too frequently. One

order in a political matter not to your liking, you gather NGOs and malign the

entire institution that you have no trust in it. One wrong order, articles are

written. This is a part of that."

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 5/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

CJI then intervened, "You know Mr.Solicitor, one of the practices of this Court,

one good practice, is that when a senior judge retires, the matter goes to the

next available senior judge of the bench".

"I have absolutely no issue. I started by saying, I can't choose a bench or

avoid a bench", SG replied.

"Now as heading the administration, I try and be as objective as possible by

applying a golden yardstick that when the presiding judge retires, matter

goes to the next judge and if that judge refuses saying he has no time, it goes

to another bench", CJI clarified.

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 6/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

"Some bench will be maligned", SG said. This invited a sharp retort from Sibal

who said, "Justice Hima Kohli was in that bench. Did we malign? We just said

hold it over".

"Mr.Sibal, I just wanted to check if my l predecessor made any specific

assignment to any bench", CJI said. "It could not have been, Justice Shah did

not have a criminal roster", Sibal stated.

SG suggested that the matter may be taken up by the combination of CJI,

Justice Ajay Rastogi and Justice SR Bhat. "We have no problem with any

bench", Sibal said.

"One order of not someone's liking and the entire institution is maligned", SG

repeated. "Very very unfair", Senior Advocate Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for

respondents, took objection.

"It goes to the second or third bench, and if nobody is available, it goes

elsewhere", Rohatgi said.

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 7/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

As the exchanges were getting heated up, CJI tried to ease the pressure by

saying "All of you have a lot of fresh matters to do".

After sometime, the SG again 'mentioned the matter by saying "One way out

can be that the bench be of my lord the Chief Justice, Justice Rastogi and

Justice Bhat. I cannot choose or avoid any bench. That's not within my

domain".

CASE TITLE: ED v. Anil Tuteja And Ors. SLP(Crl) No. 6323-24/2020

TAGS #JUSTICE MR SHAH CJI DY CHANDRACHUD CHHATTISGARH

Subscribe to LiveLaw, enjoy Ad free version and other unlimited features,

just INR 899 Click here to Subscribe. All payment options available.

loading....

+ VIEW MORE
SIMILAR
POSTS

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 8/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

Why LiveLaw
Premium
FIR Registered In 1990 ;
Subscription Is A Union Law Minister Kiren Trial Not Complete Even
Must For Your Rijiju Criticises Lawyers' After Three Decades : SC
Legal Research Protests; Says Not Good To
Directs Kolkata Court To
And Practice Question Every Collegium
Complete Trial Within 6
Decision Which Has Govt Months
15 Nov 2022
Support
11:42 AM 19 Nov 2022 5:26 PM 19 Nov 2022 1:47 PM

Judicial Service Supreme Court

Contractual Expressions
Examination- Practice Judgments Weekly
Must Be Understood As
Questions- First Round Up: November
Intended By The Parties To
Information Report 7- November 13, 2022
The Contract : Supreme
(FIR)
Court
19 Nov 2022 12:29 PM 19 Nov 2022 10:24 AM 19 Nov 2022 8:08 AM

Supreme Court Supreme Court

News Updates Quarterly Digest on
Weekly Round Up: Prevention of 'Shocking That Private Medical
November 7- Corruption Act [July Colleges Are Asking For Bonds
November 13, 2022 - September, 2022] From Students' : Supreme Court
Affirms Direction To Refund Rs 5

19 N 2022 8 08 19 N 2022 7 57

Lakhs To Student
https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 9/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy
19 Nov 2022 8:08 19 Nov 2022 7:57
Lakhs To Student
AM AM 19 Nov 2022 7:24 AM

Courts Today- A Daily

Supreme Court Issues
Round Up Of Supreme Court Issues
Contempt Notice To
Important Legal Notice On Plea Challenging
Advocate ML Sharma &
Developments- Assam Govt Decision To
AoR For Scandalising
18.11.22 Discharge Members Of
High Court In Petition
200 Foreigners Tribunals
19 Nov 2022 6:30 AM 18 Nov 2022 7:42 PM 18 Nov 2022 5:16 PM

JUST ENTER YOUR EMAIL FOR THE

LIVELAW DAILY NEWS BRIEFING BY
EMAIL ALL THE DAY"S HEADLINES AND
HIGHLIGHTS FROM LIVELAW, DIRECT
TO YOU EVERY MORNING

NEWSLETTERS
DIRECTLY IN YOUR MAILBOX

Enter Your Email

Submit

+ MORE
LAW FIRMS

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 10/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

The Seat Or The Assets – Where Do You Enforce The Award?

LATEST NEWS + MORE

1 Union Law Minister Kiren Rijiju Criticises Lawyers' Protests; Says Not
Good To Question Every Collegium Decision Which Has Govt Support

2 Alleged Remarks Against UP CM | Allahabad HC Refuses To Quash FIR

Against Samajwadi Party Leader Anurag Bhadouria

3 Bombay HC Seeks State's Response On PIL Seeking Mandatory Charging

Infrastructure For Electric Vehicles in Housing Societies

4 Kerala HC Deprecates Invocation Of Writ Jurisdiction Alleging 'Breach Of

Duty' By Police To Register Complaint When The Dispute Is Civil In Nature

5 FIR Registered In 1990 ; Trial Not Complete Even After Three Decades : SC
Directs Kolkata Court To Complete Trial Within 6 Months

Madras High Court Restrains Over 12K Websites From Illegally

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 11/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

Broadcasting FIFA World Cup 2022

6

7 Former CJI U U Lalit To Join NUJS Kolkata As Visting Professor

8 High Court Refuses To Halt CCI Probe Against Karnataka Chemists And
Druggists Association, Calls Plea 'Premature'

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 12/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

लाइव लॉ हिंदी + MORE

पूर्व मुख्य न्यायाधीश यू यू ललित NUJS कोलकाता के विजिटिंग प्रोफे सर के तौर पर ज्वाइन करें गे

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 13/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

' निजी मेडिकल कॉलेजों का छात्रों से बॉन्ड मांगना परे शान करने वाला' : सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने छात्र को
पांच लाख रुपये लौटाने के निर्देश की पुष्टि की

सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने गौतम नवलखा की हाउस अरे स्ट की अनुमति देने वाले आदेश को वापस लेने से
इनकार किया, NIA को 24 घंटे में इसे निष्पादित करने का निर्देश दिया

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 14/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

जस्टिस एमआर शाह की खंडपीठ के समक्ष छत्तीसगढ़ एनएएन घोटाला मामले की लिस्टिंग से
विवाद खड़ा हुआ

'इसमें कोर्ट का कोई दखल नहीं'- सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने दो बच्चों के मानदंड और देश भर में जनसंख्या
नियंत्रण नीति को लागू करने की मांग वाली याचिका पर सुनवाई से इनकार किया

INTERNATIONAL + MORE

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 15/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

1 Banning Conditional Sentences For Certain Offences Is Constitutional:

Canada Supreme Court Holds In 5:4 Majority

2 Canada Supreme Court Says Mandatory And Lifetime Registration On Sex

Offender Registry Unconstitutional

3 Indian-American Attorney Arun Subramanian Nominated As US District

Judge In New York By President Joe Biden

4 Ketanji Brown Jackson Sworn In As US Supreme Court Justice- First Black

Woman In Court's History

+ MORE
ENVIRONMENT

1 Supreme Court Dismisses Plea Against ₹64 Lakh Penalty On Municipal

Body For Dumping Solid Waste In Wular Lake

2 NGT Should Test Bonafides & Credentials Of Applicants Before Passing

Orders Having Far Reaching Effect: Supreme Court

3 'Lack Of Good Governance': NGT Slaps ₹35 Cr Penalty On J&K Admin For
Doodh Ganga Pollution

4 Grant Of Ex Post Facto Environmental Clearance Permissible In

Exceptional Circumstances : Surpeme Court

JOB UPDATES

1. Chief Manager (Administration) & Secretary Vacancy At Jawaharlal Nehru Port

Authority

2. Business Analyst Vacancy At Centre For Management Development, Kerala

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 16/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

3. Assistant General Manager (Law) Vacancy At NMDC Limited

4. Legal Associate Vacancy At Meharia And Company (MCO Legals) [Apply Now]

5. Legal Officer Vacancy At National Institute Of Rural Development And Panchayati

Raj

+ VIEW MORE

TOP STORIES KNOW THE LAW

NEWS UPDATE LAW FIRMS

COLUMNS JOB UPDATES

INTERVIEWS BOOK REVIEWS

INTERNATIONAL EVENTS CORNER

RTI UPDATES COVER STORY

EDITOR'S PICK PLACEMENTS

LAW SCHOOL CORNER SCHOLARSHIPS

ARTICLES SEMINARS

CALL FOR PAPERS ENVIRONMENT

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 17/18
11/19/22, 5:27 PM Listing Of Chhattisgarh NAN Scam Matter Before Justice MR Shah's Bench Attracts Controversy

COMPETITIONS BOOK REVIEWS

INTERNSHIPS

2022 © All Rights Reserved @LiveLaw

Powered By Hocalwire

Who We Are Careers Advertise With Us Contact Us Privacy Policy Terms And Conditions



X
Live Law subscriptions starting ₹ 899 +GST

Subscribe to Live Law now and get unlimited access.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Already have an account? Sign In

https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/listing-of-chhattisgarh-nan-scam-matter-before-justice-mr-shahs-bench-attracts-controversy-214455 18/18