Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Stroke-Related Dysphagia
Cecilia C. Felix, M.A., CCC-SLP,1
Megan E. Joseph, M.Ed., CCC-SLP,1,2 and
Stephanie K. Daniels, Ph.D., CCC-SLP2
ABSTRACT
Learning Outcomes: As a result of this activity, the reader will be able to (1) discuss the various levels of
swallowing evaluation and identify the information obtained with each; (2) implement knowledge of the clinical
swallowing examination to increase the extent of information obtained in the evaluation; and (3) summarize
the factors to consider when implementing management strategies in patients with stroke-related dysphagia.
1
Department of Speech Pathology, Memorial Hermann Clinical Decision Making in Dysphagia; Guest Editors,
Health System, Houston, Texas; 2Department of Commu- Gary H. McCullough, Ph.D., CCC-SLP and Balaji Ran-
nication Sciences and Disorders, University of Houston, garathnam, Ph.D., CCC-SLP.
Houston, Texas. Semin Speech Lang 2019;40:188–202. Copyright
Address for correspondence: Stephanie K. Daniels, # 2019 by Thieme Medical Publishers, Inc., 333 Seventh
Ph.D., CCC-SLP, Department of Communication Avenue, New York, NY 10001, USA. Tel: +1(212) 584-
Sciences and Disorders, University of Houston, 4455 4662.
Cullen Blvd., Houston, TX 77204-6018 DOI: https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0039-1688815.
(e-mail: skdaniels@uh.edu). ISSN 0734-0478.
188
CLINICAL DECISION MAKING IN PATIENTS WITH STROKE-RELATED DYSPHAGIA/FELIX ET AL 189
BJH-SDS,11,15 Gugging Swallowing Screen,16 to any CSE. A thorough chart review should
RAS3,12,17 TOR-BSST,13 and the 3-oz Water include neurological damage, structural chan-
Swallow Challenge/Yale Swallow Protocol.18–20 ges, diagnostic imaging, relevant consultations,
While there is currently no consensus on a single current medications, appropriate laboratory
best SST for patients with suspected stroke, this results, and history of dysphagia with any
does not mean that screening should not be previous evaluations and/or treatment.
completed. Rather it suggests that the stakehol- The interview portion can fill in any mis-
ders in the stroke SST should carefully review sing information not available during the chart
the strengths and limitations of the research for review; although the amount of information
each available screening and then select the one gathered can vary widely based on the setting in
that most meets their needs. which it is completed and the patient’s ability.
Various models in which an SST can be At the inpatient level, the SLP may be consul-
implemented are available.21 Many hospitals ted for a failed swallowing screen, reduced oral
may follow a model in which the stroke SST is intake, or signs of dysphagia during oral intake.
completed by a frontline health care provider The patient may not realize that there is a
informally evaluate cognition and communica- rule out possibility of aspiration.26 Further-
tion throughout the CSE. The SLP should more, the number of decayed teeth is associated
determine if the patient can comprehend and with development of pneumonia.25
respond to open-ended questions about swal-
lowing, if yes/no questions are required, or if
history needs to be obtained from family due to Cranial Nerve Examination
decreased comprehension or expression. Like- The cranial nerve examination can highlight
wise, during the cranial nerve examination, the decreased sensation, range of motion (ROM),
SLP should determine if the patient follows symmetry, and strength of orofacial muscula-
commands without demonstration or if a model ture that may result in deficits during the oral
of the movement is required to facilitate com- phase of swallowing as well as provide the SLP
prehension. As the patient is talking, in addi- with a unique opportunity to infer potential
tion to focusing on content and language changes to the otherwise unobservable muscu-
abilities, the clinician should assess the patient’s lature of the pharynx. Typically subjective
vocal quality paying particular attention to binary judgement (weak, strong) is used during
Table 1 (Continued)
Cranial nerve Muscles Assessment examples Potential effects
Cervical nerve 1 - Geniohyoid - Palpate larynx during - Decreased UES open-
- Thyrohyoid swallowing ing due to decreased
anterior laryngeal
movement with pyri-
form sinus residue
- Decreased laryngeal
elevation
Abbreviations: BOT, base of tongue; PPW, posterior pharyngeal wall; UES, upper esophageal sphincter.
10 mL) along with patient-regulated volumes assessment and initiating, continuing, or hal-
(e.g., putting 30 mL in a cup and having a ting oral intake. Rather than integrating the
patient take a “normal” size swallow). Depen- components of a comprehensive CSE, the SLP
rehabilitation, for example, no aspiration, redu- bolus hold to determine if larger volumes of thin
ced valleculae residue, without exposing the liquid can be safely swallowed for pleasure with
patient to further radiation. Manometry, both supervision or to implement as a compensatory
low resolution and high resolution, may be a strategy during mealtime as the patient’s
good adjunctive evaluation if abnormalities in memory improves. Conversely, the SLP can
pharyngeal or upper esophageal sphincter follow up with VEES to test these other
pressure and/or mistiming of muscular contrac- compensatory strategies as cognition improves.
tion are suspected.34 Some compensatory strategies such as the
The protocol for the swallowing tasks in Mendelsohn maneuver can be difficult to learn
VFSS should be similar to the protocol used in even in individuals with intact comprehension
the CSE in which various volumes, consisten- and cognition. If findings from the CSE sug-
cies, and trials are tested. Unlike the CSE, the gest that the Mendelsohn maneuver may be
duration of the VFSS is restricted due to indicated, ideally the SLP can attempt to teach
radiation exposure. Like the CSE, the SLP it prior to the VFSS. If this cannot be achieved,
starts with small thin liquid volumes (5 mL) of a the SLP can address teaching the maneuver in
likely be required for implementation of com- ments describe a specific regimen (e.g., expira-
pensatory techniques. For individuals who are tory muscle strength training [EMST],50
weak or deconditioned, rehabilitation can still Shaker exercise,51 lingual resistance),52 the
be targeted, although at a reduced intensity. majority of exercises do not, which makes it
difficult for the clinician to prescribe an effec-
tive dose.
Compensation As with compensation, the quality of the
Compensatory strategies are designed to allow a evidence varies across each rehabilitation tech-
person to achieve a safe and efficient oral diet by nique. Many studies target sign (residue, aspi-
eliminating signs of dysphagia, for example, ration) as the outcome and not the underlying
aspiration, residue. Even though some research impairment (e.g., increased BOT to PPW
has suggested correlation between the CSE and contact); both should be evaluated. For some
VFSS in broad diet recommendations,39 nume- treatments, only immediate effects following
rous studies support the need for instrumental rehabilitation are reported (e.g., thermal-tactile
evaluation to determine the need for and effec- application)53 or investigators have studied only
Self-regulated or sequential - Swallowing apraxia - Volume size with patients who are impulsive
swallowing - Ensure no aspiration with increased volume
Volume regulation - Pharyngeal pooling with/without airway invasion before or - Can be implemented with individuals with cognitive and/or
during the swallow comprehension impairment with commercially available
devices
- If devices are unavailable, these individuals will require direct
supervision
3-s bolus hold - Discoordinated oral transfer - Individuals with cognitive and/or comprehension impairment
- Pharyngeal pooling with/without airway invasion before or will require direct supervision
during the swallow
Chin tuck - Pharyngeal pooling with airway invasion before or during the - Individuals with cognitive and/or comprehension impairment
swallow will require direct supervision
- Airway invasion during the swallow due to reduced supra-
glottic closure
- Valleculae residue with/without airway invasion after the
swallow
SEMINARS IN SPEECH AND LANGUAGE/VOLUME 40, NUMBER 3
Carbonation - Pharyngeal pooling with/without airway invasion before or - Individuals with cognitive and/or comprehension impairment
during the swallow will require direct supervision
2019
Thermal-tactile application - Delayed initiation of pharyngeal - As multiple sessions are required, care-
swallow giver will need to be trained to facilitate
completion in individuals with cognitive or
comprehension impairment or individuals
with dominant side hemiparesis
Lingual resistance exercises - Reduced orolingual control and - Visual feedback with external device such
strength as the IOPI may increase participation in
- Reduced BOT-PPW contact individuals with cognitive or comprehen-
sion deficits
Masako maneuver - Reduced BOT-PPW contact - Individuals who are edentulous and
without dentures will have increased diffi-
culty completing exercise
Table 3 (Continued)
Exercise Underlying impairment Stroke-related considerations
Recline exercise - Reduced UES opening - Easy to demonstrate, for patient to
imitate, and for clinician to manipulate the
body for individuals with comprehension
or cognitive deficits
Wada exercise - Reduced UES opening - Easy to demonstrate, for patient to
imitate, and for clinician to manipulate the
body for individuals with comprehension
or cognitive deficits
- Avoid in individuals with TMJ issues pain
with jaw opening
Abbreviations: BOT, base of tongue; CTAR, chin tuck against resistance; EMST, expiratory muscle strength training;
IOPI, Iowa Oral Performance Instrument; PPW, posterior pharyngeal wall; sEMG, surface electromyography; SLP,
Implementation of an oral hygiene pro- along with left lingual asymmetry on protru-
gram to reduce risk of pneumonia is suggested sion with decreased ROM and strength
in the AHA/ASA guidelines for management (hypoglossal cranial nerve). The swallowing
of acute ischemic stroke.63 While nursing staff portion of the CSE was completed with trials
frequently assumes the burden of completing of water (5 mL, 10 mL, self-regulated cup
dental care, multidisciplinary collaboration bet- sip), applesauce, and cheese crackers. LB
ween nursing, speech pathology, occupational exhibited impulsivity with oral trials charac-
therapy, and dental hygiene would appear to be terized by not waiting for prompts, eating
most appropriate to develop and implement quickly, and poor control of volume. Oral
effective training and adherence to an oral phase dysphagia was evident characterized
care program for patients following stroke. by impaired bolus preparation with prolonged
and inefficient mastication of solids, reduced
bolus cohesion with oral residue present on
CASE SCENARIO left lingual/dental surface and buccal space,
LB, a 54-year-old male patient with history of and prolonged oral transit time with solids.
obesity and insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus Coughing was evident in both trials of self-
type 2, was admitted to general hospital with regulated cup sip; however, LB appeared
complaint of left-sided weakness and slurred unconcerned as he attempted to continue
speech for 1 day. His MRI scan revealed a right drinking the water. Larger liquid volumes
middle cerebral artery ischemic stroke. Speech– were not administered.
language pathology was consulted for dysphagia A VFSS was completed later that day with
evaluation as the patient was NPO following a the following trials tested: thin liquid Varibar
positive nursing-administered swallowing barium (5 mL, 10 mL, self-regulated cup sip),
screen. Prior to the stroke, LB consumed nectar thick Varibar barium (self-regulated cup
regular solids with thin liquids at home with sip, sequential swallowing), Varibar barium
no history of dysphagia. pudding, and a barium pudding-coated cracker.
The informal cognitive screen during the The oral phase was noted to be the same as
CSE revealed disorientation, impaired short- during the CSE with the addition of reduced
term memory, impulsivity, reduced insight orolingual control for thin liquids resulting in
into deficits, and left neglect. Cranial nerve pyriform sinus pooling and aspiration before
assessment revealed reduced left labial asym- the swallow (weak cough but no clearing) with
metry at rest and with extension as well as the self-regulated cup sip trials. Given cognitive
decreased ROM and strength (facial cranial deficits, 3-second bolus hold, and chin tuck
nerve). Weak volitional cough was identified, were not attempted as compensatory strategies.
200 SEMINARS IN SPEECH AND LANGUAGE/VOLUME 40, NUMBER 3 2019
Nectar thick liquid, however, was attempted M.E.J. receives salary support from the Uni-
and proved successful in preventing airway versity of Houston and Memorial Hermann
invasion during self-regulated cup sip and Health System.
sequential swallowing. During the pharyngeal S.K.D. receives salary support from the Uni-
phase, LB exhibited decreased BOT retraction versity of Houston, and royalties from Plural
yielding moderate valleculae residue and redu- Publishing and MedBridge.
ced UES opening due to decreased anterior
hyolaryngeal elevation yielding moderate bila-
teral pyriform sinus residue with semisolids and REFERENCES
the masticated solid. The residue did not build
up with subsequent swallows. 1. Daniels SK, Huckabee ML, Gozdzikowska K.
Dysphagia Following Stroke, 3rd ed. San Diego,
The SLP recommended nectar thick liquids
CA: Plural Publishing; 2019
(International Dysphagia Diet Standardization 2. Martino R, Foley N, Bhogal S, Diamant N,
Initiative [IDDSI] level 2; www.iddsi.org) and Speechley M, Teasell R. Dysphagia after stroke:
minced and moist solids (IDDSI level 5). Super- incidence, diagnosis, and pulmonary complications.
suspected stroke: Part 2: Initial and sustained nurse tors of swallowing recovery in stroke. J Rehabil Res
accuracy and reliability. Arch Phys Med Rehabil Dev 2006;43(03):301–310
2016;97(09):1449–1455 25. Langmore SE, Terpenning MS, Schork A, et al.
13. Martino R, Silver F, Teasell R, et al. The Toronto Predictors of aspiration pneumonia: how important
Bedside Swallowing Screening Test (TOR-BSST): is dysphagia? Dysphagia 1998;13(02):69–81
development and validation of a dysphagia scree- 26. McCullough GH, Rosenbek JC, Wertz RT,
ning tool for patients with stroke. Stroke 2009;40 McCoy S, Mann G, McCullough K. Utility of
(02):555–561 clinical swallowing examination measures for
14. Freeland TR, Pathak S, Garrett RR, Anderson JA, detecting aspiration post-stroke. J Speech Lang
Daniels SK. Using medical mannequins to train Hear Res 2005;48(06):1280–1293
nurses in stroke swallowing screening. Dysphagia 27. Vanderwegen J, Guns C, Van Nuffelen G, Elen R,
2016;31(01):104–110 De Bodt M. The influence of age, sex, bulb
15. Edmiaston J, Connor LT, Steger-May K, Ford position, visual feedback, and the order of testing
AL. A simple bedside stroke dysphagia screen, on maximum anterior and posterior tongue
validated against videofluoroscopy, detects dyspha- strength and endurance in healthy Belgian adults.
gia and aspiration with high sensitivity. J Stroke Dysphagia 2013;28(02):159–166
Cerebrovasc Dis 2014;23(04):712–716 28. Smith Hammond CA, Goldstein LB, Horner RD,
swallowing physiology. Dysphagia 2016;31(04): 53. Rosenbek JC, Robbins J, Willford WO, et al.
491–497 Comparing treatment intensities of tactile-thermal
40. Baylow HE, Goldfarb R, Taveira CH, Steinberg application. Dysphagia 1998;13(01):1–9
RS. Accuracy of clinical judgment of the chin- 54. Fujiu M, Logemann JA. Effect of a tongue-holding
down posture for dysphagia during the clinical/ maneuver on posterior pharyngeal wall movement
bedside assessment as corroborated by videofluo- during deglutition. Am J Speech Lang Pathol 1996;
roscopy in adults with acute stroke. Dysphagia 5(01):23–30
2009;24(04):423–433 55. Felix VN, Corrêa SM, Soares RJ. A therapeutic
41. Fraser S, Steele CM. The effect of chin down maneuver for oropharyngeal dysphagia in patients
position on penetration-aspiration in adults with with Parkinson’s disease. Clinics (São Paulo) 2008;
dysphagia. Can J Speech-Lang Pathol Audiol 63(05):661–666
2012;36(02):142–148 56. McCullough GH, Kamarunas E, Mann GC,
42. Miles A, McFarlane M, Scott S, Hunting A. Schmidley JW, Robbins JA, Crary MA. Effects
Cough response to aspiration in thin and thick of Mendelsohn maneuver on measures of swallo-
fluids during FEES in hospitalized inpatients. Int J wing duration post stroke. Top Stroke Rehabil
Lang Commun Disord 2018;53(05):909–918 2012;19(03):234–243
43. Bülow M, Olsson R, Ekberg O. Videomanometric 57. Yoon WL, Khoo JK, Rickard Liow SJ. Chin tuck