You are on page 1of 8

EMPIRICAL STUDIES doi: 10.1111/j.1471-6712.2010.00823.

Parent perspectives of therapy services for their children with


physical disabilities

Snaefridur Thora Egilson PhD, OT (Professor)


University of Akureyri, School of Health Sciences, Akureyri, Iceland

Scand J Caring Sci; 2011; 25; 277–284 sessions. Most parents wished for mutual respect, joint
decision-making in planning intervention, and collabora-
Parent perspectives of therapy services for their chil-
tion with the therapy services. The aspiration for active but
dren with physical disabilities
manageable roles that did not demand a burdensome
Background: Children who have physical disabilities typi- amount of the parents’ time and energy was evinced. The
cally attend occupational and physical therapy services on parents became increasingly critical of the services, as their
a regular basis. The importance of being family centred children grew older. They placed emphasis on services
when providing services to children with a disability has being offered in their local community, and that more
been highlighted in recent years. Thus, it was considered specialized service should be centralized, especially for the
important to gather the opinions of parents towards the children with the most complex needs.
services their child receives. Conclusions: The results reflect the importance of the needs
Aim: To explore the perspectives of parents of children and wants of the parents and children being respected.
with physical disabilities to occupational and physical Thus, parents should play an active role in defining pri-
therapy services provided to their child. orities and strategies for implementation. The results also
Method: Open interviews were conducted with 17 parents indicate that therapists need to put more thought into the
(14 mothers and three fathers) of children aged 7–13, conditions and environment of the child instead of focus-
selected through a purposeful sample. Data analysis was ing solely on underlying issues connected to their impair-
based on an inductive approach. ments.
Results: Nine categories emerged and were organized under
three main headings: The role of the therapist, service Keywords: physical impairment, family-based practice,
location and arrangements, and characteristics of good intervention, collaboration, therapy services.
service. Although several positive remarks were made,
many parents in this study were poorly informed of Submitted 23 September 2009, Accepted 19 June 2010
intervention goals and what took place during therapy

individual culture and values. Professionals are asked to


Introduction
review the needs of each family, work closely with them,
All over the Western world, there is a call for compre- and make use of their strengths. Emphasis is placed on the
hensive therapy services for children with physical practical involvement of the family in identifying therapy
disabilities, emphasizing family-based practice and inter- goals, organizing intervention methods, and evaluating
disciplinary coordination (1–6). Family-based practice results (4–7).
operates on the main principle that parents know their New research highlights the importance of family-based
children best and that the best way to promote the func- approaches. Parents’ satisfaction with services seems to be
tioning of a child with disability is to foster their family and directly related to how family-based they are, while good
immediate environment. Keeping in mind that families are flow of information, respect, and the support of profes-
unique, the services should take into consideration their sionals are also highly regarded by parents (2, 6–11).
Flexibility and compatibility in the services offered are
important, especially at turning points in the child’s and
family’s lives when transitions between service providers
Correspondence to: are made. This relates to the start of school at all grade
Snaefridur Thora Egilson, University of Akureyri, School of Health levels and changes in roles as the child moves towards
Sciences, Solborg við Nordurslod, 600 Akureyri, Iceland. adolescence and adulthood (1, 12). Interdisciplinary
E-mail: sne@unak.is coordination is often counted as the main precondition for
Ó 2010 The Author
Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences Ó 2010 Nordic College of Caring Science 277
278 S.T. Egilson

the families of children with complex needs receiving conducted with the mother only and three with both
adequate services (10, 13). parents present. In ten cases, the children lived with both
In spite of this discourse, changing traditional working parents, while four children lived only with their mothers.
habits can be challenging. It has been pointed out that Eight families resided in or near the capital, and six families
therapists are more likely to take into account the needs resided in other parts of Iceland, either in towns or in rural
and goals of children and their families if they are similar to areas. The parents were selected through a purposeful
their own. Some therapists find it difficult to work so sample designed to reflect typical variations regarding their
closely with parents and to deal with their emotions and children’s type and severity of impairment, and differences
thus are inclined to use traditional methods where the in their environment. Nine parents had a child with
division of power is clear (5, 14). Therapists typically work cerebral palsy (CP); six parents had a child with neuro-
in a clinic culture where the professional is viewed as a muscular or musculoskeletal disorders; and two parents
specialist and emphasis is placed on assessment and treat- had a child with myelomeningocele. Seven of these chil-
ment at the therapy setting (15). In addition, therapists dren had mild learning disabilities. All the children, nine
may find it hard to work with parents who have different boys and five girls, ranging in age from 7 to 13 years were
backgrounds, values, and views than they do especially if in a regular class in their local school.
the needs of the child and the family do not coincide in The children and their families had been in close contact
their opinion (7, 16, 17). All of these factors can hinder the with occupational and physical therapists from a young
realistic practice of family-based services. age. At the time of the study, 13 children had connections
Occupational and physical therapy services to Icelandic to occupational therapy on some level and all attended
children with physical disabilities have traditionally been physical therapy services on a regular basis.
provided by special institutions or agencies. Recently, there
has been a trend to establish the expertise needed on a
Data collection and analysis
community level and more holistic services focusing on the
child in his or her context are emerging. The national Research data were based on open interviews with the
habilitation centre serves the whole population, which is parents conducted by the author. Prior to the interviews,
only slightly over 300 000. Most children with physical guidelines were developed with the key issues that were to
disabilities are discharged at the age of six, but children be discussed. The parents were asked about the services
with myelomeningocele and neuromuscular disorders their child used and about the connection and communi-
continue to receive follow-up services through specialty cation of the therapists with home and school, what kind
clinics (18). of services they wanted and where they should take place.
Although more focus is being placed on the nature and The interviews averaged 60 min; they took place in the
content of therapy services for children with disabilities in family’s homes and at convenient times for them. In
many countries (5, 15, 19–21), little has been written addition, the parents were contacted by phone 1–2 years
about this situation in the Nordic countries. In the wake of after the initial interview to gauge how their situations had
changing professional views, it is important to review the developed. With prior parent’s permission, all interviews
situation by gathering the opinions of parents on the ser- were recorded and transcribed.
vices they receive. This information may help therapists to Data analysis was guided by the work process recom-
tailor their services to the needs and wants of families and mended by Bogdan and Biklen (22) for a descriptive
to assist educators in preparing their students for working analysis. Open coding was used initially to separate data
with parents. The aim of this study was to obtain an into categories and to see processes connected to the topic
understanding of the opinions of Icelandic parents of under study. The open codes were then compared and
children with physical disabilities towards the services of contrasted to detect similarities and differences across
occupational and physical therapists. cases. For reflexive analyses, the coded transcripts were
re-read to recall the initial reactions during and after the
interviews. Categories were then synthesized and larger
Material and methods
segments of the data connected through focused coding.
The study was conducted within a qualitative framework Comparing the data to these categories helped refining
(22, 23). It was approved by the Icelandic Bioethical them and acknowledging their intensity and impact. When
Committee (03-116). reduncancy was consistently seen in the coding of the
data, the developed categories were considered saturated.
To strengthen credibility and confirm that the interpre-
Participants
tations reflected the parent’s actual perspectives, a member
Seventeen parents of children with physical disabilities check was conducted by providing summaries of the
participated in the study, 14 mothers and three fathers all findings to parents and asking for feedback. The minor
between 40 and 60 years old. Eleven interviews were comments made were all included in the final analysis. To

Ó 2010 The Author


Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences Ó 2010 Nordic College of Caring Science
Parent perspectives of therapy services 279

further enhance trustworthiness, an audit trail was com- people must of course have the education, they have
piled, describing the reasoning steps taken when moving the pamphlets, they have the experience.
from the transcribed text towards final interpretations While many parents were content with the situation at
(24). Additionally, the analysis was shared with a profes- home, they felt that the therapists needed to better con-
sional research team for discussion and review. The sider the school environment. In several instances, there
interviews were taped and analysed in Icelandic. To cor- was limited follow-up, or the parents followed up on their
rectly convey the tone and meaning of the direct quota- own and passed information between the therapists and
tions, assistance was sought from a professional translator. the school.
The parent’s accounts often reflected how much was at
stake and how their communication and patience were put
Results
to the test, as evident in the description of the mother of an
The results are presented as nine categories under the 8 -year-old child who had great difficulty getting around.
three main headings (Table 1): The role of the therapist, A tricycle was ordered that we’d waited for for a very
service location and arrangements, and characteristics of long time. Way too big, as if she hadn’t had in mind
good service. In general, the first two headings identify the who she was ordering it for. And I remember, we were
present situation, while the third looks to the future. so disappointed and the trike was returned right away.
And then another process was set in motion and you
just feel like there’s so much inconsideration. And it
The role of the therapist
was just horrible. And with all the patience we’d
The interviewees highlighted a few main points in their shown, keeping our cool, always being polite, always
descriptions of the therapists, represented by the following positive but decisive. And it can be so hard because
three categories: Monitoring the use of assistive devices, you have to have good communication with these
providing information and advice, and improving physical people. Because as soon as you have that disabled
function or promoting participation? child you he’s yours and you share him with a million
people. And it’s not a good thing if you end up on the
Monitoring the use of assistive devices. The parents considered sidelines. It’s not worth it. But it can be really hard.
assistive devices as very important, both to enable their In general, the parents felt that the issue of assistive devices
child to participate in various settings, to improve his or was well addressed during the children’s early years, but
her function, and to prevent future problems. In the par- much less after the children began attending elementary
ent’s opinion, the therapists played key roles in advising on school.
devices, supplying them, and in following up on their use.
The mother of a 13 -year-old boy said: Providing practical information and advice. The interviewees
As far as assistive devices are concerned the employees described how their therapists offered useful information,
have...been so on top of things that I’ve just said, yes, instructions, and recommendations that eased daily life for
thanks. And they’ve pushed things forward, but the family. Reflecting on the preschool years, the parents
always in very good contact with me. reported getting information about the child’s disability,
Others found inadequacies in devices being adjusted reg- learning about handling and positioning, and obtaining
ularly and their usage reviewed, like this mother of an instructions about their child’s therapeutic programme.
8 -year-old boy: When the child entered school, the parents were usually
Last year and up until this year he had a physical less involved and consequently did not receive as many
therapist who was a decent therapist for his body guidelines.
needs. But when it came to equipment and all that, Information on the selection, organization, and layout of
she didn’t do anything, in my opinion. And I was kind the homes was also in focus. The situations varied, from
of bothered by this...of having to always point out and remodelling of houses to the choice of shower rails and
to even get lukewarm responses back. Because these faucet handles. The father of a 13 -year-old boy said:

Table 1 Major categories identified

The role of the therapist Service location and arrangements Characteristics of good service

Monitoring the use of assistive devices Therapy within the local community The family in the forefront
Providing practical information and advice Service coordination at a national level Help towards self-sufficiency
Improving physical function or promoting participation? Professional behaviour
Coordinating and preparing for the future

Ó 2010 The Author


Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences Ó 2010 Nordic College of Caring Science
280 S.T. Egilson

Before we bought here we asked whether it was safe community. Alternatively, parents felt that not enough
for us to move like this up onto the second floor. We emphasis was placed on these tasks or the transfer from the
didn’t dare make the decision by ourselves without therapy setting to the child’s daily environment. The father
getting advice and recommendations on it. of a 13 -year-old boy claimed his son had learned various
The parents wanted clear information that could be easily practicalities during occupational therapy sessions, such as
accessed. Instead, many reported that it was often like an dressing himself and using different tools. However, he
obstacle course. The parents often shared information be- was concerned about the transference of these learnings:
tween them that they felt the professionals should have He doesn’t bring the skills home to apply to all the
made available. things he does here at home and at school. Far from it.
It was consistently noted that responsibility was not well Of course he keeps on doing things the way he feels is
enough defined, and it was often random who saw to or easiest, though it’s not right and though there may be
took initiative in situations. Most wished for much better much better methods for him.
coordination and communication flow between service All the parents were concerned with their child’s social
providers. One mother said: participation but reportedly this was not the centre of
Very rare for professionals to, for example, show up at attention in therapy.
schools to look over the conditions there, usually not
even then unless the parents request it.
Service arrangements
According to many, it became the parent’s responsibility to
ensure that things went well. Two categories emerged on service arrangements. These
constitute therapy within the local community and service
Improving physical function or promoting participation? The coordination at a national level.
parents described physical therapists focusing on mobility,
promoting stamina and endurance, and reducing the risk Therapy within the local community. All the children had
of contractures and deformities. A few parents followed up access to physical therapy although some had to travel as
on the exercises at home as this mother of a 13 -year-old much as 20 km each way to reach the service. Access to
boy: occupational therapists was less and seldom available in
Tumi’s just switched physical therapists and the one local communities outside of the capital area.
who took over is just great. He showed initiative in The interviewees wanted services in their local com-
increasing the number of visits from two times a week munity. It was made clear that trips to the therapists took
to three. He brought a new exercise program that has up much time, put pressure on the family life, and reduced
been so easy for us parents to follow in regards the amount of time the children had to engage with their
stretching and that kind of thing. peers. The parents of the children living in rural areas
Although the parents considered the therapy as important, sought therapy in the capital area, some up to 2 weeks
some doubtful voices were also heard regarding the worth each summer. Most voiced the difficulties that accompa-
of the therapy sessions, especially from the parents of older nied the travelling and the discussions often focused on
children. The mother of an 11 -year-old boy said: whether it was worth the effort. A description of the sit-
But you don’t know the real benefit of these physical uation is revealed in the words of a 12- year-old boy’s
therapies...He goes on summer vacation of course, mother: ‘‘The child goes to therapy at a center at some
maybe for two months or even more. And I don’t random place in town that has nothing to do with the
stretch him out, we stopped taking on the physical child’s reality.’’ Later in the interview, she said:
therapist role during vacations a long time ago. And The therapy should just clearly be a part of everyday
what I find strange and actually a little disturbing is life as much as possible. It should be in the home, it
that I don’t see any difference in him during spring should be in the preschools, it should be in the
and autumn, I don’t see that he’s deteriorated at all. schools. Where the child is.
Limited communication about the therapy goals or what Some thought it best for therapy to be a part of local health
happened during therapy sessions was reported by many. clinic services, while others mentioned that above all there
Or, as one mother said: should be therapy centres near their neighbourhoods. All
As far as I know there aren’t even any meetings with the parents wanted to see therapists in contact with
the parents about the goals of the therapy, about what schools to consider access issues, the use of assistive
the parents would like to get out of them. They don’t devices, and to provide advice on practical situations.
even know what’s going on in therapy. The parent’s emphasis was not only focused on the
The occupational therapy interventions traditionally location of services, but on its content and follow-up in the
focused on fine-motor activities and improving the chil- child’s daily environments. Or as one mother put it: ‘‘Two
dren’s performance in self-care tasks, such as bathing, hours in physical therapy are a total waste if the child sits
personal care awareness, and moving about in the the rest of the week in a broken-down chair.’’

Ó 2010 The Author


Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences Ó 2010 Nordic College of Caring Science
Parent perspectives of therapy services 281

Service coordination at a national level. The parents of chil- I take it upon myself at the beginning of each year to
dren with the most extensive impairments stressed the make sure that they sit down with the family, with the
importance of the national habilitation centre. Some of child and his family, and that we go over his needs.
these families lived outside of the capital area where pro- That there is a clear goal that is being worked toward.
fessional knowledge was limited. This description is typical And to make that possible we need therapists who are
of these interviewee’s responses: well involved in what is happening with people on a
I see a strong central facility like we have in Reykjavik daily basis. That they realize what the needs are. And
that services the whole country and then smaller included in these goals are adjustments to his chair at
facilities in rural areas that could take on and see to school, access at school, access at home, the shower
the situation a little more. situation, the toilet situation, his bed, his food, how
The importance of service coordination at a national level the kitchen is organized. And so on. It touches
to ensure continuity and to fight instability because of staff everything.
turnover was highlighted. The parents of the children with One mother described her first few years of experience
myelomeningocele and neuromuscular disorders were in with therapy services and how she ultimately took matters
general content with the speciality clinics for children up into her own hands and decided to trust her own judge-
to 16 years old. The same was not available for children ment:
with CP, and their parents were vocal about the lack of I felt like there were all these commands, that you
follow-up after the age of six. On this subject, many should always do this and that for the child...So
praised the preschool years in retrospect and claimed the then I just stopped it, you know. I found out myself
difficulties increased after the children entered elementary what was best for her and for me. I was always
school. unhappy with this walker that she had before she
started walking, thought she always looked like a
slouch in it and completely ridiculous to see her in
Characteristics of good service
it. So I went to a toy store and found a doll carriage.
In relation to good service, four categories emerged: The And she stood perfectly with the carriage and
family in the forefront, help towards self-sufficiency, pro- walked...You just have to find things out a little
fessional behaviour, and coordinating and preparing for yourself.
the future. In general, parents wanted more information and initiative
from therapists but ultimately wanted the autonomy to
The family in the forefront. A distinct desire for the therapists choose, reject, and decide for themselves.
to take into more consideration the needs of the family was
reported. But opinions varied and the follow-up data Help towards self-sufficiency. When their child was young,
showed that what was currently happening in the child’s most parents considered it important to get clear guide-
and family’s life had much impact on their experience and lines, preferrably that the therapist was a step ahead of the
their desire for service arrangements. Some parents family. Alternatively, as their child grew older, the parents
wanted to take part in everything relating to their child, wanted more flexibility and mutual planning. The parents
while others wanted therapists to take responsibility for of the oldest children placed emphasis on the importance
specific issues. Most wanted an active part in decision- of therapists supporting the actions of the children and
making while not bearing the main responsibility for their families, and that the strengths of each family would
services, either by being team coordinators for their own be used to their advantage. The mother of a 13 -year-old
agendas or by being information bearers between services. boy said:
They felt it important that they receive information to It is very important that parents get the help they
reflect on to then make their own informed, independent need, and there are different considerations that have
decisions. A shortage of clear communication channels and to be taken into account, as everyone is different.
definitions of roles and responsibilities complicated matters Those who work with the parents, first, have to learn
as one mother noted: ‘‘You don’t always know when to listen. Second, take into account the strength of
you’re infringing on the professionals and when you each individual, both the child and the parent. And if
should show initiative.’’ they see that you could do things differently, then
Some differences between the parents of younger and help you with it. And it is very important to ask the
older children emerged in the analysis as the parents parents (what they want).
became increasingly critical of the service provided as their Another mother said:
children grew older. Additionally, the parents of the older The parents need to be taught along with the children,
children often offered ideas of how therapists and profes- because it’s through the parents that everything flows
sionals should work together. The mother of a 12 -year-old to the child, this ‘problem solving.’ It can’t just be a
boy had this to say: professional who has all the answers.

Ó 2010 The Author


Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences Ó 2010 Nordic College of Caring Science
282 S.T. Egilson

Some requested closer support and instruction from ther-


Discussion
apists. As one father noted: ‘‘We aren’t perfect and we a lot
of times don’t see the forest for the trees. We’re just nor- The purpose of this study was to explore how parents of
mal.’’ Rather than expansive therapy plans, the parents Icelandic children with physical disabilities view the ther-
wanted useful pointers to make daily routine easier and to apy services that their children had received. Although
increase the capabilities and comforts of the child and the several positive remarks were made about the services,
family. As has been noted, some wished for clear guidance, many parents in this study were poorly informed of
while others wanted to control the journey, especially the intervention goals and what took place during therapy
parents of older children. sessions. This lack of communication about principle focus
points and expectations is rather surprising given the
Professional behaviour. The parents’ descriptions of the current emphasis on family-centred services in the litera-
professionals they had met were often very personal and ture (4–8). Therapists need to think carefully about how to
used to define how service should and should not be. increase their collaboration with the family. They also
Individual characteristics meant much more than profes- have to find a way to express what they do so that their
sional title or degree. The most emphasis was placed on the service is more visible. The results of this study indicate
initiative, insight, interest, reliability, and communication that therapists need to place emphasis on family choice
skills of the therapists, and that they reacted quickly and and decisions, cooperation with parents and teachers, and
well to people’s requests. The parents wanted strong and the transference of learnings in therapy sessions to the
capable professionals who kept them on track. As one home and school.
mother of a 12 -year-old boy stated: Specific issues raised by the parents involved supplying
I want people who ask questions. I don’t want people assistive devices in school and monitoring their use.
who agree with everything I say, because those aren’t Promoting accessibility and efficient use of assistive
people who are thinking. And that means they’re not devices should be a priority in service to children with
using the resources, you know? physical disabilities in order to enable them to access and
In addition, the parents felt that concern and aspirations participate in important activities and settings. The needs
for the child and family were necessary qualities for ther- of the child within a particular setting should be matched
apists. They needed the knowledge, vigour, and skills to get with the available technology to enhance or enable active
involved, bring in ideas, and following them through. The involvement, interaction with others, and independence
great majority wished for enthusiastic and responsible (25).
professionals to support the family, help them take on Interestingly, the therapy services seemed to be mutable
daily life, and set standards for the increased function and and dependent on what individual took on the service
participation of their children. each time – highlighting the importance of professional
competencies and help-giving practices, consistently found
Coordinating and preparing for the future. All the parents in research (6, 9, 26). The lack of coordinated practices
expressed a desire for more coordination of services. meant that the ability, interest, and perspective of the
Consultation to schools and other institutions were high- therapists were imperative. To guarantee best practice, the
est on their list. The parents felt it important for service to role and responsibilities of the therapist has to be well
be visible and that it was clear who had what rights, who defined, while simultaneously allowing for flexibility to
had what responsbilities, when and how. The need for a accommodate different families. Therapists need to con-
single point of contact, a person who had an overview of sider the content and arrangement of their service and to
the child’s situation and who guided the family through ensure that their interventions are informed by a sound
the jungle of the system came up repeatedly. One mother theoretical base and crafted to meet the changing needs
said: and priorities of the child and the family (27–29).
There needs to be one person with a whole view over The parents in this study placed emphasis on services
all the developmental elements, motor development, being offered in their local community and that they
cognitive development and social development. They would not have to seek it out in many locations. After this
need to connect the home, school and other places study was conducted, more therapists work within the
where the child seeks services, help people to priori- community, such as in schools, which may facilitate
tize and push things along. This is necessary to guar- increased collaboration and the transference of learnings
antee a holistic approach, that people are headed for over into the daily environments of the child. Neverthe-
the same goal. less, given the population and geography of Iceland, some
Finally, the informants felt it important that ways were families will continue to travel for necessary services. It
found to anticipate and prepare for problems that lay in the should be noted that the parents felt that more specialized
future and to offer support to help their children to service should be centralized at a national level, especially
develop and utilize their strengths to the fullest. for the children with the most complex needs.

Ó 2010 The Author


Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences Ó 2010 Nordic College of Caring Science
Parent perspectives of therapy services 283

Although the respondents had much in common, anal-


Conclusion
ysis showed variations in their desire for services. Some
parents wanted to take a very active role, while others Compared to many other nations, the Nordic countries
chose foremost to consider selected issues. These results have a long tradition of community focus to health service
underscore that services need to be tailored to individual provision, concentrating on the individual within his or her
situations, with the values and culture of each family as a environment. Thus, it is even more interesting that the shift
guide. This is consistent with literature, emphasizing that in parent–therapist partnership reported in the literature
families have options with respect to their level of (5, 7, 16) is not better adopted in Iceland. It should be noted
involvement at different times (4, 8). that many studies have focused mainly on the services
Noteworthy are the different views expressed by the provided to the families of preschool children, and there
parents of the younger and older children, and the fact that may be less family involvement as the child gets older.
parents became increasingly critical of the services, as their The study has implications beyond Iceland as it points to
child grew older. The parents of the younger children the importance of studying actual practices from the user’s
focused mainly on the present and wanted clear messages point of view, that is, whether new attitudes and knowl-
and guidance from the therapists. The parents of the older edge are translated into practice. The message to educators
children asked for mutual planning and decision-making is to prepare their students with the necessary skills to
with the therapists and more consideration for the future work in partnership with families of children with dis-
of their child. Quite probably the therapists had the chil- abilities – defining and developing helpful strategies and
dren’s future in mind but had not communicated their focusing on professional qualities and behaviour. How-
goals clearly enough to the parents. It is important for ever, some of the hindrances in adopting family-centred
intervention issues to focus on the child being able to live a services may be structural in nature and thus require a
functional and fulfilling adult life. For this to happen, broader approach than merely new knowledge, and
thought needs to be given to the conditions and environ- improvements in attitudes or behaviour. Rather, they
ments of the child and to thoroughly prepare for a positive speak to the fundamental structure of the way services are
transition into adulthood (12). organized and carried out. Therefore, each society should
The parents in this study frequently carried information consider convenient infrastructures from their own per-
between therapists and schools. They felt the role of spective as situations can be varied.
‘middleman’ difficult and reportedly it lead at times to Presently, there is an ongoing discussion about designing
conflict between families and schools. Thus, therapists and implementing family-centred services in Iceland. In
should take more responsibility for coordinating informa- 2007, the Icelandic Ministry of Social Affairs introduced a
tion and service than they do now. Parents’ need for policy statement, focusing on service cooperation to meet
functional yet manageable responsibilities that do not take the needs and wants of families of children with disabilities
up too much time is consistent with results from another (33). Quantitative studies, using the Measure of Processes
study (30). The results of this study reflect the importance of Care (34, 35) and Measure of Processes of Care for
of the needs and wants of the parents and children being Service Providers (36) to evaluate the implementation of
respected. Thus, parents should play an active role in therapy services, are in process and will enable an objec-
defining priorities and strategies for implementation. The tive examination of how family-centred the services are.
parents know their children’s strengths best and the ulti- Although this study was limited to a relatively small
mate responsibility for their child is theirs. number of parents, it has provided important insights into
Finally, it is necessary to prepare for the future by delin- the perspectives of Icelandic parents of children with
eating strategies and methods that support the child’s par- physical disabilities. Additional research in this area may
ticipation in as many situations as possible. It is essential that monitor and reflect changes in the services provided by
increased participation outcomes for children with disabili- Icelandic occupational and physical therapists, as regarded
ties and their families are the centre of therapists’ efforts and by parents.
attention. Traditional child-focused service delivery
approaches need to be replaced by ways of looking at what
children and families really want and need (2, 31, 32).

pation and quality of life for children know? Child Care Health Dev 1999; 25:
References and youth with disabilities. Phys Occup 85–99.
1 King G, Tucker MA, Baldwin P, Lowry Ther Pediatr 2002; 22(2): 53–77. 3 Law M, Majnemer A, McColl MA,
K, LaPorta J, Martens L. A life needs 2 Sloper P. Models of service support Bosch J, Hanna S, Wilkins S, Birch S,
model of pediatric service delivery: for parents of disabled children: what Telford S, Stewart D. Home and com-
services to support community partici- do we know? What do we need to munity occupational therapy for chil-
dren and youth: a before and after

Ó 2010 The Author


Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences Ó 2010 Nordic College of Caring Science
284 S.T. Egilson

study. Can J Occup Ther 2005; 72: 289– twelve years of change. Am J Occup practice. In Qualitative Research in
97. Ther 2002; 56: 556–63. Evidence-Based Rehabilitation (Hamm-
4 Rosenbaum P, King S, Law M, King G, 17 Sloper P. Facilitators and barriers for ell KW, Carpenter C, eds.), 2004,
Evans J. Family-centred service: a co-ordinated multi-agency services. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburg.
conceptual framework and research Child Care Health Dev 2004; 30: 571– 30 Law M, Haight M, Milroy B, Willms
review. Phys Occup Ther Pediatr 1998; 80. D, Stewart D, Rosenbaum P. Envi-
18(1): 1–20. 18 Althingi. Lög um Greiningar- og ronmental factors affecting the occu-
5 Hanna K, Rodger S. Towards family- ráðgjafarstöð rı́kisins [Act on the State pations of children with physical
centred practice in paediatric occupa- Diagnostic and Counseling Centre; disabilities. J Occup Sci 1999; 6: 102–
tional therapy: a review of the litera- 2003. 10.
ture on parent-therapist collaboration. 19 Knox V, Menzies S. Using the Mea- 31 CanChild, Law M, Rosenbaum P,
Aust Occup Ther J 2002; 49: 14–24. sure of Processes of Care to assess Jaffer S, Plews N, Kertoy M, King S.
6 Dempsey I, Keen D. A review of pro- parents’ views of a peadiatric therapy Service Coordination for Children and
cesses and outcomes in family-cen- service. Br J Occup Ther 2005; 68: 110– Youth with Complex Needs: Report for the
tered services for children with a 6. Ministry of Children and Youth Services,
disability. Topics Early Child Spec Educ 20 Stewart S, Neyerlin-Beale J. The im- 2004, CanChild Centre for Disability
2008; 28: 42–52. pact of community peadiatric occu- Research, Hamilton.
7 Franck LS, Callery P. Re-thinking pational therapy on children with 32 King G. ‘‘Best approaches’’ in Pediatric
family-centred care across the contin- disabilities and their carers. Br J Occup Rehabilitation: Intervention Principles for
uum of children’s healthcare. Child Ther 2000; 63: 373–8. Service Providers. 2003, Research Alli-
Care Health Dev 2004; 30: 265–77. 21 Bjerre IM, Larsson M, Franzon A-M, ance for Children with Special Needs,
8 King S, Teplicky R, King G, Rosen- Nilsson MS, Strömberg G, Westbom London, ON.
baum P. Family-centered service for LM. Measure of Processes of Care 33 Ministry of Social Affairs. Mótum
children with cerebral palsy and their (MPOC) applied to measure parent’s framtı́ð. Þjónusta við fötluð börn og
families: a review of the literature. Se- perception of the habilitation process fullorða 2007–2016. [Designing the
min Pediatr Neurol 2004; 11(1): 78–86. in Sweden. Child Care Health Dev future. Services to children with dis-
9 King G, Cathers T, King S, Rosenbaum 2004; 30: 123–30. abilities and their families]. Retrieved
P. Major elements of parents’ satisfac- 22 Bogdan RC, Biklen SK. Qualitative from: http://www.felagsmalaradun
tion and dissatisfaction with pediatric Research for Education. An Introduction eyti.is/media/thjonusta_f/framtidars
rehabilitation services. Child Health to Theory and Methods, 3rd edn. 1998, yn_stefna_samantekt.pdf.
Care 2001; 30: 111–34. Allyn and Bacon, Needham Heights, 34 King S, King G, Rosenbaum P. Eval-
10 Law M, Hanna S, King G, Hurley P, MA.. uating health service delivery to
King S, Kertoy M, Rosenbaum P. Fac- 23 Patton MQ. Qualitative Research & children with chronic conditions and
tors affecting family-centred service Evaluation Methods, 3rd edn. 2002, their families: Development of a re-
delivery for children with disabilities. Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA. fined measure of processes of care
Child Care Health Dev 2003; 29: 357–66. 24 Curtain M, Fossey E. Appraising the (MPOC-20). Child Health Care 2004;
11 Sloper P. Key worker services for dis- trustworthiness of qualitative studies: 22: 35–7.
abled children: what characteristics of guidelines for occupational therapists. 35 King S, Rosenbaum P, King G. The
services lead to better outcomes for Aust Occup Ther J 2007; 54: 88–94. measure of Processes of Care, MPOC: A
children and families? Child Care Health 25 Skär L. Disabled children’s percep- Means to Assess Family-Centred Behav-
Dev 2006; 32: 147–57. tions of technical aids, assistance and iours and Health Care Providers. 1995,
12 Stewart S. Evidence to support a posi- peers in play situations. Scand J Caring Mc Master University, Neurodevel-
tive transition into adulthood for Sci 2002; 16: 27–33. opmental Clinical Research Unit,
youth with disabilities. Phys Occup Ther 26 Schoot T, Proot I, terMeulen R, Ontario, Retrieved from: http://www.
Pediatr 2006; 26(4): 1–4. deWitte L. Recognition of client val- canchild.ca/Portals/0/measures/1995_
13 King G, Meyer K. Service integration ues as a basis for tailored care: the MPOC_>Manual_MPOC-56_MPOC-
and co-ordination: a framework of view of Dutch expert patients and 20_questionnaires.pdf.
approaches for the delivery of co- family caregivers. Scand J Caring Sci 36 Woodside JM, Rosenbaum PL, King
ordinated care to children with dis- 2005; 19: 169–76. SM, King GA. Family-centered ser-
abilities and their families. Child Care 27 Sackett D, Strauss S, Richardson V, vice: developing and validating a sel-
Health Dev 2006; 32: 477–92. Rosenberg W, Haynes R. Evidence- assessment tool for pediatric service
14 Sumsion T, Smyth G. Barriers to client- Based Medicine, 2nd edn. 2000, Chur- providers. The Measure of Processes
centredness and their resolution. Can J chill Livingstone, Edinburgh, Scot- of Care for Service Providers (MPOC-
Occup Ther 2000; 67: 15–21. land. SP). Child Health Care 2001; 30: 237–
15 Lawlor M, Mattingly C. The complex- 28 Taylor MC. Evidence-Based Practice for 52.
ities embedded in family-centered Occupational Therapists, 2nd edn. 2007,
care. Am J Occup Ther 1998; 48: 361–6. Blackwell Publishing, Oxford.
16 Hinojosa J, Mankhetwit S, Sproat J. 29 Hammell KW. Using qualitative evi-
Shifts in parent-therapist partnerships: dence as a basis for evidence-based

Ó 2010 The Author


Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences Ó 2010 Nordic College of Caring Science

You might also like