Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 4
Chapter 4
• A research design is a master plan specifying the methods and procedures for
• The way you choose to answer your research question will be influenced by
• Reliability
• Validity
• Generalization
• Action research
6
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD)
Experiment
• In their purest form experiments are infrequently used in management research,
their roots in natural science laboratory-based research.
• For instance, we do not want (for obvious reasons) to assign workers to highly
stressful situations to investigate the effect of work‐related stress on personal &
professional relations.
7
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD)
Survey
• The survey strategy is usually associated with the deductive approach.
• Surveys are popular as they allow the collection of a large amount of data from a
sizeable population in a highly economical way.
8
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD)
Case study
• Case studies focus on collecting information about a specific object, event or
activity, such as a particular business unit or organization.
• The idea behind a case study is that in order to obtain a clear picture of a
problem one must examine the real‐life situation from various angles and
perspectives using multiple methods of data collection.
9
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD)
Action research
• Action research is a research strategy aimed at effecting planned changes.
• Here, the researcher begins with a problem that is already identified, and gathers
relevant data to provide a tentative problem solution. This solution is then
implemented.
• The effects are then evaluated, defined, and diagnosed, and the research
continues on an ongoing basis until the problem is fully resolved.
10
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD)
Grounded theory
• Grounded theory is a systematic set of procedures to develop an
inductively derived theory from the data.
11
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD)
Ethnography
• Ethnography is rooted firmly in the inductive approach.
• Ethnography involves immersion in the particular culture of the social group that is
being studied observing behavior, listening to what is said in conversations, and
asking questions. It thus aims to generate an understanding of the culture and
behavior of a social group from an “insider’s point of view.”
• This is obviously a research strategy that is very time consuming and takes place
over an extended time period as the researcher needs to immerse herself or himself
in the social world being researched as completely as possible.
12
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD)
Archival research
• An archive is any collection of records.
• Archival research, makes use of administrative records and documents as the principal
source of data.
• Archival research is a research design which involves seeking out and extracting
evidence from archival records.
13
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD)
Research approaches
• Research approaches are plans and the procedures for research that span the
steps from broad assumptions to detailed methods of data collection, analysis,
and interpretation.
• Quantitative,
• Qualitative, and
• Mixed methods.
of a whole to show • Save costs: Less expensive to study the sample than the
what the rest is like”. population.
• Sampling helps to • Save time: Less time needed to study the sample than
determine the the population .
corresponding value • Accuracy(??): Since sampling is done with care and
of the population studies are conducted by skilled and qualified
and plays a vital role interviewers, the results are expected to be accurate.
in business research.
• Destructive nature of elements: For some elements,
• Universe or population is the whole mass • A sample frame is the list of all elements in the
under study. population (such as telephone directories,
• What are the sampling units? • A sample frame which does not fully represent
an intended population will result in frame
• What is the specific designation of the
error and affect the degree of reliability of
units to be covered?
sample result.
• What time period does the data refer to?
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD) 17
Step – 3: Determination of Sample Size
• Sample size may be determined by using:
• Cost basis approach: The number that can be studied with the available
funds;
• Confidence level
• Sequential sampling
• Means n = (ZS/E) 2
• Proportions n = Z2 pq/ E2
• Percentiles n = pc (1 – pc) Z2/ E2
• I want to be 95% confident about the average salary and I’m willing to tolerate an
estimate that is within $500 (plus or minus) of the true estimate. If we’re off, we can
always adjust salaries at the end of the probation period.
• Solution:
• n = (ZS/E) 2
• n = ((1.96*3,000)/500)^2
• n 139 (plus allowance for a possible non-response)
• We know from past educational TV programs that such a program would likely capture 2
out of 10 viewers on a typical night.
• Let’s say we want to be 99% confident that our obtained sample proportion of viewers
will differ from the true population proportions by not more than 5%.
• A recent poll showed that 52% of Americans questioned preferred the Liberals.
• Solution:
• n = pc (100 – pc) Z2/ E2
• n = 0.52 (100 – 0.52) 1.962/ 0.052
• n 384 (plus allowance for a possible non-response)
• Non-sampling errors are more serious and are due to mistakes made in the acquisition
of data or due to the sample observations being selected improperly.
Sampling
Methods
Probability Non-
Samples probability
Simple
Cluster Judgment Quota
Random
• Problem: can be very costly if population is large. Choices come from a list; who
makes the list?
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD) 28
Probability sampling…..
• Systematic random sampling – samples according to a rule
• E.g., every fifth person is chosen
• Stratified sampling – break the sample into various subgroups or strata and sample
from them.
• Must have good knowledge of strata
• Cluster sampling - the subjects are selected in groups or clusters rather than
randomly
• E.g., interviewing Kaldi’s employees
• Clusters would be every employee at a particular store.
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD) 29
Probability sampling…..
• One-stage cluster sampling – sample all members of the cluster
• Importance of context
• Problems
• no representativeness
• Not random
• Quota sampling - quotas for certain types of people or organizations are selected as
sample
• E.g., certain number of samples from each regions, age groups, etc.
3. Case studies analysis – find important individuals and study them in depth.
• Chain sampling
• Issues:
Provide anonymity
• Secondary data
• Primary data
• May not have been collected long enough for detecting trends.
• Unless such missing information is caught and corrected for, analysis will be biased.
• Did variables drop out over time? Did variables change in definition over time?
• In some cases, may have to use “proxy variables” – variables that may
approximate something you really wanted to measure. Are they reliable? Is there
correlation to what you actually want to measure?
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD) 41
Secondary Data – Advantages
• No need to reinvent the wheel.
• If someone has already found the data, take advantage of it.
• Entry of data?
• To answer that
• Then you need to decide what data is needed to scientifically answer the question
• If that data exist in secondary form, then use them to the extent you can, keeping in
mind limitations.
• But if it does not and you are able to fund primary collection, then it is the method of
choice.
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD) 44
Primary Data - Examples
• Questionnaires
• Personal interviews
• The underlying research problem and objectives must be clearly understood by the
researchers
• Using common sense, good grammar and imagination alone cannot guarantee
producing a high quality questionnaire
• What is the best questionnaire layout for the research problem in question?
• Accuracy means that the questions are worded in a manner which ensures the
collection of correct information from respondents
• Open-ended questions allow the respondent to ask or probe the respondent further if
he/she feels that clarification or additional information, is needed.
• Disadvantage:
• Also, there is the possibility of bias and bias caused by the different education levels
of the respondents
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD) 49
Phrasing Questionnaires….
• Fixed-Alternative Questions –require the respondent to choose, among a limited
number of alternative given
• Fixed Alternative questions allow the respondent to ask or probe the respondent further
if he/she feels that clarification of a point, or additional information, is needed.
• Advantages include requiring less time, less skill and ease of answer for
respondents.
• Disadvantages are that the researcher may be basing the response structure on
assumptions which may be incorrect, and that there may be additional responses
which are not indicated.
• Also, care must be taken to ensure that response categories are mutually exclusive
and do not overlap
• Leading means implying certain answers which respondents are pushed towards;
• Counter-biasing Statements
• Asking questions requiring respondents to give personal details at the beginning of the
questionnaire is generally not recommended unless it is relevant to the objectives
• Usually, researchers prefer to ask general questions from respondents before moving
on to specific questions (funnel technique)
• Ensure that the title and subtitles of the questionnaire are carefully phrased and
captures the respondents attention
• Personal interviewers are often used for pretesting provide answers to important
questions for the business researcher, such as:
• Advantages • Challenges
• Costly, time taking and impractical for large sample size study
• Disadvantage:
• can be difficult to interpret seen behaviors
• can be expensive
Note: to make the best use of observation, it is better to have a pre-set categorization
of possible observable phenomena or criteria of acceptance or rejection. To do so,
preset observation checklist is indispensable.
6. Tell them how to get in touch with you later if they want to
• Ensure that the same general area of information are collected from all interviewees
• It facilitates faster interviews that can be more easily analyzed and compared
4. Closed, fixed-response interview - all interviewees are asked the same questions and
asked to choose answers from among the same set of alternatives
Zenegnaw Abiy Hailu (PhD) 66
Sequence of Questions
1. Get the respondents involved in the interview as soon as possible.
2. Before asking about controversial matters (such as feelings and conclusions), first
ask about some facts
4. Ask questions about the present before questions about the past or future
• Write down any observations made during the interview right after the interview