of HRM HHDNP Opatha The Topic • Is it short? • Is it clear? • Is it relevant to the field of HRM? • Is it representing what is being proposed to study? • Is it not a sentence? • Does it have a substantial body of literature associated with it? • Has it captured your interest seriously? Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP Opatha Introduction • Has it been given? Or an alternative such as Problem Context or Background to the Study? • Is it clearly stated? • Are paragraphs consistent? Is there a flow among the paragraphs? • Is there a link between the introductory part and the next part, i.e., Problem Statement? • Does it have a sufficient number of references? Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP Opatha Problem Statement • Has it been clearly given? • Does it indicate/mention the gap between what is existing and what should be? • Is it loaded? Does it involve several research questions if it is broken down? • Is it consistent with the objectives of the study? • Is it related to the background? • Is it consistent with the title? • Is there an intellectual puzzle to be investigated? • Does it have several references to show the gap? Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP Opatha Research Questions • Have they been specifically given? • Are they consistent with the problem statement and the research objectives? • Are they researchable when reality and time given are considered? • Are there several research questions? At least two?
Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP
Opatha Objectives • Have they been specifically stated? • Are they achievable? • Are they consistent with research problem/research questions? • Are they matched with the title? • Are they chronologically OK? • Are they adequate? Many or few?
Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP
Opatha Importance of the Study • Has it been given? • Has it been given clearly? • Does it contribute to theoretical understanding? • Does it contribute empirically? • Does it involve new tools for future studies? • Does it propose new issues/questions for future research? Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP Opatha Literature Review • Have the origins and definitions of the topic been given clearly? • Have the key theories, concepts and ideas/aspects been given clearly? • Is conceptualization of variables sufficient and appropriate? • Does it have a sufficient number of references? • Are there classic references? • Are there latest references?
Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP
Opatha Theoretical Framework • Have the variables considered relevant to the study been clearly identified and labeled in the discussion? • Do the discussions state how two or more variables are related to each other? • Is there a clear explanation of why the researcher would expect these relationships to exist?
Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP
Opatha • Does it use previous research findings and/or arguments of the noted authors? Logical beliefs? Common theories? • Is there a schematic diagram of the theoretical framework given so as to visualize the theoretical relationships?
Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP
Opatha Hypotheses (if any) • Does it (each hypothesis) have a statement of an expected relationship or the expected difference between two or more variables in the study? Or effect of one variable on another or several variables? • Has it been stated lucidly and unambiguously in terms of a declaratory sentence? No doubts about what you are saying • Is it testable? • Is it simple and concise to the extent that is possible? • Does it base on a good rationale/justification?
Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP
Opatha Methodology • Has the purpose/nature of the study been clearly identified and mentioned? • Has the type of investigation been clearly identified and mentioned? • Has the setting been identified and clearly mentioned? • Has the study design been mentioned clearly? Extent of researcher interference, time horizon, unit of analysis? • Are all these appropriate?
Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP
Opatha • Has the study sampling procedure been clearly mentioned ? (population of the study covered, sample, sampling frame, method of sampling, etc.) • If it is a case study, has it clearly been described? Case profile • Is the measurement clear, appropriate and acceptable? Operationalization of variables and instrumentation • Is data collection clear, appropriate and acceptable? • Have methods of data analysis been given? Are they appropriate? Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP Opatha Limitations • Have they been given? • Are they clear? • Are they acceptable? • Do they not affect the quality of the study significantly? • Are there delimitations (inherent weaknesses of the methods and tools used)? Are they right? Litterarum Doctor, Senior Professor HHDNP Opatha References • Have they been given? • Are they relevant? • Is there a gap between inside and the list? • Are they sufficient? • Are they up to date? • Have they been given in an academically acceptable way?