REPUBLIC VS.

CA 236 SCRA 257

FACTS:
Respondent Angelina M. Castro and Edwin F. Cardenas were married in a civil ceremony performed
by a City Court Judge of Pasig City and was celebrated without the knowledge of Castro's
parents.Defendant Cardenas personally attended the procuring of the documents required for the
celebration of the marriage, including the procurement of the marriage license.

The couple did not immediately live together as husband and wife since the marriage was unknown
to Castro's parents. They decided to live together when Castro discovered she was pregnant. The
cohabitation lasted only for four months. Thereafter, the couple parted ways. Desiring to follow her
daughter in the U.S, Castro wanted to put in order he marital status before leaving for the U.S. She
then discovered that there was no marriage license issued to Cardenas prior to the celebration of
their marriage as certified by the Civil Registrar of Pasig, Metro Manila.

Respondent then filed a petition with the RTC of Quezon City seeking for the judicial declaration of
nullity of her marriage claiming that no marriage license was ever issued to them prior to the
solemnization of their marriage.

The trial court denied the petition holding that the certification was inadequate to establish the
alleged non-issuance of a marriage license prior to the celebration of the marriage between the
parties. It ruled that the "inability of the certifying official to locate the marriage license is not
conclusive to show that there was no marriage license issued. On appeal, the decision of the trial
court was reversed.

ISSUE:
Is the marriage valid? Is there such a thing as a "secret marriage"?

HELD:
At the time of the subject marriage was solemnized on June 24, 1970, the law governing marital
relations was the New Civil Code. The law provides that no marriage license shall be solemnized
without a marriage license first issued by the local civil registrar. Being one of the essential requisites
of a valid marriage, absence of a license would render the marriage void ab initio.

It will be remembered that the subject marriage was a civil ceremony performed by a judge of a city
court. The subject marriage is one of those commonly known as a "secret marriage" - a legally non-
existent phrase but ordinarily used to refer to a civil marriage celebrated without the knowledge of
the relatives and/or friends of either or both of the contracting parties. The records show that the
marriage between Castro and Cardenas as initially unknown to the parents of the former.