Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DB9/32643/17
CHUKA UNIVERSITY
AUGUST, 2021
i
DECLARATION
This proposal comprises only my original research work towards the project of Bachelors of
Hotel Management.
For works of others involved, every effort is made to indicate this clearly with due reference to
This work was done under the guidance of my supervisor Dr Jedidah Kiharason, Chuka
University.
DB9/32643/17
DR JEDIDAH KIHARASON
SUPERVISOR
Sign______________________________ Date_____________________________
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
My sincere gratitude goes to my supervisor Dr Jedidah Kiharason for making time to guide me in
Above all this, I thank God for the gift of good health.
iii
ABSTRACT
Managers in hospitality industry don’t consider kitchen planning and design to a similar degree.
Consequently, a few hotels plan their kitchens such that kitchen staffs are not ready to work
productively. In this way the study will aim at investigating and studying the effects of kitchen
planning and design on kitchen staff productivity and thought of conceivable approaches to
enable hotel managers understand the significance of good kitchen planning and design to
improve staff productivity. The objectives of the study are to evaluate the effects of efficiency in
kitchen planning and design on kitchen staff productivity, to determine how comfort in kitchen
planning and design influences kitchen staff productivity, and to examine how safety in kitchen
planning and design affects kitchen staff productivity in hospitality industry in Nakuru Town.
The study will review more information based on the objectives of the study and two theories;
the kitchen triangle theory and Herzberg’s two factor theory. Descriptive survey design will be
adopted. The study will be conducted in Nakuru Town. You begin with the population size, from
which now you draw a sample sizeThe sample size will be 35 respondents comprising of hotel
managers and 5 kitchen staffs from each hotel. The researcher will select 5 hotels. Better still,
say how many staff (managers and kitchen staff) you will get form each of the 5 hotels. That way
it becomes clear Unstructured and structured questionnaires will be used to collect data.
Questionnaires will be distributed in different hotels to various kitchen staff and managers to
collect data on effects of kitchen planning and design on kitchen staff productivity in hospitality
industry.
iv
Table of Contents
DECLARATION.........................................................................................................................................ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT..........................................................................................................................iii
ABSTRACT...............................................................................................................................................iv
CHAPTER ONE..........................................................................................................................................1
Introduction.................................................................................................................................................1
1.1 Background...........................................................................................................................................1
1.2 Statement of the problem.......................................................................................................................3
1.3 Purpose of the study..............................................................................................................................3
1.4 Research objectives...............................................................................................................................3
1.5 Research questions................................................................................................................................3
1.6 Significance of the study.......................................................................................................................4
1.7 Scope of the study.................................................................................................................................4
1.8 Limitations............................................................................................................................................4
1.9 Expected outcomes................................................................................................................................5
Definition of terms......................................................................................................................................5
CHAPTER TWO.........................................................................................................................................6
2.0 LITERATURE REVIEW......................................................................................................................6
Introduction.................................................................................................................................................6
Theoretical framework................................................................................................................................6
2.3 The Kitchen triangle Theory..................................................................................................................6
2.4 Herzberg’s two factor theory.................................................................................................................8
2.5 EMPIRICAL FRAMEWORK...............................................................................................................9
2.5.1 Staff productivity................................................................................................................................9
2.5.2 Comfort of kitchen planning and design on kitchen staff productivity.............................................10
2.5.2.1 Good working conditions...............................................................................................................11
2.5.2.1 Provide wholesome meals.............................................................................................................11
2.6 Safety of kitchen planning and design on kitchen staff........................................................................11
2.7.1 Incentive program.............................................................................................................................13
2.7.2 Fixed shifts and overtime policy.......................................................................................................14
2.8 Conceptual framework.........................................................................................................................14
v
.................................................................................................................................................................. 14
.................................................................................................................................................................. 14
.................................................................................................................................................................. 14
CHAPTER THREE...................................................................................................................................15
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY..............................................................................................................15
3.1. Research Design.................................................................................................................................15
3.2. Study area characteristics...................................................................................................................15
3.3 Target population.................................................................................................................................15
3.4. Research sample and sampling procedure..........................................................................................16
3.5. Data collection....................................................................................................................................16
3.5.1 Validity of the instrument.................................................................................................................17
3.5.1 Reliability of the instrument.............................................................................................................17
3.6. Data analysis.......................................................................................................................................17
3.7Ethical considerations...........................................................................................................................17
REFERENCES..........................................................................................................................................20
APPENDICES...........................................................................................................................................22
Questionnaires...........................................................................................................................................22
Introduction...............................................................................................................................................22
vi
LIST OF FIGURES
vii
CHAPTER ONE
Introduction
1.1 Background
A kitchen is a room or area designed and equipped for preparation of cooking healthy nourishing
substance that is eaten, drunk and otherwise taken into the body to sustain life, provide energy,
and promote growth and repair worn out tissues. The layout and design of a kitchen is one of the
most evident characteristics of a productive operation because it determines the appearance of its
environment (Slack et al, 2002). Organization of working environment influences the way
processes flow, which evidences the importance of a good layout for a kitchen performance
(Bougoure and Lee, 2009). Most small and medium sized hotels rarely have a system that
ensures the measurement of their performance and action on any deviation (Horng et
A well organized and planned kitchen helps minimize food wastage and deterioration and reduce
on the time taken for preparation, production and also reduces accidents by kitchen staff.
Pehkonen et al. (2009), stated that layout and design of the kitchen needs to take into account
employee productivity. Space needs to be adequate to complete work required, but not so large
that employee spends lots of time walking from place to place. Durability of the kitchen is an
important consideration in planning the layout and design of the facility. Kitchen layout is
A productive environment requires management that can positively motivate its staff. Adequate
working space, safe and clean working environment, enough ventilation in the kitchen motivates
1
staff positively. The importance of a high quality workplace has never been more evident than in
today’s climate of rising real estate costs and increasing business competition. To attract and
retain high caliber employees and to improve the performance of existing employees, an
organization must be able to offer a safe, comfortable, and stimulating work environment.
The actual physical layout of the kitchen is extremely important when it comes to maximizing
(Gutnick, 2007).Most managers and business owners choose to operate with certain minimum
level of kitchen furniture and accessories, thereby ignoring what can amount to a major obstacle
that is able to positively motivate its employees in an infrastructure that is good to employee’s
needs.
A poorly designed kitchen contributes a lot to low staff performance. A poorly designed kitchen
can happen due to additional of new equipment, new hired staff. This makes working in the
kitchen difficult and too much time is spent on preparation and production hence loss of morale
and low productivity realized. They should be designed properly to avoid too much warmth and
dampness that can create room for pathogens and allergens. Inhalation of smoke particles can
lead to health problems among staff members. The process of kitchen work and activities
contained in the kitchen reflect the requirements that need to be considered in order to design
efficient kitchen with components suitable for preparation and cooking, storage and accessibility
efficient usage of storage space and creating ergonomic comfort into the kitchen space. This
2
would enhance great saving on time and effort during any activity occurring in the kitchen and
During designing of restaurant kitchens, most restaurant managers do not put in much effort
compared to other areas like the dining. Most managers assume the extent to which a restaurant
kitchen should be designed due to lack of knowledge, financial challenges and poor
management. The study will be carried out to determine how kitchen planning and design affects
the productivity of kitchen staff in Nakuru town hotels, try to come up with possible ways hotel
managers can understand importance of kitchen planning and design on kitchen productivity.
To evaluate the relationship between kitchen planning and design and staff productivity in
1. To evaluate effects of safety in kitchen planning and design on productivity of the staff in
1. What is the influence of kitchen safety in kitchen planning and design to staff
productivity?
3
2. What is the effect of kitchen comfort in kitchen planning and design on staff
productivity?
3. To what extent does efficiency influence kitchen planning and design on staff
productivity?
The findings of the study will benefit both hotel managers and staff. The kitchen staff will have a
conducive working environment thus increase in the number of guests in the hotel. This will
contribute to increase of hotel revenue. This will help managers understand the importance of a
well-planned and designed kitchen. There will be increase in revenue of Nakuru town hotels.
This will enhance growth in the hospitality industry in Nakuru town due to well-planned and
The study will be carried out in Nakuru town hotels. It will focus on effects of kitchen planning
and design on staff productivity. The study will be carried out for a period of two
1.8 Limitations.
The period of study will be limited and therefore information provided will not be enough. There
will be a challenge in financing the research. The time for the research should be increased.
The employees of various hotels in Nakuru may be reluctant in responding to questions. The
researcher would identify some people to assist in the research so as to get enough information.
4
1.9 Expected outcomes
1. The contribution of comfort in kitchen planning and design on staff productivity would
be determined.
2. The contribution of safety in kitchen planning and design on staff productivity would be
determined.
3. The contribution of efficiency in kitchen planning and design on staff productivity would
be determined.
Definition of terms
Kitchen-room or part of a room used for cooking and food preparation in a dwelling or
commercial establishment.
Ergonomics-the study of working conditions, especially the design of equipment and furniture, in
5
CHAPTER TWO
Introduction
The chapter will outline the various theories that are used to explain the relationship between
staff performance and kitchen design and planning. This part shows existing writing dependent
on the objectives of the study. This will be reviewed out through the following research
objectives: determining how comfort in kitchen planning and design affects productivity of the
staff, to evaluate how safety in kitchen planning and design affects productivity of the kitchen
staff and to evaluate how training on kitchen planning and design affects productivity of kitchen
staff.
Theoretical framework
The theory was developed in the 1940s also known as the kitchen triangle. Kitchens were mostly
based around large appliances, minimal workspace and the idea that one person would work in
It expresses a kitchens three principle work zones: the sink, the refrigerator and the stove. As
indicated by it, each leg of the triangle formed should be between four and nine feet each, and
the total separation of the triangle ought not to be under at least 13 or more than 26 feet, neither
too far separated nor excessively normal. The parts of the triangle represent the traffic flow
within a kitchen, making a rotational movement between the tasks of cooking (stove),
6
An increased number of people preparing food in the kitchen has led to many specialists
advocating for the possibility of a kind of evolved kitchen triangle, going from three work
regions to making work zones inside the kitchen that are independent. For instance, when
baking, your baking zone should have everything you would possibly need for baking-measuring
cups and spoons, rolling pin, baking sheets-ideally situated close to both storeroom and stove.
Additionally, it will be essential to assess the traffic flow between work zones (Blakeley, 2018).
The space between each station, the sink, and the stove/oven is ideally between 1.2metres and
2.7metres with overall distances between 4metres and 7.9meters. Anything smaller will make it
hard to work in and anything bigger means there are too many steps between each movement
which makes it feel disjointed. No major pathways should pass through the triangle which is why
this theory worked well when a kitchen was a private room. The need for the work triangle has
changed with introduction of new technology for inside kitchens nowadays, the way we live and
ways food is prepared. At the end of the day, efficiency has to be the priority(Novak, 2016).
Sink
Work Triangle
Refrigerator Stove
7
2.4 Herzberg’s two factor theory
The two factor theory or the motivator- hygiene theory was proposed by Frederick Herzberg in
1959. Herzberg characterized two sets of variables in choosing representatives working attitude
and dimension of execution, named motivation and hygiene factors (Robbins,2009) Motivational
factors are characteristic factors to keep any representatives’ dissatisfaction. To build staff
execution or efficiency, motivational factors must be addressed. The two-factor theory is firmly
identified with Maslow’s order of necessities, yet it introduced more factors to measure how
people are motivated in the working environment. This theory argued that gathering the lower-
level needs (extrinsic or hygiene factors) of people would not motivate them to apply effort but
rather would just keep them from being dissatisfied. To motivate worker’s higher-level needs
(intrinsic or motivation factors) must be provided. These elements serve as a direction for
employees in making a good workplace where staff feels great working inside. At the point when
all these external factors are accomplished, staff will be free from upsetting outside working
conditions that will take away feelings of disappointments, for example: staff working in a
kitchen where the working conditions such as the temperature, humidity, and air circulation are
well regulated will feel satisfied and consequently will work productively. This can possibly
apply if the kitchen itself is very much arranged and planned to guarantee that even the working
place is satisfactory.
8
2.5 EMPIRICAL FRAMEWORK
The physical environment influences how staff interacts and perform tasks. Hughes (2007) in a
survey reported that nine out of ten workers believed that quality of work environment affects
the attitude of employees and increases their productivity. An unsafe and unhealthy workplace
environment in terms of poor ventilation, inappropriate lighting, excessive noise etc. affects
workers’ productivity and health (Chandraseker 2011). Such factors influence staff attitude,
McCoy and Evans (2005) expressed that the components of the physical work environment
should be appropriate with the goal that the employees would not be pushed while completing
their tasks. (Vischer, 2007) essential factors in the workplace, for example, commotion, lighting,
building shading, temperature, design, work environment layout, workstation set up, furniture,
equipment and space ought to be considered. This will help staff work quiet and, in this manner,
productivity will be high. (Schuss and Palmer, 2011) expressed that color impacts the state of
mind as well as wellbeing and productivity. Color has been proposed to build effectiveness in
performance, reduce accidents and raise staff morale and give an increasingly charming
workplace. At the same time, it can aid in the wellbeing of the staff. Berry, Bowen and
Kjellstorm (2010) affirmed that temperature plays an important role in the work environment
condition, particularly how the human body tries to keep up a perfect temperature. The moderate
temperature encourages staff efficiency while high and low temperature leads to discomfort of
the staff and lessening in productivity (Jaakola, 2012). Darker (2013) cleared up that workspace
plan and the spaces among equipment and furniture directly affect staff productivity. The
presence of many staff in a little space with the equipment particularly a kitchen leads to
9
discomfort. Equipment organization, proper lighting, bright colors, appropriate temperature
levels, proper planning and design are overall basic as they improve staff productivity (Edmans,
Productivity of kitchen staff will entirely depend on comfort of the kitchen. The factors that
contribute to comfort are air quality, temperature, overall comfort, noise and lighting.
Insufficient fresh air can contribute to reduced ability to work or sometimes employees leaving
work earlier. There is need for appropriate heating ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC). The
desired environment is one that provides a safe, healthy, comfortable climate and supports the
productivity of employees. The HVAC system works by taking in outdoor air and combining
with indoor air. The restaurant kitchen should be well ventilated to let out smell of foods
prepared and smoke thus allowing staff comfort (Gyaan, 2018).The kitchen should be designed
with enough space for movement of kitchen staff from one point to another. Small kitchen will
leave staff struggling for space thus unable to provide smooth work flow (Dareker, 2016). It is
important for staff to move around with ease without bumping into each other or fixtures.
Humidity is high especially in the summer. Modification of kitchen canopies and other
ventilation means to make the place a healthy environment for working of the kitchen staff.
Design and layout have a direct effect on work environment, workers and their attitude. High
temperatures are due to narrow space of the place, the lack of arrangement of the tools and
equipment which affect the workers and raise their sense of dissatisfaction.
10
2.5.2.1 Good working conditions
Most hotels concentrate much on providing excellent facilities to their customers, but forget to
consider comfort of kitchen staff. This is one of the main reasons for high staff turnover in hotel
industry. Most tasks performed by kitchen staff require them to be on their feet always therefore
exhaustive hours and tedious nature of the job is tiresome both physically and mentally.
Therefore, creating a healthy workplace, providing proper designated places for staff will make
them have emotional and psychological support thus comfortable to work productively (Mathis,
2014).
Most hotels provide meals that are not of good quality to their staff. It may not be possible to
provide same quality of meals to staff as that provided to customers. Management should
therefore ensure that quality of staff meals is good. If the staff is well fed since no one can
perform on an empty stomach, productivity of staff will increase because their morale will be
According to Gyaan (2018), a kitchen layout and design should ensure proper circulation and
movement of staff in the restaurant. The design of the kitchen has to meet compliance guidelines
set by Safe work to ensure workplace safety for employees. There should be wide paths to keep
off staff from stumbling and harming themselves as they work. The design of the kitchen should
incorporate enough space between various workstations since a kitchen has the most extreme
number of accidents that occur because of clashes among the staff and dangerous floors.
Most restaurant kitchens force staff to stand for long periods of time in practically static
movement due to their small size. This causes distress and pain thus it is essential that restaurant
11
ergonomics are considered. Proper planning and design of a kitchen will allow well-being for the
general population who use it. A genuine ergonomic structure will minimize movement of
kitchen staff working in the kitchen, spare their time, minimize accidents and reduce food spill
outcomes. Position of doors and exits should be considered as well. To avoid collision, tension
and chaos, work zones should be created in a kitchen for maximum wellbeing. Overall, safety
and ergonomics should be considered in commercial kitchen planning and design (Shoes for
Crews, 2017).
Accidents due to poorly planned and designed kitchen are unavoidable. A poor kitchen layout
affects performance of employees (Hertzman and Barrash 2007). Though no one sets out to
create a poorly designed kitchen, a poor kitchen layout may arise due to new equipment and
supplies being added as well as new employees. This can cause employees to overstretch, stand
too long or use awkward postures in cooking. This makes working in the kitchen too difficult,
takes long in preparing meals and creates and creates an unsafe atmosphere and environment for
Regular training sessions on safety of kitchen and implementing them. This keeps staff
Kitchen staff should be well groomed and overall hygiene of the kitchen observed. Proper
hygiene will boost staff confidence and will be willing to work productively (Mathis, 2014).
Working in a poorly designed kitchen can lead to stress, respiratory problems, bodily pains and
headaches to the staff. Brick (2016), found one of the best approaches to maximize efficiency in
12
the kitchen is to design based on work stations. This can be done by use of a ‘work triangle’
which says the sink, refrigerator and store should be in triangular proximity. The concept of
kitchen work stations defines the room into five categories to maximize efficiency and minimize
staffs’ energy as they work in the kitchen. These work stations include consumable, preparation,
cooking and cleaning zone. They should be designed with specific intent and mindful use of
storage, movement and work flow zones in the space to maximize efficiency.
A well designed kitchen should be big enough for staff to cook, prepare and move about without
danger. Dareker (2016), explains that kitchen environments are in every case quick paced and
require the most extreme effectiveness. Improving production and staff effectiveness begins with
the planning and design of the kitchen. An ergonomically structured business kitchen is where
staff can remain in one spot and does most of their work with minimal bending, strolling or
turning therefore in this manner ergonomics can reduce injuries, discomfort and fatigue in the
kitchen
Incentive programs helps in motivating staff and keeping them happy and productive. Incentives
and recognition help to encourage staff to perform better in their workplace. For example, the
kitchen staff can be motivated through incentive programs such as “star chef”, or “staff of the
month” etc. thus this will not only encourage staff but will likewise boost their morale at work
(Lieberman, 2018).
13
2.7.2 Fixed shifts and overtime policy
Fixed shift and overtime policy should be there to ensure staff rest between shifts since
overworked and tired staff will not be productive at their workplace. It is important to
compensate staff for the extra effort they give in their work to avoid dissatisfaction among them.
This will not only encourage them but will likewise boost their performance as they will work an
Comfort
Good working
Kitchen planning and design
condition
Safety
Regular training
Proper hygiene
14
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.0 Introduction
The objectives of the research proposal are to determine the effects of kitchen design and layout
on kitchen staff production. The methodology comprises of research design, location of the
study, the target population, research instruments, validity and reliability of the research
instruments, data collection procedure, data analysis procedures as well as ethical considerations.
The chapter outlines the research methodology that will be used for the study.
It is a plan for fulfilling objectives and responding to questionnaires. It constitutes the outline
that maps how research data will be gathered, estimated and examined (Cooper and Schindler,
2014). The study will take on a descriptive design since the research will involve surveys, a case
study of the effects of kitchen design and layout on kitchen staff productivity in Nakuru Town.
The research will be carried out in Nakuru town, located in Nakuru County. Nakuru town is
highly developed and contributes a higher percentage to the hospitality industry. It consists of a
good number of well-established hotels tourist attraction sites that play a big part in generating
The study targets a total of 35 respondents which will comprise of two managers and five kitchen
staff members from each hotel. This makes the target population for the study and will help
15
Respondents Total Percentage
Staff 25 71.43%
Total 35 100%
Merica Hotel 4 2 16 5
Hotel Kunste 3 2 13 5
Seravic Hotel 4 2 15 5
Total 19 10 76 25
Interviews: This method will be used to gather information from the hotel managers and the
staff. A number of them will be interviewed. Questionnaires: they will be issued to hotel
managers and kitchen staff in the different hotels to determine how kitchen design and layout
16
3.5.1 Validity of the instrument
Content validity will be used to check the representation of research questions in the
questionnaires. The items found inadequate will be discarded while others will be modified. The
researcher will also seek assistance from the supervisor in order to help improve validity of the
instrument.
Ability of the instrument to produce same results in a different geographical location or when
giving consistent results after several trials. A pilot study is done prior to the actual study to be
The study will employ descriptive analysis to analyze the data obtained. Data from the field will
be collected, coded and recorded. The questionnaires will be coded and analyzed. The data will
be organized and presented in form of tables, figures and pie- figures. This will enable the
3.7Ethical considerations
This study will be guided by the principles of voluntariness, anonymity, no harm, and gratitude,
as respondent’s safety will be guaranteed, and their consent sought, and is thanked for their
responses.
17
3.8: Research work plan.
Research
proposal
writing and
submission
Data
collection
Data entry
Data testing
and
verification
Data
analysis and
processing
Project
writing
Project
submission
18
3.9: Budget
of questionnaires
19
REFERENCES.
Freeman, J., & Freeman, J. (2004). The making of the modern kitchen: A cultural history. Berg
Publishers.
Fujii, N., Kaihara, T., Uemura, M., Nonaka, T., & Shimmura, T. (2013, September). Facility
layout planning of central kitchen in food service industry: application to the real-scale problem.
Gutnick, L. (2007). A workplace design that reduces employee stress and increases employee
Hagan, J. A., Kwofie, A. S., & Baissie, F. (2017). Assessing the effect of kitchen layout on
9229), 3(1), 36-45.
Hertzman, J., & Barrash, D. (2007). An assessment of food safety knowledge and practices of
Jaakkola, J. J. (1998). The office environment model: a conceptual analysis of the sick building
Mathis, T. L. (2014). Safety drivers: The first level of leading indicators. EHS Today.
Pehkonen, I., Takala, E. P., Ketola, R., Viikari-Juntura, E., Leino-Arjas, P., Hopsu, L., ... &
Rodgers, S. (2007). Innovation in food service technology and its strategic role. International
20
Schloss, K. B., & Palmer, S. E. (2011). Aesthetic response to color combinations: preference,
Elbert, K. K., Kroemer, H. B., & Hoffman, A. D. K. (2018). Ergonomics: how to design for ease
21
APPENDICES
Questionnaires
Introduction
productivity. Kindly provide the answers to the following questions precisely and honestly. Your
SECTION A
Kindly react to the following questions by ticking in the suitable box (✓)
Male ( ) Female ( )
High school ( )
College ( )
University ( )
Other ( )
22
4. How long have you been working in your hotel?
1-3 years ( )
3-5 years ( )
5-10 years ( )
SECTION B
1. Depending with the design of the kitchen is this related to the question you are asking as far
as the respondent is concerned? May be the design issue should be separate, either to be filed
in by the respondent or researcher observes and fills in the questionnaire, what kind of
2. Which factors does your kitchen environment ensure are considered for staff productivity?
3. How is the plan/arrangement of your kitchen where you perform your tasks? Here it is…. So
for qn 1, just ask the question and remove the issue of design…
One-wall plan
Corridor plan
L-shape plan
U-shape plan
4. What are the main causes for delays in preparation of guest meals?
Fatigue
23
Poor layout of the kitchen
Inadequate lighting
SECTION C
Poor layout
Ignorance
Poor lighting
6. At your facility are you often given a chance to make suggestions about your workplace
Yes
No
7. What are some of the effects of a kitchen that is poorly planned and designed to kitchen staff?
Accidents
Fatigue
Turnover
Poor productivity
8. What type of hazards do you encounter when carrying out your duties?
24
Ergonomic
Physical
Psychological
Chemical
Biological
SECTION D
Weekly
Monthly
Yearly
Not at all
Yes
No
Fatigue
Sickness
Family matters
Back pain
Headache
Shoulder pain
25
Waist pain
Others (specify)………………………………………………….
26