Professional Documents
Culture Documents
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11665-021-06437-1 1059-9495/$19.00
Tara tannin is studied as an inhibitor of aluminum corrosion, immersed in an aerated and near-neutral
NaCl solution and in a wash-primer formulation. Electrochemical tests prove that tara tannins provide
good corrosion resistance for aluminum, and scanning electron microscopy coupled to energy dispersive x-
ray spectroscopy shows a low formation of corrosion products, absence of Cl and presence of C. These
results indicate that tannins act as a mixed-type inhibitor without changing the mechanism of oxygen or
aluminum reactions, and that tannin is adsorbed on aluminum surfaces forming a compact hydrophobic
barrier that blocks anodic and cathodic areas. A tara tannin primer was formulated and applied on
aluminum. Its anticorrosive properties were studied by electrochemical techniques and humidity chamber
testing, in which it exhibited an acceptable performance compared with a zinc tetroxychromate primer.
Taking into account their less harmful environmental impact, tara tannins are proposed as an alternative to
chromates in the formulation of wash-primers.
rod of 0.28 cm2 exposed area as a working electrode, a Pt isopropyl alcohol, water and phosphoric acid, the last one being
electrode as a counter electrode and an SCE as reference. The essential to provide good adhesion to the substrate. The volume
experiments were performed after 5 and 24 h of immersion, percentages of the components used in the formulation of each
selecting a scan range of ± 20 mV from the open circuit pack are detailed in the Supporting Information section,
potential and a scan rate of 0.25 mV s1. The corrosion current Table S1, and the primers preparation procedure is summarized
density (Ic) was calculated using Gamry Echem Analyst in Figure S1. Pigment volume concentration (PVC) values were
Version 6.33 software. Inhibitory efficiency (IE) was calculated kept constant to allow for the comparison of the three primers.
according to the following Eq (1): A commercial AA1050 sheet with 1 mm thickness was cut into
coupons with dimensions of 75 mm x 75 mm. The AA1050
IE(% ) ¼ 100 ðI0 IÞ=I0 ðEq 1Þ
coupons were degreased by brushing them vigorously with
wherein I0 indicates the Ic of the aluminum immersed in the isopropyl alcohol and were left to dry at 20 ± 2 C and 70 ±
blank solution, while I is the Ic of the aluminum immersed in 5% relative humidity. In each coupon a thin primer layer was
each tannin solution at the same time of exposure. applied, by brush, up to a dry film thickness of 10 ± 2 lm (5
Polarization curves were performed after 5 and 24 h of coupons per primer). The film thickness was measured with a
immersion through a cell similar to the cell described above, Schwyz SC117-02 Coating Thickness Gauge. The coated
using a potential scan range of ± 250 mV from the open circuit coupons (called T40, CR or TAL, according to the primer used)
potential and a scan rate of 1 mV s1. From each curve the were then allowed to cure for 5 days at 20 ± 2 C and 70 ± 5%
corrosion potential (Ec), the corrosion current density (Ic) and relative humidity. The coated coupons were tested together with
the cathodic and anodic slopes were obtained by means of the a series of degreased coupons not subjected to any painting
classic Tafel extrapolation method. In E-log I curves, Tafel treatment (blank coupons, B). The edges of the coupons were
extrapolation was done employing the least-squares approxi- protected with blue vinyl duct tape (Brand 3M, model 3903).
mation method in the cathodic and anodic branches, taking into
account that at Ic = 0, both lines must intersect. 2.4 Evaluation of the Coated Coupons
2.2.4 Study of the Exposed Surface 2.4.1 Electrochemical Evaluation. The coated coupons
by SEM-EDS. AA1050 rods of 1.33 cm2 exposed areas were electrochemically characterized by open circuit potential
were immersed in 0.05 and 0.5 % solutions for 5 h and for (EOCP) measurements, conductivity measurements to determine
24 h. Once that period elapsed, the electrode was rinsed with ionic resistance (Ri), and by linear polarization tests to
distilled water and left to dry at 20 ± 2 C and 70 ± 5% determine polarization resistance (Rp). The electrochemical
relative humidity. Then, the immersed end of the rod was sawed tests were performed in cells constructed by delimiting a
off and the characteristics of the exposed surface were studied circular area of 3 cm2 on the coated surface using a polyvinyl
by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Likewise, its compo- chloride tube. Each tube was adhered to the panel with epoxy
sition was determined by means of energy dispersive X-ray type glue and then sealed with beeswax on the outside. Finally,
spectroscopy (EDS). The equipment used was a Philips SEM a defined volume of 0.1 M NaCl was added as electrolyte. For
505 microscope and an EDAX DX PRIME 10 energy each type of coated coupons, the determinations were carried
dispersive micro-analyzer. out in triplicates after different times of exposure to the chloride
solution.
2.3 Formulation, Preparation and Application The EOCP measurements were performed with a Gamry
of an Anticorrosive Primer Interface 1000 instrument, and an SCE was used as reference.
A primer based on T40 extract (T40 primer) was developed Ionic resistance between the coated substrate and a Pt
and its anticorrosive efficiency was compared to a primer electrode was calculated through conductivity (Ci) measure-
containing zinc tetroxychromate (provided by Société Nouvelle ments with an ATI Orion Model 170 conductivity meter at
des Couleurs Zinciques) as anticorrosive pigment (CR primer) 1000 Hz, according to the following Eq (2):
and with another in which the anticorrosive pigment was RiðX cm2 Þ ¼ ½1=CiðlSÞ 3 cm2 106 ðEq 2Þ
replaced by talc (TAL primer). The primers were formulated as
a two- pack system, A and B, which were stored separately and Linear polarization tests (without IR compensation) were
mixed (4 parts of A and 1 part of B, by weight), before carried out with a Gamry Interface 1000 potentiostat-galvanos-
application. Pack A contained the anticorrosive pigment (tara tat, employing a typical three-electrode cell, with a Pt counter
extract or zinc tetroxychromate), the filler (talc), the prime electrode and SCE as reference. The selected scan range was of
pigment (carbon black), the resin (film-forming material, in this ± 20 mV from the open circuit potential, and the scan rate was
case Butvar B-76, a thermoplastic polyvinyl butyral resin), of 1 mV s1. Polarization resistance (Rp) was calculated using
the organic solvents to adjust the viscosity (isopropyl alcohol the Gamry Echem Analyst Version 6.33 software. The employ-
and n-butyl alcohol) and water. The components of pack A ment of this technique was justified by the low ionic resistance
were dispersed in a 1 L ball mill for 24 h to achieve a of the primer film (Ref 46, 47).
dispersion degree of 5 in the Hegmans gage. Pack B contained
No appreciable attack (N) There is no appreciable attack; the surface may be discolored
Pitting (P) Discrete pits
Filiform (F) Appearance of corrosion filaments
General (G) Fairly uniform corrosion with accumulation of dusty corrosion products
Exfoliation (E) Visible separation of metal in layers
extract can be seen in Fig. 4. Only selected concentrations were destabilization of the oxide film by Cl– would occur as follows:
studied as the results in the previous assays were similar. For a (i) in near-neutral solutions the oxide/solution interface (an
better visualization, log I is represented as a function of the oxyhydroxide type material) has a net positive charge and so
overpotential g, which was calculated as the difference between chloride anions are electrostatically attracted to the surface; (ii)
the working electrode potential E and the corrosion potential Ec Cl– is adsorbed on the oxide surface; (iii) Cl– is incorporated
obtained by the extrapolation method: into the bulk of the oxide; (iv) Cl– moves into the oxide film;
(v) weakening the Al-O bonds and forming soluble aluminum
g ¼ EEc ðEq 3Þ
chloride (Al-Cl) and oxychloride (O-Al-Cl) complexes; (vi) the
Taking as reference the 0.1 M NaCl solution without extract oxide film becomes thinner and breaks down; (vii) localized
(blank solution), the current density decreases in both cathodic Cl-assisted dissolution of aluminum at the metal/oxide
and anodic branches, with a more marked effect on the 0.5 % interface in consecutive one-electron transfer reactions takes
solution. This mixed inhibition is consistent with the mecha- place; (viii) and blisters, cracks and pits are formed (Fig. 5a).
nism of adsorption and film formation that is characteristic of In near-neutral aerated solutions, the cathodic reaction is
many organic inhibitors, where a compact hydrophobic barrier dominated by the diffusion and the reduction of dissolved
is formed on the surface, blocking anodic and cathodic areas oxygen (Ref 69, 71). The presence of the organic film restricts
(Ref 63, 64). The efficiency of these organic inhibitors has been the diffusion of oxygen and, in consequence, slows down the
associated with the presence of heteroatoms (N, S, O and P) or cathodic reaction. According to Fig. 4, this restriction is more
p-electrons, which serve as adsorption centers. Tannin effective in the more concentrated tannin solution.
molecules can retard corrosion reactions by adsorbing on metal In tara extract solutions, tannin molecules are adsorbed and
surfaces (Ref 65). Several authors (Ref 39, 40) have pointed out form a stable organic layer onto aluminum, which interferes
that the adsorption of tannin molecules may occur via the high with both the adsorption of Cl– ions and the diffusion of Al (III)
electronic densities of the oxygen lone pairs in hydroxyl groups soluble complexes from the oxide surface to the bulk solution
and of the p-system of the aromatic rings, forming an (Ref 32). In addition, the adsorption of tannin molecules on the
adsorption layer on the metal surface. aluminum surface removes or depletes some of the water
In NaCl solutions, the anodic reaction is the dissolution of molecules originally adsorbed onto the surface, which blocks
aluminum catalyzed by Cl– ions (Ref 66). The aluminum the formation of hydrated/hydroxylated intermediate species
dissolution is an activation-controlled process. However, at during the aluminum dissolution (Ref 64). Consequently, the
high anodic overpotential, a limit diffusion current appears due tannin addition inhibits the anodic metal dissolution reaction,
to the transport of chloride ions from the solution to the metal and corrosion is retarded (Fig. 5b). Again, this inhibitory effect
surface through the oxide film. Chloride ions play a crucial role is more marked in the more concentrated tannin solution.
in the anodic dissolution process of aluminum. These anions Figure 6 shows the potentiodynamic polarization curves for
not only compensate the charge of the Al3+ cations generated in AA1050 samples immersed for 24 h in 0.1 M NaCl solutions
the anodic reaction, but they also actively intervene in a process with 0, 0.05 and 0.5% tara tannin extract. It can be observed
of destabilization of the oxide passive film that leads to pitting. that after 24 h of immersion the 0.05% extract addition has
According to the literature (Ref 13, 67-70), the mechanism of almost no effect on the cathodic process but still reduces the
1445
1540
1610
1317
1700
1089
1195
757
869
Table 4 Corrosion current density and inhibition efficiency obtained from the linear polarization experiments (mean
value ± SD)
Ic (lA/cm2) IE (%)
Time (h) Time (h)
T40 extract concentration (%w/v) 5 24 5 24
0 61±1 43 ± 2
0.01 2.9 ± 0.6 8.3 ± 2.0 95 ±2 81 ± 3
0.05 2.4 ± 0.6 8.3 ± 2.0 96 ±2 81 ± 3
0.10 3.1 ± 0.2 7.0 ± 1.0 95 ±2 84 ± 3
0.30 2.8 ± 0.6 5.1 ± 1.0 95 ±2 88 ± 3
0.50 2.3 ± 0.6 1.5 ± 0.3 96 ±2 97 ± 3
Incipient pits and fine particles with colloidal dimensions that demonstrated the presence of C and lack of chlorine, indicating
show a strong tendency toward agglomeration can also be the high blocking capacity of the organic layer.
observed. EDS analysis demonstrated the presence of chlorine Figure 8(a)-(c) and Table 6 show SEM micrographs of the
on the surface, indicating the existence of chloride anions either aluminum samples exposed surfaces after 24 h of immersion in
adsorbed or incorporated into the structure of the oxide film the tested solutions and their respective compositions as
(Fig. 5a). In the AA1050 immersed in 0.05% tannin solution determined by EDS analysis. In the sample immersed in the
(Fig. 7c), SEM examination revealed the presence of small NaCl solution without tannin addition (Fig. 8a), the presence of
amounts of corrosion products, but the sanding scratches were pits, cracks and a large accumulation of corrosion products with
still clearly visible. The EDS analysis shows that the surface globular structure can be observed. EDS analysis reveals again
had a higher Al/O ratio (7.2) compared to the one immersed in a low Al/O ratio (2.5) and the presence of chlorine on the
the blank solution, indicating a smaller amount of corrosion surface. SEM images of the aluminum samples immersed for
products, due to the lower corrosion rate in the presence of 24 h in both NaCl solutions with tara extract (Fig. 8b and c,
tannins. Moreover, the presence of C was detected, indicating 0.05% and 0.5%, respectively) show the presence of incipient
the formation of a protective film of an organic nature. Finally, pits, cracks and some areas covered with corrosion products.
no chlorine was present within EDS resolution limits, indicat- EDS analysis reveals the presence of C and the absence of
ing that a high blocking capacity of chloride adsorption can be chlorine, indicating the formation of organic films that retain
achieved by this protective layer. their inhibitory action on chloride adsorption after a 24 h
The micrographs of the aluminum sample immersed in the exposure, which is in agreement with that suggested previously
0.5 % tannin solution (Fig. 7d) show a more homogeneous in the potentiodynamic polarization curves. Finally, it can be
surface, with hardly any presence of corrosion products and verified that the Al/O ratio is also high for the samples
with the sanding scratches partially covered. The Al/O ratio immersed in the tannin solutions (with a slightly higher value
(6.8) is also higher than the one immersed in the blank solution, for the more concentrated solution), indicating less formation of
and similar to that of the 0.05% tannin solution. EDS analysis
Fig. 10 Ionic resistance values (Ri) as a function of time for coated coupons
Table 7 Adhesion grade and visual evaluation results of the coated coupons after different exposure times in the
humidity chamber
Adhesion grade (ASTM D 3359)* Classification of corrosion**
Time (days) Time (days)
Coated coupons 0 4 8 14 4 8 14
B … … … … G G G
T40 4B 3B 2B 2B N N N
CR 4B 3B 2B 2B N N N
TAL 4B 0B 0B 0B N P G
*5B: 0% area removed 4B: 0-5% 3B: 5-15% 2B: 15-35% 1B: 35-65% 0B: >65%
**N: No appreciable attack; P: Pitting; F: Filiform; G: General; E: Exfoliation