You are on page 1of 23

!

" # $

% ! #

& % ! #' ( % !

! ! " # $%&' # (
) * + ! * *
* , - . / 0 - $%&'1
2 ! 3 ! ,
* * /( 3 * 0+ ) * # 0 $4 5 # $%&'1
3 * * /(5
0+ + $%0 $%&61 , * # 0
* 7 # 0! 8 - , $%&90

* ! , # & ! , ! $9 /910 $%&40 4'9:499 -


, , - , , * * *

* #, # 0; . 0 . 0 ! .# 0 <
. 80 - ; 0 = 0"* = 2 0> #0 - 0 ( *0+ !
* , (- . +/ * #. 0 0 8 ! 20 2
? , 10 # 0 * 0 , * * ! *
* , # @ * 0 #0
* * * 0 # * # ! #
* 0 * 0 ,

Reprinted with permission of Springer.


2 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

* # & ! , ! $9/910 $%&40


! * # @ , 0 0 0 * 0
8 ! 2 2 A ? , 0 # #
/(B . - * +1 * ! C # 0
, 0 3 . / ! / , 0 $%%'10 % 0
, 1 /A 2 A 0 0 0 $%&D01 2 0 /64E6D0 $%&&1

* 2 2 * / @
1 *# B7 / 5 * 1 * *
* # * ! 0 * # ,
* * # * *
* # , ! *
- ? 0 2 # 3
# # *
* 0! , * , ,
#0 *# * 0 *# : * * 0
* 0 * *
* ? ! # ! 0 *
* 0 * # # ,
0 0! ! * ,
, 0 , , 0
(! 2 , * +0 # 0 * *
# * # # ! $ 0 , !
! # 0!
# # * ! " 3 ! !
,, 8 0 ! ! * *
! * ,, 2 * A , !
, ! # * * # * * ! *
# @ ! # * * *
* * , , #
C * # 2 # 2
! * #* * ), 0 # 2
, 0 ! 2 * * * # ! * #
0 ! * * *
! , * , F? C
$ * * * !: ! * ! : 0 # 0 # * #
! ! ! , ! / 1
van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism 3

* ! G @ !
2 C ! *2 * ,* # 0 *
! 0 ! * #0 ! * *
* ? # # : # * :! #
! , , * # *
* * #! 2 ! : # :!
# , , * * #
* # ** @ # , , ,
* * # * # , 0
* 0 * 3 * * * 0 ! 5
! * # , # ! ! 2
* * * #* 0 0 ! , ,
* 0 7 , : * 0! !
, ! : #
, , * ! * 0
0 0 0

5 " 0 ( * + 0
# 0 * *
( * + * ! " * ! , *
3 # & 4 & + 5 * # ! * ! 2
* * # ! * : ! * #
* * # * ! ! , *
0 # ** , * ( * ** ,
+ ( 0+ 0 , ,
* 0 * * 8 3 # & 4 & + 5 6
# * (5 * ** , 0 *
** , + : ! * * *
* ! # /$1 # 3 * C # 0
/G1 * 3 # / #
1 * ' - * 0 0 ( +

G - /$%&90 - * 91 /$%&D0 - * 41 * !
' (* 0+ 0 * * ! * #
! 2 0 0 ( * + @ * * ! * * #
* # ! )! ! * 0 ! 0 2 * ! !
* 0 * # * ! ( ** ,
4 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

: ! 2 ! * * : !
* 0 0 ( + : *
* , # !
? # ! * F ? # * 3 ! ,
* F ! ! C A
* , ! * )!
* 0 , 0 , 0 &0
* * C * !
* * * * #) ! *
* ! 2 *
* ! * * * @ ! *
* * ! ) /$1 # *
E * #0 /G1 *
# * #* 0 # * * !
* # ! @ ! 0 !
0 * ! * # *

A # ! / * *1 * *
, 0 0 * * * 7 2 ,
* ! 2 # # ! *
* * # 2 5 2 , 0
! 0 * , *
* , * ! # * , * 0
* C / 0 0 ! *
* # ! , 1 0 2
* # ! * *
! , * 0 " * 3 #
& 4 & + 5 * * ** , :
! ! 2
* * * * !
, * * * ** ,
7H7 ** , * 6 , ,

+ * # ,* * ( +
(* +
6 5 * * 0 /$%&61
van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism 5

C ! , #
, * * 0 ! 2 * ,# #
* ! 0 ! / *0 0 , 0
0 , #0 2 1 * 0 ! #
, C ! 29 " 0
* ! 20 , 8 0 * !
* * ! 0! 0
! * # * # ? 20
" 3 0* * ( 3 ! +4
@# * , , : ! 2
! , ! 2: * #
# ! # 0 #
2 * #
0 / 1 ! 2 ! ,
, ! , # * *
* , 0 0 ! *
* ,*

! " #

, * , 0 #
, * * # 5 " # 0 , ! *
* / * !1 # *
* 2 * " * #0 * #, !
* : 2 , ,
* ** : 2
C # ! 20 * *
* * * ,
* D

9 - /$%&$1 ! 2 # / * 0
* 0 0 * 10 C ! #
4 B ,- 3 ,#0 * * # * #0 ! * * 0 * #
, * / # ! ! 21 #
( # #+ /, , ! , 3 * 1 (* + / ,
* 3 * 1 - - /$%D%10 - * 6 ; ! 0 # * ,
, # * # C 5 *
# # *
D ! 0 ! # ! * * !
* #0 * * * ** , 0
0* , # / 0 $%&91
6 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

C 0 0 ! * # , ! 0
0 * : * # :
! * * * , * #
, ! " * , *
$&9% 3 , 0 ,
* * # * ) *
* # , ! ! !
* ! * , 0 0 * ! *
* 8 0! * * * * 20
* #* * ! 8 * # :!
* ! ,:! 8
C * # / ( , +1 * # / (
* +1 * - * C
* # * * / * 1 ,/ *1
0 ** , * 0 * C 0! *
C * * # ,
* 3 * 0 # * 0! , * 0
# # ! 2 3! , 0 ! , * 0 *
# * # ! , ! 2 ! 0
# * # , ! 2 ; *
* C ! * * # !
* * * , #
#* * " 3 #0 * ( ,+
* * ! #0 !0 *
* " , ,
* * / * 1
* * , * , * 0 ** , *
0 * * * # * &

, ! 0 ! 0 * * # *
* C 8 * # 0 *
* ! * 0 0 *

& 5 * * * * ( ,0+ * * ! 7 ,
7 ,0 . /$%&' 1 - " , 2 " 3 ! 2 *
/ * #1 * , / # , 1 * *
* , * @ * # # /
0 $%&IJ $%&'1 " 0 , ! C # # * * :
0 " 3 * , * ! * *) *
* 7 * C * 0 , **
* ! ** ! # *
* * * , , 0 #0 ! 0 / $%%90 * 41
van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism 7

# # * * * * 0 ! *
* C * # 2 ,
* * , " 0 ! # * 0
* , * C * ! # 8 * #!
# # * * 0 8 #
* * , ! 2 , / !
* , * 0 * , #
F1 # ! * * , * C
8 2 * # *
! ,
- # # K ! * # !
, # 7 * C # 0 C 0
! * # * #0 * ! * #
0 2 # # 0# ! ! # *2
# ( * + ! # " 0 #
8 /! * 2 1
, * C / * 7
* ( # +10 * ! 8
* # # * * * * *
** * 8 0 0 , !
* * * ?
,* 0 * ,! *
* # , , ! ,
* * * , /; !
, ! , **
* 1 ,0 * , * * *
! 0 #* #0 * 8
C #0 * ,
* 0 , * ( ,+ * * * * * *
7 8 ,* %

0 * * , * 3 #
* ! " 0 * * #
* , , A 0 , * 2
* , * ! , *
* * # * , 0 # * 0

% # ? 8 L*2 - /$%D$1J - /$%D'J $%&G1 5


, * * " ! * ! *
* 0 /$%&'1J /$%&90 - * 'GG 9 $ '1
8 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

# 0 , ! * #
! 2 ! # 0 *
! 2 ( * + 2 #*
8 * * * 0
0 * ! # * , 0
* 2# * FA * 0* *
, C # ! 2 ! 0
! ** , 0 * * #!
* * , ! , @ !
#0 2 # * , & * * * *
, #

$ % &

@ * , * , , * C * 0
# * *2 * ,
! 2 ! * #*
* * ) *
/ #1 * * ,
* # , * 0 ! # ,
* # , * # , !
* #
@ 0 ! * ! # # , * ,
* ) * ! # , , ! 0
! 0 0 * 0
0 ! # / 1 *
A # * * 0
0 * * # * ! #
# * # * * * 0
* #! 8 * #*
* , 0
* * * * * 2 #
* * 0 0 # ! *
* 0 * * , * ! *
! !
* * * #
/$1 # * * 0 /G1
* * * , * * * #
van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism 9

** ! , *2 * #
0 ! *
* * $I * 0 ! 0! ! *2
# " ! 2 " 0C *
* * ! 0 0 * # ? # 0
! , * 0 ! # * *
0 ! * # * *
* ? 2 *
* 0 ! C ! *
* , *

' ( ) ! "

* # # * *
, # ! * 0 * 0
* @ * * #
( * * +! * * # , *
# * * * 0 * ! 0 ,
! ( * * +
- * ! , # * * *
! * 5 0 , ( * * + #
* ! ! 2 ! 20 , #
* ! # * * * A #
! #* ! 20 *
# * 0
! @ #3 * # 0 , 0 # .
7= 0 < . 80 " 7 > $$ * * 0
: ! , ! 2:
( * * 0+ * , 8 * *
! ** ,
A 0 ! 0 , , , * )
* * ! * * # * 0
0 ! # ! * * !
* # 7 5 # &
## :! * , # ! # ! * * * * # * #! 2
* * * * ! #

$I - /$%&6J $%%90 * 91J /$%&D1


$$ - 7= /$%D%10 . 8 /$%&'J $%&910 > /$%&61
10 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

0 ! * * 0
5 0 ! * # * ,
, * / , * 1: * #
@ $G * # * * , ! ,
, ? $'

* ! 0 2 # *
( * * + * /* 1
* 0 # ** , * 0
# # * #/ # * ,* 0 *2
! * 0 * * 1
(, * + 0!
* 0 *
(, * + /! , * ,#0 *2 0
* 10 ! * * ! *
* # $6 0 *
* C * * ! ! # )
! ! *2 *
0 ,! # * ,

* + , - . /

2 # 7* 5 :! # #
* * , *
: # , 8 ! ( + #
! , ) ! ** / ! *
2 0 , ,1 , * 0 *
** , ! * , * # ! !
! ! 2 ,/ * * * 0 ! 20
*1 , 0 * C * ! ! * @
2 7 , * * , , 0
* * ! 2 * # * 2
, ! , 0 7* # " 0 *
, * , , ! 7 ! 2
! # , * A * 0
, , * 0 ,
$G /$%$&0 &$1
$' - 0 0 /$%D'J $%&90 '1J 2 /$%D%1J /$%&G1J " /$%&'1J # /$%&61 5
# * * 0 @ , /$%&90 G1
$6 A - C * * !
van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism 11

* , # 0 3 * * *
! 2 , / 2 (! +1 ! 2 , / ( , +
3 ! 21 ! 2 7 , * 0
0! * ! ! * ! 2
! ! # " 0 ! #
* # 2 ,0 * C !
2 ,
0 0, * 2 5 0
* # ! # * 8 0 , @ *
* 8 , , ! *
* 0 # , * # # ! 20
! ! # ! #
, 2 / * 7 ! 20
* # ! , 0 * # , 0 * 10
, ! 2 # *
! # ! C #0 , * 2 0
, ! , , * ! ! 2 !
! * " 0 ! : !
* # : ! , * * * # 0
* 0 * (* +/ , 10
*0 ! , # ! ( + $9

0 + 1 " - . /

C #0 * * ! * * #0
#! # , * , *
, 8 * * *
" 8 , , *
* ! 3 ! 72 ! ( * * +)
! , * C C
, : ! * 0 * 2 0
, : ! $4 - *
, ! # * , C # * *# #
* # $D @ * * ! " *
, 0 ! * 0 0
$9 > < /$%&91
$4 - ! /$%DG0 - * $'1
$D - 0 0 /$%&90 G'I10 ! , ! 3 * *
* * * ** ,
12 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

, * 8
* ! ! * * * *
3 * 0 ! * , *
* *
A * 0! * ,#0 *
0 * 0 ! # ( +
, / * 1 $II * * * 0 0
, * # * @
! 0 2 0 , * * #
* 0 * 8 * *0 *
* / ! C , 1! , *
C #0 " * * * #
, * 8 * #3
* ** , ) ,
, 0 0 * * * 3
> * * * , 0 * *
2 ** 0 * ! 2 , ,0 *
* @ # *
( * + ! 2 * , * *
# * # 3 * # /
* 0 ! * 2 * ** 1
* 0 , * * !
* * #0 ! ( * + *
, * #
! , # ! $&

? * * * * # ,
2 * , C
* @ ! # * *
! 2 * ) # * , *
, : , * # 2 7
, * : ! * *
A * 0 * * 0 * * /! (
+F10 * # # *

$& , 2 - /$%&G1 , * *
* ! * * 0! * /$%&' 1 *
B ! 2 * 0 # , / #1 # ! 20 #
* * 2 / 1 B ,
* 0 * , ) # # ! 20
, , /* * 1
van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism 13

* 2 2
, * * , , 0 ! ! *
! ,C * *
* * 0 ! 0 * ,#0 *2 0
* * 0 * * * 0
# ! , * *
( +! , * # ! !
; ! * # * * , * F
* ! C ! # C * #
! # , ! * / * * 0
, 10 ! # ! ** , , 0
! * ! * * 0
#, 0 ! 0 * * , *
, * * * 3 , * !
* # * @ ! ! * * #
* / 0 # 0
*1 ! * # 5 ! 2 3
* , ! #
! , * 0 ! , ! 2 /! * !
* ** 1 , ! 5 ! ,
* 0 * # ! ,! 2/ * *
#! #0 * ! ** , 7C # ! ,
* 1 C #0 * ,* ! 0 *
#0 * * , 8 * ,
C # ! 2 # * , # C
*
, ! * # * ,
* # ! ! * #
* # * ? , #0 #0
C * , * *0
** , ** , * 0! * ,
, ? !
, ! * # 0 ! 0 !
! # 8 , * * ,
! * , * / * # * #1
, ! , ! , * #
* ! * * # * , ,
/ # * , # ! 1
14 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

* , 0 * * ! # !
*

2 , && 3 1 ! 1 4

( * + #7 * * ! *
/ , 1 * * , , * *
* # $% 5 , * ,#0 , *
! * 0 , / 1 * 0 * *
* /* C #1
* * , * / 1 A
0 * 0! * , # * #
0 * * / 2 , 1 !
* , 0 *
* 0 ! 0 * / * 1
! 2 , #* / 0 * / * 1
* 0 * * # ! ! *
0 * 2 * # * 0 # #
7 # * 0 * /! , 1 #
* ! / #0 * * 1
*# , , * , #* ,
# * * ) *
$ 8 * / * 1 *
, * , /(5 &*
$ 1J
G 8 , / $ 1J
' 8 , /
* 1:! * 0 0 8 ,
: * !
, /(. / $ 1J
6 8 C #0 # ,
* *0 * , / * # ,1
* , !
/ 3 !* $ 1

$% * * * # * , 0
* * *2 *
van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism 15

** ! * /61 * # !
! ** ! * /G1 /'1 5
* * * # ! #0 0 0
, 0 * * , # * #
, * ! #
, * * 0 8 ,
C # /* /611 ! * * # C 8 ,
! * 2 * /* /'11 0
* ,# * #* , 0! *
* # * : 0 * # #
* #/ C # 1 *
, * * * #
, 0 8 , C # /* /611
* * # C 8 , # /* /G11 A
* , * * , 5, $

5 + 6 "" . - . /

K * * #3 * * .
* * # / # 1
* * ! * ! * ,
! #" , ,
# , / 0! " C .1
I $II * 0 ! 2 3 * # *
! * # I0 / , , * C * 1
* * K! * ,#
* / # * .10 *
* , *
* * , , , * /
*1 * 0
8 * * / * *1
* ! * 0 * *
.0 ! # !0
* ! * *) ! ,
" * 0 , .!
I # , 0 ! 0 *
* ! *0 . ! $II
* ! ! I $II * 0 * *
16 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

! * # * ." 0 2
*
5, $ * * ! 2
, * C
* # 3 * 0 , 0
#" * * /'1) ,*
, 0 , , 8
* # 3 K , 2 *
* * * 2 , ! !
! 0 C # ? * /'1 , 0
! 0 ( +! *
! , , ! ! C #
@# C , 8 *
* 0* /'1 ! 20 * ! 20
* , * ! 0
, , ! 2 , #
, , C # ! 2 * # /
* 1, ! / 5 , G10 * , # ,
* 0 0 0 # * ,
, 2 ! ,
* , 2 * , *
* , 0 / 1 *
, , # 2 :
! * * * /'1 : ! 2 , # 2
, ! , C # ! 22 , 0 *
* , ! 2) # ! 2 *
, ! 2 GI

GI5 * , ! ( ( . 8 /$%&I0 $6G:$991J


/$%&90 - * G1
van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism 17

K * *
K3 * *
. ,, , ,
.M .* , # 3 *
." .

/$1 , ! 7 *
/G1 ! *
/'1 " *
/61 C #7 *

,4 7 " 6 "" .
18 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

K$0 KG * * $0 G
.$0 .G ,, , , $0 G
.M .* , # 3 *

/$1 , ! 7 *
/G1 ! *
/'1 " *

,4 7! # 8 & . .
van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism 19

C #0 " * /'1 ** 0 , !
0 # 0 ! # - *
G$ * *
! / #0 # * * (
, ! +1 * # * * . * #
* * * ! , /
0 5, G ! 1 * * * #
C # , * # , /?
, # *2 ! ! #
0 , # * F1 / , 1
, ! * 0 0 2 #*
** " * * , 0 * 0 C !
! ) (5 * ** , 0
* ** , N+

, 81 8 / 9

- 0 # ! (" + * /'1 #
* 5 0 # 0 * * * /'1 #
5 , ( + #
* , * #3 ! * * 0
7 * 0 0 ! 20 * ,
, * ! # ) *
7 , *2 7 # * # 2 #
, , ( + * , # ,
, # , * #2 ! 2 , 0
0 * # * , ! ( +
0 0 * ! , ! C
, C # # * * /61 @
! # : , # " :
0 0! #
* C 0 * # 3
* #! #
* , , , * /'1
# * C # 7H7
! 2 , C # ! 20

G$ * , )( ! ! 0
#* ! , , +/ 7
= $%D%0 4'1.
20 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

3 ! ## , ,
! * : ! *
* # * / 1 !
, - 0 0 ! /
, C # 1 # ! * !
## * A * * # * ,
! * /'1 /G1 0 (" +* /'1 C
# C # # # ! !
* 0! ( ! +* /G1 C C #
, 0 * !
C # ! 2 , @ 0 0 !
* C # 5 8 A * 0
0 8 * * ,
* * 0 0 * (, ! 7 +
* /$10 ! 0 * #, ! 0
C * * / 0
21 0 * #
* (" + * /'1 ! 0 * #
0 * , ! 0* #0 7 !
# 3 , #
* * 0 * !
* /'1 ! * /G1 /$1
- * * , 0 #0 *
2 ! , ! * # , , ! 0
# (" +* /'10 #* * # 7 ,
7C #7 , * #
# B , * /$1 8 ,
, ! 0 0 !
, ; , 7 ) ! , ,
8 , # * ,
, , *
, : , , * *
, !
0 * *
# 0 * 0 *
! * # * # #
8 , : 8 , , # # ,
* * # * #
van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism 21

, * , # 3 0
* # 2 / * 1 C #! #
2 , ! * # , *
*
@ , 2 , * : *
* C * , , * #
* * * ! * *
/ * , 1! *
# # * #* * 0! * * "
! 2 ! # ! *
* * * : * #0
7 , * * * , * ! * , *
* *, ! : ! * *
& !0 !
* #0 ! 2 0 0,
* 0 #* , 0
0 * * ! , * * #
* # 0 # ,
# # : * * #
C #0 ! 2 * # 0 * 3 , *
! * * # ,

"

7= 0 . /$%D%1 ( ? * ! *
? , * ,) B $ . 5
0 & 1 9 & *: & G'0 6I:4'
#0 /$%&61 , , ! # - 5 :& 9 / ; ) *
#A , 8
@ , 0 7" 0 > # / 1 /$%&91
( 3 * ) B < 0+ ' &$
/ * 10 '6$:'66
0 ; /$%&$1 )3 ! . & . 7 6 * , )B #
* ,
0. /$%&' 1 (5 * * 0+ @ " ! / 1. /
( " < 6 ) ! * ?
0 . /$%&' 1 ( - * B 0+ +& &! + 0
## $G0 ':''
20 - /$%D%1 - * ? , - B # F ? 2 , $490
@ , )B # " ,
22 Basic Income Studies Vol. 1 [2006], No. 1, Article 6

> <0 /$%&91 (O <, * <F >


, H 3 * 0+ ' &$0 '4$:
'DG
> 0" 7 /$%&61 ' ## & 8 6 ) -#
0 /$%&91 . 7 5 , # . /6 , ) , B #
. 80 < /$%&I1 / 6 )-
. 80 < /$%&'1 ' & '8 5 6 ). <
. 80 < /$%&91 ( 3 * ) , * 0+ '
&$0 6$%:6G&
0 @ /$%D'1 + & . 7 5 # & 9 5 6 ) ,
= ,
0 @ /$%&91 & , & ! !6 A ) @ *2!
" 0 /$%&'1 - * > 0 ? 2 , $0 , )
; ? B #0 > * *
! 0 /$%DG1 & ! # 6A )A B #
0= /$%&G1 % ! & = 0 # 6" * )
? 2 - * #
0 /$%&'1 * * C 0 - * )
# - 0 ? 2 , G$'0 B # 0 > )
> * *
0@ /$%&$1 > , & ,! 6 )
B !
- 0 /$%D'1 (A # 7 * , * ,0+
+ 5 # & 9 ! #, DI0 G$I%:G$GG
- 0 /$%&G1 ( * # " 3
, 0+ , & ) 6%0 $$:$&
- 0 # /$%D%1 ( 5 0+ 5 ; " ; / 1 +& &!
) & !6 A )A B # 0 $%D%
- 0 /$%&G1 - - * O 0 0B # " * )
> * *
0 /$%&61 (5 7 * *
# ! 5 0+ + $&0 64':6%G
0 /$%&D1 ( - * @ 7 F+ !
/ 1. & # )/ )- ,
0 /$%&91 0
5 ) 5 0 ? 2 , &9I$0 B <
C 0 >< -* * * C
0 /$%&I1 ( 5 ,7 7 7 # )
* * # ? # A #0+ # + ) $G0
$:$4
0 /$%&'1 (? # " * * "* )
* A #0+ # + ) $90 $$$:$G6
van der Veen and Van Parijs: A Capitalist Road to Communism 23

0 /$%&61 (? / # ,1 * #? ,? F+
+& & '60 &9:$IG
0 /$%&91 (" 0 3<* , * *
* 0+ @ * / 1 . / 6 )
3P* ; P -* * - *
0 /$%&D1 ( #0+ + , ! $90
69':6&G
0 /$%%91 > # 6 :& # !& 5 #! ;
A )
? 8 L*2 0 - /$%D$1 ( ! #
, , B @ , 0+ + 5
# & 9 ! #, 4&0 $$%G:$$%6

> * -* *
B #
AQ * ,! G'D
$I$G > 0
) R

; 3< C <* C *
B < C
* " C 0'
@7$'6& 7 7 0@ ,
) R * *

You might also like