The Memo of Agreement between the Village of Albion and the Albion Police Benevolent Association outlining how pay will be calculated for police department employees.
The Memo of Agreement between the Village of Albion and the Albion Police Benevolent Association outlining how pay will be calculated for police department employees.
The Memo of Agreement between the Village of Albion and the Albion Police Benevolent Association outlining how pay will be calculated for police department employees.
This Memorandum of Agreement (“MOA”) is by and between the Village of Albion
(“Village”) and the Albion Police Benevolent Association (“PBA”). The parties agree as
November 2022 Memorandum of Agreement |
|
follows: |
1, The Village and the PBA agree to replace Section 29.6 of the Collective Bargaining
‘Agreement in its entirety with the following language:
The Village has, since July 3, 2016, properly implemented and adopted for its
police officers an 84-hour two-week work period under Section 7(k) of the Fair
Labor Standards Act (29 U.S.C. § 207(k)). The 84-hour two-week work period
starts on Saturday at 6:00 p.m. and ends on the second subsequent Saturday at 6:00
pam, As a result, overtime pay for police officers is not determined on a weekly
basis, but instead is determined over this two-week work period, and except for
overtime owed under this Collective Bargaining Agreement when an officer works
beyond twelve hours in one day (Section 21.1) or on his or her scheduled day off
(Section 21.3), no overtime is owed to any officer unless and until he or she works
more than 84 hours within the two-week work period.
2. Subject to Section 14 of the November 2022 Settlement Agreement which could
render this Section void ab initio, the Village and the PBA agree that Section 28.1 of the
Collective Bargaining Agreement is amended to add the following language:
The Village and the PBA agree that the bargaining unit employees’ hourly rate of
pay shall be obtained by dividing the basic annual salary by 2080 hours.
3. The Village and the PBA agree to add Section 29.12 of the Collective Bargaining, which
will read as follows:
The Village and the PBA acknowledge and agree that their custom and prac
under the collective bargaining agreements between them has been to exclude any
and all time spent by police officers in changing clothes and washing at the
beginning and end of each work shift from working time, and that such exclusion
from working time was proper, correct, and authorized under Section 3(0) of the
Fair Labor Standards Act (29 U.S.C. § 203(0)). Going forward, the Village and the
PBA wish to memorialize this custom and practice in the express terms of their
collective bargaining agreement. To that end, the parties expressly agree, through
this provision, that any and all time spent by police officers in changing clothes and
washing at the beginning and end of each work shift has been and will remain
excluded from working time, in accordance with Section 3(0) of the Fair Labor
Standards Act (29 U, 203(0)). The Village and the PBA agree that police
officers are free to change info and out of their uniform and other items at their
residence and that no officer is required to do so at any Village facility or location.
The Village makes changing facilities available to police officers solely as a
convenience for the officers, and each officer is free, at his or her election, to usesuch facilities, use his or her own residence, or use such other facility as is
appropriate for the officer.
4. This MOA will become effective on the first date that all of the following statements are
true: (a) the MOA has been executed by the PBA; (b) the MOA has been executed by the
Village; and (c) the MOA, fully executed by both parties, has been submitted to and approved by
formal action of the Board of Trustees of the Village.
AGREED FOR THE VILLAGE: AGREED FOR THE PBA:
Angel dice des & Daniel Base,
Mayor President
jllalaa _ Milos flit
Date Date‘November 2022 Settlement Agreement
‘This November 2022 Settlement Agreement (“Agreement”) is entered into by and between the Village of
Albion (the “Village”) and the Albion Police Benevolent Association (the “PBA”).
1, Back Pay. From June 1, 2022 through June 11, 2022 (the “Impacted Period”), the Village derived
an hourly rate for each police officer represented by the PBA by taking each officer's basic annual salary
plus any longevity payment due under Article XXII of the Collective Bargaining Agreement in effect from
June 1, 2021 to June 2, 2024 (the “CBA”), and then dividing that sum by 2,184 hours (the “2,184 Hourly
Rate Calculation”). The Village agrees that its utilization of the 2,184 Hourly Rate Calculation during the
Impacted Period was in error, and that it should have instead derived the hourly rate of each officer by
taking each officer's basic annual salary plus any longevity payment due under Article XXII of the CBA, and
then dividing that sum by 2,080 hours (the “2,080 Hourly Rate Calculation”). Any officer who was
underpaid as a result of the Village's use of the 2,184 Hourly Rate Calculation during the Impacted Period
will receive a payment from the Village in an amount equal to the difference between the hourly rate
computed using the 2,080 Hourly Rate Calculation and the hourly rate computed using the 2,184 Hourly
Rate Calculation, for each hour underpaid as a result of the Village’s use of 2,184 Hourly Rate Calculation
that he or she worked during the Impacted Period (the “Back Pay”). The Back Pay will be paid by the Village
following the Effective Date (defined below), no later than thirty (30) days after the first date that all of
the following statements are true (a) the PBA has accomplished the complete withdrawal, with prejudice,
of both the Grievance (defined below) and the Improper Practice Charge (defined below), and (b) the PBA
has provided the Village with documentation which confirms the accomplishment of the complete
withdrawal of both the Grievance and the Improper Practice Charge.
2. Correct Hourly Rate. The Village and the PBA agree that since on or about July 3, 2016, except for
the Impacted Period, the Village correctly computed the officers’ hourly rates using the 2,080 Hourly Rate
Calculation, and that the 2,080 Hourly Rate Calculation was the computation that should have been used
during the Impacted Period. The Village releases and waives any claim it may have to recover from each
police officer the difference between the amount each officer was paid using the 2,080 Hourly Rate
Calculation and the amount he or she would have been paid had the Village utilized the 2,184 Hourly Rate
Calculation, for any work period occurring prior to the Effective Date (defined below). In addition, the
Village agrees that it will utilize the 2,080 Hourly Rate Calculation going forward from the Effective Date
(defined below) when it computes the officers’ hourly rates. The regular rate of pay for overtime purposes
will be calculated in accordance with Section 3,
3. Overtime Rate Calculation. Starting no later than the first full work period immediately following
the Effective Date (defined below), the Village will calculate each officer's regular rate of pay so that it
includes (a) any shift differential due to that officer under Section 29.4 of the CBA, and (b) any sick bonus
due to that under Section 7.9 of the CBA. In addition, the Village will continue to calculate each officer's
regular rate of pay so that it includes any longevity pay due to that officer under Article XXll of the CBA.
‘These regular rate of pay calculations will be made in accordance with the manner and methods provided
by the Fair Labor Standards Act. So, for example, because no officer's sick bonus can be ascertained until
after the close of the calendar year, the sick bonus will be excluded from the regular rate of pay until it
can be determined. Once an officer's sick bonus is ascertained, his or her sick bonus (if any) will be
apportioned back equally across each work period of the year to which itis attributable, the regular rate
of pay for each work period with overtime hours will be recalculated to account for the apportioned sick
bonus, and the Village will pay the officer any additional overtime wages ata rate of one-half times the
increase in the regular rate of pay that is attributed to the apportioned sick bonus for that work period.4, Pre-Shift Briefing Time. Starting no later than the first full work period immediately following the
Effective Date (defined below), for as long as the Village retains the practice of requiring a pre-shift
briefing before each Eligible Shift (defined below), each officer will be required to report to work (a) fifteen
(45) minutes before the scheduled start of each Eligible Shift (.e., :45 a.m. or 5:45 p.m., depending on
the officer's platoon), or (b) an earlier time before an Eligible Shift whenever directed by the Chief of
Police (“Pre-Shift Briefing Time”), so that he or she can be briefed on relevant matters by management
and/or officers on the outgoing platoon. An “Eligible Shift” refers to only an officer’s regularly-scheduled
42-hour shift that begins at either 6:00 a.m. or 6:00 p.m. (depending on the officer's platoon); no other
shift wil be considered an Eligible Shift, including for example any “detail” shift (eg,, training, DWI, STEP,
BUNY, and the like). An officer's Pre-Shift Briefing Time will be considered hours worked and will be paid,
but only to the extent that he or she was actually present and in attendance for such Pre-Shift Briefing
Time. No officers will be paid for any Pre-Shift Briefing Time (or have it counted as hours worked) for any
time not actually worked.
5. One-Time Ratification Payment. Provided that the PBA enters into and executes this Agreement,
the Village will make a special, one-time ratification-inducement payment to each current officer
computed as follows: 104 * one-eighth (1/8 or 0.125) his or her then-current hourly rate (computed using
the 2,080 Hourly Rate Calculation) * 3 (the “Ratification Payment”). The Ratification Payment will be paid
by the Village following the Effective Date (defined below), no later than thirty (30) days after the first
date that all of the following statements are true: (a) the PBA has accomplished the complete withdrawal,
with prejudice, of both the Grievance (defined below) and the Improper Practice Charge (defined below),
‘and (b) the PBA has provided the Village with documentation which confirms the accomplishment of the
complete withdrawal of both the Grievance and the Improper Practice Charge. The Ratification Payment
will be less all applicable taxes, withholdings, and deductions.
6. Attorneys’ Fees. The Village will pay $7,500.00 (the “Attorneys’ Fees") to the PBA’s counsel,
Bartlo, Hettler, Weiss & Tripi for the PBA’s attorneys’ fees and costs. The PBA acknowledges and agrees
that this payment by the Village to the PBA’s counsel will fully and finally release the Village of and from
any and all claims that the PBA or the PBA’s counsel may have for attorneys’ fees or costs incurred on or
before the Effective Date (defined below}. The Attorneys’ Fees will be paid by the Village following the
Effective Date (defined below), no later than thirty (30) days after the first date that all of the following
statements are true: (a) the PBA has accomplished the complete withdrawal, with prejudice, of both the
Grievance (defined below) and the Improper Practice Charge (defined below), (b) the PBA has provided
the Village with documentation which confirms the accomplishment of the complete withdrawal of both
the Grievance and the Improper Practice Charge, and (c) the Village has received a completed IRS Form
W-8 from the PBA and the PBA’s counsel. The Attorneys’ Fees will be paid via a check that will be provided
to the PBA’s counsel (Bartlo, Hettler, Weiss & Tripi, 22 Victoria Boulevard, Buffalo, New York 14217). The
Attorneys’ Fees will be reported to the PBA and its counsel on IRS Form 1099-MISC, as appropriate.
7. Release of Claims. For and in consideration of the mutual promises contained in this Agreement,
including the Village's promise to pay the Ratification Payment and Attorneys’ Fees, together with other
good and valuable consideration, the sufficiency of which the PBA hereby acknowledges, the PBA, on
behalf of itself and each and every one of its current and former members (each a “Releasor,” and
collectively, the “Releasors”) hereby fully, finally, and irrevocably releases, acquits, and discharges the
Village and each of its current and former trustees, mayors, managers, supervisors, insurers, attorneys,
and agents, in both their individual and official capacities, as appropriate (each a “Release,” and
collectively, the “Releasees”), of and from any and all actions, causes of action, suits, debts, dues, sums of
‘money, accounts, reckonings, bonds, bills, specialties, controversies, judgments, obligations, grievances,
claims, charges (including improper practice charges), complaints, appeals, demands, and any otherliabilities of any kind or nature whatsoever (collectively, “Claims”) that any Releasor now has or ever had
against any Release, whether known or unknown, suspected or unsuspected, asserted or unasserted, for
(2) Claims for any unpaid, underpaid, or late-paid wages, (b) Claims arising under the Fair Labor Standards
Act, (c) Claims arising under the New York Labor Law or any other federal, state, or local law, regulation,
or ordinance related to wages, hours of work, wage payment, benefits, or any amounts alleged to be owed
in exchange for work, and (d) Claims for attorneys’ fees, penalties, interest, costs, or expenses (the Claims
released by this paragraph may collectively be referred to as the "Released Claims”).
For the avoidance of doubt, and not by way of limitation, the Released Claims include, but are not limited
to, any and all Claims involving (a) alleged unpaid time officers spent donning and doffing uniforms and
equipment, (b) alleged unpaid time officers spent attending preliminary or postliminary briefings or
meetings, (c) alleged unpaid time officers incur due to missed or interrupted meal periods, (d) alleged
unpaid overtime to officers due to the Village's alleged failure to properly adopt a two-week, 84-hour
“work period” under Section 7(k) of the FLSA, (e) alleged failure to include any sick leave bonus provided
under the CBA in each officer's regular rate of pay for overtime purposes, (f) alleged failure to include any
shift differential provided under the CBA in each officer’s regular rate of pay for overtime purposes,
regardless of how such Claims were, are, or may be pled or characterized (e.g., as statutory violation,
common-law claims, contract claims, tort claims, collective bargaining agreement claims, past practice
claims, improper practice charge claims, grievance/arbitration claims, etc).
‘The Released Claims do not include any claim or claims that arise after the Effective Date.
8 Acknowledgement_of Bona Fide Dispute; Pre-titigation Dispute. The Village and the PBA
acknowledge and agree that this Agreement reflects a fair and reasonable resolution of a bona fide
dispute under the Fair Labor Standards Act and any other applicable federal, state, and local laws. The
Village and the PBA also acknowledge and agree that this Agreement is an enforceable, pre-litigation
settlement and release within the meaning of cases that include Gaughan v. Rubenstein, 16-cv-8062, 2017
WL 2964818 (S.D.N.Y. July 11, 2017) and Martin v. Spring Break ’83 Prods., LLC, 688 F.3d 247 (Sth Cir.
2012) among others. On behalf of each Releasor, the PBA acknowledges, represents, and agrees that the
PBA and the PBA’s counsel have provided adequate representation in negotiations with the Village
regarding the Fair Labor Standards Act and other claims raised, each Releasor has been fully apprised of
is or her rights under the Fair Labor Standards Act by the PBA and the PBA’s counsel, there is a bona fide
dispute between the Village and the PBA as to whether and to what extent any Releasor has any
entitlement to wages under the Fair Labor Standards for the claims raised by the PBA, the Village and the
PBA have engaged in good faith and arms-length negotiations over the last few months in an effort to
resolve the various claims between the parties, and the PBA and the Releasors are receiving substantial
benefits in exchange for their release of claims provided under this Settlement Agreement.9. Withdrawal of Grievance without Prejudice. As soon as possible following the Effective Date, the
PBA agrees that will undertake all actions necessary to, and will accomplish, the complete withdrawal
without prejudice of the June 16, 2022 grievance filed by the PBA (the “Grievance”, a copy of which is
attached at Exhibit A. The PBA further agrees that it will not file any grievance or arbitration arising out
of the same nucleus of facts at issue in the June 16, 2022 grievance. The PBA and the Village agree that
the accomplishment of the complete withdrawal without prejudice of the Grievance is a material
condition of this Agreement.
10. Withdrawal of Improper Practice Charge without Prejudice. As soon as possible following the
Effective Date, the PBA agrees that it will undertake all actions necessary to, and will accomplish, the
complete withdrawal without prejudice of the October 13, 2022 Improper Practice Charge the PBA filed
with the New York State Public Employment Relations Board (the “Improper Practice Charge”), a copy of
which is attached at Exhibit B. The PBA further agrees that it will not file any improper practice charge
arising out of the same nucleus of facts at issue in the October 13, 2022 Improper Practice Charge. The
PBA and the Village agree that the accomplishment of the complete withdrawal without prejudice of the
Improper Practice Charge is a material condition of this Agreement.
11. Cooperation. The PBA and each of its members, together with their counsel, agree to fully
cooperate, in good faith, with the Village and its counsel in defending the validity and enforceability of
each term of this Agreement, and in taking all steps necessary to implement and comply with the terms
of this Agreement.
12. Acknowledgements. The PBA acknowledges and agrees that:
a. _ithas had a reasonable period of time to consider the terms of this Agreement, and the
PBA will deliver an executed original of this Agreement to John M. Godwin, Esq., Hodgson Russ LLP, 140
Pearl Street, Suite 100, Buffalo, New York 14202, with a copy via email to 1Godwin@hodgsonruss.com;
b. _itand the Releasors have been represented by competent and independent legal counsel,
Bartlo, Hettler, Welss & Tripl, in connection with the review, negotiation, and execution of this
Agreement;
._ithas voluntarily executed this Agreement on behalf of itself and its members;
d. itis legally competent and duly authorized to enter into this Agreement and make each
of the representations and binding commitments contained herein, and such competence and authority
is not subject to any limitations or restrictions; and
fe. the making of this Agreement is not, and shall not be construed or represented as, an
‘admission that the Village or any other Releasee has violated any law or has committed any wrong against
the PBA or any other person or entity.
13. Effective Data. This Agreement will become effective on the first date that all of the following
statements are true: (a) the Agreement has been executed by the PBA; (b) the Agreement has been
executed by the Village; and (c) the Agreement, fully executed by both parties, has been submitted to and
approved by formal action of the Board of Trustees of the Village (the "Effective Date”), For the avoidance
of doubt, this Agreement cannot become effective or binding without the Board of Trustees ofthe Village
affirmatively voting to approve this Agreement.
14, Breach, Invalidity, or Unenforceability. This Agreement and Section 2 of the November 2022
Memorandum of Agreement between the Village and the PBA (including the new sentence added to
Section 28.1 of the Collective Bargaining Agreement) will all be deemed void ab initio, and of no force or
effect whatsoever, asf this Agreement and Section 2 of the November 2022 Memorandum of Agreement
had never been executed or agreed to, if any of the following occur: (2) any court or arbitrator of
competent jurisdiction finds that the PBA or the Village has breached any of its obligations orrepresentations under this Agreement; or (b) any court o arbitrator of competent jurisdiction finds that
any term, condition, or other part of this Agreement is invalid or unenforceable; or (c) the PBA or any
member of the bargaining unit subsequently files any grievance or arbitration arising out of the same
nucleus of facts at issue in the June 16, 2022 grievance; or (d) the PBA or any member of the bargaining
unit subsequently files any improper practice charge arising out of the same nucleus of facts at issue in
‘the October 13, 2022 Improper Practice Charge; or (e) the PBA or any member of the bargaining unit
subsequently files any claim in any other forum arising out of the same nucleus of facts at issue in the
June 16, 2022 grievance or the October 13, 2022 Improper Practice Charge.
15. General Provisions. Electronic signatures and copies of signatures transmitted by facsimile, PDF,
or electronic means shall have the same effect as original signatures. This Agreement represents the entire
‘agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof and supersedes all prior and
contemporaneous understandings, agreements, offers, representations and warranties, both written and
oral, with respect to such subject matter. This Agreement may not be modified orally or through any
practice or conduct, but rather only in a writing executed by both parties. This Agreement will be governed
by the laws of the State of New York, without regard to the principles of conflict of law.
16. Interpretation. Each party has participated in the negotiating and drafting of this Agreement in
consultation with legal counsel, and therefore, this Agreement will be fairly interpreted as drafted, rather
than for or against either party
17. No Precedent or Practice. For the avoidance of doubt, the parties agree that the Village’s payment
of the Back Pay, the Ratification Payment, and the Attorneys’ fees will not establish (or be cited as) any
precedent or practice between the parties, including the method the Village will follow to resolve any
future disputes with the PBA.
FOR VILLAGE OF ALBION: FOR ALBION POLICE BENEVOLENT ASSOCIATION:
wv Ange fein Lo on Dane! Brose Bek Loos
Tile:_ Mayer Title:_ “Pesichert
pate:_1}]4/ vate: 05/2023.