Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1, July 2010
Developing Culture Technology of Indigenous Small Fish Species Mola in Aquaculture Ponds in Sunderbans
M. Kunda, B. Mahakur, G. Sengupta, M. A. Wahab, N. Roos*** and S. H. Thilsted***
Abstract
To develop culture technology of indigenous small fish species mola in Aquaculture pond with carps and prawn, a trial with three treatments was conducted from July to December 2006 in 33 ponds, belonging to poor households in Sunderbans region, India. Rohu, mrigal, prawn and mola were stocked at 3,000 ha-1, 1,000 ha-1, 3,750 ha-1 and 20,000 ha-1, respectively, in all ponds. Of the planktivorous carp species, silver carp was stocked at 2,500 ha-1, 1,750 ha-1 and 1,000 ha-1 and catla at 1,000 ha-1, 1,750 ha-1 and 2,500 ha-1 in treatment I, treatment II and treatment III, respectively. Before stocking, the ponds were treated with urea (50 kg ha-1), TSP (50 kg ha-1) and cow dung (1500 kg ha-1). Mustard oil cake and rice bran (1:2 ratio) were fed daily, at the rate of 3 per cent body weight. Mola was partially harvested several times throughout the production season. Mola production was highest with the highest stocking density of silver carp and lowest of catla. It may be concluded that mola-carpprawn polyculture may be a good option for rural farmers of the Southern region of West Bengal to reduce poverty and ensure household nutrition.
1.0 Introduction
Sunderbans, West Bengal, India, with an extensive water area, sub-tropical climate and fertile soil is ideally suited to fish farming. With increasing human population, there has been a decline in natural fish. Aquaculture offers a vast potential to make use of the rich fisheries resources in Sunderbans, and leads to increased fish production.
Department of Fisheries (DoF), Bangladesh. Email: mrityunjoy68@yahoo.com Joygopalpur Gram Vikash Kendra, Basanti, South 24 Parganas, West Bengal, India. Department of Fisheries Management, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh, Bangladesh Department of Human Nutrition, Faculty of Life Sciences, University of Copenhagen, Frederiksberg, Denmark.
19
SIS are considered to be fish which grow to a length of approximately 5 to 25 cm at maturity (Felts et al. 1996). Some SIS, for example mola (Amblypharyngodon mola), are rich in vitamin A and contain moderate amounts of haem iron and zinc, and a large amount of highly bioavailable calcium (Hansen et al. 1998 and Larsen et al. 2000), contributing considerably to the recommended daily intakes of these, often limited in plant based-diets. Moreover, mola has the potential to provide several nutrients in considerable amounts, some of which are not found in the large fish, rohu. In 100 g of mola, the vitamin-A, calcium and iron contents are approximately 1960 mg, 1071 mg and 7.0 mg respectively (Thilsted et al. 1997). Many small, indigenous fish species (SIS) are found in Sunderbans, and these can be brought into culture and management. With the introduction of aquaculture in ponds in Bangladesh, SIS were regarded as weed or trash fish and eradicated using piscicides. However, data and research are showing that SIS are commonly consumed, making up an integral part of the rural, Bangladeshi diet and are an essential source of vitamins, minerals and animal protein, successful pond polyculture technologies, with carps and nutrient-dense SIS have been introduced (Thilsted et al. 1997). Freshwater prawn (Macrobrachium rosenbergii) is a very popular species in aquaculture, due to its fast growth, good taste and high international market value. In recent years, the global production of freshwater prawn has increased steadily (FAO 1997), with the major production in the Asian countries China, Vietnam, India, Thailand, Bangladesh, Taiwan, Brazil, Equador and Malaysia. During the last two decades, considerable attention has been given to freshwater prawn production due to its export potential (Ahmed 2003). Within the overall agro-based economy of Bangladesh, the contribution of prawn production plays a role in creating jobs, earning foreign currency and supplying animal protein (Rahman 1995). Indian major carps, rohu (Labeo rohita), catla (Catla catla) and mrigal (Cirrhinus cirrhosus) are very popular fish in Southeast Asia and have good market value. Silver carp (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix), a filter feeder Chinese carp, is fast growing and due to its relatively low price is affordable by poor people. Therefore, these species, together with freshwater prawn and mola were selected for a study on pond polyculture in Sunderbans, West Bengal in order to develop an optimal production strategy for poor farmers. The study was aimed to achieve the following production objectives:
20
i.
to optimise the production of catla and silver carp as well as accommodate mola in carp-prawn polyculture ii. to assess the production performance of mola in carp-prawn polyculture iii. to understand the combined production in presence of mola; and iv. to understand the economics in different treatments.
21
cow-dung were applied at 10 days interval at the rate of 100 g, 100 g and 4 kg per decimal, respectively.
22
covariant during the ANOVA. If main effects were significantly different, differences among the treatments were tested with DMRT. The analyses were run at 5 per cent significance level using SPSS statistical package.
3.0 Results
3.1 Growth and Production of Fish and Prawn
Results for growth and production of all species are presented in Table 1. The relative contributions of fish species and prawn to the total production in each treatment are presented in Figure 1. As mola bred in the ponds; the harvested numbers were much higher than that stocked and individual harvesting weight and survival were not recorded. The total yield of mola was significantly higher (P<0.05) in T1 than T3, but no significant difference was found between T1 and T2. The mean individual stocking weight of mola were 2.5 g in all treatments. There was no significant difference in stocking weight of mola, as the juveniles were collected from the same stock and distributed randomly in all the research ponds. The individual harvesting weight of prawn and SGR found significantly higher (P<0.05) in treatment T1 than in T3. The mean survival varied between 72-82 per cent, without showing any significant differences (P>0.05) among treatments. The total yield in treatment T1 was significantly higher than in T2 and T3. The mean individual stocking weight of mrigal was same in all treatments, because fingerlings were collected from the same stock and distributed randomly. There were no significant differences (P>0.05) in individual harvesting weight, survival, SGR, total yield and net yield of mrigal among the treatments. The mean stocking weight of rohu was also the same in all treatments. There were no significant differences (P>0.05) in harvesting weight, SGR, survival, total yield and net yield of rohu among treatments. Comparatively higher survival, 81 per cent and higher yield, 270 kg ha-1 of rohu were found in T1. The mean individual stocking weight of catla was also same 10.17 g in all treatments. The harvesting weight of catla and SGR in treatment T1 found significantly higher (P<0.05) than in treatment T2 and T3. There was no significant difference in the survival of catla among treatments. Total yield and net yield of catla did not show any significant difference among treatments. The mean individual
23
Table 1: Comparisons of Means (SE) of Yield Parameters of Fish and Prawn in Three Treatments with a Four-Month Culture Period (Mean values followed by different superscript letters in each row indicate significant differences, P<0.05, based on Duncans multiple range test.)
Species/Parametres T1 Mola (Amblypharyngodon mola) Mean individual stocking weight (g) Total yield (kg ha ) Net yield (kg ha-1)
-1
Treatments T2 T3
156.3 27.9ab
Freshwater prawn (Macrobrachium rosenbergii) Mean individual stocking weight (g) Individual harvesting weight (g) Survival rate (%) SGR (% bw day ) Total yield (kg ha-1) Net yield (kg ha-1) Rohu (Labeo rohita) Mean individual stocking weight (g) Individual harvesting weight (g) Survival rate (%) SGR (% bw day ) Total yield (kg ha ) Net yield (kg ha ) Catla (Catla catla) Mean individual stocking weight (g) Individual harvesting weight (g) Survival rate (%) SGR (% bw day-1) 10.17 0.55 388.2 37.8 77.5 3.1 2.3 0.07a
a -1 -1 -1 -1
3.6 0.03 53.8 2.8b 73.63 4.5 1.7 0.03b 145.7 9.6b 132.4 9.6b
8.1 0.11 269.6 26.6 81.1 3.7 4.20 0.09 665.18 88.5 641.3 88.5
8.1 0.11 269.6 29.8 77.9 3.6 4.2 0.1 629.1 83.9 605.2 83.9
8.1 0.11 232.3 21.7 76.7 2.7 4.1 0.09 531.1 59.9 507.2 59.9
24
Silver carp (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix) Mean individual stocking weight (g) Individual harvesting weight (g) Survival rate (%) SGR (% bw day-1) Total yield (kg ha ) Net yield (kg ha-1) Mrigal (Cirrhinus cirrhosus) Mean individual stocking weight (g) Individual harvesting weight (g) Survival rate (%) SGR (% bw day ) Total yield (kg ha ) Net yield (kg ha-1)
-1 -1 -1
4.68 0.06 356.4 49.4 79.18 3.3 2.7 0.09 712.8 23.4
a
4.68 0.06 380.9 47.5 79.0 3.0 2.8 0.08 525.10 70.2
ab
4.68 0.06 410.0 67.8 78.6 3.3 2.79 0.116 318.67 56.6b 314.04 56.6b
701.2 23.4a
517.0 70.2ab
8.6 0.07 383.64 29 80.9 3.3 2.4 0.05 310.9 32.3 302.4 32.3
8.6 0.07
8.6 0.07
344.5.6 41.87 378.18 31.32 81.9 2.5 2.3 0.14 283.8 37.8 275.3 37.8 78.5 3.1 2.4 0.06 295.8 31.4 287.3 31.4
Note: Mean values followed by different superscript letters in each row indicate significant differences (P<0.05) based on Duncans multiple range test.
stocking weight of silver carp was 4.7 g in all treatments. There were no significant differences in individual harvesting weight, survival and SGR among treatments. The total and net yield of silver carp were significantly higher (P<0.05) in T1 than T3. The combined production of catla and silver carp was higher in T1, in which the stocking density of silver carp was higher than that of catla.
25
Table 2: Benefit-Cost Analysis in the Treatments (based on 1 ha pond area and 155-day culture period)
Items Purchased inputs Lime Urea TSP in the text, you write phosphate Feed Mola Prawn juveniles Rohu fingerlings Catla fingerlings Silver carp fingerlings Mrigal fingerlings Total costs of purchased items Bank interest (10% per annuum) Total financial investment Financial returns Prawn sale Mola sale Rohu sale Catla sale Silver carp sale Mrigal sale Total financial returns Net financial benefit Benefit-cost ratio (BCR) 46,125 20,090 26,600 10,395 21,360 10,885 135,455 72,696 2.16:1.00 36,250 15,260 25,160 11,900 15,750 9,940 114,260 54,520 1.91:1.00 36,500 13,510 21,240 13,955 9,750 8,880 103,835 46,064 1.80:1.00 T1 T2 T3
Amount of money (INR) (37 INR=1USD) 2,000 820 1,450 32,000 5,000 11,250 3,000 2,000 1,250 1,000 59,770 2,989 62,759 2,000 820 1,450 28,000 5,000 11,250 3,000 3,500 875 1,000 56,895 2,845 59,740 2,000 820 1,450 25,000 5,000 11,250 3,000 5,000 500 1,000 55,020 2751 57,771
26
Figure 1: Relative Contribution of Freshwater Prawn, Mola, Catla, Silver Carp, Rohu and Mrigal to Combined Total Production
3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 T1 T2 Treatment T3
Prawn Rohu Mola Silver carp Catla Mrigal
27
4.0 Discussion
4.1 Growth and Production of Fish and Prawn
Mola production was highest with the highest stocking density of silver carp and lowest of catla, indicating that silver carps have no negative impact on the growth and production. As mola breed 2-3 times in natural pond condition, it is important to harvest at least once in a week in order to obtain a higher production and keep the adequate number of mola in the pond. Compared to all other species, silver carp showed the better performance in terms of growth and production. There were no significant differences in individual harvesting weight, indicating that silver carp production was not affected by mola. Roy (2004) also reported that silver carp production was not affected by the presence or absence of mola in carp-mola polyculture system. The growth of catla was negatively affected with its higher stocking density. It might have been due to intraspecies competition for food and space. There was no significant difference in silver carp growth among the treatments, indicating that the stocking density of catla did not affect its growth. Also stocking density of silver carp (1,000-2,500 ha-1) did not affect its growth and was positively related to total production, being highest in T1, having the highest stocking density. There was no significant difference of growth of rohu among the treatments perhaps due to rohu being the only column feeder species, and therefore having no competition with food and space. The stocking density of catla and silver carp used in this study did not affect the growth of rohu. The growth and production of mrigal
28
were also good in all treatments. This might be due to the low-stocking density of mrigal used in this study and the availability of organic matter in the pond bottom which helps create nutrient rich organisms. The growth and production of prawn were significantly higher in treatment T1 than treatment T2 and T3. The highest stocking density of silver carp in T1 was associated with a higher prawn production, perhaps due to a synergistic effect between silver carp and prawn. There have also been synergism between mola and prawn, as both species has the highest productions in the same treatment, T1. The economic analysis shows the economic returns of carp-mola-prawn polyculture under low-input management as used in the three treatments in this study. The cost of physical labour by household members was not taken into consideration. Due to significant higher production of mola, prawn and silver carp in T1 than T2 and T3, the highest financial returns were observed in this treatment. Roy (2004) reported a net benefit of 88,330 Bangladeshi Taka (BDT) (70 BDT = 1 USD) per hectare per 7 months for carp-mola polyculture systems which were similar to the treatments used in this study. Roos (2001) reported a net benefit of 34,100 BDT ha-1 in carp-native SIS ponds culture in Bangladesh, which is lower than that of this study. However, from the production, economics and nutritional point of view, mola-carpsprawn culture system is a better option for rural farmers. People can derive money by selling the large carps and prawn at the end of the culture period and mola can be consumed once in a week after it started breeding. Farmers or their family members even women can easily catch mola by using cast net/push net/lift net. As mola breed 2-3 times in a year, so, addition of mola in carp-prawn polyculture would be a regular source of animal protein as well as vitamin-a and micro-nutrients for the farmers.
29
and Kohinoor (2000), recording temperature ranges of 26.7-33.7 oC, 26-32.4 oC and 18.5-32.9 oC, respectively in the carp polyculture ponds in Bangladesh which is the same in the geographical region like the present research area. Boyd (1982) recommended a transparency ranging from 15 to 40 cm as appropriate for fish culture which is similar to that found in this study. Some ponds were turbid due to flashing of the rainfall from the embankment. Overall, the transparency indicated the good growth of planktonic population which is necessary for fish culture. pH values of water ranging from 7.0 to 9.2 is recommended as being suitable for fish culture (Swingle 1967; Boyd 1982) and the pH values of this study were within this range. Kohinoor et al. (1998) observed a pH range of 7.18 to 7.24 in carpmola polyculture ponds at the Fisheries Field Laboratory Complex, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh. DO concentrations were also in a suitable range, with few occasional low values, especially on rainy days. Banerjea (1967) reported that DO ranging from 5 to 7 mg/l is good for fish culture. Ophenheimer et al. (1978), Wahab et al. (1995) and Roy (2004) recorded similar DO values, 3.187.58 mg/L and 2.2-7.1 mg/L and 3.65 -7.65 mg/L respectively.
30
References
Ahmed, N. 2003. Freshwater Prawn Farming in South-western Bangladesh. Bangladesh J. Agril. Sci., 30 (1): 69-75. Banerjea, S.M. 1967. Water quality and soil condition of fish ponds in some states of India in relation to fish production. Indian J. Fish., 14 (1&2): 115-144. Boyd, C.E. 1992. Water Quality Management for Pond Fish Culture. Department of Fisheries and Allied Aquaculture, Albama Agricultural Experiment Station, Auburn University, Alabama, USA. P. 318. FAO (Food and Agriculture Organisation). 1977. China: Recycling of organic wastes in agriculture. FAO soils. bull. P. 40. Felts, R., A. Rajts and M. Akteruzzaman. 1996. Small Indigenous Fish Species Culture in Bangladesh (Technical Report). IFADEP Sub-Project-2, Department of Fisheries, Bangladesh. P. 52. Hansen, M., S.H. Thilsted, B. Standstorm, K. Kongsbak, T. Larsen, M. Jensen and S.S. Sorensen. 1998. Calcium absorption from small soft-boned fish. J. Trace Elem. Med. Biol., 12:148-154. Kohinoor, A.H.M. 2000. Development of culture technology of three small indigenous fish mola (Amblypharyngodon mola), punti (Puntius sophore) and chela (Chela cachius) with notes on some aspects of their biology. Ph.D dissertation, Department of Fisheries Management, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh. P. 363. Kohinoor, A.H.M., M.L. Islam, M.A. Wahab and S.H. Thilsted. 1998. Effect of mola (Amblypharyngodon mola Ham.) on the growth and production of carps in polyculture. Bangladesh J. Fish Res., 2:119-126. Larsen, T., S.H. Thilsted, K. Kongsbak, M. Hansen. 2000. Whole small fish as a rich calcium source. Br. J. Nutr., 83:191-206. Mollah, M.F.A and A.K.M.A. Haque. 1978. Studies on monthly variations of plankiton in relation to the physico-chemical conditions of water and bottom soil of two ponds. 2. Zooplankton. Bangladesh J. Fish., 1(2):99-103. Ophenheimer, J.R., M.G. Ahmed, A. Huq, K.A. Haque, A.K.M.A. Alam, K.M. Aziz, S. Ali and A. S. M. N. Haque. 1978. Limnological studies of three ponds in Dhaka, Bangladesh. Bangladesh J. Fish., 1:10-28. Paul, S. 1998. Comparison between carp polyculture system with silver carp (Hypophthalmichthys molitrix) and with small indigenous fish mola (Amblypharyngodon mola). M. S. dissertation, Department of Fisheries Management, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh. Rahman, M.A. 1995. Rice-cum-fish farming. Fisheries Development Technologies. A fish fortnight compendium. 1995. Fisheries Research Institute, Mymensingh, Bangladesh. Pp. 44-45. Rahman, M.S., M.Y. Chowdhury, A.K.M.A. Haque and M.S. Haq. 1982. Limnological studies of four ponds. Bangladesh J. Fish., 2-5 (1-2): 25-35.
31
Roos, N. 2001. Fish consumption and aquaculture in rural Bangladesh: Nutritional contribution and production potential of culturing small indigenous fish species (SIS) in pond polyculture with commonly cultured carps. Ph. D. thesis, Research Department of Human Nutrition, The Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Copenhagen, Denmark. P. 121. Roy, N.C. 2004. Effects of Carp-SIS Polyculture System on Pond Fish Production, Nutritional Security and Socioeconomic Benefit of the Rural People, Ph.D. Dissertation, Department of Fisheries Management, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh. P. 184. Swingle, H.S. 1967. Standardization of chemical analyses for waters and pond muds. FAO Fisheries Report, 4 (44): 397-421. Thilsted, S.H., N. Ross and N. Hassan. 1997. The role of indigenous fish species in food and nutrition security in Bangladesh. NACA News letter, July-Dec, 13p. Tripathy, S.D. 1997. The role of fishes and aquaculture in improving the food and nutrition security in Bangladesh. Paper presented at the Training Workshop in food nutrition security in BD. Organized by BRRI and ENRECA project, 12 March, Bangladesh. Wahab, M.A., Z.F., Ahmed, M.A. Islam, and S.M. Rahmatullah, 1995. Effect of introduction of common carp, Cyprinus carpio (L) on the pond ecology and growth of fish in polyculture. Aquacult. Res., 26: 619-928.
32
Copyright of Asia-Pacific Journal of Rural Development is the property of Centre on Integrated Rural Development for Asia & the Pacific and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.