CAN SCIENCE
CREATE LIFE?
AA British scientist who accidentally produced life in his
laboratory made a discovery nobody wanted.
By Pel Thence
[iets me ee
iat are
aes
wamica a
aceon
Serpe
ay ies
cormorant
Pe
gece
Mile Sn omy
waruore cm
eos
ener
Sere
Seas
Saeaees
Svageaernnts
an he
state, Then, ponessing 2 steady if
Modest income, “Crosse devoted
whatever he could afer to the sadly
OF science wich had bee is pasion
Since boyhood
(rots was seal inflcacd in his
‘aly seat career bythe poneet
ectisan George John Singer What
%
Ste ean ca anaes
‘ad been the music hall in Crosse
Mansion was converted into a
Iaboratory. The gan at was aid
house vatey of ela! squipent
(coe large deve cada cada.
Tue catoned is engraving: “Fig
il Saree oe
None not me tongere—do 201th
me) Beeen 607 and 187 Sige aad
‘Crome stung yards and yar of cone
Be it ver he wounds of teats
‘Wit thi gan atenne the to
able to conduct powerful ha
St tmombere dearcty io tee
ieirtoy hee ty toed ae Se,
bebavior tnd characters,
‘Dut Singer ed in
(rose without mento.
ot
ina col
1: ice wih natura sce mite. Fig.
combined win nad oneal ino?
actly ceased hie esearch forthe
et 20 years
His scenic peers id nt het fom
(Grose agin oul 136. That pear be
‘ts ivited 10 speak to the ‘Beti
Atoction forthe Advascemect ot
ence assembled fa Brinal He
the formation of rk sta
nex to electri, mierslogy ws Rs
favorie pursuit’ While it) Brel,
Crome’ alto dewonsrned htm.roverestt on the design of the
‘otal ile and shared his data om at
‘mosphere eerily The Assocation
was impesed expecially ence Crone
‘Rl sgh inthe comple
Fret from his Biol tmp,
rosie returned homeo Fyne Court to
bepahis ost mous and controver-
silexperiment He decided to combine
his two favre studies and atempe to
dacoer whee s weak erent of dee.
wt would affect the formation of
‘ysl of sea out of ston
outed hydrochloric ai unl the
‘elution was supersaturated.
He bull x mahogany frame to Bold
the component of hi epermest, Oa
{he top thal Crosse put large bala
containing the acca gud. By
‘meas of spo sme he a as
Sipboved down othe net shell where
‘Tunnel vas owned In the oneal
Was chon of raturl oxide of ron,
‘bined from the slges of Mount
Vesuvius. "AS the ‘luton slowly
App onto the sone, th oro ar
{ace of the reck seated up Attached
toeach def the dampened rock were
lina wits wich were conse ts
Foner Chamber’ bok Vesiges ante
‘ate Darwin, et Acar ents
fone of Crose's mull bates.
[clow the spout of the nel was
‘othr far which aupe te eee ge
{4 ripping of the sone. The excess
‘ould te returned tothe op basi
‘Alter 1 days white ots appeared on
the upper surface of the electrified
one, directly beneah the dripping
Diese of Manne. By the 18th day the
ots tad grown into sonal exer
‘ences with dd hae flaments al
‘ver them. After 6 days the coal ob
Jess had become recognisable a mites
Gn the 2th day the miter detached
‘hemselves frm the sone aad moved
‘atound of thelr own vltion. Andrew
Crosse was amazed, He had observed
‘ei developaen daly bet when ty
showed powers of locomotion. and
‘hunger he wa stunned indy were
ia fa ale
tamination unde 2 ens revealed
thatthe minute eeture were Cah
legal epimers ofthe genus Aes
(oday wie called crim). When
‘over 100 of thee Acar came off
Stone Crosse reali tat here was,
phenomenon beyond be Know edge ot
He id tw thing First, he repeated
his experiment in ode to ola the
sient ingredient noted for the
‘evelopment of more Acari. Secon, he
contacted his newiyaet sient cae
leegues for" help i anaiying ‘is
‘mysterious mites, Before Crosse foul
Prepare acarefl saemest on the ap.
bearance of the Aah The Western
Gazette got hold of the story
remature, Imceente stores roke
bout the ran who ha ested Ining
‘aerials and a seamagined resin
“He wasattacked fom pulps aos the
»
‘managed te rena objecive a pbc
pinion raged around hia. He never
hime to have create fended, hs
Sat pe wafer assigning
Among thote who fist examin
specie ofthe Acar were Si Richard
nen, Hustrian Profesor a the Cal
lege of Surgeons in. London, and
William CU, conservator of the
‘museum ofthe same college: Me, Clit
Ilda conversion a he Repl la,
‘ton on February 7, 1837, andthe
‘cri were the mala tems on spay
‘Asainple acon preserved scot,
‘nas sen othe Academe der Senet
in Paris where was studied by the
Noted microveopit PI. Tei,
Jn the meanine, Crosse coined
is research ino the ogi of he Acar
‘The mites were being called varonly
Acer Cress, Acont Elcrias OfGatvanics. Cross eliminated the ac
and stone om hit appara od fond
could produce Acer rom solutions
‘of potassium siete by pasa elec
ty, through the ligid. A ayer of
eatinous sles would colect on the
Sites and the mites would deveop ia
this gelatin ke bad. Siee the rt
sere always santo develop gradually
Beneath the sutaceo
Ing in the appaats could not be con.
sidered valid. Cros atfuly cleaned
of his equipment by baking Hot
‘eshing i
Dechgmmrbiens
=
Trot tery
eoteerermmee
ose
rca
Richipertaee
oa et
Soret
me
ots
eel
nai dene
Sarareatens
i
a me
nea Sa
FATE
sts) conviction that advance of
Knowledge hase tendeny to subvert
find. destroy the p
Felon yet he refieetion al
United Sites were unanimously sep.
‘ea. Although no hit of ftaud ever
mas atached to Andrew Crosse, the
‘reall epiion wat that Crowe had
ttade some ertor or overlooked sme
‘Spec othe experiments which would
Soil for he eparans of Aer
‘Except for personal fiends of Crosse,
scents associated theese fom
the dear
"Nocoubx many were duel by the
caperenc of Michael Faraday Pareday
‘wi preset at Clits meting with the
Royal estat of Great Brain when
the Acer! were presented. Unreliable
enters ofthe Bish pee ceustd
por to the effect that Faraday told
(ot sein Acar developing duty is
(en seca experimen. This canard
‘eas quickly refuted by Prada in
ter fo many papers and. journals,
Including the Literary Caste andthe
Times. The alse sation of Fada
sith the Acari might have ben org
"ep had it wot been predominaly
featured by Harriet Martineau a het
snidey rad book 4 History of the
Thinty Years Peace (189). Maines
evi several pages to Andiew Crome
nd the Acai controversy, epesting the
‘pocryphal story of Faraday Acar,
Gn Apr, 180, Michael Faraday
ote diel to Marines, advising
er that theory was i ere. The
CCAN SCIENCE CREATE LiFe?
uth acknowledged the eror but to
this day i reain inthe modern ed
tions of Marina's story,
‘The microscopic aaa by Turpin
ida to Crone’ repuaion, The
ofthe salution the
Acar ed wed red ina manner conse,
{cat wit other members of the spec
They Ived oaly unl the fest font
yhch as invaciby tal to every
‘Trp’ repon, published in Volume
V of the Comps Rend, adnited the
carte examined wat ab ous end
ever before catalogued ‘ype, Turpin
‘Ruse here dere Hots fr
them. The mites were. apparently
‘eles, et verve ight. Foe mite
bodied two sections, head and
abdomen, Mature specimens bad eight
legs bt some examples remened fro
hele selution ad nly Tis
cluractrisic & ot enkown among.
‘Acari as inmate mites of the
‘cara Sro uso beg ie with gs
‘nd later develop another pai
“Tupin'sexceleat engraving shows
the Aca covered wih long fie a
(rouse describe thee fants aap
‘eating before tee rother eure
‘Turpin remarked that he knew of no
ther pe of Acuna which poses
‘uch lengthy and abundant flamene
‘By 1839 twas apparent to Crowe
thats enrique inte aot
ihe Acar tet forcing: Aine
tite open oi tee co
Besjamin ‘Silliman, “ede ofthe
“American Journal of Scene snined
ip the cotservateatade when ae
(ered, We cansot bebe tae
‘Ec orpniton hve be produc Oy
‘ante power”
‘rome dd st et the dein.
Indeed, be fe 0 tony te eas
of i 'dicovery tat he shcooned
Dl and reared to te ene
Scusion of br Somer ete
‘Tirouphot the Lar and upto hs
death fa 138, Crome cond
‘Satie wort He made import
Sin towed ihe apa
the staining ater ad wad
the knowidge of how dea
Sted hoagie and gd
“The ‘crt tad bowpht Crone
thing at raion bt ewe
inetosee nate a roe tc om
Movers aed give an early new
Semon al
Tet Wii Heny We
MD. themunkipal decor ete tors
of Sadi Ket eps odpcae
ine eprint Crouse iad performed
Ireyeaneariee Werke wast oe
2 ining 0 by rah tion he
som we he le "acer even
Scene
‘Wests a more pecie expec
than Grose hd eo ena of
‘Sent curacy Wek no eit
{he Acar was tigeroulyconsaed
Week sled beste of pin
set uner aga bel He educa
bs trough an arg
{asker dtd valet noe
low peso esepe th bt woldot allow aio enter. Weekes connect
the lads to his Baery and left the
eve aloe. He made observations at
‘gla intervals to check on the Se
‘omposiion ofthe sete solution. ta
Weekes jar 10 months Daou to
‘ovenber 14 aped before the iat
Acor appeared. Five were ietied
‘sawing around quite itincy onthe
Interior ofthe as,
“Tocacde ay posibityofexermal
‘comtmination Werks ried other novel
sarangenea In one ese eed sere
‘vyee intead ofa unde the el and
sil produced Acar. On snother occa.
sion be wed pcoaous hydtofeorc
‘d'un chlorine gu The fest was
Perfectly formed bt lees Aco
Curouly "suggestive result wre
bane by Weekes in his nperinene
He observed dune ans inthe fore
ation of Acar begining as eye
fine, ter tc owes no
men-beaing cones Finally
became itingushabe andthe cera
spayed he it spas of ie. Weches
found thatthe higher the proportion of
‘carbon in the chemial he wed the
fetter numberof cert which
{sopeated. Whes he conrniied an
spparatas identical oss step bt
mite be elect he obi
“The ests oF W.H, Weekes exper-
snes tba ll
Iti the Procedingr ofthe London
ketal Sci. (This sae body had
‘rind Crose's report in 1837) Ase
{fom minor notes, the work of Weekes
i ot atrac be testo ofthe world
‘n the way Crove's ad ‘There wa
‘modest cottage nthe self ours
‘als bat no publ denuncaisns of
Weekes were bead.
FATE
Luts known shout Wim Heary
‘Weeks aie fom bs ae are
ies. Det ofthe doctor's Ue arse
‘bay that even the dt of hs death
octal: appease ded 1847,
Sandwich hetremerbered fo accep,
ing the post of muscipl doctor and
‘ile midwife of St Mary’ par for
‘ee toney tha hiscoleagocs would
Gent. Daring Meine Wesker
Published 20 siete papers dealing
‘with “meteorology, elecricity and
Paeanatis
Ti deol Cc and Neve
‘tring angen lash 6
{he besoin ofthe set theory
‘of even. The controvery of 1857
‘ve the Acerca othe station of
sn. Edioburghpoblisher, Robert
Canter. Chambers had siding
interest in natural try andthe Aco
far suggested to in hat thee ight
be physical nonin) onpins of
te: Chambers cae ade Andrew
rose a sa an a's sat
(Cotte recived favorable etion 1,
Chambers" Ednborgh magasine and
‘ser was menoned again Chamber?
The Book of Ds (88,
1p 18k anonymously authored
‘ook ented Pegs ofthe Natural
History of Creation appeaied. This
beck propounded be hoy hte on
ath war much older than the
‘honology of the Bitlewoul allow.
further postulated, various asl
seat hg
Sveloped nto the at ray of formas
"at now coer theca, Like Dari
‘magnum opus The Oris of Spelt
(G15), Yeti was denounced ts the
ork of an iacortigble sth. One
Famous reviewer, St David Brewster
ssidof Veigesand authors" Were
CAN SCIENCE CREATE LiFe?
wwlting to charge our author with &
‘ystematle attempt fo underine
foundations of natural and revealed
we boul cary the
‘Tis isreminicent of the charge—of
‘og a mate and seifamagingd
‘Sealor—that ass vebeteny baad
Crome
The author of Vege tuned out 19
‘be Robert Chamber nan xy edtion
of his book Chambers mates cb
{efereaces to Crowe's xperincn it
‘chapter called "Vexign of Crestive
Ew” the Acai ae ied a eigen
{aie cn result om combinations
of chemicals under the stun oft
satura ore lke etry. The fat
‘ons of Vesties inci a
ies two leters fom W. H Weekes
esrbcg his work with the ear since
‘ns last reports othe Londo Elected
Society Realing the skeptics hers
aguas the Acar, Chambers wrote,
“tt his new preseatmeat ofthe Ass,
{rosa shal ti excite tide Ta
‘nly reget the ssood of mind fame
Sibi caer
Sect es ae
Exaneratae ae
Exesoveerace
Epoecuneengine
Eoemesatae
mares
FuSaasaat
‘arouy cause i no: posopicl and
Wherefore deserves no consideration”
By the fourth elton of Peniger
(1840), Coambers had prea amended
ister nstead ofthe eutows apport
the above pass, bei out al.
acceptance ofthe vat of the Acard
rufa creatures and hide the
‘cictie community fori conned
dlsregard of this “mat inerening
‘hapterof nature's mjtrea™
By the time Rober Chamber fly
Fly conde
an honorable foeraaer of Darwin
1s fact that in eons of Veet
‘sued afte 145 references to Crosse
Weekes and the Acar have bee ite
out Whether ts wat to maketh book
Ser more scent and eco)
simpy to hea oe pose, no ont
weer dota
saint
imcianenate
Se eee
Stceirarece
pet roid
Egeneaitee
Emianas
Sone Setaas
iecSsies Seca
Same nana
eae
ee
a Leetvious and widely ackaowedged. What
‘Seven more interesting, rom he post
(of view of Aairew Crone’ etper=
‘ment that Darwin van devoted
feader ofthe works of Harit Mase
nea He read vo fever than at of ter
books between November 1842 tnd
‘Acgust S2. As the Faraday debacle
‘showed, Cotes amaor prt of Mar:
{inea's Book. V ia A Ftary of the
Thiry Years Pesce.
‘Allis raises some antazng ques
tions. Darwin must have know about
the dco: What ile hk of thea
How much credence did he give to
‘en? Did Darwin, however finly,
sider the Acer a evidence that le
ould crigiate in a purty physical
Fashion iisirnia nk that Darwin
say have been the iheror of the
burden oF vtuperation for knpious
‘materialim ir pul upon Ande
Cro and Robert Chambers From
Crowe, to Wee, 19 Mariacat, 10
‘Chambers, 19 Darwin—the unwanted
‘Acar may tavesontbuted more 19
‘iene thin mat people realise,
“Anirew Crone ed July 61833,
ahoneinhis ona te His sod wife
(Cornea Burs Crowe publi small
‘ook ax his ero years ter. eas
filed. Memory Slenific and
{teary of Andrew Crowe, the Ei
‘rein ake Yas folowing i eth,
(Crosse became sctnlerendary fiat
in his neighborhood: he wa
femembered at the thunder aed
lightning am” He les buried inthe
sfurchyard of St. Mary's chapel in
Broomfield. The tone abesk which
‘marks hs grave sald to ave teen
strock by ighting twice although
biher more acebletrgetsare ne
‘by. Cra gui absurd et bere
FATE
it because itis absurd)
Eve if we divegard the anomalous
stence of the dear, 3¢hiory tad
Science have done, the cotrveny
lavohing Andew Cron was So off
‘ales ‘examples of the ‘Kind of
‘oofronation incressiegy common
today: namely, the event 10 wich
‘siene can intrude onthe meal and
‘elgious belts of soe. How fat
should we allow scene to 90 in
Penetrating the soces of le? Pace
‘were no eat answers la Cros’ day
Ad there are none today
‘What were the te origins of the
Acari
Dep he rpid advance of cence
lwo the world of DNA aod gene
cogiceing (worlds. Andiew Grose
‘ever dreamed ot stil cade
Inpossite 10 crete ving, compe
‘organi trem simple chemicals by
‘ean of electricity.
In 1836 bicloptt A.C. Oudemans
xplained the Acar! of Crosse and
‘Weekes as an nestaon othe odioary
Gheophogus domestics which sah
Denia semingly beret sealed
‘omtainers. This theory has ben aur
facing petodicaly ever snc 1837 bu
le reported observations of Cross
Weekes and other witness Maly ule
it out The Acart were play sen fo
develop under the arta te sale
Solutions. alwaye onthe eatteat.
Carrying wees. Once emerge rom the
Sidhe Acar woul rowel they fe
Dick in. Enbibiting ‘characters
unique to themselves, the Ae cannot
be explained away at common rites,
faulty observation, bad techque ot
{aud "The only aa to duplicate
(Crosie'sexperinens, Dr, Wee, ss:
‘seeded No doubr hi work aso canbe
CAN SCIENCE CREATE LIFE?
amie as fay by the shee. The
Mernaive ie jst too disurbiag 19
‘aterain. And who would dream of
rouble replat the expe
iment tay?
(Of the Acar, nothing remais exept
‘he papers desing therm, None of the
ry
‘names bestowed om them survive ia
‘oder biological nameacature, not
ven Tupn's crashed Te fate
the Acari sya of what nape
Pens 10 a discovery no one realy
Want is conigned 10 hoy’
tsi and orga7
‘MALVA DEE
“Canada’s Lesa
5 | ONG Mew orca
% rsrenouctnr swe
shanti hk in
ADVERTISE IN FATE.
a Eeoncnney reo
L__nietiond Past 8 ces “<= |
COUPES erg ots
Let me help you ena contro
‘and uncertantyin your life will
‘veal keys tha can brighton yout
future with abundent fove, ow
rospely and greater 28st Send
{gry tte POSTAL READINGS
BROCHURE wich explain oy
PREY. BRIAN SEABROOK
P.O. Box