Professional Documents
Culture Documents
24 Pr i ma r y De n ta l J ou r n a l journals.sagepub.com/home/PRD
Microbes that invade the root canal
system do not simply float as single
cells inside the main root canals; they
exist in the form of a biofilm and may
invade all parts of the root canal
system.11 Endodontic biofilms are
complex communities of microbes,
predominantly bacteria, that stick to root
canal walls and each other, and are
embedded in a self-produced protective
Figure 1: Cleaning the mesial root canals of a mandibular first molar: (left) inflamed slime of extracellular polymeric
pulp, (middle) sodium hypochlorite in root canals, (right) clean and dry root canals substances (Figure 3). Biofilms are
difficult to remove, and highly resistant
to antimicrobial agents and the host
There is a diverse range of terminology the root canal system (Figure 2). defense system.
in the field of endodontics. With regards The complex anatomy may:
to cleaning the root canal system,
examples of commonly interchangeable •• Contain biofilm and remnants of pulp
terminology include ‘chemical tissue in teeth affected by endodontic
preparation’, ‘chemical debridement’, disease6
‘irrigation’, and ‘disinfection’. The term •• Become clogged with smear layer
‘cleaning’, as used by Schilder,1 is used and hard tissue debris in teeth
throughout this paper for consistency of undergoing root canal treatment7,8
terminology. •• Be inaccessible to hand and machine-
driven files9,10
Aim of cleaning the root •• Be inaccessible to cleaning solutions
canal system and which cannot easily flow into these
complicating factors areas
As dentists, we set out to control Figure 3: Scanning electron microscope
microbes that have invaded the root image of an in vivo biofilm in a root
canal system so that the balance can be canal x300 magnification
shifted from infection-related disease to Adapted with permission from Oxford University
Press, courtesy of Sadia Niazi
healing and healthy dental and
periradicular tissues. Achieving this aim
is complicated by several factors: A smear layer and hard tissue debris
may be generated by the cutting
1. The complex and intricate anatomy of action of endodontic instruments on
root canal systems dentine. The smear layer is composed
2. The complex nature in which of organic (pulp tissue remnants and
microbes grow and adhere to the microbes) and inorganic (dentinal
root canal walls ‘mud’) debris which may coat the
3. The formation of smear and debris surface of the root canal wall and
during shaping of root canals Figure 2a: Micro computed tomography penetrate the dentinal tubules. Debris
scan showing root canal anatomy of a can also be compacted into complex
The anatomy of the root canal system is maxillary molar anatomy which may interfere with the
usually very small, delicate, and Courtesy of Sophie Parker, Endo Reality Ltd flow and effectiveness of cleaning
complex; root canals are not straight solutions.11
tubes with a circular cross-section. The
complex anatomy may include lateral Taking into account the above
root canals, fins, webs, anastomoses, complications, the aims of contemporary
isthmi, apical deltas, and root canals cleaning of root canal systems are to
which have an ovoid, ribbon, or disrupt and kill biofilms, dissolve and
C-shaped cross section. In 1842, flush out pulpal tissue, and remove
Carabelli2 was the first to publish on smear and debris. Ideally, this should be
root canal anatomy. In 1925, Hess and applicable to all of the root canal
Zürcher3 demonstrated the complexities Figure 2b: Micro computed tomography anatomy, but realistically it applies to as
of root canal anatomy using a scan showing isthmus connecting two much of it as is practicable. It would be
vulcanised-rubber demineralised-tooth root canals a similar feat to removing crunchy sticky
technique. Modern micro-CT studies4,5 Adapted with permission from Oxford University peanut butter from the rough porous
continue to reveal the complexities of Press, courtesy of Shanon Patel surface of toast.
Vol. 9 N o . 4 De c em b er 2020 25
Contemporary cleaning of the root canal system
Sodium hypochlorite fulfills many of the It has also been suggested that other
properties of an ideal endodontic antimicrobial solutions may be used as
cleaning solution (Table 1). It is a highly final rinse or an alternative to sodium
effective antimicrobial and antibiofilm hypochlorite.13,15 Chlorhexidine
agent, and it can dissolve organic matter gluconate (CHX) solution may be useful
including inflamed pulp tissue, necrotic in situations where sodium hypochlorite
pulp remnants, biofilm, and the organic is unsuitable to use, for example,
component of the smear layer. There is Figure 4: Examples of sodium patients who have an allergy to
no widespread agreement on the hypochlorite solutions at 3% household bleach; however, CHX may
optimal concentration, temperature, concentration also cause an allergic reaction. Other
volume, delivery time, soak time, and disadvantages of CHX solution include
timing of use (i.e. final rinse) of sodium its inability to dissolve organic and
hypochlorite. Despite this, there is inorganic tissue, and that it does not
general agreement that sodium effectively disrupt biofilm.19
hypochlorite should be frequently
replenished to maintain an effective Care should be taken when alternating
concentration of its active components to cleaning solutions as negative
compensate for their rapid interactions may occur. Sodium
inactivation.16,17 Most suppliers provide hypochlorite loses its tissue dissolving
commercially available sodium capacity when combined with EDTA
hypochlorite solutions at concentrations solution.20 A toxic and carcinogenic
of 2%, 3% or 6% (Figure 4). These are precipitate, parachloranaline, forms
licensed for use in endodontics and are when CHX solution is combined with
considered more appropriate to use than sodium hypochlorite.21 It is therefore
household bleach. Disadvantages of advisable not to mix solutions or
sodium hypochlorite include foul taste, repeatedly alternate them during
treatment.
26 Pr i ma r y De n ta l J ou r n a l
and devices.22,23 It is difficult to draw
reliable conclusions due to a lack of
a standardised research protocols to
investigate the in vivo impact on clinical
outcome.24,25 It should also be pointed
out that several devices have now been
discontinued from the market.
Manual cleaning
Manual cleaning of the root canal
system is low cost and convenient.
It involves delivering fresh cleaning
solution into root canals using positive
pressure via a side-venting needle
(Figure 6) and syringe, and then
manually agitating the solution. Manual
agitation techniques may include:
Vol. 9 N o . 4 De c em b er 2020 27
Contemporary cleaning of the root canal system
28 Pr i ma r y De n ta l J ou r n a l
Iatrogenic (nosocomial) •• Root canal anatomy is usually
infections complex and can be challenging to
Microbes may be iatrogenically clean
transmitted into the root canal system •• Shaping root canals creates a smear
via contaminated gloves, instruments, layer and hard tissue debris, which
and materials. Skin commensal can complicate cleaning the root
bacteria have been identified in canal system
endodontic infections.34 The following •• Contemporary cleaning of the root
infection control measures are canal system aims to disrupt and kill
advisable to reduce transmission of biofilms, dissolve and flush out pulp
pathogens: tissue, and remove smear and debris
from ideally all of the root canal
Figure 10: The use of personal
•• Correct hand hygiene:35 anatomy, but realistically as much of
protective equipment decreases the risk
handwashing with soap and water or it as is practicable
of iatrogenic microbial transmission into
handrubbing with an alcohol-based the root canal system •• Contemporary cleaning solutions
formulation continue to be sodium hypochlorite
•• Correct donning, use, and doffing and EDTA solution
of personal protective equipment •• Removal of infected debris from the •• Effective cleaning is achieved
(Figure 10) flutes of files to prevent cross- by frequently delivering fresh
•• Disinfection of tooth and contamination between root canals cleaning solution into the root canal
environmental surfaces. It is if treating a multirooted tooth or system and then agitating the
advisable that once rubber dam has simultaneously treating multiple teeth37 solution manually and/or with
been placed, the tooth surface and •• Changing gloves frequently a device
rubber dam sheet are disinfected throughout endodontic procedures,34 •• Controlling infection is key: this not
using an appropriate cleaning in particular, after taking only applies to existing root canal
solution36 intraoperative radiographs infections, but also to preventing
•• Sterilization and disinfection of •• Use of high-speed vacuums/suction to iatrogenic endodontic infections
instruments, devices, and equipment. minimize droplets and splatter
It is advisable to use presterilized Acknowledgements
files, needles, and paper points; and Summary points
The author would like to thank Dr Sadia Niazi,
to disinfect gutta-percha points in •• Endodontic disease is a biofilm- Dr Sophie Parker, Dr Shanon Patel, and Oxford
sodium hypochlorite prior to filling mediated infection. Biofilms can be University Press who kindly gave permission to
root canals challenging to disrupt and kill reproduce material.
References 6 Ricucci D, Siqueira Junior JF, Bate study of prevalence and Endodontics and Fluid Dynamics.
AL, et al. Histologic investigation of association with clinical and In: Basrani B. (Ed.) Endodontic
1 Schilder H. Cleaning and shaping root canal-treated teeth with apical histopathologic findings. J Endod. Irrigation. Switzerland: Springer
the root canal. Dent Clin North periodontitis: a retrospective study 2010;36(8):1277-8. International Publishing Ltd; 2015.
Am. 1974;18(2):269-96. from twenty-four patients. J Endod. 12 Paqué F, Rechenberg DK, Zehnder 18 Dotto L, Onofre RS, Bacchi A, et al.
2 Carabelli G. Systematisches 2009;35(4):493-502. M. Reduction of hard-tissue debris Effect of Root Canal Irrigants on the
Handbuch der Zahnheilkunde. Bd 7 Paqué F, Laib A, Gautschi H, et al. accumulation during rotary root Mechanical Properties of
2. Anatomie des Mundes. Vienna: Hard-tissue debris accumulation canal instrumentation by etidronic Endodontically Treated Teeth:
Braumüller und Seidel; 1842. analysis by high-resolution acid in a sodium hypochlorite A Scoping Review. J Endod.
3 Hess W, Zürcher E. The anatomy of computed tomography scans. irrigant. J Endod. 2012;38(5): 2002;45: 596-604.e3.
the root canals of the teeth of the J Endod. 2009;35(7):1044-7. 692-5. 19 Mohammadi Z, Abbott PV. The
permanent and deciduous 8 De-Deus G, Marins J, Silva EJ, 13 Young GR, Parashos P, Messer HH. properties and applications of
dentitions. London: John Bale Sons et al. Accumulated hard tissue The principles of techniques for chlorhexidine in endodontics.
& Danielsson; 1925. debris produced during cleaning root canals. Aust Dent J. Int Endod J. 2009;42(4):
4 Bjørndal L, Carlsen O, Thuesen G, reciprocating and rotary nickel- 2007;52(1 Suppl):S52-63. 288-302.
et al. External and internal titanium canal preparation. J 14 Good M, El Karim I, Hussey DL. 20 Grawehr M, Sener B, Waltimo T,
macromorphology in Endod. 2015;41(5):676-81. Endodontic ’solutions’ part 1: a et al. Interactions of ethylenediamine
3D-reconstructed maxillary molars 9 Peters OA, Schönenberger K, Laib literature review on the use of tetraacetic acid with sodium
using computerized X-ray A. Effects of four Ni-Ti preparation endodontic lubricants, irrigants and hypochlorite in aqueous solutions.
microtomography. Int Endod techniques on root canal geometry medicaments. Dent Update. Int Endod J. 2003;36(6):411-5.
J.1999;32(1):3-9. assessed by micro computed 2012;39(4):239-40, 242-4, 246. 21 Basrani BR, Manek S, Sodhi RN,
5 Wolf TG, Stiebritz M, Boemke N, tomography. Int Endod J. 15 Darcey J, Jawad S, Taylor C, et al. et al. Interaction between sodium
et al. B. 3-dimensional Analysis 2001;34(3):221-30. Modern Endodontic Principles Part hypochlorite and chlorhexidine
and Literature Review of the Root 10 Paqué F, Balmer M, Attin T, et al. 4: Irrigation. Dent Update. gluconate. J Endod.2007;33(8):
Canal Morphology and Preparation of oval-shaped root 2016;43(1):20-30. 966-9.
Physiological Foramen Geometry canals in mandibular molars using 16 Moorer WR, Weeselink PR. Factors 22 Gu LS, Kim JR, Ling J, et al. Review
of 125 Mandibular Incisors by nickel-titanium rotary instruments: a promoting the tissue dissolving of contemporary irrigant agitation
Means of Micro-Computed micro-computed tomography study. capability of sodium hypochlorite. techniques and devices. J Endod.
Tomography in a German J Endod. 2010;36(4):703-7. Int Endod J. 1982;15(4):187-96. 2009;35(6):791-804.
Population. J Endod. 11 Ricucci D, Siqueira Junior JF. 17 Boutsioukis C, van der Sluis LWM. 23 Mohammadi Z, Jafarzadeh H,
2020;46(2):184-191. Biofilms and apical periodontitis: Syringe Irrigation: Blending Shalavi S, et al. Recent Advances
Vol. 9 N o . 4 De c em b er 2020 29
Contemporary cleaning of the root canal system
in Root Canal Disinfection: A 27 Ruddle CJ. Endodontic disinfection: root canal system. Int Endod J. Sources of Nosocomial Endodontic
Review. Iran Endod J. 2017; power of the hand-held syringe. 2017;50(11):1034-54. Propionibacterium acnes Infections.
12(4):402-6. Available from: https://www. 31 Lukač N, Jezeršek M. Amplification J Endod. 2016;42(8):1202-11.
24 Machtou P. Manual Dynamic endoruddle.com/jit/detail/88/ of pressure waves in laser assisted 35 World Health Organization. WHO
Activation (MDA) Technique. Endodontic+Disinfection. endodontics with synchronized Guidelines on hand hygiene in
In: Basrani B. (Ed.) Endodontic 28 Ruddle CJ. Hydrodynamic delivery of Er:YAG laser pulses. health care: first global patient
Irrigation. Switzerland: Springer Disinfection: Tsunami Lasers Med Sci. 2018;33(4): safety challenge clean care is safer
International Publishing Ltd; Endodontics. Dent Today. 823-833. care. Geneva: World Health
2015. 2007;26(5):110-7. 32 Plotino G, Grande NM, Mercade Organization; 2009.
25 Virdee SS, Seymour DW, 29 van der Sluis LWM, Versluis M, M. Photodynamic therapy in 36 European Society of Endodontology.
Farnell D, et al. Efficacy of irrigant Wu Mk, et al. Passive ultrasonic endodontics. Int Endod Quality guidelines for endodontic
activation techniques in removing irrigation of the root canal: J.2019;52(6):760-774. treatment: consensus report of the
intracanal smear layer and a review of the literature. 33 Silva EJNL, Prado MC, Soares DN, European Society of Endodontology.
debris from mature permanent Int Endod J. 2007;40(6): et al. The effect of ozone therapy Int Endod J. 2006;39(12):
teeth: a systematic review and 415-26. in root canal disinfection: a 921-30.
meta-analysis. Int Endod J. 30 Konstantinidi E, Psimma Z, Chávez systematic review. Int Endod J. 37 Giovarruscio M, Sauro S,
2017;51(6):605-21. de Paz LE, et al. Apical negative 2020;53(3):317-32. Makeeva I, et al. Strategies to reduce
26 Machtou PP. Manual dynamic pressure irrigation versus syringe 34 Niazi SA, Vincer L, Mannocci F. the risk of reinfection and cross-
activation technique. Clin Dent Rev. irrigation: a systematic review of Glove Contamination during contamination in endodontics.
2018;2:21. cleaning and disinfection of the Endodontic Treatment Is One of the Clin Dent Rev. 2019;3:8.
FGDP
MEMBE (UK)
50% O
RS REC
EIVE
AVAILABLE NOW
IN PRINT & ONLINE
UPDATED IN 2018 TO REFLECT
THE IRR17 & IR(ME)R17 REGS
First published in 1998, and now in its third edition, Selection Criteria
for Dental Radiography covers the use of radiographs for the developing dentition,
endodontic assessment, caries diagnosis, periodontal assessment, and implantology, and reflects
more recent developments in radiography and dentistry, including digital radiography and CBCT.
FGDP
30 Pr i ma r y De n ta l J ou r n a l MEMBE (UK)
5
RS REC
0% OF EIVE
Dementia-Friendly ALL OU
R F
AND GSTANDARDS