THE FALL OF FOURTH PILLAR
The media has the power to manipulate, influence
and even shape society. Every day, whether
voluntarily or involuntarily, we consume a lot of
media, and every decision we make can be largely
traced back to it. There is a web of data and news
that can shock us, inspire us or invoke feelings of
despair and hopelessness. Our opinions, views and
beliefs are all influenced to an unimaginable degree
by the media. With increasing polarisation, it
becomes crucial to examine the country's sources of
information since the media doesn't simply cover
what people care about, it tells us what to care
about.
When media houses function not as a pillar of society
and democracy but as profit-centric businesses, their
accountability is no longer to their readers but to
their stakeholders. In this atmosphere, where news
organisations compete for higher TRPs and the favour
of corporations and political parties for funding,
partisanship is higher than ever. They tend to focus
on influencing, creating opinions and sensationalising
stories that sell instead of delivering unbiased
information. The general public has given into
‘confirmation biases' and sought out information that
agrees with the beliefs we have already formed while
considering contradictions as false. In some cases,this has also led to harassment and threats to
journalists who present an alternative view, leading
to India's rank of 142nd in the RSF Press Freedom
Report.
Direct ownership and advertisements pose some of
the greatest threats to the free and independent
press. An RTI inquiry revealed that the government
has spent over Rs 890 crore advertising in Hindi and
over Rs 719 crore in English newspapers over the last
five years. The media houses' financial dependency
on state advertisements makes them unable to
question the government effectively. Investments
from large corporations or individuals with strong
political affiliations result in biased, fabricated
propaganda being peddled off as news. This limits the
media from being able to freely report as seen when
a former CNN-IBN employee claimed to be told to
tone down coverage of AAP and the investigation of
Ambani and policymakers regarding alleged
corruption.
Keeping in mind the media's power to mould and
even manufacture public opinion, it is necessary for it
to reflect the diversity of society. A report by Oxfam
India and Newslaundry uncovered the utter lack of
representation in newsrooms. Out of 121 leadership
positions across the country's most popular
newspapers and channels, 106 are occupied by
journalists from the upper castes and none by thosebelonging to the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled
Tribes. Even in articles regarding caste issues, a
majority of the writers are upper caste individuals.
The under-representation of different socio-economic
groups means that their perspective is being left out.
How can the media hope to cover the issues of
people when it doesn't even truly represent the
people?
In recent years, there has been a paradigm shift, with
more and more people turning to online media
platforms and independent journalism for news.
Since many of these derive their income from
crowdfunding or viewership, it lessens the issue of
media ownership. However, there are rising concerns
over the credibility of the smaller news organisations
and the sustainability of a user-based business model
in times of economic hardship. We, as viewers, need
to be more aware of what we read and watch to
differentiate between fact and fiction. It is the
media's job to examine the world, but it is our job to
examine the media.