Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Wine Making
Wine Making
OBSERVATIONS
PARAMETERS
Initial Final
Color/Appearance of the
Solution
Odor
Texture
pH Level
Group Member
Name of Rater Workload Contribution(s) Rating
Names
A–
B–
C–
Asst. Surgeon:
D–
E–
TOTAL –
Chief Surgeon:
*
Criteria 1 2 3 4 5
Set-up of equipment Set-up of equipment
Set-up of equipment
is not accurate, is generally All equipment
is generally
(A) help is required
with several major
workable with
several details that
accurate with 1 or
All equipment
accurately placed
accurately placed
All necessary
Set-up and 2 small details that
details need refinement All necessary supplies on hand
need refinement
Equipment Many necessary Some necessary supplies on hand Very neat and
All necessary
Care supplies must supplies must be organized
supplies on hand
found in mid-lab searched out
Demonstrates very
Demonstrates good
good knowledge
knowledge of the Demonstrates sound
of the lab
Lacks the appropriate lab procedures knowledge of lab
Demonstrates procedures
knowledge of the Will ask peers for procedures
general knowledge Gladly helps other
(B) lab procedures
Often requires help
of lab procedures
help with
problems in lab
Will discuss with
peers to solve
students to follow
Following Requires help from procedures
from the teacher to procedures problems in
teacher with some Thoroughly and
Procedure even complete Works to follow each procedures
steps in procedures carefully follows
basic procedures step before Carefully follows
each step before
moving on to the each step
moving on to next
next step
step
Measurements are Measurements are
somewhat Measurements are both accurate and
Measurements are
inaccurate and Measurements are accurate with precise
incomplete,
very imprecise mostly accurate reasonable Observations are
inaccurate and
Observations are Observations are precision very thorough and
imprecise
(C) Observations are
incomplete or
recorded in a
generally complete Observations are
Work is organized thorough
may recognize
possible errors in
incomplete or not
Data confusing way Only 2 or 3 minor Work is generally data collection
included
Collection There are 3 or more errors using neat and organized Work is neat and
Symbols, units and
minor errors using symbols, units and Includes symbols, organized
significant figures
symbols, units and significant digits units and Includes appropriate
are not included
significant digits significant digits symbols, units and
or 2 major errors significant digits
Proper safety
Proper safety Proper safety Proper safety precautions are
Proper safety
precautions are precautions are procedures are consistently used
(D) consistently often missed
precautions are
generally used
consistently used Consistently thinks
missed Needs to be Uses general ahead to ensure
Safety May need to be
Needs to be reminded more reminders of safe safety
reminded once
reminded often than once during practices Will often help other
during the lab
during the lab the lab independently students to
conduct labs safely
Proper clean-up Needs to be Consistently uses
Proper clean-up
procedures are reminded more proper clean-up
procedures
seldom used than once during Consistently uses procedures
(E) Often requires help the lab to use
generally used
May need some help
proper clean-up Often will help other
to complete clean- proper clean-up procedures students to
Clean-up on occasion to
up procedures Station generally complete tasks
complete tasks
3 or more items left 1 or 2 items left at neat and clean properly
Station generally left
at station or station station or not Station always left
clean
not cleaned cleaned neat and clean