Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BACHELOR OF BUSINESS
ADMINISTRATION
SEMESTER 3
DBB2101
LEGAL AND REGULATORY
FRAMEWORK
Unit 2
Indian Contract Act, 1872
Table of Contents
3 Essentials of a Contract - 2
- -
3.1 Offer or proposal
5–9
- -
3.2 Acceptance of proposal
- -
3.3 Revocation of offer
4 - 3 10 – 11
Types of Contracts
5 - 4 12 – 14
Capacity of Parties
6 - 5 15 – 18
Modes of Discharge of a Contract
7 - 6 19 – 20
Remedies for Breach of Contract
8 - - 21 – 22
Summary
9 - - 22
Glossary
10 - - 22
Terminal Questions
11 - - 23 – 24
Answers
1. INTRODUCTION
Contracts are an indispensable part of our lives. We enter into various types of contracts in
our everyday life without realising that we are doing so. Your day may start with a cup of tea.
Where does it come from? When you purchase tea leaves, sugar and milk, or when you buy
a t-shirt, a cake of soap or a music system, you enter into a contract. The Electricity Board
has agreed to provide your house with electricity against the promise of payment by you.
You deposit your money in the bank or take a loan against some predetermined conditions.
All these are forms of contracts that we enter into voluntarily.
Whenever you buy something or enjoy some service you agree to pay a certain amount of
money to the seller or service provider, and the provider agrees to give you that something.
This is the basic principle of a contract.
The Indian Contract Act, 1872 (ICA), which has its source in the usage and practices of
merchants in Europe, is the most important law governing business transactions. This law
codifies how we enter and execute a contract and implement its provisions. It also deals with
the issues of breach of contract.
In this unit you will become familiar with the basic provisions of this law.
1.1 Objectives:
After studying this unit, you should be able to:
❖ Define the essential provisions of a contract
❖ Discuss the modes of discharge of a contract
❖ Explain the remedies for breach of contract
The ICA lays down the norms for a contract to be entered into, executed and dealt with in
case it is breached. However, the rights and duties of parties and terms of agreement are
decided by the contracting parties themselves. In case of breach, the courts have the right to
enforce the contract or impose compensation costs or damages on the defaulting party.
ICA came into effect on September 1, 1872. The Act has a wide scope as it provides that no
usage or custom or trade or any incident of contract is affected as long as it is consistent with
the provisions of the Act.
A contract may be oral or in writing. A verbal contract that can be proved is also enforceable.
However, some contracts, especially the ones that require stamping and registration like sale
of immovable property, Bill of Exchange or Promissory Note, Trust Deed, promise to pay a
time barred debt are valid only if they are in writing.
Self-Assessment Questions - 1
3. ESSENTIALS OF A CONTRACT
Agreement
According to the ICA, “every promise and every set of promises forming the consideration for
each other is an agreement.”
This implies that a promise or a set of promises made mutually by two parties is an
agreement. For example, A makes a proposal (offer) to B. When B accepts the proposal and
communicates his agreement to A, it becomes a promise.
Promise cannot be one sided. Only a mutual promise forming consideration for each other is
an ‘agreement’. For example, when you go to buy a shirt, you agree to pay a certain amount
to the shopkeeper, and he, in return, agrees to give you the shirt. This is a set of promises
which form consideration for each other. However, if you agree to pay some amount to
someone without him promising to give you anything in return, it is not an agreement.
Acceptance and promise – When the offeror communicates his assent to act as per the
proposal to the proposer, he gives his ‘acceptance’ to the proposal. A proposal, when
accepted, becomes a promise. The proposal can be accepted only by the person to whom it
is made.
The person making the proposal is called the ‘promisor’, and the person accepting the
proposal is called the ‘promisee’.
2. Intention to create a legal relationship – The parties entering into a contract must have
a clear intention to enter into a mutually binding legal relationship. Agreements of social or
domestic nature are not considered to be contractual in nature.
3. Free consent – Both the offer and the acceptance must be made by the concerned parties
of their own free will. Consent obtained through coercion, undue misrepresentation, fraud,
or influence is not valid.
4. Capacity to contract – Every person who has attained the age of majority is competent to
contract provided he/ she is of sound mind and is not disqualified from contracting by any
law to which he is subject.
5. Consideration for promise – The definition of ‘agreement’ clearly states that mutual
promises should form consideration of each other. A promise without consideration is not
an ‘agreement’ and is not considered a ‘contract’.
Consideration: When, at the desire of the promisor, the promisee or any other person who
acts on behalf of the promisee does or abstains from doing or promises to do or to abstain
from doing, something, it is called a ‘consideration’.
6. Lawful object and consideration – The object of the contract and the consideration
should be lawful and must not violate any law.
7. Agreement not declared void – The agreement must not have been declared void under
the ICA. Agreements in restraint of marriage, legal proceedings, trade and wagering
agreements have been declared void under the ICA.
8. Certainty of meaning – The terms of the agreement must be clear, certain and
unambiguous.
9. Possibility of promise – The terms of the contract must have the possibility of
performance. An agreement to do an impossible task is considered void.
10. Legal formalities – The contract must be entered into as per the stipulated legal
formalities.
Self-Assessment Questions - 2
4. TYPES OF CONTRACTS
ii) Voidable contract: A contract that can be nullified at the option of a party under
certain circumstances is called a voidable contract.
iii) Void contract: Void means null. A void contract is a contract which has no legal
validity. According to the ICA, ‘a contract which ceases to be enforceable by law
becomes void when it ceases to be enforceable.’
v) Illegal or unlawful contract: A contract which violates the law of the land is
considered void ab-initio (void since the inception).
ii) Implied contract: Where both the offer and acceptance constituting an agreement
enforceable by law are made other than in words i.e., by acts and conduct of the
parties, it is an implied contract.
iii) Constructive or Quasi contract: When the law infers or recognises a contract under
certain special circumstances even though the parties have not made an
agreement, express or implied, it is called a Quasi or Constructive Contract.
iv) Wagering and Contingent contract: A wager is a bet. Wagering contract promises
to give money or money’s worth upon the determination of an uncertain event
like a lottery.
Self-Assessment Questions - 3
5. CAPACITY OF PARTIES
1. Minors
According to the Indian Majority Act ,1875 a person, domiciled in India, who is under 18 years
of age, is a minor.
The law acts as the guardian of minors with the aim of protecting their rights, because their
mental faculties are not mature. An agreement made by a minor is treated as follows:
i) It is considered void ab-initio and hence, inoperative.
Case: Mohiri Bibi V. Dharamadas Ghose
A minor mortgaged his house in favour of a money lender to secure a loan of
Rs.20,000, out of which the minor was paid Rs.8000. Later, the minor sued for setting
aside the mortgage, claiming that he was underage. Held, mortgage was void and
cancelled. Moneylender’s contention that the minor should repay the amount was not
accepted.
ii) A minor can be a beneficiary under a contract provided that he is not required to bear
any obligation.
iii) It cannot be ratified even when he reaches the age of maturity.
iv) The principle of ‘estoppel’ does not apply to a minor. A minor is not estopped from
pleading minority to escape liability.
v) If he gets some benefit by fraudulently misrepresenting his age, the court can direct
him to restore that benefit to the other party.
vi) A person supplying necessities to a minor is entitled to be reimbursed from his/her
property.
vii) A minor cannot enter into a partnership except through his legal guardian and with
the consent of the other partners.
viii) A minor can be an Agent but he cannot be held personally liable for any negligence or
breach of contract.
ix) A minor cannot be declared insolvent, for he is considered legally incapable of
contracting debts.
x) Where an adult stands as a surety for a minor in a contract, the adult is liable under
the contract, not the minor.
xi) The parents of a minor are not liable for agreements made by a minor unless the child
is contracting as their agent.
xii) A minor, being incompetent to contract, cannot be a shareholder of a company except
through his lawful guardian.
The person making a contract must be sane and rational enough to know what is good or bad
for him. The following people are not considered to be of sound mind:
i) An idiot who has completely lost his mental faculties.
ii) A lunatic whose mental powers are deranged due to some mental sickness or
abnormality.
iii) A person who is drunk or in a state of intoxication and therefore incapable of making
a contract during such state.
3. Disqualified persons
ICA disqualifies the following persons from contracting:
i) Alien friend can contract but an alien enemy cannot. It means that a foreigner living
in India can enter into a contract during peace time between his country and India.
But he cannot do so if his country is at war with India.
ii) Foreign ambassadors or diplomats can enter into a contract and can sue others to
enforce the contract but they cannot be sued without obtaining prior sanction of the
Central Government. Thus, they are in a privileged position and are ordinarily
considered incompetent to contract.
iii) A convicted and imprisoned person is incompetent to make a contract or to sue on
contracts made before his conviction. However, he can do so on the expiry of his
sentence.
iv) A person declared insolvent cannot enter into a contract relating to his property.
Self-Assessment Questions - 4
When the rights and obligations arising out of a contract are fulfilled by both the parties, the
contract is said to be discharged or terminated. A contract may be discharged in the following
ways:
1. By performance
A contract may be discharged by performance in the following ways:
i) Actual performance: When each party to a contract fulfils his obligation as per the
stipulations of the contract, it amounts to actual performance and the contract
stands discharged. But if only one party fulfils his promise, he alone is discharged
and gets a right of action against the party guilty of breach.
ii) Attempted performance or tender: When the promisor offers to perform his
obligation under the contract, but is unable to do so because the promisee has not
yet accepted the performance, it is called ‘attempted performance’ or ‘tender.’
2. By mutual agreement
A contract may be discharged by mutual consent through:
i) Novation: When a new contract is substituted for the original one, the latter stands
discharged.
ii) Rescission: When one or all the parties cancel the contract, it is called rescission.
iii) Alteration: When alterations are made to the original contract with mutual consent
of both the parties, the original contract stands discharged.
iv) Remission: Remission means acceptance by a promisee of a lesser amount, or lesser
degree of performance than what was contracted for.
v) Waiver: Waiver is the willing relinquishment of rights by any one of the parties to
the contract.
4. By lapse of time
The Limitation Act, 1963 states that in case of breach of contract, the suffering party can
initiate legal action within a specified period, called the period of limitation. If he does not
do so, the case becomes time-barred and the contract cannot be enforced.
5. By operation of law
A contract terminates by operation of law in the following cases:
i) Death: The death of the promisor discharges the contract that is of a personal
nature. In other contracts the rights and liabilities of the deceased person pass onto
the legal representatives of the dead man.
ii) Insolvency: When a party of the contract is declared insolvent by law and the court
passes an ’order of discharge’ exonerating the insolvent from liabilities on debts
incurred prior to his being declared insolvent, the contract is discharged.
iii) Merger: Where an inferior right accruing to a person merges with a superior right
vesting in the same person, the contract pertaining to the inferior right stands
automatically discharged.
iv) Unauthorised material alteration: Any alteration made in a written document or
contract by one party without the consent of the other renders the whole contract
void.
6. By breach of contract
When a party to the contract defaults in fulfilling its part of the agreement, the contract
stands breached, and hence, terminated. The aggrieved party has the right to sue for
damages for breach of contract as per law. Breach of contract may be of two kinds:
i) Anticipatory breach of contract occurs when one party declares its intention not to
fulfil its obligations under the contract before the performance is due. It can be of two
types:
a) Express: When one party to the contract communicates his intention not to
perform to the other party, in words, either spoken or written, before the due date
of performance.
b) Implied: When a party implies its unwillingness to perform through its conduct.
Case: Lovelock v. Franklyn
A promised to assign to B all of his interest in a lease for a sum of £140, within 7
years. Before the end of 7 years, he assigned the interest to another person. Held,
this was anticipatory breach by implied repudiation.
Self-Assessment Questions - 5
Whenever there is breach of a contract, the aggrieved party becomes entitled to seek
remedies in any one or more of the following ways:
1. Rescission: The aggrieved party may decide not to take any legal action against the guilty
party but they can rescind the contract and need not perform their part of obligations
under the contract.
If the aggrieved party decides to sue the guilty party for damages for breach of contract,
they have to file a suit for rescission. When the court grants rescission, the aggrieved party
is freed from all their obligations under the contract; and becomes entitled to
compensation for damages.
2. Suit for damages: Damages are monetary compensation allowed for the loss suffered by
the aggrieved party as a result of the breach of contract. By granting damages, the court
aims not to punish but to compensate. Damages are not awarded if actual loss cannot be
proved.
i) Ordinary damages: These are damages that are awarded for direct consequences
of the breach of contract.
ii) Special damages: Special damages arise because of special or unusual
circumstances affecting the plaintiff. Special damages cannot be claimed as a
matter of right. Such damages must be in contemplation of the parties at the time
when the contract is made.
iii) Exemplary damages: The cardinal principle of damages is to award compensation
to the aggrieved party. However, damages may be awarded with a view to
punishing the guilty party as in the following cases:
a) Breach of a promise to marry which may have caused mental injury to the
aggrieved party.
b) Wrongful dishonour of a cheque by a banker though there are sufficient funds
to the credit of the customer.
iv) Nominal damages: Nominal damages are awarded when the breach has occurred
due to a technical violation and no actual loss has been caused to the aggrieved
party. These are token damages.
v) Damages for inconvenience and discomfort: The aggrieved party can claim damages
for physical discomfort and inconvenience caused due to the breach of contract.
vi) Liquidated damages and penalty: Liquidated damages means a pre-determined
sum fixed at the time of the formation of the contract. It is a fair and genuine pre-
estimate of the probable loss that would be payable in case of a breach of contract.
vii) Penalty is the specified sum which is in excess of the loss likely to be caused due to
breach of contract.
viii) Stipulation for interest: The payment of interest may or may not be in the nature of
penalty. The court adjudicates whether interest is payable or not, and from which
date on a case-to-case basis.
ix) Forfeiture of security deposits: Certain contracts stipulate the forfeiture of security
in case of a breach of contract.
3. Suit for specific performances: The aggrieved party may file a suit to seek the court’s
direction to compel the defaulting party to perform his/her part of the contract.
4. Suit upon quantum meruit: It is a claim for equitable compensation for partial
performance of the contract. ‘Quantum Meruit’ literally means ‘as much as is earned’ or ‘in
proportion to the work done’. A party can claim compensation for the work already done.
5. Suit for an Injunction: ‘Injunction’ is an order from the court directing a party to do a
certain act or to restrain the party from doing a certain act.
Self-Assessment Questions - 6
8. SUMMARY
• Contracts are an indispensable part of our lives. We enter into various types of contracts
in our everyday life. Whenever we buy something or enjoy some service we agree to pay
a certain amount of money to the seller or service provider and he agrees to give us that
something. Indian Contract Act, 1872 is the most important law governing contracts.
• An agreement enforceable by law is a contract. ICA provides the framework within
which the contract may be entered into, executed; and also makes provisions for dealing
with breach of the contract.
• A contract becomes valid when there is proper offer and acceptance between the parties
who have the legal capacity to contract. There must be an intention to create a legal
relationship, free consent of the parties, lawful consideration for promise, competent
parties and the object of the contract must be lawful.
• Contracts can be classified according to the following criteria:
i) Enforceability by law: Valid, voidable, void, unenforceable and Illegal or unlawful
contracts.
ii) Mode of Creation: Express, implied, constructive, quasi, wagering or contingent
contracts.
iii) Extent of execution: Executed or executory contracts.
• The parties making an agreement must be legally competent to contract. In India anyone
who is a major, is of sound mind and is not debarred by law is entitled to contract.
• A contract is discharged or terminated when both the parties fulfil their rights and
obligations as per the contract. It may be discharged by performance, mutual agreement,
subsequent or supervening impossibility or illegality, lapse of time, operation of law or
breach of contract.
• When there is breach of a contract, the aggrieved party becomes entitled to seek
redressal through rescission or a suit for damages, specific performance, quantum
meruit or injunction.
In the above sections, we have discussed the general principles relating to the Indian
Contracts Act, 1872. Further, contracts can be classified into several types such as Bailment,
Pledge, Indemnity and Guarantee. These are contracts which are entered into for specific
reasons. For example, indemnity is the type of contract in which “one person promises to
save the other from the loss caused to him by the conduct of the promisor himself or by the
conduct of any other person” (Sec.124 of the Indian Contract Act). Here, one person
undertakes to compensate for the loss suffered by another. Similarly, bailment, pledge and
guarantee are types of contracts which are entered into for specific reasons. However, it is
important to note that for these specific contracts, all the principles relating to general
contracts hold good and there are certain unique conditions which apply to them, over and
above the general principles.
9. GLOSSARY
Ab-initio: From the beginning
Breach: Breaking of a promise or agreement
Contingent: Dependent on uncertain events or circumstances
Damages: Financial compensation for loss or injury
Injunction: Judicial order restraining a person or body from an act
Insolvency: Legally recognised inability to pay debts
Quantum Meruit: In proportion to the work done
Quasi: Apparently/seemingly
Revocation: Withdrawal
Supervening: Interrupting
Voidable: That can be rendered illegal
Void: Invalid, not legally binding
Wagering: Based on betting
11. ANSWERS
Self-Assessment Questions:
1. False
2. True
3. False
4. Promise, set of promises, consideration
5. Positive, negative
6. Proposer, propose
7. Communicated
8. True
9. False
10. False
11. Void ab-initio
12. Unsound
13. Friend, enemy
14. Foreign sovereigns and ambassadors
15. Novation
16. Remission
17. Supervening impossibility
18. False
19. False
20. True
21. True
Terminal Questions:
1. A valid contract must fulfil certain essential conditions like proper offer and acceptance,
legal capacity of parties to contract etc. For more details refer to section 3.
2. Offer and acceptance must be made as per the provisions of ICA. (Section 3)
3. Contracts can be classified according to enforceability by law, mode of creation and
extent of execution. For more details refer to section 4.
4. Parties making a contract must have the legal capacity to contract. For more details refer
to section 5.
5. A contract may be terminated or discharged in various ways. For more details refer to
section 6.
6. An aggrieved party can seek redressal in case the other party breaches the contract. For
more details refer to section 7.
References:
• Bedi, Suresh. (2004). Business Environment. Excel Books, New Delhi.
• Tulsian P.C. (2000). Business Law. Tata McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Ltd. New
Delhi.
• Pathak, Akhileshwar. (2007). Legal Aspects of Business. Tata McGraw- Hill Publishing
Company Ltd. New Delhi.