Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Several complexones and amino compounds have been investigated as to their ability to form alkali-stable
coordination compounds with iron, which can be used as mediators for the indirect electrochemical reduction of
dispersed organic dyestuffs with different structures. A characterisation of the reducing efficiency can be
obtained when the cathodic current maxima of the mediator solution containing the dyestuff is compared with
the cathodic peak current without the reducible vat dye.
Published on 01 January 1993 on http://pubs.rsc.org | doi:10.1039/FT9938902451
In the textile industry the use of vat dyes, indigo and sulfur trochemical reduction of anthraquinones.'** In a further pos-
dyestuffs is of great importance for cellulosic textiles. About sible reaction mechanism a second electron transfer from a
30% of the textile products manufactured from cellulosic reduced mediator to a radical anion cannot be excluded,
fibres are coloured with such dyes. In the application of these, which also gives one fully reduced dyestuff dianion as a reac-
Downloaded by Duke University on 26 December 2012
powerful reducing agents must be used in order to reduce the tion product [eqn. (4)]. In an additional reaction the equi-
dispersed oxidised dyestuff particles. In the reduced form librium between the fully reduced dyestuff molecules and the
these particles are dissolved in alkaline aqueous solutions, insoluble oxidized form of the dye is built up [eqn. (5)].
and then the dye shows a great affinity for the cellulosic fibre. Although a theoretical treatment of the complex reactions
After the adsorption of the dyestuff an oxidation step leads to was not attempted, a qualitative discussion gives valuable
the insoluble oxidized, well fixed form. information on the reaction mechanism. Eqn. (1)-(5) give no
The reducing agents in technical use today are mainly indication as to which requirements a ligand has to fulfill.
Na,S,O, , organic sulfinates, organic ketoalcohols or carbo- The following experiments, however, show that fewer ligands
hydrates such as glucose.' The main disadvantage of these can be applied practically than was previously expected.
reducing agents is that their reduced form cannot be regener- The general requirements for a ligand to form coordination
ated. In particular, the surplus reducing agent causes severe compounds that are usable as mediators are: (i) the forma-
problems in the textile waste-water treatment. tion of stable coordination compounds with Fe" and Fe"' in
In the literature an attempt to solve the reduction prob- an alkaline medium, (ii) reversible charge transfer from Fe"'
lems by means of a direct electrolytic process is described.2 It to Fe", whereby minimal dissociation of the complex occurs,
was, however shown that only an indirect electrolysis process (iii) sufficient negative redox potential in alkaline solution, at
has the potential for a technical replacement of the one-way least -600 mV for indigo, or better -1OOO mV us.
reducing chemical^.^ Ag I AgClI3 mol dm-' KCl, to reduce all vat dyestuffs com-
Bechtold et ~ 1 have found that the coordination com-
. ~ 9 ' monly used in the textile industry, (iv) a high rate of electron
pounds of iron with triethanolamine and diethanolamine can transfer from the cathode to the oxidized Fe'" complex, (v) a
be used as mediators for the indirect reduction of dispersed large number of catalytic cycles (possibility for multiple reuse
organic dyestuffs. The reduced forms of these complexes, espe- of the dyeing liquor) and (vi) rapid electron transfer from the
cially the more stable complexes with triethanolamine as reduced form of the mediator to the oxidized dyestuff.
ligand, are well suited to reducing the dispersed dyestuffs. In this work the results are given of a large number of
A general reaction scheme for such an electrochemical screening experiments on the ability of the so-called
process can be established as follows: 'complexones' '3'' to act as ligands and the characterization
of the alkali-stable iron coordination compounds that are
Fe3+L+ e- + F e 2 + L (1) suitable as mediators.
Fe2+L + D y e e F e 3 + L + Dye'- (2)
To obtain more information about the reaction mechanism
of the redox reactions between the iron complexes and the
2 Dye'- s Dye2- + Dye (3) dispersed dyestuffs, photometric investigations using a stirred
flow apparatus were performed. After optimization of the
Dye'- + Fe2+L+Dye2- + Fe3+L (4) concentrations of the dyestuffs and of the iron" complexes
Dye2- =Dye + 2e- (5) used as reducing agents, the progress of the reduction step
was studied by varying the steady-state conditions in the
In the first reduction step the iron complex is cathodically photometric celI.
reduced [eqn. (l)] in a reversible electrochemical p r o ~ e s s . ~
The reduced complexes diffuse from the electrode towards the
dyestuff particles. At the surface of the dispersed particle a Experimental
one-electron charge transfer occurs [eqn. (2)]. Since the dyes The different ligands, the NaOH and the Fe2(S0,),.6H20
investigated require two electrons for the reduction of each (22% Fe content) used were of analytical grade. The dye
molecule, the primary formation of a radical anion is sup- systems investigated were technical products : indanthrene
posed according to the reaction mechanism of Cu' ions with yellow G (CI vat yellow 1) BASF, brillant indigo 4B-D (CI
1-bromoanthraquinone in aqueous solution.6 Two radical vat blue 5 ) BASF, hydron blue 3R Stabilosol (CI sulphur vat
anions are assumed to give one fully reduced molecule and to blue 43) Hoechst. Indanthrene yellow G is a dyestuff with
regenerate one molecule in its oxidized form [eqn. (3)], in anthraquinoid structure (l),brillant indigo 4B-D is a techni-
agreement with the reaction path observed by the direct elec- cal preparation of 5,5,5',7'-tetrabromindigo(2). Hydron blue
View Article Online
3R consists of reaction products of carbazolindophenol with cipitated iron hydroxide, the solution was made up to 500
sodium polysulfide and its structure is not fully defined, but cm3. The dye component was dispersed separately
the existence of reducible disulfide groups must be accepted (indanthrene yellow G 0.5 g dmd3, brillant indigo 4B-D 2 g
as a fact (3)' ' dm-3, hydron blue 3R 0.5 g dm-3). The solutions to be
0 investigated were prepared by mixing the mediator solution
with an adequate volume of the dye stock solution.
The apparatus used for the experiments was a 264 A
Potentiostat (EG&G, Princeton, NJ) with a 303A HMDE-
electrode (small drop size, drop area 0.96 x lo-, cm2). A
platinum wire served as the counter-electrode. The cyclic
voltammograms were recorded on an X-Y recorder
1 (Rikadenki, Tokyo). All potentials were measured against an
Ag I AgCl I sat. KCl reference electrode. The scan rates re-
ported are given in mV s-'. The test solutions were aerated
for at least 4 min with N, to eliminate interfering oxygen.
The photometric experiments were performed with a
Published on 01 January 1993 on http://pubs.rsc.org | doi:10.1039/FT9938902451
:::p,
For use as mediator a high number of catalytic cycles
should be possible in the indirect electrolysis process. The
reversibility of the charge-transfer reaction is a very impor-
tant property in such mediator systems. The linearity of the
Downloaded by Duke University on 26 December 2012
-
h
\a
0.10
order mechanism a relatively high excess of dispersed
material is necessary, which leads to interfering direct elec-
trode reactions caused by the reaction of the adsorbed dye-
0.05 stuff particles at the electrode surface, and by the auxiliaries
which are added to the technical product formulation to
assure the necessary fine distribution in water. (ii) The
0 5 10 15 20 25 reduced dyestuff molecule is soluble in the aqueous alkaline
solution and leaves the surface of the dyestuff particle,
Jv/mV1/2 s- ' 1 2 thereby building up a reversible redox system. (iii) The full
Fig. 1 Dependence of the cathodic peak current (ZJd for a soiution reduction of the dyestuff requires two electrons; but the iron
of Fe,(SO4),-6H,O (1.57 x lo-' mol dm-') in (a) Hedta (0.03 mol complex provides only one electron for the reduction, so that
drn-,) and (b) bicine (0.03 mol dm-3) in alkaline solution (NaOH 0.2 after the transfer of the first electron, either dispro-
mol dm-3) on the square root of the scan rate portionation of two dyestuff radicals or a second electron
View Article Online
n
P
zn2
lj
na
v
\
Published on 01 January 1993 on http://pubs.rsc.org | doi:10.1039/FT9938902451
0
0 I
.,
I I I
Downloaded by Duke University on 26 December 2012
1.6
1.4
1.2
1 I n 4 \
8 1.0
s0 0.8
2 0.6
m
0.4
0.2
0
350 400 450 500 550 600 650 70
0
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 L/nm
[indanthrene yellow G]/g dm-3
.,
Fig. 9 Absorption spectra of a solution containing FeSO4.7H,O
Fig. 7 Enhancement factor (Zp)J(Zp)d as a function of dyestuff con- (2.5 g dm-, 9.0 x lo-, rnol drn-,), Hedta-trisodium salt (10 g
centration (indanthrene yellow G) at various scan rates in the system drn-,, 0.02 mol drn-,), NaOH (4 g drn-,, 0.1 mol drn-,) and indan-
Fe,(S04),-6H,0 (1.57 x lo-' mol drn-,), Hedta (0.03 mol dm-,) threne yellow G (1 g drn-,) at different reaction times: (1) 4.5 s, (2)
and NaOH (0.29 mol dm-'). o/mV s-': 5 ; *, 20; x , 100; A,500. 16.1 s, (3) 32.2 s, (4) 64 s, ( 5 ) 187 s
View Article Online
2456 J. CHEM. SOC. FARADAY TRANS., 1993, VOL. 89
0.8
8 0.6
A and decreasing enhancement factors are calculated at higher
scan rates. A current plateau, which is typical for electro-
chemical reactions with fast catalytic regeneration of the
reactants, is reached only at very low scan rates.
A detailed kinetic analysis based on the existing electro-
chemical data and photometric experiments becomes very
complex because the simultaneously occurring reactions have
0.2 not yet enabled a mathematical solution to be found.
The results prove that bicine and Hedta are well suited to
forming iron complexes which can act as mediators for the
0 -
350 400 450 500 550 600 650 71 indirect electrochemical reduction of dispersed dyestuffs.
While Hedta iron complexes are favourable mediators for the
I/nm
Fig. 10 Absorption spectra of solution containing, FeSO, .7H,O
reduction of indigo, sulfur vat dyes and vat dyes with low
(1.25 g dm-3, 4.5 x mol dm-3), triethanolamine (10 g dm-3, reduction potential, the bicine complexes can produce
Published on 01 January 1993 on http://pubs.rsc.org | doi:10.1039/FT9938902451
0.067 mol dm-3), NaOH (2.5 g dm-3, 0.063 mol dm-3) and brillant reduction potentials of -850 mV and are therefore the more
indigo 4B-D (1 g dm-3) at different reaction times: (1) 4.5 s, (2) 8.2 s, universal reducing agents. Comparing these results with those
(3) 16.1 s, (4) 32.2 s, (5) 93 s of the experiments using TEA and DEA,4 it is remarkable
that all ligands which fulfil the above cited requirements
contain an N-(2-hydroxyethyl)amino group in their molecu-
Summarizing the results given in Fig. 5-8 a discussion of lar structure.
Downloaded by Duke University on 26 December 2012
the relative rate constants is possible. Under the experimental The investigations on the electrochemical behaviour of the
conditions, especially at lower scan rates, the enhancement Hedta and the bicine complexes in the presence of dispersed
factors increase with higher dyestuff concentrations, so the organic dyestuffs show that the use of iron-amine complexes
velocity of the redox reaction between the reduced form of for indirect electrochemical reduction is a generally applic-
the mediator and the oxidised form of the dyestuff according able method. By selecting the necessary mediator system to
to eqn. (2) is rate determining. The lack of detectable reach the required reduction potential and adjusting the elec-
amounts of intermediate dyestuff radicals resulting from a trode material and surface, the reaction conditions can be
reaction according to eqn. (3) or (4) proves that none of these optimised fairly easily.
steps is rate determining.
Generally the enhancement factors decrease with increas-
ing scan rate and the CV curves become more similar to the The authors are indebted to the Fonds zur Forderung der
reversible case. As the electrode reaction of the mediator Wissenschaftlichen Forschung (Austria, P 7957-CHE) for
[eqn. (l)] is faster than the redox reaction according to eqn. financial support of this work.
(2) the influence of reoxidation of the mediator by the reac-
tion with oxidised dye molecules decreases at high scan rates
on the CV timescale. The reaction rate according to eqn. (2)
References
1 U. Baumgarte, Melliand Textilber., 1987,68, 189; 276.
1.4 2 E. H. Daruwalla, TextileAsia, 1975, 165.
3 T. Bechtold, E. Burtscher, D. Gmeiner and 0. Bobleter, Tex-
1.2 tilveredlung, 1990,25, 221.
4 T. Bechtold, E. Burtscher, D. Gmeiner and 0. Bobleter, J. Elec-
1 .o troanal. Chem., 1991,306, 169.
5 T. Bechtold, E. Burtscher, A. Amann and 0. Bobleter, Angew.
8 0.8 Chem., 1992,104,1046.
C
6 H. Zollinger, Color Chemistry, VCH, Weinheim, 1987.
5 0.6 7 S. I. Bailey, Chem. Aust., 1982,50, 202.
a 8 D. 0. Wipf, K. R. Wehmeyer and R. M. Wightman, J. Org.
% 0.4 Chem., 1986,51,4760.
9 B. J. J. Engbers and G. Dierkes, Textilpraxis Int., 1992,47, 365.
0.2 10 G. Andregg, in Comprehensive Coordination Chemistry, ed.
Geoffrey Wilkinson, Pergamon Press, Oxford 1987, vol. 2, p.
0
3J 400 450 500 550 600 650
I
777.
1 1 M. Schubert, 2. Angew. Chem., 1948, @A, 141.
I/nm 12 R. S. Nicholson and I. Shain, Anal. Chem., 1964,36,706.
Fig. 11 Absorption spectra of a solution containing FeSO, * 7H,O 13 E. Steckhan, Angew. Chem., 1986,98,681.
(2.5 g dm-3, 9.0 x mol dm-3), Hedta trisodium salt (10 g dm-3 14 H. Lund and J. Simonet, J. Electroanal. Chem., 1975,65,205.
0.02 mol dm-3), NaOH (4 g dm-3, 0.1 mol dmb3)and hydron blue
3R (1 g dm-3) at different reaction times: (1) 4.5 s, (2) 8.2 s, (3) 16.1 s,
(4)32.2 s, (5) 93 s Paper 2/05447G; Received 12th October, 1992