HOBAS| eae) aha SO (@. Oils yan A3BYKA-KAACCUKAHOBAA meee Sea) ; iene fore Mane enm eure umue need (ei fom MI AXAUA TOBMTCA WIACTEALCTROM B COTPYAHMYECTBE C De rol ue MLA so olce ere ceo TE eA \¥4I A | ui el seer te Miro den Nt -rea Wiel on t= om Ere nmUr elo erm Muon yc ager i oiso) MCKYCCTG. YYVTRIBOIOWION NEPECMOTPSHHbIE: M1 BHOBb YCTCHOBASHHHIE CPOKTH! M MCNOAbSy- souwon Gorareswume MOTePUaARI 1 KOHLENUAM, Piece ialus Meese erenie Lm ielelo cre geredi kee Ecol etl Bea fel 111} Ka@kAGA KHUTG, KOK NPABMAG. NPYHAAAe- MUT NEPY OAHOTO ABTOPA MW HECeT YepTEI ero Paw Aas tse seals a ee Tae MAST OTHOCHTEAHOR CBOBOAG GBTOPCKGM MH- TEPNPSTALIMM XYAOKECTBEHHBIX SIBACHKIA Vi CO- Loe ake cals samc MEL a k=) s)7.° eles Pcyer s RerN reea slo eLiter Reale) olan foo Beco eeumeMen Me comme cey MaCTepG WM NPOMaBeAeHMA WekyCCTEa Bo3- FCoE ae acon =) ee ae) arenes) OTMYLUEHHOrO VIM XVUSHEHHOFO CPOka, HO M HO 3HOUMTEABHOA BDEMEHHOM AMCTOHLUMH, Mouxann 1Opbesvm TepMcH, WaBeCTHBIA ne- isle oncent meaty) 1a eu gerent Lo McA yoo Reena nee erie ere rere eL()cic npocbeccop. astop Gonee Tonauiatw KHur 4 Sone claro omelet Nas meesl |e.) ero uHTepecos — ucKyccTao 3anaaa XVIIL— XX B@KO8, PYCCKMA GBGHTApPA, TEOPYeCTEO. felel ele hme er ULce ee We Lae M. 10. Tepmanua HavGonee visBeCTHE: «AHTBEP- eM mee ATL Mn nc i cole oar eee ol Ghee ee lace mht amb ac) «AnGep MapKe» (1995), «Muxava BpyGenb» Qi Mserra a im cenr ue tCma ba) Mee ube) memyapos «Caa@kHoe npoweauies» (2000), «Mopyekckan WkKOAG» (2003) 4 Ap. Kavra M, lO. TepMaHa — HECOMHEHHO, Lorelle Me oe era Cornel ort erent Te): Ite Hiv. OHA NPeACTABAHeET CAO MKHYIO M MHOrO- Loe eM ce erence ae a en 8) 10) te ere ee tee Mt ebe)-\sle soe Ue, Loecticdeciecter ene helene terd os Sens eke iu ame el an UeelLe! Mee os Bt eT TakMx MacTepoB, KOK Ce3qHH, Toe ce ereemmL colt el dai Mae Alcott oF Loner Palos oaks AMC Lae) Uti OPvIVHOALHOCTS GBTOPCKOA KOHWeNUM, He- felottt terior e\ anverh ti meceren iste MOAOVIBECTHEK MANOCTDGLIMA NOSBOASIOT HO- 3B0Tb STOT TPYA HOBOTOPCKUM, WWW, AZBOOKA.RU — a) Le oe.aAlpesumii Bocrox Jipesuss Tpeuusa Apesuni Pum Pannee Cpeanesekospe Pomanckuit nepuon Toruxa Mcxyccerso Bu3sanTun Bospoxgenne. Urania. XIV—XV Beka Bospoxyenne. Mranus. XVI nex Bospoxyenne. Tepmanna, Ppanuua, Tommanana Hosoe spema. Mcxycerso u kyabrypa XVII-XVII pexos Esponelickwit KiaccHyH3M Esporeiickoe ucxyccrBno XTX Beka Monxepuusm, Mckyccrso nepsoit nonoBMHbI XX pexa TlocrmojepHu3MMuxann TEPMAH MOAEPHH3M Mcxyccrso nepsoli nonoBuHbI XX Beka Canxr-Ilerep6ypr Hanareanctro «AS BYKA-KJIACCHKA» 2003" YAK 7.0 BBK 85.1 T 38 Cepua ~HOBAA HCTOPHA HCKYCCTBA- Asrop npoexra aoxrop nckyccrnosenems C. M. JAHM9JIb Apropcxtit kouexrim cepun: JI. Vi, AKAMOBA, goxrop nexyceraoncacnis M. 10, PEPMAH, aoxtop ucxyccrsoneacnia C. M. JAHHSJIb, aoxtop uckyccrmovegcna TC. KOANAKOBA, xaragar uckyccrsonezena LU. HECCEJIDUITPAYC, kanaursar uckyeersonenennst B. V1. PAS IOJIBCKAA, kangugar uckyccronejenias A.B, CTEHAHOB, xanaunar ncxyccraoncacnaa A. K. AKHMOBM4L, aoxrop icxycersopeacnia Odopmacnue ncpensera B. B. MOKA AEBA Macer JI. H. KHCEIEBOH, B. T. JOUIMKCAPEBOR Mog6op wucerpauuit M. 10, [EPMAHA Toarorosxa ixinocrpanuit B, A, MAKAPOBA Matermoit yxasarean H. B. XMEJIEBCKHX ISBN 5352008140 © M. Fepwan, rexcr, noa6op WuLIO © KC BOCHpH HItMaa CaM aBaHTapA Kak MCTOUHIK, HOBYIO K1aCCHKy, CHCTEMY Tpit WHINIOR, KOTOPy® CKOpee pasuiBar, HEXEN NOABEpran COMHEH WO man onposcprat. 1 ppirieccHHere B snurpad cnona 2KaKo6a: «3aa- MCHHE NpOMSBCACHIA MCKYCCTBa — B HEM CaMOM, a He B Mpeano- JaraeMbIx CpaBHCHMSIX C pCaTbHOCTIOm’ — BNOMHE MoryT BOcHpH- HMMaTbCA OFHOMM M3 CaMbIX ACHCTBREHHBIX NOCTOAHHBIX BENMUHH MowepHHgMa. [pt sceit sHauntenbuoctn 1 oGbemHocTH HcTopHorpadun XX Beka, KaK HHKOMa CHEMMBUIEH MHCaTh HCTOpHO He KyCCTBa COG crscHHoro Bpemcin, B Heit erKo NpocMaTpuBaetca HtaBecTHaM ar PECCHBHOCTD, paBHO Kak M HAIMEHHOCTS 10 OTHOMICHINO K pes e~ crayoumi snoxaM. Sto ecrecTaeHHo. O aHKOBHHHBIx repemenax B HCKYCCTRE HOBOFO CTOMETHA XOTEIM M PellAtich NMCaTh HMCHHO npvitactibie ero Talinam. Acropua coppemMeHHore MCKyCCTBa H Mpo- AODKACT IMCATHCA Malle BCCFO KaK CO aNOAOLUA, NOCKOABKY OHO HYALVIOCH HM HYKLACTCH B ZANTE OT MHOFOUMCICHHDIX HanlaloK, a eme 8 Sonbinelt Mepe — B nocTomHHoli HHTepmpeTanst, TOAKOBA- HUH, Gea KOTOPLIX He COCOGHO GbITS MOAHONEHHO BOCMpHUATO. A TONKOBAHHE HENPHBLMHOLO H MHOPHM HEBHATHOPO S3bIKa AONIK- Ho NOCTOMHHO MoKpeNAATECA yrREPAACHHEM ETO HeOGXOAHMOCTH H HOBH3HDI. Heymepernrii BocTopr no noBogy copepinenHott Hosein 1c KYCCTBOM PeROMONHH MpeACTABIETCA CTOMb 2K GeCCMbICAENTILIM, CKO 1 (PHAHNTHKH HAH MpoHTA B ee aapec. B 210G0M HcKyccTRE €CTb COM BEPIIMHbI, CBO MOTePH, CRON OTKPHITHA H CBOf CATOH. Tipu stom, kak enpanewumo 3amersin Kosmmirsyn, 8 ucropim 1e- Kyectea, B OTNMUNE OT HayKH, TexHHtKH, diLIocodun, mo6oit nep- Of KOHMATCH ynaAKOM', TEM CAMBIM «BePINHHbI> PasHbIX 3T10X CO BpeMeHeM «ypaBHHBalorcn B MIpapax», UTo xe KacaeTCa KaecTREH- HbIX KPHTepHes, TO MOXKHO OOpaTHTbCA K CyaccHHo Tajamepa (mpo- HPHOpHpoBaHHOMy ajlentaMyt «BHCONCHOUKOID’, «roctMomepHNICT- cxoit» xytoxkecTBCHHO! KPHTHKH, AcKTapupylonelt OOpraHo CROC RocxmeHne ati iecopom): «Coppemennintii xyoxHIIK HC CTOMKO THOPEH, CKOABKO OTKPBE BaTenb HeBHaHHoro, Gorce Toro, OH — M306peTaTeNb eme HUKOTAA He CyIeCTHOBaBINCTO, KOTOPOE Hepes Hero NPOHMKaeT B ACieTBH TeabHocth Sarria. [pimcuatcabio, otaKo, To Mepa, KOTOpolt OH NofeilaCTCH, MOXOXKE, Ta Ke CAMAH, C KOTOPO!! NOAA K OLCH MOEPHHSM, Hexyccrso nepeoy monogamy XX BenaKe TROPYECTBA XYOKHHKA C HesanamsTHEIX BpeMen. Ona Sputa BbIpaxkena Apuctotesem (1a 1 KaKHX TOKO MbICSeit MbI He Haii- mem y ApHCTOTe.As!): HCTHHHOe TROPEH He — TO, B KOTOPOM HET Iyc- ‘TOT H HET HHYEFO SHMIHETO, K KOTOPOMY HeYero NPHOABHTh HOT KoToporo Hetero yGasnTD. Hpocras, cypowam Mepan’. Hamenenvia b ricxycctse, mpunecerttie XX wexom, ne noKaaKyT- CH BAYMUHBOMY 3PHTCMNO CANTIKOM YAMBHTENBHBIMH, CCAM OH 6yACT MMeTb B BITAY TY ONEBHARYIO, HO 4aCTO 3aGpMBaeMyIO HCTHHY, UTO HCKYCCTRO 9BOMONHOHPYeT BMECTE ¢ TOPOARAAIOMIC!! CTO %*KHSHBIO H NTO CTPeMHTeAbHOe HaMCHEHHe MAacTHYECKOTO ABDIKAa — He CTonpKo nepakHit SKCTIEPHMEHT, CKOADKO HCTOPHCCKH OBycnOBNEH- Has, ecTCCTReHHaa (BO MHOTOM Hf 3aIUITHas) peak Ha HOBBIC 1 conepmenHo Henprprurnie peatm XX croaetua. HcnoKon Bexor UCKYCCTBO BLITIOAHANO (PYHKIH CBOCTO POsa IMONHOHATBHBIX H HH TEMMEKTYANDHLIX AMOPTHSATOPOB MEX Ay PCaAbHOCTBO 1 YeTOBCTC- ckHM co3HaHHeM, 1B Hosoe Bpema Hx poab upesspruaiino BOspec- aa (HarpHMep, «tlosHTHBMCTCKOE 3epKato» HCKycCTBa XIX croseTHa cmenmoc 8 XX sexe «pas6ureim acpkatom», a 6biTb MoxeT, Hm 3a- 3EPKATBEM KYOHSMa, B KOTOPOM MO2XKHO pasMaAeTh ojHOBpEMeHHO ¢ pasHLre CTOpOH, B PAsHEIX paKypeaN H CABHHYTEIE MacurraGax ye MHYIO, HCBCAOMYIO, C TAKMM TpyOM BOCIPHHHMaeMy!> peatbHOCTD). «Hexycerso,— ncaa BuirorcKuit,— ects waxneiimee cpeaoroune BCcX GHONOTHICCKHX M1 CONMATBHBIX NPOICCCOB AMMHOCTH B OGUIC™ CTBe, CHOCOG ypasxosemuUsanUuA YeLogeKa € MUpoM (KYpCHB MOti.— M. 7) B cambie KpuTHuecKHe 1 OTRETCTREHHBIE MIHYTBI KU3HH>7, Hi nonaruo, 4To Ana YacTH AMIIb MHHTCH NOHATHBIM, HO Oc- TaCTCA SaKPIThIM H OTKPbIBAeTCA TOARKO HErpas~HOMy H HCKy- meuHomy Barasqy (cron BcnomunT Eacrepraka, ncammcro, «To (Matbpo). Camo xe HCKYCCTBO MoqepHHta ma o6oranact 4 O6OCTPHET Ky[bTypy, HeBMaHHO paciiHpaeT HM Mo- ApH pyeT ee BOIMOAHOCTH, BOBCE He paspymiasl H HHKAK We OBE Has KaccH4ecKoe Hacaeque. Ckopee HaoGopor. Henpeasaatitii SpHTelb, OTBELABINHH Npanlii H HapKOTHYEcKHi M0, MO,epHHa- Ma, OCTABAHCb BETO PEANbHOM KOHTEKCTE, C HOBLIM HHTEPECOM OT- KPOET H LEHHOCTh WACCHKH, 1 CBAIH «HOBeHIMMX KOAOB” C GpLIbIMH TaCTHMECKHMH CHCTeMaMH, HX eAHHCTRO, HX OOMYIO «KpoBeHOCHyIO cuctemy» Hecropua kyaprypht ApaMaTHuna, Nopoii B Heli cayyaloTes H Tpa- THYECKHE CTpaHHitbl, HO B COM OHa HCNOAHEHa ONTHMHaMa, 160: oTmc4aeT HenpepbiBHbiii npouecc OborameHHA Halcro AyXoBHOrO Mupa i, ® cymafocTH, He sHacT noTeps. PrsH4ecKoe paapymcHHe SWaHnii, OKMTAHMe KH WIM THpaHHa OPMUHOSHOH sCTETHKM — CIE cree MoACKOre NpoUsBOAa, HO MINKAK He 2%UBOTO 1 HeOOpaTHMorO. Mpoyecca xydowecmeennot sBOMOUMM, KorIcKTHBHAA NaMATb CO- Xpannet B ce6c Gace m cyMCe KyAbTYpbI, HH4CTO He TepsA. H ccan paraanyrp Ha ncropmio ickyceTa XX Beka C TOUKH 3pe- HII TOrO, 476 Ona OBpena, NaMATYs, ITO OHA MH4CTO He OTMCHITTA, can RoOpyKUTECA CraroxKe7TaTeNbHOI TepMUMOCTHIO, a He 9KCTPe- MHGMOM, KOTOPEIM OTMCYCHEI paBHo HM ropgearMEblit HeraTHEM3M KOHCEPBATOPOR, H BCCHAHAA BOCTOPACHHOCTh ATENTOB aK TYATbHO- CTH, TO H34€Cb HET NOBOAOB JIA COMHEHHiT: ymreqm Mit XX Bex mper- Craver nepes Ham He TOADKO It He CTOAKO INOXOI GopKGDE H 110- ‘Tepb, HO BPeMeHEM XOTE H HE-TEEKO JOCTUTHYTEIX, HO — O6peTenuit. eee Ceppesneiimas npoSzeMa, scraromad neper awropom, Hecaesy- 1oMLMM HcTOpMIO HcKyccrBa XX croreTHs,— B OMMOBpeMcHHOCTH onpesennompx cc COOH, B HeHCHOCTH IpHopirteToB, B Heuer: KocTH qMMAMHKH. Uo, B CyINMOCTH, ECTb MaBHoe AMIEHMe HCTOPUH HCKyeCTBa? Han papacune, ataans KoTOporo nosBoadeT OnpescanTtD BaakHel init eKTop ee sBIKeHHa? Tame Bcero HMeHHO MOCIEAO- BaTEABHOE PaCCMOTPEHHE XYAOXKECTBCHHEIX PpyIIMPOBOK H Hampas- JCHHi CTAHOBUTCH ONPEAENAIONIHM METO LOM TpyAOB NO HeTOpHH Hc kyccTpa XX pexka. Mu AnBHAyaABHOCTL Kpynneimero Macrepa, cTaBilero BbI- PasHTeNeM BPeMeHH H cro MaBHeHINHX xynoRKecTREHHBIX KaTeCTR? PaccMoTpenne «BepmnH» HacacqHa WeHTpabHbIx dpuryp HcKyccT- Ba TOKE HepeAKO MCNONbayeTCA B KAYeCTBC TIpHHUHMa NOCTpocHHA HCTOpH4eCKOO HECAeZOBaH HA Vat, waxoney, oTACALMEIC MpoMsne_enHA, craops- IWICCA BEXAMH, NOBOPOTHDIMH MYHKTaMH, OTKpbIBAlOMHMH HOBOC puacHne? Dro nociesree ckopee HEMOpupyerca HCC ACROBATELAMH BRE DEMME14 TIpHantinee n ecTecTReHHce paccMaTpHBaTh, CKMKEM, HCTOPHIO AMTepary pwr To TepcCoHarHaM 1 HalHOHaAbHbIM mnkenaM. Tak, pac- cMotpenne Thopyectsa Toactoro npeamectayer paccmoTpenimo reopuectsa JoctoescKoro”, Jocroerckoro — Uexosa, ananna bpannysckoit auTepatypsr creqyer 3a anarnsom pyecKoit (Ma Ha- oBopor) Hr. A, ‘Tpadituonnaa HeTopua nTepatyphl (H¢eKyceTBa, TeaTpa HT. A.) OSpHO HE HecregyeT ABIOKEHHE OT, Hapumep, «JleTcTBa» (1852) JI. Teacroro x pomany @aoGepa «Focnoxa Bonapy, taneuatanHo- MY, kak M ToaCToBckas « Maxesitua, manincpect Mapunerrn? Te pac- HodaraiOTCs Te BAPBIBHBIE CIYCTKH NpOS.eM HM HCTOUHMKM pasBHTHs NcKyccTBa, KoTOpEIe ONpeyeRsLOT camry ero HeTOpMIO? B KaKoM KOH TEKCTE H B KaKOM BpeMeHHOM NepHone paccMaTpHpata, HanpHMep, CTO YHUKaAbHble (buryppl, kak Naum Cytun wi Mopaiyy? K kako My Hanpa7eHiio MoxkHO (1 Moxkito 11 Boobie) OTHECTH Taya Knee, PpaBHo 3HadHMOrO JIA sBOMONMM skCIpeccHoHMama, Aaya, abcTpakT- HOTO HCKYCCTBA H jwKe Cloppeati3Ma? ITH BoMpoce! HE MoryT OBITS pemenss a priori, Ho Ges Hx NocTaHOBKN 11H XOTS Gb! OGOsHAYeHHs aBTOP PHCKYeT BILACTh B TPawHNHOHHbIi Hepeckas H, BO BCAKOM Cly- dae, OO peub CeOA Ha Te NPHBHIMHBIe, MHOFOKPaTHO HCTOABIOBAHHDIE CTPYKTYpHBIe CxeMLI, KOTOPHIE MoryT CTaTH Nperpanoit Ha HyTH K CO- BPeEMeHHOMY NOHMMaHMio HcKyccTBa XX Beka. MOAEPHNSM, HexyecrBo nepBoA nozoBKHe XX BexaCelivac cranopnTca Bce Gonee O4eBIAHDIM, 4TO paccMaTpuBaTh ueToprio Hoseiimero nckyccTBa Kak YepeqoBaHnte wrt Maake Cocy- MecTBOBAHHE yCTOH4IBBIX (HE CTOAKO B PCAIDHOCTH, CKOIBKO B11C- Topnorpadun) o6besuiHcHHit 1 TeHAeHITA — OT cositama Hn aKc- mpeccuonnama « yrypuamy, KyOnamy, opdamy u KONCTpyKTH- BHOMy, Jalee K MypHaMy, GecipeaMeTHOMY McKyCCTBY, aqau3My, metausnueckomy rckyeeTBy, COppeamnsMy ctc — SHadHT MOAMe- HATH [MAICKTHMCCKH A aHaMa H MOCTpocHHe XoTh MpHGananTenb HbIX KAYECTBCHHBIX HEpapxH4CCKHX CTPYKTYP CBOCTO posta HCTOPH- ucckoit muBeHTapusancit. Eme Goce Secnepcnextiaxo YeMaTpHBaTh OcHOBHOe MpoTHB0- pede BPeMCHH B NIPAMOM ONMOsHHH: PurypaTnBHoe—Hed@urypa- THBHo, Tem Gorce u osu3M, HW KYGHSM, H OTLCABHbIC KpyNHeimue acrepa Havana Beka (Maricc, KanguetcKnit, Kacc, Manresa, Mor Apia ut Ap.), KasK {bri o-CRoemy, OTKPpIBaIoT pOpory Kk GecupeaMeT- not (XOTH H He KaxBI HET MO Hei 70 KOHMA). K Toy %e a6CO- juoTHaa a6cTpakuyis eypa an AOCTINKHMA (Kak, BIIpoweM, 1 aGCoMIOT- Has MpeaMeTHocTb). BepoaTHo, CTpyKTypa H HHAMMKa HCKyceTBa XX cka peamsycTca B KaKHXTO HHBIX CH¢TeMOOOpasyioMx ABC HVLAX Hl TCHRCHIAX. Moxsio npeqnioaoxkuTe ¢ HaBecTHOI ZoTelt yecpeHHOCTH, UTO He TOKO AOCTOMHEIE TeopeTHUECKHe CouMHEHIA Mactepos XX weKxa (Kananucknii, Kee), Ho 1 rpomkue MporpaMMBl, MaHMpecrbl, Cyb- Gbt pasMHMEbIX PPYTM, HX, CCI YTOAHO, MOUTH aBAHTHOPHBIC HAH, BO BCAKOM CayYae, BECbMa SAHHMAaTCDHBIC HCTOpHH C sTlaTaaKeM, CKAH a JaMM, MHOCO3HA4HMTCIDHDIMM 3AXBACHMAMI 1 KHBOIMCHBIMIT eKOpa umm (Monmaprp, Monnaprac, HbioiiopxcKuit Apceran, [punenu LILUYDK, NpeACTasenne «[oGespi Hag COAHIEM™, acts pyTypHcToB, Gye TASH, AWWANCTOB 1 Mp.) B IHAYNTEALHOD Mepe MCUIaIOT YBHACTb HHL OT YCTO He 3ABHCHMOE 3HAYCHME CaMHX XYAOAHMKOB, @ LIABHOE, HX pabor. H pMecTe c Tem SHaMEHYIOT IIPHHIWAMHaIbHbIe CABHIH 1 Tepe MCHBI & KYABTYPHOM CO3HAHMIH 1 OGULECTRCHHOM BKYCe. Thskacco, cosqanannimit HanpasaeHus 1 cam OT HHX yxoaHBami, Ajouan, Npomequnii nyTb OT Crporoit %KHBONIHCH K M€pBbIM OLB TaM «Ja, HOI-apTa H NOCTMOAEPHHSMA (Apa NOCAEAHHX TepMHHa HosBHNch AMM NoaBeKa crycTa), bypgean 1 Mapxe, cuoKoiiHo coeminnautne XIX 1 XXI1 weka, curesnponan Tpaquitonnoe 2013- HenoOAOGHE CKECTKHMH ILACTHMECKHMH COpMYNpORKAMH HOT BUKHDIMM OTKPBITHAMH HOBeiMero BpeMeHu, KaHAMHCKIit, 1Ipo- paaBuINit peanbHocTs, 4TOGDI BlepEBIE IMCaTE (COBH ¢ HatypEt!) BHYTPeHHHe MHpbi COsHaHHA, CyTHH C Efe 2*KECTOKOI XyMORECTBEH- nolt orparoii, ep Myp, spit cparrracta4eckne durypet mpunan- Aekat paBHoO K1accH4eckoll TpagHuMH 1 abcTpaknHn,— BCE ITO OTUMIMHinB!, PENITeALHO He BIINCBIBAIONINECH B «HaNpaBnenne> 1 ckopee paspyiiaiontve emocTHEre IpeACTaBeHH A O rpyrmiax H-TEH* JCHUHAX, HEA HX CTPOAUIHE, BBEAEHHE 15a Tpmregeriaa paime vaicas Koanunrnyga KacaTe/ibHo HeMMtty- emoro ynaaKka s060re nepHoga NCTOpHM HckyccTBa CnpaBeaAHBa OTHOCHTC.rDHO HMCHHO nepHogos, TeMeHMi. Hcropua HeKyccTBA XX Beka, GbiTb MoxeT, Goree 4em BCHKAA APyrad LOKASBIBACT, TO Xy- AOKHUKM WAX CO3AAHHS HEU3MCHHO MPOODKAIOT, YMHOXKAIOT, a TO H NOAHOCTHIO PCATH3yIOT TO, "TO HE y{anOCb Ppynie HIM HaNpawWieHNo. «Bea HcTOpHa HCKyceTBa CCTL MCTOpHaA THNMOB (modes) BH3yanb- Horo BocnpHatia' (I. Pra). MoxHo a1» nostopute: TapaszeabHocTe, onHoBpeMeHHOCTh ACHTCIDHOCTH KPYTHCHIMMX XyO%KHUKOB COS {ACT NPHHUMITMAIbEBIC NpenaTcTeHA Ha HyTH NOCHE AOBATeALHOLO pacCMOT PeHHA HX HCKYC: cTpa. He ropopa ye o TOM, UTO B XX BeKe Kak HHKONZa 3HaYMMbI He BIHCaBINNGeA B rpynny, HanpaBrcHne WAH jaxKe HeKyIO caMylO ob uIyio TeHACHUHO CoBCpIIcHHE «oAMHOKHEe» Mactepa Kpome Toro, scebMa cymiccrcHHo onpeAcTT To, 4TO MoxKHO 6110 6bi HagBaTD «aRe3ZHBIM Wacom» HanpanacHua 11K Crist. Bens, Kak NpaBMAG, CaMbIE PasMKAIHbIe XyAOOKECTBEHHEIE 3KCNEpHMeH- TbI HE TOABKO HMEIOT CBOH BEPIHHbI, HO H ROKASbIBAIOT CBO HEOG- XO/IMMOCTD JIA COBPEMCHHOFO BOIMIOUICHHA BEY HbIX MOTHBOB H TEM yTRepaAACHHEM HX HEHOMeHHOM WeHHOCTH, K Tomy xe MacTo 9TO MpOHCXOAMT HMCHHO Ha «cKpcUIeHHM HanpansieHuiin, THostomy, oTgaRas ORKHOE PearBHOl UCTOPHM XyAOXKHUKOR, TEHACHIit H HaNpawICHHii, BOIMOXKHO MPEMOAOKHUTE, ITO XX Bek — CKOPEE BCEFO Ucmopud xydomKeCmMEeNHeIx CoOMMUL U KEAEnUL, ABre- wit, O6pasylouurx HeKHe OGUINE BEKTOPEI, HEdaBHCHMbIE OT OB equacnnii, rpynn H Manncpecron. Vi asaenua atv — npexye weero mponsawencnua weKyC cra Kak TaKoBEe. OHM H CTaHYT OCHOBHEIMH Me¢pcoHaxkaMH 9TOH KHHTH, eee Yetpemacrna xyjoxHMKoB XX croaerua Bee saMeTHee pasqean- loTeA B OTHOMeRHN cnoco6a nocTIDKeHUA H peanwaanun, Hi xa- ACKO HE TOABKO 1 «KHO Npe¢NoNOxKUTh, CTaHoORATesH B XX croneTun onpercamMoUHMH. Tipeaxgze scero sTo npoG6iema OTHOMCHHH «H306paxcHHe—HH- Tepmperanna», Apanrapa, HacTofitieo jexiapupyionutit oTKa3 OT BCAKOI MOBe- CTRORATEABHOCTH, COKETHKH, AMTEpaTypHOCTH, BONpeKH COBCTRCE HbIM TPOMOTMACHBIM 3A#B1CHHSIM CTPeMHTCALHO O6pacTas TeopHeli, mannipectami, O6mHpHElMAM HETeATERTYANBHEIM 1 BEPBANLHBIM noaem, HarecTHo, sro ne proc snoane cpopMadbHoe, yraepanaIoMee MOAEPHMSM, Mexycc1B6 nepBom NonoBMNE XX BeKabHenpeyMeTHoe ocBOeHHe Npocrpancrpa TeveHMe — KyOH3aM — cyuTe: CTBOBAO B KHIyYeH AMTepaTypHOH Jape, 8 TOI NpHHUHIIMabHO HO- sol Cpege — He KPHTHKH (anosorerHueckoll, O6bAcHAKOUIeH HIM ocyaujaiomel, Kak ITO CAydamocb Npexkze), HO HATE pupeTanHH, CIC ‘TEHHOH C _BHOKE HEM JIMTe paTypbI por paMMMbIMH 3aHBJICHHSMM, HH TepnperanHH, KOTOpas CTaHOBWIaCh HE MpOCTO YaCTbIO HEKyCCTBA, Ho ycrouvem sine qua non, MHTepnperanHH, KoTOpas maa HE TMpO- CTO PAZOM C MPOHSBEEHHEM, HO TO aC HW BNEpPEeAM HETO, & CO BPE McHeM Hadaia B 3HAUMTe HOF MEpe HM NOAMEHITh HCKYECTBO. Ky63m, socnerbili Anowmuepom, pasbsrniii n npocaasacnnpilt Thesom 1 Metueiwxe, crasmit mpeametom Teopermueckax mryaHii He TOKO Bo panywH, Ho mB Poccun. MraapancKnit dytypu3m, HACTOAHHBIA Ha AeKapauMsx Mapnuettu w BowwoHn, pyccKuit kyGotpyTypHaM, BooGine OLIBINHI AWTepaTypHbIM AWIEHHEM HAYyTE He p McHbmeit CTeTIEHH, HEM xyoxecTBEHHDIM (CM. HHDKe). HaKo- uet— M970 CaMbIit KpacHopeuMuiit NpuMep — mepppie oNrTBI Jhourana («Benocumeauoe kosteco», «bouTar 1 ap.), KOTOpBIE BEE TepnpeTayHH He cymyecTByIOT, HOO, He ABAAACE CaMM TIO cebe PYKOTBOPHBIMH TIpOHSBEAEHHAMHM HCKYCCTBa, OHM HMGJIH CBocit 3a- Aaxeit NpoBOKALIIO CHCTEMbI BOCHPHATHA, ChOMa KOHTEKETa, 4TO OCOsHAETCA B NMepByEO OFepeb HMEHHO H TOMDKO BepGanbHo. II po- vasexeHuat Jbomara (4 ero avarorH) OcymeCTBAMOT CBOI XyAOrKe- cremuylo yHKnM0, meperocs ce Ha BocNPHHMMaIoMyI cropony (Ha peuHnHenra), Npespamad Npouecc KOMMYHHKALHH B sBseHHe He MeHee BUKHOE, YEM CAM HCTOUHHK CyKACHHH WH BNewaTeHHil, A never 3a oTHM— nentenbHocTh «Jlaqam, n KOTOpO!t Mponece npe- ScHTALWM, apaloKHpOBE pas MHIDIX ABAEHHIT H TIpoMaBeAEHHHK Hc- KyCCTBA CTA pemMTeNbHO JOMMHApyIOMHM, Aeticrawren.uo: yrainace — 8 mo6yio cropouy — or mpeyMerHoro (TpaqHMMOHHOrO, CPHrypaTHBHOTO, «peabHOTO», TCPpMHH B aHHOM coyyae He CTO naxwer) HeKyccTRA, xyjoutMK XX weKa Bee Goce HC- prrspact HCOGxOAMMOCTD Be pSambHOro yraepareHHs, OObACHEHHT, a 10 HW TeopeTHuecKOro OSOCHOBaHUA CBOETO TROPUECTBa. B kakoiito Mepe 9T0 Npononypyetcs H_KPHTHKOM, H xKypHamHc: THKOH, Tpe6ylomci) INeMCHTapHOrO OGRACHCHHA GHUPMATHY eCKAX XYLOKCCTRCHHDIX CTPYKTYP, YTO MHOXKHT YHCIO HHTEPBIO, a HHOT- Ja W CaMOCTORTENDHBIX, HO ABHO BHIFYRACHMBIX (KAK, HaNpHMep, y Maruca) Texctop camHx xyoxnHKon, Ho eme Bonce peanusyer- Ca 8 H3HAIANLMO MPHcyMleM MacTepaM aBanrapaa «xydomcecmaennas nonyusner, OTKPLITOM KEMAHA HpaBHTbes H OBIT 3aMcUCHHBIM. Kpyniciimue macrepa XX pexa— KatzHAcKhii, Manesny, Kace MMHOTHe ApyTite — NHcaTH nese TpakTaTor, paspabaTorBanK TEeOpHH, MCTOAMIGL, yTREPAUIATM CBOC NOHHMAHHe HOBDIX 3aKOHOB HICKYCCTBA, Hoy rarux, kax Kanauncknit Knee, o6pasosaxunix HATEIICK- Tyanon, 370 O6opauHBATOCe CosqaHMen HEKHX KoHNETMMi, CMemEI< H AOKagaTeALHLIX, OCOGCHHO Jia CBOcrO BpeMeHH, HO Npeycrasta- SBE ACHHE 1718 JOMNX HbIHC (BOTANY OT HX MCKYCCTBA) AVI HeTOpHYce KH WH tepec, A mapHoe, HST He MelIaiouNNx BOCHpHATHIO HX rpaHsae o3HOrO HaACICAWA. Uro xe Kacactesn Manesuua, TO y Hero Bep6aimgayun MeTonA mpuaoguaa K ”BolicrReHHOmy peayneTaty. C onHoit CropouE, xyqox- HHK CIOBHO Obl CTApAICA BOIBECTH PAAOM C BEAHYABBIM 31aHHEM CBOETO HCKYCCTBA PHTANTCKOE, HO HEYCTOH4MBOE TeopeTH4EcKo’ anaHne, CroaBUIce Ha pbrxiom dyHAAMCHTe He_OCTaTOUHOli OGpa- SORAHHOCTH, 3 aHHC SKICKTHMHOE, NOpoli CKpEIBAIOMCE B CBO TEHUL NO/LIMHHBIE AOCTIOKEHHA ero xy,OXKECTBEHHOM NpakTuKn. C apyroii, ero TEMMepaMeHTHBIC H BAOXHOBEHHBIE TeEOpeTMUECKHE CyRACHHA CTaHOBMAKCh OCHOBO! ONpeAeACHHO! XYORKECTRCHHO! METOANKH, MIpHHCCINeHt HEAT MOABSEI 1 IIPHBACKINCHA MHOIKECTHO yBICICHHDIX, AXCHTOR, HO IKOABI, HECOMHCHHO, patarHaHolt, HeTeprMoli, a1 NOAHCHHOM BOAHC GonBUICBUCTCKOrO MaKCHMaJIM3Ma. Mrak, nereg 3a auayof «paynoHaibHoe—sMOyHOHabHOe» BOs HHKAeT, CTANO GbITb, HOB H EME Goree rmoGaabHas: 1) HCKyCCTBO, CYMLECTBYIONICE BHE FABHCHMOCTH OT HHTepMpeTauHn, 4 2) HCKyCCT- BO, BHE MHTEplpeTayHn Houpocty HE cyulecTByIOMCe. V1 naxonen, cneunuucckum spacunem XX pexa cranopnres MoulHoe OrserBaeHue BTOpoOlt TeHACHUMA: MATepLpeTanMs, OGOpar uneaiomasca urpoti. Cpoero poga arpeccueHBI JtyKaBCTBOM, KOTO- poe TO CYMLECTBYET KAK OHH 13 XONOB B BAPHATHBHOM BEEpE (Kak nopoii y [likacco), To kak ocHosHaa sanata— or romana no Sunn Yopxoaa (cm. raapy V. «Artifex ludens'»"). Vara remennna — Tenjennna urpst— nocreneHHo, 4 HeyMo- AMMO TIpespanmeTes 13 OTRETRAeHHA B HacTOitMByIO yorpesvier: HOCTh, & B IIOCIEBOCHHOE BPEMA, B Nopy MOMAapTa H CKAAALIBAIO- MLeTOCA HOCTMOAEPHHaMa, — B AOMHHAHTY. OT Reka TIpHcymHe He- KYCCTBY NOHATHA TpareqHH, KaTApeNca, ITHYECKOI OTRETCTREHHOC- TH, KYABTYpbI pemecaa yxoasT Ha HepHdpepmi0 TROpECTRA. ECan y Kupxnepa, Mypa, Tuxacco, sake y Sprcra wn Mupo B jon0e HBIe PoE Mpa GbuIa COCTaRAAOMNeH B XyOXKECTREHHOL CTpyKTYpe, BbIPAKAOMEH TpareqHio, TO BO BTOPO!i NOAOBHHE XX BeKa CaMbIe CepbesHBIe, PPOSHbIE MOTHBHI peamMayrOTCA B aHaHMTeADHO! Mepe no npPasuAam Uepol H KATAPCHC CCIM H BOSHHKACT, TO KaK éenvrwKa UMeLIeKmaadxOlL AKMUEKOCMU, KAK OULYUICAHE MrHOBERHO! HOC: Tpoli KOHTeHMAIBHOCTH, paseadKu, NepecedeHnit HaNpsKEHHBIX, HO PALHOHAILABIX ACCOUMATHBHBIX PAAOB ABTOpA H 3pHTerA. TlosTomy, Ip MHOXCCTRCHHOCTH MAaCTHYCCKHX CTPYKTYp, TCH- ACHIM, HanpanaAcHnit, HAAMBHAyAIDHDIX HOBATi, yCHAMBAIO MH CA BEKTOP UTPb1, BEPOSTHO, OCTACTCA OCHOBHDIM B AMHAMHKe HCKYC- cra neproii noxopunnt XX pexa. B avauutersuoil mepe 370 cyacte- He MOAKpermaeTca TeM, 4TO MpeAMEcTRYIOIce (ycIOBHO roROps, * Xysoxceitk vrpaiouurit (2am.). MOAEPHH3M, MexycctB0 nepsoA nonoBMHE XX BeKaKaCCHYECKOe) HCKYCCTBO HCKMIOYAIO Hpy 43 IIpHOpHTeTOB, BOC- MpHHMMad €€ Kak YACTh MOTHBa, CIOKETAa, HO OTHIOAb HE Kak X¥A0- KECTBEHHBIT TIpHELUMIT. Bee sro 1 Hosnoaser rosopurt oO Tpex TIpHunHtMaHBIN TeH: ACHUHAX (MKAULHX OTYACTH B pasHbIX NPOCTpaHCTBaX, MOpOlt Me PECEKAOILMXCA HH MPOHHKaKIX ApyT B Apyra), KOTOpble tpo- OratpHBaiorest B ucKyccTBe XX cromeTHH C AOCTATOMHOH ACHOCTHIO. Oun ne pasqeseub peskoii rpannneit 4 npeiaraioTca Ha 9THX CTpa HINIAX He KaK KOHTIETHHs, 2 Kak paouas KOHCTPYKEMS, Kak MeTOR PACCMOTPEHMA, AOU BOIMOKHOCTE HE KECTKOM KraceHpUKa- HH, HO HEKOTO POH KOHREHIHAIBHOH CTpyKTYpHPOBAHHOCTH. Oatia H3 HX — spoMarTH4ecKad”, «acTeTH4ECKaa» — «COxpaHs- eT MomMAHHe>, AOBOALCTRYACH CaMOIL XYAOAECTREHHOIL CTPyKTYpoit (posucrat, Mapxe, Moqumann, Yrprato, Myp, Cytan, Mopanan vw ap.). Auanazon nexyccrna Takoro poga AOCTATOUHO UNpOK: OT conpHkacalomuxcs ¢ aGcTpakyHel HHBIX paboT Matncca AO MOTT hex oF 0GmeHnit MapKe 1 mOSTH4ECKOrO dboTOpeatnama Xonmepa. Bropaa — ycrpemacitiaa kK noctosunomy copmoTaopyectay, chaGxcHnaa (wim HeT) TeoperMueckoii 6a30ii U OOMABHBIM CTO. KonaHHeM, HO CyIeCTBYIONaH H Cama mo CeGe — HesaBHcHMo Hit OT uero CoaqaeT HORYIO ACHCTRUTEABHOCTS B HOCTORHHO MoALp HHpY- EMBIX, MlaCTHYCCKH CAMOMUCHHBIX KOMaX, HC OGAIATCABHO YXOAAIIMX oT mpeametHore mupa (Kanaunckni, Kupuko, Mapx, Tmxacco, Maran, Kace, Pyo). Hmenno Ha 970M «a3nike», noHstTHOM Ges C108, CrpacrHom 1 HocToaHHo MoAMduuNpylomemcs, HCKyCCTRO XX Beka ToROpuT O Gom H MBICHIX BpeMeHH. ‘Tpetba — yKoperena B MHTepmperauMH H CymeCcTayeT AMI BAH aiore, B fiiasMe AMCKYCCHM, OOpACHeHMA, Bepbammsanun (Joan, oyrypncrm1, GyaetaaHe, zaxancret, 8 GomUOM Mepe cloppeancTet), noctencuHo oGopaunsach Hrpoit uM BTATUBAN Bone CROErO MPH TOKEUMS CAMBIE PAIHBIe TECHN HM MMCHA, MOAN HUMpysce 13 OTBETRACHHS B HPPOBYIO AOMHHAHTY XX Beka, B ato mpocrpauerno BPEMCHAMH IIPOHHKAWT eABa TH HE BCE HILYIHe H MSTYIMHeCH Ta- aavTbt XX neka— or [nkacco ao Agkaxometru # Jlenbso. Io ecre- cTBeHHO: KybType XX cromerns BEOMbI KH Mpa4Hpte GesaHpl Gecco- 3HATEABHOLO, H AYKABbIE ETO KapHaBatbl. H wakoney, versepras TenjeHa, OGOsHAYeHHE KOTOpOit, Re- PoRTHO, Govlee Bcero pMCcKyCCHOHHO!, Oco6oe Mecro B XX croseTun ’aHHMaeT HCKYCCTBO, COXPAHAIO- mee TpayMUMOHHyIO (burypaTHBHOCTh, 2MBHCNOAOGHE, TO, ITO B OObr ACHHOM CO3HaHMM aCCOMMMpyeTCs C NONSTHEM «peamam». TomHmo UCKYCCTRa NPOCTO KOHCEPBATHBHOTO, CATOHHOTO, AaKe OGCKYpaH TUCTCKOrO (0 KOTOPOM HeT CMBICTa CepbesHo roROpuTs), HaTypatu CTHYCCKad W3IOGPAIHTCABHOCTE KaK ASbIK, TpagHUMOHHO MOHATHETIT HHEPTHOMY S3pHTEMO, HCHOM3yETCA Tame BCCTO B COBEpUIEHHO CHe- umdprteckHx WyesT8x. BBEAEHME 1920 Peb HE HAET O NOSTHYECKOM 1 BOADHOM CONeTaHHH (purypaTHe- HOCTH ¢ JaMapHoit n OCTpoOit BHIPasHTenDHOCTHO, HarwTaHHO; pa- AWKQIbHBIMH JOCTIVKEH WMH HOBCHLIMX HCKaHHi, MpHMepoM HeMy MOXKET CAPKUTE KHBOTUCE MapKe, Cyruua, Yrpwza0, Merposa- Bogknna, Bepst Iecreas, Monuanst win Tpomepa, Taxoro popa MACTEpa, B CYIMHOCTH, CTOAD 2Ke CBOGOAHE! 1 COBpEMEHHEI B OGac- ‘TH (Popa, CKOAH H pankaaBHEIe Ce OGHORNTERH. Bux HeKyCeTRE MOTHBhI, MeTadpopht 1 AAKE NO_OGHA OGHACHHOI peanbHOCTH, 3C- TeTHSMpOsAHHBE UH NpeoSpaxkenuBie HE AMBUAYATDEIM BOCHpUsITH €M, COOTHECEHHTIC B OCOGMX XyAOKECTRCHHBIX OTHOUICHHSX, COs AMOT HHI MHpEt. Himcerca 5 sully nHoc — Te ycTpeMICHuA B HCkyCCTBC, KOTOpHIC, onepupys TpaamumonHpinn dopmamn, HenoAayIoT Hx: —1nGo a coxepmncHHo HCOGEMMHOM Co¥cTAHHM, CosnaBas CTpyK- Typhi, KOTOpHIE MOXKHO OMLIO Gui HagBaTE H HATypamcTHYecKuMM, Mm meraopmueckumn. 3aech 8 nepsyIo ONeperD peu useT © COp- PCQIMCTAX, XOTA H JAICKO HE 060 BCEX, HITpa H MHOFOCMbICACHHOCT B-MCKYCCTBE KOTOPHIX saKOUAOTCH HE B HEOGBTUHOCTH opm, HO B HCOKHAAHHOM COUCTAHHM HECONOCTABHMBIX 1 BICHMIt; — auGo 419 coaqaHna CBocrO poda «yTOMMMECKOrO HaTypamn3- Ma», P€ BOSH HKAET NpOAYMAHHas! M WaMNe BCeTO BIOKOSHEHHAA «Mrpa Hei WH , KIOHAMAICH K HAPKOTHYECKOMY BOgelt- TBH Ha JpHTEena, NpUMEpaMn 4Ero MOARET CayAUTE OcHNOaHOE HCKYCCTBO HaruIaMa H CoBETCKOrO ToTAMHTapHaMa. Takoro ake posta yrepxsiaiouuiMH cyutee Kak OSpasen Gurrnsl Mucororemamn CraHo- BATCA HHOTa MW PHNeppeamMcTH4eCKHe NOMCKH aMepHKaHTes. VM — eme oan mapagoke — noqo6uoro poga MannnyanpoBanue OKHSHEeMONOGHEM Gre BCErO HMCHHO HrpaM, GpyTabHbIM vrTpaM XX pena. PasymMeeros, M@KIY HASBAHHHIMH TEHCHIMIMA ECTD HEKOE Hel ‘TPaAbHOe MpOCTpavCTBO, B KOTOPOM CyIECTBYIOT RECHMA 3HAUHTEAy He HMeHa 1 IRTEHHH, CCTR pasHooGpasHEte NOTA HANpsLKeHIS, HO MARNE REKTOPH MpeACTARTIOTCH ONPeAeAMOMMH, ‘Uto kacaeTca CTpykTypH xpOHOmOrHMuecKOl, BpeMcHHt UH, TO 3nech NpOSeMa KaKeTeH HEcCKOABKO Goace sicHOli. Josocuunte roa, nepuog KaHyHOB, TpCBOrH, CMYTHHIX MpCA4yB- crenit OTMeueH MoMCcKaMN HOBO! reorpadmio MmpuBElunEIx MpescTanreHit 06 uckyceTse XX Beka, HCTOPHK CTapaeTca AMCTAHYHpOBATLCA OT caoxnameiica reoxyroxectacnnoit cxemer ([lapuaxcKaa moa, opus 1 KyGuam — Ppamiuw, sKcripeccnornan — Lepmarina, cpyry puam ~ raans, cynpemarusm — Poccua 1 7. 4.) wm paciimMputh 3Ty cxewy, Crpesaeniia Takoro poga sacayanpaior yraxenns, HO OcTa- 1OTCH YACTHRIMM SKCHEPUMeHTaMH, HakOmieHHoe 3HaHHe, C1OKHB- BBEQEHKE 21I. «ACKYCCTBO MOJIEPHH3MA>. UCTOKH, CPEAA OBHTAHHA30 Pycckast kHBOTHCH, MpeCbILeHHAas NOBECTBOBATEMbHOCTHIO, TpatHiyi- OHNO COBECEIMBOCTBIO, CHEN MOLI pbIBOK B CrOpOHy aBanrap- auioro neraTuBHaMa. PhiboK Kyra Gonee peskuii, vem na Banae, o- CKOULKY ‘Tas NYT OF HMMIpeccHOmama, Cesanua, Ban Tora, «Habits kK tposnamy, kyGuamy 4 Awiee HoANOi GecripesmerHocrn GEL! Kya GO- JI@e NOCTENEHLBIM 1 MOCAEOBATEMbHEIM, PyceKHe MetlenaTb! (Mopo- aon, Llyxnin), cocrasinsuine KOJIeKUMH KaptHH CAMbIX paJLHKaibHbix ppannysckux macrepos, JLanmies c ero «Pycckvimn ceaonamit» Tak IKE CHOCOGCrBOBAIN NEPEMEHAM B «KYAKTypHOM PeoKOmMTUKED. Tpexae pyeckas Kyimtypa ¢ €€ HaCTOUMBEIM pHTOpHaMoM Ht IK ‘TepatyPOLEHTPH3MOM OTAABAA NPEAMOUTEHME COMMAIBHBIM Ht STH: ‘ueckuM WeHHOCTSM. PasBHTHE CHMBOJIM3MA HPO IUIACTHYeCKOTO gabika (CTHUIb MOZepH!), APXECTeKTypa MOfepHA C ero HacToOiuHBEDIM cTpemieHuem K CHHTesy HeKyccrTs (B Mockne ocennio 1902 roga oT- KPhiTa Ghia GONBIAA BRICTABKA “APXHTEKTYPbI H XYMOKECTREHHON NPOMbINLICHHOCTH HOBOTO CTHAA», te tpexcrapaeupr Gp 11 HHO- crpannnie macrepa), Boo6me axrunnnti pocr cmrerisma (1H mpo- cro acreriama) B pyCcKom HicKyectHe, OcTaGAcHHE MpodpeTITIEcKHX crpacreli cram Baxnoiit pexoli ma nyTn ppmxenns K HarrepHarHo- HaIBHOM CHCTeEMe IeHHOCTEIt. (CémxKeune pycckoii iquistyppr c sanaquoit 6ni10, KoHeUHO, mm YACTHIO POGANHOTO HHTerpalMOHHOro MporeEcca, BEpyUIero K Par MBIRANHWO PpaHHI, HalMOHATHDIX DKON, OHH OcTABAIMch H OCTA- 1OTCH, PASYMEETCH, HO MHOXKECTRO AeATENeiT HCKycCTBA NepenocaT ye ¢ nauata XX BeKA NPOUECC CBOErO THOPYECTBA B HHYIO HalyHO- HaIHYIO Cpenty. Penomonps, sarrent Cranonaerine toramrrapritx pexuMmon B COCE, namncrckoli Fepmannn 1 aumcrexo#t Hrann cnoco6crsyior Mac- cosoti amurpanun — 1. Bynnn, B, HaGoxos, M. Hlaras, B. Karuuar cxuii, T. Mann, JL. Peiixreaurep, wcex ne nepeuectn. OcoGwili de- nomen XX veka —snrepatypa, o6peraiontan Bropoit sank (Yalu, HaGoxos). Bee aTo NOMOraer, paayMEeTCA, H CraHOBAEHHIO MOUUIBIX TpaHc- HALMOHAIBHDIX TEMEHHT, BHIXOAALINX 3a TIPEncapl OAHOI CrpaHDt (» nepsoii verseprit neKa OcOGEHHO ApKO M AeKApaTHBHO STO CKA- S@10Cb Ha IpuMepe faanisma — cM. nvpKe). J[BioKeHME KyIbTYpbI HMeHHO c Hayat 1900- ronoB MoaKHO EcTecTBEHHbIM OOpasom pac- CMaTpHEaTE Kak sEAeHHe » GombUIO! Mepe ‘TpancrtarnonamBHoe. Caegyer, ogHako, uMer® B BITAY, UTO HeTopHuecKaa OneHKa me progam ero camocosnarie O6n14HO posHsrrcs. Ha pyGexe crote- Tnii 1B Hauase XX BeKa gra pasHnya npumyimanpsta. Kyaprypa Toll NopH, BOCNPHHMMaeMad Celiac Kak POMAHTHYC- cxnii, GaecTalyHii MB BbICHICH CTeHeHH Nio_OTBOpHDM TlepHoO,, nepvion BateTa, HOBEEX HCKANHT, ACpaKHX HOBaIMii, CranoneHHA HeBH/aHEDIX XyROKECTBEHNDIX CHCTEM 1 TeopHii, sapoaRertHs 1 Gyp- HOPO pasBurHA aBalrapAa, BOBCE He OMTyULATACh CoBpeMeHHMKAMM Kak CUACTIMBAS, CBETIAN HIM AWKE MIPOCTO MporpeccuBHasd sN0Xxa. MOAEPHHSM. HexyccrB0 nepsoli nonoBKtes XX BeKa