Failure of Bank of Credit & Commerce International

Introduction

The Bank of Credit and Commerce International (BCCI) was a major international bank founded
in 1972 by Agha Hasan Abedi, a Pakistani financier. It was registered in Luxembourg with head
offices in Karachi and London. By the 1980s, BCCI had over 400 branches in 78 countries and
assets in excess of $20 billion.

BCCI became the target of a two-year-long investigation by the U.S. Federal Reserve Board of
Governors, which began in June 1988. The investigation revealed that BCCI was involved in
massive fraud, corruption, and money laundering. The bank was found to have taken deposits
from customers without providing them with adequate security, and to have hidden loans from
regulators. It was also revealed that BCCI was using the funds to finance terrorist activities, bribe
government officials, and launder drug money.

In July 1991, BCCI was declared insolvent and was placed into liquidation. The liquidators were
unable to recover all of the funds that had been deposited with BCCI, and many depositors were
left with significant losses. The failure of BCCI was one of the largest banking scandals in
history and highlighted the need for increased regulation and oversight of international banks.

Financial Costs

The financial cost of Bank of Credit & Commerce International (BCCI) was estimated to be in
the billions of dollars. The exact figure is difficult to determine, but some estimates place the
total cost to be between $15 and $20 billion. This includes the costs of fines, settlements, legal
fees, and other expenses associated with the bank’s closure. Additionally, the International Bank
of Credit & Commerce International was one of the largest banks in the world at the time of its
collapse, and its failure had a significant impact on the global financial system. The failure of the
bank also caused significant losses for its shareholders, creditors, and depositors.

Human Costs

The human costs of the Bank of Credit & Commerce International (BCCI) scandal included the
loss of billions of dollars for investors and depositors, the loss of thousands of jobs, and the
destruction of the reputations of those involved in the scandal. Additionally, the scandal led to

1
the imprisonment of some of the key players, including BCCI founder Agha Hasan Abedi and
BCCI President Swaleh Naqvi. The scandal also had a devastating impact on the banking
industry, as it highlighted the need for increased regulation and oversight.

Other Nonfinancial Costs

1. Loss of Public Trust:

BCCI's criminal activities led to a significant loss of public trust in the banking sector.
This loss of trust had a major impact on the industry, with consumers and businesses
becoming more hesitant to use banking services.
2. Damage to Reputation:
BCCI's involvement in numerous criminal activities and scandals damaged the reputation
of the banking industry, as well as the reputation of the bank itself.
3. Regulatory Sanctions:
BCCI was subject to numerous regulatory sanctions, including fines, restrictions, and
bans on certain activities. These sanctions cost the bank significant time and money.
4. Legal Costs:
BCCI's involvement in criminal activities resulted in numerous lawsuits, which resulted
in high legal costs.
5. Loss of Customer Base:
BCCI's criminal activities resulted in the loss of many customers, as consumers and
businesses became hesitant to use banking services. This resulted in a significant loss of
revenue for the bank.

How Did It Happen?

BCCI collapsed in 1991 after a series of frauds, money laundering activities, and illegal activities
were uncovered. The major contributing factors to its collapse were poor corporate governance
and inadequate oversight by regulators. BCCI’s rapid growth was largely facilitated by its ability
to circumvent traditional banking regulations.

The bank was able to open hundreds of branches worldwide without obtaining the necessary
licenses and was able to move money between countries without disclosing its true sources.

2
These activities enabled BCCI to secretly launder money for drug cartels, terrorist organizations,
and regimes with questionable human rights records.

The bank also relied heavily on inter-company loans, which were not properly disclosed, and it
was found to be involved in fraudulent activities, such as creating false loans in order to hide
losses and increase profits.

The frauds were eventually uncovered by bank regulators in the United States and the United
Kingdom, who conducted a joint investigation into BCCI’s activities. The investigation revealed
that the bank had been operating as a Ponzi scheme and had laundered billions of dollars for its
clients.

The scandal resulted in BCCI’s collapse, as well as major fines and legal action against those
involved. The bank’s founder, Agha Hasan Abedi, was later arrested and charged with fraud,
money laundering, and criminal conspiracy. He died in 1995 before going to trial.

Fractured Supervision

The primary cause of the lack of supervision of BCCI was the fractured nature of the system.
BCCI was a multinational bank, and as such, it operated in multiple countries and was subject to
the jurisdiction and regulations of those countries. Several countries had a say in how BCCI was
supervised, and this fractured system led to a lack of coordination between the various governing
bodies. Furthermore, BCCI had complex ownership and management structures and a web of
subsidiaries that made it difficult for regulators to effectively monitor the bank.

The lack of effective supervision of BCCI contributed to its ultimate collapse. In response to the
scandal, many countries have taken steps to strengthen their regulations and oversight of
international banking. These changes include increased transparency and disclosure
requirements, better coordination between international banking authorities, and more stringent
enforcement of regulations.

Structure of Bank of Credit & International

BCCI’s organizational structure consisted of a Board of Directors, which was headed by the
Chairman and included representatives from the major shareholders of the bank. The Chief

3
Executive Officer (CEO) was responsible for the day-to-day operations and was supported by
other senior executives. There were also regional offices, which were responsible for managing
the bank's operations in different countries.

BCCI had a complex network of interlocking companies and subsidiaries, which were used to
facilitate its activities and to ensure secrecy. The bank also had a number of offshore companies,
which were located in tax havens such as the Cayman Islands and the Bahamas, and which were
used for illegal activities such as money laundering.

The bank collapsed in 1991 after it was revealed that it had been involved in a number of
fraudulent activities. It was closed down by regulators and its assets were frozen.

Covert Presence Bank of Credit & Commerce international

The covert presence of Credit & Commerce International (CCI) is a complex story of a criminal
organization that used its banking and financial operations to facilitate money laundering and
other criminal activities. CCI was a private international banking and finance company founded
in 1972 by the Pakistani-born businessman Agha Hasan Abedi. The company grew to become
one of the largest private banks in the world, with offices in more than 70 countries. It was
involved in a number of financial scandals and illegal activities, including money laundering,
arms dealing, and fraud. After a series of investigations and scandals, CCI’s operations were shut
down in 1991.

Although CCI is no longer operational, its legacy lives on in many ways. Its involvement in
money laundering activities is still studied by academics and financial experts as an example of
how a company can use the banking system to facilitate criminal activities. CCI’s international
presence has also had a lasting impact on international banking regulations, which have become
much more stringent since the scandal. Many of the measures introduced after the scandal are
still in place today.

Auditing of BCCI's Global Operations

Auditing of Bank of Credit and Commerce International (BCCI) Global Operations is a critical
and necessary process. The purpose of the audit is to ensure that the bank’s operations are
compliant with applicable laws and regulations, as well as to identify any potential weaknesses

4
or irregularities in the bank’s operations. The audit should cover all aspects of BCCI’s
operations, including its financial statements, risk management systems, internal controls, and
compliance with applicable laws and regulations. The audit should also include an assessment of
the bank’s financial condition, capital adequacy, liquidity, and internal controls. Furthermore, the
audit should include an evaluation of the bank’s management’s performance and its ability to
manage its operations effectively. Finally, the audit should assess the bank’s current and future
risks and its ability to manage those risks. The audit should be conducted by an independent,
qualified auditing firm.

Corporate Organization

The Bank of Credit & Commerce (BC&C) was a large multinational banking and financial
services company, headquartered in Luxembourg. BC&C was one of the largest banks in Europe
and had operations in more than 70 countries, including the United States, the United Kingdom,
France, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and Brazil. BC&C's primary business activities included
corporate and investment banking, asset management, and private banking. The bank also
provided a range of financial services such as securities trading, foreign exchange, and financial
advice. BC&C was founded in 1972 and was one of the first banks to recognize the potential of
international banking. The bank was acquired by Credit Suisse in 1997.

Corporate Culture

The corporate culture of Bank of Credit & Commerce (BCC) is one of collaboration and
teamwork. BCC encourages its employees to take ownership of their work and to be creative in
their problem-solving approaches. BCC also values diversity, fairness, and respect for all. BCC
strives to create a work environment that is conducive to a productive and enjoyable work
experience. BCC encourages open communication and feedback, which helps the company stay
agile and responsive to changes in the marketplace. BCC also emphasizes the importance of
customer service and encourages its employees to maintain a high level of customer satisfaction.
BCC values its employees and strives to create opportunities for growth and development.
Above all, BCC strives to create a culture that promotes integrity, trust, and respect.

5
Why Is BCCI Important to Banking Supervisors?

The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS) is an important forum for international
banking regulators to discuss and agree on measures to ensure global financial stability. The
committee was created in 1974 by the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) with the aim of
developing the framework for the supervision and regulation of banks around the world. The
BCCI is important to banking supervisors because it provides a platform for them to share best
practices, exchange information, and discuss regulatory and supervisory issues that affect the
banking sector. The BCCI also proposes and supports the development of global standards for
banking supervision and works to ensure that banks are adequately capitalized and well-
managed. This helps to promote financial stability and soundness worldwide.

Federal Reserves Actions Against the BCCI Organization

The Federal Reserve took a number of actions against the BCCI organization, including issuing
cease-and-desist orders, imposing civil money penalties, and initiating legal action against the
bank. In July 1991, the Federal Reserve Board of Governors issued a cease-and-desist order
requiring the Bank of Credit and Commerce International (BCCI) to cease and desist from
engaging in certain activities in the United States. The order also required the bank to take steps
to ensure that its operations in the U.S. we’re following applicable laws and regulations. In July
1992, the Federal Reserve imposed a civil penalty of $10 million against BCCI for failing to
comply with the cease-and-desist order. In addition, the Federal Reserve initiated legal action
against the bank for violations of banking laws. The bank eventually agreed to a settlement with
the Federal Reserve in which it paid a $25 million penalty and agreed to transfer certain assets
and liabilities out of the United States.

Usc of New Statutory Powers in Bank of Credit & Commerce

The Bank of Credit & Commerce (BCC) has recently been granted new statutory powers by the
government, allowing it to expand its operations and services. The new statutory powers mean
that BCC can now:

6
1. Offer a wider range of financial products and services such as mortgages, stockbroking, and
investment banking.

2. Open physical branches in multiple countries to provide better access to international markets.
3. Participate in mergers and acquisitions of other banks and financial institutions.

4. Issue bonds and other debt instruments to raise capital for investments.

5. Set up subsidiaries and special purpose vehicles to manage its investments.

6. Offer additional services such as foreign exchange and money transfers.

7. Offer financial advice and services to customers.

8. Utilize its new powers to create innovative products and services to better meet the needs of its
customers.

Fund for Compensating BCCI Victims

The Fund for Compensating BCCFs Victims is a charitable fund established to provide financial
assistance to victims of the now-defunct BCCI, a large Canadian investment firm that went
bankrupt in 2015. The fund was created by the Canadian government to help individuals and
businesses affected by the collapse of the BCCI. It provides a range of assistance, including
direct payments, debt relief, and access to financial counseling and education. The fund is
administered by an independent board of trustees and is supported by public donations. All funds
are used exclusively for the purpose of providing support to victims of the BCCI.

The corporate governance issues that led to the collapse of BCCI can be summarized as follows:

1. Lack of Transparency and Accountability:

BCCI was a privately-held bank, and its financial records and activities were not subject
to public scrutiny. This allowed the bank to operate without oversight and accountability
and enabled the bank to engage in fraudulent activities without detection.
2. Poor Risk Management:

7
 BCCI had inadequate risk management policies in place. This allowed the bank to take
on excessive risk and engage in risky investments without assessing and mitigating the
potential losses.

3. Inadequate Financial Controls:

BCCI lacked adequate financial controls, which allowed the bank to hide losses and to
engage in money laundering activities.
4. Poor Governance and Internal Controls:
BCCI had inadequate corporate governance policies in place, and its internal controls
were inadequate. This allowed the bank to engage in fraudulent activities without
detection.
5. Poor Supervision and Oversight:
BCCI was not adequately supervised or regulated by the banking authorities. This
allowed the bank to operate without proper oversight and monitoring.

Solution of failure Bank of Credit & Commerce international

The failure of the Bank of Credit & Commerce International (BCCI) was a result of a
combination of factors.

Firstly, the bank was found to be engaging in fraud and money laundering activities, which
included false accounting and the concealment of losses, as well as involvement in the financing
of illegal arms sales.

Secondly, BCCI had a complex corporate structure with multiple cross-border and offshore
subsidiaries, making it difficult to properly track and monitor its activities. This structure
allowed BCCI to circumvent regulatory oversight, which allowed it to engage in fraudulent
activities with impunity.

Thirdly, BCCI's corporate governance was weak, with inadequate disclosure and oversight of its
activities. The bank was found to have inadequate capitalization and poor lending practices,
leading to significant losses.

Finally, BCCI had weak liquidity management, leading to a liquidity crisis in the early 1990s.
This caused the bank to seek a bailout from the Bank of England, which was ultimately

8
unsuccessful. These factors combined to lead to the collapse of the Bank of Credit & Commerce
International in 1991.