You are on page 1of 47

ECG 344

HIGHWAY ENGINEERING
Chapter 5
Road Pavement Design

MOHD MUSTAQIM BIN MOHD NORDIN


Contact: 019-598 2087
Room @ Makmal Lukisan Teknik 2
mustaqimnordin@uitm.edu.my
mohd86mustaqim@yahoo.com

ECG344 HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 1


CHAPTER OUTLINE

1. Chapter Overview

2. Types & Characteristic of Flexible & Rigid Pavement

3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement

4. Materials and Properties of Flexible Pavement

5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method

ECG344 HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 2


1. Chapter Overview

PROGRAM OUTCOME
Apply knowledge of mathematics, natural science, engineering
fundamentals and an engineering specialization to wide practical
procedures and practices. (C)

COURSE OUTCOME
Discuss highway construction, maintenance and highway geometric
design according to standard specification. (C6)

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 3
2. Types & Characteristic of Flexible & Rigid Pavement
Learning Outcome
• At the end of the lesson, students should be able to distinguish
between types of road pavement.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 4
2. Types & Characteristic of Flexible & Rigid Pavement
Introduction
• Function of pavement
• Distribute traffic load, stress to the soil at a magnitude that it will not shear or
distort the soil
• Guide the driver, where pavement & shoulder give a visual perspective of the
horizontal and vertical alignment of the travel path

5
FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 5
2. Types & Characteristic of Flexible & Rigid Pavement
Introduction
• 2 types of pavement structure
o Flexible pavement
o Rigid pavement

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 6
2. Types & Characteristic of Flexible & Rigid Pavement
Flexible pavement
• Constructed with asphaltic cement & aggregates
• Consist of several layers:
o The lowest (subgrade) – natural soil
o Subbase – crushed aggregate
o Roadbase – crushed aggregates with a cementing material.
o Top layer (surfacing) – asphaltic concrete

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 7
2. Types & Characteristic of Flexible & Rigid Pavement
Rigid pavement
• Constructed with Portland cement concrete & aggregates (coarse & fine)
• Consist of several layers:
• Lower layer (subgred) – In-situ soil.
• Subbase – granular material or suitable stabilized material.
• Top layer – Portland cement concrete slab.
• Transverse contraction joints are built into the pavement to control the
cracking of the slab due to the shrinkage of the concrete during the curing of
fresh concrete.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 8
2. Types & Characteristic of Flexible & Rigid Pavement
Factor Selecting Type of Pavement
Deterioration due to climatic
effects, Ease of recycling &
Environmental
Noise
Traffic loading, Materials, Soils,
Pavement performance &
Safety

Engineering Social

Selection of
pavement type:
Road User Cost
Contractor’s capability
& Paving equipment

Construction Cost Maintenance

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 9
2. Types & Characteristic of Flexible & Rigid Pavement
The Differences Between Flexible and Rigid Pavement

Flexible Pavement Rigid Pavement


• Asphaltic cement (i.e. bitumen) & • Portland cement, aggregates, steel for
aggregates reinforcement
• Last for 20 years • Last for 40 years
• Low initial cost • High initial cost
• Cheap & easy to get material • Material shortage problem
• High cost & scheduled maintenance • More economic maintenance, no schedule

• Less economic for long duration • More economic for long duration
• Easy to upgrade • Cannot upgrade
• Rutting, potholes • Free from rutting, potholes
• Can be used once ready •Traffic disturbance – wait 28 days for max
strength

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 10
3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement
Learning Outcome
At the end of the lesson, students should be able to Select the
appropriate materials for used in road construction.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 11
3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement
Introduction
• Typical structural layer arrangement for each pavement type
Portland cement concrete

Asphaltic concrete Contraction


joint

Load
Base course transfer Base course
device

Subbase course
Subgrade

Subgrade

a) Flexible pavement b) Rigid Pavement

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 12
3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement
Introduction
Flexible Rigid
Surfacing course Forms impermeable n flexible lining Surface from Portland cement concrete slab
– high elastic modulus o Contraction joints – control cracking due to
o wearing – resist abrasion, shrinkage of concrete during curing
prevent skidding, waterproof o Load transfer device – dowel bars –
o binder – support & disperse minimize deflection and reduce stresses
traffic, resist shear near the edges of the slab
Base Course Crushed aggregate Optional, depend on subgrade’s engineering
o higher strength than used for properties
subbase o If subgrade soil poor – use this layer
o reduce compression stress o If subgrade stiff enough and drain well
sufficient, this layer is not necessary
Subbase Course Rock – Not required
o bearing capacity higher than
subgrade
o disperse load from base course
before transmitting it to
subgrade
o as drainage layer
Subgrade o Supporting the load transmitted from the overlying layers
o Compacted to maximum density

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 13
3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement
Introduction
Flexible Pavement
o depend on material strength & layer thickness
o some deflection within the elastic limit is allowed
o surface rideability good but less durable to high temperature that cause cracking

Structural Strength and


Performance

Rigid Pavement

o high flexural strength slab & reinforcement


o slab performance good under high loading – expansion and contraction joints
should be allowed
o rough surface – skid resistance – resulting to bumpy n noise

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 14
3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement
Typical Structural Layer Arrangement
1. Subgrade (Prepared Road Bed)
o Natural material located along the horizontal alignment of the
pavement
o Serves as the foundation of the pavement structure
o May also consists of a layer of selected borrow materials, well
compacted.
o It may be necessary to treat the subgrade material to achieve
certain strength properties.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 15
3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement
Typical Structural Layer Arrangement
1. Subgrade (Prepared Road Bed)
2. Subbase Course
o Above the subgrade
o Consists of material of a superior quality than subgrade.
o May be omitted if subgrade material meets the requirements of the subbase
material.
o Can be treated to achieve necessary properties – gradation, plastic chac &
strength.
o The process known as stabilization – treating soils to improve their
engineering properties.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 16
3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement
Typical Structural Layer Arrangement
1. Subgrade (Prepared Road Bed)
2. Subbase Course
3. Base Course
o Above the subbase or subgrade if a subbase course is not used.
o Consists of granular materials such as crushed stone, crushed/uncrushed
slag, crushed/uncrushed gravel and sand.
o Specs usually higher than subbase material in terms of plasticity, gradation
& strength.
o Material that are properly stabilized with Portland cement, asphalt or lime
can be used.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 17
3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement
Typical Structural Layer Arrangement
1. Subgrade (Prepared Road Bed)
2. Subbase Course
3. Base Course
4. Prime Coat
o Protect subgrade and underneath layers from moisture and weathering

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 18
3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement
Typical Structural Layer Arrangement
1. Subgrade (Prepared Road Bed)
2. Subbase Course
3. Base Course
4. Prime Coat
5. Binder Course
o Distribute load from traffic to unbound layer
o Provide flat surface for upper layer (i.e. wearing course)

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 19
3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement
Typical Structural Layer Arrangement
1. Subgrade (Prepared Road Bed)
2. Subbase Course
3. Base Course
4. Prime Coat
5. Binder Course
6. Tact Coat
o Provide adhesion contact between binder and wearing course

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 20
3. Structural Components for Flexible Pavement
Typical Structural Layer Arrangement
1. Subgrade (Prepared Road Bed)
Should be capable:
2. Subbase Course • withstanding high tire pressures
3. Base Course • resisting the abrasive forces due to
traffic
4. Prime Coat • providing a skid-resistant driving surface
5. Binder Course • preventing the penetration of surface
water into the underlying layers.
6. Tact Coat
7. Surface Course

o Upper course of the road pavement.


o Consists of a mixture of mineral
aggregates and asphaltic materials.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 21
4. Materials and Properties of Flexible Pavement
Material Properties

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 22
4. Materials and Properties of Flexible Pavement
Material Properties

Sub-Grade
• Is dependent on soil type, density and
moisture
• CBR used to categories this support
layer
• Input properties such elastic modulus
and Poisson’s ratio

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 23
4. Materials and Properties of Flexible Pavement
Material Properties

Subbase
• Crushed or natural granular material
with maximum 10% fines
• Capability as drainage material or/and
load distribution function.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 24
4. Materials and Properties of Flexible Pavement
Material Properties

Road Base
• Bituminous road base / DBM
• Crushed aggregate /& wet-mix road
base
• Stabilized road base

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 25
4. Materials and Properties of Flexible Pavement
Material Properties
Surface Layer
• Wearing course
• Binder course
• Prime coat
• Tack coat

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 26
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Learning Outcome
• Design the flexible pavement according to JKR Arahan Teknik (Jalan)
method amended 2013.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 27
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Introduction – Design Procedure

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 28
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Introduction – Design Traffic Input
Initial annual commercial traffic for one way, Vo
Vo = ADT (bothways) x ½ x 365 x Pc/100
where, Pc = % commercial vehicles

Total no. of commercial vehicles for one way, Vc


Vc = Vo [(1+r)x – 1]/r
where,
r = annual growth rate
x = design periods (in years)

Equivalent Standard Axle, ESA = Vc x e


e = equivalent factor

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 29
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Introduction – Pavement Thickness Estimation
Based on std CBR value (3%) and ESA – find TA – from Nomograph→Total
thickness of bituminous layer, TA

TA = a1D1 + a2D2 + a3D3


Where;
a = structural coeff. – based on material used for each layer
D = thickness of each layer (not include s

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 30
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
D
10
Thickness Design - Nomograph
C 10
2x106
A 3% B
104

Equivalent Thickness,
Subgrade CBR (%)

Corrected Equivalent
Thickness, TA‘ (cm)
106

TA (cm)
ESA

4%
28cm 44

29cm
44
FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 31
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Thickness Design
Corrected Equivalent Thickness, TA‘ → can be found by using Nomograph
based on CBR value given in the Question and previous TA

Thickness for each layer can be calculated – by trial and error

Asphaltic concrete D1

Base course
D2

Subbase course
D3

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 32
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Thickness Design

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 33
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Thickness Design – Example 5.1
Design a suitable flexible pavement for two-lane highway in rolling terrain using
JKR design method. The current average daily traffic is 6600 vehicles and the
percentage of commercial vehicles is 15%. The annual growth rate expected is
7%. The CBR value of soil in-situ is 5% and the road design life is to be 10
years.
See the relevant charts in the Appendix.
Given Material Used:
Base Course – Crushed Aggregate
Subbase– Sand
Given;

ADT = 6600
Pc = 15%
Annual growth rate, r = 7%
CBR = 5%
road design life = 10 years

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 34
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Thickness Design – Example 5.1

V0 = ADT x (Pc/100) x 365 x ½


= 6600 x 15/100 x 365 x ½
= 180675

VC = V0 [(1+r)x – 1] = 180675 [(1+0.07)10 – 1]


r 0.07
= 2.5 x 106

ESA = e x VC
= 2 x 2.5 x 106
= 5 x 106

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 35
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Thickness Design – Example 5.1

From Nomograph: TA’ = 26 cm

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 36
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Thickness Design – Example 5.1
First Trial:
TA’ = a1D1 + a2D2 + a3D3
= 1.00 (10) + 0.32 (15) + 0.23 (25)
= 20.55 cm < TA’ = 26 cm

Second Trial:
TA’ = a1D1 + a2D2 + a3D3
= 1.00 (15) + 0.32 (16) + 0.23 (25)
= 25.9 cm ~ TA’ = 26 cm
Therefore:
Surfacing Layer = 15 cm (150 mm)
Base Layer = 16 cm (160 mm)
Subbase Layer = 25 cm (250 mm)
FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 37
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Thickness Design – Example 5.1

150 mm Asphaltic
Concrete

160 mm Crushed
Aggregate

250 mm
Sand

Subgrade

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 38
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Check for Highway Capacity
Maximum hourly capacity of traffic for one way,
c = IRT
Where; I = maximum hourly capacity under ideal condition
R = carriageway roadway reduction factor
T = traffic reduction factor

Assuming that max hourly capacity, c only represents 10% from the daily
capacity, C

C = 10 x c

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 39
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Check for Highway Capacity
Total daily traffic flow for one way, Vx →actual
Vx = Vi x (1+r)x
where Vi = initial daily traffic for one way
= ADT (bothways) x ½
Compare Vx and C

If Vx < C → highway capacity has not been reached after x years OK


If Vx > C → highway capacity has been reached before x years NOT OK

So, number of years, n required to reach capacity highway


n = log (C/Vi)
log (1+r)

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 40
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Check for Highway Capacity

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 41
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Check for Highway Capacity – Example 5.2
A two lane expressway in rolling terrain is expected to carry 50 million
standard axles during its 15 years performance life. The subgrade CBR
test results indicate the design value to be 6%. Check the highway
capacity after 15 years.

- Carriageway width = 7.5 m


- Shoulder width = 2.0 m
- Percentage of commercial vehicles, Pc = 11%
- Annual growth rate, r = 4.5%
- Initial ADT (both ways) = 7500

See the relevant charts in the Appendix.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 42
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Check for Highway Capacity – Example 5.2

Capacity check:

Total one way traffic flow after 15 years:


Vx = Vi (1+r)x
Vx = 7500 (1+0.045)15
2

= 7257 veh/day/lane

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 43
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Check for Highway Capacity – Example 5.2
Maximum hourly one way traffic flow:
c=IxRxT
From Appendix: I = 1000, R = 1.00
T = 100 / (100 + 2Pc)
= 100 / [100 + 2 (11)] = 0.82
Therefore,
c = 1000 x 1.00 x 0.82 = 820 veh/hr/lane
Maximum daily one way traffic flow:
(*Assume hourly capacity is 10% of daily capacity)
C = 10 x 820 = 8200 veh/day/lane
C = 8200 veh/day/lane > Vx = 7257 veh/day/lane
Therefore the maximum capacity has not been reached after 15 years.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 44
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Check for Highway Capacity – Exercise 5.1
Based on the following information, proposed a suitable design period
on two lane highway.

- Carriageway width = 7.5 m


- Shoulder width = 2.0 m
- Gradient of the road = 4% (rolling)
- Percentage of commercial vehicles, Pc = 18%
- Annual growth rate, r = 9%
- Initial ADT (both ways) = 8000
- Subgrade CBR = 6%

See the relevant charts in the Appendix.

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 45
5. Design of Flexible Pavement – JKR Method
Road categories

Mountainous/hilly area Rolling area


FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 46
THANK YOU
FOR YOUR KIND ATTENTION

Contact: 019-598 2087


mustaqimnordin@uitm.edu.my
mohd86mustaqim@yahoo.com

FACULTOF
ECG344 CIVIL ENGINEERING
HIGHWAY ENGINEERING FACULTY OF CIVIL ENGINEERING 47

You might also like