Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/51169597
CITATIONS READS
25 2,593
6 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Chronic kidney disease in sugarcane workers in Cameroon, sub-Saharan Africa View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Andre P Kengne on 13 December 2013.
Marie-Patrice Halle1,2, Alexandre Hertig1, Andre Pascal Kengne3, Gloria Ashuntantang4,5, Eric Rondeau1
and Christophe Ridel1
1
Department of Nephrology Intensive Care and Transplantation, Tenon Hospital, Paris, France, 2Department of Internal Medicine,
General Hospital, Douala, Cameroon, 3The George Institute for International Health, The University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia,
4
Department of Internal Medicine and specialties, Faculty of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences, University of Yaounde I, Yaounde,
Abstract Introduction
Background. Acute pulmonary oedema (APO) in patients
undergoing chronic dialysis (CD), a common cause of hos- The global population of individuals with end-stage renal
pital admission in this population, is poorly documented. disease (ESRD) has rapidly increased over the past two
The objective of this study was to determine the causes, decades [1, 2]. In Europe, for instance, available data
profile, clinical course and outcomes of APO in CD pa- indicate an increase in both the incidence and the preva-
tients admitted in an intensive care unit (ICU). lence of chronic dialysis (CD) patients at the average
Methods. Medical charts of all CD patients consecutively annual pace of 4% [2]. CD patients are at increased risk
admitted for APO in the renal ICU of the Tenon Hospital of multiple organ dysfunctions resulting from pre-existing
(Paris, France) between January 2000 and December 2007 medical conditions and secondary complications of renal
were considered. Data collection included patient charac- replacement therapy. As a consequence, they are frequently
teristics, etiologic factors for chronic renal failure and co- hospitalized, particularly in intensive care units (ICUs). In a
morbidities, past history of APO, precipitating factors, recent study, it was estimated that 2% of CD patients per
clinical evolution and outcomes. year would require an ICU admission [3]. The evolution of
Results. Of the 112 files considered, 102 (65% men) were these patients in ICU is characterized by a significant mor-
included in the final analysis. Patients were aged 20–88 bidity and mortality. Cardiovascular diseases including
years and had been dialysed for a median duration of 2 acute pulmonary oedema (APO) are the most common
years. Hypertension (36.3%), chronic glomerulonephritis causes of hospital admission in CD patients [4, 5]. The
(25.5%) and diabetes mellitus (17.6%) were the main etio- dramatic presentation of APO usually calls for emergency
logic factors of chronic renal failure; 38.2% had a past care, usually in ICU. Available studies of APO have mostly
history of APO. Acute pulmonary infection (26%), exces- been conducted in acute coronary care units [6-10]. The
sive interdialytic weight gain (25%) and inappropriate dry few reports about CD patients in ICU have generally
weight prescription (23%) were the leading causes of APO. focused on the reason for their admission and on their
The duration of hospitalization was <4 days in 60% of clinical course [3, 11, 12] but not specifically on APO.
participants. Nine deaths (four being of cardiac origin) The main purpose of this study was to determine the
were recorded. Being referred from another hospital service causes of APO in CD patients admitted in an ICU and
was the main predictor of death. second to determine the clinical course and outcomes.
Conclusions. APO fuelled in part by chest infection,
excessive interdialytic weight gain and inappropriate dry Materials and methods
weight are important causes of hospitalization in CD
patients. Mortality is high among those referred from other The study was conducted in the renal ICU and Transplantation Unit of Tenon
services usually in critical conditions. Hospital in Paris, France. This department is a referral centre with a capacity
of 12 ICU beds, a group of critical care nephrologists. A mean 500 admissions
are recorded per year. Medical records of CD patients admitted from January
Keywords: acute pulmonary oedema; chronic dialysis; intensive care 2000 to December 2007 were retrospectively reviewed for evidence of APO
unit; outcome as reason for admission. Final diagnosis of APO was based on a set of clinical
and radiological findings such as onset of severe cough, dyspnoea, respiratory
distress and clinical and radiological signs of pulmonary congestion. Patients
were excluded if they were not already on chronic dialysis at the time of
The Author 2011. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of ERA-EDTA. All rights reserved.
For Permissions, please e-mail: journals.permissions@oup.com
604 M.-P. Halle et al.
50
45
40
Monday-Wednesday-Friday
Percentage of patients ( )
35
Tuesday-Thursday-Saturday
30
Total
25
20
15
10
0
Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sunday
Admission day
Fig. 1. Days of admission of patients (overall and according their past dialysis schedules: either Monday, Wednesday and Friday or Tuesday, Thursday
Hypertension 76
Pulmonary oedema 39
Ischaemic cardiomyopathy 31
Heart failure 29
Diabetes mellitus 28
Cancers 16
Rythmic disorders 16
Others 15
Lower limbs arteriopathy 13
Dyslipidaemia 11
Smoking 10
Valvulopathy 10
Chronic obstructive bronchopneumopathy 7
Cerebrovascular accident 7
HIV inf ection 4
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Number of patients
admission (for a minimum of 3 months). Data were collected on patient tients with excessive weight gain between dialysis sessions, in the pres-
characteristics at baseline, including demographics, day of admission and ence of adequate volaemic control in dialysis and appropriate target
reasons for admission, primary cause of ESRD and duration of dialysis weight. Inappropriate target weight assessment was defined in patients
dependence as well as prior dialysis schedule (Monday, Wednesday and with fluid congestion resulting from ineffective ultrafiltration during
Friday versus Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday), compliance with dialysis dialysis. Lower respiratory chest infection was based on (i) fever, bio-
and chronic treatment, causes of pulmonary oedema, biological, radiologic logical inflammatory syndrome, asymmetrical basal lung opacities on
and echocardiographic parameters, treatment and outcome. chest X-ray, together with typical radiological signs of pulmonary oedema
before dialysis and (ii) resolution of the radiological signs of pulmonary
Definitions
oedema following dialysis and of the basal asymmetrical opacities only
Routine outpatient dialysis discontinuation was used to characterize pa- after treatment with antibiotics. Precipitating cardiac events were diag-
tients who had missed at least the last scheduled dialysis session in their nosed in the presence of positive biomarkers (troponin).
usual care centre prior to the admission in our ICU. Medication discontin- Data were analysed with the use of SPSS version 9.0.0 for Windows.
uation was used for patients who stopped their chronic medications in- Comparisons used chi-squared test and equivalents for categorical variables
cluding diuretics and blood pressure-lowering medications for at least 7 and t-test and Mann–Whitney U-test for quantitative variables. Logistic
days prior to their admission of APO. Non-compliance with dialysis, diet regressions were used to assess baseline variables that were likely predictors
and medications were used to characterize patients who followed the of death during hospitalization. Unless stated otherwise, comparison tests
above irregularly. Excess interdialytic weight gain was diagnosed in pa- were two sided and a P-value <0.05 was considered statistically significant.
CD and pulmonary oedema 605
Table 1. Characteristics of the study population The median number of past medical events per patient was
3 (ranging from 0 to 8); the most frequent being hypertension
Variables Value (74%) and pulmonary oedema (36%), see Figure 2. The main
causes of ESRD were hypertension (36%), chronic glomer-
N 102
Men, n (%) 66 (65%)
ulonephritis (25%) and diabetes (18%). The initial clinical
Mean age, years (SD) 59.2 (15.7) and paraclinical presentation was dominated by the classical
Mean systolic blood pressure, mmHg (SD) 162.8 (44.8) features of pulmonary oedema (Table 1). Patients were on the
Mean diastolic blood pressure, mmHg (SD) 89.2 (24.4) following treatments prior to admission: calcium channel
Mean heart rate, beats/min (SD) 95 (23) blockers (42), angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors
Mean respiratory rate, per min (SD) 29 (10)
Mean temperature, C (SD) 37.2 (1) (38), beta-blockers (37), diuretics (26), vasodilator (24), an-
Mean weight, kg (SD) 68.9 (17.7) giotensin II receptor antagonists (22), anti-platelets (20) and
Mean oxygen saturation, % (SD) 88 (9) anti-vitamin K anticoagulants (5). Four patients were on peri-
Mean Glasgow score (SD) 14 (2) toneal dialysis and 98 on intermittent conventional haemo-
Median APACHE II score, 28 (25–32)
(25th–75th percentiles)
dialysis. Overall, 75 (73.5%) were compliant with diet,
Median SOFA, (minimum–maximun) 6 (4–10) medication and dialysis; 9 (8.8%) had discontinued the med-
Mean serum potassium, mEq/L (SD) 5.09 (1.44) ication, while 16 (15.7%) had discontinued their dialysis prior
Median brain natriuretic peptide, (IQR) 3247 (2011– to admission.
4896.5) Pulmonary infections (26%), excessive interdialytic weight
Radiological findings
Cardiomegaly 53 (51%) gain (25%) and inappropriate dry weight prescription (23%)
Interstitial oedema 91 (87%) were the most frequent triggering factors associated with
Bronchopneumonia 27
Hypertensive crisis 18
Dialysis discontinuation 8
Sepsis 8
Arythmia 8
Others 3
Treatment discontinuation 3
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Frequency
features of pulmonary oedema. Cardiovascular disorders Treatment and prognosis of pulmonary oedema depend
were the leading cause of pulmonary oedema in our study on its cause. As a result of the high cardiovascular risk
population. However, extracellular volume expansion or profile of individuals with CKD, cardiovascular disease
fluid overload secondary to poor compliance to diet and was an important cause of pulmonary oedema in our pop-
inappropriate estimation of the dry weight, and chest in- ulation [15-17]. Fluid and salt abuse have been reported as
fections were also major causes for this condition. Infec- the most common causes of pulmonary oedema in patients
tions and cardiovascular disease were the main causes of on renal replacement therapy [20]. We also found a high
death. percentage of poor dietary compliance in our study. Over-
We are not aware of any similar study which could estimation of the dry weight and pulmonary infection
provide comparative figures. Existing series of CD were also common causes in our patients. The estimation
patients in ICU have generally focused on causes of hos- of dry weight in patients on CD is a daunting task. It is
pitalizations and outcomes [3, 11, 12]. These studies, very often based on the occurrence of clinical signs attrib-
however, have acknowledged the high prevalence of pul- utable to extracellular volume contraction. The dry weight
monary oedema among CD patients [3, 11, 12]. Our should be reviewed often taking into account new clinical
study population was made up of more men, reflecting events. An important finding was the number of patients
the well-described male dominance among individuals successfully treated medically, indicating that vasodilators,
with chronic renal diseases [13]. A striking finding nitrates and diuretics were still effective in CD patients.
was the pattern of admission day: patients on the The death rate in our study (9%) is similar to that reported
Monday-Wednesday-Friday maintenance dialysis sched- by studies of APO in patients with coronary diseases or heart
ule were typically admitted on a Sunday, while those on failure [6, 9, 18-20] and also in patients with APO in general
the Tuesday-Thursday-Saturday were typically admitted internal medicine [13] or in CKD patients in general in ICU
on a Monday. Because these admission days are virtually [11] This finding is striking and should be interpreted with
the days at which these patients would have received caution given the small size of our population. CVD and
their dialysis session in the absence of a Sunday gap, infections have well been documented as leading causes of
we speculate that weekend gaps represent a key contrib- death in CD patients [3, 15-17]. Interestingly, the cause of
utor to pulmonary oedema in our population. Recent pulmonary oedema was not a determinant of death in our
evidence suggests that ‘intensive dialysis’ (six sessions study. The association of hospital source with death is prob-
per week) as opposed to conventional dialysis (three ably explained by the fact that patients often deteriorate
sessions per week) does not affect hospitalization or following inter-hospital transfers. Their underlying illnesses
death unrelated to vascular access in the general popula- were likely to be more severe. Mechanical invasive ventila-
tion of CD patients [14]. Our findings could thus merely tion is known as a predictor of death [11, 13, 19]. In our
reflect a decreased tolerance to fluid overload in selected study, the primary indication for mechanical ventilation in
patients with a poor heart condition and/or with poor many patients was not for pulmonary oedema, but instead
adherence to the common restrictions in salt and water for pulmonary infection, a common cause of decompensa-
during the weekend. tion in this population.
CD and pulmonary oedema 607
Table 2. Characteristics for those who survived and those who died identify the predictors of the outcome in this specific
during hospitalization population and to better tailor their management.
Variables Survivors Non-survivors P
Conflict of interest statement. None declared.
Number 93 9
Age (years) 59.7 6 15.7 53.7 6 15.9 0.27
Sex (men, n) 61 5 0.72
Average number 362 362 0.57 References
of antecedents
Origin (hospital, n) 32 8 0.002 1. Ruggenenti P, Schieppati A, Remuzzi G. Progression, remission,
Mean duration on 362 363 0.86 regression of chronic renal diseases. Lancet 2001; 357: 1601–1608
dialysis (years) 2. Berthoux F, Jones E, Gellert R et al. Epidemiological data of treated
Blood pressure (BP) end-stage renal failure in the European Union (EU) during the year
Systolic (mmHg) 167.6 6 42.8 115.4 6 37.4 0.001 1995: report of the European Renal Association Registry and the
Diastolic (mmHg) 91.5 6 23.3 65.9 6 24.5 0.004 National Registries. Nephrol Dial Transplant 1999; 14: 2332–2342
BP control 0.01 3. Uchino S, Morimatsu H, Bellomo R et al. End-stage renal failure
Hypotension 3 3 patients requiring renal replacement therapy in the intensive care unit:
Optimal 26 3 incidence, clinical features, and outcome. Blood Purif 2003; 21:
Non-optimal 64 3 170–175
Heart rate (beats/min) 96 6 24 86 6 17 0.29 4. Sarnak MJ, Levey AS. Epidemiology, diagnosis, and management of
Mean potassium level, 5.17 (1.46) 4.00 (0.63) 0.06 cardiac disease in chronic renal disease. J Thromb Thrombolysis
mEq/L (SD) 2000; 10: 169–180
Hypokalaemia 4/82 1/6 0.06