Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Riph Reviewer
Riph Reviewer
3 APPROACHES OF HISTORIOGRAPHY
1. History from Above - regarded as a matter of what the powerful, the ruling class, the famous, the
colonizers, and the wealthy people thought of and what they did, and what the "ordinary" people felt and
tried to accomplish was insignificant and therefore not worth mentioning as part of history.
- chronicles written by explorers in the middle ages after a successful invasion of
unexplored territory
- Fray Juan de Plasencia - an Italian priest who was able to come to the country thru
the sponsorship of the Spanish king. His book “Customs of the Tagalogs” - told of
the daily lives of the natives in early colonial society and described the existing
social classes during this period.
-
2. History from Below - a movement that asserts workers, women, immigrants, and minorities have their
own respective stories or history. (Ka-May Cheng, 2012)
- originated from the British Marxist historian E.P. Thompson and the German historian Hans Ulrich
Wehler with his book “Historical Social Science” (Ka-May Cheng, 2012)
HISTORIOGRAPHY - the writing of history using any of the approaches (History from Above, History from
Below, Pantayong Pananaw)
- involves historical writing culled from many sources in order to avoid biases.
- writing of history, a study on its methodology, and the sources that were used by
the historian.
- re-telling of one’s own significant/meaningful experiences inhis life.
- 3 Categories Of History;
1. Documents - include many classifications: ordinances, letters, written laws, statutes, resolutions,
personal data, or testimonies of witnesses to that past,
2. Relics or Remains - buildings, ruins, churches, temples; could be immovable objects
3. A. Artifacts - eating implements, cooking devices, kitchen utensils, work implements, work
animals (in the form of fossils); are portable items - “clue about the past simply by virtue of their
existence in a place”.
B. The Testimonies of Witnesses to the Past - of oral history wherein a historian interviews face-
to face a person who may either be a participant to a past event, or he had witnessed first-hand
a particular activity that had bearing to meaningful one.
- “the oral and written reports that describe an event” (Howell and Prevenier, 2001).
HISTORICAL METHOD - historians have to verify sources, date them, locate their place of origin and
identify their intended functions. (Candelaria and Alporha (2018).
Historical Source - objects from the past or testimonies concerning the past on which historians depend
in order to create their own depiction of that past (Howell and Prevenier, 2001).
Another type of classifications: (a) written and non-written, (b) published or unpublished and, (c) textual,
oral, or visual sources
2 CLASSIFICATION OF HISTORICAL SOURCE
1. PRIMARY SOURCES - a source of historical data or information described as first-hand
- a source free from anyone’s interpretation.
- raw and unprocessed
- element of having a close and direct connection to the subject under study.
2. SECONDARY SOURCE - the information it provides has already underwent a process of filtration.
- the information it carries has been screened, interpreted, organized, rephrased,
judged and simplified by a certain individual or group of individuals through the
historical methods to produce a particularly easy-to-read materials in making sense
of the past.
- Examples of secondary sources:
1. History textbook
2. Printed materials (serials, periodicals which interprets previous research)
OTHER SOURCES (OR MIXED SOURCES) - are documents that contain both eyewitness accounts of the
participant but may also include statements from family members of the eyewitness who told of the
details of the story.
- called mixed since it combines documents or printed materials, like diaries and
newspapers, or a written testimony like a court record.
- Examples: diaries and newspapers, community newspapers, or tabloids.
- Newspapers - published printed materials that contain narration of events and
situations locally or maybe globally
Bantay Kasaysayan - an organization of history professors who pursue history writing and re-tells these as
it is: “Ang kasaysayan ay mahalaga kung ito’y magagamit sa kasalukuyan upang magsilbing paalala, at
babala, kung ito’y pahahalagahan upang mapatigil o mapahinto ang katanghan (katangahan) ng
kahapon na maulit pa sa ngayon at sa hinaharap”
• History is a record of past events, a study of the past events that were considered significant in a peoples’
life. It can be written thru eyewitness accounts and declarations, or it may be retold by others who were
not participants to the event.
• Historiography is the science of writing history, and a study of its methods. It has three approaches
namely 1) HISTORY FROM ABOVE 2) HISTORY FROM BELOW and 3) PANTAYONG PANANAW. Sources for
writing the past events have 5 kinds: primary source, primary testimony, secondary source, secondary
testimony, and others (mixed sources). There are several types of these sources that include documents,
records, statutes, photographs, birth certificates, death certificates, artifacts, relics, and others.
• The importance or relevance of knowing and studying about one’s past stems from the fact that
governance policies and laws were crafted based on the knowledge of the past. It is also being studies
about in order to avoid mistakes of the past or at least prevent a repetition of it.
Historical Criticism - in order for a source to be used as evidence in history, basic matters about its form
and content must be settled: External Criticism & Internal Criticism
EXTERNAL CRITICISM - historical criticism that addresses the problems of authenticity of the evidence.
- process of scrutinizing every aspect related to its forms.
- to prevent the use of evidence that are fabricated, forged, and faked in making
historical claims
- physical form
- distinguish which evidence is a hoax or misrepresentation (Gottschalk, 1969)
Hoax- a humorous or malicious deception
External Test:
1. Date of the Document
2. Author of the Document
3. Anachronistic Style – general, specific time (ten commandments)
4. Provenance or Custody – (lupang hinirang origin)
5. Anachronistic Reference
6. Definitions
7. Ambiguities - kalabuan
INTERNAL CRITICISM - looks into the problems of credibility of the evidence
- Credibility - accuracy of the contents
- considers every significant aspect the existing evidence carries (Gottschalk, 1969)
Internal Test:
1. Identification of the Author
2. Approximate date
3. Author’s ability for truth – background/experiences
4. Author’s willingness for truth – biases/prejudices
5. Corroboration – not rely to the material but also look for other documents related to study we want to
established
Lesson 2
FIRST VOYAGE AROUND THE WORLD BY ANTONIO PIGAFFETA
- 1519-1522
September 6, 1522 - a travelogue containing a cartographic and ethnographic record, existed first as a
summary, later as a fuller version published in 1524
Four known manuscripts: One is in Italian at the Ambrosiana Library, Milan, and three others in French
are located at other repositories such as the Yale University (McCarl, 2014).
- a primary source
Kartilya - written to introduce new recruits to the principles and values that Katipunan organization
upholds (Candelaria and Alporha, 2018).
Every year, the Philippines commemorates its anniversary of its Independence proclaimed on
June 12, 1898, in the province of Cavite. This event is widely received as a significant turning point in the
history of the country primarily because it signaled the end of over three centuries (333 years) of Spanish
colonization. However, in contrast to this popularity, most Filipinos especially teachers and students,
never get the chance to read the details of the actual document (Candelaria and Alporha, 2018).
The document was written and prepared by a Filipino lawyer named Ambrosio Rianzares Bautista.
This 21 page document was originally written in Spanish which indicates the level of fluency of Filipinos in
the use of Spanish language at the time. The original title of the document was Acta de la Proclamacion
de la Independencia del Pueblo Filipino. Aside from being the author of the declaration document,
Ambrosio Rianzares was also the one who read and waved the Philippine flag during the declaration
(Viray, 2019).
ALFREDO ROCES
• April 29, 1932 (age 90 years), Santa Cruz, Manila
• Artist writer from the known Roces clan in Philippine Print Media.
• Known Journalist in Manila Times
HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
• During the American era (1900-1941), Philippine Political Cartoons Gained Full Expression
• Filipino Artists recorded national attitudes towards the coming of the Americans as well as the
changing mores and times
• While the 377 cartoons compiled in this book speak for themselves
• Historian Alfred McCoy’s extensive research in Philippine and American archives provides a
comprehensive background not only to the cartoons but to the turbulent as well.
CONTENT ANALYSIS
• The presentation of the cartoons varies from racial to conservative, vivid and wordy to express
the cartoonist’s views and languages used are either in English or Spanish.
• The victims are presented in a bad story state to convey sympathy for the readers.
• The characters to emphasize on the “ good side” are shown in normal features while the “ bad”
emaciated, leering, laughing creatures, more on animal features than human.
• The artists, using the cartoons, illustrates not just their opinions, but broad image of the
Philippines under US
• The transition from Spanish colonial period to American occupation shows different changes as
well as in culture, society and political.
• The drastic introduction of democracy to a nation not properly oriented about it and its
consequences are far from ideas. This, it ushered free press.
• The rich remained affluent and powerful, while the poor people remained poor, desperate, and
victims of state repression.
Samples of Caricatures
• THE INDEPENDENT (MAY 20, 1916)
• THE INDEPENDENT (JUNE 16, 1917)
• The Independent on the 27th of November 1915
• Lipang Kalabaw on the 24th of August 1907
CONTRIBUTION AND RELEVANCE OF THE IMPORTANT HISTORICAL INFORMATION
• The cartoons can be used to look at the political situation in the American era
• Clarifies historical information and served as an eyeopener
• Used as medium to inform the masses about the society’s condition
• Pressing issues are shown in the caricatures during this era
• Brought back patriotism
Political cartoons and caricature are form of art whose technique is centered on the exaggeration
of human features and poking fun at its subjects. Such art genre and technique became a part of the print
media as a form of social and political commentary, which usually targets persons of power and authority.
Cartoons and caricature became an effective tool of publicizing opinion through heavy use of
symbolism. Their ability to represent opinion and capture the audience’s imagination is among the
reasons that compelled historians to examine political cartoons and conduct historical examination
(Candelaria and Alporha, 2018).
HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
• Feud between Ferdinand Marcos and Ninoy Aquino
• Declaration of Martial Law (September 21, 1972)
• Assassination of Senator Benigno Aquino (August 21, 1983)
• Snap Election
• Marcos signed Proclamation No. 1081 on September 21, 1972, placing the Philippines under
Martial Law. However, announcement was made on September 23, 1972 [the start of 14 years
Martial Law in the Philippines]
• People’s Power Revolution (Feb 22-25, 1986)
• Epifanio de los Santos Avenue (EDSA)
• Corazon’s Presidency
• Speech of President Corazon Aquino during the Joint Session of the U.S. Congress ( September
18, 1986)
• 1987 Constitution [pinalit ni Corazon Aquino sa constitution ni Marcos]
CONTENT ANALYSIS
• The death of her husband Ninoy Aquino
• Ninoy’s death was the third and the last time that Cory and children lost Ninoy
• Cory introduced the democratic that she claimed as coming also from her husband
• Restoration of democracy from authoritarianism of Ferdinand Marcos
CONTRIBUTION AND RELEVANCE OF THE IMPORTANT HISTORICAL INFORMATION
• Corazon "Cory" Cojuangco Aquino functioned as the symbol of the restoration of democracy and
the overthrow of the Marcos Dictatorship in 1986
• The document is relevant in the philippine history especially in the diplomatic and political
history
• This document contributed to Philippine history as it traced back the first step of the country to
restore democracy the Marcos outlawed.
After the eventful overthrow of the Marcos Dictatorship in 1986 through EDSA People Power,
Cory came out easily as the symbol of democracy. As the widow of the slain Senator Benigno “Ninoy’
Aquino Jr., the leader of Marcos oppositionist, Cory was seen mourning by the public. She was then seen
as the torch bearer of all that her husband fought for. Though without political experience as she was a
plain housewife at the time, people begun to see her as the symbol of hope and freedom— the sentiment
that made her president.
On September 18, 1986, seven months since she became president, Cory went to the United
States to deliver a speech. Before the joint session of the U.S. Congress and with a prepared script written
by Teddy Locsin Jr, Cory stood and spoke with eloquence and passion. This historic speech of Cory holds
answers to questions related to political uncertainty and international diplomacy the Philippines had at
the time (Candelaria and Alporha, 2018).
LESSON 3
Perspective – the way how you see or view things which is basically anchored to what you have already
knew.
Historical interpretations - judgments of historians on how the past should be seen, hence the history we
read, though based on facts, is strictly speaking, not factual at all, but a series of accepted judgments
(Candelaria and Alphora, 2018).
1872 - historic year of two events in Philippine history: as significant as the 1896 and 1898
1. Cavite Mutiny
2. Martyrdom of the three priest or GOMBURZA
Truth is freedom and freedom is the foundation of a sincere love for our nation
Journalists during this time would use the phrase “el grito de rebellion” which translates to “the cry of
rebellion” to describe the beginning of these momentous events (rebellions) that were rampantly
happening across Spanish colonies.
August 1896 – Filipinos declared our own rebellion—our “cry” against the said colonizers.
Manuel Sastron - Spanish historian, 1897 book, “La Insurreccion en Filipinas”
Teodoro Agoncillo used the term “cry” to refer to that momentous event of Katipunan tearing their
sedulas accompanied by a scream.
CONTROVERSY 3: Did Rizal Retract?
Jose Rizal - hero of the revolution because of his writings that center on ending colonialism and liberating
the Filipino minds because he believed that these are the initial steps toward the creation of a Filipino
nation.
- the writings were largely scrutinizing the friars whom he referred to as the major cause of injustices and
sufferings of Filipinos.
- the retraction of Rizal is a proof that Jose Rizal took back everything he said against the church and died
as a Catholic.
LESSON 4
A. AGRARIAN REFORM POLICIES – Analyze the agrarian policies pursued by Ferdinand Marcos
(1965-1986) up until to the present administration, President Rodrigo Duterte.
i. What were the agrarian policies of each administration (give the highlights only)?
ii. Do these agrarian policies able to address the problems of our farmers (e.g. no land, lack of
farming equipment and capital)?
iIi. What are your recommendations to solve the given issue?
B. PHILIPPINE CONSTITUTION – Analyze the four (4) constitutions of the Philippines (Malolos
Constitution, 1935 Constitution, 1973 Constitution, and 1987 Constitution).
• MALOLOS CONSTITUTION
-In 1899, the Malolos Constitution, the first Philippine Constitution—the first republican
constitution in Asia—was drafted and adopted by the First Philippine Republic, which
lasted from 1899 to 1901. The constitution specifically provided for safeguards against
abuses, and enumerated the national and individual rights not only of the Filipinos and
of the aliens. The legislative powers were exercised by the Assembly of Representatives
composed of delegates elected according to law. The Government of the Republic is
popular, representative, alternative, and responsible, and shall exercise three distinct
powers: namely, the legislative, the executive, and the judicial.
• 1935 CONSTITUTION
-The 1935 Constitution, which featured a political system virtually identical to the
American one, became operative. The system called for a President to be elected at large
for a 4-year term (subject to one re-election), a bicameral Congress, and an independent
Judiciary.
• 1973 CONSTITUTION
The 1973 Constitution: draft presented to President Marcos by the 1971 Constitutional
Convention on December 1, 1972; deemed ratified by Citizens' Assemblies held from
January 10 to 15, 1973, proclaimed in force by Proclamation by President Marcos,
January 17, 1973. The declaration of Martial Law through Proclamation No. 1081 by
former President Ferdinand E, Marcos in 1972 brought about the transition from the
1935 Constitution to the 1973 Constitution. This transition had implications on the
Court’s composition and functions. The Justices of the Court were appointed by the
President alone, without the consent, approval, or recommendation of any other body
or officials.
• 1987 CONSTITUTION
The 1987 Constitution established a representative democracy with power divided
among three separate and independent branches of government: the Executive, a
bicameral Legislature, and the Judiciary.