You are on page 1of 4

Toxicon xxx (2015) 1e4

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Toxicon
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/toxicon

Depression e An emerging indication for botulinum toxin treatment


Tillmann H.C. Kruger a, M.Axel Wollmer b, *
a
Department of Psychiatry, Social Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, Medical School Hannover, Germany
b
Asklepios Clinic North d Ochsenzoll, Asklepios Campus Hamburg, Medical Faculty, Semmelweis University, Germany

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: The treatment of glabellar frown lines with botulinum toxin injection is one of the most prevalent
Received 15 July 2015 procedures in esthetic medicine. It is possible that the popularity of this intervention is not only owing to
Received in revised form its cosmetic effect but also to modulatory effects on mood and affectivity.
10 September 2015
Recently, a series of studies including three randomized controlled trials have consistently shown that
Accepted 22 September 2015
Available online xxx
such effects can be used in the treatment of depression. Predominantly female patients suffering from
partly chronic and treatment resistant unipolar depression experienced a quick, strong and sustained
improvement in depressive symptoms after a single glabellar treatment with botulinum toxin A as a sole
Keywords:
Embodied emotions
or adjunctive therapy.
Body therapy If these findings are further corroborated in additional studies, the ever-growing spectrum of appli-
Major depressive disorder cations for botulinum toxin may spread into the field of psychiatry, showing that the superficial paralysis
of facial muscles may, probably via proprioceptive feedback mechanisms, have profound effects on the
emotional brain.
© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction 2009). Moreover the perception of visual emotional stimuli is


altered and also the comprehension of sentences with negative
With several million applications per year injections of botuli- emotional connotations is delayed (Davis et al., 2010; Havas et al.,
num toxin as a treatment of glabellar frown lines, this is probably 2010). Accordingly, the treatment reduces the activation of the
the most frequent intervention in esthetic medicine (Winter and left amygdale during imitation of an angry facial expression
Spiegel, 2009). Glabellar frown lines are produced by the contrac- (Hennenlotter et al., 2009).
tion of the corrugator muscles that occurs under exposure to bright
light, during concentration and above all in order to express 2. The first case series
negative emotions like anger, fear, or sadness. Thus, the motivation
to undergo glabellar botulinum toxin treatment and remove frown Physicians in esthetic medicine who treat patients with botuli-
lines may not be only the whish for a more youthful facial num toxin are familiar with psychological effects of this treatment
appearance but also for a more relaxed and positive facial expres- (Sommer et al., 2003). The dermatologist and plastic surgeon Eric
sion. Hence, it has been shown that the facial expression is shifted Finzi was the first to specifically test the hypothesis that glabellar
away from negative towards positive emotions by glabellar botu- injections of botulinum toxin may be useful in the treatment of
linum toxin treatment (Heckmann et al., 2003). However, it is not depression, a psychiatric disorder in which negative emotions
only emotional expression that is changed by the treatment, but abound. In a case series Finzi and Wasserman treated ten middle-
also emotional experience: This procedure may lead to an aged women with moderate to severe partly chronic and
enhancement of emotional wellbeing beyond the mere cosmetic treatment-resistant depression with a single open label application
benefit (Sommer et al., 2003). It is also associated with reduced of botulinum toxin A (BTA) injections in the glabellar region ac-
levels of irritable, depressed, and anxious mood (Lewis and Bowler, cording to a standard protocol also used for cosmetic treatment of
frown lines (Finzi and Wasserman, 2006). As measured on the Beck
Depression Inventory (BDI) II before (mean ¼ 29) and eight weeks
* Corresponding author. Asklepios Clinic North e Ochsenzoll, Langenhorner
after the treatment (mean ¼ 5.3) nine patients responded to the
Chaussee 560 22419 Hamburg, Germany. treatment with eight of them going to remission of depression. The
E-mail address: m.wollmer@asklepios.com (M.Axel Wollmer). only one who showed only partial response was a patient suffering

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.toxicon.2015.09.035
0041-0101/© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Please cite this article in press as: Kruger, T.H.C., Wollmer, M.A., Depression e An emerging indication for botulinum toxin treatment, Toxicon
(2015), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.toxicon.2015.09.035
2 T.H.C. Kruger, M.Axel Wollmer / Toxicon xxx (2015) 1e4

from severe bipolar depression. Half of the participants received actually had a delayed start design, in which one group received
BTA as a sole and the other half as an adjunctive treatment of BTA treatment immediately and the other with a delay of 12 weeks.
depression. With an overall follow up period of 24 week this study allowed for a
rather long-term observation of those patients who were in the BTA
3. The first randomized controlled trial first group. From the visit after 15 weeks to the final visit after 24
weeks, depression scores and frown line severity showed a diver-
In the first randomized controlled trial (RCT), Wollmer and gent development with further improvement in the former and a
colleagues showed that a single glabellar treatment with BTA can return to baseline of the latter. Thus, the clinical improvement in
lead to a quick, strong and sustained improvement in the symp- depression outlasted the cosmetic BTA effect. The group that
toms of depression (Wollmer et al., 2012). Their study included 30 received BTA as the second injection after 12 weeks also showed an
patients, mostly women with an average age of about 50 years, who improvement in depression after that second injection. Another
suffered from mild to moderate, partly chronic, and treatment phase II RCT on the use of BTA as a treatment of major depression
resistant unipolar depression currently under stable treatment (NCT02116361) with an estimated enrollment of 140 female pa-
with one or two antidepressants. These patients were able to tients will probably be completed early in 2016.
produce moderate to severe frown lines and where randomized to
receive blinded injection of either BTA or saline according to the 5. Other studies
same scheme also applied in the case series by Finzi and Wasser-
man. Men received a total of 39 units onabotulinumtoxinA instead Hexsel et al. conducted an open label study on the effects of
of the 29 units applied in women to account for the higher muscle glabellar BTA injections on self-esteem and depression (Hexsel
mass. In comparison with the placebo group that remained more or et al., 2013). In a group of 25 depressed subjects the BDI score
less stable throughout the study, the BTA group showed a signifi- dropped from an average of 27 to an average of 13, which corre-
cant improvement in the symptoms of depression as early as two sponds to the effects observed in the RCTs described above.
weeks after the injection both on the Hamilton Depression Rating Recently, Boudreau et al. studied the effect of BTA on mild
Scale (HAM-D) and in the BDI. This effect was strong at the primary depressive symptoms in patients (n ¼ 32) with chronic migraine
end point after six weeks (47%; d ¼ 1.28) and increased further until (Boudreau et al., 2015). BTA was applied according to the scheme
the end of the study after sixteen weeks (d ¼ 1.87). The improve- developed for the treatment of chronic migraine. The authors re-
ment in the depression scales was accompanied by an improve- ported improvement not only in the number of headache free days
ment also in Clinical Global Impressions. Partial response (>25% but also in the severity of depressive symptoms as measured by the
reduction in HAM-D score; 87%) and response (>50% reduction in BDI-II after 12 and 24 weeks. However, it can't be excluded the one
HAM-D score; 60%) rates were significantly higher in the BTA group occurred as function of the other.
than in the placebo group and 33% of the BTA treated patients An overview of all clinical trials on the use of BTA in the treat-
attained remission. Those participants with higher levels of psy- ment of depression is given in Table 1.
chomotor agitation at the baseline (HAM-D item 9 > 2) had a
particularly high probability to respond (100%, Wollmer et al., 6. Mechanism of action
2014).
Although there is consistent evidence suggestive of that
4. Further randomized controlled trials glabellar injection of BTA can reduce the symptoms of depression,
the mechanism of action by which improvement in mood is
In a second, larger (n ¼ 74) RCT Finzi and Rosenthal confirmed accomplished is still unknown. There are several possibilities how
the antidepressant effect of BTA. The participants in this trial were BTA alleviates depression: cosmetic effects achieved by glabellar
slightly more depressed with otherwise similar baseline charac- muscle relaxation may result in a better body image, enhanced self
teristics compared to the study by Wollmer et al. (Finzi and esteem, and elevated mood (Molina et al., 2015). However, several
Rosenthal, 2014). According to the same protocol of the previous findings make it unlikely that this is the main mechanism of action:
trials, patients were randomized to receive either BTA (n ¼ 33) or In the first RCT the method under investigation, i.e. the injection of
saline (n ¼ 41) injections and were examined after three and six BTA was not disclosed in the advertisement for the recruitment of
weeks using the BDI-II and Montgomery-Asberg Depresssion Rat- participants but only at screening, in order to avoid participants
ing Scale depression rating scales. Highly significant improvement that were particularly attracted by the perspective to receive a BTA
in depression occurred after three weeks and was more pro- treatment with the known cosmetic effects. In the RCT treatment
nounced after six weeks, which was the primary end point of the outcome did not correlate with the appreciation of the cosmetic
study with similar improvement and response rates observed in change (Wollmer et al., 2012). Improvement in BDI scores did not
the study by Wollmer et al. (Wollmer et al., 2012). In addition Finzi correlate with changes in self esteem scores as measured by the
and Rosenthal also observed a significantly higher remission rate in Rosemberg scale (Hexsel et al., 2013) Moreover, presence of frown
the BTA group compared to placebo. Of note, BTA was effective both lines at the baseline was not a prerequisite for response in a RCT
as a sole (remission rate 21%) and as an adjunctive (remission rate that did not have frown lines as an inclusion criterion (Finzi and
36%) treatment and the antidepressant effect did not seem to Rosenthal, 2014). One patient with a structurally fixed severe
require the presence of glabellar frown lines at baseline (remission frown line did not experience any cosmetic change but went into
in 5 of 13 participants without frown). remission. Another subject even reported that she specifically dis-
In a third RCT (n ¼ 30) by Magid et al. the previous findings were liked the cosmetic change but still attained remission of her
further corroborated and extended (Magid et al., 2014). This study depression (Wollmer et al., 2012). Moreover, the antidepressant
had a crossover design, in which those patients who initially where effect outlasted the cosmetic change in a RCT with a follow-up
randomized to the BTA (n ¼ 11) arm received a second injection of period of 24 weeks (Magid et al., 2014).
saline and those who were in the placebo arm (n ¼ 19) were It is possible that a change in facial expression from the negative
switched to BTA after 12 weeks. Since the muscle relaxing effect of emotions associated with depression towards more positive emo-
the first BTA injection had not worn off after 12 weeks and the tions may confer a more positive social feedback during the inter-
observed improvement in depression remained stable, the study action with the own mirror image or a social interaction partner.

Please cite this article in press as: Kruger, T.H.C., Wollmer, M.A., Depression e An emerging indication for botulinum toxin treatment, Toxicon
(2015), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.toxicon.2015.09.035
T.H.C. Kruger, M.Axel Wollmer / Toxicon xxx (2015) 1e4 3

Table 1
Trials on the use of botulinum toxin in the treatment of depression.

Yeara Studyb Authors Patients Interventionc Outcome

2006 Finzi & Wasserman N ¼ 10 29 U onabotulinumtoxinA First study showing that BTA can improve
female Glabella the symptoms of depression. Response or
remission was attained by almost all patients.
2012 RCT Wollmer et al. N ¼ 30 29/39 U onabotulinumtoxinA First RCT showing significant improvement in
NCT00934687 or saline placebo depression and higher partial response and
Glabella response rates after adjunctive BTA injection
compared to placebo.
2013 RCT Finzi & Rosenthal N ¼ 74 29/40 U onabotulinumtoxinA Significant improvement in depression, higher
NCT01556971 or saline placebo response and also higher remission rates after
Glabella sole or adjunctive BTA injection compared to placebo.
2013 NCT01004042 Hexsel et al. N ¼ 25 20-40 U onabotulinumtoxinA Improvement in the symptoms of depression
after injection of BTA
2014 RCT Magid et al. N ¼ 30 29/39 U onabotulinumtoxinA Significant improvement in depression, higher
NCT01392963 or saline placebo response and also higher remission rates after
Glabella BTA injection compared to placebo outlasting
muscular paralysis and cosmetic change.
2015 Boudreau et al. N ¼ 32 155 U onabotulinumtoxinA Improvement in depressive symptoms associated
Head and neck with chronic migraine.
n.a. RCT Allergan N ¼ 140 Two different doses n.a.
NCT02116361 onabotulinumtoxinA
or saline placebo
a
Year of first online or print journal publication.
b
Trial number in the ClinicalTrial.gov study registry.
c
Doses separated by “/” refer to women and men, respectively.

However, both people living on their own and people living in them with chronic and treatment-resistant depression (Gilmer
partnerships or families took part in the studies and the respective et al., 2005). Thus, there is a strong medical, social and economic
social status did not predict the outcome (Wollmer et al., 2012, need for the development of new methods to treat depression. To
2014). Therefore, it is unlikely that altered social feedback is the use BTA in the treatment of depression is a new approach with
main mechanism of action. several favorable aspects: The long-lasting effect of a single treat-
The most plausible and most probable mechanism by which BTA ment may facilitate therapy adherence, which may be a critical
may reduce the symptoms of depression is the interruption of a issue in the treatment of patients with depression (Serna et al.,
feedback loop from the face to the brain that would reinforce and 2010). If the costs are allocated per treatment day the long treat-
maintain the negative emotions associated with depression. These ment intervals render BTA an economic therapeutic option (Beer,
emotions are expressed by the contraction of the corrugator mus- 2010). The safety and tolerability record of BTA injections to the
cles which is abolished by the BTA injection. A relative over activity glabellar region is very good (Brin et al., 2009). All these aspects
of the corrugator muscles can be recorded by electromyography in make BTA an attractive potential option in the future treatment of
patients suffering from depression (Schwartz et al., 1976). It may be depression for patients, physicians, and the public health system.
corrected by the paralytic effect of the injected BTA. The underlying Because glabellar injection of BTA is registered for the treatment of
facial feedback hypothesis dates back to William James and Charles frown lines, depressed patients with such lines may be treated
Darwin in the 19th century. It means that the facial expression of an today without going off label.
initially faint and cool emotion generates a proprioceptive feedback
signal from the face to the brain that enhances the emotion and
allows for its powerful and warm experience (Adelmann and 8. Open questions
Zajonc, 1989; Al Abdulmohsen and Kruger, 2011). The facial feed-
back hypothesis has been validated in classical experiments Low or absent placebo effects in conjunction with difficulties to
showing that the arbitrary contraction of facial muscles can blind patients for their treatment allocation raises the question, to
modulate the emotional appraisal of a presented visual stimulus what extent the results of the RCTs may be attributed to placebo
(Strack et al., 1988; Larsen et al., 1992). effects. A facial injection that leads to a visible change in facial
There is experimental evidence that a fraction of locally injected expression certainly has a considerable suggestive power. There-
BTA may undergo axonal and even trans-synaptic transport into the fore it is possible that the proportion of placebo effects in the
CNS (Caleo and Schiavo, 2009). Central effects may be of clinical clinical improvement of depression is higher after BTA treatment
relevance in humans and we can't formally exclude that they could than after treatment with an oral antidepressant. Conversely it is
be involved in the mood-lifting effects of BTA observed in our possible that disappointment over the obvious absence of a
studies (Marchand-Pauvert et al., 2013). cosmetic change under placebo condition may have led to nocebo
effects in this group. This may have led to an inflation of the group
differences in the randomized controlled trials and to an over-
7. Significance for the management of depression estimation of the efficacy of BTA as a treatment of depression.
However, the RCTs patient's expectations and credibility regarding
Affecting more than 350 million people worldwide major the method did not correlate with the outcome (Wollmer et al.,
depression is one of the leading causes of disability in the world 2012). Moreover, in one of the RCTs their hit rate when guessing
(Kessler et al., 2003). There are several effective psychotherapeutic, group allocation was scarcely above chance level and correct or
pharmacological and biological approaches to the treatment of incorrect guessing was not associated with outcome either (Finzi
depression. However, a considerable proportion of patients do not and Rosenthal, 2014). Importantly, in another RCT the improve-
sufficiently respond to these existing treatment options, leaving ment in depression outlasted the cosmetic effect of the treatment

Please cite this article in press as: Kruger, T.H.C., Wollmer, M.A., Depression e An emerging indication for botulinum toxin treatment, Toxicon
(2015), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.toxicon.2015.09.035
4 T.H.C. Kruger, M.Axel Wollmer / Toxicon xxx (2015) 1e4

(Magid et al., 2014). Caleo, M., Schiavo, G., 2009. Central effects of tetanus and botulinum neurotoxins.
Toxicon 54, 593e599.
Very few men took part in the hitherto concluded clinical trials
Davis, J.I., Senghas, A., Brandt, F., Ochsner, K.N., 2010. The effects of BOTOX in-
and an ongoing trial (NCT02116361) enrolls only women. In the first jections on emotional experience. Emotion 10, 433e440.
RCT there was actually a trend towards a gender effect in favor of Finzi, E., Rosenthal, N.E., 2014. Treatment of depression with onabotulinumtoxinA: a
women (Wollmer et al., 2012). Thus, the efficacy of BTA as a randomized, double-blind, placebo controlled trial. J. Psychiatr. Res. 52, 1e6.
Finzi, E., Wasserman, E., 2006. Treatment of depression with botulinum toxin A: a
treatment of depression in men is an open question that should be case series. Dermatol Surg. 32, 645e649.
specifically addressed in future trials. It is unclear if BTA is also Gilmer, W.S., Trivedi, M.H., Rush, A.J., Wisniewski, S.R., Luther, J., Howland, R.H.,
effective in severe, psychotic, or bipolar depression. A comparator et al., 2005. Factors associated with chronic depressive episodes: a preliminary
report from the STAR-D project. Acta Psychiatr. Scand. 112, 425e33.
study in which BTA is tested against an established pharmacolog- Havas, D.A., Glenberg, A.M., Gutowski, K.A., Lucarelli, M.J., Davidson, R.J., 2010.
ical treatment may further clarify the true effect sizes and over- Cosmetic use of botulinum toxin-a affects processing of emotional language.
come the problems associated with blinding. It is possible that Psychol. Sci. 21, 895e900.
Heckmann, M., Teichmann, B., Schroder, U., Sprengelmeyer, R., Ceballos-
other facial muscles involved in the expression of sad mood, like Baumann, A.O., 2003. Pharmacologic denervation of frown muscles enhances
the mentalis muscle or the depressor anguli oris, may also be tar- baseline expression of happiness and decreases baseline expression of anger,
geted with BTA. Moreover it is possible that patients suffering from sadness, and fear. J. Am. Acad. Dermatol. 49, 213e216.
Hennenlotter, A., Dresel, C., Castrop, F., Ceballos-Baumann, A.O., Wohlschlager, A.M.,
other psychiatric disorders in which negative emotions are preva- Haslinger, B., 2009. The link between facial feedback and neural activity within
lent may benefit from BTA treatment, too. To date only onabotuli- central circuitries of emotion-new insights from botulinum toxin-induced
numtoxinA has been investigated as a treatment of depression. It is denervation of frown muscles. Cereb. Cortex 19, 537e542.
Hexsel, D., Brum, C., Siega, C., Schilling-Souza, J., Dal'Forno, T., Heckmann, M.,
probable, but formally remains to be established, that also other
Rodrigues, T.C., 2013. Evaluation of self-esteem and depression symptoms in
types of botulinum toxin are effective in this new indication. depressed and nondepressed subjects treated with onabotulinumtoxinA for
glabellar lines. Dermatol Surg. 39, 1088e1096.
Conflicts of interest Kessler, R.C., Berglund, P., Demler, O., et al., National Comorbidity Survey Replica-
tion, 2003. The epidemiology of major depressive disorder: results from the
National Comorbidity Survey Replication (NCS-R). JAMA 289, 3095e3105.
M.A.W. received honoraria for talks from Merz, Eli Lilly, Lund- Larsen, R.J., Kasimatis, M., Frey, K., 1992. Facilitating the furrowed brow: an unob-
beck, and Novartis. T.H.C.K. received honoraria for talks from Eli trusive test of the facial feedback hypothesis applied to unpleasant affect. Cogn.
Emot. 6, 321e38.
Lilly, Lundbeck, Servier, and Schwabe. These activities were all Lewis, M.B., Bowler, P.J., 2009. Botulinum toxin cosmetic therapy correlates with a
unrelated to the study. M.A.W. received a grant from the Asklepios more positive mood. J. Cosmet. Dermatol. 8, 24e26.
Hamburg GmbH Forschungsfo € rderung for related research. In April Magid, M., R, J.S., Poppy, P.E., Robertson, H.T., LaViolette, A.K., Kruger, T.,
Wollmer, M.A., 2014. Treatment of major depressive disorder using botulinum
2012, i.e. after conclusion and publication of their original study, toxin a: a 24-week randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. J. Clin.
M.A.W. and T.H.C.K. became members of the advisory board of Psychiatry 75, 837e844.
Allergan. This activity ended in April 2014 for M.A.W. and in Marchand-Pauvert, V., Aymard, C., Giboin, L.S., Dominici, F., Rossi, A., Mazzocchio, R.,
2013. Beyond muscular effects: depression of spinal recurrent inhibition after
September 2014 for T.H.C.K. botulinum neurotoxin A. J. Physiol. 591 (Pt 4), 1017e1029.
Molina, B., Grangier, Y., Mole, B., Ribe, N., Martín Diaz, L., Prager, W., Paliargues, F.,
Transparency document Kerrouche, N., 2015. Patient satisfaction after the treatment of glabellar lines
with Botulinum toxin type A (Speywood Unit): a multi-centre European
observational study. J. Eur. Acad. Dermatol. Venereol. 29, 1382e1388.
Transparency document related to this article can be found Schwartz, G.E., Fair, P.L., Salt, P., Mandel, M.R., Klerman, G.L., 1976. Facial muscle
online at http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.toxicon.2015.09.035. patterning to affective imagery in depressed and nondepressed subjects. Sci-
ence 192 (4238), 489e491.
Serna, M.C., Cruz, I., Real, J., Gasco , E., Galva
n, L., 2010. Duration and adherence of
References antidepressant treatment (2003e2007) based on prescription database. Eur.
Psychiatry 25, 206e13.
Adelmann, P.K., Zajonc, R.B., 1989. Facial efference and the experience of emotion. Sommer, B., Zschocke, I., Bergfeld, D., Sattler, G., Augustin, M., 2003. Satisfaction of
Annu. Rev. Psychol. 40, 249e280. patients after treatment with botulinum toxin for dynamic facial lines. Der-
Al Abdulmohsen, T., Kruger, T.H., 2011. The contribution of muscular and auditory matol. Surg. 29, 456e460.
pathologies to the symptomatology of autism. Med. Hypotheses 77, 1038e1047. Strack, R., Martin, L.L., Stepper, S., 1988. Inhibiting and facilitating conditions of
Beer, K., 2010. Cost effectiveness of botulinum toxins for the treatment of depres- facial expressions: a nonobstrusive test of the facial feedback hypothesis.
sion: preliminary observations. J. Drugs Dermatol. 9, 27e30. J. Personal. Soc. Psychol. 54, 768e77.
Boudreau, G.P., Grosberg, B.M., McAllister, P.J., Lipton, R.B., Buse, D.C., 2015. Pro- Winter, L., Spiegel, J., 2009. Botulinum toxin type-A in the treatment of glabellar
phylactic onabotulinumtoxinA in patients with chronic migraine and comorbid lines. Clin. Cosmet. Investig. Dermatol. 3, 1e4.
depression: an open-label, multicenter, pilot study of efficacy, safety and effect Wollmer, M.A., de Boer, C., Kalak, N., et al., 2012. Facing depression with botulinum
on headache-related disability, depression, and anxiety. Int. J. Gen. Med. 9, toxin: a randomized controlled trial. J. Psychiatr. Res. 46, 574e581.
79e86. Wollmer, M.A., Kalak, N., Jung, S., et al., 2014. Agitation predicts response of
Brin, M.F., Boodhoo, T.I., Pogoda, J.M., James, L.M., Demos, G., Terashima, Y., et al., depression to botulinum toxin treatment in a randomized controlled trial.
2009. Safety and tolerability of onabotulinumtoxinA in the treatment of facial Front. Psychiatry 5, 36.
lines: a meta-analysis of individual patient data from global clinical registration
studies in 1678 participants. J. Am. Acad. Dermatol. 61, 961e970.e1-11.

Please cite this article in press as: Kruger, T.H.C., Wollmer, M.A., Depression e An emerging indication for botulinum toxin treatment, Toxicon
(2015), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.toxicon.2015.09.035

You might also like