Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gould 2005
Gould 2005
LISA J. GOULD, MD, PhD; MIMI LEONG, MD; JOSEPH SONSTEIN, BS; SHELLY WILSON, BS
Localized tissue ischemia is a key factor in the development and poor prognosis of chronic wounds. Currently,
there are no standardized animal models that provide sufficient tissue to evaluate the effect of modalities that
may induce angiogenesis, and in vitro models of angiogenesis do not mimic the complexity of the ischemic
wound bed. Therefore, we set out to develop a reproducible ischemic model for use in wound-healing studies.
Male Sprague–Dawley rats underwent creation of dorsal bipedicle skin flaps with centrally located excisional
wounds. Oxygen tension, wound-breaking strength, wound area, lactate, and wound vascular endothelial
growth factor (VEGF) were compared in flaps measuring 2.5 and 2.0 11 cm with and without an underlying
silicone sheet. We found that the center of the 2.0 cm flap with silicone remains in the critically ischemic range
up to 14 days without tissue necrosis (3374 vs. 4976 mmHg in controls). Wound healing and breaking strength
were significantly impaired and tissue lactate from the center of this flap was 2.9 times greater than tissue from
either nonischemic controls and 2.5 cm flap (0.2370.05 mg/dL/mg sample vs. 0.0970.02 and 0.0870.02, re-
spectively). Vascular endothelial growth factor was 2 times greater than the nonischemic control. This ischemic
wound model is relatively inexpensive, easy to perform, reproducible, and reliable. The excisional wounds pro-
vide sufficient tissue for biochemical and histologic analysis, and are amenable to the evaluation of topical
and systemic therapies that may induce angiogenesis or improve wound healing. (WOUND REP REG
2005;13:576–582)
576
WOUND REPAIR AND REGENERATION
VOL. 13, NO. 6 GOULD ET AL. 577
studying therapeutic modalities are currently lacking. Animal Welfare Act. Rats were anesthetized with inhala-
The ischemic rabbit ear dermal ulcer model, while ele- tional isoflurane. Their backs were shaved and a template
gant in design, requires use of an operating microscope was used to outline the flap with a surgical marking pen.
and heals in 7–10 days.8 A modification of this model, The template, used to reduce interanimal variability was
developed to more closely simulate a chronic wound, re- centered along the spinal column and placed between the
quired reoperating on the rabbits on days 5, 10, 17, and base of the scapulae and the iliac crest. Marks are also
21.9 Furthermore, this model depends on the large rabbit made in the center of the flap at 5.0 cm from the top to
ear and has not been successfully adapted to either rats indicate planned wound placement. This placement is just
or mice, limiting the availability of molecular probes. We cranial to the vertical midline of the flap and corresponds
have developed a longitudinally oriented, dorsal, biped- to the greatest delay in healing as noted in Figure 1 of
icle flap model that addresses these criteria and will Chen et al.11 The rats were then sprayed liberally with
prove to be a valuable model for studying tissue ischemia. topical Betadine and the entire surgery performed under
This model is a modification of the ischemic wound aseptic technique. A single dose of ampicillin (15 mg/kg)
model originally described by Schwartz et al.10 and sub- was administered subcutaneously prior to making the in-
sequently utilized in modified form by Chen et al.11 Full- cision. Thirty-nine rats were divided into five groups: con-
thickness excisional wounds are created within a biped- trol, no flap, n 5 6; 2.5 cm flap without silicone, n 5 6;
icle dorsal skin flap in rats. Two critical changes have 2.5 cm flap with silicone, n 5 11; 2.0 cm flap without sil-
been made, namely making the skin flap sufficiently icone, n 5 6; 2.0 cm flap with silicone, n 5 10.
narrow, so the blood supply is random and the wounds Two adjacent 6 mm full-thickness excisional wounds
located in the midpoint of the flap are ischemic, and in- were created in the center of the flap using a sterile 6 mm
serting a silicone sheet beneath the skin flap, which pre- disposable biopsy punch. Control animals received exci-
vents readherence and reperfusion of the flap from the sional wounds at the same craniocaudal location as those
underlying tissue. in which flaps were performed. The depth of excision
Rodents as animal models are practical because of was down to, but not through, the anterior fascia of the
their low cost, ease of care and handling, and availability panniculus carnosus. The full-thickness punch biopsy,
of molecular probes for tissue analysis. However, ro- including skin and panniculus carnosus muscle, was re-
dents have a subcutaneous panniculus carnosus muscle, moved by dissecting with scissors in the plane between
which has been shown to contribute to healing by al- the panniculus carnosus and the fascia. A dorsal, biped-
lowing substantial wound contraction, and which also icle skin flap was raised in the craniocaudal direction
contributes collagen to the wound bed.12,13 In this mod- deep to the panniculus carnosus muscle. Precut and ster-
el, we remove the panniculus carnosus muscle from the ilized nonreinforced 0.01 in. thickness Sil-Tec medical
wound bed by dissecting just above the muscle fascia. grade sheeting (Technical Products Inc. of Georgia, De-
Wound contraction is limited but not eliminated by tack- catur, GA) was then placed underneath the flap. The sil-
ing the flap to the silicone sheet. The excisional wound icone strips were precut to 2.5 10 cm for the 2.5 cm
model has the advantage of providing sufficient tissue wide flaps and 2.0 10 cm for the 2.0 cm wide flaps to
for cellular and molecular analysis and can be used to ensure proper fit under the skin flap without buckling or
study the effect of topical or systemic agents. folding. The skin flaps and silicone sheet were sutured to
To validate and document the degree of ischemia the adjacent skin edges with interrupted nonabsorbable
achieved with this model, we have determined the tissue sutures. Suturing the flap, silicone, and skin edge to each
oxygen tension at the level of the wound, measured other along the length of the flap prevents movement of
wound surface area, tissue lactate, and tensile strength. the silicone sheet. We have also noted that the silicone
These parameters have been compared in 2.0 and 2.5 cm sheet inhibits wound contraction. Internal control, non-
flaps with and without an intervening sheet of silicone ischemic full-thickness wounds were created with the 6
and normal skin. In addition, we show that the excisional mm biopsy punch, 0.5 cm lateral to the flap, at the same
wounds provide sufficient tissue for molecular and cel- craniocaudal location as the ischemic wounds (Figure 1).
lular analysis by creating extracts of the wound bed and A sterile occlusive dressing (Tegaderm, 3M Health Care,
determining the amount of excised tissue, protein con- St. Paul, MN) was applied to cover all four wounds. The
tent, and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) con- rats were awakened from general anesthesia, extubated,
tent by enzyme-linked immunosorbant assay (ELISA). and placed in individual cages. They were allowed stand-
ard laboratory rat chow and water ad libitum.
Tissue for Lactate (Instron Corp, Canton, MA) with a 50 N load cell at a
Ischemic Wounds crosshead speed of 10 cm/min.
Internal Control Wounds
Tissue for Breaking Strength
Lactate analysis
Tissue stored at 801C was homogenized in 3 M HClO4
11 cm
using a handheld glass tissue grinder and transferred
2 cm
to tubes in a 8 to 101C ice/salt bath and agitated un-
til mixed. One milliliter H2O/0.3 mL HClO4 was added
and the suspension mixed at 41C for 10 minutes. Fol-
lowing centrifugation at 11.500 rpm for 10 minutes at
41C, the supernatant was removed and stored at 701C.
FIGURE 1. Schematic diagram of the ischemic wound-healing L-lactate was determined spectrophotometrically at 340
model. A bipedicle skin flap measuring 2.5 or 2.0 11 cm was nm using a commercially available kit (Sigma-Aldrich,
centered on the dorsum of the rat from the base of the scap-
ulae to the iliac crest. Two full-thickness, 6 mm excisional wounds
St. Louis, MO) which follows the production of reduced
were created in the center of the flap. The panniculus carnosus nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) according
fascia was left intact in the base of the wounds. Insertion of a to the following reaction: pyruvate1NADH # NAD11
silicone sheet beneath the skin flap prevented readherence lactate.
and reperfusion of the flap from the underlying tissue. Control
animals had excisional wounds at the same craniocaudal lo-
cation without creation of the flap. Two 6 mm full-thickness VEGF analysis
wounds adjacent (lateral) to the flap served as internal, non-
ischemic controls. The wounds were covered with an occlusive Tissue stored at 801C was homogenized in tissue lysis
dressing for the first 7 days. buffer (10 mM Tris, pH 7.4, 150 mM NaCl, 1% Triton).
Following centrifugation at 14,000 r.p.m. for 20 minutes,
the supernatant was removed and stored at 701C.
VEGF levels were determined using a commercially
threaded above the panniculus carnosus such that the
available ELISA kit (R&D Systems, Minneapolis, MN)
tip was located between the two wounds on the flap.
according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Briefly,
This was flushed with 0.2 mL of sterile saline, capped,
samples were diluted (1 : 5) with calibrator diluent as
and sutured in place. On day 14, a polarographic oxygen
per manufacturer’s instructions and then loaded onto 96-
electrode and a temperature probe (Licox, Haut Medical
well plates. Recombinant mouse VEGF was used to cre-
Technology, Sea Cliff, NY) were passed through the pre-
ate the standard curve. Following addition of the conju-
viously placed angiocatheter to provide continuous
gate and substrates, the reaction was stopped with the
oxygen measurements for a minimum of 15 minutes.
stop solution and the optical density read on a Bio-Tek
Anesthesia was not required during this measurement.
EL800 microplate reader at 450 nm (correction wave-
length set at 540 nm; Winooski, VT). Protein levels in the
tissue homogenates were determined using a commer-
Tissue sampling
cially available kit according to the BCA (bicinchoninic
With the rats under inhalational isoflurane anesthesia,
acid) method (Pierce Biotechnology, Rockford, IL).
the wounds were traced to determine surface area. As VEGF levels were expressed as picograms per milligram
illustrated in Figure 1, one ischemic wound was har-
protein.
vested in a longitudinal strip for tensiometry. The other
ischemic wound and one nonischemic internal con-
trol wound were excised from each animal and snap Statistical analysis
frozen in liquid nitrogen for VEGF analysis. Tissue for Data are presented as mean7SEM. One-way analysis of
lactate analysis was harvested from the skin bridge be- variance with post hoc comparisons using Tukey’s high-
tween the two ischemic wounds and from nonischemic ly significant difference test was used to determine the
skin lateral to the flap. Blood for lactate analysis was statistical significance between groups using InStat ver-
collected by cardiac puncture and the animals were sion 3.0 (Graphpad Software, San Diego, CA). A p-value
euthanized. of less than 0.05 was considered significant.
20
Tissue lactate and VEGF content
Blood lactate from anesthetized rats was 0.03 mg/dL.
10 With Silicone This was compared with lactate levels from non-
Without Silicone
ischemic tissue and from the tissue bridge between the
0 ischemic wounds (Figure 5). The 2.5 cm flap tissue lac-
Day 3 Day 7 Day 10 Day 14 tate was not significantly different from the nonischemic
Change in pO2 Over Time controls (0.0970.02 vs. 0.0870.02 mg/dL/mg sample).
The mean tissue lactate in the 2.0 cm flap with silicone
FIGURE 2. PscO2 levels in the ischemic wounds. (A) Day 14 ox-
ygen tension. Oxygen tension was measured by placing a po-
was 2.9 times greater than in the 2.5 cm flap (0.2370.05
larographic electrode in the subcutaneous tissue between the vs. 0.0870.02 mg/dL/mg sample, p 5 0.063) and 1.5
two wounds. Anesthesia was not required during this measure- times greater than in the 2.0 cm flap without silicone
ment. n 5 6 for control (no flap), n 5 6 for 2.5 cm flap without (0.2370.05 vs. 0.1570.02 mg/dL/mg sample).
silicone, n 5 7 for 2.5 cm flap with silicone, n 5 6 for 2.0 cm flap
without silicone, and n 5 6 for 2.0 cm flap with silicone. (B)
Change in pO2 over time. The temporal nature of the flap is- 0.25
chemia was examined by comparing PscO2 in the 2.0 cm flap *†‡§
with (n 5 3) and without silicone (n 5 6). Addition of the inter-
0.20
vening silicone decreases day-to-day variability and increases
Surface Area (cm2)
ischemia.
0.15
0.10
tissue pO2 was unchanged between days 7 and 14 (un-
published data). The PscO2 at the level of the wounds in 0.05
the 2.5 cm flap without silicone was equivalent to con-
trol. Placement of the silicone sheet reduced this by 7 0.00
Control 2.5 cm 2.5 cm 2.0 cm 2.0 cm
mmHg, and narrowing the flap to 2.0 cm reduced the flap flap flap flap
oxygen tension to the equivalent of what would be ex- (no silicone) (no silicone)
pected in the unwounded tissue of an ischemic extrem- FIGURE 3. Day 14 wound surface area. The ischemic flap
ity (TcPO2o39 mmHg)14 and correlates well with the wounds are compared with nonischemic controls (no flap)
PscO2 values reported for the rabbit ear model (non- and with flaps without the intervening silicone sheet. (po0.05
ischemic ear 5 5378 mmHg, ischemic ear 5 2779 compared with control) n 5 6 for control, n 5 7 for 2.5 cm
flap without silicone, n 5 5 for 2.5 cm flap with silicone, n 5 6
mmHg at day 14).15 While there was no significant
for 2.0 cm flap without silicone and n 5 8 for 2.0 cm flap with sil-
change in oxygen tension when silicone was placed un- icone. 5 vs. Control po0.001, w 5 vs. 2.5 cm with silicone po
der the 2.0 cm flap, there was less variability in tissue 0.05, z 5 vs. 2.5 cm flap po0.05, y 5 vs. 2.0 cm without silicone
pO2 for the duration of the experiment (Figure 2B). po0.01.
WOUND REPAIR AND REGENERATION
580 GOULD ET AL. NOVEMBER–DECEMBER 2005
12 120
10 100
Tensile Strength (N)
4
40
2
20
0
Control 2.5 cm 2.5 cm 2.0 cm 2.0 cm 0
flap flap flap flap 2.5 cm 2.5 cm 2.0 cm 2.0 cm 2.0 cm
(no silicone) (no silicone) Control flap Control flap flap
(no silicone)
FIGURE 4. Wound tensile strength decreases with increasing is-
chemia. Tensiometry of ischemic flap wounds is compared with FIGURE 6. Effect of increasing tissue ischemia on wound vascu-
wounds on control animals that did not have a flap raised. As lar endothelial growth factor (VEGF) content. VEGF content of
the flap is made more ischemic, by addition of a silicone sheet nonischemic internal control wounds is compared with ischemic
and narrowing the flap, the tensile strength decreases. (po wounds on the 2.5 and 2.0 cm flaps. n 5 8 for nonischemic in-
0.001 vs. control, wpo0.05 vs. 2.5 cm flap without silicone) n 5 6 ternal control wounds, n 5 11 for 2.5 cm flaps, n 5 8 for 2.0 cm
for control, n 5 6 for 2.5 cm flap without silicone, n 5 7 for 2.5 cm control wounds, n 5 5 for 2.0 cm flap without silicone, and n 5 10
flap with silicone, n 5 6 for 2.0 cm flap without silicone, and n 5 6 for 2.0 cm flap with silicone. VEGF levels are expressed as mean
for 2.0 cm flap with silicone. 5 vs. Control po0.01, w 5 vs. 2.5 cm pg/mg protein7SEM.
with silicone po0.05.
7. Zhu WH, MacIntyre A, Nicosia RF. Regulation of angiogenesis by 14. Padberg FT, Back TL, Thompson PN, Hobson RW II. Transcutane-
vascular endothelial growth factor and angiopoietin-1 in the rat aorta ous oxygen (TcPO2) estimates probability of healing in the
model: Distinct temporal patterns of intracellular signaling correlate ischemic extremity. J Surg Res 1996;60:365–9.
with induction of angiogenic sprouting. Am J Pathol 2002;161:823–30. 15. Siddiqui A, Davidson JD, Mustoe TA. Ischemic tissue oxygen ca-
8. Ahn ST, Mustoe TA. Effects of ischemia on ulcer wound healing: A pacitance after hyperbaric oxygen therapy: A new physiologic
new model in the rabbit ear. Ann Plast Surg 1990;24:17–23. concept. Plast Reconstr Surg 1997;99:148–55.
9. Bonomo SR, Davidson JD, Tyrone JW, Lin X, Mustoe TA. Enhance- 16. Hunt TK. The physiology of wound healing. Ann Emerg Med
ment of wound healing by hyperbaric oxygen and transforming 1988;17:1265–73.
growth factor beta3 in a new chronic wound model in aged rabbits. 17. Vella A, Carlson LA, Blier B, Felty C, Kuiper JD, Rooke TW. Cir-
Arch Surg 2000;135:1148–53. culator boot therapy alters the natural history of ischemic limb
10. Schwartz DA, Lindblad WJ, Rees RS. Altered collagen metabolism ulceration. Vasc Med 2000;5:21–5.
and delayed healing in a novel model of ischemic wounds. Wound 18. Burgess EM, Matsen FA III, Wyss CR, Simmons CW. Segmental
Rep Reg 1995;3:204–12. transcutaneous measurements of PO2 in patients requiring below-
11. Chen C, Schultz GS, Bloch M, Edwards PD, Tebes S, Mast BA. the-knee amputation for peripheral vascular insufficiency. J Bone
Molecular and mechanistic validation of delayed healing rat Joint Surg Am 1982;64:378–82.
wounds as a model for human chronic wounds. Wound Rep Reg 19. Crowther M, Brown NJ, Bishop ET, Lewis CE. Microenvironmental
1999;7:486–94. influence on macrophage regulation of angiogenesis in wounds
12. Davidson JM. Animal models for wound repair. Arch Dermatol Res and malignant tumors. J Leukoc Biol 2001;70:478–90.
1998;290 (Suppl.):S1–11. 20. Constant JS, Feng JJ, Zabel DD, Yuan H, Suh DY, Scheuenstuhl H,
13. Cohen IK, Moore CD, Diegelmann RF. Onset and localization of Hunt TK, Hussain MZ. Lactate elicits vascular endothelial growth
collagen synthesis during wound healing in open rat skin wounds. factor from macrophages: A possible alternative to hypoxia.
Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 1979;160:458–62. Wound Rep Reg 2000;8:353–60.