Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Case 2 - Intention To Shop Online
Case 2 - Intention To Shop Online
Using the theory of planned behavior as the theoretical framework, this study aimed to examine the
relationships between attitude towards online shopping, subjective norm, perceived behavioral control,
and intention to shop online. Based on a sample of 146 baby boomers who are Internet users but not
online shoppers, the study found that two of the three determinants--attitude towards online shopping
and subjective norm--were significantly related to intention to shop online. Implications of the research
findings and recommendations for future research were discussed.
Key words: Online shopping, intention to shop online, attitude towards online shopping, theory of planned
behavior.
INTRODUCTION
The use of the Internet has gained a rapid growth since unlimited range of products and services from companies
its introduction in the early 1980s. Such a growth is around the world, and it has reduced the time and effort
mainly due to its unique characteristics of flexibility, consumers spend on shopping (Ko et al., 2004).
interactivity, and personalization. In particular, the According to Internet World Stats, worldwide Internet
Internet has been a very useful tool for communication, user growth rate for the period 2000-2008 was 342.2%.
entertainment, education, and electronic trade (Ko, Jung, As of March 2009, there are 49 countries, out of the 271
Kim, and Shim, 2004; Koyuncu and Lien, 2003). From a countries and territories listed by Internet World Stats,
business perspective, the Internet has transformed the have an Internet penetration rate of higher than 50%
way business is done. This is due to the fact that it (http://www.internetworldstats.com). Internet penetration
enables retailers to offer unlimited range of products and rate refers to the percentage of a population using the
services to all consumers from around the world at any Internet. It is the number of Internet users over the total
point in time. It is also considered to be the most population in percentage. In addition, online retail sales
significant direct marketing channel for the global are growing strong and are expected to increase in the
marketplace. From a consumer perspective, the Internet future. For example, US online retail sales are estimated
has provided consumers more control in accessing to grow $144 billion in 2004 to $316 billion in 2010,
information on products and services. Consumers pull for according to Forrester Research, a technology research
online content - they decide whether, when, where, what, firm.
and how much commercial content they wish to view. As of March 2009, Malaysia is one of the 49 highly
The Internet also allows consumers to access an penetrated countries with a penetration rate of 62.8%.
Besides, the Malaysian government has been promoting
the development of information technology (IT) within the
country for economic advancement. For example, a state
*Corresponding author. E-mail: government has planned to embark an “E-mail 4 All”
lee.teck.heang@buseco.monash.edu.my. Tel: (+603) 5514 project under its IT movement. The project will push
6317. Fax: (+603) 5514 6192. parents into the IT age and aims to achieve a 40% e-mail
1712 Afr. J. Bus. Manage.
usage in the rural areas by 2010 (“E-mail Soon for Perak foundation in studying information technology (IT)
newborns,” 2005). Other state governments have set up adoption. For examples, Taylor and Todd (1995a and
plans to get some rural areas with full Internet access 1995b) have used TPB to assess IT usage; Barnett and
and super-wireless connections (“Full Internet access to Presley (2004) have examined Internet technology
rural planning,” 2006; “SuperWifi for homes in Sarawak,” adoption behavior among university professors; and
2008). In addition, Malaysian people are also urged to be Jaruwachirathanakul and Fink (2006) have studied
more IT-savvy in order to start their own business using Internet banking adoption among the Thai consumers.
IT. Housewives are encouraged to use IT to do business In the area of online consumer behavior, a few studies
by marketing their home-made products online and have examined consumers’ intention and actual Internet
making home deliveries (“Use IT to get ahead, house- purchases using TPB as the theoretical base. Using two
wives urges,” 2005). Farmers and fishermen will also be variations of TPB (pure TPB and decomposed TPB
selling their fresh produce online once their website is up, models), Lin (2007) examined 297 undergraduate
under the program “Community Media for Local Socio- students’ intention to buy textbooks online. The author
Economic Development” jointly organized by a local found that in both pure and decomposed TPB models,
entrepreneurs club and Balik Pulau Internet Center, a both attitude towards online shopping and perceived
division of the Energy, Water and Communications behavioral control were positively and significantly related
Ministry (“Balik Pulau’s online marketing bid, website to to intention to shop online. The third antecedent,
offer fresh produce in a click,” 2009). subjective norms, was not a significant predictor of
Given the increasing usage of the Internet in the behavioral intention. The results of Kim and Park’s (2005)
country and the significant growth and optimistic outlook study also indicated support for the direct relationship
for the future of online shopping, it is timely to examine between attitude toward the online store and perceived
the intention to shop online among the Malaysian behavioral control and purchase intention via the online
population. Specifically, the present author attempts to store. The subjects of their studies were 262
examine the factors that help explain intention to shop undergraduate students in a large US Midwestern
online based on the theory of planned behavior proposed university.
by Icek Aizen. The target respondents of the present In their study of 201 college students in Taiwan, Hsu,
study are baby boomers of the Chinese ethnic group. Yen, Chiu, and Chang (2006) used TPB to predict
continuance intention to shop online. Their study showed
that users’ attitude toward continuance, perceived control
Literature review behavior, and perceived internal social influences were
significantly associated with their continuance intention.
Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) George (2004) argued for a direct path from attitudes
toward Internet purchasing, subjective norm, and
TPB attempts to explain what predicts behavioral perceived behavioral control to actual online purchasing
intention, which in turn, predicts the actual behavior. In its behavior (intention to make online purchases was omitted
most basic form, the theory postulates that there are from the research model.) The author’s argument was
three conceptually independent determinants of that it was not possible to include both intention and
behavioral intention—attitude, subjective norm, and actual behavior in the model as intention reflects future
perceived behavioral control. The first determinant is the behavior, and all the data of the study were collected at
attitude toward the behavior, which is an individual’s one point in time. Similar to Lin‘s (2007) findings, George
favorable or unfavorable evaluation of the behavior in (2004) found that both attitudes toward Internet pur-
question. It is composed of the individual’s salient belief chasing and perceived behavioral control were positively
about the perceived consequences of performing the and significantly related to online purchasing behavior,
behavior. The second determinant of behavioral intention but subjective norms were not. Again, the respondents of
is subjective norm. It reflects an individual’s belief about his study were undergraduate students, with a sample
significant others’ approval or disapproval of performing size of 193.
the behavior, or about social pressure of performing or From the brief review of the studies on TPB in the area
not performing the behavior. The last determinant of of online shopping above, all of the studies used students
behavioral intention is perceived behavioral control. as the research subjects. These researchers believe that
which reflects an individual’s belief about the ease or students are the typical Internet users and are the
difficulty of performing the behavior (Ajzen, 1991). primary potential customers in online shopping (Hsu, et
TPB is a popular approach used to examine various al., 2006; Lin, 2007). They believe that students
types of intentions and behaviors in specific contexts. represent online consumers population who are generally
Psychological behaviors studied under the framework of younger and better educated. However, how about the
TPB include playing video games, loosing weight, older age groups—the baby boomers in particular—the
cheating, shoplifting, and lying (as reported in Ajzen, grey market that has been large ignored (Reisenwitz and
1991). TPB has also been used as a theoretical Iyer, 2007; Vuori and Holmlund-Rytkönen, 2005)?
Lim et al. 1713
Table 2. Item, Alphas, means, and standard deviations of the variables in TPB.
Subjective Norm People who are important to me think that I should shop online. 3.88 0.58
(α = 0.83) People who influence my behavior think that I should shop online.
Shopping online is common in my circle of friends.
Online shopping is well accepted by the people of my community.
People who are around me think that I should shop online.
I have read / seen news reports which say that the Internet provide a
good way to shop online.
The popular press has a positive review towards online shopping.
The mass media has influenced me to try online shopping.
Perceived I think I am proficient in using the Internet for shopping. 3.59 0.98
behavioral control I think I feel confident in using the Internet for shopping.
(α = 0.96) I think I know exactly what to do in using the Internet for shopping.
shopping and subjective norm and weakly correlated with DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
perceived behavioral control. Multiple regression analysis
was used to examine the simultaneous effects of the The focus of the present study is to examine the intention
three determinants of intention to shop online. The model to shop online of baby boomer Internet users whom have
was significant with R2 = 0.478 and adjusted R2 = 0.467. not purchased anything via the Internet yet. The aim of
Two of the three determinants were found to be the study is to determine which factor would link to
significant predictors—they were attitude towards online intention to shop online, which in turn, should lead to
shopping and subjective norm. Attitude towards online actual online purchase behavior as postulated by TPB.
shopping was the more important predictor between the The results of the study show that baby boomer’s
two. Table 4 presents the regression results. favorable attitude towards online shopping and perceived
Lim et al. 1715
F1 F2 F3 F4
Attitude towards Online Shopping (F1) 1.000
Subjective Norm (F2) 0.562** 1.000
Perceived Behavioral Control (F3) 0.467** 0.273** 1.000
Intention to Shop Online (F4) 0.666** 0 .527** 0 .306** 1.000
** Correlation is significant at p < 0.01.
Attitude towards
Online Shopping
Intention to Shop
Subjective Norm Online
Perceived Behavioral
Control
social influences play an important role in the formation of of newspaper ads, flyers, billboards, posters, banners,
their intention to engage in Internet shopping. event campaign, and TV and radio service messages to
These research findings have practical implications to promote that online shopping is in trend now. The value
the Internet marketers. Since positive attitude towards and the ease of online shopping should be heavily
online shopping is important to the formation of online promoted to exert an influence on these baby boomers
shopping intention, online marketers should cultivate a non-shoppers as well as those people around them.
good impression on online shopping among the baby Company websites and Internet advertising are some
boomers non-Internet shoppers. Online marketers should others tools that can be used to entice baby boomers to
educate non-shoppers on the trustworthiness, low risks, shop online. Company websites can be a marketing and
security and privacy, convenience, cost savings, product communication tool in the Internet operations. Through
variety, compatibility, and usefulness and ease of use in the web, consumers can research information about the
online shopping. Several studies have found these products or services—product attributes, pricing informa-
factors to be associated with favorable attitudes toward tion, promotion, payment method, delivery arrangement,
Internet shopping and purchasing (George, 2002 and returns and exchange, and after-sales support. Detailed
2004; Lin, 2007). information about what is being offered and how to order
With regard to social influences, online marketers may must be clearly provided in the websites. E-marketers
develop a persuasive communication strategy in the form should design the webs in such a way that consumers
1716 Afr. J. Bus. Manage.
find it easy, pleasant, attractive, and efficient to browse. A online and its impact on online buying are much needed.
website must be well-designed to facilitate browsers to E-commerce is going international, and the under-
find what they need and to achieve satisfaction while standing of consumers’ intention to shop online in various
browsing. A clear and easy to use website would countries has profound implications for international
encourage potential shoppers to click through the web vendors.
and this may lead to actual online purchase.
With regard to online advertising, e-marketers should
REFERENCES
place ads that appear to be interesting and attractive to
create consumers’ curiosity and to draw their attention. Ajzen I (1991). The theory of planned behavior. Organ. Behav. Hum.
Consumers are exposed to various forms of online ads Decis. Process., 50(2): 179-211.
(such as banners, pop-up windows, and text-based Balik Pulau’s online marketing bid: Website to offer fresh produce in a
click. (2009,). The Star. March 23, p. 3.
hyperlinks) when they spend considerable amount of time Barnett W, Presley A (2004). Theory of planned behavior model in
online. They may click on the ads if they are stimulating electronic learning: A pilot study. Issues Info. Syst., 5(1): 22-28.
visually. Generally, consumers would do aimless Bloch PH, Sherrell DL, Ridgway NM (1986). Consumer search: An
browsing for something interesting (Rowley, 2000), and extended framework. J. Consum. Res., 13: 119-126.
aimless or general browsing is a variation of ongoing E-mail soon for Perak newborns. (2005,). The Star. June 1, p. 3.
Full Internet access to rural Pahang. (2006). The Star. July 19, p. 26.
search which may lead to impulse buying (Bloch, George JF (2002). Influences on the intent to make Internet purchase.
Sherrell, and Ridgway, 1986). Internet Research: Electron. Netw. Appl. Policy, 12(2): 165-180.
It is interesting to find that perceived behavioral control George JF (2004). The theory of planned behavior and Internet
purchasing. Internet Res., 14(3): 198-212.
was not a significant predictor of intention to shop online
Haynes L (2004). Baby boomers. Brand Strateg., 179: 31.
in the present study. This result was not consistent with Hsu MH, Yen CH, Chiu CM, Chang CM (2006). A longitudinal
previous empirical evidences, which supported the investigation of continued online shopping behavior: An extension of
linkage between perceived behavioral control and the theory of planned behavior. Int. J. Human-Comput. Stud., 64:
889-904.
behavioral intention (Kim and Park, 2005). Data showed Jaruwachirathanankul B, Fink D (2006). Internet banking adoption
that the baby boomers’ perceived efficacy in using the strategies fro a developing country: the case of Thailand. Internet
Internet for shopping was relatively low at a mean of 3.59 Res., 15(3), 295-311.
on the 6-point scale. This may explain the insignificant Kim J, Park J (2005). A consumer shopping channel extension model:
relationship between perceived behavioral control and attitude shift toward the online store. J. Fash. Mark. Manag., 9(1):
106-121.
their intention to shop online. Ko H, Jung J, Kim JY, Shim SW (2004). Cross-cultural differences in
However, the research findings of this study may only perceived risk of online shopping Retrieved June 21, 2005, from
be generalized to the generation of baby boomers. It http://www.jiad.org/vol4/no2/ko. J. Interact. Advert., 4(2).
Koyuncu C, Lien D (2003). E-commerce and consumer’s purchasing
must be used with caution as the sample size is relatively
behaviour. Appl. Econ., 35(6): 721-726.
small in understanding perceptions and intention of online Lee L (2005, October 24). Love those boomers. Bus. Week., 94-102.
shopping. Furthermore, the sample consisted of Chinese Lin HF (2007). Predicting consumer intentions to shop online: An
ethnic group, which is not representative of the general empirical test of competing theories. Electron. Com. Res. Appl, 6:
433-442.
Malaysian population. Future research in the Malaysian Littrell MA, Ma YJ, Halepete J (2005). Generation X, baby boomers, and
market should include other races of Malays and Indians swing: Marketing fair trade apparel. J. Fash. Mark. Manag., 9(4),:
and other generations of X and Y for comparison 407-419.
purpose. Future studies may also use student samples Niemelä-Nyrhinen J (2007). Baby boom consumers and technology:
and compare their intention to shop online with that of shooting down stereotypes. J. Consum. Mark., 24(5): 305-312.
Norum PS (2003). Examination of generational differences in household
non-student samples. Demographics and lifestyle apparel expenditures. Fam. Consum. Sci. Res. J., 32(1): 52-75.
characteristics may also be included in future studies to Reisenwitz T, Iyer R (2007). A comparison of younger and older baby
produce profiles of typical Malaysian online shoppers. boomers: Investigating the viability of cohort segmentation. J.
Consum. Mark., 24(4): 202-213.
Despite the limitations, the present study has
Roberts JA, Manolis C (2000). Baby boomers and busters: An
contributed to our understanding of intention to shop exploratory investigation of attitudes toward marketing, advertising
online, which has profound implications for organizations and consumerism. J. Consum. Mark., 17(6): 481-499.
promoting business via the Internet. It helps online Rowley J (2000). Product search in e-shopping: A review and research
propositions. J. Consum. Mark., 17: 20-35.
retailers better address the acceptance of online
SuperWiFi for homes in Sarawak. (2008). The Star. January 12, p.30.
shopping among their consumers and devise their online Taylor S, Todd PA (1995a). Understanding information technology
marketing strategies accordingly. Given the number of usage – A test of competing models. Info. Syst. Res., 6(2): 144-176.
older individuals and their increasing purchasing power, Taylor S, Todd PA (1995b). Assessing IT usage: The role of prior
marketers should be giving more attention to this older experience. MIS Quart., 19(4): 561-570.
Trocchia PJ, Janda S (2000). A phenomenological investigation of
consumer group. Internet usage among older individuals. J. Consum. Mark., 17(7):
Finally, data on the intention to shop online are much 605-616.
needed in lieu of the gaining importance of online Use IT to get ahead, housewives urged. (2005). The Star. June 3, p. 22.
Vankatesh V, Davis FD (2000). A theoretical extension of the
retailing in the global market. More studies on cross-
technology acceptance model: Four longitudinal field studies. Manag.
cultural comparisons of baby boomer’s intention to shop Sci., 46(2): 186-204.
Lim et al. 1717
Vijayasarathy LR (2004). Predicting consumer intentions to use on-line Weingarten RM (2008). Four generations, one workplace: A Gen X-Y
shopping: the case for an augmented technology acceptance model. staff nurse’s view of team building in the emergence department. J.
Info. Manag., 41: 747-762. Emerg. Nurs., 35(1): 27-30.
Vuori S, Holmlund-Rytkönen M (2005). 55+ people as Internet users.
Mark. Intel. Plan., 23(1): 58-76.