Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SelinWallinBerg2008 Dystociainlabour-Riskfactorsmanagementandoutcome ActaObstetGynecol
SelinWallinBerg2008 Dystociainlabour-Riskfactorsmanagementandoutcome ActaObstetGynecol
net/publication/5619860
CITATIONS READS
63 2,567
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Marie Berg on 31 January 2020.
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Dystocia in labour risk factors, management and outcome: a
retrospective observational study in a Swedish setting
Abstract
Background. Labour dystocia (LD) is associated with adverse maternal and child outcomes. This study investigated obstetric
risk factors, frequency of interventions and delivery outcomes for LD. Methods. A retrospective, observational, study of
1,480 deliveries was undertaken in a Swedish district hospital during 2000 and 2001. Results. LD was identified in 21% of
deliveries, 16.7% of which ended in caesarean section (CS) compared to 1.7% of deliveries without LD. Multiparity with no
previous vaginal delivery (OR6.0), epidural analgesia (EDA) at cervical dilation 55 cm (OR 4.6), primiparity (OR
4.5), gestational age ]42 weeks (OR 3.1), birth weight 4,000 g (OR2.7) and EDA at cervical dilation 5 cm (OR
2.0) were major independent risk factors for LD. Conclusions. In delivery management, special attention should be directed
to primiparous women and multiparous women with no previous vaginal delivery. Women given EDA, especially at cervical
dilation 55 cm are also of particular interest. Furthermore, rigorous routines for LD diagnosis and oxytocin augmentation
are important.
Abbreviations: CS: caesarean section, EDA: epidural analgesia, LD: labour dystocia, MNPVD: multiparity with no
previous vaginal delivery, TOL: trial of labour
Correspondence: Lotta Selin, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, NU Hospital Group, 46186 Trollhättan, Sweden. E-mail: lotta.selin@vgregion.se
Table I. Descriptive statistics for the study population and more often at an early stage (37.3 versus 14.9%) in
excluded parturients.
the LD group than in the non LD-group. LD
affected 33.4% of the women who were given EDA
Included Excluded% compared to 12.5% of women who were not
(n 1,480)* (n520)*
administered EDA. Oxytocin was administered
Maternal age (years), mean9SD 29.195.0 29.894.7 frequently in both groups. The frequency of induc-
Parity tion of labour was quite similar in the two groups
Primipara 717 (48.5) 154 (29.6) (Table III). Notably, 40.2% of women with sponta-
Multipara 723 (48.9) 357 (68.7)
neous onset of labour and without LD were given
MNPVD$ 40 (2.8) 9 (1.7)
oxytocin during delivery. LD affected 39% of
High-risk pregnancy 168 (11.4) 52 (10.0) primiparas whose labour had been induced com-
Gestational age ]42 weeks 91 (6.1) 40 (7.7)
Induction of labour 182 (12.3) 39 (7.5)
pared with 32.7% of primiparas with spontaneous
onset (p 0.25). In the case of multiparas, 9.1% of
*Data shown as numbers and percentages unless otherwise stated. induced deliveries were affected by LD compared
$Multipara with no previous vaginal delivery.
with 7.4% in the spontaneous onset group (p
%Missing partogram or cervical dilation ]7 cm on admission to
the delivery ward. 0.65).
The multiple linear logistic regression model in-
with and without LD are presented in Table II.
cluded the following variables: maternal age, parity,
Significant associations were found between LD and
MNPVD, gestational age, induction of labour, EDA,
maternal age, parity, gestational age ]42 weeks,
interval from onset of established labour to accom-
birth weight 4,000 g and abnormal vertex pre-
plished amniotomy, abnormal vertex presentation
sentation. The frequency of primiparity, MNPVD,
and birth weight. The variables that emerged sig-
gestational age ]42 weeks and birth weight 4,000
g in the LD group was almost double that in the nificant in the model are presented in Table IV.
non-LD group. Deliveries in abnormal vertex pre- The frequency of operative deliveries, i.e. instru-
sentations were increased 3-fold in the LD group mental vaginal delivery or CS, was high among
(Table II). Among deliveries resulting in a birth women with LD (Table V). Intrapartum CS was
weight 4,000 g, 30.6% were affected with LD 16.7% compared with 1.7% in the non-LD group.
compared with 17.4% of deliveries with a birth MNPVD gave birth spontaneously in 75%. The
weight 54,000 g (pB0.001). Women in the non- adjusted OR for CS in women with LD was 6.3. The
LD group were older. However, further analysis of unadjusted frequency of postpartum haemorrhage
the primiparas showed that mean maternal age in the and perineal trauma was significantly increased in
LD group was 27.9, compared to 26.8 in the non- women with LD, but no significant difference could
LD group (p B0.01). No significant difference in age be seen between the 2 groups after controlling for
related to LD or non-LD was found, either in the parity, birth weight and EDA. Furthermore, no
MNPVD or in the other multiparas. significant difference was found in the proportion
EDA was administered to 41% of the women, of infants with a 5-min Apgar score B7 or umbilical
57.3% primiparas and 24.4% multiparas. EDA was cord arterial pH B7.10, between the LD and non-
administered more frequently (65 versus 34.5%) and LD groups.
Table II. Demographic and clinical characteristics in pregnancies with and without LD.
Table III. Characteristics of management of labour for women with and without LD.
LD (n 311)* Non-LD (n 1,169)* Unadjusted OR (95% CI)$ Adjusted OR% (95% CI)
Mode of delivery
Spontaneous vaginal delivery 191 (61.4) 1,094 (93.6)
Operative vaginal delivery 68 (21.9) 55 (4.7) 5.7 (3.98.3) 3.5 (2.35.4)
Caesarean section 52 (16.7) 20 (1.7) 11.5 (6.819.7) 6.3 (3.511.2)
Postpartum haemorrhage 1,000 ml 29 (9.3) 59 (5.0) 1.9 (1.23.1) 1.5 (0.92.4)
Retained placenta 7 (2.7) 24 (2.1) NS
Perineal trauma’ 20 (7.7) 32 (2.8) 2.9 (1.65.2) 1.6 (0.83.0)
5-min Apgar score B7 2 (0.6) 6 (0.5) NS
Umbilical cord arterial pH B7.10 3 (1.1) 17 (1.7) NS
among primiparas. The Swedish National Birth Board concludes that assessment of progress and
Register reported administration of EDA to 43% of diagnosis of LD is probably mostly based on
primiparas and 15.2% of multiparas (total: 27.7%) individual judgment, taking several factors into
in 2004. EDA is considered the most potent pain consideration (8). In our study, labour was augmen-
relief method, albeit associated with a number of ted with oxytocin in 40.2% of the women with
side effects, foremost among them being LD. The spontaneous onset and no diagnosed LD, indicating
method is also associated with increased use of that the diagnosis of LD and indications for the
oxytocin and an increase in instrumental vaginal administration of oxytocin were probably often
deliveries, but not with increased CS (15,16). In this neglected.
study, 41% of women had EDA, 57.3% of primi- Women with LD suffered postpartum hemorrhage
paras and 24.4% of multiparas. LD occurred more and third- and fourth-degree perineal lacerations
frequently among women with EDA (33.4 versus significantly more often; however, this was not
12.5%). The multiple linear logistic regression verified after multivariate analysis standardising for
model demonstrated that early-stage EDA (cervical parity, EDA and birth weight. Other research yields
dilation 55 cm) increased the risk more than EDA contradictory findings; Sheiner et al. (3) did not find
administered later (cervical dilation 5 cm). Earlier an association between increased postpartum he-
research (7) showed that LD is diagnosed early morrhage and first-stage LD, while Janni et al. (20)
during labour, well before EDA has been adminis- found an association, but for LD in the second stage.
tered. LD is probably partly due to the effect of Feinstein et al. (21) reported an increased risk of
EDA, but women choosing EDA also differ from third- and fourth-degree lacerations in cases of
women who do not, both from obstetric and other prolonged second stage.
perspectives. In our study, the occurrence of LD did not
We found that amniotomy in the LD group was increase the risk of Apgar score B7 at 5 min or of
performed an average of almost 1 h (54 min) later umbilical cord arterial pH B7.10, which supports
than in the non-LD group. This supports a review other findings (20,22). However, Feinstein et al.
(17) concluding that amniotomy is associated with a (21) found a significantly higher prevalence of LD in
reduction in labour duration of 12 h. cases of Apgar B7 at both 1- and 5-min (study
Augmentation of labour using oxytocin is com- population of 93,266 births), but they did not
mon at present (18). However, there is a major discuss the clinical implications of this finding.
variation in administration and dose (19), indicating Unfortunately, our study did not yield any in-
that administration can correspond to the lack of formation about the women’s BMI, childbirth ex-
good routines for augmentation rather than to a real perience, food intake or degree of fatigue, nor of any
need (18,19). There is apparently no unequivocal relationship between these factors and LD. In order
definition of the onset of the active phase of labour; to obtain a more holistic view of factors influencing
furthermore, the definition of LD is also obscure. LD, these are important parameters that should be
According to The Swedish National Board of Health included in future research, in which the presence of
and Welfare (8), the partogram is mostly used in a supporting person/doula in the labour room should
Sweden, but the action line is seldom identified. The also be registered.
Dystocia in labour risk factors, management and outcome 221
Downloaded By: [Göteborg University Library] At: 13:57 1 February 2008
and neonatal outcome in relation to LD may 10. Lavender T, Alfirevic Z, Walkinshaw S. Partogram Action
contribute to improved care of women in labour. Line Study a randomised trial. Br J Obstet Gynaecol. 1998; /
105:97680.
MNPVD was shown to be a major risk factor for LD /
82430.
The authors express their gratitude to the Fyrbodal 14. Ohel G, Yaacobin N, Linder N, Younis J. Postdate antenatal
R&D Council and to the Department of Obstetrics testing. Int J Gynecol Obstet. 1995;49:1457. / /
and Gynecology, NU Hospital Group, especially 15. Anim-Somuah M, Smyth R, Howell C. Epidural versus non
Anne Hofling, for supporting and participating in epidural or no analgesia in labor. Cochrane Database Syst
the study. Rev. 2005;(4):CD000331.
/ /
1428.
1. Florica M, Stephansson O, Nordström L. Indications asso- 17. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Dys-
ciated with increased section rates in a Swedish hospital. Int J tocia and augmentation of labor. Int J Gynecol Obstet.
Gynecol Obstet. 2006;92:1815. / /
2004;85:31524.
2. National Board of Health and Welfare. Centre of Epidemiol- 18. Svärdby K, Nordström L, Selström E. Primiparas with or
ogy. Available online at: http://www.socialstyrelsen.se/Statistik/ without oxytocin augmentation: a prospective descriptive
statistikdatabas/ study. J Clin Nurs. 2007;16:17984.
/ /
3. Sheiner E, Levy A, Feinstein U, Hallak M, Mazor M. Risk 19. Alfirevic Z, Edwards G, Platt MJ. The impact of delivery suite
factors and outcome of failure to progress during the first guidelines on intrapartum care in ‘standard primigravida’.
stage of labor: a population-based study. Acta Obstet Gynecol Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol. 2004;115:2831. / /
Scand. 2002;81:2226. / /
/ /
10:5865. /
affect maternal and neonatal outcome? Am J Obstet Gynecol.
8. National Board of Health and Welfare. Handläggning av 2004;191:9938.
/ /