Professional Documents
Culture Documents
of Milk in Sweden
LIVIA ALM
Aria
S-105 46 Stockholm, Sweden
1Tryptophan may be converted into niacin equivalents, in the ratio 1:60; 60 mg tryptophan = 1 mg niacin.
(citrovorum), and cultured at 20°C for 20 to 24 and cultured at 37°C for 40 h, pH range 4.3 to
h, pH range 4.4 to 4. 5. 4.5.
Sweet buttermilk. Nonfermented cream, Bifidus milk. V-medium is inoculated with
40% (wt/vol) fat, is churned to obtain butter. Bifidobacterium bifidum (Lactobacillus bifidus
After churning, the sweet buttermilk has a fat (NCDO 11863) and cultured at 37°C for 40 to
content of .7% (wt/vol) and pH range 6.7 to 50 h, pH range 4.2 to 4.4.
6.8.
Fermented (sour)buttermilk. Nonfermented Handling of the Samples
cream, 40% (wt/vol) fat, is inoculated with a Samples either were taken directly from
commercial mixed culture of Streptococcus commercial production and analyzed immedi-
lactis, Streptococcus cremoris, Streptococcus ately or preserved before analysis by lyophiliza-
diacetylactis, and Leuconostoc cremoris (citro- tion. Before analysis, the lyophilized samples
vorum), cultured at 20 to 21°C for 20 to 24 h, were reconstituted to the original state by the
and churned to obtain butter. The fermented addition of 9 volumes distilled water. No
buttermilk has a fat content of .7% (wt/vol) differences in vitamin contents between non-
and a pH range of 4.4 to 4.5. preserved and lyophilized and reconstituted
Kefir. Cow's milk, 3.0% (wt/vol) fat, is heat
treated (92°C for 3 min), cooled, inoculated
with a commercial mixture of kefir grains, and
cultured at 20°C for 18 to 20 h, pH range 4.3 TABLE 2. B-vitamins in noninoculated milk. (Each
to 4.5. mean was from observations on four samples from
Ropy milk. Cow's milk, 3.0% (wt/vol) fat, is different batches.)
heated (90°C for 3 rain), cooled, inoculated
with a commercial mixture of Streptococcus Vitamin X SD Units
lactis var. longi and Leuconostoc cremoris
(citrovorum), and cultured at 17 to 18°C for 20 B1, Thiamine .34 .03 mg/liter
to 22 h, pH range 4.5 to 4.6. B:, Riboflavin 1.16 .01 mg/liter
B6 , Pyridoxine .38 .01 mg/liter
V-medium. Lowfat cow's milk, .5% (wt/vol) Pantothenic acid 2.6 .20 rag/liter
fat, added with .5% (wt/vol) soybean oil, pH Biotin 14.0 1.0 tag/liter
6.7 to 6.8, is heat treated (75°C for 15 s) and Folic acid 37.0 8.0 /~g/liter
fortified with a protein concentrate from skim BI2., Cobalamine 3.1 .3 #g/liter
milk. In this way the protein of the milk Nicotinic acid .68 .01 mg/liter
Tryptophant 308.0 10.0 mg/liter
formula was increased from about 3.4 to 5.0%. Niacin equivalents 5.8 .2 mg/liter
The mixture was allowed to swell for 15 to 18 B~.~,Orotic acid 67.1 .7 rag/liter
h at 4°C and then was heated at 140°C for 3 to
4s. 1Tryptophan may be converted into niacin equi-
Acidopbilus milk. V-medium is inoculated valents, in the ratio 1:60; 60 mg tryptophan = 1 mg
with Lactobacillus acidopbilus (NCDO 1748) niacin.
O
Ox
Z
o
0o
bo
356 ALM
Methods of V i t a m i n Assay
Vitamin profile, %
+140.l l
Thiamine (B1) was measured by a fluoromet- +100: i
ric method (4). Riboflavin (B2) was measured +80. i
by two methods, a fluorometric method (4, 33) +60 Buttermilk
and a microbiological assay (43). Orotic acid +40.
(OA) was measured by a spectrophotometric +20.
method according to Adachi (1). Other B- +0
vitamins were measured by microbiological -20 1 111Days
assay with microorganism strains in Table
+1207
1. The procedure for analysis is described ~100~
in detail in Pharmacopoea Nordica (43).
+80 i
+60 Yoghurt
I
RESULTS +4oi
i
i i
+20i
V i t a m i n Content of Milk -+0-~
The B-vitamin in noninoculated milk is in -207
-40 - ill
Table 2. As compared to averages reported
I
1 -il
I
11!1
,
1111111111111,1 11 Days
(Table 3), vitamin contents were low.
+40] ! Ke~ir i I i
+201 i i
Changes in V i t a m i n Content Following Fermentation +0" i_ ! ! I I a-
Figures 1 and 2 show B-vitamin concentra- _2oJ 1 "
+223- 111 iii
I! '
Ii
-i1
11 'l '11" ll Days
11 1 11 1
tions of fermented products at different stages
of storage. Concentrations are percent changes +160 -~
i
of B-vitamin of nonfermented milk. Vitamins +120-"
lil
B6, B12, and biotin decreased in buttermilk by +80-"
about 15% whereas folic acid increased by +60- i
Ropy milk
about 140%. Pantothenic acid, biotin, and B12 +40-
decreased in yogurt; folio acid increased also in +20 -
this product by about 120%. Vitamin B6, B12,
and biotin decreased by 15% in kefir. Folic acid -20 -
increased by nearly 40% day 1, although its -40 -
-60- 1 I 1 13 13 1 13,1 13, 1 13!Days
content was reduced to 25% of nonfermented
milk after storage for 11 days.
+100]
Minor changes of vitamin BI, B~, B6, and
biotin in ropy milk were seen. Folic acid
+801
+601 Sour buttermilk I
increased more than two times after one day's
+401
fermentation. During storage for 13 days, its
-;°Jl@
+2Oll
content decreased to about 120% of nonfer- +O/m
mented milk. Vitamin Bl: decreased continu- i 1 '1
ously (by about 20% and 40% on days 1 and
13). ® ,@ i® @
Vitamin B1 and folic acid content increased
by about 20% and 100% in sour buttermilk. Figure 1. The B-vitamin profile in buttermilk,
Concentration of other B-vitamins showed only yogurt, kefir, ropy milk, and fermented sour butter-
minor alterations. milk. Percent increase or decrease compared with the
milk from which the products were made. 1 = B,,
The only milk product where folic acid did thiamine; 2 = B2 , riboflavin; 3 = B6, pyridoxine;
n o t increase during fermentation was acidophi- 4 = pantothenic acid; 5 = biotin; 6 = folic acid; 7 =
lus milk (Figure 2). When acidophilus milk was B,~, cobalamin; 8 = niacin equivalents.
manufactured from low fat milk, the concen- yogurt, the concentration of thiamine decreased
tration of vitamin B1 increased by about 30% whereas riboflavin remained unchanged. Blanc
whereas the content of the other B-vitamins (7, 8) and others (3) reported increased thiamine
only showed minor changes. However, when and riboflavin, whereas Koser (34) reported
acidophilus milk was made from V-medium, an decreases of both these B-vitamins in yogurt.
entirely different vitamin profile was observed. The pyridoxine content in yogurt remained
The concentration of folic acid decreased by 20 almost unchanged during fermentation whereas
to 40% and that of vitamin B12 by 40 to 60%. Blanc (8) reported a decrease. Nicotinic acid
The B-vitamin profile of bifidus milk also is increased during fermentation (10, 36), but our
shown in Figure 2. The most pronounced investigation failed to confirm this result. The
changes were an increase in folic acid concen- varying results reported by different investiga-
tration by about 100% and a decrease in the tors may reflect different metabolic activities of
content of B12 (to about half the original fermenting microorganisms.
mean) after 13 days of storage. The general increase in folic acid following
The OA in milk and fermented milk prod- fermentation agrees well with findings reported
ucts are in Table 4. Concentration of OA by other authors (17, 27, 45). Also, the general-
decreased significantly in all samples. The most ly lower OA in fermented milk products than in
pronounced reduction was for" yogurt and the original milk seems to be a common finding.
buttermilk where OA content decreased by The particularly high consumption of OA by
more than 45%. yogurt starters (cf. also 18, 41, 48) might be
related to the relatively high fermentation
DISCUSSION temperature (42 to 45°C) and the relatively
Fermentation affects most B-vitamins. In high cell number per milliliter in yogurt pro-
duction.
Milk and milk products are the only sources
of OA in the human diet. The OA affects lipid
Vitamin profile, %
metabolism in experimental animals (9, 49) and
+4o~ | Acidophilusmilk[.
[
I i !
humans (5, 49). In large amounts, OA may
+2otl promote the development of fatty liver (5, 35,
-+0{" 42). Hence, it may be questioned whether OA
-20Jl 1 il I~ Day
is of any nutritional value or whether it repre-
Acidophilusmilk sents a dietary component that can only be
+20 - I
I
+-0- tolerated in limited amounts, especially in
-20 -
F infants. If this is the case, the reduction in OA
-40
-60- 1 12: Days
+100-
+80-
+60-
} TABLE 4. Orotic acid content in milk and fermented
Bifidusmiik products.
+40-
+20- Samples Orotic acid
'+0- n=5 (rag/liter)' % Reduction
-20-
-40-
- I ! 1 13jDaySlvit. SD
-60- L 13-1 1311(~)1311 13'1
[ 13i1! [
Regular milk 67.1 .41
® Buttermilk 35.9 .83 46~5
Yogurt 35.0 .88 47.8
Figure 2. The~B:vitamin profile in lowfat acid0phi- Kefir 55.2 .96 17.7
lus milk, acidophilus milk, and bifidus milk made from Ropy milk 42.6 .66 36.5
V-medium. Percent increase or decrease compared Acidophilus milk 52.0 4.17 22.5
with the milk from which the products were made.
I = B , , thiamine; 2=B2, riboflavin; 3 = B e, pyri-
doxine; 4 = panthothenic acid; 5 = biotin; 6 = folic i AII means for fermented milk products differ
acid; 7 = B,2, cohalamin; 8 = niacin equivalents. (P<.001) from regular milk.
25 Hallanger, L. E. 1953. Orotic acid in milk. J. Biol. orotic acid content in milk.) Milchwissenschaft
Chem. 99-103:83. 26:210.
26 Hegedfis, M. 1972. Elelmizserek B12 vitamintar- 39 Nelson, E. W., R. R. Streiff, and J. J. Cerda. 1975.
talmfinak meghat~roz~sa mikrobiologiai modszerrel. Comparative availability of folate and vitamin C
II. Elelmiszerek B~2 vitamintartalmanak vizsg~lata. from a synthetic and natural source. Am. J. Clin
(Determination of BI~ using microbiological Nutr. 28:1014.
methods. II. The content of B~2 in various foods. 40 O'Donovan, G. A. and J. Neuhard. 1970. Pyrimidine
Elelmiszerv. K6zlem~nyek, 18:19. metabolism in microorganisms. Bacteriol. Rev.
27 Hoppner, K., B. Lampi, and D. E. Perrin. 1972. 34:275.
The free and total folate activity in foods available 41 Okonkvo, P. O., and J. E. Kinsella. 1969. Orotic
on the Canadian market. Can. J. Food Technol. acid in yoghurt. J. Dairy Sci. 52:1861.
5:60. 42 Okonkvo, P. O., and J. E. Kinsella. 1974. Fatty
28 Joe, A. M., K. M. Shahani, and A. Kilara. 1975. livers induction by orotic acid content in skim
Vitamin B content of cultured and acidified sour milk powder. Experientia 30:993.
cream. J. Dairy Sci. 58:791. 43 Pharmacopoea Nordica, 1963. Microbiological
29 Karlin, R. 1958. Sur l'enrichissement du kefir en assay of vitamins. Pharmacopoea Nordica, Vol IV
vitamine BI: par l'adjonction de Propioniibac- (1963).
terium sbermanii. (Increased levels of B12 in kefir 44 Polansky, M. M., and E. M. Toepfer. 1969. Vitamin
by addition ofPropioniibacterium shermanni.) Int. B6 components in meats, fish, dairy products and
Z. Vitaminforsch. 12:358. commercial infant formulas. J. Agric. Fed. Chem.
30 Karlin, R. 1969. On the content of folates in bulk 17:1394.
milk. Effects of various heat treatments on levels 45 Reddy, K. P., K. M. Shahani, and S. M. Kulkarni.
of folates. Int. Z. Vitaminforsch. 39:359. 1975. B-complex vitamins in cultured and acidified
31 Kiermeier, F., and A. Buckl. 1968. Einfiiisse auf yoghurt. J. Dairy Sci. 59:19.
der Orotsiiure Gehait in Kuhmilch. (Influence on 46 Reif, G. D., K. M. Shahani, J. R. Vakil, and L. K.
orotic acid content in milk.) Z. Lebensm. Unters. Crowe. 1976. Factors affecting B-complex vitamin
forsch. 138:284. content of cottage cheese. J. Dairy Sci. 59:410.
32 Kobata, A., S. Ziro, and M. Kida. 1962. The acid 47 Renner, E. 1974. Milch und Milchprodukte in der
soluble nucleotides in milk. J. Biochem. 51:277. Ernghrung des Menschen. (Milk and milk products
33 Kon, S. K., and S. Y. Thomson. 1957. Measure- in human nutrition.) Arbeitsgemeinschaft fiir das
ments of vitamins in the control of milk processing. Milchwirtschaftliche Fachbuch. Hitdesheim. Volks-
Milchwissenschaft 12:166. wirtsch. Verlag.
34 Koser, S. A. 1968. Vitamin requirements of 48 Ritter, W. 1977. Die quantitative Bestimmung der
bacteria and yeasts. Charles Thomas Publ., Spring- Orotsiiure als M6glichkeit zur Ermittlung des
field IL. Milchanteils in Lebelsmitteln. (The quantitative
35 Larson, B. L., and H. M. Hegarthy. 1977. Orotic determination of orotic acid and its possible use as
acid and pyrimidine nucleotides of ruminant an indicator of the level of milk additives in food.)
milks. J. Dairy Sci. 60:1223. Mitt. Geb. Lebensmittelunters. Hyg. 68:240.
36 Lasitsa, O. J. 1967. Pyridoxine content of different 49 Richardson, T. 1978. The hypercholesteremic
types of milk and kefir. (Paediatria Akush. Ginekol. effect of milk. J. Food Prot. 41:226.
1:23.) Dairy Sci. Abstr. 29(1967). Abstr. No 50 Shahani, K. M., and C. R. Chandan. 1979. Nutri-
2047. tional and healthful aspects of cultured and culture-
37 Levenson, S. M., and B. Tennant. 1963. Contribu- containing dairy foods. J. Dairy Sci. 62:1685.
tion of intestinal flora to the nutrition of the host 51 Shahani, K. M., and A. D. Ayebo. 1980. Role of
animal. Some metabolic and nutritional studies dietary lactobacilli in gastrointestinal microecology.
with germfree animals. Fed. Proc. 22:109. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 33:2448.
38 Munchberg, F., G. Tsompanidou, and R. Leskova. 52 Webb, B. H., A. H. Johnson, and J. A. Alford.
1971. Untersuchung ilber das Vorkommen der 1975. Fundamentals of dairy chemistry. 3rd ed.
Orots'~iure in der Milch. (Determination of the Avi Publ. Co., Westport, CT.