Cep. 9. 2007. Bam. 4.4. Il BECTHHK CAHKT-IIETEPBYPPCKOrO _YHHBEPCHTETA JKYPHAJIMCTUKA LK. A6ooruna 2KYPHAJIMCTCKOE PACCJIEJOBAHHE HA TEJIESKPAHE: OMIT HM MPOBJIEMBI 2KypHanueteKue paccnenosama orpaxkator cospeMeHHy:o elicrBHTeMSHOCTE Ha cpese ocrTpeitiNHX MOMMTHYeCKHX, SKOHOMMYECKHX 1 HpaBcTBeHHEIX NloTpaccHMit, O6yCnOBNEHHEIX HHTCHCHBHBIM CTaHOBNCHHeM PBIHOUHBIX OTHOMeHHIL, panuKaMbHot NeMoKpaTusaruelt Bcex cTOpoH Hamelt x31. Kak MpaBiio, Bce OH MOCBAMIeHSI TOMICKAM peIleHus axTyanbHEIX mpoGaem: npectynHocts, Koppynuns, HapKomanus, 9Konorua Ht Mp. [Ip BceM pasooGpasun TeMATHEH HX OOSCAHHSCT HAMHUHe MKPHIAMN PakToR, aHAMUTHIecKHit BSTMAN Ha MpoucKo- AsMlee, OTKPEITOCTS aBTOPCKO!t NOSHIHH. Tlo Mepe pa3BUTHA NMBHTH30BaHHBIX (OPM NeMOKpaTHH, YIYaUIeHUA 9kOHOMMYCCKOTO HW HpaBcTBeHHOTO cocTORHMA ObINeCTRA, CTAOIANBALMH KHBHH POCCHAH MOXxKHO MpemonoxaaTs WBMeHeHMe MpoGreMaTHkH 2kypHANMCTCKHX paccrenoBaHHit, Kora NosuNHH MHAMpYIOMINX TpeH- JOB OKHHYT TakHe MpUBEIMHEIe M OObIICHHBIC A GypHEIX H pedbopMeHHBIX 1990-x ronoB TeMEr Kak TONMTHYCCKOe KUJLIepeTBO Ht «rpaBHBIe TeXHONOrUM MHapa. Tem He MeHee, B peallbHOCTH 06 9TOM TloKa erie pato roBopuTs. Hac 2Ke HATepecyeT B paceMoTpeHHM NpoONeMEl %KypHAMHCT- cKOTO paccieoRaHHA He CTOMEKO TeMATIIeCKHit ACTIOKT, CKONLKO OMpenenene sto! crrenHdH- Yeckoii opMbI xKypHaNucTcKOro Tpyza B OOuIe! MpodeccnoHaTbHOI MeToRONOrH. B wacrosuii MoMeHT B TeOpHH H MpakTHKe %ypHANMCTHKU OTYETIMBO MpocHexHBa- eTcad QUcKype mpoOseMbl ompegenenua coOcTBeHHol oHTONOrMM paccmenoBaHua. C onnolt CTOPOHBI, NPHHATO CHUTATS, YTO XKYPHAMCTCKOE paccsIeLOBAHHe ECT OCOOHIH MeTON padorEt npenctasureneli pasnnanbix CMH, sOuparonmit 8 ceGa npasossie, TBopyeckHe H OpraHHsaul- OHHBIe acrieKTBI. C Apyroii, HexOTOpsIe CKOHAIOTCA K TOUKe speHus Ha IKP Kak #kaHp KypHA- AMCTCKOTO TBOPYeCTBA. Ha oty Temy yoke cyWlecTBYeT ps1 CONMAHBIX HCCHeTOBAHHii, K KOTOPBIM MO2KHO OTHEC- ‘mm paGorsi H. Beprep, A. Koncrantanosa, 0. Tony6nosoii, A. Teprsraoro. Mbt He crapum ceGe Hemblo BHECTH OKOHYATEMbHYI0 SICHOCTS B CTOMb CHOKHBIH 1 TOCTOAHHO JMCKyTHpyeMBIlt BOTPOC 0 2KypHamcTcKoM paccnenoBanun. Hac uHTepecyer: HackON’KO BeMHKO OBepHe ca MUX jeaTeneit CMH x stoit ope paOorsi. Apropst nanaxnia WKypramcteoe paccmeslopariiie: MeTomHMyeckHe peKoMeHlaltuM», roBO- slo paccnemoparenscKoit »kypHAMMOTHKE, OMpeslenmoT IkypHarcToKOe paccneNoBaHHe Kak XaHp: «CaM 2kaHp %KYPHANHCTCKOTO paccseNoBaHHA Mpeytlonaraet BCeCTOPOHHee Hi ToLpoOHoe HccMey0- BaHHe Hexoil Marlo HByueHHOll, saKpBITO! WMH THATeATbHO CKpEIBAeMOHt TeMBI, B TIpotlecce paGorEt Hay KOTOpolt MpuXonMTeA MpeosoneBaTe HexKeNAHMe OMperleMeHHEIX CTPyKTyp MpeqocTaBHTs WH- ‘Tepecylomllyio Bac HH(hopMalliMo. ...cHOBHOe OTHE *kYpHAMMCTCKOTO paccmteMOBAHMA KaK 7aH- pa sakouaeTCs, NOxKaTyi, B TOM, YTO ABTOp He OTpaHHYHBAeTCA MOcTaHOBKOlt MpoGIeMBI H ee ca MOCTOsTENBHBIM HiccmenoBaHeM. Musecrurelitop, kak MpaBHino, npewiaraet KaKHe-To BapHaHTBI 231OTBeTOB Ha BOSHMKINMe BOTTpOCEI, BBIBONEI, KOTOPEIE BEITeKAIOT 13 MpomesIaHHO! HM paGorst. Hott paB OH MOXET Nake He ear ITOTO OTKPEITSIM TEXCTOM, HO COOPAHHBIe GakTEI H KOMMEHTApHH K HMM CaMH IIOKTOMKHYT YHTATeNA WIM 3pHTEMA K MpaBHIbHOMY 3aKMOueHHIO!, Tipmumenmee B Poccmo 13 3anaqusix CMH, nonstue «ansectureitropersa» (oxypra- AMCTCKOTO paccieqoBaHus) MpHoGperto B OTeYeCTBeHHBIX cpencTBAX MaccoBOll uaopManHH Gonee y3Kutt xapaxrep: «Pocculickas »kypHanncTHKa HecKONbKO CyAKAeT H SA0CTPAeT NOHATHE 2KypHallMcTCKOTO paccnezoBaHis, Oxo cite He MpHoGpemo cBoelt akaneMHYecKOlt opMEI, HO yoke celiac MHOTHe MOHUMaIoT Mo HUM UccHleoBaHHe TeMBI, CBAZAHHOH co SmoynoTpeGneHH- IMM BuaCT}O H Koppynieit. [lems Takoro paccieqOBaHHA ~ MIpesaTb OTMacKe CKPBITHIC CBA3H MeXKIY BIACTbIO H OpraxMa0BaHHOH mpecrynHocTsio. Ha caMoM 3xKe ses pacomemoBaHHe Kak 2kaHP He MOXKET O5ITS CBA3AHO paMKaMH Kaxoli-ro onpenemeHHO! mpobmemst. Tarantmestit oKYpHanHcT cyMeeT cienaTs Onectammit Marepuan. Knaccwueckuit BapwaxT momobxoit me- ATCNbHOCTH — HCTOPHA 2KYPHAMHcTOB aMepuKaxcKoit raseTs “Baumurtox Moc» Boba Byn- sopa 1 Kapa Bepxcraiitia, KoTopsie cyMemH paccnemoBars eno 0 BTopxeHHH B UrTa6-KBap- Tupy NeMoxparu4eckoli napruu CLIA B orene «Yorepreiit B Bamuurtore?. Tipu 970M, Kak orMeyaior apToper WKypHanucTcKoro paccnenloBaHHa», OCHOBHOHt Te- Moi OTeqeCTBeHHBIX 2%kYpHAMUCTCKHX paccnefoRaHHi CTAHOBMTCA HMCHHO KpuMuHaNbHas, «Cyry6o KpHMHHanbHas HATH MpaBoBas TeMa CTAHOBHTCH CeTOMHA MpewMCTOM MHOTHX IKYpHa- JIMCTCKMX paccreoBaHHii He cmyuaiino. Sto cneumpuveckoe, HaltoHAMbHOe poccHiicKoe oT- HOIIeHHe K 3aKOHY, Kak K [IBIILTY, BO MHOTOM sBAKeTCA IPHIMHO! Tex COMMANSHEIX, 9KOHOMA- HOCKHX 1 axe NONATHYECKHX MpoOHeM, KOTOpsIe MeperuienHcs B HalieM obmecTRe. H ecaH, Kak CBHJeTEsBCTBYIOT CONMOMOTHYCCKHeE OMPOCKI, POCCHAHE CTABAT Ha IlepBOE MECTO BONPOCHI Ges0macHOCTH, TO ecTeCTBEHHO, YTO 2yPHANHCTHKa KaK MHCTPYMeHT OOleCTBEHHOTO MHEHHA 9STOMY MIpewMery # npugaet ocoboe sHavenne’, SapySexHBle HCCHenOBaTeNH MpHlepKUBAIOTCA CHeMYIOUIAX B3ITANOB Ha 2%kypHaNHcT- ckoe paccneqosanne: OKypHammcrckoe paccneqopanue, — numer J. PoHzai, — cyulecTBeHHO OTAMMACTCA OT APYTHX BANOB YPHAHCTCKOHt NeaTenbHOCTH. Bor TpH ero OcobeHHOCTH: — nepsHanoe paccnenosanne, BuiOparias TeMa MIpenronoxKHTeNbHO cBa3aHa c COMHH- ‘TENBHBIMH NeNaMH WIM C XaaTHOCTSIO, HO NOKa3aTeNbCTB STOMY HeT; ~ KTO-To TbrTaeTes COXpaHHTs HEopMarmno B TaitHe. KKypuanucroKoe paccnenonanne HauHHaeTes TAM, Tle 3aKAHUHRacTCA MOBCeTHeBHaA padoTa. Ova MTHOpupyer CKPEITHOCTS HH HOBHMKOB H OTKa3 laBaTb HHCbopMalmo, Tomyyenue HHopMalun — BOT Lens 2%kypHamUcTeKoro paccaenoBanna; KypHaANCTCKOE paccneMOBAHHe BO3MOK- Ho 10 mo6oit Teme B mOGoii chepe oSmecTReHHON KUBHHD'. Wi, our tak omucerBaer akypHanucTcKoe paccneqoBaune: «Ecnu HHopManMoHHoe co- oStenne npentcTapnaet coGoli cOanancuposaHnbiii oTYeT O KOHKpeTHOM COOBITHH HHBHOKeHHe axrow 6e3 KOMMeHTapHa, TO 2kypHAMMICTCKOe paccmenoBAHHe CTABHT CBOeHi HleMbIO MOKazaTS mpapily W214 sloxb. ABTOp paccieqOBaHHA 3aHUMaeT ONpeleneHHy10 MO3HUHIO, OOLYHO HatH- Has C MOCBIIKU, YTO YTO-TO He Tak. [TpenB3aTocTs 3ampettena. Mpemnonoxenve MpoBepsetca NO MomBexeHHA HTOFOB, Kora HCXORHaK TuNOTesa mMGo MoATBep»xLaeTcs, MuGO OTBepraeTca. Ockoxoit 2kypranucrcKoro paccnenonaHHA aBnacTcA OOMIMpHas, nonpobHaa uAopManua, coOpanian 8 6ecipucrpactHol Maxepe, HO eTO Lemb ~ 4TO-To JOKasaTb HIM OMpoBeprHyT, a He NpocTo H3MOKUTE copHBIe daKroD»’. 2KypHanucreKoe paccuenopanve — onHO 43 CaMBIX CHJIBHBIX cpe/lCTB B apceHane Te- aeHosoctelt, HonyepkuBaet Pour, OnHako penopraxk-paccmenoBaHHe MOET OLITS CTOM 2e CHOpHBIM, CKONb M NOMyRApHbIM. BosMoxkHO, HH B KaKOH Apyroit oGmacTH xypHaNMcTHKH 232TpaBoBBle H STHYeCKHe BOMpOcbI He MepenmeraioTcs TAK CHIBHO, Kak 37ecb. PUCK oKynaeToa POCTOM aymuTOpuH, XoTA MHOTHe CUNTAIOT paccnenoBaHHte HeynasHolt nonBITKoi TB u paquo peanHs0BaTs yHKUNH CTOpOxeBOTO Mica, BOSTOXKCHHBIe Ha «HeTBEpTYIO BACT», T. e. Mpeccy. Tary aMepHKaHicKHX >kypHanicTop K paccnenonanism H. Dour oOpacuset Tem, ¥To BOTHMUKE OT OOBTHHEIX COOOUIeHHI M Make peakKUMOHHEIX KOMMCHTapHeB 3TOT %KaHp YacTO act npeneneHHDIit NomOKUTeNBHEI pesymbTaT, NPHBONUT K OLLYTHMBIM V3MEHEHHAM B KOH- KperHoii cepe. B cBASH C aKTHBHEIM NPOHHKHOBeHHeM paccmemOBaTeNbKOit 2ypHANMCTUKM B pasHEle Bust CMH n psizenenieM ce 8 OTMeMbHBIIi 2kaHp, HOABIACTCH MHOTO Hay4HEIX pa6or, uccHe- AYIONIAX 9TO ABNEHHe, ero HOpMBI H MIPHSHAKH, ITHYECKHe M CONMANbHBIE MpOONeMBI, OMHCEI- BalOULMX XapakTepHEIe YepTbI KYPHAMMCTCKOTO paccaenoOBaHHA, «Meron xypramictckoro paccnenlosanua, — cuuraer B.B, Eropos, — Bo3MOxXHOCTS JUL 2KypHACTOB caMUM OTBeYaTs Ha MOCTARIeHHBIe YHTATEMAMM, O6tlecTREHHOCTBIO BOMpoosI. Tep- MHH «paccsleopakien, B3ATBIH 13 OGnaCTH IOpHEMpyNeHLMM, CBAAeTeMBCTBYeT 0 TOM, YTO 2yp- HONMCTHKa HAMIUX AHeli MpHHMMaeT Ha ceOx HoBbIe, paee He CBOlicTReHEBIe WIA Hee, byHKUMH. Hapany c mponarannoli, arwtanueli u opransauuelt, c couMaNbHEIM opHeHTMpoBanveM ‘HTaTe- seit 1 KOHTPOIEM 9a ViCTIONHeHHeM petlieHnit Ha BCeX YPOBHAX >KyPHAuIHCTHKa CTpeMHITCA aKTHBHO Hi OMepaTHBHO BMEIIMBaTECA B KOHKPeTHBIC KPHTHYECKHe DKONOTHYECKHe CHTYALMH, HCHOMbSys BeCb apceHall BOSMO>KHOCTeH, B TOM YHICHIe H Te, KOTOpble Pakiee cio He HcTloMBs0BaNHCBNS, PackpsiBad THaTebHO OGeperaebie TaliHbI, MPOHMKad MON MOKPOBbI MOAHTHKH, 3KO- HOMHKH, MpaBa # OOUIecTReHHO! Mopanh, HeucToBbIe TeslepentoprepsI MPUBNeKalOT K 9KpaHaM PeKOPAHEIe 110 HUCHEHHOCTH ayIHTOPUH, TBOPAT CeHCALIMH, Pe3yTbTATOM KOTOPBIX CTAHOBATCA TPOMKHe CKaHiaiIbI ¢ OTCTABKAMH, apecTaMH, PasBonaMH. Onnit ocBoenia 2xypHarlucTeKoro paccmeonaHsl Ha OTeYeCTBEHHOM TeneBHsLeHHM HaceH- ‘ToIBaeT HcTOpHO He Gorlee YeM B rlowTopa AecaTKa eT, OAHKM 13 TepBEIX ero yraepmun B aupe oxypHanucr Aprem Boposux, cognarens 1 pykosoumreil Xora «COsepuleHHO CeKperHoy. On- HOMMeHHast TeMeBUSHOHHas Meperlawa crarta neppoit B AIMHHOM H pasHoobpasHoM mepeune nocme- AYOUIX MporpaMM aHalorH4Hoii TeMaTHyeckoli H %KAaHPOBO! OpHeHTHpoBaHHOCTH. Tak WIM MHave, MpMeMsl, XapakTepHBIe JUL KYPHANMCTCKOTO paccnenoBaHHA, BrIOC- JICHCTBHM HCMONB3OBANHCh Hake B TeX NporpaMMax, re OTCYTCTBROBAIAa KpHMHHaNbHAL coctapnaloulas, MoxkHo 3aMeTHTs ompenemeHHsie Yeprs! paccnegoBarenbcKolt %xypHamic- THKH B H3BECTHOM TesIeBHSHOHHOM UMKTe JeoHHma Haphenosa «HaMenHM, a TaKKe UyTS T03%Ke — HB ONHOMMeHHO! exeHererbHO! Nepenaye. XapaxtepHoit ocoGeHHocTs!0 poccuiicKoro OMBITa 9BOMOUUM jaRHOTO 2axpa cnezy- eT MpH3HATb HCMOMB3OBAHHE MPHeMOB %kYpHANHCTCKOTO paccieNOBAHHA B TIOMHTHYeCKH OpH- eHTMpOBAHHBIX BEMYCKax OMpeNeNeHHBIX TesleMIpoeKToB B MepHON MpenBEIGOpHEIX KaMTAHHi, Hanonee apxuit mpumep — nextensuocts Ceprea Jjoperko B KauecTBe Beylero TIporpaMMEt B nlepvioy BbISopos B TocynaperBexxyt0 Jlymy 8 1999 rony. Tora on oT¥asHHO Gopostcsa NpoTHB Goxa «OtevecTao — Bes Pocus», Hcnonb3ys Komnpomerupyroume Matepuamsi. Ocoby10 yoe- JMTeNBHOCTS BBICTyTIeHHAM C.JlopeHKo Mpwsanana HBOUIpeHHaT HarMLADHOCTs ero paccenoBa- nui, KoTopad BorMiomanace B BEIBORe Ha 2Kpan hoTorpaduit, pasmM4HEIx cxem 1 rpaiikos, Ta- KHIM o6pa30M, BeNYUINit PEMA ONY WS MABHBIX MpOOseM, CYMIeCTBYIOUUAX B AMATKTHYECKAX OTHOUICHIIX MEXKLY TEMEBHICHHEM 1 LeMIMH CaMOTO 2YPHAMCTCKOTO pacciteOBaHHA, roi npobemoi Bcerna Osu1a, ects m OyneT MpoGnema HarazmHocTH H MsmocTpa- THBHOCTH B TeeBH3KOHHOM odupe. KoMMyHHKaTHBHbIe MpHpomHble OcobcHHOCTH AaHHOTO SIeKTpOHHOTO Me/iHa CBA3AHBI c HasImueM Buseopasa. Ero OTCyTCTBHe cepbesHo CHIDKAeT 233BOSMOKHOCTS aleKBATHOTO YoROeHHA MaTepHana aymuTopuelt. Xota B pale cmywaer, Kora Beye COsHATEbHO MaHHMYAMpyIOT BOCTIPHATHEM 3PHTeNBCKHM CO3HAHMeM, KaK pas OT- CYTCTBHe “KapTHHKI) H MOBBIIIacT BeposTHYIO «OCTOBEPHOCTS» H3NATAeMEIX cBemCHH, Xapaxrepustit npumep — mporpamma Anzpea Kapaysiona “Moment HoTHHst», 8 KOTOpOHi BeAYINMHt OYeHb YaCTO HCMOMb3yeT BACOpAN, KOTOpbIc BOSMeHiCTByeT He C TOUKM 3peHHA J0- THKH 1 HEOpMALWN, ac TouKH speHHA sMouni. Korma xe HANHENe «KaprHHKWD BaxKHO It HOCTpOeHHa Ha Skpane yOenuTenbHoll OOsMHsOMell KOTO-nMGo KoHCTpyKuM, TO KapaynoB UCTIONb3yeT METON HeKOppeKTHOTO MOHTa2Ka, KOTa MapaslenbHBIMM BU;COpAsaMM «CXONsT- cm Ha oKpaxe. HanpuMep, 8 mporpame, KoTopas 6b11a ocpsmleHa 9Kc-rySepHaropy IIpu- Mopcxoro kpas Esrenuto Hasmparenxo. Ero A.Kapaysop oOBMHAM B CBA3AX C MECTHBIMM TIpe- cTYTHSIMH rpyrmmposkamn. Viunocrpattuamn chy HAI KaypsI MOGHTeNBCKOl BANOCBEMKH, (buxcupyiomme mpenctasureneli MectHoro npectynHoro cooburectBa. B npsMoM MOHT@KHOM cTbIKe K 9THM KapaM MPHCOeAMHAITC. KaNpbI, KOTOpsIe 3arleuatnenn TyGepHatopa B. Hasnpa- ‘TeHKO COBCEM B ApyToe BpeMA H B pyToM MecTe’, OnHuM 13 caMBIX U3M0GeHHBIX NpHeMoB, KOTOpsIe MpHMeHsAMOTCA poceniicKHMH *Kyp- HaMCTAMM B peaNlH3allHv 2kaHpa %ypHAMMCTCKOTO paccseMOBAHHA Ha TeNeIKpave, sBIAeTCA HHCUeHHSalIMA COOsITHA, ero pexoncTpyKuMA. MeTox cTan HacTONBKO Momymapex, YTO pay nporpam («Yectasitt netexrmp», «Upesssriaiizioe npoucitectsien, «SanpetHas 30a»), opH- eCHTHPOBAHHBIX Ha KPHMMHAMbHY!0 TeMaTHKY Hi HCIIOMbSY!OUIAX NPHEME! paccneoBaHHs, STOT MpHeM HcTIosMb3y}OT NOCTOsHHO Jane o6cTosTenscTBo TaKKe OOGACHACTCA TEMH TPYNHOCTAMH, KoTOpBIe HeMbITSIBa- 10T 2KYPHAMHCTSI MIP PaccnelOBaHHH W MOCK MOLMEHO NOCTOBEpHBIX H JOKYMeHTAIbHBIX Kanpos, @uKCHPYIOMIUX KPHMHHANbHDIe Nea, HAN MpoTuBoNpaBHEIe AelcTBUA. OT stro HCXOMHOTO MOCTyMaTa H MPOHCXO/MT BBIRYKMCHHAM OMlOpa B TeeBESHOHHBIX MporpaMMax HE- ‘Tepecyiomlero Hac 2karipa Ha UMUTanHIo coOsITHA, NporcurecBHs. ToROpuTS 0 cTerIeHs MOCTO- BepHOCTH IIpH PeKOHCTPYKIUMH OGCTOATEMECTB B XOMe %KYPHANHCTCKOTO paccieOBaHHA MOXKHO ‘THUNB c onpenleneRHoit fomeli yenoBHocta. Bech O4eBNHA pasHulla MexXY KpeaTHBHBIM MeTONOM, KoTOpHIii NpHMeHsAeT XKYPHANKCT, MbITAACh BOCHPOUSBECTH MPOM30MIeMUICe, M CHeACTBeHHBIM DKCIIepUMeH- TOM, KOryla KapTHHa MIpectynmenus uKcUpyetca Ha MecTe cro coBepuleHHA B BHUe pacckasa monospesaemoro®. IIpuuem 3auxcuposanHbiit 9xcnepuMeHT o6petaet pH- juNecky! CMY oka3aTenbcrBa, Tora Kak PeXOHCTPYKIMA COOBITHA B TeseBHSHOHHOM TporpaMMe, OCHOBaHHOit Ha 2kypHANHCTCKOM paccHeAOBAHHM, CCT BCCTO THM OM 3 BO3MOXHBIX, HO H€ CHHCTBEHHBIH BapHaHT TOrO, Kak B peabHOCTH CIy4HNOCk TO WIM HHOe MponcmecTBHe. MoxHo npeqnonoxvT, YTO JalbHeliliad SBOMONMA XKyPHANMCTCKOTO paccheqoBanua Gyner UMeTb BeKTOPOM YReNMYeHHe MOMH SpeMHMHOCTH H HarTATHOCTH B KOHeIHO!t bopme ‘TOTO WI HHOTO TenesKpaHHOTO posta. Bo BCAKOM ciTy4ae, BCe OOCTOATEMBCTBA OEITORARHA cTom HomlympHoro 2%kakpa B OTeveCTBEHHOM Tenes*upe cBAAeTEMCTBYIOT B TONb3y NaHHOHk ‘TOUKH SpeHHA. * Illy FOnuii, Kypuanncreroe paccnesiosate. Metoanaeckwe pexomesauum. M., 2000. C. 13 > Ha marepnasax sToro paccmenosanns ‘kypHAMMCTAMH O&LIa HATHCaHa NOKyMeHTANBHAS KuHa «Box mpesMqcHToKaR arin, ynoctoemHax mpecricxnofi Tyammieposckoii npewmm., B 1976 r. pexnccep Amax Tlaxyna noctasnx 10 ¢e MoTHBaM Qu1em, yrocroenmesti veruspex mpemili AmepmxaHcKoii kiHoaKatenm «Ockap». TaasaBre pon s diureMe cemrpana Pobept Poapopa [actu Xospsau. 2342 Tan xe. C15. * Ponda J. Yampepcansmsti xypuamet. M., 1999. C.145, 5 Tencnosoctu: cexperst xypHamHcToKOTO NacTepoTBa (pedepar KitUrH H.Osura «TexenonocrH, panmoonocrm). M., 1997. C.168-169. * Ezopoe B.B. Tenesuesme: Teopnx H mpaxtika, Yae6xoe nocobue. M., 1993, 0.47. 7 JhoSomsrmo, sro E.Hasparenno nonam » oy na A.Kapayzona UMeHHO 8 cBsSH ¢ STO Mepenaselt. . Ero HCK K Te nenexytemy 6s yloBaeTsopen. B noswentenne MopansHoro yatep6 astop «MoMenTa nority omKeH Guu BBxnzaTT EHaspparenxo necsrs rere zonapos CIA. 5 Vpounaice msoGpaxenite Mpotlecca MoxHO OSHApYAHTE B pale sTHsONOB dyLTEMa K.CepeGpemmunosa «Hsobpaxat okeprny>>.