You are on page 1of 4

TUTORIAL

Optical Design using Fresnel Lenses


Basic Principles and some Practical Examples

The Fresnel lens can be used in a


THE AUTHORS
wide variety of applications. The basic
principles of the Fresnel lens are review-
ed and some practical examples are des- ARTHUR DAVIS FRANK KÜHNLENZ
cribed. There are definite advantages and Art is the Senior Optical Frank received his Ph. D.
tradeoffs that should be considered when Engineer at Reflexite in experimental physics
deciding if a Fresnel lens is the appropri- Optical Solutions Busi- in 2004 from Friedrich
ate component to use in a design. Some ness in Rochester, NY. Schiller University in Jena,
basic optimization rules are presented Art completed his undergraduate degree Germany. He worked on material characte-
which may facilitate a first order design in Optics in 1996 and received his Mas- rization by using different laser related
or feasibility study. ters in Optics in 2000 from the University methods. Frank is located at Fresnel Optics
of Rochester. Art designs a wide range of GmbH in Apolda, Germany, as an Optical
imaging and nonimaging optics for spe- Engineer where his work is focused on the
Background cialized customer OEM applications. He optical design of different microstructured
maintains an optics knowledge base at op- optical components, especially with Fres-
A Fresnel lens is an optical component which
tics.reflexite.com and a library of his tech- nel structures.
can be used as a cost-effective, lightweight
nical writings are available at hologram.
alternative to conventional continuous sur-
homeip.net/optics.
face optics. The principle of operation is
straightforward enough: given that the re-
fractive power of a lens is contained only at OO
the optical interfaces (i. e. the lens surfaces), OO
Frank Kühnlenz
Arthur Davis Reflexite Optical Solutions Business
remove as much of the optical material as Sr. Optical Engineer Fresnel Optics GmbH
possible while still maintaining the surface Reflexite Optical Solutions Business Flurstedter Marktweg 13
curvature. Another way to consider it is that 500 Lee Rd., Rochester, NY 14606, USA Apolda, Germany
the continuous surface of the lens is ”col- E-mail: Art.Davis@Reflexite.com E-mail: Frank.Kuehnlenz@Fresnel-Optics.de
Website: www.display-optics.com Website: www.fresnel-optics.de
lapsed“ onto a plane. An example of this
concept is shown in figure 1.
The practical aspect of compressing the
lens surface power into a plano surface re- The definition of focal length may depend This terminology comes from photography
quires a finite prism pitch, a slope angle com- on the way the lens is used in application where a lens of lower f-number would use
ponent (which acts to refract the rays in the (an individual lens may even have variable a faster shutter speed. Another useful mne-
prescribed manner) and a draft component focal distances across its aperture). Generally monic is that a lens of smaller f-number will
(which for the normal refractive lens design though, the focal length is the distance from concentrate light faster then an equivalent
is optically inactive but necessary to return the lens to where an idealized collimated in- diameter lens of larger f-number (which
the surface profile ”back to the plane“). See put beam converges to a point. More spe- will concentrate light slower). A diagram is
figure 2 for cross section schematic illustra- cifically, for a lens with prism facets on one shown in figure 3.
ting these components. The convention is to side and a flat plano surface on the other
specify the slope angle with respect to the side, the effective-focal-length is very closely
Design of a Fresnel Lens
plane of the lens and the draft angle with re- approximated as the distance from the prism
spect to the normal. For example, a small slo- surface of the lens to the focal point. Also, An evident disadvantage to using a lens
pe angle would correspond to a prism with it is commonplace to define the back-focal- with grooves is the possibility of lost light
a gradual incline whereas a small draft angle length as the distance from the plano side of due to incidence on the draft facet. The first
corresponds to a very steep prism decline. the lens to the focal point. step one may take to minimize this so cal-
The f-number is the ratio of the lens fo- led draft-loss is to make the facet perfectly
cal length (f ) to the clear aperture diameter vertical (i. e. perpendicular to the plane of
Focal Length and f-number
of the lens (F). This term is also referred to the optic). The reality of manufacturing
A few other concepts typically used to as the ”speed“ of the lens. The lower the however requires at least a few degrees of
specify a Fresnel lens are focal length and f-number, the ”faster“ the lens and the hig- tilt to the draft to facilitate mold release.
f-number (or f/#). her the f-number, the ”slower“ the lens. Nevertheless, loss can be minimized by very

52 Optik & Photonik December 2007 No. 4 © 2007 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
TUTORIAL

FIGURE 1: Conceptual illustration


(in side-profile) of collapsing a continuous Draft Facet
surface aspheric lens into an equivalent
Slope Facet
power Fresnel lens.
Facet Spacing

Slope Angle
Draft Angle FIGURE 2: Side-profile
schematic of Fresnel
Plano Surface lens prisms with nomen-
clature conventions.

”Slow“ Lens ”Fast“ Lens

F F

FIGURE 3: Demonstration
of f-number. The lens
focal length is f. The lens
diameter is F. The ”fast“
f f lens has a lower f-num-
ber than the ”slow“ lens.

judicious design which optimally locates the maximum pitch size that will be visible for a To conclude the discussion on optical ef-
draft facet within the ”shadow“ of a slope given distance from the eye: fects due to periodic prism structures, consi-
facet. Although this keeps the total trans- der the geometric and diffraction limits of the
mission efficiency high, the luminance is ne- d b z · 2.91 x 10 – 4 lens performance. Geometrically, the smaller
cessarily reduced because of beam ”voids“ the prism size, the closer small flat prism slo-
as described in reference [1]. Where d is the maximum visually resolvab- pe facets come to approximating the idea-
Based on the direction the Fresnel lens le pitch size (a smaller value should be se- lized aspherical surface. However, operating
facets face, it is possible to calculate the ide- lected) and z is the effective distance of the contrarily are diffractive effects. As the pitch
al transmission efficiency versus the lens f- lens to the eye. As an example, for a lens 1 becomes smaller, the prisms become more
number by taking into account the surface meter away, the facets will be unresolvab- efficient at acting like a grating which will de-
reflections and the draft-loss. An example le for a pitch size of 0.29 mm or smaller. liver more light into higher diffractive orders
computation is shown in reference [2]. A A convenient rough approximation to this away from the desired focal position. From
collimating lens converts a point source to formula is to take a quarter of the distance reference [3] an optimum balance can be
a beam of parallel light and a concentrating the lens is to the observer and then move achieved by choosing the pitch size d as:
lens collects a collimated input beam onto the decimal three places smaller (using the
the focal point. A grooves-out design directs example above, this yields a pitch size of d z 1.5 · •L· f
the facets towards the side of the collima- around 0.25 mm).
ted beam (also called the infinite conjuga- Using the minimum resolvable pitch as
te or the long conjugate) and a grooves-in a limit, the next step is to ensure that the THE COMPANY
design orients the facets towards the focal pitch of the Fresnel lens does not create a
point (also called the short conjugate). As beat frequency with any of the other micro- Reflexite Optical Solutions
shown in figure 4, selection of the facing prismatic components of the system. This
direction of the grooves, especially for fast is called a Moiré pattern and an example Reflexite Optical Solutions Business
lenses, plays an important role in determi- is shown in figure 5. A rule of thumb is to (consisting of Reflexite Display Optics in
ning the lens transmission efficiency. select the pitch as: Rochester, NY, USA, and Fresnel Optics
When a Fresnel lens is used in some GmbH in Apolda, Germany) combines
component of a display application (or any d = (m + 0.35) · d2 expertise in optical engineering, micro-
application in which an observer will be replication and polymer processing to
”looking-through“ the lens), care must be Where again, d is the Fresnel lens prism provide microstructured polymer op-
taken to minimize the visual impact of the pitch, m is an integer (the larger the better) tics for Display, Lighting, Instrumenta-
grooves. This is first achieved by making and d2 is the pitch of the other micro-pris- tion, Solar Collection and many other
sure to pick a facet pitch less than or equal matic component in the system. As indica- light management applications. Refle-
to the resolving power of the human eye. In ted, the larger the value you can choose for xite Corporation is a globally operating
other words, make the prisms smaller than m, the less moiré will be visible. However, in world leader in the development and
can be seen. A typical healthy human eye order to keep the pitch d smaller than the production of optical microstructured
has a visual acuity of around 1 arcminute minimum visually resolvable pitch, usually components and films.
(or 1/60°). This can be used to compute the only a value of m = 1 or 2 is feasible.

© 2007 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.optik-photonik.de 53


TUTORIAL

1.0

0.9
Fractional Transmission Efficiency

0.8

0.7

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.3
Collimating: Grooves Out
0.2 Collimating: Grooves In
Concentrating: Grooves Out FIGURE 5: Example of a Moiré pattern
0.1 Concentrating: Grooves In generated when a linear pattern (such
as the grooves of a lenticular lens) and a
0.0 circular pattern (such as the grooves of
2.0 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 a Fresnel lens) are overlapped. The pat-
F-number (f/#) tern can be minimized by more carefully
choosing the pitch of each component.
FIGURE 4: Idealized efficiency values of Fresnel lenses in various configurations. The
curves are computed based on the surface reflections and the draft-loss. The chart can
be read by selecting an f-number on the abscissa and then seeing what the efficiency collimating an idealized point source. In real
is at the ordinate for a selected configuration. The read efficiency is the transmission of life, no source is a true point, however so-
the lens for the ray bundle at that specific f-number.
lid state emitters such as LEDs can be quite
small, so with enough distance between the
lens and the LED, it may be approximated
Where L is the primary wavelength of con- and the preferred visible height h1 of the as a point source. A Fresnel lens can there-
cern and f is the focal length of the lens. As object. Then the diameter F of the lens is fore be used to collimate the LED output.
an example, for L= 550 nm (central value given by: Also, traditional incandescent sources gene-
of the visible spectrum) and a lens of fo- m · h1 rate a lot of radiated heat which has limited
F=
cal length f = 100 mm, the optimum prism 1+ ¥m · s1´ the use of plastic optics in close proximity
pitch size would be d = 0.35 mm. §l – s1 ¶ (2) to the source. Since the majority of the heat
generated by an LED is conductive, it is less
A typical comfortable reading distance difficult to apply a plastic lens.
Applications
is l = 350 mm. Consider an example of a A rule of thumb for the distance at which
Fresnel Lens Magnifier desired magnification of m = 2, a visible the LED die can be approximated as a point
Magnifiers are an example of one of the object size of h1 = 20 mm and a lens to ob- emitter is given according to the far field
simplest applications of the Fresnel lens. Typi- ject distance of s1 = 25 mm. Substituting region convention:
cally, a magnifier is a positive lens that forms into Equation 1, we find a lens focal length
a virtual upright image. Assuming the object of f = 50 mm and then using Equation 2, an a2
z> (3)
to lens distance and the desired magnifica- aperture size of F= 35 mm is found. L
tion of the magnifier are known, the thin lens
Newtonian equation can be used to find an Where z is the LED to lens distance, a is the
Fresnel Lens Collimator
expression for the lens focal length f : size of the LED die and L is the wavelength
Normally a Fresnel lens is cut according to of the light. As an example, consider an LED
s an aspheric surface profile in order to mini- die size of a = 50 µm at the central visib-
f= 1
¥1– 1´ mize the imaging optical aberrations. The le wavelength of L= 550 nm. Then, from
§ m¶ (1) lens can therefore do an excellent job of Equation 3, the lens to die distance should

Where s1 is the object to lens distance and


m is the magnification (which is defined
as the ratio of the desired object size divi-
ded by the actual object size; for instance a
magnification of m = 2 would make letters
FIGURE 6: Representation
on a page look twice as big). See figure 6
of rays and variable definitions
for a sketch of the variable definitions. for the magnifier application.
Next it is necessary to choose a lens size The smaller red arrow to the
such that the requisite extent of the object left of the lens represents
is visible. For this we need to add two more the object and the longer blue
variables; the reading distance l which is the arrow to the far left represents
distance from the object to the observer; the magnified virtual image.

54 Optik & Photonik December 2007 No. 4 © 2007 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
TUTORIAL

be at least z = 4.5 mm. Then a Fresnel lens Because the real task for maximizing so-
of focal length equal to 4.5 mm should do a lar radiation onto a cell for electrical conver-
very good job of collimating the output. sion does not require minimizing the ima-
This computation is valid considering an ging aberrations, it is actually advantageous
LED die which is not otherwise magnified to design the Fresnel lens for maximum flux
by an encapsulant. However, most com- transfer without regard for image quality. A
mercial LED products include the die chip Fresnel lens design of this type is referred to
contained within some form of dome lens. as nonimaging. The design and optimiza-
This lens effectively acts as a magnifier for tion of nonimaging Fresnel lenses is discus-
the die and the far field region must be sed in detail in reference [4].
found by calculating the die size based on Typical for solar Fresnel lens concentra-
the magnified image formed by this dome. tors is to orient the grooves towards the
A straightforward geometric method for solar cell. This is opposite to the normal
calculating this magnified image is presen- sense as described by the earlier collimator
ted in reference [2]. application in which the grooves face the
When attempting to collimate the beam long conjugate. With the grooves-in there is
pattern for an LED emitter with a wide an- the potential advantage of minimizing the
gle, it is most likely advantageous to use a impingement of solar radiation on the draft
reflector in combination with a Fresnel lens and also to avoid buildup of dirt and debris
in order to minimize the package volume of within the facets.
the optics. However reflector design is not
within the scope of this discussion. Here we
Summary
will compute the necessary lens diameter
for a Fresnel lens without a reflector: Just a few applications of the Fresnel lens The new Mirror Mount
were discussed. Many more are possible.
F = 2 · z · tan Q The formulas and examples presented here
can be used as guidelines for the initial
adjust.x™
Where F is the necessary lens diameter, z is
again the LED to lens distance (or as descri-
design phase of a custom application. For
more examples of applications and additio-
The all-purpose
bed previously, the effective lens to LED die nal technical discussions, more information Mirror-Mount
image distance) and Q is the emission half is freely available at the weblinks in refe-
angle of the LED. Continuing the earlier ex- rence [5].
• Best cost-performance ratio
ample where z = 4.5 mm, consider an LED
• Precise adjustment
of half angle Q= ±30°, we calculate a neces-
• Robust, solid and long term stable
sary lens diameter of F = 5.2 mm.
• Flexible in everyday use

Fresnel Lens Concentrator


An optical system in which the goal is to Learn more:
converge light from a relatively large regi- www.linos.de/adjust.x
onal area to a significantly smaller aperture
can be labeled as a condenser or concentra-
tor. For a concentrator system a Fresnel lens See us at:
design will be thinner and lighter weight
than an equivalent continuous surface op-
tic. The gain is most evident at especially
References
large area applications (200 x 200 mm2 or
larger for example) in which solid core con- [1] O. E. Miller, J. H. McLeod, W. T. Sherwood, Thin
tinuous refractive lenses will become very sheet plastic Fresnel lenses of high aperture,
heavy and unwieldy indeed. Journal of The Optical Society of America, Vo-
A field in which this advantage is of gre- lume 41, No. 11
LINOS Photonics GmbH & Co. KG
Telefon +49 (0)551 69 35-0
at importance is solar concentration. The [2] A. Davis, Light Emitting Diode Source Mode-
E-mail sales@linos.de
simplest way to think of a solar Fresnel con- ling for Optical Design, Intertech-Pira LEDs
www.linos.de
centrator is to consider a lens with the focal 2004, http://display-optics.com/pdf/LensDe-
point located right on the solar cell. When signForLeds_WorkBook_Davis3.pdf
lens is pointed directly at the sun, the light [3] John R. Egger, Use of Fresnel lenses in optical
will be focused onto the cell with increased systems: some advantages and limitations
concentration thereby requiring less active (1979), Proc. SPIE, 193, 63 – 68
cell area which can be an economical ad- [4] R. Leutz, A. Suzuki, Nonimaging Fresnel
vantage. A Fresnel lens design of this type Lenses: Design and Performance of Solar Con-
is referred to as imaging because there is centrators (2001), Springer
a fixed finite focal length across the whole [5] display-optics.com/literature.htm & display-
aperture of the lens. optics.com/technical_papers.htm

© 2007 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim www.optik-photonik.de 55

You might also like