Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 s2.0 S0254627215300479 Main
1 s2.0 S0254627215300479 Main
CLINICAL STUDY
TOPIC
Huilin Zhang, Nursing Department, the Second Xiangya ing the 5 premenstrual days and differences in the
Hospital of Central South University, Changsha 410011, Chi- total DRSP scores between the 5 premenstrual days
na; Kiang Wu Nursing College of Macau, Macau 999078, Chi- and the follicular phase were both significantly re-
na
duced. Of note, the physical symptom total scores
Mingxia Zhu, Research Service Office, Kiang Wu Nursing
College of Macau, Macau 999078, China
in the 5 premenstrual days and the differences be-
Meirong Kong, Gynecology and Obstetrics Teaching and tween its total score in the 5 premenstrual days
Research Office, Kiang Wu Nursing College of Macau, Macau and in the follicular phase were both significantly
999078, China reduced. The differences between the total scores
Yang Song, Gynaecology and Obstetrics, Guangzhou Uni- of depressed mood, anxious mood, loss of interest,
versity of Chinese Medicine, Guangzhou 510405, China and reduction in social activity during the 5 pre-
Correspondence to: Prof. Huilin Zhang, Nursing Depart- menstrual days and the follicular phase were also
ment, the Second Xiangya Hospital of Central South Univer-
reduced.
sity, Changsha 410011, China. huilin-aileen0000@163.com
Telephone: +86-731-85294072
CONCLUSION: Baduanjin exercise was able to im-
Accepted: October 15, 2013
prove the mental and especially the physical symp-
toms of PMS.
JTCM | www. journaltcm. com 460 August 15, 2014 | Volume 34 | Issue 4 |
Zhang HL et al. / Clinical Study
JTCM | www. journaltcm. com 461 August 15, 2014 | Volume 34 | Issue 4 |
Zhang HL et al. / Clinical Study
DRSP items were explained, and the participants were Table 2 Comparison of total DRSP scores in the 5 premen-
instructed on how to complete the DRSP form. Each strual days of the four menstrual cycles ( xˉ ±s)
participant was given four copies of the scale for four Menstrual cycle DRSP score F value P value
menstrual cycles. (b) Instructions on Baduanjin exercis-
First 145±51 - -
es were given by a professional coach combined with a
standardized demonstrative video of Baduanjin exer- Second 132±55 - 0.23
cise before intervention. After participants mastered Third 118±45 - 0.01
the Baduanjin exercise, the research and related data Forth 118±43 - 0.01
collection were carried out. (c) The finished surveys
Notes: P-values were calculated by student's t-test. F=2.901, P<
were collected at the end of each menstrual cycle. (d)
0.05, was calculated by ANOVA. DRSP: daily record of severity
DRSP scores are expressed as mean±SD. ANOVA and of problems.
student's t-test were performed. A P-value less than
0.05 was considered significant. All data were analyzed Table 3 Differences in total DRSP scores between the 5 pre-
by SPSS 16.0 (IBM SPSS, Armonk, NY, USA) soft- menstrual days and the follicular phase ( xˉ ±s)
ware. Menstrual cycle DRSP score F value P value
First 31±40 - -
RESULTS Second 14±42 - 0.05
Third 6±28 - 0.00
Changes in the total DRSP scores before and after
Baduanjin exercise Forth 15±33 - 0.06
The total DRSP scores of the 5 premenstrual days and Notes: P-values were calculated by student's t-test. F=2.599, P<
the differences in total DRSP scores between the 5 pre- 0.05, was calculated by ANOVA. DRSP: daily record of severity
of problems.
menstrual days and the follicular phase significantly de-
creased after Baduanjin exercise (Tables 2, 3).
DISCUSSION
Changes in the DRSP item scores before and after In this study, as a means of intervention, we found
Baduanjin exercise that Baduanjin exercise has certain effects on the im-
The total scores of the physical symptoms item provement of PMS symptoms. During four consecu-
("breast tenderness") during the 5 premenstrual days tive menstrual cycles, total premenstrual DRSP scores
and the differences in the total scores between the 5 decreased significantly after Baduanjin exercise com-
premenstrual days and the follicular phase both de- pared with DRSP scores before Baduanjin exercise.
creased significantly after Baduanjin exercise. Symp- This indicates that Baduanjin exercise could improve
tom sores for depression, anxiety, decreased interest, PMS symptoms. When practicing Baduanjin exercise
and less participation in social activities also decreased during the three menstrual cycles, total premenstrual
significantly (Tables 4, 5). DRSP scores of the second and third menstrual cycles
JTCM | www. journaltcm. com 462 August 15, 2014 | Volume 34 | Issue 4 |
Zhang HL et al. / Clinical Study
Table 4 Comparison of the total DRSP item scores in the 5 premenstrual days of the four menstrual cycles ( xˉ ±s)
No. The first menstrual cycle The second menstrual cycle The third menstrual cycle The forth menstrual cycle F value P value
1 11.0±4.8 9.1±4.5 8.5±4.1 9.0±4.2 2.28 0.08
2 11.0±5.0 9.2±4.6 8.8±4.2 8.7±3.8 2.10 0.10
3 10.6±4.2 9.8±4.6 8.5±4.0 9.0±4.1 1.74 0.16
4 11.0±4.5 9.6±5.0 8.9±3.9 9.2±3.7 1.65 0.17
5 10.8±4.1 9.2±4.9 8.4±3.6 8.7±4.3 2.27 0.08
6 11.6±5.3 9.8±5.0 9.3±4.3 8.8±3.8 2.51 0.06
7 13.1±5.2 12.4±5.6 11.0±4.4 10.7±4.5 1.90 0.13
8 10.4±4.9 10.2±5.2 8.9±4.1 8.6±3.9 1.54 0.20
9 11.6±4.5 11.0±5.5 10.0±4.4 9.8±4.8 1.11 0.34
10 8.6±4.0 7.9±3.9 7.4±3.3 7.6±3.8 0.73 0.53
11 11.4±5.5 11.5±6.7 8.2±4.3 8.7±3.6 4.39 0.00a
12 8.3±4.0 7.6±4.6 6.6±3.2 6.6±2.8 1.78 0.15
13 8.0±3.8 7.2±4.0 6.2±2.6 6.4±2.9 2.08 0.10
14 7.8±4.2 6.9±3.7 6.3±2.4 6.4±2.9 1.53 0.30
Notes: the P-values were calculated by ANOVA. Comparing the total DRSP item scores in the 5 premenstrual days of the four menstrual
cycles together, aP<0.01. DRSP: daily record of severity of problems.
Table 5 Differences in total DRSP item scores between the 5 premenstrual days and the follicular phase ( xˉ ±s)
No. The first menstrual cycle The second menstrual cycle The third menstrual cycle The forth menstrual cycle F value P value
were significantly lower than that of the first cycle. strual and follicular phase DRSP scores decreased sig-
This suggest that PMS symptoms began to improve nificantly compared with those before Baduanjin exer-
one month after practicing Baduanjin exercise, and the cise. Combined with the changes in total premenstrual
symptoms gradually improved during the exercise DRSP scores, Baduanjin exercise can relieve both pre-
course. menstrual and postmenstrual symptoms, and the differ-
Compared with that before Baduanjin exercise, the dif- ence between premenstrual and postmenstrual symp-
ferences between premenstrual and follicular phase toms were lower. However, during the third menstrual
DRSP scores after Baduanjin exercise were reduced, cycle while practicing Baduanjin exercise, the differ-
but not significantly. During the second menstrual cy- ence between premenstrual and follicular phase DRSP
cle when practicing Baduanjin exercise, the premen- scores was no significant. We inferred that because
JTCM | www. journaltcm. com 463 August 15, 2014 | Volume 34 | Issue 4 |
Zhang HL et al. / Clinical Study
Baduanjin exercise was a good intervention for psycho- menstrual dysphoric disorder comorbidity: a systematic re-
somatic regulation, it not only improved patients' pre- view. Rev Bras Psiquiatr 2012; 34(4): 467-479.
menstrual mental and physical state, but coordinated 3 Kwan I, Onwude JL. Premenstrual syndrome. Clin Evid
the overall psychosomatic state of the practitioners dur- 2009; 12: 806-833.
ing the whole menstrual cycle. Before exercise, the 4 Qiao MQ, Zhang ZY, Xu XJ, Han XQ, Ci YZ, Ye Q. Ep-
PMS state was poor, and Baduanjin exercise could im- idemiological survey on syndromes distribution in PMS.
prove the premenstrual state. Therefore, after two men- Zhong Guo Zhong Yi Ji Chu Yi Xue Za Zhi 1997; 3(3):
strual cycles, the premenstrual state was better coordi- 31-33.
nated. Finally, after the third menstrual cycle, although 5 Rapkin AJ, Mikacich JA. Premenstrual dysphoric disor-
the premenstrual state did not change significantly, the der and severe premenstrual syndrome in adolescents. Pae-
patients' psychosomatic state during the entire men- diatr Drugs 2013; 15(3): 191-202.
strual cycle, including follicular phase, was improved 6 Craner J, Sigmon S, Martinson A, McGillicuddy M. Per-
greatly. Therefore, the difference between the premen- ceptions of health and somatic sensations in women re-
strual and follicular phase DRSP scores increased be- porting premenstrual syndrome and premenstrual dysphor-
cause the follicular phase DRSP scores were significantly ic disorder. J Nerv Ment Dis 2013; 201(9): 780-785.
reduced. 7 Samadi Z, Taghian F, Valiani M. The effects of 8 weeks
This study found that Baduanjin exercise significantly of regular aerobic exercise on the symptoms of premenstru-
improved mental symptoms including when patients: al syndrome in non-athlete girls. Iran J Nurs Midwifery
"felt depressed, sad, down, or blue; hopeless; worthless, Res 2013; 18(1): 14-19.
or guilty" and "felt anxious, tense, 'keyed up' or 'on 8 Yonkers KA, Pearlstein TB, Gotman N. A pilot study to
edge'". Baduanjin exercise also showed significant im- compare fluoxetine, calcium, and placebo in the treatment
provement in symptoms such as "had less interest in of premenstrual syndrome. J Clin Psychopharmacol 2013;
usual activities" and "at least one of the problems not- 33(5): 614-620.
ed above interfered with hobbies or social activities." 9 Nazari H, Yari F, Jariani M, Marzban A, Birgandy M.
Therefore, these improvements suggest that Baduanjin Premenstrual syndrome: a single-blind study of treatment
exercise was able to produce positive mental health ef- with buspirone versus fluoxetine. Arch Gynecol Obstet
fects, help reduce the risk of diverse premenstrual nega- 2013; 287(3): 469-472.
tive mental health outcomes, and markedly improve 10 Koh TC. Baduanjin-an ancient Chinese exercise. Am J
family and social barriers caused by these negative out- Chin Med 1982; 10(1): 14-21.
comes. Meanwhile, the study also found that Baduan- 11 Zhou XQ, Zeng YQ, Yang BL, Wang AL. Effects of
jin exercise was able to significantly relieve physical dis- health Qigong and Baduanjin on the middle and old aged
comfort. The premenstrual DRSP scores and the differ- people's blood lipid. Beijing Ti Yu Da Xue Xue Bao 2007;
ences between the premenstrual and follicular phase 30(6): 795-797.
DRSP scores for physical symptoms, "had breast ten- 12 Mei L, Chen Q, Ge L, Zheng G, Chen J. Systematic re-
derness; had breast swelling, felt 'bloated', or had view of Chinese traditional exercise Baduanjin modulating
weight gain; had headache; had joint or muscle pain," the blood lipid metabolism. Evid Based Complement Al-
were significantly reduced after Baduanjin exercise ternat Med 2012; 11: 1-8.
compared with those before Baduanjin exercise. There- 13 Gao DM, Qiao MQ, Zhang HY. Biochemical indexes of
fore, regular Baduanjin exercise can improve both men- curative effect on premenstrual syndrome. Yao Xue Yu
tal and especially physical PMS symptoms to some ex- Lin Chuang Yan Jiu 2008; 16(6): 423-427.
tent. 14 Endicott J, Nee J, Harrison W. Daily record of severity of
problems (DRSP): reliability and validity. Arch Womens
Ment Health 2006; 9(1): 41-49.
REFERENCES 15 Qiao MQ, Zhang HY, Sun YX, Meng YC. Chinese ver-
1 Le J. Obstetrics and gynecology. 7th edition. Beijing: Peo- sion of the DRSP reliability test and validity estimates.
ple's Medical Publishing House, 2008: 319. "Emotions in health and disease and Traditional Chinese
2 Cirillo PC, Passos RB, Bevilaqua MC, López JR, Nardi Medicine interventions" International Symposium; 2007
AE. Bipolar disorder and premenstrual syndrome or pre- Aug 24-27; Qingdao, China. 2007: 261-269.
JTCM | www. journaltcm. com 464 August 15, 2014 | Volume 34 | Issue 4 |