Fence wrett uae arate
a Hare, RE BET
Sou eure uae & we,
agar, snare 380 004
SSS ‘BRUNT: 079-22862061, 22867251
‘BATT: 079-29725833
‘¢¥eq : ceoahmeda-stats@nic.in
Syrande : wwyn.cbahmedabad.ora in
Ua His : 33/CBM/2019-20/ feria : 10/01/2020
Proceedings of Cantonment Board ordinary meeting held on 10-01-2020 at 1200 hrs. in
the office of Cantonment Board, Ahmedabad ~ 380 004.
MEMBERS PRESENT
1. Brig Ajit Milu Heel - President
2.Pathan Aiyubkhan Sariyakhan - Vice President
3. Shri Dhiraj Sonaje - Member Secretary
4, Brig. Manoj Kumar ~ Health Officer(S.E.M.O.)
5. Col. Shishir Thimmaiah,SM - Nominated Member
6. Pareek Rekhaben Nareshbhai - Elected Member
7. Sonvane Sunil Ramchandra - Elected Member
8. Rajput Sumersingh Devisingh - Elected Member
9. Pathan Mahmad Salim Sariyakhan - Elected Member
10.Pathan Sirinbanu Mahmad Salim - Elected Member
11.Shri Ganesh Girishbhai Ramchandrabhai _- Elected Member
MEMBERS NOT PRESENT
1. Additional District Magistrate, - District Magistrate's nominee
2. Col. Harpreet Singh - Nominated Member
3. Shri K Ramesh Babu, IDSE - Garrison Engineer(MES)
Special Invitees not present
Hon'ble Shri Hasmukhbhai Patel (MP) - Special Invitee
Hon'ble Shri Balram Thawani (MLA) - Special Invitee
At the commencement of the meeting Brig.Ajit Meelu, took oath for having become
President of Ahmedabad Cantonment Board.
Agenda no.14
Monthly account statement from October 2019 to December 2019
To consider the statement (placed as annexure ‘A’) of Accounts branch reg. the
receipts and expenditure incurred during the month from October to December 2019. In
this connection the necessary documents are placed on the table for consideration and
noting by the Board.
Resolution no.1
Monthly account statement from October 2019 to December 2019
Considered and unanimously approved.
RYovorl
(Dhiraj Sonaje) (Brig Ajit Meelu)
Chief Executive Officer, President,
Ahmedabad Cantt. Board, Ahmedabad Cantt. Board
Dated : 10-01-2020 Dated : 10-01-2020Agenda no.2
Arrears of revenue’ from October 2019 to December 2019
To consider the statement (placed as annexure ‘B’) of Tax branch for the position of
outstanding arrears of revenue during the month from October 2019 to December 2019 in
respect of Tax branch. All connected documents are placed on the table.
Resolution no.2
Arrears of revenue from October 2019 to December 2019
Considered, scrutinized, verified and unanimously approved.
Agenda no.3
Circular agenda dated 10/12/2019 regarding renewal of expired leases of Ahmedabad
Cantonment Board.
To note & approve the Circular agenda no.1(a) to 1(c) dated 10-12-2019.
In this connection the all relevant documents are placed on the table for
considerations and decision by the Board
Resolution no.3
Circular agenda dated 10/12/2019 regarding renewal of expired leases of Ahmedabad
Cantonment Board.
Considered and unanimously approved circular agenda no.1(a) to 1(c) and further
unanimously resolved to forward the proposal to the competent authority for necessary
sanction in this regard.
Agenda no.4
Repairs to buildings in Cantonment Areas
Reference : Die. DE SC, Pune letter no.8073/Expert Committee/C/DE/2018 (FMS =
49362-C) dt.12-12-2019
It is brought to the notice of the Board that the MoD vide above referred letter have
informed that in the context of Cantonment areas, in furtherance of provisions contained in
section 235(2) of the Cantonment Act, 2006 and structural stability of the building, repair
works to authorized buildings shall include the following for which notice for sanction of
erection or re-erection u/s.236 of the Cantonments Act 2006 may not be required, the
details of same are as under :~
a) Erection, re-erection, addition to, or alteration of —
() An internal partition wall which does not involve sub-division of property,
or
(i) A parapet wall or a cornice or chajja within the boundaries of the
permissible setbacks and ground coverage area of the site. Provided that
the total height of the parapet wall shall not be more than 1.20 m and
width of the comice or chajja shall not be more than 50 cm.
b) Repairing of a staircase;
¢) White washing or painting;
4d) Reflooring of the surface of an existing floor
@) Minor repairs and recasting of an existing damaged roof without changing the
character and dimension of such roof,
Petouatd
(Ohiraj Sonaje) (Brig. Ajit Meelu)
Chief Executive Officer, President,
‘Ahmedabad Cantt. Board. Ahmedabad Cantt. Board.
Dated : 10-01-2020 Dated : 10-01-20203
f) Erection’of a false ceiling in any floor for air-conditioning, lighting or decorative
purpose:
g) Plastering and patch work;
h) Providing or closing an internal door or window or a ventilor not opening directly
‘opposite a door or a window of another building;
i) Replacing of fallen bricks or stones;
j) Repairing or renewing existing plumbing, sanitary and other utllty services;
k) Repairing of boundary wall;
1) Installation of air-conditioner/water tank/solar panels/solar water heater/ete.
Further, it is also informed that the Govt. has considered the suggestion of the
Expert Committee regarding misinterpretation of the words ‘material alteration’ appearing
in Section 235(2)(a) of the Cantonments Act, 2006, and it has accordingly been decided
that the said term shall refer to substantial alteration which would include any works not
listed above: for which necessary sanction for erection or re-erection of building would be
required under ibid provisions of the Act. The definition of the term ‘material alteration’
should be clearly brought out by the Cantonment Boards while revising the building bye
laws.
In this connection the decision of the MoD is placed before the Board for
information and taking necessary action by giving adequate publicity to the instructions of
the MoD for enabling all the concerned for availing benefit in this regard.
Resolution no.4
Repairs to buildings in Cantonment Areas
Noted and unanimously resolved to give wide publicity for spreading awareness
among the general public.
Agenda no.5
Devolution of powers of Vice Presidents of Cantonment Boards & Constitution of three
committees — Regarding
Reference : (i) MoD ID no.14(12)/2018-D(Q&C) dated 23-12-2019
(i) DGDE, Delhi Cant. letter no.76/67/Expert Comittee/C/DE/2018/Vol-IV
dated 24-12-2019.
(ii)Dte. DE SC, Pune letter no.8073/Expert Committee/C/DE/2018
dated 27-12-2019 in this regard.
It is brought to the notice of the Board that the Cantt. Boards are required to
forward their amended business regulations proposals in light of the instructions contained
in MoD ID cited at reference (i) and circulated by the competent authority i.e. DGDE, Delhi
Cantt. through Dte. DE SC, Pune, cited at reference (ii) & (ili). The business regulations
proposals should be consistent with the compositon and delegate roles and
Tesponsibilities and furiction suggested by the Govt. The roles and responsib
assigned should include those included in Annexure -B. In the event of Boards having a
‘committee which has overlapping functions as mentioned in annexure -B, the functions &
nomenclature of those Committees may be suitably amended to align with the above said
Committees. The existing provision in the business regulation may remain unchanged.
(Dhiraj Sonaje) (Brig Ajit Meelu)
Chief Executive Officer, President,
Ahmedabad Cantt. Board Ahmedabad Cantt. Board,
Dated : 10-01-2020 Dated : 10-01-20204.
The brief instructions circulated vide MoD ID are as under :-
(A) Devolution of more responsibilities to Vice President of Cantonment Boards &
constitute three more Committees.
(8) Empowerment of Civil Area Committee
(C)Amendment of business regulations
The action taken report inrespect of submission of draft of amended Business
Regulations proposal inrespect of Ahmedabad Cantonment Board has to be submitted on
or before 15-01-2020 to the Dte. DE SC, Pune and the final proposal is required to be
submitted to the Dte. DE SC, Pune by 10-02-2020 without fail. The draft of amended
business regulations in respect of Ahmedabad Cantonment Board alongwith relevant
papers in file are placed on table for consideration and approval by the Board,
Resolution no.5
Devolution of powers of Vice Presidents of Cantonment Boards & Constitution of three
committees — Regarding
CEO explained the Board in detail regarding the instructions circulated vide MoD ID
as mentioned at the agenda side. Board welcomed the decision of empowerment of
elected members through constitution of committees.
CEO presented the draft business regulations whereby after a brief discussion the
Board unanimously approved the draft of Business Regulations for Ahmedabad
Cantonment Board and further unanimously resolved to invite suggestions, objections
from general public with time limit of 15 days.
Agenda no.6
Repair/Modification/Addition to Water supply Network for Water distribution Station of
‘Ahmedabad Cantonment board
Reference: CBR no 08 dated 19/10/2019
It is brought to the notice of board that vide CBR no 08 19/10/2019 board resolved
to demolition of existing water tank and carry out associated work such as
repairs/modification/addition of water supply network for water distribution, repairing of
leakage lines for switching over to direct supply systems. In this connection this office had
initiated the tender process for “Repair/Modification/Addition to Water supply Network for
Water distribution Station of Ahmedabad Cantonment board” vide e-tender notice no
ACB/EB/2019-20/10 dated 03/10/2019 in which no bidder participated. Further this office
re-invited the reference tender vide notice no ACB/EB/2019-20/10/02 dated 25/10/2019 in
which again no bidder participated. Therefore this office again reinvited tender vide notice
no ACB/EB/2019-20/10/03 dated 17/12/2019 in which 01 nos of bidder participated and
qualified in Technical bid.
Details of bid is as below:
delouale, a
Spouald
(Ohiraj Sonaje) (Brig.Ajit Meelu)
Chief Executive Officer, President,
Ahmedabad Cantt. Board. Ahmedabad Cantt. Board.
Dated : 10-01-2020 Dated : 10-01-20205.
Sr.No. Name of Bidder Estimated | Amount quoted by
Amount as | Bidder
per reference
Tender |
1 Mis Aqua Gaseous | Rs. [f= 4,83,143/-
Controls (India) 5,00,000/-
In this connection, this office has issued work order to M/s Aqua Gaseous Controls
(India) amounting to Rs. 4,83,143/-.
In this connection necessary documents are placed before board for noting of the
board
Resolution no.6
Repair/Modification/Adaition to Water supply Network for Water distribution Station of
‘Ahmedabad Cantonment board
"At the start of the discussion Shri Ayubkhan Pathan, V.P. stated that in the recent
past the submersible pump collapsed and water supply was affected for a period of three
days and there is also a requirement for placing a booster for enhancing existing force in
water supply. VP also pointed out that he has already informed the Board that a new
submersible water supply pump and booster should be procurred for ensuring that there is
ho risk of break in water supply to avoid public hardship and some elected members
agreed to his statement. CEO clarified that as the pipe line network is very old in nature
there is possibilty of pipe burst and water leakage as the old pipeline network is not
designed to take pressure of booster pump and further CEO clarified that he shall procure
the water supply pump in the next financial year if itis required. VP and EMs desired to
know whether there is any provision in agreement that ifthe water supply pump fails then
agency shall immediately replace the faulty pump with the new one, PCB also agreed and
facked the CEO that if no such condition is there in agreement then a new clause should
be incorporated into the agreement in this regard.
Considered and unanimously approved the action intiated by the CEO for issue of
work order in this regard. Further unanimously authorised the CEO to incur all the
necessary expenditure in this regard.
Agenda no.7
Purchase of Printer for Anmedabad Cantonment board office.
With reference to requirement for Multifunction Laser Printer with Capacity to print
'A3, A4 and legal with attached ADF, a bid was placed on GeM vide bid no
GEM/2019/B/472192 dated 20/12/2019. The last day for placing bid was 30/12/2019. In
the reference bid 04 nos of bidders participated and qualified in the technical
requirements. Details of the financial bid is as below
Seiovoa. yb
(Dhiraj Sonaje) (Brig. Ajit Meelu)
Chief Executive Officer, President,
Ahmedabad Cantt. Board. ‘Ahmedabad Cantt. Board.
Dated : 10-01-2020 Dated : 10-01-2020Offered Item Total Price — Awarded
1 AOne Item Categories 88,888.00 L1
Services Multifunction Machines MFM
2 CANN OFFICE _ Item Categories : 89,500.00 L2
EQUIPMENT Multifunction Machines MFM
PRIVATE
LIMITED
3 JINTECH Item Categories : 96,311.00 L3
SOLUTION Multifunction Machines MFM
LIMITED
4 Mehulendra Item Categories : 99,243.00 L4
Corporation Multifunction Machines MFM
In the above bid,L1 bidder “M/s A One services" has offered the product “HP
Laserjet MFP M72630 dn Digital copier” for Rs. 88,888/- (In words Rupees Eight eight
thousand eight hundred eighty eight only).
In this connection necessary documents are placed before board for consideration
and approval of board.
Resolution no.7
Purchase of Printer for Ahmedabad Cantonment board office.
Considered and unanimously approved the lowest rates quoted by M/s.A One
Services @ Rs.88,888/- for the product “HP Laserjet MFP ~M722630 dn Digital copier’.
Further unanimously resolved to issue supply order to L1 bidder and authorised CEO to
incur the necessary payment in this regard. Board also had detailed discussion regarding
expenditure related to office administration. Board authorised CEO to procure all such
items which are necessary for smooth functioning of office. Board directed that in such
cases Board authorises CEO for financial sanction subject to budget provision.
Giounw 4
(Dhiraj Sonaje) (Brig Ajit Meelu)
Chief Executive Officer, President,
Ahmedabad Cant. Board. Ahmedabad Cantt. Board.
Dated : 10-01-2020 Dated : 10-01-2020Agenda ni :
Implementation of Higher Grade Scale to the eligible Cant. Fund Servants
To consider implementation of the Higher Grade Scale scheme of Govt. of Gujarat
to the eligible Cantt. fund servants to deal with the problem of absence of or restricted
chances of promotion in respect of Cantt. fund servants. The Govt. of Gujarat have
approved the Higher Grade Scale to their employees, govt. of Gujarat granting next higher
grade on completion of 20y ears and in this connection the Finance Department
Resolution No.PAY/1009/56/Pay Cell/M dt. 18-02-2011.
The list of employees is as under :-
Si. Name Designation | Date of initial | Date applicable | Date applicable
No. appointment | for HGS for HGS
After 9 years After 20 years
(1 HGS) (2 HGS)
7 | Smt HasumatibenK | Asst. 04-03-1989 | 04-03-1998 04-03-2009
Parmar Teacher
2 | Smt Chandrikaben | Asst. 08-08-1989 | 08-08-1998 08-08-2009
G Makwana Teacher
In this connection report of Accounts branch dt.01-01-2020 regarding grant of their
higher grade scale due to eligible employees is placed in file alongwith other relevant
papers before Board for approval by the Board.
Resolution no.
Implementation of Higher Grade Scale to the eligible Cantt. Fund Servants
Considered and unanimously resolved to grant Higher Grade scale to both the
teaching staff as per details mentioned at agenda side. Further unanimously resolved that
a proposal be forwarded to the Competent authority for obtaining necessary sanction in
this regard.
PRovaso
(Dhiraj Sonaje) (Brig Ajit Meelu)
Chief Executive Officer, President,
Ahmedabad Cantt. Board. Ahmedabad Cantt. Board.
Dated : 10-01-2020 Dated : 10-01-20208.
SUPPLEMENTARY ITEMS WITH THE PERMISSION OF THE CHAIR
Agenda no.9
Periodic review under Fundamental Rule (FR) 56(j)(i) and Rule 48 of CCS (Pension)
Rules, 1972, in respect of employees of Cantonment Boards.
Reference (i) DGDE, Delhi Cantt. letter no.76/38/CFSR-1937/GEN/C/DE/19 (FMS:66653)
dated 22-10-2019 in this regard.
(ii) Dte. DE SC, Pune letter no.8073/EstUXVII/DE (FMS:38628-C)
dated 24-10-2019 & even no.27-11-2019 in this regard.
(iii) Dte. DE SC, Pune letter no.8073/EstUXVIV/DE (FMS:38628-C)
dated 04-12-2019 in this regard.
(iv) Dte. DE SC, Pune letter no.8073/EsttXVII/DE dated 31-12-2019
in this regard
It is brought to the notice of the Board that the Competent Authority vide above
referred letter have made a partial supersession of the order contained in their letter cited
at reference (ii) in which modification has been made by exclusion of the name of
Sh.S.Prabakaran, Dy.Director, SC, Pune from being a co-opted member of Screening
Committee and inducting the name of Smt.Vibha Sharma, Director, DE SC, Pune.
All relevant papers in this regard are placed on table for consideration and noting
by the Board.
Resolution no.9
Periodic review under Fundamental Rule (FR) 56(j)(i) and Rule 48 of CCS (Pension)
Rules, 1972, in respect of employees of Cantonment Boards.
Noted.
Agenda no.10
Solid Waste Management Bye-Laws in respect of Delhi Cantonment Board ~ Regarding,
Ref : (i) DGDE Delhi Cant. letter no.76/38/Rules/MSW Rules/C/DE/17
dated 02-12-2019 refers.
(ii) Dte. DE, SC, Pune letter no.19648/C/X/DE dated 05-12-2019
It is brought to the notice of the Board that vide above referred letter DGDE, Delhi
Cantt. directed to frame draft Solid Waste Management Bye-Laws on the basis of SWM
bye-laws framed by Delhi Cantonment Board as a model, keeping in view the local
conditions / geographic feature of respective Cantonment area. If the Board approves
these subject draft-SWMbye-laws for Ahmedabad Cantonment Board, then the proposal
in this regard shall be forwarded to the Competent authority for obtaining approval from
the Govt. & publication as per laid down standard procedure.
Al relevant papers alongwith file are placed before Board for consideration,
decision and approval by the Board.
setovad