Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DARSHAN JAIN
B.COM [HONS.] THIRD YEAR
ST. ALOYSIUS COLLEGE [AUTONOMOUS]
ADMISSION NO:- 46855
MOBILE NO:- 6260538108
CHAPTER – 1
Abstract
Mutual funds allow for portfolio diversification and
relative risk aversion through collection of funds from
the households and investment of the same in the
stock and debt markets. Fixed- Income Funds in India
are a kind of mutual fund which makes investment in
debt securities that have been issued either by the
companies, banks, or government. Fixed- Income
Funds in India are also known as debt funds and
income funds.
Using various statistical measures the present study
aims to evaluating the performance of a few selected
income or debt mutual funds schemes of India on the
basis of their daily NAV. Popularity of income
schemes has only increased in the last decade. Income
mutual funds they have seen tremendous growth in
their number of schemes from 91 on 31st march 2001
to 330 on 31st march 2010. 506 in 2008 was the
maximum ever in terms of total schemes floating in
the market. This category has seen a decline only
twice in the last decade. First fall was posted in the
year 2003 and the second fall was reported in the year
2010. One striking fact which comes to light is the
huge percentage contribution of income schemes
towards the total AUM of the Indian mutual funds
industry.
1.Introduction
Mutual Funds:
A mutual fund is like a bridge or a financial
intermediary that allows a group of investors
to pool in their money together with a pre-
determined investment objective and then this
gathered money is invested by the fund
manager into specific securities (stocks or
bonds).
Mutual funds can be considered as one of the
best investment avenues because they are very
cost efficient and also easy to invest in. Thus
by pooling money together in a mutual fund,
investors can purchase stocks or bonds with
much lower trading costs than if they tried to
do it on their own.
b) Debt funds:
Debt mutual fund is a type of mutual fund
that is designed especially for the low risk
investor whose main aim is capital
appreciation coupled with decent returns on
investment. These are for investors who
prefer funds with lesser volatility and want a
regular income.
Debt funds can give:
Capital Appreciation
Regular Income
c) Balanced funds:
As the name suggest, they are mixture of
both - equity and debt funds. They invest in
both equities and fixed income securities,
which are in line with pre-defined
investment objective of the scheme. Equity
part provides growth and the debt part
provides stability in returns.
CHAPTER – 2
REVIEW OF THE LITERATURE
CHAPTER - 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research methodology is a collective term for the
structured process of conducting research. There
are many different methodologies used in various
types of research and the term is usually
considered to include research design, data
gathering and data analysis.
rp = Mean
rate of return
on NAV of
MF rf = risk-
free rate of
return
ıp = standard deviation of MF
iii. Beta:
Beta is a measure of the volatility of a
particular fund in comparison to the market
as a whole, that is, the extent to which the
fund's return is impacted by market factors.
Beta is calculated using a statistical tool
called ‘regression analysis.’
Formula to calculate Beta is: 𝑇 ൌ 𝑎 𝛽𝑥
iv. R-Square
So, while considering the beta of any fund,
an investor also needs to consider another
statistic concept called ‘R-squared’ that
measures the correlation between beta and
its benchmark index. The beta of a fund has
to be seen in conjunction with the R-squared
for better understanding the risk of the fund.
DATA COLLECTION:-
Sr.
no. Equity Mutual Fund Debt Mutual Fund Scheme
Scheme
1 Fidelity Equity Fund IDFC Dynamic Bond - IP B (G)
(G)
2 UTI Opportunities Fund SBI Magnum Income Fund (G)
(G)
3 ICICI Pru Focused HDFC Short Term Opportunities
BluechipEqty (G) (G)
4 Birla Sun Life MNC IDFC G Sec Fund - Investment
Fund (G) Plan - Plan B
5 HDFC MidCap Kotak Gilt – Investment
Opportunities (G)
6 SBI Magnum Emerging Birla Sun Life Ultra Short Term
Busi (G) Fund
HDFC Cash Management Fund -
7 Mirae (I) Opportunities- Treasury
RP (G) Advantage Plan
8 Quantum Long-Term ICICI Prudential Flexible Income
Equity (G) Plan
9 Can RobecoEqty JM Money Manager Fund Plan
TaxSaver (G)
10 Franklin India Tax UTI Treasury Advantage Fund
Shield (G)
Analysis of data:
Fund category
To compare the performance of top 10 equity
n
Ri
R
i …(2)
i1
Similarly for market index, which is
either NIFTY or SENSEX, we define:
Rmi: Daily Growth rate of the Market
index
I Ii1
R i
mi Ii …(3)
Rm : Mean daily growth rate of 1
the market index
n R
mi
…(4)
Rm
n
i1
Where Rmi is the growth rate of the market index and n is the
number of days for which it has been studied.
2
m [( R )2 …(5)
Rmi m]
Var(Rm )
4.2 Expected Rate of Return (E[Ri])
After calculating the risk parameter (beta) of an asset,
and the annual growth rate of the market index, we calculate
the expected rate of return of the mutual fund scheme. The
formula is derived from the CAPM :
E[Ri] = Rf + β( E[Rm]- Rf ) …(6)
I. Emperical Findings
CHAPTER – 4 :
How mutual funds work
COMPOUNDING
When you invest in a financial asset, you earn on the amount
invested. Over time, you can either reinvest this amount or put it in
a bank account. Either way, you earn some amount on your
existing profits – either through investment returns or from bank
interest. Thus, your total returns over time increase. This is called
compounding. Over time, compounding can produce significant
growth in the value of an investment.
PORTFOLIO
This is the collection of assets owned by the mutual fund or even
you as an individual. It includes all the financial instruments
invested in like stocks, bonds, and other securities.
In a mutual fund, an expert handles all these assets. He or she also
decides which assets to buy and sell. This specialist is called the
Portfolio Manager. The frequency of the trading activity – how
often assets are bought and sold – in the fund’s portfolio is called
the Portfolio Turnover.
TOTAL RETURN:
This is the total amount of profits an investor makes keeping in
mind the dividends, capital gains from selling units, distribution of
fund income as well as returns earned on reinvestments. The total
amount paid to funds in the form of fees or commissions should be
deducted to get the total return. It can be used to measure a fund’s
performance. It is often written as a percentage of the total initial
investment.
Yield is also used by analysts to measure the income earned by the
underlying assets in a fund’s portfolio. It is calculated by
subtracting the fund’s expenses from the income earned by the
assets through dividend payments and capital gains, and then
dividing by the total price per share. The yield is usually expressed
as a percentage.
REDEEM:
There are two ways to exit a mutual fund – sell it to another
investor or back to the fund. The latter is called ‘redeeming’. Once
an investor redeems his or her lot of MF units, the NAV of the
fund changes. This is because the total number of units issued to
investors differs.
Many mutual funds charge investors for exiting within certain
period of time. This charge is deducted from the Net Asset Value
(NAV) and the remaining is paid to the investor. This price is
called the redemption price.
TYPES OF MUTUAL FUNDS:-
Debt Funds
Debt funds are funds that invests in debt instruments like bonds,
government securities, and debentures. It provides returns on your
investment at a fixed interest rate over a fixed period of time.
Simply put, a mutual fund is a pool of money. Investors put their
money in the fund and the fund house invests this in stocks and
bonds. These may be stocks and bonds of private companies or
those issued by the government. When these companies or the
government make a profit, the fund generates profits in return. The
money it makes is distributed to the investors. Mutual funds may
be categorised based on what they invest in. The three common
categories are equity funds, debt funds, and hybrid funds.
How does a debt fund work?
Debt funds are funds that lend money to companies, banks, or the
government. In other words, these funds invest in stocks, bonds,
and debentures, which act as a borrowing mechanism for
companies, banks, or the government. They take money from the
market and invest it in infrastructure or growth of the business.
The money from the fund is invested to reap bigger profits. The
investors get their money back over a period of time. They also
earn interest on the amount they invest. Both the rate of interest
and the maturity period are fixed.
Here, the maturity period is the time at which the principal amount
is returned to the investor.
Basic features of a debt fund
Regular pay-out:
Usually, you get regular interest payments when you invest in a
debt fund. Many people prefer it for the regularity of income.
Low risk:
Debt funds pose low risk. The interest amount is fixed. The
principal you invest is returned to you at a fixed time as well.
Unless there is a huge upheaval in the market, debt funds are safe
investments.
Low return:
Low risk also means low returns. Debt funds are ideal for people
who value safety over high returns.
Flexible time period:
Debt funds may have long or short maturity periods. Accordingly,
they are divided into long-term and short-term debt funds.
Range of investments:
Debt funds may invest in one single type of debt instrument. Or,
they may choose to invest in several assets like securities or bonds.
This choice tells you about the risk involved. For instance, gilt
funds are debt funds that lend money to the government by buying
government securities. Since the government is unlikely to default,
these funds pose a low risk to the investor.
Equity Funds
An equity fund is a fund that puts the majority of your money in
shares or stocks. When 60% or more of a fund’s assets are invested
in equity, it is an equity fund. The rest of the assets can be put into
debt instruments. These are often termed as growth funds. Equity
funds have had a track record of delivering high returns. On an
average, they deliver between 10% and 12% returns, before taxes.
Types of equity fund
The categorisation of equity funds depends on various factors.
These include the fund house’s investment approach, the market
capitalisation of the company, or what a particular fund invests in.
Active and passive funds:
These categories refer to the investment approach. A fund manager
may follow his own investment strategy. He may do this after
studying the market performance and the company’s background.
This is an active fund. When your investment portfolio reflects a
market index like Sensex, it is a passive fund. Such funds that
follow one index are also termed as index funds.
Large-cap, mid-cap, small-cap, and micro-cap funds:
This refers to market capitalisation. Market capitalisation is the
value the capital market places on a company’s equities. So, large-
cap equities are usually of well-established companies. Such funds
tend to be stable. Mid-cap and small-cap funds invest in smaller
companies. But such companies may not have found a stable
footing. So, the returns may be irregular. Some equity funds invest
across large-cap, mid-cap, and small-cap stocks. These are called
multi-cap funds.
Diversified and sectoral funds:
This would tell you what the fund invests in. Diversified funds
invest in a range of companies across industries. But sectoral funds
invest only in one predetermined sector. There is a third category
too—thematic funds. These funds invest according to a set theme.
For example, a particular thematic fund might invest only in
technology start-ups.
Hedge Fund
A hedge fund is an investment vehicle that pools capital from high-
net-worth investors and invests in a wide variety of assets. Hedge
funds have complex portfolio-construction and risk-management
techniques.
While reading about mutual funds, you might have come across the
term ‘hedge fund’. At times people think that hedge funds are a
type of mutual fund. But that is a mistake. Mutual funds and hedge
funds both pool money from investors, which they invest on their
behalf in different securities.
A hedge fund is an alternative form of investment open to high-
net-worth individuals and families or institutions. It may be in the
form of an offshore investment corporation or a private investment
partnership. It collects money from investors and invests it in
different types of securities. Hedge funds are managed more
aggressively and use sophisticated and risky investment strategies.
Characteristics Of Hedge Funds
Limited investor type:
In this case, ‘limited’ means that it is limited to investors who are
high-net-worth families and individuals, pension funds,
endowment funds, banks, and insurance companies. Hedge fund
investors are ‘accredited investors’. They meet certain stipulations
for investing in securities that are not open to the general public. In
India, you require a minimum investment amount of Rs 1 crore to
invest in a hedge fund.
Not regulated:
Securities market regulators such as the Securities Exchange Board
of India (SEBI) do not regulate hedge funds. Hedge funds do not
have to give reports, such as a periodic disclosure of net asset
values (NAVs).
Wide investment type:
Hedge funds invest in traditional stocks and bonds. They also
invest in derivatives, real estate, currencies, mortgage products,
and more. Hedge funds use both long-term and short-term
investment strategies.
Use of leverage:
Leverage is an investment technique whereby hedge funds use
borrowed capital to amplify returns. But leverage is a risky
practice. It could significantly increase the returns or even wipe out
a hedge fund.
Less liquidity:
It is more difficult to sell hedge fund shares. Mutual funds have a
per-share price that is calculated every day. This price is the net
asset value (NAV). You can use the NAV as a guide to sell your
shares at any time. Hedge funds, in contrast, attempt to generate
returns over a certain timeframe called the lock-in period, which is
at least a year. During this time, investors cannot sell their shares.
Moreover, investors can make withdrawals only at certain
intervals. These intervals may be quarterly or bi-annual.
Fee structure:
Hedge funds have a fee structure known as ‘two and twenty’. This
is because they charge a 2% asset management fee and a 20% cut
of any profits. The asset management fee may range from 1% to
4% of the funds’ NAV. At times, hedge fund managers invest
aggressively to achieve higher returns. This leads to increased risk
for the investors.
Global macros strategy:
Hedge funds use long-short positions in large financial markets.
This is also known as the global macros strategy. The fund
manager aims to reduce market risks by investing in convertible
bonds, arbitrage funds, long/short funds, and fixed-income
products.
What Is Hybrid Fund?
A hybrid fund is a type of mutual fund that invests in debt, equity,
and other asset classes. Such funds ensure capital protection to
some extent and bring modest returns.
A common question crops up when you start investing in mutual
funds: Should you invest in debt or equity?
You know that equity exposure brings higher returns but also
carries a greater risk of loss. Meanwhile, debt funds protect your
investment, but they limit your returns potential. This puts you in a
dilemma. Is there no middle path?
Hybrid funds are the answer as they invest in both equity and debt
instruments. As a result, they are less risky than equity funds, but
more so than debt funds.
The mixed exposure has an impact on the returns they bring as
well. As an investor in hybrid funds, you are likely to get higher
returns than with debt funds. But, the returns may be lower than
with equity funds.
What Is Liquid Fund?
A liquid fund is a debt mutual fund scheme that carries minimal
risk. It is considered a safe investment option for the short term.
For example, say, you have recently sold off a plush property in
Navi Mumbai. Chances are that the money is idling in your bank
account. You are probably waiting for the bank deposit rates to go
up before you make a more meaningful investment. Wouldn’t it be
nice if you could find a place to park the funds in the meanwhile?
A liquid fund can help you achieve just that. It keeps your money
relatively safe, besides giving you higher returns compared to
savings bank accounts or even fixed deposits.
Regulation
Mutual funds in India are regulated by the Securities and
Exchange Board of India (SEBI). Indian mutual funds are subject
to stringent requirements about who is eligible to start a fund, how
the fund is managed and administrated and how much capital a
fund must have on hand. To start a mutual fund, for example, the
fund sponsor must have been in the financial industry for at least
five years and have maintained positive net worth for the five
years immediately preceding registry.
The SEBI regulations include a minimum startup capital
requirement of Rs. 500 million for open-ended debt funds and Rs.
200 million for closed-ended funds. In addition, Indian mutual
funds are only allowed to borrow up to 20% of their value for a
term not to exceed six months to meet short-term liquidity
requirements.
CONCLUSIONS
In this paper we use monthly holdings data to examine some
accepted hypotheses about mutual fund behavior. Existing
empirical tests of these hypotheses have analyzed return data on
funds or have used holdings data observed at quarterly or semi-
annual intervals. The conclusions change when monthly holdings
data are used. There are two reasons for this. The first is that the
timing of events can be more precisely measured using more
frequent data. The second is that using quarterly or semi-annual
holdings data misses a significant proportion of trades – the very
trades that might well be initiated by the phenomenon under
investigation. In fact, we have shown that employing quarterly data
misses 18.5% of the trades found using monthly data, while
employing semi-annual data misses 34.2% of such trades.
Furthermore, the fact that the estimate of turnover based on
monthly holdings data is so close to that reported by Morningstar
means that few trades are missed with monthly data. The first
hypothesis we examine concerns momentum trading. Past studies
using quarterly data have found that funds on average follow a
momentum strategy, buying winners and selling losers. But these
studies suffer from the very problems described above, and when
fund actions are viewed on a monthly basis momentum disappears
and as many funds seem to buy past losers (contrarians) as buy past
winners (momentum buyers). The second hypothesis we examine
is tax selling. We find that funds increase their turnover in the
month preceding the calculation of taxes and that funds that have
realized capital Page 31 gains during the year increase their
realization of tax loss in the two months before taxes are computed.
Using losses to offset realized capital gains is in the best interests
of both managers and investors, and seems to take place. The third
hypothesis we examine is window dressing: do funds trade in the
period immediately preceding quarterly, semi-annual and annual
reports to show more attractive holdings? We find that funds trade
more in the months preceding the annual report, that they tend to
lower the illiquid securities in their portfolio in that month, and that
they tend to buy past winners and sell past losers. While we find
strong evidence of window dressing with respect to the annual
report, we find no such evidence for quarterly or semi-annual
reports. The final subject we examine is tournament models of
mutual fund behavior. The existing literature has used return data
to examine whether mutual funds that are doing well increase risk
in the second part of the reporting year. Theoretical results and
empirical results are mixed. Using monthly holdings data we
observe what funds are doing over time, yielding more precise
estimates of risk changes. We find evidence that high-return funds
increase risk and lowreturn funds decrease risk. The use of
monthly holdings data leads to new conclusions regarding well-
accepted beliefs. This paper presents important evidence on the
usefulness of monthly data and suggests that correct public policy
should encourage the availability of such data on a universal basis.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Barclay, Pearson and Weisbach (1998). Open-end mutual funds
and capital gains taxes. Journal of Financial Economics 4, 3-43.
Busse, Jeff (2001). Another look at mutual fund tournaments.
Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 26, 53-73.
Brown, Keith; Harlow, W.V.; Starks; Keith Laura (1996). Of
tournaments and temptations: an analysis of managerial incentives
in the mutual fund industry. Journal of Finance 51(1), 85-110.
Chan, K.C. (1986). Can tax-loss selling explain the January
seasonal in stock returns? Journal of Finance XLI(5), 1115-1128.
Chevalier, Judith and Ellison, Glenn (1997). Risk taking by mutual
funds as a response to incentives. Journal of Political Economy
105(6), 1167-1206.
Elton, Edwin J.; Gruber, Martin J.; Blake, Christopher (2007).
Monthly holdings data and the selection of superior mutual funds.
NYU working paper.
Elton, Edwin J.; Gruber, Martin J; Blake, Christopher (2003).
Incentive fees and mutual funds. Journal of Finance 58(2), 779-
804.
Ge, Weili and Zheng, Le (2005). The frequency of mutual fund
portfolio disclosure. University of Michigan working paper.
Gibson, Scott; Safieddine, Assem; and Titman, Sheridan (2000).
Tax-motivated trading and price pressure: an analysis of mutual
fund holdings. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis
35(3), 386-398.
Grinblatt, Mark; Titman, Sheridan; and Wermers, Russ (1995).
Momentum investment strategies, portfolio performance, and
herding: A study of mutual fund behavior. American Economic
Review 85(5):1088-1105.
He, Jia; Ng, Lilian; and Wang, Qinghai (2004). Quarterly trading
patterns of financial institutions. Journal of Business 77(3) 493-
510.
Huddart, Steven J. and Narayaman, V. G. An Empirical Evaluation
of Tax Factors and Mutual Fund Stock Sales Decisions. Review of
Accounting Studies 7 (2-3), 319-341.
Jegadeesh, Narasimhan and Titman, Sheridan (1993). Returns to
buying winners and selling losers: implications for stock market
efficiency. Journal of Finance, 48 (1), 65-91.
REFERENCES:
1.Allen D.E. and Tan M.L. (1999), A Test of the Persistence in the
Performance of UK Managed Funds, Journal of Business Finance
and Accounting, 25, pp. 559-593.
2.Amenc N. and Le Sourd V. (2005), Rating the Ratings, EDHEC
Publication.
3.Anderson T.W. and L.A. Goodman (1957), Statistical Inference
about Markov Chains, Annals of Mathematicals Statistics, 28, pp.
89-110.
4.Barras L., Scaillet O. and Wermers R. (2010), False Discoveries
in Mutual Fund Performance: Measuring Luck in Estimated
Alphas, Journal of Finance, 65(1), pp. 179-216.
5.Berk J. and Green R. (2004), Mutual Fund Flows and
Performance in Rational Markets, Journal of Political Economy,
112, pp. 1269-1295.
6. Bhattacharya S., Dasgupta A., Guembel A. and Prat A. (2008),
Incentives in Funds Management: A Literature Overview, in
Thakor A.V. and Boot A.W.A.
7.Blake C.A. and Morey M. (2000), Morningstar Ratings and
Mutual Fund Performance Journal of Financial and Quantitative
Analysis, 35, pp. 451-483.
8.Blake C.R., Elton E.J. and Gruber M.J. (1993), The Performance
of Bond Mutual Funds, Journal of Business, 66(3), pp. 371-403.
9.Blake D. and Timmermann A. (1998), Mutual Fund
Performance: Evidence for the UK, European Finance Review, 2,
pp. 57-77. 10.Bollen N. and Busse J. (2004), Short-term
Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance, Review of Financial
Studies, 18, pp. 569-597.
So it can be said that with the structural liberalization policies no
doubt Indian economy is likely to return to a high grow path in few
years. Hence mutual fund organizations are needed to upgrade their
skills and technology. Success of mutual fund however would
bright depending upon the implementation of suggestions. With
regard to the Mutual Fund investor we are of the view that the
investor needs to adopt two crucial skills for successful investing
i.e. a sense of timing and investment discipline both need to be
adopted at the same time.