Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Held
Apex Court dismissed the appeal and upheld
the Delhi High Court judgment by directing the
Central Public Information Officer, Supreme
Court to furnish information regarding
collegium decision-making, personal assets of
judges, correspondence with CJI. No general
decision came up relating to the universal
disclosure of above-mentioned information.
Judgment
The Court read the inherent limitation in
Sections 3 and 6 as pertaining to revelation of
information that is likely to conflict with other
public interests including efficient operations
of the Governments, optimum use of limited
fiscal resources and the preservation of
confidentiality of sensitive information. UPSC
was accordingly directed to disclose the raw
marks as well as the model answers of the
questions in the examination. The Supreme
Court referred to the problems in showing
evaluated answers sheets in the UPSC Civil
Services Examination in Prashant Ramesh
Chakkarwar v. UPSC, 2013.